betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Radial modes of pressure bumps and dips in astrophysical discs

Abstract

This study investigates the signatures of pressure extrema on global oscillations in discs. To this end, we use the framework of wave topology to establish a generalised local dispersion relation that includes pressure gradients. We highlight the influence of a previously unrecognized epicyclic-acoustic frequency and derive an analytical criterion for the existence of a branch of modes transiting between the inertial and the pressure bands. We find that pressure extrema consist of wave guides in which such topological modes propagate. The fundamental mode trapped at a pressure bump can propagate at all frequencies, allowing it to resonate with any temporal forcing, while the mode associated with a pressure gap propagates at a fixed frequency, propagates with arbitrary vertical phase velocity. These specific features make them attractive candidates for future discoseismology.

Introduction

Solids in protoplanetary discs drift towards regions of higher pressure [1]. As such, pressure maxima – often called pressure bumps – are privileged places to collect solids and foster planet formation (e.g. [2]; [3]; Drażkowska et al. 2023), with locating and characterising such features of great interest to the planet formation community. Only dust can be imaged directly, while the gas pressure profile has recently been quantitatively constrained from inverting the mean rotational profile, using high-precision kinematic data of CO emission lines obtained with ALMA (e.g. [4]). Departures from circular Keplerian motion can arise from pressure gradients, disc eccentricity or inclination, secondary flows, or additional physical processes such as self-gravity, dust dynamics, or magnetic fields (e.g. [5]). These processes and the presence of protoplanets shape the pressure profile of the gas into a structured disc, with pressure bumps and dips. Probing this flow and these processes by a seismic analysis could be achieved with spatially or time-resolved kinematic data: this is the very goal of discoseismology, essentially introduced so far to study accretion discs around black holes (Solheim et al. 1998; Tsang and Lai 2009; Tsang and Butsky 2013; Ortega-Rodríguez et al. 2020; Dewberry et al. 2020a,b; Kato 2024). This approach aims at constraining the structure of the disc not via the mean flow, but through the study of linear perturbations about its equilibrium.

Linear waves and instabilities have a well-established history as mechanisms for forming structures in discs (Toomre 1964; Goldreich and Lynden-Bell 1965a; Lynden-Bell and Ostriker 1967; Papaloizou and Pringle 1985), for instance the spiral arms of galaxies are understood to be density waves (Lin and Shu 1966; Lynden-Bell and Kalnajs 1972). External perturbers can excite both inertial and acoustic waves at Lindblad resonances, where the orbital period of the mean flow is commensurable with the perturbation’s period, which launches waves in the disc (Lindblad 1948; Goldreich and Tremaine 1978, 1979; Lubow and Ogilvie 1998). This occurs in Saturn’s rings, where ring waves in resonance with oscillations of the planet have been observed by Cassini which provided the first and only seismic data of Saturn (Marley 1991; Hedman and Nicholson 2013; Fuller 2014).

While global modes of isothermal and polytropic discs have been widely investigated (Kato and Fukue 1980; Kato 1983; Papaloizou and Pringle 1985; Blaes 1985; Blaes et al. 2006, 2007), the analysis becomes simpler when focusing solely on small-scale perturbations within the shearing-box framework, where the fluid evolution is described in a small cartesian box rotating with the flow (Hill 1878; Goldreich and Lynden-Bell 1965b). This has led to important advances in our understanding of wave propagation, instabilities, turbulence, angular-momentum transport and planetesimal formation in accretion and protoplanetary discs (e.g. Kato 1978; Goldreich and Tremaine 1980; Balbus and Hawley 1991; Lubow and Pringle 1993; Goodman 1993; Korycansky and Pringle 1995; Ogilvie 1998; Balbus and Hawley 1998; Ogilvie and Lubow 1999; Youdin and Goodman 2005; Johansen et al. 2007; Nelson et al. 2013).

On the other hand, as in the case in stellar seismology (e.g. Aerts et al. 2010), key targets for discoseismology are the large-scale global modes, since they probe the overall structure of the disc and are the easiest to detect. Among these, topological modes are especially attractive, since they can be studied and constrained without the need for short-wavelength or local techniques. These modes stem from a topological property of the differential operator that governs their evolution. While such modes have been investigated for decades in condensed-matter physics, their study in hydrodynamics has emerged only recently ((Delplace et al. 2017; Perrot et al. 2019; Perez et al. 2022; Parker et al. 2020; Qin and Fu 2023; Perez et al. 2025)). Since topological analysis has received little attention in astrophysical fluids to date, characterization of topological modes may enable new methods of probing the structure of interesting objects. The example of topological waves in stars is to this respect particularly instructive. Leclerc et al. (2022) demonstrated that the cancellation of a particular characteristic frequency in stars necessarily gives rise to a topological mode, explaining why ff-branch modes with small harmonic degrees are not confined to the stellar surface. These modes were subsequently shown to remain robust in the presence of convective regions, radiative dissipation, and are excited by convective motions ((Leclerc et al. 2024a; Le Saux et al. 2025)). They have also been observed to hybridize with gg-modes, providing the most reliable method to date for inferring the rotation rate of the solar core ((Le Saux et al. 2025)). Stellar rotation was also found to induce topological modes in seismic spectra ((Leclerc et al. 2024b)).

Building on these developments performed in the stellar context, we aim to address the following questions: do topological modes exist in discs? If so, how are they related to the pressure profile? We address these questions here, and highlight the special properties these modes have, suggesting their interest for protoplanetary discs seismology and dynamics. In Sect. 2, we start by examining the local propagation of waves, by performing a so-called microlocal analysis of the linear wave operator of a simple model of a disc to obtain the local dispersion relation as well as the local polarization relations between the wave fields (Keppeler 2004; Hall 2013; Onuki 2020; Vidal and de Verdière 2024). This is the first time that this method is used in the context of astrophysical discs. In Sect. 3, we exhibit the topological properties of the problem, and predict the existence of topological modes. We then focus on the role of the presence of extrema in the pressure profile in Sect. 4, analysing how they are reflected in the spectrum of large-scale modes. Further extensions of this study are discussed in Sect. 5.

Local waves without shearing box

Epicyclic-acoustic frequency

We consider an unstratified disc made of a non-self gravitating ideal gas around a star of mass MM. The equations of motion for the velocity v\mathbf{v}, pressure pp and density ρ\rho are

∂tv+(v⋅∇)v=−1ρ∇p−GMr2er,(1)\partial_t\mathbf{v}+(\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla)\mathbf{v}=-\frac{1}{\rho}\nabla p-\frac{\mathcal{G}M}{r^2}\mathbf{e}_r, \tag*{(1)}
∂tρ+∇⋅(ρv)=0,(2)\partial_t\rho+\nabla\cdot(\rho\mathbf{v})=0, \tag*{(2)}

along with an appropriate energy equation. We restrict our analysis to the case of a circular disc. In cylindrical coordinates (r,θ,z)(r,\theta,z), the equilibrium profile is parametrized by ρ=ρ0(r)\rho=\rho_0(r), p=p0(r)p=p_0(r), v=(0,rΩ(r),0)\mathbf{v}=(0,r\Omega(r),0). Along the radial direction,

rΩ2=1ρ0dp0dr+GMr2.(3)r\Omega^2=\frac{1}{\rho_0}\frac{\mathrm{d}p_0}{\mathrm{d}r}+\frac{\mathcal{G}M}{r^2}. \tag*{(3)}

We linearly expand the quantities as X=X0+X′X=X_0+X' in Eqs. (1)–(2), assuming adiabatic axisymmetric perturbations of the gas (δp=cs2δρ\delta p=c_s^2\delta\rho). One obtains (Latter and Papaloizou 2017)

∂tvr′=2Ωvθ′−1ρ0∂rp′+p′cs2ρ02dp0dr,(4)\partial_t v'_r=2\Omega v'_\theta-\frac{1}{\rho_0}\partial_r p'+\frac{p'}{c_s^2\rho_0^2}\frac{\mathrm{d}p_0}{\mathrm{d}r}, \tag*{(4)}
∂tvθ′=−(2Ω+rdΩdr)vr′,(5)\partial_t v'_\theta=-\left(2\Omega+r\frac{\mathrm{d}\Omega}{\mathrm{d}r}\right)v'_r, \tag*{(5)}
∂tvz′=−1ρ0∂zp′,(6)\partial_t v'_z=-\frac{1}{\rho_0}\partial_z p', \tag*{(6)}
∂tp′=−p0(1r∂r(rvr′)+∂zvz′)−dp0drvr′.(7)\partial_t p'=-p_0\left(\frac{1}{r}\partial_r(rv'_r)+\partial_zv'_z\right)-\frac{\mathrm{d}p_0}{\mathrm{d}r}v'_r. \tag*{(7)}

We apply the change of variables

(vr′,vθ′,vz′)↦u≡(rρ0 vr′,22−s vθ′,vz′),(8)(v'_r,v'_\theta,v'_z)\mapsto\mathbf{u}\equiv\left(\sqrt{r\rho_0}\,v'_r,\sqrt{\frac{2}{2-s}}\,v'_\theta,v'_z\right), \tag*{(8)}
p′↦h≡rρ0csp′,(9)p'\mapsto h\equiv\frac{\sqrt{r}}{\sqrt{\rho_0}c_s}p', \tag*{(9)}

where s≡dln⁡Ωdln⁡rs\equiv\frac{\mathrm{d}\ln\Omega}{\mathrm{d}\ln r}. It reveals a symmetrized set of equations, which simplifies the subsequent choice inner product introduced for the topological analysis (Leclerc et al. 2022, see Sect. 2.2). Performing a Fourier transform eiωt−ikzze^{i\omega t-ik_z z} yields a wave equation for XT=(uz ur uθ h)X^{\mathsf{T}} = (u_z\ u_r\ u_\theta\ h) of the form

HX=ωX,(10)\mathcal{H}X=\omega X, \tag*{(10)}
H=(000cskz00−iκics∂r+i2dcsdr−iS0iκ00cskzics∂r+i2dcsdr+iS00),(11)\mathcal{H}= \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 0 & 0 & c_s k_z \\ 0 & 0 & -i\kappa& ic_s\partial_r+\frac{i}{2}\frac{dc_s}{dr}-iS \\ 0 & i\kappa& 0 & 0 \\ c_s k_z & ic_s\partial_r+\frac{i}{2}\frac{dc_s}{dr}+iS & 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(11)}

where κ≡2(2−s)Ω\kappa\equiv\sqrt{2(2-s)}\Omega is the epicyclic frequency and

S=cs2(dln⁡p0dr+dln⁡csdr+1r)(12)S=\frac{c_s}{2}\left(\frac{d\ln p_0}{dr}+\frac{d\ln c_s}{dr}+\frac{1}{r}\right) \tag*{(12)}

denotes the epicyclic-acoustic frequency of the disc, acting as a cutoff frequency as we will show in the local dispersion relation. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first explicit identification of the frequency that governs momentum exchange between the inertial and acoustic bands in discs. Its expression follows directly from the rescaled symmetric Hermitian formulation of the wave equations. SS depends on the radial inhomogeneity and the curvature of the disc. Terms associated to Eq. (12) break the symmetry (r,ur,uθ)→−(r,ur,uθ)(r,u_r,u_\theta)\rightarrow-(r,u_r,u_\theta), which is only restored when S=0S=0. SS plays the role, in discs, of the buoyant–acoustic frequency identified in stars by (Leclerc et al. 2022). For a stratified disc, this expression can be conveniently rewritten

S=12[dln⁡p0dln⁡r+dln⁡csdln⁡r+1]HPrΩ,(13)S=\frac{1}{2}\left[\frac{d\ln p_0}{d\ln r}+\frac{d\ln c_s}{d\ln r}+1\right]\frac{H_P}{r}\Omega, \tag*{(13)}

where HP≡csΩ−1H_P\equiv c_s\Omega^{-1} is the pressure scale height of the disc.

We impose impenetrable boundaries, such that ur(r0)=ur(r1)=0u_r(r_0)=u_r(r_1)=0. For real κ\kappa (a Rayleigh stable disc), the operator H\mathcal{H} is self-adjoint with respect to the canonical inner product ⟨X,Y⟩=∫dr X†Y\langle X,Y\rangle=\int dr\,X^\dagger Y. The frequencies ω\omega are then guaranteed to be real: the perturbations considered here are linearly stable. The self-adjointness of H\mathcal{H} gives the following energetic constant of motion

I=12⟨X,X⟩,(14)I=\frac{1}{2}\langle X,X\rangle, \tag*{(14)}
=∫dr 12(∣u∣2+∣h∣2),=∫dr r[12ρ(∣vr′∣2+22−s∣vθ′∣2+∣vz′∣2)+12ρcs2∣p′∣2],(15)\begin{aligned} &=\int dr\,\frac{1}{2}\left(|u|^2+|h|^2\right),\\ &=\int dr\,r\left[\frac{1}{2}\rho\left(|v'_r|^2+\frac{2}{2-s}|v'_\theta|^2+|v'_z|^2\right)+\frac{1}{2\rho c_s^2}|p'|^2\right], \tag*{(15)} \end{aligned}

(see Appendices for a proof). The solutions to Eqs. (10)–(11), together with these boundary conditions, are the axisymmetric oscillation modes of the disc, i.e. the standing waves in the radial direction.

Local wave equation

Microlocal analysis is a representation of differential operators on a phase space using the Wigner transform (Keppeler 2004; Hall 2013). This transform maps (pseudo-)differential operators to symbols, i.e functions of the phase space. Three useful symbols used here are

Symb⁡[cs(r)]=cs,(16)\operatorname{Symb}[c_s(r)] = c_s, \tag*{(16)}
Symb⁡[i∂r]=kr,(17)\operatorname{Symb}[i\partial_r] = k_r, \tag*{(17)}
Symb⁡[ics∂r+i2dcsdr]=cskr.(18)\operatorname{Symb}\left[ic_s\partial_r+\frac{i}{2}\frac{dc_s}{dr}\right] = c_s k_r. \tag*{(18)}

It gives a appropriate way to define a local wavenumber krk_r for a wave (Onuki 2020).

The operator H\mathcal{H} is then mapped to its symbol HH

H=(000cskz00−iκcskr−iS0iκ00cskzcskr+iS00).(19)H= \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 0 & 0 & c_s k_z \\ 0 & 0 & -i\kappa& c_s k_r-iS \\ 0 & i\kappa& 0 & 0 \\ c_s k_z & c_s k_r+iS & 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(19)}

The Wigner transform has a number of useful properties, among which is the conservation of Hermiticity: H\mathcal{H} is a self-adjoint differential operator if and only if HH is a Hermitian matrix function (one can find this property in (Hall 2013), page 266). It is then guaranteed that HH gives the local dispersion relation of the waves without introducing spurious instabilities, as it has been shown to happen when including pressure gradients in local studies (e.g. see discussions in Lin and Youdin 2015; Latter and Papaloizou 2017). Indeed, one has H†=HH^\dagger=H. The local wave equation is

HX=ωX,(20)HX=\omega X, \tag*{(20)}

and the local dispersion relation is simply obtained by det⁡(H−ωI)=0\det(H-\omega I)=0, which yields

cs2kr2=(cs2kz2−ω2)(κ2−ω2)ω2−S2.(21)c_s^2k_r^2=\frac{(c_s^2k_z^2-\omega^2)(\kappa^2-\omega^2)}{\omega^2}-S^2. \tag*{(21)}

Equation (21) is a quadratic polynomial in ω2\omega^2, whose smaller root corresponds to the inertial band (or rr-band) and the larger to the pressure band (or pp-band). For inertial waves, one has 0≤ω2≤κ20\leq\omega^2\leq\kappa^2, while for pressure waves, ω2≥κ2+S2\omega^2\geq\kappa^2+S^2. Thus, a nonzero value of SS opens a frequency gap between the bands, and no wave with ω2∈(κ2,κ2+S2)\omega^2\in(\kappa^2,\kappa^2+S^2) can propagate radially in the disc. The dispersion relation derived by other local expansions, which neglect both the curvature term and the pressure gradient, is recovered for S=0S=0. In that special case, there is a degeneracy between acoustic and inertial waves at ω=κ\omega=\kappa for (kr,kz)=(0,κ/cs)(k_r,k_z)=(0,\kappa/c_s), but it is lifted by any nonzero value of SS, i.e any nonzero pressure gradient or by the curvature term.

Topology and global modes

Chern numbers

The symbol HH obtained from the microlocal analysis formally coincides with that derived for stellar oscillations in Leclerc et al. (2022), who demonstrated that these degeneracies in the local dispersion relation are linked to topological charges known as Chern numbers (Volovik 2003; Delplace 2022). According to the principle called index theorem, this implies the presence of a spectral flow in the dispersion relation of the global modes {ωn}n∈N\{\omega_n\}_{n\in\mathbb{N}} (Delplace et al. 2017; Delplace 2022; Faure 2023). A spectral flow is the fact that a finite number of modes branches transit from one band to the other as the parameter kzk_z increases, in that case between the band of rr-modes and the band of pp-modes. This number of branches precisely equals a topological index of the symbol called the first Chern number.

Following Leclerc et al. (2022), we define and compute the Chern numbers for the wavebands in the disc. For a given eigenvector XX of a given band of HH (either the rr- or the pp- band), the Berry curvature is the vector field in the parameter space (kr,S,kz)(k_r,S,k_z) expressed as

F=i∇×(X⋅∇X),(22)\boldsymbol{F}=i\boldsymbol{\nabla}\times\left(X\cdot\boldsymbol{\nabla}X\right), \tag*{(22)}

where ∇=(∂kr,∂S,∂kz)\boldsymbol{\nabla}=(\partial_{k_r},\partial_S,\partial_{k_z}). This convenient expression only holds in a 3D parameter space, although more general definitions exist (Delplace 2022). F\boldsymbol{F} is singular when frequencies degenerate, which occurs for kr=S=0k_r=S=0 and cskz=±κc_s k_z=\pm\kappa. Figure 1 displays F\boldsymbol{F} for the acoustic wave, revealing the two singularities associated with the degeneracies.

Berry curvature of the acoustic wave

Figure 1. The Berry curvature F\boldsymbol{F} of the acoustic wave is singular at (cskr,S,cskz)=(0,0,±κ)(c_s k_r,S,c_s k_z)=(0,0,\pm\kappa). This obstruction is a topological constraint, characterized by the two charges C=±1\mathcal{C}=\pm1. Length and brightness of the arrows indicate the norm of F\boldsymbol{F}.

The Chern number characterizes these singularities. It is an integer defined as

C=12π∮ΣF⋅dΣ,(23)\mathcal{C}=\frac{1}{2\pi}\oint_{\Sigma}\boldsymbol{F}\cdot\mathrm{d}\boldsymbol{\Sigma}, \tag*{(23)}

where Σ\Sigma is any closed surface enclosing one singularity. Numerical computations show that the two degeneracies at kr=S=0k_r=S=0 and cskz=±κc_s k_z=\pm\kappa have Chern numbers

C=±1.(24)\mathcal{C}=\pm1. \tag*{(24)}

These values are expected from the formal analogy with the problem of Leclerc et al. (2022).

The Chern number is computed in the local analysis; however, it has direct consequences on the global waves by imposing a spectral flow, the existence of modes whose frequencies approach both wavebands (inertial and acoustic) for different limits of kzk_z. The nonzero Chern numbers calculated by Leclerc et al. (2022) impose the propagation of a Lamb-like wave in non-rotating stars crossing the frequency gap between acoustic and internal gravity waves (Perrot et al. 2019; Leclerc et al. 2022). We then expect to have one global wave branch with such spectral behavior in the spectrum of a disc.

Location of topological modes

The spatial location of topological modes corresponding to the spectral flow branch is determined by whether a radius exists where

S=0,(25)S=0, \tag*{(25)}

as it is the point where the topological degeneracy occurs in Figure 1. If such a topological interface is present in the disc, the energy of the modes are concentrated in a volume centered around this interface over a typical radial length L\mathcal{L} given by

L≡cs∣dSdr∣−1∣S=0.(26)\mathcal{L}\equiv\sqrt{\left.c_s\left|\frac{\mathrm{d}S}{\mathrm{d}r}\right|^{-1}\right|_{S=0}}. \tag*{(26)}

The steeper SS is near the S=0S=0 interface, the more tightly confined the topological modes are. If SS has a constant sign throughout the object, the modes are located at one of the boundaries: at the inner edge if S<0S<0 and at the outer edge if S>0S>0 (See the discussion of Iga 2001, page 483 for a similar result in an atmospheric context). This behavior is a manifestation of the general bulk-boundary correspondence known in condensed matter physics: the topological properties of a material, calculated in the bulk of the domain, determine the existence and nature of some modes that appear at its boundaries (Delplace 2022).

Monotonic disc profiles

We first consider a disc whose density, temperature and rotation rate are parametrized by typical power-laws Armitage (2011). More precisely, the temperature scales as T(r)∝r−qT(r) \propto r^{-q}, the surface density as Σ(r)∝r−p\Sigma(r) \propto r^{-p} and the rotation rate as Ω(r)∝r−s\Omega(r) \propto r^{-s}. Hence, volume density scales as ρ∝Ωcs2Σ∝r−p−s+q2\rho\propto\frac{\Omega}{c_s^2}\Sigma\propto r^{-p-s+\frac{q}{2}} and

S=12[1−p−q−s]HrΩ.(27)S = \frac{1}{2}\left[1-p-q-s\right]\frac{H}{r}\Omega. \tag*{(27)}

For physically realistic profiles, 1−p−q−s<01-p-q-s < 0 and thus S<0S < 0 throughout the disc. As discussed in Sect. 3.2, a topological mode is expected to be located at the inner edge of the disc.

We verify this prediction by solving Eqs. (10)–(11) numerically using the EVP class of the Dedalus python package (Burns et al. 2020; Oishi et al. 2021). The gas is contained between two radii r0r_0 and r1=10r0r_1=10r_0. Units of lengths and time are r0r_0 and Ω(r0)−1\Omega(r_0)^{-1} and the dimensionless parameters are p=1p=1, q=12q=\frac{1}{2}, s=32s=\frac{3}{2} and csrΩ∣r0=0.1\left.\frac{c_s}{r\Omega}\right|_{r_0}=0.1. Figure 2 shows the density profile of the disc and the frequencies of the global waves for a range of vertical wavenumbers kzk_z. The average energy-weighted position ⟨r⟩≡⟨X,rX⟩/⟨X,X⟩\langle r\rangle\equiv\langle X,rX\rangle/\langle X,X\rangle for a mode X(r)X(r) is provided via the color bar. Low frequency pp-modes are located mostly in the outer parts of the disc, where the sound speed is the lowest. High frequency rr-modes are located mostly in the inner part, where the epicyclic frequency κ\kappa is maximal. Due to these spatial variations, the two bands of frequency of these two families of modes superimpose significantly, but separate asymptotically at kz→0k_z\to0 and kz→∞k_z\to\infty. Indeed, at low kzk_z, acoustic modes reach nonzero frequencies, while inertial waves all have zero frequency. On the other hand at large kzk_z, the inertial wave reach finite frequencies, while the acoustic waves follow ω∝kz\omega\propto k_z.

Global modes of a monotonic disc

Figure 2. Global modes of a monotonic disc. The one topological branch transits from inertial modes (blue) at low kzk_z to acoustic modes (yellow) at high kzk_z. It matches the dispersion relation ω=cs(r0)kz\omega=c_s(r_0)k_z (grey thin line).

One mode falls outside this classification: it reaches zero frequency as kz→0k_z\to0, yet behaves as ω∝kz\omega\propto k_z for large kzk_z. This mode corresponds to the spectral flow: as kzk_z increases, its branch transits from the inertial wave-band to the acoustic waveband. Numerical integration shows that this branch corresponds to the fundamental modes of the disc, which have no radial node of pressure or vertical velocity. It follows the dispersion relation ω=cs(r0)kz\omega=c_s(r_0)k_z (grey thin line on Figure 2), as it is indeed located at the inner boundary r0r_0, and is acoustic in nature.

Pressure extrema

Slender tori

Singularities of Berry curvature occur when S=0S=0. Interestingly, when the spatial curvature term is negligible in Eq. (13), this coincides with local pressure extrema, which occur in structured discs in the form of rings and gaps (Andrews et al. 2018). One therefore expects topological modes to propagate around pressure maxima and minima. To investigate this expectation, we study the isothermal slender torus model (Papaloizou and Pringle 1985), a model of rings in which the radial extent of the gas is assumed to be small compared to the distance to the star rr, thereby enforcing strong radial pressure gradients. The gas density of the slender torus is parametrized by

ρ0(r)=ρcexp⁡(−(r−r0)22L2),(28)\rho_0(r)=\rho_c\exp\left(-\frac{(r-r_0)^2}{2L^2}\right), \tag*{(28)}
S(r)=−cs2L2(r−r0),(29)S(r)=-\frac{c_s}{2L^2}(r-r_0), \tag*{(29)}

where here r0r_0 is the position of the pressure maximum, L2=cs2Ω022s−3L^2=\frac{c_s^2\Omega_0^2}{2s-3}, with s=dln⁡Ωdln⁡rs=\frac{\mathrm{d}\ln\Omega}{\mathrm{d}\ln r} and Ω0=Ω(r0)\Omega_0=\Omega(r_0). SS vanishes at r=r0r=r_0, which implies that the topological mode is trapped around this position.

Since SS varies linearly with rr, analytical solutions for global modes can be found (a similar solution has been derived for stars in Leclerc et al. 2022). For an isothermal disc, eliminating uθu_\theta and uzu_z in Eq. (10), it can then be written in the compact form

ur=(ω−κ2ω)−1Dh,(30)u_r=\left(\omega-\frac{\kappa^2}{\omega}\right)^{-1}\mathcal{D}h, \tag*{(30)}
D†Dh=λh,(31)\mathcal{D}^{\dagger}\mathcal{D}h=\lambda h, \tag*{(31)}

where D≡ics∂r−iS(r)\mathcal{D}\equiv ic_s\partial_r-iS(r) and λ≡(ω−κ2ω)(ω−cs2kz2ω)\lambda\equiv\left(\omega-\frac{\kappa^2}{\omega}\right)\left(\omega-\frac{c_s^2k_z^2}{\omega}\right). The slender torus model verifies Eq. (29) and as such, the global modes equation Eq. (31) reads

(−∂rr+(r−r0)24L4−12L2−λcs2)h=0,(32)\left(-\partial_{rr}+\frac{(r-r_0)^2}{4L^4}-\frac{1}{2L^2}-\frac{\lambda}{c_s^2}\right)h=0, \tag*{(32)}

which is the differential eigenvalue equation of the Quantum Harmonic Oscillator (Abramowitz and Stegun 1972). Imposing regularity at infinity, the solutions of Eq. (32) are Hermite polynomials HnH_n with associated frequencies ωn\omega_n, so that the normal modes of the disc are

p′/ρ0∝vz′∝Hn(r−r02L),(33)p'/\rho_0 \propto v'_z \propto H_n\left(\frac{r-r_0}{\sqrt{2}L}\right), \tag*{(33)}
vr′∝vθ′∝nHn−1(r−r02L),(34)v'_r \propto v'_\theta\propto\sqrt{n}H_{n-1}\left(\frac{r-r_0}{\sqrt{2}L}\right), \tag*{(34)}
nL2=(cs2kz2−ωn2)(κc2−ωn2)cs2ωn2.(35)\frac{n}{L^2}=\frac{(c_s^2k_z^2-\omega_n^2)(\kappa_c^2-\omega_n^2)}{c_s^2\omega_n^2}. \tag*{(35)}

In the solutions, nn is a non-negative integer that corresponds to the number of radial nodes in the pressure perturbation profile. For n≥1n \ge1, two modes satisfy Eq. (35): one acoustic and one inertial, both of radial order nn. For n=0n=0, only a single solution with finite kinetic energy exists (for which vr′=vθ′=0v'_r=v'_\theta=0), namely

ωn=0=±cskz.(36)\omega_{n=0}=\pm c_sk_z. \tag*{(36)}

This mode propagates at all frequencies and as such, transits between the frequency bands. This mode and its behavior among the rest of the spectrum of the slender torus are shown on Figure 3.

Figure 3. Dispersion relations of the global modes in a slender torus.

Pressure minima

Interestingly, the topological arguments also suggests modes trapped at a pressure minima. We therefore study a model of a gap given by the inverse of the slender torus profile, parametrized by

ρ0(r)=ρcexp⁡(+(r−r0)22L2),(37)\rho_0(r)=\rho_c\exp\left(+\frac{(r-r_0)^2}{2L^2}\right), \tag*{(37)}
S(r)=+cs2L2(r−r0).(38)S(r)=+\frac{c_s}{2L^2}(r-r_0). \tag*{(38)}

While SS passes through zero with a negative slope at pressure maxima, at pressure minima this slope is instead positive. Nevertheless, the differential equation Eq. (11) differs very little, and the solutions of this model read

p′/ρ0∝vz′∝nexp⁡(−(r−r0)22L2)Hn−1(r−r02L)(39)p'/\rho_0\propto v'_z\propto\sqrt{n}\exp\left(-\frac{(r-r_0)^2}{2L^2}\right)H_{n-1}\left(\frac{r-r_0}{\sqrt{2}L}\right) \tag*{(39)}
vr′∝vθ′∝exp⁡(−(r−r0)22L2)Hn(r−r02L),(40)v'_r\propto v'_\theta\propto\exp\left(-\frac{(r-r_0)^2}{2L^2}\right)H_n\left(\frac{r-r_0}{\sqrt{2}L}\right), \tag*{(40)}
nL2=(cs2kz2−ωn2)(κc2−ωn2)cs2ωn2.(41)\frac{n}{L^2}=\frac{(c_s^2k_z^2-\omega_n^2)(\kappa_c^2-\omega_n^2)}{c_s^2\omega_n^2}. \tag*{(41)}

Again, in this set of solutions, the n=0n=0 case only has one solution with finite kinetic energy, which is the mode with constant frequency

ω=±κ(42)\omega=\pm\kappa \tag*{(42)}

This mode is a spectral flow in the other direction than at a pressure maximum, since the branch transits from the acoustic band to the inertial band as kzk_z increases, and is shown in Figure 4.

Figure 4. Dispersion relations of the global modes in a pressure minimum.

Gap in a disc

In order to test these predictions in a realistic gap in a disc, we study the spectrum of an extended disc with power-law profiles as discussed in § 3.3, on top of which is carved a gap. More precisely, volume density is taken as

ρ∝r−p−s+q2×(1−Aexp⁡(−(r−rgap)22Lgap2)).(43)\rho\propto r^{-p-s+\frac{q}{2}} \times\left(1-A\exp\left(-\frac{(r-r_{\mathrm{gap}})^2}{2L_{\mathrm{gap}}^2}\right)\right). \tag*{(43)}

This profile is shown on Figure 5 (top), with the position of the gap rgap=8r0r_{\mathrm{gap}}=8r_0, width of the gap Lgap=0.2r0L_{\mathrm{gap}}=0.2r_0 and relative depth of the gap A=0.99A=0.99.

Density profile and spectrum for a disc with a gap

Figure 5. Same as Figure 2, for a disc with a gap and zoomed on lower frequencies. In a disc where a gap of density is present, one local minimum and one local maximum of density are found. Associated to these extrema, two topological modes are expected and found in the spectrum, one inertial and one acoustic respectively. Grey lines: ω=κ(r=rmin⁡)\omega=\kappa(r=r_{\min}) and ω=cs(r=rmax⁡)kz\omega=c_s(r=r_{\max})k_z.

Interestingly, the addition of a gap in the disc causes the addition of two new extrema of density: a minimum and a maximum, separated by approximately half the gap width. By the analysis described in the sections above, one expects two topological modes localized at these regions of the disc, trapped by the density extrema. Close to rmin⁡r_{\min} and therefore close to the center of the gap, one expects an epicyclic mode with dispersion relation ω=κ(r=rmin⁡)\omega=\kappa(r=r_{\min}), and an acoustic mode close to rmax⁡r_{\max} with dispersion relation ω=cs(r=rmax⁡)kz\omega=c_s(r=r_{\max})k_z.

The bottom panel of Figure 5 presents the numerically obtained spectrum of the disc. As before, the colors indicate the average mode positions, with modes located inside the gap highlighted in pink.

In addition to the inertial and acoustic branches already present in the monotonic disc, one observes a new set of inertial branches (low-frequency, pink) as well as a new set of acoustic branches (yellow). Moreover, the two branches of modes predicted by the topological analysis are also visible, with their dispersion relations overlaid as thin grey lines. An inertial branch appears at ω=κ(r=rmin⁡)\omega=\kappa(r=r_{\min}), while an acoustic branch follows ω=cs(r=rmax⁡)kz\omega=c_s(r=r_{\max})k_z. Because these two modes occupy nearby regions in radius, they hybridize when their frequencies align, leading to an avoided crossing near r0kz∼0.8r_0k_z\sim0.8. The low-frequency pink branch is not incidental: it represents a mode trapped in the gap and corresponds to the topological epicyclic mode, as evidenced by its eigenfunctions (see Appendix § 11). Therefore, the density extrema act as waveguides, trapping modes in the way described in the analytical models presented in Sect. 4.1 and 4.2. In addition to the two topological modes, new branches of inertial modes appeared in the spectrum at low frequency, trapped in the gap. New branches of acoustic modes appear with average position in the yellow region, as those are instead trapped between the gap and the outer boundary. In that case, it appears that the gap of the disc acts as a reflector for acoustic waves.

Discussion

By leveraging topological methods, our analysis characterizes how large-scale modes behave in radially structured discs. Emphasis was put on the role that radial pressure and density gradients play on linear stable waves, encapsulated by the characteristic frequency SS. Using microlocal techniques, we show that these gradients modify the local dispersion relations by coupling acoustic and inertial waves and removing their frequency degeneracy. As such, SS naturally acts as a cutoff frequency and offers a consistent way to account for gradient effects in local analyses. Topological arguments highlight the significance of points where S=0S=0, which carry topological charges (Chern numbers C=±1C=\pm1). These charges enforce the emergence of modes with unique spectral properties, namely branches that transit between rr-modes and pp-modes. While a monotonic disc hosts only one such branch, structured discs contain additional ones, as illustrated in Figure 5. We emphasize that the gapped-disc model presented in Sect. 4.3 is intended as an illustrative example of trapped modes; although it reproduces the expected topological modes at pressure extrema, it is not meant to be realistic or to remain stable against the Rossby wave instability ((Lovelace et al. 1999)).

The fundamental mode trapped at a pressure maximum propagates for all frequencies and is the sole mode to do so (see Figure 3), making it capable of resonating with any temporal forcing, unlike modes with forbidden frequency domains. It is a vertical acoustic wave (see Figure 6–Figure 7). By contrast, the fundamental mode associated with a pressure minimum (a gap) propagates only at the constant frequency ω=κ\omega=\kappa (see Figure 4 and Figure 8–Figure 9), and is a horizontal, epicyclic wave. This unique property thereby allows for a propagation at arbitrary vertical phase velocities. Indeed, since κkz=κkz\frac{\kappa}{k_z}=\frac{\kappa}{k_z} can take any value, this mode is unique among the modes in having an arbitrary vertical phase velocity. This is a necessary condition for resonating with any vertical dust flow involved in dust-settling instabilities, a class of resonant drag instabilities (e.g. Squire and Hopkins 2018; Zhu 2019; Lehmann and Lin 2023; Paardekooper and Aly 2025). In the analytical model of § 4.2, this mode has no vertical velocity and therefore does not couple to vertical flows a priori. However, we emphasize that this is a peculiarity of that model. In general, the mode does exhibit some vertical-velocity perturbation (see Appendix § 11): this topological mode may thus couple to vertical flows in settling-instability mechanisms. It would be worthwhile to further investigate its role at the outer edge of a planetary gap, where dust accumulates.

Relative amplitudes of the components of a fundamental $p$-mode with large $k_z$

Figure 6. Relative amplitudes of the components of a fundamental pp-mode with large kzk_z, of topological origin, induced by a pressure bump located close to rmax⁡r_{\max}. The amplitudes are displayed as functions of the distance to the central object in the mid-plane (top right panel) and for a (r,z)(r,z) slice of the disc (bottom panel). The selected mode is marked with a cross in the top left panel (same as Figure 2). This mode clearly has amplitudes in (uz,h)(u_z,h) and as such, is of acoustic nature. Interestingly, it mixes with both the fundamental rr-mode of the gap and an inertial mode of the inner disc, which both have amplitudes in uru_r and uθu_\theta. It is more spatially extended around rmax⁡r_{\max} than the fundamental rr-mode is around rmin⁡r_{\min} (see below).

Image not extracted

Figure 7. Same as Figure 6, but for a mode a low kzk_z (note the different zz scale). The properties of this mode are similar to the one displayed in Figure 6.

Image not extracted

Figure 8. Same as Figure 6 for the fundamental rr-mode, topologically induced by the existence of the a pressure gap. The mode exhibits strong horizontal motions around rmin⁡r_{\min} (note the scales colorbars), where the amplitude peaks. The mode extends outwards of the gap, and has non-zero amplitude at rmax⁡r_{\max}, where grains may eventually pile-up. The mode mixes with acoustic vibrations outside of rmin⁡r_{\min}.

Profiles of modes for larger values of $k_z$

Figure 9. Same as Figure 8, but for larger values of kzk_z (note the different scale on zz). The fundamental vibration of the gap couples with an inertial vibration of the rest of the disc, such that vertical motions have comparable amplitudes with horizontal motions within the gap (note the scales colorbars).

The spectrum of a disc with a pressure bump instead of a pressure gap produces similar results (see Figure 10).

Profiles of modes for a disc having a pressure bump

Figure 10. Same as Figure 6, but for a disc having a pressure bump. The parameters of the bump are similar to the ones used to parametrize the gap, with a reversed amplitude A=−20A=-20. The mode is essentially of acoustic nature, while it mixes with inertial modes in the inner regions. The inertial topological mode associated to the presence of a pressure minimum at the inner edge is present, but difficult to distinguish since it is very delocalized.

At low kzk_z (see Figure 8) this mode exhibits a very similar character to the trapped rr-modes found in black hole accretion discs (Kato 2004, 2008; Ferreira and Ogilvie 2008; Dewberry et al. 2018). Only here the mode is confined by the epicyclic-acoustic frequency rather than by the maximum in the relativistic epicyclic frequency found in black hole discs. This leaves open the possibility that this mode could be excited to large amplitudes via a similar three-wave coupling mechanism (Kato 2004, 2008; Ferreira and Ogilvie 2008), where the rr-mode is coupled to a global m=1m = 1 deformation in such a way that it leads to growth in the rr-mode amplitude. Candidates for such a global m=1m = 1 deformation include remnant disc eccentricity left over from the disc formation process (Commerçon et al. 2024), or disc warping and eccentricity excited by an embedded planet (Lubow and Ogilvie 2001; Teyssandier and Ogilvie 2016).

The main limitations of the present study are the absence of vertical stratification and of any linear instability. The vertical stratification is sometimes separated from the radial problem by averaging vertically (e.g. Papaloizou and Pringle 1985 or Blaes et al. 2006); we instead chose to assume no stratification, in order to keep the notion of a vertical wavenumber kzk_z. We note that our analytical solutions for the slender torus Eq. (35) matches those of Blaes et al. (2006), see their Eq. 56 for their nn set to ∞\infty and our kz=0k_z = 0.

We also note that Eq. (21) is analogous to the one found by Okazaki et al. 1987 (Eq. 4.4) who studied vertical isothermal stratification and no radial stratification, with two expected differences: the addition of S2S^2 representing radial gradients in our case, and the replacement of cs2kz2c_s^2 k_z^2 by nz2κ2n_z^2 \kappa^2 in their case, where nzn_z is a positive integer counting the number of nodes in the profile of pressure perturbation given by the Hermite function of order nzn_z. Thus, vertical isothermal stratification seems to be fully taken into account by discretizing wavenumbers as cskz=nz1/2κc_s k_z = n_z^{1/2} \kappa. However, the results of Korycansky and Pringle 1995 suggest an interesting behavior of the modes with vertical stratification and no radial gradients (see their Fig. 1). Indeed, they show that a pair of fundamental pp-modes with indices nz=0,1n_z = 0, 1 have frequencies connecting inertial modes and acoustic modes, possibly performing a spectral flow. This suggests that, complementarily, vertical stratification imposes another set of topological properties and topological modes, regardless of radial gradients.

The analytical techniques and solutions found for modes of non-axisymmetric polytropic discs, slender (Papaloizou and Pringle 1985; Blaes 1985; Blaes et al. 2006) or thick (Blaes et al. 2007) provide the support to explore the topology of these waves rising from vertical inhomogeneity, and from azimuthal wavenumbers, and possibly associated topological modes. Our goal in the present study is to provide a starting point for applying topological analysis to linear waves in discs, a framework whose predictive power can yield new insights into large-scale oscillations in inhomogeneous discs, with the perspective of establishing robust and possibly unique properties of large-scale modes falling out of WKB approaches. This line of research is motivated by the anticipated potential of discoseismology in protoplanetary discs, facilitated by line-kinematic measurements from ALMA (e.g. [4, 5]). While this perspective is still far off, we expect that the spatial patterns of the eigenmodes may provide constraints on modes—a key distinction from stellar pulsation studies. The employment of topological analysis to study linear instabilities in discs requires further investigation, as it is a field of research less developed than topology of stable waves. In stellar context, these ideas have led to the unveiling of fast-growing large-scale modes of compressible convective instability (Leclercq et al. 2024a). Similar results may be expected in discs instabilities, when accounting for the role of pressure gradients as we did in the present study.

Conclusion

Motivated by the foreseen potential of discoseismology in protoplanetary discs enabled by line-kinematic measurements from ALMA, we conduct a topological analysis of radial waves in unstratified astrophysical discs. The main conclusions are:

  1. Existence of robust topological modes: Global large-scale modes transiting between the inertial and the acoustic bands exist in discs. These modes find their roots in topological numbers, and as such qualify as being topological modes. This special origin provides them with unique properties.

  1. Epicyclic–acoustic frequency: The existence of topological modes in discs is associated with the cancellation of the epicyclic-acoustic frequency SS given by Eq. (12), which gives the rate of momentum exchange between the inertial and acoustic bands. This is why monotonic-density discs support a single topological mode at their inner edge.

  1. Role of pressure extrema: Pressure maxima and minima, acting as waveguides, generate additional topological modes because S=0S = 0 at these locations. The associated topological branch is

acoustic at pressure maxima and inertial at pressure minima, both having unique specificity across the spectrum (any frequency or any phase velocity). Their distinct features make them appealing targets for future line-based discoseismology. Furthermore, they are potentially easier to detect as they are localized, and their radial trapping would provide a direct measure of the pressure gradient of the bump/dip.

  1. Microlocal framework: The microlocal analysis introduced here enables the study of local wave properties without using a shearing box, while preserving the Hermitian structure of the problem. This approach provides a powerful framework for studying linear modes in discs.

As commented on in the discussion, we focused on the midplane, ignoring for the moment the influence of vertical stratification. Treating simultaneously vertical and radial gradients requires a complementary study, which may reveal additional topological structures in the higher-dimensional parameter space involved. A stepping stone towards general results and potentially discoseismology is to study a dual simplified problem where radial gradients are neglected while keeping vertical stratification. A study focusing on the topological modes of this problem will be the object of a future work.

Acknowledgements

AL was funded by Contrat Doctoral Spécifique Normaliens during this work. GL, EL and NP acknowledge funding from ERC CoG project PODCAST No 864965. We used Mathematica (Wolfram Research, Inc. 2024). The scripts used for numerical calculations are accessible at https://github.com/ArmandLeclerc/radialStratifDisc.

Appendix

Constant of motion

The evolution equation of the perturbations X(r,kz,t)X(r,k_z,t) is

i∂tX=HX.(44)i\partial_t X = \mathcal{H}X. \tag*{(44)}

As H\mathcal{H} is self-adjoint with respect to the inner product

⟨X,Y⟩=∫dr XT∗⋅Y,(45)\langle X,Y\rangle= \int dr\ X^{\mathsf{T}*}\cdot Y, \tag*{(45)}

where ⋅\cdot is the matricial product, such that ⟨X,HY⟩=⟨HX,Y⟩\langle X,\mathcal{H}Y\rangle=\langle\mathcal{H}X,Y\rangle for boundary conditions with zero radial velocity. One then has

i∂t⟨X,X⟩=⟨−i∂tX,X⟩+⟨X,i∂tX⟩,(46)i\partial_t\langle X,X\rangle= \langle-i\partial_tX,X\rangle+\langle X,i\partial_tX\rangle, \tag*{(46)}
=−⟨HX,X⟩+⟨X,HX⟩,(47)= -\langle\mathcal{H}X,X\rangle+\langle X,\mathcal{H}X\rangle, \tag*{(47)}
=−⟨X,HX⟩+⟨X,HX⟩,(48)= -\langle X,\mathcal{H}X\rangle+\langle X,\mathcal{H}X\rangle, \tag*{(48)}
=0.(49)=0. \tag*{(49)}

I=12⟨X,X⟩I=\frac{1}{2}\langle X,X\rangle is then a constant of motion, given by the self-adjointness of the evolution operator H\mathcal{H}. Equation (15) gives it in dimensional form, where one reads that it is a pseudo-energy of the wave, as the sum of kinetic and pressure energy contributions.

Self-adjointness of H\mathcal{H}

We show here that H\mathcal{H} is self-adjoint on the Hilbert space {X=(uz ur uθ h)T,ur(r0)=ur(r1)=0}\left\{X=\left(u_z\ u_r\ u_\theta\ h\right)^{\mathsf{T}},u_r(r_0)=u_r(r_1)=0\right\} with respect to the canonical inner product ⟨X1,X2⟩=∫drX1∗X2\langle X_1,X_2\rangle=\int dr X_1^*X_2.

⟨X1,HX2⟩=∫dr(cskz(uz,1∗h2+h1∗uz,2)+iκ(uθ,1∗ur,2−ur,1∗uθ,2))+∫dr ur,1∗(ics∂rh2+ics′2h2−iSh2)+∫dr h1∗(ics∂rur,2+ics′2ur,2+iSur,2).(50)\begin{aligned} \langle X_1,\mathcal{H}X_2\rangle={}&\int dr\left(c_sk_z(u_{z,1}^*h_2+h_1^*u_{z,2})+i\kappa(u_{\theta,1}^*u_{r,2}-u_{r,1}^*u_{\theta,2})\right)\\ &+\int dr\,u_{r,1}^*\left(ic_s\partial_rh_2+i\frac{c_s'}{2}h_2-iSh_2\right)+\int dr\,h_1^*\left(ic_s\partial_ru_{r,2}+i\frac{c_s'}{2}u_{r,2}+iSu_{r,2}\right). \tag*{(50)} \end{aligned}
=∫dr(cskz(uz,1∗h2+h1∗uz,2)+iκ(uθ,1∗ur,2−ur,1∗uθ,2))+[icsur,1∗h2]−∫dr(ics∂rur,1∗+ics′2ur,1∗+iSur,1∗)h2+[icsh1∗ur,2]−∫dr(ics∂rh1∗+ics′2h1∗−iSh1∗)ur,2.(51)\begin{aligned} ={}&\int dr\left(c_sk_z(u_{z,1}^*h_2+h_1^*u_{z,2})+i\kappa(u_{\theta,1}^*u_{r,2}-u_{r,1}^*u_{\theta,2})\right)\\ &+[ic_su_{r,1}^*h_2]-\int dr\left(ic_s\partial_ru_{r,1}^*+i\frac{c_s'}{2}u_{r,1}^*+iSu_{r,1}^*\right)h_2+[ic_sh_1^*u_{r,2}]\\ &-\int dr\left(ic_s\partial_rh_1^*+i\frac{c_s'}{2}h_1^*-iSh_1^*\right)u_{r,2}. \tag*{(51)} \end{aligned}
=∫dr((cskzuz,1)∗h2+(cskzh1)∗uz,2+(−iκuθ,1)∗ur,2+(iκur,1)∗uθ,2)+[icsur,1∗h2]+∫dr(ics∂rur,1+ics′2ur,1+iSur,1)∗h2+[icsh1∗ur,2]+∫dr(ics∂rh1+ics′2h1−iSh1)∗ur,2.(52)\begin{aligned} ={}&\int dr\left((c_sk_zu_{z,1})^*h_2+(c_sk_zh_1)^*u_{z,2}+(-i\kappa u_{\theta,1})^*u_{r,2}+(i\kappa u_{r,1})^*u_{\theta,2}\right)\\ &+[ic_su_{r,1}^*h_2]+\int dr\left(ic_s\partial_ru_{r,1}+i\frac{c_s'}{2}u_{r,1}+iSu_{r,1}\right)^*h_2+[ic_sh_1^*u_{r,2}]\\ &+\int dr\left(ic_s\partial_rh_1+i\frac{c_s'}{2}h_1-iSh_1\right)^*u_{r,2}. \tag*{(52)} \end{aligned}
=⟨HX1,X2⟩+[ics(ur,1∗h2+h1∗ur,2)].(53)=\langle\mathcal{H}X_1,X_2\rangle+[ic_s(u_{r,1}^*h_2+h_1^*u_{r,2})]. \tag*{(53)}

The bracket term goes to zero for impenetrable boundaries. H\mathcal{H} is therefore self-adjoint.

Profiles of modes

References

  1. [1]V. S. Safronov. Evolution of the protoplanetary cloud and formation of the earth and planets. 1972.
  2. [2]J. Bae, A. Isella, Z. Zhu, R. Martin, S. Okuzumi, and S. Suriano. Structured Distributions of Gas and Solids in Protoplanetary Disks. In S. Inutsuka, Y. Aikawa, T. Muto, K. Tomida, and M. Tamura, editors, Protostars and Planets VII, volume 534 of Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, page 423, July 2023. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2210.13314.
  3. [3]G. Lesur, M. Flock, B. Ercolano, M. K. Lin, C. Yang, J. A. Barranco, P. Benitez-Llambay, J. Goodman, A. Johansen, H. Klahr, G. Laibe, W. Lyra, P. S. Marcus, R. P. Nelson, J. Squire, J. B. Simon, N. J. Turner, O. M. Umurhan, and A. N. Youdin. Hydro-, Magnetohydro-, and Dust-Gas Dynamics of Protoplanetary Disks. In S. Inutsuka, Y. Aikawa, T. Muto, K. Tomida, and M. Tamura, editors, Protostars and Planets VII, volume 534 of Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, page 465, July 2023. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2203.09821.
  4. [4]C. Pinte, R. Teague, K. Flaherty, C. Hall, S. Facchini, and S. Casassus. Kinematic Structures in Planet-Forming Disks. In S. Inutsuka, Y. Aikawa, T. Muto, K. Tomida, and M. Tamura, editors, Protostars and Planets VII, volume 534 of Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, page 645, July 2023. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2203.09528.
  5. [5]Richard Teague, Myriam Benisty, Stefano Facchini, Misato Fukagawa, Christophe Pinte, Sean M. Andrews, Jaehan Bae, Marcelo Barraza-Alfaro, Gianni Cataldi, Nicolás Cuello, Pietro Curone, Ian Czekala, Daniele Fasano, Mario Flock, Maria Galloway-Sprietsma, Himanshi Garg, Cassandra Hall, Iain Hammond, Thomas Hilder, Jane Huang, John D. Ilee, Andrés F. Izquierdo, Kazuhiro Kanagawa, Geoffroy Lesur, Giuseppe Lodato, Cristiano Longarini, Ryan A. Loomis, Frédéric Masset, Francois Menard, Ryuta Orihara, Daniel J. Price, Giovanni Rosotti, Jochen Stadler, Leonardo Testi, Hsi-Wei Yen, Gaylor Waffard-Fernandez, David J. Wilner, Andrew J. Winter, Lisa Wölfer, Tomohiro C. Yoshida, and Brianna Zawadzki. exoALMA. I. Science Goals, Project Design, and Data Products. ApJL, 984(1):L6, May 2025. https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/adc43b.

Paper details

vlnc:W_fecrywpk
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 3

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents