betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Baryon-antibaryon generalized distribution amplitudes and e+e−→BBˉγe^+ e^- \to B \bar{B} γ

Abstract

Baryon-antibaryon generalized distribution amplitudes (GDAs) give an access to timelike gravitational form factors (GFFs) which are complementary to the spacelike ones which can be deduced from the hadronic generalized parton distributions (GPDs) measured in deep exclusive electroproduction processes. They allow to probe the GFFs of unstable baryons in the baryon octet, since the second moments of hadronic generalized distribution amplitudes (GDAs) lead to the timelike GFFs. These GDAs can be measured in the process e+e−→BBˉγe^+ e^- \to B \bar{B} γ, in the generalized Bjorken regime where the invariant mass of the BBˉB \bar{B} pair is near threshold at high energy facilities, such as BESIII, Belle II, and the proposed Super Tau-Charm Facility. In this work, we investigate this process using the QCD collinear factorization framework, where the scattering amplitudes are expressed in terms of the baryon timelike electromagnetic (EM) FFs and Compton FFs. We also provide a numerical estimate of the cross sections with a model for baryon-antibaryon GDAs. Our work provides us a possibility to extract the timelike baryon GFFs from near future experimental measurements, and these GFFs may be further used to study longstanding questions in hadronic physics such as the baryon spin decomposition and D-term.

Introduction

The hadronic matrix elements of the energy-momentum tensor (EMT) are key physical quantities that reveal the inner structures of hadrons, and they are parameterized in terms of EMT form factors (FFs), which are also known as gravitational FFs (GFFs) in the literature. The study of GFFs is related to currently hot topics in hadronic physics, such as spin decomposition [1–3], mass radius [4–9], and mechanical properties of the hadron [10–18]. It is impossible to directly probe the EMT FFs by experiment as the gravitational interaction is too week. Fortunately, the generalized parton distributions (GPDs) of the nucleon can be accessed by the exclusive processes such as deeply virtual Compton scattering (DVCS) and timelike Compton scattering (TCS), where only electromagnetic (EM) and strong interactions are involved. The second moments of hadronic GPDs are the spacelike EMT FFs, and the study of GPDs is considered as an alternative to probe the GFFs. Thus, accessing hadronic GPDs with unprecedented precision is a top scientific priority for the forthcoming Electron-Ion Collider (EIC).

It is well known that most hadrons are not stable, and we cannot access their GPDs by exclusive processes1. For example, only the nucleon GPDs can be probed at existing or future lepton-nucleon facilities in the baryon octet and decuplet families. Transition GPDs like N→ΔN \to\Delta or N→N∗N \to N^{*} enter the description of electroproduction amplitudes such as DVCS with N→ΔN \to\Delta [23] or N→ΔˉN \to\bar{\Delta} baryon transition (see the review [24] and references therein). They allow but a first step in the study of unstable baryons.

However, one can investigate the generalized distribution amplitudes (GDAs) of unstable hadrons through the production of a hadron-antihadron pair such as γ∗γ→hhˉ\gamma^{*}\gamma\to h\bar{h} [5, 25–31] and γ∗→hhˉγ\gamma^{*} \to h\bar{h}\gamma [32–34], where the hhˉh\bar{h} GDAs describe the amplitude of qqˉ→hhˉq\bar{q} \to h\bar{h} under the QCD factorization. The second moments of GDAs allow us to access the timelike GFFs, and the spacelike GFFs can be deduced from the timelike ones using dispersion relation techniques. Thus, a complete picture of GFFs may be obtained from the study of the hadronic GDAs. For the production of a pseudoscalar meson pair, recent measurements of the cross sections for γ∗γ→MMˉ\gamma^{*}\gamma\to M\bar{M} and γ∗→MMˉγ\gamma^{*} \to M\bar{M}\gamma have been reported by the Belle [35, 36] and BaBar [37] collaborations, respectively. The dipion GDA and the pion GFFs were extracted from a theoretical analysis of Belle results [5].

We can extend the study of GDAs to the production of a baryon-antibaryon pair, and the amplitude of this process is expressed in terms of baryon-antibaryon GDAs. To satisfy the QCD factorization criteria [25], the photon virtuality needs to be much larger than the invariant mass of the baryon pair. The measurements of the reactions γ∗→BBˉγ\gamma^{*} \to B\bar{B}\gamma are possible at BESIII, Belle II, and the proposed Super Tau-Charm Facility (STCF) [38], where the virtual photon comes from a e+e−e^{+}e^{-} annihilation. Since the real photon can be emitted from the initial lepton in e+e−→BBˉγe^{+}e^{-} \to B\bar{B}\gamma, one also needs to consider the contribution of the initial state radiation (ISR) process in the extraction of baryon GDAs; the ISR contribution is described by the baryon EM FFs, similarly to the Bethe-Heitler process in the DVCS reaction. Recently, extensive experimental measurements have been reported on the timelike EM FFs of the baryon octet, such as nucleons [39–45], Λ\Lambda [46–48], Σ\Sigma [52, 53] [49, 50, 51], and Ξ\Xi [54, 55]. The subsequent theoretical analysis of these measurements can be found in Refs. [56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65]. Thus, the time has come to investigate the baryon-antibaryon GDAs in e+e−→BBˉγe^+e^- \to B\bar{B}\gamma with the baryon EM FFs as inputs. Actually, the process e+e−→BBˉγe^+e^- \to B\bar{B}\gamma has frequently been used for the recent measurements of baryon EM FFs [52] [41, 45, 48, 51]. In this work, we investigate the baryon-antibaryon GDAs for the process e+e−→BBˉγe^+e^- \to B\bar{B}\gamma using QCD factorization, and theoretical formulas and numerical estimates are presented at leading twist and leading order in αs\alpha_s.

The present paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II, we discuss the kinematics of e+e−→BBˉγe^+e^- \to B\bar{B}\gamma, and introduce the definition of the four leading-twist chiral-even 2 baryon-antibaryon GDAs. The relations between GDAs and timelike FFs are discussed in Sec. III. The scattering amplitudes for the ISR and QCD processes are given, respectively, in terms of timelike EM baryon FFs and Compton FFs in Sec. IV. We introduce the models of EM FFs and baryon GDAs in Sec. V, and derive numerical estimates for the various contributions to the cross section for the production of a proton-antiproton pair. In Sec. VI we calculate and discuss a forward-backward baryon asymmetry which is proportional to the interference of the ISR and QCD amplitudes, and is thus linear in baryon-antibaryon GDAs. Our results are summarized in Sec. VII.

Generalized Distribution Amplitudes in e+e−→BBˉγe^+e^- \to B\bar{B}\gamma

The baryon GDAs were first proposed to study the process γγ→BBˉ\gamma\gamma\to B\bar{B} at large energy and momentum transfer [66] as well as the reversed process [67], in a simplified handbag model; these cross sections were expressed in terms of the first moments of GDAs. In addition, the meson GDAs can be probed in the process γ∗→MMˉγ\gamma^* \to M\bar{M}\gamma, where virtual photon comes from the e−e+e^-e^+ annihilation, and its virtuality is large enough to satisfy the QCD factorization [32]. In this work, we extend this process to the production of a baryon-antibaryon pair,

e−(k1)e+(k2)→γ∗(q1)→B(p1)Bˉ(p2)γ(q2).(1)e^-(k_1)e^+(k_2) \to\gamma^*(q_1) \to B(p_1)\bar{B}(p_2)\gamma(q_2). \tag*{(1)}

We define the following variables,

s=(q1)2=(k1+k2)2,u=(k1−q2)2,s^=P2=(p1+p2)2,Δ=p2−p1.(2)s = (q_1)^2 = (k_1 + k_2)^2,\qquad u = (k_1 - q_2)^2,\qquad\hat{s} = P^2 = (p_1 + p_2)^2,\qquad\Delta= p_2 - p_1. \tag*{(2)}

The lightcone vectors nn and nˉ\bar{n} are given by the photon momenta q1q_1 and q2q_2,

n=2ss−s^q2,n~=2s(q1−ss−s^q2).(3)n = \frac{\sqrt{2s}}{s-\hat{s}}q_2,\qquad\tilde{n} = \sqrt{\frac{2}{s}}\left(q_1-\frac{s}{s-\hat{s}}q_2\right). \tag*{(3)}

For a Lorentz vector vv, the lightcone components v+=v⋅nv^+ = v\cdot n and v−=v⋅nˉv^- = v\cdot\bar{n} are defined, and the transverse component is given by

vTα=gTαβvβ,(4)v_T^\alpha= g_T^{\alpha\beta}v_\beta, \tag*{(4)}

with

gTαβ=gαβ−nαn~β−nβn~α.(5)g_T^{\alpha\beta}=g^{\alpha\beta}-n^\alpha\tilde{n}^\beta-n^\beta\tilde{n}^\alpha. \tag*{(5)}

The parameter ζ0\zeta_0 corresponds to the light-cone fraction of the momentum Δ\Delta,

ζ0=Δ⋅nP⋅n,(6)\zeta_0 = \frac{\Delta\cdot n}{P\cdot n}, \tag*{(6)}

and one can obtain ΔT2=gTμνΔμΔν=4m2−(1−ζ02)s^\Delta_T^2 = g_T^{\mu\nu}\Delta_\mu\Delta_\nu= 4m^2-(1-\zeta_0^2)\hat{s}, where mm is the baryon mass. In the center-of-mass frame of the baryon-antibaryon pair, the zz axis is chosen along the momentum q1q_1, and the momenta of the baryon pair lie in the xx-zz plane, as illustrated by Figure 1. The polar angle of p1p_1 is denoted as θ\theta,

Center-of-mass frame of the baryon-antibaryon pair

Figure 1. The Center-of-mass frame of the baryon-antibaryon pair for the process e−(k1)e+(k2)→γ∗(q1)→B(p1)Bˉ(p2)γ(q2)e^{-}(k_{1})e^{+}(k_{2}) \rightarrow\gamma^{*}(q_{1}) \rightarrow B(p_{1})\bar{B}(p_{2})\gamma(q_{2}).

p1=(p10,∣p1∣sin⁡θ,0,∣p1∣cos⁡θ).(7)p_1 = (p_1^0, |\mathbf{p}_1|\sin\theta, 0, |\mathbf{p}_1|\cos\theta). \tag*{(7)}

and it can be expressed as

cos⁡θ=q1⋅(p2−p1)β0(q1⋅q2),(8)\cos\theta= \frac{q_{1}\cdot(p_{2}-p_{1})}{\beta_{0}(q_{1}\cdot q_{2})}, \tag*{(8)}

with

β0=1−4m2s^.(9)\beta_{0}=\sqrt{1-\frac{4m^{2}}{\hat{s}}}. \tag*{(9)}

Combining Eqs. (6) and (7), we obtain the relation ζ0=β0cos⁡θ\zeta_{0}=\beta_{0}\cos\theta. The azimuthal angle φ\varphi between the lepton plane and the hadron plane is given by

sin⁡φ=−4ϵαβγδq1αq2βp1γl1δβ0sin⁡θuss^(s^−u−s),(10)\sin\varphi=\frac{-4\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}q_{1}^{\alpha}q_{2}^{\beta}p_{1}^{\gamma}l_{1}^{\delta}}{\beta_{0}\sin\theta\sqrt{u s\hat{s}(\hat{s}-u-s)}}, \tag*{(10)}

where the convention ϵ0123=1\epsilon^{0123}=1 is used.

Two types of subprocesses contribute to the reaction e−e+→BBˉγe^{-}e^{+}\rightarrow B\bar{B}\gamma, and we can distinguish them by the charge conjugation CC of the baryon-antibaryon pair. The CC-even baryon pair comes from the subprocess (a): e−e+→γ∗→BBˉγe^{-}e^{+}\rightarrow\gamma^{*}\rightarrow B\bar{B}\gamma. At leading order in αs\alpha_{s}, the amplitude of subprocess (a) can be factorized into the hard part γ∗→qqˉγ\gamma^{*}\rightarrow q\bar{q}\gamma and the soft part qqˉ→BBˉq\bar{q}\rightarrow B\bar{B} using the QCD factorization as illustrated by Figure 2, and the soft part is parameterized by the baryon GDA. In the lightcone gauge, we define the leading-twist chiral-even baryon-antibaryon quark GDAs for a spin-12\frac{1}{2} baryon pair [66],

The QCD subprocess

Figure 2. The QCD subprocess (a) γ∗→BBˉγ\gamma^{*}\rightarrow B\bar{B}\gamma, where the blob represents the baryon-antibaryon GDAs. A second Feynman diagram should be added, it is obtained by interchanging the photon vertices.

P+∫dX−eizP+⋅x−⟨Bˉ(p2)B(p1)∣qˉ(−x−)γ+q(0)∣0⟩=ΦVq(z,ζ0,s^)uˉ(p1)γ+v(p2)+ΦSq(z,ζ0,s^)P+2muˉ(p1)v(p2),P^{+}\int dX^{-}e^{izP^{+}\cdot x^{-}}\langle\bar{B}(p_{2})B(p_{1})|\bar{q}(-x^{-})\gamma^{+}q(0)|0\rangle=\Phi_{V}^{q}(z,\zeta_{0},\hat{s})\bar{u}(p_{1})\gamma^{+}v(p_{2})+\Phi_{S}^{q}(z,\zeta_{0},\hat{s})\frac{P^{+}}{2m}\bar{u}(p_{1})v(p_{2}),
P+∫dX−eizP+⋅x−⟨Bˉ(p2)B(p1)∣qˉ(−x−)γ+γ5q(0)∣0⟩=ΦAq(z,ζ0,s^)uˉ(p1)γ+γ5v(p2)+ΦPq(z,ζ0,s^)P+2muˉ(p1)γ5v(p2).(11)P^{+}\int dX^{-}e^{izP^{+}\cdot x^{-}}\langle\bar{B}(p_{2})B(p_{1})|\bar{q}(-x^{-})\gamma^{+}\gamma_{5}q(0)|0\rangle=\Phi_{A}^{q}(z,\zeta_{0},\hat{s})\bar{u}(p_{1})\gamma^{+}\gamma_{5}v(p_{2})+\Phi_{P}^{q}(z,\zeta_{0},\hat{s})\frac{P^{+}}{2m}\bar{u}(p_{1})\gamma_{5}v(p_{2}). \tag*{(11)}

where zz is the momentum fraction carried by the quark qq, and we omit to write the factorization scale dependence of the GDAs. One can obtain the following relations using the charge conjugation symmetry,

Φiq(z,ζ0,s^)=Φiq(zˉ,−ζ0,s^),for i=V, A, P,ΦSq(z,ζ0,s^)=−ΦSq(zˉ,−ζ0,s^),(12)\Phi_i^q(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})=\Phi_i^q(\bar{z},-\zeta_0,\hat{s}),\quad\text{for }i=V,\ A,\ P, \\ \Phi_S^q(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})=-\Phi_S^q(\bar{z},-\zeta_0,\hat{s}), \tag*{(12)}

and we note xˉ≡1−x\bar{x}\equiv1-x. In Figure 3, the CC-odd baryon-antibaryon pair is produced from the ISR subprocess (b): e−e+→γ∗γ→BBˉγe^-e^+\to\gamma^*\gamma\to B\bar{B}\gamma and its amplitude is expressed in terms of the timelike baryon EM FFs.

ISR subprocess (b) producing a baryon-antibaryon pair and a photon

Figure 3. The ISR subprocess (b) e−e+→γ∗γ→BBˉγe^-e^+\to\gamma^*\gamma\to B\bar{B}\gamma; the photon-baryon-antibaryon coupling is described by the timelike baryon EM FFs.

Generalized Distribution Amplitudes and Timelike Form Factors

For a spin-12\frac{1}{2} baryon-antibaryon pair, the timelike FFs of vector and axial-vector currents are defined as

⟨Bˉ(p2)B(p1)∣qˉ(0)γμq(0)∣0⟩=FVq(s^)uˉ(p1)γμv(p2)+FSq(s^)Δμ2muˉ(p1)v(p2),⟨Bˉ(p2)B(p1)∣qˉ(0)γμγ5q(0)∣0⟩=FAq(s^)uˉ(p1)γμγ5v(p2)+FPq(s^)Pμ2muˉ(p1)γ5v(p2),(13)\begin{aligned} \langle\bar{B}(p_2)B(p_1)|\bar{q}(0)\gamma^\mu q(0)|0\rangle &=F_V^q(\hat{s})\bar{u}(p_1)\gamma^\mu v(p_2)+F_S^q(\hat{s})\frac{\Delta^\mu}{2m}\bar{u}(p_1)v(p_2),\\ \langle\bar{B}(p_2)B(p_1)|\bar{q}(0)\gamma^\mu\gamma_5q(0)|0\rangle &=F_A^q(\hat{s})\bar{u}(p_1)\gamma^\mu\gamma_5v(p_2)+F_P^q(\hat{s})\frac{P^\mu}{2m}\bar{u}(p_1)\gamma_5v(p_2), \tag*{(13)} \end{aligned}

and a linear combination of FVq(s^)F_V^q(\hat{s}) and FSq(s^)F_S^q(\hat{s}) leads to the timelike electric and magnetic FFs,

GE(s^)=FVq(s^)+(τ−1)FSq(s^),GM(s^)=FVq(s^),(14)\begin{aligned} G_E(\hat{s})&=F_V^q(\hat{s})+(\tau-1)F_S^q(\hat{s}),\\ G_M(\hat{s})&=F_V^q(\hat{s}), \tag*{(14)} \end{aligned}

where τ=s^/(4m2)\tau=\hat{s}/(4m^2). These timelike FFs are related to the first moments of baryon GDAs [66]

∫01dzΦiq(z,ζ0,s^)=Fiq(s^)for i=V, A, P,∫01dzΦSq(z,ζ0,s^)=ζ0FSq(s^),(15)\int_0^1 dz\Phi_i^q(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})=F_i^q(\hat{s})\quad\text{for }i=V,\ A,\ P, \\ \int_0^1 dz\Phi_S^q(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})=\zeta_0F_S^q(\hat{s}), \tag*{(15)}

The hadronic matrix elements of the EMT operator are parameterized in terms of the EMT FFs. In the spacelike region, one finds the parametrization of these matrix elements in Refs. [68, 69, 70, 71, 72] [1]. The timelike EMT FFs (GFFs) for a baryon can be obtained by taking the ss-tt crossed expression of the corresponding spacelike matrix element,

⟨Bˉ(p2)B(p1)∣Tqμν(0)∣0⟩=uˉ(p1)[Aq(s^)ΔμΔν4m+Dq(s^)PμPν−gμνs^4m−Jq(s^)Δ{μiσν}P2m+Cˉq(s^)mgμν]v(p2).(16)\langle\bar{B}(p_2)B(p_1)|T_q^{\mu\nu}(0)|0\rangle =\bar{u}(p_1)\left[A^q(\hat{s})\frac{\Delta^\mu\Delta^\nu}{4m}+D^q(\hat{s})\frac{P^\mu P^\nu-g^{\mu\nu}\hat{s}}{4m}-J^q(\hat{s})\frac{\Delta^{\{\mu}i\sigma^{\nu\}}P}{2m}+\bar{C}^q(\hat{s})mg^{\mu\nu}\right]v(p_2). \tag*{(16)}

One can use dispersion relations to relate the timelike GFFs to the spacelike ones, as illustrated in Figure 4. Thus, we can acquire a complete picture of the EMT FFs through the study of the timelike ones. The timelike GFF Cˉq(s^)\bar{C}^q(\hat{s}) of Eq. (16) breaks the conservation law of EMT, and it must vanish when summing over quark flavors and gluon. These EMT FFs are expressed by the second moments of baryon GDAs except for Cˉq(s^)\bar{C}^q(\hat{s}),

Spacelike and timelike EMT form factors probed by different reactions

Figure 4. Spacelike and timelike EMT FFs are probed by different reactions, and the former ones can be obtained from the latter ones using dispersion relation.

∫01dz(2z−1)ΦVq(z,ζ0,s^)=−2ζ0Jq(s^),∫01dz(2z−1)ΦSq(z,ζ0,s^)=Dq(s^)+[Aq(s^)−2Jq(s^)](ζ0)2,(17)\int_0^1 dz(2z-1)\Phi_V^q(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})=-2\zeta_0J^q(\hat{s}), \\ \int_0^1 dz(2z-1)\Phi_S^q(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})=D^q(\hat{s})+[A^q(\hat{s})-2J^q(\hat{s})](\zeta_0)^2, \tag*{(17)}

The inner structure of hadrons can be revealed with the help of the EMT FFs. For a spin-12\frac{1}{2} baryon, the angular momentum (AM) carried by quark flavor qq can be given by the EMT FF Jq(0)=JzqJ^q(0)=J_z^q, which is the sum of the orbital AM LzqL_z^q and helicity contribution SzqS_z^q. The latter is related to the axial FF FAq(s^)F_A^q(\hat{s}) of Eq. (13) as Szq=12FAq(0)S_z^q=\frac{1}{2}F_A^q(0), and the quark orbital AM is expressed as [1]

Lzq=Jq(0)−12FAq(0),(18)L_z^q=J^q(0)-\frac{1}{2}F_A^q(0), \tag*{(18)}

Thus, the spin decomposition of the baryons, nucleons as well as Λ\Lambda, Σ\Sigma and Ξ\Xi, can be probed by studying the leading-twist GDAs of Eq. (11). In addition, we can use the EMT FF Dq(s^)D^q(\hat{s}) to study the DD-terms of baryons [73],

D=∑qDq(0)+Dg(0),(19)D=\sum_q D^q(0)+D^g(0), \tag*{(19)}

where DgD^g is the gluonic EMT FF, and is related to the gluonic GPDs or GDAs. The DD-term is a renormalization-scale invariant quantity, and it is also known as the last global unknown charge of hadrons, which has attracted a lot of attention in the past decades.

Scattering amplitudes and cross sections

To describe the leading twist amplitude of subprocess (a) in Figure 2, we first introduce the hadron tensor for γ∗→BBˉγ\gamma^* \to B\bar{B}\gamma,

Tμν=i∫d4x e−iq1⋅x⟨Bˉ(p2)B(p1)∣T{jμem(x)jνem(0)}∣0⟩,(20)T_{\mu\nu}=i\int d^4x\,e^{-iq_1\cdot x}\langle\bar{B}(p_2)B(p_1)|T\{j_\mu^{\mathrm{em}}(x)j_\nu^{\mathrm{em}}(0)\}|0\rangle, \tag*{(20)}

where a CC-even baryon-antibaryon pair is produced. At leading twist, the hadron tensor TμνT_{\mu\nu} only receives contribution from the transversely polarized photons,

Tμν=−22s{gTμν[ζ0FVuˉ(p1)γ+v(p2)+FSP+2muˉ(p1)v(p2)]−iϵTμν[FAuˉ(p1)γ+γ5v(p2)+FPP+2muˉ(p1)γ5v(p2)]},(21)T^{\mu\nu}=-\frac{2}{\sqrt{2s}}\left\{g_T^{\mu\nu}\left[\zeta_0 F_V\bar{u}(p_1)\gamma^+v(p_2)+F_S\frac{P^+}{2m}\bar{u}(p_1)v(p_2)\right]-i\epsilon_T^{\mu\nu}\left[F_A\bar{u}(p_1)\gamma^+\gamma^5v(p_2)+F_P\frac{P^+}{2m}\bar{u}(p_1)\gamma^5v(p_2)\right]\right\}, \tag*{(21)}

where the transverse tensor ϵTμν=ϵμναβn~αnβ\epsilon_{T}^{\mu\nu} = \epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\tilde{n}_{\alpha}n_{\beta} is defined, and the hadron tensor satisfies the electromagnetic gauge invariance condition Tμνq1μ=Tμνq2ν=0T_{\mu\nu}q_{1}^{\mu}=T_{\mu\nu}q_{2}^{\nu}=0. The functions FiF_i can be regarded as the timelike version of the Compton FFs in DVCS, and they are expressed at leading (zeroth) order in αs\alpha_s in term of the four leading-twist GDAs,

ζ0FV=∑qeq22∫01dz2z−1zzˉΦVq(z,ζ0,s^),\zeta_0\mathcal{F}_V=\sum_q\frac{e_q^2}{2}\int_0^1 dz\frac{2z-1}{z\bar{z}}\Phi_V^{q}(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s}),
FS=∑qeq22∫01dz2z−1zzˉΦSq(z,ζ0,s^),\mathcal{F}_S=\sum_q\frac{e_q^2}{2}\int_0^1 dz\frac{2z-1}{z\bar{z}}\Phi_S^{q}(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s}),
Fi=∑qeq22∫01dz1zzˉΦiq(z,ζ0,s^)for i=A,P,(22)\mathcal{F}_i=\sum_q\frac{e_q^2}{2}\int_0^1 dz\frac{1}{z\bar{z}}\Phi_i^{q}(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})\quad\text{for }i=A,P, \tag*{(22)}

where only the CC-even GDAs contribute, and they are defined as

Φiq+(z,ζ0,s^)=12[Φiq(z,ζ0,s^)−Φiq(zˉ,ζ0,s^)]for i=V,S,\Phi_i^{q+}(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})=\frac{1}{2}\left[\Phi_i^q(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})-\Phi_i^q(\bar{z},\zeta_0,\hat{s})\right]\quad\text{for }i=V,S,
Φiq+(z,ζ0,s^)=12[Φiq(z,ζ0,s^)+Φiq(zˉ,ζ0,s^)]for i=A,P.(23)\Phi_i^{q+}(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})=\frac{1}{2}\left[\Phi_i^q(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s})+\Phi_i^q(\bar{z},\zeta_0,\hat{s})\right]\quad\text{for }i=A,P. \tag*{(23)}

Then, the contribution of subprocess (a) to the differential cross section is expressed as

dσGds^dud(cos⁡θ)dφ=αem3β08πs311+ϵ[∣FA∣2−∣FS∣2+2Re⁡(FAFP∗)+s^(∣FP∣2+∣FS∣2)4m2+(β0)2cos⁡2θ[∣FV∣2+2Re⁡(FSFV∗)−∣FA∣2]−(β0)4cos⁡4θ∣FV∣2],(24)\frac{d\sigma_{\mathrm{G}}}{d\hat{s}dud(\cos\theta)d\varphi}=\frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{em}}^3\beta_0}{8\pi s^3}\frac{1}{1+\epsilon}\left[|\mathcal{F}_A|^2-|\mathcal{F}_S|^2+2\operatorname{Re}(\mathcal{F}_A\mathcal{F}_P^*)+\frac{\hat{s}\left(|\mathcal{F}_P|^2+|\mathcal{F}_S|^2\right)}{4m^2}+\left(\beta_0\right)^2\cos^2\theta\left[|\mathcal{F}_V|^2+2\operatorname{Re}(\mathcal{F}_S\mathcal{F}_V^*)-|\mathcal{F}_A|^2\right]-\left(\beta_0\right)^4\cos^4\theta|\mathcal{F}_V|^2\right], \tag*{(24)}

where the ϵ\epsilon parameter is given by

ϵ=y−11−y+y22,y=q1⋅q2k1⋅q2.(25)\epsilon=\frac{y-1}{1-y+\frac{y^2}{2}},\qquad y=\frac{q_1\cdot q_2}{k_1\cdot q_2}. \tag*{(25)}

The contribution of the ISR subprocess (b) to the cross section has been investigated in [74, 75], and depends on the baryon EM FFs of Eqs. (13) and (14). In this work, this cross section will be discussed in the center-of-mass frame of the baryon-antibaryon pair, and it is given by

dσISRds^dud(cos⁡θ)dφ=αem3β034πs21s^ϵ[b0+b1cos⁡2θ+b2sin⁡2θ+b3sin⁡(2θ)cos⁡φ+b4sin⁡2θcos⁡(2φ)].(26)\frac{d\sigma_{\mathrm{ISR}}}{d\hat{s}dud(\cos\theta)d\varphi}=\frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{em}}^3\beta_0^3}{4\pi s^2}\frac{1}{\hat{s}\epsilon}\left[b_0+b_1\cos^2\theta+b_2\sin^2\theta+b_3\sin(2\theta)\cos\varphi+b_4\sin^2\theta\cos(2\varphi)\right]. \tag*{(26)}

where the coefficients bib_i read

b0=[1−2x(1−x)(1+ϵ)](2λ−1)∣GM∣2,b_0=\left[1-2x(1-x)(1+\epsilon)\right](2\lambda-1)|G_M|^2,
b1=[1−2x(1−x)(1−ϵ)]∣GM∣2+4ϵx(x−1)(λ−1)[∣GE∣2−∣GM∣2],b_1=\left[1-2x(1-x)(1-\epsilon)\right]|G_M|^2+4\epsilon x(x-1)(\lambda-1)\left[|G_E|^2-|G_M|^2\right],
b2=2ϵx(x−1)∣GM∣2+[1−2x(1−x)](λ−1)[∣GE∣2−∣GM∣2],b_2=2\epsilon x(x-1)|G_M|^2+\left[1-2x(1-x)\right](\lambda-1)\left[|G_E|^2-|G_M|^2\right],
b3=ϵ(1−ϵ)2x(x−1)(2x−1)sgn⁡(ρ)(λ−1)∣GE∣2−λ∣GM∣2,b_3=\sqrt{\epsilon(1-\epsilon)}\sqrt{2x(x-1)}(2x-1)\operatorname{sgn}(\rho)(\lambda-1)|G_E|^2-\lambda|G_M|^2,
b4=2ϵx(1−x)[(λ−1)∣GE∣2−λ∣GM∣2].(27)b_4=2\epsilon x(1-x)\left[(\lambda-1)|G_E|^2-\lambda|G_M|^2\right]. \tag*{(27)}

The dimensionless parameters xx and λ\lambda are defined as x=s/(s−s^)x=s/(s-\hat{s}) and λ=1/(β0)2\lambda=1/(\beta_0)^2, respectively. In Eq. (27), sgn⁡(ρ)\operatorname{sgn}(\rho) is the sign function for the variable ρ=s^−s−2u\rho=\hat{s}-s-2u.

In addition, we need to consider the contribution coming from the interference of the two amplitudes for subprocesses (a) and (b),

dσIds^dud(cos⁡θ)dφ=αem3β08πs22β0s^ϵ(1+ϵ)[c0cos⁡θ+c1cos⁡3θ+c2sin⁡θcos⁡φ+c3sin⁡(2θ)cos⁡θcos⁡φ].(28)\frac{d\sigma_{\mathrm{I}}}{d\hat{s}dud(\cos\theta)d\varphi}=\frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{em}}^3\beta_0}{8\pi s^2}\frac{\sqrt{2}\beta_0}{\sqrt{\hat{s}\epsilon}(1+\epsilon)}\left[c_0\cos\theta+c_1\cos^3\theta+c_2\sin\theta\cos\varphi+c_3\sin(2\theta)\cos\theta\cos\varphi\right]. \tag*{(28)}

where the coefficients cic_i are expressed as

c0=2sgn⁡(ρ)ϵ(1−ϵ)2x(x−1)[Re⁡(FVGM∗)+Re⁡(FSGE∗)],c1=2(β0)2sgn⁡(ρ)ϵ(1−ϵ)2x(x−1)[(λ−1)Re⁡(FVGE∗)−λRe⁡(FVGM∗)],c2=2[1−(1−x)(1+ϵ)]Re⁡(FAGM∗)+2[1−(1−x)(1−ϵ)]Re⁡(FSGE∗),c3=(β0)2[1−(1−x)(1−ϵ)][(λ−1)Re⁡(FVGE∗)−λRe⁡(FVGM∗)].(29)\begin{aligned} c_0 &= 2\operatorname{sgn}(\rho)\sqrt{\epsilon(1-\epsilon)}\sqrt{2x(x-1)}\left[\operatorname{Re}(\mathcal{F}_V G_M^*)+\operatorname{Re}(\mathcal{F}_S G_E^*)\right],\\ c_1 &= 2(\beta_0)^2\operatorname{sgn}(\rho)\sqrt{\epsilon(1-\epsilon)}\sqrt{2x(x-1)}\left[(\lambda-1)\operatorname{Re}(\mathcal{F}_V G_E^*)-\lambda\operatorname{Re}(\mathcal{F}_V G_M^*)\right],\\ c_2 &= 2[1-(1-x)(1+\epsilon)]\operatorname{Re}(\mathcal{F}_A G_M^*)+2[1-(1-x)(1-\epsilon)]\operatorname{Re}(\mathcal{F}_S G_E^*),\\ c_3 &= (\beta_0)^2[1-(1-x)(1-\epsilon)]\left[(\lambda-1)\operatorname{Re}(\mathcal{F}_V G_E^*)-\lambda\operatorname{Re}(\mathcal{F}_V G_M^*)\right]. \tag*{(29)} \end{aligned}

The timelike Compton FFs depend on the baryon GDAs, which only appear in the cross sections of Eqs. (24) and (28). There are no Compton FFs in the cross section of the ISR subprocess (b), which gives the largest contribution in e−e+→BB‾γe^-e^+ \to B\overline{B}\gamma; this may be understood, provided that the timelike Compton FFs and GFFs are of the comparable magnitude, by the simple scaling rule:

dσG:dσI:dσISR∼1s:1ss^:1s^.(30)d\sigma_G : d\sigma_I : d\sigma_{\mathrm{ISR}} \sim\frac{1}{s} : \frac{1}{\sqrt{s\hat{s}}} : \frac{1}{\hat{s}}. \tag*{(30)}

A full extraction of baryon GDAs from the cross section necessitates studying the interference contribution in Eq. (28). This is because baryon GDAs are complex functions, meaning Eq. (24) alone cannot fully constrain the reconstruction of the timelike Compton FFs. Crucially, the interference term allows the extraction of the Compton FFs’ imaginary phases, provided the EM FFs are used as inputs. If we consider the exchange of (θ,φ)→(π−θ,π+φ)(\theta,\varphi)\to(\pi-\theta,\pi+\varphi) in the cross sections, Eqs. (24) and (26) will remain the same, however, a minus sign will appear in Eq. (28) because of the different charge conjugation of the baryon-antibaryon pair in the subprocesses (a) and (b). Thus, the interference contribution can be obtained from taking the difference of the cross-section in this exchange, dσ(BB‾)−dσ(B‾B)=2dσId\sigma(B\overline{B})-d\sigma(\overline{B}B)=2d\sigma_I.

Numerical Estimates of the Cross Sections

For the numerical calculation of the cross sections, we need to use the EM FFs and GDAs as inputs, and we explain here the models of the EM FFs and GDAs that are adopted in this work. The effective proton EM FF3 contains two ingredients [56],

Fp(s^)=F3p(s^)+Fosc(p),(31)F_p(\hat{s})=F_{3p}(\hat{s})+F_{\mathrm{osc}}(p), \tag*{(31)}

where the three-pole component F3p(s)F_{3p}(s) gives the dominant contribution and Fosc(p)F_{\mathrm{osc}}(p) describes a periodic oscillating behavior. These functions are expressed as

F3p(s^)=F0(1+s^m02)(1−s^m02)2,Fosc(p)=Ae−Bpcos⁡(Cp+D),(32)\begin{aligned} F_{3p}(\hat{s})&=\frac{F_0}{\left(1+\frac{\hat{s}}{m_0^2}\right)\left(1-\frac{\hat{s}}{m_0^2}\right)^2},\\ F_{\mathrm{osc}}(p)&=Ae^{-Bp}\cos(Cp+D), \tag*{(32)} \end{aligned}

with

p=s^(s^4m2−1).(33)p=\sqrt{\hat{s}\left(\frac{\hat{s}}{4m^2}-1\right)}. \tag*{(33)}

The modulus of the ratio of the timelike electric and magnetic FFs is denoted as R(s^)=∣GE(s^)∣/∣GM(s^)∣R(\hat{s})=|G_E(\hat{s})|/|G_M(\hat{s})|, and is parameterized as [57]

R(s^)=11+ω2/r0[1+r1e−r2ωsin⁡(r3ω)],ω=s^−2m.(34)R(\hat{s})=\frac{1}{1+\omega^2/r_0}\left[1+r_1e^{-r_2\omega}\sin(r_3\omega)\right],\qquad\omega=\sqrt{\hat{s}}-2m. \tag*{(34)}

Then, GEG_E and GMG_M are expressed in terms of the effective EM FF FpF_p and the ratio RR,

∣GE(s^)∣=Fp(s^)1+2τ1+2τ/R(s^)2,∣GM(s^)∣=Fp(s^)1+2τR(s^)2+2τ.(35)\begin{aligned} \lvert G_E(\hat{s})\rvert&= F_p(\hat{s})\sqrt{\frac{1+2\tau}{1+2\tau/R(\hat{s})^2}},\\ \lvert G_M(\hat{s})\rvert&= F_p(\hat{s})\sqrt{\frac{1+2\tau}{R(\hat{s})^2+2\tau}}. \tag*{(35)} \end{aligned}

The authors of Ref. [57] perform a global analysis of recent experimental measurements on e+e−→ppˉe^+e^- \to p\bar{p}, and the parameters of the effective FF FpF_p and the ratio RR are summarised in Table I. We neglect the imaginary phases of EM FFs GEG_E and GMG_M in the numerical estimate, as our knowledge of the imaginary phases is quite limited at the current stage.

F0F_09.7DD0.04r1r_10.5
AA0.073m02 (GeV2)m_0^2\ (\mathrm{GeV}^2)0.71r2 (GeV−1)r_2\ (\mathrm{GeV}^{-1})1.5
B (GeV−1)B\ (\mathrm{GeV}^{-1})1.05ma2 (GeV2)m_a^2\ (\mathrm{GeV}^2)7.1r3 (GeV−1)r_3\ (\mathrm{GeV}^{-1})9.3
C (GeV−1)C\ (\mathrm{GeV}^{-1})5.51r0r_03

Table I. Parameters are obtained from a global fit for the effective FF FpF_p and the ratio RR [57].

The proton-antiproton GDAs or the timelike Compton FFs are completely unknown. In this work, we assume that the vector GDAs are of a similar magnitude for the proton-antiproton and dipion meson cases,

ΦSq∼ΦVq∼Φππq,(36)\Phi_S^q \sim\Phi_V^q \sim\Phi_{\pi\pi}^q, \tag*{(36)}

and the latter has been extracted from experimental measurements [5]. The pion vector GDA is expressed as

Φππq(z,cos⁡θ,s^)=3(2α+3)5B(α+1,α+1)zα(1−z)α(2z−1)[B~10q(s^)+B~12q(s^)P2(cos⁡θ)].(37)\Phi_{\pi\pi}^q(z,\cos\theta,\hat{s}) = \frac{3(2\alpha+3)}{5B(\alpha+1,\alpha+1)} z^\alpha(1-z)^\alpha(2z-1) \left[\widetilde{B}_{10}^q(\hat{s})+\widetilde{B}_{12}^q(\hat{s})P_2(\cos\theta)\right]. \tag*{(37)}

where α=1.157\alpha=1.157, and B(a,b)B(a,b) is Euler’s beta function. The complex functions B~nl\widetilde{B}_{nl} are dependent on the invariant mass of the pion pair, and their imaginary parts are given by the phases δl\delta_l,

B~nlq(s^)=B‾nlq(s^)eiδl.(38)\widetilde{B}_{nl}^q(\hat{s})=\overline{B}_{nl}^q(\hat{s})e^{i\delta_l}. \tag*{(38)}

Since the relative phase δ0−δ2\delta_0-\delta_2 is only determined below s^=4 GeV2\hat{s}=4\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 through the analysis of Belle measurements, and since perturbative QCD arguments show that the phases will be suppressed by αs\alpha_s for the large s^\hat{s}-region [76] [31], we will ignore the phases δl\delta_l in our numerical estimate of the proton pair production. The real parts of B~nl\widetilde{B}_{nl} are parameterized as

B‾10q(s^)=−10Rq9(1+2m2s^)Fq(s^),B‾12q(s^)=10Rq9(1−4m2s^)Fq(s^).(39)\begin{aligned} \overline{B}_{10}^q(\hat{s}) &= -\frac{10R_q}{9}\left(1+\frac{2m^2}{\hat{s}}\right)F_q(\hat{s}),\\ \overline{B}_{12}^q(\hat{s}) &= \frac{10R_q}{9}\left(1-\frac{4m^2}{\hat{s}}\right)F_q(\hat{s}). \tag*{(39)} \end{aligned}

with

Fq(s^)=1[1+(s^−4m2)/Λ2]2,(40)F_q(\hat{s})=\frac{1}{\left[1+(\hat{s}-4m^2)/\Lambda^2\right]^2}, \tag*{(40)}

where Ru=1/3R_u=1/3, Rd=1/6R_d=1/6, Λ=1.928 GeV\Lambda=1.928\ \mathrm{GeV}, and we replace the pion mass with the proton mass mm. The resonance contribution is neglected in Eq. (39). The corresponding Compton FF is expressed as

Fπ=∑qeq22∫01dz 2z−1zzˉΦππq(z,ζ0,s^).(41)F_\pi=\sum_q\frac{e_q^2}{2}\int_0^1 dz\,\frac{2z-1}{z\bar{z}}\Phi_{\pi\pi}^q(z,\zeta_0,\hat{s}). \tag*{(41)}

Combining Eqs. (41), (36), and (22), we can derive

FS=Fπ,ζ0FV=Fπcos⁡θ,(42)F_S = F_\pi, \qquad \zeta_0 F_V = F_\pi\cos\theta, \tag*{(42)}

where cos⁡θ\cos\theta appears to make sure that FVF_V is a even function of cos⁡θ\cos\theta. Since there are no studies on the axial-vector GDAs ΦSq\Phi_S^q and ΦVq\Phi_V^q, we just express their corresponding Compton FFs as

FA=FP=gAFπ,(43)F_A = F_P = g_A F_\pi, \tag*{(43)}

where gA=eugAu+edgAdg_A = e_u g_A^u + e_d g_A^d, and the recent lattice QCD results indicate gAu=0.832g_A^u = 0.832 and gAd=−0.417g_A^d = -0.417 for the axial charges [77].

Now we use the models of EM FFs and GDAs we have discussed to calculate the cross sections for the process e+e−→ppˉγe^+e^- \to p\bar{p}\gamma. After integration over azimuthal angle, the differential cross sections are expressed as

dσISRds^dud(cos⁡θ)=αem3β032s21ϵs^[b0+b1cos⁡2θ+b2sin⁡2θ],dσGds^dud(cos⁡θ)=αem3β04s311+ϵ[∣FA∣2−∣FS∣2+2Re⁡(FAFP∗)+s^(∣FP∣2+∣FS∣2)4m2+(β0)2cos⁡2θ[∣FV∣2+2Re⁡(FSFV∗)−∣FA∣2]−(β0)4cos⁡4θ∣FV∣2],dσIds^dud(cos⁡θ)=αem3(β0)24s22ss^ϵ(1+ϵ)[c0cos⁡θ+c1cos⁡3θ].(44)\begin{aligned} \frac{d\sigma_{\mathrm{ISR}}}{d\hat{s}du d(\cos\theta)} &= \frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{em}}^3\beta_0^3}{2s^2}\frac{1}{\epsilon\hat{s}}\left[b_0+b_1\cos^2\theta+b_2\sin^2\theta\right],\\ \frac{d\sigma_G}{d\hat{s}du d(\cos\theta)} &= \frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{em}}^3\beta_0}{4s^3}\frac{1}{1+\epsilon}\left[\left|F_A\right|^2-\left|F_S\right|^2+2\operatorname{Re}\left(F_A F_P^*\right)+\frac{\hat{s}\left(\left|F_P\right|^2+\left|F_S\right|^2\right)}{4m^2}\right.\\ &\qquad\left.+(\beta_0)^2\cos^2\theta\left[\left|F_V\right|^2+2\operatorname{Re}\left(F_S F_V^*\right)-\left|F_A\right|^2\right]-(\beta_0)^4\cos^4\theta\left|F_V\right|^2\right],\\ \frac{d\sigma_I}{d\hat{s}du d(\cos\theta)} &= \frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{em}}^3(\beta_0)^2}{4s^2}\frac{\sqrt{2}}{\sqrt{s\hat{s}\epsilon(1+\epsilon)}}\left[c_0\cos\theta+c_1\cos^3\theta\right]. \tag*{(44)} \end{aligned}

The maximum values are s=5.6\sqrt{s}=5.6 GeV and s=7\sqrt{s}=7 GeV for the center-of-mass energy of e+e−e^+e^- at BESIII and the proposed STCF, respectively, and the designed peak luminosity of STCF can be 0.5×1035 cm−2s−10.5\times10^{35}\ {\rm cm}^{-2}{\rm s}^{-1} or higher [38], which indicates that precise measurements of e−e+→BBˉγe^-e^+\to B\bar{B}\gamma will be possible at STCF. We choose s=4\sqrt{s}=4 GeV in this numerical estimate, and this value should be typical for these two experimental facilities. To satisfy the QCD factorization condition s≫s^s\gg\hat{s}, we use the range 2.02.0 GeV <W=s^<< W=\sqrt{\hat{s}} < 2.72.7 GeV for the invariant mass of the proton-antiproton pair.

The cross section of the ISR process is depicted in Figure 5, and we choose cos⁡θ=0.2\cos\theta=0.2 and cos⁡θ=0.6\cos\theta=0.6 for the red and blue lines, respectively. The variable u=−2 GeV2u=-2\ {\rm GeV}^2 is fixed for the solid lines, and the dashed ones are for u=−4 GeV2u=-4\ {\rm GeV}^2. Since we only use the magnitude of baryon EM FFs ∣GE∣\left|G_E\right| and ∣GM∣\left|G_M\right| as inputs, and these FFs have been constrained in the recent experiments, the result for the ISR process should be regarded as a rather precise prediction.

Differential cross section of the ISR process

Figure 5. The differential cross section of the ISR process e−e+→γ∗γ→ppˉγe^-e^+\to\gamma^*\gamma\to p\bar{p}\gamma.

Moreover, this process is not described in terms of a QCD twist expansion. In Figure 6, the differential cross section of e−e+→γ∗→ppˉγe^{-}e^{+} \to\gamma^{*} \to p\bar{p}\gamma is provided, with same conventions as those in Figure 5. The ISR contribution is much larger than the GDA contribution as expected. However, the latter does not decrease rapidly with the growing invariant mass of the baryon pair, which is different from the ISR case. This behavior appears due to the functional form choosen here for the nucleon-antinucleon GDAs. As our knowledge is quite limited for the baryon GDAs, further theoretical and experimental studies on the baryon-antibaryon GDAs are necessary for a more precise evaluation of this GDA contribution.

Differential cross section of electron-positron annihilation into a proton-antiproton pair and a photon

Figure 6. The differential cross section of e−e+→γ∗→ppˉγe^{-}e^{+} \to\gamma^{*} \to p\bar{p}\gamma.

Baryon-antibaryon asymmetry

The different charge-conjugation properties of the ISR and QCD process allows to define and exploit a new and most interesting observable, namely a baryon-antibaryon asymmetry. This procedure is very similar to the charge asymmetry observable defined in the TCS process [78] and used in the first observation of the TCS process in the JLab-CLAS experiment [79]. Since in the BBˉB\bar{B} center of mass frame, the baryon and antibaryon 33-momenta are opposite, one may define a differential asymmetry as

A(θ,φ)=dσ(θ,φ)dcos⁡θ dφ−dσ(π−θ,φ+π)dcos⁡θ dφdσ(θ,φ)dcos⁡θ dφ+dσ(π−θ,φ+π)dcos⁡θ dφ,(45)A(\theta,\varphi) = \frac{\frac{d\sigma(\theta,\varphi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi} - \frac{d\sigma(\pi-\theta,\varphi+\pi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi}}{\frac{d\sigma(\theta,\varphi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi} + \frac{d\sigma(\pi-\theta,\varphi+\pi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi}}, \tag*{(45)}

or one can integrate over one hemisphere (i.e. π/2<φ<3π/2\pi/2 < \varphi< 3\pi/2) and subtract the integration over the complementary region, to get a forward-backward asymmetry:

AFB(θ)=∫π/23π/2dφdσ(θ,φ)dcos⁡θ dφ−∫3π/22πdφdσ(π−θ,φ)dcos⁡θ dφ−∫0π/2dφdσ(π−θ,φ)dcos⁡θ dφ∫π/23π/2dφdσ(θ,φ)dcos⁡θ dφ+∫3π/22πdφdσ(π−θ,φ)dcos⁡θ dφ+∫0π/2dφdσ(π−θ,φ)dcos⁡θ dφ.(46)A_{FB}(\theta) = \frac{\int_{\pi/2}^{3\pi/2} d\varphi\frac{d\sigma(\theta,\varphi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi} - \int_{3\pi/2}^{2\pi} d\varphi\frac{d\sigma(\pi-\theta,\varphi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi} - \int_{0}^{\pi/2} d\varphi\frac{d\sigma(\pi-\theta,\varphi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi}}{\int_{\pi/2}^{3\pi/2} d\varphi\frac{d\sigma(\theta,\varphi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi} + \int_{3\pi/2}^{2\pi} d\varphi\frac{d\sigma(\pi-\theta,\varphi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi} + \int_{0}^{\pi/2} d\varphi\frac{d\sigma(\pi-\theta,\varphi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi}}. \tag*{(46)}

As one easily sees from Eq. (28), the interference term is the only contribution that survives in the numerator and it does not contribute to the denominator. Denoting the numerator of AFBA_{FB} as ∫ΔφdφdΔσ(θ,φ)dcos⁡θ dφ\int_{\Delta\varphi}d\varphi\frac{d\Delta\sigma(\theta,\varphi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi}, one gets:

dσFBds du d^(cos⁡θ)=∫ΔφdφdΔσ(θ,φ)dcos⁡θ dφ=αemβ038πs22β0sε(1+ε)[2π(c0cos⁡θ+c1cos⁡3θ)−4(c2sin⁡θ+c3sin⁡(2θ)cos⁡θ)].(47)\begin{aligned} \frac{d\sigma_{FB}}{ds\,du\,d\hat{}(\cos\theta)} = \int_{\Delta\varphi}d\varphi\frac{d\Delta\sigma(\theta,\varphi)}{d\cos\theta\,d\varphi} \\ &= \frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{em}}\beta_{0}^{3}}{8\pi s^{2}}\frac{\sqrt{2}\beta_{0}}{\sqrt{s\varepsilon(1+\varepsilon)}}\left[2\pi(c_{0}\cos\theta+c_{1}\cos^{3}\theta)-4(c_{2}\sin\theta+c_{3}\sin(2\theta)\cos\theta)\right]. \tag*{(47)} \end{aligned}

We show on Figure 7 this difference of cross sections as a function of the invariant mass of the proton-antiproton pair WW, and u=−2 GeV2u=-2\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2} (−4 GeV2-4\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2}) is chosen for the solid (dashed) lines. The colors (red, blue) of lines represent different values of cos⁡θ\cos\theta (±0.2\pm0.2, ±0.6\pm0.6). The cross section increases from W=2.0 GeVW = 2.0\ \mathrm{GeV} to 2.1 GeV2.1\ \mathrm{GeV} with the growing phase space, whereas beyond the peak it decreases as WW rises, due to diminishing Compton FFs and EM FFs. We find that the interference term is larger than the pure QCD contribution in Figure 6, which means that this baryon-antibaryon asymmetry should play an important role in the future extraction of baryon GDAs. Let us stress that almost nothing is known about the baryon-antibaryon GDAs at the current stage, and the actual GDAs could be significantly different from the model we use in this work. Thus, our numerical results of the interference term and the GDA contribution can be only considered as order-of-magnitude estimates for the cross section.

Two panels showing the cross section difference as a function of the invariant mass W for different values of cos theta and u

Figure 7. The cross section difference (Eq. (47)) allows to measure the interference term of e−e+→ppˉγe^-e^+ \to p\bar{p}\gamma. It depends on the invariant mass of the proton-antiproton pair and on the polar angle θ\theta of the nucleon.

Summary

The hadronic GPDs are three-dimensional functions of hadrons, which are accessed in the exclusive processes such as the DVCS reaction γ∗h→γh\gamma^* h \to\gamma h. The second moments of GPDs lead to the hadronic matrix elements of the EMT operator, which are parametrized in terms of EMT FFs. If we take the ss-tt crossed channel of DVCS, namely the reaction γ∗γ→hhˉ\gamma^*\gamma\to h\bar{h}, hadronic GDAs are involved. GDAs can be regarded as the timelike crossed GPDs; thus, the study of GDAs sheds light on the GPDs and vice versa. The extraction of GDAs from experimental cross sections is possible even for the unstable hadrons, and corresponding measurements can be conducted at many electron-positron facilities.

In this work, we investigate the process e+e−→BBˉγe^+e^- \to B\bar{B}\gamma, which depends on two subprocesses: the ISR process and e+e−→γ∗→BBˉγe^+e^- \to\gamma^* \to B\bar{B}\gamma. The ISR process is described by the baryon EM FFs, and using QCD factorization, the amplitude of the latter subprocess can be factorized into two ingredients : the hard amplitude γ∗→qqˉγ\gamma^* \to q\bar{q}\gamma and the non-perturbative hadronic matrix element describing the process qqˉ→BBˉq\bar{q} \to B\bar{B}, known as the baryon-antibaryon GDAs. The relations between the baryon GDAs and timelike EMT FFs are discussed, and these FFs can be used to study the spin decompositions and D-terms of the baryons. We calculate the cross sections of e+e−→BBˉγe^+e^- \to B\bar{B}\gamma at twist 2, and they are expressed in terms of the timelike baryon Compton FFs and EM FFs. Even though there are now no detailed theoretical or experimental studies on the baryon-antibaryon GDAs, we try to build a model for the proton-antiproton GDAs. For the proton EM FFs, they have been extracted from recent experimental measurements. Using these proton-antiproton GDAs and EM FFs, we have provided numerical estimates for the process e+e−→ppˉγe^+e^- \to p\bar{p}\gamma, which should be helpful to future measurements of this process at BESIII, Belle II, and the proposed STCF.

This work is but a first step in the analysis of the reaction e+e−→ppˉγe^+e^- \to p\bar{p}\gamma. The mass of the nucleon makes quite uncertain the validity of the assumption s^≪s\hat{s} \ll s where the GDA factorization is proven. Higher twist corrections of O(s^/s)O(\hat{s}/s) should be evaluated before any precise extraction of baryon-antibaryon GDAs. Part of these higher twist corrections, the so-called kinematic higher twist ones [80], which have been estimated for DVCS and TCS [81, 82], can readily be computed for this reaction, as it has been done for the reaction e+e−→ππγe^+e^- \to\pi\pi\gamma, [?, ?]. We shall deal with these corrections, as well as with the leading-twist NLO corrections in αs\alpha_s, in a future work.

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge useful discussions with Dr. Xiao-Yu Wang. Qin-Tao Song was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant Number 12005191.

References

  1. [52]G. Gong et al. [Belle], Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) no.7, 072008
  2. [53]M. Ablikim et al. [BESIII], Phys. Lett. B 831 (2022), 137187
  3. [54]M. Ablikim et al. [BESIII], Phys. Lett. B 820 (2021), 136557
  4. [55]M. Ablikim et al. [BESIII], Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) no.1, 012005
  5. [56]A. Bianconi and E. Tomasi-Gustafsson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114 (2015) no.23, 232301
  6. [57]E. Tomasi-Gustafsson, A. Bianconi and S. Pacetti, Phys. Rev. C 103 (2021) no.3, 035203
  7. [58]E. L. Lomon and S. Pacetti, Phys. Rev. D 85 (2012), 113004 [erratum: Phys. Rev. D 86 (2012), 039901]
  8. [59]R. Q. Qian, Z. W. Liu, X. Cao and X. Liu, Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) no.9, L091502
  9. [60]B. Yan, C. Chen, X. Li and J. J. Xie, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) no.3, 036033
  10. [61]K. S. Kuzmin, N. M. Levashov and M. I. Krivoruchenko, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) no.1, 1
  11. [62]A. Bianconi and E. Tomasi-Gustafsson, Phys. Rev. C 105 (2022) no.6, 065206
  12. [63]Q. H. Yang, D. Guo, M. Y. Li, L. Y. Dai, J. Haidenbauer and U. G. Meißner, JHEP 08 (2024), 208
  13. [64]X. Cao, J. P. Dai and H. Lenske, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) no.7, L071503
  14. [65]Y. H. Lin, H. W. Hammer and U. G. Meißner, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128 (2022) no.5, 052002
  15. [66]M. Diehl, P. Kroll and C. Vogt, Eur. Phys. J. C 26 (2003), 567-577
  16. [67]A. Freund, A. V. Radyushkin, A. Schafer and C. Weiss, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90 (2003), 092001
  17. [68]H. Pagels, Phys. Rev. 144 (1966), 1250-1260
  18. [69]I. Y. Kobzarev and L. B. Okun, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 43 (1962), 1904-1909
  19. [70]M. Diehl, Phys. Rept. 388 (2003), 41-277
  20. [71]B. L. G. Bakker, E. Leader and T. L. Trueman, Phys. Rev. D 70 (2004), 114001
  21. [72]C. Lorcé, P. Schweitzer and K. Tezgin, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) no.1, 014012
  22. [73]M. V. Polyakov and C. Weiss, Phys. Rev. D 60 (1999), 114017
  23. [74]H. Czyż, A. Grzelinska and J. H. Kühn, Phys. Rev. D 75 (2007), 074026
  24. [75]G. Fäldt, Eur. Phys. J. A 51 (2015) no.7, 74
  25. [76]M. Diehl, T. Feldmann, P. Kroll and C. Vogt, Phys. Rev. D 61 (2000), 074029
  26. [77]C. Alexandrou, S. Bacchio, J. Finkenrath, C. Iona, G. Koutsou, Y. Li and G. Spanoudes, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) no.5, 054505
  27. [78]E. R. Berger, M. Diehl and B. Pire, Eur. Phys. J. C 23 (2002), 675-689
  28. [79]P. Chatagnon et al. [CLAS], Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 (2021) no.26, 262501
  29. [80]V. M. Braun and A. N. Manashov, JHEP 01 (2012), 085
  30. [81]V. M. Braun, A. N. Manashov, D. Müller and B. M. Pirnay, Phys. Rev. D 89 (2014) no.7, 074022
  31. [82]V. Martinez-Fernandez, B. Pire, P. Sznajder and J. Wagner, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) no.7, 074034

Paper details

vlnc:W_fkdccagv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents