betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

An (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category of conically smooth stratified bordisms

Abstract

To study derived defect topological quantum field theories, we construct an (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category of stratified bordisms and sketch its (∞,d)(\infty,d)-dimensional analogue. In the first chapters we develop a method for constructing symmetric monoidal (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categories, inspired by Segal spaces but better suited to geometric inputs, which we call interval Segal spaces. Using this framework, we construct the (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category of dd-dimensional smooth manifolds via smooth ∞\infty-sheaves thereof, in an attempt to address fibrancy issues present in prior work on this subject. We further equip this category with a symmetric monoidal structure, compute its homotopy 1-category, and extend the construction to manifolds endowed with tangential structures, obtaining the interval Segal space of dd-dimensional bordisms with tangential structure. To model the stratifications supporting topological defects, we work with conically smooth stratified spaces, a suitably smooth framework for conical stratifications. We define stratified topological manifolds as stratified B\mathcal{B}-manifolds for a suitable (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category of basics B\mathcal{B}. Using these, we construct an interval Segal space whose objects are compact closed stratified topological (d−1)(d-1)-manifolds and whose 1-morphisms are stratified dd-dimensional bordisms, and we endow it with a symmetric monoidal structure. We also use tangential structures on conically smooth stratified spaces to formulate a notion of defect labels, aiming toward bordisms with labeled defects in the style of Carqueville et al. Finally, we sketch a higher-dimensional generalization of the interval category to a category of dd-cubes for d>1d>1, conjecturally presenting (∞,d)(\infty,d)-categories, and outline how stratified factorization homology may be used to produce derived stratified defect TQFTs.

Supervisor: Doctor John Gmerek Huerta

Co-supervisor: Doctor Pedro Boavida de Brito

Thesis approved in public session to obtain the PhD Degree in Mathematics

Jury final classification: Pass with Distinction

Supervisor: Doctor John Gmerek Huerta

Co-supervisor: Doctor Pedro Boavida de Brito

Thesis approved in public session to obtain the PhD Degree in Mathematics

Jury final classification: Pass with Distinction

Jury

Chairperson:

Doctor Filipe Artur Pacheco Neves Carteado Mena, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa.

Members of the Committee:

Doctor David Ayala, Department of Mathematical Sciences, College of Letters & Science, Montana State University, USA.

Doctor Filipe Artur Pacheco Neves Carteado Mena, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa.

Doctor Nils Carqueville, Faculty of Physics, University of Vienna, Austria.

Doctor Roger Francis Picken, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa.

Doctor Marko Stosic, Faculdade de Ciências, Universidade de Lisboa.

Doctor John Gmerek Huerta, Faculty of Physics, Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, Germany.

Funding Institution

FCT: Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia

2026

Resumo

Palavras-chave:

  • espaços estratificados conicamente suaves

  • bordismos estratificados

  • espaços de Segal intervalares

  • categorias superiores

  • teorias de campo quântico topológicas

Resumo Alargado

A noção de defeitos em teorias de campo quântico (QFTs) tem ganho uma atenção e importância extraordinárias na física e, talvez de modo menos esperado, também na matemática. Seja MM uma variedade diferenciável nn-dimensional na qual vive uma dada QFT τ\tau. Heuristicamente, um defeito de dimensão dd pode ser descrito como o dado de uma subvariedade D⊂MD \subset M de codimensão (n−d)(n-d), juntamente com alguma descontinuidade de τ\tau ao longo de DD que produz outra teoria de campo quântico. Exemplos paradigmáticos destes fenómenos são os defeitos de linha de Wilson e de ’t Hooft na teoria de Yang–Mills. Dar uma definição geral e uma classificação conceptual destes defeitos é hoje tema de um vasto corpo de trabalho em desenvolvimento.

QFTs que não dependem de quaisquer parâmetros geométricos são chamadas QFTs topológicas (TQFTs). Em particular, defeitos cuja interação com a teoria de bulk é independente da classe de isotopia do seu mergulho são chamados defeitos topológicos. Pode então organizar-se uma TQFT topológica com defeitos topológicos num único pacote, chamado teoria topológica de campo quântico com defeitos, ou teoria topológica de campo quântico estratificada. Em linguagem categórica, estas teorias são modeladas por funtores simetricamente monoidais da categoria de cobordismos estratificados com dados de defeito para uma categoria-alvo linear, como a categoria dos espaços vetoriais complexos de dimensão finita.

Se enriquecermos estas categorias “para cima”, acrescentando difeomorfismos estratificados, isotopias estratificadas e isotopias de ordem superior, obtemos versões derivadas destas TQFTs; se, por outro lado, as estendermos “para baixo”, permitindo decomposições em peças estratificadas com cantos de profundidade arbitrária, obtemos versões mais computáveis dessas teorias. Esta tese ocupa-se da construção de um tal objeto, numa primeira etapa ao nível de uma (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categoria e, de forma prospetiva, ao nível totalmente estendido.

No seu esboço de prova da Hipótese do Cobordismo, Lurie introduziu uma primeira encarnação da (∞,d)(\infty,d)-categoria completamente estendida de cobordismos framizados como um espaço de Segal completo dd-vezes iterado. Na secção final desse trabalho, sugere ainda uma definição de uma (∞,d)(\infty,d)-categoria de cobordismos com singularidades, baseada numa noção de variedade com singularidades suficientemente geral para capturar defeitos. Em princípio, esse é precisamente o tipo de objeto que aqui pretendemos construir. Contudo, na prática, essa classe de espaços não vinha acompanhada dos fundamentos diferencial-topológicos necessários para uma teoria robusta. A presente tese revê esse programa em três direções complementares: usa um modelo alternativo para categorias superiores, recorre à teoria de espaços estratificados conicamente suaves e às suas estruturas tangenciais, e restringe-se a cobordismos estratificados cujo espaço subjacente é uma variedade topológica.

A tese começa por introduzir, no Capítulo 2, um novo modelo para (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categorias, a que chamamos espaços de Segal intervalares. Estes são copré-feixes simpliciais na categoria Int⁡\operatorname{Int}, uma subcategoria do poset dos abertos de [0,1][0,1], concebida de modo a tornar mais natural a codificação geométrica de composição. Mostramos que a categoria correspondente admite uma estrutura de modelo equivalente de Quillen à estrutura clássica dos espaços de Segal de Rezk. A motivação desta escolha é geométrica: muitos modelos de (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categorias são tecnicamente poderosos, mas pouco adequados à construção direta de espaços de módulos geométricos. Uma exceção notável é dada pelas striation sheaves de Ayala, Francis e Rozenblyum, desenhadas precisamente para construir (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categorias a partir de dados ao nível de conjuntos. Os espaços de Segal intervalares introduzidos nesta tese podem ser vistos como uma alternativa mais próxima da tecnologia tradicional dos espaços de Segal, mas ainda assim suficientemente adaptada a construções geométricas e, por isso, promissora para generalizações a dimensões superiores.

No Capítulo 3 aplicamos este formalismo para construir uma nova versão da (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categoria de cobordismos dd-dimensionais suaves. A abordagem inspira-se em três antecedentes principais: o trabalho de Galatius, Madsen, Tillmann e Weiss sobre o tipo de homotopia da categoria de cobordismos; o programa de Lurie para a hipótese do cobordismo; e a reformulação proposta por Scheimbauer e Calaque. O ponto de partida é que as construções existentes apresentam pequenas falhas técnicas quando reinterpretadas no contexto necessário para uma prova cuidada das condições de Segal e de fibrância. Em particular, a construção de Lurie não satisfaz literalmente uma condição de constância essencial, e a correção posterior de Scheimbauer e Calaque apoia-se numa afirmação problemática sobre a fibrância de certos níveis simpliciais.

Para ultrapassar estas dificuldades, recorremos à teoria de ∞\infty-feixes suaves no sítio das variedades diferenciáveis e aos respetivos espaços classificantes, tal como desenvolvidos por Berwick-Evans, Boavida de Brito e Pavlov. A ideia central é construir, a partir de dados geométricos honestos, espaços classificantes de variedades suaves, cobordismos suaves e famílias suaves de composições de cobordismos. Mais concretamente, definimos um bifuntor Bord⁡d,V(−,−)\operatorname{Bord}_{d,V}(-,-) em Man⁡op×Int⁡\operatorname{Man}^{\mathrm{op}} \times\operatorname{Int} que, para cada intervalo TT, produz um feixe de conjuntos sobre variedades suaves e codifica famílias de variedades dd-dimensionais mergulhadas num espaço euclidiano auxiliar VV. Tomando a sua resolução por concordâncias e restringindo depois ao longo da variedade co-simplicial padrão, obtemos um conjunto simplicial Bord⁡d,V\operatorname{Bord}_{d,V} que funciona como espaço classificante de variedades (d−1)(d-1)-dimensionais, de cobordismos dd-dimensionais e das suas composições. A parte técnica central do capítulo consiste em mostrar que este pré-espaço intervalar satisfaz as condições que o tornam num espaço de Segal intervalar e que a sua categoria de homotopia 11-truncada recupera a categoria de cobordismos esperada.

No Capítulo 4 passamos à geometria estratificada propriamente dita. Introduzimos a teoria dos espaços estratificados conicamente suaves, desenvolvida por Ayala, Francis, Tanaka e Rozenblyum, como o contexto geométrico adequado para modelar defeitos. Esta escolha é motivada por duas exigências fundamentais: trabalhar com famílias de estratificações e formular noções suficientemente flexíveis de estrutura tangencial em contexto singular. O capítulo desenvolve o ferramental diferencial-topológico necessário para os capítulos seguintes: a (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categoria de espaços estratificados conicamente suaves, a categoria de caminhos de saída e o fibrado tangente construtível. Para além disso, demonstramos resultados novos sobre a contratilidade de certos espaços de mergulhos de espaços estratificados em espaços euclidianos, bem como um análogo estratificado do teorema de Ehresmann. Estes resultados são essenciais para transportar para o mundo estratificado parte da infraestrutura já conhecida no caso liso.

O Capítulo 5 contém o núcleo geométrico da tese: a construção de uma (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categoria de cobordismos dd-dimensionais estratificados conicamente suaves. Começamos por introduzir a noção de variedade topológica estratificada conicamente suave, modelada como uma B\mathcal{B}-variedade estratificada para uma adequada (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categoria de básicos Bscdd−1\mathrm{Bsc}_{d}^{d-1}, cujas ligações são esferas estratificadas das codimensões relevantes. Esta restrição a espaços subjacentes topológicos permite manter um equilíbrio entre generalidade geométrica e tratabilidade técnica. Construímos então um pré-espaço intervalar de cobordismos estratificados, novamente através da resolução por concordâncias de ∞\infty-feixes suaves e da restrição ao longo da variedade co-simplicial padrão, e provamos que ele satisfaz a condição de Segal intervalar.

Em seguida, dotamos este espaço de uma estrutura simetricamente monoidal compatível com a união disjunta, obtendo assim o candidato natural à categoria de cobordismos estratificados necessária para formular TQFTs estratificadas derivadas. Um aspeto importante desta construção é a incorporação de estruturas tangenciais no contexto estratificado. Em particular, introduzimos a noção de dado de defeito discreto orientado através de fibrados à direita discretos sobre a categoria de básicos escolhida, com o objetivo de aproximar o formalismo geométrico desenvolvido nesta tese dos dados de defeito considerados por Carqueville e colaboradores. Como primeiro teste desta perspetiva, provamos um resultado de comparação no caso orientado estratificado de dimensão 2. O capítulo culmina com a definição de uma teoria topológica de campo quântico estratificada derivada como um funtor simétrico monoidal da (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categoria simétrica monoidal de cobordismos estratificados construída na tese para uma (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categoria simétrica monoidal alvo C\mathcal{C}.

O Capítulo 6 tem natureza prospetiva e delineia duas direções de desenvolvimento futuro. Na primeira, seguindo ideias não publicadas de Manuel Araújo e Pedro Boavida de Brito, introduzimos uma generalização de dimensão superior da categoria Int\mathrm{Int}, denotada ■d\blacksquare_d, com vista à formulação de um análogo intervalar para (∞,d)(\infty,d)-categorias. Argumentamos que copré-feixes simpliciais em ■d\blacksquare_d satisfazendo análogos superiores das condições de Segal e de completude deverão apresentar a (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categoria Cat(∞,d)\mathrm{Cat}_{(\infty,d)}, e esboçamos como este formalismo poderá ser usado para construir um ■d\blacksquare_d-espaço de cobordismos estratificados. Na segunda direção regressamos ao contexto não estendido e indicamos como álgebras de fatorização construtíveis e homologia de fatorização estratificada podem servir de mecanismo de produção de TQFTs estratificadas com defeitos, generalizando para o contexto estratificado e derivado ideias presentes na abordagem de Calaque e Scheimbauer.

Em síntese, a tese propõe um novo quadro para a construção de categorias superiores geométricas adaptadas ao estudo de cobordismos estratificados e de teorias topológicas de campo quântico com defeitos. A introdução dos espaços de Segal intervalares, a nova construção da categoria de cobordismos lisos via ∞\infty-feixes suaves, e a passagem para o contexto dos espaços estratificados conicamente suaves constituem os três pilares principais deste programa. O resultado é uma construção rigorosa de uma (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categoria de cobordismos estratificados suficientemente rica para servir de domínio a TQFTs estratificadas derivadas, bem como um esboço das extensões futuras necessárias para tratar a versão totalmente estendida do problema.

Extended Abstract

The notion of defects in quantum field theories (QFTs) has amassed an extraordinary amount of attention and importance in physics and, perhaps surprisingly, also in mathematics. Let MM be a smooth nn-dimensional manifold on which a given QFT τ\tau lives. A defect of dimension dd can be heuristically articulated as the data of a submanifold D⊂MD \subset M of codimension (n−d)(n-d), together with some discontinuity of τ\tau along DD which produces another quantum field theory. Examples of these phenomena are given by Wilson and ’t Hooft line defects in Yang–Mills theory. Giving a definition and a classification of these general defects is the subject of extensive ongoing work (see [1, 2]).

QFTs which lack dependence on any geometric parameter are dubbed topological QFTs (TQFTs). In particular, defects whose interaction with the bulk theory is independent of the isotopy class of their embedding are called topological defects. One can organize topological QFTs with topological defects into a single package, called a defect (or stratified) topological quantum field theory. These are symmetric monoidal functors out of the category of (oriented) stratified cobordisms with defect data into the category of finite-dimensional complex vector spaces

Z ⁣:Bord⁡dstrat⟶Vect⁡Cf.d..Z \colon\operatorname{Bord}^{\mathrm{strat}}_{d} \longrightarrow\operatorname{Vect}^{\mathrm{f.d.}}_{\mathbb{C}}.

Extending these categories upwards — by adding stratified diffeomorphisms and stratified isotopies between them, and higher stratified isotopies between these, etc. — we can contemplate derived versions of these defect TQFTs; whereas by extending them downwards — letting stratified bordisms be cut into stratified cornered pieces of arbitrary depth — we can contemplate more computable versions of these derived defect TQFTs. This thesis is concerned with building such an extended object.

In his sketch of a proof of the Cobordism Hypothesis [3], Lurie introduces the first incarnation of the fully extended (∞,d)(\infty,d)-category of framed cobordisms as a (complete) dd-fold Segal space. In the last section of that paper, he gives a very rough sketch of a definition for an (∞,d)(\infty,d)-category of cobordisms with singularities through a convoluted notion of X⃗\vec{X}-manifold with singularities. In principle, this is the object we are after; but in practice, this class of spaces lacks differential-topological foundations that would enable its widespread use. We revise his construction in three ways: 1) we use a different model for higher categories; 2) we make use of the theory of conically smooth stratified spaces and their tangential structures; 3) we limit our construction to stratified bordisms whose underlying space is a topological manifold.

We now provide a general outline of the thesis. In Chapter 2 we introduce a model for (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categories that complements the existing literature, which we call interval Segal spaces — these are simplicial co-presheaves on Int⁡\operatorname{Int}, a subcategory of the poset of opens of [0,1][0,1]. In particular, we construct a model structure on coPSh⁡(Int⁡)\operatorname{coPSh}(\operatorname{Int}) which is Quillen equivalent to that of Rezk’s Segal spaces. The motivation here is geometric: most models of (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categories are not tailored for the construction of geometric moduli spaces. A rare exception is the recent work of Ayala–Francis–Rozenblyum [AFR18a], where the authors present striation sheaves — a highly bespoke class of constructible sheaves on stratified spaces, designed precisely for constructing (∞,1)(\infty,1)-categories of a moduli flavour using point-set data. Our construction attempts a similar feat, while being less ambitious and remaining closer to more traditional Segal spaces, thereby facilitating higher-dimensional versions thereof.

In Chapter 3 we present a new construction of the dd-dimensional bordism (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category. This construction is a spiritual cousin of other works, namely those of Galatius–Madsen–Tillman–Weiss [Gal+09], which later inspired the work of Lurie [3], and more recently that of Scheimbauer–Calaque [CS19].

The pioneering work of Galatius–Madsen–Tillman–Weiss offered the first tools to construct an (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category of cobordisms. In their paper on the homotopy type of the cobordism category, they construct a topologically enriched category of dd-dimensional bordisms using classifying spaces. Building on their work, Lurie, in his sketch of a proof of the cobordism hypothesis [3], put forth a first construction of a model for an (∞,n)(\infty,n)-category of cobordisms using nn-fold complete Segal spaces. This construction contained a small mistake preventing it from satisfying the essential constancy condition. In order to address this, in her PhD thesis and in a subsequent paper, Scheimbauer–Calaque propose an alternative definition, which fixes Lurie’s while retaining the use of nn-fold complete Segal spaces. Despite this almost successful attempt at a corrigendum, the work of Scheimbauer–Calaque contains a separate flaw in its claim that the simplicial sets modelling the spatial levels of its nn-fold Segal spaces are Kan complexes — a claim which, being false, translates into a loss of fibrancy necessary for the proof of the Segal condition.

To remedy this, we make use of the theory of smooth ∞\infty-sheaves, i.e. ∞\infty-sheaves on the site of smooth manifolds, and their respective classifying spaces — as articulated in the work of Berwick-Evans–Boavida de Brito–Pavlov [BBP24] — as a conduit for constructing appropriate moduli spaces of smooth manifolds, smooth bordisms, and smooth families of composed bordisms. This gives our approach a distinct flavour and clarifies the minor pathologies identified in previous constructions.

Let us sketch the path we will take in this section. We start by defining a general construction Bord⁡d,V(−,−)\operatorname{Bord}_{d,V}(-,-) which is a bifunctor on Man⁡op×Int⁡\operatorname{Man}^{\mathrm{op}} \times\operatorname{Int} that, when fixing T∈Int⁡T \in\operatorname{Int}, produces a sheaf of sets on Man⁡op\operatorname{Man}^{\mathrm{op}} and captures a type of moduli space construction for dd-dimensional smooth manifolds embedded in VV and fibred over smooth manifolds of varying dimension — designed so that, upon taking its concordance resolution and further restricting along the cosimplicial manifold Δ→Man⁡\Delta\to\operatorname{Man}, we obtain a simplicial set Bord⁡d,V\operatorname{Bord}_{d,V}, or space, which we show is the classifying space of (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional manifolds, dd-dimensional bordisms, and composites of dd-dimensional bordisms. Lastly, the most dense and technical part of this chapter is spent showing that this construction, a pre-interval space, is an interval Segal space which recovers the dd-dimensional bordism category Cob⁡d\operatorname{Cob}_d as its homotopy 11-category.

In Chapter 4 we finally turn to the theory of conically smooth stratified spaces. These were first introduced in the work of Ayala–Francis–Tanaka and further elaborated in the subsequent works of Ayala–Francis–Rozenblyum [AFT17; AFR18a; AFR18b]. They form the geometric foundations for our stratified higher bordism categories, and their adoption for that role is undoubtedly one of the more novel features of this thesis.

This chapter contains a heavier dose of exposition. We introduce the necessary differential-topological toolkit for our construction of the stratified bordism category, namely: we introduce an (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category of conically smooth stratified spaces; the exit-path (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category; and the constructible tangent bundle — all of which are necessary for a discussion of stratified tangential structures thereon. We prove new theorems about the contractibility of spaces of embeddings of stratified spaces into Euclidean space, and we prove a stratified analogue of the famed Ehresmann fibration theorem — which is the key to unlocking comparisons with the infrastructure developed for the unstratified case.

In Chapter 5 we construct an interval Segal space, i.e. an (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category of conically smooth stratified dd-dimensional bordisms. We begin by introducing the notion of a conically smooth stratified topological dd-manifold by stipulating a suitable (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category of basics BscdSd−1\mathrm{Bsc}^{S^{d-1}}_{d}, whose links are stratified spheres of appropriate codimensions. Secondly, we produce a pre-interval space SBordd\mathcal{S}\mathrm{Bord}_{d} of stratified topological dd-dimensional bordisms, again using the concordance resolution for smooth ∞\infty-sheaves and a restriction along the cosimplicial smooth manifold Δ⟶Man\Delta\longrightarrow\mathrm{Man}, and show that it is an interval Segal space.

Lastly, we endow this interval Segal space with a symmetric monoidal structure agreeing with the expected one coming from disjoint union. After defining this symmetric monoidal interval Segal space, we initiate a discussion on suitable notions of tangential structures for stratified bordisms — in particular, we introduce the notion of oriented discrete defect datum by way of discrete right fibrations over BscdSd−1\mathrm{Bsc}^{S^{d-1}}_{d}, as an attempt to make contact with the defect data for stratified bordisms introduced in the work of Carqueville et al. (see [CRS19]) and we prove a comparison result for the stratified oriented case d=2d=2.

We conclude Chapter 5 by endowing the resulting interval Segal space of conically smooth stratified dd-bordisms with the symmetric monoidal structure induced by disjoint union. We then initiate a discussion of tangential structures in the stratified setting and, in particular, explain how discrete defect data can be encoded as tangential data via discrete right fibrations over the chosen (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category of basics. As a first test of this perspective, we prove a comparison result in the oriented stratified case d=2d=2. Finally, we define a (derived) stratified topological quantum field theory to be a symmetric monoidal functor from the symmetric monoidal (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category of stratified bordisms constructed here to a symmetric monoidal (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category C\mathcal{C}.

Chapter 6 is a future outlook. In the first section, following ideas in unpublished work of Manuel Araújo and Pedro Boavida de Brito, we introduce a higher-dimensional generalization of Int\mathrm{Int}, denoted □d\square_{d} for d>1d>1, aimed at extending interval Segal techniques to the study of (∞,d)(\infty,d)-categories. We prove that simplicial co-presheaves on □d\square_{d} satisfying suitable higher-dimensional analogues of the Segal and completeness conditions present the (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category Cat(∞,d)\mathrm{Cat}_{(\infty,d)}, and we outline how this formalism should be used to build a □d\square_d-space of stratified bordisms and verify the corresponding Segal condition, thus providing a candidate model for fully extended stratified TQFTs à la Atiyah–Baez–Dolan–Lurie. In the second section we return to the non-extended setting and sketch how constructible factorization algebras and stratified factorization homology can be leveraged as a mechanism for producing stratified (and derived) defect TQFTs from appropriate stratified disk-algebras, in the spirit of the factorization-homological approach of Scheimbauer and Calaque.

Acknowledgments

The effort that has culminated in this thesis is mostly invisible to the casual reader: mere words that blend into sections, which in turn blend into chapters. The hours spent talking to people, reading, writing, absorbing and being absorbed; the time and space for reflection asked of those close to me; the doubts, detours, and conversations that shaped the work — all remain out of sight, except perhaps in this brief section.

I will begin with my advisors, John Huerta and Pedro Boavida de Brito. To John, without whom I would never have considered the possibility of attempting to be a mathematician: you have become a friend, and I hope your courage and attitude towards mathematical and academic freedom are threaded throughout this text — your patience, your mathematical culture, and your razor-blade rigour, too, have saved me from terminal exhaustion. To Pedro Boavida de Brito, your willingness to endure my many unannounced door knocks has helped shape this thesis as much as any theorem or proposition: our endless conversations and your kindness and generosity in sharing your ideas are the lifeblood of this thesis — doing manifold topology near you has been an honour reserved for a select few. I would also like to acknowledge my former co-supervisor, Roger Picken — to you I am indebted for all the hours spent listening to me talk in seminars, all the time you spent engaging me and my ideas, and for your unmatched attentiveness to the well-being of your students.

I am also grateful to the Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT) for funding my PhD, and for making possible the years of attention and freedom on which this work depended. I thank Pedro Resende, president of CAMGSD, for his constant support, for the kindness with which he accompanied this process, and for the enthusiasm for category theory that he has always made feel not only legitimate, but contagious. I am equally grateful to Filipe Mena, president of the Doctoral Program in Mathematics and a member of the jury, for his steady support of the program and for the care with which he accompanied this final stage. I would also like to leave a note of appreciation to João Pimentel Nunes, from whom I learned so much about geometry and teaching, and who always heeded my calls to attend conferences, workshops, and seminars.

I am deeply indebted to Manuel Araújo for our many hours of conversation about TQFTs, string diagrams, and higher categories, for your kindness in sharing your unpublished work, and for your generosity in calmly explaining it to me. To David Ayala I owe all the courage I had to muster to face the homotopical higher-category theory laid bare in this thesis — your kindness in sharing your work, your encouragement, and your mentorship left an indelible mark on me. Your work, together with that of John Francis, Aaron Mazel-Gee, Hiro Lee Tanaka, and Nick Rozenblyum, on stratified spaces and factorization homology is among the strongest foundations on which this thesis stands. To Nils Carqueville I in some sense owe this thesis: our long conversations during your stay in Lisbon, and your stern and steady words, helped me channel and focus my attention towards the problem of strengthening the foundations of (higher) homotopical defect TQFTs. Your seminal work on defect TQFTs, together with that of Jürgen Fuchs, Catherine Meusburger, and Ingo Runkel, is the raison d’être for this work. Thanks for your generosity and your stewardship.

Across the many years I spent thinking about higher algebra and topological field theories, I met some of the most passionate, brilliant, and kindest people I have ever met: Chun-Yu — to whom I owe some joint work —, Jennifer Brown, Rodrigo Duarte, Ben Haioun, David Jordan — I will never again witness someone draw skeins with such fiery passion on their kitchen table —, Patrick Kinnear, Theodoros Lagiotis, L’ukas Muller, Jack Romo — an academic brother of sorts —, Chris Schommer-Pries — it was one of my greatest pleasures to hear about 3-dualizability and the status of the cobordism hypothesis directly from you —, Arber Selimi, Luuk Stehouwer, Daniel Teixeira, Matthew Yu, and Markus Zetto. All of you have made my four-year path through research mathematics among the most enjoyable and intellectually stimulating years I have had. A final note of sincere appreciation to Nino Scalbi — one my academic brothers with whom I shared hours and hours talking about mathematics and higher categories, without your precious inputs and your example to lead the way, I fear for what could have been. To Rui Peixoto, my other academic sibling, to you I owe you the moments of brilliance you shared with me in the form of questions, seminars, lectures, notes, insights, travels and so much more — I wish you well.

To my office mates: Filipe Berletta, for being our office’s academic stepfather — without you we would all have been lost; Rafael Ferreira, for all the forró and all the relaxed energy you brought to our office; Lucas Ferrero; Diogo Franquinho, for all we have shared and lived so far, and for all we will still live together — you have become a friend for life; long live Gradient; Jasper Kager; Mena; Christoph Obenaus, thank you for being a friend, for sharing your passion for sports and for learning, and for inspiring me to become a better man; Francisco Pais, you have become a friend with whom I am sure I will still share great memories — thanks for everything; João Rodrigues; Miguel Santiago, thank you for your camaraderie and for our discussions about cylinders and life; Serena; and Leander Stecker, for all the beers and camaraderie.

To those who made my life outside Técnico not only bearable, but joyful, I begin with the people with whom I had the pleasure of teaching at Nova SBE. Frederico Toulson, more than an academic cousin and my shadow through the halls of Nova, you have become a trusted friend; it was a pleasure to do everything with you: mathematics, lunches, teaching, meetings, everything — please stay around. To Maria João Braga, I owe my job at Nova SBE to you; more importantly, I owe you all the compassion, respect, and kindness with which you always treated me — you are, without a shadow of a doubt, my academic mother. To Tânia I owe our many long conversations about mathematics and teaching, and a great deal of gratitude for your patience in hearing me ramble on about what needed to change in the Linear Algebra course. So many more people should be named here: Maria Helena Almeida, Rodrigo Barrela, Ernesto Freitas, Patrícia Ramos, and, I am sure, many others whose names I cannot now recall.

To Feliu and Lu, thank you for the warmth with which you made me feel at home in Barcelona when I felt as though the world was ending.

To my family and friends: no words will ever make good on the debts I owe you. To my parents, everything — I speak for the four of us: everything. To my siblings, Madalena, Miguel, and Carolina, I owe the joy you have brought into my life. Discovering the world beside you gave me the confidence, and the reason, to pursue a PhD in the first place.

Finally, to Elisa: I owe you the most of what can be measured, and possibly all of what cannot. Without you, I would have given up on writing this long ago; without you, this journey would have been a fruitless chase for reason. I am happy to have had your hand in mine through it all, and happier still to feel it holding mine as I write these words.

Index of notation

  • The symbol ≅\cong means isomorphism in whichever category the morphism inhabits.

  • The symbol ≃\simeq means equivalence. Further context should specify what type of equivalence we are referring to.

  • Cat\mathrm{Cat} means the category of small categories and functors.

  • Δ\Delta means the skeleton of the category of finite totally ordered sets and order-preserving maps.

  • O±\mathrm{O}_{\pm} refers to the category of finite linearly ordered sets with a distinguished minimum and maximum and order- and extrema-preserving maps.

  • Γ\Gamma refers to the Segal category.

  • Δn\Delta^n is the simplicial set corresponding to the representable of [n]∈Δ[n]\in\Delta—it is also referred to by the standard nn-simplex.

  • Δ[n]\Delta[n] is the simplicial space corresponding to Δn\Delta^n under the image of sSet↪Fun(Δop,sSet)\mathrm{sSet}\hookrightarrow\mathrm{Fun}(\Delta^{\mathrm{op}},\mathrm{sSet}).

  • Int\mathrm{Int} refers to the interval category.

  • cInt\mathrm{cInt} refers to the closed interval category.

  • γ:Int⟶Δop\gamma:\mathrm{Int}\longrightarrow\Delta^{\mathrm{op}} is the canonical comparison functor.

  • U(A1,…,An)∈Int\mathrm{U}(A_1,\ldots,A_n)\in\mathrm{Int} denotes the interval object determined by a finite string of closed intervals.

  • cor⁡(I)\operatorname{cor}(I) denotes the core of an interval object I∈IntI\in\mathrm{Int}.

  • Wπ0\mathcal{W}_{\pi_0} denotes the class of morphisms in Int\mathrm{Int} inducing isomorphisms on path components.

  • ISSp\mathrm{ISSp} denotes the model category of interval Segal spaces.

  • CISSp\mathrm{CISSp} denotes the model category of complete interval Segal spaces.

  • Ho(C)\mathrm{Ho}(\mathcal{C}) denotes the homotopy category of an (∞,1)(\infty,1)-category or Segal-type model C\mathcal{C}.

  • Man\mathrm{Man} denotes the category, or site, of smooth manifolds.

  • A∙A^\bullet denotes the standard cosimplicial smooth affine simplex.

  • Bord~d,V\widetilde{\mathrm{Bord}}_{d,V}, Bordd,V\mathrm{Bord}_{d,V}, and Bordd\mathrm{Bord}_d denote the smooth bordism pre-interval object, the fixed-ambient interval Segal space, and the stabilized interval Segal space of dd-dimensional smooth bordisms, respectively.

  • Θn\Theta_n is the iterated wreath product Δ≀Θn−1\Delta\wr\Theta_{n-1}.

  • □n\Box_n denotes the nn-cubes category introduced in the outlook chapter.

  • C‾(X)\overline{C}(X) refers to the closed cone on a topological stratified space (X→P)(X\to P).

References

  1. [1][CEG23]
  2. [2][CDR25]
  3. [3][Lur09b]

Paper details

vlnc:W_fc2g22rm
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents