betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

A Reconfigurable Circuit Strategy and Its Application in Low-Power Rectifier for Ambient Energy Harvesting

Abstract

In ambient electromagnetic energy harvesting systems, the input power to the rectifier is low. To improve rectification efficiency, Schottky diodes, which are sensitive to low power, are commonly selected as rectifying devices to convert microwave power into dc power. However, low-power rectifying diodes typically have low reverse breakdown voltages, making them susceptible to reverse breakdown under high power conditions. This letter proposes a low-power rectifier with reconfigurable function. The rectifying diode is connected in parallel with the p-i-n diode. At low input power, the output dc voltage is low, and the p-i-n diode remains off, having no impact on the rectifier operation. As the input power increases, the p-i-n diode turns on, causing change in circuit structure and impedance mismatch. This leads to increased reflected power, thereby preventing the rectifying diode from receiving excessive power. In addition, the turn-on voltage of the p-i-n diode is lower than the reverse breakdown voltage of the rectifying diode, protecting it from reverse breakdown.

Introduction

With the rapid development of wireless communication technologies, the amount of electromagnetic energy in the environment is increasing. At the same time, a large number of wireless sensors are being used in the Internet of Things (IoT). Currently, most wireless sensors are powered by batteries, and their ability to function normally is dependent on battery life. Regularly replacing batteries leads to increased costs and pollution issues. Additionally, some wireless sensors are located in areas that are inaccessible to humans, making battery replacement difficult. Therefore, harvesting electromagnetic energy from the environment to power wireless sensors could effectively address the power supply issue of these wireless sensors[1][2].

Rectifiers can convert microwave power into dc power [3][4][5], and are the core component of an electromagnetic

energy harvesting system. Given that the energy density of electromagnetic waves in the environment is relatively low, the power input to the rectifier is also low. In order to achieve high conversion efficiency at low power levels, rectifying diodes are typically very sensitive to power. However, when close to a signal source, the received power increases rapidly, causing the rectifier's output voltage to rise. This may result in the rectifying diode being reverse-biased beyond its breakdown voltage, leading to the failure of the rectifier, as shown in Figure 1.

Electromagnetic energy harvesting powers wireless sensors

Figure 1. Electromagnetic energy harvesting powers wireless sensors.

Some researchers have employed switches or additional rectifying diodes to increase the reverse breakdown voltage of the rectifying diodes. In [6], By using FET switches to reconfigure the rectifier, the reverse breakdown voltage of the diode is increased in the rectifier. Ref. [7] proposed a synergistic structure that introduces a high-power diode in front of the low-power diode to prevent it from breakdown. A recently proposed power-adaptive distribution structure enables the low-power rectifying diode to operate under low-power conditions, while the high-power rectifying diode functions under high-power conditions[8].

Currently, there is limited research on the protection of low-power rectifiers. This letter proposes a novel reconfigurable mechanism for low-power rectifying diodes by introducing a PIN diode as a dc switch. This mechanism adaptively adjusts the switch based on the output voltage. When the PIN diode is turned on, the circuit structure is reconfigured, causing impedance mismatch. This prevents high input power from reaching the rectifying diode, protecting it from damage.

Principle of the Reconfigurable Strategy

In the protection of low-power nonlinear components, the

The authors are with the School of Electronics and Information Engineering, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610064, China (e-mail: [email protected]). conventional and straightforward approach is to introduce a limiter. As shown in Figure 2(a), when the input microwave power exceeds a certain threshold, the output microwave power remains constant, thereby protecting the subsequent circuits.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Methods for protecting rectifiers. (a)Traditional low-power rectifier with a limiter, and (b)the proposed rectifier with a voltage-controlled component.

Different from the traditional design method, this letter proposes a novel circuit structure that utilizes an adaptive structure regulation mechanism to control the power entering the rectifying diode and the output dc voltage, as shown in Figure 2(b). The switch state of the voltage-controlled component depends on the voltage across it. This component is connected in parallel with the rectifying diode. When the input power is low, the output dc voltage remains low, keeping the voltage-controlled component in the off state and leaving the rectifier's operation unaffected. As the input power gradually increases and the output dc voltage rises, the voltage-controlled component turns on, restructuring the circuit. This reconfiguration causes impedance mismatch and increased reflection, preventing excessive power from reaching the rectifying diode.

Design of the Proposed Rectifier

DC Voltage at the Maximum Conversion Efficiency

When the input microwave power is low, the rectifying efficiency is low due to the influence of the diode's turn-on voltage. As the power gradually increases, the conversion efficiency improves and eventually reaches its peak value, achieving the optimal dc voltage. However, as the power continues to rise, the efficiency of the rectifier rapidly decreases due to the impact of the reverse breakdown voltage, which may also lead to damage.

The goal of the reconfigurable strategy proposed in this letter is to maintain the maximum conversion efficiency of the rectifier; meanwhile, as the power continues to increase, prevent the rectifier from outputting excessively high voltage, thereby protecting the rectifying diode from reverse breakdown. Therefore, it is first necessary to study the dc voltage of the rectifier at its maximum conversion efficiency.

Fig. 3 is the nonlinear model of the rectifying diode [9], including the series resistance RsR_s, the junction resistance RjR_j, and the junction capacitance CjC_j.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Nonlinear model of the rectifying diode.

The input voltage VinV_{in} can be written as:

Vin=−Vdc+Vmwcos⁡(ωt)(1)V_{in}=-V_{dc}+V_{mw}\cos(\omega t) \tag*{(1)}

where VdcV_{dc} is the dc voltage on the load, and VmwV_{mw} is the input microwave voltage.

According to Figure 4, the junction voltage VjV_j can be expressed as:

Image not extracted

Figure 4. I-V characteristic curve of the rectifying diode and the time-domain waveform of the junction voltage VjV_j.

Vj={Vbi,Vj>Vbi,−Vjdc+Vjmwcos⁡(ωt−φ0),Vbi>Vj>−Vbr,−Vbr,−Vbr>Vj(2)V_j= \begin{cases} V_{bi}, & V_j>V_{bi},\\ -V_{jdc}+V_{jmw}\cos(\omega t-\varphi_0), & V_{bi}>V_j>-V_{br},\\ -V_{br}, & -V_{br}>V_j \end{cases} \tag*{(2)}

where VbiV_{bi} and VbrV_{br} are the diode's forward conduction voltage and reverse breakdown voltage, respectively, and VjdcV_{jdc} and VjmwV_{jmw} represent the dc component and the fundamental amplitude of the junction voltage when the diode operates in the reverse-biased state. In Figure 4, θbi\theta_{bi} and θbr\theta_{br} are the forward conduction angle and reverse breakdown angle, respectively. Due to the presence of the junction resistance RsR_s, there exists a phase difference φ0\varphi_0 between the input voltage VinV_{in} and the diode junction voltage VjV_j.

When the diode junction voltage exceeds the forward conduction voltage, the diode operates in the conduction state, satisfying the following relationship:

Vjmwcos⁡θbi−Vjdc=Vbi(3)V_{jmw}\cos\theta_{bi}-V_{jdc}=V_{bi} \tag*{(3)}

When the diode junction voltage exceeds the reverse breakdown voltage, the diode operates in the breakdown state, satisfying the following relationship:

Vjmwcos⁡θbr+Vjdc=Vbr(4)V_{jmw}\cos\theta_{br}+V_{jdc}=V_{br} \tag*{(4)}

When the diode operates in the off state, the junction resistance RjR_j is ideally infinite. The diode junction current Ioff,RsI_{off,Rs} flowing through RsR_s entirely flows into the junction capacitance CjC_j, and is expressed as:

Ioff,Rs=d(CjVj)dt=Vin−VjRs(5)I_{off,Rs}=\frac{\mathrm{d}(C_jV_j)}{\mathrm{d}t}=\frac{V_{in}-V_j}{R_s} \tag*{(5)}

Substituting equations (1) and (2) into the above equation (5), we obtain:

Ioff,Rs=−ωCjVjmwsin⁡θ=(Vjdc−Vdc)+(Vmwcos⁡φ0−Vjmw)cos⁡θI_{off,Rs}=-\omega C_jV_{jmw}\sin\theta=(V_{jdc}-V_{dc})+(V_{mw}\cos\varphi_0-V_{jmw})\cos\theta
−Vmwsin⁡φ0sin⁡θ(6)\qquad-V_{mw}\sin\varphi_0\sin\theta \tag*{(6)}

where θ=ωt−φ0\theta=\omega t-\varphi_0.

This equation has a solution and can be easily seen to satisfy the following relationship:

Vjdc=Vdc(7)V_{jdc}=V_{dc} \tag*{(7)}
Vjmw=Vmw(8)V_{jmw}=V_{mw} \tag*{(8)}

It should be noted that, since the microwave rectifying diode used typically has a small series resistance, the resulting diode voltage drop is also small [9]. Here, the phase difference φ0\varphi_0 caused by it is approximated to be zero, i.e., φ0≈0\varphi_0 \approx0.

Substituting (7) and (8) into (3) and (4), the following critical state relationship can be obtained:

Vdc+Vbicos⁡θbi=Vbr−Vdccos⁡θbr(9)\frac{V_{dc}+V_{bi}}{\cos\theta_{bi}}=\frac{V_{br}-V_{dc}}{\cos\theta_{br}} \tag*{(9)}

Under ideal conditions, the power loss during microwave-to-dc conversion is primarily attributed to the power dissipation on the diode.

When the diode is in the forward conduction state, the junction resistance RjR_j is approximately zero, and the conduction current is relatively high [9]. This conduction current flowing through the series resistance RsR_s and the junction resistance RjR_j results in power losses denoted as Lbi,RsL_{bi,Rs} and Lbi,RjL_{bi,Rj}, respectively.

When the diode is in the reverse cutoff state, the junction resistance RjR_j becomes infinite, and the leakage current flowing through RsR_s results in power loss Loff,RsL_{off,Rs}.

When the diode is in the breakdown state, the breakdown current is also relatively high, leading to power losses Lbr,RsL_{br,Rs} and Lbr,RjL_{br,Rj} due to the current passing through RsR_s and RjR_j. Table I summarizes the five types of losses in a rectifying diode.

Conduction StateCutoff StateBreakdown State
RsR_sLbi,RsL_{bi,Rs}Loff,RsL_{off,Rs}Lbr,RsL_{br,Rs}
RjR_jLbi,RjL_{bi,Rj}0Lbr,RjL_{br,Rj}

Table I. POWER LOSSES ON THE RECTIFYING DIODE

The forward conduction angle θbi\theta_{bi} must satisfy 0<θbi<π0 < \theta_{bi} < \pi, while the reverse breakdown angle θbr\theta_{br} must satisfy 0≤θbr<π0 \leq\theta_{br} < \pi. The smaller the forward conduction angle θbi\theta_{bi} and the reverse breakdown angle θbr\theta_{br}, the lower the power loss. When the rectifier reaches its maximum conversion efficiency, it implies that θbr=0\theta_{br}=0 and θbi→0\theta_{bi}\to0. This condition represents the critical state, which can be expressed as:

cos⁡θbr∣θbr=0=1(10)\left.\cos\theta_{br}\right|_{\theta_{br}=0}=1 \tag*{(10)}
cos⁡θbi∣θbi→0≈1(11)\left.\cos\theta_{bi}\right|_{\theta_{bi}\to0}\approx1 \tag*{(11)}

Substituting the above critical state conditions (maximum efficiency) into equation (9), it can be determined that when the rectifier operates at its highest efficiency, the dc output voltage VdcV_{dc} satisfies:

Vdc=Vbr−Vbi2(12)V_{dc}=\frac{V_{br}-V_{bi}}{2} \tag*{(12)}

It can thus be concluded that when the microwave rectifier operates at its optimal state (maximum efficiency), the dc output voltage is approximately equal to half the difference between the absolute values of its breakdown voltage and forward conduction voltage.

This conclusion will guide the rectifier design proposed in this letter, and we will protect the rectifier without affecting the maximum conversion efficiency.

Rectifier Design

Fig. 5 shows the schematic diagram of the designed low-power rectifier. In series with the rectifying diode is an eighth-wavelength short-ended transmission line, whose input impedance is given by:

ZTL=jZ0tan⁡(π4ωω0)={0,ω=0jZ0,ω=ω0∞,ω=2ω0(13)Z_{TL}=jZ_0\tan\left(\frac{\pi}{4}\frac{\omega}{\omega_0}\right)= \begin{cases} 0, & \omega=0\\ jZ_0, & \omega=\omega_0\\ \infty, & \omega=2\omega_0 \end{cases} \tag*{(13)}

where Z0Z_0 is the characteristic impedance of the eighth-wavelength short-ended transmission line.

The eighth-wavelength short-ended transmission line exhibits an infinite impedance at the 2{sup}nd harmonic, effectively suppressing the 2{sup}nd harmonic and improving the rectification efficiency.

Figure 5. Schematic of the proposed rectifier.

The rectifying diode is a Schottky diode SMS 7630, from Skyworks Solutions, Inc.. According to the datasheet of the SMS 7630, its forward turn-on voltage and reverse breakdown voltage are Vbi=0.34V_{bi}=0.34 V and Vbr=2V_{br}=2 V, respectively. As derived from Equation (12), when the diode SMS 7630 achieves its optimal conversion efficiency, the output dc voltage is approximately 0.8 V. The voltage-controlled switch in the proposed rectifier is two PIN diodes SMP 1345 (the conduction voltage of a single PIN diode is 0.89V, which will affect the maximum efficiency of the rectifier), from Skyworks. They are widely used in RF circuits.

According to the input power, the rectifier can be divided into two operating modes.

Mode 1: When the input power is low, the dc voltage output by the rectifying diode is low, and the PIN diode remains off. At this time, the microstrip line in series with the PIN diode is in an open-circuit state. The rectifier is in an impedance-matched state and operates efficiently.

Mode 2: When the input power is high, the rectifying diode outputs a higher voltage, causing the PIN diode to turn on. At this point, the microstrip line in series with the PIN diode transitions from an open-circuit state to a short-circuit state. This results in impedance mismatch in the rectifier, increasing reflection and reducing the power entering the rectifying diode, thereby protecting the rectifying diode from receiving excessive power. Additionally, the PIN diode limits the maximum output dc voltage—specifically, the output voltage cannot exceed the PIN diode's turn-on voltage. This effectively protects the rectifying diode from reverse breakdown under high-power conditions.

Simulation, and Measurement

To verify the proposed reconfigurable strategy for the low-power rectifier, we fabricated the proposed rectifier operating at 2.45 GHz. Its layout and the photograph are shown in Fig. 6(a). The rectifier is optimized around 0 dBm, and the measured ∣S11∣|S_{11}| is shown in Fig. 6(b). when the power is lower than 2 dBm, the reflection coefficients of the protected and unprotected rectifiers match well. However, as the input power increases, the PIN diodes in the protected rectifier turn on, restructuring the circuit and causing impedance mismatch. This leads to increased reflection (reflected power increased fivefold @ 8 dBm), preventing excessive power from entering the rectifying diode and protecting it from breakdown.

Layout and photograph of the proposed rectifierMeasured $|S_{11}|$

Figure 6. (a) Layout and photograph of the proposed rectifier. (b) Measured ∣S11∣|S_{11}|.

The traditional circuit protection method using limiters is employed for comparison. We selected two limiters from Mini-Circuits: the ZFLM-252-1WL-S+ (limiter 1) [11] and the VLM-33W-2W-S+ (limiter 2) [12]. These limiters can restrict the microwave power at 2.45 GHz to within -2 dBm and 10 dBm, respectively. Their insertion losses are approximately 4 dB and 0.6 dB around the input power level of 0 dBm, respectively.

The measurement results of the rectifier without protection, with two PIN diodes, the limiters 1 and 2, respectively, are shown in Figure 7. When the output dc voltage is around 0.8 V, the unprotected rectifier achieves its peak efficiency of 69.8% at 2 dBm, which is consistent with the analysis presented in § 2. As the input power continues to increase, the dc voltage will reach the reverse breakdown voltage, leading to circuit damage.

Measured dc voltageMeasured efficiency

Figure 7. Measured (a) dc voltage and (b) efficiency of the rectifier without protection, with two PIN diodes, the limiters 1 and 2, respectively.

Limiter 1 can successfully keep the voltage within a safe range; however, its high insertion loss results in very low efficiency. Limiter 2 fails to keep the voltage within a safe range and also introduces insertion loss.

While, the proposed reconfigurable strategy hardly reduces the efficiency of the rectifier at low power levels. Even when the input power increases (up to 0 dBm), the rectification efficiency only decreases by less than 6%. More importantly, even if the input power reaches 20 dBm (a power that is almost impossible to receive), the rectifier can still limit the voltage within a safe range.

In terms of circuit cost, the PIN diode is much cheaper than a

limiter. Therefore, this design offers advantages over traditional designs in both performance and cost.

Ref.YearFreq. (GHz)Eff. @0dBmMax. Eff.Protection MethodVoltage LimitSize (mm²)
[7]20192.453%60.1% @10dBmCooperative StructureNo55 × 38
[5]20242.454%71.2% @12dBmTwo-Stage RectifierNo40 × 35
[8]20242.4353.4%69% @14dBmPower DivisionNo39 × 35
This work20252.4562.8%63% @1dBmReconfigurable CircuitYes30 × 21

Table 2. Comparison with Rectifiers with Low-Power Diode Protection

As shown in Table II, this design demonstrates advantages in terms of efficiency in low power, voltage limit, the number of dc loads, and circuit size.

Conclusion

A low-power rectifier protection strategy for electromagnetic energy harvesting applications was designed and validated in this letter. By incorporating a PIN diode to dynamically adjust the structure of the rectifier, the rectifier is effectively protected from reverse breakdown with almost no impact on the rectification efficiency. Moreover, the proposed protection strategy can also be applied to other circuits that are at risk of reverse breakdown and high power.

References

  1. [2]L. Lin, K. A. Ahmed, P. S. Salamani and M. Alioto, "Battery-Less IoT Sensor Node with PLL-Less WiFi Backscatter Communications in a 2.5-μW Peak Power Envelope," 2021 Symposium on VLSI Circuits, Kyoto, Japan, 2021, pp. 1-2.
  2. [5]Q. Wang et al., "A Two-Stage Rectifier With Adaptive Power Distribution for Extending the Input Power Range," IEEE Microw. Wireless Compon. Lett., vol.34, no.1, pp.115-118, 2024.
  3. [6]H. Sun, Z. Zhong and Y. -X. Guo, "An Adaptive Reconfigurable Rectifier for Wireless Power Transmission," IEEE Microw. Wireless Compon. Lett., vol. 23, no. 9, pp. 492-494, Sept. 2013.DOI
  4. [7]S. Y. Zheng, S. H. Wang, K. W. Leung, W. S. Chan and M. H. Xia, "A High-Efficiency Rectifier With Ultra-Wide Input Power Range Based on Cooperative Structure," IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Techn., vol. 67, no. 11, pp. 4524-4533, Nov. 2019.DOI
  5. [8]Z. He, L. Yan and C. Liu, "An Adaptive Power Division Strategy for Nonlinear Components in Rectification," IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 39, no. 12, pp. 15436-15440, Dec. 2024.DOI
  6. [9]J. O. McSpadden, Lu Fan and Kai Chang, "Design and experiments of a high-conversion-efficiency 5.8-GHz rectenna," IEEE Trans. on Microw. Theory Techn., vol. 46, no. 12, pp. 2053-2060, Dec. 1998.DOI
  7. [11]https://www.minicircuits.com/pdfs/ZFLM-252-1WL-S+.pdf.
  8. [12]https://www.minicircuits.com/pdfs/VLM-33W-2W-S+.pdf.

Paper details

vlnc:W_f99r2c75
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 7

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents