betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Photon-induced production of the exotic charged charmonium-like state Zc(3900)Z_c(3900) off nuclear targets and its internal structure

Abstract

In this paper, we investigate the possibility to study the famous charged charmonium-like state Zc(3900)Z_c(3900) production off nuclear targets and its properties in inclusive photon-induced reactions near the kinematic threshold within the collision model based on the nuclear spectral function. The model accounts for its charged components Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} production in direct photon-nucleon interactions as well as three different popular scenarios for their internal structures: compact tetraquarks, molecules of the two open-charm mesons and mixtures of both of them. We calculate the absolute and relative excitation functions for production of Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} mesons on 12^{12}C and 184^{184}W target nuclei at initial photon energies of 9.0-17.5 GeV, the absolute momentum differential cross sections and their ratios for the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} production off these target nuclei at laboratory polar angles of 0∘^{\circ}-10∘^{\circ} and at photon energy of 14 GeV as well as the A-dependences of the ratios of the total cross sections for Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} production at photon energy of 14 GeV within the adopted scenarios for the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} internal structures. We demonstrate that the absolute and relative observables considered show a certain sensitivity to the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} internal structures which are by far the best known. Hence, they might be useful for the determination of these structures – the issue which has attracted much attention in the hadron physics community – from the comparison of them with the experimental data from the future high-precision experiments at the CEBAF facility.

Introduction

In the last two decades, high-energy experiments have reported a plethora of exotic narrow hadronic structures, which cannot be accommodated within the conventional quark model for quark-antiquark mesons and three-quarks baryons and which are composed of four or five quarks (and antiquarks) and are named as tetraquark and pentaquark states, respectively. Thus, many unconventional charmonium- and bottomonium-like states with hidden charm or beauty, charged or neutral, usually referred to as XYZXYZ states as well as the hidden-charm non-strange PcP_c and strange PcsP_{cs} pentaquark states, the doubly-charmed tetraquark Tcc+(3875)T_{cc}^{+}(3875) state, the fully charmed tetraquark X(6900)X(6900) state and so on have been observed in particular in the BB meson decays and in the e+e−e^{+}e^{-} collisions in various experiments, as summarized in recent reviews [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. The discovery of these exotic QCD states has motivated an extensive theoretical and experimental efforts to understand their properties [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21]. Notwithstanding, their nature is still largely unknown and further investigations are needed. In the literature, various interpretations of these states, including tightly-bound tetraquark and pentaquark states, loosely-bound meson-meson and baryon-meson molecular states, hadro-charmonium and charmonium-molecule mixtures or the product of rescattering effects, have been proposed (see, for example, Refs. [22, 23, 24, 25]).

Among these exotic hadrons, the first charged charmonium-like state Zc(3900)Z_c(3900) having charged components Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm}, which was observed in 2013 simultaneously by the BESIII [26] and Belle [27] Collaborations in the J/ψπ±J/\psi\pi^{\pm} invariant mass distributions from the sequential process e+e−→Y(4260)→π∓Zc(3900)±→π∓(π±J/ψ)→π+π−J/ψe^{+}e^{-}\to Y(4260)\to\pi^{\mp}Z_c(3900)^{\pm}\to\pi^{\mp}(\pi^{\pm}J/\psi)\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}J/\psi at center-of-mass energy of 4.26 GeV, has attracted much attention as the first undoubted tetraquark candidate in the charm sector. The Zc(3900)±→J/ψπ±Z_c(3900)^{\pm}\to J/\psi\pi^{\pm} decays indicate that the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} are definitely tetraquark states with quark contents ccuˉdˉcc\bar{u}\bar{d} and ccdˉuˉcc\bar{d}\bar{u}, respectively. Their existence were also confirmed in the analysis of e+e−e^{+}e^{-} annihilation data taken with the CLEO-c detector at s=4.17\sqrt{s}=4.17 GeV [28] and in the semi-inclusive decays of bb-flavored hadrons by the D0 Collaboration [29]. Evidence for the neutral partner Zc(3900)0Z_c(3900)^{0} of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} and its observation were reported in Refs. [28] and [30], correspondingly 1. The isospin-spin-parity quantum numbers of the Zc(3900)Z_c(3900) state were determined by the BESIII Collaboration to be I(JP)=1(1+)I(J^{P})=1(1^{+}) [31]. It is interesting to note that similar exotic charmonium-like Zc(3885)Z_c(3885) states, both charged [32, 33] and neutral [34], were observed in the (DDˉ∗)±,0(D\bar{D}^{*})^{\pm,0} mass distributions in the e+e−→π±(DDˉ∗)∓e^{+}e^{-}\to\pi^{\pm}(D\bar{D}^{*})^{\mp} and e+e−→π0(DDˉ∗)0e^{+}e^{-}\to\pi^{0}(D\bar{D}^{*})^{0} processes. Due to the close values of the masses and widths of the Zc(3900)Z_c(3900) and Zc(3885)Z_c(3885) states, it is natural to assume that they correspond to the same state [32]. Since the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} states are observed in the J/ψπ±J/\psi\pi^{\pm} mass distributions slightly above the open-charm DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^{*} mass threshold 2, they can be interpreted as SS-wave DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^{*} resonant or virtual molecular states from the DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^{*} interaction (see, for example, Refs. [41, 42] and those cited below). Also other possible theoretical explanations of the Zc(3900)Z_c(3900) states, including the compact tetraquark states [43, 44], hadro-charmonium states [45, 46, 47] 3, mixtures of the compact tetraquark states and molecular states [48, 49, 50], kinematic threshold cusp effects [51, 52] or kinematical triangle singularities [53, 54, 55] have been proposed in recent years (see also references herein below). But, despite a lot of theoretical and experimental efforts, the full understanding of the nature of the intriguing Zc(3900)Z_c(3900) states remains a challenging open problem and further studies are also needed here.

To confirm the existence of the exotic Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm states, to diagnose them and to set a strong constraints on their properties, it is of importance to investigate their photoproduction on nuclei at energies close to the threshold for their production off a free nucleon. This has the advantage compared to the heavy-ion [56] and pion–nucleus [57] collisions that the interpretation of data from such experiments is less ambiguous owing to a negligible strength of initial-state photon interaction and since the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm production proceeds through a few channels in a cleaner environment - in static cold nuclear matter whose density is sufficiently well known. The study of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm states photoproduction off a proton target has been carried out previously in Refs. [58, 59, 60]. Their exclusive and inclusive production cross sections from pion exchange have been predicted. The discovery potential for charmonium-like states Z(4430)±Z(4430)^\pm and Zc(4200)+Z_c(4200)^+ by their photoproduction on the proton was discussed in Refs. [61] and [62], respectively. The authors of Ref. [63] suggested to search for charged Z(4430)±Z(4430)^\pm by the nucleon–antinucleon scattering, while the production of neutral Z(4430)0Z(4430)^0 and Zc(4200)0Z_c(4200)^0 states by antiproton–proton annihilation was studied in Refs. [64] and [65], correspondingly. It is also worth mentioning that, based on the theoretical predictions obtained in Ref. [58], a search for the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm hadrons through their exclusive photoproduction on the nucleon has been performed by the COMPASS Collaboration [66]. The data cover the range from 7 GeV to 19 GeV in the center-of-mass energy WW of the photon–nucleon system. Unfortunately, no signal of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm was observed in the J/ψπ±J/\psi\pi^\pm mass spectrum. A possible explanation of this unexpected result is that the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm are rarely produced and the predicted in [58] total and differential cross sections of γp→Zc(3900)+n\gamma p \to Z_c(3900)^+n reaction are overestimated. It is obvious that the particle production off nuclei is enhanced compared to that on the proton. Therefore, searching for the charmonium-like states through their photoproduction on nuclei is an important topic since the photoproduction offers an ideal setup to study them. Such a search could be performed at the proposed CEBAF upgraded facility with a 22 GeV photon beam, in addition to that of these exotic states in exclusive reactions on the proton target, using the capabilities of the GlueX and CLAS12 detectors for reconstructing J/ψ→e+e−J/\psi\to e^+e^- and pions [67, 68].

To motivate it, in this work we present the detailed predictions of some observables for Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm production in photonuclear reactions at threshold energies obtained in the framework of the collision model based on the nuclear spectral function within three different scenarios for their internal structures. The predictions can be confronted to the experimental data from the future measurements at the upgraded up to 22 GeV CEBAF facility to discriminate between these scenarios. This would clearly be of great importance as a valuable test of the theoretical predictions in the field of exotic charmonium-like states.

Direct Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm photoproduction mechanism: photoproduction cross sections and their ratios

The main goal of this paper is to provide predictions for the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm photoproduction cross sections and their ratios on nuclear targets near the threshold within plausible different scenarios for the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm internal structures. By near-threshold, we mean the incident photon energy region Eγ≤17.5E_\gamma\leq17.5 GeV where the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm mesons can be observed in the γp\gamma p and γA\gamma A reactions at an energy-upgraded CEBAF facility [67, 68].4 The direct production of the charged components Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} on nuclear targets in the laboratory photon energy region of interest can occur in the following γp\gamma p and γn\gamma n elementary processes with zero and one pions in the final states [58, 59, 60] 5:

γ+p→Zc(3900)++n,(1)\gamma+ p \to Z_c(3900)^{+} + n, \tag*{(1)}
γ+p→Zc(3900)++π−+p,(2)\gamma+ p \to Z_c(3900)^{+} + \pi^{-} + p, \tag*{(2)}
γ+p→Zc(3900)++π0+n,(3)\gamma+ p \to Z_c(3900)^{+} + \pi^{0} + n, \tag*{(3)}
γ+n→Zc(3900)++π−+n(4)\gamma+ n \to Z_c(3900)^{+} + \pi^{-} + n \tag*{(4)}

and

γ+n→Zc(3900)−+p,(5)\gamma+ n \to Z_c(3900)^{-} + p, \tag*{(5)}
γ+n→Zc(3900)−+π++n,(6)\gamma+ n \to Z_c(3900)^{-} + \pi^{+} + n, \tag*{(6)}
γ+n→Zc(3900)−+π0+p,(7)\gamma+ n \to Z_c(3900)^{-} + \pi^{0} + p, \tag*{(7)}
γ+p→Zc(3900)−+π++p.(8)\gamma+ p \to Z_c(3900)^{-} + \pi^{+} + p. \tag*{(8)}

The Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} mesons, nucleons and pions, produced in these processes, are sufficiently energetic. Thus, for example, the kinematically allowed Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^{+} meson and final neutron laboratory momenta in the direct process (1), proceeding on the free target proton at rest, vary within the momentum ranges of 8.347–12.989 GeV/c and 1.011–5.653 GeV/c, respectively, at photon energy of Eγ=14E_{\gamma}=14 GeV. The kinematical characteristics of Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} mesons and final nucleons, produced in the reactions (2)–(8), are similar to those of final particles in the process (1). And outgoing in these reactions pions have an average laboratory momentum ∼1.0\sim1.0 GeV/c. Since the medium effects are expected to be reduced for high momenta, we will neglect the medium modifications of the final high-momentum Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} hadrons, π\pi mesons and nucleons in the case when the reactions (1)–(8) proceed on nucleons embedded in a nuclear target 6.

Then, neglecting the distortion of the incident photon 7 and describing the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} (in what follows denoted as Zc±Z_c^{\pm}) absorption by intranuclear nucleons by the absorption cross sections σZc±p\sigma_{Z_c^{\pm}p} and σZc±n\sigma_{Z_c^{\pm}n}, we represent the total cross sections for the production of Zc±Z_c^{\pm} mesons on nuclei from the direct photon-induced reactions (1)–(8) as follows [71]:

σγA→Zc+X(dir)(Eγ)=IV[A,ρp,σZc+p,σZc+n][⟨σγp→Zc+n(Eγ)⟩A+⟨σγp→Zc+π−p(Eγ)⟩A+⟨σγp→Zc+π0n(Eγ)⟩A]+IV[A,ρn,σZc+p,σZc+n]⟨σγn→Zc+π−n(Eγ)⟩A,(9)\begin{aligned} \sigma_{\gamma A\to Z_c^{+}X}^{(\mathrm{dir})}(E_{\gamma})={}&I_V[A,\rho_p,\sigma_{Z_c^{+}p},\sigma_{Z_c^{+}n}] \left[\left\langle\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^{+}n}(E_{\gamma})\right\rangle_A+\left\langle\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^{+}\pi^-p}(E_{\gamma})\right\rangle_A+\left\langle\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^{+}\pi^0n}(E_{\gamma})\right\rangle_A\right]\\ &+I_V[A,\rho_n,\sigma_{Z_c^{+}p},\sigma_{Z_c^{+}n}] \left\langle\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^{+}\pi^-n}(E_{\gamma})\right\rangle_A, \tag*{(9)} \end{aligned}
σγA→Zc−X(dir)(Eγ)=IV[A,ρp,σZc−p,σZc−n]⟨σγp→Zc−π+p(Eγ)⟩A+IV[A,ρn,σZc−p,σZc−n][⟨σγn→Zc−p(Eγ)⟩A+⟨σγn→Zc−π+n(Eγ)⟩A+⟨σγn→Zc−π0p(Eγ)⟩A];(10)\begin{aligned} \sigma_{\gamma A\to Z_c^{-}X}^{(\mathrm{dir})}(E_{\gamma})={}&I_V[A,\rho_p,\sigma_{Z_c^{-}p},\sigma_{Z_c^{-}n}] \left\langle\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^{-}\pi^+p}(E_{\gamma})\right\rangle_A\\ &+I_V[A,\rho_n,\sigma_{Z_c^{-}p},\sigma_{Z_c^{-}n}] \left[\left\langle\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^{-}p}(E_{\gamma})\right\rangle_A+\left\langle\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^{-}\pi^+n}(E_{\gamma})\right\rangle_A+\left\langle\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^{-}\pi^0p}(E_{\gamma})\right\rangle_A\right]; \tag*{(10)} \end{aligned}

Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^{+} (and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^{-}) meson and neutron free space masses, respectively) 0≤ϵ≤1.00 \le\epsilon\le1.0 GeV.

where

IV[A,ρp(n),σZcp,σZcn]=2π∫0Rr⊥dr⊥∫−R2−r⊥2R2−r⊥2dzρp(n)(r⊥2+z2)××exp⁡[−σZcp∫zR2−r⊥2ρp(r⊥2+x2)dx−σZcn∫zR2−r⊥2ρn(r⊥2+x2)dx].(11)\begin{aligned} I_V[A,\rho_p(n),\sigma_{Z_c p},\sigma_{Z_c n}] = 2\pi\int_0^R r_\perp dr_\perp\int_{-\sqrt{R^2-r_\perp^2}}^{\sqrt{R^2-r_\perp^2}} dz \rho_p(n)(\sqrt{r_\perp^2+z^2}) \times\\ &\times\exp\left[-\sigma_{Z_c p}\int_z^{\sqrt{R^2-r_\perp^2}}\rho_p(\sqrt{r_\perp^2+x^2})dx-\sigma_{Z_c n}\int_z^{\sqrt{R^2-r_\perp^2}}\rho_n(\sqrt{r_\perp^2+x^2})dx\right]. \tag*{(11)} \end{aligned}

Here, ρp(r)\rho_p(r) and ρn(r)\rho_n(r) (rr is the distance from the nucleus center) are normalized to the numbers of protons ZZ and neutrons NN the local proton and neutron densities of the target nucleus with mass number AA (A=Z+NA = Z + N), having mass MAM_A and radius RR. And ⟨σi→f(Eγ)⟩A\langle\sigma_{i\to f}(E_\gamma)\rangle_A are ”in-medium” total cross sections σi→f(s∗)\sigma_{i\to f}(\sqrt{s^*}) (i→f=γp→Zc+n,Zc+π−p,Zc+π0n,Zc−π+p;γn→Zc−p,Zc−π+n,Zc−π0p,Zc+π−ni \to f = \gamma p \to Z_c^+n, Z_c^+\pi^-p, Z_c^+\pi^0n, Z_c^-\pi^+p; \gamma n \to Z_c^-p, Z_c^-\pi^+n, Z_c^-\pi^0p, Z_c^+\pi^-n) for the production of Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm mesons in reactions (1)–(8) at the in-medium γp\gamma p center-of-mass energy s∗\sqrt{s^*} (8), averaged over target nucleon binding and Fermi motion. They are defined by Eq. (6) from Ref. [71], in which one needs to make the substitution: γp→X(3872)p→i→f\gamma p \to X(3872)p \to i \to f.

As in Ref. [71], we assume that the ”in-medium” cross sections σi→f(s∗)\sigma_{i\to f}(\sqrt{s^*}) for Zc±Z_c^\pm production in reactions (1)–(8) are equivalent to the vacuum cross sections σi→f(s)\sigma_{i\to f}(\sqrt{s}), in which the center-of-mass energy squared ss of the free space photon-proton system for given photon laboratory energy EγE_\gamma and momentum pγ\mathbf{p}_\gamma, presented by the formula

s=s(Eγ)=W2=(Eγ+mp)2−pγ2=mp2+2mpEγ,(12)s = s(E_\gamma) = W^2 = (E_\gamma+ m_p)^2 - \mathbf{p}_\gamma^2 = m_p^2 + 2m_pE_\gamma, \tag*{(12)}

is replaced by the in-medium expression

s∗=(Eγ+Et)2−(pγ+pt)2,(13)s^* = (E_\gamma+ E_t)^2 - (\mathbf{p}_\gamma+ \mathbf{p}_t)^2, \tag*{(13)}

Here, EtE_t and pt\mathbf{p}_t are the total energy and internal momentum of the struck target nucleons involved in the collision processes (1)–(8). The quantity EtE_t is determined by Eq. (8) in Ref. [71].

For the free total cross sections of the photon-induced reaction channels (1)–(8) no data are available presently at the considered photon energies Eγ≤17.5E_\gamma\le17.5 GeV relevant for the upgraded to the energy of 22 GeV CEBAF facility. Therefore, we have to rely on some theoretical predictions and estimates for them, existing in the literature at these energies. For the free total cross sections σγp→Zc+n(s)\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+n}(\sqrt{s}) and σγp→Zc+π−p(s)\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+\pi^-p}(\sqrt{s}) of the reactions (1) and (2) in the considered photon energy range we have used the following parametrizations of the results of calculations of these cross sections here within the charged pion exchange approach [59, 60]8:

σγp→Zc+n(s)=42.5(1−sths)0.378(sths)1.357 [nb],(14)\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+n}(\sqrt{s}) = 42.5\left(1-\frac{s_{\mathrm{th}}}{s}\right)^{0.378}\left(\frac{s_{\mathrm{th}}}{s}\right)^{1.357}\ [\mathrm{nb}], \tag*{(14)}
σγp→Zc+π−p(s)=343.0(1−s~ths)2.122(s~ths)3.808 [nb],(15)\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+\pi^-p}(\sqrt{s}) = 343.0\left(1-\frac{\tilde{s}_{\mathrm{th}}}{s}\right)^{2.122}\left(\frac{\tilde{s}_{\mathrm{th}}}{s}\right)^{3.808}\ [\mathrm{nb}], \tag*{(15)}

where

sth=Wth2=(mZc+mn)2,s~th=W~th2=(mZc+mπ−+mp)2.(16)s_{\mathrm{th}} = W_{\mathrm{th}}^2 = (m_{Z_c} + m_n)^2,\quad\tilde{s}_{\mathrm{th}} = \tilde{W}_{\mathrm{th}}^2 = (m_{Z_c} + m_{\pi^-} + m_p)^2. \tag*{(16)}

Here, mπ−m_{\pi^-} and mpm_p are the free space π−\pi^- meson and proton masses. According to the predictions of Ref. [60], one may conclude that the total cross sections of the reactions (2) and (3), (2) and (8) are linked by the relations:

σγp→Zc+π0n(s)≈σγp→Zc+π−p(s),σγp→Zc−π+p(s)≈3σγp→Zc+π−p(s).(17)\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+\pi^0 n}(\sqrt{s}) \approx\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+\pi^- p}(\sqrt{s}), \quad\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^-\pi^+ p}(\sqrt{s}) \approx3\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+\pi^- p}(\sqrt{s}). \tag*{(17)}

In line with the ”isospin considerations” of the processes (1)–(8), it is natural to assume that the following relations among the total cross sections of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm production channels (1) and (5), (2) and (6), (3) and (7), (4) and (8) exist:

σγn→Zc−p(s)≈σγp→Zc+n(s),σγn→Zc−π+n(s)≈σγp→Zc+π−p(s),\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^-p}(\sqrt{s}) \approx\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+n}(\sqrt{s}), \quad\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^-\pi^+n}(\sqrt{s}) \approx\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+\pi^-p}(\sqrt{s}),
σγn→Zc−π0p(s)≈σγp→Zc+π0n(s),σγn→Zc+π−n(s)≈σγp→Zc−π+p(s).(18)\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^-\pi^0p}(\sqrt{s}) \approx\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+\pi^0n}(\sqrt{s}), \quad\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^+\pi^-n}(\sqrt{s}) \approx\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^-\pi^+p}(\sqrt{s}). \tag*{(18)}

It is worth noting that for photon energies near the thresholds (W∼6.0W \sim6.0 GeV), the cross sections for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- production in γp\gamma p collisions are predicted to be of the order of 20–30 nanobarns [59, 60], which are well within reach of the upgraded up to 22 GeV CEBAF facility.

We will use the relations (14)–(18) in our subsequent calculations as a guideline for a reasonable estimation of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm yield in γA\gamma A reactions.

The local proton and neutron densities, adopted in the calculations of the quantities IV[A,ρp(n),σZcp,σZcn]I_V[A,\rho_{p(n)},\sigma_{Z_cp},\sigma_{Z_cn}] entering into Eqs. (9) and (10), for the target nuclei 612C{}^{12}_{6}\mathrm{C}, 1327Al{}^{27}_{13}\mathrm{Al}, 2040Ca{}^{40}_{20}\mathrm{Ca}, 2963Cu{}^{63}_{29}\mathrm{Cu}, 4193Nb{}^{93}_{41}\mathrm{Nb}, 50112Sn{}^{112}_{50}\mathrm{Sn}, 74184W{}^{184}_{74}\mathrm{W}, 82208Pb{}^{208}_{82}\mathrm{Pb} and 92238U{}^{238}_{92}\mathrm{U} considered in the present work are given in Ref. [71]. As before in Ref. [71], for medium-weight 4193Nb{}^{93}_{41}\mathrm{Nb}, 50112Sn{}^{112}_{50}\mathrm{Sn} and heavy 74184W{}^{184}_{74}\mathrm{W}, 82208Pb{}^{208}_{82}\mathrm{Pb}, 92238U{}^{238}_{92}\mathrm{U} target nuclei we use the neutron density ρn(r)\rho_n(r) in the ’skin’ form.

To estimate the rates of the Zc±Z_c^\pm photoproduction off nuclei in different scenarios for their intrinsic structures, we have to specify the effective input Zc±Z_c^\pm–nucleon absorption cross sections σZc±p\sigma_{Z_c^\pm p} and σZc±n\sigma_{Z_c^\pm n} in these scenarios. They determine the numbers (11) of the target nucleons participating in the direct processes (1)–(8). To this end in our exploratory study we consider three different popular scenarios for the Z±Z^\pm [72]: i) compact, ∼1\sim1 fm, diquark-antidiquark tetraquark bound states: relatively tightly bound pairs [cu][cu] and [cˉdˉ][\bar c\bar d] for the Zc+Z_c^+ and [cd][cd] and [cˉuˉ][\bar c\bar u] ones for the Zc−Z_c^-, which interact by the gluonic color force [43, 44, 56, 69, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81], ii) genuine resonant or virtual bound DDˉ∗+D∗DˉD\bar D^*+D^*\bar D molecular states - SS-wave hadronic molecules formed by pairs of charmed and anticharmed mesons [41, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101]10, and iii) hybrid states - a states in which the Zc±Z_c^\pm are considered as the mixtures of compact diquark-antidiquark and molecular components [48, 49, 50].

Since the mass of the observed charmonium-like structure Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm is very close to that of the famous X(3872)X(3872), it can be considered as the charged isovector partner of the X(3872)X(3872) state [43]. Therefore, interpreting the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm as a compact tetraquarks, it is natural to assume for the high-momentum Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm–proton (neutron) absorption cross sections σZc±p(n)4q\sigma^{4q}_{Z_c^\pm p(n)} in this picture for the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm the same value as that for the absorption cross section of the X(3872)X(3872) resonance with similar momenta considering it as a compact tetraquark as well, i.e., σZc±p(n)4q=13.3\sigma^{4q}_{Z_c^\pm p(n)}=13.3 mb [71].

Within the ”pure” hadronic molecular interpretation of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm, their wave functions take the following charge-conjugation forms [41, 81, 83, 85, 89]:

∣Zc(3900)+⟩mol=12(∣D+Dˉ∗0⟩+∣D∗+Dˉ0⟩),(19)\lvert Z_c(3900)^+\rangle_{\mathrm{mol}}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(\lvert D^+\bar D^{*0}\rangle+\lvert D^{*+}\bar D^0\rangle\right), \tag*{(19)}
∣Zc(3900)−⟩mol=12(∣D−Dˉ∗0⟩+∣D∗−Dˉ0⟩).(20)\lvert Z_c(3900)^-\rangle_{\mathrm{mol}}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(\lvert D^-\bar D^{*0}\rangle+\lvert D^{*-}\bar D^0\rangle\right). \tag*{(20)}

In lieu of an appropriate theory, we assume that the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm states dissociate while one of their constituent charmed mesons flying with an average laboratory momentum ∼5\sim5 GeV/c (see above) scatters (elastically or inelastically) with the intranuclear nucleon (proton or neutron) and the other charmed meson is a spectator (cf. [71, 104, 105])11. Then, assuming that the total cross sections of the free high-momentum Dˉ∗0N\bar{D}^{*0}N, D∗0ND^{*0}N and D∗+ND^{*+}N, D∗−ND^{*-}N interactions are the same as those for the Dˉ0N\bar{D}^{0}N, D0ND^{0}N and D+ND^{+}N, D−ND^{-}N ones [107, 108, 109, 110], we can evaluate the cross sections for Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm absorption in the molecular scenario, σZc±p(n)mol\sigma^{\mathrm{mol}}_{Z_c^\pm p(n)}, as [71, 107, 108, 109, 110]:

σZc+pmol≈σD+pel+σD+pin+σDˉ0pel+σDˉ0pin,(21)\sigma^{\mathrm{mol}}_{Z_c^+p} \approx\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{D^+p}+\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{D^+p}+\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{\bar{D}^0p}+\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{\bar{D}^0p}, \tag*{(21)}
σZc+nmol≈σD+nel+σD+nin+σDˉ0nel+σDˉ0nin+σDˉ0n→D−p+σD+n→D0p,(22)\sigma^{\mathrm{mol}}_{Z_c^+n} \approx\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{D^+n}+\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{D^+n}+\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{\bar{D}^0n}+\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{\bar{D}^0n}+\sigma_{\bar{D}^0n\to D^-p}+\sigma_{D^+n\to D^0p}, \tag*{(22)}
σZc−pmol≈σD−pel+σD−pin+σD0pel+σD0pin+σD−p→Dˉ0n+σD0p→D+n,(23)\sigma^{\mathrm{mol}}_{Z_c^-p} \approx\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{D^-p}+\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{D^-p}+\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{D^0p}+\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{D^0p}+\sigma_{D^-p\to\bar{D}^0n}+\sigma_{D^0p\to D^+n}, \tag*{(23)}
σZc−nmol≈σD0nel+σD0nin+σD−nel+σD−nin.(24)\sigma^{\mathrm{mol}}_{Z_c^-n} \approx\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{D^0n}+\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{D^0n}+\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{D^-n}+\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{D^-n}. \tag*{(24)}

Here, σD+p(n)el(in)\sigma^{\mathrm{el(in)}}_{D^+p(n)} and σD−p(n)el(in)\sigma^{\mathrm{el(in)}}_{D^-p(n)} as well as σDˉ0p(n)el(in)\sigma^{\mathrm{el(in)}}_{\bar{D}^0p(n)} and σD0p(n)el(in)\sigma^{\mathrm{el(in)}}_{D^0p(n)} are the elastic (inelastic) cross sections of the free D+p(D+n)D^+p(D^+n) and D−p(D−n)D^-p(D^-n) as well as Dˉ0p(Dˉ0n)\bar{D}^0p(\bar{D}^0n) and D0p(D0n)D^0p(D^0n) interactions, respectively. And, σDˉ0n→D−p\sigma_{\bar{D}^0n\to D^-p}, σD+n→D0p\sigma_{D^+n\to D^0p}, σD−p→Dˉ0n\sigma_{D^-p\to\bar{D}^0n} and σD0p→D+n\sigma_{D^0p\to D^+n} are the total cross sections of the free charge-exchange reactions Dˉ0n→D−p\bar{D}^0n \to D^-p, D+n→D0pD^+n \to D^0p, D−p→Dˉ0nD^-p \to\bar{D}^0n and D0p→D+nD^0p \to D^+n, correspondingly. In our calculations we adopt for them the following constants which are relevant to the momentum regime above of 1 GeV/c of interest: σD+p(n)el=σD−p(n)el=σD0p(n)el=σDˉ0p(n)el=10\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{D^+p(n)}=\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{D^-p(n)}=\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{D^0p(n)}=\sigma^{\mathrm{el}}_{\bar{D}^0p(n)}=10 mb, σD+p(n)in=σD0p(n)in=10\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{D^+p(n)}=\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{D^0p(n)}=10 mb, σD−p(n)in=σDˉ0p(n)in=0\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{D^-p(n)}=\sigma^{\mathrm{in}}_{\bar{D}^0p(n)}=0, σDˉ0n→D−p=σD+n→D0p=σD−p→Dˉ0n=σD0p→D+n=12\sigma_{\bar{D}^0n\to D^-p}=\sigma_{D^+n\to D^0p}=\sigma_{D^-p\to\bar{D}^0n}=\sigma_{D^0p\to D^+n}=12 mb [107, 108, 109]. Using these values, we obtain that σZc+pmol=30\sigma^{\mathrm{mol}}_{Z_c^+p}=30 mb, σZc+nmol=54\sigma^{\mathrm{mol}}_{Z_c^+n}=54 mb and σZc−pmol=54\sigma^{\mathrm{mol}}_{Z_c^-p}=54 mb, σZc−nmol=30\sigma^{\mathrm{mol}}_{Z_c^-n}=30 mb.

In the hybrid scenario, it is assumed that the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm wave functions are a linear superpositions of the compact four-quark (or 4q) and molecular components [48, 49, 50]:

∣Zc(3900)+⟩hyb=α∣ccˉudˉ⟩+β2(∣D+Dˉ∗0⟩+∣D∗+Dˉ0⟩),(25)\lvert Z_c(3900)^+\rangle_{\mathrm{hyb}}=\alpha\lvert c\bar{c}u\bar{d}\rangle+\frac{\beta}{\sqrt{2}}\left(\lvert D^+\bar{D}^{*0}\rangle+\lvert D^{*+}\bar{D}^0\rangle\right), \tag*{(25)}
∣Zc(3900)−⟩hyb=α∣ccˉuˉd⟩+β2(∣D− ⁣D∗0⟩+∣D∗−D0⟩).(26)\lvert Z_c(3900)^-\rangle_{\mathrm{hyb}}=\alpha\lvert c\bar{c}\bar{u}d\rangle+\frac{\beta}{\sqrt{2}}\left(\lvert D^-\!D^{*0}\rangle+\lvert D^{*-}D^0\rangle\right). \tag*{(26)}

Here, the amplitudes α\alpha and β\beta squared, α2\alpha^2 and β2\beta^2, represent the probabilities to find a relevant ”elementary” compact non-molecular and two-body molecular hadronic components in the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm resonances, respectively. They are normalized as

α2+β2=1(27)\alpha^2+\beta^2=1 \tag*{(27)}

and are named in the literature [48, 50, 111, 112, 113], correspondingly, as the ”elementariness” (or the ”elementarity” [112, 113]) ZZ and ”compositeness” XX.12 The limiting case of α2=0\alpha^{2}=0, β2=1\beta^{2}=1 corresponds to the pure molecular interpretation of the Zc(3900)±Z_{c}(3900)^{\pm} states, while the case of α2=1\alpha^{2}=1, β2=0\beta^{2}=0 refers to their pure compact four-quark treatment. Recently, in Ref. [48] the Zc(3900)Z_{c}(3900) state was studied as the J/ψπJ/\psi\pi and DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^{*} coupled-channel system and in particular the compositeness XˉA\bar{X}_{A} of the DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^{*} component in this state was calculated to be less than 0.5 (XˉA≈0.36\bar{X}_{A}\approx0.36), indicating that other hadronic components or components of short-distance nature compared to the DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^{*}-compact quark states could be also important in the formation of the Zc(3900)Z_{c}(3900). The value of XˉA\bar{X}_{A} of about 0.5 (XˉA≈0.48\bar{X}_{A}\approx0.48) for the Zc(3900)Z_{c}(3900) was obtained very recently in Ref. [50] in the unified analysis of the experimental data of the π+π−\pi^{+}\pi^{-} and J/ψπ±J/\psi\pi^{\pm} invariant mass spectra for e+e−→J/ψπ+π−e^{+}e^{-}\rightarrow J/\psi\pi^{+}\pi^{-} and the D0D∗−D^{0}D^{*-} mass spectrum for e+e−→D0D∗−π+e^{+}e^{-}\rightarrow D^{0}D^{*-}\pi^{+} at e+e−e^{+}e^{-} center-of-mass energies of 4.23 and 4.26 GeV, suggesting that the DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^{*} molecular and non-molecular components are of similar importance in the structure of the Zc(3900)Z_{c}(3900). In view of the above, following Refs. [49, 50], we will assume that the Zc(3900)±Z_{c}(3900)^{\pm} wave functions (25), (26) contain 50% of the genuine non-molecular 4q4q component and 50% of the molecular DDˉ∗+DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^{*}+D\bar{D}^{*} component (α2=β2=0.5\alpha^{2}=\beta^{2}=0.5). In the hybrid interpretation (25), (26) of the Zc(3900)±Z_{c}(3900)^{\pm}, we can represent the Zc(3900)±Z_{c}(3900)^{\pm}–proton (neutron) absorption cross sections σZc±p(n)hyb\sigma_{Z_{c}^{\pm}p(n)}^{\mathrm{hyb}} in the following incoherent probability-weighted sum [71]:13

σZc±p(n)hyb=α2σZc±p(n)4q+β2σZc±p(n)mol.(28)\sigma_{Z_{c}^{\pm}p(n)}^{\mathrm{hyb}}=\alpha^{2}\sigma_{Z_{c}^{\pm}p(n)}^{4q}+\beta^{2}\sigma_{Z_{c}^{\pm}p(n)}^{\mathrm{mol}}. \tag*{(28)}

According to the above, we set σZc±p(n)4q=13.3\sigma_{Z_{c}^{\pm}p(n)}^{4q}=13.3 mb and σZc+p(n)mol=30\sigma_{Z_{c^{+}}p(n)}^{\mathrm{mol}}=30 (54) mb, σZc−p(n)mol=54\sigma_{Z_{c^{-}}p(n)}^{\mathrm{mol}}=54 (30) mb. With these values, the σZc±p(n)hyb\sigma_{Z_{c}^{\pm}p(n)}^{\mathrm{hyb}} absorption cross sections (28) are σZc+p(n)hyb=21.65\sigma_{Z_{c^{+}p(n)}}^{\mathrm{hyb}}=21.65 (33.65) mb and σZc−p(n)hyb=33.65\sigma_{Z_{c^{-}p(n)}}^{\mathrm{hyb}}=33.65 (21.65) mb for the non-molecular and molecular probabilities of the Zc(3900)±Z_{c}(3900)^{\pm} 50% and 50%. Now, we summarize here the results obtained above for the Zc(3900)±Z_{c}(3900)^{\pm}–proton (neutron) absorption cross sections σZc±p(n)\sigma_{Z_{c^{\pm}p(n)}} in the adopted scenarios for the Zc(3900)±Z_{c}(3900)^{\pm}:

σZc+p={13.3 mbfor tetraquark (4q) state,21.65 mbfor hybrid state (50%,50%),30 mbfor DDˉ∗ molecule;(29)\sigma_{Z_{c^{+}p}}= \begin{cases} 13.3\ \mathrm{mb} & \text{for tetraquark }(4q)\text{ state},\\ 21.65\ \mathrm{mb} & \text{for hybrid state }(50\%,50\%),\\ 30\ \mathrm{mb} & \text{for }D\bar{D}^{*}\text{ molecule}; \end{cases} \tag*{(29)}
σZc+n={13.3 mbfor tetraquark (4q) state,33.65 mbfor hybrid state (50%,50%),54 mbfor DDˉ∗ molecule(30)\sigma_{Z_{c^{+}n}}= \begin{cases} 13.3\ \mathrm{mb} & \text{for tetraquark }(4q)\text{ state},\\ 33.65\ \mathrm{mb} & \text{for hybrid state }(50\%,50\%),\\ 54\ \mathrm{mb} & \text{for }D\bar{D}^{*}\text{ molecule} \end{cases} \tag*{(30)}

and

σZc−p=σZc+n,σZc−n=σZc+p.(31)\sigma_{Z_{c^{-}p}}=\sigma_{Z_{c^{+}n}},\qquad\sigma_{Z_{c^{-}n}}=\sigma_{Z_{c^{+}p}}. \tag*{(31)}

One can see that the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} as DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^{*} molecules have the largest absorption cross sections and, hence, they are expected to be more easily absorbed in this case than their other internal configurations in a nuclear medium. We will employ these values for the quantities σZc±p(n)\sigma_{Z_c^{\pm}p(n)} in our subsequent total and differential cross-section calculations. It is also worth noting that according to Eqs. (9)–(11), (29)–(31) and our assumptions about the elementary Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} production cross sections in γN\gamma N collisions for nuclei, like 612C{}^{12}_{6}\mathrm{C}, 2040Ca{}^{40}_{20}\mathrm{Ca}, with the same local proton ρp(r)\rho_p(r) and neutron ρn(r)\rho_n(r) densities the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^{+} and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^{-} total and differential (defined below) production cross sections are the same.

We consider now two additional integral observables that can be used to verify properties of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} tetraquark states. Both are cross-section ratios, which are sensitive to the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm}–nucleon absorption cross sections (and, hence, to their intrinsic structures) and which are more robust than cross sections themselves to systematic effects associated with luminosity and detector efficiency. The first observable - the so-called Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} transparency ratio - is the ratio of the nuclear Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} photoproduction cross sections (9), (10) divided by AA times the same quantities on a free nucleon (cf. Ref. [71] and references herein):

SA=σγA→Zc±X(dir)(Eγ)A σγN→Zc±N′(s(Eγ))(32)S_A=\frac{\sigma_{\gamma A\to Z_c^\pm X}^{(\mathrm{dir})}(E_\gamma)}{A\,\sigma_{\gamma N\to Z_c^\pm N'}\left(\sqrt{s(E_\gamma)}\right)} \tag*{(32)}

where

σγN→Zc+N′(s(Eγ))=σγp→Zc+n(s(Eγ))(33)\sigma_{\gamma N\to Z_c^+N'}\left(\sqrt{s(E_\gamma)}\right)=\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+n}\left(\sqrt{s(E_\gamma)}\right) \tag*{(33)}

and

σγN→Zc−N′(s(Eγ))=σγn→Zc−p(s(Eγ)).(34)\sigma_{\gamma N\to Z_c^-N'}\left(\sqrt{s(E_\gamma)}\right)=\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^-p}\left(\sqrt{s(E_\gamma)}\right). \tag*{(34)}

The second observable is the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm transparency ratio SAS_A normalized to a light nucleus like 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} [71, 115]:

TA=SASC=12 σγA→Zc±X(dir)(Eγ)A σγC→Zc±X(dir)(Eγ).(35)T_A=\frac{S_A}{S_C}=\frac{12\,\sigma_{\gamma A\to Z_c^\pm X}^{(\mathrm{dir})}(E_\gamma)}{A\,\sigma_{\gamma C\to Z_c^\pm X}^{(\mathrm{dir})}(E_\gamma)}. \tag*{(35)}

Evidently that the definition of the quantities SAS_A and TAT_A via Eqs. (32) and (35) implies that they should be considered only at above threshold photon energies. But since the right-hand side of Eq. (35) is defined both above and below the threshold, we will employ it in calculating the transparency ratio TAT_A also at subthreshold photon energies (cf. Figure 9 given below). The formulas (32)–(35) will be used in our calculations of the integral observables SAS_A and TAT_A.

Image not extracted

Figure 9. (Color online.) Transparency ratios TAT_A for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ (left panel) and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- (right panel) mesons, respectively, from the direct processes (1)–(4) and (5)–(8) proceeding on an off-shell target nucleons as functions of the incident photon energy for combination 184W/12C{}^{184}\mathrm{W}/{}^{12}\mathrm{C} in the considered theoretical pictures describing their intrinsic structures. The arrows indicate the threshold energy for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- photoproduction on a free nucleons in reactions (1) and (5), correspondingly.

The information on the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm inner structure can also be extracted from the comparison of the measured and calculated momentum distributions of Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm mesons from nuclei in the photon energy range of interest. Therefore, we consider now the momentum-dependent inclusive differential cross sections for their production with momentum pZc±p_{Z_c^\pm} on nuclei from the photon-induced elementary production channels (1)–(8). Accounting for the fact that the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm mesons move in the nucleus essentially forward in the lab system 14, we will calculate the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm momentum distributions from considered target nuclei for the laboratory solid angles ΔΩZc±=0∘≤θZc±≤10∘\Delta\Omega_{Z_c^\pm}=0^\circ\leq\theta_{Z_c^\pm}\leq10^\circ, and 0≤φZc±≤2π0\leq\varphi_{Z_c^\pm}\leq2\pi. Then, according to Eqs. (9)–(11) and Ref. [71], we represent these distributions as follows:

dσγA→Zc+X(dir)(pγ,pZc+)dpZc+=2πIV[A,ρp,σZc+p,σZc+n]∫cos⁡10∘1dcos⁡θZc+×[⟨dσγp→Zc+n(pγ,pZc+,θZc+)dpZc+dΩZc+⟩A+⟨dσγp→Zc+π−p(pγ,pZc+,θZc+)dpZc+dΩZc+⟩A+⟨dσγp→Zc+π0n(pγ,pZc+,θZc+)dpZc+dΩZc+⟩A]+2πIV[A,ρn,σZc+p,σZc+n]∫cos⁡10∘1dcos⁡θZc+⟨dσγn→Zc+π−n(pγ,pZc+,θZc+)dpZc+dΩZc+⟩A,(36)\begin{aligned} \frac{d\sigma_{\gamma A\to Z_c^+X}^{(\mathrm{dir})}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^+})}{dp_{Z_c^+}} ={}&2\pi I_V[A,\rho_p,\sigma_{Z_c^+p},\sigma_{Z_c^+n}] \int_{\cos10^\circ}^{1}d\cos\theta_{Z_c^+}\\ &\times\left[\left\langle\frac{d\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+n}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^+},\theta_{Z_c^+})}{dp_{Z_c^+}d\Omega_{Z_c^+}}\right\rangle_A +\left\langle\frac{d\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+\pi^-p}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^+},\theta_{Z_c^+})}{dp_{Z_c^+}d\Omega_{Z_c^+}}\right\rangle_A +\left\langle\frac{d\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^+\pi^0n}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^+},\theta_{Z_c^+})}{dp_{Z_c^+}d\Omega_{Z_c^+}}\right\rangle_A\right]\\ &+2\pi I_V[A,\rho_n,\sigma_{Z_c^+p},\sigma_{Z_c^+n}] \int_{\cos10^\circ}^{1}d\cos\theta_{Z_c^+} \left\langle\frac{d\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^+\pi^-n}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^+},\theta_{Z_c^+})}{dp_{Z_c^+}d\Omega_{Z_c^+}}\right\rangle_A, \tag*{(36)} \end{aligned}
dσγA→Zc−X(dir)(pγ,pZc−)dpZc−=2πIV[A,ρp,σZc−p,σZc−n]∫cos⁡10∘1dcos⁡θZc−⟨dσγp→Zc−π+p(pγ,pZc−,θZc−)dpZc−dΩZc−⟩A+2πIV[A,ρn,σZc−p,σZc−n]∫cos⁡10∘1dcos⁡θZc−×[⟨dσγn→Zc−p(pγ,pZc−,θZc−)dpZc−dΩZc−⟩A+⟨dσγn→Zc−π+n(pγ,pZc−,θZc−)dpZc−dΩZc−⟩A+⟨dσγn→Zc−π0p(pγ,pZc−,θZc−)dpZc−dΩZc−⟩A].(37)\begin{aligned} \frac{d\sigma_{\gamma A\to Z_c^-X}^{(\mathrm{dir})}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^-})}{dp_{Z_c^-}} ={}&2\pi I_V[A,\rho_p,\sigma_{Z_c^-p},\sigma_{Z_c^-n}] \int_{\cos10^\circ}^{1}d\cos\theta_{Z_c^-} \left\langle\frac{d\sigma_{\gamma p\to Z_c^-\pi^+p}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^-},\theta_{Z_c^-})}{dp_{Z_c^-}d\Omega_{Z_c^-}}\right\rangle_A\\ &+2\pi I_V[A,\rho_n,\sigma_{Z_c^-p},\sigma_{Z_c^-n}] \int_{\cos10^\circ}^{1}d\cos\theta_{Z_c^-}\\ &\times\left[\left\langle\frac{d\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^-p}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^-},\theta_{Z_c^-})}{dp_{Z_c^-}d\Omega_{Z_c^-}}\right\rangle_A +\left\langle\frac{d\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^-\pi^+n}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^-},\theta_{Z_c^-})}{dp_{Z_c^-}d\Omega_{Z_c^-}}\right\rangle_A +\left\langle\frac{d\sigma_{\gamma n\to Z_c^-\pi^0p}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^-},\theta_{Z_c^-})}{dp_{Z_c^-}d\Omega_{Z_c^-}}\right\rangle_A\right]. \tag*{(37)} \end{aligned}

Here, ⟨dσi→f(pγ,pZc±,θZc±)dpZc±dΩZc±⟩A\left\langle\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{i\to f}(p_\gamma,p_{Z_c^\pm},\theta_{Z_c^\pm})}{\mathrm{d}p_{Z_c^\pm}\mathrm{d}\Omega_{Z_c^\pm}}\right\rangle_A are the off-shell differential cross sections for production of Zc±Z_c^\pm mesons with momenta pZc±p_{Z_c^\pm} in the processes (1)–(8) (i→fi\to f), averaged over the Fermi motion and binding energy of the intranuclear nucleons. Such differential cross sections for production of Zc+Z_c^+ and Zc−Z_c^- mesons in the processes (1) and (5) with two-body final states can be expressed by Eqs. (28), (31)–(39) from Ref. [116], in which one needs to make the substitution: (γp→Υ(1S)p)→(γp→Zc+n)(\gamma p\to\Upsilon(1S)p)\to(\gamma p\to Z_c^+n), Υ(1S)→Zc+\Upsilon(1S)\to Z_c^+ and (γp→Υ(1S)p)→(γn→Zc−p)(\gamma p\to\Upsilon(1S)p)\to(\gamma n\to Z_c^-p), Υ(1S)→Zc−\Upsilon(1S)\to Z_c^-. In order to calculate the c.m. Zc±Z_c^\pm angular distributions in reactions (1) and (5) (cf. Eq. (34) from Ref. [116]) one needs to know their exponential tt-slope parameters bZc±b_{Z_c^\pm} in the threshold energy region. In view of the above, we adopt for both these parameters the value of 2.0 GeV−2^{-2} obtained in Ref. [71] for the X(3872)X(3872) slope parameter bX(3872)b_{X(3872)} for incident photon energy of 13 GeV. The analogous differential cross sections of the processes (2)–(4) and (6)–(8) with three-body final states, entering into Eqs. (36), (37), can be described by the expressions (6), (28)–(31) from Ref. [117] in which the respective changes have to be made. For the sake of conciseness, we do not give these expressions here as well.

Predictions

The excitation functions for production of Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm mesons on 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} and 184W{}^{184}\mathrm{W} target nuclei, calculated in line with Eqs. (9), (10) for three adopted pictures for their intrinsic structures (compact tetraquarks, DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^* hadronic molecules and the superpositions of both of them in which there are 50% of the 4q4q components and 50% molecular components) as well as for an off-shell intranuclear target nucleons and for a free ones being at rest, are shown in Figure 1 and Figure 2, respectively. One can see that the difference between calculations with and without accounting for the medium effects (the target nucleon binding and Fermi motion) is sufficiently small at well above threshold photon beam energies ∼13\sim13–17 GeV, while at lower beam energies their impact on the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm yields is substantial. It is also nicely seen yet that for both target nuclei considered and for all photon energies studied these yields show a definite sensitivity to the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm inner configurations. Thus, we observe for 184W{}^{184}\mathrm{W} a well distinguishable and experimentally measurable changes between the considered scenarios for these configurations: between pure molecular DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^* states and hybrid states with the non-molecular and molecular probabilities of 50% and 50%, between hybrid states with the non-molecular and molecular probabilities of 50% and 50% and pure compact tetraquarks states. They are ∼40\sim40 and 70% for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and ∼35\sim35 and 55% for the Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^-. For the light target nucleus 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C}, the sensitivity of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm production cross sections to their internal structures becomes lower and, respectively, the same changes as above become somewhat smaller. In line with the aforementioned, they are ∼21\sim21 and 27%27\% both for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and for the Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- and will also be experimentally accessible as well in the future high-precision experiments at the CEBAF facility. More clear information about the sensitivity of the cross sections to the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm intrinsic configurations is contained in Figure 3 and Figure 4, where the initial photon energy dependences of the ratios RZc±R_{Z_c^\pm} between the cross sections presented, respectively, in Figure 1 and Figure 2 are given. In the case of the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ production, the ratios RZc+R_{Z_c^+} being considered take the values of RZc+(4q/hyb)=1.266R_{Z_c^+}(4q/\mathrm{hyb}) = 1.266 and 1.7061.706, RZc+(hyb/mol)=1.213R_{Z_c^+}(\mathrm{hyb}/\mathrm{mol}) = 1.213 and 1.4091.409 for carbon and tungsten target nuclei, respectively. The analogous ratios RZc−R_{Z_c^-} for the Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- are 1.2661.266 and 1.5541.554, 1.2131.213 and 1.3451.345. At the same time, the absolute values of the total cross sections have at above threshold photon energies of ∼13\sim13–1717 GeV a well measurable strengths ∼50\sim50–200200 nb and 200200–15001500 nb for Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and ∼50\sim50–200200 nb and 300300–20002000 nb for Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- for carbon and tungsten target nuclei, correspondingly. To stimulate such measurements at the JLab, it is desirable to estimate the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm production rates (the event numbers) in the γ12C(184W)\gamma^{12}\mathrm{C}(^{184}\mathrm{W}) reactions. For this aim, we translate the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm photoproduction total cross sections, reported above, into the expected event numbers for the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm from the reactions γ12C(184W)→Zc(3900)±X\gamma^{12}\mathrm{C}(^{184}\mathrm{W}) \to Z_c(3900)^\pm X, Zc(3900)±→J/ψπ±Z_c(3900)^\pm\to J/\psi\pi^\pm, J/ψ→l+l− 15)J/\psi\to l^+l^- \,^{15)}. To estimate the total numbers of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm events in a one-year run at the CEBAF facility, one needs to multiply the given above Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm photoproduction total cross sections on the carbon and tungsten target nuclei by the integrated luminosity of ∼500 pb−1\sim500\ \mathrm{pb}^{-1} [67] as well as by the experimental detection efficiency

Image not extracted

Figure 1. (Color online.) Excitation functions for the production of Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^{+} and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^{-} mesons off 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C}, respectively, from the direct processes (1)–(4) and (5)–(8) proceeding on an off-shell target nucleons and on a free ones being at rest. The curves are calculations in the scenarios, in which the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} are treated as a purely compact four quark (4q4q) states, as a purely molecular states, or as a hybrid states: mixtures of the non-molecular (compact) and molecular (non-compact) components, in which there are 50% of the 4q4q components and 50% molecular components. The arrow indicates the threshold energy for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^{+} and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^{-} photoproduction on a free nucleons in reactions (1) and (5), correspondingly.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. (Color online.) Excitation functions for the production of Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ (left panel) and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- (right panel) mesons off 184W{}^{184}\mathrm{W}, respectively, from the direct processes (1)–(4) and (5)–(8) proceeding on an off-shell target nucleons and on a free ones being at rest. The curves are calculations in the scenarios, in which the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm are treated as a purely compact four quark (4q) states, as a purely molecular states, or as a hybrid states: mixtures of the non-molecular (compact) and molecular (non-compact) components, in which there are 50% of the 4q components and 50% molecular components. The arrows indicate the threshold energy for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- photoproduction on a free nucleons in reactions (1) and (5), correspondingly.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. (Color online.) Ratios between the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and between the Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- production cross sections on 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C}, shown in Figure 1 and calculated in the compact tetraquark and hybrid scenarios, in the hybrid and molecular scenarios of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm for an off-shell target nucleons, as functions of photon energy. The arrow indicates the threshold energy for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- photoproduction on a free nucleons in reactions (1) and (5), respectively.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. (Color online.) Ratios between the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ (left panel) and between the Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- (right panel) production cross sections on 184W^{184}\mathrm{W}, shown in Figure 2 and calculated in the compact tetraquark and hybrid scenarios, in the hybrid and molecular scenarios of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm for an off-shell target nucleons, as functions of photon energy. The arrows indicate the threshold energy for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- photoproduction on a free nucleons in reactions (1) and (5), respectively.

and by the appropriate branching ratios Br⁡[Zc(3900)±→J/ψπ±]≈50%\operatorname{Br}[Z_c(3900)^\pm\to J/\psi\pi^\pm] \approx50\%16 and Br⁡[J/ψ→l+l−]≈12%\operatorname{Br}[J/\psi\to l^+l^-] \approx12\%. Using a conservative detection efficiency of 10% for both charged states, we estimate 1.5⋅1051.5\cdot10^5–6.0⋅1056.0\cdot10^5 and 6.0⋅1056.0\cdot10^5–4.5⋅1064.5\cdot10^6 event numbers per year for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ signals in the cases of the 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} and 184W^{184}\mathrm{W} target nuclei, respectively. The analogous event numbers for the Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- signals are 1.5⋅1051.5\cdot10^5–6.0⋅1056.0\cdot10^5 and 9.0⋅1059.0\cdot10^5–6.0⋅1066.0\cdot10^6. We see that a sufficiently large number of Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm events17 could be observed at above threshold photon energies of 13–17 GeV for both nuclear targets considered. Therefore, the excitation function measurements for the exotic Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm hadrons both on light and heavy target nuclei at upgraded electron accelerator CEBAF-22 will provide a good platform to deepen our understanding of their internal structures18.

The absolute momentum distributions of the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- mesons from direct processes (1)–(8) in the γ12C\gamma{}^{12}\mathrm{C} and γ184W\gamma{}^{184}\mathrm{W} reactions, calculated on the basis of Eqs. (36) and (37) for three adopted scenarios for their inner configurations for laboratory polar angles of 0∘0^\circ–10∘10^\circ and for initial photon energy of 14 GeV, are shown, respectively, in Figure 5 and Figure 6. The absolute values of the momentum distributions of the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ mesons have a well measurable strengths ∼10\sim10–50 nb/(GeV/c) and 50–500 nb/(GeV/c) in the central momentum region of 9–13 GeV/c in the cases of the 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} and 184W{}^{184}\mathrm{W} target nuclei, respectively. The analogous values for the Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- hadrons in this momentum region are about of 10–50 nb/(GeV/c) and 50–700 nb/(GeV/c). The differential cross sections considered show a rather sizeable variations, especially for the heavy target nucleus 184W{}^{184}\mathrm{W}19, when going from the hadronic molecular to compact tetraquark treatments of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm states. This behavior of the differential cross sections can also be used to decipher the nature of the exotic charged charmonium-like Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm states from comparison the present model calculations with data expected from experiments at the upgraded up to 22 GeV CEBAF facility.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. (Color online.) Momentum differential cross sections for the production of Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- mesons, respectively, from the direct reactions (1)–(4) and (5)–(8) proceeding on an off-shell target nucleons in the laboratory polar angular range of 0∘0^\circ–10∘10^\circ in the interaction of photons with energy of Eγ=14E_\gamma=14 GeV with 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} target nucleus in the considered theoretical pictures describing their intrinsic structures.

Image not extracted

Figure 6. (Color online.) Momentum differential cross sections for the production of Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ (left panel) and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- (right panel) mesons, respectively, from the direct reactions (1)–(4) and (5)–(8) proceeding on an off-shell target nucleons in the laboratory polar angular range of 0∘0^\circ–10∘10^\circ in the interaction of photons with energy of Eγ=14E_\gamma= 14 GeV with 184W{}^{184}\mathrm{W} target nucleus in the considered theoretical pictures describing their intrinsic structures.

Figs. 7 and 8 show the A-dependences of the transparency ratios SAS_A and TAT_A of Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm production from the direct processes (1)–(8) in photon-induced reactions on nuclei 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C}, 27Al{}^{27}\mathrm{Al}, 40Ca{}^{40}\mathrm{Ca}, 63Cu{}^{63}\mathrm{Cu}, 93Nb{}^{93}\mathrm{Nb}, 112Sn{}^{112}\mathrm{Sn}, 184W{}^{184}\mathrm{W}, 208Pb{}^{208}\mathrm{Pb}, and 238U{}^{238}\mathrm{U}. They have been calculated for the photon energy of 14 GeV in line with Eqs. (32) and (35), respectively, and for three adopted interpretations of the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm. We see that the transparency ratios SAS_A and TAT_A show strong variations as ”functions” of these interpretations and of the mass number. They drop strongly with increasing nuclear mass number AA and the transparency ratios SAS_A and TAT_A reach values of the order of 0.1 and 0.4, correspondingly, for heavy nuclei like 208Pb{}^{208}\mathrm{Pb} and 238U{}^{238}\mathrm{U} in the DDˉ∗D\bar{D}^{*} hadronic molecular scenario – a large deviation from unity which should be easily seen in a future dedicated experiment. The sensitivity of the transparency ratios SAS_A and TAT_A to the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} intrinsic structures is nicely seen in Figure 7 and Figure 8. Thus, there are a sizeable and measurable changes ∼23,45%\sim23, 45\% in the ratio SAS_A both for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^{+} and for the Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^{-} between calculations performed assuming for Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} pure molecular and hybrid scenarios, hybrid and tetraquark pictures for relatively ”light” nuclei (27Al,40Ca{ }^{27}\mathrm{Al},{}^{40}\mathrm{Ca}). For the medium-mass (93Nb,112Sn{ }^{93}\mathrm{Nb},{}^{112}\mathrm{Sn}) and heavy (184W,238U{ }^{184}\mathrm{W},{}^{238}\mathrm{U}) target nuclei these changes are in general even larger. They are about 50, 45% and 45, 65%, respectively. For the quantity TAT_A the analogous changes are smaller but yet are experimentally distinguishable in the range of medium and large AA. They are about 5, 15%, 25, 15% and 18, 30%, correspondingly, in the cases of ”light”, medium-mass and heavy target nuclei mentioned above. Therefore, one can conclude that the observation of the AA-dependences of the transparency ratios SAS_A and TAT_A, at least, for medium and large mass numbers AA in the future experiments at JLab upgraded to 22 GeV would allow to discriminate between compact tetraquarks, hybrid and molecular interpretations of exotic QCD Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} states and thus to elucidate their nature.

Image not extracted

Figure 7. (Color online.) Transparency ratios SAS_A for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^+ (left panel) and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^- (right panel) mesons, respectively, from the direct processes (1)–(4) and (5)–(8) proceeding on an off-shell target nucleons at incident photon energy of 14 GeV in the laboratory system as functions of the nuclear mass number AA in the considered theoretical pictures describing their intrinsic structures. The lines are to guide the eyes.

Image not extracted

Figure 8. (Color online.) The same as in Figure 7, but for the transparency ratios TAT_A.

Additional sources of information about this nature are shown in Figure 9 and Figure 10 the photon energy and meson momentum dependences of the transparency ratio TAT_A for Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} mesons for the 184W/12C{}^{184}\mathrm{W}/{}^{12}\mathrm{C} combination calculated in line with Eq. (35), using the results presented in Figure 1, Figure 2 and Figure 5, Figure 6, respectively 20. One can see that the sensitivity of both dependences to different interpretations of Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm mesons is similar to that available in Figure 8 for heavy nuclei. Therefore, they can also be used for discriminating between possible scenarios for their internal structures.

Image not extracted

Figure 10. (Color online.) Transparency ratios TAT_A for the Zc(3900)+Z_c(3900)^{+} (left panel) and Zc(3900)−Z_c(3900)^{-} (right panel) mesons, respectively, from the direct processes (1)–(4) and (5)–(8) proceeding on an off-shell target nucleons as functions of their laboratory momenta for incident photon energy of 14 GeV for combination 184W/12C{}^{184}\mathrm{W}/{}^{12}\mathrm{C}, calculated in the laboratory polar angular range of 0∘0^\circ–10∘10^\circ in the considered theoretical pictures describing their intrinsic structures.

In the end, we evaluate the theoretical uncertainties of our absolute and relative calculations, reported above, associated mainly with the experimentally unknown total cross section for γp→Zc+n\gamma p \to Z_c^+n reaction giving the main contribution to the Zc+Z_c^+ yields from nuclei at near-threshold photon energies. For this aim, we adopted for this cross section also that corresponding to the total cross section of the γp→J/ψπ+n\gamma p \to J/\psi\pi^+n process presented in Fig. 8 of Ref. [58] for the realistic partial decay width Γ[Zc+→J/ψπ+]=29\Gamma[Z_c^+ \to J/\psi\pi^+] = 29 MeV and corrected for the respective branching ratio Br[Zc+→J/ψπ+]=63%Br[Z_c^+ \to J/\psi\pi^+] = 63\%. By comparing this cross section with that from Refs. [59, 60] (Eq. (14)), we find that their behaviors are quantitatively similar to each other at c.m. energies Wth≤W≤5.0W_{\mathrm{th}} \le W \le5.0 GeV, while for energies 5.0<W≤5.85.0 < W \le5.8 GeV the former cross section is larger than the latter one by a factor about 1.5–2.7. The replacement of the elementary cross section (14) by that from Ref. [58] leads, as we found, to an enhancement of the absolute Zc+Z_c^+ production cross sections on the considered target nuclei by factor of about 1.3–1.5 at photon laboratory energies 13–17 GeV and to a reduction of the transparency ratios SAS_A and TAT_A by only the small fractions of about 10–15% and 1–3%, respectively. In view of the above-mentioned, this means that we can definitely use the parametrization (14) for the total cross section of the γp→Zc+n\gamma p \to Z_c^+n reaction to provide certain guidance for the measurements of the absolute yields of Zc+Z_c^+ mesons from nuclei in future photoproduction experiments and to impose some (preliminary) constraints on their internal structure. To put a strong constraints on this structure using the Zc+Z_c^+ absolute yields one needs to know precisely the proton-target Zc+Z_c^+ production cross sections. On the other hand, since the calculated differences between the considered scenarios for the Zc+Z_c^+ inner configuration for the quantities SAS_A and TAT_A, in line with the aforementioned, are substantially bigger than the above fractions, the use of the obtained in the present work predictions for them for discriminating between these scenarios is sufficiently well justified. The analogous conclusions can be also made for the Zc−Z_c^- state.

Finally, we conclude that the absolute and relative observables (integral and differential) considered in the present work can help elucidate the genuine Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm intrinsic structures.

Summary and outlook

In this paper, we have investigated the possibility to study the charged charmonium-like state Zc(3900)Z_c(3900) production off nuclear targets and its intrinsic structure in inclusive near-threshold photon-induced reactions within the collision model based on the nuclear spectral function. The model accounts for its charged components Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm production in direct photon–nucleon interactions as well as three different popular scenarios for their internal structures: compact tetraquarks, hadronic molecules formed by pairs of charmed and anticharmed mesons, and mixtures of both of them. We have calculated the absolute and relative excitation functions for production of Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^\pm mesons on 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} and 184W{}^{184}\mathrm{W} target nuclei at initial photon energies of 9.0–17.5 GeV, the absolute momentum differential cross sections and their ratios for the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} production off these target nuclei at laboratory polar angles of 0∘0^\circ–10∘10^\circ and at photon energy of 14 GeV as well as the AA-dependences of the ratios of the total cross sections for Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} production at photon energy of 14 GeV within the adopted scenarios for the Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} internal structures. We show that the absolute and relative observables considered reveal a certain sensitivity to the still unknown Zc(3900)±Z_c(3900)^{\pm} internal structures. Therefore, they might be useful for determination of these structures – the issue which has attracted considerable interest in recent years – from the comparison of them with the experimental data from the future high-precision experiments at the upgraded up to 22 GeV CEBAF facility. We hope that the findings of the present work will additionally stimulate the conducting here such experiments.

References

  1. [1]W. Shan (for the BESIII Collaboration), AIP Conf. Proc. 1735, 060001 (2016).
  2. [2]Z. Liu and R. E. Mitchell, Sci. Bull. 68, 2148 (2023); arXiv:2310.09465 [hep-ex].DOI
  3. [3]S. Jia, W. Xiong, and C. Shen, Chin. Phys. Lett. 40, 121301 (2023); arXiv:2312.00403 [hep-ex].DOI
  4. [4]F. Zhu, G. Bauer, and K. Yi, Chin. Phys. Lett. 41, 111201 (2024); arXiv:2410.11210 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2410.11210
  5. [5]N. Husken, E. S. Norella, and I. Polyakov, arXiv:2410.06923 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2410.06923
  6. [6]H.-X. Chen, W. Chen, X. Liu, and S.-L. Zhu, Phys. Rep. 639, 1 (2016); arXiv:1601.02092 [hep-ph].DOI
  7. [7]A. Hosaka, T. Iijima, K. Miyabayashi, Y. Sakai, and S. Yasui, Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2016, 062C01 (2016); arXiv:1603.09229 [hep-ph].DOI
  8. [8]H.-X. Chen, W. Chen, X. Liu, Y.-R. Liu, and S.-L. Zhu, Rept. Prog. Phys. 80, 076201 (2017); arXiv:1609.08928 [hep-ph].DOI
  9. [9]A. Esposito, A. Pilloni, and A. D. Polosa, Phys. Rep. 668, 1 (2017); arXiv:1611.07920 [hep-ph].DOI
  10. [10]F.-K. Guo, C. Hanhart, U.-G. Meissner, Q. Wang, Q. Zhao, and B.-S. Zou, Rev. Mod. Phys. 90, 015004 (2018); arXiv:1705.00141 [hep-ph].DOI
  11. [11]S. L. Olsen, T. Skwarnicki, and D. Zieminska, Rev. Mod. Phys. 90, 015003 (2018); arXiv:1708.04012 [hep-ph].DOI
  12. [12]Y.-R. Liu, H. X. Chen, W. Chen, X. Liu and S.-L. Zhu, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 107, 237 (2019); arXiv:1903.11976 [hep-ph].DOI
  13. [13]N. Brambilla, S. Eidelman, C. Hanhart, A. Nefediev, C.-P. Shen, C. E. Thomas, A. Vairo, and C.-Z. Yuan, Phys. Rep. 873, 1 (2020); arXiv:1907.07583 [hep-ex].DOI
  14. [14]F.-K. Guo, X.-H. Liu, and S. Sakai, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 112, 103757 (2020); arXiv:1912.07030 [hep-ph].DOI
  15. [15]L. Maiani and A. Pilloni, arXiv:2207.05141 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2207.05141
  16. [16]C.-Z. Yuan, EPJ Web of Conf. 274, 01001 (2022); arXiv:2211.07217 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2211.07217
  17. [17]M. Albaladejo et al. [The JPAC Collaboration], Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 127, 103981 (2022); arXiv:2112.13436 [hep-ph].DOI
  18. [18]H.-X. Chen, W. Chen, X. Liu, Y.-R. Liu and S.-L. Zhu, Rept. Prog. Phys. 86, 026201 (2023); arXiv:2204.02649 [hep-ph].DOI
  19. [19]L. Meng, B. Wang, G.-J. Wang and S.-L. Zhu, Phys. Rep. 1019, 1 (2023); arXiv:2204.08716 [hep-ph].DOI
  20. [20]Z.-G. Wang, arXiv:2502.11351 [hep-ph].DOI
  21. [21]M.-Z. Liu, Y.-W. Pan, Z.-W. Liu, T.-W. Wu, J.-X. Lu, and L. S. Geng, Phys. Rep. 1108, 1 (2025); arXiv:2404.06399 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2404.06399
  22. [22]S. Patal, M. Shah, and P. C. Vinodkumar, Eur. Phys. J. A 50, 131 (2014); arXiv:1402.3974 [hep-ph].
  23. [23]Yu. S. Kalashnikova and A. V. Nefediev, Phys. Usp. 62, 568 (2019); arXiv:1811.01324 [hep-ph].DOI
  24. [24]G. Yang, J. Ping, and J. Segovia, Symmetry 12(11), 1869 (2020); arXiv:2009.00238 [hep-ph].DOI
  25. [25]N. Brambilla et al., arXiv:2203.16583 [hep-ph]; C. Hanhart, arXiv:2504.06043 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2203.16583
  26. [26]M. Ablikim et al. [The BESIII Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 252001 (2013); arXiv:1303.5949 [hep-ex].
  27. [27]Z. Q. Liu et al. [The Belle Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 252002 (2013); arXiv:1304.0121 [hep-ex].
  28. [28]T. Xiao, S. Dobbs, A. Tomaradze, and K. K. Seth, Phys. Lett. B 727, 366 (2013); arXiv:1304.3036 [hep-ex].DOI
  29. [29]V. M. Abazov et al. [The D0 Collaboration], Phys. Rev. D 98, 052010 (2018); arXiv:1807.00183 [hep-ex].
  30. [30]M. Ablikim et al. [The BESIII Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 112003 (2015); arXiv:1506.06018 [hep-ex].
  31. [31]M. Ablikim et al. [The BESIII Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 072001 (2017); arXiv:1706.04100 [hep-ex].
  32. [32]M. Ablikim et al. [The BESIII Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 022001 (2014); arXiv:1310.1163 [hep-ex].
  33. [33]M. Ablikim et al. [The BESIII Collaboration], Phys. Rev. D 92, 092006 (2015); arXiv:1509.01398 [hep-ex].
  34. [34]M. Ablikim et al. [The BESIII Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 222002 (2015); arXiv:1509.05620 [hep-ex].
  35. [35]D.-Y. Chen and X. Liu, Phys. Rev. D 84, 034032 (2011); arXiv:1106.5290 [hep-ph].DOI
  36. [36]M. Ablikim et al. [The BESIII Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 242001 (2013); arXiv:1309.1896 [hep-ex].
  37. [37]M. Ablikim et al. [The BESIII Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 212002 (2014).
  38. [38]M. Ablikim et al. [The BESIII Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 132001 (2014); arXiv:1308.2760 [hep-ex].
  39. [39]M. Ablikim et al. [The BESIII Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 182002 (2015); arXiv:1507.02404 [hep-ex].
  40. [40]A. Bondar et al. [The Belle Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 122001 (2012); arXiv:1110.2251 [hep-ex].
  41. [41]E. Wilbring, H.-W. Hammer, and U.-G. Meissner, Phys. Lett. B 726, 326 (2013); arXiv:1304.2882 [hep-ph].DOI
  42. [42]J. He, Phys. Rev. D 92, 034004 (2015); arXiv:1505.05379 [hep-ph].DOI
  43. [43]J. M. Dias, F. S. Navarra, M. Nielsen, and C. M. Zanetti, Phys. Rev. D 88, 016004 (2013); arXiv:1304.6433 [hep-ph].DOI
  44. [44]E. Braaten, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 162003 (2013); arXiv:1305.6905 [hep-ph].DOI
  45. [45]S. Dubynskiy and M. B. Voloshin, Phys. Lett. B 666, 344 (2008); arXiv:0803.2224 [hep-ph].DOI
  46. [46]M. B. Voloshin, Phys. Rev. D 87, 091501 (2013); arXiv:1304.0380 [hep-ph].DOI
  47. [47]X. Li and M. B. Voloshin, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 29(12), 1450060 (2014); arXiv:1309.1681 [hep-ph].DOI
  48. [48]L.-W. Yan, Z.-H. Guo, F.-K. Guo, D.-L. Yao, and Z.-Y. Zhou, arXiv:2307.12283 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2307.12283
  49. [49]Y. Ma, D.-S. Zhang, C.-Q. Pang, and Z.-F. Sun, arXiv:2412.11144 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2412.11144
  50. [50]Y.-H. Chen, M.-L. Du, and F.-K. Guo, Sci. China Phys. Mech. Astron. 67, 291011 (2024); arXiv:2310.15965 [hep-ph].DOI
  51. [51]X.-H. Liu and G. Li, Phys. Rev. D 88, 014013 (2013); arXiv:1306.1384 [hep-ph].DOI
  52. [52]E. S. Swanson, Phys. Rev. D 91, 034009 (2015); arXiv:1409.3291 [hep-ph].DOI
  53. [53]A. P. Szczepaniak, Phys. Lett. B 747, 410 (2015); arXiv:1501.01691 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/1501.01691
  54. [54]X.-H. Liu, M. Oka, and Q. Zhao, Phys. Lett. B 753, 297 (2016); arXiv:1507.01674 [hep-ph].DOI
  55. [55]Q. Wang, C. Hanhart, and Q. Zhao, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 132003 (2013); arXiv:1303.6355 [hep-ph].DOI
  56. [56]L. M. Abreu, R. O. Magalhaes, H. P. L. Vieira, and F. S. Navarra, J. Phys. G 51, 095003 (2024); arXiv:2310.18747 [hep-ph].DOI
  57. [57]Y. Huang, J. He, X. Liu, H. F. Zhang, J. J. Xie, and X. R. Chen, Phys. Rev. D 93, 034022 (2016); arXiv:1512.00981 [hep-ph].DOI
  58. [58]Q.-Y. Lin, X. Liu, and H.-S. Xu, Phys. Rev. D 88, 114009 (2013); arXiv:1308.6345 [hep-ph].DOI
  59. [59]M. Albaladejo et al., Phys. Rev. D 102, 114010 (2020); arXiv:2008.01001 [hep-ph].DOI
  60. [60]D. Winney et al., Phys. Rev. D 106, 094009 (2022); arXiv:2209.05882 [hep-ph].DOI
  61. [61]X.-H. Liu, Q. Zhao, and F. E. Close, Phys. Rev. D 77, 094005 (2008); arXiv:0802.2648 [hep-ph].DOI
  62. [62]X.-Y. Wang, X.-R. Chen, and A. Guskov, Phys. Rev. D 92, 094017 (2015); arXiv:1503.02125 [hep-ph].DOI
  63. [63]H.-W. Ke and X. Liu, Eur. Phys. J. C 58, 217 (2008); arXiv:0806.0998 [hep-ph].DOI
  64. [64]X.-Y. Wang, J. J. Xie, and X.-R. Chen, Phys. Rev. D 91, 014032 (2015).
  65. [65]X.-Y. Wang and X.-R. Chen, Adv. High Energy Phys. 2015, 918231 (2015); arXiv:1509.08553 [hep-ph].DOI
  66. [66]C. Adolph et al. [the COMPASS Collaboration], Phys. Lett. B 742, 330 (2015); arXiv:1407.6186 [hep-ex].DOI
  67. [67]J. Arrington et al., Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 127, 103985 (2022); arXiv:2112.00060 [nucl-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2112.00060
  68. [68]A. Accardi et al., Eur. Phys. J. A 60, 173 (2024); arXiv:2306.09360 [nucl-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2306.09360
  69. [69]K. Azizi and N. Er, Phys. Rev. D 101, 074037 (2020); arXiv:2001.09356 [hep-ph].DOI
  70. [70]E. Ya. Paryev, Eur. Phys. J. A 5, 307 (1999).
  71. [71]E. Ya. Paryev, Nucl. Phys. A 1047, 122876 (2024); arXiv:2405.01089 [hep-ph].
  72. [72]M. Cleven, F.-K. Guo, C. Hanhart, Q. Wang, and Q. Shao, JPS Conf. Proc. 10, 010017 (2016); arXiv:1510.00854 [hep-ph].DOI
  73. [73]L. Maiani, V. Riquer, R. Faccini, F. Piccinini, A. Pilloni, and A. D. Polosa, Phys. Rev. D 87, 111102(R) (2013); arXiv:1303.6857 [hep-ph].DOI
  74. [74]M. Karliner and S. Nussinov, JHEP 1307, 153 (2013); arXiv:1304.0345 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/1304.0345
  75. [75]N. Mahajan, arXiv:1304.1301 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/1304.1301
  76. [76]C.-F. Qiao and L. Tang, Eur. Phys. J. C 74, 3122 (2014); arXiv:1307.6654 [hep-ph].DOI
  77. [77]Z.-G. Wang and T. Huang, Phys. Rev. D 89, 054019 (2014); arXiv:1310.2422 [hep-ph].DOI
  78. [78]C. Deng, J. Ping, and F. Wang, Phys. Rev. D 90, 054009 (2014); arXiv:1402.0777 [hep-ph].DOI
  79. [79]S. S. Agaev, K. Azizi, and H. Sundu, Phys. Rev. D 93, 074002 (2016); arXiv:1601.03847 [hep-ph].DOI
  80. [80]A. Pilloni et al., Phys. Lett. B 772, 200 (2017); arXiv:1612.06490 [hep-ph].DOI
  81. [81]Z.-G. Wang and J.-X. Zhang, Eur. Phys. J. C 78, 14 (2018); arXiv:1711.07215 [hep-ph].DOI
  82. [82]Z.-Y. Zhou and Z. Xiao, Phys. Rev. D 92, 094024 (2015); arXiv:1505.05761 [hep-ph].DOI
  83. [83]F.-K. Guo, C. Hidalgo-Duque, J. Nieves, and M. P. Valderrama, Phys. Rev. D 88, 054007 (2013); arXiv:1303.6608 [hep-ph].DOI
  84. [84]J.-R. Zhang, Phys. Rev. D 87, 116004 (2013); arXiv:1304.5748 [hep-ph].DOI
  85. [85]Y. Dong, A. Faessler, T. Gutsche, and V. E. Lyubovitskij, Phys. Rev. D 88, 014030 (2013); arXiv:1306.0824 [hep-ph].DOI
  86. [86]H.-W. Ke, Z.-T. Wei, and X.-Q. Li, Eur. Phys. J. C 73, 2561 (2013); arXiv:1307.2414 [hep-ph].DOI
  87. [87]C.-Y. Cui, X.-H. Liao, Y.-L. Liu, and M.-Q. Huang, J. Phys. G 41, 075003 (2014); arXiv:1304.1850 [hep-ph].DOI
  88. [88]Z.-G. Wang and T. Huang, Eur. Phys. J. C 74, 2891 (2014); arXiv:1312.7489 [hep-ph].DOI
  89. [89]Y. Chen et al., Phys. Rev. D 89, 094506 (2014); arXiv:1403.1318 [hep-lat].DOI
  90. [90]E. Oset et al., EPJ Web of Conf. 81, 01011 (2014).
  91. [91]F. Aceti, M. Bayar, E. Oset, A. Martinez Torres, K. P. Khemchandani, J. M. Dias, F. S. Navarra, and M. Nielsen, Phys. Rev. D 90, 016003 (2014); arXiv:1401.8216 [hep-ph].DOI
  92. [92]W. Chen, T. G. Steele, H.-X. Chen, and S.-L. Zhu, Phys. Rev. D 92, 054002 (2015); arXiv:1505.05619 [hep-ph].DOI
  93. [93]M. Albaladejo, F.-K. Guo, C. Hidalgo-Duque, and J. Nieves, Phys. Lett. B 755, 337 (2016); arXiv:1512.03638 [hep-ph].DOI
  94. [94]Q.-R. Gong, Z.-H. Guo, C. Meng, G.-Y. Tang, Y.-F. Wang, and H.-Q. Zheng, Phys. Rev. D 94, 114019 (2016); arXiv:1604.08836 [hep-ph].DOI
  95. [95]D.-Y. Chen, Y.-B. Dong, M.-T. Li and W.-L. Wang, Eur. Phys. J. A 52, 310 (2016).
  96. [96]M. Albaladejo, P. Fernandez-Soler,and J. Nieves, Eur. Phys. J. C 76, 573 (2016); arXiv:1606.03008 [hep-ph].DOI
  97. [97]J. He and D.-Y. Chen, Eur. Phys. J. C 78, 94 (2018); arXiv:1712.05653 [hep-ph].DOI
  98. [98]P. G. Ortega, J. Segovia, D. R. Entem, and F. Fernandez, Eur. Phys. J. C 79, 78 (2019); arXiv:1808.00914 [hep-ph].DOI
  99. [99]M.-C. Du, Q. Wang, and Q. Zhao, arXiv:2011.09225 [hep-ph].
  100. [100]M.-L. Du, M. Albaladejo, F.-K. Guo, and J. Nieves, Phys. Rev. D 105, 074018 (2022); arXiv:2201.08253 [hep-ph].DOI
  101. [101]Z.-S. Jia, G. Li, P.-P. Shi, and Z.-H. Zhang, Phys. Rev. D 110, 014031 (2024); arXiv:2405.02619 [hep-ph].DOI
  102. [102]R. L. Workman et al. (Particle Data Group), Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2022, 083C01 (2022).
  103. [103]M. Mai, arXiv:2502.02654 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2502.02654
  104. [104]L. M. Abreu, H. P. L. Vieira, and F. S. Navarra, Phys. Rev. D 105, 116029 (2022); arXiv:2202.10882 [hep-ph].DOI
  105. [105]L. M. Abreu, F. S. Navarra, M. Nielsen, and H. P. L. Vieira, arXiv:2209.03862 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2209.03862
  106. [106]K. U. Can, G. Erkol, M. Oka, A. Ozpin​​eci, and T. T. Takahashi, Phys. Lett. B 719, 103 (2013); arXiv:1210.0869 [hep-lat].DOI
  107. [107]W. Cassing, E. L. Bratkovskaya, and A. Sibirtsev, Nucl. Phys. A 691, 753 (2001); arXiv:nucl-th/0010071.DOI
  108. [108]Ye. S. Golubeva, W. Cassing, and L. A. Kondratyuk, Eur. Phys. J. A 14, 255 (2002); arXiv:nucl-th/0202084.arxiv.org/abs/nucl-th/0202084
  109. [109]Ye. S. Golubeva, E. L. Bratkovskaya, W. Cassing, and L. A. Kondratyuk, Eur. Phys. J. A 17, 275 (2003); arXiv:nucl-th/0212074.DOI
  110. [110]A. B. Larionov, M. Strikman, and M. Bleicher, Phys. Lett. B 749, 35 (2015); arXiv:1502.03311 [nucl-th].DOI
  111. [111]I. Matuschek, V. Baru, F.-K. Guo, and C. Hanhart, Eur. Phys. J. A 57, 101 (2021); arXiv:2007.05329 [hep-ph].DOI
  112. [112]T. Hyodo, arXiv:2503.15376 [hep-ph]; T. Kinugawa and T. Hyodo, arXiv:2503.21554 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2503.15376
  113. [113]T. Kinugawa and T. Hyodo, Phys. Rev. C 109, 045205 (2024); arXiv:2303.07038 [hep-ph].DOI
  114. [114]T. Kinugawa and T. Hyodo, arXiv:2411.12285 [hep-ph].DOI
  115. [115]V. Montesinos, N. Ikeno, E. Oset, M. Albaladejo, J. Nieves, and L. Tolos, Phys. Lett. B 860, 139172 (2024); arXiv:2407.19295 [nucl-th].DOI
  116. [116]E. Ya. Paryev, Nucl. Phys. A 1042, 122792 (2024); arXiv:2310.04123 [hep-ph].DOI
  117. [117]E. Ya. Paryev, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 39, No. 30, 2450115 (2024); arXiv:2408.00360 [hep-ph].DOI
  118. [118]Y. Zhang, A. Hosaka, Q. Wang, and S. Yasui, arXiv:2503.19374 [hep-ph].DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_f5q3a7k3
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents