betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Signatures of slow particle transport in the interacting Aubry-André chain

Abstract

Slow delocalization in strongly disordered many-body quantum chains can originate from two distinct mechanisms: rare resonances and avalanches, rooted in the energy statistics, or an energy-independent combinatorial path-entropy obstruction in operator space. Quasiperiodic potentials eliminate rare regions with similar potentials that are thought to be responsible for avalanche instabilities and modify the statistics of resonances, thus allowing us to delineate the two mechanisms. To do so, we numerically study the entanglement entropy S(t)S(t), number entropy SN(t)S_N(t), and Hartley number entropy SH(t)S_H(t) following a quantum quench in the interacting Aubry-André chain with disorder strength DD. We find S(t)∼μln⁡tS(t)\simμ\ln t, SN(t)∼νln⁡ln⁡tS_N(t)\simν\ln\ln t with growth rates μ∼ν∼D−γμ\simν\sim D^{-γ} and γ≈3γ\approx 3, the same behavior that was previously found in the case of quenched disorder. Furthermore, the saturation values SH(t→∞)S_H(t\to\infty) continue to grow with system size LL as ln⁡L\ln L, a growth that persists for D≳8D\gtrsim 8 where MBL was argued to be stable. The similarity of the quasi-periodic and quenched disorder cases points to a common origin of the slow particle transport that does not rely on rare-region avalanches and persists despite strongly modified resonance statistics.

Introduction

Localization has been a cornerstone of disordered quantum physics since Anderson’s work on the absence of diffusion in random lattices [1]. In 2006, Basko, Aleiner, and Altshuler argued that localization might survive even in the presence of interactions [2]. This gave rise to the concept of many-body localization (MBL), thought of as representing a breakdown of thermalization in interacting systems [3, 4]. Studies of the MBL phase and its associated ergodic to non-ergodic phase transition have been largely based on numerical studies of small systems [5, 6, 7, 8, 9]. By 2019, a broad consensus had formed that MBL can indeed be a phase stable in the thermodynamic limit in one dimensional systems with quenched disorder. This consensus was, however, then questioned based on the observations of (1) an apparent shift in the critical disorder strength with increasing system size [10, 11], (2) an analysis of the fidelity scaling [12, 13, 14], and (3) an analysis of the number and Hartley number entropies [15, 16, 17, 18, 19].

On the much less explored analytical side, efforts have been focussed on investigating if a microscopic Hamiltonian in an MBL phase can be transformed unitarily into an effective Hamiltonian of quasi-local charges [20, 21, 22, 23, 24]. Here, two distinct obstructions occur. On the one hand, many-body resonances and so-called avalanche instabilities—caused by rare regions with small potential differences—have to be kept under control [21, 25, 26]. On the other hand, there is a potential path-entropy instability in many-body systems which is independent of the distribution of energies. While in a Gaussian system, there are only ∼N2\sim N^2 possible operators for a system of size NN and the commutator branching is O(1)\mathcal{O}(1), there are exponentially many possible operators in an interacting system and the branching is extensive [27, 28].

The goal of this work is to try to obtain evidence to distinguish between these two potential instabilities by studying the quasi-periodic interacting Aubry-André chain. This allows us to define potentials such that the potential energies near the bond where the system is cut in half are exactly the same for different system sizes. Only the sites added at the two ends of the chains when increasing the system size have novel potentials. Furthermore, we choose Diophantine frequencies such that extended regions of almost equal potential are impossible and near-repetitions of the potential landscape only occur at large distances. Avalanche instabilities therefore play no role by construction and the statistics of pairwise resonances is strongly modified as compared to the quenched disorder case. If many-body resonances and avalanches are the main factors in destabilizing the potential MBL phase, then one would therefore expect that the results for the Aubry-André chain are qualitatively different from the case of quenched disorder.

To address this question, we will use exact diagonalizations and a Trotterization of the time-evolution operator to study the dynamics after a quantum quench. Specifically, we will calculate the entanglement entropy S(t)S(t), number entropy SN(t)S_N(t), and Hartley number entropy SH(t)S_H(t) for cutting a system with an even number of sites into two equal halves. For the entanglement entropy, it has been suggested that the change from a power-law growth, S(t)∼tαS(t) \sim t^\alpha, to a slower logarithmic growth S(t)∼ln⁡tS(t) \sim\ln t, is a signature of the ergodic-MBL phase transition [5, 29, 30]. For systems where the total particle number is conserved, like the Aubry-André chain studied here, the reduced density matrix ρA\rho_A of the subsystem AA has a block structure with respect to the number of particles NAN_A in the subsystem. This block structure can be used to split the entanglement entropy into two components S=SC+SN\mathcal{S} = S_C + S_N with [31, 32]

SC=∑NApA(NA)S[ρA(NA)/Tr⁡ρA(NA)],S_C = \sum_{N_A} p_A(N_A) S[\rho_A^{(N_A)}/\operatorname{Tr}\rho_A^{(N_A)}],
SN=−∑NApA(NA)ln⁡pA(NA),(1)S_N = -\sum_{N_A} p_A(N_A)\ln p_A(N_A), \tag*{(1)}

where SCS_C is called the configurational entropy and SNS_N the number entropy. pA(NA)=Tr⁡ρA(NA)p_A(N_A) = \operatorname{Tr}\rho_A^{(N_A)} denotes the probability to find NAN_A particles in subsystem AA and ρA(NA)\rho_A^{(N_A)} is the block of the reduced density matrix ρA\rho_A with NAN_A particles. We will also consider the Rényi number entropy which is defined as

SN(α)=11−αln⁡{∑NA(pA(NA))α}.(2)S_N^{(\alpha)} = \frac{1}{1-\alpha}\ln\left\{\sum_{N_A}\left(p_A(N_A)\right)^\alpha\right\}. \tag*{(2)}

In the limit α→1\alpha\to1, this reduces to the number entropy SNS_N defined above, while for α→0\alpha\to0 it gives the Hartley number entropy which returns the logarithm of the number of particle-number sectors that the time-evolved wavefunction populates with nonzero weight. Because it weights all populated sectors equally, SH=SN(α→0)S_H = S_N^{(\alpha\to0)} is sensitive to configurations which occur with low probability. In other words, the Hartley number entropy captures rare events that may be too small to noticeably affect the number entropy SNS_N, and is a direct probe of how many particles cross the bipartition; it therefore provides a more sensitive measure of how particles spread across the system during the time evolution.

The particle number and Hartley number entropies provide a probe of particle transport; in a truly localized phase, SNS_N and SHS_H should saturate rapidly to a value independent of the system size, reflecting no particle transport. However, a series of numerical studies by Kiefer-Emmanouilidis et al. [16, 17, 18, 19] for the XXZ chain with random magnetic fields demonstrated otherwise. Their findings show that in the putative MBL phase, both the number and the Hartley number entropy continue to grow slowly in time, following a double-logarithmic scaling SN,H∼ln⁡ln⁡tS_{N,H} \sim\ln\ln t with saturation values that increase logarithmically with system size [16, 17]. Furthermore, the time scale tdt_d where the double logarithmic scaling breaks down and saturation sets in scales as td∼eLt_d \sim e^L [18], questioning the stability of the MBL phase in the thermodynamic limit in line with concerns previously expressed by Suntajš et al. [10].

This interpretation has been debated however [33, 34, 35, 36]. Ghosh and Znidarič’s [34] study attributed the slow growth of SNS_N to rare resonances between localized regions and argued that the resulting dynamics remains compatible with localization. In a Comment, Kiefer-Emmanouilidis et al. questioned this interpretation [37]. The resonance model predicts a power-law approach to a system-size independent saturation value, SN(t)=const−B/tS_N(t) = \mathrm{const}-B/t. Fits of the numerical data, however, yield a power-law 1/tb1/t^b with an exponent bb that decreases with system size. The data presented in the Comment [37] are instead described by SN∼1D3ln⁡ln⁡tS_N \sim\frac{1}{D^3}\ln\ln t for all considered system sizes and disorder strengths before finite-size saturation sets in. Furthermore, for a quench from the Néel state the saturation values are not constant but rather increase as ln⁡L\ln L, both for SNS_N and for the Hartley number entropy SHS_H. The latter is more sensitive to small fluctuations and is bounded above by ln⁡3\ln3 if only a single particle crosses the cut [18, 19]; the observed saturation values exceed this bound substantially, implying fluctuations involving more than one particle. Finally, for the initial states and strong disorder where the resonance model in Ref. [34] describes the data best, the configurational entropy is negligible and S≈SNS \approx S_N, i.e. the dynamics in the numerically accessible regime is of single-particle type and not related to the question of MBL.

A different perspective was recently put forward in an ℓ\ell-bit circuit study which demonstrated ultraslow growth of SNS_N even in models localized by construction, suggesting that the presence of a SN∼ln⁡ln⁡tS_N \sim\ln\ln t growth alone may not be sufficient to rule out an MBL phenomenology [35]. This confirms earlier results in a very similar study for an effective model of interacting Anderson orbitals, for which the particle fluctuations can be shown to be bounded [19]. In both of these ℓ\ell-bit models, SNS_N and SHS_H indeed saturate to values that show only a very weak dependence on system size. In particular, the Hartley number entropy saturates for all system sizes to values ≈1\approx1 below the bound ln⁡3\ln3 for a single particle crossing the cut (see Suppl. Mat. of Ref. [35]), indicating that multi-particle fluctuations do not occur. This is fundamentally different from the XXZ case with quenched disorder—which the ℓ\ell-bit results were directly compared with in Ref. [19]—where the saturation values of SHS_H increase logarithmically with system size and many-particle fluctuations are clearly visible.

Very recently, another study proposed a microscopic mechanism for small particle fluctuations in a localized phase [36]. That small particle fluctuations and a corresponding increase of the number entropy do occur even in models localized by construction is consistent with our findings in Ref. [19]. However, the proposed quantum-beat mechanism does not account for the observed multi-particle fluctuations and the logarithmic increase of the saturation value with system size. The predicted differences between quenched disorder and quasi-periodic potentials are also not consistent with the findings presented in the following.

All three of these studies show the importance of a proper finite-size scaling analysis and of considering the Hartley number entropy instead of concentrating solely on SNS_N. They do not establish that the observed slow particle transport in the XXZ model with quenched disorder can be understood within an ℓ\ell-bit model or any other localized model. In fact, Ref. [19] reaches the opposite conclusion.

For quasiperiodic potentials, rare regions with anomalously weak disorder do not exist and avalanche instabilities are therefore absent by construction. Based on exact diagonalizations and finite-size extrapolations of the inverse participation ratio, Vu et al. [38] argued that the interacting Aubry-André chain is many-body localized for potential strengths D≳4D \gtrsim4 and interaction strengths of the order of the hopping. By numerically studying a quasiperiodic chain coupled to a Markovian bath and supported by real-space RG arguments, Tu et al. [39] further argued that quasiperiodic systems are more stable against delocalization than randomly disordered ones for D≳16D \gtrsim16, potentially up to arbitrarily large system sizes. Recently, however, long-range resonances have been identified also in the quasiperiodic case [40]. Studying the Heisenberg chain in an Aubry-André potential, the authors found fat-tailed distributions of longitudinal correlations at long distances and a typical correlation length which grows with system size in an intermediate regime where standard diagnostics indicate MBL, and identified the responsible rare eigenstates as quasi-degenerate pairs of resonant cat states. At even stronger potentials, on the other hand, the distributions become exponential and the correlation length system-size independent, which was interpreted in Ref. [40] as a standard, stable MBL phase.

In this work, we probe the regime of intermediate to strong disorder by studying the dynamics after a quantum quench in the interacting Aubry-André chain. We find that all considered entropies behave qualitatively the same as in the case of quenched disorder: S(t)∼μln⁡tS(t) \sim\mu\ln t and SN(t)∼νln⁡ln⁡tS_N(t) \sim\nu\ln\ln t with growth rates μ∼ν∼D−γ\mu\sim\nu\sim D^{-\gamma} and γ≈3\gamma\approx3, in close agreement with the value found for random disorder [18]. Most importantly, the saturation values of the Hartley number entropy grow with system size as SH(t→∞)∼ln⁡LS_H(t \to\infty) \sim\ln L and remain well above the single-particle bound ln⁡3\ln3 even at strong quasiperiodic potentials D≳10D \gtrsim10, where avalanches are absent by construction and rare resonances have been argued to become inoperative [40].

Our paper is organized as follows: In Sec. II, we introduce the interacting Aubry-André chain and discuss the numerical methods used to study its quench dynamics. In Sec. III, we present our results. The last section discusses these results in comparison to earlier results for quenched disorder and presents our conclusions.

Model and numerical methods

We consider spinless fermions on a chain with open boundary conditions of length LL with a Hamiltonian given by

H^=−J∑j=1L−1(cj†cj+1+h.c.)+V∑j=1L−1(nj−12)(nj+1−12)+∑j=1LDj(nj−12).(3)\begin{aligned} \hat{H} = -J \sum_{j=1}^{L-1} \left(c_j^\dagger c_{j+1} + \mathrm{h.c.}\right) \\ &+ V \sum_{j=1}^{L-1} \left(n_j - \frac{1}{2}\right)\left(n_{j+1} - \frac{1}{2}\right) + \sum_{j=1}^{L} D_j\left(n_j - \frac{1}{2}\right). \tag*{(3)} \end{aligned}

Here cj(†)c_j^{(\dagger)} is an annihilation (creation) operator of a spinless fermion at site jj, nj=cj†cjn_j = c_j^\dagger c_j is the occupation number operator, J=1J = 1 the hopping amplitude, VV the nearest-neighbor interaction, and the Aubry-André onsite potential is given by

Dj=Dcos⁡(2πβj+ϕ),(4)D_j = D \cos(2\pi\beta j + \phi), \tag*{(4)}

with amplitude DD. Here, β\beta is chosen to be the golden ratio (1+5)/2(1+\sqrt{5})/2 which satisfies a Diophantine condition; this ensures that to achieve a near-repetition with a mismatch of order DδD\delta a distance of order 1/δ1/\delta is required. In the non-interacting limit V=0V = 0, the Aubry-André model is then mathematically equivalent to the almost Mathieu operator and exhibits a sharp localization transition at Dc=2JD_c = 2J [41]. We work at half filling and bipartition the chain into two equal subsystems AA and BB. We note that the Hamiltonian (3) is equivalent by a Jordan-Wigner transformation to a spin-1/2 XXZ chain with DjD_j playing the role of site-dependent magnetic fields.

The system is always prepared in a Néel state (alternating occupied and unoccupied sites) and then unitarily time-evolved with the Hamiltonian (3). For system sizes L≤18L \le18 we use exact diagonalizations, and for L=24L = 24 and L=28L = 28 we use a second-order Suzuki-Trotter decomposition of the time-evolution operator with a time step δt\delta t chosen such that the discretization error on the time scales we are able to study is negligible compared to the statistical error of averaging over a finite number of potential configurations. We sample the phase offset ϕ\phi uniformly in [0,2π][0,2\pi]. The number of realizations of the potential RR varies with system size: R=20000R = 20000 for L=8,10L = 8,10, R=8000R = 8000 for L=12,14L = 12,14, R=10000R = 10000 for L=16L = 16, R=798R = 798 for L=18L = 18, R=1069R = 1069 for L=24L = 24, and R=586R = 586 for L=28L = 28.

To make the time evolution comparable across system sizes, we define for each potential realization the sequence {Dj}\{D_j\} once on the indices j=0,1,…,27j = 0,1,\ldots,27 corresponding to the largest system size L=28L = 28. For smaller LL, we truncate symmetrically from both ends so that the chain L=24L = 24 uses j=2,…,25j = 2,\ldots,25 and so on. The site index jj in Eq. (3) always refers to this absolute index. Therefore, new on-site potentials only appear at the left and right edges of the system when increasing the system size and only influence the late-time dynamics.

All calculations are performed in double precision, limiting the times that can be explored using exact diagonalizations to t≲1013t \lesssim10^{13}. The calculations using a Trotter-Suzuki decomposition are limited to even shorter times because of the accumulating discretization errors.

Results

Disorder dependence

We begin with the time evolution of the entanglement and number entropies in the interacting Aubry-André chain for V=1V = 1 and note that for interaction strengths VV of the order of the hopping J=1J = 1 and potential strengths D>VD > V, the results are expected to only weakly depend on the precise value of VV, see also Sec. III B. Figure 1 shows S(t)S(t) and SN(t)S_N(t) for L=16L = 16 and potential strengths D=5D = 5–2020, averaged over R=10,000R = 10{,}000 realizations. The entanglement entropy shows three distinct regimes in time. An initial fast increase at times of order of the hopping JJ, followed by a slower increase consistent with S(t)∼μln⁡tS(t) \sim\mu\ln t, see the fits (dashed lines) in Figure 1(a). This is followed by a saturation. The prefactor μ\mu of the logarithmic growth monotonically decreases with increasing potential strength DD, as does the saturation value. The growth of the number entropy SN(t)S_N(t) also shows three regimes. At short times, there is overall growth but with strong fluctuations, followed by a regime where SN∼νln⁡ln⁡tS_N \sim\nu\ln\ln t holds, and finally, again, a regime where SNS_N saturates. As for the entanglement entropy, the prefactor ν\nu of the double logarithmic growth as well as the saturation values are monotonically decreasing functions of the potential strength DD.

Figure 1. Time evolution of entanglement entropy SS and number entropy SNS_N for system size L=16L = 16 and various potential strengths DD. The initial state is a Néel state and results are averaged over R=10000R = 10000 realizations. (a) S∼μln⁡tS \sim\mu\ln t at intermediate times with decreasing μ\mu for increasing potential strengths DD, followed by finite-size saturation at long times. (b) SN∼νln⁡ln⁡tS_N \sim\nu\ln\ln t at intermediate times followed by saturation. Inset: Deviation times td∼eaDt_d \sim e^{aD} with almost identical exponents aa for SS and SNS_N.

The inset of Figure 1(b) shows the deviation times tdt_d for both SS and SNS_N as a function of DD. Here, the deviation time is defined as the time at which the data deviates by a fixed threshold of 10%10\% from the logarithmic and double-logarithmic fits, respectively. We note that while the exact values of tdt_d do depend on the threshold chosen, the scaling as a function of DD is generic. For both entropies, the deviation times increase as ln⁡td∼aD\ln t_d \sim aD with the potential strength DD and with nearly identical exponents aa. There is, in particular, no indication that tdt_d continues to grow for the entanglement entropy while it starts to saturate for the number entropy, a behavior which might be expected if we cross from an ergodic into an MBL phase at some critical potential strength DcMBLD_c^{\mathrm{MBL}}, where particle spreading stops but dephasing continues. The data are consistent with the relation SN∼ln⁡SS_N \sim\ln S established for the quenched disorder case [15, 16, 17, 18], and we find no qualitative difference between the quasiperiodic and the previously studied quenched disorder case when considering the relation between entanglement and number entropy as well as the deviation times. These results are further supported by a quantitative analysis of the logarithmic and double logarithmic fits, respectively. As shown in Figure 2, both prefactors μ\mu and ν\nu decrease as a power law, μ,ν∼D−γ\mu,\nu\sim D^{-\gamma}, with increasing potential strength DD. The exponent γ\gamma is consistent with γ=3\gamma= 3 (see dashed lines in Figure 2) and also consistent with the exponent found in the quenched disorder case studied in Ref. [17]. As for every numerical study, we cannot exclude that the relation SN∼ln⁡SS_N \sim\ln S breaks down for even larger strengths of the potential DD but for the time scales, lengths, and potential strengths we can study we find no qualitative differences in the behavior of the entanglement and number entropy for the quasi-periodic Aubry-André chain as compared to the XXZ chain with quenched disorder.

Figure 2. Scaling of the parameters μ\mu and ν\nu as a function of the potential strength DD extracted from fits S∼μln⁡tS \sim\mu\ln t and SN∼νln⁡ln⁡tS_N \sim\nu\ln\ln t. Both parameters show the same power-law scaling μ∼ν∼D−γ\mu\sim\nu\sim D^{-\gamma} consistent with γ≈3\gamma\approx3, see dashed lines.

As we have already alluded to in the introduction it is, however, extremely important to also consider measures that are more sensitive to small particle number

fluctuations than the number entropy and to perform an analysis of how the results depend on system size. To address both of these points, we consider next the Hartley number entropy SHS_H which is formally defined as the limit of the Rényi number entropy (2) for α→0\alpha\to0. Numerically, however, taking this limit exactly is not possible. Specifically, for α→0\alpha\to0 every particle number sector would fully be counted for arbitrarily small occupation even if this occupation is smaller than double precision. Numerically, we therefore fix α=10−3\alpha= 10^{-3} instead of trying to take the limit α→0\alpha\to0. This will only result in a slight overall suppression of the Hartley number entropy but will not change the results qualitatively. Second, we introduce a cutoff where we only consider sectors with pA(NA)>10−10p_A(N_A)>10^{-10} and we then normalize the sum of the probabilities which fulfill this condition to 1. Choosing different cutoffs will mostly correspond to a renormalization of time: for a smaller cutoff a sector starts to contribute earlier while for a larger cutoff it starts to contribute later. As a consequence, also the saturation value will shift by a constant offset that depends on the chosen cutoff. However, the qualitative structure of the Hartley number entropy, and in particular the scaling of the saturation value with system size, remains unchanged. We call the numerical Hartley number entropy obtained using this procedure SH(t)S_H(t).

Figure 3 shows SH(t)S_H(t) at D=7D=7, well above the non-interacting localization threshold Dc=2D_c=2, for system sizes L=8L=8 to L=28L=28. The Hartley number entropy as defined above essentially gives the logarithm of the number of the particle sectors with pA(NA)p_A(N_A) above the cutoff. As a result of the cutoff, the time evolution in panel (a) shows a clear staircase structure, with the data passing through ln⁡2\ln2, ln⁡3\ln3, and ln⁡4\ln4 as additional particle-number sectors become populated above the threshold. The maximum value of SHS_H in a half-filled system which is cut in half is ln⁡(L/2+1)\ln(L/2+1). We find again three dynamical regimes. First, SHS_H increases rapidly and even for the smallest system size investigated, L=8L=8, quickly reaches values larger than ln⁡3\ln3. At this point, particle number fluctuations include sectors where two particles have crossed the cut. SHS_H also quickly crosses SH≈1.40S_H\approx1.40 which is the saturation value

Figure 3. (a) SH(t)S_H(t) for D=7D = 7 and system sizes L=8,10,12,14,16,18L = 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18 obtained from ED and L=24,28L = 24, 28 from a Trotter-Suzuki decomposition of the time evolution operator. The continuations of the L=24,28L = 24, 28 curves are guides to the eye connecting the data to the saturation values predicted in panel (c). The number of potential realizations RR is given in the legend. The non-interacting model (V=0V = 0) saturates at SH≈1.40S_H \approx1.40 for L→∞L \to\infty. (b) The same data shown against ln⁡ln⁡t\ln\ln t with a constant offset 0.025 and fits to SH(t)=c+ηln⁡ln⁡tS_H(t) = c + \eta\ln\ln t; the fit parameters c,ηc, \eta are extracted independently for each LL. (c) Saturation values SH(t→∞)S_H(t \to\infty) as a function of LL. Filled blue circles: late-time average of the L=8L = 8–18 data. Open blue squares: extrapolation of the 0.16ln⁡L+1.140.16 \ln L + 1.14 fit to L=24,28L = 24, 28. Filled red triangles: Self-consistent estimate (c+ηln⁡ln⁡td)/(1+τ)(c + \eta\ln\ln t_d)/(1 + \tau), where tdt_d is the time at which the data first deviate from the fit by τSH(t→∞)\tau S_H(t \to\infty) with τ=0.03\tau= 0.03. Open red triangles: same estimate for L=24,28L = 24, 28, with tdt_d obtained from the scaling ln⁡td=aLL+bL\ln t_d = a_L L + b_L established for L=8L = 8 to 18.

value in the thermodynamic limit for the non-interacting model with D=7D=7. Beyond this initial regime, the data enter a slow growth phase in which SH(t)∼ln⁡ln⁡tS_H(t)\sim\ln\ln t, i.e. the same qualitative increase as the number entropy SN(t)S_N(t), see Figure 3(b). We can fit the growth in this regime by

SH(t)=c+ηln⁡ln⁡t,(5)S_H(t)=c+\eta\ln\ln t, \tag*{(5)}

with c,ηc,\eta extracted independently for each system size LL. Finally, SHS_H starts to saturate to a length-dependent value.

In Figure 3(c), the saturation of SHS_H as a function of length LL is further analyzed. For L=8−18L=8-18, where the late time plateau is directly accessible (filled blue circles), the saturation values increase with LL and are well described by a logarithmic growth with system size (see dashed line in Figure 3(c)). For L=24L=24 and L=28L=28, the Trotter-Suzuki dynamics has not reached the saturation plateau within the accessible time window, and we estimate the saturation value for these two lengths by two complementary methods. The first is the extrapolation of the logarithmic fit established for the smaller systems (open blue squares). The second is a self-consistency estimate, (c+ηln⁡ln⁡td)/(1+τ)(c+\eta\ln\ln t_d)/(1+\tau), where tdt_d is the time at which the data first deviate from the ln⁡ln⁡t\ln\ln t fit in the intermediate time regime by a fraction τ\tau of the saturation value (filled red triangles for L≤18L\leq18, open red triangles for L=24,28L=24,28, with tdt_d for the largest two systems obtained from the scaling ln⁡td=aLL+bL\ln t_d=a_L L+b_L established for L=8L=8 to 18). The two estimates agree within better than 1% for all system sizes LL, lending confidence to the extrapolated values at L=24,28L=24,28.

In a many-body localized phase, the model is by definition unitarily equivalent to an effective model of quasi-local conserved charges. As a result, particle fluctuations across a cut should be limited and measures such as the number and Hartley number entropies ultimately have to converge to system-size independent values. For the XXZ model with quenched disorder such an effective model was constructed in [19] and it was shown that in such an effective model a saturation of the Hartley number entropy independent of system size indeed occurs for sufficiently large systems. In contrast, the full XXZ model with quenched disorder showed the same ln⁡L\ln L dependence of the saturation values we observe here in the quasi-periodic Aubry-André chain; the latter is shown in Fig. 3(c). We therefore conclude that for the studied potential strengths and system sizes the results for the Aubry-André chain are qualitatively similar to the XXZ chain with quenched disorder and, in particular, inconsistent with a stable MBL phase at the considered strength of the disorder potential of D=7D=7.

As a next step, we therefore also consider SHS_H for even larger values of DD where other numerical studies using different measures have argued in favour of a stable MBL phase [39, 40]. Note that in the convention of Ref. [40] the potential strength is given by h=D/2h=D/2. Fig. 4(a) shows SHS_H for D∈[5,20]D\in[5,20] and system size L=16L=16. We observe that the SH∼ηln⁡ln⁡tS_H\sim\eta\ln\ln t scaling persists for all DD; only the prefactor changes as η∼D−3\eta\sim D^{-3}, see Figure 4(c). This scaling is the same as the one we observed for the entanglement and number entropies, see Figure 2. Also consistent with the previous results is that the deviation time increases exponentially td∼eaDt_d \sim e^{aD}, see Figure 4(b). We note, furthermore, that we observe the same logarithmic scaling of the saturation values with length LL as shown in Figure 3(c) for potentials D>7D > 7 where we, however, can only consider system sizes L≤16L \le16 because of the saturation times increasing exponentially with DD (data not shown). We conclude that we do not see any qualitative changes in the behavior of SHS_H for D≥12D \ge12, corresponding to h≥6h \ge6, where Ref. [40] finds exponentially suppressed tails of the long-distance correlations and a system-size independent correlation length, i.e. no signatures of long-range resonances.

Figure 4. Hartley number entropy SH(t)S_H(t) of the Aubry-André chain with V=1V=1 and L=16L=16 for disorder strength D=5D=5–2020, averaged over 10,000 disorder realizations. (a) SH∼ηln⁡ln⁡tS_H\sim\eta\ln\ln t at intermediate times with decreasing η\eta for increasing potential strength. (b) Deviation times tdt_d, defined as times at which the data deviate from the ln⁡ln⁡\ln\ln-fit by 10%, scale as td∼eaDt_d\sim e^{aD}. For D=12,16,20D=12,16,20 the simulations do not reach saturation and the values are obtained by extrapolation. (c) The prefactor η\eta as a function of DD. The dashed line indicates η∼D−3\eta\sim D^{-3}.

Interaction dependence

In addition to the disorder dependence studied in the previous subsection, it is also useful to study the interaction dependence. This will highlight the differences between the Anderson and the many-body case and the mechanisms responsible for the logarithmic growth of the entanglement entropy and the double logarithmic growths of the number and Hartley number entropies, respectively. The entanglement entropy ΔS=S−S0\Delta S = S - S_0, where S0S_0 is the entanglement entropy of the non-interacting model (V=0V = 0), is shown in Figure 5(a) as a function of the scaled time VtVt. Two conclusions can be drawn from the numerical data: (i) ΔS\Delta S starts to deviate from zero at times Vt∗∼1Vt^* \sim1, i.e., the onset time t∗t^* where many-body effects become visible in the entanglement entropy scales as t∗∼1/Vt^* \sim1/V. (ii) The slope of the logarithmic increase, S∼μln⁡tS \sim\mu\ln t, shows only a weak dependence on the interaction strength VV.

Figure 5. (a) Entanglement entropy ΔS=S−S0\Delta S=S-S_0, where S0S_0 is the entanglement entropy for V=0V=0, plotted as a function of VtVt for interaction strengths V∈[0.05,1]V\in[0.05,1] and D=7D=7. (b) Same as in (a) for the number entropy ΔSN\Delta S_N.

Both of these points can be understood in the standard dephasing picture [4]. Sites a distance rr apart feel an effective interaction Jeff∼Ve−r/ξJ_{\mathrm{eff}}\sim V e^{-r/\xi} where ξ\xi is some effective localization length. For nearby sites, r≪ξr\ll\xi, this leads to an onset of dephasing at times t∗∼Jeff−1∼1/Vt^*\sim J_{\mathrm{eff}}^{-1}\sim1/V consistent with the numerical data. The length scale, over which dephasing is active, grows as r(t)∼ξln⁡(Vt)r(t)\sim\xi\ln(Vt). For the entanglement entropy it follows that

S(t)∼r(t)∼ξ(V,D)ln⁡(t).(6)S(t)\sim r(t)\sim\xi(V,D)\ln(t). \tag*{(6)}

This predicts that the slope of the logarithmic increase only depends on VV indirectly through the effective localization length ξ(V,D)\xi(V,D). The latter is expected to change strongly with disorder but to show only a weak dependence on VV. This is again consistent with the numerical data, see also Figure 6(b).

Figure 6. (a) SHS_H for interaction strengths V∈[0.05,1]V \in[0.05,1] and D=7D=7. Note that each curve has a vertical offset of 0.045. The dashed lines are ln⁡ln⁡t\ln\ln t fits at intermediate times. (b) Prefactors of the logarithmic (double logarithmic) growth of SS (SN,SHS_N,S_H) versus interaction strength VV. The dashed lines are power-law fits, the dotted line is a linear guide to the eye.

What is surprising and not consistent with this naive picture of a pure dephasing between frozen particles is the increase in the number entropy, see Figure 5(b). As for the entanglement entropy, we find again that the particle dynamics starts to deviate from the non-interacting case at times t∗∼1/Vt^*\sim1/V while the double logarithmic increase at intermediate times shows only a weak dependence on interaction strength VV. This suggests that the dynamics setting in at times t∗t^* is not a pure dephasing dynamics but goes hand in hand with an increase in particle fluctuations between the two subsystems. A separation between entanglement and particle dynamics, as would be expected in a pure dephasing picture deep in an MBL phase, is not observed consistent with the investigation of the disorder dependence in the previous subsection.

Finally, we show results for the interaction dependence of the Hartley number entropy SHS_H in Figure 6(a). We find for all interaction strengths an intermediate time interval with SH∼ηln⁡ln⁡tS_H\sim\eta\ln\ln t. Here, the onset of the scaling shows only a weak dependence on VV while the prefactor, η∼V\eta\sim V, changes continuously, see Figure 6(b). This can be explained as follows: while SNS_N is only sensitive to major changes of the particle number distribution, SHS_H in contrast is sensitive to the tails of the distribution. The results show that additional particle sectors start contributing to SHS_H already at times t∼1/Jt\sim1/J while the speed at which new sectors get filled above the threshold pA(NA)=10−10p_A(N_A)=10^{-10} is set by VV.

Conclusions

There are two known mechanisms that can destabilize a potential MBL phase. On the one hand, there can be energy resonances and regions that are almost thermal, leading to avalanche instabilities. This mechanism is energy-based and affects the denominators in any scheme that tries to transform the microscopic Hamiltonian to an effective Hamiltonian based on quasi-local charges. On the other hand, there is a path-entropy obstruction caused by the exponentially large size of the operator space in an interacting many-body system that leads to extensive branching when changing the operator basis. This mechanism affects the numerators of any transformation scheme and is independent of the resonance and

avalanche mechanism.

If resonances and avalanches are the dominant mechanism destabilizing MBL phases, then one would expect to see qualitative differences in the dynamics of a system with quenched disorder as compared to a system with a quasi-periodic potential, where avalanches are absent by construction and the statistics of resonances is strongly modified. Dynamical indicators which should be able to see such changes are the growth of the particle number and the Hartley number entropies after a quench. For the XXZ chain with quenched disorder we have established previously that these indicators point to a continuing slow delocalization of particles [16, 17, 18, 37].

Here we have contrasted these results with a study of the same indicators for the interacting Aubry-André chain, a model with a quasi-periodic potential. We have chosen the frequency of the potential to be the golden ratio such that in order to find near-repetitions of the potential with a mismatch as small as O(Dδ)O(D\delta) one has to consider distances of O(1/δ)O(1/\delta), i.e., this is the badly approximable case in which approximate repetitions are as poor as possible for any irrational frequency. Furthermore, for each realization of the potential—each realization consists of picking the potential with a specific phase factor ϕ∈[0,2π]\phi\in[0,2\pi]—we have defined the sequence {Dj}\{D_j\} once on the sites of the largest system size considered and truncated it symmetrically for smaller LL, so that the potential landscape around the cut is identical for all system sizes.

We have found that in the intermediate time regime—following a fast initial growth of the entropy and before finite-size saturation sets in—the entanglement entropy is well described by S∼μln⁡tS \sim\mu\ln t and the number entropy by SN∼νln⁡ln⁡tS_N \sim\nu\ln\ln t for all potential strengths DD and system sizes LL we considered. Both prefactors scale as μ,ν∼D−γ\mu,\nu\sim D^{-\gamma} with γ≈3\gamma\approx3 and thus remain tied to each other. In particular, there is no indication of the particle fluctuations saturating while the entanglement entropy keeps growing, as expected for an MBL phase. This behavior, including the power-law scaling of the prefactors ∼D−3\sim D^{-3}, is the same as for the quenched disorder case.

To be more sensitive to small particle number fluctuations across the cut, we also considered the Hartley number entropy SHS_H. This quantity significantly exceeds at long times the bound ln⁡3\ln3 and also the non-interacting value, ruling out simple single-particle resonances as an explanation. Furthermore, we find that the saturation values increase with system size as ln⁡L\ln L for all potential strengths we investigated. In particular, we do not see a transition into a phase where the saturation value becomes independent of system size even for potential strengths consistent with what other recent numerical studies have identified as the critical potential strength for the MBL transition. Notably, the ln⁡L\ln L growth persists at D≥12D \ge12, where Ref. [40] finds no signatures of long-range resonances in the eigenstate correlations. Since in a localized-by-construction ℓ\ell-bit model the saturation values of SNS_N and SHS_H become independent of system size [19, 35], the observed ln⁡L\ln L growth is inconsistent with a stable MBL phase. We also note that at intermediate times SH∼ηln⁡ln⁡tS_H \sim\eta\ln\ln t holds with η∼D−3\eta\sim D^{-3}, i.e., the exact same scaling as a function of disorder as observed for SS and SNS_N.

We also considered the interaction dependence of these three entropies at fixed disorder strength. The results for SS are consistent with the standard dephasing picture with an onset time of the logarithmic growth scaling as t∗∼1/Vt^* \sim1/V and the slope of the logarithmic increase being only weakly dependent on VV. However, we find again, and in contrast to a simple dephasing picture, that the number entropy closely follows the behavior of the entanglement entropy, SN∼ln⁡SS_N \sim\ln S, for all VV. I.e., t∗t^* not only indicates the onset of dephasing due to the interaction but also the onset of substantial particle number fluctuations.

The most important conclusion of our study is that the quenched disorder and the quasi-periodic case show very similar behavior—including an even quantitative agreement in the scaling of the logarithmic and double logarithmic growth of the entanglement and number entropies with potential strength and of the deviation times—despite the fundamentally different potential spectra of the two models. Moreover, the slow particle transport persists in a regime where avalanches are excluded by construction and where dedicated eigenstate diagnostics detect no long-range resonances [40], i.e., where both known energy-based mechanisms appear to be inoperative. We interpret our results as pointing towards a universal obstruction against the stability of an MBL phase in the thermodynamic limit that is independent of resonances and avalanches. Such an obstruction was recently discussed in Refs. [27, 28] and springs from the generic extensive branching of operator content in many-body systems.

References

References

  1. [1]P. W. Anderson, Absence of diffusion in certain random lattices, Phys. Rev. 109, 1492 (1958).
  2. [2]D. Basko, I. Aleiner, and B. Altshuler, Metal-insulator transition in a weakly interacting many-electron system with localized single-particle states, Ann. Phys. 321, 1126 (2006).
  3. [3]R. Nandkishore and D. A. Huse, Many-body localization and thermalization in quantum statistical mechanics, Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics 6, 15 (2015).DOI
  4. [4]D. A. Abanin, E. Altman, I. Bloch, and M. Serbyn, Colloquium: Many-body localization, thermalization, and entanglement, Rev. Mod. Phys. 91, 021001 (2019).
  5. [5]M. Žnidarič, T. Prosen, and P. Prelovšek, Many-body localization in the heisenberg xxx magnet in a random field, Phys. Rev. B 77, 064426 (2008).DOI
  6. [6]A. Pal and D. A. Huse, Many-body localization phase transition, Phys. Rev. B 82, 174411 (2010).
  7. [7]V. Oganesyan and D. A. Huse, Localization of interacting fermions at high temperature, Phys. Rev. B 75, 155111 (2007).
  8. [8]D. J. Luitz, N. Laflorencie, and F. Alet, Many-body localization edge in the random-field heisenberg chain, Phys. Rev. B 91, 081103 (2015).
  9. [9]D. J. Luitz, N. Laflorencie, and F. Alet, Extended slow dynamical regime close to the many-body localization transition, Phys. Rev. B 93, 060201 (2016).
  10. [10]J. Šuntajs, J. Bonča, T. Prosen, and L. Vidmar, Quantum chaos challenges many-body localization, Phys. Rev. E 102, 062144 (2020).DOI
  11. [11]J. Šuntajs, J. Bonča, T. Prosen, and L. Vidmar, Ergodicity breaking transition in finite disordered spin chains, Phys. Rev. B 102, 064207 (2020).DOI
  12. [12]D. Sels and A. Polkovnikov, Dynamical obstruction to localization in a disordered spin chain, Phys. Rev. E 104, 054105 (2021).DOI
  13. [13]T. LeBlond, D. Sels, A. Polkovnikov, and M. Rigol, Universality in the onset of quantum chaos in many-body systems, Phys. Rev. B 104, L201117 (2021).DOI
  14. [14]D. Sels and A. Polkovnikov, Whither many-body localization?, Journal Club for Condensed Matter Physics (2022).DOI
  15. [15]M. Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, R. Unanyan, J. Sirker, and M. Fleischhauer, Bounds on the entanglement entropy by the number entropy in non-interacting fermionic systems, SciPost Phys. 8, 083 (2020).
  16. [16]M. Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, R. Unanyan, M. Fleischhauer, and J. Sirker, Evidence for unbounded growth of the number entropy in many-body localized phases, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 243601 (2020).
  17. [17]M. Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, R. Unanyan, M. Fleischhauer, and J. Sirker, Slow delocalization of particles in many-body localized phases, Phys. Rev. B 103, 024203 (2021).
  18. [18]M. Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, R. Unanyan, M. Fleischhauer, and J. Sirker, Unlimited growth of particle fluctuations in many-body localized phases, Annals of Physics 435, 168481 (2021).
  19. [19]M. Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, R. Unanyan, M. Fleischhauer, and J. Sirker, Particle fluctuations and the failure of simple effective models for many-body localized phases, Sci-Post Phys. 12, 034 (2022).
  20. [20]J. Z. Imbrie, Diagonalization and many-body localization for a disordered quantum spin chain, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 027201 (2016).DOI
  21. [21]J. Imbrie, On many-body localization for quantum spin chains, J. Stat. Phys. 163, 998 (2016).DOI
  22. [22]J. Z. Imbrie, V. Ros, and A. Scardicchio, Local integrals of motion in many-body localized systems, Annalen der Physik 529, 1600278 (2017).DOI
  23. [23]W. De Roeck, L. Giacomin, F. Huveneers, and O. Prośniak, Absence of normal heat conduction in strongly disordered interacting quantum chains (2024), arXiv:2408.04338 [math-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2408.04338
  24. [24]F. Huveneers, Many-body localization: an introduction for mathematicians (2026), arXiv:2609.39462 [math-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2609.39462
  25. [25]A. Morningstar, D. A. Huse, and J. Z. Imbrie, Many-body localization near the critical point, Phys. Rev. B 102, 125134 (2020).DOI
  26. [26]W. De Roeck and F. Huveneers, Scenario for delocaliza- tion in translation-invariant systems, Phys. Rev. B 90, 165137 (2014).
  27. [27]A. Weisse, R. Gerstner, and J. Sirker, Operator growth in disordered spin chains: Indications for the absence of many-body localization, Phys. Rev. Res. 7, 033018 (2025).
  28. [28]J. Sirker, Length-resolved operator growth and path-entropy obstructions to many-body localization (2026), arXiv:2606.07774.arxiv.org/abs/2606.07774
  29. [29]J. H. Bardarson, F. Pollmann, and J. E. Moore, Unbounded growth of entanglement in models of many-body localization, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 017202 (2012).DOI
  30. [30]M. Serbyn, Z. Papić, and D. A. Abanin, Universal slow growth of entanglement in interacting strongly disordered systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 260601 (2013).
  31. [31]K. Monkman and J. Sirker, Symmetry-resolved entanglement: general considerations, calculation from correlation functions, and bounds for symmetry-protected topological phases, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical 56, 495001 (2023).
  32. [32]A. Lukin, M. Rispoli, R. Schittko, M. E. Tai, A. M. Kaufman, S. Choi, V. Khemani, J. Léonard, and M. Greiner, Probing entanglement in a many-body-localized system, Science 364, 256 (2019).
  33. [33]D. J. Luitz and Y. Bar Lev, Absence of slow particle transport in the many-body localized phase, Phys. Rev. B 102, 100202 (2020).DOI
  34. [34]R. Ghosh and M. Žnidarič, Resonance-induced growth of number entropy in strongly disordered systems, Phys. Rev. B 105, 144203 (2022).DOI
  35. [35]D. Aceituno, C. A. Artiaco, T. Klein Kvorning, L. Herviou, and J. H. Bardarson, Ultraslow growth of number entropy in an ℓ-bit model of many-body localization, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 126502 (2024).
  36. [36]B. Faulend, H. Buljan, and A. Štrkalj, Quantum beats in many-body-localized systems (2026), arXiv:2603.28721 [cond-mat.dis-nn].arxiv.org/abs/2603.28721
  37. [37]M. Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, R. Unanyan, M. Fleischhauer, and J. Sirker, Comment on “resonance-induced growth of number entropy in strongly disordered systems” (2022), arXiv:2203.06689.
  38. [38]D. Vu, K. Huang, X. Li, and S. Das Sarma, Fermionic many-body localization for random and quasiperiodic systems in the presence of short- and long-range interactions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 146601 (2022).DOI
  39. [39]Y.-T. Tu, D. Vu, and S. Das Sarma, Avalanche stability transition in interacting quasiperiodic systems, Phys. Rev. B 107, 014203 (2023).
  40. [40]A. Padhan, J. Colbois, F. Alet, and N. Laflorencie, Long-range resonances in quasiperiodic many-body localization, Phys. Rev. Lett. 136, 197101 (2026).
  41. [41]S. Y. Jitomirskaya, Metal-insulator transition for the almost mathieu operator, Ann. Math. 150, 1159 (1999).arxiv.org/abs/math/9911265

Paper details

vlnc:W_fbvhgegm
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents