WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Impact of modified gravity theory on neutron star and nuclear matter properties
Abstract
New observational data, measured with a high degree of accuracy, of compact isolated neutron stars and binary stars in gravitational wave remnants have the potential to explore the strong field gravity. Within the framework of energy-momentum squared gravity (EMSG) theory we study its impact on several properties of neutron stars and plausible modifications from the predictions of general relativity. Based on a representative set of relativistic nuclear mean field models, non-relativistic Skyrme-Hartree-Fock models and microscopic calculations, we show deviations of neutron star mass-radius sequence in EMSG theory as compared to general relativity. The variation in the effective nuclear equation of state in EMSG, results in distinct magnitudes in the reduced pressure, speed of sound, and maximum compactness at the center of neutron stars. We perform extensive correlation analysis of the nuclear model parameters with the neutron star observables in light of the new observational bounds. Perceptible modifications in the correlations are found in the models of gravity that provide different estimates of the slope and curvature of nuclear matter symmetry energy. The available neutron star data however do not impose stringent enough constraints for clear evidence of deviations from general relativity.
Introduction
Understanding the stellar structures, such as the compact neutron stars, relies entirely on the physics of high-density matter [1]. The two major impediments to a precise determination of neutron star (NS) properties at supranuclear densities are the lack of detailed knowledge of nuclear interaction in particular [4] [2, 3] and gravitational interaction [5, 6, 7, 8, 9]. The repulsive nuclear equation of state (EoS: characterizing the dependence of matter pressure on energy density ) and the balancing attractive strong-field gravitational physics are intertwined via the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equations [10, 11] for hydrostatic equilibrium of the star configuration, hence their uncertainties could impact the predictions of structure and properties of neutron stars.
While terrestrial experiments and ab initio calculations provide nuclear matter description only about the saturation densities, one relies on several sophisticated nuclear many-body interaction theories [2, 3] for high density behaviour. These models by construction reproduce the ground state nuclear matter properties, as a consequence, the higher density predictions of these EOSs are very diverse and remain largely unconstrained. Particularly uncertain are the supranuclear density behavior of nuclear symmetry energy , its slope and curvature at saturation density and thus the EoS of neutron-rich matter [12, 13] [1]. Considerable attempts have been made to put stringent constraints on the EoS by employing the combined measurements of neutron star masses and radii, and the observed tidal deformability bound from the detected gravitational waves [14].
On the other hand, the impact of various theories of gravity in the strong-field regime remains largely unexplored [5, 8]. While Einstein’s General theory of Relativity (GR) continues to be a very effective theory of gravitational interaction at various scales, especially with the detection of gravitational waves, sufficient motivation to investigate alternate viable theories of gravity arises from unexplained dark matter and dark energy at the galactic and cosmological scales, and the presence of singularity in the early universe and inside black holes [6]. Being a superdense object with strong gravitational field, neutron stars offer an exciting avenue for investigation of general relativity in the strong field or high curvature domain and open up a direction for the study of new gravitational physics. Hence, it will be appealing to explore and test alternative theories of gravity in the case of super-dense stars in addition to the traditional approach based on GR.
In the absence of a fundamental quantum gravity theory for the description of complete gravitational action, the formulation of modified theories mainly focused initially on the simplest modification of the gravitational Lagrangian by some analytic function different from the linear function of the spacetime curvature (the Ricci scalar) . This approach enforces a modification on the left-hand side of Einstein’s field equations , in the usual notation [5]. Subsequently, a generalized gravity was developed [15] that also includes the trace of the energy-momentum tensor of matter. More recently, a more generic covariant form was proposed that considers a nonlinear Lorentz scalar involving the entire matter Lagrangian and dubbed as energy-momentum squared gravity (EMPG), where is a parametric constant [6, 7, 9, 16, 17, 18, 19]. This theory provides non-minimal matter and geometry coupling, and introduces a higher-order contribution to the material stresses on the right-hand side of the Einstein’s equations. The case with dimensionless parameter (referred to as energy-momentum squared gravity: EMSG) can be effective at high energy densities relevant to the neutron star interior [6, 7]. The EMSG theory also resolves the ineffectiveness of the gravity for a perfect fluid with EoS where the trace and reduces to the usual theory. The EMSG gives deviations from GR also at low curvature domains [20] and compatible to GR at vacuum. Technically, the field equations alter the expressions of the TOV equations, and hence the astrophysical properties of stars.
The EMPG theory suggests a bounce in the early universe due to maximum energy density and correspondingly a minimum length scale factor, thereby addressing the problem of big-bang singularity as well as the current cosmic accelerated expansion. This theory also correctly predicts cosmic behaviour and follows the actual progression of cosmological eras [21]. Since EMSG is proposed to resolve the singularities classically, it is expected that the deviations from GR appear in the properties of compact stars [6]. Further, the EMSG model passes the weak field tests for the Solar System regime where the EMSG light deflection, Shapiro time delay and gravitational microlensing scenarios are found similar to GR [17, 22]. Moreover, this theory is consistent with the strong-field gravity test as investigated from analysis of the first time derivative of the orbital period of binary pulsars [17]. Consequently, the EMSG theory is considered to be a viable model that explains the cosmological behavior as well as passes the weak and strong gravity-field tests, and thus ideally suited to test GR modifications in neutron stars.
Recently, the parameter in the EMSG model has been constrained [7] by using the maximum mass NS constraint and physicality of certain effective EoSs in the center of NS, to be in the range . Whereas, binary pulsar observation [9] yields a compatible value of , but that reported from solar system test are relative lower .
In the present study, we shall compare the predictions of EMSG theory relative to general relativity to explore the strong field effects in neutron stars. The field equations in EMSG with the standard physical energy-momentum tensor can be mapped into the GR Einstein’s field equations, but with an effective or modified energy-momentum tensor. This enables a rather straightforward calculation of the moment of inertia, tidal deformation, and other properties of the stars [23]. For the nuclear EoS, we have employed a comprehensive set of relativistic mean field (RMF) theory for nuclear interaction that provides Lorentz covariant extrapolation from sub- to supra-saturation densities. The model has been extensively applied in the description of several finite nuclei properties and studies in NS structure. Further, we have employed a representative set of non-relativistic Skyrme-Hartree-Fock (SHF) model, and two microscopic theories based on Bruckner-Hartree-Fock (BHF) and variational approaches. Within these model EoSs, that have diverse high-density behavior, we shall explore the EMSG and the GR effects on the neutron star properties. Furthermore, we will examine the correlations between the NS properties, namely mass, radius, tidal deformability with the key nuclear EoS parameters (as well as between the thermodynamic variables, namely the pressure, speed of sound). Only if tight correlations between NS observables and EoS parameters in various models of gravity can be established, one can then provide suitable (model independent) bounds on these nuclear matter quantities by employing the precisely measured NS observables. Alternatively, these relations can be used to constrain an astrophysical observable from the knowledge of the correlated nuclear matter observables. In fact, by using a larger number of unified EoSs, extensive correlation analysis in general relativity have been conducted between neutron star mass , radius , etc with the parameters of the nuclear EoS, such as the nuclear matter incompressibility , its slope , the nuclear symmetry energy slope and curvature , at the saturation density [24], and their linear combinations [25, 26, 27, 28, 29], as well as with the tidal deformability [26] and corrections to mass-weighted tidal deformability [27] of the detected gravitational waves GW170817 [30]. While the individual EoS parameters were found to be weakly correlated, their specific linear combinations showed a rather strong correlation [14, 25, 26, 27, 29, 31]. It will be instructive to investigate and understand how these correlations between the astrophysical observables and nuclear EoS behave in the alternative energy-momentum squared gravity (EMSG) model as compared to the predictions of General Relativity, and whether an approximate universal constraint can be imposed on the EoS parameters that is independent of nuclear and gravitational interactions.
The outline of the paper is as follows. In § 0.2, we briefly describe the modified field equations in EMSG. The modified structure in TOV equations for neutron star in EMSG are discussed in Sec. III. We then discuss the methodology to compute the moment of inertia in slow rotation approximation in Sec. IV and the tidal deformability parameter in § 0.5. Next, we provide a brief review of the key EoS parameters and the EoSs used the analysis in Sec. VI. Our results on the calculations of neutron star configurations within EMSG and GR are presented in Sec. VII. Within various diverse EoSs, correlations between the parameters of the EoSs and the NS properties in the EMSG modified theory of gravity will be also discussed. Finally, the conclusions are drawn in Sec. VIII. We will adopt the system of units throughout the manuscript.
Energy-Momentum Squared Gravity
In the energy-momentum squared gravity theory, the Einstein-Hilbert action is modified by the addition of a scalar term leading to [7, 8, 9]:
where is Newton’s constant, denotes the Ricci scalar, is the determinant of the metric, the cosmological constant, and the coupling parameter. The Lagrangian density represents source of the matter described by the energy-momentum tensor which can be defined as usual:
Consequently, the Einstein’s field equation for the modified action becomes
where is the Einstein tensor and the new tensor is defined as
Here is the trace of the energy-momentum tensor. We consider the star to be a perfect fluid (i.e. non-viscous and stress-free), with energy-momentum tensor , where is the energy density, is the isotropic pressure, and is the four-velocity. Since the definition of matter Lagrangian for the perfect fluid described via the energy-momentum tensor is not unique, one can consider or ; both these choices lead to the same in the case of GR. In contrast, for non-minimal coupling of matter with gravity as in EMSG, it gives rise to distinct theories with different predictions [32, 33]. In this work we consider the former choice of that has been commonly employed to construct a viable astrophysical/cosmological model [32, 33, 34]. The covariant divergence of Eq. (3) then becomes
Note that the local/covariant energy-momentum conservation is not identically zero for . Using Eqs. (3), (4) and the above definition of , one finally obtains [7]
ToV equations in EMSG
Equation (6) can be recast into GR Einstein’s field equation
with an effective energy momentum tensor for an ideal fluid, where the effective energy density and pressure are given by
It is important to note that the EMSG model with an isotropic energy-momentum tensor (ideal fluid) can be mapped exactly into GR with an isotropic effective appearing only in the material side of the field equations [33]. While many modified gravity theories (such as ) do not have this feature, the Eddington-inspired-Born-Infeld (EiBI) theory although can be mapped into GR but has an anisotropic effective energy-momentum tensor [20, 23]. Hence, the mapped expressions for the field equations in case of EMSG theory allows a straightforward calculation of the NS properties. One can easily see from Eq. (7) that twice contracted Bianchi identity yields vanishing of the covariant divergence . Thus, the (isotropic) effective energy-momentum tensor is conserved in EMSG gravity. This generalized conservation is local (stemming from equivalence principle), which is the actual criterion that should be considered for modified gravity and not the conservation of conventional matter fluids. These equations in curved space-time have essentially distinct description from the usual conservation in absence of gravity; detail discussion can be found in Ref. [35]. Consequently, due to isotropy of the effective energy-momentum tensor and its conservation in EMSG, one does not require any additional equations for thermodynamical consistency via the general maximum entropy principle [36, 37].
TOV equations in EMSG
To obtain the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff equations [10, 11] for a non-rotating star in the EMSG description, we adopt the general spherically symmetric metric as
where metric functions and depend only the radial coordinate . Using Eqs. (3) and (10), one obtains the and components of EMSG field equation as
where and are the effective values of mass density and pressure at a distance from the center of NS. By defining the metric function in terms of the mass function as
and the metric function via the pressure as [7]
one obtains the modified TOV equations in EMSG:
The structure of the relativistic stars i.e. the mass and radius can be obtained by solving Eqs. (15)–(16) simultaneously with an input EoS , which describes the relation between the pressure and the density of the matter. It is evident from Eqs. (15)–(16) or equivalently from Eqs. (8)–(9), that EMSG modifications to GR for the NS configurations stem from the additional terms contributing to the energy density and pressure . Due to isotropic and perfect fluid nature of the effective energy-momentum tensor, one can also obtain the above generalized TOV equations by using the effective thermodynamic variables and maximizing the effective entropy [36, 37].
Moment of Inertia
In this section we briefly present the calculation of the moment of inertia of a rotating neutron star in the energy-momentum squared gravity. We consider that the star rotates uniformly with a stellar frequency which is much lower in comparison with the Kepler frequency at the equator, i.e. . The moment of inertia of such an axially symmetric and uniformly rotating neutron star [38, 39] in EMSG can be written as
Note that the effective energy density and pressure of Eqs. (8) and (9) enter the expression. is the angular momentum, and are the metric functions. In the slowly rotating approximation, the line element for the background metric of a stationary and axially symmetric star can be taken as
Here the metric functions and will be identical to the case of a static and spherically symmetric neutron star, and simply follow Eqs. (13) and (14).
To calculate the moment of inertia, we further require the form of metric function which appears due to the slow rotation of the star. The dimensionless relative frequency, defined as
obeys the differential equation
where
The solution to the above equation can be obtained by using the following two boundary conditions:
To solve the differential equation (20), one can start with a guess value of the central frequency and numerically integrate the equation up to the surface of the star. Since we start with an arbitrary value of , usually, the boundary condition at will not be satisfied. However, this can be achieved by simply rescaling by an appropriate constant. Once we have the solution of , the moment of inertia can be calculated from Eq. (17). After obtaining the solutions of and , the consistency of the formalism can be verified from the condition [38, 39].
Tidal Deformability
The phase of the gravitational wave signal resulting from the merger of two neutron stars carries valuable information about the tidal deformability parameter that is directly related to the internal structure and composition of the star, particularly the equation of state of nuclear matter. It quantifies the deformations induced in the star due to an external tidal field of the companion star. The tidal deformability parameter can be expressed as [26, 31, 40, 41, 42, 43],
where represents the components of the induced quadrupole moment tensor and denotes the components of the tidal field tensor. In terms of the Love number , the mass normalized dimensionless tidal deformability parameter is given by
where and are the radius and mass of the star, and is its compactness. The tidal Love number depends on the underlying EoS of the star and it can be expressed in terms of the dimensionless compactness parameter as [40, 41, 42, 43],
The function is related to the metric perturbation and satisfies the following differential equation:
where the functions and are given
For a spherically symmetric star, the Love number and tidal deformability parameter can be determined by simultaneously solving Eq. (27) and the TOV equations (Eqs. (15)–(16)), with the boundary conditions and in addition to that arises from perturbative expansion of the deformed metric up to the second order.
Nuclear matter equations of state
In the parabolic approximation, the equation of state of isospin asymmetric nuclear matter at a given density and asymmetry can be written as [13, 44]
where is the total energy per nucleon at a nucleon density , and is neutron-proton asymmetry parameter, with and the neutron and proton densities, respectively. The first term on the right-hand side represents the EoS for symmetric nuclear matter, and the second term is the nuclear symmetry energy. The isoscalar part and the isovector part can be further Taylor series expanded around the saturation density as
where the dimensionless variable gives the deviation of density from the saturation value . The saturation parameters for the symmetric nuclear matter are the binding energy per nucleon , incompressibility , skewness coefficient . Similarly, the parameters for the symmetry energy expansion are the symmetry energy coefficient , and the slope and curvature of symmetry energy i.e. and , respectively. The slope of the incompressibility, , at the saturation density can be expressed in terms of and as [31]
and the symmetry energy incompressibility is defined as , where is the saturation density of asymmetric nuclear matter corresponding to the asymmetry . The symmetry energy parameters and are related by the following expression [31],
For analysis of neutron star properties, we employ a representative set of 18 relativistic mean field (RMF) models [2, 3], 24 non-relativistic Skyrme-Hartree-Fock (SHF)-type models, and 2 microscopic calculations, one of these use the Bruckner-Hartree-Fock (BHF) approach with Argonne plus 3-body Urbana-type nuclear potentials [45, 46], and the other a variational approach namely the Akmal-Pandharipande-Ravenhall (APR) EoS [47, 48]. In the RMF model, the nucleon-nucleon interactions are described by the exchange of scalar-isoscalar meson, vector-isoscalar meson, and vector-isovector mesons. Over the years, the model has been improved by the inclusion of non-linear self- and cross-couplings between the mesons. Based on the form of the interactions in the Lagrangian density, the RMF models that we have employed in this study, can be broadly classified as: NL-type with nonlinear term [49, 50]; NL3-type with additional - and - term, [51], NL34, NL36 [52], NL302 [53], NL303 [54]; TM-type with nonlinear term, TM1 [55], TM1-2 [56]; FSU-type with an additional form of nonlinear coupling FSU2 [57]; BSR-families with more nonlinear couplings [58, 59]; and DD-type with density-dependent couplings, DD2 [60], DDH [61], DDHMod [48], DDME1 [62], DDME2 [63], TW [64], and the GM1 [65].
The SHF models we have taken in the present calculation are SKa, SKb [66], SkI2, SkI3, SkI4, SkI5 [67], SkI6 [68], Sly2, Sly9 [69], Sly230a [70], Sly4 [71], SkMP [72], SKOp [73], KDE0V1 [74], SK255, SK272 [75], Rs [76], BSk20, BSk21 [77], BSk22, BSk23, BSk24, BSk25, and BSk26 [78]. The coupling constants are obtained by sophisticated fitting procedures to the finite nuclei such as the binding energies and charge radii, and the infinite nuclear matter properties at the saturation density .
All the models considered here have been successful in reproducing various experimental data for finite nuclei. These models are also consistent with constraint for the measured maximum mass of neutron star in general relativity. The SHF-type models can often exhibit a causality problem at very high densities. The SHF models that we have selected in this study, do not become causal up to the central density of neutron star with mass . To obtain the EoS for neutron star matter, we have employed a unified inner-crust-core EoS, i.e. the inner crust EoS and the core EoS have been calculated using the same nuclear model, and the outer crust EoS is taken from the work of Baym-Pethick-Sutherland [79].
The values of the EOS parameters at and the corresponding properties of neutron star obtained in these models show a significant variation. In this regard, we note that large-scale analysis [3] of experimental data from finite nuclei and heavy-ion collisions with various model calculations have provided reliable bounds on incompressibility of symmetric nuclear matter MeV [80, 81], the symmetry energy MeV [82] from combined analysis of observational data, and a reasonable constraint on the slope of symmetry energy MeV [83, 84, 85] at the saturation density . However, other nuclear matter parameters are not constrained and exhibit wide variations even at the saturation density. The large set of models of different classes employed in the present study will predict different NS configurations and thus will allow us to perform the correlation analysis between the nuclear matter parameters and NS observables with more accuracy.
It may be mentioned that alternative approaches have been developed to construct the high-density EoS by incorporating state-of-the-art chiral effective field theories at the low nuclear matter density and the quark EoS based on perturbative Quantum Chromodynamics for . The EoS at the intermediate density region is constructed by interpolation methods [86, 87, 88] or piecewise polytropes [89] those satisfy the causality condition of sound speed squared and follow thermodynamic consistency. This approach is independent of models of gravity but ignores the crucial nuclear interactions at intermediate densities. On the other hand, we note that the microphysics used to calculate the dense matter EoS may depend on the inherent gravity theory. Nontrivial effects of curved spacetime have been indicated in calculations performed in the Fermi gas by maximizing the entropy in Palatini gravity [37] and in the simple model by including the effect of gravitational time dilation [90]. In contrast, it has been shown that for hydrostatic equilibrium of dense matter within GR and relativistic fluid dynamics, the EoS should be calculated in flat spacetime, so as to be consistent with local thermodynamic relations and energy-momentum conservation of the fluid [91]. In what follows, as our study involves diverse sets of realistic EoSs derived from different underlying microscopic theories with distinct nuclear interactions, such involved calculation incorporating curved spacetime for various EoSs is beyond the scope of the present paper. Thus, the study mainly focuses on the effects of modified gravity from matter Lagrangian on the modification of hydrostatic equilibrium equations only and thereby the properties of neutron stars and their connections to the nuclear matter parameters.
Results and Discussions
In this section, we first discuss with a few selected nuclear EoS how the results in the EMSG model for gravity differ from GR for the NS configurations due to modifications of the hydrostatic equilibrium. Thereafter, we will focus on correlation analysis between the nuclear matter parameters and properties of neutron stars composed of neutrons, protons, electrons and muons in -equilibrium.
Neutron star properties in EMSG theory
It is useful to estimate the effects of EMSG modifications to GR on the observational properties of neutron stars using three nuclear EoSs with diverse high-density behaviour. Figure 1 displays the mass-radius relations obtained as solutions of TOV equations using three different representative EoSs: namely the relativistic NL3 [52, 53, 54] based on the RMF model, the relativistic BSR2 [58, 59] which is an extended version of RMF with non-linear meson-meson cross-couplings, and the non-relativistic Sly4 [71] based on the SHF approach. To explore the EMSG modifications to GR, one ensures that the magnitude of the parameter should be such that it only induces perturbative changes in the structure of NS compared to GR. To this end, we consider the maximum (positive) value of cm/erg as estimated in Ref. [7] from combined constraints (at the 68% confidence level) from measurements of NS in low-mass X-ray binaries [98]. The exact value depends on the matter EoS that causes distinct effective stiffening/softening inside the NS. For the NL3, BSR2, Sly4 models the upper-bound on are respectively . For larger values of , the mass-radius curves increase continuously and will not satisfy the constraints (see Figure 3 in Ref. [7]). For clarity of presentation in the figure we have considered a fixed maximum value of which is also consistent for diverse sets of EOSs used in subsequent correlation analysis. The minimum value of is obtained by the NS conditions: from the surface () to the center () of the star, from central pressure to the surface value , as well as the stability criterion , where the equality criterion provides the maximum mass at the central energy density . From the TOV equation (15), the condition is satisfied when . On the other hand, Eq. (16) determines the stability condition for which is dictated by the dominant last (negative) term within the square brackets leading to the condition . Note that this term itself gives singularity in the TOV equation at a negative which is then avoided by the condition. Hence no further restriction on is required to exclude the singular value in
Figure 1. Neutron star mass-radius curves in the BSR2, NL3, and Sly4 nuclear EoSs. The results are in GR (dotted lines) and in EMSG with a maximum value for parameter of (solid lines) and minimum values of (dashed lines) that correspond to stable configuration stars in NL3, BSR2, Sly4 EoSs, respectively (see text for details). The contours and bands refer to - constraints from NICER measurements of PSR J0030+0451 [92] and PSR J0740+6620 [93], the pulsars PSR J0348+0432 [94] and PSR J1614-2230 [95, 96], the secondary component of the gravitational waves GW190814 with mass [97] (horizontal bands), and from the GW170817 event [30] (orange and grey contours).
Figure 3. Dependence of neutron star compactness parameter on (a) moment of inertia , (b) dimensionless Love number , (c) dimensionless tidal deformability and quadrupole polarizability (inset) in the NL3, BSR2, and Sly4 nuclear EoSs in the GR and EMSG as referred to in Figure 1.
EMSG, in contrast to that in the Palatini gravity for a conformal equation of state [88]. Figure 1 depicts the mass-radius results with the minimum values of determined using these stability conditions for the (NL3, BSR2, Sly4) EoSs. (However, in the correlation analysis involving several diverse sets of EoSs, we will use the minimum value of [7] which can be obtained by enforcing, in the stability condition for , the typical (lower) central values and .)
For our choice of the three EoSs, the NL3 has the stiffest variation and hence reveals the largest maximum mass and the correspondingly the largest radius . As compared to GR, the EMSG model, in general, causes an effective stiffening of the EoS at low densities and softening at high densities for , and conversely for . The maximum masses are found to remain almost unaffected, whereas the radii increase (decrease) appreciably for the maximum (minimum) values of employed here. For the constant positive value of , the softest Sly4 has as the largest increase in radii , whereas for , the stiffest NL3 (with smallest ) exhibit the maximum decreases in . In fact, the maximum variation of the radius is seen for the NS, relative to the GR calculation. These EMSG modifications can be understood by noting that
TOV equations can be represented by a single relevant dimensionless quantity . This translates to the dimensionless compactness parameter of a star given that a larger degenerate pressure essentially leads to a larger star radius [12]. As discussed in subsection III, the corresponding ratio in the EMSG model turns out to be . Finite limits can be placed at (vacuum), (ultra-relativistic Fermi gas: conformal bound) and (causality condition), which translate respectively to . This implies from Eqs. (15), (16) that for , EMSG stiffens the effective EoS below the conformal bound and softens the effective EoS above the bound, and conversely for . Figure 2(a) illustrates such a variation of the ratio in the NS centers with the masses of the star sequence. Note that for each EoS shown, most of the stars in the sequence are confined within leading to stiffening (softening) for positive (negative) values of , and correspondingly predict larger (smaller) star radii. On other hand, the stars at and near the maximum mass are located above the conformality bound and well within the causality constraint .

Figure 2. The ratio for central values of pressure and energy densities as a function of (a) neutron star mass , (b) moment of inertia , (c) Love number , (d) tidal deformability in the NL3, BSR2, and Sly4 nuclear EoSs. The results are in GR and EMSG with parameters as given in Figure 1.
Profound implications may follow in EMSG theory for negative . For example, various parametrizations of the nuclear EoSs strive to simultaneously describe the observational tidal deformability bound of of a canonical NS inferred from GW170817 event [30] and the maximum mass bound . The current tension can be effectively addressed in EMSG (for ) that predicts smaller radii (thereby even smaller ) for low mass neutron stars but relatively insensitive to the maximum mass of NSs. Furthermore, a star of extremely small mass and radius is estimated within the supernova remnant HESS J1731-347 [99], which has posed the interesting possibility of exotic strange stars. We emphasize that even a pure nucleonic star, owing to its small radius in the EMSG strong-field gravity, can be an exciting viable alternative.
Figure 3 explores the EMSG effects on the NS observables: the moment of inertia , tidal Love number and the tidal deformability as a function of compactness parameter for each of the NL3, BSR2, Sly4 EoSs. The variation of these observables on the central pressure to central energy density ratio for the star sequence are shown in Figure 2(b)-(Figure 2d). As discussed above, the dimensionless naturally translates into a measure of the neutron stars pressure and energy at the center via the relation . The moment inertia can be a useful estimate of the EMSG effects since the dimensional relation gives relatively larger ranges from changes in the radius, and moreover, the accuracy of radius estimations are largely limited by uncertainties. Although the moment of inertia depends on the underlying stiffness/softness of the EoS, one notices in Figure 3(a), small effects of gravity on the variation of moment of inertia with the dimensional parameter in any individual nuclear EoS. This can be traced from Figure 2(b) to the subdued effect of EMSG on the ratio , irrespective of the choice of nuclear EoS.
On the other hand, the variation of Love number of [25] with compactness in Figure 3(b) shows noticeable modifications in EMSG primarily near the peak at that corresponds to . Whereas, is found to be relatively independent of the details of the models of gravity as well as the EoSs at small compactness that is dominated by the large crustal radii for these small stellar masses. At large near the maximum mass configurations, the values of become much smaller than at their . Although is seen here to be quite sensitive to the EoS, the EMSG modifications to GR at this strong gravity field regime are however smaller compared to the observed spread in for stars.
Tidal fields from inspiraling binary neutron stars induce a quadrupole polarizability or a dimensional tidal deformability , which may be sensitive to models of gravity due to dependence. The inset of Figure 3(c) depicts a larger variation of with in the EMSG, especially near as seen at the -peak. In contrast, a strong correlation between the dimensionless tidal deformability and compactness (as well as between –; see Figure 2(d)) appears, irrespective of the models of gravity and the three representative EoSs. In fact, such a tight correlation was found between and for canonical pure nucleonic stars [100] and with nucleon-quark phase transition [101] suggesting the possibility to constrain the radius and perhaps the symmetry energy .
Figure 5. Same as Figure 4 but for correlation between and the ratio for the maximum mass and corresponding radius of neutron stars.
Correlation analysis between neutron star properties and nuclear matter parameters
In the following we shall explore the possible correlations between the NS observables (, , ) with the nuclear matter (NM) saturation parameters (, , , , , ) and linear combination of two NM parameters (such as , , ), and their impact due to the EMSG theory. To facilitate the correlation study we include all the RMF, SHF and microscopic models described in section VI. Hereafter, we shall employ the fixed maximum and minimum values of the parameter estimated in the EMSG theory [7], and for all the EoSs employed, which ensure stable configurations for all the neutron stars.
Before attempting such NS-NM correlations, it is instructive to employ the causality bound of speed of sound squared to impose limits on the maximum value at the center and its natural transform for the superdense NS matter. Figure 4 displays the correlation between central sound speed and the reduced central pressure from all the diverse EoSs in the EMSG theory for the parameter (red solid symbols) and in GR (green open symbols). The central speed of sound for the maximum mass stars increases with the reduced central pressure which is a measure of stiffness of dense nuclear matter inside a NS. Reasonably good correlations are found, given that a broad class of EoSs are employed. Albeit, the correlations are found to be distinct in EMSG and GR which are a direct consequence of the strong-field gravity. Compared to GR, a stiffer EOS in EMSG below the conformality bound and a softer EoS above this bound for manifest in an increase in at and a reduced at larger . We find that the conformability bound () appears to be violated at the central densities reached in all the stars. Also depicted in Figure 4 are the linear regressions between and in EMSG (solid lines) and GR (dashed lines) with slope and intercept as:
Figure 4. Correlation between speed of sound squared and the ratio of central values of pressure and energy densities corresponding to maximum mass stars in the RMF, SHF and microscopic models of EoS. The results are in EMSG with (red solid symbols) and in GR (green open symbols). The lines represent the linear best-fit and the shaded regions correspond to 95% confidence band.
The intercept at enables to set an upper bound on reduced central pressure that is enforced by the causality requirement . Our analysis suggests a central upper bound of in EMSG and in the effectively stiffer EoS in GR.
The dependence of on translates into its dependence on for the maximum mass configurations at the NS centers as displayed in 5. The intrinsic structures in the TOV equations however prevent a perfect dimensionless mapping leading to some cluttering in the correlation with the compactness parameter. In fact, some model-dependence is revealed, viz the relatively stiffer EoSs in the relativistic mean field model generate stars with large but also have fairly large radius , and thus yield less compact stars with smaller as compared to those in the non-relativistic Skyrme-Hartree-Fock models. In general, the central speed of sound is found to increase with the compactness of the NSs [102]. The EMSG theory, that predicts slightly larger for , have smaller sound speed compared to GR. Also depicted in Figure 4 are our constructed linear regressions between and with 95% confidence bands by accounting for the EoS scatter in the EMSG and GR as:
From the causality condition, we obtain a central upper bound on the compactness of about that corresponds to a lower limit for the radius in EMSG theory. Similarly in the GR, a maximum compactness of translates to the radius bound of . These compactness bounds are much smaller than Buchdahl’s upper limit [103]. A direct comparison of our estimated radius bound can be made with the NICER observations for the PSR J0740+6620 [93] radius of about with a mass and for the PSR J0030+0451 radius with a mass [92]. Clearly, our estimated radii lower bounds in the models of gravity are well consistent with the NICER measurements.
with the NICER measurements. Inversely, constraints on the EoS variables can be applied by using the NS measurements. For example, the central mass-radius (, ) of PSR J0740+6620 yields from Eq. (36), a central sound speed of which (from Eq. (34)) corresponds to a reduced central pressure of .
Various approximate universal relations connecting the NS observables, such as the compactness , dimensionless moment of inertia , dimensionless tidal deformability , have been established that are insensitive to the microscopic details of the high-density EoSs [14, 26, 27, 29]. It is useful to test and validate these relations with respect to our collection of EoSs and to the models of gravity as well. Figure 6 shows correlations between the reduced central
Figure 6. Correlation between and several neutron star quantities: (a) compactness , (b) scaled moment of inertia , (c) tidal deformability in the RMF, SHF, and microscopic models of EoS. The results are in GR (green circles) and EMSG with (magenta stars). The lines are fifth-order polynomial fits to the correlations.
pressure with the dimensionless quantities , , of the NSs. Remarkably tight correlations do exist that are insensitive primarily to the EoSs and the gravitational interactions. Measurements of these NS observables thus provide accurate estimates of pressure at the fiducial densities which can be invoked in the model EoSs to constrain nuclear interactions and the nuclear matter parameters. Polynomial fits up to fifth order of the form , where are shown in EMSG and GR.
To explore the impact of tidal deformability on the structure of a star in EMSG, we display in Figure 7 the correlation between and radius for stars of computed for all the EOSs. The increase of with is simply due to the fact that quantifies the variation of gravitational field relative to a point-mass object. The proportionality of on , reveals in a tight correlation, i.e. an approximate universal relation independent of the input EoSs. Interestingly, the increase in for positive values (as seen in - curve of Figure 1) enforces distinct class of universalities for the EMSG and GR gravity models. In fact, the correlations can be expressed as , that are practically EOS-insensitive and reveal a small but finite dependence on the models of gravity, as evident from the parameters and for EMSG (GR). A bound on at 90% confidence was extracted by LIGO-VIRGO from the observed binary neutron-star merger GW170817 event using Bayesian analysis with a common EoS for the compact binaries [104].
Figure 7. Correlation between tidal deformability and radius of neutron star of mass . The symbols are the same as in Figure 4. The fits are represented by in EMSG (solid line) and in GR (dashed line). The grey shaded region refers to and bounds from GW190814 event [97].
The more recent observation of GW190814 signal [97] from coalescence of a massive black hole and a compact object of mass can provide an intriguing opportunity to test modifications of GR due to large asymmetry in the masses. While the primary component of GW190814 is conclusively proven to be a black hole (BH), the lack of measurable tidal deformations and the nondetection of an electromagnetic counterpart are consistent with the secondary component being either a NS or a BH. Considering that the NSBH scenario cannot be completely discounted, a stringent constraint was given [97] for the NS that favors a stiff EoS which translates to radius and tidal deformability of a canonical NS of km and at 90% credible level. Currently, GW190814 offers this unique observational bound simultaneously for and , which we shall use hereafter to constrain the EoS. Imposing this bounds in Figure 7 (grey shaded region), we find that the rather small sensitivity of the gravity models cannot be disentangled from the relation. In this respect, we note that the higher multipole moments of the gravitational signal, that enables to test the multipolar structure of gravity, do not show any deviations from the predictions of GR [97]. While our derived correlations are consistent with the GW190814 constraints, the bound clearly favours EoSs with soft symmetry energy at density and rules out the super-stiff EoSs that predict large radii.
We next analyze the correlation between the neutron star bulk observables presented above with the key nuclear clear matter (NM) parameters of the EoS, namely , , , and a few selected linear combinations of these parameters. In particular, we also explore the influence of the EMSG modifications to GR on these correlations. The Pearson correlation coefficient, , has been used for a quantitative analysis of a linear correlation between two quantities and , which can be expressed as [105],
| 0.704 | 0.572 | 0.743 | 0.559 | 0.743 | 0.713 | ||
| 0.698 | 0.554 | 0.728 | 0.576 | 0.762 | 0.717 | ||
| 0.703 | 0.570 | 0.742 | 0.560 | 0.744 | 0.713 | ||
| 0.730 | 0.605 | 0.778 | 0.507 | 0.696 | 0.719 | ||
| 0.729 | 0.572 | 0.757 | 0.521 | 0.732 | 0.736 | ||
| 0.734 | 0.602 | 0.778 | 0.501 | 0.698 | 0.720 | ||
| 0.729 | 0.609 | 0.781 | 0.451 | 0.673 | 0.731 | ||
| 0.724 | 0.582 | 0.761 | 0.473 | 0.706 | 0.745 | ||
| 0.728 | 0.607 | 0.779 | 0.453 | 0.676 | 0.733 |
Table 1. Pearson correlation coefficients between the parameters in RMF, SHF, microscopic nuclear models and the radii , moment of inertia and tidal deformability of a mass NS. The nuclear matter EoS parameters are incompressibility , skewness , slope of incompressibility , symmetry energy , its slope , and curvature , and the parameter all calculated at the saturation density. The correlations are calculated in GR and EMSG with coupling parameters and , and denoted respectively by superscript (GR, , ) on the NS quantities.
where the covariance, , is given by
The index runs over the number of models used in the analysis; and respectively refer to the NS properties (such as radius, moment of inertia, deformability) at a fixed mass, and the NM parameters in the EoS. A correlation coefficient would suggest a perfect correlation/anticorrelation between the two quantities of interest, and would indicate no correlation.
Figure 8 displays the NS mass dependence of the Pearson correlation coefficients between the NS quantities (, , ) and the EoS parameters in the EMSG model with coupling parameter (solid lines) and (dashed lines) corresponding to the minimum and maximum estimated bounds [7]. Noticeable effects of the parameter on the correlation coefficients are seen. The isovector parameter, , corresponding to the slope of symmetry energy induces somewhat enhanced correlation due to larger radius (smaller compactness ) for positive . In
Figure 8. Neutron star mass dependence of the Pearson correlation coefficients between NS observables and nuclear EoS parameters within the RMF, SHF and microscopic models. The correlations involve NS radii (top panels), moment of inertia (middle panels), tidal deformability (bottom panels), with the EoS parameters and their linear combinations: , , . The results are in the EMSG gravity model with coupling parameter (dashed lines) and (solid lines).
| 0.878 | 0.848 | 16.972 | 0.923 | 5.351 | 0.914 | |
| 0.963 | 0.858 | 18.484 | 0.926 | 5.596 | 0.907 | |
| 0.886 | 0.849 | 17.103 | 0.923 | 5.373 | 0.914 | |
| 0.670 | 0.837 | 13.846 | 0.919 | 5.008 | 0.941 | |
| 0.768 | 0.856 | 15.979 | 0.925 | 5.482 | 0.937 | |
| 0.666 | 0.840 | 13.918 | 0.920 | 5.027 | 0.942 | |
| 0.614 | 0.823 | 12.917 | 0.907 | 5.136 | 0.950 | |
| 0.710 | 0.839 | 14.820 | 0.912 | 5.548 | 0.945 | |
| 0.622 | 0.824 | 13.081 | 0.908 | 5.173 | 0.949 |
Table 2. Pearson correlation coefficients between the NS quantities and linear combinations of EoS parameters in the RMF, SHF, and microscopic models. The EMSG parameters and notations are the same as in Table I.
contrast, the correlations with the isoscalar parameters , show opposite dependence on . On the other hand, for the isovector symmetry curvature , the correlation strengths between the positive and negative show inversion at . Further, the low mass NS exhibit much stronger sensitivity to , (characterized by large correlation function) which gradually decreases with increasing NS mass, and eventually at the isoscalar parameters , dominate the correlations. Such trends can be understood form the expressions of pressure on energy density (i.e. the EoS) when these are expressed in term of the NM parameters [25]. The linear combinations, , and indicate the strongest sensitivity to the NS observables over the entire mass range, wherein the correlations are designed to yield optimum values by tuning the coefficients . This means, that these combinations have a stronger correlation compared to that for the individual nuclear parameters. Interestingly, the correlation , which shows an increasing trend with NS masses, has the largest value near the canonical star in case of all the NS observables , , . For orientation, we have listed in Tables I and II the correlation coefficients of the NS quantities with the individual NM parameters and their linear correlations for solar mass NS.
In Figure 9 we display the envisaged strong correlation between the NM parameters , and with the radii (left panels) and tidal deformability (right panels) for NS in the EMSG theory. Such strong correlations can be traced essentially to the increase in the NS radius with the increase of isoscalar and symmetry energy pressures at [106]. Correspondingly, the stiffer effective EoS for at this density range leads to smaller correlation strength relative to as evident from the linear regression fits to these correlations. For , the constructed linear regressions (solid lines) can be represented as:
Figure 9. Correlation between NS quantities , and linear combinations of nuclear matter parameters , , in the EMSG gravity model with coupling parameter (blue open symbols) and (red solid symbols). The linear regressions are for (dashed lines) and (solid lines). The grey shaded regions refer to and bounds from GW190814 event [97].
Here are in the units of MeV and in km. We use the above set of relations (and the coefficients listed in Table II) in conjunction with the GW190814 bound on and [97] to estimate the nuclear matter parameters. We utilize the quite accurately constrained nuclear matter incompressibility at the saturation density of obtained from analysis of isoscalar giant monopole resonance (ISGMR) collective excitations in and nuclei [80, 81, 107]. The central values are estimated to be MeV for the constraint, and MeV for the constraint. The obtained slope of symmetry energy are in line with MeV extracted from available nuclear masses of heavy nuclei [83], as well as the reported values of MeV [84] and MeV [85] from analysis of neutron skin thickness measurements of by the PREX-II experiment. Further, our estimated slope of the incompressibility are consistent with the empirical constraint MeV determined by comparing Skyrme-like energy density functional and the energies of the ISGMR and nuclei [108, 109]. Our estimate of the curvature parameter of symmetry energy lies well within the present fiducial value MeV obtained from combined analysis of NS observables of GW170817 signal [26, 27, 110], energy density functionals constrained by terrestrial experiments and observational data [111], and metamodelling of nuclear EoS with these constraints [112].
Likewise, the linear regressions for correlations with EMSG parameter value (dashed lines in Figure 9) can be utilized to extract the NM parameters from the GW190814 constraints. The deviations from are found to be at the level of about 18% for and for . The symmetry energy curvature was found to have large sensitivity to parameter. Combining all these results, our estimated central values are found to be MeV, MeV, and MeV. Although the EMSG theory suggests different classes of approximate relations for various , the nuclear matter parameters obtained are within the current bounds from various model analysis of terrestrial and observational measurements.
For orientation, the linear regression in general relativity is given as
Adopting the same approach as in EMSG, we obtain in GR the central values MeV for the constraint, and MeV for the constraint. The estimated NM parameters in GR and EMSG (with for example) are found to be somewhat different. However, the large uncertainty associated with the current bounds (from nuclear experiments and/or detected NS observables) prevents a clear preference for the various descriptions of gravity.
We would like to mention that the above bounds in EMSG theory of gravity are obtained by employing the observational constraints that are often performed based on general relativity. In particular, the tidal deformability is extracted from the gravitational wave signal using waveform models derived assuming GR. However, the current detectors are not sensitive to the new class of modes that may appear from additional degrees of freedom in the modified theories of gravity which do not exist in GR [113]. Consequently, the detected observables cannot clearly resolve GR from the modified theories of gravity.
While our results are based on EoSs with purely nucleonic degrees of freedom, possible existence of exotic phases, such as phase transition to hyperons [114], kaon condensation [115], deconfined quark matter [101, 116] at high densities in the core of neutron stars cannot be excluded. In general, the onset of phase transition inside the star at nucleon density softens the EoS resulting in decrease in the speed of sound, masses, radii, moment of inertia and tidal deformability of NSs. Hence, as compared to GR results, the reduction in the magnitude of these observables as found here in EMSG theory for , will be further accentuated with phase transition. Conversely, the increase seen for will be minimised by softening of the EoS in presence of phase transition. The validity of the universal relations connecting with compactness, moment of inertia and tidal deformability as seen in EMSG and GR (Figure 6) is expected to persist even with phase transition, as universality has been established with phase transition in GR itself [117]. Since non-nucleonic degrees of freedom (for realistic EoS) are likely to appear in massive stars only, one expects the strong correlations observed between the nuclear matter parameters and low mass neutron star observables (Figure 8, Figure 9) will have marginal effect.
Conclusions
Using a representative set of accurately calibrated models of nuclear equations of state, we have investigated within the energy-momentum squared gravity theory (EMSG: a non-minimal matter-coupling extension to general relativity) the impact of strong-field gravity on several properties of dense neutron star. In particular, correlations between nuclear matter parameters at saturation density and the neutron star observables were studied in the EMSG theory to ascertain the effectiveness of the theory and to quantify its modifications to the predictions in general relativity (GR). By using three realistic EoSs (NL3, BSR2, Sly4), we first showed that for a fixed value of the coupling strength in EMSG, the NS mass-radius curves are affected differently as compared to GR predictions. The softest EoS in Sly4 enforces the largest increase in the radii of especially the small mass stars for the positive value. Whereas, the stability conditions, and (from center to surface of NS), enable smallest in the stiffer NL3 EoS and correspondingly provides the largest decrease in the radii near the neutron star. While the variation of the NS compactness with the moment of inertia and tidal deformability in particular, are quite small, the peak value of tidal Love number was found to have appreciable modifications to GR in the EMSG model.
We next explored the correlations between the NS observables and nuclear matter EoS parameters in EMSG and GR. An approximate universal correlation, independent of the nuclear model EOSs, was established for the variation of the central speed of sound squared with the reduced pressure and its natural transform the compactness at the center of the stars. We found that has a linear increase with and . However, the universality is violated to some extent by the strong-field gravity that induces distinct correlations for different values of the parameter in EMSG. For instance, the causality bound on the NS mass-radius curve in EMSG suggested a lower limit on the star radius in direct contrast to the GR bound of .
We also demonstrated that gravity modifications have marginal effects on the universal properties of the compactness, , tidal deformability relations with the reduced central pressure and thus could be inferred from measurements of NS properties. A truly universal correlation within the realms of current observational bounds was found between the measurable radius and tidal deformability of NS that is practically EoS-insensitive and depicted marginal separation between different classes of universality in the EMSG and GR. The correlation between nuclear matter incompressibility , its slope , the symmetry energy slope and curvature and their linear combinations revealed the previously studied correlation with NS radii and deformability. These relations were found to be quite sensitive to EMSG theory of gravity that may hinder a precise estimation of the nuclear matter parameters from these correlations. To conclude, our study emphasizes that certain neutron star observables are insensitive to nuclear EoSs and gravity modifications and can be employed as approximate universal relations to determine the EoS parameters, whereas small, yet detectable signatures of gravity effects are evident in some neutron star observables.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
N.A. and S.P. acknowledge financial support by the Department of Atomic Energy (Government of India) under Project Identification No. RTI 4002.
References
- [4]J. M. Lattimer and A. W. Steiner, Euro. Phys. J 50, 40 (2014).
- [5]S. Capozziello and M. De Laurentis, Phys. Rept. 509, 167 (2011).
- [6]N. Nari and M. Roshan, Phys. Rev. D 98, 024031 (2018).
- [7]O. Akarsu, J. D. Barrow, C. Sercan, K. Y. Eksi, and N. Katirci, Phys. Rev. D 97, 124017 (2018).
- [8]G. J. Olmo, D. Rubiera-Garcia, and A. Wojnar, Phys. Rept. 876, 1 (2020).
- [9]O. Akarsu, J. D. Barrow, and N. M. Uzun, Phys. Rev. D 102, 124059 (2020).
- [10]R. C. Tolman, Phys. Rev. 55, 364 (1939).
- [11]J. R. Oppenheimer and G. M. Volkoff, Phys. Rev. 55, 374 (1939).
- [12]B. A. Brown, W. A. Richter, and R. Lindsay, Phys. Lett. B 483, 49 (2000).
- [13]B.-A. Li, L.-W. Chen, and C. M. Ko, Phys. Rep. 464, 113 (2008).
- [14]K. Yagi and N. Yunes, Science 341, 365 (2013).
- [15]T. Harko, F. S. N. Lobo, S. Nojiri, and S. D. Odintsov, Phys. Rev. D 84, 024020 (2011).
- [16]N. Katirci and M. Kavuk, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 129, 163 (2014).
- [17]E. Nazari, Phys. Rev. D 105, 104026 (2022).
- [18]E. Nazari, M. Roshan, and I. De Nartino, Phys. Rev. D 105, 044014 (2022).
- [19]H. R. Fazlollahi, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 138, 211 (2023).
- [20]M. D. Danarianto and A. Sulaksono, Eur. Phys. J. C 83, 463 (2023).
- [21]M. Roshan and F. Shojai, Phys. Rev. D 94, 044002 (2016).
- [22]O. Akarsu, A. K. Camlibel, N. Katirci, I. Semiz, and N. M. Uzun, Phys. Dark Univ. 42, 101305 (2023).
- [23]A. Rahmansyah, D. Purnamasari, R. Kurniadi, and A. Sulaksono, Phys. Rev. D 106, 084042 (2022).
- [24]M. Fortin, C. Providência, A. R. Raduta, F. Gulminelli, J. L. Zdunik, P. Haensel, and M. Bejger, ArXiv e-prints (2016), arXiv:1604.01944 [astro-ph.SR].DOI
- [25]N. Alam, B. K. Agrawal, M. Fortin, H. Pais, C. Providência, A. R. Raduta, and A. Sulaksono, Phys. Rev. C 94, 052801 (2016).
- [26]T. Malik, N. Alam, M. Fortin, C. Providência, B. K. Agrawal, T. K. Jha, B. Kumar, and S. K. Patra, Phys. Rev. C 98, 035804 (2018).
- [27]Z. Carson, A. W. Steiner, and K. Yagi, Phys. Rev. D 99, 043010 (2019).
- [28]G. F. Burgio, H.-J. Schulze, I. Vidana, and J.-B. Wei, Symmetry 13, 3 (2021).
- [29]S. Yang and D. Wen, Phys. Rev. D 107, 063009 (2023).
- [30]B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo), Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 161101 (2017).
- [31]N. Alam, B. K. Agrawal, J. N. De, S. K. Samaddar, and G. Colò, Phys. Rev. C 90, 054317 (2014).
- [32]Z. Haghami, T. Harko, and S. Shahidi, arXiv:2301.12133 (2023).
- [33]O. Akarsu, M. Bouhmadi-Lopez, N. Katirci, E. Nazari, M. Roshan, and N. M. Uzun, arXiv:2306.11717 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2306.11717
- [34]V. Faraoni, Phys. Rev. D 80, 124040 (2009).
- [35]M. Khodadi, A. Allahyari, and S. Capozziello, Phys. Dark Univ. 36, 101013 (2022).
- [36]S. Gao, Phys. Rev. D 84, 104023 (2011); Phys. Rev. D 85, 027503 (2012).
- [37]A. Wojnar, Phys. Rev. D 107, 044025 (2023).
- [38]J. B. Hartle, Astrophys. J. 150, 1005 (1967).
- [39]I. A. Morrison, T. W. Baumgarte, S. L. Shapiro, and V. R. Pandharipande, Astrophys. J. 617, L135 (2004).
- [40]E. Flanagan and T. Hinderer, Phys. Rev. D 77, 021502(R) (2008).
- [41]T. Hinderer, Astrophys. J. 677, 1216 (2008).
- [42]T. Hinderer, B. D. Lackey, R. N. Lang, and J. S. Read, Phys. Rev. D 81, 123016 (2010).
- [43]T. Damour, A. Nagar, and L. Villain, Phys Rev. D 85, 123007 (2012).
- [44]M. B. Tsang et al., Phys. Rev. C 86, 015803 (2012).
- [45]G. Taranto, M. Baldo, and G. F. Burgio, Phys. Rev. C87, 045803 (2013).
- [46]D. Davesne, A. Pastore, and J. Navarro, Astronomy and Astrophysics 585, A83 (2016).
- [47]A. Akmal, V. Pandharipande, and D. Ravenhall, Phys. Rev. C 58, 1804 (1998).
- [48]C. Ducoin, J. Margueron, C. Providência, and I. Vidana, Phys. Rev. C 83, 045810 (2011).
- [49]M. Centelles, M. X. Viñas, F. Garcias, and M. Barranco, Nucl. Phys. A510, 397 (1990).
- [50]M. Liu, N. Wang, Z. Li, and F. Zhang, Phys. Rev. C 82, 064306 (2010).
- [51]G. A. Lalazissis, J. König, and P. Ring, Phys. Rev. C 55, 540 (1997).
- [52]H. Pais and C. Providência, Phys. Rev. C 94, 015808 (2016).
- [53]C. J. Horowitz and J. Piekarewicz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 5647 (2001).
- [54]J. Carriere, C. Horowitz, and J. Piekarewicz, Astrophys. J. 593, 463 (2003).
- [55]Y. Sugahara and H. Toki, Nucl. Phys. A 579, 557 (1994).
- [56]C. Providência and A. Rabhi, Phys. Rev. C 87, 055801 (2013).
- [57]W.-C. Chen and J. Piekarewicz, Phys. Rev. C 90, 044305 (2014).
- [58]S. K. Dhiman, R. Kumar, and B. K. Agrawal, Phys. Rev. C 76, 045801 (2007).
- [59]B. K. Agrawal, Phys. Rev. C 81, 034323 (2010).
- [60]S. Typel, G. Ropke, T. Klahn, D. Blaschke, and H. H. Wolter, Phys. Rev. C 81, 015803 (2010).
- [61]T. Gaitanos, M. Di Toro, S. Typel, V. Baran, C. Fuchs, V. Greco, and H. H. Wolter, Nucl. Phys. A732, 24 (2004).
- [62]T. Niksic, D. Vretenar, P. Finelli, and P. Ring, Phys. Rev. C 66, 024306 (2002).
- [63]G. A. Lalazissis, T. Niksic, D. Vretenar, and P. Ring, Phys. Rev. C 71, 024312 (2005).
- [64]S. Typel and H. H. Wolter, Nucl. Phys. A 656, 331 (1999).
- [65]N. K. Glendenning and S. A. Moszkowski, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 2414 (1991).
- [66]H. Kohler, Nuclear Physics A 258, 301 (1976).
- [67]P.-G. Reinhard and H. Flocard, Nucl. Phys. A 584, 467 (1995).
- [68]W. Nazarewicz, J. Dobaczewski, T. R. Werner, J. A. Maruhn, P.-G. Reinhard, K. Rutz, C. R. Chinn, A. S. Umar, and M. R. Strayer, Phys. Rev. C 53, 740 (1996).
- [69]E. Chabanat, Ph.D. thesis, University Claude Bernard Lyon-1, Lyon, France (1995).
- [70]E. Chabanat, P. Bonche, P. Haensel, J. Meyer, and R. Schaeffer, Nucl. Phys. A 627, 710 (1997).
- [71]E. Chabanat, P. Bonche, P. Haensel, J. Meyer, and R. Schaeffer, Nucl. Phys. A 635, 231 (1998).
- [72]L. Bennour, P.-H. Heenen, P. Bonche, J. Dobaczewski, and H. Flocard, Phys. Rev. C 40, 2834 (1989).
- [73]P. G. Reinhard, Nucl. Phys. A 649, 305c (1999).
- [74]B. K. Agrawal, S. Shlomo, and V. K. Au, Phys. Rev. C 72, 014310 (2005).
- [75]B. K. Agrawal, S. Shlomo, and V. Kim Au, Phys. Rev. C 68, 031304 (2003).
- [76]J. Friedrich and P.-G. Reinhard, Phys. Rev. C 33, 335 (1986).
- [77]S. Goriely, N. Chamel, and J. M. Pearson, Phys. Rev. C 82, 035804 (2010).
- [78]S. Goriely, N. Chamel, and J. M. Pearson, Phys. Rev. C 88, 024308 (2013).
- [79]G. Baym, C. Pethick, and P. Sutherland, Astrophys. J. 170, 299 (1971).
- [80]G. Colo, N. Van Giai, J. Meyer, K. Bennaceur, and P. Bonche, Phys. Rev. C 70, 024307 (2004).
- [81]G. Colo, U. Garg, and H. Sagawa, Eur. Phys. J. A 50, 26 (2014).
- [82]B.-A. Li, P. G. Krastev, D.-H. Wen, and N.-B. Zhang, Eur. Phys. J. A 55, 117 (2019).
- [83]X. Fan, J. Dong, and W. Zuo, Phys. Rev. C 89, 017305 (2014).
- [84]B. T. Reed, F. J. Fattoyev, C. J. Horowitz, and J. Piekarewicz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 172503 (2021).
- [85]P.-G. Reinhard, X. Roca-Maza, and W. Nazarewicz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 232501 (2021).
- [86]O. Komoltsev and A. Kurlakela, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 202701 (2022).
- [87]E. Lope-Oter and F. J. Llanes-Estrada, Eur. Phys. J. A 58, 9 (2022).
- [88]E. Lope-Oter and A. Wojnar, (2023), arXiv:2306.00870 [gr-qc].
- [89]E. Annala, T. Gorda, A. Kurkela, J. Nättilä, and A. Vuorinen, Nature Phys. 16, 907 (2020).
- [90]G. M. Hossain and S. Mandal, Phys. Rev. D 104, 123005 (2021).
- [91]J. Li, T. Guo, J. Zhao, and L. He, Phys. Rev. D 106, 083021 (2022).
- [92]T. E. Riley et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 887, L21 (2019).
- [93]T. E. Riley et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 918, L27 (2021).
- [94]J. Antoniadis and et. al, Science 340, 448 (2013).
- [95]P. B. Demorest, T. Pennucci, S. M. Ransom, M. S. E. Roberts, and J. W. T. Hessels, Nature 467, 1081 (2010).
- [96]Z. Arzoumanian et al., The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 235, 37 (2018).
- [97]R. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo), Astrophys. J. Lett. 896, L44 (2020).
- [98]F. Özel and P. B. Freire, Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 54, 401 (2016).
- [99]V. Doroshenko et al., Nature Astron. 6, 1433 (2022).
- [100]R. Nandi, P. Char, and S. Pal, Phys. Rev. C 99, 052802 (2019).
- [101]R. Nandi and S. Pal, Eur. Phys. J. ST 230, 551 (2021).
- [102]B.-J. Cai, B.-A. Li, and Z. Zhang, (2023), arXiv:2307.25223 [nucl-th].
- [103]H. A. Buchdahl, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 150, 1 (1970).
- [104]B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo), Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 161101 (2018).
- [105]S. Brandt, Statistical and Computational Methods in Data Analysis (Springer, New York, 3rd English edition, 1997).
- [106]J. M. Lattimer and M. Prakash, Astrophys. J. 550, 426 (2001).
- [107]B. G. Todd-Rutel and J. Piekarewicz, Phys. Rev. Lett 95, 122501 (2005).
- [108]E. Khan, J. Margueron, and I. Vidaña, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 092501 (2012).
- [109]E. Khan and J. Margueron, Phys. Rev. C 88, 034319 (2013).
- [110]M. B. Tsang, T. X. Liu, L. Shi, P. Danielewicz, C. K. Gelbke, X. D. Liu, W. G. Lynch, W. P. Tan, G. Verde, A. Wagner, and H. S. Xu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 062701 (2004).
- [111]C. Mondal, B. K. Agrawal, J. N. De, and S. K. Samaddar, Phys. Rev. C 93, 044328 (2016).
- [112]J. Margueron, J. Navarro, and N. V. Giai, Phys. Rev. C 66, 014303 (2002).
- [113]R. F. P. Mendes and N. Ortiz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 201104 (2018).
- [114]J. Schaffner-Bielich, M. Hanauske, H. Stoecker, and W. Greiner, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 171101 (2002).
- [115]J. A. Pons, S. Reddy, P. J. Ellis, M. Prakash, and J. M. Lattimer, Phys. Rev. C 62, 035803 (2000).
- [116]D. Sen, N. Alam, and G. Chaudhuri, Phys. Rev. D 106, 083008 (2022).
- [117]K. Yagi and N. Yunes, Phys. Rept. 681, 1 (2017).







