We analyze the notion of indefinite causal order (ICO) from the standpoint of the deterministic de Broglie–Bohm theory, based on the notion of trajectories in configuration space. More precisely, we study the physics of the quantum switch (QS) interferometer within a Bohmian framework and show how the notion of causality is preserved in this approach. Furthermore, we investigate device-independent certification and causal inequalities applied to an entangled quantum system, and show that in this regime too, the notions of trajectories and of a strict causal order are perfectly preserved.
Introduction
The question of causality—its meaning, its fate—has haunted quantum mechanics since its birth in the 1920s–30s. Indeed, nearly a century ago, in Brussels in October 1927, the fifth Solvay Conference gathered most of the founders of the new quantum theory [1]. Bohr, Heisenberg, Born and Pauli championed a radically new, positivist and operationalist view that shattered the classical ideal of clarity grounded in Newtonian and Laplacian determinism in space and time. For Bohr and Heisenberg, classical causality had to be relinquished in favor of a framework in which complementary pictures of reality—such as position and momentum—require mutually exclusive experimental arrangements, yet jointly provide a complete account of the real [2, 3].
As Bohr wrote in the proceedings of the Volta Conference in Como in September 1927 [2]:
The very nature of the quantum theory thus forces us to regard the space-time co-ordination and the claim of causality, the union of which characterizes the classical theories, as complementary but exclusive features of the description.
In the same year, in his seminal article introducing the uncertainty principle, Über den anschaulichen Inhalt der quantentheoretischen Kinematik und Mechanik, Heisenberg argued that Laplacian causality was definitively untenable [4]:
But what is wrong in the sharp formulation of the law of causality, “When we know the present precisely, we can predict the future,” it is not the conclusion but the assumption that is false. Even in principle we cannot know the present in all detail. For that reason everything observed is a selection from a plenitude of possibilities and a limitation on what is possible in the future.
For Heisenberg, the central problem of quantum causality concerns the tension between, on the one hand, the causal and deterministic evolution of the wave function understood as a catalogue of potentialities (potentia) and, on the other hand, the measurement process, which necessarily involves a random phenomenon of collapse and actualization of one of the alternatives contained in this catalogue. This is the origin of the measurement problem, in which the very location of this collapse defines a cut—not only epistemic but ontological—between the quantum and classical worlds. Heisenberg’s approach, completed by von Neumann [5], and interwoven with Bohr’s, constitutes a scaffolding that is not always fully coherent, known as the Copenhagen interpretation—a term Heisenberg himself introduced in 1955 in his Gifford Lectures and popularized in 1958 in Physics and Philosophy[6, 7].
Bohr and Heisenberg’s approach to causality is, however, far from universally accepted. As early as 1927, at the fifth Solvay Conference, Louis de Broglie—who had extended the wave-particle duality of light to matter in 1923 [9, 8]—presented an alternative formulation, which he called the “pilot-wave theory” [10, 11, 12]. In this picture, particles follow deterministic trajectories in space-time, as in classical physics, guided by a Schrödinger wave propagating in configuration space. Laplacian causality is thus preserved, along with the ontological clarity of the classical world of Newton and Einstein. As de Broglie explained:
...it does not seem to us that there is any reason to renounce believing in the determinism of individual physical phenomena, and it is in this that our conception, which are very similar in other respects to those of Mr Born, appear nevertheless to differ from them markedly. [12]
After being heavily criticized and falling into obscurity for decades, de Broglie’s approach was rediscovered by David Bohm in 1952 as a “hidden-variable theory,” also referred to as the “causal interpretation” [13, 14]. Interestingly, an early manuscript by Bohm from 1951–52 was titled “A Causal and Continuous Interpretation of Quantum Theory” [15]. It is now understood that this theory—today universally known as Bohmian mechanics or de Broglie–Bohm theory (dBB) [16, 16, 18, 19, 20]—reproduces the full range of quantum phenomena, both in the non-relativistic domain and in large parts of quantum field theory, although no consensus has yet been reached on its definitive formulation in the latter regime [21, 22].
Long relegated to metaphysics, the debate on causality acquired experimental relevance with Bell’s inequalities, which enabled direct tests of quantum mechanics against local hidden-variable theories, including local and causal extensions of de Broglie’s proposal [23, 24]. Experiments have since established the non-local, or more accurately non-locally causal, nature of quantum theory [26, 25, 27, 28, 29]. As an explicitly non-local theory, dBB theory is therefore a fully legitimate alternative—a natural completion of quantum mechanics without the conceptual vagueness of the orthodox view.
In the last fifteen years, however, the question of causality in quantum mechanics has been radically revived
with the introduction of superposed causal states—the so-called indefinite causal order (ICO) [32, 30, 31]. In its original, essentially operational formulation, quantum systems such as qubits or photonic polarization states undergo successive operations in a definite order, say A then B then C, or in another order, C then B then A[33, 34]. Thanks to linearity, quantum mechanics allows superpositions of these alternative causal histories, enabling a host of applications that are in principle impossible with any single, well-defined causal order.
Among them, the quantum switch (QS)—sketched in Figure 1—is the paradigmatic example of ICO. First proposed by Chiribella et al.[34], it is a higher-order quantum operation in which the order of two quantum channels, A^ and B^, is placed in a coherent superposition controlled by a quantum control qubit ∣c⟩. If ∣c⟩=∣0⟩, the target system undergoes A^ then B^; if ∣c⟩=∣1⟩, it undergoes B^ then A^. If the control is prepared in (∣0⟩+∣1⟩)/2, the system experiences A^ then B^ and B^ then A^ in superposition—a causally non-separable process [32, 35]. No definite causal history can be assigned. The construction is fundamentally operational: it does not require in principle a classical or quantum space-time, only quantum control of the order of operations performed sequentially [34, 36].
Figure 1. Feynman diagram-style schematic of the quantum switch (QS). Depending on the state of a control qubit, ∣0⟩ or ∣1⟩, a target degree of freedom — depicted by the red and blue trajectories — undergoes successive unitary operations in different orders: first Alice then Bob, or first Bob then Alice. Their coherent superposition defines an indefinite causal order (ICO) state
It has been demonstrated photonically with path and polarization as control and target [37, 38, 39], and more recently using time-bin encoding [42, 40, 41]. Moreover, the landscape of QS implementations and applications has expanded rapidly. Its proven ability to outperform causally ordered circuits in metrology [44, 43], channel discrimination [45], communication complexity [46, 47], quantum communication [48, 49, 50] and thermodynamics [51, 52] has become a research field in its own right, now covered by several dedicated reviews [53, 54, 55, 56, 57].
Reflections on ICO and its paradigmatic example, the QS, are not limited to information processing. Questions of superposed causal structures have, from the outset, lain at the heart of attempts to develop quantum gravity by extending the causal spatio-temporal framework of general relativity into the quantum realm [30, 31, 59, 58, 60].
The significance of studies on ICO in recent years—all conducted within a primarily operational framework—nevertheless overlooks the fundamental, ontological questions at the heart of quantum mechanics. Within a Bohmian framework, where the notion of a well-defined trajectory—and thus of history—is central [16, 17, 18], the concept of ICO suggests paradoxes or contradictions that deserve closer examination.
In this article, we explore the connection between ICOs, and the QS in particular, and the causal de Broglie–Bohm theory. We demonstrate how the issue of Bohmian trajectories—which are inherently well-defined and causal—can be reinterpreted in ICO-type scenarios, using the QS as a working example. Ultimately, our main result is that, similar to the elusive wave-particle duality [2, 6], there is fundamentally no ICO in dBB at the trajectory level. Like any interference effect, ICOs are associated with the guiding wave function, but particles always follow a unique and well-defined history [13, 14, 16].
The article is structured as follows. In Section 2, we revisit the principle of thecQs in relation to ICO from an elementary standpoint, using the standard Mach-Zehnder interferometer as a guiding analogy. In Section 3, we briefly recall the theoretical framework of the dBB approach, applied to both spinless and spin-1/2 particles. In Section 4, we address QS and ICO from a Bohmian perspective and, on the basis of an analytical and numerical model, construct dBB trajectories in QS, thereby showing that QS always admits a description in terms of well-defined paths. In Section 5, we examine the recent problem of the device-independent verification of ICO, as addressed by the no-go theorem of Ref. [61], and we argue that, within dBB theory, this theorem cannot rule out the existence of causally well-defined trajectories, owing to the nonlocality inherent in the theory. We conclude with some perspectives for future work
Physics of the quantum switch
We begin by reviewing the operating principle of the QS [34, 37]. To do so, we will limit ourselves to the original implementation used by Procopio et al. [37], which employs an internal degree of freedom (the photon’s polarization in their version) as the “target” and the particle’s path as the “control.” Furthermore, since we are interested in a thought experiment, we will replace the photon and its polarization with a non-relativistic electron and its spin, which has the advantage of having a relatively simple and widely accepted dBB-type description. The implementation of the QS starts with a type of Mach-Zehnder interferometer with unfolded arms, as shown in Figure 2. In practice, this diagram is merely a conceptual illustration, and this has led to numerous debates regarding the actual or simulated implementation of the QS [37, 49, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 59, 67, 60, 68, 69]. However, we will not get bogged down in these debates here and will assume that the QS is perfectly well represented by this “unfolded” version of the QS, in which we have a completely standard Mach-Zehnder interferometer with two well-defined arms, but in which we have two unitary operations (or gates), A^ and B^, have been placed to act successively on the particle’s spin state. In the two paths, the gates are arranged in the order A^ then B^ or B^ then A^, which generally results in different output states, unless the operators commute, i.e., [A^,B^]=0.
Figure 2. Schematic diagram of the interferometer acting as an unfolded QS used in our simulations and calculations of dBB trajectories. The system considers, in the z−t plane, two symmetric BSs (BS1 and BS2) and two mirrors operating over a finite time interval so as not to block the propagation of the wave trains, which also have finite spatiotemporal extent. The initial beam splits into two beams, U and V, and the unitary operators A^ and B^ are placed within the beams to act on the spin degree of freedom (target) associated with the particle. At the end of the experiment, the beams exit the interferometer through outputs M and N corresponding to Charlie observable c=1 or c=0 respectively.
We write the initial quantum state before the electron entering the QS interferometer as a spinor:
Ψin(z,t)=χinΦin(z,t)(1)
where Φin(z,t)∈C, ‘the control’ degree of freedom, is a complex valued and normalized single electron wave function belonging to L2(R) and associated with a localized wave-packet in a 1+1 dimensional space-time z,t (the transverse motion of the wave packet is here neglected). The ‘target’ degree of freedom is the initial pure spinor
χin=(χ+zinχ−zin)≡χ+zin∣+z⟩+χ−zin∣−z⟩(2)
where χ±zin∈C are the complex probability amplitudes for having respectively a spin up or down along the z direction (we assume the normalization χin∗χin=χ+zin∗χ+zin+χ−zin∗χ−zin=1).
The wave packet associated with the control degree of freedom first encounters a balanced (50/50) beam splitter, denoted BS1 (see Figure 2). The reflected component follows a path in which the particle interacts successively with the unitary gates A^ and then B^, both acting only on the spin (target) degree of freedom. The transmitted component follows the other path, where the same gates are applied in the reverse order, first B^ and then A^. We denote by U(z,t) and V(z,t) the normalized wave packets associated with the transmitted and reflected components, respectively, and by χB≺A=A^B^χin, χA≺B=B^A^χin the corresponding spin states after the action of the unitaries in each branch. Finally, the two wave packets are recombined by a second balanced beam splitter, BS2, yielding the two output normalized wave packets N(z,t) and M(z,t).
Formally the different steps of the unitary evolution are summarized by the equation
where the minus sign is coming from a π-phase shift due to wave reflection on the mirrors. From a computational standpoint, the QS depicted here provides a clear advantage over any causally ordered circuit. As shown by Chiribella et al. [34], when the unitary gates A^ and B^ either commute or anticommute, the QS can perfectly discriminate between these two cases with a single query to each gate. This is impossible for any conventional sequential circuit with fixed causal order, which requires at least two uses of one of the gates to achieve the same task. The advantage stems directly from the ICO: by placing A^ and B^ in a coherent superposition of the two orderings A^B^ and B^A^, the control qubit acquires a relative phase of +1 in the commuting case and −1 in the anticommuting case, making the two alternatives perfectly distinguishable through a simple measurement of the control in the basis associated with the M(z,t),N(z,t) spatial modes.
Regarding QS, a fundamental question concerns how to quantify its associated ICO—or, more precisely, its causal nonseparability. One approach, developed by analogy with quantum entanglement, introduces a causal witness operator [70, 49, 71, 72] that distinguishes causally separable processes (for instance, a configuration involving only one arm of the interferometer) from causally nonseparable ones, such as the QS. This approach ultimately relies on the process matrix formalism, originally developed by Oreshkov, Costa, and Brukner [32]. Here, we will instead characterize the quality of the QS and its ICO through the Greenberger–Yasin duality inequality[73, 74, 75]. We point out that recent works already used this duality in connection with ICO for the QS [76, 77].
To do this, we first insert a waveplate into one arm of the interferometer to introduce a time delay. This is equivalent to multiplying the probability amplitude in this arm by a phase factor eiφ. The role of this delay is just to obtain oscillation fringes in the output channels. Moreover, to further generalize quantum superposition by incorporating environmental effects and decoherence, we assume that the target–control system interacts with external parties, hereafter called Alice and Bob. Alice and Bob receive bipartite inputs x and y, and produce outputs a and b, respectively. The causal order of their interventions differs between the two arms: if, for instance, Alice acts before Bob (A≺B), she may signal to Bob while he cannot signal to her. Oreshkov, Costa, and Brukner exploited this asymmetry to introduce causal games, such as "Guess Your Neighbor’s Input" (GYNI) [78, 79, 80], which give rise to causal inequalities [32]. A violation of these inequalities would provide a device-independent certification of ICO. Unfortunately, in Minkowski spacetime the QS does not violate causal inequalities unless one invokes hypothetical quantum superpositions of geometries. Recent work suggests this can be fixed by entangling the QS with a third party and adding extra assumptions—relativistic causality and free interventions—to obtain stronger causal inequalities that the QS can violate. We postpone this to § 5 and focus here on the standard model, where Alice and Bob are entangled with the QS, to discuss the Greenberger-Yasin duality inequality.
References
[1]Électrons et Photons: Rapports et Discussions du Cinquième Conseil de Physique tenu à Bruxelles du 24 au 29 Octobre 1927; Gauthier-Villars: Paris, France, 1928.
[2]Bohr, N. The quantum postulate and the recent development of atomic theory. Nature 1928, 121 Suppl., 580–590.
[3]Bohr, N. The quantum postulate and the recent development of atomic theory. In Atti del Congresso Internazionale dei Fisici, Como, 11–20 Settembre 1927; Zanichelli: Bologna, Italy, 1928; Vol. 2, pp. 565–588.
[4]Heisenberg, W. Über den anschaulichen Inhalt der quantentheoretischen Kinematik und Mechanik. Z. Phys. 1927, 43, 172–198.
[5]von Neumann, J. Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik; Springer: Berlin, Germany, 1932.
[6]Heisenberg, W. The Physical Principles of the Quantum Theory and the Development of Philosophical Ideas Since Descartes; Gifford Lectures 1955–1956; Unpublished; later published as Physics and Philosophy.
[7]Heisenberg, W. Physics and Philosophy: The Revolution in Modern Science; Harper and Row: New York, NY, USA, 1958.DOI
[8]de Broglie, L. Ondes et quanta. C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 1923, 177, 507–510.
[9]de Broglie, L. Recherches sur la théorie des quanta. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Paris, Paris, France, 1924; Ann. Phys. 1925, 10, 22–128.DOI
[10]de Broglie, L. La mécanique ondulatoire et la structure atomique de la matière et du rayonnement. J. Phys. Radium 1927, 8, 225–241.DOI
[11]de Broglie, L. La nouvelle dynamique des quanta. In Électrons et Photons: Rapports et Discussions du Cinquième Conseil de Physique; Gauthier-Villars: Paris, France, 1928; pp. 105–132.
[12]de Broglie, L. et al. Discussion. In Électrons et Photons; 1928; p. 134, p. 135.
[13]Bohm, D. A suggested interpretation of the quantum theory in terms of “hidden” variables. I. Phys. Rev. 1952, 85, 166–179.DOI
[14]Bohm, D. A suggested interpretation of the quantum theory in terms of “hidden” variables. II. Phys. Rev. 1952, 85, 180–193.DOI
[15]Drezet, A.; Stock, B. A causal and continuous interpretation of the quantum theory: About an original manuscript by David Bohm sent to Louis de Broglie in 1951. Ann. Fond. de Broglie 2021, 46, 169–195.arxiv.org/abs/2103.00576
[16]Bohm, D.; Hiley, B.J. The Undivided Universe: An Ontological Interpretation of Quantum Theory; Routledge: London, UK, 1993.
[17]Holland, P.R. The Quantum Theory of Motion; Cambridge Univ. Press: Cambridge, UK, 1993.DOI
[18]Dürr, D.; Goldstein, S.; Zanghì, N. Quantum equilibrium and the origin of absolute uncertainty. J. Stat. Phys. 1992, 67, 843–907.
[19]Bricmont, J. Making sense of quantum mechanics; Vol. 37, Springer: Cham, 2016.DOI
[20]Dürr, D.; Lazarovici, D. Understanding quantum mechanics. Cham: Springer 2020.
[21]Struyve, W. De Broglie–Bohm field beables for quantum field theory. Rep. Prog. Phys. 2010, 73, 106001.
[22]Colin, S.; Struyve, W. A Dirac sea pilot-wave model for quantum field theory. J. Phys. A 2015, 48, 465301.
[23]Bell, J.S. On the Einstein Podolsky Rosen paradox. Physics 1964, 1, 195–200.
[24]Clauser, J.F.; Horne, M.A.; Shimony, A.; Holt, R.A. Proposed experiment to test local hidden-variable theories. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1969, 23, 880–884.
[25]Freedman, S.J.; Clauser, J.F. Experimental test of local hidden-variable theories. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1972, 28, 938–941.DOI
[26]Aspect, A.; Dalibard, J.; Roger, G. Experimental test of Bell’s inequalities using time-varying analyzers. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1982, 49, 1804–1807.DOI
[27]Hensen, B.; et al. Loophole-free Bell inequality violation using electron spins separated by 1.3 kilometres. Nature 2015, 526, 682–686.
[28]Giustina, M.; et al. Significant-loophole-free test of Bell’s theorem with entangled photons. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2015, 115, 250401.
[29]Shalm, L.K.; et al. Strong loophole-free test of local realism. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2015, 115, 250402.DOI
[30]Hardy, L. Towards quantum gravity: a framework for probabilistic theories with non-fixed causal structure. J. Phys. A 2007, 40, 3081–3099.
[31]Hardy, L. Quantum gravity computers: On the implications of general relativity with indefinite causal structure. In Quantum Reality, Relativistic Causality, and Closing the Epistemic Circle; Springer: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2009.DOI
[32]Oreshkov, O.; Costa, F.; Brukner, Č. Quantum correlations with no causal order. Nat. Commun. 2012, 3, 1092.DOI
[33]Chiribella, G.; D’Ariano, G.M.; Perinotti, P. Transforming quantum operations: Quantum supermaps. Europhys. Lett. 2008, 83, 30004.DOI
[34]Chiribella, G.; D’Ariano, G.M.; Perinotti, P.; Valiron, B. Quantum computations without definite causal structure. Phys. Rev. A 2013, 88, 022318.DOI
[35]Branciard, C.; Araújo, M.; Feix, A.; Costa, F.; Brukner, Č. The simplest causal inequalities and their violation. New J. Phys. 2016, 18, 013008.DOI
[36]Chiribella, G.; et al. Quantum computations with indefinite causal structures. Phys. Rev. A 2013, 88, 022318
[37]Procopio, L.M.; et al. Experimental superposition of orders of quantum gates. Nat. Commun. 2015, 6, 7913.
[38]Procopio, L.M.; Moqanaki, A.; Araújo, M.; Costa, F.; Calafell, I.A.; Dowd, E.G.; Hamel, D.R.; Rozema, L.A.; Brukner, Č.; Walther, P. Experimental superposition of orders of quantum gates. Nat. Commun. 2015, 6, 7913.
[39]Rubino, G.; Rozema, L.A.; Feix, A.; Araújo, M.; Zeuner, J.M.; Walther, P.; et al. Experimental verification of an indefinite causal order. Sci. Adv. 2017, 3, e1602589.DOI
[40]Antesberger, M.; et al. Entanglement-enhanced communication complexity using indefinite causal order. arXiv 2022, arXiv:2208.00081.
[41]Antesberger, M.; Richter, C.M.D.; et al. High-fidelity photonic quantum switch. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2024, 132, 110803.
[42]Rubino, G.; Rozema, L.A.; Massa, F.; Araújo, M.; Zych, M.; Brukner, Č.; Walther, P. Experimental entanglement of temporal order. Quantum 2022, 6, 621.DOI
[43]Chiribella, G. Quantum superpositions of causal orders and metrology. Phys. Rev. A 2012, 85, 042331.
[44]Zhao, X.; et al. Quantum metrology with indefinite causal order. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2020, 124, 110503.DOI
[45]Bavaresco, J.; et al. Strict Hierarchy between Operational Theories of Indefinite Causality. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2022, 129, 230401.
[46]Guérin, P.A.; Feix, A.; Araújo, M.; Brukner, Č. Exponential communication complexity advantage from quantum superposition of the direction of communication. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2016, 117, 100502.DOI
[47]Wei, K.; et al. Experimental quantum switching for exponentially superior quantum communication complexity. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2019, 122, 120504.DOI
[48]Ebler, D.; Salek, S.; Chiribella, G. Enhanced communication with the assistance of indefinite causal order. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2018, 120, 120502.DOI
[49]Goswami, K.; Giarmatzi, C.; Kewming, M.; Costa, F.; Branciard, C.; Romero, J.; White, A.G. Indefinite causal order in a quantum switch. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2018, 121, 090503.DOI
[50]Goswami, K.; Cao, Y.; Paz-Silva, G.A.; Romero, J.; White, A.G. Increasing communication capacity via superposition of causal order. Phys. Rev. Research 2020, 2, 033292.DOI
[51]Felce, D.; Vedral, V. Quantum refrigeration with indefinite causal order. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2020, 125, 070603.DOI
[52]Chiribella, G.; et al. Indefinite causal order enables perfect quantum communication with zero capacity channels. et al., and thermodynamic advantages: Phys. Rev. Research 2021.
[53]Brukner, Č. Quantum causality. Nat. Phys. 2014, 10, 259–263.DOI
[54]Goswami, K.; Romero, J. Experiments on quantum causality. AVS Quantum Sci. 2020, 2, 037101.DOI
[55]Chiribella, G.; Kristjánsson, H. Quantum Shannon theory with superpositions of trajectories. Proc. R. Soc. A 2021, 477, 20190525.
[56]Rozema, L. A.; Strömberg, T.; Cao, H.; Guo, Y.; Liu, B.-H.; Walther, P. Experimental aspects of indefinite causal order in quantum mechanics. Nat. Rev. Phys. 2023, 5, 367–380.DOI
[58]O’Riordan, J.; Hardy, L. Quantum gravity and indefinite causality. Phys. Rev. D 2022 style.
[59]Zych, M.; Costa, F.; Pikovski, I.; Brukner, Č. Bell’s theorem for temporal order. Nat. Commun. 2019, 10, 3772.
[60]Ormrod, N.; Vanrietvelde, A.; Barrett, J. Causal structure in the presence of sectorial constraints, with application to the quantum switch. Quantum 2023, 7, 1028. https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2023-06-01-1028
[61]van der Lugt, T.; Barrett, J.; Chiribella, G. Device-independent certification of indefinite causal order in the quantum switch. Nat. Commun. 2023, 14, 5811.
[62]Paunković, N.; Vojinović, M. Causal orders, quantum circuits and spacetime: Distinguishing between definite and superposed causal orders. Quantum 2020, 4, 275. https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2020-05-28-275
[63]Abbott, A.A.; Wechs, J.; Horsman, D.; Mhalla, M.; Branciard, C. Communication through coherent control of quantum channels. Quantum 2020, 4, 333. https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2020-09-24-333
[64]Oreshkov, O. Time-delocalized quantum subsystems and operations: On the existence of processes with indefinite causal structure in quantum mechanics. Quantum 2019, 3, 206. https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2019-12-02-206
[65]Wechs, J.; Branciard, C.; Oreshkov, O.; Existence of processes violating causal inequalities on time-delocalized subsystems. Nat. Commun. 2023, 14, 1471. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-36893-3
[67]Vilasini, V.; Renner, R. Embedding cyclic information-theoretic structures in acyclic space-times: No-go results for indefinite causality. Phys. Rev. A 2024, 110, 022227; Phys. Rev. Lett. 2024, 133, 080201. arXiv:2203.11245.DOI
[68]Kristjánsson, H.; Gardner, S.; Chiribella, G. Coherent control of causal order and its resource theory. New J. Phys. 2020, 22, 073065.
[69]de la Hamette, A.-C.; Kabel, V.; B, C. What an event is not: unravelling the identity of events in quantum theory and gravity. arXiv:2404.00159arxiv.org/abs/2404.00159
[70]Branciard, C. Witnesses of causal nonseparability: An introduction and a few case studies. Sci. Rep. 2016, 6, 26018. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep26018
[71]Rubino, G.; Rozema, L.A.; Feix, A.; Araújo, M.; Zeuner, J.M.; Procopio, L.M.; Brukner, Č.; Walther, P. Experimental verification of an indefinite causal order. Sci. Adv. 2017, 3, e1602589.DOI
[72]Araújo, M.; Branciard, C.; Costa, F.; Feix, A.; Giarmatzi, C.; Brukner, Č. Witnessing causal nonseparability. New J. Phys. 2015, 17, 102001.DOI
[73]Greenberger, D.M.; Yasin, A. Simultaneous wave and particle knowledge in a neutron interferometer. Phys. Lett. A 1988, 128, 391–394. https://doi.org/10.1016/0375-9601(88)90114-4
[76]Valibouse, Y.; Cladera-Rosseló, M.; Antesberger, M.; Lima, P.; Walther, P.; Rozema, L.A. Time-delocalized local measurements in an indefinite causal order. arXiv:2604.11878
[78]Almeida, M.L.; Bancal, J.-D.; Brunner, N.; Acín, A.; Gisin, N.; Pironio, S. Guess your neighbor’s input: A multipartite nonlocal game with no quantum advantage. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2010, 104, 230404. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.104.230404
[79]Branciard, C.; Araújo, M.; Feix, A.; Costa, F.; Brukner, Č. The simplest causal inequalities and their violation. New J. Phys. 2015, 18, 013008. arXiv:1508.01704.DOI
[80]Acín, A.; Almeida, M.L.; Augusiak, R.; Brunner, N. Guess your neighbor’s input: No quantum advantage but an advantage for quantum theory. arXiv 2012, arXiv:1205.3076.arxiv.org/abs/1205.3076
[81]Madelung, E. Quantentheorie in hydrodynamischer form. Z. Für Phys. 1926, 40, 322–326.DOI
[82]Drezet, A.; Amblard, A. Can de Broglie–Bohm mechanics be considered complete? Entropy 2025, 27, 399.DOI
[83]Valentini, A. Beyond the quantum: A quest for the origin and hidden meaning of quantum mechanics; Oxford University Press, Oxford , UK, 2025.
[84]Bohm, D.; Schiller, R.; Tiomno, J. A causal interpretation of the Pauli equation (A). Suppl. Nuovo Cimento 1955, 1, 48–66.DOI
[85]Bohm, D.; Schiller, R. A causal interpretation of the Pauli equation (B). Suppl. Nuovo Cimento 1955, 1, 67–91.DOI
[86]Dewdney, C. Rekindling of de Broglie–Bohm pilot wave theory in the late twentieth century: A personal account. Found. Phys. 2023, 53, 24.DOI
[87]Holland, P. Uniqueness of conserved currents in quantum mechanics. Ann. Phys. 2003, 515, 446–462.DOI
[88]Bell, J.S. On the problem of hidden variables in quantum mechanics. Rev. Mod. Phys. 1966, 38, 447–452.
[89]Das, S.; Dürr, D. Arrival time distributions of spin-1/2 particles. Sci. Rep. 2019, 9, 2242.DOI
[90]Goldstein, S.; Tumulka, R.; Zanghi, N. Arrival times versus detection times. Found. Phys. 2024, 54, 63.DOI
[92]Amblard, A. Drezet, A. Arrival-time distributions as a probe of the preferred foliation in relativistic bohmian mechanics. Entropy 2026, 28, 1057.arxiv.org/abs/2604.17507
[93]Purves, T.; Short, A.J. Quantum Theory Cannot Violate a Causal Inequality. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2021, 127, 110407.DOI
[94]Wechs, J.; Dourdent, H.; Abbott, A.A.; Branciard, C. Quantum Circuits with Classical Versus Quantum Control of Causal Order. PRX Quantum 2021, 2, 030335.DOI
[95]Einstein, A. Letter to Heisenberg reported in: Heisenberg, W. Der Teil und das Ganze: Gespräche im Umkreis der Atomphysik; Piper: München, Germany, 1969; p. 92; English translation Physics and Beyond; Harper & Row: New York, NY, USA, 1971. [“Erst die Theorie entscheidet darüber, was man beobachten kann”].
[96]Heisenberg, W. Der Teil und das Ganze: Gespräche im Umkreis der Atomphysik; Piper: München, Germany, 1969.
[97]Heisenberg, W. Physics and Beyond: Encounters and Conversations; Harper & Row: New York, NY, USA, 1971.DOI
[98]Philippidis, C.; Dewdney, C.; Hiley, B.J. Quantum interference and the quantum potential. Nuovo Cimento B 1979, 52, 15–28. [Premières trajectoires dBB double-fente montrant non-crossing].DOI
[99]Wheeler, J.A. The “past” and the “delayed-choice” double-slit experiment. In Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Theory; Marlow, A.R., Ed.; Academic Press: New York, NY, USA, 1978; pp. 9–48.DOI
[100]Wheeler, J.A. Law without law. In Quantum Theory and Measurement; Wheeler, J.A., Zurek, W.H., Eds.; Princeton University Press: Princeton, NJ, USA, 1984; pp. 182–213.
[101]Heisenberg, W. The Physical Principles of the Quantum Theory; University of Chicago Press: Chicago, IL, USA, 1930; p. 20. [Original: Physikalische Prinzipien der Quantentheorie, 1930].
[102]von Weizsäcker, C.F. Ortsbestimmung eines Elektrons durch ein Mikroskop. Z. Phys. 1931, 68, 114–117.
[103]Hermann, G. Die naturphilosophischen Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik. Abhandlungen der Fries’schen Schule 1935, 6, 75–152.
[104]Hermann, G. Die Kausalität in der Quantenmechanik. Die Naturwissenschaften 1935, 23, 718–719.
[105]Bell, J.S. Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1987.
[106]Acín, A.; Brunner, N.; Gisin, N.; Massar, S.; Pironio, S.; Scarani, V. Device-independent security of quantum cryptography against collective attacks. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2007, 98, 230501.DOI
[107]Pironio, S.; Acín, A.; Massar, S.; Boyer de la Giroday, A.; Matsukevich, D.N.; Maunz, P.; Olmschenk, S.; Hayes, D.; Luo, L.; Manning, T.A.; Monroe, C. Random numbers certified by Bell’s theorem. Nature 2010, 464, 1021–1024.DOI
[108]Dourdent, H.; Abbott, A.A.; Verma, R.; Branciard, C. Network-device-independent certification of causal nonseparability. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2022, 129, 090402.
[109]van der Lugt, T.; Ormrod, N. Possibilistic and maximal indefinite causal order in the quantum switch. Quantum 2024, 8, 1543.DOI
[110]Gogioso, S.; Pinzani, N. The geometry of causality. arXiv:2303.09017arxiv.org/abs/2303.09017
[111]Woodhead, E. Imperfections and self testing in prepare- and-measure quantum key distribution, Ph.D. thesis, Laboratoire d’Information Quantique Université libre de Bruxelles (2014).
[112]Barrett, J.; Kent, A.; and Pironio, S. Maximally nonlocal and monogamous quantum correlations. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2006 97, 170409.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17155453
[113]Bong, K.-W.; Utreras-Alarcón, A.; Ghafari, F.; Liang, Y.-C.; Tischler, N.; Cavalcanti, E. G.; Pryde, G. J.; and Wiseman, H. M. A strong no-go theorem on the Wigner’s friend paradox. Nature Physics 2020 16, 1199.DOI
[114]Haddara, M.; Wiseman, H.M.; Cavalcanti, E.G.Properties and applications of partially deterministic polytopes. arXiv:251025127arxiv.org/abs/2510.25127
[115]Richter, C.M.D.; Antesberger, M.; Cao, H.; Walther, P.; Rozema, L.A. Towards an Experimental Device-Independent Verification of Indefinite Causal Order. PRX Quantum 2026, 7, 010354.DOI
[116]Ou, D.; Lin, Q.; Xiao, L.; Zhan, X.; Xue, P. Experimental violation of a Bell-like causal inequality in a photonic quantum switch. Sci. Adv. 2026, 12, eaee9271.
[118]Cao, H.; Bavaresco, J.; Lami, L.; Rozema, L.A.; Walther, P.; et al. Semi-device-independent certification of indefinite causal order in a photonic quantum switch. Optica 2023, 10, 561–568.DOI
[119]Einstein, A. Induction and Deduction in Physics. Berliner Tageblatt, 25 December 1919. Reprinted in English translation as Doc. 28 in The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein, Vol. 7: The Berlin Years: Writings, 1918–1921; Buchwald, D.K., et al., Eds.; Princeton University Press: Princeton, NJ, USA, 2002.
[120]Grinbaum, A. How device-independent approaches change the meaning of physical theory. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 2017, 58, 22-30.DOI
[121]Handsteiner, J.; Steiner, J.; Friedman, A.S.; Rauch, D.; Gallicchio, J.; Liu, B.; Hosp, H.; Kofler, J.; Bricher, D.; Fink, M.; et al. Cosmic Bell test: Measurement settings from milky way stars. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2017, 118, 060401.DOI
[122]Drezet, A. A time-symmetric soliton dynamics à la de Broglie. Found. Phys. 2023, 53, 72.arxiv.org/abs/2207.06809
[123]Drezet, A. Whence nonlocality? Removing spooky action-at-a-distance from the de Broglie Bohm pilot-wave theory using a time-symmetric version of the de Broglie double solution. Symmetry 2024, 16, 8.
[124]Letertre, L. Causal nonseparability and its implication for spatiotemporal relations. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 2022, 95, 64-74.DOI
[125]de la Hamette, A.-C.; Kabel, V.; Christodoulou, M.; and Brukner,Č. Indefinite causal order and quantum coordinates. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2025, 135, 141402.DOI
[126]Friedman, J.; Morris, M.S.; Novikov, I.D.; Echeverria, F.; Klinkhammer, G.; Thorne, K.S.; Yurtsever, U. Cauchy problem in spacetimes with closed timelike curves. Phys. Rev. D 1990, 42, 1915–1930.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10013039
[127]Morris, M.S.; Thorne, K.S.; Yurtsever, U. Wormholes, time machines, and the weak energy condition. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1988, 61, 1446–1449.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10038800
[128]Baumeler, Ä.; Feix, A.; Wolf, S. Maximal incompatibility of locally classical behavior and global causal order in multi-party scenarios. Phys. Rev. A 2014, 90, 042106.DOI
[129]Ho, M.C.T.; Costa, F.; Giarmatzi, C.; Ralph, T. C. Violation of a causal inequality in a spacetime with definite causal order. arXiv:1804.05498.arxiv.org/abs/1804.05498
[130]Felce, D.; Tibau Vidal, N.; Vedral, V.; Dias, E.-O. Indefinite causal orders from superpositions in time. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2022, 105, 062216.DOI
[131]Valentini, A. Pilot-Wave Theory of Fields, Gravitation and Cosmology. In Bohmian Mechanics and Quantum Theory: An Appraisal; Cushing, J.T., Fine, A., Goldstein, S., Eds.; Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science; Springer: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1996; Volume 184, pp. 45–66. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-015-8715-0_3
[132]Pinto-Neto, N.; Struyve, W. Bohmian Quantum Gravity and Cosmology. In The Routledge Handbook of Philosophy of Physics; Knox, E., Wilson, A., Eds.; Routledge: London, UK, 2018; Chapter 6. https://arxiv.org/abs/1801.03353