WorksMathematics
Isospectral Density Design and Distinct Global Shape Transitions in Weighted Yukawa Droplets
Abstract
We study Euclidean perimeter plus Yukawa repulsion with a fixed radial source density and a fixed ordinary volume. For each sufficiently small positive screening parameter, we construct two smooth, positive, strictly increasing densities whose constrained shape Hessians at the unit ball agree for every coupling. Their source masses, Yukawa moments, and ball self-energies also agree. Just above their common first global transition threshold, all minimizers form one rotation orbit of tetrahedral shapes for one density and one orbit of sectoral threefold shapes for the other. Both transitions are continuous, and the minimizing shapes are strictly convex. We obtain the two densities by fixing the boundary data that determine the Hessian and changing the higher derivatives that determine the reduced quartic energy. We compute a positive quartic coefficient, restore the three scalar observables by interior corrections, and add a finite exterior density barrier to control all finite-perimeter competitors.
The question and the main result
The shape Hessian at a sphere determines its unstable modes. It need not determine the shapes that minimize the nonlinear energy. We construct two radial source densities with the same ball Hessian, the same source mass, Yukawa moment, and ball self-energy, and the same first global transition threshold. The two models have different minimizing shapes just above that threshold.
For , let
Here is Euclidean perimeter, , and is fixed in space. The admissible sets have finite perimeter and ordinary volume , where . Sets are identified up to null sets. The integral is allowed to be ; such sets are irrelevant for minimization when . At the energy means perimeter alone. The density weights both sources in the interaction. The perimeter and volume are unweighted.
Write for the real spherical harmonics of degree , with the inner product. The constrained Hessian at is diagonal on . We use “isospectral” to mean equality of the Hessian operators on each degree. Define
and let be the supremum of the positive couplings at which is a global minimizer. The construction below proves that this set of couplings is exactly .
The two unit critical harmonics used throughout are
Their full orthogonal stabilizers are the tetrahedral group and the sectoral threefold group , respectively. The associated droplets are three-dimensional. The term “sectoral” describes the spherical harmonic.
Theorem 1.1 (Identical linear and scalar data, distinct first global shapes). There exists such that, for every fixed , there are two radial densities , smooth as functions on , and numbers with the following properties.
The densities are positive, satisfy for , coincide outside a compact annulus, and have quadratic growth at infinity. Their constrained ball Hessians agree for every , and
For each density a global minimizer exists for every . The centered ball is the unique global minimizer for . Its Hessian is positive definite for and has kernel exactly at . Also,
For , all global minimizers of the th model form exactly one orbit of nonspherical, strictly convex domains, for any fixed . Their full orthogonal stabilizers are for and for .
Put . Up to rotation, the boundary is with
where , , are positive. The first global transition is continuous, with different leading angular shapes.
The densities depend on the fixed screening parameter and the unit reference volume. We do not require one pair to have the same Hessians at all screening parameters or radii. The theorem compares two functionals; it makes no claim that both shape types minimize the same functional. The boundary-layer width, exterior barrier strength, and transition interval may depend on ; no uniform bounds on these choices as are claimed.
Relation to earlier work. Frank [1] constructed nonspherical volume-constrained equilibria of the Coulomb liquid drop model through bifurcation from a ball. De Regibus, Grossi, and Musso [2] study further bifurcations for nonlocal isoperimetric problems. For screened interactions, Bronsard, Merlet, and Pegon [3] establish connected nonball minimizers in Yukawa and truncated Coulomb models, with nonradial minimizers for the latter. Bronsard, DeMason, and Topaloglu [4] study existence and sharp ball stability for the unweighted Yukawa problem. These papers concern bifurcation or minimization for prescribed models. Here we choose the source density while fixing the ball Hessian and three scalar observables.
Weights and confinement have also been studied in related liquid drop problems. Alama, Bronsard, Topaloglu, and Zuniga [5] place the density in the perimeter, while Alama, Bronsard, Choksi, and Topaloglu [6] use a background potential. Their models differ from (1), whose ordinary perimeter and volume are fixed while a radial source density multiplies both factors of the interaction.
The bifurcation theory, the two orbit types, and the quartic invariants of harmonic cubics are classical [7, 8, 9, 10]. We realize the two orbit types using positive increasing Yukawa source densities with the same spectral and scalar data. We also prove that the first global thresholds agree and classify all minimizers just above them. We include the invariant calculations with the normalizations used in the proof.
Outline of the proof. The ball Hessian depends only on the boundary value, the first boundary derivative, and one interior Yukawa moment. We change higher boundary derivatives in a thin layer and use three interior corrections to restore the observables. We choose the second derivative so that the radial quartic coefficient is positive, then choose the third derivative to select either angular orbit. A common finite increase of the exterior density excludes distant competitors and leaves all near-ball energies unchanged.
Linear data and exact density realization
The complete ball Hessian
Let , , , and . The radial Green formula gives
Here differentiates the fixed ball potential in space.
Lemma 2.1 (Spectrum and its finite data). The ball is volume-constrained critical for every , and the Hessian eigenvalue on , with multiplicity , is
where . For fixed , decreases strictly to zero, and
The data determine the whole Hessian for every coupling.
Proof. The first variations are , , and . At the sphere the multiplier is . The second variation of the Lagrangian is
The local term is ; the remaining term is the single-layer operator. On its eigenvalue is the reciprocal of the jump between the interior and exterior logarithmic radial derivatives. The normalized solutions are proportional to and , respectively. Their Wronskian gives as stated.
The same eigenvalue has the variational formula: is the minimum over of
Comparing degrees at the higher-degree minimizer proves strict monotonicity. Completing squares on and gives the lower energy bound . Testing with inside and outside gives the upper bound on the minimum and proves (7). These trial functions have finite massive energy for .
At a known nonzero coupling, two distinct labeled eigenvalues determine and : if , then and . We preserve the stronger data . The translation modes are retained, since the density is fixed in space.
Lemma 2.2 (A common degree-three crossing). Set
For all sufficiently small positive , this density has a first positive Hessian crossing at with kernel exactly . At the crossing the complement is uniformly coercive in , and .
Proof. At , , , , and . This gives
For integer this is zero only at and positive otherwise. The degree-three slope is , while the degree-one slope is . At small set
Continuity preserves the positive gap for every finite set of noncritical degrees. For the remaining degrees, and and are bounded, so uniformly. This proves the gap for all noncritical degrees. Since every eigenvalue is affine in , positivity at and , together with the positive degree-one slope, proves positivity for . The degree-three eigenvalue is exactly .
Changing finite boundary derivatives with exact compensation
Lemma 2.3 (Finite-jet realization). Fix . Given arbitrary finite values for , , there is a smooth positive radial density realizing them and preserving
of the baseline (8). Its difference from the baseline has compact support away from the origin, and can be arbitrarily small in . The density satisfies for every .
Proof. With a cutoff near zero, first add
The constants are the prescribed increments. This changes the second and third derivatives, leaves the value and first derivative fixed, and tends to zero in as for fixed .
Choose an interval disjoint from this layer. On consider the derivatives of the three observables:
where . These functionals are independent. The first two weights are independent because is strictly increasing. Dependence of the third would imply on ; applying would make constant there, a contradiction. Choose three test functions with invertible derivative matrix. The finite-dimensional implicit function theorem applied to
gives small corrections restoring all three values exactly. We apply the theorem with the density in on the fixed ball. The first two functionals are linear, and is a continuous quadratic form. The higher derivatives of need not be small. The corrections are small and supported away from the boundary, so they leave the prescribed derivatives unchanged. Positivity and strict increase follow from the positive minima of and on the compact perturbation support. Outside that support the baseline is unchanged.
The total perturbation preserves . An individual interior correction may have nonzero moment to compensate for the boundary layer. If an interior perturbation supported in has zero moment, then outside by (5). For every , the resulting change in is independent of , so relative shape energies are unchanged.
Exact reduction and quartic control
Reduction in a strong space, comparison in a weaker norm
Use the exact volume coordinate
Then , and . Fix , put , and let be its orthogonal complement among mean-zero functions. For define .
Lemma 3.1 (Exact reduction and energy comparison). For every fixed smooth radial density with the ball data of Lemma 2.2, there is a smooth, -equivariant map near such that
The reduced energy is even in and has the expansion
with the corresponding bounds after up to two derivatives. For every sufficiently small mean-zero graph, write , . There are such that
A positive definite then makes the critical ball a strict local minimizer among small equal-volume graphs.
Proof. The exact area and interaction first variations are
The projected Euler operator is smooth from mean-zero to mean-zero . For the nonlocal term, we account for the moving singularity as follows. Extend the boundary map to a smoothly -dependent, uniformly bi-Lipschitz map of space, equal to the identity near zero and outside a fixed annulus. The potential trace becomes
Each parameter derivative of the kernel contains differences of parameter derivatives of . Each such difference is , with a bound multilinear in the norms of the directions. So the differentiated integrands are bounded by ; one tangential derivative is bounded by . Both are uniformly integrable in three dimensions. Taylor’s formula along parameter segments gives the same bounds for Fréchet remainders, with a factor tending to zero. Integration then controls these remainders in the Lipschitz norm of the trace, and so in . This proves smoothness to every finite order. Smoothness of the local area operator is immediate from (13).
The linearization on is plus a constant and a lower-order single-layer operator. It is Fredholm of index zero between these Hölder spaces, and the spectral gap makes it invertible by elliptic estimates. The implicit function theorem gives . The ball is critical for all and the linearization preserves and , proving the two vanishing identities. Uniqueness gives equivariance. Central inversion acts as on , so is even. Its quadratic term is exactly , which proves (11) by Taylor expansion.
To compare graphs, we prove that the Hessian is continuous as an bilinear form. Differentiating (13) gives, with ,
The derivative in the first line is radial. The volume potential has a continuous gradient across the boundary. If , then the source difference is bounded and supported on a set of volume ; the kernels and give and . The first coefficient in (14) then converges uniformly. For the second line,
The difference from the ball kernel is at most . Its operator norm tends to zero by Schur’s bound. The perimeter Hessian has coefficients continuous in . Combining these estimates,
as . The integral formulas and Taylor’s formula extend to graphs by smooth approximation and the displayed uniform bounds.
The spectral gap is coercive on in , so (15) preserves that coercivity along the segment . The first derivative along vanishes at . Integrating the second derivative proves (12). If , then at this gives after shrinking the neighborhood. Equality forces .
The graph topology and the coercivity norm differ, as in the shape stability results of [11]. Here the needed continuity estimate is (15).
One positive radial coefficient and one angular control
Set and . The invariant calculation in § 4 shows that every quartic invariant on is uniquely .
Proposition 3.2 (The two quartic forms needed for the construction). For every sufficiently small fixed positive there exist two densities satisfying Lemma 2.3 whose reduced quartics are
Both can be realized while fixing .
Proof. First fix this second derivative and set , using Lemma 2.3. Finite-order shape derivatives depend only on the boundary derivatives of the required orders and the ball Yukawa moment. This also follows from the signed-shell argument below. The coefficient of does not depend on the particular interior correction. The direct transmission calculation in Appendix § 7 gives
It is positive because . The coefficients involve only finitely many homogeneous radial solutions and finitely many boundary derivatives, and are continuous as . So for small positive .
To change the third derivative by , use another density with the same second and lower derivatives and the same moment. Write its difference as , let , , and put . Since , . The radial equation implies inside, while it vanishes outside. The exact difference of the relative interaction energies is
Here . The first contribution is . A spherical shell of thickness has Coulomb potential uniformly; since , the cross terms in (18) are . So the first changed energy term is at degree four. More generally the same argument shows that if the boundary derivatives through order three and the moment agree, all derivatives of relative energy through order four agree.
The quadratic complement correction is determined by the cubic energy, which has not changed. The two reduction graphs first differ at order three, and the energy cost of that difference is order six. The change in the reduced quartic is
Since , this sets its coefficient to either or , for example with . Both prescribed third derivatives are finite for the fixed and are realized by Lemma 2.3. We take the limit only in the local coefficient formula. The interior corrections need not depend continuously on at zero.
Angular selection and the unique near-ball minimizing orbit
We compute the angular bounds and Hessians for harmonic cubics in our normalization. The invariant theory and orbit types are described in [7, 8, 9, 10].
Two invariants and their extremal orbits
Write with symmetric and trace-free, and set
Repeated indices are summed.
Lemma 4.1 (Quartic invariants, equality orbits, and angular Hessians). The quartic invariants on have basis , and
The equality sets are respectively and . On the three-dimensional normal space to either orbit inside the unit sphere of , the Hessian of has eigenvalues
Proof. The complexified has rotation weights . In its fourth symmetric power the multiplicities at weights zero and one are respectively 18 and 16: count nondecreasing quadruples in of sums 12 and 13. Their difference, two, is the multiplicity of the trivial representation. Quartics are even under central inversion, so the and invariant spaces coincide. The invariants are independent, having ratios for and for .
The moment formula
and vanishing of odd-coordinate moments give
For example ; this follows by applying the Laplacian twice to the homogeneous polynomial . These identities prove that is a basis.
The matrix is nonnegative, so . For the upper bound choose a positive maximum of as north pole and diagonalize its tangential quadratic part. Then . Put , , , , . The trace conditions give
So , with equality exactly when and or ; both give rotations and multiples of . If is scalar, then and . A rotation about the pole makes , , giving
where , , and are orthogonal coordinates. This proves the lower equality classification. Formula (23) now gives (20). The negatives of both representatives are proper rotations of them: combine a coordinate interchange with central inversion for , and use a rotation about for .
At a unit critical harmonic the constrained angular Hessian is
At , a transverse orthonormal basis consists of and its cyclic partners. At , use
The corresponding diagonal moments are
All mixed moments vanish by parity. Equation (24) gives (21). The three rotational directions are exact zero modes by invariance. Their polynomial spans are at , and at . These are orthogonal to the transverse vectors displayed above. Since the unit sphere has dimension six and each orbit dimension three, no further directions remain.
From quartic preference to exact minimizing shapes
Proposition 4.2 (Unique near-ball minimum modulo rotations). Suppose the reduced quartic is one of (16), and let or for the chosen quartic. Put . At the ball is a strict local minimizer. For every sufficiently small , the shapes attaining the least energy in a fixed sufficiently small graph neighborhood of the ball form exactly one rotation orbit, with representative
Its energy is relative to the ball. Its full stabilizer is that of , and it is strictly convex for small .
Proof. Lemma 4.1 shows that with equality precisely along the chosen angular orbit. Positivity at follows from Lemma 3.1. The fixed-point space of the stabilizer of in is . For , the even coordinate sign changes and permutations leave only ; for , reflection in and the planar rotation and reflection leave only the cosine mode of frequency three. By equivariance, a stationary point on that line is a stationary point of the full reduced energy. If , its equation is
The implicit function theorem in gives . This function is even and strictly increasing for small , so every sufficiently small has exactly one small positive amplitude, with the stated expansion.
To prove angular uniqueness near the selected orbit, take a normal slice to the orbit in the finite-dimensional unit sphere of . Divide the angular equation at by . It extends smoothly to , with invertible angular derivative given by . Symmetry makes the slice origin a solution for all small . The implicit function theorem makes it the unique one there. The radial equation above then gives a single critical orbit in the cone. The slice argument takes place in , so no differentiability of the rotation action on the Hölder graph space is needed.
We now show that every near-ball minimizer lies in that cone. Choose and then so that the remainder in (11) is at most for , . Then
Choose and decrease so that . The energy is positive when , while the constructed branch has negative energy. The minimum on the closed ball is then interior and has . Under , the energies divided by converge in on that fixed ball to
Its global minimizing set is exactly . Any sequence of minimizers of the scaled energies has a convergent subsequence; comparison with each fixed makes its limit a minimum of . It follows, uniformly over all minimizers, that they enter the previously chosen cone and stay away from zero in scaled coordinates. Angular and radial uniqueness identify them with the constructed orbit. This step uses the angular bounds on the whole unit sphere.
Choose the fixed graph neighborhood so that its center projections lie in the ball and (12) holds. That estimate compares every graph in the neighborhood with its exact reduction graph. Each graph has energy at least the reduced minimum, with equality only if and its coordinate lies on that orbit. The constructed graphs lie in the chosen neighborhood for small , so they attain the minimum. Substitution in (11) gives the stated energy expansion. Equivariance gives every symmetry of as a symmetry of the graph; projecting the graph onto shows that any symmetry of the graph also fixes . Finally and , so the boundaries are nonspherical strictly convex perturbations of the unit sphere. □
From local selection to the first global transition
Fix and write . In this section we consider smooth positive densities satisfying
with positive constants depending on the density. All densities constructed above satisfy these bounds. So do their modifications by any fixed bounded nonnegative function. Sets are identified up to null sets. To pass from graph minimality to minimality, we use penalization as in [12, 13]. We give the argument for a Hessian with a kernel. For BV compactness and perimeter slicing, we use [15].
Lemma 5.1 (Existence and parameter compactness). For every , has a global minimizer among finite-perimeter sets of volume . If and are corresponding global minimizers, a subsequence converges in to a global minimizer at .
Proof. For , let , , and . Positivity of the kernel gives
The lower bound in (25) implies . Bounded self-energy then gives uniform tightness of the ordinary volume. Comparison with bounds the perimeter and self-energy of a minimizing sequence. Local BV compactness and tightness give global convergence preserving volume. Perimeter is lower semicontinuous, and Fatou’s lemma treats the positive double integral. This proves existence.
For varying parameters, comparison with and give and a uniform perimeter bound. The same compactness argument applies. Since is bounded, replacing by changes the energy by . Lower semicontinuity and comparison with each fixed finite-energy competitor then prove that the limit is a minimizer. Infinite-energy competitors impose no additional condition at a positive coupling.
We need the following local estimate for the unbounded density. For a compact set and any ,
The contribution from is bounded by local boundedness of and integrability of . On , the function is uniformly bounded for , by the upper quadratic bound and exponential decay. Its integral over is bounded by that supremum times . So if and , then
To see this, set and expand the difference as . The first term is controlled by (26); the second by . So bounded local modifications preserve finiteness of the energy.
Lemma 5.2 (Uniform regularity near the ball). Let lie in a compact subinterval of , and let be real-valued penalties with a common Lipschitz constant for the distance . Suppose minimize at volume and in . For all sufficiently large , their essential supports are uniformly bounded, and there exist such that
whenever and . Their boundaries are eventually spherical graphs converging to in for every .
Proof. Comparison with bounds and uniformly, since . Choose bounded neighborhoods with disjoint closures near two separated sphere patches, and smooth fields compactly supported in , with . Then for large . For the flows , bounded second derivatives of the Jacobian give a common interval on which the derivative of stays positive. Any volume correction can be made with . The tangential-Jacobian and local BV flow estimates give
Equations (26)–(27) and the penalty bound show that the full correction costs at most . If a preliminary modification leaves unchanged, the volume-change function and local perimeter in this argument are unchanged. The same cost estimate applies to the truncations and bounded local modifications below; their intermediate volumes are at most .
For outside the two correction neighborhoods, put and for almost every . The perimeter slicing identity reads
Removing the tail decreases the positive interaction energy. Whenever , restore its volume using either flow. Minimality, the correction estimate, and the isoperimetric inequality yield
Choose a fixed containing , , . Since , the correction is allowed and for and large . Where , it follows that . So all these tails vanish before a common finite radius .
Choose smaller than one quarter of the distance between , with . If is disjoint from , (28) is automatic. Otherwise all changes occur in a fixed enlarged ball. One is disjoint from ; use its flow to correct the volume error of , whose size is at most . The local perimeter on is still that of , even when is large. The correction costs and (27) then give by minimality. The exterior perimeter terms cancel, proving (28).
Since , this is area almost minimality with a common error . We apply the spherical convergence theorem in [14 Theorem 2.2]: uniform perimeter bounds and global convergence to imply eventual spherical graphs and convergence of their graph functions in , . □
Lemma 5.3 (Strict graph minimality implies strict minimality). Fix . If is a strict minimizer among sufficiently small normal graphs of volume , it is a strict local minimizer among all finite-perimeter sets of that volume. The constrained Hessian may have a kernel.
Proof. Choose a smooth compactly supported field with and on . The divergence formula gives . Positivity also gives , while . Writing , we get
If the assertion fails, choose with . For a fixed , minimize at volume . The direct method above applies to this nonnegative -continuous penalty. Its minimizers satisfy
The penalties have common Lipschitz constant . Lemma 5.2 makes the nonball sets eventually small graphs of the prescribed volume, a contradiction. □
Proposition 5.4 (A common finite exterior density barrier). Consider finitely many radial densities satisfying (25). Suppose that, at a common , the ball is a strict graph minimizer in each model, while every slightly larger coupling admits arbitrarily small equal-volume graphs of lower
energy than the ball. There exist , a bounded smooth nondecreasing radial function , zero on and positive outside, and a common finite , such that the modified densities have . The centered ball is their unique global minimizer for . All global minimizers converge to in as , uniformly over the choice of minimizer. The barrier preserves the exact energy near the ball, all ball data, and strict radial monotonicity when present.
Proof. Lemma 5.3 provides strict radii; let be their minimum. Choose with . Every of volume then satisfies , so is the unique minimizer in this hard-wall class. Fix , for example for and zero otherwise.
Work first with one density. If arbitrarily large finite strengths fail, there are and nonball global minimizers for at . Existence holds for each fixed . Comparison with and the isoperimetric inequality give a uniform perimeter bound and
The tightness estimate for the original density gives global convergence along a subsequence. Fatou’s lemma forces its limit to satisfy , so by strict positivity of the kernel. Lower semicontinuity gives , so . Strict minimality for the original density now contradicts
This proves that every sufficiently large finite strength works. Take the largest required threshold for the finitely many models and fix one common . The contradiction uses strict minimality for the fixed original density, so it needs no regularity bound uniform in .
For a finite-energy competitor and ,
gives strict uniqueness, since . Infinite-energy competitors are irrelevant for positive couplings. Graphs sufficiently close to lie in , so their exact energies are unchanged. The lower-energy competitors just above persist. For each such competitor at , and imply ; the same competitor defeats the ball at every . So the ball cannot become minimizing again, and . Parameter compactness and uniqueness at give the stated uniform convergence. Finally, on preserves local energies, and preserves strict radial monotonicity. The common addition also preserves agreement of the densities at all sufficiently large radii. Its fixed finite size preserves (25). □
Proposition 5.5 (Every global minimizer lies on the exact reduction graph). Fix one model after the finite barrier construction, with the reduction and energy estimate of Lemma 3.1. For all sufficiently small , every global minimizer has the form , where minimizes over a fixed small center neighborhood.
Proof. For any sequence , global minimizers converge to in by Proposition 5.4. Lemma 5.2, with zero penalty, gives small graphs. In exact volume coordinates write , . Compare the minimizer with the reduced shape at the same . Equation (12) gives
The estimate forces . Comparison with every other small reduced shape proves minimality in the center neighborhood. A sequence of counterexamples would contradict this argument, so the conclusion holds for every minimizer throughout a sufficiently small parameter interval. □
If the reduced minimizers form one rotation orbit, existence and rotation invariance imply that the global minimizers form the same orbit. All constants in this section concern fixed densities. We first fix the boundary derivatives, then the finite exterior barrier, and then shrink the parameter interval.
Proof of the main theorem
Proof of Theorem 1.1. Choose small enough for Lemma 2.2 and Proposition 3.2. Fix for the rest of the construction. Use Lemma 2.3 to realize (16), with the same second derivative and the two prescribed third derivatives. Call these preliminary densities . They preserve the common boundary value, first derivative, mass, Yukawa moment, and ball self-energy. Lemma 2.1 gives identical constrained Hessians for every coupling, including all degree-one and all high-degree modes. Both densities satisfy two-sided quadratic growth bounds and are strictly increasing.
Their quartics have positive angular minima
Lemma 3.1 gives strict graph minimality of the critical ball, and Lemma 5.3 upgrades it to strict local minimality. Choose the common exterior radius and a common finite barrier strength as in Proposition 5.4, and set
The increment is smooth, nonnegative, nondecreasing, bounded, and zero throughout , where . It preserves strict increase, quadratic growth, all the ball data, and the entire exact energy of every shape contained in . The two densities coincide away from the compact annuli supporting their preliminary perturbations.
Proposition 5.4 makes uniquely globally minimizing for . Proposition 4.2 gives near-ball competitors of lower energy for every sufficiently small ; these lie in and remain unchanged by the barrier. Proposition 5.4 then gives . The common linear threshold and its limit follow from Lemma 2.2.
Fix these two final densities. By compactness and uniqueness at , all their global minimizers converge to in as . Proposition 5.5 places every such minimizer on the exact reduction graph. Its center coordinate minimizes the reduced energy in a fixed small neighborhood. Proposition 4.2 identifies that minimizing set as the single prescribed rotation orbit. Global existence gives a point of each orbit, and rotation invariance makes the whole orbit globally minimizing. Taking the smaller of the two parameter neighborhoods gives the common . The stabilizers, convexity, and expansions (4) follow from the same proposition. □
A finite transmission calculation for the positive coefficient
We prove (17) by expanding the original shape energy to fourth order and eliminating the noncritical variables. The reduction in Lemma 3.1 uses the full shape equation.
All quantities in this calculation are Newtonian limits. Set
Along , , the radial height is
Add homogeneous corrections of orders to the interior and exterior radial ball potentials, with traces at . The radial factors on degree are and . Let and let and have multipliers and . The Poisson equation gives
Expanding continuity of the potential and its radial derivative at yields
At second order the base solution contributes to the value jump, and the first-order correction contributes . This gives . In the third-order derivative equation one uses and , which follow from the radial homogeneous equation. These identities fix the signs in (A.2).
For the system , , the exterior trace is . This gives
If is the coefficient of the exterior potential evaluated at the moving boundary, then
The density at that boundary is
Multiplication gives the nonlocal Euler gradient in exact volume coordinates, by (13).
Quadratic forcing. The cubic perimeter energy is , whose gradient at is . So the quadratic coefficient of the full projected gradient is
The constant channel is removed by the exact volume constraint.
Direct quartic coefficient. Pairing the cubic Euler-gradient coefficient with and dividing by four gives the direct quartic interaction energy. The part multiplying , modulo a multiple of , is
For the perimeter, expansion of the exact area integrand gives
Here and . We obtain
Exact complement elimination. The quadratic correction is . In degree four it contributes . This gives
There is a constant channel in (A.5), but none in this elimination sum.
Define . Since , and , so is exactly the coefficient of . The required data are
| 0 | excluded | excluded | |
| 2 | 4 | ||
| 4 | |||
| 6 |
Table A.7.
The last column follows from these projection values:
| 0 | 2 | 4 | 6 | |
| 0 | ||||
To compute them from (22), write the square of the homogeneous harmonic cubic as . Then , , , and the remainder is . Restriction to the sphere gives each projection.
Finally, (A.5)–(A.7) give
For positive , replace the radial powers by the normalized modified Bessel solutions and the Poisson equation by the Yukawa equation. Their boundary derivatives at the finitely many degrees involved converge to the data above. The denominators stay positive. This proves the finite coefficient continuity used in Proposition 3.2.
Independent algebraic check. The ancillary program check_transmission.py reconstructs the moving-boundary matching equations, the area expansion, and the Schur correction from polynomial operations over . It does not use fitted numerical values. The program check_angular.py checks the harmonic projections and angular Hessians using exact spherical moments. These programs check the finite algebraic calculations. The reduction and global minimization arguments are proved in the text.
Use of generative AI. ChatGPT (OpenAI) was used for language refinement and consistency checks. The authors reviewed and verified all content and take full responsibility for the final manuscript.
References
- [1]R. L. Frank. Non-spherical equilibrium shapes in the liquid drop model. Journal of Mathematical Physics 60 (2019), 071506. doi:10.1063/1.5095603. arXiv:1903.04344.DOI
- [2]F. De Regibus, M. Grossi, and M. Musso. Bifurcations in Isoperimetric Problems with Nonlocal Interactions. Preprint, 2026. arXiv:2604.19170v1.arxiv.org/abs/2604.19170
- [3]L. Bronsard, B. Merlet, and M. Pegon. Symmetry breaking in the liquid drop model with screened interactions. Preprint, 2025; revised 6 September 2026. arXiv:2510.11893v2.arxiv.org/abs/2510.11893
- [4]L. Bronsard, K. DeMason, and I. Topaloglu. The Liquid Drop Model with a Yukawa Potential: Existence of Minimizers and Sharp Stability of the Ball. Preprint, 2026. arXiv:2608.19340v1.arxiv.org/abs/2608.19340
- [5]S. Alama, L. Bronsard, I. Topaloglu, and A. Zuniga. A nonlocal isoperimetric problem with density perimeter. Calculus of Variations and Partial Differential Equations 60 (2021), article 1. doi:10.1007/s00526-020-01865-8.DOI
- [6]S. Alama, L. Bronsard, R. Choksi, and I. Topaloglu. Droplet breakup in the liquid drop model with background potential. Communications in Contemporary Mathematics 21(3) (2019), 1850022. doi:10.1142/S0219199718500220. arXiv:1708.04292v2.DOI
- [7]E. Ihrig and M. Golubitsky. Pattern selection with O(3) symmetry. Physica D 13 (1984), 1–33. doi:10.1016/0167-2789(84)90268-9.DOI
- [8]P. Chossat, R. Lauterbach, and I. Melbourne. Steady-state bifurcation with O(3)-symmetry. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis 113 (1991), 313–376. doi:10.1007/BF00374697.
- [9]Y. Chen, S. Hu, L. Qi, and W. Zou. Irreducible function bases of isotropic invariants of a third order three-dimensional symmetric and traceless tensor. Frontiers of Mathematics in China 14(1) (2019), 1–16. doi:10.1007/s11464-019-0748-x. arXiv:1712.02087.DOI
- [10]J.-P. Børnsen and A. E. M. van de Ven. Tangent Developable Orbit Space of an Octupole. Preprint, 2018. arXiv:1807.04817.
- [11]M. Dambrine and J. Lamboley. Stability in shape optimization with second variation. Journal of Differential Equations 267(5) (2019), 3009–3045. doi:10.1016/j.jde.2019.03.033. We use the corrected author version dated 20 September 2021: corrected full text.DOI
- [12]E. Acerbi, N. Fusco, and M. Morini. Minimality via second variation for a nonlocal isoperimetric problem. Communications in Mathematical Physics 322 (2013), 515–557. doi:10.1007/s00220-013-1733-y.DOI
- [13]M. Bonacini and R. Cristoferi. Local and global minimality results for a nonlocal isoperimetric problem on ℝ^N. SIAM Journal on Mathematical Analysis 46(4) (2014), 2310–2349. doi:10.1137/130929898.DOI
- [14]N. Fusco and V. Julin. A strong form of the quantitative isoperimetric inequality. Calculus of Variations and Partial Differential Equations 50 (2014), 925–937. doi:10.1007/s00526-013-0661-1. author manuscript. Theorem 2.2 records the spherical improved-convergence theorem of White used here.DOI
- [15]F. Maggi. Sets of Finite Perimeter and Geometric Variational Problems: An Introduction to Geometric Measure Theory. Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics 135. Cambridge University Press, 2012. doi:10.1017/CBO9781139108133.DOI