WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Signature of long-ranged spin triplets across a two-dimensional superconductor/helimagnet van der Waals interface
Abstract
The combination of a superconductor with a magnetically inhomogeneous material has been established as an efficient mechanism for the generation of long-ranged spin-polarized (spin-triplet) Cooper pairs. Evidence for this mechanism, however, has been established based on studies done on three-dimensional systems, where the strong bonds existing at the interface between the superconductor and the magnetic material should in principle enhance proximity effects and strengthen any electronic correlations. Here, we fabricate devices based on van der Waals stacks of flakes of the two-dimensional superconductor combined with flakes of , which has a built-in magnetic inhomogeneity due to its helimagnetic spin texture at low temperatures. We find that the critical temperature of these vdW bilayers is strongly dependent on the magnetic state of , whose degree of magnetic inhomogeneity can be controlled via an applied magnetic field. Our results demonstrate evidence for the generation of long-ranged spin-triplet pairs across the / vdW interface.
*Correspondence to: [email protected]
Introduction
The interplay between ferromagnetism and superconductivity has been widely investigated in superconductor/ferromagnet (S/F) thin film multilayers with a conventional S, where the Cooper pairs of electrons are in an antiparallel-aligned (spin-singlet) state. Although early studies on such S/F hybrids showed that magnetic exchange field () of a F quickly suppresses the spin-singlet superconductivity from the S/F interface [1, 2, 3], over the past 20 years several groups have demonstrated, confirming a theoretical prediction [4], that long-ranged parallel-aligned (spin-triplet) Cooper pairs of electrons can be generated in S/F devices with non-collinear Fs [5, 6, 7, 8, 9] or with an intrinsically-inhomogeneous magnetic material like the helimagnet Ho [10, 11, 12]. Evidence for long-ranged spin triplets in these S/F hybrids has been found via measurements of the dependence of their superconducting critical temperature () on the magnetic state (i.e., collinear/non-collinear) [7, 8, 9] or via measurements of a long-ranged supercurrents (compared to the F’s coherence length, , for spin-singlet pairs) in S/F/S Josephson junctions (JJs) [4, 5, 6, 10, 13]. Spectroscopic evidence for spin-triplet states has also been reported via measurements of sub-gap states in the superconducting density of states [12, 14, 15] or via measurements of an inverse Meissner effect [11]. All these studies have established the research field of superconducting spintronics [16] that aims at exploiting long-ranged spin triplets, which carry a net spin, to do spintronics in the superconducting state with low-energy dissipation.
Van der Waals (vdW) materials can be exfoliated down to the two-dimensional limit and exhibit physical properties that often do not have a counterpart in three-dimensional systems. Over the past years, a variety of vdW Ss and Fs has been explored both as single flakes and stacked to form vdW heterostructures [17, 18, 19, 20, 21]. S/F vdW heterostructures can be used to realize superconducting spintronic devices with novel functionalities compared to those based on thin film multilayers. Before this occurs, however, it is essential to determine at which S/F vdW interfaces long-ranged spin triplets can be generated.
Several groups have recently studied the proximity effect in S/F vdW hybrids, and they have observed signatures of phenomena like a 0-to- transition in S/F/S vdW JJs [22], which had only been known for JJs made from thin film multilayers [2, 3]. Spin-triplet generation at the interface between electrodes of NbN (S) and the vdW material FeTaS (F) has also been reported [23], although this S/F interface may not be truly vdW in nature. A long-ranged coupling has also been measured in lateral NbSe/FeGeTe/NbSe (S/F/S) vdW JJs [24], but the spin-triplet nature of the supercurrent and the mechanism behind its generation remains unclear because FeGeTe does not have an intrinsic magnetic inhomogeneity.
In this Letter, we explore the superconducting proximity effect across the vdW interface forming between a flake of a vdW S (NbS) and a magnetic flake of CrNbS. CrNbS is helimagnetic at low temperatures [26, 27] and therefore has a built-in magnetic inhomogeneity ideal for spin-triplet generation. Studying the evolution of the of CrNbS/NbS (F/S) stacks as a function of the magnetic state of CrNbS, we find that the of these vdW devices strongly depends on the CrNbS magnetization, in a way that cannot be reconciled with a conventional short-ranged S/F proximity effect or with stray fields. Supported also by a theoretical model, we show that our results are consistent with the generation of long-ranged spin-triplet pairs across the CrNbS/NbS vdW interface.
Results and discussion
We fabricate vdW heterostructures of CrNbS/NbS (CrNbS on top) on pre-patterned Au(33 nm)/Ti(7 nm) electrodes using the dry-transfer technique [25], as shown in Figure 1(a). We use CrNbS flakes with thickness ranging between 200 nm and 500 nm, which are obtained via subsequent mechanical cleaving and exfoliation of CrNbS single crystals synthesized as in ref. [26].
Figure 1. (a) Optical microscope image of a (200 nm)/ (20 nm) vdW heterostructure on Au (23 nm)/Ti (7 nm) electrodes, with inset showing the materials stack, and corresponding as a function of an in-plane in (b). The feature vanishes as is increased above . (c) versus for ranges specified in the legend. (d) Model showing the origin of due to the presence of regions with different for (bottom panel) assuming equal for (top panel). Red and blue curves refer to bare and , respectively.
We choose CrNbS as our magnetic flake because it is the closest equivalent to the helimagnet Ho, which previous studies on S/F thin film multilayers have shown to be efficient for spin-triplet generation [10, 11, 12]. Like in Ho, the helimagnetic spin texture of CrNbS can be unzipped by an in-plane magnetic field which, above a certain value depending on thickness [26, 27], makes CrNbS fully ferromagnetic. This property provides a tool to control whether any observed effects is due to long-ranged spin triplets because such triplets should be only generated in the magnetically-inhomogeneous (helimagnetic) state of CrNbS and be suppressed when CrNbS is driven into its magnetically-homogeneous (ferromagnetic) state.
CrNbS is an ionic compound, which makes it difficult to obtain flakes with thickness smaller than 50 nm [26, 27]. Nonetheless, this is not a limitation for our experiment, since we deliberately choose CrNbS flakes with thickness larger than 200 nm. Thick flakes of CrNbS are necessary because, if long-ranged spin-triplet pairs are generated at the CrNbS/NbS vdW interface, these pairs must have enough room to propagate into CrNbS for them to affect the of the proximitized NbS. Theory and experiments on
S/F thin film multilayers have in fact shown that, to maximize the effect of long-ranged spin triplets on , a F with thickness larger than its is needed [9, 28]. To increase the effect on , the S should also have thickness comparable to or smaller than its superconducting coherence length () [8, 9].
The reason why long-ranged spin triplets can reduce the of a S/F heterostructure with and can be understood by thinking of a S as a reservoir of Cooper pairs: once long-ranged spin-triplet pairs are generated, they can propagate deeply into the F (much deeper than ), which drains pairs out of the S and reduces . On the other hand, if only short-ranged spin-triplet pairs are generated, the proximity effect remains confined at the S/F interface within (typically a few nanometers [29]) and is higher.
To determine whether long-ranged spin triplets are generated in our devices, we study the evolution of their resistance versus temperature, , measured across , as a function of an in-plane (i.e., perpendicular to the -axis). As is increased, the helimagnetic texture of progressively unzips until reaches a saturation field (), at which becomes ferromagnetic [26, 27].
For the device in Figure 1(a), the curve measured in shows a peak-like feature, , at the onset of the superconducting transition. persists in the helimagnetic state of as is increased and it vanishes as approaches Tesla ( being the vacuum permeability). At , coincides with the normal-state resistance of the device () at K (Figure 1(b) and Figure 1(c)). These observations and the fact that is only measured in this device with a specific arrangement of contacts rule out magnetic impurities as explanation for . The data reported in Figure 1(c) also show that, as the polarity is reversed and is decreased below , reappears in the helimagnetic state of before vanishing again at . These results suggest that must be correlated to the magnetically-inhomogeneous state of .
To understand the origin, we note that, for the device in Figure 1(a), we inject the current with two electrodes ( and ) that are contacting only the bare , and we collect the voltage signal with two other electrodes ( and ) placed under the stack. These two regions (i.e., bare and stack) may have different , which should be lower for the S/F stack due to the proximity effect [29]. As done in ref. [30], where a similar is observed, in the Supplementary Material we show that can be reproduced considering a network of resistors equivalent to our sample, where each resistor corresponds to a sample region with different . Our analysis also confirms that the regions in the F/S stack have lower than those in the bare S.
For to vanish at , the of the F/S stack (), which is lower than the of the bare S () for , must become closer to when (Figure 1(d)). This behavior of is opposite to that expected for a F/S proximity with a homogeneous F or for stray fields, since both effects should get stronger and decrease as is driven ferromagnetic (see discussion below).
The positive shift of towards for (Figure 1(d)), which leads to the disappearance can be due to an unconventional proximity effect at the (F/S) vdW interface involving long-ranged spin triplets. This is because, when is in its helimagnetic state, long-ranged spin triplets can be generated and can propagate deeply into reducing compared to (Figure 1(d); bottom). As is driven ferromagnetic for , only short-ranged Cooper pairs can be generated, which remain confined close to the CrNbS/NbS interface making approach (Figure 1(d); top).
The F/S vdW device in Figure 1, however, makes it difficult to argue generation of long-ranged spin triplets across the CrNbS/NbS vdW interface due the presence of two contributions (from bare NbS and CrNbS/NbS stack) to the total .
To validate our interpretation of the data in Figure 1, we make another CrNbS/NbS vdW device (Figure 2(a)), where all electrodes are in contact with the CrNbS/NbS stack. As shown in Figure 2(b), the of this device does not exhibit any , independently on , which supports our claim that in Figure 1 originates from two regions with different .
Figure 2. (a) Optical microscope image of a CrNbS (350 nm)/NbS (25 nm) vdW heterostructure made on Au (33 nm)/Ti (7 nm) electrodes with inset showing the materials stack and corresponding in (b) as a function of an in-plane (values in the color bar) used to switch CrNbS from a helimagnetic to a ferromagnetic state.
To determine if long-ranged spin triplets affect the of the device in Figure 2(a), from each of the curves in Figure 2(b), we extract defined as the where reaches the 50% of its normal-state value at K ( K). Based on these values, we study how varies with , , for both increasing and decreasing (Figure 3(a)). We always apply in the normal state of our devices at K and, at every , we record whilst both cooling (from 7.0 K down to 3.0 K) and warming (from 3.0 K to 7.0 K) our samples, to extract the corresponding values. Unless differently specified, the curves shown are based on sample-cooling data.
Figure 3. (a) versus in-plane of a CrNbS/NbS device, , determined from curves in Figure 2(b) for upsweep (blue curve) and downsweep (red curve). The lower and upper sketches show the magnetic configuration of CrNbS for and , respectively. (b) Theoretical for a S/F with a helimagnet becoming ferromagnetic at (blue curve) and for S/F with homogeneous ferromagnet (red curve). The theoretical model used is shown in the lower panel, whilst the upper inset shows the decay of pairing amplitudes from the S/F interface in the F helimagnetic state: spin-singlets (), long-ranged triplets () and short-ranged triplets ().
for the device in Figure 2(a) is shown in Figure 3(a), for both upsweep (blue curve) and downsweep (red curve). As is increased, shows a first feature (at $\mu_0H followed by a decrease with different slope at and then by a positive shift at . During the downsweep, for , coincides with measured during the upsweep, but shows a difference of from the latter for .
The positive shift in at in Figure 3(a) is consistent with our explanation for the data in Figure 1 and the disappearance of at due to a positive shift.
Also for this device in Figure 3(a), if long-ranged spin triplets are generated, then in the CrNbS helimagnetic state () must be lower than in the CrNbS ferromagnetic state (), meaning that should exhibit a positive shift at – as we observe. Consistently with the disappearance of in Figure 1(b), the jump in at in Figure 3(a) cannot be due to a conventional F/S proximity involving short-ranged Cooper pairs or due to stray fields, since both effects should decrease rather than increase at . Vortices also cannot account for our results, as discussed in the Supplementary Material.
To rule out stray fields, like in previous studies on thin film multilayers [15, 31], we fabricate a vdW device where a 10-nm-thick insulator (I) of hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) is placed between CrNbS and NbS to suppress any superconducting proximity effects. The profile of this F/I/S vdW heterostructure (Supplementary Fig. S4), , shows some features at like those in Figure 3(a) for , which we associate to stray fields, but then follows a parabolic trend different from in Figure 3(a). This parabolic trend resembles that measured for bare NbS (S) (Supplementary Fig. S5). Also, has a negative rather than positive jump at , unlike in Figure 3(a), confirming that stray fields should get stronger and reduce at . Based on these results for the F/I/S device, we conclude that only the features in at in Figure 3(a) are due to stray fields, whilst all the other features including the positive jump at are due to a proximity effect involving long-ranged spin triplets.
Spectroscopic studies on Nb/Ho thin films have shown that spin-triplet generation is sensitive to the misalignment of the magnetic moments near the Nb/Ho interface, compared to the bulk Ho helix [12]. Like for Nb/Ho [12], interface magnetic moments misaligned to the CrNbS helix can have a non-null out-of-plane component and generate dipolar fields into NbS, which can account for the variation at low in our S/F vdW devices.
Previous transport experiments on epitaxial Ho/Nb thin film heterostructures [32] also show, consistently with our results, that decreases as Ho is driven from its helimagnetic to ferromagnetic state by an in-plane . However, when Ho becomes ferromagnetic, a negative shift in is observed which, as argued by the authors, is opposite to that expected for spin-triplet generation. By contrast, in our F/S vdW devices, we observe a positive shift in at .
In addition to the F/S vdW device in Figure 3(a), we have made another F/S vdW device with thinner NbS ( nm), to determine whether the shift in increases as gets reduced and closer to – which would further indicate that the shift is due to a superconducting proximity effect. As shown in Supplementary Fig. 5(a), this device has two regions, one made of a CrNbS/NbS stack and the other made of bare NbS (S) but of the same NbS flake used for the F/S stack. Each of these regions has its own set of electrodes to measure independently on . For this device, we find that has a parabolic trend consistent with -induced orbital depairing (Supplementary Fig. 5(b)). In contrast, deviates from for and shows a first drop at mT, which we ascribe to stray fields, followed by a slower decrease that we relate to spin-triplet generation (see above). For , where long-ranged spin triplets cannot be generated, follows , but with a constant (negative) offset due to . For mT , the proximity effect must therefore involve long-ranged spin triplets, since a F/S proximity with short-ranged triplets, which occurs for , gives a profile like (see theory model below). Also, the shift in from for this device is mK at , which is larger than that in Figure 3(a), consistently with the decrease in thickness from 20 nm to 10 nm.
To support our claims that long-ranged spin-triplets are generated at the vdW interface, we develop a model describing the proximity effect in our F/S system. Our theoretical description of the effect is based on the quasiclassical Green’s function method in the diffusive limit (Usadel approach). A sketch of our model is reported in the inset of Figure 3(b). We consider a S of length coupled to an infinitely-long helimagnet F with . The in-plane magnetization (in the - plane) of the helimagnet is modeled using the exchange field , where relates to the pitch of the helix () defined along the -direction perpendicular to the S/F interface. The quality of the interface in our model is related to the parameter (see Supplementary Material), which defines the interface transparency, and to depending on the mismatch between the normal-state conductivities of F () and S (). We assume that an in-plane is applied (along the -direction), which modulates the F’s magnetic textures and penetrates the S affecting , and we only consider -induced orbital depairing. Also, we simply assume that the transition from a helimagnetic to a ferromagnetic state in F occurs abruptly at like for the device in Figure 3(a) and we model it as a step function.
Our hypothesis is that an inhomogeneous (helical) magnetization in a F can generate long-range spin-triplet correlations at the S/F interface thus suppressing the superconducting gap in S. Effectively, this gap suppression is seen in our theoretical curves as a reduction of the superconducting critical temperature . We observe that the theoretical in Figure 3(b) (blue curve) calculated with our model for a helimagnet becoming ferromagnetic at T is in very good agreement with the experimental data in Figure 3(a). In the same Figure 3(b), we also report the theoretical profile (red curve) calculated for a S/F system with a homogeneous confirming a parabolic trend.
The inset of Figure 3(b) shows the anomalous Green’s functions (pairing amplitudes) as a function of the position inside F. We find that the helical ordering of the F induces a non-vanishing long-ranged pairing amplitude, which suppresses the S gap and reduces . The curves in Figure 3(b) are calculated using the following parameters: , , , , , nm ( being the superconducting gap). The bulk and upper critical field of S are assumed to be K ( being the Boltzmann constant) and T, respectively. The only fitting parameters are and , whereas all the other parameters are taken from the literature or estimated. The best fits for are obtained for , which suggests that the F/S vdW interface must have a good transparency, to observe our experimental results. This confirms that we can get a strong proximity effect in our devices despite the weak vdW nature of their F/S interfaces.
In conclusion, the dependence of in devices on the magnetic state of is consistent with the generation of long-ranged spin-triplet pairs across their vdW interface. A strong proximity effect involving long-ranged spin-triplet pairs can therefore not only occur across a S/F interface with strong covalent bonds, as already reported, but also across a weakly-bonded vdW interface. Our results pave the way for the combination of helimagnetic metals like or stacks of vdW ferromagnets with other vdW superconductors to study how spin-triplet pairs can be generated and manipulated in vdW systems for superconducting spintronics.
Acknowledgements
We thank David Mandrus for providing the single crystals during the first phase of the project and Uli Nowak and Moumita Kundu for discussion. A.S., H.S., A.D.B, W.B., and E.S. acknowledge funding from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) through the SPP 2244 priority programme (grant No. 443404566). O.M. acknowledges support from the Academia Sinica – Hebrew University Research program and the Harry de Jur Chair in Applied Science. We also acknowledge support from the EU’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under Grant Agreement No. 964398 (SUPERGATE) and from DFG via SFB 1432 (project No. 425217212).
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts to declare.
References
- [1]T. Kontos, M. Aprili, J. Lesueur and X. Grison, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 304 (2001).
- [2]V. V. Ryazanov, V. A. Obznov, A. Yu. Rusanov, A. V. Veretennikov, A. A. Golubov, and J. Aarts, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 2427 (2001).
- [3]Y. Blum, A. Tsukernik, M. Karpovski, and A. Palevski, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 187004 (2002).
- [4]F. S. Bergeret, A. F. Volkov, and K. B. Efetov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 4096 (2001).
- [5]T. S. Khaire, M. A. Khasawneh, W. P. Pratt, and N. O. Birge, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 137002 (2010).
- [6]C. Klose, T. S. Khaire, Y. Wang, W. P. Pratt, Jr., N. O. Birge, B. J. McMorran, T. P. Ginley, J. A. Borchers, B. J. Kirby, B. B. Maranville, and J. Unguris, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 127002 (2012).
- [7]P. V. Leksin, N. N. Garif’yanov, I. A. Garifullin, Ya. V. Fominov, J. Schumann, Y. Krupskaya, V. Kataev, O. G. Schmidt, and B. Büchner, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 057005 (2012).
- [8]X. L. Wang, A. Di Bernardo, N. Banerjee, A. Wells, F. S. Bergeret, M. G. Blamire, and J. W. A. Robinson, Phys. Rev. B 89, 140508(R) (2014).
- [9]A. Singh, S. Voltan, K. Lahabi, and J. Aarts, Phys. Rev. X 5, 021019 (2015).
- [10]J. W. A. Robinson, J. D. S. Witt and M. G. Blamire, Science 329, 59 (2010).
- [11]A. Di Bernardo, Z. Salman, X.L. Wang, M. Amado, M. Egilmez, M.G. Flokstra, A. Suter, S.L. Lee, J.H. Zhao, T. Prokscha, E. Morenzoni, M.G. Blamire, J. Linder, and J.W.A. Robinson, Phys. Rev. X 5, 041021 (2015).
- [12]A. Di Bernardo, S. Diesch, Y. Gu, J. Linder, E. Scheer, M.G. Blamire, and J.W.A. Robinson, Nat. Commun. 6, 8053 (2015).
- [13]R. S. Keizer, S. T. B. Goennenwein, T. M. Klapwijk, G. Miao, G. Xiao, and A. Gupta, Nature 439, 825 (2006).
- [14]S. Diesch, P. Machon, M. Wolz, C. Sürgers, D. Beckmann, W. Belzig, and E. Scheer, Nat. Commun. 9, 5248 (2018).
- [15]Y. Kalcheim, O. Millo, A. Di Bernardo, A. Pal, and J. W. A. Robinson, Phys. Rev. B 92, 060501(R) (2015).
- [16]J. Linder, and J. W. A. Robinson, Nat. Phys. 11, 307 (2015).
- [17]M. Gibertini, M. Koperski, A. F. Mpourgo, and K. S. Novoselov, Nat. Nanotechnol. 14, 408 (2019).
- [18]M. C. Wang, C. C. Huang, C. H. Cheung, C. Y. Chen, S. G. Tan, T. W. Huang, Y. Zhao, Y. Zhao, G. Wu, Y. P. Feng, H. C. Wu, and C. R. Chang, Ann. Phys. 532, 1900452 (2020).
- [19]X. Xi, Z. Wang, W. Zhao, J. H. Park, K. T. Law, H. Berger, L. Forró, J. Shan, and K. F. Mak, Nat. Phys. 12, 139 (2016).
- [20]E. Navarro-Moratalla, J. O. Island, S. Mañas-Valero, E. Pinilla-Cienfuegos, A. Castellanos-Gomez, J. Quereda, G. Rubio-Bollinger, L. Chirolli, J. A. Silva-Guillen, N. Agrait, G. A. Steele, F. Guinea, H. S. J. van der Zant, and E. Coronado, Nat. Commun. 7, 11043 (2016).
- [21]R. Yan, G. Khalsa, B. T. Schaefer, A. Jarjour, S. Rouvimov, K. C. Nowack, H. G. Xing, and D. Jena, Appl. Phys. Express 12, 023008 (2019).
- [22]K. Kang, H. Berger, K. Watanabe, T. Taniguchi, L. Forró, J. Shan, and K. F. Mak, Nano Lett. 22, 5510 (2022).
- [23]R. Cai, Y. Yao, P. Lv, Y. Ma, W. Xing, B. Li, Y. Ji, H. Zhou, C. Shen, S. Jia, X. C. Xie, I. Zutic, Q. F. Sun, and W. Han, Nat. Commun. 12, 6725 (2021).
- [24]G. Hu, C. C. Wang, S. Wang, Y. Zhang, Y. Feng, Z. Wang, Q. Niu, Z. Zhang, and B. Xiang, Nat. Commun. 14, 1779 (2023).
- [25]S. Fan, Q. A. Vu, M. D. Tran, S. Adhikari, and Y. H. Lee, 2D Mater. 7, 022005 (2020).
- [26]S. Tang, R. S. Fishman, S. Okamoto, J. Yi, Q. Zou, M. Fu, A. P. Li, D. Mandrus, and Z. Gai, Nano Lett. 18, 4023 (2018).
- [27]L. Wang, N. Chepiga, D. K. Ki, L. Li, F. Li, W. Zhu, Y. Kato, O. S. Ovchinnikova, F. Mila, I. Martin, D. Mandrus, and A. F. Mpourgo, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 257203 (2017).
- [28]Ya. V. Fominov, A. A. Golubov, T. Yu. Karminskaya, M. Yu. Kupriyanov, R. G. Deminov, and L. R. Tagirov, JETP Lett. 91, 308 (2010).
- [29]A. I. Buzdin, Rev. Mod. Phys. 77, 935 (2005).
- [30]R. Vaglio, C. Attanasio, L. Maritato, and A. Ruosi, Phys. Rev. B 47, 15302 (1993).
- [31]A. Stellhorn, A. Sarkar, E. Kentzinger, J. Barthel, A. Di Bernardo, S. Nandi, P. Zakalek, J. Schubert, and T. Brückel, New J. Phys. 22, 093001 (2020).
- [32]Y. Gu, J. W. A. Robinson, M. Bianchetti, N. A. Stelmashenko, D. Astill, F. M. Grosche, J. L. MacManus-Driscoll, and M. G. Blamire, APL Mater. 2, 046103 (2014).