betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Projective symmetries and differential recursions for the large-NN Gross–Witten–Wadia and one-dimensional QCD matrix models

Abstract

We compare the fixed-charge planar Gross–Witten–Wadia (GWW) model with source-free one-dimensional QCD at large NN and Nf/NN_f/N fixed. In both models the resolvent and one-cut condition give an algebraic equation for a derivative of the free energy: a quartic for GWW and a sextic for QCD. Finite-NN Toeplitz determinants independently check the selected QCD branch. Signed permutations of homogeneous parameter triples realize S4S_4; the resulting action on the algebraic branches and operator labels gives a common projective description of the two models. For QCD, the sextic yields a differential recurrence linking small-charge rows two apart. The same second-order PDE gives a finite-width column recursion that reconstructs the coefficient pyramid from its GWW boundary. A distinct boundary, obtained from the first resummed coefficient, is the Narayana triangle. A formally collapsed slice counts decorated bipartite plane trees and admits an exact symmetric product formula. The many-flavor scaling reduces the sextic to the quartic and retains transverse projective data: the QCD divided-difference triple coalesces at this boundary, whereas the limiting quartic satisfies the full standard GWW third-order system. We distinguish algebraic degree, mixed differential order, and fixed-parameter ordinary differential order throughout.

Introduction

Large-NN unitary matrix integrals often admit several descriptions that appear quite different when expressed in their original variables. A small-source expansion organizes the answer into rational coefficient functions. A spectral construction gives an algebraic relation for a mass or source derivative of the free energy. Differential recursions relate successive expansion coefficients, whereas functional transformations connect expressions obtained in different parameter regions. The purpose of the present account is to place these structures in a common framework for two closely related models: the Gross–Witten–Wadia (GWW) model [1, 2] in a fixed determinant-charge sector and the source-free one-dimensional QCD model in the joint large-NN, large-NfN_f limit (for source-deformed Polyakov-loop extensions, see Refs. [3, 4]).

We organize the comparison in fixed determinant-charge sectors, represented by U(N)U(N) integrals. The SU(N)SU(N) partition functions are reconstructed by summing over these sectors. Earlier large-NN results for the SU(N)SU(N) GWW integral and the one-dimensional QCD partition function are given in Refs. [5, 6], respectively.

Determinant deformations of GWW provide a related line of work. Russo analyzed the planar phases of fermion-inspired U(N)U(N) deformations [7]; Russo and Tierz studied characteristic-polynomial insertions using Toeplitz determinants and Fisher–Hartwig asymptotics [8]. Santilli and Tierz established exact relations between determinant-deformed unitary ensembles and other random matrix ensembles and showed that their large-NN phase diagrams can differ [9]. Malik studied the spectral density and phase structure of QCD-inspired U(N)U(N) and SU(N)SU(N) models with linear sources and determinant terms [10]. Malik and Ahmed examined a complex unitary potential with Fisher–Hartwig singularities [11]. The comparison here centers on the algebraic generating functions at fixed charge, their projective symmetries, and the differential recursions of their coefficients.

The algebraic curves organize the paper. § 3 and § 4 start from the planar resolvent and the one-cut condition, obtaining the quartic and the sextic. The projective coordinates of § 2 make their parameter symmetries explicit, while the coefficient identities and generating PDEs are established on the curves. § 5 uses the QCD sextic to derive the small-charge recurrence, its generating equation, and the pyramid with GWW and Narayana boundaries. § 6 then explains how the GWW boundary also arises as a scaling limit of the QCD integral and curve. The finite-NN calculation in § 4.3 tests the chosen branch independently of these derivations.

The central observation is that the relevant parameter transformations become elementary when the parameters are represented by homogeneous triples. For GWW the triple is [u:h:i][u : h : i], where u=q/Nu = q/N and hh is the source. For one-dimensional QCD it is [k:k+1:ku][k : k + 1 : ku], where k=Nf/Nk = N_f/N and u=q/Nfu = q/N_f. Permutations and sign changes of these coordinates induce rational, and sometimes complex, transformations in the usual affine parameters. Their apparent complexity is largely a consequence of restoring an affine normalization after performing a simple homogeneous operation.

Geometrically, the quartic and sextic describe algebraic coverings of the corresponding parameter charts. The signed permutations act on the base coordinates and transport roots between fibers; in QCD the mass is a separate coordinate. For GWW a permutation can change the sign of the orientation covariant, while the normalized QCD root WW is invariant on its transported sheet. The physical germ is selected by boundary data of the integral. This distinction is why projective equivalence alone does not assert equality of separately selected thermodynamic branches.

This projective viewpoint also clarifies what it means for a differential equation to respect a symmetry. A group transformation can permute several component operators even when a particular combination of them is preserved up to a scalar factor. Conversely, a covariant transformation law for one complete operator does not determine how all possible decompositions of that operator behave. The distinction is visible already in GWW. There, the difference of two operators can change sign under a duality transformation, preserving its homogeneous equation, while the two component operators are exchanged. It is therefore natural to seek a comparable formulation in one-dimensional QCD rather than infer the operator structure solely from an invariant partial differential equation.

A second issue concerns differential order. The algebraic degree of a generating function, the total order of a partial differential equation, and the order of an ordinary differential equation obtained by fixing external parameters are separate quantities. In particular, an algebraic function of degree six can satisfy a mixed partial differential equation of order two without admitting a second-order ordinary differential equation in the mass alone. Similarly, replacing a free energy by a suitable first derivative can lower the order of its partial differential equation, whereas an invertible change of coordinates preserves the order of a given differential operator. These distinctions are essential when comparing the explicit third-derivative GWW raising recursion with the second-order parameter constraints that arise in QCD.

We retain the intermediate normalizations needed to move between the free energy, its algebraic derivative, and its projective generating function. This is particularly useful for interpreting earlier GWW recursions, whose generating function differs from the regular free energy by a sign and an elementary quadratic term. For QCD, a specific logarithmic subtraction converts an affine transformation of the free energy into a homogeneous transformation law. In those variables, the permuted operator triple has a short expression in Euler derivatives. The presentation concerns analytic fixed-sector branches before any sector summation or charge extremization. Polynomial identities are established at the level of the algebraic curve, and therefore hold for every regular local root of the relevant polynomial. A physical branch requires additional information from the matrix integral, including its small-source boundary condition and the continuation of the saddle contour. These qualifications enter at the points where they affect the interpretation of a formula. They do not restrict the purely algebraic or operator identities derived below.

The comparison is organized around the following results.

  1. The one-cut resolvent gives the GWW quartic and QCD sextic (§ 3 and § 4). The GWW raising recursion is the reference case; the Toeplitz calculation is an independent test of the QCD branch.

  1. The projective S4S_4 maps act on both curves. The induced operator action is a literal permutation in homogeneous coordinates and involves normalization factors in the physical charts.

  1. The QCD row recurrence (109) and generating PDE (111) yield the explicit column reconstruction (113). The first column is GWW, and the leading resummed boundary is Narayana at all orders. The collapsed slice admits a separate exact tree count.

  1. The many-flavor scaling relates the matrix integrals, the curves and the coefficient expansions (§ 6). The limit needs transverse coordinates and does not identify the particular operator triples component by component.

Sector integrals, normalizations, and projective coordinates

Fixed-charge integrals and algebraic derivatives

We use the GWW sector integral

DqG(N,h)=∫U(N)dU (det⁡U)qexp⁡[Nh2Tr⁡(U+U−1)],u=qN.(1)D_q^{\mathrm{G}}(N,h)=\int_{U(N)}\mathrm{d}U\,(\det U)^q\exp\left[\frac{Nh}{2}\operatorname{Tr}\left(U+U^{-1}\right)\right],\qquad u=\frac{q}{N}. \tag*{(1)}

The symmetry D−qG=DqGD_{-q}^{\mathrm{G}}=D_q^{\mathrm{G}} allows us to choose u≥0u\ge0 on the real fixed-sector branch. For algebraic continuation, uu will be treated as a complex parameter. The planar free energy and its source derivative are

ΨG(u,h)=lim⁡N→∞N−2log⁡DqG,g(u,h)=h2∂hΨG=x∂xΨG,x=h2.(2)\Psi_{\mathrm{G}}(u,h)=\lim_{N\to\infty}N^{-2}\log D_q^{\mathrm{G}},\qquad g(u,h)=\frac{h}{2}\partial_h\Psi_{\mathrm{G}}=x\partial_x\Psi_{\mathrm{G}},\qquad x=h^2. \tag*{(2)}

The exact finite-NN determinant

DqG(N,h)=det⁡1≤i,j≤NIq+i−j(Nh)(3)D_q^{\mathrm{G}}(N,h)=\det_{1\le i,j\le N} I_{q+i-j}(Nh) \tag*{(3)}

provides an independent definition and fixes the normalization of the small-source expansion. Its role here is to identify the sector and its boundary data; the planar algebraic description can be developed without expanding this determinant in representations.

For source-free one-dimensional QCD we consider

DqQ(N,Nf,h)=∫U(N)dU (det⁡U)qdet⁡(1+hU)Nfdet⁡(1+hU−1)Nf.(4)D_q^{\mathrm{Q}}(N,N_f,h)=\int_{U(N)}\mathrm{d}U\,(\det U)^q\det(1+hU)^{N_f}\det(1+hU^{-1})^{N_f}. \tag*{(4)}

The two determinants are retained exactly. The parameters in the Veneziano limit are

k=κ=NfN,u=qNf,v=ku=qN.(5)k=\kappa=\frac{N_f}{N},\qquad u=\frac{q}{N_f},\qquad v=ku=\frac{q}{N}. \tag*{(5)}

The QCD charge uu thus differs from the GWW charge by a factor kk. This distinction will be maintained explicitly in the scaling limit. For positive physical charge the source-free determinant has the saturation range 0≤u≤10 \le u \le1, whereas the GWW sector has no corresponding upper bound.

The static mass factor has been removed from (4). With h=e−mh=e^{-m}, the free energy normalized by NNfNN_f and the determinant free energy normalized by N2N^2 are related by

ΨQ=lim⁡N−2log⁡DqQ,S(k,u;h)=−log⁡h+ΨQ(k,u;h)k.(6)\Psi_{\mathrm{Q}}=\lim N^{-2}\log D_q^{\mathrm{Q}}, \qquad S(k,u;h)=-\log h+\frac{\Psi_{\mathrm{Q}}(k,u;h)}{k}. \tag*{(6)}

We define

GQ=x∂xΨQ,R=GQk−12=h2Sh.(7)G_{\mathrm{Q}}=x\partial_x\Psi_{\mathrm{Q}}, \qquad R=\frac{G_{\mathrm{Q}}}{k}-\frac{1}{2}=\frac{h}{2}S_h. \tag*{(7)}

The additive 1/21/2 is a normalization effect of the static mass factor. For example, ∂mS=−2R\partial_m S=-2R in the convention of (6). Selecting a sector or combining several sectors is a subsequent operation.

In what follows, the term algebraic generating function refers to gg, GQG_{\mathrm{Q}}, RR, or an explicitly normalized version of these derivatives. The free energies themselves contain logarithms. Their algebraic derivatives determine them up to functions of the external parameters, which must be fixed by the sector normalization. This integration freedom is also responsible for additive terms in the functional transformations of the free energy.

Homogeneous triples and the finite projective group

A homogeneous triple represents the same projective point after a common nonzero rescaling,

[a:b:c]=[λa:λb:λc].(8)[a:b:c]=[\lambda a:\lambda b:\lambda c]. \tag*{(8)}

In the chart a=1a=1, let p=b/ap=b/a and q=c/aq=c/a. The three elementary permutations of the homogeneous coordinates act as

(p,q)→bc(q,p),(p,q)→ab(1/p,q/p),(p,q)→ac(p/q,1/q).(9)(p,q)\xrightarrow{bc}(q,p), \qquad(p,q)\xrightarrow{ab}(1/p,q/p), \qquad(p,q)\xrightarrow{ac}(p/q,1/q). \tag*{(9)}

The denominators in these transformations arise from the restoration of the chart. They are the elementary origin of the fractional-linear relations encountered in coefficient expansions.

The two models admit the triples

[a:b:c]G=[u:h:i],[a:b:c]Q=[k:k+1:ku].(10)[a:b:c]_{\mathrm{G}}=[u:h:i], \qquad[a:b:c]_{\mathrm{Q}}=[k:k+1:ku]. \tag*{(10)}

Their different dependence on hh is significant. The GWW source is a coordinate of the triple and can be exchanged with the charge by a projective transformation. In QCD the mass remains an additional variable, while the triple consists of flavor and charge data.

Together with independent sign changes, permutations generate

Γ=((Z2)3/Z2)×S3≃(Z2)2×S3≃S4.(11)\Gamma=((\mathbb{Z}_2)^3/\mathbb{Z}_2)\times S_3 \simeq(\mathbb{Z}_2)^2\times S_3 \simeq S_4. \tag*{(11)}

The quotient removes the common sign, which is a projective rescaling. The resulting group has order 24. On the three squared coordinates A1=a2A_1=a^2, A2=b2A_2=b^2, and A3=c2A_3=c^2, sign changes act trivially, and only the quotient S3S_3 permutes the coordinate labels. This is the permutation action that will exchange the differential operators.

This finite action should be distinguished from invariance under the entire projective linear group. It should also be distinguished from a Galois group over a fixed coefficient field: the transformations in (11) change external parameters, whereas a Galois action fixes the prescribed coefficient field. A relation between these two structures would require a separate analysis.

Symmetric invariants and orientation

The elementary symmetric polynomials in AiA_i are

e1=A1+A2+A3,e2=A1A2+A1A3+A2A3,e3=A1A2A3.(12)e_1 = A_1 + A_2 + A_3,\qquad e_2 = A_1A_2 + A_1A_3 + A_2A_3,\qquad e_3 = A_1A_2A_3. \tag*{(12)}

On e1≠0e_1 \ne0 we use the rational projective invariants

r=e2e12,s=e3e13.(13)r = \frac{e_2}{e_1^2},\qquad s = \frac{e_3}{e_1^3}. \tag*{(13)}

Indeed, Ai/e1A_i/e_1 are the roots of

λ3−λ2+rλ−s=0.(14)\lambda^3 - \lambda^2 + r\lambda- s = 0. \tag*{(14)}

The normalized orientation covariant and its square are

d=(A1−A3)(A2−A3)(A1−A2)e13,d2=Δ=r2−4r3−4s+18rs−27s2.(15)d = \frac{(A_1-A_3)(A_2-A_3)(A_1-A_2)}{e_1^3},\qquad d^2 = \Delta= r^2 - 4r^3 - 4s + 18rs - 27s^2. \tag*{(15)}

An odd permutation reverses the sign of dd, while rr, ss, and Δ\Delta remain unchanged. This orientation information is needed in the depressed GWW quartic. The QCD sextic, in contrast, can be written entirely in the symmetric invariants. Passing from the ordered coordinates to rr, ss is locally invertible away from the corresponding ramification loci, but it identifies points related by permutations. Consequently an invariant description can conceal an operator permutation that is transparent in homogeneous coordinates.

The GWW algebraic generating function and its differential system

A rational coordinate for the fixed-charge branch

The GWW quartic, its projective transformations and the associated hierarchy of differential recursions are discussed in Ref. [12]. Here we give a short resolvent derivation in the same form as the QCD calculation in § 4.1: a rational spectral function, a one-cut double-zero condition, and elimination to an algebraic relation for the free-energy derivative.

The algebraic curve can be obtained from a one-cut planar construction. For nonzero charge, the saddle contour generally moves into the complex eigenvalue plane. Combining the Haar measure with the determinant insertion gives the effective potential

V(z)=−h2(z+1z)−(u−1)log⁡z.(16)V(z) = -\frac{h}{2}\left(z+\frac{1}{z}\right)-(u-1)\log z. \tag*{(16)}

References

  1. [1]D. J. Gross and E. Witten, Possible third-order phase transition in the large-N lattice gauge theory, Phys. Rev. D 21 (1980), 446–453, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.21.446.DOI
  2. [2]S. R. Wadia, N = ∞ phase transition in a class of exactly soluble model lattice gauge theories, Phys. Lett. B 93 (1980), 403–410, doi:10.1016/0370-2693(80)90353-6.DOI
  3. [3]S. Voloshyn, Polyakov loop model with exact static quark determinant in the ’t Hooft–Veneziano limit: U(N) case, arXiv:2507.00689.arxiv.org/abs/2507.00689
  4. [4]S. Voloshyn, Polyakov loop model with exact static quark determinant in the ’t Hooft–Veneziano limit: SU(N) case, arXiv:2512.07026.arxiv.org/abs/2512.07026
  5. [5]O. Borisenko, V. Chelnokov and S. Voloshyn, The large N limit of SU(N) integrals in lattice models, Nucl. Phys. B 960 (2020), 115177, doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2020.115177, arXiv:2008.00773.DOI
  6. [6]O. Borisenko, V. Chelnokov, S. Voloshyn and P. Yefanov, One-dimensional QCD at finite density and its ’t Hooft–Veneziano limit, JHEP 01 (2025), 008, doi:10.1007/JHEP01(2025)008, arXiv:2410.02328.DOI
  7. [7]J. G. Russo, Phases of unitary matrix models and lattice QCD₂, Phys. Rev. D 102 (2020), 105019, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.102.105019, arXiv:2010.02950.DOI
  8. [8]J. G. Russo and M. Tierz, Multiple phases in a generalized Gross–Witten–Wadia matrix model, JHEP 09 (2020), 081, doi:10.1007/JHEP09(2020)081, arXiv:2007.08515.DOI
  9. [9]L. Santilli and M. Tierz, Exact equivalences and phase discrepancies between random matrix ensembles, J. Stat. Mech. (2020), 083107, doi:10.1088/1742-5468/aba594, arXiv:2003.10475.DOI
  10. [10]A. Malik, Large-N dynamics of a QCD-inspired unitary matrix model, arXiv:2604.18182v1 [hep-th] (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2604.18182
  11. [11]A. Malik and A. Ahmed, Spectral and phase structure of a unitary matrix model with Fisher–Hartwig singularities, arXiv:2601.02953 [hep-th] (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2601.02953
  12. [12]S. Voloshyn, Differential Recursions, Projective Discriminants, and Algebraic Generating Functions, arXiv:2609.31189.arxiv.org/abs/2609.31189
  13. [13]OEIS Foundation, A336110: Irregular triangle of Catalan-based numbers, read by rows, https://oeis.org/A336110.
  14. [14]R. Cori and G. Schaeffer, Description trees and Tutte formulas, Theoretical Computer Science 292 (2003), 165–183, doi:10.1016/S0304-3975(01)00221-3.DOI
  15. [15]OEIS Foundation, A000309: Rooted planar bridgeless cubic maps and description trees of type (2, 2), https://oeis.org/A000309.
  16. [16]O. Bernardi, Bijective counting of Kreweras walks and loopless triangulations, J. Combin. Theory Ser. A 114 (2007), 931–956, doi:10.1016/j.jcta.2006.09.009.DOI
  17. [17]R. P. Stanley, Catalan Numbers, Cambridge University Press, 2015, doi:10.1017/CBO9781139871495.DOI
  18. [18]G. Muntingh, Implicit divided differences, little Schröder numbers, and Catalan numbers, J. Integer Seq. 15 (2012), Article 12.6.5, arXiv:1204.2709.arxiv.org/abs/1204.2709
  19. [19]T. V. Narayana, Lattice Path Combinatorics with Statistical Applications, Mathematical Expositions 23, University of Toronto Press, 1979, doi:10.3138/j.ctvfrxdw5.DOI
  20. [20]G. Labelle and P. Leroux, Enumeration of (uni- or bicolored) plane trees according to their degree distribution, Discrete Mathematics 157 (1996), 227–240, doi:10.1016/S0012-365X(96)83017-2.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_ewxmpzsj
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents