Introduction
Baykur [3 ] constructed a planar contact 3–manifold, supported by the open book ( Σ 0 6 , t d B ) (\Sigma^6_0,t_dB) ( Σ 0 6 , t d B ) with B = t u t v t w t z B=t_ut_vt_wt_z B = t u t v t w t z , where u , v , w , z , d u,v,w,z,d u , v , w , z , d are the curves of Figure 4 , and t c t_c t c denotes the right-handed Dehn twist along a simple closed curve c c c . We use functional notation for products in the mapping class group, so that t a t b t_at_b t a t b means that we first apply t b t_b t b . Here Σ 0 6 \Sigma^6_0 Σ 0 6 is the disk with holes δ 1 , … , δ 5 \delta_1,\ldots,\delta_5 δ 1 , … , δ 5 , numbered from left to right, and outer boundary δ 0 \delta_0 δ 0 . Baykur’s Stein fillings X n B X^B_n X n B , n ≥ 0 n\geq0 n ≥ 0 , are the Lefschetz fibrations of the positive factorizations t d t α n B t α − n t_dt_\alpha^nBt_\alpha^{-n} t d t α n B t α − n , where α \alpha α is the curve of Figure 2 , whose Dehn twist commutes with B B B , and they are pairwise non-homeomorphic since π 1 ( X n B ) ≅ Z / ( 2 n + 1 ) ⋊ − 1 Z \pi_1(X^B_n)\cong\mathbb{Z}/(2n+1)\rtimes_{-1}\mathbb{Z} π 1 ( X n B ) ≅ Z / ( 2 n + 1 ) ⋊ − 1 Z . In [19 ] we identified the smooth topology of Baykur’s example, showed that the Lefschetz fibration of the factorization B B B is diffeomorphic to the disk cotangent bundle D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K of the Klein bottle K K K , and constructed further fillings and rational homology ball fillings of related planar contact 3–manifolds.
Figure 2. Top two rows: the vanishing cycles V 0 , … , V 3 V_0,\ldots,V_3 V 0 , … , V 3 of B ′ B' B ′ , and the curves α ′ \alpha' α ′ and β ′ \beta' β ′ . Bottom row: Baykur’s curves α \alpha α and β \beta β , the curve d ′ d' d ′ , and the free generators x 1 , … , x 5 x_1,\ldots,x_5 x 1 , … , x 5 of π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,*) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) , with ∗ ∈ δ 0 *\in\delta_0 ∗ ∈ δ 0 .
Figure 4. Baykur’s curves u u u , v v v , w w w , z z z , d d d on the page Σ 0 6 \Sigma^6_0 Σ 0 6 .
In this paper we show that Baykur’s construction can be carried out directly on the canonical contact structure of the unit cotangent bundle S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K , the boundary of D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K , and that this explains the infinitely many fillings geometrically. Let ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) (\Sigma^6_0,B') ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) , with B ′ = t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 B'=t_{V_0}t_{V_1}t_{V_2}t_{V_3} B ′ = t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 , be the planar open book of Oba and the author [17 Theorem 3.7] supporting ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) . Its Lefschetz fibration is Johns’ exact symplectic Lefschetz fibration on D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K [13 ] , and its vanishing cycles V 0 , V 1 , V 2 , V 3 V_0,V_1,V_2,V_3 V 0 , V 1 , V 2 , V 3 , in the notation of [14 Figure 1] , are shown in Figure 2 . Let β \beta β be the round curve enclosing δ 3 \delta_3 δ 3 and δ 4 \delta_4 δ 4 , shown in Figure 2 , and let σ i \sigma_i σ i denote the half twist interchanging δ i \delta_i δ i and δ i + 1 \delta_{i+1} δ i + 1 (§ 2 ). We consider the curves
d ′ = σ 2 ( β ) , α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 ( β ) , d'=\sigma_2(\beta),\qquad\alpha'=\sigma_1\sigma_2(\beta), d ′ = σ 2 ( β ) , α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 ( β ) ,
shown in Figure 2 . We use primes because B ′ B' B ′ , d ′ d' d ′ and α ′ \alpha' α ′ correspond to Baykur’s B B B , d d d and α \alpha α : there is a diffeomorphism g g g of the page Σ 0 6 \Sigma^6_0 Σ 0 6 with g B g − 1 = B ′ gBg^{-1}=B' g B g − 1 = B ′ , g ( d ) = d ′ g(d)=d' g ( d ) = d ′ and g ( α ) = α ′ g(\alpha)=\alpha' g ( α ) = α ′ (§ 4 ).
Our main result is the following.
2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. 57K33, 57K43, 57K20.
Key words and phrases. contact structure, Stein filling, planar open book, Klein bottle, unit cotangent bundle, Kirby calculus.
Theorem 1.1. (1) The Dehn twist t α ′ t_{\alpha'} t α ′ commutes with B ′ B' B ′ , and it induces a contactomorphism ψ \psi ψ of ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) .
(2) Let ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) be the contact 3 3 3 –manifold obtained from ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) by Legendrian surgery along a page realization of d ′ d' d ′ . For every n ≥ 0 n \ge0 n ≥ 0 , the Stein domain
X n = D T ∗ K ∪ h ψ − n ( d ′ ) , X_n = DT^*K \cup h_{\psi^{-n}(d')}, X n = D T ∗ K ∪ h ψ − n ( d ′ ) , obtained by attaching a Weinstein 2 2 2 –handle along the image of this Legendrian knot under ψ − n \psi^{-n} ψ − n , is a Stein filling of ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) , and π 1 ( X n ) ≅ Z / ( 2 n + 1 ) ⋊ − 1 Z \pi_1(X_n) \cong\mathbb{Z}/(2n+1)\rtimes_{-1}\mathbb{Z} π 1 ( X n ) ≅ Z / ( 2 n + 1 ) ⋊ − 1 Z . In particular the fillings X n X_n X n are pairwise non-homeomorphic, and no positive power of ψ \psi ψ extends over D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K , even as a homeomorphism.
(3) The contact $3$–manifold ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) is contactomorphic to Baykur’s planar contact 3 3 3 –manifold, and X n X_n X n is diffeomorphic to Baykur’s filling X B X_B X B for every $n \ge 0.
Here D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K carries the Stein structure of the Lefschetz fibration of ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) (\Sigma^6_0,B') ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) , transported by the diffeomorphism constructed in the proof, which is compatible with the boundary contact structures. We expect it to be deformation equivalent to the canonical one (Remark 3.1). The 2 2 2 –handle is attached with framing one less than the page framing. In the proof we show that ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) is supported by the open book ( Σ 0 6 , t d ′ B ′ ) (\Sigma^6_0,t_{d'}B') ( Σ 0 6 , t d ′ B ′ ) , and that X n X_n X n is the Lefschetz fibration of the positive factorization t d ′ t α ′ n B ′ t α ′ − n t_{d'}t_{\alpha'}^nB't_{\alpha'}^{-n} t d ′ t α ′ n B ′ t α ′ − n of t d ′ B ′ t_{d'}B' t d ′ B ′ . In particular, X 0 X_0 X 0 is the Lefschetz fibration of t d ′ B ′ = t d ′ t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 t_{d'}B'=t_{d'}t_{V_0}t_{V_1}t_{V_2}t_{V_3} t d ′ B ′ = t d ′ t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 . The point of Theorem 1.1 is that it takes place on ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) itself. Part (1) follows from B ′ ( α ′ ) = α ′ B'(\alpha')=\alpha' B ′ ( α ′ ) = α ′ , which we see by following α ′ \alpha' α ′ through the four twists of B ′ B' B ′ (Lemma 2.1 ), and part (2) uses Johns’ theorem and a computation of fundamental groups (Lemma 2.2 ). For part (3) we show that Baykur’s factorization B B B becomes B ′ B' B ′ after three Hurwitz moves and a diffeomorphism g g g of the page with g ( d ) = d ′ g(d)=d' g ( d ) = d ′ and g ( α ) = α ′ g(\alpha)=\alpha' g ( α ) = α ′ (§ 4 ).
The monodromy of the canonical open book of S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K also satisfies a lantern-type relation, which comes from an arrangement of five real lines with two triple points (Proposition 2.3):
t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 t α ′ t β ′ = t δ 0 t δ 1 2 t δ 2 2 t δ 3 2 t δ 4 2 t δ 5 2 . t_{V_0}t_{V_1}t_{V_2}t_{V_3}t_{\alpha'}t_{\beta'}=t_{\delta_0}t_{\delta_1}^{2}t_{\delta_2}^{2}t_{\delta_3}^{2}t_{\delta_4}^{2}t_{\delta_5}^{2}. t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 t α ′ t β ′ = t δ 0 t δ 1 2 t δ 2 2 t δ 3 2 t δ 4 2 t δ 5 2 .
where β ′ \beta' β ′ is the curve of Figure 2 , disjoint from α ′ \alpha' α ′ . It is Baykur’s generalized lantern relation [3 Lemma 3] transported by g g g (Remark 4.3). Thus B ′ B' B ′ is a product of boundary twists composed with negative Dehn twists along the two disjoint curves α ′ \alpha' α ′ and β ′ \beta' β ′ . Since boundary twists are central, this gives another explanation of Theorem 1.1 (1).
A geometric point of view on the fillings. Part (2) replaces the list of positive factorizations by a single geometric picture with three ingredients: a fixed filling, a Legendrian knot, and a contact mapping class. The fixed filling is D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K . By Li and the author [14 Corollary 1.2] , every minimal weak symplectic filling of ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) is homeomorphic to D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K . The Legendrian knot is a page realization of d ′ d' d ′ , and the contact mapping class is ψ \psi ψ . Since ψ \psi ψ is a contactomorphism, Legendrian surgery along every translate produces the same contact manifold ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) , and the pairwise non-isomorphic fundamental groups show that the framed attaching knots are inequivalent under boundary diffeomorphisms that extend over the fixed filling. From this point of view, the infinitely many fillings are produced by the gap between the contact mapping class group of the boundary and the subgroup of mapping classes that extend over the filling. As a consequence, we obtain the following.
Corollary 1.2. There is a Stein fillable planar contact 3 3 3 –manifold with a unique minimal weak symplectic filling, up to homeomorphism, such that a single Legendrian surgery on it yields a contact 3 3 3 –manifold with infinitely many Stein fillings, up to homeomorphism. In particular, finiteness of minimal symplectic fillings is not preserved under Legendrian surgery, even within planar contact 3 3 3 –manifolds.
In fact ψ \psi ψ has infinite order in the smooth mapping class group of S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K , and no nontrivial power of ψ \psi ψ is isotopic to the restriction of a homeomorphism of D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K (Corollary 3.3).
Rational homology ball fillings. The planar contact 3 3 3 –manifolds ( Y m , ξ m ) (Y_m,\xi_m) ( Y m , ξ m ) and ( Y m ′ , ξ m ′ ) (Y'_m,\xi'_m) ( Y m ′ , ξ m ′ ) , m ≥ 1 m \ge1 m ≥ 1 , of [19 Theorem 1.1] are supported by the open books ( Σ 0 6 , t d m B ) (\Sigma^6_0,t_{d_m}B) ( Σ 0 6 , t d m B ) and ( Σ 0 6 , t d m ′ B ) (\Sigma^6_0,t_{d'_m}B) ( Σ 0 6 , t d m ′ B ) , which differ from Baykur’s only in the curve d d d . (The prime in d m ′ d'_m d m ′ and Y m ′ Y'_m Y m ′ is the notation of [19 ] , and it is unrelated to the primes in B ′ B' B ′ , d ′ d' d ′ and α ′ \alpha' α ′ .) The same construction applies to them.
Corollary 1.3. For every m ≥ 1 m \ge1 m ≥ 1 , the contact 3 3 3 –manifolds ( Y m , ξ m ) (Y_m,\xi_m) ( Y m , ξ m ) and ( Y m ′ , ξ m ′ ) (Y'_m,\xi'_m) ( Y m ′ , ξ m ′ ) are obtained from ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) by a single Legendrian surgery, along page realizations of g ( d m ) g(d_m) g ( d m ) and g ( d m ′ ) g(d'_m) g ( d m ′ ) , where g g g is the diffeomorphism of the page of Lemma 4.1, and their pairwise non-homeomorphic rational homology ball Stein fillings X m , n X_{m,n} X m , n and X m , n ′ X'_{m,n} X m , n ′ , n ≥ 0 n \ge0 n ≥ 0 , of [19 Theorem 1.1] are diffeomorphic to D T ∗ K ∪ h ψ − n ( g ( d m ) ) DT^*K \cup h_{\psi^{-n}(g(d_m))} D T ∗ K ∪ h ψ − n ( g ( d m )) and D T ∗ K ∪ h ψ − n ( g ( d m ′ ) ) DT^*K \cup h_{\psi^{-n}(g(d'_m))} D T ∗ K ∪ h ψ − n ( g ( d m ′ )) , respectively. In particular, a single Legendrian surgery on a contact 3 3 3 –manifold with a unique minimal weak symplectic filling, up to homeomorphism, can produce a contact 3 3 3 –manifold with infinitely many pairwise non-homeomorphic rational homology ball Stein fillings.
Outline. In § 2 we recall the canonical contact structure ξ c a n \xi_{\mathrm{can}} ξ can on S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K and its planar open book ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) (\Sigma^6_0,B') ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) , introduce the curves d ′ d' d ′ , α ′ \alpha' α ′ and β ′ \beta' β ′ , and prove that t α ′ t_{\alpha'} t α ′ commutes with B ′ B' B ′ (Lemma 2.1 ). We also compute the fundamental groups needed later (Lemma 2.2 ). In § 2.3 we state a lantern-type relation for B ′ B' B ′ (Proposition 2.3), which comes from an arrangement of real lines, and we show that the second configuration of vanishing cycles left open in [14 ] occurs (Remark 2.4). In § 3 we prove parts (1) and (2) of Theorem 1.1 and Corollary 1.2, extend the construction to arbitrary page curves (Proposition 3.2), and derive the consequence for the mapping class groups of S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K (Corollary 3.3). In § 4 we relate Baykur’s factorization to B ′ B' B ′ by Hurwitz moves and a diffeomorphism of the page, which proves Theorem 1.1 (3), and we deduce Corollary 1.3 . In § 5 we give a Stein diagram for the underlying smooth manifold of a related filling W 0 W_0 W 0 , and we state a conjecture. In Section A we give two proofs of Proposition 2.3.
Declaration on the use of AI. In the preparation of this paper the author used LLM tools for drawing the figures in TikZ from the author’s own diagrams, and for editing the text to improve the presentation. The author takes full responsibility for the content of the paper.
The open book of S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K
The canonical contact structure
Let Σ \Sigma Σ be a closed surface, orientable or not, and let π : T ∗ Σ → Σ \pi:T^*\Sigma\to\Sigma π : T ∗ Σ → Σ be its cotangent bundle. The canonical 1 1 1 –form λ c a n \lambda_{\mathrm{can}} λ can on T ∗ Σ T^*\Sigma T ∗ Σ is defined at a covector p ∈ T q ∗ Σ p \in T_q^*\Sigma p ∈ T q ∗ Σ by λ c a n ( v ) = p ( d π ( v ) ) \lambda_{\mathrm{can}}(v)=p(d\pi(v)) λ can ( v ) = p ( d π ( v )) , and in local coordinates ( q 1 , q 2 ) (q_1,q_2) ( q 1 , q 2 ) on Σ \Sigma Σ , with the dual fiber coordinates ( p 1 , p 2 ) (p_1,p_2) ( p 1 , p 2 ) , it is λ c a n = p 1 d q 1 + p 2 d q 2 \lambda_{\mathrm{can}}=p_1\,dq_1+p_2\,dq_2 λ can = p 1 d q 1 + p 2 d q 2 . Its differential ω c a n = d λ c a n = d p 1 ∧ d q 1 + d p 2 ∧ d q 2 \omega_{\mathrm{can}}=d\lambda_{\mathrm{can}}=dp_1\wedge dq_1+dp_2\wedge dq_2 ω can = d λ can = d p 1 ∧ d q 1 + d p 2 ∧ d q 2 is a symplectic form, so ω c a n ∧ ω c a n \omega_{\mathrm{can}}\wedge\omega_{\mathrm{can}} ω can ∧ ω can is a volume form, and T ∗ Σ T^*\Sigma T ∗ Σ is canonically oriented even when Σ \Sigma Σ is nonorientable. Fix a Riemannian metric on Σ \Sigma Σ , and let D T ∗ Σ DT^*\Sigma D T ∗ Σ and S T ∗ Σ ST^*\Sigma S T ∗ Σ be the bundles of covectors of norm at most one and exactly one. The Liouville vector field of λ c a n \lambda_{\mathrm{can}} λ can is the fiberwise radial vector field p 1 ∂ p 1 + p 2 ∂ p 2 p_1\partial_{p_1}+p_2\partial_{p_2} p 1 ∂ p 1 + p 2 ∂ p 2 , which is transverse to S T ∗ Σ ST^*\Sigma S T ∗ Σ and points outward. Hence λ c a n \lambda_{\mathrm{can}} λ can restricts to a contact form on S T ∗ Σ ST^*\Sigma S T ∗ Σ , whose kernel is the canonical contact structure ξ c a n \xi_{\mathrm{can}} ξ can , and ( D T ∗ Σ , ω c a n ) (DT^*\Sigma,\omega_{\mathrm{can}}) ( D T ∗ Σ , ω can ) is an exact symplectic filling of ( S T ∗ Σ , ξ c a n ) (ST^*\Sigma,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ Σ , ξ can ) , with S T ∗ Σ ST^*\Sigma S T ∗ Σ oriented as its boundary. Up to isotopy, ξ c a n \xi_{\mathrm{can}} ξ can does not depend on the metric. Moreover D T ∗ Σ DT^*\Sigma D T ∗ Σ carries a Stein structure inducing ξ c a n \xi_{\mathrm{can}} ξ can on its boundary. For a nonorientable surface Σ \Sigma Σ , an explicit Stein diagram of D T ∗ Σ DT^*\Sigma D T ∗ Σ can be obtained from the solution of [10, Exercise 11.2.5(a)]: Figure 12.75 there gives Stein diagrams of the disk bundles over $\mathbb{R}P^2$, and Figure 12.76 shows how to obtain the general case by band summing. This is worked out in [18 Figure 2] , and for the Klein bottle the resulting Stein diagram of $DT^*K$ is shown in {xref}Fig. 6`, after removing the green knot.
A planar open book supporting the canonical contact structure
For the closed nonorientable surface N k N_k N k of genus k k k , Oba and the author [17 Theorem 3.7] constructed a planar open book, with page the disk with 2 k + 1 2k+1 2 k + 1 holes and monodromy the product of the Dehn twists along k + 2 k+2 k + 2 curves V 0 , … , V k + 1 V_0,\ldots,V_{k+1} V 0 , … , V k + 1 , supporting the canonical contact structure on the unit cotangent bundle S T ∗ N k ST^*N_k S T ∗ N k . For the Klein bottle K = N 2 K=N_2 K = N 2 this is an open book ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) (\Sigma^6_0,B') ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) supporting ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) (the monodromy B ′ B' B ′ is denoted ϕ 2 \phi_2 ϕ 2 there), with
B ′ = t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 , B'=t_{V_0}t_{V_1}t_{V_2}t_{V_3}, B ′ = t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 ,
see also [14 Lemma 2.3] .
The left of Figure 1 shows the curves of [14 Figure 1] for k = 2 k=2 k = 2 , where we write V 3 V_3 V 3 for V k + 1 V_{k+1} V k + 1 . The holes labeled 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 0,1,2,3,4 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 there are our δ 3 , δ 2 , δ 1 , δ 4 , δ 5 \delta_3,\delta_2,\delta_1,\delta_4,\delta_5 δ 3 , δ 2 , δ 1 , δ 4 , δ 5 , and the outer boundary, labeled 5 5 5 , is δ 0 \delta_0 δ 0 . Fix a basepoint ∗ ∈ δ 0 \ast\in\delta_0 ∗ ∈ δ 0 and the free generators x 1 , … , x 5 x_1,\ldots,x_5 x 1 , … , x 5 of π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,\ast) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) shown in Figure 2 , which are the same generators of [3 Figure 2(h)] . We read products of paths from left to right. Moving the holes as indicated on the right of Figure 1 places them in a row, and carries the curves V 0 , … , V 3 V_0,\ldots,V_3 V 0 , … , V 3 to those of Figure 2 . In terms of the generators x 1 , … , x 5 x_1,\ldots,x_5 x 1 , … , x 5 , they are given by the words
Figure 1. Left: the curves V 0 , … , V 3 V_0,\ldots,V_3 V 0 , … , V 3 of [14 Figure 1] for k = 2 k=2 k = 2 , with V 3 = V k + 1 V_3=V_{k+1} V 3 = V k + 1 . Right: moving the holes along the arrows places them in a row.
V 0 = x 4 x 3 x 2 , V 1 = x 2 x 1 , V 2 = x 5 x 4 , V 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 , (1) V_0=x_4x_3x_2,\qquad V_1=x_2x_1,\qquad V_2=x_5x_4,\qquad V_3=x_5x_4x_3x_1x_4^{-1}, \tag*{(1)} V 0 = x 4 x 3 x 2 , V 1 = x 2 x 1 , V 2 = x 5 x 4 , V 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 , (1)
up to conjugation and inversion.
We also fix the half-twist convention on π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,\ast) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) . With our convention for path products, the boundary of the two-hole disk containing δ i \delta_i δ i and δ i + 1 \delta_{i+1} δ i + 1 is represented by γ i = x i + 1 x i \gamma_i=x_{i+1}x_i γ i = x i + 1 x i . For 1 ≤ i ≤ 4 1\leq i\leq4 1 ≤ i ≤ 4 , let σ i \sigma_i σ i denote the clockwise half twist interchanging δ i \delta_i δ i and δ i + 1 \delta_{i+1} δ i + 1 , with the page oriented as in Figure 2 . Its action is
σ i : x i ↦ x i − 1 x i + 1 x i , x i + 1 ↦ x i , x j ↦ x j ( j ≠ i , i + 1 ) . (2) \sigma_i:\quad x_i\mapsto x_i^{-1}x_{i+1}x_i,\qquad x_{i+1}\mapsto x_i,\qquad x_j\mapsto x_j\ (j\ne i,i+1). \tag*{(2)} σ i : x i ↦ x i − 1 x i + 1 x i , x i + 1 ↦ x i , x j ↦ x j ( j = i , i + 1 ) . (2)
Its inverse acts by
σ i − 1 : x i ↦ x i + 1 , x i + 1 ↦ x i + 1 x i x i + 1 − 1 , x j ↦ x j ( j ≠ i , i + 1 ) . (3) \sigma_i^{-1}:\quad x_i\mapsto x_{i+1},\qquad x_{i+1}\mapsto x_{i+1}x_ix_{i+1}^{-1},\qquad x_j\mapsto x_j\ (j\ne i,i+1). \tag*{(3)} σ i − 1 : x i ↦ x i + 1 , x i + 1 ↦ x i + 1 x i x i + 1 − 1 , x j ↦ x j ( j = i , i + 1 ) . (3)
These formulas fix γ i \gamma_i γ i and satisfy σ i 2 ( x j ) = γ i − 1 x j γ i \sigma_i^2(x_j)=\gamma_i^{-1}x_j\gamma_i σ i 2 ( x j ) = γ i − 1 x j γ i for j = i , i + 1 j=i,i+1 j = i , i + 1 . Thus they are compatible with the based boundary word, and σ i 2 \sigma_i^2 σ i 2 acts as the left-handed Dehn twist along the boundary of the disk containing δ i , δ i + 1 \delta_i,\delta_{i+1} δ i , δ i + 1 .
A right-handed Dehn twist along the boundary of a disk containing the consecutive holes δ i , … , δ j \delta_i,\ldots,\delta_j δ i , … , δ j conjugates each of x i , … , x j x_i,\ldots,x_j x i , … , x j by the boundary word x j ⋯ x i x_j\cdots x_i x j ⋯ x i and fixes the other generators, since σ i 2 \sigma_i^2 σ i 2 is the left-handed twist. In particular β = x 4 x 3 \beta=x_4x_3 β = x 4 x 3 , and (2) gives
β ′ = σ 2 ( β ) = x 4 x 2 , α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 ( β ) = x 4 x 1 ∼ x 1 x 4 , \beta'=\sigma_2(\beta)=x_4x_2,\qquad\alpha'=\sigma_1\sigma_2(\beta)=x_4x_1\sim x_1x_4, β ′ = σ 2 ( β ) = x 4 x 2 , α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 ( β ) = x 4 x 1 ∼ x 1 x 4 ,
where ∼ \sim ∼ denotes conjugacy. We also use the curve β ′ \beta' β ′ of Figure 2 , which is disjoint from α ′ \alpha' α ′ and represents x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5x_4x_3x_2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 up to conjugacy. Since freely homotopic essential simple closed curves on a surface are isotopic [4 ] , identities between curves can be checked on conjugacy classes in π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,*) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) , up to inversion.
Lemma 2.1. B ′ ( α ′ ) = α ′ B'(\alpha')=\alpha' B ′ ( α ′ ) = α ′ up to isotopy. Hence t α ′ t_{\alpha'} t α ′ commutes with B ′ B' B ′ .
Proof. Since B ′ t α ′ B ′ − 1 = t B ′ ( α ′ ) B't_{\alpha'}B'^{-1}=t_{B'(\alpha')} B ′ t α ′ B ′ − 1 = t B ′ ( α ′ ) , the second statement follows from the first. Applying the Dehn twists t V 3 t_{V_3} t V 3 , t V 2 t_{V_2} t V 2 , t V 1 t_{V_1} t V 1 and t V 0 t_{V_0} t V 0 to α ′ \alpha' α ′ in turn gives the four curves of Figure 3 , each obtained from the previous one by twisting along the corresponding curve of Figure 2 . The last of them is α ′ \alpha' α ′ .
Figure 3. The images of α ′ \alpha' α ′ under the four twists of B ′ = t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 B'=t_{V_0}t_{V_1}t_{V_2}t_{V_3} B ′ = t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 , applied from right to left (Lemma 2.1 ). The last curve is α ′ \alpha' α ′ .
Let X B ′ X_{B'} X B ′ denote the total space of the Lefschetz fibration with fiber Σ 0 6 \Sigma^6_0 Σ 0 6 and vanishing cycles V 0 , V 1 , V 2 , V 3 V_0,V_1,V_2,V_3 V 0 , V 1 , V 2 , V 3 .
Lemma 2.2. The fundamental group of X B ′ X_{B'} X B ′ is Q = ⟨ r , b ∣ b r b − 1 = r − 1 ⟩ ≅ π 1 ( K ) Q=\langle r,b\mid brb^{-1}=r^{-1}\rangle\cong\pi_1(K) Q = ⟨ r , b ∣ b r b − 1 = r − 1 ⟩ ≅ π 1 ( K ) , where the generators of π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,*) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) map to
x 1 ↦ r b , x 2 ↦ b − 1 r − 1 , x 3 ↦ r − 1 , x 4 ↦ b , x 5 ↦ b − 1 . x_1\mapsto rb,\qquad x_2\mapsto b^{-1}r^{-1},\qquad x_3\mapsto r^{-1},\qquad x_4\mapsto b,\qquad x_5\mapsto b^{-1}. x 1 ↦ r b , x 2 ↦ b − 1 r − 1 , x 3 ↦ r − 1 , x 4 ↦ b , x 5 ↦ b − 1 .
For every n ≥ 0 n\geq0 n ≥ 0 , the image of the curve t α ′ − n ( d ′ ) t_{\alpha'}^{-n}(d') t α ′ − n ( d ′ ) in Q Q Q is conjugate to r − ( 2 n + 1 ) r^{-(2n+1)} r − ( 2 n + 1 ) .
Proof. The fundamental group of a Lefschetz fibration over the disk is the fundamental group of its fiber divided by the normal closure of its vanishing cycles [10 §8.2] . By (1) , the relation V 1 = 1 V_{1}=1 V 1 = 1 gives x 2 = x 1 − 1 x_{2}=x_{1}^{-1} x 2 = x 1 − 1 , the relation V 2 = 1 V_{2}=1 V 2 = 1 gives x 5 = x 4 − 1 x_{5}=x_{4}^{-1} x 5 = x 4 − 1 , then V 3 = 1 V_{3}=1 V 3 = 1 gives x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 = 1 x_{3}x_{1}x_{4}^{-1}=1 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 = 1 , i.e., x 3 = x 4 x 1 − 1 x_{3}=x_{4}x_{1}^{-1} x 3 = x 4 x 1 − 1 , and finally V 0 = 1 V_{0}=1 V 0 = 1 becomes x 4 2 x 1 − 2 = 1 x_{4}^{2}x_{1}^{-2}=1 x 4 2 x 1 − 2 = 1 . So π 1 ( X B ′ ) = ⟨ x 1 , x 4 ∣ x 1 2 = x 4 2 ⟩ \pi_{1}(X_{B^{\prime}})=\langle x_{1},x_{4}\mid x_{1}^{2}=x_{4}^{2}\rangle π 1 ( X B ′ ) = ⟨ x 1 , x 4 ∣ x 1 2 = x 4 2 ⟩ . With r = x 1 x 4 − 1 r=x_{1}x_{4}^{-1} r = x 1 x 4 − 1 and b = x 4 b=x_{4} b = x 4 , so that x 1 = r b x_{1}=rb x 1 = r b , the relation x 1 2 = x 4 2 x_{1}^{2}=x_{4}^{2} x 1 2 = x 4 2 becomes r b r b = b 2 rbrb=b^{2} r b r b = b 2 , which is equivalent to b r b − 1 = r − 1 brb^{-1}=r^{-1} b r b − 1 = r − 1 . This gives the presentation Q Q Q and the images of the generators. In Q Q Q the element b 2 b^{2} b 2 is central, and b − 1 r k = r − k b − 1 b^{-1}r^{k}=r^{-k}b^{-1} b − 1 r k = r − k b − 1 for every k ∈ Z k\in\mathbb{Z} k ∈ Z .
Let η = σ 1 σ 2 \eta=\sigma_{1}\sigma_{2} η = σ 1 σ 2 , so that α ′ = η ( β ) \alpha^{\prime}=\eta(\beta) α ′ = η ( β ) and t α ′ = η t β η − 1 t_{\alpha^{\prime}}=\eta t_{\beta}\eta^{-1} t α ′ = η t β η − 1 . By (3) , η − 1 ( d ′ ) = η − 1 ( x 4 x 2 ) = x 4 x 3 x 1 x 3 − 1 \eta^{-1}(d^{\prime})=\eta^{-1}(x_{4}x_{2})=x_{4}x_{3}x_{1}x_{3}^{-1} η − 1 ( d ′ ) = η − 1 ( x 4 x 2 ) = x 4 x 3 x 1 x 3 − 1 . The twist t β − n t_{\beta}^{-n} t β − n conjugates x 3 x_{3} x 3 and x 4 x_{4} x 4 by β − n \beta^{-n} β − n , where β = x 4 x 3 \beta=x_{4}x_{3} β = x 4 x 3 , so it maps x 4 x 3 x 1 x 3 − 1 x_{4}x_{3}x_{1}x_{3}^{-1} x 4 x 3 x 1 x 3 − 1 to β x 1 β − n x 3 − 1 β n \beta x_{1}\beta^{-n}x_{3}^{-1}\beta^{n} β x 1 β − n x 3 − 1 β n . By (2) , η ( x 1 ) = x 1 − 1 x 2 x 1 \eta(x_{1})=x_{1}^{-1}x_{2}x_{1} η ( x 1 ) = x 1 − 1 x 2 x 1 , η ( x 3 ) = x 1 \eta(x_{3})=x_{1} η ( x 3 ) = x 1 and η ( x 4 ) = x 4 \eta(x_{4})=x_{4} η ( x 4 ) = x 4 , so η ( β ) = x 4 x 1 \eta(\beta)=x_{4}x_{1} η ( β ) = x 4 x 1 and
t α ′ ( d ′ ) = ( x 4 x 1 ) ( x 1 − 1 x 2 x 1 ) ( x 4 x 1 ) − n x 1 − 1 ( x 4 x 1 ) . t_{\alpha^{\prime}}(d^{\prime})=(x_{4}x_{1})(x_{1}^{-1}x_{2}x_{1})(x_{4}x_{1})^{-n}x_{1}^{-1}(x_{4}x_{1}). t α ′ ( d ′ ) = ( x 4 x 1 ) ( x 1 − 1 x 2 x 1 ) ( x 4 x 1 ) − n x 1 − 1 ( x 4 x 1 ) .
In Q Q Q we have x 4 x 1 ↦ b r b = r − 1 b 2 x_{4}x_{1}\mapsto brb=r^{-1}b^{2} x 4 x 1 ↦ b r b = r − 1 b 2 , and x 1 − 1 x 2 x 1 x_{1}^{-1}x_{2}x_{1} x 1 − 1 x 2 x 1 and x 1 − 1 x_{1}^{-1} x 1 − 1 both map to b − 1 r − 1 = r b − 1 b^{-1}r^{-1}=rb^{-1} b − 1 r − 1 = r b − 1 . Since b 2 b^{2} b 2 is central, the image is
( r − 1 b 2 ) ( r b − 1 ) ( r n b − 2 n ) ( r b − 1 ) ( r − n b 2 n ) = b − 1 r n + 1 b − 1 r − n b 2 = r − ( n + 1 ) b − 2 r − n b 2 = r − ( 2 n + 1 ) . (r^{-1}b^{2})(rb^{-1})(r^{n}b^{-2n})(rb^{-1})(r^{-n}b^{2n})=b^{-1}r^{n+1}b^{-1}r^{-n}b^{2}=r^{-(n+1)}b^{-2}r^{-n}b^{2}=r^{-(2n+1)}. ( r − 1 b 2 ) ( r b − 1 ) ( r n b − 2 n ) ( r b − 1 ) ( r − n b 2 n ) = b − 1 r n + 1 b − 1 r − n b 2 = r − ( n + 1 ) b − 2 r − n b 2 = r − ( 2 n + 1 ) .
A lantern-type relation
In this subsection we state a lantern-type relation satisfied by the monodromy B ′ B^{\prime} B ′ . It expresses B ′ B^{\prime} B ′ as a product of boundary twists composed with negative Dehn twists along two disjoint curves α ′ \alpha^{\prime} α ′ and β ′ \beta^{\prime} β ′ . Since boundary twists are central, this gives another reason why t α ′ t_{\alpha^{\prime}} t α ′ commutes with B ′ B^{\prime} B ′ . The relation comes from an arrangement of five real lines with two triple points, by Hironaka’s construction of relations in the mapping class group from line arrangements [11 ] , and it is Baykur’s generalized lantern relation [3 Lemma 3] transported by the diffeomorphism g g g of § 4 (Remark 4.3).
Proposition 2.3. We have
B ′ t α ′ t β ′ = Δ ′ , Δ ′ = t δ 0 t δ 1 2 t δ 2 2 t δ 3 t δ 4 2 t δ 5 2 . B^{\prime}t_{\alpha^{\prime}}t_{\beta^{\prime}}=\Delta^{\prime},\qquad\Delta^{\prime}=t_{\delta_{0}}t_{\delta_{1}}^{2}t_{\delta_{2}}^{2}t_{\delta_{3}}t_{\delta_{4}}^{2}t_{\delta_{5}}^{2}. B ′ t α ′ t β ′ = Δ ′ , Δ ′ = t δ 0 t δ 1 2 t δ 2 2 t δ 3 t δ 4 2 t δ 5 2 .
We give two proofs of Proposition 2.3 in Section A. The first follows Baykur’s proof of his generalized lantern relation via a line arrangement [3 , 11 ] , and the second is a direct computation of the action on the fundamental group of the page.
Remark 2.4. By Wendl [20 ] and Niederkrüger–Wendl [16 ] , every minimal weak symplectic filling of ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^{*}K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) is symplectically deformation equivalent to a Stein filling given by a positive allowable Lefschetz fibration, that is, by a positive factorization of B ′ B^{\prime} B ′ . Li and the author showed [14 Lemma 2.8 and Remark 2.9] that the vanishing cycles of such a factorization enclose the same holes as V 0 , … , V 3 V_{0},\ldots,V_{3} V 0 , … , V 3 , or else the holes { δ 1 , δ 2 , δ 3 } \{\delta_{1},\delta_{2},\delta_{3}\} { δ 1 , δ 2 , δ 3 } , { δ 3 , δ 4 , δ 5 } \{\delta_{3},\delta_{4},\delta_{5}\} { δ 3 , δ 4 , δ 5 } , { δ 2 , δ 4 } \{\delta_{2},\delta_{4}\} { δ 2 , δ 4 } and { δ 1 , δ 5 } \{\delta_{1},\delta_{5}\} { δ 1 , δ 5 } , a possibility left open in [14 Remark 2.9(2)] . This second possibility does occur. Let σ β ′ \sigma_{\beta^{\prime}} σ β ′ be the half twist supported in the disk bounded by β ′ \beta^{\prime} β ′ , interchanging δ 2 \delta_{2} δ 2 and δ 5 \delta_{5} δ 5 . It exchanges t δ 2 t_{\delta_{2}} t δ 2 and t δ 5 t_{\delta_{5}} t δ 5 , which have the same exponent in Δ ′ \Delta^{\prime} Δ ′ , so by Proposition 2.3 it commutes with B ′ = Δ ′ t β ′ − 1 t α ′ − 1 B^{\prime}=\Delta^{\prime}t_{\beta^{\prime}}^{-1}t_{\alpha^{\prime}}^{-1} B ′ = Δ ′ t β ′ − 1 t α ′ − 1 . Conjugating the factorization t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 t_{V_{0}}t_{V_{1}}t_{V_{2}}t_{V_{3}} t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 by σ β ′ \sigma_{\beta^{\prime}} σ β ′ gives a positive factorization of B ′ B^{\prime} B ′ whose vanishing cycles enclose the holes of the second possibility. Since it is a global conjugate, its Lefschetz fibration is isomorphic to that of t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 t_{V_{0}}t_{V_{1}}t_{V_{2}}t_{V_{3}} t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 .
The infinitely many Stein fillings
For a page curve c c c , i.e., a homologically nontrivial simple closed curve on a page, a page realization of c c c is a Legendrian knot isotopic to c c c on a (possibly slightly perturbed) page, with contact framing equal to the page framing. Such a realization exists by Honda’s Legendrian realization principle [12 ] . Adding the twist t c t_{c} t c to the monodromy of an open book corresponds to Legendrian surgery along a page realization of c c c [2 ] .
Proof of Theorem 1.1 (1) and (2). Oba and the author considered in [17 §3.2] Johns’ exact symplectic Lefschetz fibrations on the disk cotangent bundles of the nonorientable surfaces N k N_k N k . For the Klein bottle K = N 2 K=N_2 K = N 2 , the one denoted π : ( M , ω ) → D 2 \pi\colon(M,\omega)\to D^2 π : ( M , ω ) → D 2 there has fiber Σ 0 6 \Sigma^6_0 Σ 0 6 and ordered vanishing cycles ( V 0 , V 1 , V 2 , V 3 ) (V_0,V_1,V_2,V_3) ( V 0 , V 1 , V 2 , V 3 ) , so M = X B ′ M=X_{B'} M = X B ′ , and its boundary carries the contact structure ξ J = ker ( λ ∣ ∂ M ) \xi_J=\ker(\lambda|_{\partial M}) ξ J = ker ( λ ∣ ∂ M ) , where λ \lambda λ is the Liouville form of ( M , ω ) (M,\omega) ( M , ω ) , supported by the induced open book ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) (\Sigma^6_0,B') ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) . By Johns’ theorem [13 Theorem 1.1] , as recalled in [17 §3] , ( M , ω ) (M,\omega) ( M , ω ) is, after smoothing its corners, conformally exact symplectomorphic to ( D T ∗ K , ω c a n ) (DT^*K,\omega_{\mathrm{can}}) ( D T ∗ K , ω can ) by a map φ \varphi φ with φ ∗ λ ′ = c λ + d θ \varphi^*\lambda'=c\lambda+d\theta φ ∗ λ ′ = c λ + d θ , c > 0 c>0 c > 0 , for a function θ \theta θ . Here λ ′ \lambda' λ ′ is the Liouville form of D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K , so that both λ \lambda λ and φ ∗ λ ′ \varphi^*\lambda' φ ∗ λ ′ restrict to contact forms on ∂ M \partial M ∂ M . The forms α t = ( c λ + t d θ ) ∣ ∂ M \alpha_t=(c\lambda+t\,d\theta)|_{\partial M} α t = ( c λ + t d θ ) ∣ ∂ M , t ∈ [ 0 , 1 ] t\in[0,1] t ∈ [ 0 , 1 ] , satisfy d α t = c d λ ∣ ∂ M d\alpha_t=c\,d\lambda|_{\partial M} d α t = c d λ ∣ ∂ M , so α t ∧ d α t \alpha_t\wedge d\alpha_t α t ∧ d α t is a convex combination of the positive volume forms α 0 ∧ d α 0 \alpha_0\wedge d\alpha_0 α 0 ∧ d α 0 and α 1 ∧ d α 1 \alpha_1\wedge d\alpha_1 α 1 ∧ d α 1 , and each α t \alpha_t α t is a contact form. By Gray’s theorem, after an isotopy supported in a collar of the boundary, φ \varphi φ restricts to a contactomorphism from ( ∂ M , ξ J ) (\partial M,\xi_J) ( ∂ M , ξ J ) to ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) .
The total space X B ′ X_{B'} X B ′ also carries the Stein structure of the positive allowable Lefschetz fibration with vanishing cycles V 0 , … , V 3 V_0,\ldots,V_3 V 0 , … , V 3 [2 , 15 ] , and its boundary contact structure is also supported by ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) (\Sigma^6_0,B') ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) . By Giroux’s uniqueness theorem [7 ] the two boundary contact structures are isotopic, and by Gray’s theorem this isotopy is realized by an isotopy of ∂ M \partial M ∂ M , which we extend over a collar. Composing the resulting diffeomorphism of X B ′ X_{B'} X B ′ , isotopic to the identity, with φ \varphi φ , we obtain a diffeomorphism from X B ′ X_{B'} X B ′ to D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K which restricts to a contactomorphism from the boundary of the Stein domain X B ′ X_{B'} X B ′ to ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) . We transport the Stein structure of the Lefschetz fibration to D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K by this diffeomorphism. From now on we write φ \varphi φ for this diffeomorphism, and ( Y B ′ , ξ B ′ ) (Y_{B'},\xi_{B'}) ( Y B ′ , ξ B ′ ) for the boundary of the Stein domain X B ′ X_{B'} X B ′ , so that φ ∣ Y B ′ \varphi|_{Y_{B'}} φ ∣ Y B ′ is a contactomorphism from ( Y B ′ , ξ B ′ ) (Y_{B'},\xi_{B'}) ( Y B ′ , ξ B ′ ) to ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) .
We construct the contactomorphism Ψ \Psi Ψ of ( Y B ′ , ξ B ′ ) (Y_{B'},\xi_{B'}) ( Y B ′ , ξ B ′ ) induced by t α ′ t_{\alpha'} t α ′ . A mapping class is an isotopy class of diffeomorphisms, and to build mapping tori we fix representatives. We denote the representatives of B ′ B' B ′ and t α ′ t_{\alpha'} t α ′ by the same letters, and we choose them equal to the identity near the boundary, with t α ′ t_{\alpha'} t α ′ supported in an annular neighborhood of α ′ \alpha' α ′ . The map ( x , s ) ↦ ( t α ′ ( x ) , s ) (x,s)\mapsto(t_{\alpha'}(x),s) ( x , s ) ↦ ( t α ′ ( x ) , s ) is a diffeomorphism from the mapping torus of B ′ B' B ′ to the mapping torus of t α ′ B ′ t α ′ − 1 t_{\alpha'}B't_{\alpha'}^{-1} t α ′ B ′ t α ′ − 1 . Since t α ′ B ′ t α ′ − 1 = B ′ t_{\alpha'}B't_{\alpha'}^{-1}=B' t α ′ B ′ t α ′ − 1 = B ′ as mapping classes by Lemma 2.1 , these two diffeomorphisms are isotopic rel Σ 0 6 \Sigma^6_0 Σ 0 6 , and such an isotopy induces a diffeomorphism between their mapping tori carrying pages to pages. The composite, extended by the identity on the binding, is a diffeomorphism Ψ 0 \Psi_0 Ψ 0 of Y B ′ Y_{B'} Y B ′ which preserves the open book, mapping each page to a page and the binding to itself and preserving their orientations. We choose the isotopy so that the identification of the mapping tori is the identity on a reference page, so that Ψ 0 \Psi_0 Ψ 0 restricts to t α ′ t_{\alpha'} t α ′ on that page. Hence ( Ψ 0 ) ∗ ξ B ′ (\Psi_0)_*\xi_{B'} ( Ψ 0 ) ∗ ξ B ′ is again supported by ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) (\Sigma^6_0,B') ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) , so it is isotopic to ξ B ′ \xi_{B'} ξ B ′ by Giroux’s uniqueness theorem [7 ] . Composing Ψ 0 \Psi_0 Ψ 0 with the diffeomorphism given by Gray’s theorem along such an isotopy yields a contactomorphism Ψ \Psi Ψ of ( Y B ′ , ξ B ′ ) (Y_{B'},\xi_{B'}) ( Y B ′ , ξ B ′ ) , smoothly isotopic to Ψ 0 \Psi_0 Ψ 0 . Let ψ \psi ψ be the contactomorphism of ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) obtained by transporting Ψ \Psi Ψ by φ ∣ Y B ′ \varphi|_{Y_{B'}} φ ∣ Y B ′ . This proves part (1).
For part (2), let L L L be a page realization of d ′ d' d ′ , and let j j j denote the framed embedding, into Y B ′ Y_{B'} Y B ′ , of a neighborhood of a copy of d ′ d' d ′ on the reference page, with framing one less than the page framing. Since Ψ 0 \Psi_0 Ψ 0 maps pages to pages and preserves page framings, Ψ 0 − n ∘ j \Psi_0^{-n}\circ j Ψ 0 − n ∘ j is the framed embedding of a copy of t α ′ − n ( d ′ ) t_{\alpha'}^{-n}(d') t α ′ − n ( d ′ ) on a page, again with framing one less than the page framing. Since Ψ \Psi Ψ is smoothly isotopic to Ψ 0 \Psi_0 Ψ 0 , the framed embedding Ψ − n ∘ j \Psi^{-n}\circ j Ψ − n ∘ j is framed isotopic to Ψ 0 − n ∘ j \Psi_0^{-n}\circ j Ψ 0 − n ∘ j . Attaching a 2–handle to X B ′ X_{B'} X B ′ along Ψ − n ∘ j \Psi^{-n}\circ j Ψ − n ∘ j therefore gives, as a smooth manifold, the Lefschetz fibration with vanishing cycles t α ′ − n ( d ′ ) , V 0 , … , V 3 t_{\alpha'}^{-n}(d'),V_0,\ldots,V_3 t α ′ − n ( d ′ ) , V 0 , … , V 3 , which is the Lefschetz fibration of the positive factorization
P n ′ = t d ′ t α ′ n B ′ t α ′ − n P'_n=t_{d'}t_{\alpha'}^nB't_{\alpha'}^{-n} P n ′ = t d ′ t α ′ n B ′ t α ′ − n
of t d ′ B ′ t_{d'}B' t d ′ B ′ , conjugated by t α ′ − n t_{\alpha'}^{-n} t α ′ − n . Transporting by φ \varphi φ , and writing again L L L and j j j for the transports of L L L and j j j to S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K , the Stein domain X n = D T ∗ K ∪ h ψ − n ( L ) X_n=DT^*K\cup h_{\psi^{-n}(L)} X n = D T ∗ K ∪ h ψ − n ( L ) is obtained by attaching a Weinstein 2–handle along the Legendrian knot ψ − n ( L ) \psi^{-n}(L) ψ − n ( L ) , whose contact framing is the image of the page framing of L L L . So the handle is attached along ψ − n ∘ j \psi^{-n}\circ j ψ − n ∘ j , and X n X_n X n is diffeomorphic to the Lefschetz fibration of P n ′ P'_n P n ′ . Since ψ \psi ψ is a contactomorphism, Legendrian surgery along ψ − n ( L ) \psi^{-n}(L) ψ − n ( L ) gives the same contact manifold as Legendrian surgery along L L L , namely ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) , which is supported by ( Σ 6 0 , t d ′ B ′ ) (\Sigma^0_6,t_{d'}B') ( Σ 6 0 , t d ′ B ′ ) . Hence each X n X_n X n is a Stein filling of ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) .
By Lemma 2.2 , π 1 ( X n ) ≅ Q / N ( r 2 n + 1 ) \pi_1(X_n)\cong Q/N(r^{2n+1}) π 1 ( X n ) ≅ Q / N ( r 2 n + 1 ) , where N ( S ) N(S) N ( S ) denotes the normal closure of S S S , and this group is Z / ( 2 n + 1 ) ⋊ − 1 Z \mathbb{Z}/(2n+1)\rtimes_{-1}\mathbb{Z} Z / ( 2 n + 1 ) ⋊ − 1 Z by [19 Lemma 4.6] . For n ≥ 1 n\geq1 n ≥ 1 it is not isomorphic to π 1 ( X 0 ) ≅ Z \pi_1(X_0)\cong\mathbb{Z} π 1 ( X 0 ) ≅ Z , since it has torsion, and the groups for different n n n have torsion subgroups of different orders. So the X n X_n X n are pairwise non-homeomorphic. Finally, suppose that ψ n \psi^n ψ n , for some n ≥ 1 n\geq1 n ≥ 1 , extends to a homeomorphism F F F of D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K . Then F ∘ ψ − n ∘ j = j F\circ\psi^{-n}\circ j=j F ∘ ψ − n ∘ j = j on the boundary, so F F F together with the identity on the attached handle is a homeomorphism from X n X_n X n to X 0 X_0 X 0 , a contradiction. Hence no positive power of ψ \psi ψ extends over D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K , even as a homeomorphism.
Remark 3.1. We expect the Stein structure on X B ′ X_{B'} X B ′ given by the Lefschetz fibration [2 , 15 ] to be deformation equivalent to ( D T ∗ K , ω c a n ) (DT^*K,\omega_{\mathrm{can}}) ( D T ∗ K , ω can ) . Here and below, deformation equivalence of Stein or Weinstein domains is in the sense of [8 ] , i.e., a Weinstein homotopy of the underlying Weinstein structures, allowing birth–death of critical points. Johns’ theorem gives a conformally exact symplectomorphism, which is what we use, but not a Weinstein deformation equivalence, and we do not claim one here. Only the smooth identification of X B ′ X_{B'} X B ′ with D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K and the identification of the boundary contact structures enter the proof of Theorem 1.1 .
Proof of Corollary 1.2. By [14 Corollary 1.2] , ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) has a unique minimal weak symplectic filling up to homeomorphism, and it is planar, supported by ( Σ 6 0 , B ′ ) (\Sigma^0_6,B') ( Σ 6 0 , B ′ ) . By Theorem 1.1 (2), a single Legendrian surgery on it gives ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) , which has infinitely many pairwise non-homeomorphic Stein fillings. Stein fillings are exact, and hence minimal, so ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) has infinitely many minimal symplectic fillings up to homeomorphism.
The attaching knots are not cotangent-circle fibers: by Lemma 2.2 , the curve ψ − n ( d ′ ) \psi^{-n}(d') ψ − n ( d ′ ) represents r − ( 2 n + 1 ) r^{-(2n+1)} r − ( 2 n + 1 ) in π 1 ( D T ∗ K ) ≅ Q \pi_1(DT^*K)\cong Q π 1 ( D T ∗ K ) ≅ Q , an element of infinite order, whereas a fiber bounds a disk in D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K .
The proof of Theorem 1.1 (2) uses the curve d ′ d' d ′ only as a page curve. For a page curve c c c , let ( Y c B ′ , ξ c B ′ ) (Y^{B'}_c,\xi^{B'}_c) ( Y c B ′ , ξ c B ′ ) be the contact 3–manifold supported by the open book ( Σ 6 0 , t c B ′ ) (\Sigma^0_6,t_cB') ( Σ 6 0 , t c B ′ ) , and let X n B ′ ( c ) X^{B'}_n(c) X n B ′ ( c ) be the Lefschetz fibration of the positive factorization t c n t α ′ B ′ t α ′ − n t_c^n t_{\alpha'}B't_{\alpha'}^{-n} t c n t α ′ B ′ t α ′ − n of t c B ′ t_cB' t c B ′ , n ≥ 0 n\geq0 n ≥ 0 .
Proposition 3.2. For every page curve c c c , the contact 3–manifold ( Y c B ′ , ξ c B ′ ) (Y^{B'}_c,\xi^{B'}_c) ( Y c B ′ , ξ c B ′ ) is obtained from ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) by Legendrian surgery along a page realization of c c c , and X n B ′ ( c ) ≅ D T ∗ K ∪ h ψ − n ( c ) X^{B'}_n(c)\cong DT^*K\cup h_{\psi^{-n}(c)} X n B ′ ( c ) ≅ D T ∗ K ∪ h ψ − n ( c ) for every n ≥ 0 n\geq0 n ≥ 0 , where the 2–handle is attached with framing one less than the page framing.
Proof. The proof of Theorem 1.1 (2), with d ′ d' d ′ replaced by c c c , applies verbatim.
The non-extension statement of Theorem 1.1 (2) has the following consequence for the mapping class groups of S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K .
Corollary 3.3. The contactomorphism ψ \psi ψ has infinite order in the contact mapping class group of ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) , and even in the smooth mapping class group of S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K . More precisely, for every k ≠ 0 k\neq0 k = 0 , the diffeomorphism ψ k \psi^k ψ k is not isotopic, through homeomorphisms, to the restriction of a homeomorphism of D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K .
Proof. Suppose ψ k \psi^k ψ k , k ≠ 0 k\neq0 k = 0 , is isotopic to the restriction of a homeomorphism F F F of D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K . Replacing k k k by − k -k − k and F F F by F − 1 F^{-1} F − 1 if necessary, we may assume that k ≥ 1 k\geq1 k ≥ 1 . Using the isotopy in a collar of S T ∗ K = ∂ D T ∗ K ST^*K=\partial DT^*K S T ∗ K = ∂ D T ∗ K , we modify F F F to a homeomorphism of D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K whose restriction to the boundary is ψ k \psi^k ψ k , which contradicts Theorem 1.1 (2). Taking F F F to be the identity, ψ k \psi^k ψ k is not isotopic to the identity for k ≠ 0 k \ne0 k = 0 , so ψ \psi ψ has infinite order in the smooth mapping class group of S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K . Since contactomorphisms which are contact isotopic are smoothly isotopic, ψ \psi ψ also has infinite order in the contact mapping class group.
Relation with Baykur's example
In this section we prove Theorem 1.1 (3). In the generators of Figure 2 , Baykur’s curves are u = x 3 x 2 u=x_3x_2 u = x 3 x 2 , v = x 5 x 4 x 2 v=x_5x_4x_2 v = x 5 x 4 x 2 , w = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x 2 − 1 x 4 − 1 w=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1x_2^{-1}x_4^{-1} w = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x 2 − 1 x 4 − 1 , z = x 4 x 2 x 1 x 2 − 1 z=x_4x_2x_1x_2^{-1} z = x 4 x 2 x 1 x 2 − 1 and d = x 3 x 1 d=x_3x_1 d = x 3 x 1 , up to conjugation [3 ] , and α = x 2 x 1 \alpha=x_2x_1 α = x 2 x 1 and β = x 4 x 3 \beta=x_4x_3 β = x 4 x 3 are the round curves of Figure 2 . Baykur’s generalized lantern relation [3 Lemma 3] is B t α t β = Δ B t_\alpha t_\beta=\Delta B t α t β = Δ , with Δ = t δ 0 t δ 1 − 1 t δ 2 − 1 t δ 3 − 1 t δ 4 − 1 t δ 5 \Delta=t_{\delta_0}t_{\delta_1}^{-1}t_{\delta_2}^{-1}t_{\delta_3}^{-1}t_{\delta_4}^{-1}t_{\delta_5} Δ = t δ 0 t δ 1 − 1 t δ 2 − 1 t δ 3 − 1 t δ 4 − 1 t δ 5 , and it gives [ B , t α ] = 1 [B,t_\alpha]=1 [ B , t α ] = 1 . We write ( Y B , ξ B ) (Y_B,\xi_B) ( Y B , ξ B ) for the contact 3–manifold supported by the open book ( Σ 0 6 , B ) (\Sigma^6_0,B) ( Σ 0 6 , B ) . The two factorizations B = t u t v t w t z B=t_ut_vt_wt_z B = t u t v t w t z and B ′ = t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 B'=t_{V_0}t_{V_1}t_{V_2}t_{V_3} B ′ = t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 are not related by a diffeomorphism of the page carrying vanishing cycles to vanishing cycles: V 1 V_1 V 1 and V 2 V_2 V 2 are disjoint, whereas any two of u , v , w , z u,v,w,z u , v , w , z intersect. They become so related after three Hurwitz moves. All that is needed are the following identities between curves, where β ′ \beta' β ′ is the curve of Figure 2 .
Lemma 4.1. Let
g = σ α ′ ′ σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 4 , σ α ′ ′ = σ 1 σ 2 σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 1 − 1 . g=\sigma_{\alpha'}'\sigma_3^{-1}\sigma_2^{-1}\sigma_4,\qquad\sigma_{\alpha'}'=\sigma_1\sigma_2\sigma_3^{-1}\sigma_2^{-1}\sigma_1^{-1}. g = σ α ′ ′ σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 4 , σ α ′ ′ = σ 1 σ 2 σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 1 − 1 . in functional order, with σ i \sigma_i σ i as in (2) . Here σ α ′ ′ \sigma_{\alpha'}' σ α ′ ′ is the counterclockwise half twist supported in the disk bounded by α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 ( β ) \alpha'=\sigma_1\sigma_2(\beta) α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 ( β ) , interchanging δ 1 \delta_1 δ 1 and δ 4 \delta_4 δ 4 , since it is conjugate to σ 3 − 1 \sigma_3^{-1} σ 3 − 1 . Then g g g acts on π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,*) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) by
x 1 ↦ x 4 , x 2 ↦ x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 , x 3 ↦ x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 , x 5 ↦ x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 , x_1\mapsto x_4,\qquad x_2\mapsto x_4x_1x_4^{-1},\qquad x_3\mapsto x_4x_2x_4^{-1},\qquad x_5\mapsto x_4x_3x_4^{-1}, x 1 ↦ x 4 , x 2 ↦ x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 , x 3 ↦ x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 , x 5 ↦ x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 . x_4\mapsto x_4x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5x_4x_3x_4^{-1}. x 4 ↦ x 4 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 . Moreover, g g g is the identity on δ 0 \delta_0 δ 0 , permutes the holes by δ 1 ↦ δ 4 \delta_1\mapsto\delta_4 δ 1 ↦ δ 4 , δ 2 ↦ δ 1 \delta_2\mapsto\delta_1 δ 2 ↦ δ 1 , δ 3 ↦ δ 2 \delta_3\mapsto\delta_2 δ 3 ↦ δ 2 , δ 4 ↦ δ 5 \delta_4\mapsto\delta_5 δ 4 ↦ δ 5 , δ 5 ↦ δ 3 \delta_5\mapsto\delta_3 δ 5 ↦ δ 3 , and, up to isotopy,
g ( d ) = d ′ , g ( α ) = α ′ , g ( β ) = β ′ , g(d)=d',\qquad g(\alpha)=\alpha',\qquad g(\beta)=\beta', g ( d ) = d ′ , g ( α ) = α ′ , g ( β ) = β ′ , g ( u ) = V 1 , g ( v ) = V 3 , g ( t v ( z ) ) = V 2 , g ( t u t v ( w ) ) = V 0 . g(u)=V_1,\qquad g(v)=V_3,\qquad g(t_v(z))=V_2,\qquad g(t_ut_v(w))=V_0. g ( u ) = V 1 , g ( v ) = V 3 , g ( t v ( z )) = V 2 , g ( t u t v ( w )) = V 0 .
Proof. As explained in § 2 , it suffices to compare conjugacy classes in π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) = F ( x 1 , … , x 5 ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,*)=F(x_1,\ldots,x_5) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) = F ( x 1 , … , x 5 ) , up to inversion. Since g g g is the identity on δ 0 ∋ ∗ \delta_0\ni* δ 0 ∋ ∗ , it induces an automorphism of this group, and since only identities between curves are asserted, nothing is lost in passing to π 1 \pi_1 π 1 : the action of the mapping class group on π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,*) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) fails to detect only twists along the inner boundary components, which play no role here.
We first compute the action of g g g . Composing the formulas (2) –(3) one factor at a time, from the right, we obtain the following automorphisms, where generators not listed are fixed:
σ 1 − 1 : x 1 ↦ x 2 , x 2 ↦ x 2 x 1 x 2 − 1 , \sigma_1^{-1}: \quad x_1 \mapsto x_2,\quad x_2 \mapsto x_2x_1x_2^{-1}, σ 1 − 1 : x 1 ↦ x 2 , x 2 ↦ x 2 x 1 x 2 − 1 ,
σ 2 − 1 σ 1 − 1 : x 1 ↦ x 3 , x 2 ↦ x 3 x 1 x 3 − 1 , x 3 ↦ x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 , \sigma_2^{-1}\sigma_1^{-1}: \quad x_1 \mapsto x_3,\quad x_2 \mapsto x_3x_1x_3^{-1},\quad x_3 \mapsto x_3x_2x_3^{-1}, σ 2 − 1 σ 1 − 1 : x 1 ↦ x 3 , x 2 ↦ x 3 x 1 x 3 − 1 , x 3 ↦ x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 ,
σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 1 − 1 : x 1 ↦ x 4 , x 2 ↦ x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 , x 3 ↦ x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 , \sigma_3^{-1}\sigma_2^{-1}\sigma_1^{-1}: \quad x_1 \mapsto x_4,\quad x_2 \mapsto x_4x_1x_4^{-1},\quad x_3 \mapsto x_4x_2x_4^{-1},\quad x_4 \mapsto x_4x_3x_4^{-1}, σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 1 − 1 : x 1 ↦ x 4 , x 2 ↦ x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 , x 3 ↦ x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ,
σ 2 σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 1 − 1 : x 1 ↦ x 4 , x 2 ↦ x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 , x 3 ↦ x 4 x 2 − 1 x 3 x 2 x 4 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 , \sigma_2\sigma_3^{-1}\sigma_2^{-1}\sigma_1^{-1}: \quad x_1 \mapsto x_4,\quad x_2 \mapsto x_4x_1x_4^{-1},\quad x_3 \mapsto x_4x_2^{-1}x_3x_2x_4^{-1},\quad x_4 \mapsto x_4x_2x_4^{-1}, σ 2 σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 1 − 1 : x 1 ↦ x 4 , x 2 ↦ x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 , x 3 ↦ x 4 x 2 − 1 x 3 x 2 x 4 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 ,
σ α ′ : x 1 ↦ x 4 , x 2 ↦ x 4 x 1 − 1 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 , x 3 ↦ x 4 x 1 − 1 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 . \sigma_{\alpha'}: \quad x_1 \mapsto x_4,\quad x_2 \mapsto x_4x_1^{-1}x_2x_1x_4^{-1},\quad x_3 \mapsto x_4x_1^{-1}x_3x_1x_4^{-1},\quad x_4 \mapsto x_4x_1x_4^{-1}. σ α ′ : x 1 ↦ x 4 , x 2 ↦ x 4 x 1 − 1 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 , x 3 ↦ x 4 x 1 − 1 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 .
For example, in the second line, σ 2 − 1 σ 1 − 1 ( x 2 ) \sigma_2^{-1}\sigma_1^{-1}(x_2) σ 2 − 1 σ 1 − 1 ( x 2 ) is obtained by applying σ 2 − 1 \sigma_2^{-1} σ 2 − 1 to σ 1 − 1 ( x 2 ) = x 2 x 1 x 2 − 1 \sigma_1^{-1}(x_2)=x_2x_1x_2^{-1} σ 1 − 1 ( x 2 ) = x 2 x 1 x 2 − 1 , which gives x 3 x 1 x 3 − 1 x_3x_1x_3^{-1} x 3 x 1 x 3 − 1 . Similarly,
σ 4 : x 4 ↦ x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 , x 5 ↦ x 4 , \sigma_4:\quad x_4\mapsto x_4^{-1}x_5x_4,\quad x_5\mapsto x_4, σ 4 : x 4 ↦ x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 , x 5 ↦ x 4 ,
σ 2 − 1 σ 4 : x 2 ↦ x 3 , x 3 ↦ x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 , x 5 ↦ x 4 , \sigma_2^{-1}\sigma_4:\quad x_2\mapsto x_3,\quad x_3\mapsto x_3x_2x_3^{-1},\quad x_4\mapsto x_4^{-1}x_5x_4,\quad x_5\mapsto x_4, σ 2 − 1 σ 4 : x 2 ↦ x 3 , x 3 ↦ x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 , x 5 ↦ x 4 ,
σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 4 : x 2 ↦ x 4 , x 3 ↦ x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 , x 5 ↦ x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 . \sigma_3^{-1}\sigma_2^{-1}\sigma_4:\quad x_2\mapsto x_4,\quad x_3\mapsto x_4x_2x_4^{-1},\quad x_4\mapsto x_4x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5x_4x_3x_4^{-1},\quad x_5\mapsto x_4x_3x_4^{-1}. σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 4 : x 2 ↦ x 4 , x 3 ↦ x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 , x 4 ↦ x 4 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 , x 5 ↦ x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 .
Finally g = σ α ′ ∘ ( σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 4 ) g=\sigma_{\alpha'}\circ(\sigma_3^{-1}\sigma_2^{-1}\sigma_4) g = σ α ′ ∘ ( σ 3 − 1 σ 2 − 1 σ 4 ) , so g ( x i ) g(x_i) g ( x i ) is obtained by applying σ α ′ \sigma_{\alpha'} σ α ′ to the image of x i x_i x i in the last line. This gives g ( x 1 ) = σ α ′ ( x 1 ) = x 4 g(x_1)=\sigma_{\alpha'}(x_1)=x_4 g ( x 1 ) = σ α ′ ( x 1 ) = x 4 , g ( x 2 ) = σ α ′ ( x 4 ) = x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 g(x_2)=\sigma_{\alpha'}(x_4)=x_4x_1x_4^{-1} g ( x 2 ) = σ α ′ ( x 4 ) = x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 ,
g ( x 3 ) = σ α ′ ( x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 ) = ( x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 x 1 − 1 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 x 1 − 1 x 4 − 1 ) = x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 , g(x_3)=\sigma_{\alpha'}(x_4x_2x_4^{-1})=(x_4x_1x_4^{-1})(x_4x_1^{-1}x_2x_1x_4^{-1})(x_4x_1^{-1}x_4^{-1})=x_4x_2x_4^{-1}, g ( x 3 ) = σ α ′ ( x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 ) = ( x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 x 1 − 1 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 x 1 − 1 x 4 − 1 ) = x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 ,
and in the same way, since σ α ′ ( x 3 ) = x 4 x 1 − 1 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 \sigma_{\alpha'}(x_3)=x_4x_1^{-1}x_3x_1x_4^{-1} σ α ′ ( x 3 ) = x 4 x 1 − 1 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 ,
g ( x 5 ) = σ α ′ ( x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ) = ( x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 x 1 − 1 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 x 1 − 1 x 4 − 1 ) = x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 . g(x_5)=\sigma_{\alpha'}(x_4x_3x_4^{-1})=(x_4x_1x_4^{-1})(x_4x_1^{-1}x_3x_1x_4^{-1})(x_4x_1^{-1}x_4^{-1})=x_4x_3x_4^{-1}. g ( x 5 ) = σ α ′ ( x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ) = ( x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 x 1 − 1 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 x 1 − 1 x 4 − 1 ) = x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 .
Writing x 4 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 = ( x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ) − 1 x 5 ( x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ) x_4x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5x_4x_3x_4^{-1}=(x_4x_3x_4^{-1})^{-1}x_5(x_4x_3x_4^{-1}) x 4 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 = ( x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ) − 1 x 5 ( x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ) and using σ α ′ ( x 5 ) = x 5 \sigma_{\alpha'}(x_5)=x_5 σ α ′ ( x 5 ) = x 5 , we get g ( x 4 ) = g ( x 5 ) − 1 x 5 g ( x 5 ) = x 4 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 g(x_4)=g(x_5)^{-1}x_5g(x_5)=x_4x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5x_4x_3x_4^{-1} g ( x 4 ) = g ( x 5 ) − 1 x 5 g ( x 5 ) = x 4 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 , as claimed.
The classes of the curves involved are
α = x 2 x 1 , β = x 4 x 3 , u = x 3 x 2 , v = x 5 x 4 x 2 , \alpha=x_2x_1,\qquad\beta=x_4x_3,\qquad u=x_3x_2,\qquad v=x_5x_4x_2, α = x 2 x 1 , β = x 4 x 3 , u = x 3 x 2 , v = x 5 x 4 x 2 ,
t v ( z ) = x 5 − 1 x 1 x 5 x 4 , t u t v ( w ) = x 1 x 5 x 3 , α ′ = x 1 x 4 , β ′ = x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 , t_v(z)=x_5^{-1}x_1x_5x_4,\qquad t_ut_v(w)=x_1x_5x_3,\qquad\alpha'=x_1x_4,\qquad\beta'=x_4^{-1}x_5x_4x_3x_2x_3^{-1}, t v ( z ) = x 5 − 1 x 1 x 5 x 4 , t u t v ( w ) = x 1 x 5 x 3 , α ′ = x 1 x 4 , β ′ = x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 ,
V 0 = x 4 x 3 x 2 , V 1 = x 2 x 1 , V 2 = x 5 x 4 , V 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 . V_0=x_4x_3x_2,\qquad V_1=x_2x_1,\qquad V_2=x_5x_4,\qquad V_3=x_5x_4x_3x_1x_4^{-1}. V 0 = x 4 x 3 x 2 , V 1 = x 2 x 1 , V 2 = x 5 x 4 , V 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 .
The curves t v ( z ) t_v(z) t v ( z ) and t u t v ( w ) t_ut_v(w) t u t v ( w ) , obtained from the curves of Figure 4 by twisting z z z along v v v , and w w w along v v v and then along u u u , are shown in Figure 5 , from which their classes are read off. These two classes can also be computed algebraically, with the description of round twists in § 2 . Thus t u t_u t u conjugates x 2 , x 3 x_2,x_3 x 2 , x 3 by u = x 3 x 2 u=x_3x_2 u = x 3 x 2 . Let ρ \rho ρ be the boundary of the disk containing δ 3 , δ 4 , δ 5 \delta_3,\delta_4,\delta_5 δ 3 , δ 4 , δ 5 , represented by x 5 x 4 x 3 x_5x_4x_3 x 5 x 4 x 3 . Then σ 2 ( ρ ) = x 5 x 4 x 2 = v \sigma_2(\rho)=x_5x_4x_2=v σ 2 ( ρ ) = x 5 x 4 x 2 = v , so t v = σ 2 t ρ σ 2 − 1 t_v=\sigma_2t_\rho\sigma_2^{-1} t v = σ 2 t ρ σ 2 − 1 . Composing σ 2 − 1 \sigma_2^{-1} σ 2 − 1 , then t ρ t_\rho t ρ , which conjugates x 3 , x 4 , x 5 x_3,x_4,x_5 x 3 , x 4 , x 5 by ρ \rho ρ , and then σ 2 \sigma_2 σ 2 , one finds that t v t_v t v fixes x 1 x_1 x 1 , conjugates x 2 , x 4 , x 5 x_2,x_4,x_5 x 2 , x 4 , x 5 by v = x 5 x 4 x 2 v=x_5x_4x_2 v = x 5 x 4 x 2 , and maps x 3 x_3 x 3 to ( x 5 x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 2 − 1 ) x 3 ( x 5 x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 2 − 1 ) (x_5x_4x_2x_4^{-1}x_5^{-1}x_2^{-1})x_3(x_5x_4x_2x_4^{-1}x_5^{-1}x_2^{-1}) ( x 5 x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 2 − 1 ) x 3 ( x 5 x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 2 − 1 ) . Substituting into z = x 4 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 z=x_4x_2x_1x_4^{-1} z = x 4 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 and w = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 3 − 1 x 2 − 1 x 1 − 1 w=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1x_5^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_3^{-1}x_2^{-1}x_1^{-1} w = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 3 − 1 x 2 − 1 x 1 − 1 and freely reducing gives t v ( w ) = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 3 − 1 x 2 − 1 x 1 − 1 t_v(w)=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1x_5^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_3^{-1}x_2^{-1}x_1^{-1} t v ( w ) = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 3 − 1 x 2 − 1 x 1 − 1 , and then applying t u t_u t u , which conjugates x 2 , x 3 x_2,x_3 x 2 , x 3 by u = x 3 x 2 u=x_3x_2 u = x 3 x 2 and fixes the other generators, gives
Figure 5. The curves t v ( z ) t_v(z) t v ( z ) and t u t v ( w ) t_ut_v(w) t u t v ( w ) of Lemma 4.1.
t v ( z ) = ( x 5 x 4 x 2 ) x 5 − 1 x 1 x 5 x 4 ( x 5 x 4 x 2 ) − 1 , t_v(z)=(x_5x_4x_2)x_5^{-1}x_1x_5x_4(x_5x_4x_2)^{-1}, t v ( z ) = ( x 5 x 4 x 2 ) x 5 − 1 x 1 x 5 x 4 ( x 5 x 4 x 2 ) − 1 ,
t u t v ( w ) = ( x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 ) x 1 x 5 x 3 ( x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 ) − 1 . t_ut_v(w)=(x_5x_4x_3x_2)x_1x_5x_3(x_5x_4x_3x_2)^{-1}. t u t v ( w ) = ( x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 ) x 1 x 5 x 3 ( x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 ) − 1 .
Applying the formulas for g g g and reducing,
g ( d ) = g ( x 3 ) g ( x 1 ) = ( x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 ) = x 4 x 2 = d ′ , g ( α ) = ( x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 ) = x 4 x 1 ∼ x 1 x 4 = α ′ , g ( β ) = x 4 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 4 − 1 ∼ x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 ∼ β ′ , g ( u ) = x 4 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 ∼ x 2 x 1 = V 1 , g ( v ) = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 = V 3 , g ( t v ( z ) ) = x 4 x 3 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ∼ x 5 x 4 = V 2 , g ( t u t v ( w ) ) = ( x 4 ) ( x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 ) = x 4 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 4 − 1 ∼ V 0 , \begin{aligned}
g(d) &= g(x_3)g(x_1)=(x_4x_2x_4^{-1})(x_4)=x_4x_2=d',\\
g(\alpha) &= (x_4x_1x_4^{-1})(x_4)=x_4x_1\sim x_1x_4=\alpha',\\
g(\beta) &= x_4x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5x_4x_3x_2x_4^{-1}\sim x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5x_4x_3x_2\sim\beta',\\
g(u) &= x_4x_2x_1x_4^{-1}\sim x_2x_1=V_1,\\
g(v) &= x_5x_4x_3x_1x_4^{-1}=V_3,\\
g(t_v(z)) &= x_4x_3^{-1}x_5x_4x_3x_4^{-1}\sim x_5x_4=V_2,\\
g(t_ut_v(w)) &= (x_4)(x_4x_3x_4^{-1})(x_4x_2x_4^{-1})=x_4x_4x_3x_2x_4^{-1}\sim V_0,
\end{aligned} g ( d ) g ( α ) g ( β ) g ( u ) g ( v ) g ( t v ( z )) g ( t u t v ( w )) = g ( x 3 ) g ( x 1 ) = ( x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 ) = x 4 x 2 = d ′ , = ( x 4 x 1 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 ) = x 4 x 1 ∼ x 1 x 4 = α ′ , = x 4 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 4 − 1 ∼ x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 ∼ β ′ , = x 4 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 ∼ x 2 x 1 = V 1 , = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 = V 3 , = x 4 x 3 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ∼ x 5 x 4 = V 2 , = ( x 4 ) ( x 4 x 3 x 4 − 1 ) ( x 4 x 2 x 4 − 1 ) = x 4 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 4 − 1 ∼ V 0 ,
where ∼ \sim ∼ denotes conjugacy. The permutation of the holes is read off from the images of x 1 , … , x 5 x_1,\ldots,x_5 x 1 , … , x 5 , each a conjugate of a generator, and g g g is the identity near δ 0 \delta_0 δ 0 since its support can be chosen away from it. □
Proposition 4.2. Three Hurwitz moves transform Baykur’s factorization into
B = t u t v t w t z = t u t v ( w ) t u t v ( z ) t v (4) B=t_ut_vt_wt_z=t_ut_v(w)t_ut_v(z)t_v \tag*{(4)} B = t u t v t w t z = t u t v ( w ) t u t v ( z ) t v (4) and the diffeomorphism g g g of Lemma 4.1 carries the four curves on the right to the curves V 0 , V 1 , V 2 , V 3 V_0,V_1,V_2,V_3 V 0 , V 1 , V 2 , V 3 of Figure 2 . In particular g B g − 1 = B ′ gBg^{-1}=B' g B g − 1 = B ′ and ( Y B , ξ B ) ≅ ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (Y_B,\xi_B)\cong(ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( Y B , ξ B ) ≅ ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) .
Proof. The identity (4) is obtained from t u t v t w t z t_ut_vt_wt_z t u t v t w t z by the elementary moves t a t b = t t a ( b ) t a t_at_b=t_{t_a(b)}t_a t a t b = t t a ( b ) t a , applied to the second, third and first pairs of factors in turn:
( u , v , w , z ) → ( u , t v ( w ) , v , z ) → ( u , t v ( w ) , t v ( z ) , v ) → ( t u t v ( w ) , u , t v ( z ) , v ) . (u,v,w,z)\to(u,t_v(w),v,z)\to(u,t_v(w),t_v(z),v)\to(t_ut_v(w),u,t_v(z),v). ( u , v , w , z ) → ( u , t v ( w ) , v , z ) → ( u , t v ( w ) , t v ( z ) , v ) → ( t u t v ( w ) , u , t v ( z ) , v ) . Since g t c g − 1 = t g ( c ) gt_cg^{-1}=t_{g(c)} g t c g − 1 = t g ( c ) for every simple closed curve c c c , Lemma 4.1 gives
g B g − 1 = t g ( t u t v ( w ) ) t g ( u ) t g ( t v ( z ) ) t g ( v ) = t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 = B ′ . gBg^{-1}=t_{g(t_ut_v(w))}t_{g(u)}t_{g(t_v(z))}t_{g(v)}
=t_{V_0}t_{V_1}t_{V_2}t_{V_3}=B'. g B g − 1 = t g ( t u t v ( w )) t g ( u ) t g ( t v ( z )) t g ( v ) = t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 = B ′ . Conjugate monodromies give isomorphic open books [5 §2] : the conjugating diffeomorphism need only preserve the orientation of the page and map ∂ Σ 0 6 \partial\Sigma_0^6 ∂ Σ 0 6 to itself. Here, for a representative of B B B , denoted by the same letter, the map ( x , t ) ↦ ( g ( x ) , t ) (x,t)\mapsto(g(x),t) ( x , t ) ↦ ( g ( x ) , t ) from the mapping torus of B B B to that of g B g − 1 gBg^{-1} g B g − 1 , which represents B ′ B' B ′ , extended by g ∣ ∂ Σ 0 6 × id g|_{\partial\Sigma_0^6}\times\operatorname{id} g ∣ ∂ Σ 0 6 × id on ∂ Σ 0 6 × D 2 \partial\Sigma_0^6\times D^2 ∂ Σ 0 6 × D 2 , is an isomorphism of open books ( Σ 0 6 , B ) → ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) (\Sigma_0^6,B)\to(\Sigma_0^6,B') ( Σ 0 6 , B ) → ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) which permutes the binding components. Hence ( Y B , ξ B ) (Y_B,\xi_B) ( Y B , ξ B ) is contactomorphic to the contact manifold supported by ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) (\Sigma_0^6,B') ( Σ 0 6 , B ′ ) , which is ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) by [17 Theorem 3.7] . □
Remark 4.3. Proposition 2.3 is Baykur’s generalized lantern relation B t α t β = Δ Bt_\alpha t_\beta=\Delta B t α t β = Δ , with Δ = t δ 0 t δ 1 2 t δ 2 2 t δ 3 2 t δ 4 2 t δ 5 \Delta=t_{\delta_0}t_{\delta_1}^2t_{\delta_2}^2t_{\delta_3}^2t_{\delta_4}^2t_{\delta_5} Δ = t δ 0 t δ 1 2 t δ 2 2 t δ 3 2 t δ 4 2 t δ 5 [3 Lemma 3] , transported by g g g . Indeed, by Lemma 4.1, g ( α ) = α ′ g(\alpha)=\alpha' g ( α ) = α ′ and g ( β ) = β ′ g(\beta)=\beta' g ( β ) = β ′ , and g g g carries δ 5 \delta_5 δ 5 , the hole with exponent one in Δ \Delta Δ , to δ 3 \delta_3 δ 3 , so g Δ g − 1 = Δ ′ g\Delta g^{-1}=\Delta' g Δ g − 1 = Δ ′ . Together with Proposition 4.2 this gives B ′ t α ′ t β ′ = g ( B t α t β ) g − 1 = g Δ g − 1 = Δ ′ B't_{\alpha'}t_{\beta'}=g(Bt_\alpha t_\beta)g^{-1}=g\Delta g^{-1}=\Delta' B ′ t α ′ t β ′ = g ( B t α t β ) g − 1 = g Δ g − 1 = Δ ′ .
Remark 4.4. The diffeomorphism g g g and the Hurwitz moves were found by a computer search in the action on π 1 ( Σ 6 0 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma_6^0,*) π 1 ( Σ 6 0 , ∗ ) of the group Γ ^ \widehat{\Gamma} Γ of [19 §4.1] , which contains g g g . The verification above is by hand. In hindsight, g g g is explained by Proposition 2.3, which is proved independently: any diffeomorphism carrying ( α , β ) (\alpha,\beta) ( α , β ) to ( α ′ , β ′ ) (\alpha',\beta') ( α ′ , β ′ ) and δ 5 \delta_5 δ 5 to δ 3 \delta_3 δ 3 conjugates B = Δ β t α − 1 B=\Delta_{\beta}^{t_{\alpha}^{-1}} B = Δ β t α − 1 to Δ β ′ t α ′ − 1 = B ′ \Delta_{\beta'}^{t_{\alpha'}^{-1}}=B' Δ β ′ t α ′ − 1 = B ′ .
Proof of Theorem 1.1 (3). By Proposition 4.2 and Lemma 4.1, the diffeomorphism g g g satisfies g B g − 1 = B ′ gBg^{-1}=B' g B g − 1 = B ′ , g ( d ) = d ′ g(d)=d' g ( d ) = d ′ and g ( α ) = α ′ g(\alpha)=\alpha' g ( α ) = α ′ . Since g t c g − 1 = t g ( c ) gt_cg^{-1}=t_{g(c)} g t c g − 1 = t g ( c ) for every simple closed curve c c c , conjugation by g g g carries Baykur’s monodromy t d B t_dB t d B to t d ′ B ′ t_{d'}B' t d ′ B ′ . As in the proof of Proposition 4.2 , conjugate monodromies give isomorphic open books, so Baykur’s contact 3–manifold is contactomorphic to the one supported by ( Σ 6 0 , t d ′ B ′ ) (\Sigma_6^0,t_{d'}B') ( Σ 6 0 , t d ′ B ′ ) , which is ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) .
For the fillings we compare ordered vanishing cycles. A Lefschetz fibration over the disk is determined up to diffeomorphism by its fiber and the isotopy classes of its ordered vanishing cycles, and Hurwitz moves do not change it up to diffeomorphism [10 §8.2] . Baykur’s filling X n B X_n^B X n B has the ordered vanishing cycles d d d , t α n ( u ) t_\alpha^n(u) t α n ( u ) , t α n ( v ) t_\alpha^n(v) t α n ( v ) , t α n ( w ) t_\alpha^n(w) t α n ( w ) , t α n ( z ) t_\alpha^n(z) t α n ( z ) . Keeping d d d fixed, we apply to the last four the three Hurwitz moves of Proposition 4.2 , transported by t α n t_\alpha^n t α n , which gives d d d , t α n ( t u t v ( w ) ) t_\alpha^n(t_ut_v(w)) t α n ( t u t v ( w )) , t α n ( u ) t_\alpha^n(u) t α n ( u ) , t α n ( t v ( z ) ) t_\alpha^n(t_v(z)) t α n ( t v ( z )) , t α n ( v ) t_\alpha^n(v) t α n ( v ) . Applying g g g and using g t α g − 1 = t α ′ gt_\alpha g^{-1}=t_{\alpha'} g t α g − 1 = t α ′ and Lemma 4.1, this list becomes d ′ d' d ′ , t α ′ n ( V 0 ) t_{\alpha'}^n(V_0) t α ′ n ( V 0 ) , t α ′ n ( V 1 ) t_{\alpha'}^n(V_1) t α ′ n ( V 1 ) , t α ′ n ( V 2 ) t_{\alpha'}^n(V_2) t α ′ n ( V 2 ) , t α ′ n ( V 3 ) t_{\alpha'}^n(V_3) t α ′ n ( V 3 ) , which are the ordered vanishing cycles of the factorization P n ′ = t d ′ t α ′ n B ′ t α ′ − n P_n'=t_{d'}t_{\alpha'}^nB't_{\alpha'}^{-n} P n ′ = t d ′ t α ′ n B ′ t α ′ − n . Hence X n B X_n^B X n B is diffeomorphic to the Lefschetz fibration of P n ′ P_n' P n ′ , which is diffeomorphic to X n X_n X n by the proof of Theorem 1.1 (2). □
**Proof of Corollary 1.3 .** As in the proof of Theorem 1.1(3), conjugation by $g$ carries the open book $(\Sigma_6^0,t_{d_m}B)$ to $(\Sigma_6^0,t_{g(d_m)}B')$. Moreover, the three Hurwitz moves of {xref}Proposition 4.2, transported by $t_\alpha^n$ and applied with $t_{d_m}$ held fixed, followed by $g$, carry the ordered vanishing cycles of the factorization $t_{d_m}t_\alpha^nBt_\alpha^{-n}$, whose Lefschetz fibration is $X_{m,n}$, to those of $t_{g(d_m)}t_{\alpha'}^nB't_{\alpha'}^{-n}$. By {xref}Proposition 3.2 with $c=g(d_m)$, the contact 3–manifold $(Y_m,\xi_m)$ is obtained from $(ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}})$ by Legendrian surgery along a page realization of $g(d_m)$, and $X_{m,n}\cong DT^*K\cup h_{\psi^{-n}(g(d_m))}$. The same argument applies to $d'_m$. By {citep}[19 Theorem 1.1] these fillings are rational homology balls, pairwise non-homeomorphic for fixed $m$, and $(ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}})$ has a unique minimal weak symplectic filling up to homeomorphism by {citep}[14 Corollary 1.2] `. □
Corollary 1.3 also explains why these fillings are rational homology balls. The disk cotangent bundle D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K has the rational homology of a circle, since H 1 ( D T ∗ K ; Z ) ≅ H 1 ( K ; Z ) ≅ Z ⊕ Z / 2 H_1(DT^*K;\mathbb{Z})\cong H_1(K;\mathbb{Z})\cong\mathbb{Z}\oplus\mathbb{Z}/2 H 1 ( D T ∗ K ; Z ) ≅ H 1 ( K ; Z ) ≅ Z ⊕ Z /2 and H 2 ( D T ∗ K ; Z ) = 0 H_2(DT^*K;\mathbb{Z})=0 H 2 ( D T ∗ K ; Z ) = 0 . Under the diffeomorphism induced by g g g , the attaching circle of X m , n X_{m,n} X m , n corresponds to t α − n ( d m ) t_\alpha^{-n}(d_m) t α − n ( d m ) , whose image in π 1 ( K ) = ⟨ r , b ∣ b r b − 1 = r − 1 ⟩ \pi_1(K)=\langle r,b\mid brb^{-1}=r^{-1}\rangle π 1 ( K ) = ⟨ r , b ∣ b r b − 1 = r − 1 ⟩ , under the identification of [19 §4.2] , is r − 4 ( m n + 1 ) b 2 r^{-4(mn+1)}b^2 r − 4 ( mn + 1 ) b 2 [19 Lemma 5.2] . Its image in H 1 ( D T ∗ K ; Q ) ≅ Q H_1(DT^*K;\mathbb{Q})\cong\mathbb{Q} H 1 ( D T ∗ K ; Q ) ≅ Q , generated by the image of b b b , is 2 ≠ 0 2\ne0 2 = 0 , and for d m ′ d'_m d m ′ it is − 2 -2 − 2 [19 Lemma 5.2] . So the 2–handle kills the rational first homology and creates no rational second homology.
A Stein diagram
The fillings X n X_n X n of Theorem 1.1 are obtained from D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K by attaching a single Weinstein 2–handle. Figure 6 shows a Stein domain of the same shape, which is diffeomorphic to the filling W 0 W_0 W 0 of [19 Example 4.7] of ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) . For W 0 W_0 W 0 we use Baykur’s description, which is equivalent to ours by Theorem 1.1 (3).
Figure 6. A Stein structure on W 0 W_0 W 0 . Removing the green knot gives Gompf’s Stein diagram of D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K .
The purple Legendrian knot, with tb = − 3 \operatorname{tb}=-3 tb = − 3 , together with the two pairs of balls, is Gompf’s Stein diagram [9 , 18 ] of D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K , which is deformation equivalent to ( D T ∗ K , ω c a n ) (DT^*K,\omega_{\mathrm{can}}) ( D T ∗ K , ω can ) by [1 Theorem 7.3] . The green curve is a Legendrian unknot with tb = − 1 \operatorname{tb}=-1 tb = − 1 and rot = 0 \operatorname{rot}=0 rot = 0 , a meridian of the purple knot. After the purple handle is attached, it becomes a Legendrian knot in S T ∗ K ST^*K S T ∗ K representing the belt circle of the 2–handle of D T ∗ K DT^*K D T ∗ K , which is smoothly a circle fiber of S T ∗ K → K ST^*K\to K S T ∗ K → K , and attaching a Weinstein 2–handle along it gives a Stein domain diffeomorphic to W 0 W_0 W 0 by [19 Proposition 4.8] . The generator of H 2 ( W 0 ; Z ) ≅ Z H_2(W_0;\mathbb{Z})\cong\mathbb{Z} H 2 ( W 0 ; Z ) ≅ Z is the 2–handle along the green knot, which runs over no 1–handle and has rotation number zero, so c 1 = 0 c_1=0 c 1 = 0 in H 2 ( W 0 ; Q ) H^2(W_0;\mathbb{Q}) H 2 ( W 0 ; Q ) . The same holds for the Stein structure of the Lefschetz fibration W 0 W_0 W 0 , whose generator is represented by the difference of the 2–handles along two parallel copies of d d d . Since χ ( W 0 ) = 1 \chi(W_0)=1 χ ( W 0 ) = 1 and σ ( W 0 ) = − 1 \sigma(W_0)=-1 σ ( W 0 ) = − 1 , both induced contact structures on Y Y Y have d 3 d_3 d 3 -invariant 1 4 ( c 1 2 − 2 χ − 3 σ ) = 1 4 \frac{1}{4}(c_1^2-2\chi-3\sigma)=\frac{1}{4} 4 1 ( c 1 2 − 2 χ − 3 σ ) = 4 1 .
Conjecture 5.1. The Stein domain of Figure 6 is deformation equivalent to the Stein filling W 0 W_0 W 0 of [19 Example 4.7] . In particular, ( Y , ξ ) (Y,\xi) ( Y , ξ ) is obtained from ( S T ∗ K , ξ c a n ) (ST^*K,\xi_{\mathrm{can}}) ( S T ∗ K , ξ can ) by Legendrian surgery along a Legendrian realization of a circle fiber of S T ∗ K → K ST^*K\to K S T ∗ K → K .
Similarly, a Legendrian realization of the Kirby diagram of X 0 X_0 X 0 on the left of [19 Figure 4] , with one 1–handle and a 2–handle along a Legendrian trefoil with tb = − 7 \operatorname{tb}=-7 tb = − 7 and rot = 0 \operatorname{rot}=0 rot = 0 , gives a Stein structure on X 0 X_0 X 0 with c 1 = 0 c_1=0 c 1 = 0 and d 3 = 1 4 d_3=\frac{1}{4} d 3 = 4 1 , as for the Lefschetz fibration of τ d ′ B ′ \tau_d' B' τ d ′ B ′ , and we expect the two Stein structures to be deformation equivalent.
Appendix A. Proofs of Proposition 2.3
We give two proofs of the relation (5) below, from which Proposition 2.3 follows at the end of this appendix. The first explains how the relation arises, and the second does not depend on it.
First proof, via the line arrangement
Consider the five lines L 1 : y = 2 x , L 2 : y = x − 1 , L 3 : y = 0 , L 4 : y = 1 − x , L 5 : y = − 2 x L_1:y=2x,\quad L_2:y=x-1,\quad L_3:y=0,\quad L_4:y=1-x,\quad L_5:y=-2x L 1 : y = 2 x , L 2 : y = x − 1 , L 3 : y = 0 , L 4 : y = 1 − x , L 5 : y = − 2 x in R 2 \mathbb{R}^2 R 2 , shown in Figure 7 . They meet in two triple points, p 1 = ( 1 , 0 ) ∈ L 2 ∩ L 3 ∩ L 4 p_1=(1,0)\in L_2\cap L_3\cap L_4 p 1 = ( 1 , 0 ) ∈ L 2 ∩ L 3 ∩ L 4 and p 4 = ( 0 , 0 ) ∈ L 1 ∩ L 3 ∩ L 5 p_4=(0,0)\in L_1\cap L_3\cap L_5 p 4 = ( 0 , 0 ) ∈ L 1 ∩ L 3 ∩ L 5 , and four double points, p 2 = L 1 ∩ L 4 p_2=L_1\cap L_4 p 2 = L 1 ∩ L 4 and p 3 = L 2 ∩ L 5 p_3=L_2\cap L_5 p 3 = L 2 ∩ L 5 at x = 1 3 x=\frac{1}{3} x = 3 1 , and p 5 = L 1 ∩ L 2 p_5=L_1\cap L_2 p 5 = L 1 ∩ L 2 and p 6 = L 4 ∩ L 5 p_6=L_4\cap L_5 p 6 = L 4 ∩ L 5 at x = − 1 x=-1 x = − 1 . The line L 3 L_3 L 3 contains two intersection points, and each of the other lines contains three.
Figure 7. The five lines of Proposition 2.3, with y y y scaled by 1 2 \frac{1}{2} 2 1 . Each intersection point is labeled by the curve it contributes to the relation.
We recall where the relation comes from [11 , 3 ] . Regard the L i L_i L i as complex lines in C 2 \mathbb{C}^2 C 2 , and consider the projection ( x , y ) ↦ x (x,y)\mapsto x ( x , y ) ↦ x . Over a point x x x of the x x x -plane, the vertical line { x } × C \{x\}\times\mathbb{C} { x } × C meets the arrangement in five points, one on each L i L_i L i . Removing small disks around these points and truncating at large ∣ y ∣ |y| ∣ y ∣ , the fiber becomes the disk with five holes, where the hole δ i \delta_i δ i corresponds to L i L_i L i . Over the complement of the x x x -coordinates x ( p ) x(p) x ( p ) of the intersection points, these fibers form a locally trivial family, so moving x x x along a loop gives a mapping class of the fiber. Near an intersection point p p p , the points of the lines through p p p come together, and the monodromy along a small loop around x ( p ) x(p) x ( p ) is the Dehn twist along a curve enclosing the holes of these lines, up to twists along the boundaries of these holes, which depend on the framings [11 Lemmas 2.1 and 2.2] . A large loop around all the x ( p ) x(p) x ( p ) rotates all five points once around each other, and its monodromy is a product of boundary twists. Comparing the two gives the relation, and capping off all holes but one shows that the exponent of t δ i t_{\delta_i} t δ i is k i − 1 k_i-1 k i − 1 , where k i k_i k i is the number of intersection points on L i L_i L i . Since the lines are real, all the curves can be compared in one reference fiber by moving along the real axis of the x x x -plane, passing each x ( p ) x(p) x ( p ) along a small half circle, as in the bottom of Figure 8 . Along the real axis the five points are real and ordered from top to bottom, and each half circle reverses the order of the points of the lines through p p p by a half twist.
Figure 8. Top: the sweep in the proof of Proposition 2.3. The reference fiber x = x 0 x=x_0 x = x 0 (blue) meets L 1 , … , L 5 L_1,\ldots,L_5 L 1 , … , L 5 in this order from top to bottom, and it is identified with the disk with holes δ 1 , … , δ 5 \delta_1,\ldots,\delta_5 δ 1 , … , δ 5 , shown on the right. Moving the vertical fiber from right to left, as indicated by the arrow, it passes p 1 , … , p 6 p_1,\ldots,p_6 p 1 , … , p 6 . The gray line is an intermediate fiber. Bottom: the x x x -plane, the image of the projection ( x , y ) ↦ x (x,y)\mapsto x ( x , y ) ↦ x , with the x x x -coordinates of the intersection points directly below them, where x ( p 2 , 3 ) = x ( p 2 ) = x ( p 3 ) x(p_{2,3})=x(p_2)=x(p_3) x ( p 2 , 3 ) = x ( p 2 ) = x ( p 3 ) and x ( p 5 , 6 ) = x ( p 5 ) = x ( p 6 ) x(p_{5,6})=x(p_5)=x(p_6) x ( p 5 , 6 ) = x ( p 5 ) = x ( p 6 ) , the path from x 0 x_0 x 0 passing each of them along a small half circle, and a loop around all of them.
We follow the conventions of [3 ] for Hironaka’s line-arrangement relation [11 Theorem 1.2] . Choose a vertical fiber x = x 0 x=x_0 x = x 0 to the right of all the intersection points, as in Figure 8 . Its intersections with L 1 , … , L 5 L_1,\ldots,L_5 L 1 , … , L 5 , ordered from top to bottom, occur in the order 12345, and we identify this fiber with the disk with holes δ 1 , … , δ 5 \delta_1,\ldots,\delta_5 δ 1 , … , δ 5 , where δ i \delta_i δ i corresponds to L i L_i L i . Move the vertical fiber from right to left, so that it passes through p 1 , … , p 6 p_1,\ldots,p_6 p 1 , … , p 6 in this order, where p 2 , p 3 p_2,p_3 p 2 , p 3 and p 5 , p 6 p_5,p_6 p 5 , p 6 are crossed simultaneously. These two pairs have the same x x x -coordinate. The projection ( x , y ) ↦ x + ε y (x,y)\mapsto x+\varepsilon y ( x , y ) ↦ x + ε y , for small ε > 0 \varepsilon>0 ε > 0 , separates them, and since the lines through p 2 p_2 p 2 and p 3 p_3 p 3 are disjoint from each other, as are those through p 5 p_5 p 5 and p 6 p_6 p 6 , the corresponding half twists and Dehn twists commute, so the order within each pair does not matter. Upon crossing p k p_k p k , the lines through p k p_k p k form a consecutive block in the current vertical ordering, and that block is reversed. The entries in ( i , j ) (i,j) ( i , j ) below refer to the current positions of the strands, not to the labels of the lines.
Table 1.
The blocks ( 1 , 2 ) (1,2) ( 1 , 2 ) , ( 4 , 5 ) (4,5) ( 4 , 5 ) and ( 2 , 4 ) (2,4) ( 2 , 4 ) are reversed by the half twists σ 1 \sigma_1 σ 1 , σ 4 \sigma_4 σ 4 and τ = σ 2 σ 3 σ 2 \tau=\sigma_2\sigma_3\sigma_2 τ = σ 2 σ 3 σ 2 , respectively. The point p k p_k p k contributes the Dehn twist along the curve c k c_k c k obtained from the round curve enclosing the holes in the positions of its block by applying the inverses of the half twists of p 1 , … , p k − 1 p_1,\ldots,p_{k-1} p 1 , … , p k − 1 , the one of p 1 p_1 p 1 applied last. Hironaka’s relation [11 Theorem 1.2] , in the conventions of [3 ] , whose factors occur in the reverse order p 6 , … , p 1 p_6,\ldots,p_1 p 6 , … , p 1 , gives
t c 6 t c 5 t c 4 t c 3 t c 2 t c 1 = t δ 0 ∏ i t δ i k i − 1 , t_{c_6}t_{c_5}t_{c_4}t_{c_3}t_{c_2}t_{c_1}=t_{\delta_0}\prod_i t_{\delta_i}^{k_i-1}, t c 6 t c 5 t c 4 t c 3 t c 2 t c 1 = t δ 0 i ∏ t δ i k i − 1 ,
where k i k_i k i is the number of intersection points on L i L_i L i . Here k 3 = 2 k_3=2 k 3 = 2 and k i = 3 k_i=3 k i = 3 for i ≠ 3 i\ne3 i = 3 , so the right side is Δ ′ \Delta' Δ ′ . By (2) and (3) ,
c 1 = x 4 x 3 x 2 = V 0 , c 2 = τ − 1 ( x 2 x 1 ) = x 4 x 1 ∼ α ′ , c 3 = τ − 1 σ 1 − 1 ( x 5 x 4 ) = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 ∼ β ′ , c 4 = τ − 1 σ 1 − 1 σ 4 − 1 ( x 4 x 3 x 2 ) = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 = V 3 , c 5 = τ − 1 σ 1 − 1 σ 4 − 1 τ − 1 ( x 5 x 4 ) ∼ x 2 x 1 = V 1 , c 6 = τ − 1 σ 1 − 1 σ 4 − 1 τ − 1 σ 4 − 1 ( x 2 x 1 ) = x 5 x 4 = V 2 . \begin{aligned}
c_1&=x_4x_3x_2=V_0,\\
c_2&=\tau^{-1}(x_2x_1)=x_4x_1\sim\alpha',\\
c_3&=\tau^{-1}\sigma_1^{-1}(x_5x_4)=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}\sim\beta',\\
c_4&=\tau^{-1}\sigma_1^{-1}\sigma_4^{-1}(x_4x_3x_2)=x_5x_4x_3x_1x_4^{-1}=V_3,\\
c_5&=\tau^{-1}\sigma_1^{-1}\sigma_4^{-1}\tau^{-1}(x_5x_4)\sim x_2x_1=V_1,\\
c_6&=\tau^{-1}\sigma_1^{-1}\sigma_4^{-1}\tau^{-1}\sigma_4^{-1}(x_2x_1)=x_5x_4=V_2.
\end{aligned} c 1 c 2 c 3 c 4 c 5 c 6 = x 4 x 3 x 2 = V 0 , = τ − 1 ( x 2 x 1 ) = x 4 x 1 ∼ α ′ , = τ − 1 σ 1 − 1 ( x 5 x 4 ) = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 ∼ β ′ , = τ − 1 σ 1 − 1 σ 4 − 1 ( x 4 x 3 x 2 ) = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 = V 3 , = τ − 1 σ 1 − 1 σ 4 − 1 τ − 1 ( x 5 x 4 ) ∼ x 2 x 1 = V 1 , = τ − 1 σ 1 − 1 σ 4 − 1 τ − 1 σ 4 − 1 ( x 2 x 1 ) = x 5 x 4 = V 2 .
The intermediate curves of these computations are shown in Figure 9 .
Figure 9. The curves c 1 , … , c 6 c_1,\ldots,c_6 c 1 , … , c 6 of the proof of Proposition 2.3, after each half twist.
Since V 1 V_1 V 1 and V 2 V_2 V 2 are disjoint, as are α ′ \alpha' α ′ and β ′ \beta' β ′ , the relation becomes
t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 t α ′ t β ′ t V 0 = t δ 0 t δ 1 2 t δ 2 2 t δ 3 t δ 4 2 t δ 5 2 . (5) t_{V_1}t_{V_2}t_{V_3}t_{\alpha'}t_{\beta'}t_{V_0}=t_{\delta_0}t_{\delta_1}^{2}t_{\delta_2}^{2}t_{\delta_3}t_{\delta_4}^{2}t_{\delta_5}^{2}. \tag*{(5)} t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 t α ′ t β ′ t V 0 = t δ 0 t δ 1 2 t δ 2 2 t δ 3 t δ 4 2 t δ 5 2 . (5)
Figure 9 shows the curves c 1 , … , c 6 c_1,\ldots,c_6 c 1 , … , c 6 of the proof of Proposition 2.3. The curve c 1 = V 0 c_1=V_0 c 1 = V 0 is round, and c 2 , … , c 6 c_2,\ldots,c_6 c 2 , … , c 6 are obtained from round curves by applying the half twists one at a time, starting with the rightmost, using (3) . Each arrow is labeled by the half twists applied since the previous picture, and pictures in which the curve does not change are omitted. The last picture in each row is the corresponding curve of Figure 2 .
Second proof, via the action on the fundamental group
We prove (5) directly, for the six curves found above. This proof uses neither Hironaka’s theorem nor the conventions of the sweep, such as the direction of the half circles or the framings of the inner boundary components. Let L L L denote the left side of (5).
First, each of the six Dehn twists is a round twist or the conjugate of a round twist by an explicit braid. The curves V 0 V_0 V 0 , V 1 V_1 V 1 and V 2 V_2 V 2 are round. By (2), σ 1 σ 4 ( x 4 x 3 x 2 ) = x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 \sigma_1\sigma_4(x_4x_3x_2)=x_4^{-1}x_5x_4x_3x_1 σ 1 σ 4 ( x 4 x 3 x 2 ) = x 4 − 1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 , which is conjugate to V 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 V_3=x_5x_4x_3x_1x_4^{-1} V 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 1 x 4 − 1 , so V 3 = η ( V 0 ) V_3=\eta(V_0) V 3 = η ( V 0 ) with η = σ 1 σ 4 \eta=\sigma_1\sigma_4 η = σ 1 σ 4 . By definition α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 ( β ) \alpha'=\sigma_1\sigma_2(\beta) α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 ( β ) , where β \beta β is round. By the computation of c 3 c_3 c 3 above, β ′ = τ − 1 σ 1 − 1 ( V 2 ) = τ − 1 ( V 2 ) \beta'=\tau^{-1}\sigma_1^{-1}(V_2)=\tau^{-1}(V_2) β ′ = τ − 1 σ 1 − 1 ( V 2 ) = τ − 1 ( V 2 ) , where τ = σ 2 σ 3 σ 2 \tau=\sigma_2\sigma_3\sigma_2 τ = σ 2 σ 3 σ 2 is the half twist reversing δ 2 , δ 3 , δ 4 \delta_2,\delta_3,\delta_4 δ 2 , δ 3 , δ 4 , since σ 1 − 1 \sigma_1^{-1} σ 1 − 1 fixes x 5 x 4 x_5x_4 x 5 x 4 . Hence
t V 3 = η t V 0 η − 1 , t α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 t β ( σ 1 σ 2 ) − 1 , t β ′ = τ − 1 t V 2 τ . t_{V_3}=\eta t_{V_0}\eta^{-1},\qquad t_{\alpha'}=\sigma_1\sigma_2t_\beta(\sigma_1\sigma_2)^{-1},\qquad t_{\beta'}=\tau^{-1}t_{V_2}\tau. t V 3 = η t V 0 η − 1 , t α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 t β ( σ 1 σ 2 ) − 1 , t β ′ = τ − 1 t V 2 τ .
Second, we compute the action of L L L on π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,*) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) . A right-handed Dehn twist along a round curve enclosing δ i , … , δ j \delta_i,\ldots,\delta_j δ i , … , δ j conjugates each of x i , … , x j x_i,\ldots,x_j x i , … , x j by x j ⋯ x i x_j\cdots x_i x j ⋯ x i and fixes the other generators (§ 2 ), and the half twists act by (2) and (3). Applying t V 0 , t β ′ , t α ′ , t V 3 , t V 2 t_{V_0},t_{\beta'},t_{\alpha'},t_{V_3},t_{V_2} t V 0 , t β ′ , t α ′ , t V 3 , t V 2 and t V 1 t_{V_1} t V 1 in turn, we find that L L L conjugates each of x 1 , … , x 5 x_1,\ldots,x_5 x 1 , … , x 5 by x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 . The intermediate images are listed at the end of this appendix. The curve parallel to δ 0 \delta_0 δ 0 is the round curve enclosing δ 1 , … , δ 5 \delta_1,\ldots,\delta_5 δ 1 , … , δ 5 , so t δ 0 t_{\delta_0} t δ 0 acts in the same way. Hence L t δ 0 − 1 Lt_{\delta_0}^{-1} L t δ 0 − 1 acts trivially on π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,*) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) .
Third, a mapping class f f f of Σ 0 6 \Sigma^6_0 Σ 0 6 that acts trivially on π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,*) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) is a product of twists along δ 1 , … , δ 5 \delta_1,\ldots,\delta_5 δ 1 , … , δ 5 . Indeed, capping each inner boundary component by a disk with one marked point gives a homomorphism from the mapping class group of Σ 0 6 \Sigma^6_0 Σ 0 6 to that of the disk with five marked points, whose kernel is the free abelian group generated by t δ 1 , … , t δ 5 t_{\delta_1},\ldots,t_{\delta_5} t δ 1 , … , t δ 5 [6 ] . The image of f f f acts trivially on the fundamental group of the disk minus the marked points, which is again the free group on x 1 , … , x 5 x_1,\ldots,x_5 x 1 , … , x 5 , so it is trivial by Artin’s theorem that this action is faithful [6 ] . Hence f f f lies in the kernel. Applied to f = L t δ 0 − 1 f=L t_{\delta_0}^{-1} f = L t δ 0 − 1 , this gives
L = t δ 0 t δ 1 e 1 t δ 2 e 2 t δ 3 e 3 t δ 4 e 4 t δ 5 e 5 L=t_{\delta_0}t_{\delta_1}^{e_1}t_{\delta_2}^{e_2}t_{\delta_3}^{e_3}t_{\delta_4}^{e_4}t_{\delta_5}^{e_5} L = t δ 0 t δ 1 e 1 t δ 2 e 2 t δ 3 e 3 t δ 4 e 4 t δ 5 e 5
for some integers e 1 , … , e 5 e_1,\ldots,e_5 e 1 , … , e 5 .
Finally, we determine the exponents. Fix i i i , and cap off every inner boundary component other than δ i \delta_i δ i by a disk. This gives an annulus with boundary δ 0 ∪ δ i \delta_0\cup\delta_i δ 0 ∪ δ i , whose mapping class group is infinite cyclic, generated by the twist t t t along its core. Under capping, t δ 0 t_{\delta_0} t δ 0 and t δ i t_{\delta_i} t δ i both map to t t t , and t δ j t_{\delta_j} t δ j for j ≠ i j\ne i j = i maps to the identity. A curve enclosing δ i \delta_i δ i becomes parallel to the core, so its twist maps to t t t , and a curve not enclosing δ i \delta_i δ i bounds a disk, so its twist maps to the identity. The six curves enclose the holes
V 1 : { δ 1 , δ 2 } V_1:\{\delta_1,\delta_2\} V 1 : { δ 1 , δ 2 } , V 2 : { δ 4 , δ 5 } V_2:\{\delta_4,\delta_5\} V 2 : { δ 4 , δ 5 } , V 3 : { δ 1 , δ 3 , δ 5 } V_3:\{\delta_1,\delta_3,\delta_5\} V 3 : { δ 1 , δ 3 , δ 5 } , α ′ : { δ 1 , δ 4 } \alpha':\{\delta_1,\delta_4\} α ′ : { δ 1 , δ 4 } , β ′ : { δ 2 , δ 5 } \beta':\{\delta_2,\delta_5\} β ′ : { δ 2 , δ 5 } , V 0 : { δ 2 , δ 3 , δ 4 } V_0:\{\delta_2,\delta_3,\delta_4\} V 0 : { δ 2 , δ 3 , δ 4 } ,
so δ i \delta_i δ i is enclosed by exactly k i k_i k i of them, namely three for i ≠ 3 i\ne3 i = 3 and two for i = 3 i=3 i = 3 . Hence L L L maps to t k i t^{k_i} t k i , and the right side maps to t 1 + e i t^{1+e_i} t 1 + e i . This gives e i = k i − 1 e_i=k_i-1 e i = k i − 1 , that is, ( e 1 , … , e 5 ) = ( 2 , 2 , 1 , 2 , 2 ) (e_1,\ldots,e_5)=(2,2,1,2,2) ( e 1 , … , e 5 ) = ( 2 , 2 , 1 , 2 , 2 ) , and (5) holds.
We list the action on π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) \pi_1(\Sigma^6_0,*) π 1 ( Σ 0 6 , ∗ ) used in the second step. We apply t V 0 t_{V_0} t V 0 , t β ′ t_{\beta'} t β ′ , t α ′ t_{\alpha'} t α ′ , t V 3 t_{V_3} t V 3 , t V 2 t_{V_2} t V 2 , and t V 1 t_{V_1} t V 1 in turn, where t V 3 = η t V 0 η − 1 t_{V_3}=\eta t_{V_0}\eta^{-1} t V 3 = η t V 0 η − 1 with η = σ 1 σ 4 \eta=\sigma_1\sigma_4 η = σ 1 σ 4 , t α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 t β ( σ 1 σ 2 ) − 1 t_{\alpha'}=\sigma_1\sigma_2t_\beta(\sigma_1\sigma_2)^{-1} t α ′ = σ 1 σ 2 t β ( σ 1 σ 2 ) − 1 and t β ′ = τ − 1 t V 2 τ t_{\beta'}=\tau^{-1}t_{V_2}\tau t β ′ = τ − 1 t V 2 τ , and each round twist acts as described in § 2 . After each step, the image of x j x_j x j is c j x j c j − 1 c_jx_jc_j^{-1} c j x j c j − 1 for a word c j c_j c j , and we list these words, after free reduction.
After t V 0 t_{V_0} t V 0 : c 1 = 1 c_1=1 c 1 = 1 , c 2 = x 4 x 3 c_2=x_4x_3 c 2 = x 4 x 3 , c 3 = c 4 = x 4 x 3 x 2 c_3=c_4=x_4x_3x_2 c 3 = c 4 = x 4 x 3 x 2 , c 5 = 1 c_5=1 c 5 = 1 .
After t β ′ t_{\beta'} t β ′ : c 1 = 1 c_1=1 c 1 = 1 , c 2 = x 5 x 4 x 3 c_2=x_5x_4x_3 c 2 = x 5 x 4 x 3 , c 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 c_3=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5^{-1}x_4 c 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 , c 4 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 x 3 c_4=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5^{-1}x_4x_3 c 4 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 x 3 , c 5 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 c_5=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1} c 5 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 .
After t α ′ t_{\alpha'} t α ′ : c 1 = x 4 c_1=x_4 c 1 = x 4 , c 2 = x 5 x 4 x 3 c_2=x_5x_4x_3 c 2 = x 5 x 4 x 3 , c 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 c_3=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5^{-1}x_4 c 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 , c 4 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 x 3 x 1 c_4=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1}x_5^{-1}x_4x_3x_1 c 4 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 x 4 x 3 x 1 , c 5 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 c_5=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_3^{-1}x_4^{-1} c 5 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 3 − 1 x 4 − 1 .
After t V 3 t_{V_3} t V 3 : c 1 = c 2 = x 5 x 4 x 3 c_1=c_2=x_5x_4x_3 c 1 = c 2 = x 5 x 4 x 3 , c 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 c_3=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1 c 3 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 , c 4 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 c_4=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1x_4^{-1}x_5^{-1} c 4 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 x 5 − 1 , c 5 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 c_5=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1x_4^{-1} c 5 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x 4 − 1 .
After t V 2 t_{V_2} t V 2 : c 1 = c 2 = x 5 x 4 x 3 c_1=c_2=x_5x_4x_3 c 1 = c 2 = x 5 x 4 x 3 , c 3 = c 4 = c 5 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 c_3=c_4=c_5=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1 c 3 = c 4 = c 5 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 .
After t V 1 t_{V_1} t V 1 : c 1 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 c_1=x_5x_4x_3x_2 c 1 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 , c 2 = c 3 = c 4 = c 5 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 c_2=c_3=c_4=c_5=x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1 c 2 = c 3 = c 4 = c 5 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 .
In the last line, c 1 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 c_1=x_5x_4x_3x_2 c 1 = x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 may be replaced by x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 , since x 1 x_1 x 1 commutes with itself. So the last line is conjugation by x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 x_5x_4x_3x_2x_1 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 , which is the action of t δ 0 t_{\delta_0} t δ 0 .
In either case, since the right side of (5) is a product of boundary twists, it is central, and conjugating by t V 0 t_{V_0} t V 0 gives
t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 t α ′ t β ′ = t δ 0 t δ 1 2 t δ 2 2 t δ 3 2 t δ 4 2 t δ 5 2 t_{V_0}t_{V_1}t_{V_2}t_{V_3}t_{\alpha'}t_{\beta'}=t_{\delta_0}t_{\delta_1}^{2}t_{\delta_2}^{2}t_{\delta_3}^{2}t_{\delta_4}^{2}t_{\delta_5}^{2} t V 0 t V 1 t V 2 t V 3 t α ′ t β ′ = t δ 0 t δ 1 2 t δ 2 2 t δ 3 2 t δ 4 2 t δ 5 2
that is, B ′ t α ′ t β ′ = Δ ′ B't_{\alpha'}t_{\beta'}=\Delta' B ′ t α ′ t β ′ = Δ ′ .
References