betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Millimeter-Wavelength Constraints on Circular Polarization of the Cosmic Microwave Background at Arcminute Scales with the Simons Array

Abstract

We present constraints on the cosmic microwave background (CMB) circular polarization anisotropy at arcminute angular scales, using dedicated measurements from the Simons Array taken with a quarter-wave plate and rotating half-wave plate. A detection of circular polarization in the CMB would probe a range of proposed generation mechanisms, from Standard Model astrophysics to physics beyond it. At an observing frequency of 90 GHz, we place constraints over the multipole range 300≤ℓ≤2000300 \leq \ell \leq 2000, corresponding to angular scales of 5.4-36 arcmin, in bands of width Δℓ=100Δ\ell = 100, roughly tripling the highest multipole previously reached by a VV-mode power spectrum measurement. Within this domain, we constrain the 95% confidence upper bound of ℓ(ℓ+1)CℓVV/(2π)\ell (\ell+1) C_\ell^{VV} / (2π) to range from ∼22 μKCMB2\sim 22\,μ\mathrm{K}_\mathrm{CMB}^2 at the ℓ=350\ell = 350 bandpower to ∼3.5×103 μKCMB2\sim 3.5 \times 10^3\,μ\mathrm{K}_\mathrm{CMB}^2 at the ℓ=1950\ell = 1950 bandpower. These limits are derived from ∼\sim2.5 months of observations of each of two small regions of the sky located away from the Galactic plane, totaling ∼\sim12 deg2^2 of effective sky area. Because the methodology of this study marginalizes known foreground contamination, these bounds serve as robust, conservative limits on the true CMB circular polarization signal down to the sensitivity limits of the instrument. Additionally, we provide an experimental and analytical framework for implementing circular polarization observations on other telescopes by utilizing a quarter-wave plate and half-wave plate design.

Introduction

The cosmic microwave background (CMB) is a mostly unpolarized blackbody radiation signal which is the most distant detectable direct evidence of the Big Bang and its immediate aftermath. Understanding how the post-Big Bang events affect the CMB signal is one of the foremost ongoing scientific goals in the field of cosmology, and experiments have constrained the temperature anisotropies at both small and large angular scales [11, 61, 6, 47]. Most contemporary experiments measuring the CMB focus on characterizing the linear polarization (EE and BB-modes), which can shed light on inflationary physics and other early-Universe phenomena [28, 68] (W. Hu & M. White 1997). The standard cosmological model, Lambda cold dark matter (ΛCDM), predicts a measurable linear polarization signal, but no appreciable circular polarization in the CMB. However, there are several potential secondary mechanisms that could produce it.

Before decoupling, a primordial magnetic field acting on the cold pre-decoupling plasma sources VV modes in the presence of adiabatic curvature perturbations [21]. After decoupling, the most studied channel is Faraday conversion, whereby a magnetic field threading a relativistic plasma converts pre-existing linear polarization, considered both for magnetized galaxy clusters [10] and for the supernova remnants of Population III (Pop. III) stars (S. De & H. Tashiro 2015). Circular polarization may also be generated after decoupling through scattering of CMB photons off the cosmic neutrino background (CνB) [39] and through the nonlinear photon–photon interactions of the Euler–Heisenberg effective Lagrangian [56, 40]. A smaller set of proposals instead invokes physics beyond the Standard Model, coupling photons to an external vector field through a Chern–Simons term [1] or to a cosmological pseudoscalar field acting as dark matter [17]. A comprehensive summary of these origins is provided by S. King & P. Lubin [30]. Distinct from all of these are foregrounds, which emit circular polarization of their own rather than acting on CMB photons. Galactic components, such as synchrotron and thermal dust emission, are not expected to contribute appreciably at 90 GHz [30]. The far brighter atmospheric signal, produced by Zeeman splitting of molecular oxygen, is dominant at larger angular scales than those within this study’s scope [42, 19], and is in any case removed by the filtering described in § 4.2. A diffuse signal observed here would therefore be dominated by converted CMB photons, and we refer to it as CMB circular polarization throughout.

Observational upper limits on the circular polarization anisotropy of the CMB have historically spanned disparate angular scales and employed varied instrumental techniques. The earliest came from Very Large Array (VLA) interferometry at 5 GHz, whose highly localized measurements constrained the root-mean-square fractional circular polarization to ΔV/T≤6.3×10−5\Delta V/T \leq6.3 \times10^{-5}, or ∼173 μKCMB\sim173\,\mu\mathrm{K}_{\mathrm{CMB}} at the widest synthesized beam, on scales 60′′≤θ≤160′′60'' \leq\theta\leq160'' [44]. On much larger angular scales, the Milano Polarimeter (MIPOL) utilized a correlation receiver at 33 GHz to set constraints at scales of 8∘8^\circ to 24∘24^\circ, bounding the VV-mode power spectrum at the level of 105 μKCMB210^5\,\mu\mathrm{K}_{\mathrm{CMB}}^2 [35]. The SPIDER balloon-borne experiment significantly improved these large-scale constraints at 95 GHz and 150 GHz; by leveraging nonidealities in their half-wave plate polarization modulators, SPIDER placed upper limits on scales <10∘<10^\circ at the level of 102 μKCMB210^2\,\mu\mathrm{K}_{\mathrm{CMB}}^2 [41]. Most recently, the Cosmology Large Angular Scale Surveyor (CLASS) achieved a direct measurement of circular polarization at 40 GHz using a Variable-delay Polarization Modulator. After characterizing and filtering a bright atmospheric oxygen dipole at the level of (124±4) μK(124 \pm4)\,\mu\mathrm{K}, CLASS established the tightest limits at the time on the large-scale CMB circular polarization power spectrum [42]. That analysis has since been extended to the CLASS 90 GHz, 150 GHz and 220 GHz bands, improving the large-scale limits by a factor of ∼5\sim5 and reaching ℓ=700\ell= 700 [14].

In this paper, we present new millimeter-wavelength constraints on the circular polarization of the CMB using data from the PolarBear-2b (PB-2b) receiver of the Simons Array, the successor telescope to PolarBEAR. This study presents a novel approach to efficiently measuring circular polarization, using a stationary quarter-wave plate (QWP) positioned in front of a constantly spinning half-wave plate (HWP). The technique is available to any experiment already operating linear polarization sensitive detectors and a rotating HWP, along with established CMB mapmaking and power spectrum estimation analysis tools. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: § 2 describes the instrument, optical configuration, and observations; § 3 describes the calibration techniques; § 4 details the data analysis pipeline and our systematic error characterization; § 5 presents our unblinded limits; and we conclude in § 6.

Instrument and Observations

The measurements presented in this work utilize data collected by the PB-2b receiver, the second deployed receiver of the Simons Array [4, 62, 60], located in the Atacama Desert in Chile. It features a continuously rotating cryogenic HWP [23] to modulate incoming polarization and systematically suppress low-frequency atmospheric noise. In this section, we detail the optical and cryogenic architecture of the receiver, the properties of the transition-edge sensor (TES) bolometer array, and the specific observational campaigns that form the basis of our circular polarization constraints.

The POLARBEAR-2b Receiver

The Simons Array is located at an altitude of 5200 m in the Atacama Desert in Chile. The PB-2b receiver was mounted on an off-axis Gregorian telescope featuring a 2.5-meter primary mirror aperture [62, 38], shown in Figure 1. The PB-2b focal plane consists of 7,588 TESs coupled to dichroic, dual-polarization pixels utilizing lenslet-coupled sinuous antennas, providing sensitivity to radiation at 90 GHz and 150 GHz [67] (however, only 90 GHz is utilized for this study as explained in § 2.2), so chosen to avoid foregrounds, specifically atmospheric absorption bands and Galactic synchrotron radiation at lower frequencies. The detectors are read out using a 40×\times digital frequency-domain multiplexing (DfMUX) system [5]. The focal plane detectors are split into QQ-pixels and UU-pixels, while the latter are rotated by 45° from the former.

Schematics describing the setup of PB-2b

Figure 1. Schematics describing the setup of PB-2b. Left: Telescope receiver mounted, with the waved orange arrow indicating path of light rays as they travel across the two mirrors, through the QWP, and into the receiver. Right: Interior of the receiver, with the path traced through the QWP at ambient air temperature, through the cold HWP (CHWP), lenses and filters, and into the detectors on the focal plane. The QWP is placed 15 cm from the vacuum window.

Following the initial deployment of the PB-2b receiver to the Simons Array in 2022, the instrument’s baseline optical performance and readout electronics were successfully validated [34, 54]. However, in-field evaluations determined that the on-sky sensitivity did not reach the initial design targets. The median detector noise-equivalent temperature (NET) for PB-2b at 90 GHz is ∼3000 μKCMBs\sim3000\,\mu\mathrm{K}_{\mathrm{CMB}}\sqrt{\mathrm{s}}, against a design value of 360 μKCMBs360\,\mu\mathrm{K}_{\mathrm{CMB}}\sqrt{\mathrm{s}}, a loss driven by low optical throughput and elevated readout noise [15]. Furthermore, overall detector performance was hampered by an excess noise component that is strongly suspected to originate from environmental radio frequency (RF) interference at the observing site [15]. This characterization predates the installation of the QWP of § 2.2, whose ∼13%\sim13\% transmission loss [55] further degrades the effective sensitivity of the observations presented here. Regardless, the elevated instrument noise primarily propagates as statistical uncertainty rather than as a systematic bias.

Polarization Modulators

To modulate the incoming celestial polarization above unpolarized 1/f1/f atmospheric fluctuations, the receiver utilizes a cryogenic HWP. The HWP is situated inside the optics tube at 50 K and rotates continuously at approximately 2.025 Hz, placing the polarization modulation at 4fHWP=8.14f_{\mathrm{HWP}} = 8.1 Hz. While a standard continuously rotating HWP provides modulation of linear polarization (Stokes QQ and UU) and was the primary focus of the initial PB-2b commissioning [54], explicitly isolating the circular polarization (Stokes VV) signal at high efficiency requires additional optical configuration. For the observations presented in this work, our optical system utilizes both a static QWP and the rotating HWP. The addition of the QWP introduces a known phase retardance that, when coupled with the rotating HWP, allows the incoming Stokes VV signal to be modulated and effectively separated from the linear polarization terms in the timestream, as shown in K. Sakaguri et al. [55].

The physical characteristics and optical performance of this QWP-HWP system have been extensively evaluated and optimized for the 90 GHz band [55]. The QWP is installed on the sky-side of the receiver and is kept at ambient air temperature. It is constructed from Rexolite 1422 (cross-linked polystyrene)1, which is not itself a birefringent material; instead, grooves machined into both faces produce form birefringence, giving different effective indices parallel and perpendicular to the grooves. These grooves are machined with depth and separations to optimize performance at 90 GHz. The 150 GHz band is disfavored in turn because the atmosphere is both brighter and less stable there, sitting between the 118 GHz oxygen line and the wing of the 183 GHz water line [43]. Laboratory measurements demonstrate that the QWP achieves a band-averaged circular-to-linear conversion efficiency (∣MVUQWP∣\lvert M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VU}\rvert) of 99.0%, with a band-averaged unconverted fraction (MUUQWP=MVVQWPM^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{UU} = M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VV}) of −7.2%-7.2\%; because only II, QQ, and UU are physically reconstructed downstream of the QWP, with sky VV recovered from the UU channel, this leakage represents sky UU that fails to convert and remains as spurious UU, directly contaminating the recovered VV measurement. Spatial variations across the plate differ by less than 1% in amplitude and 3° in phase [55]. The average transmission is approximately 87%. When coupled with the cryogenic HWP, a three-stacked sapphire design structure with anti-reflective coatings achieving ≥99%\geq99\% modulation efficiency, the combined system provides highly efficient conversion and subsequent temporal modulation of the incoming Stokes VV signal. The QWP has a Mueller matrix,

MQWP=(MIIQWPMQIQWPMUIQWPMVIQWPMIQQWPMQQQWPMUQQWPMVQQWPMIUQWPMQUQWPMUUQWPMVUQWPMIVQWPMQVQWPMUVQWPMVVQWP),(1)M_{\mathrm{QWP}} = \begin{pmatrix} M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{II} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{QI} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{UI} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VI} \\ M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{IQ} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{QQ} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{UQ} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VQ} \\ M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{IU} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{QU} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{UU} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VU} \\ M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{IV} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{QV} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{UV} & M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VV} \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(1)}

where for an ideal QWP, MIIQWP=MQQQWP=MVVQWP=−MUVQWP=1M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{II} = M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{QQ} = M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VV} = -M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{UV} = 1 and MIQQWP=MIUQWP=MIVQWP=MUUQWP=MVVQWP=0M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{IQ} = M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{IU} = M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{IV} = M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{UU} = M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VV} = 0; the antisymmetric U↔VU \leftrightarrow V block encodes the 90° phase retardance, so MVUQWP=−MUVQWPM^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VU} = -M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{UV} and both have the same magnitude. Here MQWPM_{\mathrm{QWP}} describes the QWP alone. The quantities measured on the sky instead belong to the effective Mueller matrix MM of the full optical chain in the QWP basis, schematically Mrec MHWP MQWP MtelM_{\mathrm{rec}}\,M_{\mathrm{HWP}}\,M_{\mathrm{QWP}}\,M_{\mathrm{tel}}, where MtelM_{\mathrm{tel}} represents the telescope mirrors and MrecM_{\mathrm{rec}} the remaining receiver optics (window, filters, and lenses). Its elements MXYM_{XY}, written without superscript, follow the same input-to-output index convention as Equation (1). The HWP modulation is treated separately in § 4.2, and, following K. Sakaguri et al. [55], the polarization efficiency of everything other than the QWP is factored out of MM as a single scalar ηP\eta_P that multiplies the polarized signal in that modulation model. The remaining Stokes mixing is dominated by the QWP, so that M≈MQWPM \approx M_{\mathrm{QWP}}, since the cross-polarization of the telescope optics is small and the receiver optics are approximately rotationally symmetric (K. Sakaguri et al. [55]).

Based on astrophysical point-source calibrations in K. Sakaguri et al. [55], we express the measured efficiencies and leakages in terms of the elements of MM, with both MM and MQWPM_{\mathrm{QWP}} normalized to unit transmission so that MII=MIIQWP=MQQQWP=1M_{II}=M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{II}=M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{QQ}=1. The linear polarization efficiency of the system independent of the QWP, ηP\eta_P, was measured on-sky from Tau A by fitting the observed Q/IQ/I fraction as a function of parallactic angle. Both QQ and II are measured from the same detector data and so carry the overall transmission as a common factor; their ratio is therefore insensitive to it, and returns ηP\eta_P in the same normalization as Equation (1). K. Sakaguri et al. [55] obtain (46±2)%(46 \pm2)\% from timestreams that were not deconvolved for the detector time constants, so that value also contains the single-pole attenuation of the signal at 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}}, [1+(2π⋅4fHWPτ)2]−1/2≈0.86[1+(2\pi\cdot4f_{\mathrm{HWP}}\tau)^2]^{-1/2}\approx0.86 for τ≈12 ms\tau\approx12\,\mathrm{ms}. Because the science timestreams here are deconvolved (§ 3.3), we repeat the Tau A fit on the same observations after the identical deconvolution with stimulator time constants, obtaining ηP=0.533±0.032\eta_P=0.533\pm0.032. The net circular polarization efficiency and the leakages that enter the converted-UU channel are defined from the elements of MM, together with their approximate forms in terms of the QWP alone, as

ηV=ηP∣MVU∣≈ηP∣MVUQWP∣,(2)\eta_V = \eta_P\lvert M_{VU}\rvert\approx\eta_P\lvert M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VU}\rvert, \tag*{(2)}
ϵUV=MUU/MVU≈MUUQWP/MVUQWP,(3)\epsilon^{UV} = M_{UU}/M_{VU} \approx M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{UU}/M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VU}, \tag*{(3)}
ϵQV=MQU/MVU≈MQUQWP/MVUQWP,(4)\epsilon^{QV} = M_{QU}/M_{VU} \approx M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{QU}/M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VU}, \tag*{(4)}
ϵIV=MIU/MVU≈MIUQWP/MVUQWP.(5)\epsilon^{IV} = M_{IU}/M_{VU} \approx M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{IU}/M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VU}. \tag*{(5)}

The QWP conversion efficiency is near unity, MVUQWP=−MUVQWP=99.0%M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{VU}=-M^{\mathrm{QWP}}_{UV}=99.0\%, so ηV=0.528±0.032\eta_V=0.528\pm0.032 is limited primarily by ηP\eta_P. The retained sky UU is constrained on-sky from Tau A to ϵUV=(−11.7±5.1)%\epsilon^{UV}=(-11.7\pm5.1)\%, consistent with the laboratory value of −7.2%-7.2\% quoted above. Because the Tau A fit sees the full optical chain, this value is the effective ratio MUU/MVUM_{UU}/M_{VU}, whereas the laboratory value is its QWP-only approximation. Leakage from sky QQ is not a property of the plate itself, so its QWP-only form above does not apply. It enters through residual miscalibration of the detector polarization angles relative to the QWP axis, which rotates QQ into the UU channel. Calibrating the angles from the HWPSS (§ 3.4) intrinsically suppresses this effect. The residual is set by the alignment of the QWP to the telescope, measured at the site to within 0.3∘0.3^\circ, which bounds ϵQV≲1.1%\epsilon^{QV}\lesssim1.1\% (K. Sakaguri et al. Unlike ϵUV\epsilon^{UV}, this bound comes from the alignment measurement rather than from the sky. The remaining term, II-to-VV leakage ϵIV\epsilon^{IV}, is retained rather than set to zero. An ideal birefringent plate couples intensity only to QQ, but we do not assume that this structure holds exactly. An additional intensity leakage is generated downstream of the optics, in the detector response itself, and therefore lies outside this Mueller-matrix description; it is discussed in § 4.2.4. Both are absorbed into the effective coefficient measured in Section 4.8.1.

In summary, the static QWP maps the Stokes VV on-sky into the instrument-frame Stokes UU, which the HWP then modulates at four times its rotation frequency. The circular-polarization measurement channel of this analysis is therefore the demodulated UU timestream; all subsequent steps construct per-run, per-detector UobsU_{\mathrm{obs}} maps, estimate their cross spectra C^ℓUU,obs\hat{C}_{\ell}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}} and convert these to CℓVVC_{\ell}^{VV}, disentangling instrument systematics. The companion QobsQ_{\mathrm{obs}} channel carries the linear polarization of the measured sky, and is not used in this analysis.

Scan Strategy and Observations

Two CMB patches, RA23 and RA4.5, were chosen for this analysis, both legacy patches from Polarbear (Polarbear Collaboration et al. [49]). These patches are so named due to the right ascension (RA) of their approximate centers in units of hours, which are for RA23 and RA4.5, αRA23=23h01m48s\alpha_{\mathrm{RA23}} = 23^{\mathrm{h}}01^{\mathrm{m}}48^{\mathrm{s}}, δRA23=−32∘12′00′′\delta_{\mathrm{RA23}} = -32^\circ12^\prime00^{\prime\prime} (J2000) and αRA4.5=04h40m12s\alpha_{\mathrm{RA4.5}} = 04^{\mathrm{h}}40^{\mathrm{m}}12^{\mathrm{s}}, δRA4.5=−45∘00′00′′\delta_{\mathrm{RA4.5}} = -45^\circ00^\prime00^{\prime\prime}. These locations were chosen to lie away from the Galactic plane, avoiding significant contamination in the sky signal from synchrotron radiation. The dimensions of these patches are ∼9∘×9∘\sim9^\circ\times9^\circ, small enough that we work in the flat-sky approximation for later analysis. The small patch sizes are utilized in order to target sub-degree size angular scales (300≤ℓ≤2000300 \le\ell\le2000). The geometric distortion introduced by the flat-sky approximation is ≪1%\ll1\% and strictly negligible compared to the statistical noise.

An observation of a given patch is taken with a constant elevation scan (CES), which tracks back and forth a minimum and maximum azimuth at a constant elevation. The telescope scans at ∼0.4∘/s\sim0.4^\circ/\mathrm{s} in azimuth with a sampling rate of ∼152.6 s−1\sim152.6\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}; the duration of an observation is typically around 860 s. The CMB patches are observed both rising and setting, at elevations >30∘>30^\circ, high enough to avoid ground pickup, and <70∘<70^\circ, to maintain elevations roughly in the same range as where detector tuning occurs (∼40∘\sim40^\circ) (K. Sakaguri et al. [55]). Throughout, a detector is called “tuned” when it has been successfully biased onto its superconducting transition, and “optical” when it is coupled to the sky through its antenna rather than being a dark channel; only detectors that are both can contribute usable data. The scan strategy of observing both when rising and setting provides multiple parallactic angles, which decreases the non-radial systematics of the beam maps (discussed in more detail in § 3.2) and the amount of P→VP \rightarrow V leakage (see § 4.8).

We observed RA23 and RA4.5 for about 2.5 months each, in staggered periods. During that time, corruption with the telescope timestamp data resulted in a large amount of data becoming unusable. For RA23 (RA4.5), 114 (99) of the 798 (576) runs with nonzero tuned and optical detectors have technical issues resulting in a total loss of usable detector-observations (the data from a single detector within a single observation), arising from corrupted timestream files, improperly stored identifiers in the database tracking each observation, failed tuning, or faults within the timestream data despite it being saved. In addition to these observation-wide technical failures, a subset of detectors in each observation are not usable because they do not have time constant or absolute gain calibration factors; this is explained in § 3.3. For these reasons, 356,385/566,694 (232,866/414,612), about 62% (56%) of detector-observations across all observations for RA23 (RA4.5), have usable timestreams for the analysis detailed in § 4. A typically behaved observing run yields between 600–700 tuned and optical detectors in the 90 GHz band. These instrument-level losses, together with the data quality cuts imposed after map-making, are tabulated in § 4.4.

Calibrations

This section describes the calibrations that fix the instrumental quantities entering the forward model of § 4.9. The pointing model (§ 3.1) sets the suppression PℓP_{\ell} of small-scale power by residual pointing error, and Jupiter observations set the beam window function BℓB_{\ell} (§ 3.2). A thermal stimulator provides the detector time constants and the absolute gain gg (§ 3.3), while the detector polarization angles are calibrated from the half-wave plate synchronous signal (HWPSS) fourth harmonic so that every detector can be rotated into the common QWP basis (§ 3.4). The circular polarization efficiency ηV\eta_{V} and the leakages ϵUV\epsilon^{UV} and ϵQV\epsilon^{QV} follow from the optical chain described in § 2.2, while the pipeline transfer function TℓT_{\ell} and the I→UI \rightarrow U and P→VP \rightarrow V leakage spectra are determined from the processed data and are deferred to § 4.7 and § 4.8. Table 3 collects all of these, with the role each plays in the likelihood and the section in which it is determined.

QuantityValueUncertaintyRoleDim.Section
Cˉ^ℓUU,obs\hat{\bar{C}}_{\ell}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}—∼0.001 μKCMB2\sim0.001\ \mu\mathrm{K}_{\mathrm{CMB}}^2Data—4.5.2
CˉℓUU,obs\bar{C}_{\ell}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}——Sampled (likelihood)NbN_b—
ηV\eta_V0.5280.032Sampled (prior)12.2
gg1.0000.046Sampled (prior)13.3
BℓB_\ell∼0.4\sim0.4–0.90.9per bandpowerSampled (prior)NbN_b3.2
TℓT_\ell∼0.4\sim0.4–0.80.80.1Sampled (prior)NbN_b4.7
PℓP_\ell∼0.99\sim0.99–1.001.000.007Sampled (prior)13.1
ϵℓ,totIU\epsilon_{\ell,\mathrm{tot}}^{IU}∼1.8%\sim1.8\%0.3%0.3\%Fixed nuisance—4.8.1
gτg_\tau1.0000.0037 / 0.0062Fixed nuisance—3.3
ϵQV\epsilon^{QV}≲1.1%\lesssim1.1\%—Fixed nuisance—2.2
ϵUV\epsilon^{UV}−11.7%-11.7\%5.1%5.1\%Fixed nuisance—2.2
CˉℓQQ,in\bar{C}_{\ell}^{QQ,\mathrm{in}}≲0.004 μK2\lesssim0.004\ \mu\mathrm{K}^20.001Fixed nuisance—4.8.2
CˉℓUU,in\bar{C}_{\ell}^{UU,\mathrm{in}}≲0.004 μK2\lesssim0.004\ \mu\mathrm{K}^20.001Fixed nuisance—4.8.2
CˉℓQU,in\bar{C}_{\ell}^{QU,\mathrm{in}}≲250 nK2\lesssim250\ \mathrm{nK}^2100Fixed nuisance—4.8.2

Table 3. Inputs of the likelihood estimator, Equation (43), and the model it evaluates, Equation (42). The spectral values are roughly estimated to demonstrate relative significance, and are approximately the same in both patches, except gτg_\tau, quoted as RA23 / RA4.5; no central value is quoted for the measured bandpowers because they scatter about zero, so only their scale is meaningful. Each quantity is classified by the role it plays: the measured bandpowers are the data; sampled parameters carry their own chain dimension, with the stated distribution acting as a prior except for CˉℓUU,obs\bar{C}_{\ell}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}, which is constrained by the likelihood itself; fixed nuisances are held at their central values during sampling and marginalized afterwards. Uncertainties are 1σ1\sigma and carry the units of the adjacent value; that of BℓB_\ell is set per bandpower by the scatter of the Jupiter observations rather than by a single number. The “Dim.” column gives the number of chain dimensions each sampled quantity contributes, with Nb=17N_b=17 bandpowers and TℓT_\ell counted per patch, so that the per-patch chains are 3+3Nb=543+3N_b=54 dimensional and the joint chain of Section 4.10, which carries a separate TℓT_\ell for each patch, is 3+4Nb=713+4N_b=71 dimensional. PℓP_\ell enters through the single amplitude of Equation (44) rather than one dimension per bandpower, and the uncertainty quoted for it is that at the highest bandpower. The last column gives the section in which each quantity is determined.

Pointing

The PB-2b pointing model is a 14-parameter TPoint-style correction (P. T. Wallace [66]) that maps the encoder azimuth/elevation to the true boresight pointing before the az/el →\rightarrow RA/Dec conversion, which is a more expansive model than the five-parameter model used in PB14. The corrections (in arcminutes) decompose into structural, thermal-flexure, solar-flexure, and second-harmonic “nod” terms. The 14 coefficients follow F. T. Matsuda [38] and are fit by minimizing a χ2\chi^2 against a catalog of point-source centroid offsets. The fit leaves a per-axis residual scatter of σaz=14.7′′\sigma_{\mathrm{az}} = 14.7^{\prime\prime} and σel=20.5′′\sigma_{\mathrm{el}} = 20.5^{\prime\prime} (≈ 25′′25^{\prime\prime} total). A few corrections and physical improvements to the model were found to be necessary, detailed in J. Ito et al. (2026, in preparation). These adopt parameters from the pointing models of the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) (J. G. Mangum [36]) and the Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) Field System (W. E. Himwich [24]) as adopted by Square Kilometre Array Observatory (SKAO) (SKA Observatory [58]), reducing the RMS further. However, as the existing model already has reduced pointing suppression significantly from the no-model case, as shown in Figure 2, and its residual uncertainty is carried through the likelihood as a sampled parameter, as discussed in § 4.10, the adjustments were not implemented due to computational restrictions. A comparison of the two models is described in that work, showing comparable performance. The updated model lowers the residual pointing RMS from 25.2′′25.2^{\prime\prime} to 23.3′′23.3^{\prime\prime}, which changes the pointing transfer function by at most 0.13% for ℓ≤2000\ell\le2000, no more than 0.2σ0.2\sigma of its sampled uncertainty, a negligible difference.

Figure 2. Suppression factor in ℓ\ell-space with (solid line) and without (dashed line) pointing model correction. The dotted black line shows a Gaussian suppression from the determined RMS for reference; both patches are Gaussian at low-ℓ\ell but have less suppression at higher ℓ\ell.

Because the relevant question for this analysis is how the pointing affects the recovered spectrum, we validate the model with geometry-only simulations, isolating the az/el →\to RA/Dec geometry to quantify the impact as an effective amplitude transfer function. Concretely, we synthesize a temperature-only sky with the Boltzmann code CAMB (A. Lewis et al. [33]) at the Planck best-fit cosmology (Planck Collaboration et al. [48]), sample it along the azimuth and elevation actually recorded during the real observations, both with and without the pointing model applied, and coadd the resulting maps following the same procedure used for the data. A pointing error is a purely geometric remapping of where each sample lands on the sky, so its effect on the recovered spectrum does not depend on which Stokes parameter carries the signal; a TT-only input sky is therefore sufficient, and this is what “geometry-only” denotes here. The model transfer function is ≳0.99\gtrsim0.99 in amplitude out to ℓ∼2000\ell\sim2000. The uncorrected maps yield pointing scatter up to 5% at ℓ=2000\ell= 2000, compared to ≲1%\lesssim1\% for those with the pointing correction, as shown in Figure 2. In addition, by propagating the parameter covariance and cosmic variance through Monte Carlo simulations into ℓ\ell-space, we find a pointing suppression uncertainty δP^ℓ≲1%\delta\hat{P}_{\ell} \lesssim1\% at the highest bin. Because this term arises from smearing it grows as ℓ2\ell^2, so it is negligible below ℓ∼1000\ell\sim1000 but becomes comparable to other spectral sensitivity systematics such as the beam suppression and mapmaking pipeline transfer function (visible in Figure 5) in the highest bandpowers. It is therefore sampled in the likelihood rather than propagated afterwards (§ 4.10).

Figure 5. Per-mode amplitude transmission of the VVVV analysis versus multipole. Dashed steps show the simulation transfer function TℓT_{\ell} (Equation (33)) for RA23 (blue) and RA4.5 (orange), the dotted lines represent the pointing transfer function for each patch (blue and orange), and the solid teal line represents the independently measured beam window function BℓB_{\ell}. The solid blue and orange curves represent the product TℓPℓBℓT_{\ell}P_{\ell}B_{\ell} per patch, with 1σ1\sigma bands from the combined TℓT_{\ell}, PℓP_{\ell}, and BℓB_{\ell} uncertainties. The two patches are nearly identical.

Beam Characterization

To estimate the beam window function BℓB_{\ell} at 90 GHz, we analyze 68 Jupiter observations taken over our observing season, extending the beam analysis in N. Farias et al. [15] (see Figure 8 of that work for the inverse-variance average beam map). Jupiter is chosen because it is a bright point-like source that is negligibly polarized at 90 GHz. Each map is apodized with a 2′ two-dimensional cosine taper so it smoothly tapers to zero at the edge, then zero-padded for finer ℓ\ell-sampling. A 2D fast Fourier transform (FFT) is performed on the resulting padded map, and the result is normalized by the DC mode (effectively the monopole term in a flat-sky approximation). This is then divided by the Fourier transform of the Airy disk to deconvolve the planet’s angular size, which is determined from ephemeris data for each observation date. The resulting function in ℓ\ell-space is squared, radially binned in Δℓ=100\Delta\ell= 100 rings to match the science binning scheme (with ℓ\ell denoting the bin center hereafter), and the square root is taken. Finally, we divide by the pixel-window function wℓbeam=sinc⁡(ℓΔx2)w_{\ell}^{\mathrm{beam}} = \operatorname{sinc}\left(\frac{\ell\Delta x}{2}\right), where Δx=0.001∘\Delta x = 0.001^\circ is the map resolution.

The resulting beam window function is shown in Figure 5. As noted in Figure 8 from N. Farias et al. [15], the beams are not perfectly radially symmetric, despite the radial-symmetry assumption used in the binning above. This, in conjunction with the statistical uncertainty, is reflected in the error bars in the plot, computed as standard errors of the points in each ℓ\ell-bin. Observing over a range of azimuths and elevations provides multiple parallactic angles that mitigate the azimuthal artifacts in the beam, as discussed in § 2.3. The ellipticity of the 90 GHz beam is quoted at 3% (N. Farias et al. [15]), sufficiently low to contribute negligibly to the overall systematic uncertainty, following the PoLARbear analyses ((Polarbear Collaboration et al. 2017, 2020)).

Time Constants and Absolute Gain Calibration

PB-2b detectors are about four times slower than Polarbear’s, with a median effective time constant of 12.1 ms at 90 GHz ([15]) compared to ≲3\lesssim3 ms ([49] (Polarbear Collaboration et al. 2017)). This imposes non-negligible attenuation and phase retardance on the polarization signal at the modulation frequency 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}}, and the timestreams therefore require deconvolution before demodulation. As discussed in N. Farias et al. [15], effective time constants are determined by fitting the first-harmonic amplitude of a chopped thermal signal (known hereafter as a stimulator) to a single-pole model at a series of seven frequencies; 5 Hz, 9 Hz, 13 Hz, 19 Hz, 27 Hz, 37 Hz, and 44 Hz; so chosen to avoid the significant HWP harmonics. Fit parameters from this methodology are saved for later use as long as they produce plausibly physical values (single-pole model amplitude ≤200\le200 analog-to-digital converter (ADC) counts and τ≤500\tau\le500 ms) and have at least three surviving frequency points within the sweep. These calibration runs are taken immediately before and after each science observation, and the effective time constant used is their mean, τ=(τbefore+τafter)/2\tau= (\tau_{\mathrm{before}} + \tau_{\mathrm{after}})/2. We deconvolve per timestream before demodulation by Fourier-transforming and dividing by the single-pole model evaluated at this time constant.

Absolute gain calibration factors convert the instrument’s measured current units (ADC counts) into KCMB_{\mathrm{CMB}}. The stimulator, operating simultaneously with a Jupiter observation, is used to determine these factors. Jupiter’s known thermodynamic temperature, measured by Planck Collaboration et al. [46], is first converted into a Rayleigh–Jeans brightness temperature and then into an equivalent KCMB_{\mathrm{CMB}} temperature fluctuation. This conversion incorporates the Simons Array instrument characterization ([67, 62]), including the effective detector bandpasses and Lyot efficiencies (ηLyot=0.537\eta_{\mathrm{Lyot}} = 0.537 and 0.849 for the 90 GHz and 150 GHz bands, respectively). Furthermore, to account for sources with different spectral indices, color-correction scaling factors are calculated internally by integrating the source spectra over the instrument’s simulated diplexer bandpass. The 90 GHz bandpass is flat, spanning 76.1 GHz to 94.3 GHz, utilizing the Fourier-transform spectrometer measurement adopted by K. Sakaguri et al. [55], which gives a band center of 85.18 GHz and a bandwidth of 18.25 GHz (a fractional bandwidth of 0.214). The color correction is normalized to a Rayleigh–Jeans source, α=2\alpha= 2 for a flux density S∝ναS \propto\nu^\alpha, which is appropriate for Jupiter. The spectrum relevant to CMB anisotropies is instead dBν/dTdB_\nu/dT, whose effective index is αeff=4+x−2xex/(ex−1)≈1.6\alpha_{\mathrm{eff}} = 4 + x - 2xe^x/(e^x - 1) \approx1.6 at 90 GHz, where x=hν/kBTCMBx = h\nu/k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{CMB}}; the resulting correction relative to the Rayleigh–Jeans normalization is ≈0.8%\approx0.8\%.

The QWP conversion efficiency ∣MVUQWP(ν)∣\lvert M_{VU}^{\mathrm{QWP}}(\nu)\rvert does not enter this absolute gain calibration, which is an intensity measurement. Its frequency dependence across the band instead enters through the band-averaged value used in ηV\eta_V (Equation (2a)). As in the typical planet scans, we fit a 2D Gaussian to the source in ADC counts. By comparing the amplitude of this Gaussian fit and the measured beam size to the expected temperature and solid angle of Jupiter, a conversion factor in KCMB_{\mathrm{CMB}}/ADC is determined. Ten such Jupiter scans with the stimulator were used to build the absolute gain calibration template database.

As a secondary calibration source, we use the HWPSS, a spurious non-sky signal generated due to imperfections in the HWP, following a procedure similar to the relative gain calibration in K. Sakaguri et al. [55]. We build a template of calibration factors from observations with reliable stimulator calibration, determining, per detector, a conversion between the amplitude of the HWPSS fourth harmonic (at 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}}) and the equivalent stimulator amplitude. Likewise, we estimate the effective time constant from the 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} phase. The 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} phase is primarily set by the physical angle between each detector and the QWP axis, but the time constant introduces an additional phase offset. We build a template for the τ=0\tau= 0 phase corresponding to the physical angle; the difference between each observation’s 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} phase and this template gives the effective time constant. This method agrees well with the stimulator-based approach, as validated on observations for which both stimulator calibration and the HWPSS 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} signal are available. This alternative method is utilized when there are technical issues with the stimulator that prevent it from being used as a reliable calibration source.

The time constant during an observation may differ from the mean τ\tau used for deconvolution to the extent that it drifts between the two calibrations, which are ∼2\sim2 h apart. Taking the true value to lie uniformly between them gives στ=∣τafter−τbefore∣/12\sigma_\tau= \lvert\tau_{\mathrm{after}} - \tau_{\mathrm{before}}\rvert/\sqrt{12} for each detector-observation, which the single-pole model converts into a fractional error on the deconvolution gain of x2/(1+x2) στ/τx^2/(1 + x^2)\,\sigma_\tau/\tau, with x=2π⋅4fHWPτx = 2\pi\cdot4f_{\mathrm{HWP}}\tau. The drift is largely common to the array within one calibration interval, so we treat each interval’s error as coherent across its detectors and independent between intervals, and average over each patch with the map weights. Time constants from the HWPSS phase are measured within the observation and carry no such term. The result is a unit-mean gain factor gτg_\tau, with uncertainty 0.37% for RA23 and 0.62% for RA4.5, which multiplies the data in the same way as gg. An overall bias in the stimulator time constants does not enter gτg_\tau, as it cancels against the calibration of ηP\eta_P (§ 2.2).

Because the gain enters the measured spectrum only as an overall factor of g2g^2, a fractional calibration error rescales CℓC_\ell by twice that fraction at every multipole—its effect is therefore analytic rather than something that must be propagated by simulation, and we account for it explicitly through the residual gain coefficient gg defined in Equation (8). All science observations analyzed here were taken in the QWP configuration, and the applied calibration is therefore the mean over only the four planet observations available in that configuration; their 8.9 % common-mode scatter averages down to 4.45 %, which dominates the budget. The remaining terms are the Jupiter brightness-temperature model of Planck Collaboration et al. [46] (∼1.0\sim1.0 %), the per-detector calibration scatter (7.6 % across 706 detectors, or 0.29 % after averaging), and the HWPSS template fit error (<0.1<0.1 %). Summing in quadrature gives a total absolute gain uncertainty of σg=4.6\sigma_g = 4.6 %, corresponding to a 9.1 % multiplicative scale uncertainty on the quoted limits. Rather than propagate this through the pipeline, we carry it into the model of § 4.9 as a prior on gg.

Detector Polarization Angles

The QWP converts sky VV into the Stokes UU of its own frame, for which the efficiency and leakage terms of Equations (2a)–(2d) are defined. Circular polarization is invariant under rotation about the line of sight, so were VV the only signal present no orientation reference would be needed. It is the linear polarization, spin-2 and hence basis-dependent, that forces one—a detector whose polarization axis lies at an angle θdet(j)\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)} to the QWP axis measures QQ and UU mixed by 2θdet(j)2\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)}, so without correcting for it each detector would fold an uncontrolled fraction of sky linear polarization into its circular polarization channel. We therefore rotate every detector into the common QWP basis, both to keep sky linear polarization out of the measured UU and because ϵUV\epsilon^{UV}, ϵQV\epsilon^{QV}, and ϵIV\epsilon^{IV} are themselves ratios of Mueller elements about the QWP axis, quantifying the leakage only once the data are expressed in that frame.

Because the HWPSS fourth-harmonic signal is physically related to the QWP transmission (K. Sakaguri et al. [55]; N. Farias et al. [15]) and is dominant over the other harmonics by several orders of magnitude, we can calibrate these angles directly from the timestream data. This permits us to rotate from the individual detector orientations into the common QWP basis. For each detector, the mean-subtracted timestream prior to HWPSS removal is binned into 128 uniform bins in the encoder-measured HWP angle ϕ\phi over [0,2π)[0, 2\pi). Because the samples are sorted by measured angle rather than by time, no constant rotation rate is assumed and departures from the nominal rotation rate are absorbed by the binning. The resulting binned HWPSS profile is then fit by least squares to a harmonic series in ϕ\phi,

d(j)(ϕ)=∑n=16[An(j)sin⁡(nϕ)+Bn(j)cos⁡(nϕ)].(6)d^{(j)}(\phi) = \sum_{n=1}^{6} \left[A_n^{(j)} \sin(n\phi) + B_n^{(j)} \cos(n\phi)\right]. \tag*{(6)}

The physical alignment angle per detector is determined from the fourth-harmonic amplitudes as

θdet(j)=12arctan⁡(A4(j),B4(j)),(7)\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)} = \frac{1}{2}\arctan\left(A_4^{(j)}, B_4^{(j)}\right), \tag*{(7)}

which is defined on (−π/2,π/2](-\pi/2,\pi/2].

Data Analysis

This section describes the analysis pipeline in the order in which the data flow through it. Timestreams are calibrated, cleaned, and demodulated into per-detector Stokes components (§ 4.2); these are binned into per-observation maps (§ 4.3) and screened by the data quality cuts of § 4.4. The surviving maps are combined into cross-spectra, yielding the measured UUUU bandpowers and their covariance (§ 4.5), whose internal consistency is then established with the null test suite of § 4.6. The remaining sections quantify the terms needed to invert those bandpowers into a circular polarization spectrum: the pipeline transfer function (§ 4.7) and the instrumental leakages (§ 4.8). These are assembled into the forward model described in § 4.9, which is inverted in the likelihood of § 4.10 to give CℓVVC_\ell^{VV}. Figure 3 traces the Stokes parameters through this chain and defines the subscripts used throughout.

Figure 3. Schematic describing the Stokes parameters at each part of the observing and analysis pipeline, with indicated leakages and efficiencies and associated bases. This is the path traced by Figure 1. The subscripts label successive stages along this path: “sky” denotes the true celestial signal; “in” the same signal transformed into the telescope basis; “conv” the Stokes parameters after the QWP has applied its phase delay, converting VV into UU and vice versa; “mod” the II, QQ, and UU of the converted signal modulated by the rotating HWP into a detector timestream; and “obs” the signal actually recorded by the detectors, either in the time domain as a function of tt or in the map domain as a function of n^\hat{n}. This figure is based on Figure 7 from K. Sakaguri et al. [55].

Blinding Scheme

To prevent analysis choices from being biased, consciously or otherwise, toward the final circular polarization result, we developed the analysis pipeline on a benchmark dataset with full access to its power spectra, then applied it to the science data under a blinding scheme that hides the VVVV bandpowers. The benchmark set comprises ∼10\sim10% of the usable RA23 data, on which we had unblinded access to its power spectra. These observations were selected on observing conditions and detector yield alone, requiring more than 500 tuned and optical detectors and a precipitable water vapor (PWV; a measure of water vapor in the line of sight to the zenith) below 3 mm, so that pipeline development was carried out on data of reliably good quality rather than on observations chosen for any property of their recovered spectra. All analysis choices were initially set using this benchmark set alone, including the time-domain filtering parameters, glitch-flagging and HWPSS-removal procedures, data-quality cut thresholds (§ 4.4), the power-spectrum estimator configuration (§ 4.5), and the leakage and transfer-function treatments (§ 4.7 and § 4.8). Because the RA4.5 observations were acquired chronologically later, and to maintain a uniform analysis pipeline across both sky patches, we did not define a separate benchmark dataset for RA4.5. Instead, the analysis pipeline developed on the RA23 benchmark was applied directly to the RA4.5 dataset, validated by the success of the RA4.5 null tests (§ 4.6). A separate set of RA4.5 observations was set aside for the transfer-function simulations of § 4.7. It was not used to develop or validate the pipeline, so it was not excluded from the RA4.5 science data.

We then applied this pipeline to the remaining ∼90%\sim90\% of the data. Throughout this stage the VVVV bandpowers themselves were blinded; while the intermediate pipeline products (filtered timestreams, detector and coadded maps, and the various calibration and leakage estimates) remained accessible, the recovered science spectra were withheld from inspection. The null tests of § 4.6 were run in this blinded configuration for both patches, with only the summary probabilities-to-exceed (PTEs) exposed and the underlying bandpowers hidden, so that internal-consistency failures could be diagnosed without sight of the science spectra. Failures were addressed with additional data-quality cuts and adjustments to the pipeline, made in parallel and based only on these PTEs and on secondary data products such as the timestreams and maps; the VVVV bandpowers, and hence the upper limits derived from them, remained blinded throughout. The unblinding sequence was fixed in advance rather than settled as results became available. The pipeline was frozen, with no analysis choice or data cut changed thereafter, once the null-test passage criteria of § 4.6 were met, and only then were the VVVV bandpowers revealed. The benchmark observations are themselves excluded from the final science dataset, at a ∼10%\sim10\% sensitivity cost, so that the limits reported in § 5 derive entirely from data whose spectra were unseen during pipeline construction.

Timestream Processing

In this section we will detail the data processing that occurs from the intake of raw modulated detector data to isolated Stokes timestreams, including the time-domain filters meant to improve the quality of the data. A schematic of how the data passes through each component, both physically in the telescope and later in the analysis pipeline, is shown in Figure 3.

Calibration and Modulation

The raw detector data are first converted from ADC counts into KCMB_{\rm CMB} using the procedures in § 3.3. That conversion is a single scalar responsivity value per detector, which propagates to being a scalar multiplier in ℓ\ell-space. We parameterize any residual error in it with a dimensionless coefficient gg,

dmod(j)(t)=gdmod,true(j)(t),(8)d_{\mathrm{mod}}^{(j)}(t) = g d_{\mathrm{mod,true}}^{(j)}(t), \tag*{(8)}

defined as the ratio of the applied calibration factor to the true one, where dmod,true(j)d_{\mathrm{mod,true}}^{(j)} is what a perfectly calibrated detector would record. The calibration of § 3.3 has already been applied to the data, so gg is unity by construction and only quantifies how far that calibration may be from the truth, with a width given by the absolute gain uncertainty derived there. As mentioned in § 3.3, we account for its residual uncertainty once, in spectrum space (§ 4.9), to avoid propagating the parameter through hundreds of thousands of individual detector timestreams.

The time constants determined from the same procedures are also deconvolved at first order. We also mask the first and last second of each subscan, a single left- or right-going sweep in azimuth at constant elevation, to exclude transients from the turnaround between sweeps. At this point, we also determine the corresponding RA and declination (Dec) based on each detector’s position in the focal plane and the focal plane’s boresight pointing at a given timestamp, and these are corrected according to the pointing model from § 3.1. The HWP encoder data is also reconstructed per the procedure discussed in B. Bixler et al. [7], which is used in the following subsection to demodulate into individual Stokes components.

As discussed in K. Sakaguri et al. [55], the HWP modulates polarized signal according to the following equation for each detector jj,

dmod(j)(t)=Iconv(j)(t)+Re⁡[(ηP(Qconv(j)(t)+iUconv(j)(t))+ϵdetIPIconv(j)(t))e−i[4θHWP(t)−2θdet(j)]]+AHWPSS(j)(t)+Nw(j)(t)+Natm(j)(t),(9)d_{\mathrm{mod}}^{(j)}(t) = I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t) + \operatorname{Re}\left[\left(\eta_{\mathrm{P}}\left(Q_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t) + iU_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right) + \epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP}I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right)e^{-i\left[4\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t)-2\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)}\right]}\right] + A_{\mathrm{HWPSS}}^{(j)}(t) + N_{\mathrm{w}}^{(j)}(t) + N_{\mathrm{atm}}^{(j)}(t), \tag*{(9)}

where “conv” represents the Stokes components after passing through the QWP, θHWP(t)\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t) is the angle of the HWP as it rotates, θdet\theta_{\mathrm{det}} is the detector’s polarization angle relative to the QWP axis (§ 3.4), AHWPSS(t)A_{\mathrm{HWPSS}}(t) is the HWPSS signal, Nw(t)N_{\mathrm{w}}(t) is white noise, and Natm(t)N_{\mathrm{atm}}(t) is low-frequency noise caused by changes in atmospheric loading. In addition, as noted in § 2.2, the detector response is not strictly linear, so a second-order term mixes the HWP-synchronous signal with the unmodulated intensity and produces sidebands about 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} that survive demodulation. This leaks the intensity timestream into the demodulated Stokes components, which we denote with the complex leakage parameter ϵdetIP\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP}, where the subscript denotes that it originates in the detector response rather than the optics. The same term was identified in POLARBEAR as an excess I→PI \to P leakage and derived from the bolometer response model ([64, 63]).

HWPSS Removal

The first step before demodulating is to remove the HWPSS, which we model as a sum of harmonics of the HWP angle with slowly varying complex amplitudes,

AHWPSS(t)=∑mRe⁡[dm(t)eimθHWP(t)].A_{\mathrm{HWPSS}}(t) = \sum_m \operatorname{Re}\left[d_m(t)e^{im\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t)}\right].

Following POLARBEAR Collaboration et al. [53], for each m=1,…,12m = 1,\ldots,12 we band-pass the timestream within ±0.1\pm0.1 Hz of mfHWPmf_{\mathrm{HWP}} (1023-tap finite impulse response filter), demodulate by 2e−imθHWP(t)2e^{-im\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t)}, and low-pass at 0.1 Hz to obtain dm(t)d_m(t), then subtract the reconstructed harmonic before proceeding to the next. Notably, m=4m = 4 is included, so any polarization sky signal that varies slowly enough to lie within ±0.1\pm0.1 Hz of 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} is subtracted along with the HWPSS, while faster HWP-modulated polarization signal content (at 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}}) is preserved for downstream demodulation. The effect this has on real data is encapsulated when we calculate the pipeline transfer function, which will be discussed in § 4.7.

Filtering and Glitch Removal

The modulated data is put through two polynomial filters, one on the entire timestream and one per subscan. Both utilize Chebyshev polynomials, the former with n=5n = 5 and the latter with n=1n = 1. These are designed to remove the low-frequency noise primarily associated with fluctuations in atmospheric loading and the gain drifts that accompany them. These dominate the low-frequency content of the modulated timestream because the bulk atmospheric emission is unpolarized and therefore not modulated by the HWP.

In addition, during timestream processing, we identified populations of transient glitches and scan-synchronous spikes. Transient glitches are well documented in bolometric detector arrays generally, where energetic particle interactions with the silicon detector wafers produce events spanning a wide range of amplitudes and time constants ([9]). The scan-synchronous component is instead tied to the observing environment, arising from far-sidelobe ground pickup and from radio frequency interference (RFI) coupling into the multiplexed readout ([5]), the latter also being the suspected origin of the excess noise reported for PB-2b ([15]). Because the precise coupling mechanisms of out-of-band RFI and ground emission cannot be easily modeled from first principles, we employ a masking procedure and replacement with Gaussian noise for the purposes of demodulation. First, the autocorrelation function (ACF) is used as a convergence criterion; glitches are repeatedly flagged and the ACF is repeatedly recomputed, cleaning until the maximum ACF in the 5–400 s lag window drops below 0.08 or after four iterations. Each pass flags samples whose median-subtracted absolute deviation exceeds 3σ3\sigma, then extends each flagged region outward from its peak to the nearest local minimum on either side to capture the glitch’s full rise and fall, saving the mask. The masked regions are replaced with a linear baseline interpolated between the five-sample means on either side, plus a realization of white Gaussian noise scaled to that detector’s 6.5 Hz to 7.5 Hz noise floor. The noise is multiplied by a half-sine window that goes to zero at the first and last masked sample, so that no noise discontinuity is spliced against the surrounding real data. This Gaussian-filled timestream is used for demodulation, but those timestamps remain masked for later mapmaking.

Demodulation

This section primarily follows the framework described in S. Takakura et al. [64]. To demodulate, we apply a bandpass filter spanning 4fHWP±3.84f_{\mathrm{HWP}} \pm3.8 Hz to the modulated signal, isolating the polarization modulation at 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}}. This effectively removes the intensity signal, as with the scan speed of 0.4∘/s0.4^\circ/\mathrm{s} the lower bound of our bandpass is above the beam-imposed diffraction limit of the intensity timestream (∼1.8 Hz\sim1.8\,\mathrm{Hz} with beam size 4.9′4.9' [15]). This allows us to retain resolving power while not contaminating the modulated polarized signal with low-frequency noise. The remaining signal after HWPSS removal and bandpass filtering is, with Φ(j)(t)=4θHWP(t)−2θdet(j)\Phi^{(j)}(t)=4\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t)-2\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)} for brevity (where the detector polarization angle θdet(j)\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)} is calibrated per § 3.4),

dbp(j)(t)=Re⁡[(ηP(Qconv(j)(t)+iUconv(j)(t))+ϵdetIPIconv(j)(t))e−iΦ(j)(t)+Nw,bp(j)(t)+Natm,bp(j)(t)]=12{ηP(Qconv(j)(t)+iUconv(j)(t))+ϵdetIPIconv(j)(t)e−iΦ(j)(t)+[ηP(Qconv(j)(t)−iUconv(j)(t))+ϵdetIP∗Iconv(j)(t)]eiΦ(j)(t)}+Nw,bp(j)(t)+Natm,bp(j)(t),(10)\begin{aligned} d_{\mathrm{bp}}^{(j)}(t)=\operatorname{Re}\left[\left(\eta_{\mathrm{P}}\left(Q_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+iU_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right)+\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP}I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right)e^{-i\Phi^{(j)}(t)}+N_{\mathrm{w,bp}}^{(j)}(t)+N_{\mathrm{atm,bp}}^{(j)}(t)\right] \\ &=\frac{1}{2}\left\{\eta_{\mathrm{P}}\left(Q_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+iU_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right)+\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP}I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)e^{-i\Phi^{(j)}(t)}+\left[\eta_{\mathrm{P}}\left(Q_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)-iU_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right)+\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP*}I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right]e^{i\Phi^{(j)}(t)}\right\}+N_{\mathrm{w,bp}}^{(j)}(t)+N_{\mathrm{atm,bp}}^{(j)}(t), \tag*{(10)} \end{aligned}

where “bp” denotes a bandpass-filtered timestream. This is then shifted to baseband, i.e., the polarization signal is moved from the 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} carrier to zero frequency, by multiplying Equation (10) by 2e4iθHWP(t)2e^{4i\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t)}, resulting in

dbb(j)(t)=[ηP(Qconv(j)(t)+iUconv(j)(t))+ϵdetIPIconv(j)(t)]e2iθdet(j)+[ηP(Qconv(j)(t)−iUconv(j)(t))+ϵdetIP∗Iconv(j)(t)]ei[8θHWP(t)−2θdet(j)]+2Nw,bp(j)(t)e4iθHWP(t)+2Natm,bp(j)(t)e4iθHWP(t),(11)\begin{aligned} d_{\mathrm{bb}}^{(j)}(t)={}&\left[\eta_{\mathrm{P}}\left(Q_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+iU_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right)+\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP}I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right]e^{2i\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)}}\\ &+\left[\eta_{\mathrm{P}}\left(Q_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)-iU_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right)+\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP*}I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right]e^{i[8\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t)-2\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)}]}\\ &+2N_{\mathrm{w,bp}}^{(j)}(t)e^{4i\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t)}+2N_{\mathrm{atm,bp}}^{(j)}(t)e^{4i\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t)}, \tag*{(11)} \end{aligned}

where “bb” stands for “baseband.” A low-pass filter is then applied at 3.8 Hz3.8\,\mathrm{Hz}, which removes the term shifted up to 8θHWP(t)8\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t). The remaining modulated timestream is,

dLPF(j)(t)=[ηP(Qconv(j)(t)+iUconv(j)(t))+ϵdetIPIconv(j)(t)]e2iθdet(j)+2Nw,bp(j)(t)e4iθHWP(t)+2Natm,bp(j)(t)e4iθHWP(t).(12)d_{\mathrm{LPF}}^{(j)}(t)=\left[\eta_{\mathrm{P}}\left(Q_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+iU_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right)+\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP}I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right]e^{2i\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)}}+2N_{\mathrm{w,bp}}^{(j)}(t)e^{4i\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t)}+2N_{\mathrm{atm,bp}}^{(j)}(t)e^{4i\theta_{\mathrm{HWP}}(t)}. \tag*{(12)}

The timestream is then rotated into the QWP axis basis by multiplying by e−2iθdet(j)e^{-2i\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)}},

dQWP(j)(t)=e−2iθdet(j)dLPF(j)(t)=ηP(Qconv(j)(t)+iUconv(j)(t))+ϵdetIPIconv(j)(t)+2[Nw,bp(j)(t)+Natm,bp(j)(t)]eiΦ(j)(t),(13)\begin{aligned} d_{\mathrm{QWP}}^{(j)}(t)&=e^{-2i\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)}}d_{\mathrm{LPF}}^{(j)}(t)\\ &=\eta_{\mathrm{P}}\left(Q_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+iU_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\right)+\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP}I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+2\left[N_{\mathrm{w,bp}}^{(j)}(t)+N_{\mathrm{atm,bp}}^{(j)}(t)\right]e^{i\Phi^{(j)}(t)}, \tag*{(13)} \end{aligned}

with Φ(j)(t)\Phi^{(j)}(t) as defined above. This removes the detector-angle dependence of the sky terms exactly, so the real and imaginary components may be saved directly as Qobs(j)(t)Q_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(j)}(t) and Uobs(j)(t)U_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(j)}(t) without any residual dependence on θdet(j)\theta_{\mathrm{det}}^{(j)}. The intensity Iobs(j)(t)I_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(j)}(t) is recovered separately, from the unmodulated low-frequency component of the timestream (denoted “lp”) rather than from the band around 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}}, so it carries no ηP\eta_{\mathrm{P}} factor and retains the full low-frequency atmospheric noise. Together,

Iobs(j)(t)=Iconv(j)(t)+Nw,I(t)+Natm,I(t),(14)I_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(j)}(t)=I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+N_{\mathrm{w},I}(t)+N_{\mathrm{atm},I}(t), \tag*{(14)}
Qobs(j)(t)=ηPQconv(j)(t)+ϵdetIQIconv(j)(t)+Nw,Q(t)+Natm,Q(t),(15)Q_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(j)}(t)=\eta_{\mathrm{P}}Q_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IQ}I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+N_{\mathrm{w},Q}(t)+N_{\mathrm{atm},Q}(t), \tag*{(15)}
Uobs(j)(t)=ηPUconv(j)(t)+ϵdetIUIconv(j)(t)+Nw,U(t)+Natm,U(t),(16)U_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(j)}(t)=\eta_{\mathrm{P}}U_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IU}I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)+N_{\mathrm{w},U}(t)+N_{\mathrm{atm},U}(t), \tag*{(16)}

where the intensity leakage coefficients are the real and imaginary parts of ϵdetIP\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP},

ϵdetIQ=Re⁡[ϵdetIP],ϵdetIU=Im⁡[ϵdetIP],(17)\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IQ}=\operatorname{Re}\left[\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP}\right],\qquad\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IU}=\operatorname{Im}\left[\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IP}\right], \tag*{(17)}

and the noise terms follow the same demodulation as the sky signal. The intensity inherits the low-pass-filtered noise directly, Nw/atm,I=Nw/atm,lp(j)(t)N_{\mathrm{w/atm},I}=N_{\mathrm{w/atm,lp}}^{(j)}(t), while the polarization channels carry the bandpassed noise projected onto the two demodulation quadratures, Nw/atm,Q=2Nw/atm,bp(j)(t)cos⁡Φ(j)(t)N_{\mathrm{w/atm},Q}=2N_{\mathrm{w/atm,bp}}^{(j)}(t)\cos\Phi^{(j)}(t) and Nw/atm,U=2Nw/atm,bp(j)(t)sin⁡Φ(j)(t)N_{\mathrm{w/atm},U}=2N_{\mathrm{w/atm,bp}}^{(j)}(t)\sin\Phi^{(j)}(t).

To express this in terms of the Stokes components on the sky in the QWP basis, we use the effective matrix of § 2.2, Sconv=MSin\mathbf{S}_{\mathrm{conv}}=M\mathbf{S}_{\mathrm{in}}. For the observed Stokes UU,

Uobs(j)(t)=ηP[MIUIin(j)(t)+MQUQin(j)(t)+MUUUin(j)(t)+MVUVin(j)(t)]+ϵdetIUIin(j)(t)+N(j)(t),(18)\begin{aligned} U_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(j)}(t)={}&\eta_{\mathrm{P}}\left[M_{IU}I_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)+M_{QU}Q_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)\right.\\ &\left.+M_{UU}U_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)+M_{VU}V_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)\right]\\ &+\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IU}I_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)+N^{(j)}(t), \tag*{(18)} \end{aligned}

with Iconv(j)(t)≈Iin(j)(t)I_{\mathrm{conv}}^{(j)}(t)\approx I_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t), assuming negligible polarization leakage to intensity [55]. Using Equations (2a)–(2d), the observed Stokes UU becomes

Uobs(j)(t)=ηV[Vin(j)(t)+ϵQVQin(j)(t)+ϵUVUin(j)(t)]+(ϵdetIU+ηVϵIV)Iin(j)(t)+N(j)(t).(19)U_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(j)}(t)=\eta_V\left[V_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)+\epsilon^{QV}Q_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)+\epsilon^{UV}U_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)\right] +\left(\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IU}+\eta_V\epsilon^{IV}\right)I_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)+N^{(j)}(t). \tag*{(19)}

The intensity term of Equation (19) collects two contributions of distinct origin: ϵdetIU\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IU}, generated downstream of the optics in the nonlinear detector response, and ηVϵIV\eta_V\epsilon^{IV}, any static intensity leakage in the optics. We assume a value for neither, and therefore define the total intensity-to-UU-channel leakage, including the transferred II-to-VV as well as the downstream II-to-UU, to be

ϵtotIU≡ϵdetIU+ηVϵIV,(20)\epsilon_{\mathrm{tot}}^{IU} \equiv\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IU}+\eta_V\epsilon^{IV}, \tag*{(20)}

as the single quantity carried through the remainder of this work. The observed Stokes UU timestream is then, in final form,

Uobs(j)(t)=ηV[Vin(j)(t)+ϵQVQin(j)(t)+ϵUVUin(j)(t)]+ϵtotIUIin(j)(t)+N(j)(t).(21)U_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(j)}(t)=\eta_V\left[V_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)+\epsilon^{QV}Q_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)+\epsilon^{UV}U_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)\right]+\epsilon_{\mathrm{tot}}^{IU}I_{\mathrm{in}}^{(j)}(t)+N^{(j)}(t). \tag*{(21)}

Because ϵtotIU\epsilon_{\mathrm{tot}}^{IU} is measured as a ratio of beam window functions (Section 4.8.1), it is in general multipole dependent, and is written ϵℓ,totIU\epsilon_{\ell,\mathrm{tot}}^{IU} wherever it appears in ℓ\ell-space. As mentioned earlier, Equation (17) will be discussed in more detail in § 4.8. From the bandpass, the two noise terms are between ±3.8\pm3.8 Hz in baseband, which corresponds to between 4.34.3 Hz to 11.911.9 Hz in the modulated regime. Generally the atmospheric low-frequency noise shows up below 11 Hz, which is primarily decimated by the bandpass, and while the white noise is flat in frequency space, it becomes independent in QQ and UU and is independent detector-to-detector ([31]), so it averages down with more observing time.

Additional Filtering

In the event that low-frequency noise is not fully mitigated by the initial bandpass filtering, we reapply the polynomial filters described in § 4.2.3. This residual noise is mostly unpolarized and driven by inhomogeneously distributed, turbulent water vapor and line-of-sight temperature gradients. In addition, because this secondary filtering stage acts on the demodulated timestreams, it also suppresses circularly polarized emission from atmospheric oxygen via Zeeman splitting ([22, 59, 45, 19], see also Appendix § 10). Unlike water vapor, oxygen is well-mixed, producing a signal that varies smoothly with the telescope’s pointing relative to Earth’s magnetic field. While this signal is carried at 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} through the initial filtering stages, demodulation downconverts it to low frequencies. Because the telescope sweeps monotonically in azimuth during a subscan, a low-order polynomial filter in the time domain acts effectively as a low-order expansion in azimuth, absorbing the bulk of this smoothly varying atmospheric signal. Any surviving residuals remain tied to telescope azimuth rather than celestial coordinates, and are subsequently removed by the scan-synchronous filter (see Appendix § 10).

To address this remaining azimuth-locked pickup, such as ground spillover and far-sidelobe emission that recur at fixed pointings, we apply a scan-synchronous filter. Because left- and right-going sweeps generally couple differently to the local topography, the timestreams for each detector are divided into individual subscans and processed independently by scan direction. Within each direction, the subscans are pooled to construct an empirical template of the detector’s azimuthal response. The data are binned in fixed 0.2∘0.2^\circ azimuth intervals, and the median of each bin is taken to suppress transient noise and outliers; bins with insufficient samples are discarded. We then fit a Chebyshev polynomial of degree n=5n=5 to this profile, weighted by the intra-bin variance so that well-determined bins govern the fit. Finally, this smooth, direction-dependent azimuth template is evaluated at each sample’s true pointing and subtracted directly from the timestream.

Mapmaking

The result at the end of this processing is a set of timestream data, consisting of {RA(j)(t)}\left\{\mathrm{RA}^{(j)}(t)\right\}, {Dec(j)(t)}\left\{\mathrm{Dec}^{(j)}(t)\right\}, and {Iobs(j)(t)}\left\{I_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(j)}(t)\right\}, for which we have associated turnaround buffer and glitch masks. For each detector in each observation we construct flat-sky maps of its associated timestream. A tangent-plane (gnomonic) projection is defined about the field center, spanning 9∘9^\circ on a side at a fixed pixel scale with width 0.04∘0.04^\circ, and detectors are mapped independently before being combined. The best-fit planar gradient in sky coordinates is then subtracted from each detector’s retained samples, suppressing residual large-scale scan-synchronous and atmospheric gradients that survive the time-domain filtering. The cleaned samples are accumulated into the map by inverse-variance weighting, scaled according to the number of timestamp hits within a given pixel. Following collection of all detector maps within a single observation, the coadded observation map is computed as the per-pixel inverse-variance-weighted mean of the detector maps, utilizing the weight map saved alongside each map. This produces one map per CES, yielding 448 maps for RA23 and 341 for RA4.5 that survive the data quality cuts of § 4.4.

At 0.04∘0.04^\circ/pix (2.4′2.4') over a 9∘×9∘9^\circ\times9^\circ field, the map oversamples the science band. The pixel Nyquist multipole, ℓNyq=180∘/(Δθ)≈4500\ell_{\mathrm{Nyq}}=180^\circ/(\Delta\theta)\approx4500, sits well above the highest analyzed multipole ℓmax⁡=2000\ell_{\max}=2000 (a factor ∼2.25\sim2.25 in margin), so aliasing from pixelization is negligible over the analyzed multipoles. Pixelization does still smooth the map, suppressing power by the azimuthally averaged pixel window function,

Wℓ2=12π∫02πsinc⁡2(ℓΔθ2cos⁡φ)sinc⁡2(ℓΔθ2sin⁡φ) dφ(22)W_{\ell}^{2} = \frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{0}^{2\pi} \operatorname{sinc}^{2}\left(\frac{\ell\Delta\theta}{2}\cos\varphi\right) \operatorname{sinc}^{2}\left(\frac{\ell\Delta\theta}{2}\sin\varphi\right)\,d\varphi \tag*{(22)}

where φ\varphi is the relative azimuthal angle of the 2D Fourier mode. The value of this function is ∼0.996\sim0.996 at ℓ=300\ell= 300 and ∼0.850\sim0.850 at ℓ=2000\ell= 2000. This suppression is folded into the measurement of the transfer function, discussed in § 4.7, as the simulated maps are generated at the same resolution as the observed maps. The pixel window therefore enters the forward model of § 4.9 exactly once, through TℓT_{\ell}. The explicit WℓW_{\ell} of Equation (22) is used only in Equation (38), to remove a second copy from a quantity that would otherwise carry one.

Data Quality Cuts

We impose additional data quality cuts to ensure that known systematics do not propagate into the final analysis, motivated by the null test suite of § 4.6. We split these cuts into both observation-level and detector-level cuts, as was done in the null tests. The yields in the following table are relative to the previous cut. Instrument loss refers to detector-observations lost to the technical failures described in § 2.3, such as corrupted timestream files, improperly stored database identifiers, or failed detector tuning. It also includes detectors that lack time constants or absolute gain calibration factors. The two observation cuts are whether a given run has associated temperature and PWV from the Atacama Pathfinder EXperiment (APEX, ∼5\sim5 km from the PB-2b site) and focal plane temperatures within 0.30 K to 0.38 K. APEX weather readings were required to run null tests with associated criteria and the focal plane temperature ranges exclude a focal plane with elevated temperatures. With the detector splits, we eliminate detectors with extreme non-physical limits of calibration parameters. Gain calibration factors must be negative (due to TES polarity) and ≥−20\geq-20 mKCMB_{\mathrm{CMB}}/ADC, time constant must be <50<50 ms, and measured white noise must be between 10 μ10\ \muKCMB/Hz_{\mathrm{CMB}}/\sqrt{\mathrm{Hz}} and 100100 mKCMB/Hz_{\mathrm{CMB}}/\sqrt{\mathrm{Hz}}. These ensure the calibration factors are physical and the saved maps are within expected bounds. Finally, we make selections based on quantities derived from the maps themselves. Detector maps with known issues, such as spatial artifacts resulting from filtering, HWPSS removal, or glitch masking, are intentionally not used. These only appear in the RA23 patch. Runs with pixels that point to the edge of the patch footprint are not used; this is typically reflective of the boresight getting stuck and not tracking properly as the sky rotates. Finally, detector maps with abnormally high RMS, >500>500 mKCMB_{\mathrm{CMB}}, are also dropped, as a final removal of any detector maps that are unphysical yet survive the earlier cuts.

The results of these cuts, as well as the earlier losses due to instrument technical issues, are represented in Table 1.

Selection TypeRA23RA4.5
Instrument Loss Yield62.9%56.2%
Observation selection82.0%83.2%
Weather data exists98.1%95.6%
Focal plane temperature83.6%87.0%
Detector selection89.3%83.2%
Gain calibration factor92.3%84.6%
Time constant99.6%99.4%
White noise97.1%99.0%
Map selection94.1%91.3%
Map artifacts96.1%100%
Boresight pointing drift99.9%92.5%
High variance98.1%98.8%
Overall Yield43.3%35.5%

Table 1. Summary of data retention yields from saved detector-observations. The first row reflects the instrument losses described in § 2.3, both observation-wide and from detectors lacking calibration factors; all subsequent yields are relative to the preceding cut.

Power Spectrum Estimation

MASTER Estimator

The angular auto-power spectrum is estimated from a set of cross-power spectra, computed from pairs of independently coadded maps using the flat-sky implementation of the MASTER (Monte-Carlo Apodised Spherical Transform Estimator) pseudo-power-spectrum formalism via NaMASTER and its Python wrapper pymaster ([25, 3]). Because each pair of maps is built from two disjoint sets of observations, their instrumental noise is uncorrelated and approximately averages to zero in the cross-correlation, so the resulting bandpowers are an unbiased estimate of the sky signal free of the noise-bias term that contaminates a single-map auto-spectrum. Each map is treated as a small patch of the celestial sphere projected onto a flat grid in right ascension and declination; the physical angular extent of the grid is set by the patch size, with the right-ascension axis rescaled by the cosine of the central declination to account for the convergence of meridians, so that the two-dimensional Fourier modes correspond to well-defined angular multipoles.

Before the transform, each map is lightly conditioned. Unobserved pixels are set to zero, the pixel-value distribution is iteratively sigma-clipped to obtain a robust per-map noise amplitude used to weight that pair relative to others, and a weighted monopole is subtracted so that the mean within the observed region vanishes. The coverage mask for each field is the region of valid coverage, defined as pixels with hit count >−5>-5 dB of the maximum. The threshold is set logarithmically rather than as a linear fraction because the hit count of a constant-elevation scan falls off across more than an order of magnitude between the deeply covered center of the field and its turnaround-dominated perimeter, so a decibel cut places the boundary on the natural scale of the coverage profile. The −5-5 dB value, retaining pixels above ∼32%\sim32\% of the peak hit count, balances sky area against edge quality. Pixels below it carry the highest per-pixel noise and the largest residuals from the ground-template and polynomial filtering of § 4.2, so they contribute little statistical weight relative to the systematic risk they introduce; they also lie where the coverage boundary becomes most irregular, which broadens the mode-coupling kernel and degrades the conditioning of the binned coupling matrix. For RA4.5 a 0.2∘0.2^\circ-radius circular hole is additionally cut at the position of the bright point source J0440−-4333 (see Appendix § 11) (M. Bonato et al. [8]), the only significant potentially contaminating point source within either footprint (K. Sakaguri et al. [55]), so that its compact emission does not contribute to the bandpowers. The mask is apodized with a 0.2∘0.2^\circ-wide cosine taper. At five map pixels, this width is well resolved by the grid, so its smooth roll-off replaces the slowly decaying mode-coupling sidelobes of a sharp edge with a compact kernel that keeps the binned coupling matrix well conditioned. It nonetheless remains small compared to both the ∼2∘×3∘\sim2^\circ\times3^\circ effective footprint retained by the hit-count threshold and the ∼1.2∘\sim1.2^\circ angular wavelength of the lowest analyzed multipole (ℓ=300\ell= 300). The apodized footprint is not applied as a binary weight; it is multiplied by the per-pixel inverse-variance weight map from mapmaking (§ 4.3), and it is the power spectrum of this combined weight map that sets the mode-coupling matrix.

The masked, apodized maps are then carried through the MASTER estimator, which deconvolves the mode coupling induced by the finite apodized footprint using the coupling matrix computed from the power spectrum of the mask itself (E. Hivon et al. [25]). Because that matrix is singular at the level of individual multipoles, the spectrum is first averaged into uniform bandpowers over the range where the binned matrix can be inverted. No beam is deconvolved at this stage, so these bandpowers remain beam-smoothed. The beam is removed only in the final inversion of § 4.9.

In the context of this study, this MASTER estimation procedure is primarily used to determine the measured circular polarization spectra as cross-spectra between pairs of independently coadded observation maps. However, we also use this estimator within the context of simulated maps, in order to estimate transfer functions (see § 4.7) and leakages (see § 4.8).

Measured UU Spectra

The quantity accessible directly from the maps is the UUUU power spectrum of UobsU_{\mathrm{obs}}, not the circular polarization spectrum itself. As shown in Equation (21), the observed UU carries the sky VV signal converted by the QWP, but scaled by the circular polarization efficiency ηV\eta_V and accompanied by leakage from sky II, QQ, and UU, as well as suppression by the instrument beam, residual pointing error, and the filtering applied to the timestreams. Recovering CℓVVC_\ell^{VV} therefore requires measuring the observed UUUU bandpowers first and then disentangling each of these contributions from them. This section presents that measurement; the transfer function and leakage terms are quantified in § 4.7 and § 4.8, and the inversion that yields CℓVVC_\ell^{VV} is carried out in § 4.9.

We estimate the average of the cross-spectra from the set of coadded observation maps, which are immune to the noise bias of an auto-spectrum because the noise in two different maps is uncorrelated. Forming cross-spectra between the individual CES maps of § 4.3 would require of order 10510^5 pairs per patch. These are therefore first combined into a smaller number of deeper maps. Each patch is observed in blocks of several consecutive CESes, and the maps within a block are coadded together. Each CES contributes to exactly one such map, so no observation is shared between any two of them and their noise remains uncorrelated. This reduces the 448 CES maps of RA23 and the 341 of RA4.5 to MpatchRA23=75M_{\mathrm{patch}}^{\mathrm{RA23}} = 75 and MpatchRA4.5=61M_{\mathrm{patch}}^{\mathrm{RA4.5}} = 61 independent maps, respectively, which we index by a∈{1,…,Mpatch}a \in\{1,\ldots,M_{\mathrm{patch}}\}. We then form the cross-power spectra of all Npatch=Mpatch(Mpatch−1)/2N_{\mathrm{patch}} = M_{\mathrm{patch}}(M_{\mathrm{patch}}-1)/2 distinct map pairs, indexed by k∈{1,…,Npatch}k \in\{1,\ldots,N_{\mathrm{patch}}\}, where the pair kk is formed from the two distinct maps aa and a′a'. Each pair spectrum is computed with the flat-sky MASTER estimator on monopole-subtracted, apodized maps and binned into Δℓ=100\Delta\ell= 100 bandpowers over 300≤ℓ≤2000300 \le\ell\le2000. The pairs are not equally informative, because the maps entering them differ in depth and different pairs overlap over different fractions of the patch. A uniform average would therefore be suboptimal, and the bandpower estimate is instead formed as an inverse-variance weighted mean over pairs,

C~^ℓUU,obs=∑kwkC^ℓ,(k)UU,obs∑kwk,(23)\widehat{\tilde{C}}_{\ell}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}} = \frac{\sum_k w_k \widehat{C}_{\ell,(k)}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}}{\sum_k w_k}, \tag*{(23)}

which is the quantity plotted as the data points. Throughout, a hat denotes a quantity estimated from the data and a bar an average, so that C^ℓ\widehat{C}_\ell is a single measured cross-spectrum and Cˉℓ\bar{C}_\ell its mean over pairs; spectra carrying a bar alone, such as the leakage terms of § 4.8, are averages over simulations rather than measurements. The one exception is n^\hat{n}, which denotes a direction on the sky.

The weight wkw_k is a single ℓ\ell-independent inverse-noise-variance factor per pair,

wk=fskyeff(k)σa2σa′2,(24)w_k = \frac{f_{\mathrm{sky}}^{\mathrm{eff}}(k)}{\sigma_a^2 \sigma_{a'}^2}, \tag*{(24)}

where σa\sigma_a and σa′\sigma_{a'} are per-map noise proxies for the two maps forming pair kk, each obtained by taking the standard deviation of the unmasked pixels, discarding those deviating by more than 4σ4\sigma, and adopting the standard deviation of the pixels that remain. The effective sky fraction fskyeff(k)f_{\mathrm{sky}}^{\mathrm{eff}}(k) is the mean over pixels of the product of those two maps’ apodized coverage masks. Because the cross-spectrum variance scales as σa2σa′2/fskyeff\sigma_a^2 \sigma_{a'}^2/f_{\mathrm{sky}}^{\mathrm{eff}}, Equation (24) is the corresponding inverse-variance weight; the common sky-signal contribution to the map variance is shared by every pair and cancels in Equation (23), so a scalar weight encoding only per-pair noise and mask overlap well approximates the optimal weight.

Estimating the uncertainty on C^ℓUU,obs\widehat{C}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}_\ell requires accounting for correlations between the pair spectra, because the NpatchN_{\mathrm{patch}} pairs are formed from a common set of MpatchM_{\mathrm{patch}} maps, with each map entering Mpatch−1M_{\mathrm{patch}}-1 pairs. In principle this couples pairs that share a map, which would make the maps, rather than the pairs, the independent units. Two such pairs are correlated, however, only through a component common to their unshared maps. These maps are dominated by instrument noise, which is independent from map to map, and each is itself a coadd of separate observations, so their atmospheric fluctuations are independent as well. The only component common to every map is the sky signal itself. Theoretical predictions place CMB circular polarization well below our sensitivity [30, 15], so this shared component is expected to be negligible. We confirm this directly by estimating the shared-map covariance ζ1≡Cov⁡(C^ℓUU,obs,(k),C^ℓUU,obs,(k′))\zeta_1 \equiv\operatorname{Cov}(\widehat{C}^{UU,\mathrm{obs},(k)}_\ell,\widehat{C}^{UU,\mathrm{obs},(k')}_\ell) between distinct pairs kk and k′k' that have one of their two maps in common, which is consistent with zero in every ℓ\ell-bin; the pairs are therefore effectively independent. We accordingly estimate the covariance of C^ℓUU,obs\widehat{C}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}_\ell with a pair-level bootstrap. In each of Nboot=103N_{\mathrm{boot}}=10^3 bootstrap realizations, indexed by r∈{1,…,Nboot}r \in\{1,\ldots,N_{\mathrm{boot}}\} and labeled throughout by the superscript (r)(r), we draw NpatchN_{\mathrm{patch}} pairs with replacement and recompute the weighted mean of Equation (23) over the resampled set,

C^ℓUU,obs,(r)=∑k∈B(r)wkC^ℓUU,obs,(k)∑k∈B(r)wk,(25)\widehat{C}^{UU,\mathrm{obs},(r)}_\ell= \frac{\sum_{k\in B^{(r)}} w_k \widehat{C}^{UU,\mathrm{obs},(k)}_\ell} {\sum_{k\in B^{(r)}} w_k}, \tag*{(25)}

where B(r)B^{(r)} is the multiset of pair indices drawn in realization rr, so that C^ℓUU,obs,(r)\widehat{C}^{UU,\mathrm{obs},(r)}_\ell is the weighted mean recovered from that realization. The bandpower covariance is the sample covariance of the NbootN_{\mathrm{boot}} resampled means,

Σℓℓ′UU,obs=1Nboot−1∑r=1NbootΔℓ(r)Δℓ′(r),(26)\Sigma^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}_{\ell\ell'} = \frac{1}{N_{\mathrm{boot}}-1} \sum_{r=1}^{N_{\mathrm{boot}}} \Delta^{(r)}_\ell\Delta^{(r)}_{\ell'}, \tag*{(26)}
Δℓ(r)≡C^ℓUU,obs,(r)−⟨C^ℓUU,obs⟩r,(27)\Delta^{(r)}_\ell\equiv\widehat{C}^{UU,\mathrm{obs},(r)}_\ell- \left\langle\widehat{C}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}_\ell\right\rangle_r, \tag*{(27)}

where ⟨⋅⟩r\langle\cdot\rangle_r averages over realizations; the uncertainty per ℓ\ell-bin is ΣℓℓUU,obs\sqrt{\Sigma^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}_{\ell\ell}}. The covariance is therefore measured directly from the resampled scatter, rather than assumed from an analytic form evaluated at a fiducial spectrum; the Gaussian likelihood of § 4.10 uses only this measured second moment. We verified that the alternative map-level bootstrap, in which whole maps rather than pairs are resampled and each pair is weighted by the product of the number of times its two maps were drawn, inflates the bandpower uncertainties ΣℓℓUU,obs\sqrt{\Sigma^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}_{\ell\ell}} by a factor of ∼1.8\sim1.8; since ζ1≃0\zeta_1 \simeq0, this excess reflects the scatter in those draw counts from one realization to the next rather than genuine map-to-map correlation, and would bias the covariance high.

Null Tests

We assess the internal consistency of the power spectrum, measured in § 4.5, with a suite of sign-flip jackknife null tests, following the framework developed for earlier POLARBEAR analyses [52, 53]. Each test is defined by a criterion cc that partitions the data into two halves according to a particular systematic. The null test criteria are listed in Appendix § 9 and are adapted from PB24, with a few additional criteria specific to PB-2b. Differencing the two half-coadds cancels the common sky signal, so the resulting null bandpower spectrum C^bnull(c)\widehat{C}^{\mathrm{null}}_b(c) (estimated via MASTER as discussed in § 4.5.1) is consistent with zero in the absence of systematic contamination or miscalibration. Throughout this section bb indexes the same Δℓ=100\Delta\ell=100 bandpowers over 300≤ℓ≤2000300\leq\ell\leq2000 used elsewhere in this work; we label bb by the discrete index bb rather than their center ℓ\ell only to keep the sums and maxima over bins compact. The null tests and the data quality cuts of § 4.4 were developed together rather than in sequence—a criterion that failed motivated a candidate cut or pipeline adjustment, which was applied before the full suite was rerun, iterating until every criterion passed. The cuts quoted in § 4.4 are the endpoint of that loop, and the PTEs reported below are those of the final iteration.

The null distribution for each criterion is estimated directly from the data by Monte Carlo simulation. We generate N=200N=200 random sign-flip realizations C^brand,i(c)\widehat{C}^{\mathrm{rand},i}_b(c), i=1,…,Ni=1,\ldots,N, each constructed identically to the data null spectrum C^bnull(c)\widehat{C}^{\mathrm{null}}_b(c) except that the observations are assigned to the two halves at random rather than by the criterion cc. Each realization therefore inherits the noise, filtering, and survey geometry of the data but contains no coherent split-dependent signal. From this ensemble we form the per-criterion mean μb(c)\mu_b(c) and standard deviation σb(c)\sigma_b(c), the standardized per-bin residuals of the data, χc,b=(C^bnull(c)−μb(c))/σb(c)\chi_{c,b} = (\widehat{C}^{\mathrm{null}}_b(c)-\mu_b(c))/\sigma_b(c), and the bandpower covariance CcC_c, which defines a covariance-weighted statistic for each criterion,

χnull2(c)=(C^null(c)−μ(c))TCc−1(C^null(c)−μ(c)),(28)\chi^2_{\mathrm{null}}(c) = \left(\widehat{\mathbf{C}}^{\mathrm{null}}(c)-\boldsymbol{\mu}(c)\right)^{\mathrm{T}} C_c^{-1} \left(\widehat{\mathbf{C}}^{\mathrm{null}}(c)-\boldsymbol{\mu}(c)\right), \tag*{(28)}

where boldface denotes vectors over the bandpower index bb. Evaluated on the data split, Equation (28) yields the observed statistic χnull2(c)\chi^2_{\mathrm{null}}(c), while the identical expression applied to each random shuffle ii (replacing C^null(c)\widehat{\mathbf{C}}^{\mathrm{null}}(c) with C^rand,i(c)\widehat{\mathbf{C}}^{\mathrm{rand},i}(c)) yields its null distribution {χrand2(c)}i=1N\{\chi^2_{\mathrm{rand}}(c)\}_{i=1}^{N}. Because the same statistics are evaluated on every shuffle, each quantity carries its own empirical null distribution and we make no assumption about its analytic form. A PTE is read off as

PTE=1+N≥N+1,(29)\mathrm{PTE} = \frac{1+N_{\geq}}{N+1}, \tag*{(29)}

where N≥N_{\geq} is the number of shuffle realizations whose value of the statistic is at least as extreme as the observed (data) value, so that the fraction of trials (data included) at least as extreme as the observed value is well defined and unbiased at finite NN.

To avoid reporting many correlated PTEs, we compress the full set of residuals into four summary statistics, each sensitive to a distinct failure mode. These are the grand mean ⟨χnull⟩c,b\langle\chi_{\mathrm{null}}\rangle_{c,b}, which detects a coherent additive bias and is evaluated two-sided; the largest single excursion max⁡c,bχnull2\max_{c,b}\chi^2_{\mathrm{null}}, sensitive to one anomalous bandpower; the worst criterion max⁡cχnull2(c)\max_c\chi^2_{\mathrm{null}}(c) from Equation (28), sensitive to one bad split; and the total ∑cχnull2(c)\sum_c\chi^2_{\mathrm{null}}(c), which captures a diffuse, low-level excess spread across many splits. Each statistic is referred to its own shuffle distribution via Equation (29) to yield a PTE (Table 2).

StatisticRA23 ValueRA23 PTERA4.5 ValueRA4.5 PTE
⟨χnull⟩c,b\langle\chi_{\mathrm{null}}\rangle_{c,b}0.0240.7650.0200.915
max⁡c,bχnull2\max_{c,b}\chi^2_{\mathrm{null}}11.220.19512.000.145
max⁡cχnull2(c)\max_c\chi^2_{\mathrm{null}}(c)34.860.06033.810.055
∑cχnull2(c)\sum_c\chi^2_{\mathrm{null}}(c)543.30.265533.10.315
PTEmetamin⁡\mathrm{PTE}^{\min}_{\mathrm{meta}}0.1900.160
PTEmetamax⁡\mathrm{PTE}^{\max}_{\mathrm{meta}}0.5750.300

Table 2. Summary of the PB-2b VV null tests for the RA23 and RA4.5 patches.

Because four statistics are examined simultaneously, the most extreme of them is biased toward small values even under a clean null, and the minimum PTE cannot be interpreted at face value. We therefore treat the “worst of four,” PTEmin⁡=min⁡kPTEk\mathrm{PTE}^{\min}=\min_k\mathrm{PTE}_k, and the “best of four,” PTEmax⁡=max⁡kPTEk\mathrm{PTE}^{\max}=\max_k\mathrm{PTE}_k, as test statistics in their own right and calibrate them against the null. The identical four-statistic reduction is applied to each shuffle, producing distributions of PTEmin⁡\mathrm{PTE}^{\min} and PTEmax⁡\mathrm{PTE}^{\max} from which we compute the look-elsewhere–corrected meta-PTEs,

PTEmetamin⁡=1+#{i:PTEimin⁡≤PTEdatamin⁡}N+1,(30)\mathrm{PTE}^{\min}_{\mathrm{meta}} = \frac{1+\#\{i:\mathrm{PTE}^{\min}_i\leq\mathrm{PTE}^{\min}_{\mathrm{data}}\}}{N+1}, \tag*{(30)}
PTEmetamax⁡=1+#{i:PTEimax⁡≥PTEdatamax⁡}N+1(31)\mathrm{PTE}^{\max}_{\mathrm{meta}} = \frac{1+\#\{i:\mathrm{PTE}^{\max}_i\geq\mathrm{PTE}^{\max}_{\mathrm{data}}\}}{N+1} \tag*{(31)}

By construction the shuffles “look elsewhere” exactly as the analysis does, so the multiple-testing penalty is incorporated automatically, without assuming Gaussianity or independence among the four statistics. The condition for passage is that both meta-PTEs fall within (0.05, 0.95). Each is uniformly distributed under a clean null, so either tail is informative, and the two bounds catch complementary failures. A low PTEmetamin⁡\mathrm{PTE}^{\min}_{\mathrm{meta}} or a high PTEmetamax⁡\mathrm{PTE}^{\max}_{\mathrm{meta}} indicates residual contamination; in the first case the least consistent of the four statistics is more extreme than the shuffle ensemble permits, and in the second even the most consistent one is not consistent enough. A high PTEmetamin⁡\mathrm{PTE}^{\min}_{\mathrm{meta}} or a low PTEmetamax⁡\mathrm{PTE}^{\max}_{\mathrm{meta}} instead signals the opposite pathology of over-consistency, the hallmark of error bars that are too conservative. Both patches pass, and we find PTEmetamin⁡=0.19 (0.16)\mathrm{PTE}^{\min}_{\mathrm{meta}}=0.19\ (0.16) and PTEmetamax⁡=0.58 (0.30)\mathrm{PTE}^{\max}_{\mathrm{meta}}=0.58\ (0.30) for RA23 (RA4.5), with the smallest individual PTE in either patch being 0.055 (Table 2, Figure 4).

Figure 4. Look-elsewhere calibration of the null tests for RA23 (blue) and RA4.5 (orange). Left: distribution over the N=200N = 200 random sign-flip shuffles of the most significant of the four summary-statistic PTEs, min⁡kPTEk\min_k \mathrm{PTE}_k; right: the least significant, max⁡kPTEk\max_k \mathrm{PTE}_k. Dashed vertical lines mark the values measured in the data, and the corrected meta-PTEs of Equation (24) are simply the shuffle fractions at or beyond them (to the left in the left panel, to the right in the right), and are tabulated alongside the individual statistics in Table 2. In both patches the data fall well within the null distributions, showing neither an anomalously low minimum PTE (left) nor the clustering near unity that would signal over-consistency (right).

Transfer Functions

The combination of ground-template removal, polynomial and subscan filtering, and demodulation suppresses and mixes power in the recovered maps; this is an effect we characterize with an end-to-end simulation transfer function TℓT_\ell. For each patch, given that true sky VV is an unknown signal, we generate Nsim=100N_{\mathrm{sim}}=100 realizations of a known input sky signal, in this case white noise smoothed with a Gaussian kernel of 5′ standard deviation so that it carries power across the full range of analyzed multipoles. The simulated sky is then scanned into timestream using the real pointing and detector set, with noise added following the measured PB-2b noise spectrum but scaled down in amplitude. The resulting timestreams are propagated through the identical map-making pipeline applied to the data (time-constant deconvolution, turnaround masking, degree-five polynomial and subscan-polynomial filtering, ground-template and notch HWPSS removal, demodulation, and per-subscan binning and coaddition). Retaining noise at all keeps the stochastic character of the timestreams that the noise-dependent stages of the pipeline respond to, such as glitch flagging, sigma-clipping, and inverse-variance weighting, while scaling it down reduces the scatter on TℓT_\ell and so the number of realizations needed for it to converge. Aside from this reduced noise level, the only difference from the data run is the substitution of the known input sky for the measured timestreams, so the resulting output map moutm^{\mathrm{out}} carries the full multiplicative and mode-mixing response of the analysis to a known input minm^{\mathrm{in}}.

We estimate the transfer function from the cross-spectrum of the processed output with the input realization. For each input sky realization s∈{1,…,Nsim}s \in\{1,\ldots,N_{\mathrm{sim}}\} we first average over a set of observations i∈{1,…,Nobs}i \in\{1,\ldots,N_{\mathrm{obs}}\} reserved for these simulations, which is the benchmark set for RA23 and a separate set for RA4.5 (§ 4.1),

T^ℓ(s)=1Nobs∑i=1NobsC^ℓm(i,s)out×m(s)inC^ℓm(s)in×m(s)in,(32)\widehat{T}_{\ell}^{(s)} = \frac{1}{N_{\mathrm{obs}}}\sum_{i=1}^{N_{\mathrm{obs}}}\frac{\widehat{C}_{\ell}^{m^{\mathrm{out}}_{(i,s)}\times m^{\mathrm{in}}_{(s)}}}{\widehat{C}_{\ell}^{m^{\mathrm{in}}_{(s)}\times m^{\mathrm{in}}_{(s)}}}, \tag*{(32)}

and then average over realizations,

Tℓ=1Nsim∑s=1NsimT^ℓ(s),(33)T_\ell= \frac{1}{N_{\mathrm{sim}}}\sum_{s=1}^{N_{\mathrm{sim}}}\widehat{T}_{\ell}^{(s)}, \tag*{(33)}

binned in the same bandpowers as our science spectra. Here m(s)inm^{\mathrm{in}}_{(s)} is the input sky of realization ss and m(i,s)outm^{\mathrm{out}}_{(i,s)} is the map recovered by propagating that realization through observation ii; the index ii runs over that set rather than over the full data set. Using the output×\timesinput cross-spectrum rather than the output auto-spectrum makes the estimator insensitive to any signal uncorrelated with the input (e.g. map noise). Normalizing by the per-realization input auto-spectrum, rather than the ensemble-mean or theory spectrum, cancels the sample variance of each realization in the ratio.

The effective number of modes per bandpower, measured directly from the scatter of the input auto-spectra, is Nℓ≈90N_\ell\approx90–700700 over the range considered, so this removes a 2/Nℓ≈5\sqrt{2/N_\ell} \approx5–15%15\% per-realization fluctuation and reduces the variance of TℓT_\ell by 20–25%. Because TℓT_\ell is formed bin by bin as this ratio, it characterizes the response of the filtering pipeline rather than any property of the sky, and is insensitive to the choice of input spectrum provided each bandpower carries sufficient power.

Circular polarization is a spin-0 field with a single auto-spectrum and no E/BE/B decomposition, and the analysis correspondingly operates on the single demodulated UU map, so the transfer function suffices; the lensed-Λ\LambdaCDM TT/TE/EE/BBTT/TE/EE/BB realizations used to evaluate the P→VP \to V leakage are described separately in § 4.8.2.

The uncertainty on TℓT_\ell is estimated from the scatter among the T^ℓ(s)\widehat{T}_{\ell}^{(s)},

Cov⁡(Tℓ,Tℓ′)=1Nsim(Nsim−1)∑s=1Nsim(T^ℓ(s)−Tℓ)(T^ℓ′(s)−Tℓ′).(34)\operatorname{Cov}(T_\ell,T_{\ell'}) = \frac{1}{N_{\mathrm{sim}}(N_{\mathrm{sim}}-1)}\sum_{s=1}^{N_{\mathrm{sim}}}\left(\widehat{T}_{\ell}^{(s)}-T_\ell\right)\left(\widehat{T}_{\ell'}^{(s)}-T_{\ell'}\right). \tag*{(34)}

Because every observation in the set processes the same set of input skies, any realization-dependent bias in T^ℓ(s)\widehat{T}_{\ell}^{(s)} is common to all ii and averages down only with NsimN_{\mathrm{sim}}; the independent samples are therefore the input skies rather than the observations, and the covariance must be taken over ss after the average over ii has been performed.

The transfer function is determined independently for each patch. C^ℓUU,obs\widehat{C}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}_{\ell} is deconvolved by TℓT_{\ell}, together with the beam and the circular polarization efficiency ηV\eta_{V}, before the upper limits are derived, and its covariance is propagated into the final error budget; the results are shown together with BℓB_{\ell} in Figure 5. Additionally, Figure 5 demonstrates low-ℓ\ell suppression, which validates that the polynomial and scan-synchronous filtering stages (described in § 4.2.3 and 4.2.5, respectively) effectively marginalize the low-ℓ\ell contamination associated with atmosphere, most notably the circularly polarized signal induced by O2\mathrm{O}_{2} Zeeman splitting and the loading fluctuations induced by variable water vapor.

Leakage Estimation

In K. Sakaguri et al. [55], the leakages between Stokes parameters due to instrument systematics were discussed. In this section we will derive bandpower intensity leakage and forecast the polarization leakage based on the scan strategy of PB-2b. The contributions of both leakage sources are shown in Figure 6, where

Figure 6. Leakages determined from Sections 4.8.1 and § 4.8.2. The left is for RA23, and the right RA4.5. The joint contribution of both leakage sources is shown as the solid step plot with associated uncertainty ranges, accounting for ηV=0.528±0.032\eta_V = 0.528 \pm0.032. The uncertainties in the plots are propagated from the circular polarization uncertainty and variance of the individual leakage contributors.

Cℓleak=∣ηV∣2CℓP→V+CℓI→U(35)C_{\ell}^{\mathrm{leak}} = |\eta_{V}|^{2} C_{\ell}^{P\to V} + C_{\ell}^{I\to U} \tag*{(35)}

based on the leakage terms present in Equation (41).

Total I→UI \to U Leakage in ℓ\ell-Space

As mentioned earlier, K. Sakaguri et al. [55] report a small but non-negligible intensity leakage into the VV channel. However, there is additional leakage from intensity generated in the detector response (S. Takakura [63]), downstream of the optics and therefore outside the Mueller-matrix description; this is the ϵdetIU\epsilon_{\mathrm{det}}^{IU} of Equation (17). The quantity measured here is therefore the total ϵℓ,totIU\epsilon_{\ell,\mathrm{tot}}^{IU} of Equation (20), which additionally absorbs the static optical leakage ηVϵIV\eta_{V}\epsilon^{IV}. We measure it directly from observations of Jupiter, which at 90 GHz is a bright and, to good approximation, unpolarized source (both in linear and circular). Any UU response in its co-added map is therefore dominated by instrumental leakage of II. We co-add all 90 GHz Jupiter maps in IobsI_{\mathrm{obs}} and UobsU_{\mathrm{obs}}, with Stokes data transformed into the QWP basis, apodize the finite map with a 2′2' taper, zero-pad, and Fourier transform; both transforms share a common normalization (the II zero-mode), which cancels in the leakage ratio below. In essence, this is the same procedure as the estimation of the instrumental beam, detailed in § 3.2, and uncertainty in each ℓ\ell-bin is propagated similarly.

As a result, the total I→UI \to U leakage is the ratio of the two amplitudes,

ϵℓ,totIU=BℓUBℓI,(36)\epsilon_{\ell,\mathrm{tot}}^{IU} = \frac{B_{\ell}^{U}}{B_{\ell}^{I}}, \tag*{(36)}

where BℓI/UB_{\ell}^{I/U} are the beam functions of the demodulated Stokes component maps IobsI_{\mathrm{obs}} and UobsU_{\mathrm{obs}}, respectively, following the same procedure in § 3.2. The uncertainty on the leakage in each multipole bin is estimated with a leave-one-out jackknife over the individual planet observations, re-coadding Stokes II and UU and re-running the full pipeline with each observation removed in turn. Across 300≤ℓ≤2000300 \leq\ell\leq2000, we find ϵℓ,totIU∼(1.8±0.3)%\epsilon_{\ell,\mathrm{tot}}^{IU} \sim(1.8 \pm0.3)\%. This is the total leakage into the VV-carrying channel, containing both the optical term of § 2.2 and the detector-response term of § 4.2.4; we do not attempt to separate the two. We carry ϵℓ,totIU\epsilon_{\ell,\mathrm{tot}}^{IU} and its uncertainty in ℓ\ell-space as systematic terms in the VVVV error budget.

We estimate the total leakage in ℓ\ell-space,

CℓI→U=∣ϵℓ,totIU∣2CℓTT,sky,(37)C_{\ell}^{I\to U} = \left|\epsilon_{\ell,\mathrm{tot}}^{IU}\right|^{2} C_{\ell}^{TT,\mathrm{sky}}, \tag*{(37)}

where CℓTT,skyC_{\ell}^{TT,\mathrm{sky}} is computed from CAMB (A. Lewis et al. [33]), using best-fit cosmological parameters from Planck (Planck Collaboration et al. [48]). Measured II maps from PB-2b were not utilized, due to high low-frequency noise from weather contaminating the demodulated intensity maps. Because II and VV are spin-0 fields, they are invariant under the rotation represented by the detector transform.

Overall P-to-V Leakage

As discussed in § 2.2, residual instrumental coupling converts a fraction of the linear polarization into the circular-polarization channel, so the measured VV map contains a leakage term ϵQVQin+ϵUVUin\epsilon^{QV}Q_{\mathrm{in}}+\epsilon^{UV}U_{\mathrm{in}}. where ϵUV\epsilon^{UV} was measured and ϵQV\epsilon^{QV} bounded in K. Sakaguri et al. [55], as described in § 2.2. Both are defined from the effective Mueller matrix in Equations (2a)–(2d). At the power-spectrum level, with pixel window function Wℓ2W_\ell^2 from Equation (22), this contributes

CˉℓP→V=1Wℓ2[∣ϵQV∣2CˉℓQQ,in+∣ϵUV∣2CˉℓUU,in+2ϵQVϵUVCˉℓQU,in](38)\bar{C}_{\ell}^{P\to V} = \frac{1}{W_\ell^2}\left[\left|\epsilon^{QV}\right|^2\bar{C}_{\ell}^{QQ,\mathrm{in}}+\left|\epsilon^{UV}\right|^2\bar{C}_{\ell}^{UU,\mathrm{in}}+2\epsilon^{QV}\epsilon^{UV}\bar{C}_{\ell}^{QU,\mathrm{in}}\right] \tag*{(38)}

for each patch, where the bar indicates this is a measured quantity from simulations, rather than a deterministic, analytical systematic. The explicit factor of 1/Wℓ21/W_\ell^2 is what prevents the pixel window from being counted twice. These leakage spectra are estimated from simulated theory skies synthesized with the same pixel grid and resolution as the data, so they carry the pixel window of that grid. The forward model of Equation (41) then multiplies them by ∣Tℓ∣2|T_\ell|^2, which already includes the pixel window by construction (§ 4.3). Dividing it out here leaves the pixel window applied exactly once, to the sky signal and the leakage alike. Propagating it into the VVVV budget requires the auto- and cross-spectra of the linear polarization as it actually projects onto our maps due to the multitude of QWP orientations relative to the sky per observation. Because the detectors measure polarization in the QWP frame, the relevant QQ and UU are the sky signal rotated by the parallactic angle and then averaged over the full set of observations, which partially cancels the leakage wherever the patch is observed over a range of parallactic angles.

We estimate these spectra from simulations. For each realization we draw a Gaussian lensed-Λ\LambdaCDM sky (TT/TE/EE/BBTT/TE/EE/BB; flat-sky QQ and UU synthesized on the survey patch geometry with the Boltzmann code wrapper CAMB (A. Lewis et al. [33])), using best-fit cosmological parameters from Planck (Planck Collaboration et al. [48]). From the real observations we build effective rotation maps, accumulating the weighted parallactic-angle factors over all observations ii,

C(n^)=∑iwicos⁡2γi∑iwi,S(n^)=∑iwisin⁡2γi∑iwi(39)C(\hat{n}) = \frac{\sum_i w_i\cos2\gamma_i}{\sum_i w_i}, \qquad S(\hat{n}) = \frac{\sum_i w_i\sin2\gamma_i}{\sum_i w_i} \tag*{(39)}

where γi\gamma_i is the parallactic angle at the patch center for observation ii. For the sake of this leakage analysis, QinQ_{\mathrm{in}} and UinU_{\mathrm{in}} are treated as spin-0 fields, assuming independent leakage per Stokes component. The effective instrument-frame polarization is then Q~=QC+US\widetilde{Q}=QC+US and U~=−QS+UC\widetilde{U}=-QS+UC, restricted to the well-observed region (pixels within −5 -5\,dB of the peak hit count). Their mask-deconvolved (MASTER) auto- and cross-spectra give one realization of CℓQQ,inC_\ell^{QQ,\mathrm{in}}, CℓUU,inC_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{in}}, and CℓQU,inC_\ell^{QU,\mathrm{in}}.

Repeating over 10410^4 sky realizations yields the mean leakage spectra (CˉℓQQ,in,CˉℓUU,in,CˉℓQU,in)(\bar{C}_\ell^{QQ,\mathrm{in}},\bar{C}_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{in}},\bar{C}_\ell^{QU,\mathrm{in}}) and their bandpower covariance, which are the products carried forward (per patch). Combined with the calibrated ϵQV\epsilon^{QV} and ϵUV\epsilon^{UV} through Equation (38), they give the P→VP\to V leakage contribution and its uncertainty in the final VVVV error budget.

Estimation of CVV

With the understanding of the instrument systematics and leakages, we can now extract Vsky(n^)V_{\mathrm{sky}}(\hat{n}). Starting with Equation (21), the mapmaking procedure in § 4.3 is utilized to produce one map per observation (ii). This brings the domain from time (tt) to map pixel space, (n^\hat{n}). Given that the instrument systematics happen in map space, the effects of the beam, pointing model, and transfer function are represented as operators B\mathcal{B}, P\mathcal{P}, and T\mathcal{T}, respectively.

Uobs(i)(n^)=ηV[Vin(i)(n^)+ϵQVQin(i)(n^)+ϵUVUin(i)(n^)]+ϵtotIUIin(i)(n^)=BPT{ηV[Vsky(i)(n^)+ϵQVQsky(i)(n^)+ϵUVUsky(i)(n^)]+ϵtotIUIsky(i)(n^)}.(40)\begin{aligned} U_{\mathrm{obs}}^{(i)}(\hat{n}) = \eta_V \left[V_{\mathrm{in}}^{(i)}(\hat{n}) + \epsilon^{QV} Q_{\mathrm{in}}^{(i)}(\hat{n}) + \epsilon^{UV} U_{\mathrm{in}}^{(i)}(\hat{n})\right] + \epsilon_{\mathrm{tot}}^{IU} I_{\mathrm{in}}^{(i)}(\hat{n}) \\ &= \mathcal{BPT}\left\{\eta_V \left[V_{\mathrm{sky}}^{(i)}(\hat{n})+\epsilon^{QV}Q_{\mathrm{sky}}^{(i)}(\hat{n}) + \epsilon^{UV}U_{\mathrm{sky}}^{(i)}(\hat{n})\right] + \epsilon_{\mathrm{tot}}^{IU}I_{\mathrm{sky}}^{(i)}(\hat{n})\right\}. \tag*{(40)} \end{aligned}

Averaging Equation (40) across all cross-spectra following the methodology of § 4.5.2, the resulting ℓ\ell-space equation relates the noise-free observed-frame spectrum CℓUU,obsC_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}, of which C^ℓUU,obs\widehat{C}_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}} of Equation (23) is the measurement, to the sky spectrum,

CℓUU,obs=g2gτ2∣Pℓ∣2∣Bℓ∣2∣Tℓ∣2[∣ηV∣2(CℓVV,sky+C‾ℓP→V)+CℓI→U],(41)C_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}} = g^2 g_\tau^2 |P_\ell|^2 |B_\ell|^2 |T_\ell|^2 \left[|\eta_V|^2\left(C_\ell^{VV,\mathrm{sky}}+\overline{C}_\ell^{P\rightarrow V}\right)+C_\ell^{I\rightarrow U}\right], \tag*{(41)}

with the leakage spectra defined in § 4.8. Solving for the sky VVVV spectrum,

CℓVV,sky=1∣ηV∣2[CℓUU,obsg2gτ2∣Bℓ∣2∣Pℓ∣2∣Tℓ∣2−CℓI→U]−C‾ℓP→V.(42)C_\ell^{VV,\mathrm{sky}} = \frac{1}{|\eta_V|^2}\left[\frac{C_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}}{g^2 g_\tau^2 |B_\ell|^2 |P_\ell|^2 |T_\ell|^2} - C_\ell^{I\rightarrow U}\right] - \overline{C}_\ell^{P\rightarrow V}. \tag*{(42)}

The absolute gain, gg, of Equation (8) enters on the measured spectrum alone. The beam, pointing, transfer function, and leakage coefficients are each ratios of maps built from the same calibrated timestreams, so gg cancels identically in all of them, while the simulated input spectra C‾ℓX,in\overline{C}_\ell^{X,\mathrm{in}} are generated in true KCMB\mathrm{K}_{\mathrm{CMB}} and carry no instrumental gain. In the joint fit of § 4.10, gg is common to both patches and so cancels exactly in the transfer-function ratio of Equation (45). It enters the RA4.5 prediction only through the small patch-difference leakage term. Because the limits scale as g2g^2, we sample it as a free parameter with the Gaussian prior g=1.000±σgg=1.000\pm\sigma_g of § 3.3, giving it its own chain dimension rather than fixing it and marginalizing afterwards. The time-constant factor gτg_\tau of § 3.3 enters in the same way, but it is specific to each patch and small, so it is not sampled; it is drawn with the fixed nuisances after sampling (§ 4.10). In the joint fit, gτg_\tau is drawn independently for each patch, and the two draws are averaged in each bandpower with weights given by each patch’s statistical inverse variance on CℓVVC_\ell^{VV}, computed from the diagonal of its C^ℓUU,obs\widehat{C}_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}} covariance and the nominal TℓT_\ell and PℓP_\ell.

Likelihood and Upper Limits

The bandpowers are compared to the model of § 4.9 through a Gaussian likelihood. Writing dp=C^ℓUU,obs,pd_p=\widehat{C}_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs},p} for the measured bandpowers of patch pp (Equation (23)), Σp\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_p for their pair-level bootstrap covariance (§ 4.5.2), and mp(θ)\mathbf{m}_p(\theta) for the predicted noise-free spectrum,

−2ln⁡L(θ)=∑p[dp−mp(θ)]TΣp−1[dp−mp(θ)]−2ln⁡π(θ),(43)-2\ln\mathcal{L}(\theta)=\sum_p\left[\mathbf{d}_p-\mathbf{m}_p(\theta)\right]^{\mathsf{T}}\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_p^{-1}\left[\mathbf{d}_p-\mathbf{m}_p(\theta)\right]-2\ln\pi(\theta), \tag*{(43)}

where π(θ)\pi(\theta) is the prior. It is Gaussian on the calibrated parameters ηV\eta_V, gg, aPa_P, BℓB_\ell, and TℓT_\ell (Table 3), truncated by the positivity bounds given below, and uniform on CℓUU,obsC_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}. The sampled parameters θ\theta are the three global scalars, the circular polarization efficiency ηV\eta_V, the absolute gain gg, and the pointing amplitude aPa_P of Equation (44), together with the per-bandpower latent spectrum CℓUU,obsC_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}, beam BℓB_\ell, and pipeline transfer function TℓT_\ell; the model is mRA23=CℓUU,obs\mathbf{m}_{\mathrm{RA23}}=C_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}} for the patch in which the signal is parameterized, and Equation (45) for RA4.5. It is essential to distinguish the two Gaussians here: the covariance Σp\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_p is the likelihood, constraining the latent spectrum by the data, whereas ηV\eta_V, gg, aPa_P, BℓB_\ell, and TℓT_\ell enter through π(θ)\pi(\theta) as Gaussian priors set by their external calibration measurements (Table 3).

The coadded map is the true sky convolved with the distribution of pointing displacements across the coadded observations, so in harmonic space the pointing error multiplies the spectrum by the characteristic function of that distribution. A displacement common to every observation is then a rigid translation, which contributes pure phase and drops out exactly, while binning in ∣ℓ∣|\ell| retains only the trace of the displacement covariance, whose anisotropy is suppressed to ∼10−4\sim10^{-4} of the effect at these scales. The pointing uncertainty therefore carries a single degree of freedom, the dispersion σcoh\sigma_{\mathrm{coh}} induced across observations by the uncertainty in the fitted pointing parameters (12.6″ for RA23 and 12.1″ for RA4.5), on the fixed shape exp⁡(−σcoh2ℓ2/2)\exp(-\sigma_{\mathrm{coh}}^2\ell^2/2), and we sample its amplitude,

Pℓ(aP)=P^ℓ+aPδPℓ,aP∼N(0,1),(44)P_\ell(a_P)=\widehat{P}_\ell+a_P\delta P_\ell,\qquad a_P\sim\mathcal{N}(0,1), \tag*{(44)}

where P^ℓ\widehat{P}_\ell is the measured transfer function of § 3.1 and δPℓ=P^ℓ[exp⁡(−σcoh2ℓ2/2)−1]\delta P_\ell=\widehat{P}_\ell[\exp(-\sigma_{\mathrm{coh}}^2\ell^2/2)-1] is its 1σ1\sigma uncertainty template. This single degree of freedom is what distinguishes PℓP_\ell from TℓT_\ell, whose filtering is mode-selective rather than a convolution, so that no single scalar controls its curve and each bandpower must be sampled separately. Diagonalizing the measured covariances confirms the distinction—one eigenmode carries 99.8% of the variance of Cov⁡(Pℓ)\operatorname{Cov}(P_\ell), against the 15 of 17 modes needed for Cov⁡(Tℓ)\operatorname{Cov}(T_\ell). A single aPa_P is shared by both patches, with per-patch templates, because one pointing-model fit underlies both. We sample Equation (43) with the affine-invariant ensemble sampler EMCEE (D. Foreman-Mackey et al. [18]). The remaining, weakly coupled systematics (gτg_\tau, ϵUV\epsilon^{UV}, ϵQV\epsilon^{QV}, ϵℓ,totIU\epsilon_{\ell,\mathrm{tot}}^{IU}, and CˉℓQQ/QU/UU,in\bar{C}_{\ell}^{QQ/QU/UU,\mathrm{in}} are held at their central values during sampling and marginalized afterwards by drawing nuisance realizations from their priors for every posterior sample and recomputing Equation (42). Hard physical limits ηV\eta_V, gg, BℓB_\ell, TℓT_\ell, Pℓ>0P_\ell> 0 are imposed throughout. We discard the first 30% of each chain as burn-in and assess convergence with the integrated autocorrelation time τint\tau_{\mathrm{int}}, estimated separately for every sampled parameter. We require Nstep/τint,max≳50N_{\mathrm{step}}/\tau_{\mathrm{int,max}} \gtrsim50, where τint,max\tau_{\mathrm{int,max}} is the largest τint\tau_{\mathrm{int}} over all sampled parameters, including the global ηV\eta_V as well as the per-bandpower ones, and both quantities are expressed in stored steps.

Because individual bandpowers may fluctuate negative, we set upper limits with the unified Feldman–Cousins construction [16] rather than a positivity-truncated posterior, which collapses asymmetrically against the boundary. From the marginalized posterior we take the per-bin mean μ^ℓ\hat{\mu}_\ell and standard deviation σℓ\sigma_\ell, treat μ^ℓ∼N(μℓ,σℓ2)\hat{\mu}_\ell\sim\mathcal{N}(\mu_\ell,\sigma_\ell^2) with the physical bound μℓ≥0\mu_\ell\ge0, and obtain the 95% interval [μℓlo,μℓhi][\mu_\ell^{\mathrm{lo}},\mu_\ell^{\mathrm{hi}}] from the likelihood-ratio ordering. We quote μℓhi\mu_\ell^{\mathrm{hi}} as the 95% upper limit; μℓlo>0\mu_\ell^{\mathrm{lo}} > 0 would flag a bandpower inconsistent with CℓVV=0C_\ell^{VV} = 0 (a two-sided detection band).

We analyze both cases:

Per-patch fits.—RA23 and RA4.5 are analyzed independently, each with a 3+3Nb3+3N_b-dimensional chain (ηV,g,(\eta_V,g, and aPa_P plus the per-bandpower CℓUU,obsC_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}, BℓB_\ell, TℓT_\ell; Nb=17N_b = 17, so 54 dimensions). We run 512 walkers for 3×1043 \times10^4 stored steps, storing every third sample; both chains are well converged (Nstep/τint,max>100N_{\mathrm{step}}/\tau_{\mathrm{int,max}} > 100).

Joint fit.—Assuming the circular-polarization signal is statistically isotropic, a single CℓVVC_\ell^{VV} is common to both patches, so a joint fit combines their constraining power. We parameterize the signal in the RA23 frame and predict the RA4.5 spectrum from it,

CℓUU,obs,RA4.5=(TℓRA4.5PℓRA4.5(aP)TℓRA23PℓRA23(aP))2CℓUU,obs,RA23+g2Bℓ2(TℓRA4.5PℓRA4.5(aP)TℓRA23PℓRA23(aP))2ηV2[(ϵQV)2ΔℓQQ+(ϵUV)2ΔℓUU+2ϵQVϵUVΔℓQU],(45)C_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs,RA4.5}} = \left(\frac{T_\ell^{\mathrm{RA4.5}}P_\ell^{\mathrm{RA4.5}}(a_P)} {T_\ell^{\mathrm{RA23}}P_\ell^{\mathrm{RA23}}(a_P)}\right)^2 C_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs,RA23}} + g^2 B_\ell^2 \left(\frac{T_\ell^{\mathrm{RA4.5}}P_\ell^{\mathrm{RA4.5}}(a_P)} {T_\ell^{\mathrm{RA23}}P_\ell^{\mathrm{RA23}}(a_P)}\right)^2 \eta_V^2\left[(\epsilon^{QV})^2\Delta_\ell^{QQ} +(\epsilon^{UV})^2\Delta_\ell^{UU} +2\epsilon^{QV}\epsilon^{UV}\Delta_\ell^{QU}\right], \tag*{(45)}

where ΔℓX=CˉℓX,RA4.5/Wℓ,RA4.52−CˉℓX,RA23/Wℓ,RA232\Delta_\ell^X = \bar{C}_\ell^{X,\mathrm{RA4.5}}/W_{\ell,\mathrm{RA4.5}}^2 - \bar{C}_\ell^{X,\mathrm{RA23}}/W_{\ell,\mathrm{RA23}}^2 is the patch-difference of each leakage spectrum, each deconvolved by its own pixel window for the reason given below Equation (38); the two differ because the right-ascension rescaling of § 4.5.1 gives each patch a slightly different effective pixel solid angle. The two patches contribute the two terms of the sum in Equation (43). The pointing transfer functions are evaluated at the shared amplitude of Equation (44), so the coherent pointing error largely cancels in the ratio. Only the difference in fractional susceptibility, 2(δPℓRA4.5/P^ℓRA4.5−δPℓRA23/P^ℓRA23)2(\delta P_\ell^{\mathrm{RA4.5}}/\hat{P}_\ell^{\mathrm{RA4.5}}-\delta P_\ell^{\mathrm{RA23}}/\hat{P}_\ell^{\mathrm{RA23}}), survives. At ℓ=1950\ell= 1950 this moves the ratio by 0.11%, against the 0.72% by which PℓP_\ell itself moves, a sevenfold cancellation. This is the expected behavior, as a single pointing model underlies both patches and its common mode should not affect their relative calibration; the per-patch fits retain the full 0.72%. Because the RA4.5 prediction depends on the transfer-function ratio, TℓT_\ell is sampled separately for each patch (raising the chain to 3+4Nb=713 + 4N_b = 71 dimensions) so that the TℓT_\ell-ratio uncertainty propagates rather than being held fixed, which would make the RA4.5 prediction artificially sharp. The larger parameter space lengthens the autocorrelation time, so the chain must be run correspondingly longer. We use 256 walkers for 7×1047 \times10^4 stored steps, retaining every sixth sample, which is roughly 4.7 times as many raw steps per walker as the per-patch fits. The heavier thinning leaves Nstep/τint,maxN_{\mathrm{step}}/\tau_{\mathrm{int,max}} unchanged, since it rescales both quantities equally, but keeps the stored chain within memory; like the individual patch likelihood estimation, this ratio is also >100>100. The joint fit yields the tightest limits, as both patches inform the common CℓVVC_\ell^{VV}.

To gauge the relative importance of each component in the CℓVVC_\ell^{VV} error budget, we propagate the measured uncertainty of each parameter through the inversion of Equation (42) one at a time. For a given parameter we draw 10410^4 Monte Carlo realizations from its measurement distribution (Gaussian, or uniform for ϵQV\epsilon^{QV}) while holding all others at their central values, and take the per-bin standard deviation of the resulting CℓVVC_\ell^{VV} as that parameter’s contribution to the uncertainty; varying all parameters simultaneously gives the total δCℓVV\delta C_\ell^{VV}, to which the individual terms add in quadrature. Because the standard deviation is sign-symmetric, this budget is unaffected by bandpowers that fluctuate below zero, and as no positivity is imposed it reproduces the unconstrained uncertainty that the Feldman–Cousins construction (§ 4.10) consumes.

Figure 7 shows the relative contributions of each parameter to the overall uncertainty, separating the six parameters that carry their own chain dimension, the latent spectrum CℓUU,obsC_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}, the circular polarization efficiency ηV\eta_V, the absolute gain gg, the beam BℓB_\ell, the transfer function TℓT_\ell, and the pointing transfer function PℓP_\ell, from the quantities propagated after sampling: gτg_\tau, shown separately, and the I→UI \to U and P→VP \to V leakages, shown as a single combined curve. The median contribution of gτg_\tau is 0.3% (0.7%) of the statistical term for RA23 (RA4.5), below every sampled calibration, which is why it is propagated rather than sampled. In both patches the statistical term CℓUU,obsC_\ell^{UU,\mathrm{obs}} traces the total at every multipole, while all calibration, beam, transfer, and leakage contributions lie one to three orders of magnitude below it across 350≤ℓ≤1950350 \le\ell\le1950. The upper limits are therefore statistics-limited, as no instrumental systematic contributes appreciably to the CℓVVC_\ell^{VV} error, and the result is robust to their calibration.

Relative contribution of overall uncertainty in a Monte Carlo realization distribution

Figure 7. Relative contribution of overall uncertainty in a Monte Carlo realization distribution of 10410^4 draws. This result shows the uncertainty is significantly dominated by the statistical uncertainty of the measured spectra; the next most significant contributions, from the absolute gain gg and the circular polarization efficiency ηV\eta_V, are comparable, with ηV\eta_V slightly larger, and typically lie one to two orders of magnitude below it. The sampled parameters and their error ranges are detailed in Table 3.

Results

We find no evidence for circular polarization in either field. The coadded UobsU_{\mathrm{obs}} maps entering the analysis are shown in Figure 8; both are consistent with noise, with no visible structure apart from the point source J0440−4333 in RA4.5. Figure 9 shows the measured detector UUUU power spectra, ℓ(ℓ+1)Cˉ^ℓUU,obs/2π\ell(\ell+1)\hat{\bar{C}}_{\ell}^{UU,\mathrm{obs}}/2\pi, for the RA23 and RA4.5 patches across 300≲ℓ≲2000300 \lesssim\ell\lesssim2000, where the error bars are the bandpower uncertainties of Section 4.5.2 and include none of the aforementioned leakages or systematics. As shown by Figure 7, the uncertainty is dominated by statistical uncertainty of the measured UU, which we know from K. Sakaguri et al. [55] is primarily sky VV. From the measured spectra, χ2=1.14\chi^2=1.14 (PTE = 0.304) for RA23 and 1.00 (PTE = 0.450) for RA4.5, consistent with the null hypothesis. We therefore place 95% confidence upper limits on CℓVVC_\ell^{VV}, constructed bin-by-bin with the Feldman–Cousins unified prescription (G. J. Feldman & R. D. Cousins [16]), which respects the physical boundary CℓVV>0C_\ell^{VV}>0. The resulting limits on ℓ(ℓ+1)CℓVV/2π\ell(\ell+1)C_\ell^{VV}/2\pi are given in Table 4 and Figure 10; the combined two-field limit ranges from 21.8 μKCMB221.8\ \mu\mathrm{K}_{\mathrm{CMB}}^2 at the bin centered at ℓ=350\ell=350 to 3.49×103 μKCMB23.49\times10^3\ \mu\mathrm{K}_{\mathrm{CMB}}^2 at the bin centered at ℓ=1950\ell=1950. Figure 10 also shows representative predicted signals from Pop. III supernova remnants, the CV_VB, and Galactic synchrotron. These lie roughly six orders of magnitude in ℓ(ℓ+1)CℓVV/2π\ell(\ell+1)C_\ell^{VV}/2\pi below the limits reported here, equivalently a factor of ∼103\sim10^3 in circular polarization amplitude, so detecting any of them remains far out of reach at this sensitivity. Furthermore, the contribution from Galactic synchrotron as represented in Figure 10, is estimated in S. King & P. Lubin [30] from full-sky simulations utilizing HAMMURABI (A. Waelkens et al. [65]). Unlike the Pop. III and CV_VB sources, Galactic synchrotron is not isotropic and homogeneous, and given that RA23 and RA4.5 are specifically chosen to lie away from the Galactic plane, this Galactic synchrotron signal is a maximum estimate. In practice, the emission signal would likely be much smaller relative to the other two sources within RA23 and RA4.5, therefore the actual on-sky VV signal within this ℓ\ell-range and at an observing frequency of 90 GHz can justifiably be claimed to consist primarily of CMB photons. Therefore, it is reasonable to claim that the upper limit constraints placed by this study are primarily on the CMB circular polarization signal with minimal contamination from foregrounds.

Figure 8. Coadded UobsU_{\mathrm{obs}} maps of the RA23 (left) and RA4.5 (right) patches, in gnomonic projection with an RA/Dec graticule. UobsU_{\mathrm{obs}} is the observed Stokes UU essentially as it comes out of the detector timestreams. It retains all leakages and has not been deconvolved for the beam, transfer function, or pointing. The maps are coadded over all observations and smoothed with a 5′-FWHM Gaussian, and both panels share a common color scale. The footprint is set by a −5 dB cut on the pixel hit count relative to its maximum, as described in § 4.5.1. These maps are noise-dominated. The point source J0440−4333, circled in the RA4.5 panel, is discussed in Appendix § 11.

Figure 9. Measured ℓ(ℓ+1)CˉℓUU,obs/(2π)\ell(\ell+ 1)\bar{C}^{\mathrm{UU},\mathrm{obs}}_{\ell}/(2\pi) for the RA23 (left) and RA4.5 (right) fields, shown as Δℓ=100\Delta\ell= 100 bandpowers over 300≤ℓ≤2000300 \le\ell\le2000. Points mark the bandpower values; vertical bars are the ±1σ\pm1\sigma bandpower uncertainties obtained from the pair-level bootstrap of § 4.5.2, while the horizontal bars denote each bandpower’s ℓ\ell-width and are not uncertainties. The dashed line is the null hypothesis of zero signal.

ℓb\ell_bRA23RA4.5Combined
35024.382.321.8
45013411395.7
550115215133
65072.817671.5
750172290157
85010827198.7
950384150147
1050311426239
1150482292228
12506151380756
13509521130763
14501200688642
1550234018201750
1650143034401800
1750102027101140
1850273028502180
1950552038503490

Table 4. PB-2b 95% C.L. upper limits on ℓ(ℓ+1)CℓVV/(2π)\ell(\ell+ 1)C^{\mathrm{VV}}_{\ell}/(2\pi) (μKCMB2\mu\mathrm{K}^{2}_{\mathrm{CMB}}), in Δℓ=100\Delta\ell= 100 bandpowers. RA23 and RA4.5 are the individual fields; “Combined” is the joint two-field limit.

CMB circular-polarization power-spectrum upper limits and bandpower sensitivities

Figure 10. Upper panel: 95% confidence upper limits on the CMB circular-polarization power spectrum, ℓ(ℓ+1)CℓVV/2π\ell(\ell+ 1)C_{\ell}^{\mathrm{VV}}/2\pi. Downward arrows denote the 95% upper limit in each bin; horizontal bars indicate the multipole width of the bandpower and are not uncertainties. The PB-2b measurements (this work) are shown for combined (bold magenta) upper limit constraints, together with previous limits from MIPOL [35], SPIDER [41], CLASS [42, 13, 14], and VLA [44] (at much higher ℓ\ell, note the break in the ℓ\ell-axis). The paired SPIDER colors denote 95 GHz and 150 GHz, the paired CLASS 40 GHz colors the 2020 and 2022 analyses, and the paired 2026 CLASS colors the 90 GHz band and the 90 GHz, 150 GHz and 220 GHz co-add, which assumes the circular polarization follows the CMB frequency dependence. Also shown are representative predictions from S. King & P. Lubin [30], evaluated at 90 GHz: Faraday conversion by Pop. III supernova remnants and scattering off the cosmic neutrino background. The simulated intrinsic full-sky circular polarization emission of Galactic synchrotron, a foreground, is shown as well [30]. The two Pop. III curves correspond to Np=100N_{\mathrm{p}} = 100 and Np=1000N_{\mathrm{p}} = 1000, where NpN_{\mathrm{p}} is the number of Pop. III stars per halo, a poorly constrained quantity to which CℓVVC_{\ell}^{\mathrm{VV}} is quadratically sensitive. Lower panel: the corresponding 1σ1\sigma bandpower sensitivities of the RA23, RA4.5, and combined PB-2b datasets, i.e. the standard deviation of the deconvolved CℓVVC_{\ell}^{\mathrm{VV}} posterior, shown as CℓC_{\ell} rather than ℓ(ℓ+1)Cℓ/2π\ell(\ell+ 1)C_{\ell}/2\pi so that the comparison between datasets is not dominated by the steep ℓ(ℓ+1)\ell(\ell+ 1) rise.

These constraints extend the measured VV-mode power spectrum to ℓ=2000\ell= 2000, or angular scales of 5.4′ to 36′, roughly three times the highest multipole previously reached. Prior bandpower limits probe larger scales and lower multipoles: MIPOL at ℓ≲30\ell\lesssim30 (R. Mainini et al. [35]), SPIDER over 33<ℓ<30733 < \ell< 307 at 95 GHz and 150 GHz (J. M. Nagy et al. [41]), and CLASS at 40 GHz over ℓ≲125\ell\lesssim125 (I. L. Padilla et al. [42]; J. R. Eimer et al. [13]) and subsequently to ℓ≲700\ell\lesssim700 at 90 GHz, 150 GHz and 220 GHz (T. Essinger-Hileman et al. [14]). The Very Large Array observations of R. B. Partridge et al. [44] reach smaller angular scales still, but bound the fractional circular polarization within individual fields rather than the angular power spectrum. Our limits are weaker at the maximum ℓ\ell in absolute μKCMB2\mu\mathrm{K}^{2}_{\mathrm{CMB}} than the large-scale SPIDER and CLASS constraints; ℓ(ℓ+1)CℓVV/(2π)\ell(\ell+ 1)C^{\mathrm{VV}}_{\ell}/(2\pi) rises steeply toward high ℓ\ell, and the instrument noise grows after beam and transfer-function deconvolution, but they are complementary, covering multipoles above ℓ≈700\ell\approx700 that have not previously been accessible to a VV-mode power spectrum measurement.

The bin-to-bin scatter of the limits in Figure 10 is an intrinsic feature of noise-dominated measured spectra of Figure 9 rather than a numerical artifact. The posterior chains are well converged (Gelman–Rubin R^<1.001\hat{R} < 1.001 in every bin, with a Monte Carlo uncertainty on each limit of ≲0.4%\lesssim0.4\%), so each bandpower’s limit is fixed by where that bin’s measured power fluctuates relative to zero. The limits vary by ≈0.2\approx0.2 dex (a factor ∼1.6\sim1.6) from bin to bin about a smooth trend, comparable to the ≈0.23\approx0.23 dex scatter of the CLASS 40 GHz limits (I. L. Padilla et al. [42]) and in contrast to the much smoother SPIDER limits (≈0.03\approx0.03 dex). This difference reflects noise structure, not sampling methodology. SPIDER utilizes V→PV \rightarrow P leakage in its HWP to measure circular polarization, and so uncertainty is dominated by a HWP calibration coupling that is strongly correlated across ℓ\ell (J. M. Nagy et al. [41]). This suppresses bin-to-bin scatter, whereas the PB-2b and CLASS limits are dominated by per-bin statistical noise.

The underlying bandpower sensitivities, shown in the lower panel of Figure 10, are better behaved than the limits themselves. The combined dataset is the most sensitive in every bandpower, with each individual field

exceeding it by an average factor of ∼1.4\sim1.4, consistent with the 2\sqrt{2} expected from combining two fields of comparable depth. The upper limits do not follow this ordering bin by bin, however, because a Feldman–Cousins limit depends on the central value as well as on its uncertainty.

Conclusions

We present results on the circular polarization of the sky at 90 GHz from a series of targeted observations with PB-2b for two specific patches over 300≤ℓ≤2000300 \le\ell\le2000, at μKCMB sensitivity. As established in § 1, these limits constrain the total diffuse circular polarization of those fields, which includes the circularly polarized CMB signal and trace foregrounds not removed by location choice, masking, and filtering. Both contributions lie far below the instrument noise that dominates the measured bandpowers, so the limits reported here are set by that noise floor rather than by any detected sky signal. This extends the measured VV-mode power spectrum into the few-arcminute regime, reaching multipoles roughly three times higher than previous measurements, and improves on the prior upper limit placed by SPIDER (J. M. Nagy et al. [41]) at 95 GHz by nearly two orders of magnitude in the single bandpower where those two analyses overlap. The CLASS constraints of T. Essinger-Hileman et al. [14] overlap this analysis over 300≲ℓ≲700300 \lesssim\ell\lesssim700; above that range these are the only VV-mode bandpower limits reported to date.

The current limitations of CMB circular polarization studies are that no current experiment utilizing a QWP has the sensitivity necessary for a statistically significant detection (S. King & P. Lubin [30]). Figure 10 conclusively demonstrates this, as the limits reported here sit roughly six orders of magnitude in ℓ(ℓ+1)CℓVV/2π\ell(\ell+ 1)C_\ell^{VV}/2\pi above the predicted signals. In addition, because the measurement is noise-dominated, with the bandpower uncertainty scaling inversely with integration time, closing that gap with PB-2b would demand of order 10610^{6} times the observing time presented here, or an equivalent growth in detector count. Focusing study on lower observing frequency, however, could reduce the discrepancy between noise sensitivity and signal magnitude without requiring an unprecedented improvement in instrument sensitivity or detector count. The Faraday conversion contribution scales as ν−3\nu^{-3}, so the factor of ∼7×102\sim7 \times10^{2} in amplitude gained between 90 GHz and 10 GHz accounts for nearly the entire gap. S. King & P. Lubin [30] correspondingly forecast a signal-to-noise ratio above unity for a 10 m telescope observing for 20 months at 10 GHz, provided Np≳100N_p \gtrsim100. In addition, the single observing band utilized in this experiment does not permit differentiation between potential sources, meaning more exotic sources of circular polarization cannot be rigorously identified among known contaminants, such as Milky Way synchrotron radiation.

CMB circular polarization provides an interesting window into early-Universe physics not encapsulated by standard linear polarization measurements probing ΛCDM. While very few other experiments with comparable sensitivity to the Simons Array are measuring microwave-band circular polarization directly, similar procedures to those of J. M. Nagy et al. [41] might be able to constrain it via leakage from linear polarization. For example, the Simons Observatory (SO) Small Aperture Telescopes (SATs) utilize rotating cold HWPs with nearly identical design to that of PB-2b, which can be used to characterize V→PV \to P leakage to even higher sensitivity than that of SPIDER’s limits (J. M. Nagy et al. [41]). Because such a measurement would rely on the small V→PV \to P leakage of the HWP rather than on the direct conversion afforded by a QWP, the effective circular polarization efficiency of the SATs is likely to fall well below the ηV=0.528±0.032\eta_V = 0.528 \pm0.032 achieved here. That penalty may be offset by raw sensitivity, as each mid-frequency SAT carries 12,292 detectors and the SAT survey is projected to reach a combined map depth of 2 μK-arcmin at 93 GHz and 145 GHz over five years (N. Galitzki et al. [20]), orders of magnitude higher than what was achievable with PB-2b. In addition, the SATs will observe at six distinct frequency bands (30 GHz, 40 GHz, 90 GHz, 150 GHz, 220 GHz, and 280 GHz), which may allow discrimination between the contributions of circular polarization sources as a function of frequency, most importantly foregrounds. This allows simultaneous probing of multiple circular polarization sources and foregrounds, which differ in their dependence on observing frequency. These prospects would allow for research in this field to persist beyond the end of PB-2b’s active observation.

Acknowledgments

This work is supported by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation Grant No. GBMF7939, the Simons Foundation Grant No. 034079, the National Science Foundation grants AST-1207892 and AST-1440338, the World Premier International Research Center Initiative (WPI) of MEXT, Japan, and the John Templeton Foundation grant 58724. In Japan, this work was supported by JSPS KAKENHI grant Nos. 18H05539 and 19H00674, and the JSPS Core-to-Core Program JPJSCCA20200003. Work at LBNL is supported in part by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of High Energy Physics, under Contract No. DE-AC02-05CH11231. Calculations were performed on the Central Computing System, owned and operated by the Computing Research Center at KEK, and the National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center, which is supported by the Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC02-05CH11231. The Simons Array operated at the James Ax Observatory in the Parque Astronómico Atacama in Northern Chile under the stewardship of the Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (ANID). We acknowledge support from the ASI-COSMOS Network (cosmosnet.it) and from the INDARK INFN Initiative (web.infn.it/CSN4/IS/Linea5/InDark). Support from the Ax Center for Experimental Cosmology at UC San Diego is gratefully acknowledged. M. Hazumi is partially supported by the Yushan Fellow Program by the Ministry of Education (MOE), Taiwan. YC acknowledges support from JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number JP24K00667.

Appendix

Null Test Criteria

We adopt a similar strategy for null splits as in Polarbear Collaboration et al. [52], both for detector-based and observation-based splits, however, we adopt several additional criteria specific to the performance of PB-2b. As with Polarbear, some of these splits are not necessarily evenly split into halves. For splits which are repeated from the detector-based splits, we average over all detectors within a given observation, then split on the median of all observation averages in the observing season, which probes changes in instrument performance over time. The full set of criteria is listed in Table 5.

SplitMotivation
Detector-based splits
A/B pixel handednessThe sinuous antennae come in two symmetric handednesses; probes the frequency dependence of the polarization angle, which is relevant here through linear-to-circular leakage.
Q/UQ/U type pixelDetectors are aligned horizontally/vertically or rotated by 45∘45^\circ. Especially crucial given that the QWP modulates VV into the UU parameter the detectors measure.
Top/bottom detectorThe two detectors within each antenna, oriented along the two polarization vectors of the pixel.
Focal plane positionLeft/right and upper/lower physical location, probing location-dependent optical systematics not captured by the pointing model.
Gain calibration factorPer-observation gain factor, without distinguishing stimulator from HWPSS calibration.
Effective time constantPer-observation detector speed, again without distinguishing the calibration method.
Calibration sourceWhether a detector draws its calibration mostly from the stimulator or from the HWPSS.
4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} amplitudeDominated by contamination from the QWP; validates optical and polarization systematics as well as the time-domain HWPSS removal.
2fHWP2f_{\mathrm{HWP}} amplitudeSeveral orders of magnitude weaker than the 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} amplitude, but associated with I→PI \to P leakage, which is small but not negligible.
White noiseTime-domain white noise level, probing noise modeling and data selection.
Input glitch ACFGlitch autocorrelation prior to cleaning.
Observation-based splits
Median detector quantitiesObservation-level analogues of the detector splits above: gain calibration factor, 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} amplitude and phase, 2fHWP2f_{\mathrm{HWP}} amplitude and phase, white noise, and effective time constant.
Calibration sourceWhich method calibrates the majority of detectors, since stimulator calibration is wholly or partly missing for some observations.
“Glitchy” runsMedian fraction of detectors with glitches exceeding an autocorrelation threshold.
1st/2nd half of seasonA time-based split probing overall drift in instrument performance across the observing season.
Median PWVLoading and general weather systematics.
PWV standard deviationVariability of PWV within a single observation, probing rapid changes in loading.
Sun/Moon distanceAngular distance to the Sun or Moon, probing far-sidelobe contamination.
ElevationMedian scan elevation, i.e. the atmospheric column along the line of sight.
Bolometer tuning strategyTuning to a fixed fractional resistance of 0.75 versus an algorithm setting a different fractional resistance per detector.
Ambient air temperatureComponents held at air temperature, notably the QWP, may have emission or transmission properties correlated with temperature.
Focal plane temperatureSets the thermal noise level, which could bias the gain and leave residual sky signal in the noise maps.
Pointing correctionMagnitude of the geometric correction required by the pointing model, which depends on the patch azimuth and elevation when observed.

Table 5. Null test splits used to assess the internal consistency of the measured spectra, following the strategy of Polarbear Collaboration et al. [52] with additional criteria specific to PB-2b.

Atmospheric Polarization

Atmospheric circular polarization emission is the result of Zeeman splitting of oxygen due to Earth’s magnetic field (W. B. Lenoir [32]; B. Keating et al. [29]; S. Hanany & P. Rosenkranz [22]; S. Spinelli et al. [59]; M. A. Petroff et al. [45]; T. Fujino et al. [19]) and presents a major foreground for CMB circular polarization measurements. Through the Zeeman effect, Earth’s magnetic field splits the rotational energy levels of atmospheric oxygen, allowing transitions that emit polarized radiation. The imbalance between the right- and left-handed circularly polarized components produces a net circular polarization signal near the oxygen resonance lines. As such, CMB experiments observe at frequencies away from these resonance lines, which are well characterized (see Figure 11). However, even away from the resonances, atmospheric emission is still a dominant foreground and therefore must be accounted for.

Frequency dependence of the absolute value of the atmospheric circular polarization

Figure 11. Frequency dependence of the absolute value of the atmospheric circular polarization evaluated at zenith. The dark dashed vertical line marks the measured band center at 89.5 GHz, and the surrounding dark shaded region indicates its uncertainty. The lighter dashed vertical lines mark the nominal lower and upper band edges, while the adjacent light shaded regions indicate the uncertainty associated with the measured bandwidth. The model is made using the software suite of M. A. Petroff et al. [45], adapted to the PB-2b observation date and frequency.

Due to its coupling with Earth’s magnetic poles, the atmospheric circular polarization obtains a dipole-like structure which depends on the projection of the telescope’s line-of-sight onto the local magnetic field vector. This produces a characteristic azimuthal dependence, with the signal largest when the line of sight is most aligned with the magnetic-field direction and smallest when it is perpendicular (see Figure 12). Further, the atmospheric signal amplitude decreases with increasing elevation due to the reduced atmospheric column density along the telescope’s line of sight. At a fixed telescope pointing, this signal remains constant in the sky, but in the detector timestream it will get modulated to 4fHWP4f_{\mathrm{HWP}} such that the corresponding raw detector signal is not constant. Demodulation then removes the HWP-angle dependence, and recovers the constant atmospheric Stokes VV signal.

Predicted azimuthal dependence of atmospheric circular polarization

Figure 12. Predicted azimuthal dependence of atmospheric circular polarization. Solid lines show the nominal fit, while dashed lines indicate the 16th and 84th percentile bounds of the Monte Carlo predictions. It can be seen that the amplitude decreases with increasing elevation. Large uncertainties can be observed, reflecting the strong sensitivity of the predicted signal to variations in the detector band center. The model is as in Figure 11, additionally accounting for the measured bandwidth.

We are able to mitigate any major contribution from the atmospheric circular polarization by a combination of polynomial and scan-synchronous signal filtering. We apply a polynomial filter both on the full timestream as well as individual subscans, as described in § 4.2.3, and reapply it after demodulation (§ 4.2.5), where the atmospheric signal is no longer modulated. Over the limited azimuth range of an individual subscan, the atmospheric circular polarization signal is expected to vary slowly and can be approximated by a low-order expansion in azimuth. Therefore, the constant and first-order terms of the subscan polynomial filter remove much of this atmospheric contribution and any other slow varying offsets. The scan-synchronous signal filter provides an additional suppression of components that are stable in telescope azimuth. Since atmospheric circular polarization is tied to the telescope line of sight relative to Earth’s magnetic field, rather than to fixed celestial coordinates, it is expected to appear primarily as an azimuth- and elevation-dependent signal and is there-

fore similarly able to be removed by the constant and low order terms of the scan-synchronous filter.

To describe the atmospheric circular polarization at the PB-2b site, we evaluate the empirical model of M. A. Petroff et al. [45] at 90 GHz, taking both azimuthal and zenith angle dependence into account. This theoretical model has previously been confirmed at 40 GHz by the CLASS experiment M. A. Petroff et al. [45] and at 150 GHz by the Polarbear project T. Fujino et al. [19]. We use a band center of (89.5±4.5)(89.5 \pm4.5) GHz and a fractional bandwidth of 0.324±0.0320.324 \pm0.032, as defined in pre-deployment detector measurements B. Westbrook et al. [67]. To determine the uncertainty in the theoretical atmospheric emission, we draw Monte Carlo realizations of the band center and fractional bandwidth from independent Gaussian distributions. We then calculate the band-averaged emission for each realization and take the 16th–84th percentile range as the bandpass-induced uncertainty. The resulting uncertainty is much larger than the nominal signal, mainly due to the strong dependence of the atmospheric signal on observing frequency. Across the frequency ranges sampled by the Monte Carlo bandpasses, the atmospheric spectrum changes sign, therefore broadening the distribution of predicted band-averaged signals. Because the zenith angle dependence is an empirical approximation, we only evaluate the model within its calibrated range from 30 to 60 degrees. Further, as the Earth’s magnetic field is not perfectly aligned with true north, we also must determine the magnetic declination. We calculate the declination using the International Geomagnetic Reference Field model P. Alken et al. [2], evaluated at a site elevation of 5200 m.

Field model P. Alken et al. [2], evaluated at a site elevation of 5200 m. Since the main geomagnetic field varies slowly in time, we evaluate the field at a representative midpoint date of the observing period and approximate it as constant over the data set. The resulting atmospheric circular-polarization curve is therefore slightly offset from true north. As expected, the atmospheric circular polarization varies slowly in azimuth and as such is mitigated by the post-demodulation filtering of § 4.2.5. Due to the limited azimuthal range of our scans, we do not currently detect any atmospheric emission.

Gain Validation with J0440-4333

The RA4.5 patch contains the bright, compact radio source J0440–4333 (redshift z=2.852z = 2.852, a Q-type blazar) Z.-Q. Shen et al. [57], which provides a unique opportunity to validate our calibration and mapmaking procedures. We measure its flux in our map (Figure 13) and compare it to a model prediction based on its cataloged intensity and expected polarization behavior.

Zoomed-in section of the RA4.5 patch showing J0440–4333

Figure 13. Zoomed-in section of the RA4.5 patch showing J0440–4333 with a −8 dB hit mask. The green circle is the 10′ aperture and the region between the solid and dashed white circles is the background annulus; together they define the aperture estimator used as a cross-check on the matched filter of Equation (46).

The pipeline’s response to a compact source is not simply the beam. The filtering of § 4.2 suppresses the source core and surrounds it with a shallow negative trench from ∼11′ to ∼32′, so a 10′ aperture with a 12′–22′ background annulus measures the suppressed core against the source’s own trench. Because that trench is coherent with the source rather than noise, it is properly treated as signal, and we estimate the flux with a matched filter built on the measured response,

F^(x)=IFFT⁡[t∗(ℓ)d(ℓ)/P(ℓ)](x)∑ℓ∣t(ℓ)∣2/P(ℓ)(46)\widehat{F}(\mathbf{x}) = \frac{\operatorname{IFFT}[t^*(\boldsymbol{\ell})d(\boldsymbol{\ell})/P(\boldsymbol{\ell})](\mathbf{x})}{\sum_{\boldsymbol{\ell}} |t(\boldsymbol{\ell})|^2/P(\boldsymbol{\ell})} \tag*{(46)}

where F^(x)\widehat{F}(\mathbf{x}) is the estimated source flux at map position x\mathbf{x}, ℓ\boldsymbol{\ell} is the two-dimensional Fourier wavevector, IFFT denotes the inverse fast Fourier transform, and the asterisk denotes complex conjugation. Here dd is the measured UU map (which contains the converted Stokes VV signal), tt is the point-source template, built from the same observations as the map, and PP is the map’s own two-dimensional power spectrum, kept anisotropic because the residual noise is striped along the scan direction. Calibrating the response on a synthetic unit-flux source makes the estimator unbiased independently of Fourier conventions; it round-trips on simulations to 1.0098. Evaluating F^\widehat{F} at the J2000 position of J0440−4333 gives the measured integrated flux FU,measF^{U,\mathrm{meas}}, and evaluating it at Noff=5354N_{\mathrm{off}} = 5354 off-source positions xk\mathbf{x}_k in the same filtered map gives the reference set Fkrand≡F^(xk)F^{\mathrm{rand}}_k \equiv\widehat{F}(\mathbf{x}_k), from which the uncertainty follows as σFmeas=1.4826⋅MAD⁡{Fkrand}\sigma^{\mathrm{meas}}_F = 1.4826\cdot\operatorname{MAD}\{F^{\mathrm{rand}}_k\}, where MAD denotes the median absolute deviation.

Converting the filtered amplitude to a flux density requires the point-source flux transfer FPSF_{\mathrm{PS}}, the ratio of recovered to injected integrated flux. This differs from the transfer function TℓT_\ell in that it also carries the fraction of the source flux that the estimator collects, and the two effects cannot be separated within a single scalar. Analytically, a mask that is unity inside an aperture of radius RapR_{\mathrm{ap}} and solid angle Ωap\Omega_{\mathrm{ap}}, and −Ωap/Ωann-\Omega_{\mathrm{ap}}/\Omega_{\mathrm{ann}} within a background annulus Rin<r<RoutR_{\mathrm{in}} < r < R_{\mathrm{out}} of solid angle Ωann\Omega_{\mathrm{ann}}, has transform ΩapK(ℓ)\Omega_{\mathrm{ap}}K(\ell), giving

FPS=Ωap2π∫dℓ ℓBℓTℓK(ℓ),(47)F_{\mathrm{PS}} = \frac{\Omega_{\mathrm{ap}}}{2\pi}\int\mathrm{d}\ell\,\ell B_\ell T_\ell K(\ell), \tag*{(47)}
K(ℓ)=W(ℓRap)−Rout2W(ℓRout)−Rin2W(ℓRin)Rout2−Rin2,(48)K(\ell) = W(\ell R_{\mathrm{ap}}) - \frac{R_{\mathrm{out}}^2 W(\ell R_{\mathrm{out}})-R_{\mathrm{in}}^2 W(\ell R_{\mathrm{in}})}{R_{\mathrm{out}}^2-R_{\mathrm{in}}^2}, \tag*{(48)}

where J1J_1 is the first-order Bessel function of the first kind and W(u)=2J1(u)/uW(u) = 2J_1(u)/u. Since K(0)=0K(0) = 0, the annulus subtraction makes this a differential estimator, so the recovered fraction falls below unity even before filtering; the aperture efficiency matters here because the measured 90 GHz beam has broad non-Gaussian wings that leave only 89.5 % of the source flux within 10′10'. We evaluate Equation (C2) over ℓ=350\ell= 350–19501950 in Δℓ=100\Delta\ell= 100 bins, holding TℓT_\ell constant outside that range, which gives FPS=0.662±0.019F_{\mathrm{PS}} = 0.662 \pm0.019. The kernel places only ∼1\sim1 % of its weight above ℓ=2000\ell= 2000, since it first vanishes near ℓ≈1300\ell\approx1300, so although TℓT_\ell is uncharacterized there, varying it over its full physical range shifts FPSF_{\mathrm{PS}} by only ±0.006\pm0.006.

We nevertheless quote the value obtained end-to-end by injection, which assumes no model of the beam, filtering, or estimator. A source of exactly known integrated flux, carrying the measured beam profile, is added to the Stokes VV channel of an input sky map, propagated through the unmodified pipeline of Sections 4.2–4.3, and photometered with the same matched filter, so FPSF_{\mathrm{PS}} is the recovered-to-injected ratio by construction; differencing against a baseline over identical observations and CMB realization cancels the sky exactly. Over the RA4.5 observations, FPS=0.6149±0.0016F_{\mathrm{PS}} = 0.6149 \pm0.0016, 7 % below the analytic value, a shortfall expected in sign because Equation (C2) treats the map-making operator as diagonal in Fourier space. Because detector weights derive from each timestream’s own noise and the simulations are far quieter per sample than the data, the injection must stay in the linear regime, which we verify through the ratio of total map weight to baseline, 0.9912 here. The measured flux density is then SUmeas=FUmeas/FPSS^{\mathrm{meas}}_U = F^{\mathrm{meas}}_U/F_{\mathrm{PS}}, converted to Jansky.

Since circular polarization data for J0440−4333 is unavailable, we model its emission and propagate it through the same leakage and flux transfer chain,

Uobspred=FPS[ηV(Vb+ϵUVUb+ϵQVQb)+ϵtotIU,effIb],(49)U^{\mathrm{pred}}_{\mathrm{obs}} = F_{\mathrm{PS}}\left[\eta_V\left(V_b+\epsilon^{UV}U_b+\epsilon^{QV}Q_b\right)+\epsilon^{IU,\mathrm{eff}}_{\mathrm{tot}}I_b\right], \tag*{(49)}

where bb denotes the blazar. The total-intensity flux IbI_b is estimated from ALMA catalog queries ([8]) and the circular polarization fraction assumed to be pV=0.3%±0.2%p_V = 0.3\% \pm0.2\% at 15 GHz ([26]). Since the linear polarization angle is unconstrained, QbQ_b and UbU_b are marginalized uniformly on [0,π)[0,\pi), introducing a variance

σpol2=12ηV2[(ϵUV)2+σϵUV2]⟨p2⟩Ib2,⟨p2⟩=plin2+σp2,(50)\sigma_{\mathrm{pol}}^2 = \frac{1}{2}\eta_V^2\left[\left(\epsilon^{UV}\right)^2+\sigma_{\epsilon^{UV}}^2\right]\langle p^2\rangle I_b^2,\qquad\langle p^2\rangle= p_{\mathrm{lin}}^2+\sigma_p^2, \tag*{(50)}

on the prediction, where σϵUV\sigma_{\epsilon^{UV}} and σp\sigma_p are the uncertainties on the leakage ϵUV\epsilon^{UV} and on the linear polarization fraction, the latter taken as plin=0.06±0.04p_{\mathrm{lin}} = 0.06\pm0.04 scaled from the 18 GHz measurements of M. Massardi et al. [37]; ϵQV\epsilon^{QV} is neglected as small. The leakage spectrum ϵℓ,totIU\epsilon^{IU}_{\ell,\mathrm{tot}} of Equation (20) is convolved with the same matched-filter weighting to give ϵtotIU,eff=0.01751\epsilon^{IU,\mathrm{eff}}_{\mathrm{tot}} = 0.01751, a value insensitive to that weighting. It is measured from Jupiter, itself a point source, and is flat enough across the band (0.0166–0.0188) that any reasonable choice alters it by at most 7 %.

The comparison is shown in Figure 14. The matched filter gives (125.9±35.2)(125.9 \pm35.2) mJy, a 3.6σ3.6\sigma detection of the source in the circular polarization channel, while the 10′10' aperture on the same map returns (149.3±113.4)(149.3 \pm113.4) mJy, consistent but 3.2 times less precise. Retaining only the leakage terms of Equation (C3) predicts (75.2±4.0)(75.2\pm4.0) mJy, differing by (50.8±35.5)(50.8 \pm35.5) mJy (1.4σ)(1.4\sigma), while adding the intrinsic polarization priors predicts (82.0±12.8)(82.0 \pm12.8) mJy, differing by (43.9±37.5)(43.9 \pm37.5) mJy (1.2σ)(1.2\sigma). Both are quoted because J0440−4333 is a variable FSRQ, so neither a single assumed pair of polarization fractions nor their omission is defensible alone; both move the comparison toward agreement, making the leakage-only prediction the conservative statement.

Figure 14. Circular polarization flux density of J0440−4333, measured against prediction. The measurement is the matched filter of Equation (46) applied to the coadded RA4.5 UobsU_{\mathrm{obs}} map, divided by the injection-calibrated flux transfer FPSF_{\mathrm{PS}}. Two predictions are shown: one retaining only the instrumental leakage terms of Equation (49), and one additionally assuming the intrinsic polarization priors described in the text. Error bars are 1σ1\sigma, propagated at first order.

The statistical power of this check is limited and should be stated plainly. Taking the prediction with intrinsic polarization priors as truth, the measurement constrains the flux transfer to FPS=0.94±0.30F_{\mathrm{PS}} = 0.94 \pm0.30, so it is sensitive only to errors above ∼32%\sim32\%. The comparison therefore does not itself determine FPSF_{\mathrm{PS}}, which rests on Equation (C2) and the injection; what the agreement establishes is that no gross error is present in the calibration and mapmaking chain, complementing the characterization in N. Farias et al. [15] and K. Sakaguri et al. [55]. This appendix does not bear on the science result, since Equation (42) deconvolves Bℓ2B_\ell^2 and Tℓ2T_\ell^2 bandpower by bandpower rather than through any scalar collapse.

References

  1. [1]Alexander, S., Ochoa, J., & Kosowsky, A. 2009, Physical Review D, 79, 063524, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.79.063524DOI
  2. [2]Alken, P., Thébault, E., Beggan, C. D., et al. 2021, Earth, Planets and Space, 73, doi: 10.1186/s40623-020-01288-xDOI
  3. [3]Alonso, D., Sanchez, J., & Slosar, A. 2019, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 484, 4127, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stz093DOI
  4. [4]Arnold, K., Stebor, N., Ade, P. A. R., et al. 2014, in Millimeter, Submillimeter, and Far-Infrared Detectors and Instrumentation for Astronomy VII, Vol. 9153 (SPIE), 91531F, doi: 10.1117/12.2057332DOI
  5. [5]Barron, D., Mitchell, K., Groh, J., et al. 2021, IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity, 31, 1, doi: 10.1109/TASC.2021.3067190DOI
  6. [6]Bennett, C. L., Larson, D., Weiland, J. L., et al. 2013, The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series, 208, 20, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/208/2/20DOI
  7. [7]Bixler, B., Arnold, K., Hill, C., & Kusaka, A. 2026, IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity, 36, 1, doi: 10.1109/TASC.2026.3680443DOI
  8. [8]Bonato, M., Liuzzo, E., Giannetti, A., et al. 2018, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 478, 1512, doi: 10.1093/mnras/sty1173DOI
  9. [9]Catalano, A., Ade, P., Atik, Y., et al. 2014, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 569, A88, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201423868DOI
  10. [10]Cooray, A., Melchiorri, A., & Silk, J. 2003, Physics Letters B, 554, 1, doi: 10.1016/S0370-2693(02)03291-4DOI
  11. [11]Das, S., Louis, T., Nolta, M. R., et al. 2014, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2014, 014, doi: 10.1088/1475-7516/2014/04/014DOI
  12. [13]Eimer, J. R., Li, Y., Brewer, M. K., et al. 2024, CLASS Angular Power Spectra and Map-Component Analysis for 40 GHz Observations through 2022, arXiv, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.2309.00675
  13. [14]Essinger-Hileman, T., Ryan, C., Li, Y., et al. 2026, Improved Constraints on Cosmic Microwave Background Circular Polarization with CLASS, arXiv; submitted to ApJ, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.2609.40125
  14. [15]Farias, N., Adkins, T., Chu, M., et al. 2026, Review of Scientific Instruments, 97, 083101, doi: 10.1063/5.0319093DOI
  15. [16]Feldman, G. J., & Cousins, R. D. 1998, Physical Review D, 57, 3873, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.57.3873DOI
  16. [17]Finelli, F., & Galaverni, M. 2009, Physical Review D, 79, 063002, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.79.063002DOI
  17. [18]Foreman-Mackey, D., Hogg, D. W., Lang, D., & Goodman, J. 2013, Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific, 125, 306, doi: 10.1086/670067
  18. [19]Fujino, T., Takakura, S., Arani, S. S., et al. 2025, The Astrophysical Journal, 981, 15, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ada89b
  19. [20]Galitzki, N., Tsan, T., Spisak, J., et al. 2024, The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series, 274, 33, doi: 10.3847/1538-4365/ad64c9
  20. [21]Giovannini, M. 2009, Physical Review D, 80, 123013, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.80.123013
  21. [22]Hanany, S., & Rosenkranz, P. 2003, New Astronomy Reviews, 47, 1159, doi: 10.1016/j.newar.2003.09.017
  22. [23]Hill, C. A., Kusaka, A., Ashton, P., et al. 2020, Review of Scientific Instruments, 91, 124503, doi: 10.1063/5.0029006
  23. [24]Himwich, W. E. 1993, Pointing Model Derivation, Mark IV field system reference manual, version 8.2, NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center
  24. [25]Hivon, E., Górski, K. M., Netterfield, C. B., et al. 2002, The Astrophysical Journal, 567, 2, doi: 10.1086/338126
  25. [26]Homan, D. C., & Lister, M. L. 2006, The Astronomical Journal, 131, 1262, doi: 10.1086/500256
  26. [28]Kamionkowski, M., Kosowsky, A., & Stebbins, A. 1997, Physical Review D, 55, 7368, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.55.7368
  27. [29]Keating, B., Timbie, P., Polnarev, A., & Steinberger, J. 1998, The Astrophysical Journal, 495, 580, doi: 10.1086/305312
  28. [30]King, S., & Lubin, P. 2016, Circular polarization of the CMB: Foregrounds and detection prospects, arXiv, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.1606.04112DOI
  29. [31]Kusaka, A., Essinger-Hileman, T., Appel, J. W., et al. 2014, Review of Scientific Instruments, 85, 024501, doi: 10.1063/1.4861834
  30. [32]Lenoir, W. B. 1968, Journal of Geophysical Research (1896-1977), 73, 361, doi: 10.1029/JA073i001p00361
  31. [33]Lewis, A., Challinor, A., & Lasenby, A. 2000, The Astrophysical Journal, 538, 473, doi: 10.1086/309179
  32. [34]Lowry, L. N., Ito, J., & POLARBEAR Collaboration. 2022, in Millimeter, Submillimeter, and Far-Infrared Detectors and Instrumentation for Astronomy XI, ed. J. Zmuidzinas & J.-R. Gao (Montréal, Canada: SPIE), 73, doi: 10.1117/12.2629114
  33. [35]Mainini, R., Minelli, D., Gervasi, M., et al. 2013, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2013, 033, doi: 10.1088/1475-7516/2013/08/033
  34. [36]Mangum, J. G. 2001, A Telescope Pointing Algorithm for ALMA, ALMA Memo 366, National Radio Astronomy Observatory, Tucson, AZ. http://legacy.nrao.edu/alma/memos/html-memos/alma366/memo366.pdf
  35. [37]Massardi, M., Burke-Spolaor, S. G., Murphy, T., et al. 2013, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 436, 2915, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stt1717
  36. [38]Matsuda, F. T. 2017, PhD thesis, UC San Diego. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/4340f15m
  37. [39]Mohammadi, R. 2014, The European Physical Journal C, 74, 3102, doi: 10.1140/epjc/s10052-014-3102-1
  38. [40]Motie, I., & Xue, S.-S. 2012, Euler-Heisenberg Lagrangian and photon circular polarization, arXiv, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.1104.3555DOI
  39. [41]Nagy, J. M., Ade, P. A. R., Amiri, M., et al. 2017, The Astrophysical Journal, 844, 151, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/aa7cfd
  40. [42]Padilla, I. L., Eimer, J. R., Li, Y., et al. 2020, The Astrophysical Journal, 889, 105, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ab61f8
  41. [43]Pardo, J., Cernicharo, J., & Serabyn, E. 2001, IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, 49, 1683, doi: 10.1109/8.982447
  42. [44]Partridge, R. B., Nowakowski, J., & Martin, H. M. 1988, Nature, 331, 146, doi: 10.1038/331146a0
  43. [45]Petroff, M. A., Eimer, J. R., Harrington, K., et al. 2020, The Astrophysical Journal, 889, 120, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ab64e2
  44. [46]Planck Collaboration, Akrami, Y., Ashdown, M., et al. 2017, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 607, A122, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201630311
  45. [47]Planck Collaboration, Akrami, Y., Arroja, F., et al. 2020a, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 641, A1, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201833880
  46. [48]Planck Collaboration, Aghanim, N., Akrami, Y., et al. 2020b, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 641, A6, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201833910
  47. [49]POLARBEAR Collaboration, Ade, P. A. R., Akiba, Y., et al. 2014, The Astrophysical Journal, 794, 171, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/794/2/171
  48. [52]POLARBEAR Collaboration, Adachi, S., Adkins, T., et al. 2024, Physical Review D, 110, 063013, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.110.063013
  49. [53]POLARBEAR Collaboration, Adkins, T., Arnold, K., et al. 2026, Physical Review D, 113, 043044, doi: 10.1103/9wqc-tgzq
  50. [54]Russell, M., Sakaguri, K., Lowry, L. N., et al. 2024, Journal of Low Temperature Physics, 216, 237, doi: 10.1007/s10909-024-03127-9DOI
  51. [55]Sakaguri, K., Barron, D. R., Chinone, Y., et al. 2026, Development and characterization of a millimeter-wave circular polarization observation method using a quarter-wave plate with Simons Array, arXiv; submitted to JCAP, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.2610.19621DOI
  52. [56]Sawyer, R. F. 2014, Photon-photon interactions can be a source of CMB circular polarization, arXiv, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.1408.5434DOI
  53. [57]Shen, Z.-Q., Wan, T.-S., Moran, J. M., et al. 1998, The Astronomical Journal, 115, 1357, doi: 10.1086/300284DOI
  54. [58]SKA Observatory. 2023, Mathematical Details of Antenna Pointing Correction, katpoint documentation, Square Kilometre Array Observatory. https://developer.skao.int/projects/katpoint/en/latest/math_pointing.html
  55. [59]Spinelli, S., Fabbian, G., Tartari, A., Zannoni, M., & Gervasi, M. 2011, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 414, 3272, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.18625.xDOI
  56. [60]Stebor, N., Ade, P., Akiba, Y., et al. 2016, in Millimeter, Submillimeter, and Far-Infrared Detectors and Instrumentation for Astronomy VIII, Vol. 9914 (SPIE), 99141H, doi: 10.1117/12.2233103
  57. [61]Story, K. T., Reichardt, C. L., Hou, Z., et al. 2013, The Astrophysical Journal, 779, 86, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/779/1/86DOI
  58. [62]Suzuki, A., Ade, P., Akiba, Y., et al. 2016, Journal of Low Temperature Physics, 184, 805, doi: 10.1007/s10909-015-1425-4DOI
  59. [63]Takakura, S. 2017, PhD thesis, Osaka University, doi: 10.18910/67054DOI
  60. [64]Takakura, S., Aguilar, M., Akiba, Y., et al. 2017, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2017, 008, doi: 10.1088/1475-7516/2017/05/008DOI
  61. [65]Waelkens, A., Jaffe, T., Reinecke, M., Kitaura, F. S., & Enßlin, T. A. 2009, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 495, 697, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/200810564
  62. [66]Wallace, P. T. 2002, in Advanced Telescope and Instrumentation Control Software II, Vol. 4848, 125–136, doi: 10.1117/12.460914
  63. [67]Westbrook, B., Ade, P. A. R., Aguilar, M., et al. 2018, Journal of Low Temperature Physics, 193, 758, doi: 10.1007/s10909-018-2059-0DOI
  64. [68]Zaldarriaga, M., & Seljak, U. 1997, Physical Review D, 55, 1830, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.55.1830DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_exvnvrbh
Version
v2 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 2

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents