betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Interplay between geostrophic vortices and inertial waves in precession-driven turbulence

Abstract

The properties of rotating turbulence driven by precession are studied using direct numerical simulations and analysis of the underlying dynamical processes in Fourier space. The study is carried out in the local rotating coordinate frame, where precession gives rise to a background shear flow, which becomes linearly unstable and breaks down into turbulence. We observe that this precession-driven turbulence is in general characterized by coexisting two dimensional (2D) columnar vortices and three dimensional (3D) inertial waves, whose relative energies depend on the precession parameter PoPo. The vortices resemble the typical condensates of geostrophic turbulence, are aligned along the rotation axis (with zero wavenumber in this direction, kz=0k_z=0) and are fed by the 3D waves through nonlinear transfer of energy, while the waves (with kz≠0k_z\neq0) in turn are directly fed by the precessional instability of the background flow. The vortices themselves undergo inverse cascade of energy and exhibit anisotropy in Fourier space. For small Po<0.1Po<0.1 and sufficiently high Reynolds numbers, the typical regime for most geo- and astrophysical applications, the flow exhibits strongly oscillatory (bursty) evolution due to the alternation of vortices and small-scale waves. On the other hand, at larger Po>0.1Po>0.1 turbulence is quasi-steady with only mild fluctuations, the coexisting columnar vortices and waves in this state give rise to a split (simultaneous inverse and forward) cascade. Increasing the precession magnitude causes a reinforcement of waves relative to vortices with the energy spectrum approaching Kolmogorov scaling and, therefore, the precession mechanism counteracts the effects of the rotation.

Introduction

Rotating turbulence is an ubiquitous phenomenon in a broad context ranging from astrophysical and geophysical flows [1, 2, 3, 4] to industrial applications [5, 6]. Understanding the impact of rotation on the turbulence dynamics is far from trivial due to the complexity of the nonlinear processes involved. In general, when a fluid is subjected to rotational motion, the nonlinear interactions are affected by the Coriolis force whose strength is quantified by the Rossby number, RoRo (the ratio of the advection time-scale to the rotation time-scale) and the Reynolds number, ReRe (the ratio of advective to viscous time-scale). If the Coriolis force is strong enough the formation of coherent columnar vortices occurs inside the fluid flow. This phenomenon has been observed in experimental campaigns for several systems such as oscillating grids [7], for decaying turbulence [8, 9], forced turbulence [10, 11, 12], and turbulent convection [13, 14]. Also numerical simulations have been instrumental to analyze such tendency in a myriad of cases [15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21], making use of large eddy simulations [22, 23, 24] and even turbulence models [25, 26].

The emergence of columnar vortices aligned along the flow rotation axis is accompanied by inertial waves which are inherent to rotating fluids. Their frequency magnitude ranges between zero and twice the rotation rate Ω\Omega of the objects [27]. The dynamics and mutual couplings between these two basic types of modes largely depend on ReRe and RoRo. The results of the asymptotic analysis at Ro≪1Ro \ll1 indicate that three-dimensional (3D) inertial waves and two-dimensional (2D) vortices are essentially decoupled and evolve independently: vortices undergo inverse cascade, while the wave energy cascades forward through resonant wave interactions in the regime of weakly nonlinear inertial wave turbulence [28– However, this picture does not carry over to moderate Rossby numbers Ro∼0.1Ro \sim0.1, where the situation is much more complex, since 3D inertial waves (the so called fast modes) and 2D vortices (also called slow modes) can coexist and be dynamically coupled. In this case, asymptotic analysis cannot be used and more complex mathematical models have been proposed to explain the geostrophic vortices-wave interaction, such as the quartic instability [32] or near-resonant instability [33]. However progress can be made mainly by numerical simulations. Several works are devoted to the study of these two manifolds and their interactions for forced rotating turbulence [29, 34, 35, 36] and also for convective and rotating turbulence [37, 38].

Indeed other forcing mechanisms have been shown to be characterized by this interplay of vortices and waves, such as elliptical instabilities [39, 40, 41, 42, 43] and tidal forcing [44, 45, 46, 47, 48]. In this respect, the precession-driven dynamics represents a possible candidate for the development of both 3D waves with embedded 2D vortices [36, 49] but so far these studies does not investigate a wide range of governing parameters. Other works were devoted to the stability analysis of the precession flows [50].

The modified local Cartesian model of a precession-driven flow was proposed by Mason and Kerswell [51] and later used by Barker [45] to study its nonlinear evolution. In the first paper, rigid and stress-free axial boundaries in the vertical direction were used, while in the second paper an unbounded precessional flow was considered in the planetary context, employing the decomposition of perturbations into shearing waves. In this paper, we follow primarily the approach of Barker [45], who analyzed the occurrence of vortices, function of the precession parameter (Poincaré number), including energy spectrum and dissipation properties. The main advantage of the local model is that it allows high-resolution study of linear and nonlinear dynamical processes in precession-driven flows, which is much more challenging in global models. Also, this model allows to focus only on the dynamics of the bulk flow itself avoiding the complications due to boundary layers. This is important for gaining a deeper understanding of perturbation evolution in unbounded precessional flows and then, comparing with the global simulations, for pinning down specific effects caused by boundaries.

In this paper, we continue this path and investigate in detail the underlying dynamical processes in the turbulence of precessional flow in the local model. We decompose perturbations into 2D and 3D manifolds and analyse their dynamics and interplay in Fourier space. Our main goal is to address and clarify several key questions: (i) how the presence and properties of columnar vortices depend on the precession strength and Reynolds number (here defined as the inverse Ekman number), (ii) what are the mechanisms for the formation of the columnar vortices in precessing driven flows, in particular, how their dynamics are affected by precessional instability of inertial waves, that is, if there are effective nonlinear transfers (coupling) between vortices and the waves; (iii) what are the dominant nonlinear processes (channels) in this vortex-wave system, i.e., the interaction of 2D-3D modes or 2D-2D modes (inverse cascade), (iv) in terms of total shell-average spectral analysis, what type of cascades (inverse, forward) occur and what kind of spectra characterize precessional flows. The paper is organized as follows: in Section II the local model and governing equations in physical and Fourier space are presented, and numerical methods introduced. Section III presents general evolution of the volume-averaged kinetic energy and dynamical terms as well as flow structure. In Section II B we investigate the nonlinear dynamics of 2D vortices and 3D inertial waves and nonlinear interaction between them in Fourier space. In this section we also characterize turbulent dissipation as a function of precession parameter PoPo. Discussions and the future perspectives are presented in Section V.

Model and equations

We consider a precessional flow in a local rotating Cartesian coordinate frame (also referred to as the ‘mantle frame’ of a precessing planet) in which the mean total angular velocity of fluid rotation Ω=Ωez\boldsymbol{\Omega} = \Omega\boldsymbol{e}_z is directed along the zz-axis. In this frame, the equations of motion for an incompressible viscous fluid take the form (see a detailed derivation in Refs. [45, 51]):

∂U∂t+U⋅∇U+2Ω(ez+ϵ(t))×U=−1ρ∇P+ν∇2U+2zΩ2ϵ(t)(1)\frac{\partial U}{\partial t}+U\cdot\nabla U+2\Omega(\boldsymbol{e}_z+\epsilon(t))\times U=-\frac{1}{\rho}\nabla P+\nu\nabla^2 U+2z\Omega^2\epsilon(t) \tag*{(1)}
∇⋅U=0,(2)\nabla\cdot U=0, \tag*{(2)}

where UU is the velocity in this frame, ρ\rho is the spatially uniform density and PP is the modified pressure equal to the sum of thermal pressure and the centrifugal potential. The last two terms on the left-hand side in the brackets are the Coriolis and the Poincaré forces, respectively, and ϵ(t)=Po(cos⁡(Ωt),−sin⁡(Ωt),0)T\epsilon(t)=Po(\cos(\Omega t),-\sin(\Omega t),0)^T is the precession vector with PoPo being the Poincaré number characterizing the strength of the precession force. The last term on the right-hand side is the second part of the precession force with vertical shear, which is the main cause of hydrodynamic instability in the system, refereed to as the precessional instability [52]. ν\nu is the constant kinematic viscosity.

The basic precessional shear flow in this local frame represents an unbounded horizontal flow with a linear shear along the vertical zz-axis and oscillating in time tt, i.e., Ub=(Ubx(z,t),Uby(z,t),0)U_b=(U_{bx}(z,t),U_{by}(z,t),0) with the components given by [45, 51]

Ub=−2ΩPo(00sin⁡(Ωt)00cos⁡(Ωt)000)(xyz)≡MrU_b=-2\Omega Po \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 0 & \sin(\Omega t)\\ 0 & 0 & \cos(\Omega t)\\ 0 & 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} x\\ y\\ z \end{pmatrix} \equiv M\boldsymbol{r}

Figure 1. Sketch of the periodic cubic domain with length LL in each direction where the base flow inside it is Ub\mathbf{U}_b with superimposed perturbation velocity u\mathbf{u}.

where r=(x,y,z)\mathbf{r}=(x,y,z) is the local position vector. Our local model deals with perturbations to this basic flow, u=U−Ub\mathbf{u}=\mathbf{U}-\mathbf{U}_b, for which from Eq. (1) we obtain the governing equation:

∂u∂t+u⋅∇u=−1ρ∇P+ν∇2u−2Ωez×u−2Ωε(t)×u−Mu−Mr⋅∇u(3)\frac{\partial\mathbf{u}}{\partial t}+\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}=-\frac{1}{\rho}\nabla P+\nu\nabla^{2}\mathbf{u}-2\Omega\mathbf{e}_{z}\times\mathbf{u}-2\Omega\varepsilon(t)\times\mathbf{u}-M\mathbf{u}-M\mathbf{r}\cdot\nabla\mathbf{u} \tag*{(3)}

where the last three terms on the rhs are related to precession and proportional to PoPo. The flow field is confined in a cubic box with the same length LL in each direction, Lx=Ly=Lz=LL_x=L_y=L_z=L. In other words, both horizontal and vertical aspect ratios of the box are chosen to be equal to one in this paper. Varying these aspect ratios affects the linearly unstable modes that can be excited in the flow and the properties of the vortices [39].

Below we use the non-dimensionalization of the variables by taking Ω−1\Omega^{-1} as the unit of time, box size LL as the unit of length, ΩL\Omega L as the unit of velocity, ρL2Ω2\rho L^{2}\Omega^{2} as the unit of pressure and perturbation kinetic energy density E=ρu2/2E=\rho u^{2}/2. The key parameters governing a precession-driven flow are the Reynolds number (inverse Ekman) defined as

Re=ΩL2νRe=\frac{\Omega L^{2}}{\nu}

and the Poincaré number PoPo introduced above.

Re=103.5Re=10^{3.5}PoPoNN⟨E⟩\langle E\rangleRe=104Re=10^{4}PoPoNN⟨E⟩\langle E\rangle
Re=103.5Re=10^{3.5}0.0164-Re=104Re=10^{4}0.0164-
0.02564-0.02564-
0.0564-0.0564-
0.07564-0.075128-
0.164-0.1128-
0.12564-0.1251281.89×10−51.89\times10^{-5}
0.1564-0.151286.04×10−56.04\times10^{-5}
0.17564-0.1751281.42×10−41.42\times10^{-4}
0.264-0.21283.54×10−43.54\times10^{-4}
0.22564-0.2251286.11×10−46.11\times10^{-4}
0.2564-0.251289.94×10−49.94\times10^{-4}
0.3646.09×10−56.09\times10^{-5}0.31282.10×10−32.10\times10^{-3}
Re=104.5Re=10^{4.5}PoPoNN⟨E⟩\langle E\rangleRe=105Re=10^{5}PoPoNN⟨E⟩\langle E\rangle
Re=104.5Re=10^{4.5}0.01128-Re=105Re=10^{5}0.01256-
0.025128-0.025256-
0.05128-0.052564.55×10−54.55\times10^{-5}
0.0751283.82×10−53.82\times10^{-5}0.0752562.37×10−42.37\times10^{-4}
0.11281.13×10−41.13\times10^{-4}0.12561.10×10−31.10\times10^{-3}
0.1251284.93×10−44.93\times10^{-4}0.1252565.90×10−35.90\times10^{-3}
0.152561.30×10−31.30\times10^{-3}0.152566.80×10−36.80\times10^{-3}
0.1752562.30×10−32.30\times10^{-3}0.1752567.50×10−37.50\times10^{-3}
0.22565.40×10−35.40\times10^{-3}0.22568.90×10−38.90\times10^{-3}
0.2252566.20×10−36.20\times10^{-3}0.2252561.02×10−21.02\times10^{-2}
0.252566.40×10−36.40\times10^{-3}0.252561.14×10−21.14\times10^{-2}
0.32569.00×10−39.00\times10^{-3}0.32561.15×10−21.15\times10^{-2}
0.52561.25×10−21.25\times10^{-2}

Table 1. List of all simulations performed in the present work. Each subtable corresponds to a specific Reynolds number and various Poincaré numbers PoPo (first column). The second column shows numerical resolution NN (before dealiasing), which is the same in each direction, Nx=Ny=Nz=NN_x=N_y=N_z=N (total number of point is N3N^3). The third column shows the time- and volume-averaged kinetic energy ⟨E⟩\langle E\rangle. Runs marked with hyphen are not sustained and quickly decay. Notice that for Re=104.5Re=10^{4.5} we have run also a simulation at very large Po=0.5Po=0.5.

Governing equations in Fourier space

Our main goal is to perform the spectral analysis of precession-driven turbulence in Fourier (wavenumber k\mathbf{k}-) space in order to understand dynamical processes (energy injection and nonlinear transfers) underlying its sustenance and evolution. To this end, following [39, 45], we decompose the perturbations into spatial Fourier modes (shearing waves) with time-dependent wavevectors k(t)\mathbf{k}(t),

f(r,t)=∑kfˉ(k(t),t)eik(t)⋅r,(4)f(\mathbf{r},t)=\sum_{\mathbf{k}}\bar{f}(\mathbf{k}(t),t)e^{i\mathbf{k}(t)\cdot\mathbf{r}}, \tag*{(4)}

where f≡(u,P)f\equiv(\mathbf{u},P) and their Fourier transforms are fˉ≡(uˉ,Pˉ)\bar{f}\equiv(\bar{\mathbf{u}},\bar{P}). In the transformation Eq. (4), the wavevector of modes oscillates in time,

k(t)=(kx0,ky0,kz0+2Po(−kx0cos⁡(t)+ky0sin⁡(t)))T,(5)\mathbf{k}(t)=\left(k_{x0},k_{y0},k_{z0}+2Po(-k_{x0}\cos(t)+k_{y0}\sin(t))\right)^{T}, \tag*{(5)}

about its constant average value ⟨k(t)⟩=(kx0,ky0,kz0)\langle\mathbf{k}(t)\rangle=(k_{x0},k_{y0},k_{z0}) due to the periodic time-variation of the basic precessional flow Ub\mathbf{U}_b. Substituting Eq. (4) into Eq. (3) and taking into account the above non-dimensionalization, we obtain the following equation governing the evolution of velocity amplitude

duˉdt=−ik(t)Pˉ−k2Reuˉ−2ez×uˉ−2ε(t)×uˉ−M(t)uˉ+Q,(6)\frac{d\bar{\mathbf{u}}}{dt}=-i\mathbf{k}(t)\bar{P}-\frac{k^{2}}{Re}\bar{\mathbf{u}}-2\mathbf{e}_{z}\times\bar{\mathbf{u}}-2\varepsilon(t)\times\bar{\mathbf{u}}-M(t)\bar{\mathbf{u}}+\mathbf{Q}, \tag*{(6)}
k(t)⋅uˉ=0.(7)\mathbf{k}(t)\cdot\bar{\mathbf{u}}=0. \tag*{(7)}

Note that the wavevector k(t)\boldsymbol{k}(t) as given by expression (5) satisfies the ordinary differential equation

dkdt=−MTk(8)\frac{d\boldsymbol{k}}{dt}=-M^{T}\boldsymbol{k} \tag*{(8)}

and as a result the last term on the rhs of Eq. (3) related to the basic flow has disappeared when substituting (4) into it. The term Q(k,t)Q(\boldsymbol{k},t) on the rhs of Eq. (6) represents the Fourier transform of the nonlinear advection term u⋅∇u=∇⋅(uu)\boldsymbol{u}\cdot\nabla\boldsymbol{u}=\nabla\cdot(\boldsymbol{u}\boldsymbol{u}) in the original Eq. (3) and is given by convolution [35, 53]

Qm(k,t)=−i∑n∑k′knuˉm(k′,t)uˉn(k−k′,t)(9)Q_m(\boldsymbol{k},t)=-\mathrm{i}\sum_n\sum_{\boldsymbol{k}'}k_n\bar{u}_m(\boldsymbol{k}',t)\bar{u}_n(\boldsymbol{k}-\boldsymbol{k}',t) \tag*{(9)}

where the indices (m,n)=(x,y,z)(m,n)=(x,y,z). This term describes the net effect of nonlinear triadic interactions (transfers) among a mode k\boldsymbol{k} with two others k−k′\boldsymbol{k}-\boldsymbol{k}' and k′\boldsymbol{k}' and thus plays a key role in turbulence dynamics.

Multiplying both sides of Eq. (6) by the complex conjugate of spectral velocity uˉ∗\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}^{*}, the contribution from Coriolis and part of the Poincaré force in the total kinetic energy of a mode cancel out, since they do not do any work on the flow, uˉ∗⋅(2ez×uˉ−2ϵ(t)×uˉ)=0\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}^{*}\cdot(2\boldsymbol{e}_z\times\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}-2\boldsymbol{\epsilon}(t)\times\bar{\boldsymbol{u}})=0, and as a result we obtain the equation for the (non-dimensional) spectral kinetic energy density E=∣uˉ∣2/2E=|\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}|^2/2 in Fourier space as

dEdt=12[uˉ∗(Muˉ)+uˉ(Muˉ)∗]⏟injection+12[uˉ∗Q+uˉQ∗]⏟nonlinear transfer−2k2ReE⏟dissipation.(10)\frac{dE}{dt}=\underbrace{\frac{1}{2}\left[\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}^{*}(M\bar{\boldsymbol{u}})+\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}(M\bar{\boldsymbol{u}})^{*}\right]}_{\mathit{injection}}+\underbrace{\frac{1}{2}\left[\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}^{*}Q+\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}Q^{*}\right]}_{\mathit{nonlinear\ transfer}}-\underbrace{\frac{2k^2}{Re}E}_{\mathit{dissipation}}. \tag*{(10)}

The pressure term also cancels out since uˉ∗⋅k(t)Pˉ=0\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}^{*}\cdot\boldsymbol{k}(t)\bar{P}=0. Thus, the rhs of Eq. (10) contains three main terms:

  • Injection

A≡12[uˉ∗(Muˉ)+uˉ(Muˉ)∗],A\equiv\frac{1}{2}\left[\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}^{*}(M\bar{\boldsymbol{u}})+\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}(M\bar{\boldsymbol{u}})^{*}\right],

which is of linear origin, being determined by the matrix MM, i.e., by the precessing background flow and describes energy exchange between the perturbations and that flow. If A>0A>0, kinetic energy is injected from the flow into inertial wave modes and hence they grow, which is basically due to precessional instability [45, 51, 52, 54], whereas at A<0A<0 modes give energy to the flow and decay.

  • Nonlinear transfer

NL≡12[uˉ∗Q+uˉQ∗]NL\equiv\frac{1}{2}\left[\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}^{*}Q+\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}Q^{*}\right]

describes transfer (cascade) of spectral kinetic energy among modes with different wavenumbers in Fourier space due to nonlinearity. The net effect of this term in the spectral energy budget summed over all wavenumbers is zero i.e.,

∑kNL(k,t)=0,\sum_{\boldsymbol{k}}NL(\boldsymbol{k},t)=0,

which follows from vanishing of the nonlinear advection term in the total kinetic energy equation integrated in physical space. Thus, the main effect of the nonlinear term is only to redistribute energy among modes that is injected from the basic flow due to AA, while keeping the total spectral kinetic energy summed over all wavenumbers unchanged. Although the nonlinear transfers NLNL produce no net energy for perturbations, they play a central role in the turbulence dynamics together with the injection term AA. The latter is thus the only source of new energy for perturbations drawn from the infinite reservoir of the background precessional flow. Due to this, below we focus on these two main dynamical terms – linear injection and nonlinear transfer functions, compute their spectra and analyse how they operate in Fourier space to the presence of precession instability using the tools of Refs. [53, 55].

  • Viscous dissipation

D=−2k2ReED=-\frac{2k^2}{Re}E

is negative definite and describes the dissipation of kinetic energy due to viscosity.

2D-3D decomposition

In the present section we follow a widely used approach in the theory of rotating anisotropic turbulence [29, 31, 35, 36, 37, 39] and decompose the flow field into 2D and 3D modes in Fourier space to better characterize this anisotropy between horizontal and vertical motions. This choice is motivated by the observation of two main types of perturbations: vortices, which are essentially 2D structures, and 3D inertial waves in rotating turbulent flows with external forcing such as libration, elliptical instability [39, 42], precession [36, 45] and other artificial types of forcing concentrated at a particular wavenumber [34, 35, 56]. The 2D vortical modes, also called slow (geostrophic) modes, have dominant horizontal velocity over the vertical one and are almost uniform, or aligned along the zz-axis, i.e., their wavenumber parallel to this axis is zero kz=0k_z=0. This slow manifold is also referred to as 2D and three-component (2D3C) field in the literature, since it varies only in the horizontal (x,y)(x,y)-plane perpendicular to the rotation axis, but still involves all three components of velocity with the horizontal one being dominant. On the other hand, 3D inertial wave modes, called fast (with nonzero frequency ω=±2Ωkz/k\omega=\pm2\Omega k_z/k) modes, have comparable horizontal and vertical velocities and vary along zz-axis, i.e., parallel wavenumber is nonzero kz≠0k_z\ne0. In the present case of the basic precessional flow, the kz(t)\boldsymbol{k}_z(t) wavenumber of modes oscillates in time according to Eq. (5), so we classify 2D and 3D modes as having ⟨kz(t)⟩=kz0=0\langle k_z(t)\rangle=k_{z0}=0 and kz0≠0k_{z0} \ne0, respectively. Specifically, these two mode manifolds are

Ψ2D={k∣kx,ky;kz=0},Ψ3D={k∣kx,ky;kz≠0}.(11)\Psi_{2D} = \left\{ \mathbf{k} \mid k_x, k_y; k_z = 0 \right\}, \qquad\Psi_{3D} = \left\{ \mathbf{k} \mid k_x, k_y; k_z \ne0 \right\}. \tag*{(11)}

and the spectral velocities for 2D vortices and 3D inertial waves can be defined as

uˉ(k)={uˉ2D(k)if k∈Ψ2Duˉ3D(k)if k∈Ψ3D.(12)\bar{\mathbf{u}}(\mathbf{k}) = \begin{cases} \bar{\mathbf{u}}_{2D}(\mathbf{k}) & \text{if } \mathbf{k} \in\Psi_{2D} \\ \bar{\mathbf{u}}_{3D}(\mathbf{k}) & \text{if } \mathbf{k} \in\Psi_{3D}. \end{cases} \tag*{(12)}

Note that the definition of 2D manifolds here differs from the Taylor-Proudman problem since it does not necessarily have vanishing vertical flow. Indeed, velocity for both the 3D and 2D modes can be decomposed in turn into respective horizontal uˉh=(uˉx,uˉy,0)\bar{\mathbf{u}}_h = (\bar{u}_x,\bar{u}_y,0) and vertical uˉz\bar{u}_z components.

Using the general Eq. (10), separate equations can be written for 2D and 3D mode spectral energies defined, respectively, as E2D=∣uˉ2D∣2/2E_{2D} = |\bar{\mathbf{u}}_{2D}|^2/2 and E3D=∣uˉ3D∣2/2E_{3D} = |\bar{\mathbf{u}}_{3D}|^2/2 [35, 39, 57],

dE2Ddt=A2D+NL2D2D+NL3D2D+D2D,(13)\frac{dE_{2D}}{dt} = A_{2D} + NL_{2D2D} + NL_{3D2D} + D_{2D}, \tag*{(13)}
dE3Ddt=A3D+NL3D3D+NL2D3D+D3D.(14)\frac{dE_{3D}}{dt} = A_{3D} + NL_{3D3D} + NL_{2D3D} + D_{3D}. \tag*{(14)}

Since injection AA and dissipation DD terms are of linear origin, they act for 2D and 3D modes separately, i.e.,

A2D=A(k),D2D=D(k),for k∈Ψ2DA_{2D} = A(\mathbf{k}), \qquad D_{2D} = D(\mathbf{k}), \qquad\text{for } \mathbf{k} \in\Psi_{2D}
A3D=A(k),D3D=D(k),for k∈Ψ3D.A_{3D} = A(\mathbf{k}), \qquad D_{3D} = D(\mathbf{k}), \qquad\text{for } \mathbf{k} \in\Psi_{3D}.

However, the nonlinear transfers can act only among modes which lie respectively within the slow or the fast manifold, that is, nonlinear interactions separately among 2D-2D modes (vortex-vortex),

NL2D2D=−uˉ2D⋅(u2D⋅∇u2D)‾,NL_{2D2D} = -\bar{\mathbf{u}}_{2D} \cdot\overline{(\mathbf{u}_{2D} \cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}_{2D})},

and among 3D-3D modes (wave-wave),

NL3D3D=−uˉ3D⋅(u3D⋅∇u3D)‾,NL_{3D3D} = -\bar{\mathbf{u}}_{3D} \cdot\overline{(\mathbf{u}_{3D} \cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}_{3D})},

(long bars denote Fourier transforms) as well as between these two manifolds, that is, nonlinear cross interactions/couplings between 2D and 3D modes (vortex-wave) [35, 58],

NL3D2D=−uˉ2D⋅(u3D⋅∇u3D)‾.NL_{3D2D} = -\bar{\mathbf{u}}_{2D} \cdot\overline{(\mathbf{u}_{3D} \cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}_{3D})}.
NL2D3D=−uˉ3D⋅(u2D⋅∇u3D)‾−uˉ3D⋅(u3D⋅∇u2D)‾.NL_{2D3D} = -\bar{\mathbf{u}}_{3D} \cdot\overline{(\mathbf{u}_{2D} \cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}_{3D})} - \bar{\mathbf{u}}_{3D} \cdot\overline{(\mathbf{u}_{3D} \cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}_{2D})}.

In this case, in a triad, 2D modes can receive/lose energy via nonlinear interaction of two 3D modes with opposite signs of kzk_z, while 3D modes can receive/lose energy via interaction of only 2D and another 3D mode (interaction between 2D and 2D modes obviously cannot feed 3D modes).

The 2D-2D and 3D-3D nonlinear transfers are each conservative, ∑kNL2D2D=0\sum_{\mathbf{k}} NL_{2D2D} = 0 and ∑kNL3D3D=0\sum_{\mathbf{k}} NL_{3D3D} = 0, whereas the cross transfer terms NL2D3DNL_{2D3D} and NL3D2DNL_{3D2D} are not, but their sum is conservative, as the net effect of these terms summed over all wavenumbers, as it should be, are equal in absolute value but have opposite signs i.e.,

∑k∈Ψ3DNL3D2D(k)=−∑k∈Ψ2DNL2D3D(k).(15)\sum_{\mathbf{k} \in\Psi_{3D}} NL_{3D2D}(\mathbf{k}) = - \sum_{\mathbf{k} \in\Psi_{2D}} NL_{2D3D}(\mathbf{k}). \tag*{(15)}

Below we analyse the action of these injection and transfer terms for different PoPo and ReRe (Table I).

In the following we will mostly use shell-averages of these spectra, which are defined in the standard way as [31]

fˉ(k)=∑k≤∣k∣≤k+Δkf(k),\bar{f}(k) = \sum_{k \leq|\mathbf{k}| \leq k+\Delta k} f(\mathbf{k}),

for each spectral quantity f≡(E,A,NL,D)f \equiv(E,A,NL,D). For 3D modes k∈Ψ3D\mathbf{k} \in\Psi_{3D} the summation is done over spherical shells with radii k=(kx2+ky2+kz2)1/2k = (k_x^2 + k_y^2 + k_z^2)^{1/2} while for 2D modes, having k∈Ψ2D\mathbf{k} \in\Psi_{2D}, the summation is over rings in the (kx,ky)(k_x,k_y)-plane with radii k=(kx2+ky2)1/2k = (k_x^2 + k_y^2)^{1/2}. When we plot spectra for 2D and 3D quantities, we implicitly assume each depends on its respective wavenumber magnitude kk and ignore any anisotropy in each spectrum.

Numerical method

We solve Eq. (3) using the pseudo-spectral code SNOOPY [59, 60] which is a general-purpose code, solving HD and MHD equations, including shear, rotation, weak compressibility, and several other physical effects. The Fourier transforms are computed using the FFTW3 library. Nonlinear terms are computed using a pseudo-spectral algorithm with antialiasing 3/2-rule. The original version of the code has been modified [45] to include precessional forcing and hence variables are decomposed in terms of shearing waves with periodically time-varying wavevector (Eq. (5)) due to the basic shear flow UbU_b induced by precession. In this way, the shearing-periodic boundary conditions in the local domain (which are in fact fully periodic in the frame co-moving with the basic flow) are naturally satisfied in the code.

General features of the precession-driven turbulence

The simulations performed in this paper for different pairs of (Po,Re)(Po,Re) are listed in Table I. All runs start with initial small random noise perturbations of velocity imposed on the basic flow. In Figure 2, we plot the time evolution of the volume-averaged kinetic energy, which is equal to the sum of energies of 2D and 3D modes over all wavenumbers, ⟨E⟩=∑kEk=∑k(E2D+E3D)\langle E\rangle= \sum_k E_k = \sum_k (E_{2D} + E_{3D}), for several precession parameters PoPo and at an intermediate Reynolds number Re=104.5Re = 10^{4.5}. In the initial linear regime, the energy grows exponentially corresponding to dominant 3D inertial waves being excited first by the precessional instability [45, 51, 52, 54] (see inset in Figure 2). In the given range of PoPo, the growth rate of the precession instability increases with PoPo. After about several hundreds of orbital times the exponential growth attains sufficient amplitude for nonlinearity to come into play and cause the instability to saturate with higher amplitudes and shorter saturation times for larger PoPo. Depending on PoPo, the saturated states are qualitatively different, exhibiting statistically steady turbulence at higher Po≳0.1Po \gtrsim0.1 with only minor fluctuations, whereas strong quasi-periodic oscillations (bursts) are observed at small Po≲0.1Po \lesssim0.1 with more than an order of magnitude variations in the kinetic energy. This temporal behavior of the volume-averaged kinetic energy in the nonlinear state of the precessional instability with PoPo is consistent with previous related local studies [36, 45]. Below we interpret this temporal evolution of the total kinetic energy in terms of the dynamics of 2D vortices and 3D waves and their interplay.

Time-evolution of the volume-averaged total kinetic energy for different precession parameters

Figure 2. Time-evolution of the volume-averaged total (2D+3D) kinetic energy for Re=104.5Re = 10^{4.5} and different PoPo. The impact of the precession parameter on the energy evolution is clearly seen, which is characterized by quasi-periodic bursts at small Po=0.075Po = 0.075 and gradually becomes statistically steady turbulence with minor fluctuations and increasing amplitude as PoPo increases. Inset panel zooms in the initial exponential (appearing as linear in logarithmic yy-axis) growth and early saturation phases.

A first comparison between the 2D and 3D mode dynamics is shown in Figure 3 where the evolution of the total kinetic energies for 2D modes, ⟨E2D⟩\langle E_{2D}\rangle, and 3D modes, ⟨E3D⟩\langle E_{3D}\rangle, are plotted for three precession parameters. For larger Po≳0.1Po \gtrsim0.1 the energy of 2D modes is more than one order of magnitude larger than that of 3D modes. However, the saturated value of ⟨E3D⟩\langle E_{3D}\rangle tends to increase more than that of ⟨E2D⟩\langle E_{2D}\rangle with increasing PoPo, implying that the waves, as they should be, are more affected and intensified by precession rather than the vortices. The 2D vortices are linearly stable against precession instability and hence cannot grow due to the latter [52]. They are driven and energetically supplied by waves via nonlinear transfers [45], which will be examined in detail below using the spectral analysis. On the other hand, for the lowest precession parameter Po=0.075Po=0.075, corresponding to the bursty regime, the energy of 3D waves periodically dominates over the 2D vortical mode energy during the growth (burst) phase (referred to as State 1). In this burst phase, waves excited by the precessional instability, lose their energy to 2D vortices due to nonlinearity. As a consequence, the energy of the waves drops by about an order of magnitude (affected additionally by viscous dissipation) relative to the 2D mode energy (State 2). After that it starts to increase again due to precessional instability, closing the cycle. Although 2D mode energy also decreases at this stage, it does so much slower, on a viscous time [45]. This cyclic behavior of both components is remarkable, indicating the quasi-periodic nature of evolution due to weak precessional forcing (Po≲0.1Po\lesssim0.1), which is relevant to astrophysical and geophysical regimes [45, 61, 62]. We explore this behavior in more detail in the spectral analysis section below.

Time-evolution of the volume-averaged kinetic energies for 2D vortices and 3D inertial waves

Figure 3. Time-evolution of the volume-averaged kinetic energies for 2D vortices, ⟨E2D⟩\langle E_{2D}\rangle (solid), and 3D inertial waves, ⟨E3D⟩\langle E_{3D}\rangle (dashed), for Re=104.5Re = 10^{4.5} and three different precession parameters representative of three characteristic regimes shown in Figure 2: bursts at weak (Po=0.075Po = 0.075) and quasi-steady turbulence at medium (Po=0.2Po = 0.2) and strong (Po=0.3Po = 0.3) precessions. Two intervals Δt1\Delta t_1 (from t=2690t = 2690 to t=2770t = 2770) in State 1 and Δt2\Delta t_2 (from t=2880t = 2880 to t=3080t = 3080) in State 2 denote those time intervals over which spectral analysis is performed for these two different states.

Figure 4 shows the structure of the vertical component of vorticity, ωz=(∇×u)z\omega_z=(\nabla\times\boldsymbol{u})_z, in physical space well after the saturation for the above regimes of weak, moderate and strong precessions. The top row shows the case Po=0.075Po=0.075 characterized by bursts. In State 1, which corresponds to the burst of 3D wave energy dominating over that of 2D modes in Figure 3, we therefore observe pronounced 3D wave structures varying along the zz–axis. By contrast, in the State 2, where the wave energy quickly decays afterwards and 2D modes dominate, only vertically uniform columnar vortical structures aligned with the rotation zz-axis are present. At larger Po=0.2Po = 0.2 and Po=0.3Po = 0.3 shown, respectively, in bottom left and right panels of Figure 4, the nonlinear states consist of vortices embedded in 3D waves, coexisting at all times. At medium Po=0.2Po = 0.2, two columnar vortices aligned with the rotation axis with opposite vorticity (cyclonic/anticyclonic) are clearly seen in the small scale waves, whose strength with respect to vortices has increased compared to that in the above bursty regime. At even higher Po=0.3Po = 0.3, the contribution of 3D wave energy is somewhat larger (Figure 3) and therefore small-scale turbulent wave structures are more pronounced with respect to a single 2D vortex.

Snapshots of the vertical component of vorticity in physical space

Figure 4. Snapshot of the vertical component of vorticity, ωz=(∇×u)z\omega_z = (\nabla\times\boldsymbol{u})_z (log-scale), in physical space for three characteristic precession parameters: Po=0.075,0.2,0.3Po = 0.075, 0.2, 0.3 and Re=104.5Re = 10^{4.5} in the saturated state (at t=3000t = 3000). The upper two boxes show the structures in State 1 (left), dominated by vertically-varying 3D inertial waves, and State 2 (right), dominated by 2D vortices nearly uniform along the zz-axis. Large-scale 2D columnar vortices are also evident together with turbulent field of waves at Po=0.2Po = 0.2 and 0.30.3.

The regime diagram in Figure 5 summarizes the properties of all the runs for different pairs (Po,Re)(Po, Re). The colored dots represent the ratio of the time- and volume-averaged energy of 2D vortices, ⟨E2D⟩\langle E_{2D}\rangle, to the total energy of all the modes, ⟨E⟩\langle E\rangle, in the statistically steady turbulent state, as shown in Figure 2 and Figure 3. The empty points represent the cases where the energy drops to negligible value meaning that the local flow in the box is stable against precessional instability. The colors show that at given ReRe, the fraction of 2D mode energy vs. total energy initially increases with PoPo when Po≲0.1Po \lesssim0.1, then reaches a maximum at medium precessions Po∼0.1Po \sim0.1 and decreases at larger Po≳0.1Po \gtrsim0.1. The maximum shifts towards smaller PoPo with increasing ReRe. We will carry out the analysis distinguishing the latter three groups in the following sections.

Regime diagram in the $(Po, Re)$-plane

Figure 5. Regime diagram in the (Po,Re)(Po, Re)-plane. The colors represent the ratio of time-averaged 2D to total (2D+3D) energies, ⟨E2D⟩/⟨E⟩\langle E_{2D}\rangle/\langle E\rangle, in the saturated state, while the empty points correspond to the cases stable to precessional instability when perturbations decay.

Having analyzed the time-development of the mode energies, next in Figure 6 we plot the evolution of the volume-averaged (or equivalently integrated in Fourier space) dynamical terms in Eqs. (13) and (14), i.e., the energy injection, ⟨A⟩=∑kA\langle A\rangle= \sum_k A, for 3D waves (top) and 2D vortical (bottom) modes together with nonlinear transfer terms between them, ⟨NL⟩=∑kNL\langle NL\rangle= \sum_k NL (middle). To obtain a better visualization and a clear trend of temporal evolution, we have smoothed these volume-averaged terms additionally over short time intervals around each time moment, thereby removing fast temporal oscillations and getting meaningful time-averages. For 3D waves, energy injection occurs due to the precession instability and hence increases with increasing precession strength PoPo, while the 2D modes are excited by the nonlinear interaction among these waves via NL3D2DNL_{3D2D} term, which also increases with PoPo. This term is overall positive in time, implying transfer of energy from 3D waves to 2D vortices (see also Ref. [39]). The excited 2D modes in turn also extract energy from the basic flow via positive ⟨A2D⟩>0\langle A_{2D}\rangle> 0 term. Note that ⟨A2D⟩\langle A_{2D}\rangle is not necessarily zero, unlike for the 2D linear modes in the background precessional flow.

Evolution of the volume-averaged dynamical terms for 3D waves and 2D vortices

Figure 6. Evolution of the volume-averaged dynamical terms – energy injection ⟨A⟩\langle A\rangle for 3D waves (top) and 2D vortices (bottom) together with nonlinear transfer ⟨NL2D3D⟩\langle NL_{2D3D}\rangle between these two modes (middle) in corresponding Eqs. (13) and (14) for different PoPo and Re=104.5Re=10^{4.5}.

As a result, the evolution of ⟨A2D⟩\langle A_{2D}\rangle is determined by the nonlinear transfer term ⟨NL2D3D⟩\langle NL_{2D3D}\rangle and hence follows the latter, as it is seen in Figure 6 where the peaks of both these functions nearly coincide. For Po=0.2Po = 0.2, ⟨A2D⟩≈⟨A3D⟩\langle A_{2D}\rangle\approx\langle A_{3D}\rangle (red), while for Po=0.3Po = 0.3, A3D>A2DA_{3D} > A_{2D} (orange curves), indicating that the precession instability feeds the waves, while the waves in turn feed vortices via nonlinear cascade. Below we will see how this process occurs scale by scale in Fourier space.

In Figure 4 we have shown the total vorticity field including both 2D vortices and 3D waves. To better visualize these fields, we computed the inverse Fourier transforms from uˉ2D\bar{u}_{2D} and uˉ3D\bar{u}_{3D} and show respective energy densities in physical space in the saturated regime in Figure 7. The left panels of this figure show energy of 2D modes, where now we can clearly distinguish two vortices for Po=0.2Po = 0.2 (top row) and a single vortex for Po=0.3Po = 0.3 (bottom row). The middle panels show the small-scale 3D mode energies in the (x,y)(x,y)-plane at the central height (z=0z = 0) of the box. There is a noticeable difference between the Po=0.2Po = 0.2 and Po=0.3Po = 0.3 cases: for Po=0.2Po = 0.2 we observe larger-scale wave structures, whereas for Po=0.3Po = 0.3 the wave field is more fluctuating and rich in smaller scales, implying that increasing precession parameter intensifies first of all 3D waves and indirectly vortices due to their nonlinear coupling with the former. Note also that the 3D wave structures are concentrated around the vortices – a feature observed experimentally in a precessing spherical containers [63]. The right panels show the vertical structure of 3D mode energy in the (y,z)(y,z)-plane at the center of vortices (located at x=−0.33x = -0.33 and x=−0.2x = -0.2, respectively, for Po=0.2Po = 0.2 and 0.30.3, which are marked with a green dotted line in the middle row). Again, the Po=0.3Po = 0.3 case shows more fluctuating behavior with fine scales surrounding the column. So, the main dynamical picture consists of the coexisting columnar (geostrophic) vortices and waves whose magnitudes and length-scales depend on the precession strength.

Kinetic energy density of 2D vortices and 3D wave modes

Figure 7. Kinetic energy density of 2D vortices (left panels) and 3D wave modes (taken at z=0z = 0) in the (x,y)(x,y)–plane (middle panels) and in the (y,z)(y,z)–plane (right panels) in the saturated state at Po=0.2Po = 0.2 (top row), Po=0.3Po = 0.3 (bottom row) both with Re=104.5Re = 10^{4.5}. The green dotted line, which is at x=−0.33x = -0.33 for Po=0.2Po = 0.2 and at x=0.2x = 0.2 for Po=0.3Po = 0.3, marks that (y,z)(y,z)–section where 3D energy is plotted.

Spectral Dynamics of Precession-driven turbulence: vortices, waves and their interplay

So far the study has been mainly conducted in the physical (coordinate) space. However, a deeper insight into the precession-driven turbulence dynamics can be gained by investigating the dynamical processes – energy injection, nonlinear transfers and viscous dissipation – in Fourier space, where a much richer dynamical picture unfolds and becomes more accessible to analysis. Following the approach of Refs. [35, 53, 55], we compute and visualize the individual injection AA, viscous dissipation DD and various nonlinear transfer NLNL terms entering spectral energy Eqs. (13) and (14) in Fourier space using the simulation data, and analyze their interplay in different regimes with respect to the precession parameter identified above.

Quasi-periodic bursts: Po = 0.075

As we have seen above, the case with weak precession forcing is characterized by cyclic bursts, where the system alternates between State 1 and State 2 and the purpose of this section is to understand the underlying mechanisms of this behavior. With this goal, we analyze and compare the dynamics in two different intervals shown in Figure 3: Δt1\Delta t_1 corresponding to State 1, when the energy of 3D wave modes initially increases due to precessional instability, while the energy of 2D modes is still at its minimum, and Δt2\Delta t_2 corresponding to State 2, when both 3D and 2D mode energies drop.

The shell-averaged spectra of the linear injection AA and dissipation DD terms for 2D and 3D modes as well as nonlinear transfer terms for 2D-2D, NL2D2DNL_{2D2D}, for 2D-3D, NL2D3DNL_{2D3D} and NL3D2DNL_{3D2D}, and for 3D-3D NL3D3DNL_{3D3D} mode interactions in these two states (also averaged over Δt1\Delta t_1 and Δt2\Delta t_2 time intervals, respectively) are shown in Figure 8. The basic dynamical picture in this regime is the following. In State 1 (top row), the most important contribution is due to A3DA_{3D} (blue), which injects energy into waves from the basic flow due to the initial development of precessional instability. This reaches a large peak at k=8πk = 8\pi whose value is positive and larger than the comparable effects of viscous dissipation D3DD_{3D} (black) and transfer NL2D3DNL_{2D3D} (red), which are both negative reaching a minimum at the same wavenumber. The effect of nonlinear transfers among waves, NL3D3DNL_{3D3D} (green) is relatively small at this time. This also implies that the viscosity is already important at this scale, that is, there is not a good scale separation (inertial range) between the injection and viscous scales. Nevertheless, A3D>0A_{3D} > 0 is sufficiently large to overcome both these negative (sink) terms and give rise to wave growth in State 1. Since NL2D3D<0NL_{2D3D} < 0 at the injection wavenumbers, its counterpart for 2D modes NL3D2D>0NL_{3D2D} > 0, indicating that the waves nonlinearly transfer their energy to and amplify 2D vortices, but at lower wavenumbers near the peak k=2πk = 2\pi of this term. These vortices additionally receive some energy from the basic flow due to the positive A2DA_{2D} (blue) term. However, the dissipation D2D<0D_{2D} < 0 (black curve in top left panel) for vortices is quite high, prevailing over the positive NL3D2DNL_{3D2D} (red) and A2DA_{2D} and as a result vortices do not yet grow at these times.

Shell-averaged spectra for 2D vortical modes and 3D wave modes

Figure 8. Shell-averaged spectra for the injection AA (blue), viscous dissipation DD (black), and nonlinear transfers among modes inside the 2D manifold, NL2D2DNL_{2D2D} (green, left panels), inside 3D manifold NL3D3DNL_{3D3D} (green, right panels) and cross transfers NL3D2DNL_{3D2D} (red, left panels) and NL2D3DNL_{2D3D} (red, right panels) between the modes in these two manifolds. For 2D vortical modes (left panels) and 3D wave modes (right panels) in the State 1 (upper row) and State 2 (bottom row) at Po=0.075Po=0.075 and Re=104.5Re=10^{4.5}.

The nonlinear transfers between waves and vortices, NL3D2DNL_{3D2D} and NL2D3DNL_{2D3D}, increase by absolute value (but retain their signs) with time and already in State 2 the mostly negative NL2D3DNL_{2D3D}, together with dissipation D3D<0D_{3D} < 0, dominates the positive injection A3DA_{3D} (bottom right plot in Figure 8). As a result, wave energy quickly drops in State 2 (see also Figure 3). On the other hand, the 2D vortices, which now receive much more energy from waves via the term NL3D2D>0NL_{3D2D} > 0, also develop an inverse cascade themselves described by NL2D2DNL_{2D2D} (bottom left panel). This is manifested in the emergence of large-scale vortices in physical space in State 2 (top right plot of Figure 4). The injection A2DA_{2D} is relatively small/insignificant at these times. However, dissipation D2DD_{2D} is still larger than the nonlinear replenishment by NL3D2DNL_{3D2D} and consequently the energy of vortices slowly decreases too (which is consistent with Figure 3). Once vortices have become weak enough, the waves can grow again due to the precessional instability and close the cycle loop. Thus, we can conclude that the bursts are caused by a quasi-periodic behavior of 3D dynamical terms which in State 1 with ∑k(A3D+NL3D+D3D)>0\sum_k(A_{3D}+NL_{3D}+D_{3D})>0 leading to wave energy amplification, whereas in State 2 with ∑k(A3D+NL3D+D3D)<0\sum_k(A_{3D}+NL_{3D}+D_{3D})<0 leading to energy decay.

Quasi-steady turbulence: Po=0.2Po=0.2 and 0.3

In this section we present a similar analysis of the dynamical processes in Fourier space, focusing on the regime of large Po=0.2Po=0.2 and 0.3 where the saturated state is characterized by a quasi-steady turbulence, where both 3D and 2D mode energies evolve in time with only mild fluctuations in contrast to the small-PoPo regime displaying quasi-periodic bursts (Figure 3). In this section, we keep the Reynolds number fixed at Re=104.5Re=10^{4.5} to focus on the impact of increasing precession on the spectral properties and dynamical balances of the turbulence.

Energy spectrum

Figure 9 shows the shell-averaged kinetic energy spectra of 2D vortices and 3D waves divided further into horizontal, Eh=(∣uˉx∣2+∣uˉy∣2)/2E_h=(|\bar{u}_x|^2+|\bar{u}_y|^2)/2, and vertical, Ez=∣uˉz∣2/2E_z=|\bar{u}_z|^2/2, components at Po=0.2Po=0.2 (left panel) and 0.3 (right panel). The time-average has been done over Δt≈1000\Delta t\approx1000 in the saturated state. We have checked the robustness of the results by comparing averages over different time ranges and found a good agreement. In this figure, the grey vertical line marks the location of Zeman wavenumber kΩk_{\Omega} defined in the presence of the energy injection due to the precessional instability as kΩ=(Ω3/⟨A2D+A3D⟩)1/2k_\Omega=(\Omega^3/\langle A_{2D}+A_{3D}\rangle)^{1/2} (equal to 1/⟨A2D+A3D⟩1/21/\langle A_{2D}+A_{3D}\rangle^{1/2} in non-dimensional units), where ⟨A2D+A3D⟩\langle A_{2D}+A_{3D}\rangle is the volume-averaged total injection term introduced. This definition of kΩk_\Omega differs from the usual one used in the rotating turbulence theory [31, 34, 64] in that the energy injection rate, ε\varepsilon, due to an external forcing is replaced here by the injection due to the instability but these definitions are consistent in steady state.

Shell-averaged energy spectra for $Po=0.2$ and $Po=0.3$

Figure 9. Shell-averaged energy spectra in a statistically steady turbulent state at Po=0.2Po=0.2 (left), 0.30.3 (right) and Re=104.5Re=10^{4.5}. In both cases, we distinguish between 2D mode energies (solid lines) and 3D mode energies (dashed lines), while the colors represent the total EE (black), horizontal, Eh=(∣uˉx∣2+∣uˉy∣2)/2E_h=(|\bar{u}_x|^2+|\bar{u}_y|^2)/2 (blue) and vertical Ez=∣uˉz∣2/2E_z=|\bar{u}_z|^2/2 (red) components. Grey vertical line shows the location of Zeman scale kΩk_\Omega.

The most remarkable aspect is the different shape and scaling of energy spectra for the 2D and 3D modes. The 2D mode energy dominates over the 3D one at small wavenumbers k≲10k\lesssim10 where it increases with decreasing kk, reaching a maximum at the largest box scale, with its horizontal component being about an order of magnitude larger than the vertical one. This corresponds to large-scale horizontal vortical motions in physical space, as is seen in Figure 4 and Figure 7. At higher 10≲k≲kΩ10 \lesssim k \lesssim k_{\Omega}, the horizontal and vertical components are comparable in the E2DE_{2D} spectrum and its slope is close to k−3k^{-3}, exhibiting the same power-law dependence of rotating geostrophic 2D turbulence [20, 29, 35, 36, 65, 66], which does not appear to change with precession parameter PoPo.

The energy spectrum of 3D waves, E3DE_{3D}, has a peak at larger k≈15k \approx15 than that of E2DE_{2D} (which approximately coincides with the peak of injection A3DA_{3D} in Figure 12). E3DE_{3D} decreases then at lower wavenumbers, while at higher wavenumbers 15≲k≲kΩ15 \lesssim k \lesssim k_{\Omega} follows a scaling ∼k−2±0.5\sim k^{-2\pm0.5} which has been typically observed in forced rotating turbulence of inertial waves [30, 31, 34, 36, 58]. However, in contrast to these papers using a forcing in a very narrow wavenumber band, we do not prescribe the forced wavenumber a priori, instead the injection wavenumbers are determined by the background flow itself through the precessional instability and extend over a broad range (see below). Precession influences the scaling exponent of the E3DE_{3D} spectrum: its slope seems to become shallower with increasing PoPo, as is seen in Figure 9 (compare left and right panels) and 14 below. Like for 2D mode energy, also for 3D mode energy, horizontal and vertical components are comparable at higher wavenumbers, but the horizontal one dominates at lower wavenumbers.

Shell-averaged spectra for injection, viscous dissipation, and nonlinear transfers among 2D and 3D modes

Figure 12. Shell-averaged spectra for the injection AA (blue), viscous dissipation DD (black), and nonlinear transfers among modes inside 2D manifold, NL2D2DNL_{2D2D} (green, left panels), inside 3D manifold NL3D3DNL_{3D3D} (green, right panels) and cross transfers NL3D2DNL_{3D2D} (red, left column) and NL2D3DNL_{2D3D} (red, right panels) between the modes in these two manifolds. For 2D vortical modes (left panels) and 3D wave modes (right panels) in the quasi-steady turbulent state at Po=0.2Po = 0.2 (top row), 0.30.3 (bottom row) and Re=104.5Re = 10^{4.5}. Dotted black vertical line marks the peak of the injection term A3DA_{3D}, while the dash-dotted line the peak of A2DA_{2D}.

It is seen in Figure 9 that the observed power-law scalings of both 2D and 3D mode energy spectra occur at k<kΩk < k_{\Omega} and therefore are strongly influenced by rotation and precession, deviating from the classical Kolmogorov k−5/3k^{-5/3} spectrum. However, as it is seen in this figure, with increasing precession strength PoPo, the Zeman wavenumber kΩk_{\Omega} (grey vertical lines) decreases, that is, the effect of rotation becomes increasingly weaker for smaller and smaller kk. We will see below that in this case the energy spectrum at k>kΩk > k_{\Omega} indeed approaches the Kolmogorov spectrum.

Dynamical balances in Fourier space

To see the structure of spectra of energy and dynamical terms in the quasi-steady precessional turbulence, in Figure 10 and Figure 11 we show the time-averaged spectra of the kinetic energy EE, energy injection AA and the total nonlinear transfer NLNL in two different horizontal (kx,ky)(k_x,k_y)-planes: at kz=0k_z=0 for the 2D modes and at kz=2π/Lzk_z=2\pi/L_z for the 3D wave modes. We have chosen kz=2π/Lzk_z=2\pi/L_z because it corresponds to the maximum injection along kzk_z-axis, for which therefore the precession instability reaches the largest growth rate in the box [50]. The most striking observation is the anisotropic nature of the 2D manifold in Fourier space (top row), for A2DA_{2D} and NL2DNL_{2D} and hence for the kinetic energy spectrum E2DE_{2D} determined by the joint action of these terms, which are all localized at smaller wavenumbers, with a clear inclination towards the kxk_x axes. The injection term A2DA_{2D} is always positive, implying some energy injection from the basic flow into vortices, however, NL2DNL_{2D} is negative at the same wavenumbers for Po=0.2Po=0.2, but changes sign at Po=0.3Po=0.3. As a result, the dynamical balances for 2D modes are different for these two values of PoPo, which will be discussed below. In contrast, the 3D manifold exhibits a quasi-isotropic distribution (bottom row, similarly at larger kz>2π/Lzk_z > 2\pi/L_z not shown here) for both Po=0.2Po=0.2 and 0.30.3, whose range extends over larger wavenumbers than that of 2D quantities. Notice the impact of PoPo on the 3D manifold: for Po=0.2Po = 0.2 a weak preferential direction (anisotropy) is present in the center of the wave-plane which tends to isotropize increasing PoPo. Comparing the A3DA_{3D} and NL3DNL_{3D}, the first injection term, which is due to the precessional instability, is always positive and appreciable at 5<∣kx∣,∣ky∣<255 < \lvert k_x\rvert, \lvert k_y\rvert< 25 (yellow/red area), while the second nonlinear term is negative (blue) and also appreciable at these wavenumbers. The similar shape of these two functions in Fourier space and comparable absolute values, imply that these two processes are in balance: 3D modes receive energy from the precessional background flow predominantly in the range 5<∣kx∣,∣ky∣<255 < \lvert k_x\rvert, \lvert k_y\rvert< 25, while nonlinearity, counteracting injection at these wavenumbers, transfer this energy to other 3D and 2D modes with different wavenumbers. From Figure 10 and Figure 11 showing the distribution of total nonlinear terms NL2DNL_{2D} and NL3DNL_{3D} in Fourier space, one cannot establish specifically what kind of transfer mechanisms operate, that is, whether the cascades inside a given manifold are direct or inverse or if there are transfers of energy between these two manifolds, since these terms encapsulate nonlinear interactions among all kinds of modes. To get insight into the details of linear (energy injection) and nonlinear cascade processes in the precessional turbulence, in Figure 12 we show the shell- and time-averaged spectra of all the dynamical terms – injection AA, nonlinear NLNL and dissipation DD terms – entering Eqs. (13) and (14) again for Po=0.2Po = 0.2 and Po=0.3Po = 0.3, as we did for the bursty case Po=0.075Po = 0.075 in the above section.

Maps of time-averaged spectral energy, injection and nonlinear transfer

Figure 10. Maps of the time-averaged spectral energy EE (left panels), injection AA (middle panels) and the total nonlinear transfer term NLNL (right panels) in the (kx,ky)(k_x,k_y)-plane for 2D vortical modes with kz=0k_z=0 (top row) and 3D wave modes at the first kz=2π/Lzk_z=2\pi/L_z in the box (bottom row) in the quasi-steady turbulent state with Po=0.2Po=0.2 and Re=104.5Re=10^{4.5}. Note the noticeable anisotropy of 2D manifold spectra compared with nearly isotropic spectra of 3D manifold.

Six Fourier-space spectra panels for $Po=0.3$

Figure 11. The same as in Figure 10, but for Po=0.3Po=0.3. Note the change of sign of NL2DNL_{2D} compared to the Po=0.2Po=0.2 case.

The precession instability injects energy into 3D waves, which is described by positive A3DA_{3D} (blue, right panels). Unlike the case of a forcing localized about certain wavenumber [35], the injection due to the instability extends over a range of wavenumbers, reaching a peak at k=6πk = 6\pi, and increases with increasing PoPo. Since it is a quasi-steady state, the energy injection is balanced by nonlinear transfers, A3D+NL3D3D+NL2D3D≈0A_{3D} + NL_{3D3D} + NL_{2D3D} \approx0, at those dynamically active wavenumbers where A3D>0A_{3D}>0 is appreciable (the role of viscous dissipation D3DD_{3D} (black, right panels) is not important at these wavenumbers). Therefore, being negative at those injection wavenumbers, NL3D3D<0NL_{3D3D}<0 (green, left panels) and NL2D3D<0NL_{2D3D}<0 (red, left panels) drain energy from the active 3D modes there and transfer it, respectively, to smaller-scale 3D waves due to positive NL3D3D>0NL_{3D3D}>0 at k>40k>40 (forward/direct cascade) and to 2D vortical modes. The latter process is mediated by positive NL3D2D>0NL_{3D2D}>0 (red, left panels) at k>18k>18, peaking at the same k=6πk=6\pi. At these wavenumbers, 2D-2D transfer term is negative NL2D2D<0NL_{2D2D}<0 (green, left panels), with a minimum also at k=6πk=6\pi, and causes inverse cascade of 2D mode energy to even smaller wavenumbers, where it is positive

Kinetic energy spectra for 3D wave modes

Figure 14. Kinetic energy spectra for 3D wave modes compensated by the Kolmogorov law k−5/3k^{-5/3}. Solid lines represent E3DE_{3D} for three different precession parameters Po=0.2Po=0.2, 0.30.3 and 0.50.5 at Re=104.5Re=10^{4.5}, while the vertical dashed lines represent the corresponding (in terms of colors) Zeman wavenumbers kΩk_{\Omega}. As PoPo is increased, kΩk_{\Omega} decreases and the spectrum approaches Kolmogorov scaling at k>kΩk>k_{\Omega}.

NL2D2D>0NL_{2D2D}>0 and reaches a maximum at k=2πk=2\pi that corresponds to the the largest box scale. These vortices draw some energy from the basic flow as well due to A2DA_{2D} term, which has a peak at the same k=2πk=2\pi as NL2D2D>0NL_{2D2D}>0. It is seen that A2DA_{2D} decreases, whereas NL2D2DNL_{2D2D} increases with PoPo. Notice that in the linear regime, idealized steady 2D vortices would be stable against precessional instability (i.e., A2D=0A_{2D}=0) in the basic flow UbU_b [52], so the positive A2D>0A_{2D}>0 in this case can be attributed to the fact that these vortices are nonlinearly generated by the waves. The 2D-3D nonlinear interaction term NL2D3DNL_{2D3D} is positive at large wavenumbers k>40k>40, redistributing part of energy of 2D large-scale vortices back to smaller-scale 3D waves (forward cascade). Thus, as it is shown from Figure 12 (left panels), similar to that for 3D modes, also for 2D modes, there is a balance among production of these modes by 2D-3D transfers, energy extraction, 2D-2D transfers, and viscous dissipation, A2D+NL2D2D+NL3D2D+D2D≈0A_{2D}+NL_{2D2D}+NL_{3D2D}+D_{2D}\approx0. Note that viscous dissipation for 2D and 3D modes have completely different behavior (compare black curves in left and right panels). It is stronger and more significant for the 2D vortices: D2DD_{2D} has a clear a minimum at low wavenumber k=2πk=2\pi, which coincides with the peak of A2DA_{2D} and NL3D2DNL_{3D2D}, and counteracts these terms, indicating a dissipative nature of the vortices. On the other hand, for 3D modes viscosity is important only at higher k>40k>40, i.e., small scales are dissipative, in contrast to that in the bursty regime, where viscous and injection scales coincide (right panels in Figure 8).

Note that the strength of all the dynamical processes depicted in Figure 12 increases with increasing PoPo. In all cases, the peaks of energy injections into 3D wave modes due to the precessional instability are concentrated at wavenumbers smaller than the corresponding Zeman wavenumber, kin,3D=6π<kΩk_{\mathrm{in},3D}=6\pi<k_{\Omega} (grey vertical lines in Figure 9). As we have seen in the left panels of Figure 12, this injection affects the 2D-3D nonlinear transfer NL3D2DNL_{3D2D}, which describes driving of 2D vortices by 3D wave modes, and also has a maximum at the same kink_{\mathrm{in}}. This is in agreement with the general condition for the upscale/inverse energy cascade of 2D vortices towards wavenumbers smaller than the injection one, i.e. k<kink<k_{\mathrm{in}}, in rotating turbulence [35]. However, in the present case of precessional driving, in the inverse cascade regime, the energy spectrum of 2D modes is slightly steeper than a k−3k^{-3} slope (Figure 9), which is usually observed in the same regime in a purely rotating case.

Overall the above-described processes of nonlinear transfers inside the 3D manifold, inside the 2D manifold, and the coupling between these two manifolds are consistent with previous spectral analysis of turbulence dynamics under rotation and an imposed external forcing [31, 35, 58]. In particular, in Figure 12 we observe the split (simultaneous inverse and forward) cascade of energy typical of rotating turbulence as demonstrated in those papers, that is, forward cascade of 3D wave mode energy to high wavenumbers (small-scales) due to NL3D3DNL_{3D3D} and NL2D3DNL_{2D3D}, and inverse cascade of 2D modes to small wavenumbers (large-scales) due to NL2D2DNL_{2D2D}.

To confirm the overall type (direction) of the nonlinear cascades inferred above on the basis of the nonlinear transfers NLNL as a function of kk, we also analyze shell-to-shell flux of the total energy defined as [31]

F(k)=∑k′≥kNL(k′).(16)F(k)=\sum_{k'\geq k}NL(k'). \tag*{(16)}

Figure 13 shows the resulting flux function F(k)F(k) and, for reference, the wavenumbers kin,2D=2πk_{\mathrm{in},2D}=2\pi and kin,3D=6πk_{\mathrm{in},3D}=6\pi at which the injection terms A2DA_{2D} and A3DA_{3D}, respectively, reach their maximum (Figure 12). The grey line in this figure represents the Zeman wavenumber kΩk_{\Omega}. The shape of the total fluxes are qualitatively similar for Po=0.2Po=0.2 and 0.30.3 and indeed display split/dual cascade: they are positive, F>0F>0, at k>kin,2Dk>k_{\mathrm{in},2D} with a maximum value around k≈50k\approx50, indicating a forward cascade of energy, and negative, F<0F<0, at small wavenumbers k<kin,2Dk<k_{\mathrm{in},2D}, indicating inverse cascade. These forward/inverse cascade regimes deduced from the behavior of the energy flux function F(k)F(k) in fact confirm those found above based on the behavior of the transfer functions in Figure 12. Specifically, the forward cascade at k>kin,2Dk>k_{\mathrm{in},2D}, is related to the transfer of 3D wave mode energy to higher-kk, while the inverse cascade at k<kin,2Dk<k_{\mathrm{in},2D} is related to the transfer of 2D vortical mode energy to smaller-kk.

Precession forcing: a way to isotropic Kolmogorov turbulence

In this section, we draw conclusions on the properties of 3D wave modes which are the ones directly influenced and driven by the precession instability. We have already seen clear indications that these modes exhibit characteristics of isotropy, direct cascade and decreasing the wavenumber range where the rotation is substantially dominant, that is, decreasing the Zeman wavenumber kΩk_{\Omega}, with increasing precession intensity. In order to confirm and generalize these concepts, we run another simulation for quite high precession parameter Po=0.5Po=0.5 and with the same Re=104.5Re=10^{4.5} to check this trend.

Figure 14 shows the spectra of 3D mode energy for the three precession parameters. This time we compensated E3DE_{3D} spectra with the Kolmogorov spectrum k−5/3k^{-5/3} to better see if the energy spectrum approaches the Kolmogorov one. Indeed, it is seen in this figure that increasing PoPo, the Zeman wavenumber decreases and the compensated spectrum at k>kΩk>k_{\Omega} becomes gradually flatter, indicating approach to the Kolmogorov one k−5/3k^{-5/3} already at Po=0.5Po=0.5, that is, the regime of isotropic homogeneous turbulence. Thus, we showed that the rotating-dominated range of wavenumbers k<kΩk<k_{\Omega} is narrowed as PoPo increases because of dramatic decrease in Zeman wavenumbers (e.g., kΩ=103k_{\Omega}=103 for Po=0.2Po=0.2 reducing to kΩ=38k_{\Omega}=38 for Po=0.5Po=0.5). This is also reflected in the behavior of Rossby number at the injection scales Ro=(A2Dkin,2D2+A3Dkin,3D2)1/3/ΩRo=(A_{2D}k_{\mathrm{in},2D}^{2}+A_{3D}k_{\mathrm{in},3D}^{2})^{1/3}/\Omega. Specifically, we have Ro≈0.176Ro\approx0.176 for Po=0.2Po=0.2, Ro≈0.24Ro\approx0.24 for Po=0.3Po=0.3 and Ro=0.32Ro=0.32 for Po=0.5Po=0.5.

Turbulent dissipation

We examine the dissipative nature of the precession-driven turbulent flow. Dissipation rate is an important quantity used in both experiments and numerical works to check global changes in the flow behavior such as hysteresis cycles or transition to turbulence, resulting in noticeable increase of this quantity. Figure 15 plots time-and volume-averaged dissipation term ⟨D⟩\langle D\rangle as a function of PoPo at different ReRe. It is seen in this figure that the turbulent dissipation more depends on PoPo and changes only weakly with ReRe. This result is in agreement with the observations by Goto et al. [67] according to which turbulence properties are mainly governed by PoPo rather than ReRe. At larger Po≳0.1Po \gtrsim0.1, the turbulent dissipation scales with Po3Po^3 in accordance with Ref. [45]. Moreover, around Po≈0.1Po \approx0.1 we observe a jump which is consistent with the global simulation results in cylindrical geometry [68, 69, 70] as well as with the local analysis [45]. This jump is associated with the transition of the bursty regime at Po≲0.1Po \lesssim0.1, dominated by large-scale columnar vortices where waves and hence turbulent dissipation are relatively weak, to the quasi-steady turbulence regime at Po≳0.1Po \gtrsim0.1, where the contribution of small-scale waves is larger leading to efficient dissipation. Therefore, the well-known transition observed in precessing fluid filled cylinders (connected with the hysteresis regime [71]) can be interpreted in light of the results of this work.

Time and volume averaged dissipation as a function of the precession parameter

Figure 15. Time and volume averaged dissipation ⟨D⟩\langle D\rangle as a function of the precession parameter. The various curves represent three different Reynolds numbers and the black solid line is the scaling ∼Po3\sim Po^{3} given for reference. Inset plot zooms into the jump around Po≈0.1Po\approx0.1 in the linear scale associated with the transition from bursty to statistically steady turbulent regimes.

Summary and discussions

In the present work, we have studied the properties of turbulence developed in precession-driven flows by using numerical simulations in the local model with a periodic box. Through an extended data-set of simulations, new results have been obtained concerning the role of precessional forcing modeled as a background flow which injects energy into our local patch. In this case, the precession ratio, or Poincaré number, is a crucial parameter to trigger and sustain a turbulent state in the flow, as observed in global simulations [62, 68, 69, 70] as well as in experiments [63, 71, 72]. Our detailed analysis was motivated mainly by the works of Barker [39, 45] and it was developed both in physical and mainly in Fourier (wavenumber kk-) space. Precessional turbulence is a type of rotating turbulence, where energy injection comes from the precessional instability instead of an externally imposed forcing, and shares several common features with those in the presence of other forcing mechanisms such as the concurrence of waves and geostrophic structures. We have used the 2D-3D manifold decomposition method (where 2D modes have kz=0k_z=0 while 3D ones kz≠0k_z\ne0) to distinguish and quantify the vortices and the waves as used by several authors for other external forcings localized in a narrow band of wavenumbers [29, 35, 36, 49, 58]. By contrast, precessional instability injects energy into turbulence over a broad range of wavenumbers which also modifies the character of nonlinear transfers compared with that in the case of external forcing. We quantified the nonlinear interactions between 3D waves and 2D geostrophic vortices, obtain the spectral scalings and determine the types of cascades in each manifold. We extended the study not just limiting to the shell-averaged approach, generalizing spectral analysis in Fourier space. In this way, we identified the anisotropic structure of these modes. Each phenomena deserves a more extended discussion:

  1. Different states observed: precession forcing is responsible for the appearance of a turbulent state and the magnitude (i.e Poincaré number) determines the flow response. We have identified three different states: quasi-periodic states, characterized by the competition between geostrophic vortex columns and 3D inertial waves at small Po≲0.1Po \lesssim0.1; intermediate states at Po∼0.1Po \sim0.1 with coexisting 2D vortices and 3D waves with comparable amplitudes, and the state dominated by smaller scale waves with some mixture of vortices at high-PoPo. At very small Po<0.05Po < 0.05, our models (with numerically accessible ReRe) are linearly stable against precessional instability and hence turbulence has not been observed.

  1. Bursting evolution: for small precession parameters we observed a cyclic trend of the flow where the vortices appear and disappear periodically. In this regime, the precession instability injects energy in the 3D waves which they transfer directly to vortices due to nonlinearity. However, they decay due to their large dissipative character which is not counteracted by the energy taken from the 3D

waves. This explanation is consistent with the analogous behavior observed for tidal elliptical instability. Indeed the bursty nature of vortices due to viscosity disappears when a hyperviscosity model is adopted, i.e., when dissipation is concentrated only at large wavenumbers [39, 45].

  1. Quasi-steady turbulent states: at moderate and large precession parameters the essential dynamical picture and balances in the precessional-driven turbulence is described in Figure 16 and can be summarized as follows. The precession background flow is unstable to precession instability, whose nonlinear development causes transition to sustained turbulence. In this state, the instability injects energy in the 3D waves, which in turn, is transferred partly to 2D vortices and partly dissipated at small scales through a forward cascade. The 2D vortices receive energy from 3D waves and at the same time they interact with the background flow. These vortices are subjected to inverse cascade which is balanced by dissipation at large scales. Their energy spectra scales as E(k)∼k−3E(k) \sim k^{-3} reminiscent of the typical geostrophic turbulence while 3D waves have E(k)∼k−2±0.5E(k) \sim k^{-2\pm0.5} as found in several works on the forced turbulence [34, 49]. The small differences in this scalings can be attributed to the influence of precession. Overall, we observe a so-called split, or dual cascade: inverse cascade for 2D vortices and direct cascade for 3D waves. The borderline between these two types of cascade occurs near the peak of energy injection for 2D vortices (see e.g., Figure 13).

Total energy flux for $Po=0.2$ and $Po=0.3$

Figure 13. Total energy flux F(k)F(k) with the vertical lines representing, for reference, the wave numbers kin,2D=2πk_{\mathrm{in},2D}=2\pi (dashed-dotted) and kin,3D=6πk_{\mathrm{in},3D}=6\pi (dotted) at the peak of the injection, respectively, for 2D and 3D modes as well as the Zeman wavenumber kΩk_{\Omega} (solid grey). Top panel is for Po=0.2Po=0.2 and bottom for Po=0.3Po=0.3. The flux is predominantly positive, F>0F>0, for larger wavenumbers k>kin,2Dk>k_{\mathrm{in},2D} corresponding to forward cascade. Inset zooms into the inverse cascade range at small kk, where F<0F<0.

Figure 16. Sketch of the main mechanism underlying precession-driven turbulence.

In any case, the 2D vortices represent condensates that gain energy from smaller-scale waves without dissipating it at the same rate [73]. Consistent with what was observed by Smith et al. [29] the vortices are produced mainly by the energy transfer from 3D waves and grow in size by the 2D inverse cascade; this is a clear indication of strongly nonlinear phenomena at moderate Rossby numbers, Ro∼0.1Ro \sim0.1. By contrast, the weakly nonlinear wave theory at small Ro≪1Ro \ll1 prohibits the interaction of geostrophic vortical mode and waves [30] allowing only resonant triads between fast 3D wave modes. This scenario, sometimes called Greenspan’s theorem [28] has led to the idea that the geostrophic flows in precessing cylinders can arise only by the nonlinear interaction in the Ekman layers at the endcaps, that is a purely boundary effect [74, 75, 76] Our local model, which by definition has no boundary layers, proves that this condition in fact is not necessary, since vortices can arise also in unbounded precessional flows for moderate RoRo. In this regard, our results are also important in relation to the recent work by Leroux [43] who showed that the inertial waves can excite the geostrophic mode through an instability driven by near-resonant triadic nonlinear interactions.

The anisotropic nature of 2D vortices is demonstrated by two aspects: they have a preferential direction with the substantial part of energy being horizontal; from a spectral point of view the kinetic energy, injection and nonlinear transfer have a preferential direction in (kx,ky)(k_x,k_y)—plane.

  1. The role of precession parameter PoPo: the precession, as other forcing mechanisms, counteracts the effects of rotation. This fact has been shown through several phenomena: the larger the precession ratio the stronger the 3D waves, thereby the flow is more isotropic and the vortices are weaker. The Zeman scale decreases with the precession ratio and this means that the range of rotationally-dominated wavenumbers is reduced, extending the inertial range (characterized by the direct cascade), while the range of wavenumbers where inverse cascade occurs shrinks. Finally, the increase of precession parameter brings the spectral law for 3D energy from k−2k^{-2} to the classical Kolmogorov k−5/3k^{-5/3}. This kind of shift was proposed initially by Zhou [77] but for the transition from strong rotation to non-rotation.

Importance of this study in the context of global simulations, laboratory experiments and geophysical applications

Even though our simple model is based on a local version of the Poincaré flow (which is typical of spheroidal containers), some similarities with the global cases has been found. For instance, the dissipation shows a quite steep jump around an intermediate precession parameter Po∼0.1Po \sim0.1 consistent with the transition to turbulence observed in global simulations [62, 67, 68, 69, 70] and experiments [71, 78]. Moreover, the presence of a geostrophic flow which dominates the bulk region is a hallmark of precessing cylinders at rather large PoPo [68, 79, 80] and could correspond to 2D vortices in our local model. At large precession parameters Po≳0.1Po \gtrsim0.1, the turbulent dissipation scales as Po3Po^3 as found already in Ref. [45] and this fact somehow challenges the analytical results by Kerswell [81] where an upper bound on dissipation for fluid filled precessing container has been claimed to be independent of PoPo. The knowledge of the dissipation behavior at strong precession is crucial to predict the power required to drive the experimental facilities. The coexistence of vortices and small-scale 3D waves has been observed in a precessing sphere by Horimoto et al. [63], however, they argue that large vortices sustain small-scale eddies through a forward cascade. This conflicts in part with our scenario since the precession injects energy directly into small-scale 3D waves, which in turn nonlinearly transfer energy to 2D vortices. Therefore, in our model, precession itself sustains small-scale waves. One of the main goals of this work was to put a theoretical basis for the analysis of turbulence properties in precession-driven flows in the context of the upcoming DRESDYN (DREsden Sodium facility for DYNamo and thermohydraulic studies) precession experiment [82, 83, 84]. This motivates the interest in the moderate to large PoPo, which are different from the ones of geophysical and astrophysical objects. However, some speculations can be made since the different regimes observed here at Re=104.5Re = 10^{4.5} may carry over to large-ReRe regime too. Because of normally weak precession of geo- and astrophysical objects, we can speculate that they would be also characterized by the bursty behavior as described in Section IV A. If this is the case, it would influence the planetary evolution, producing a series of formation and destruction events (bursts) of vortices due to the nonlinear transfer between 2D and 3D flows and oscillating dissipation.

Let us finish with some discussions related to the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) dynamo effect. It has been demonstrated numerically that precession can in general drive dynamo [85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91]. Within our local model, we can further investigate the properties of MHD turbulence and related dynamo action and how the magnetic field, when sufficiently strong, influences the studied here 2D and 3D flows. The work by Barker [45] indicates that the precession instability is able in principle to drive dynamo action locally and the turbulent flow dynamics changes completely due to the back-reaction of the magnetic field.

Acknowledgments

This project has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (grant agreement No 787544). AJB was funded by STFC grants ST/S000275/1 and ST/W000873/1.

References

References

  1. [1]S. A. Barnes, An assessment of the rotation rates of the host stars of extrasolar planets, The Astrophysical Journal 561, 1095 (2001).DOI
  2. [2]J. Y.-K. Cho, K. Menou, B. M. S. Hansen, and S. Seager, Atmospheric circulation of close-in extrasolar giant planets. i. global, barotropic, adiabatic simulations, The Astrophysical Journal 675, 817 (2008).arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0607338
  3. [3]E. Knobloch and M. R. E. Proctor, Nonlinear periodic convection in double-diffusive systems, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 108, 291–316 (1981).
  4. [4]J. P. Zahn, Circulation and turbulence in rotating stars., A and A 265, 115 (1992).
  5. [5]H. Dumitrescu and V. Cardos, Rotational effects on the boundary-layer flow in wind turbines, AIAA Journal 42, 408 (2004).DOI
  6. [6]X. He, A. Bragg, Y. Xiong, and P. Fischer, Turbulence and heat transfer on a rotating, heated half soap bubble, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 924, A19 (2021).DOI
  7. [7]E. J. Hopfinger, F. K. Browand, and Y. Gagne, Turbulence and waves in a rotating tank, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 125, 505–534 (1982).DOI
  8. [8]P. J. Staplehurst, P. A. Davidson, and S. B. Dalziel, Structure formation in homogeneous freely decaying rotating turbulence, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 598, 81–105 (2008).DOI
  9. [9]C. Lamriben, P.-P. Cortet, and F. Moisy, Direct measurements of anisotropic energy transfers in a rotating turbulence experiment, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 024503 (2011).DOI
  10. [10]A. Campagne, B. Gallet, F. Moisy, and P.-P. Cortet, Direct and inverse energy cascades in a forced rotating turbulence experiment, Physics of Fluids 26, 125112 (2014).
  11. [11]B. Gallet, A. Campagne, P.-P. Cortet, and F. Moisy, Scale-dependent cyclone-anticyclone asymmetry in a forced rotating turbulence experiment, Physics of Fluids 26, 035108 (2014).DOI
  12. [12]A. Campagne, B. Gallet, F. Moisy, and P.-P. Cortet, Disentangling inertial waves from eddy turbulence in a forced rotating-turbulence experiment, Phys. Rev. E 91, 043016 (2015).DOI
  13. [13]R. P. J. Kunnen, H. J. H. Clercx, and B. J. Geurts, Vortex statistics in turbulent rotating convection, Phys. Rev. E 82, 036306 (2010).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21230170
  14. [14]H. J. S. Fernando, R.-R. Chen, and D. L. Boyer, Effects of rotation on convective turbulence, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 228, 513–547 (1991).DOI
  15. [15]J. Bardina, J. H. Ferziger, and R. S. Rogallo, Effect of rotation on isotropic turbulence: computation and modelling, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 154, 321–336 (1985).DOI
  16. [16]N. Mansour, C. Cambon, and C. Speziale, Single point modeling of initially isotropic turbulence under uniform rotation, Annual Research Briefs, 1991 , 159 (1991).
  17. [17]N. Mansour, C. Cambon, and C. Speziale, Theoretical and computational study of rotating isotropic turbulence, in Studies in turbulence (Springer, 1992) pp. 59–75.DOI
  18. [18]M. Hossain, Reduction in the dimensionality of turbulence due to a strong rotation, Physics of Fluids 6, 1077 (1994).DOI
  19. [19]P. K. Yeung and Y. Zhou, Numerical study of rotating turbulence with external forcing, Physics of Fluids 10, 2895 (1998).DOI
  20. [20]L. M. Smith, J. R. Chasnov, and F. Waleffe, Crossover from two- to three-dimensional turbulence, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 2467 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10061961
  21. [21]Q. Chen, S. Chen, G. L. Eyink, and D. D. Holm, Intermittency in the joint cascade of energy and helicity, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 214503 (2003).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12786558
  22. [22]K. D. Squires, J. R. Chasnov, N. N. Mansour, and C. Cambon, Investigation of the asymptotic state of rotating turbulence using large-eddy simulation, in Annual Research Briefs, 1992 (1993) pp. 157–170.
  23. [23]P. Bartello, O. Métais, and M. Lesieur, Coherent structures in rotating three-dimensional turbulence, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 273, 1–29 (1994).DOI
  24. [24]X. Yang and J. A. Domaradzki, Large eddy simulations of decaying rotating turbulence, Physics of Fluids 16, 4088 (2004).DOI
  25. [25]L. Elena and R. Schiestel, Turbulence modeling of rotating confined flows, International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow 17, 283 (1996).
  26. [26]P. Spalart and M. Shur, On the sensitization of turbulence models to rotation and curvature, Aerospace Science and Technology 1, 297 (1997).DOI
  27. [27]H. P. Greenspan, The theory of Rotating Fluids, Cambridge Monographs on Mechanics (Cambridge University Press, 1968).
  28. [28]H. P. Greenspan, On the non-linear interaction of inertial modes, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 36, 257–264 (1969).DOI
  29. [29]L. M. Smith and F. Waleffe, Transfer of energy to two-dimensional large scales in forced, rotating three-dimensional turbulence, Physics of Fluids 11, 1608 (1999).DOI
  30. [30]S. Galtier, Weak inertial-wave turbulence theory, Phys. Rev. E 68, 015301 (2003).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12935189
  31. [31]A. Alexakis and L. Biferale, Cascades and transitions in turbulent flows, physrep 767, 1 (2018).DOI
  32. [32]M. Brunet, B. Gallet, and P.-P. Cortet, Shortcut to geostrophy in wave-driven rotating turbulence: The quartetic instability, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 124501 (2020).DOI
  33. [33]T. Le Reun, B. Gallet, B. Favier, and M. Le Bars, Near-resonant instability of geostrophic modes: beyond greenspan’s theorem, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 900, R2 (2020).
  34. [34]W.-C. Müller and M. Thiele, Scaling and energy transfer in rotating turbulence, Europhysics Letters (EPL) 77, 34003 (2007).DOI
  35. [35]M. Buzzicotti, H. Aluie, L. Biferale, and M. Linkmann, Energy transfer in turbulence under rotation, Phys. Rev. Fluids 3, 034802 (2018).
  36. [36]A. Khilfi, A. Salhi, S. Nasraoui, F. Godeferd, and C. Cambon, Spectral energy scaling in precessing turbulence, Phys. Rev. E 98, 011102 (2018).
  37. [37]A. M. Rubio, K. Julien, E. Knobloch, and J. B. Weiss, Upscale energy transfer in three-dimensional rapidly rotating turbulent convection, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 144501 (2014).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24765971
  38. [38]E. Knobloch, Rotating convection: recent developments, International Journal of Engineering Science 36, 1421 (1998).
  39. [39]A. J. Barker and Y. Lithwick, Non-linear evolution of the tidal elliptical instability in gaseous planets and stars, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 435, 3614 (2013).DOI
  40. [40]B. Favier, A. M. Grannan, M. Le Bars, and J. M. Aurnou, Generation and maintenance of bulk turbulence by libration-driven elliptical instability, Physics of Fluids 27, 066601 (2015).DOI
  41. [41]A. J. Barker, Non-linear tides in a homogeneous rotating planet or star: global simulations of the elliptical instability, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 459, 939 (2016).DOI
  42. [42]T. Le Reun, B. Favier, A. J. Barker, and M. Le Bars, Inertial wave turbulence driven by elliptical instability, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 034502 (2017).
  43. [43]T. Le Reun, B. Favier, and M. Le Bars, Experimental study of the nonlinear saturation of the elliptical instability: inertial wave turbulence versus geostrophic turbulence, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 879, 296–326 (2019).
  44. [44]A. J. Barker and G. I. Ogilvie, On internal wave breaking and tidal dissipation near the centre of a solar-type star, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 404, 1849 (2010).DOI
  45. [45]A. J. Barker, On turbulence driven by axial precession and tidal evolution of the spin–orbit angle of close-in giant planets, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 460, 2339 (2016).DOI
  46. [46]T. Le Reun, B. Favier, and M. Le Bars, Parametric instability and wave turbulence driven by tidal excitation of internal waves, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 840, 498–529 (2018).
  47. [47]C. Morize, M. Le Bars, P. Le Gal, and A. Tilgner, Experimental determination of zonal winds driven by tides, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 214501 (2010).
  48. [48]A. Tilgner, Zonal wind driven by inertial modes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 194501 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18233079
  49. [49]A. Salhi, A. Khilfi, and C. Cambon, Nonlinear effects on the precessional instability in magnetized turbulence, Atmosphere 11 (2020).DOI
  50. [50]A. Salhi and C. Cambon, Precessing rotating flows with additional shear: Stability analysis, Phys. Rev. E 79, 036303 (2009).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19392045
  51. [51]R. M. Mason and R. R. Kerswell, Chaotic dynamics in a strained rotating flow: a precessing plane fluid layer, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 471, 71–106 (2002).DOI
  52. [52]R. R. Kerswell, The instability of precessing flow, Geophysical & Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics 72, 107 (1993).DOI
  53. [53]G. Mamatsashvili, G. Khujadze, G. Chagelishvili, S. Dong, J. Jiménez, and H. Foysi, Dynamics of homogeneous shear turbulence: A key role of the nonlinear transverse cascade in the bypass concept, Phys. Rev. E 94, 023111 (2016).DOI
  54. [54]M. M. Naing and Y. Fukumoto, Local instability of a rotating flow driven by precession of arbitrary frequency, Fluid Dynamics Research 43, 055502 (2011).
  55. [55]G. R. Mamatsashvili, D. Z. Gogichaishvili, G. D. Chagelishvili, and W. Horton, Nonlinear transverse cascade and two-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic subcritical turbulence in plane shear flows, Phys. Rev. E 89, 043101 (2014).DOI
  56. [56]K. Seshasayanan and B. Gallet, Onset of three-dimensionality in rapidly rotating turbulent flows, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 901, R5 (2020).DOI
  57. [57]L. Biferale, M. Buzzicotti, and M. Linkmann, From two-dimensional to three-dimensional turbulence through two-dimensional three-component flows, Physics of Fluids 29, 111101 (2017).DOI
  58. [58]L. Biferale, F. Bonaccorso, I. M. Mazzitelli, M. A. T. van Hinsberg, A. S. Lanotte, S. Musacchio, P. Perlekar, and F. Toschi, Coherent structures and extreme events in rotating multiphase turbulent flows, Phys. Rev. X 6, 041036 (2016).
  59. [59]G. Lesur and P.-Y. Longaretti, On the relevance of sub-critical hydrodynamic turbulence to accretion disk transport, A&A 444, 25 (2005).
  60. [60]G. Lesur and P.-Y. Longaretti, Impact of dimensionless numbers on the efficiency of magnetorotational instability induced turbulent transport, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 378, 1471 (2007).DOI
  61. [61]M. Le Bars, D. Cébron, and P. Le Gal, Flows driven by libration, precession, and tides, Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 47, 163 (2015).
  62. [62]D. Cébron, R. L. Aguierre, J. Noir, and N. Schaeffer, Precessing spherical shells: flows, dissipation, dynamo and the lunar core, Geophysical Journal International 219, S34 (2019).
  63. [63]Y. Horimoto and S. Goto, Sustaining mechanism of small-scale turbulent eddies in a precessing sphere, Phys. Rev. Fluids 2, 114603 (2017).
  64. [64]O. Zeman, A note on the spectra and decay of rotating homogeneous turbulence, Physics of Fluids 6, 3221 (1994).DOI
  65. [65]A. Sen, P. D. Mininni, D. Rosenberg, and A. Pouquet, Anisotropy and nonuniversality in scaling laws of the large-scale energy spectrum in rotating turbulence, Phys. Rev. E 86, 036319 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23031025
  66. [66]A. Pouquet, A. Sen, D. Rosenberg, P. D. Mininni, and J. Baerenzung, Inverse cascades in turbulence and the case of rotating flows, Physica Scripta Volume T 155, 014032 (2013).arxiv.org/abs/1203.0337
  67. [67]S. Goto, A. Matsunaga, M. Fujiwara, M. Nishioka, S. Kida, M. Yamato, and S. Tsuda, Turbulence driven by precession in spherical and slightly elongated spheroidal cavities, Physics of Fluids 26, 055107 (2014).DOI
  68. [68]D. Kong, Z. Cui, X. Liao, and K. Zhang, On the transition from the laminar to disordered flow in a precessing spherical-like cylinder, Geophysical & Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics 109, 62 (2015).DOI
  69. [69]F. Pizzi, A. Giesecke, and F. Stefani, Ekman boundary layers in a fluid filled precessing cylinder, AIP Advances 11, 035023 (2021).DOI
  70. [70]F. Pizzi, A. Giesecke, J. Šimkanin, and F. Stefani, Prograde and retrograde precession of a fluid-filled cylinder, New Journal of Physics 23, 123016 (2021).DOI
  71. [71]J. Herault, T. Gundrum, A. Giesecke, and F. Stefani, Subcritical transition to turbulence of a precessing flow in a cylindrical vessel, Physics of Fluids 27, 124102 (2015).DOI
  72. [72]S. Goto, A. Matsunaga, M. Fujiwara, M. Nishioka, S. Kida, M. Yamato, and S. Tsuda, Turbulence driven by precession in spherical and slightly elongated spheroidal cavities, Physics of Fluids 26, 055107 (2014).DOI
  73. [73]G. Boffetta and R. E. Ecke, Two-dimensional turbulence, Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 44, 427 (2012).DOI
  74. [74]D. Kong, X. Liao, and K. Zhang, The sidewall-localized mode in a resonant precessing cylinder, Physics of Fluids 26, 051703 (2014).DOI
  75. [75]K. Zhang and X. Liao, Theory and Modeling of Rotating Fluids: Convection, Inertial Waves and Precession, Cambridge Monographs on Mechanics (Cambridge University Press, 2017).
  76. [76]P. Meunier, C. Eloy, R. Lafrange, and F. Nadal, A rotating fluid cylinder subject to weak precession, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 599, 405–440 (2008).DOI
  77. [77]Y. Zhou, A phenomenological treatment of rotating turbulence, Physics of Fluids 7, 2092 (1995).DOI
  78. [78]W. V. R. Malkus, Precession of the earth as the cause of geomagnetism, Science 160, 259 (1968).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17788230
  79. [79]J. J. Kobine, Azimuthal flow associated with inertial wave resonance in a precessing cylinder, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 319, 387–406 (1996).DOI
  80. [80]J. Jiang, D. Kong, R. Zhu, and K. Zhang, Precessing cylinders at the second and third resonance: Turbulence controlled by geostrophic flow, Phys. Rev. E 92, 033007 (2015).DOI
  81. [81]R. R. Kerswell, Upper bounds on the energy dissipation in turbulent precession, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 321, 335–370 (1996).DOI
  82. [82]A. Giesecke, F. Stefani, T. Gundrum, G. Gerbeth, C. Nore, and J. Léorat, Experimental realization of dynamo action: present status and prospects, Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union 8, 411–416 (2012).DOI
  83. [83]F. Stefani, S. Eckert, G. Gerbeth, A. Giesecke, T. Gundrum, C. Steglich, T. Weier, and B. Wustmann, A new facility for mhd experiments with liquid sodium, Magnetohydrodynamics 48, 103 (2012).arxiv.org/abs/1201.5737
  84. [84]F. Stefani, A. Gailitis, G. Gerbeth, A. Giesecke, T. Gundrum, G. Rüdiger, M. Seilmayer, and T. Vogt, The dresdyn project: liquid metal experiments on dynamo action and magnetorotational instability, Geophysical & Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics 113, 51 (2019).DOI
  85. [85]A. Tilgner, Precession driven dynamos, Physics of Fluids 17, 034104 (2005).DOI
  86. [86]C.-C. Wu and P. H. Roberts, On a dynamo driven by topographic precession, Geophysical & Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics 103, 467 (2009).DOI
  87. [87]C. Nore, J. Léorat, J.-L. Guermond, and F. Luddens, Nonlinear dynamo action in a precessing cylindrical container, Phys. Rev. E 84, 016317 (2011).DOI
  88. [88]L. Cappanera, J.-L. Guermond, J. Léorat, and C. Nore, Two spinning ways for precession dynamo, Phys. Rev. E 93, 043113 (2016).DOI
  89. [89]A. Giesecke, T. Vogt, T. Gundrum, and F. Stefani, Nonlinear large scale flow in a precessing cylinder and its ability to drive dynamo action, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 024502 (2018).DOI
  90. [90]O. Goepfert and A. Tilgner, Dynamos in precessing cubes, New Journal of Physics 18, 103019 (2016).DOI
  91. [91]Y. Lin, P. Marti, J. Noir, and A. Jackson, Precession-driven dynamos in a full sphere and the role of large scale cyclonic vortices, Physics of Fluids 28, 066601 (2016).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_exrx8h8v
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents