betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Ascending-descending and direct-inverse cascades of Reynolds stresses in turbulent Couette flow

Abstract

The interaction between small- and large-scale structures, and the coexisting bottom-up and top-down processes are studied in a turbulent plane Couette flow, where space-filling longitudinal rolls appear at relatively low values of the Reynolds number ReRe. A DNS database at Reτ=101Re_τ=101 is built to replicate the highest ReRe considered in a recent experimental work by Kawata and Alfredsson (Phys. Rev. Lett., vol.120, 2018, 244501). Our study is based on the exact budget equations for the second-order structure function tensor ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle δu_i δu_j \rangle, i.e. the Anisotropic Generalized Kolmogorov Equations (AGKE). The AGKE study production, redistribution, transport and dissipation of every Reynolds stress tensor component, considering simultaneously the physical space and the space of scales, and properly define the concept of scale in the inhomogeneous wall-normal direction. We show how the large-scale energy-containing motions are involved in the production and redistribution of the turbulent fluctuations. Both bottom-up and top-down interactions occur, and the same is true for direct and inverse cascading. The wall-parallel components ⟨δuδu⟩\langle δu δu \rangle and ⟨δwδw⟩\langle δw δw \rangle show that the both small and large near-wall scales feed the large scales away from the wall. The wall-normal component ⟨δvδv⟩\langle δv δv \rangle is different, and shows a dominant top-down dynamics, being produced via pressure-strain redistribution away from the wall and transferred towards near-wall larger scales via an inverse cascade. The off-diagonal component shows a top-down interaction, with both direct and inverse cascade, albeit the latter takes place within a limited range of scales.

Introduction

Provided the value of the Reynolds number ReRe is not too low, a typical wall-bounded turbulent flow features both large-scale structures located away from but extending down to the wall, and smaller-scale structures which dominate the near-wall region but populate the whole flow. In recent years, the top-down influence of large-scale structures has been thoroughly studied, and considerable efforts have been devoted to their statistical characterisation and to the understanding of the anomalous viscous scaling for the near-wall statistics attributed to the outer structures (see e.g. Smits et al. [27]). On the other hand, how the smaller-scale structures residing near the wall affect the large-scale structures away from the wall is less clear.

Early studies addressing such a bottom-up interaction attributed the existence of large-scale motions to agglomeration of smaller-scale events [10], while Toh & Itano [29] introduced the idea of a co-supporting cycle where the large structures are directly forced by the near-wall ones. There are also suggestions [7, 12] that large-scale motions in the outer layer can self-sustain and are nearly independent from the buffer layer. Such multi-scale interactions have come into focus only recently, one of the reason being that they become visible once the Reynolds number of the flow is large, owing to the required separation of scales. Moreover, they have been mostly studied in the turbulent channel flow, because of its geometrical simplicity. The tool of choice for such studies is often the spectral analysis of the transport equation for the components of the Reynolds stress tensor [22, 19]. A notable result is that in wall flows the (statistically dominant) energy transfer towards small scales is accompanied by an inverse transfer from small to large scales. However, spectral analysis can only observe energy fluxes in the space of scales, and the concept of scale is limited to homogeneous directions. An alternative tool, the Generalized Kolmogorov Equation (GKE), seems well suited for this analysis. The GKE was derived by Hill [11] as an exact budget equation for the second-order structure function: a separation in the inhomogeneous wall-normal direction can be defined, and a description of energy production, dissipation and energy fluxes in the compound space of scales and positions becomes possible.

The GKE has been used, in more or less simplified forms, to describe the effects of inhomogeneity on small-scale turbulence, most often for the plane channel flow, although for example Mollicone et al. [23] used the GKE to identify the coherent vortical structures in a separated turbulent flow behind a bump, Togni et al. [28] to describe Rayleigh–Bénard convection, Portela et al. [26] to address the turbulent cascades in the near wake of a square cylinder, and Cimarelli et al. [6] to investigate the entrainment and mixing processes in a turbulent planar temporal jet. Cimarelli et al. [4] applied the GKE to a turbulent channel flow and observed that energy fluxes originating in the near-wall region transfer energy backwards towards longer and wider turbulent structures as the distance from the wall increases, and then interact with smaller structures before eventually dissipating. In a further study, Cimarelli et al. [5] identified an additional energy source, which appears in the overlap layer as ReRe increases and leads to a complex spatial redistribution of energy which links small dissipative and large energy-containing scales through a mixed cascade. An inverse energy transfer from small- to large-scale motions has been also observed near the wall by Cho et al. [3] by means of the spectral TKE balance equation. They provided evidence that the large-scale motions near the wall scale in inner units, and Cheng et al. [2] revealed that the footprints of the large-scale motions manifest as large-scale regions of negative wall friction.

Less attention has been devoted to the plane turbulent Couette flow, where to our knowledge a GKE analysis has never been attempted. However, Couette is as geometrically simple as Poiseuille, and represents an interesting alternative for probing the inner/outer interactions at DNS-accessible Reynolds numbers. In fact, this is one of the most fundamental configurations of wall-bounded turbulence, where two indefinite parallel plates move at constant relative velocity and produce a purely shear-driven turbulence.

A key difference with the pressure-driven Poiseuille flow is that the mean velocity gradient for Couette does not vanish at the centerline, leading to a non-zero production of turbulent kinetic energy in the core region. Moreover, already at relatively low ReRe, Couette contains large-scale motions in the form of elongated streamwise vortices filling the space between the two walls: for example Tsukahara et al. [30] found evidence of these vortices already at Reτ=52Re_{\tau}=52, and Lee & Moser [18] described them at Reτ=93Re_{\tau}=93. These structures, traced down by Illingworth [13] to the linearized Squire and Orr–Sommerfeld operators, can be identified in both flows, but Couette creates stronger structures out of the mean shear (Andreolli et al. [1]). The mutual interaction between the large streamwise-elongated rolls and the smaller eddies in the turbulent flow is not entirely understood. Lee & Moser [19] discussing high-ReRe Poiseuille flow observed how energy is transferred more or less isotropically from the largest structures down to the dissipation scales via non-linear interactions. However, Kawata & Tsukahara [17] artificially constrained the wall-parallel dimensions of the computational domain for a Couette flow to indirectly characterise direct and inverse cascades, and used data computed from spanwise-minimal domains to suggest that the interscale energy transfers observed by Lee & Moser [19] with one-dimensional spanwise spectral analysis might pertain to the inner and outer dynamics, without actually representing their interactions. Kawata & Alfredsson [15] experimentally studied Couette flow via stereoscopic particle-image velocimetry, and were first to consider the Reynolds shear stress. They observed an inverse cascade from the small scales near the wall to the large scales away from the wall, but only for the shear stress. The inverse cascade mainly affects the near-wall region, and exerts a bottom-up influence from the near-wall region to the channel core. In their experimental study, Kawata & Alfredsson [15] had access to the three velocity components in nine wall-parallel planes (outside the near-wall region), and had to resort to the continuity equation to indirectly assess the wall-normal derivative of the wall-normal velocity component, whereas the remaining wall-normal derivatives were not considered in the transfer. Moreover, in their analysis the streamwise separation was neglected.

The present work comprehensively addresses the interscale exchanges across the wall-normal direction in a turbulent plane Couette flow, and builds upon a recent extension of the GKE (Gatti et al. [8]) that enables the observation of each component of the Reynolds stress tensor in the compound space of scales and wall distances. This extended tool, the Anisotropic Generalized Kolmogorov Equations or AGKE, will be used here to study a Couette flow computed with DNS at Reτ≈100Re_{\tau} \approx100, the highest ReRe considered by Kawata & Alfredsson [15]. Our aim is to address the mechanisms of direct/inverse cascading, and to identify bottom-up and top-down processes. The paper is organized as follows. First, in § 2 the budget equations for the structure function tensor are recalled, and the simulation which produced the DNS database used later for statistical analysis is briefly described. Then, in § 3 the main results concerning the components of the Reynolds stresses tensor are presented, and in § 4 a concluding discussion is given.

Methods

This work relies upon the AGKE budget equations as introduced by Gatti et al. [8] to tackle the inhomogeneity and the anisotropy of a generic turbulent flow. These equations are briefly recalled here for completeness.

The AGKE are exact budget equations for the second-order structure function tensor ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle; they derive from manipulation of the Navier–Stokes equations, and provide a dynamical description of turbulence both in the space of scales and at physical locations. The tensor ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle features the components of the increment of the fluctuating velocity vector δu=u(x′)−u(x)\delta\boldsymbol{u}=\boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{x}')-\boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{x}) between two points x\boldsymbol{x} and x′\boldsymbol{x}'; the midpoint and the separation vector are defined as X=(x′+x)/2\boldsymbol{X}=(\boldsymbol{x}'+\boldsymbol{x})/2 and r=x′−x\boldsymbol{r}=\boldsymbol{x}'-\boldsymbol{x}, respectively. In its most general form, the tensor ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle is a function of seven independent variables, i.e. the six coordinates of the vectors X,r\boldsymbol{X},\boldsymbol{r}, and the time tt. By definition, it combines the covariance VijV_{ij} of the velocity fluctuations and the spatial correlation tensor RijR_{ij}:

Figure 1. Sketch of the quantities involved in the definition of the second-order structure function tensor ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle. Velocities u\mathbf{u} and u′\mathbf{u}' are evaluated at the points x\mathbf{x} and x′\mathbf{x}' and used to define the increment δu\delta\mathbf{u}. The midpoint is X=(x′+x)/2\mathbf{X}=(\mathbf{x}'+\mathbf{x})/2, while the separation vector is r=x′−x\mathbf{r}=\mathbf{x}'-\mathbf{x}.

⟨δuiδuj⟩(X,r,t)=Vij(X,r,t)−Rij(X,r,t)−Rij(X,−r,t)(1)\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle(\mathbf{X},\mathbf{r},t)=V_{ij}(\mathbf{X},\mathbf{r},t)-R_{ij}(\mathbf{X},\mathbf{r},t)-R_{ij}(\mathbf{X},-\mathbf{r},t) \tag*{(1)}

where

Vij(X,r,t)=⟨uiuj⟩(X+r2,t)+⟨uiuj⟩(X−r2,t)(2)V_{ij}(\mathbf{X},\mathbf{r},t)=\langle u_i u_j\rangle\left(\mathbf{X}+\frac{\mathbf{r}}{2},t\right)+\langle u_i u_j\rangle\left(\mathbf{X}-\frac{\mathbf{r}}{2},t\right) \tag*{(2)}

is the sum of the covariances ⟨uiuj⟩\langle u_i u_j\rangle evaluated at the points X±r/2\mathbf{X}\pm\mathbf{r}/2 at time tt, and

Rij(X,r,t)=⟨ui(X+r2,t)uj(X−r2,t)⟩(3)R_{ij}(\mathbf{X},\mathbf{r},t)=\left\langle u_i\left(\mathbf{X}+\frac{\mathbf{r}}{2},t\right)u_j\left(\mathbf{X}-\frac{\mathbf{r}}{2},t\right)\right\rangle \tag*{(3)}

is the two-point spatial correlation tensor. For sufficiently large values of ∣r∣|\mathbf{r}|, the correlation vanishes, and ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle reduces to VijV_{ij}; thus at large separations the AGKE equations yield the sum of budget equations for the single-point Reynolds stresses at X±r/2\mathbf{X}\pm\mathbf{r}/2.

In the present work, which considers the Couette flow, the AGKE are applied to a statistically stationary flow where only the wall-normal direction yy or x2x_2 is statistically inhomogeneous; hence XX, ZZ and tt drop from the list of independent variables, which reduce to four, i.e. (rx,ry,rz,Y)(r_x,r_y,r_z,Y). Introducing the four-components vector of the scale and space fluxes (ϕk,ij,ψij)(\phi_{k,ij},\psi_{ij}) with k=1,2,3k=1,2,3, and the source term ξij\xi_{ij}, the AGKE are compactly written as:

∂ϕk,ij∂rk+∂ψij∂Y=ξij(4)\frac{\partial\phi_{k,ij}}{\partial r_k}+\frac{\partial\psi_{ij}}{\partial Y}=\xi_{ij} \tag*{(4)}

where repeated indices imply summation. The components of the vector of fluxes are defined as:

ϕk,ij=⟨δUδuiδuj⟩δk1⏟mean transport+⟨δukδuiδuj⟩⏟turbulent transport−2ν∂∂rk⟨δuiδuj⟩⏟viscous diffusionk=1,2,3(5)\phi_{k,ij}=\underbrace{\langle\delta U\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle\delta_{k1}}_{\text{mean transport}}+\underbrace{\langle\delta u_k\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle}_{\text{turbulent transport}}-\underbrace{2\nu\frac{\partial}{\partial r_k}\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle}_{\text{viscous diffusion}}\qquad k=1,2,3 \tag*{(5)}
ψij=⟨v∗δuiδuj⟩⏟turbulent transport+1ρ⟨δpδuj⟩δi2+1ρ⟨δpδui⟩δj2⏟pressure transport−ν2∂∂Y⟨δuiδuj⟩⏟viscous diffusion(6)\psi_{ij}=\underbrace{\langle v^*\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle}_{\text{turbulent transport}}+\underbrace{\frac{1}{\rho}\langle\delta p\delta u_j\rangle\delta_{i2}+\frac{1}{\rho}\langle\delta p\delta u_i\rangle\delta_{j2}}_{\text{pressure transport}}-\underbrace{\frac{\nu}{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial Y}\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle}_{\text{viscous diffusion}} \tag*{(6)}

and the source term as:

ξij=−⟨v∗δuj⟩(dUdy)δi1−⟨v∗δui⟩(dUdy)δj1−⟨δvδuj⟩(dUdy)∗δi1−⟨δvδui⟩(dUdy)∗δj1+1ρ⟨δp∂δui∂Xj⟩+1ρ⟨δp∂δuj∂Xi⟩−4ϵij∗(7)\begin{aligned} \xi_{ij}={}&-\langle v^*\delta u_j\rangle\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}U}{\mathrm{d}y}\right)\delta_{i1}-\langle v^*\delta u_i\rangle\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}U}{\mathrm{d}y}\right)\delta_{j1}\\ &-\langle\delta v\delta u_j\rangle\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}U}{\mathrm{d}y}\right)^*\delta_{i1}-\langle\delta v\delta u_i\rangle\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}U}{\mathrm{d}y}\right)^*\delta_{j1}\\ &+\frac{1}{\rho}\left\langle\delta p\frac{\partial\delta u_i}{\partial X_j}\right\rangle+\frac{1}{\rho}\left\langle\delta p\frac{\partial\delta u_j}{\partial X_i}\right\rangle-4\epsilon_{ij}^* \tag*{(7)} \end{aligned}

In the expression above, δij\delta_{ij} is the Kronecker delta, and the asterisk superscript f∗f^* denotes the generic quantity ff averaged between the two positions X±r/2\mathbf{X}\pm\mathbf{r}/2. The components of the vector of fluxes describe the flux of ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle in the space of scales and in the physical space by means of ϕk,ij\phi_{k,ij} and ψij\psi_{ij}, respectively. In each term, the mean and turbulent transport, the pressure transport and the viscous diffusion are recognized in analogy with the single-point budget equations for the Reynolds stresses ⟨uiuj⟩\langle u_i u_j\rangle [25]. The source term ξij\xi_{ij} describes the net production of ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle; in addition to production and dissipation, it also features a pressure-strain term, which redistributes turbulent energy among the different components of turbulent stresses.

It is worth pointing out that the AGKE terms possess analytical symmetries or anti-symmetries with respect to an inversion of the separation vector r\mathbf{r}; moreover, they additionally enjoy a statistical symmetry (or anti-symmetry) when both the wall-normal and streamwise coordinates are inverted. These symmetries, which are exploited in the numerical code to minimise the computational effort, have been reported by Gatti et al. [8] for the Poiseuille flow in their Appendix B, and are listed here in Appendix § 8 in the form valid for the Couette flow.

The DNS database and the AGKE code

The statistical analysis discussed in the following stems from the post-processing of a DNS database produced for a turbulent plane Couette flow at moderate Reynolds number. The two channel walls move with speed ±Uw\pm U_w along the streamwise xx direction and are separated in the wall-normal direction yy by a gap Ly=2hL_y=2h. The Reynolds number is defined as Re=Uwh/νRe=U_wh/\nu, where ν\nu is the kinematic viscosity of the fluid, and is set at Re=1666Re=1666 corresponding to a value for the Reynolds number based on the friction velocity uτ=τw/ρu_\tau=\sqrt{\tau_w/\rho} of Reτ=101.6Re_\tau=101.6. Throughout this work, all the quantities denoted with the superscript + are given in viscous units, i.e. normalized with uτu_\tau and ν\nu.

The simulation was carried out with the mixed-discretization DNS code introduced by Luchini & Quadrio [20], in which the incompressible Navier–Stokes equations are solved in the divergence-free space spawned by the wall-normal velocity vv and wall-normal vorticity η\eta by means of a pseudo-spectral method. A Fourier discretization is adopted in the homogeneous directions, and fourth-order compact explicit finite-differences schemes are used for the wall-normal derivatives. Temporal integration is partially implicit, with a third-order Runge–Kutta scheme for the explicit convective part and a second-order Crank–Nicolson scheme for the viscous terms treated implicitly.

The size of the computational domain is 12πh×2h×4πh12\pi h\times2h\times4\pi h (LxL_x, LyL_y and LzL_z respectively) in the streamwise, wall-normal and spanwise directions. The wall-parallel directions are discretized with Nx=Nz=384N_x=N_z=384 Fourier modes, including those required to exactly remove the aliasing error according to the 3/23/2 rule. In the wall-normal direction a hyperbolic tangent distribution for the Ny=128N_y = 128 points is used to obtain a more refined grid near the wall. The simulation is led to statistical equilibrium and then advanced in time for further 1500h/Uw1500h/U_w, during which one hundred equally spaced flow fields are stored for further analysis.

Figure 2 shows the wall-normal profiles of the streamwise mean velocity and of the diagonal terms of the Reynolds stress tensor; they are compared with those computed by Lee & Moser [18]. Considering that the Reynolds number is not identical, and that several other discretization choices differ (for example they employed a longer domain of Lx=20πhL_x = 20\pi h instead of Lx=12πhL_x = 12\pi h), the agreement is more than satisfactory. Figure 3 plots all the terms of the single-point budget for each non-zero component of the Reynolds tensor, and for the turbulent kinetic energy kk. In each panel, the residual of the budget is also plotted: the imbalance due to the finite averaging time is negligible, with a maximum of less than 1.8⋅10−51.8 \cdot10^{-5}.

Comparison of mean velocity profiles and diagonal Reynolds stresses

Figure 2. Comparison between the present results (color lines) and those by Lee & Moser [18] (black symbols), obtained at a slightly different ReRe. Left: mean velocity profile; right: diagonal Reynolds stresses.

Wall-normal profiles of the terms in the budget equation

Figure 3. Wall-normal profiles of the terms in the budget equation for ⟨uu⟩+\langle uu\rangle^{+}, ⟨vv⟩+\langle vv\rangle^{+}, ⟨ww⟩+\langle ww\rangle^{+}, ⟨−uv⟩+\langle-uv\rangle^{+} and k+k^{+}. The plots feature the turbulent transport (⋯\cdots), pressure transport, viscous diffusion, production, pressure strain and pseudo-dissipation. The black dashed line plots the imbalance of each equation.

The AGKE terms are computed from the database via a post-processing code that is derived with modifications from its Poiseuille counterpart described by Gatti et al. [8]. It also heavily relies on the numerical optimizations introduced by Gatti et al. [9] for a precursory GKE version, which computes correlations pseudo-spectrally whenever possible. For maximum accuracy, the derivatives in the homogeneous directions are computed in the Fourier space, whereas the derivatives in the wall-normal direction are evaluated by means of a finite-differences scheme with a five-points computational stencil. Since Couette and Poiseuille flows enjoy the same geometrical setting and in particular possess two homogeneous directions, the required modifications to the code from the Poiseuille version only involve changes to statistical symmetries. These changes are listed and discussed in Appendix § 8. For validation, the residual of the AGKE balance equations is computed to ensure that statistical convergence is reached; it is indeed found to be negligible everywhere in the four-dimensional AGKE space.

Results

Perhaps the most prominent feature of the turbulent Couette flow is the presence of elongated streamwise counter-rotating vortices which fill the gap between the moving walls. Before describing how these vortices affect the transport processes, the AGKE is used first to characterise these vortices. The analysis serves the dual purpose of discussing similarities and differences between Couette and Poiseuille flows, while demonstrating the effectiveness of the AGKE in discriminating quantitative characteristics of the turbulent structures. Figures comparing Poiseuille and Couette are presented when useful; the comparison is carried out with a turbulent Poiseuille flow at Reτ=200Re_{\tau}=200. Further details of this flow in the context of the AGKE can be found in Gatti et al. [8]. Note that such comparison is not unambiguous: owing to the different role of ReRe in the two flows (see for example Orlandi et al. [24]; Andreolli et al. [1]), which Reynolds number should be kept fixed is not established, and the comparison must be intended in a qualitative sense only.

The AGKE equations are always computed in the four-dimensional space (rx,ry,rz,Y)(r_x,r_y,r_z,Y), but in this work results are mostly presented in the three-dimensional space with rx=0r_x=0. In fact, the streamwise separation rxr_x is the least significant, because the large vortices are elongated in the xx direction, thus yielding the maximum correlation at rx=0r_x = 0. An important mention of the rx≠0r_x \ne0 case is made in the concluding discussion in § 4.

The large-scale rolls described via the AGKE

The quantitative characteristics of the large domain-filling streamwise rolls can be most easily identified by the structure function ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle, that is expected to present a maximum (i.e. largest negative correlation) at a spanwise scale rzr_z corresponding to the spanwise vortex size. Figure 4 shows a colormap for ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle drawn on the bounding planes ry+=0r_y^+ = 0, rz+=0r_z^+ = 0 and Y+=ry+/2Y^+ = r_y^+/2 of a box in the (rz+,ry+,Y+)(r_z^+,r_y^+,Y^+) space, and compares Couette (left) and Poiseuille (right). The domain is bounded by the inclined plane Y+=ry+/2Y^+ = r_y^+/2 owing to the separation ryr_y being constrained by the presence of the wall, i.e. ry<2Yr_y < 2Y. The presence of the Couette rolls with their large-scale energy footprint at the wall ([12, 18]) leads to a change of the position of the structure function maximum, which migrates towards larger spanwise separations. The position of the maximum increases from rz+=59r_z^+ = 59 in Poiseuille to rz+=183r_z^+ = 183 in Couette. The maximum region is for both flows located close to the wall at Y+≈20Y^+ \approx20, and extends for a wide range of spanwise scales. In Couette, however, large values of ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle are observed up to the channel centre; this is a striking difference with Poiseuille, and shows that the footprint of the rolls at the typical large spanwise scale rz+≈200r_z^+ \approx200 or rz≈2hr_z \approx2h extends throughout the whole channel. Analogously, the statistical trace of the rolls can be clearly identified also in ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle, ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle and ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle (not shown); Couette shows values of the structure functions significantly larger than VijV_{ij} up to the channel core. Table 1 reports value and position of the maxima of each component of the structure function tensor for the Couette flow, together with those of other AGKE terms discussed below.

Colormap of the structure function

Figure 4. Colormap of the structure function ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle in the rx+=0r_x^+ = 0 space, for Couette (left) and Poiseuille (right). The white marker locates the maximum of the structure function.

⟨δuiδuj⟩+\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle^+valuepositionξij+\xi_{ij}^+valueposition∣Πij+∣\lvert\Pi_{ij}^+\rvertvaluepositionPij+P_{ij}^+valueposition
i=j=1i=j=116.3(0,183,15)0.74(0,40,11)0.20(0,50,20)1.34(0,40,11)
i=j=2i=j=22.9(0,100,101)0.05(23,0,31)0.11(0,40,3)0-
i=j=3i=j=34.5(101,0,101)0.09(0,40,7)0.19(0,43,10)0-
i=1,j=2i=1,j=22.5(0,133,101)0.12(0,20,12)0.25(0,66,15)0.26(0,33,17)

Table 1. Maxima of ⟨δuiδuj⟩+\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle^+, source ξij+\xi_{ij}^+, absolute value of the pressure strain ∣Πij+∣\lvert\Pi_{ij}^+\rvert and production Pij+P_{ij}^+, and their positions in the (ry+,rz+,Y+)(r_y^+,r_z^+,Y^+) space for the Couette flow.

It is interesting to ascertain whether scales and positions where the structure function is largest show net production ξ11>0\xi_{11}>0. Figure 5 plots coloured contours of the source term ξ11\xi_{11} on the bounding planes, and an isosurface drawn in the volume at 75% of the maximum. Of particular interest here is the contour line ξ11=0\xi_{11}=0, discriminating regions and scales where there is net gain of ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle from those where there is net loss. Both flows present a region with net gain near the wall in correspondence of the buffer layer, i.e. Y+≈14Y^{+}\approx14. ξ11\xi_{11} peaks in this region at (ry+,rz+)≈(0,40)(r_{y}^{+},r_{z}^{+})\approx(0,40) indicating that in both cases the largest production of turbulent fluctuations is associated with the near-wall regeneration cycle ([14]). However, Couette features a second region with net positive production (of lower intensity) at the channel centre, at a spanwise scale of rz+≈150r_{z}^{+}\approx150. Since the pressure strain term Π11+\Pi_{11}^{+}, shown in Figure 6, and the dissipation D11+D_{11}^{+} (not shown) are negative (almost) everywhere, the local maximum of ξ11\xi_{11} at the centreline is unequivocally related to the positive production of the large rolls. Indeed, this positive source in the channel core, albeit of limited intensity because of the relatively low ReRe, implies that production P11+P_{11}^{+} is larger than the sum of pressure strain Π11+\Pi_{11}^{+} and dissipation D11+D_{11}^{+} for rz+∼150r_{z}^{+}\sim150. This production at the channel centre is absent in Poiseuille, where the anti-symmetry of the mean velocity gradient rules out any production. Interestingly, in Poiseuille a second tiny positive region can be identified, which is further from the wall but not at the centreline. Although based on this plot alone it might be interpreted as statistical noise, it is known ([8]) that this is an early appearance of the outer turbulence cycle, which becomes more and more evident as ReRe increases, but does not extend up to the centreline.

Colormap of the source term $\xi_{11}^{+}$ for Couette and Poiseuille

Figure 5. Colormap of the source term ξ11+\xi_{11}^{+} for Couette (left) and Poiseuille (right). The colormap on the bounding planes, with the thick line indicating the contour level ξ11+=0\xi_{11}^{+}=0, is plotted together with the isosurface ξ11+=0.55\xi_{11}^{+}=0.55, which is 75% of the maximum value.

Colormap of the pressure-strain term $\Pi^{+}_{11}$ for the Couette flow

Figure 6. Colormap of the pressure-strain term Π11+\Pi^{+}_{11} for the Couette flow. The grey isosurfaces mark the boundary of non-preferential energy transfer from streamwise fluctuations towards the others. Inner side: Π22+>Π33+\Pi^{+}_{22} > \Pi^{+}_{33}. Outer side: Π22+<Π33+\Pi^{+}_{22} < \Pi^{+}_{33}. The right panel is a top view and zoom of the left panel.

A key contributor to the source term is the redistribution provided by the pressure-strain term: Figure 6 plots the Π11+\Pi_{11}^{+} component as an example. It is (slightly) positive at all scales near the wall, but it is negative everywhere else: the streamwise fluctuations loose energy to feed the cross-stream components at all scales for Y+>2Y^{+}>2. The AGKE visualise at which scales and positions ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle is preferentially redistributed towards either ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle or ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle. In Figure 6 a grey isosurface is drawn to mark the boundary between the two situations. Following Gatti et al. (2020), the isosurface is defined by Π22+/Π11+=Π33+/Π11+=−0.5\Pi_{22}^{+}/\Pi_{11}^{+}=\Pi_{33}^{+}/\Pi_{11}^{+}=-0.5, with Π11+<0\Pi_{11}^{+}<0. In the fraction of the volume delimited by the grey isosurface towards the Y+Y^{+} axis, it is found that Π22+/Π11+<−0.5\Pi_{22}^{+}/\Pi_{11}^{+}<-0.5, hence Π11+\Pi_{11}^{+} preferentially redistributes streamwise fluctuations towards the wall-normal fluctuations. This occurs up to the channel centre, where it is true for all ry+r_{y}^{+} and rz+<100r_{z}^{+}<100 (see the zoomed right panel in Figure 6). On the remaining volume, instead, the preferential receiver of streamwise fluctuations energy is the spanwise component ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle. A similar picture was already observed in Poiseuille flow (Gatti et al. [8]), although here the preferential redistribution to ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle takes place within a narrower range of separations.

Note that the structure functions and the net productions peak at similar but not identical positions (see Table 1). These differences will be discussed in the following.

The diagonal components of ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle

We now proceed to study the interscale transfer processes in turbulent Couette flow. As a general observation, the transfers described by Gatti et al. [8] for the Poiseuille flow are visible here too: they look nearly identical for ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle and extremely similar for the other diagonal components. They attest the universality of the near-wall-turbulence cycle for the small scales. Hence, the following discussion will be mostly focused on bringing out the role of the large streamwise rolls, which are absent in Poiseuille.

The availability of fluxes in the AGKE enables a precise description of the transfer processes through their field lines, that visualise how the fluctuations are transferred among scales and positions. Although energy is not necessarily bound to be continuously transported along these lines, and the flow dynamics may be instantaneously very complex, the fluxes explain the different scales and positions at which ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle and ξij\xi_{ij} have their peak, and their field lines visualise and help understanding their spatial arrangement. Figure 7 plots the field lines of the flux vector Φ=(ϕy,ϕz,ψ)\boldsymbol{\Phi}=(\phi_y,\phi_z,\psi) for ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle, ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle and ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle. The lines are coloured by their divergence, i.e. ∇⋅Φ=∂ϕy/∂ry+∂ϕz/∂rz+∂ψ/∂Y\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Phi}=\partial\phi_y/\partial r_y+\partial\phi_z/\partial r_z+\partial\psi/\partial Y, and the colourmap shown in the background is for the corresponding source. While the field lines convey directional information, their colour code is meant to provide quantitative information about their energetic relevance: a positive value of ∇⋅Φ\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Phi} indicates fluxes energised by local mechanisms, while a negative value indicates fluxes releasing energy. Indeed, large positive values of ∇⋅Φ\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Phi} are observed in the vicinity of the points where the lines originate, whereas large negative values in the regions where they vanish.

Figure 7. Field lines of the vector of the fluxes Φ=(ϕy,ϕz,ψ)\boldsymbol{\Phi} = (\phi_y,\phi_z,\psi) coloured by its divergence ∇⋅Φ=∂ϕy/∂ry+∂ϕz/∂rz+∂ψ/∂Y\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Phi} = \partial\phi_y/\partial r_y + \partial\phi_z/\partial r_z + \partial\psi/\partial Y. Panel (a): ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle; panel (b): ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle; panel (c): ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle. Colour contours of the corresponding source term are shown on the bounding planes, with a black thick line indicating the zero level. The isosurfaces correspond to 75% of the source maximum, i.e. ξ11+=0.55\xi_{11}^{+} = 0.55, ξ22+=0.035\xi_{22}^{+} = 0.035, and ξ33+=0.07\xi_{33}^{+} = 0.07. In panel (c), the black dot is the origin of the field lines; the green dot is the singularity point from which other field lines originate.

The fluxes of ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle are considered first; see panel (a) of Figure 7. The major contributors to these fluxes are (not shown) the viscous and turbulent transport, with comparable intensity. The field lines of the total flux originating close to the maximum of ξ11\xi_{11} are analogous to those of the Poiseuille case, and show the same type of transfer; hence they are not discussed here (details can be found in Gatti et al. [8]). However, other field lines point to an additional transfer mechanism at work in Couette, which exchanges ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle between the near-wall structures and the large streamwise rolls. These lines originate near the wall but just beneath the source maximum in the core, i.e. at (ry+,rz+,Y+)≈(0,200,14)(r_y^{+},r_z^{+},Y^{+}) \approx(0,200,14), at a location in agreement with the peak of the spectral transfer of ⟨uu⟩\langle uu\rangle, placed by Kawata & Alfredsson [16] at rz+=160r_z^{+}=160 and Y+=18Y^{+}=18 in a Couette flow at Reτ=63Re_{\tau}=63. The lines show that part of the excess of ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle produced in the near-wall region is transferred towards the channel centre to feed scales and positions associated with the large rolls, indicating a bottom-up interaction. This is highlighted by ∇⋅Φ11\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Phi}_{11} which indicates that the fluxes are energised for Y+≤30Y^{+}\leq30 but release energy at larger distances. The rolls are therefore fed by both their own production and the wall turbulence itself. The field lines, once the channel core is reached, are repulsed by the region of positive source. Some lines (collectively referred to as set I) deviate towards the smallest spanwise scales. Others (set II) reach larger rzr_z. Panels (a) and (b) of Figure 8 describe quantitatively how ryr_y, rzr_z and YY evolve along a field line of each set, in terms of the normalised position ss along the line. In the same figure the position(s) along the lines where the divergence of the flux is zero is shown, thus identifying regions where energy is released or received. The excess of ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle associated with the spanwise rolls is dissipated at both the smallest scales via the usual direct cascade (set I) and at the large uncorrelated motions via a mixed cascade (set II), in which ryr_y decreases while rzr_z increases. The sink where the lines of set I end is mainly due to viscous effects, whereas along lines of set II energy is lost owing to a combined effect of pressure-strain and viscosity.

Four-panel evolution plots of $r_y^+$, $r_z^+$ and $Y^+$ along representative field lines

Figure 8. Evolution of the values of ry+r_y^+ (blue solid), rz+r_z^+ (red dashed) and Y+Y^+ (green dash-dotted) along a representative field line for ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle set I (a) and set II (b); (c) for ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle and (d) for ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle. The dimensionless arch length ss is defined as s=1/smax⁡∫0smax⁡dss=1/s_{\max}\int_{0}^{s_{\max}}ds, with ds=dry2+drz2+dY2ds=\sqrt{dr_y^2+dr_z^2+dY^2}. The black vertical lines mark the position where the divergence changes sign along the line.

The mutual connection between the near-wall region and the channel core is also evident by looking at the other wall-parallel component ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle. Like ξ11\xi_{11}, the source ξ33\xi_{33} peaks in the near-wall region at (ry+,rz+,Y+)=(0,40,7)(r_y^+,r_z^+,Y^+)=(0,40,7) and has large positive values up to the channel centre at rz+≈100r_z^+\approx100 (see Figure 7b). However, in this case the positive source is due to the redistribution of the streamwise component of the turbulent energy via the pressure-strain term, since the production P33P_{33} term is zero as ∂W/∂y=0\partial W/\partial y=0. Unlike for ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle, all the field lines of ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle originate close to the maximum of the source, i.e. at (ry+,rz+,Y+)=(12,26,13)(r_y^+,r_z^+,Y^+)=(12,26,13). They are mainly determined (not shown) by the turbulent contribution, the viscous flux being smaller in magnitude. Again, some lines resemble those of Poiseuille vanishing at the smallest scales along the YY axis, but others provide a bottom-up transfer of ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle from the smaller near-wall structures to the large spanwise rolls. Indeed, panel (c) of Figure 8 shows that part of the excess of ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle near the wall first feeds the large spanwise rolls via an inverse cascade (see the first part of the lines where both rzr_z and ryr_y increase) and then dissipates at ry→0r_y\to0 and large rzr_z via a mixed cascade (ryr_y decreases and rzr_z increases); note again that ∇⋅Φ33\nabla\cdot\Phi_{33} is positive in the near-wall region and negative away from the wall where the fluxes release energy to the large-scale structures. Overall, a bottom-up transfer of ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle is observed together with an inverse cascade followed by a mixed cascade.

Finally, ξ22\xi_{22} too peaks in the near-wall region for scales and positions associated with the near-wall cycle, i.e. (ry+,rz+,Y+)=(24,0,31)(r_y^+,r_z^+,Y^+)=(24,0,31), and it is positive up to the channel centre with a local maximum at (ry+,rz+,Y+)≈(120,0,100)(r_y^+,r_z^+,Y^+)\approx(120,0,100) (see Figure 7c). As for ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle, positive values of ξ22\xi_{22} mean that Π22\Pi_{22} is positive and larger than ∣D22∣\lvert D_{22}\rvert since the production term of ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle is null. Therefore, the pressure strain feeds the vertical fluctuations at both the small near-wall scales and the large scales away from the wall, yielding a net production of ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle. Field lines at the small scales near the wall are analogous to the Poiseuille case. Lines intercepting larger scales, instead, clearly show a top-down transfer, with scales away from the wall feeding the near-wall structures. The pressure spatial transfer dominates the flux, although viscous scale transfer and turbulent scale transfer play a role at small and large scales respectively. Some lines originate at (ry+,rz+,Y+)=(130,60,101)(r_y^+,r_z^+,Y^+)=(130,60,101), a point marked by the black dot in Figure 7c. These fluxes are further energised by the excess of ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle in the region with ry→0r_y\to0 and larger rzr_z, as indicated by the positive ∇⋅Φ22\boldsymbol{\nabla}\cdot\boldsymbol{\Phi}_{22}. Then they release ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle in the near-wall region (∇⋅Φ22<0\boldsymbol{\nabla}\cdot\boldsymbol{\Phi}_{22}<0) and eventually vanish at the wall where ξ22<0\xi_{22}<0 due to the negative contribution of both the dissipation and (mainly) the pressure strain. The negative Π22\Pi_{22} in the vicinity of the wall, together with the positive Π11\Pi_{11} (see Figure 6) and Π33\Pi_{33} (not shown), indicates that the vertical fluctuations turn into wall-parallel ones owing to the splatting effect ([21]) present in all wall-bounded flows. Other lines originate from a singularity point at (ry+,rz+,Y+)=(120,280,100)(r_y^+,r_z^+,Y^+)=(120,280,100) (green dot in the same figure) where again ξ22>0\xi_{22}>0. These lines are straight at first with YY and ryr_y remaining constant (although Figure 7c only shows those going towards lower rzr_z), with further energised fluxes; then they reorient towards the wall and become nearly vertical, i.e. ryr_y and rzr_z remain constant, as they are attracted by the sink at the wall. Before vanishing at the wall these fluxes release ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle in the near-wall region over a wide range of scales. Overall, the excess of ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle produced away from the wall at large ryr_y due to the pressure-strain action feeds a wide range of scales in the near-wall region, where ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle is dissipated due to the combined action of pressure-strain and viscosity.

Although studying how these statistics change with increasing values of ReRe is not the primary concern of this paper, it can be anticipated that the ReRe effects do not qualitatively alter the general picture, since Reτ=100Re_\tau=100 is already large enough for the outer structures to develop. To confirm this, we have processed a dataset at Reτ=500Re_\tau=500 taken from Andreolli et al. [1]; as an example, results for the ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle component are provided in Figure 9. The top panel plots the structure function itself. Compared to Figure 4 (left), the near-wall peak is now accompanied by a visible outer peak at rz≈2hr_z\approx2h, and the contours still extend to the centreline. The lower panel, to be compared to the plane at ry=0r_y=0 in Figure 7a, portrays fluxes and the source term. The field lines still originate near the wall at rz≈2hr_z\approx2h, and proceed towards larger YY to give birth to set I and II. The near-wall maximum of the source is connected to the near-wall cycle and thus scales in wall units, whereas the outer maximum becomes more evident. The source term at low ReRe is dominated by production and its outer maximum is exactly at the centreline, whereas at Reτ=500Re_\tau=500 the source maximum associated to the outer cycle is found at Y+≈250Y^+\approx250: the large-scale production keeps peaking at the centreline (not shown), but the source term also contains non-negligible contributions from pressure strain, and has its maximum around the scale and the wall-normal distance of the outer cycle.

Top: $\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle$ at $Re_\tau=500$ at $r_x=r_y=0$; bottom: field lines of the fluxes of $\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle$

Figure 9. Top: ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle at Reτ=500Re_\tau=500 at rx=ry=0r_x=r_y=0. Bottom: field lines of the fluxes of ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle coloured with their magnitude, with colormap of the source term shown in the background (black thick lines indicate the zero level).

In summary, the AGKE reveals the existence of an inverse energy cascade for ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle and ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle, coupled with an ascending spatial transport that spans the whole domain. On the contrary, ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle, which is governed by the redistribution term Π22\Pi_{22}, shows a top-down transport. As discussed later in § 4, this picture partially differs from the description by [15], where the diagonal components of the Reynolds stress tensor reportedly present a top-down transfer with a direct cascade only.

The off-diagonal component −δuδv-\delta u\delta v

The interaction between the large-scale dynamics and the near-wall turbulence is also observed in the off-diagonal component of the structure function tensor ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle. Like the single-point quantity ⟨−uv⟩\langle-uv\rangle, this component is not defined in its sign, hence ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle should not be interpreted in terms of energy. The transfer of ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle is shown in Figure 10a, where field lines of the fluxes are plotted together with the source term ξ12\xi_{12}. Fluxes taking place at scales and positions associated with the near-wall cycle are similar to Poiseuille and are not discussed here; for clarity the associated lines are not shown in Figure 10a. The remaining field lines are mainly determined (not shown) by the pressure spatial transport, although scale turbulent transport is comparable. Turbulent transport and viscous diffusion are the only non-zero contributions in the scale space, the latter dominating at the small scales and the former at the large scales. The flux lines originate from a straight line placed at large wall-normal distances (Y+=85Y^+=85 and ry+=170r_y^+=170), where ξ12\xi_{12} is positive, and involve all spanwise separations (to simplify Figure 10a, field lines are only plotted for a range of spanwise separations, and a black straight line indicates where they originate). These lines are bound to be tangent to the plane Y+=h+Y^+=h^+, because the symmetries of the terms involved in the budget equation for ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle imply ψ12=0\psi_{12}=0 at the centreline for rx+=0r_x^+=0 (see Appendix § 8). Starting from this straight line, some field lines bend and descend vertically towards the wall attracted by the sink ξ12<0\xi_{12}<0. On the contrary, other field lines direct first towards smaller vertical scales and then descend towards the wall. Overall, ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle is transferred from the central region, where it is maximum, towards the wall region, indicating again that the large rolls interact with the near-wall structures.

Field lines and representative trajectories for sets I, II.a and II.b

Figure 10. Off-diagonal component ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle. Top: field lines of the vector of the fluxes (ϕy,12,ϕz,12,ψ12)(\phi_{y,12},\phi_{z,12},\psi_{12}), coloured by their divergence and grouped in sets I and II. Colour contours of the source term ξ12+\xi_{12}^{+} are shown on the bounding planes, with a black thick line indicating the zero contour level. The black straight line placed at Y+=85Y^{+}=85 and ry+=170r_{y}^{+}=170 indicates all the spanwise separations from which some field lines originate. The yellow isosurface corresponds to ξ12+=0.09\xi_{12}^{+}=0.09. The top right panel is a zoomed top view of the lines of set II. The evolution of ry+r_{y}^{+} (—), rz+r_{z}^{+} (—) and Y+Y^{+} (—) along a representative field line from sets I, II.a and II.b are shown in the lower panels, in which the black vertical lines mark the position where the divergence changes sign along the line.

The lines going towards smaller ryr_y can be further divided into two topologically distinct groups, named set I and set II. While reducing their ryr_y, the two line sets diverge from each other. Those of set I go towards smaller rzr_z and smaller YY being attracted by the region with negative source at rz+=0r_z^{+}=0 (see the dark blue region in Figure 10a); at rz+→0r_z^{+}\to0 and small ryr_y they collapse onto a single line that first sticks to the plane rz+=0r_z^{+}=0 and then turns to become a well defined line at Y+=50Y^{+}=50 and rz+=100r_z^{+}=100. While descending towards the wall, they release ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle as indicated by the negative values of −∇⋅Φ12-\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Phi}_{12}. Conversely, while reducing their ryr_y, lines of set II are repulsed by the positive peak of ξ12+\xi_{12}^{+} on the ry+=0r_y^{+}=0 plane. Some lines remain at large Y+Y^{+} and release ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle at the smallest scales, ending up on the vertical axis corresponding to zero separations. Most of them, however, release ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle at larger rz+r_z^{+} and lower Y+Y^{+} and eventually vanish at the wall.

The lower panels in Figure 10 help understanding how separations and the wall-normal position change along selected lines of each set. For set I, the transport of ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle at first follows the classical energy cascade: the spanwise separation decreases while the transfer takes place from the channel centre towards the wall, until rz+≈0r_z^{+}\approx0 is reached. In a later stage, ry+r_y^{+} and Y+Y^{+} increase again, and eventually after the turn they become locked at ry+=100r_y^{+}=100 and Y+=50Y^{+}=50, while rz+r_z^{+} increases. For set II, for which a zoom is available in Figure 10b, the lines of subset II.b simply direct towards the Y+Y^{+} axis to dissipate. Those of

bottom-uptop-downdirectinverse
kkyesyesyes
⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangleyesset Iset II
⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangleyesyes
⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangleyesyes
⟨δuδv⟩\langle\delta u\delta v\rangleyesset Iset II.a

caption: Types of transport observed in a turbulent Couette flow.

subset II.a, instead, show first a continuous decrease of both ry+r_y^+ and rz+r_z^+, then the wall-normal separation remains constant at ry+≈7r_y^+ \approx7 as rz+r_z^+ increases, while Y+Y^+ initially remains constant and reduces afterwards to reach zero value. On such lines an inverse cascade is observed, albeit in a limited range of scales, namely 5<ry+<105 < r_y^+ < 10 and 20<rz+<13520 < r_z^+ < 135, while a spatial transfer starts from the channel centre and proceeds towards the wall.

Concluding discussion

The transfer of Reynolds stresses has been considered component-wise in a turbulent Couette flow by means of the Anisotropic Generalized Kolmogorov Equations or AGKE, which provide a complete and quantitative description of direct and inverse cascades in the space of scales as well as transfers in the wall-normal direction, for each component of the Reynolds stress tensor. The field lines of the fluxes of Reynolds stresses naturally visualize cascading in physical and scale spaces. When fluxes are observed along the wall-normal direction, top-down and bottom-up processes can be discerned; conversely, when fluxes across scales are considered, direct and inverse cascades are observed. The study builds upon a DNS database, produced for this study at Reτ=101.6Re_\tau= 101.6, which matches the largest ReRe considered in the experimental study of Kawata & Alfredsson [15]. What makes the Couette flow particularly interesting in the present context is its non-zero mean velocity gradient at the centreline, which enables turbulence production, and the presence of large-scale spanwise rolls, whose interaction with the smaller turbulent structures is not entirely understood.

The turbulent Couette flow shows a rich scenario, where direct and inverse cascades coexist, together with bottom-up and top-down interactions. While some of these patterns are also present in plane Poiseuille flow, Couette features some peculiarities, which have been addressed by the present study.

The statistical trace of the large rolls is clearly observed in the structure function ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle. In particular, ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle is significantly larger than the local covariance in a region encompassing a well-defined spanwise scale of rz+≈200r_z^+ \approx200 or rz≈2hr_z \approx2h throughout the whole channel height, with local maxima in the buffer layer and in the core. At the channel centre the source term ξ11\xi_{11} is positive and quantifies the contribution of the large-scale structures to the overall production; by increasing ReRe the maximum of the source moves towards the wall, because of the relative increased importance of the pressure-strain redistribution, which negatively contributes to the source.

Studying the field lines of the flux vector Φ=(ϕy,ϕz,ψ)\boldsymbol{\Phi} = (\phi_y,\phi_z,\psi) brings to light the transfer processes among scales and positions. The two wall-parallel components, ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle and ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle, are mainly transferred from the large and small scales near the wall towards larger scales away farther from it. The excess of energy produced near the wall partially feeds the large spanwise rolls, pointing to a scenario of bottom-up transport. In terms of cascade, ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle features both direct and inverse cascades, whereas the fluxes of ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle reveal the coexistence of an inverse and a mixed cascade. The ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle component behaves differently, as expected, and shows a top-down transfer where both inverse and mixed cascades occur. The surplus of ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle at the channel core, supplied by the pressure-strain term Π22\Pi_{22}, is transferred towards the near-wall region via two mechanisms. In the first, small rzr_z scales away from the wall feed near-wall eddies with larger spanwise but lower wall-normal scales. In the second, large rzr_z-scale motions placed at the channel core feed near-wall motions over a wide range of scales. The off-diagonal component ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle mainly features a top-down transfer with both direct and inverse cascades, although the inverse one is restricted to a confined range of ry+r_y^+ and rz+r_z^+. The dominant transport processes in both the space of scales and in the physical space are summarised in Table 2.

This picture of interscale transfers confirms the conclusions of Kawata & Alfredsson [15], who found an influence of the small near-wall scales upon the large scales away from the wall. However, the present AGKE analysis offers more insight, thanks to its ability to precisely discriminate the various processes and the scales and positions at which they take place. Some of the extra details brought forward here for the first time are not in agreement with the existing broad picture. Kawata & Alfredsson [15] pointed out that the production of turbulent kinetic energy at large scales is supported by the small near-wall scales by means of the Reynolds shear stress that is transferred from small to large scales throughout the channel. Moreover, they observed a transfer of turbulent kinetic energy from the large scales away from the wall to the small near-wall scales. While the general trend of near-wall scales feeding the large structures at the channel core is confirmed, the present results reveal different space- and scale-transfers and therefore different sustaining mechanisms. We reveal that the Reynolds shear stress ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle is mainly transferred from the large scales in the channel core to the near-wall region, where it is released at both small and large scales. On the contrary, for the turbulent kinetic energy we have described a complex picture, with a bottom-up transfer for the wall-parallel components ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle and ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle and a top-down transfer for the vertical one ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle. Thus, the present scenario indicates that the large-scale structures away from the wall are maintained by their production mechanism and by the transfer of the uu- and ww- energy contributions from the large and small near-wall scales respectively. In turn, the large-scale motions away from the wall support the near-wall motions, as shown by the transfers of ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle, and their production mechanism through the top-down transfer of ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle.

Kawata & Tsukahara [17], based on their spectral analysis, provided a schematic model to explain the self-sustaining cycle of the large vortices in the Couette flow. The current AGKE analysis confirms the essence of their model, while bringing in some additional details. The model by Kawata & Tsukahara [17] starts by observing that ⟨uu⟩\langle uu\rangle energy is present at the large scales: this is seen by the positive production at large streamwise scales (figure 10 in their paper), which descends from a positive shear coupled with the positive ⟨−uv⟩\langle-uv\rangle produced by the large-scale ⟨vv⟩\langle vv\rangle (its origin is explained below). Then ⟨uu⟩\langle uu\rangle is transferred towards smaller scales as shown by the interscale-transfer term (figure 11 in their paper), following a mechanism described as destabilization of the streaks. At the small scales, the pressure-strain mechanism redistributes ⟨uu⟩\langle uu\rangle towards ⟨vv⟩\langle vv\rangle and ⟨ww⟩\langle ww\rangle, and feeds the small-scale streamwise vortices (figure 12 in their paper). Finally, ⟨ww⟩\langle ww\rangle is transferred from the small scales to the large scales. Here the pressure strain redistributes ⟨ww⟩\langle ww\rangle towards ⟨vv⟩\langle vv\rangle, leading to a production for ⟨−uv⟩\langle-uv\rangle and, consequently, for ⟨uu⟩\langle uu\rangle at the large-scales. The loop is thus closed.

Our analysis is consistent with this view, yet the picture is slightly different and enriched. Figure 11 schematically shows the model of the closed-loop self-sustaining mechanism based on the AGKE results. The main difference is that with the AGKE the transfer among scales at different YY becomes observable, so that the model can be described as follows. Large ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle energy found at rz+≈180r_z^+ \approx180 and Y+≈15Y^+ \approx15 is the statistical trace of large-scale streaks (see Figure 4). They are fed by the mean shear and by the positive ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle, associated with the large-scale rolls and released from the fluxes at these large spanwise separations close to the wall. The excess of ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle associated with the streaks is transferred to both larger and smaller scales, as well as both towards and away from the wall, by the combined action of viscous diffusion and turbulent transport. The most part is transferred away from the wall (see Figure 7a), where pressure strain redistributes ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle towards the cross-stream components. Hence, these transfers and the pressure-strain activity explain how the large-scale streaks feed the large-scale vortices.

Image not extracted

Figure 11. Schematic model of the closed-loop sustaining mechanism for ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle in the rx=0r_x=0 space, associated with the large-scale motions.

The fluxes of ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle (Figure 7b) indicate that the spanwise fluctuations of the large spanwise rolls are fed not only by the pressure-strain redistribution, but also by the near-wall cycle. At large YY and large rzr_z the large ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle together with the mean shear generate positive production for ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle. The produced ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle is then transferred towards the wall via pressure transport, and part is released by the fluxes at rz+≈150r_z^+ \approx150 (family II.a in Figure 10). The resulting positive ⟨−δuδv⟩\langle-\delta u\delta v\rangle, joint with the mean shear, is responsible for P11>0P_{11}>0 thus sustaining the large-scale streaks. The loop is thus closed.

Although so far the streamwise separation has not been considered, it must be said that concerns have been recently raised on the conclusions derived from such partial observations neglecting streamwise separations/wavenumbers. For example, Kawata & Tsukahara [17] found via a spanwise-Fourier-mode analysis that an inverse transfer of ⟨uu⟩\langle u u\rangle is still present when the computational domain is restricted in its spanwise size to remove the outer structures. Hence, such mechanism would not represent an interaction between the near-wall cycle and the large outer structures, as confirmed by the absence of an inverse cascade in the analysis of the streamwise Fourier modes. They suggested that this may be related to the self-sustaining cycle of the inner and/or outer structures. To address this point, we show in Figure 12 fluxes for ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle and ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle in the three-dimensional space at ry=0r_y=0 that considers the streamwise separation too.

Image not extracted

Figure 12. Field lines of the vector of the fluxes in the (rx,rz,Y)(r_x,r_z,Y) space, for ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle (left) and ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle (right). Colour contours of the corresponding source term are shown on the bounding planes. The flux lines are coloured with the flux magnitude.

For ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle the lines associated to the large scales originate at rx=0r_x=0, thus their starting point is the same as in the rx=0r_x=0 space. They develop both close to the wall and at larger YY; streamwise energy is transferred via both direct and inverse cascades. These lines can thus be interpreted, as done in the previous analysis with rx=0r_x=0, as part of the self-sustaining cycle of the large-scale rolls. The lines of ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle confirm that they initially possess small spanwise separations (much like in the channel flow) and then move towards large rzr_z and large YY, indicating again an interaction of the small scales of the near-wall cycle with the large spanwise rolls located away from the wall. Thus, looking at rx=0r_x=0 already seems to provide the correct picture, and suggests that ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle is driven by an autonomous large-scale mechanism and the transfers of ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle describe an interaction between the near-wall cycle and the large outer structures.

The present analysis has mostly considered a single, relatively low value of the Reynolds number, and thus its extension to higher ReRe remains interesting and useful. Nevertheless, already at this ReRe, thanks to their capability to properly define the concept of scale in the wall-normal direction and to provide a detailed view of each component of the Reynolds stress tensor, the AGKE have been essential to understand and describe the interaction between the near-wall turbulence and the elongated rolls of the turbulent Couette flow.

Acknowledgments

The authors acknowledge computing support by the state of Baden-Württemberg through bwHPC. D.G. acknowledges partial support by the Priority Programme SPP 1881 Turbulent Superstructures of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft.

Funding

This research received no specific grant from any funding agency, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.

Declaration of Interests

The authors report no conflict of interest.

Symmetries

The symmetries in the terms of the AGKE equations are listed below for the case of the plane Couette flow.

The terms appearing in the budget equations of ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle, ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle, ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle and ⟨δuδv⟩\langle\delta u\delta v\rangle are first considered. The inversion of rr and of the spanwise coordinate zz lead to the same symmetries as in the Poiseuille flow [8]. r→−rr \to-r leads to ϕ→−ϕ\phi\to-\phi, ψ→ψ\psi\to\psi, ξ→ξ\xi\to\xi and ⟨δuiδui⟩→⟨δuiδui⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_i\rangle\to\langle\delta u_i\delta u_i\rangle; z→−zz \to-z implies rz→−rzr_z \to-r_z and consequently ϕx→ϕx\phi_x \to\phi_x, ϕy→ϕy\phi_y \to\phi_y, ϕz→−ϕz\phi_z \to-\phi_z, ψ→ψ\psi\to\psi, ξ→ξ\xi\to\xi and ⟨δuiδui⟩→⟨δuiδui⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_i\rangle\to\langle\delta u_i\delta u_i\rangle. On the contrary, the inversion of the wall-normal coordinate yy leads to different symmetries compared to the Poiseuille flow, as it implies also the inversion of the streamwise coordinate xx. It leads to Y→−YY \to-Y, rx→−rxr_x \to-r_x, ry→−ryr_y \to-r_y and consequently ϕx→−ϕx\phi_x \to-\phi_x, ϕy→−ϕy\phi_y \to-\phi_y, ϕz→ϕz\phi_z \to\phi_z, ψ→−ψ\psi\to-\psi, ξ→ξ\xi\to\xi and ⟨δuiδui⟩→⟨δuiδui⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_i\rangle\to\langle\delta u_i\delta u_i\rangle.

The terms involved in the budget equations of ⟨δuδw⟩\langle\delta u\delta w\rangle and ⟨δvδw⟩\langle\delta v\delta w\rangle are now considered. In comparison to the other components, their symmetries are the same for an inversion of rr but differ when the inversions of zz or yy (and xx) are considered. When zz is inverted the AGKE terms undergo ϕx→−ϕx\phi_x \to-\phi_x, ϕy→−ϕy\phi_y \to-\phi_y, ϕz→ϕz\phi_z \to\phi_z, ψ→−ψ\psi\to-\psi, ξ→−ξ\xi\to-\xi and ⟨δuiδui⟩→−⟨δuiδui⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_i\rangle\to-\langle\delta u_i\delta u_i\rangle, as in the Poiseuille flow. The inversion of yy (and xx) leads to ϕx→ϕx\phi_x \to\phi_x, ϕy→ϕy\phi_y \to\phi_y, ϕz→−ϕz\phi_z \to-\phi_z, ψ→ψ\psi\to\psi, ξ→−ξ\xi\to-\xi and ⟨δuiδui⟩→−⟨δuiδui⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_i\rangle\to-\langle\delta u_i\delta u_i\rangle for ⟨δuδw⟩\langle\delta u\delta w\rangle and ⟨δvδw⟩\langle\delta v\delta w\rangle.

Overall, these symmetries imply that some terms of the AGKE are zero in particular regions of the four-dimensional domain. These regions (except the trivial case of r=0r = 0) are listed below for each component ⟨δuiδuj⟩\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle. For notational simplicity the origin of the wall-normal coordinate is shifted to the centreline of the channel.

For ⟨δuδu⟩\langle\delta u\delta u\rangle, ⟨δvδv⟩\langle\delta v\delta v\rangle, ⟨δwδw⟩\langle\delta w\delta w\rangle and ⟨δuδv⟩\langle\delta u\delta v\rangle:

ϕx(Y,0,0,rz)=0ϕy(Y,0,0,rz)=0ϕz(Y,rx,ry,0)=0ψ(0,rx,ry,rz)=0.\begin{aligned} \phi_x(Y,0,0,r_z) &= 0 \\ \phi_y(Y,0,0,r_z) &= 0 \\ \phi_z(Y,r_x,r_y,0) &= 0 \\ \psi(0,r_x,r_y,r_z) &= 0. \end{aligned}

For ⟨δuδw⟩\langle\delta u\delta w\rangle and ⟨δvδw⟩\langle\delta v\delta w\rangle:

ϕx(Y,rx,ry,0)=0ϕy(Y,rx,ry,0)=0ϕz(Y,0,0,rz)=0ψ(Y,rx,ry,0)=0ψ(Y,0,0,rz)=0ψ(0,rx,ry,rz)=0ξ(Y,rx,ry,0)=0ξ(Y,0,0,rz)=0⟨δuiδuj⟩(Y,rx,ry,0)=0⟨δuiδuj⟩(Y,0,0,rz)=0.\begin{aligned} \phi_x(Y,r_x,r_y,0) &= 0 \\ \phi_y(Y,r_x,r_y,0) &= 0 \\ \phi_z(Y,0,0,r_z) &= 0 \\ \psi(Y,r_x,r_y,0) &= 0 \qquad\psi(Y,0,0,r_z) = 0 \\ \psi(0,r_x,r_y,r_z) &= 0 \\ \xi(Y,r_x,r_y,0) &= 0 \qquad\xi(Y,0,0,r_z) = 0 \\ \langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle(Y,r_x,r_y,0) &= 0 \qquad\langle\delta u_i\delta u_j\rangle(Y,0,0,r_z) = 0. \end{aligned}

References

  1. [1]Andreolli, A., Quadrio, M. & Gatti, D. 2021 Global energy budgets in turbulent Couette and Poiseuille flows. J. Fluid Mech. 924, A25–20.
  2. [2]Cheng, C., Li, W., Lozano-Durán, A. & Liu, H. 2020 On the structure of streamwise wall-shear stress fluctuations in turbulent channel flows. J. Fluid Mech. 903, A29–27.
  3. [3]Cho, M., Hwang, Y. & Choi, H. 2018 Scale interactions and spectral energy transfer in turbulent channel flow. J. Fluid Mech. 854, 474–504.DOI
  4. [4]Cimarelli, A., De Angelis, E. & Casciola, C.M. 2013 Paths of energy in turbulent channel flows. J. Fluid Mech. 715, 436–451.DOI
  5. [5]Cimarelli, A., De Angelis, E., Jimenez, J. & Casciola, C.M. 2016 Cascades and wall-normal fluxes in turbulent channel flows. J. Fluid Mech. 796, 417–436.DOI
  6. [6]Cimarelli, A., Mollicone, J.-P., van Reeuwijk, M. & De Angelis, E. 2021 Spatially evolving cascades in temporal planar jets. J. Fluid Mech. 910.DOI
  7. [7]Flores, O., Jiménez, J. & Del Álamo, J.C. 2007 Vorticity organization in the outer layer of turbulent channels with disturbed walls. J. Fluid Mech. 591, 145–154.DOI
  8. [8]Gatti, D., Chiarini, A., Cimarelli, A. & Quadrio, M. 2020 Structure function tensor equations in inhomogeneous turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 898.DOI
  9. [9]Gatti, D., Remigi, A., Chiarini, A., Cimarelli, A. & Quadrio, M. 2019 An efficient numerical method for the Generalized Kolmogorov Equation. J Turbul. 20 (8), 457–480.DOI
  10. [10]Guala, M., Hommema, S.E. & Adrian, R.J. 2006 Large-scale and very-large-scale motions in turbulent pipe flow. J. Fluid Mech. 554, 521–542.DOI
  11. [11]Hill, R.J. 2001 Equations relating structure functions of all orders. J. Fluid Mech. 434, 379–388.
  12. [12]Hwang, Y. & Cossu, C. 2010 Self-Sustained Process at Large Scales in Turbulent Channel Flow. Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 (4), 044505.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20867850
  13. [13]Illingworth, S.J. 2020 Streamwise-constant large-scale structures in Couette and Poiseuille flows. J. Fluid Mech. 889, A13.DOI
  14. [14]Jiménez, J. & Pinelli, A. 1999 The autonomous cycle of near-wall turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 389, 335–359.DOI
  15. [15]Kawata, T. & Alfredsson, P.H. 2018 Inverse interscale transport of the Reynolds shear stress in plane Couette turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 (24), 244501.DOI
  16. [16]Kawata, T. & Alfredsson, P. H. 2019 Scale interactions in turbulent rotating planar Couette flow: Insight through the Reynolds stress transport. J. Fluid Mech. 879, 255–295.DOI
  17. [17]Kawata, T. & Tsukahara, T. 2021 Scale interactions in turbulent plane Couette flows in minimal domains. J. Fluid Mech. 911.DOI
  18. [18]Lee, M. & Moser, R.D. 2018 Extreme-scale motions in turbulent plane Couette flows. J. Fluid Mech. 842, 128–145.DOI
  19. [19]Lee, M. & Moser, R.D. 2019 Spectral analysis of the budget equation in turbulent channel flows at high Re. J. Fluid Mech. 860, 886–938.DOI
  20. [20]Luchini, P. & Quadrio, M. 2006 A low-cost parallel implementation of direct numerical simulation of wall turbulence. J Comp Phys 211 (2), 551–571.DOI
  21. [21]Mansour, N., Kim, J. & Moin, P. 1988 Reynolds-stress and dissipation-rate budgets in a turbulent channel flow. J. Fluid Mech. 194, 15–44.
  22. [22]Mizuno, Y. 2016 Spectra of energy transport in turbulent channel flows for moderate Reynolds numbers. J. Fluid Mech. 805, 171–187.DOI
  23. [23]Mollicone, J.-P., Battista, F., Gualtieri, P. & Casciola, C. M. 2018 Turbulence dynamics in separated flows: The generalised Kolmogorov equation for inhomogeneous anisotropic conditions. J. Fluid Mech. 841, 1012–1039.
  24. [24]Orlandi, P., Bernardini, M. & Pirozzoli, S. 2015 Poiseuille and Couette flows in the transitional and fully turbulent regime. J. Fluid Mech. 770, 424–441.DOI
  25. [25]Pope, S.B. 2000 Turbulent Flows. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.DOI
  26. [26]Portela, F. Alves, Papadakis, G. & Vassilicos, J.C. 2017 The turbulence cascade in the near wake of a square prism. J. Fluid Mech. 825, 315–352.DOI
  27. [27]Smits, A. J., McKeon, B. J. & Marusic, I. 2011 High-Reynolds number wall turbulence. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 43 (1), 353–375.DOI
  28. [28]Togni, R., Cimarelli, A. & De Angelis, E. 2015 Physical and scale-by-scale analysis of Rayleigh–Bénard convection. J. Fluid Mech. 782, 380–404.DOI
  29. [29]Toh, S. & Itano, T. 2005 Interaction between a large-scale structure and near-wall structures in channel flow. J. Fluid Mech. 524, 249–262.DOI
  30. [30]Tsukahara, T., Kawamura, H. & Shingai, K. 2006 DNS of turbulent Couette flow with emphasis on the large-scale structure in the core region. J. Turbul. 7, N19.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_fbjt2pan
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 4

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents