WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Isospin violation and the neutron weak magnetic moment
Abstract
The recent measurement of weak magnetism in neutron beta decay [1] obtained a value that is consistent with the conserved vector current hypothesis requiring the assumption of isospin conservation. The influence of the quark-mass difference and electromagnetic effects that violate this conservation law are examined using non-relativistic constituent quark models and estimated to be of the order of at most 1%.
Ref. [1] recently combined decay asymmetry measurements with the neutron lifetime and the value of nuclear superallowed decays to make the first observation of weak magnetism (WM) in neutron decay.
The existence of WM is a consequence of the conserved vector current (CVC) hypothesis [2, 3], a cornerstone of the standard model. It relates the weak vector current to the isovector electromagnetic current as members of the same isospin triplet. The immediate result is that the weak-vector form factors are directly related to isovector magnetic moments. This means that CVC predicts that weak magnetism exists [4]. Just as the matrix element of the electromagnetic current features a Pauli term representing the anomalous magnetic coupling, the weak vector current generates an identical structure whose form factor is directly related by CVC to electromagnetic observables. WM has been observed in some nuclear transitions, with varying dependence on nuclear-structure input [5].
The simplest -decay process is that of the free neutron, but weak magnetism had never been directly measured prior to Ref. [1]. WM is the only non-negligible form factor beyond the leading coupling contributing to the differential decay rate at first order in recoil [6, 7, 8, 9, 10], so it is important for precision studies.
The definition of the WM form factor, appears in the matrix element of the weak current, decomposed as:
where is the neutron (proton) spinor, is the momentum transfer, and is the average nucleon mass. Here, denotes the form factor at . The dependence is safely neglected in neutron beta decay. The relevant component of the vector current, expressed in terms of quark operators, is
The matrix element of the electromagnetic current is given by
where represents either the proton (p) or neutron (n). The operator accounts for the vector V term, Under CVC, the WM coupling is linked to the magnetic moments of the proton and neutron, yielding [4]:
in units of nucleon magneton. Ref. [1] found that , in agreement with the CVC prediction.
The CVC expression requires the assumption of isospin conservation, a symmetry that is only approximate. Isospin violation is caused by up-down quark mass difference and electromagnetic effects [11, 12]. Such effects are expected to be of order or , very small compared to the current experimental uncertainty of 0.87. Nonetheless, the newfound ability to measure merits an assessment of the size of the effects of isospin violation. This, using non-relativistic quark models [13, 14, 15], is presented here.
Given Eq. (1) and Eq. (3) the next step is to evaluate the matrix elements. The first step is to realize that the neutron and proton and down and up quarks are related by a particular rotation in isospin space. I briefly describe the formalism, elaborated in several reviews [11, 12]. The starting point is to use the approximate invariance of the Lagrangian under the interchange of and quarks. This makes it worthwhile to define the charge symmetry (cs) operator, which is an isospin rotation by 180° about the y-axis (taking the z-axis to be associated with the charge). This is defined by
with , and , where is the light (u,d) quark field operator. The Hamiltonian consists of a charge symmetry conserving term and a breaking term such that
with . The unperturbed states are denoted by a subscript 0 and have a mass that is the average of the proton and neutron masses. It is sufficient to work to first order in such that the physical proton is expressed in terms of the unperturbed states by
with a similar equation for the neutron. The quantity is a projection operator to states orthogonal to the unperturbed ground state isospin doublet. The unperturbed neutron and proton state vectors are related by charge symmetry:
A set of non-relativistic, constituent-quark models described in Refs. [16, 17] is used as a tool to a first estimate of the effects of cs breaking. With these models, the necessary evaluations are not difficult and one gains insight into the physics of charge symmetry breaking.
To proceed further, the Hamiltonian, , and its ground state wave function must be specified. Oscillator confinement is used. Thus,
where SU(6) spin-isospin wave functions are used, with spin wave functions for a spin up proton given by
For the proton, the are obtained by replacing with . The bare neutron wave function is obtained by using Eq. (8). The spatial part of the wave function is given by
Here and and is a normalization constant.
In this model the isovector part of the nucleon magnetic moment is given by
with representing either the proton or neutron and denoting the up or down quark mass: , , . The weak magnetism term is similarly obtained from the matrix element:
The effects of on the nucleon wave functions of Eq. (7) are assessed first. The charge symmetry breaking (CSB) terms of due to the down-up quark mass difference, its effects on the kinetic energy operator, one-gluon exchange potential and the electromagnetic interaction are detailed in Refs. [16, 17]. These yield no contribution. This is because the operators excite the baryon, but the CSB terms of do not convert the nucleon to a . Thus, the entire effects of CSB are caused by the explicit effects of the nucleon and quark mass differences that enter Eq. (13) and Eq. (14).
Given the SU(6) wave functions, the evaluations of the matrix elements leads to the results:
When the mass differences are neglected, we see that . The fractional change in the value of caused by CSB effects is , and the fractional change in the value of caused by CSB effects is . The nucleon masses are known to a very high precision [18]. The average constituent quark mass is 337 MeV, a value that gives the proton magnetic moment to be the measured value of 2.79, if CSB effects are ignored. The model-dependent values of quark mass differences range from -4.5 to -6.9 MeV [17]. This gives a range of values of from -0.0016 to -0.0020 and a range of values of from 0.0067 to 0.010. The CSB effects on the magnetic moments are of order of and those on weak magnetism are of order . These are much smaller than what any conceivable measurement could achieve.
References
References
- [1]Miriam Camarasa-Domene, Martín González-Alonso, and Martín Novoa-Brunet. First observation of weak magnetism in neutron decay. 10 2026.
- [2]S. S. Gershtein and Ya. B. Zeldovich. Meson Corrections in the Theory of Beta Decay. Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz., 29:698–699, 1955.
- [3]R. P. Feynman and Murray Gell-Mann. Theory of Fermi interaction. Phys. Rev., 109:193–198, 1958.
- [4]Murray Gell-Mann. Test of the Nature of the Vector Interaction in beta Decay. Phys. Rev., 111:362–365, 1958.
- [5]Nathal Severijns, Marcus Beck, and Oscar Naviliat-Cuncic. Tests of the standard electroweak model in beta decay. Rev. Mod. Phys., 78:991–1040, 2006.DOI
- [6]J. D. Jackson, S. B. Treiman, and H. W. Wyld. Possible tests of time reversal invariance in beta decay. Physical Review, 106(3):517–521, 1957.DOI
- [7]Barry R. Holstein. Recoil effects in allowed beta decay: The elementary particle approach. Reviews of Modern Physics, 46(4):789–814, 1974.DOI
- [8]Leendert Hayen, Nathal Severijns, Kazimierz Bodek, Xavier Mougeot, and Dagmara Rozpedzik. High precision analytical description of the allowed beta spectrum shape. Reviews of Modern Physics, 90(1):015008, 2018.DOI
- [9]Hui-Yun Cao and Hai-Qing Zhou. Recoil contributions in neutron beta decay and their corrections to the correlation coefficients. arXiv preprint arXiv:2302.04647, 2023.arxiv.org/abs/2302.04647
- [10]A. N. Ivanov, R. Höllwieser, N. I. Troitskaya, M. Wellenzohn, and Ya. A. Berdnikov. Corrections of order o(e_e^2/m_n^2), caused by weak magnetism and proton recoil, to the neutron lifetime and correlation coefficients of the neutron beta decay. arXiv preprint arXiv:2010.14336,
- [11]G. A. Miller, B. M. K. Nefkens, and I. Slaus. Charge symmetry, quarks and mesons. Phys. Rept., 194:1–116, 1990.DOI
- [12]Gerald A. Miller, Allena K. Opper, and Edward J. Stephenson. Charge symmetry breaking and QCD. Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci., 56:253–292, 2006.
- [13]Nathan Isgur. Isospin violating mass differences and mixing angles: the role of quark masses. Phys. Rev. D, 21:779, 1980. [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 23, 817 (1981)].DOI
- [14]Nathan Isgur and G. Karl. Ground State Baryons in a Quark Model with Hyperfine Interactions. Phys. Rev. D, 20:1191–1194, 1979.DOI
- [15]F. E. Close. An Introduction to Quarks and Partons. Academic Press, London, 1979.
- [16]Gerald A. Miller. Nucleon charge symmetry breaking and parity violating electron proton scattering. Phys. Rev. C, 57:1492–1505, 1998.DOI
- [17]Jacob W. Crawford and Gerald A. Miller. Charge-symmetry-breaking effects on neutron β decay in nonrelativistic quark models. Phys. Rev. C, 106(6):065502, 2022.DOI
- [18]Peter J. Mohr, David B. Newell, Barry N. Taylor, and Eite Tiesinga. CODATA recommended values of the fundamental physical constants: 2022*. Rev. Mod. Phys., 97(2):025002, 2025.