betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Radiative corrections to weak interaction processes

Abstract

The search for physics beyond the Standard Model in low-energy weak interaction processes requires a precise knowledge of the Standard Model background at tree- and loop-level. In many such cases, radiative corrections represent one of the major sources of theory uncertainty due to the non-perturbative structures of nucleon or nuclei. In this review, I discuss several modern strategies based on dispersion relation, lattice gauge theory and nuclear many-body calculations to pin down the hadronic and nuclear uncertainties in the radiative corrections to low-energy weak interaction processes such as beta decays and parity-violating electron-nucleus scattering.

Key points

  • Non-perturbative strong interaction physics in radiative corrections resides in the generalized Compton tensor TμνT^{\mu\nu}

  • Dispersion relation connects TμνT^{\mu\nu} to structure functions that can be inferred from experiments, leading to the data-driven analysis of radiative corrections.

  • For meson and single nucleon, TμνT^{\mu\nu} can also be computed with lattice QCD.

  • In nuclear systems, the impact from the low-energy part of TμνT^{\mu\nu} can be computed either in terms of nuclear Green’s function or nuclear matrix elements of effective two-body potentials, both with cutting-edge nuclear ab initio techniques.

Introduction

Understanding the fundamental interactions between the elementary constituents in the universe is one of the ultimate goals in basics sciences. At the present, the Standard Model (SM) of particle physics [1, 2, 3] provides the best description of this subject. In this theory, the spectrum of elementary particles consists of six leptons (e,μ,τ,νe,νμ,ντe,\mu,\tau,\nu_e,\nu_\mu,\nu_\tau), six quarks (u,d,s,c,b,tu,d,s,c,b,t) and their anti-particles, which interact through the exchange of gauge bosons: gluons from the SU(3)cSU(3)_c gauge group that transmit the strong force, γ\gamma, WW and ZZ in the SU(2)L×U(1)YSU(2)_L \times U(1)_Y gauge group that transmit the electromagnetic (EM) and weak (electroweak) forces. The SM and weak forces is one of the most successful theory in physics ever, which is known to pass almost all experimental tests conducted on the earth. However, despite such huge success, it does not account for many important observed phenomena at the largest scale, such as the existence of dark energy [4, 5, 6], dark matter [4, 7, 8, 9], and the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe [4, 10]. Therefore, it is now a consensus that the SM is an incomplete theory that needs to be extended.

The search for physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM), or new physics in short, can proceed along a few different directions. One major direction is the “energy frontier”: by colliding highly energetic particle beams in colliders, one hopes to create new particles not included in the list of particles above. The Large Hadron Collider (LHC), for instance, serves this purpose at TeV scale. However, after the discovery of Higgs boson in 2012 that completed the SM particle spectrum [11, 12], there is so far no definitive evidence of any new particle being observed in collider experiments. Therefore, further progress along this direction will inevitably involve constructions of even more energetic particle colliders. Another direction, known as “precision frontier” (or “intensity frontier”, which I will use interchangeably), proceed as follows: experiments are done at a much lower energy scale to measure certain observable to extremely high precision. With this, one compares the result of the experimental measurement and the theory prediction from the SM; any confirmed discrepancy between the two beyond uncertainties would indicate the existence of new physics. Efforts at both frontiers are equally important to provide a more complete picture of new physics.

An important class of efforts at the precision frontier is the test of “fundamental symmetries” in SM, such as charge conjugation (C), parity (P), time reversal (T), and so on. In the SM, these symmetries are only broken by the weak interaction, which is much weaker than the strong and EM interactions. This means, testing how much these fundamental symmetries are broken provides a powerful avenue to probe signals of new physics with reduced SM background. The effective field theory (EFT) description of BSM physics provides a useful guidance for the precision goal of low energy experiments [13, 14, 15, 16, 17]: if new physics appears as dimension-six operators, its impact on electroweak observables may scale as (vH/Λ)2(v_H/\Lambda)^2, where vH∼246v_H \sim246 GeV is the Higgs vacuum expectation value, and Λ\Lambda is the characteristic energy scale of new physics. This power counting implies that, to probe new physics at ∼10\sim10 TeV scale in electroweak observables, one generally requires a precision of 10−3−10−410^{-3} - 10^{-4}. This represents a real challenge not only from the experimental side, but also the side in terms of the SM theory predictions of the observable of interest.

In this article we discuss an important class of SM effects known as EM radiative corrections (RC), that affects various weak interaction-induced processes such as decays and scatterings. These are corrections on top of the tree-level amplitude due to spontaneous emission and re-absorption of virtual photons, as well as the emission of real photons, by the interacting system. At one loop, it affects is of the order α/π∼10−3\alpha/\pi\sim10^{-3} or above, which means it needs to be computed to high accuracy to match our precision goal. If photons would just couple with leptons, then the evaluation of RC would be just a multi-loop problem in Quantum Electrodynamics (QED) which can be computed using standard diagrammatic technique. The real issue, however, is that photons also interact with quarks, and the latter form hadrons due to the strong interaction governed by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). Therefore, RC represents a mixture between the perturbative QED and the non-perturbative QCD, and the latter is the main source of theory uncertainty. To pin down the hadron and nuclear physics in the RC require fully non-perturbative methods such as dispersion relation, lattice QCD or ab initio nuclear many body methods.

The proper control of hadronic or nuclear uncertainties in RC is known to play a decisive role in the precision tests of the SM. A well-known example is the muon g−2g - 2 problem, which status has recently changed from having a 4σ4\sigma tension with the SM [18, 19] to almost consistent with the SM [20, 21]. This drastic change is due to a new lattice QCD calculation of the leading-order hadronic vacuum polarization, which is an important RC to the EM interaction of muon [22]. The same situation may also occur in weak interaction processes. In this article we will focus on two types of processes: (1) charged weak (CW) decays, and (2) parity-violating electron scattering. We will discuss their roles in the test of SM and the review the existing effort in pinning down the RC.

Basic notations and targets of study

We start by introducing the notations adopted in this article. Since our ultimate goal is to test the predictions of the SM in the electroweak (EM + weak) sector, it is instructive to first write down the SM electroweak interaction Lagrangian between quarks and gauge bosons1:

L=−g22(JWμWμ++h.c.)−eJemμAμ−g2cwJZμZμ,(1)\mathcal{L}=-\frac{g}{2\sqrt{2}}\left(J_W^\mu W_\mu^+ + \mathrm{h.c.}\right)-eJ_{\mathrm{em}}^\mu A_\mu-\frac{g}{2c_w}J_Z^\mu Z_\mu, \tag*{(1)}

where e,ge,g are the EM and weak coupling constants, cw=cos⁡θwc_w=\cos\theta_w, sw=sin⁡θws_w=\sin\theta_w with θw\theta_w the weak mixing angle. The electroweak currents read:

Jemμ=euuˉγμu+eddˉγμdJWμ=uˉiVijγμ(1−γ5)djJZμ=uˉiγμ(gVu+gAuγ5)ui+dˉiγμ(gVd+gAdγ5)di.(2)\begin{aligned} J_{\mathrm{em}}^\mu&= e_u\bar{u}\gamma^\mu u+e_d\bar{d}\gamma^\mu d \\ J_W^\mu&= \bar{u}_iV_{ij}\gamma^\mu(1-\gamma_5)d_j \\ J_Z^\mu&= \bar{u}_i\gamma^\mu(g_V^u+g_A^u\gamma_5)u_i+\bar{d}_i\gamma^\mu(g_V^d+g_A^d\gamma_5)d_i . \tag*{(2)} \end{aligned}

Here we use the subscript ii to denote the generation of quark: u1,2,3={u,c,t}u_{1,2,3}=\{u,c,t\} and d1,2,3={d,s,b}d_{1,2,3}=\{d,s,b\}. VijV_{ij} is the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix that mixes different generation of quarks in the CW interaction [23, 24]. Meanwhile, eu=2/3e_u=2/3, ed=−1/3e_d=-1/3 are the electric charge of the quarks, and gVu=I3Lu−2eusw2g_V^u=I_{3L}^u-2e_us_w^2, gAu=I3Lug_A^u=I_{3L}^u are the vector and axial neutral charges of the quarks, with I3LuI_{3L}^u the third component of the weak isospin (I3Lu=1/2I_{3L}^u=1/2, I3Ld=−1/2I_{3L}^d=-1/2). Similar expressions can be written down in the lepton sector, except that for practical purpose one can take mν→0m_\nu\to0 which renders the flavor mixing matrix irrelevant.

The amplitude of weak interactions in hadron or nuclear systems at tree level simply consists of the hadronic or nuclear matrix elements of JWμJ_W^\mu or JZμJ_Z^\mu. The RC to tree-level amplitudes involves further insertions of the EM current JemμJ_{\mathrm{em}}^\mu. A particularly important matrix structure is the following “Generalized Compton tensor”:

Tμν(p′,p,q)=∫d4xeiq⋅x⟨ϕf(p′)∣T{Jemμ(x)Jaν(0)}∣ϕi(p)⟩,(3)T^{\mu\nu}(p',p,q)=\int d^{4}x e^{iq\cdot x}\langle\phi_f(p')|T\{J_{\mathrm{em}}^{\mu}(x)J_a^{\nu}(0)\}|\phi_i(p)\rangle, \tag*{(3)}

where JaνJ_a^\nu can either be the CW current JWνJ_W^\nu or the neutral weak (NW) current JZνJ_Z^\nu, and ϕi,f\phi_{i,f} are the initial and final hadron/nuclear state. This tensor represents the process where the system exchanges two bosons: a photon (couples to JemμJ_{\mathrm{em}}^\mu) with an outgoing momentum qq, and a weak boson (WW or ZZ, depends on the current JaνJ_a^\nu) with an incoming momentum p′−p+qp'-p+q (see Figure 1). In practical applications one often needs to work only in the p′→pp'\to p limit (forward limit), where the tensor adopts the following gauge-invariant decomposition:

Diagrammatic representation of the generalized Compton tensor

Figure 1. Diagrammatic representation of the generalized Compton tensor TμνT^{\mu\nu}.

Tμν(p,q)=(−gμν+qμqνq2)T1(ν,Q2)+(pμ−p⋅qq2qμ)(pν−p⋅qq2qν)T2(ν,Q2)p⋅q−iεμναβqαpβ2p⋅qT3(ν,Q2)+iεμναβqαp⋅q[sβS1(ν,Q2)+(sβ−s⋅qp⋅qpβ)S2(ν,Q2)]+⋯(4)\begin{aligned} T^{\mu\nu}(p,q)={}&\left(-g^{\mu\nu}+\frac{q^\mu q^\nu}{q^2}\right)T_1(\nu,Q^2)+\left(p^\mu-\frac{p\cdot q}{q^2}q^\mu\right)\left(p^\nu-\frac{p\cdot q}{q^2}q^\nu\right)\frac{T_2(\nu,Q^2)}{p\cdot q}\\ &-i\varepsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\frac{q_\alpha p_\beta}{2p\cdot q}T_3(\nu,Q^2)+i\varepsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\frac{q_\alpha}{p\cdot q}\left[s_\beta S_1(\nu,Q^2)+\left(s_\beta-\frac{s\cdot q}{p\cdot q}p_\beta\right)S_2(\nu,Q^2)\right]+\cdots \tag*{(4)} \end{aligned}

with Q2≡−q2Q^2\equiv-q^2, ν≡p⋅q/M\nu\equiv p\cdot q/M, MM the mass of the external state, and sμs^\mu is the spin vector of the external state.

The invariant functions TiT_i, SjS_j encode all the non-perturbative physics that enter the RC, so their precise determination is the key to reduce the theory uncertainties. Two possible ways to achieve this goal are as follows:

  1. Data-driven approach: In this approach one first expresses the discontinuity of TμνT^{\mu\nu} with respect to the variable ν\nu (the energy of the virtual gauge boson) in the physical region (ν>0\nu>0) as:

Disc⁡Tμν≡Tμν(ν+iϵ)−Tμν(ν−iϵ)=4πWμν(5)\operatorname{Disc}T^{\mu\nu}\equiv T^{\mu\nu}(\nu+i\epsilon)-T^{\mu\nu}(\nu-i\epsilon)=4\pi W^{\mu\nu} \tag*{(5)}

The hadronic tensor WμνW^{\mu\nu} is defined as:

Wμν(p,q)=14π∑X(2π)4δ4(p+q−pX)⟨f∣Jemμ∣X⟩⟨X∣Jaν∣i⟩=(−gμν+qμqνq2)F1(ν,Q2)+(pμ−p⋅qq2qμ)(pν−p⋅qq2qν)F2(ν,Q2)p⋅q−iεμναβqαpβ2p⋅qF3(ν,Q2)+iεμναβqαp⋅q[sβg1(ν,Q2)+(sβ−s⋅qp⋅qpβ)g2(ν,Q2)]+⋯ ,(6)\begin{aligned} W^{\mu\nu}(p,q)&=\frac{1}{4\pi}\sum_X(2\pi)^4\delta^4(p+q-p_X)\langle f|J_{\mathrm{em}}^\mu|X\rangle\langle X|J_a^\nu|i\rangle\\ &=\left(-g^{\mu\nu}+\frac{q^\mu q^\nu}{q^2}\right)F_1(\nu,Q^2)+\left(p^\mu-\frac{p\cdot q}{q^2}q^\mu\right)\left(p^\nu-\frac{p\cdot q}{q^2}q^\nu\right)\frac{F_2(\nu,Q^2)}{p\cdot q}\\ &\quad-i\varepsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\frac{q_\alpha p_\beta}{2p\cdot q}F_3(\nu,Q^2)+i\varepsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\frac{q_\alpha}{p\cdot q}\left[s_\beta g_1(\nu,Q^2)+\left(s_\beta-\frac{s\cdot q}{p\cdot q}p_\beta\right)g_2(\nu,Q^2)\right]+\cdots, \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

where XX denotes all possible on-shell intermediate states. The invariant functions FiF_i, gjg_j are known as “structure functions”; they depend on on-shell current matrix elements and can in principle be inferred from experimental data, in particular inclusive scattering cross sections. One then constructs a dispersion relation that relates the full invariant amplitudes to the corresponding structure functions. In this way, one converts the theory problem of computing the invariant amplitudes into an experimental problem of measuring the structure functions in the relevant kinematic regions.

  1. First-principles theory calculations: In parallel to the approach above, one may perform pure theory calculations of the invariant amplitudes in TμνT^{\mu\nu}, which requires fully non-perturbative treatments of QCD from first principles. By “first principles”, we mean computational methods that do not involve uncontrolled and non-improvable approximations. When ϕi,f\phi_{i,f} are mesons or single nucleon, lattice QCD represents the only applicable method for such purposes; it calculates QCD matrix elements by computing the QCD path integral numerically using Monte Carlo methods on a discretized spacetime grid. When the external states involve two or more nucleons, lattice QCD calculations become unviable; instead, one resorts to nuclear many-body methods. They involve two basic ingredients: (1) Highly precise few-body nuclear forces inferred from experimental data, and (2) special computational techniques to solve the many-body Schrödinger equation to obtain nuclear states. For (2), the last two decades have seen a drastic progress in the developments of so-called ab initio nuclear many-body methods; examples include No-Core Shell Model (NCSM) [25], Coupled-Cluster (CC) [26] and In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group (IMSRG) [27, 28] that are based on shell-model constructions, as well as Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) [29] and Nuclear Lattice Effective Field Theory (NLEFT) [30] that are based on Monte Carlo approaches similar to lattice QCD. The existence of different ab initio methods to compute the same nuclear matrix element provides a consistency check of the robustness of the final result.

Having all the necessary notations stated and the general strategy outlines, below let us provide a few case study for RC to weak interaction processes.

Charged weak decay: Lifetime

Testing the unitarity of the CKM matrix at the first row:

∣Vud∣2+∣Vus∣2+∣Vub∣2=1(7)|V_{ud}|^2 + |V_{us}|^2 + |V_{ub}|^2 = 1 \tag*{(7)}

provides a powerful probe of new physics at multi-TeV scale [31]. Among the various matrix elements, ∣Vud∣∼0.97|V_{ud}| \sim0.97 is numerically the largest and therefore demands the highest precision in its extraction. It can be extracted from various CW decays: semileptonic pion decay, free neutron decay, and nuclear beta decays. The extraction is a combined effort from experiment and theory. Schematically, it looks like:

1τ=∣Vud∣2GF2×∣Mhad∣2×(1+ΔR)×Fkin,(8)\frac{1}{\tau} = |V_{ud}|^2 G_F^2 \times|M_{\mathrm{had}}|^2 \times(1+\Delta_R) \times F_{\mathrm{kin}}, \tag*{(8)}

where τ\tau is the partial lifetime, GFG_F is Fermi’s constant, MhadM_{\mathrm{had}} is the tree-level hadronic matrix element, FkinF_{\mathrm{kin}} is a kinematic factor coming from the phase space integral, which may also include leading EM effects such as the Fermi function [32] as well as recoil corrections, and ΔR\Delta_R is the radiative correction. Experimentally, one needs to measure τ\tau and the QQ-value that enters FkinF_{\mathrm{kin}}; the part of MhadM_{\mathrm{had}} that involves axial current may also be measured through decay correlations. Theoretically, one needs to compute MhadM_{\mathrm{had}} (if it is not protected by symmetry), the SM corrections to FkinF_{\mathrm{kin}}, as well as ΔR\Delta_R.

The leading contribution to ΔR\Delta_R, which scales as O(α)O(\alpha), consists of one-loop diagrams with a virtual photon and bremsstrahlung contributions with the emission of a single real photon. Diagrams where the photon only interact with the lepton are perturbatively calculable using standard field theory approaches, but those with photons interacting with the hadrons are not. So, the first task is to isolate all terms in the O(α)O(\alpha) RC that are not perturbatively calculable from the rest. The first comprehensive approach for this purpose was developed by Sirlin [33], which was based on rigorous Ward identities derived from the current algebra between electroweak currents; these identities are protected from QCD corrections. Details of the method can be found in Ref.[34], and here we simply state the main conclusion: as far as the RC to the partial decay lifetime τ\tau is concerned, the only non-perturbative contribution to the O(α)O(\alpha) RC resides in the so-called γW\gamma W-box diagram (see Figure 2), where the lepton exchanges a photon and a WW-boson simultaneously with the hadron. Neglecting recoil corrections, the upper shaded blob in this diagram is exactly the generalized Compton tensor TμνT^{\mu\nu} defined in Eq. (3), with a=Wa=W. The corresponding one-loop integral takes the following form:

The $\gamma W$-box diagram

Figure 2. The γW\gamma W-box diagram.

□γW=ie22M2∫d4q(2π)4MW2MW2−q21q2ϵμναβqαqβTμνF+,(9)\Box_{\gamma W} = \frac{i e^2}{2M^2} \int\frac{d^4q}{(2\pi)^4} \frac{M_W^2}{M_W^2-q^2} \frac{1}{q^2} \epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q_\alpha q_\beta\frac{T_{\mu\nu}}{F_+}, \tag*{(9)}

where MM is the mass of the external hadron, F+F_+ is the tree-level decay amplitude, and the epsilon tensor comes from the lepton vertices and propagator. This integral picks up the anti-symmetric component of TμνT_{\mu\nu}. In what follows, we will use free neutron decay as an illustration of how this quantity is computed non-perturbatively.

Free neutron decay

The free neutron decay n→p+e−+νˉen \to p + e^- + \bar{\nu}_e is one of the most well-studied beta decay processes. At tree level, neglecting recoil corrections, the WW-boson couples with the nucleon through the following weak current matrix element:

⟨p∣JWμ∣n⟩=uˉpγμ(g^V+g^Aγ5)un,(10)\langle p|J_W^\mu|n\rangle= \bar{u}_p\gamma^\mu(\hat{g}_V+\hat{g}_A\gamma_5)u_n, \tag*{(10)}

where g^V\hat{g}_V and g^A\hat{g}_A are the (pure-QCD) vector and axial coupling constants, respectively. The vector coupling constant is protected by isospin symmetry, which gives g^V=1\hat{g}_V=1, while the axial coupling constant is not protected: g^A≈−1.27\hat{g}_A \approx-1.27. RC renormalize the two couplings as g^V→gV\hat{g}_V \to g_V, g^A→gA\hat{g}_A \to g_A, and the ratio of the two normalized couplings, λ=gA/gV\lambda= g_A/g_V, can be directly measured from various neutron decay correlations (note that we define λ<0\lambda< 0 throughout this paper).

Neutron decay provides one of the primary avenue for the extraction of ∣Vud∣|V_{ud}|. This is done through the following master formula:

∣Vud∣2=5024.7 sτn(1+3λ2)(1+ΔRV).(11)|V_{ud}|^2 = \frac{5024.7\ \mathrm{s}}{\tau_n(1+3\lambda^2)(1+\Delta_R^V)}. \tag*{(11)}

In the expression above, the experimental inputs are the decay lifetime τn\tau_n as well as the axial-to-vector ratio λ\lambda. The 5024.7 s in the numerator arises from the phase space integration, corrected by the Fermi function, recoil corrections and the energy-dependent part of the EM RC, which can be computed assuming nucleons are point-like particles. The remaining factor 1+ΔRV1+\Delta_R^V in the denominator encodes the universal, ultraviolet piece of the electroweak RC, as well as the hadron-structure-dependent EM RC.

The box diagram integral in Eq. (9) contributes to the renormalization of the vector and axial coupling constant:

gV=g~V(1+□γWV+…),gA=g~A(1+□γWA+…).(12)g_V=\tilde{g}_V(1+\Box_{\gamma W}^V+\ldots),\qquad g_A=\tilde{g}_A(1+\Box_{\gamma W}^A+\ldots). \tag*{(12)}

Utilizing the decomposition of TμνT^{\mu\nu} in Eq. (4), one obtains the following formula:

□γWV=e22mNg~V∫d4q(2π)4MW2MW2+Q21(Q2)2ν2+Q2νT3(ν,Q2)\Box_{\gamma W}^V=\frac{e^2}{2m_N\tilde{g}_V}\int\frac{d^4q}{(2\pi)^4}\frac{M_W^2}{M_W^2+Q^2}\frac{1}{(Q^2)^2}\frac{\nu^2+Q^2}{\nu}T_3(\nu,Q^2)
□γWA=e2mNg~A∫d4q(2π)4MW2MW2+Q21(Q2)2{ν2−2Q23νS1(ν,Q2)−Q2νS2(ν,Q2)}.(13)\Box_{\gamma W}^A=\frac{e^2}{m_N\tilde{g}_A}\int\frac{d^4q}{(2\pi)^4}\frac{M_W^2}{M_W^2+Q^2}\frac{1}{(Q^2)^2}\left\{\frac{\nu^2-2Q^2}{3\nu}S_1(\nu,Q^2)-\frac{Q^2}{\nu}S_2(\nu,Q^2)\right\}. \tag*{(13)}

In particular, the first line contributes to ΔRV\Delta_R^V:

ΔRV=2□γWV+…,(14)\Delta_R^V=2\Box_{\gamma W}^V+\ldots, \tag*{(14)}

where “+…+\ldots” are all remaining terms that depend only on physics at the weak scale and can be calculated perturbatively.

Dispersive analysis

Below we introduce the dispersive treatment of the integrals in Eq. (13), interested readers can refer to Ref.[35] for more details. It is apparent that the integrals depend only on the ν\nu-odd component of the invariant amplitudes T3T_3, S1S_1 and S2S_2; one can show using isospin symmetry that this component arises from the isosinglet piece of the EM current, so we may denote it with a superscript (0). They can be connected to the structure functions of in Eq. (6) through an unsubtracted dispersion relation:

T3(0)(ν,Q2)=−4iν∫0∞dν′F3(0)(ν′,Q2)ν′2−ν2T_3^{(0)}(\nu,Q^2)=-4i\nu\int_0^\infty d\nu'\frac{F_3^{(0)}(\nu',Q^2)}{\nu'^2-\nu^2}
S1(0)(ν,Q2)=−4iν∫0∞dν′g1(0)(ν′,Q2)ν′2−ν2S_1^{(0)}(\nu,Q^2)=-4i\nu\int_0^\infty d\nu'\frac{g_1^{(0)}(\nu',Q^2)}{\nu'^2-\nu^2}
S2(0)(ν,Q2)=−4iν∫0∞dν′g2(0)(ν′,Q2)ν′2−ν2=−4iν3∫0∞dν′g2(0)(ν′,Q2)ν′2(ν′2−ν2).(15)S_2^{(0)}(\nu,Q^2)=-4i\nu\int_0^\infty d\nu'\frac{g_2^{(0)}(\nu',Q^2)}{\nu'^2-\nu^2}=-4i\nu^3\int_0^\infty d\nu'\frac{g_2^{(0)}(\nu',Q^2)}{\nu'^2(\nu'^2-\nu^2)}. \tag*{(15)}

Note that in the last line we have further simplified the DR of S2(0)S_2^{(0)} using the Burkhardt-Cottingham sum rule [36]. Substituting them into Eq. (13) gives the dispersive representation:

□γWV=απg~V∫0∞dQ2Q2MW2MW2+Q2∫01dx1+2r(1+r)2F3(0)(x,Q2)\Box_{\gamma W}^V=\frac{\alpha}{\pi\tilde{g}_V}\int_0^\infty\frac{dQ^2}{Q^2}\frac{M_W^2}{M_W^2+Q^2}\int_0^1dx\frac{1+2r}{(1+r)^2}F_3^{(0)}(x,Q^2)
□γWA=−2απg~A∫0∞dQ2Q2MW2MW2+Q2∫01dx(1+r)2{5+4r3g1(0)(x,Q2)−4mN2x2Q2g2(0)(x,Q2)},(16)\Box_{\gamma W}^A=-\frac{2\alpha}{\pi\tilde{g}_A}\int_0^\infty\frac{dQ^2}{Q^2}\frac{M_W^2}{M_W^2+Q^2}\int_0^1\frac{dx}{(1+r)^2}\left\{\frac{5+4r}{3}g_1^{(0)}(x,Q^2)-\frac{4m_N^2x^2}{Q^2}g_2^{(0)}(x,Q^2)\right\}, \tag*{(16)}

where we have defined the Bjorken variable x=Q2/(2mNν)x=Q^2/(2m_N\nu), and r=1+4mN2x2/Q2r=\sqrt{1+4m_N^2x^2/Q^2}. Among the structure functions, F3(0)F_3^{(0)} and g1(0)g_1^{(0)} contribute in the UV regime (Q2→∞Q^2\to\infty). Such contribution can be computed using perturbative QCD (pQCD):

∫01dxF3(0)(x,Q2)=g~V6CBj(Q2),∫01dxg1(0)(x,Q2)=∣g~A∣12CBj(Q2),(17)\int_0^1dxF_3^{(0)}(x,Q^2)=\frac{\tilde{g}_V}{6}C_{\mathrm{Bj}}(Q^2),\qquad\int_0^1dxg_1^{(0)}(x,Q^2)=\frac{|\tilde{g}_A|}{12}C_{\mathrm{Bj}}(Q^2), \tag*{(17)}

where CBj(Q2)C_{\mathrm{Bj}}(Q^2) is the pQCD correction to the polarized Bjorken sum rule, which is currently known to O(αs4)O(\alpha_s^4) [37, 38, 39].

Now we discuss the data inputs used to compute the dispersive integrals. The main challenge is that the structure functions above are all flavor non-diagonal, so it cannot be directly mapped to experimental cross sections without further manipulations. For the spin-dependent structure functions, isospin symmetry relates the isosinglet component g(0)g^{(0)} to the corresponding EM structure functions:

g1,2(0)=12{g1,2p−g1,2n},(18)g_{1,2}^{(0)}=\frac{1}{2}\left\{g_{1,2}^p-g_{1,2}^n\right\}, \tag*{(18)}

which means one can directly apply experimental data from EM interactions. On the other hand, F3(0)F_3^{(0)} cannot be related to EM structure functions because it is parity-odd. In principle, it can be related to the structure function F3F_3 measured in parity-violating deep inelastic scattering (PVDIS) that involves the interference between the EM and NW current, but data of the latter are not currently available. Therefore, data analysis in □γWV\Box_{\gamma W}^V must involve additional layers of theory modelings and thus is more complicated.

We start from the Born (elastic intermediate state) contribution to the structure functions, which is given by:

F3(0),B(x,Q2)=−12GA(Q2)GMS(Q2)δ(1−x)F_{3}^{(0),B}(x,Q^{2}) = -\frac{1}{2}G_{A}(Q^{2})G_{M}^{S}(Q^{2})\delta(1-x)
g1(0),B(x,Q2)=F1V(Q2)GMS(Q2)+F1S(Q2)GMV(Q2)8δ(1−x)g_{1}^{(0),B}(x,Q^{2}) = \frac{F_{1}^{V}(Q^{2})G_{M}^{S}(Q^{2})+F_{1}^{S}(Q^{2})G_{M}^{V}(Q^{2})}{8}\delta(1-x)
g2(0),B(x,Q2)=−τF2V(Q2)GMS(Q2)+F2S(Q2)GMV(Q2)8δ(1−x).(19)g_{2}^{(0),B}(x,Q^{2}) = -\tau\frac{F_{2}^{V}(Q^{2})G_{M}^{S}(Q^{2})+F_{2}^{S}(Q^{2})G_{M}^{V}(Q^{2})}{8}\delta(1-x). \tag*{(19)}

The expressions above are given entirely in terms of nucleon form factors: F1,2V=F1,2p−F1,2nF_{1,2}^{V}=F_{1,2}^{p}-F_{1,2}^{n}, F1,2S=F1,2p+F1,2nF_{1,2}^{S}=F_{1,2}^{p}+F_{1,2}^{n}, GMV=GMp−GMnG_{M}^{V}=G_{M}^{p}-G_{M}^{n}, GMS=GMp+GMnG_{M}^{S}=G_{M}^{p}+G_{M}^{n} involve the proton and neutron EM form factors, while GA(Q2)G_{A}(Q^{2}) is the nucleon axial form factor, with τ=Q2/(4mN2)\tau=Q^{2}/(4m_{N}^{2}). The large amount of nucleon form factor data [40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48] allows us to pin down this contribution to high precision.

Next we turn to non-elastic contributions. For g1,2(0)g_{1,2}^{(0)}, Eq. (18) allows us to make use of data from single-nucleon polarized DIS experiments. Measurements of the structure function g1g_{1} were carried out in SLAC [49, 50, 51], CERN [52, 53, 54, 55], DESY [56] and JLab [57, 58, 59, 60, 61]. Ref.[62] made use of the results from the EG1b experiment at JLab that measured the g1pg_{1}^{p} [61] and g1ng_{1}^{n} [60] in a wide range of {x,Q2}\{x,Q^{2}\}, which returns a highly precise determination of □γWA\Box_{\gamma W}^{A}:

□γWA=3.96(6)×10−3.(20)\Box_{\gamma W}^{A}=3.96(6)\times10^{-3}. \tag*{(20)}

On the other hand, the structure function F3(0)F_{3}^{(0)} involves an axial current and cannot be matched into pure EM-induced inclusive scattering data. Furthermore, as stated above, inclusive electron-nucleon PVDIS scattering data at all kinematical regions is not yet available, so we need to resort to other weak scattering data, but now in a intermediate-state-dependent way. The way to proceed is to first divide the kinematical space of the structure functions into different regions of Q2Q^{2} and W2=(p+q)2W^{2}=(p+q)^{2}, see Figure 3. The inelastic contributions start from the pion production threshold, Wπ2=(mN+mπ)2W_{\pi}^{2}=(m_{N}+m_{\pi})^{2}. In the inelastic region, when the virtuality of the gauge bosons is large enough (roughly, Q2>2 GeV2Q^{2}>2\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2}), QCD becomes perturbative and one needs only the pQCD-corrected sum rules of structure functions, as given in Eq. (17). At small Q2Q^{2} and W2W^{2}, the main contributors are NπN\pi and nucleon resonances. The former can be computed using low-energy effective theories such as chiral perturbation theory, while for each resonance one can compute it contribution using known resonance transition form factors [63, 64], much like the case of elastic form factors (19). Numerically, the contribution in this region is shown to be negligibly small (due to the fact that Δ\Delta does not contribute) so the theory uncertainty is not an issue.

Figure 3. Approximate kinematical regions dominated by various physical mechanisms that contribute to F3(0)F_{3}^{(0)}.

The real challenge comes from the large-W2W^{2}, small-Q2Q^{2} region, where the structure functions are contributed by multi-hadron intermediate states (which effect also penetrates to the small-W2W^{2} region as a smooth background). It is not possible to study the impact from each of the intermediate states separately. Fortunately, there is an economical way, known as the “Regge exchange picture”, to describe the high-energy contribution collectively. In this picture, the two virtual gauge bosons first fluctuate into a vector or axial meson, which then interacts with the nucleon through the exchange of a “Regge trajectory”, which resembles yet another vector or axial meson (in terms of quantum numbers). This is depicted in Figure 4; for the case of F3(0)F_{3}^{(0)} (left diagram), the photon and WW-boson fluctuate into a ω\omega and a1a_{1} respectively, which then exchange a ρ\rho-trajectory with the nucleon.

Diagrammatic illustration of the Regge exchange picture

Figure 4. Diagrammatic illustration of the Regge exchange picture description for F3(0)F_{3}^{(0)} (left) and F3WF_{3}^{W} (right).

Contraction diagrams involved in the lattice calculation of $T^{\mu\nu}$ for semileptonic pion decay.

Figure 5. Contraction diagrams involved in the lattice calculation of TμνT^{\mu\nu} for semileptonic pion decay.

The advantage of the picture is that it offers a natural connection between the structure function in □γW\Box_{\gamma W} and that in other weak processes. An example is the inclusive neutrino/antineutrino-proton charged-current scattering ν(νˉ)+p→e∓+X\nu(\bar{\nu})+p\to e^{\mp}+X triggered by a WW-exchange. The corresponding parity-odd structure function F3νp+νˉpF_3^{\nu p+\bar{\nu}p} results from the interference between the vector and the axial component of JμJ^\mu. The corresponding Regge exchange picture is given in the right diagram in Figure 4: the two WW-bosons fluctuate into a ρ\rho and a a1a_1 respectively, which then exchanges an ω\omega trajectory with the proton. An important observation is that the three-meson coupling in the two diagrams of Figure 4 are identical (and that propagators of the ρ\rho and ω\omega trajectories are almost identical due to their near mass degeneracy), which suggests that the {W2,Q2}\{W^2,Q^2\}-dependence of the Regge contribution (R) in these two cases are the same, so to map F3(0)F_3^{(0)} to F3νp+νˉpF_3^{\nu p+\bar{\nu}p} one needs only to compute a constant rescale factor that accounts for the difference in the gauge boson-meson fluctuation and the meson-nucleon coupling constants. That amounts to:

F3,R(0)(x,Q2)=118F3,Rνp+νˉp(x,Q2),(21)F_{3,\mathrm{R}}^{(0)}(x,Q^2)=\frac{1}{18}F_{3,\mathrm{R}}^{\nu p+\bar{\nu}p}(x,Q^2), \tag*{(21)}

where F3νp+νˉp=(F3νp+F3νˉp)/2F_3^{\nu p+\bar{\nu}p}=(F_3^{\nu p}+F_3^{\bar{\nu}p})/2, with

14π∑X(2π)4δ4(p+q−pX)⟨p∣(JWμ)†∣X⟩⟨X∣JWν∣p⟩=−iεμναβqαpβ2p⋅qF3νp(ν,Q2)+⋯\frac{1}{4\pi}\sum_X(2\pi)^4\delta^4(p+q-p_X)\langle p|(J_W^\mu)^\dagger|X\rangle\langle X|J_W^\nu|p\rangle =-i\varepsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\frac{q_\alpha p_\beta}{2p\cdot q}F_3^{\nu p}(\nu,Q^2)+\cdots
14π∑X(2π)4δ4(p+q−pX)⟨p∣JWμ∣X⟩⟨X∣(JWν)†∣p⟩=−iεμναβqαpβ2p⋅qF3νˉp(ν,Q2)+⋯(22)\frac{1}{4\pi}\sum_X(2\pi)^4\delta^4(p+q-p_X)\langle p|J_W^\mu|X\rangle\langle X|(J_W^\nu)^\dagger|p\rangle =-i\varepsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\frac{q_\alpha p_\beta}{2p\cdot q}F_3^{\bar{\nu}p}(\nu,Q^2)+\cdots \tag*{(22)}

Data is available for the structure function F3νp+νˉpF_3^{\nu p+\bar{\nu}p} obtained from neutrino scattering of light nuclei [65, 66], which can serve as the data input to □γW\Box_{\gamma W} through Eq. (21). Two data-driven calculations of □γW\Box_{\gamma W} based on the strategy approach was performed Refs.[67, 68] utilized the aforementioned neutrino scattering data with integrated xx, whereas Ref.[69] made use of the same set of data, but fit their functional form with both xx and Q2Q^2-dependence.

The first dispersive analysis of □γW\Box_{\gamma W} in 2018 [67] had a profound impact on the status of the first-row CKM unitarity. It substantially increased the central value of ΔRV\Delta_R^V with reduced theory uncertainty:

ΔRV:0.02361(38) , pre-2018⟶0.02467(22) , 2018(23)\Delta_R^V\quad:\quad0.02361(38)\,,\ \text{pre-2018} \longrightarrow0.02467(22)\,,\ \text{2018} \tag*{(23)}

which subsequently reduced the central value of ∣Vud∣|V_{ud}|:

∣Vud∣:0.97420(38) , pre-2018⟶0.97366(15) , 2018(24)|V_{ud}|\quad:\quad0.97420(38)\,,\ \text{pre-2018} \longrightarrow0.97366(15)\,,\ \text{2018} \tag*{(24)}

This changed the status of the first-row CKM unitarity from almost perfectly satisfied to having a ∼4σ\sim4\sigma deviation (which significance was later slightly reduced due to increased nuclear uncertainty, as will be discussed later).

Lattice QCD analysis

Lattice QCD provides a completely independent and complementary non-perturbative approach to tackle the same problem. On a discrete lattice of Euclidean spacetime, one computes the generalized Compton tensor TμνT^{\mu\nu} directly as a “four-point correlation function”: two points from the external hadron states and two points from the current insertions. In terms of evaluating □γWV\Box_{\gamma W}^V, one needs the following xx-integral of the structure function F3(0)(x,Q2)F_3^{(0)}(x,Q^2), which is called its “first Nachtmann moment” [70, 71]:

M3(0)(Q2)≡43∫01dx 1+2r(1+r)2F3(0)(x,Q2).(25)M_3^{(0)}(Q^2)\equiv\frac{4}{3}\int_0^1 dx\,\frac{1+2r}{(1+r)^2}F_3^{(0)}(x,Q^2). \tag*{(25)}

Notice that it reduces to a simple integration of F3(0)(x,Q2)F_3^{(0)}(x,Q^2) over xx at larger Q2Q^2. Lattice QCD is able to predict M3(0)(Q2)M_3^{(0)}(Q^2) to high accuracy; however, as Q2Q^2 increases, the result starts to suffer from large lattice artifacts (i.e. systematic uncertainties due to finite lattice spacing) and becomes unreliable; on the other hand, the pQCD computation (Eq. (17)) is reliable at large Q2Q^2 but not at small Q2Q^2. So, a fully first-principles treatment is achieved by combining the lattice result at low Q2Q^2 and pQCD result at large Q2Q^2. In doing so, one observes a smooth transition between these descriptions around Q2=2 GeVQ^2=2\,\mathrm{GeV}, which justifies the region separation in Figure 3.

The first lattice computation of γW\gamma W-box diagram was performed in Ref.[72] for semileptonic pion decay, π+→π0+e++νe\pi^{+} \to\pi^{0} + e^{+} + \nu_{e}, by computing the contraction diagrams in Fig.5. The result was later independently confirmed in Ref.[73]. It achieved a 3-times reduction of the hadronic uncertainty in the radiative corrections compared to the previous state-of-the-art result based on chiral perturbation theory [74], which effectively turns this decay to the theoretical cleanest channel to measure ∣Vud∣|V_{ud}| [75]. In addition, the pion box diagram result can be used to infer the Regge contribution to the neutron box diagram in the dispersive approach [76]. A complete lattice QCD calculation of ΔγWV\Delta_{\gamma W}^{V} and ΔγWA\Delta_{\gamma W}^{A} in free neutron decay was first accomplished in Ref.[77].

Box diagram in the nuclear level

The uncertainties in the extraction of ∣Vud∣|V_{ud}| from both the semileptonic pion decay and free decay are both dominated by experimental errors. For semileptonic decay, it is from the semileptonic decay branching ratio, and for neutron decay it is from both the neutron lifetime and the coupling constant ratio λ\lambda. The situation is a bit different for nuclear beta decays. An important avenue for the extraction of ∣Vud∣|V_{ud}| is the “superallowed” 0+→0+0^{+} \to0^{+} nuclear beta decays; it consists of 23 measured transitions from 10C→10B{}^{10}\mathrm{C} \to{}^{10}\mathrm{B} to 74Rb→74Kr{}^{74}\mathrm{Rb} \to{}^{74}\mathrm{Kr}, 15 of which lifetime precision is better than 0.23% [78]. Averaging over all such transitions effectively reduces the experimental uncertainty, with the price of introducing new nuclear-structure-dependent theory uncertainties not present in pion and neutron. At the present, the ∣Vud∣|V_{ud}| extracted from superallowed nuclear beta decays is claimed to have the highest precision, which imposes strong constraints on new physics [79].

The master formula for the VudV_{ud} extraction from superallowed beta decays reads [78]:

∣Vud∣2=2984.43 sft(1+δR′)(1+δNS−δC)(1+ΔRV).(26)|V_{ud}|^{2} = \frac{2984.43\ \mathrm{s}}{ft(1+\delta_{R}^{\prime})(1+\delta_{\mathrm{NS}}-\delta_{C})(1+\Delta_{R}^{V})}. \tag*{(26)}

Among the quantities at the right hand side, δR′\delta_{R}^{\prime}, ΔRV\Delta_{R}^{V} and δNS\delta_{\mathrm{NS}} originate from radiative corrections: δR′\delta_{R}^{\prime} is the so-called “outer” radiative correction that it structure independent [80, 81, 82]; ΔRV\Delta_{R}^{V} is exactly the same single-nucleon RC that appears in the free neutron formula, Eq. (11); finally, δNS\delta_{\mathrm{NS}} is the nuclear-structure (NS)-dependent part of the radiative correction. The separation of the full structure-dependent correction into ΔRV\Delta_{R}^{V} and δNS\delta_{\mathrm{NS}} is just a convention; they both arise from the nuclear γW\gamma W-box diagrams, where the ii and ff in Fig.2 are the nuclear external states.

Computing δNS\delta_{\mathrm{NS}} requires the handling of many-nucleon contributions to TμνT^{\mu\nu}, which calls for nuclear many-body methods. There are currently two approaches to do so; we will describe the details here, and interested readers may refer to Refs.[83, 84] for a more comprehensive review.

  1. Current algebra approach: In this approach developed in Refs.[68, 85], one simply applies Eq. (13) at the nuclear level, and compute the invariant amplitude T3T_{3} using many-body methods. A useful representation is{2}:

T3(ν,Q2)=−4Mν∣q∣∑X[⟨ϕf∣JXμ(q)∣X⟩⟨X∣JW†ν(−q)∣ϕi⟩νX−ν−iϵ+⟨ϕf∣JW†ν(−q)∣X⟩⟨X∣JXμ(q)∣ϕi⟩νX+ν−iϵ],(27)T_{3}(\nu,Q^{2})=-\frac{4M\nu}{|\mathbf{q}|}\sum_{X}\left[\frac{\langle\phi_{f}|J_{X}^{\mu}(\mathbf{q})|X\rangle\langle X|J_{W}^{\dagger\nu}(-\mathbf{q})|\phi_{i}\rangle}{\nu_{X}-\nu-i\epsilon}+\frac{\langle\phi_{f}|J_{W}^{\dagger\nu}(-\mathbf{q})|X\rangle\langle X|J_{X}^{\mu}(\mathbf{q})|\phi_{i}\rangle}{\nu_{X}+\nu-i\epsilon}\right], \tag*{(27)}

where XX sums over all intermediate nuclear states. In other words, one needs to compute a nuclear Green’s function: G(z)=1/(z−H)G(z)=1/(z-H), where HH is the nuclear Hamiltonian.

  1. Effective field theory (EFT) approach: In this approach developed in Refs.[86, 87], instead of computing the nuclear Green’s function, one constructs effective two-nucleon potentials that encodes the RC. It corrects the CW current as:

JWμ=∑n=1A(gVδμ0−∣gA∣δμiσ(n)iτ(n)++(J2b)μ+⋯ )+δμ0(V0+E0VE0)+δμiVi+δμνVme+⋯ ,(28)\mathcal{J}_{W}^{\mu}=\sum_{n=1}^{A}\left(g_{V}\delta^{\mu0}-|g_{A}|\delta^{\mu i}\sigma^{(n)i}\tau^{(n)+}+(\mathcal{J}^{2b})^{\mu}+\cdots\right) +\delta^{\mu0}(V^{0}+E_{0}V_{E}^{0})+\delta^{\mu i}V_{i}+\delta^{\mu\nu}V_{m_{e}}+\cdots, \tag*{(28)}

where the effective potentials V0V^{0}, VE0V_{E}^{0}, ViV_{i} and VmeV_{m_{e}} are derived from two-nucleon Feynman diagrams based on chiral effective field theory. The most piece among them is the energy-independent potential V0V^{0}, which consists of a long-distance and a short-distance piece, the latter shows up as contact interaction with unknown low energy constants (LECs) that incorporate short-distance effects not captured by chiral symmetry.

Both methods have their own advantages and disadvantages. The current algebra approach is more computationally demanding because it involves a summation over all intermediate states, but doing so explicitly includes all nuclear effects. The EFT approach, on the other hand, is simpler because it requires only the computation of ground state nuclear matrix elements of the relevant two-nucleon potentials; the price to pay is the existence of unknown LECs that give a large theory uncertainty. At the present, the current algebra approach has been applied to 10C→10B{}^{10}\mathrm{C} \to{}^{10}\mathrm{B} [88], while the EFT approach has been applied to 14O→14N{}^{14}\mathrm{O} \to{}^{14}\mathrm{N} [86] and 10C→10B{}^{10}\mathrm{C} \to{}^{10}\mathrm{B} [89].

Charged weak decay: Correlations

In the above, we discussed the impact of radiative corrections to beta decay lifetime. However, there are much more observables beta decay processes that carry information of new physics. Examples are the “decay correlations”, namely the dependence of the differential decay rate on the momentum or spin of the initial particle or (detectable) decay products. Let us take the free neutron decay as an example: At tree level, the differential decay rate possesses the following correlation structures:

dΓ∝1+ape⋅pνEeEν+bmeEe+s^n⋅[APeEe+BPνEν+⋯ ](29)d\Gamma\propto1+a\frac{\mathbf{p}_{e}\cdot\mathbf{p}_{\nu}}{E_{e}E_{\nu}}+b\frac{m_{e}}{E_{e}}+\hat{s}_{n}\cdot\left[A\frac{\mathbf{P}_{e}}{E_{e}}+B\frac{\mathbf{P}_{\nu}}{E_{\nu}}+\cdots\right] \tag*{(29)}

where s^n\hat{s}_{n} is the neutron unit spin vector. The constants aa, bb, AA, BB and so on are called “correlation coefficients”. In the SM, they are given by:

a=1−λ21+3λ2,b=0,A=−2λλ+11+3λ2,B=2λ−11+3λ2.(30)a=\frac{1-\lambda^{2}}{1+3\lambda^{2}},\quad b=0,\quad A=-2\lambda\frac{\lambda+1}{1+3\lambda^{2}},\quad B=2\frac{\lambda-1}{1+3\lambda^{2}}. \tag*{(30)}

An immediate application of these relations is the measurement of the quantity λ\lambda from various correlations, and all the outcomes should be identical if SM is correct. A discrepancy in the λ\lambda-determination from different correlation may be a hint of new physics. This turns out to be the case at the present, as the best determinations of λ\lambda from AA [90] and aa [91, 92] exhibit a discrepancy of about 3.5 σ3.5\ \sigma.

To extract λ\lambda at high precision, one needs to account for the RC to the correlation coefficients. Hadron-structure-dependent RCs, such as □‾γWV\overline{\Box}^{V}_{\gamma W} and □‾γWA\overline{\Box}^{A}_{\gamma W} in Eq.(13), are reabsorbed into the measured value of λ\lambda and hence does not alter the correlation structure in Eq.(29). Instead, we are interested in the part of the RC that depends on the lepton energies, which can be computed using elementary QED by treating the nucleon as a point particle, with the effective vector and axial coupling constants gVg_{V} and gAg_{A}. This was first performed in Refs.[80, 93], where the RC-corrected differential decay rate was expressed in terms of the electron momentum pe\mathbf{p}_{e} and the neutrino solid angle Ων\Omega_{\nu}. Their result reads:

dΓdEedΩedΩν=(GFVud)2(2π)5∣pe∣Ee(Em−Ee)2F(Ee)gV2(1+3λ2)(1+α2πδ(1)(Ee))×{1+(1+α2πδ(2)(Ee))ape⋅pνEeEν+s^n⋅[(1+α2πδ(2)(Ee))APeEe+BPνEν+⋯ ]},(31)\begin{aligned} \frac{d\Gamma}{dE_{e}d\Omega_{e}d\Omega_{\nu}}={}&\frac{(G_{F}V_{ud})^{2}}{(2\pi)^{5}}|\mathbf{p}_{e}|E_{e}(E_{m}-E_{e})^{2}F(E_{e})g_{V}^{2}(1+3\lambda^{2})\left(1+\frac{\alpha}{2\pi}\delta^{(1)}(E_{e})\right)\\ &\times\left\{1+\left(1+\frac{\alpha}{2\pi}\delta^{(2)}(E_{e})\right)a\frac{\mathbf{p}_{e}\cdot\mathbf{p}_{\nu}}{E_{e}E_{\nu}}+\hat{s}_{n}\cdot\left[\left(1+\frac{\alpha}{2\pi}\delta^{(2)}(E_{e})\right)A\frac{\mathbf{P}_{e}}{E_{e}}+B\frac{\mathbf{P}_{\nu}}{E_{\nu}}+\cdots\right]\right\}, \tag*{(31)} \end{aligned}

where

δ(1)(Ee)=3ln⁡mpme−34+4(1βtanh⁡−1β−1)(ln⁡2(Em−Ee)me+Em−Ee3Ee−32)−4βLi⁡2(2β1+β)+1βtanh⁡−1β(2+2β2+(Em−Ee)26Ee2)−4tanh⁡−1β\begin{aligned} \delta^{(1)}(E_{e})={}&3\ln\frac{m_{p}}{m_{e}}-\frac{3}{4}+4\left(\frac{1}{\beta}\tanh^{-1}\beta-1\right)\left(\ln\frac{2(E_{m}-E_{e})}{m_{e}}+\frac{E_{m}-E_{e}}{3E_{e}}-\frac{3}{2}\right)-\frac{4}{\beta}\operatorname{Li}_{2}\left(\frac{2\beta}{1+\beta}\right)\\ &+\frac{1}{\beta}\tanh^{-1}\beta\left(2+2\beta^{2}+\frac{(E_{m}-E_{e})^{2}}{6E_{e}^{2}}\right)-4\tanh^{-1}\beta \end{aligned}
δ(2)(Ee)=2(1−β2β)tanh⁡−1β+4(Em−Ee)(1−β2)3β2Ee(1βtanh⁡−1β−1)+(Em−Ee)26β2Ee2(1−β2βtanh⁡−1β−1)(32)\delta^{(2)}(E_{e})=2\left(\frac{1-\beta^{2}}{\beta}\right)\tanh^{-1}\beta+\frac{4(E_{m}-E_{e})(1-\beta^{2})}{3\beta^{2}E_{e}}\left(\frac{1}{\beta}\tanh^{-1}\beta-1\right)+\frac{(E_{m}-E_{e})^{2}}{6\beta^{2}E_{e}^{2}}\left(\frac{1-\beta^{2}}{\beta}\tanh^{-1}\beta-1\right) \tag*{(32)}

where β≡∣pe∣/Ee\beta\equiv|\mathbf{p}_{e}|/E_{e}, Em=(mn2−mp2+me2)/(2mn)E_{m}=(m_{n}^{2}-m_{p}^{2}+m_{e}^{2})/(2m_{n}) is the electron’s end-point energy, and F(E)F(E) is the Fermi function that accounts for the Coulomb interaction between the proton and the outgoing electron [32]. The result above includes both the one-loop corrections and bremsstrahlung, to ensure the cancellation of infrared divergence required by the Kinoshita-Lee-Nauenberg (KLN) theorem [94, 95]. Notice that δ(1)(Ee)\delta^{(1)}(E_{e}) includes a large logarithm 3ln⁡(mp/me)3\ln(m_{p}/m_{e}), but this is just a matter of choice since any constant term in δ(1)(Ee)\delta^{(1)}(E_{e}) can be re-absorbed into the definition of the renormalized gVg_{V}; the latter is adopted in the similar calculation based on EFT [96].

There is a hidden kinematic issue in the formalism above, namely it depends on the neutrino momentum pν\mathbf{p}_{\nu}, is not directly measured in experiment. One may think that it is deducible from the momentum conservation pν=pn−pp−pe\mathbf{p}_{\nu}=\mathbf{p}_{n}-\mathbf{p}_{p}-\mathbf{p}_{e}, but this identity works only for three-body decay. At O(α)O(\alpha), one needs to include simultaneously the three-body and four-body decay, the latter including one real photon emission, to ensure IR finiteness. The inclusion of the four-body decay invalidates the identity above. In other words, Eq.(31) is mathematically correct, but not directly applicable for experiments that do not observe the neutrino. If we are interested in correlation structures that do not depend on pν\mathbf{p}_{\nu}, for example AA, one can integrate out Ων\Omega_{\nu}, so the formula above is perfectly fine. However, for correlation structures that depend intrinsically on pν\mathbf{p}_{\nu}, for example aa and BB, the formula above is not applicable in practice.

The way to overcome this defect is simply to avoid using pν\mathbf{p}_{\nu} as the variable in the differential decay rate formula. There are two ways to implement this: (1) To probe spin-independent correlations (such as aa and bb), one can use the electron energy EeE_{e} and the proton kinetic energy KpK_{p} as independent variables; this is called the “recoil formalism” [97]. The second way, known as the “pseudo-neutrino formalism”, is to define pν=pn−pp\mathbf{p}_{\nu}=\mathbf{p}_{n}-\mathbf{p}_{p}, and use {pe,Ων′}\{\mathbf{p}_{e},\Omega'_{\nu}\} (instead of {pe,Ων}\{\mathbf{p}_{e},\Omega_{\nu}\}) as independent variables [98]. This formalism is useful in the sense that it resembles the traditional approach, and is also applicable to spin-dependent correlations such as BB that requires angular measurements.

Neutral current interaction

In the above, we discussed the search for new physics in CW decay processes; the same can be done in NW processes. The SM electroweak gauge group is SU(2)L×U(1)Y\mathrm{SU}(2)_{L}\times\mathrm{U}(1)_{Y}, which gives two neutral gauge bosons W0W^{0} and BB; these two gauge bosons “mix” to form the massless photon and the massive ZZ-boson. The mixing takes the following form:

(γZ)=(cwsw−swcw)(BW0)(33)\begin{pmatrix} \gamma\\ Z \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} c_w & s_w \\ -s_w & c_w \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} B \\ W^0 \tag*{(33)} \end{pmatrix}

which involves the weak mixing angle θW\theta_W introduced in Eq. (1). At tree level, it is given by sw2=1−MW2/MZ2s_w^2 = 1 - M_W^2/M_Z^2, but at higher order it depends on a renormalization scale μ\mu. The running of sw2(μ)s_w^2(\mu) (say, in the MS‾\overline{\mathrm{MS}} scheme) is well studied [99], which serves as a rigorous SM prediction that can be tested in experiments. Deviations from the SM prediction could indicate new physics, for example a dark ZZ-boson [100, 101].

As in Eq. (1), the neutral current depends on sw2s_w^2, so by measuring the NW interaction strength one can extract sw2s_w^2. The problem, however, is that the EM interaction strength is much larger than the NW strength, so ordinary experimental observables are dominated by EM contributions and are impossible to resolve the tiny NW contributions. One can make use of discrete symmetry to overcome this challenge. Given that EM interactions conserve parity while NW interactions do not, if we measure a parity-violating (PV) asymmetry, the leading contribution must be proportional to the NW interaction. In the following we discuss an example of such experiment, the parity-violating elastic scattering (PVES) between electron and nucleon/nucleus.

Basics of nuclear weak charge

Consider the scattering between and electron and an unpolarized, strongly-bounded state ϕ\phi, which can be a nucleon or a nucleus. At tree level, the interaction depends on two spin-independent matrix elements:

⟨ϕ(p′)∣Jemμ(0)∣ϕ(p)⟩≡QchϕFch(t)(p+p′)μ,⟨ϕ(p′)∣JZμ(0)∣ϕ(p)⟩≡12QWϕFW(t)(p+p′)μ(34)\langle\phi(p')|J^\mu_{\mathrm{em}}(0)|\phi(p)\rangle\equiv Q^\phi_{\mathrm{ch}}F_{\mathrm{ch}}(t)(p+p')^\mu,\quad\langle\phi(p')|J^\mu_Z(0)|\phi(p)\rangle\equiv\frac{1}{2}Q^\phi_WF_W(t)(p+p')^\mu \tag*{(34)}

where t≡(p−p′)2t\equiv(p-p')^2. QchϕQ^\phi_{\mathrm{ch}} and QWϕQ^\phi_W are the electric and weak charge of ϕ\phi, respectively. The charge and weak form factors Fch(t)F_{\mathrm{ch}}(t) and FW(t)F_W(t) are both normalized to 1 at t=0t=0. Since vector currents are conserved, the charges of a nucleus with ZZ protons and NN neutron would simply be the sum of the respective charges of all nucleons:

Qchϕ=Z,QWϕ=ZQWp+NQWn(35)Q^\phi_{\mathrm{ch}}=Z,\quad Q^\phi_W=ZQ^p_W+NQ^n_W \tag*{(35)}

where the weak charges of the nucleon are, in turn, the sum of those from the quarks:

QWp=2(2gVu+gVd)=1−4sw2,QWn=2(gVu+2gVd)=−1.(36)Q^p_W=2(2g^u_V+g^d_V)=1-4s_w^2,\quad Q^n_W=2(g^u_V+2g^d_V)=-1. \tag*{(36)}

So, measuring the weak charge of a proton or nuclear target provides an access to the weak mixing angle.

The PV asymmetry can be defined in terms of the difference between the differential scattering cross section of an electron with positive and negative helicity:

APV≡dσ+−dσ−dσ++dσ−.(37)A^{PV}\equiv\frac{d\sigma_+-d\sigma_-}{d\sigma_++d\sigma_-}. \tag*{(37)}

At tree level, this gives:

AtreePV=GFt4π2αQWϕFW(t)ZFcht,(38)A^{PV}_{\mathrm{tree}}=\frac{G_Ft}{4\pi\sqrt{2}\alpha}\frac{Q^\phi_WF_W(t)}{ZF_{\mathrm{ch}}t}, \tag*{(38)}

from which the nuclear weak charge can be obtained in the forward limit:

QW∣treeϕ=4π2αGFtZAPV∣t→0,(39)Q^\phi_{W\mid\mathrm{tree}}=\left.\frac{4\pi\sqrt{2}\alpha}{G_Ft}ZA^{PV}\right|_{t\to0}, \tag*{(39)}

Taking t→0t\to0 is to avoid uncertainties from the form factors, but at the same time APVA^{PV} also vanishes in the forward limit, so one must find a balance.

A particularly interesting case is the proton target, because it just turns out that sw2≈0.25s_w^2\approx0.25, so the proton weak charge 1−4sw21-4s_w^2 is accidentally suppressed. In this case, the SM contribution to APVA^{PV} is suppressed so it is more sensitive to PV effects from new physics. Recently, the QweakQ_{\mathrm{weak}} experiment at Jefferson Lab that performed an epep-PVES measured the PV asymmetry with a 6% precision:

APV=(−226.5±9.5)×10−9,(40)A_{\mathrm{PV}}=(-226.5\pm9.5)\times10^{-9}, \tag*{(40)}

which implied the following value of the proton weak charge at μ≈0.1 GeV\mu\approx0.1\ \mathrm{GeV}:

QWp=0.0719±0.0045,(41)Q^p_W=0.0719\pm0.0045, \tag*{(41)}

in excellent agreement with the SM prediction [102]. In addition, the upcoming P2 experiment at Mainz plans to measure APVA_{\mathrm{PV}} with a 1.4% precision, which will significantly improve the proton weak charge measurement [103].

Radiative corrections to epep-PVES

Electroweak RC to the epep-PVES process modifies the value of the measured proton weak charge from the tree-level expression, Eq. (39). The t→0t\to0 limit removes the bremsstrahlung contribution because there is no phase space for the emission of an extra photon. This also implies that the loop contributions are free from infrared divergences. The RC-modified expression of the proton weak charge reads [104]:

QWp=(1+Δρ+Δe)(1−4sw2+Δe′)+□WW+□ZZ+□γZ.(42)Q_{W}^{p}=(1+\Delta\rho+\Delta_{e})(1-4s_{w}^{2}+\Delta_{e}^{\prime})+\Box_{WW}+\Box_{ZZ}+\Box_{\gamma Z}. \tag*{(42)}

Let us explain the meaning of each term. First, the factor 1+Δρ1+\Delta\rho renormalizes the ratio of the NW and CW current interaction strength at low energies [105]. Next, Δe\Delta_{e} and Δe′\Delta_{e}^{\prime} are corrections to the axial ZeeZee and γee\gamma ee couplings, respectively [106, 107]. The corrections □WW\Box_{WW} and □ZZ\Box_{ZZ} come from the WWWW and ZZZZ-box diagrams, which depend only on physics at the weak scale and therefore can be computed perturbatively.

The only one-loop diagram that involves non-perturbative QCD is the γZ\gamma Z-box diagram depicted in Figure 6. The shaded blob in the figure is again the generalized forward Compton tensor TμνT^{\mu\nu} (that involves the neutral weak current, i.e. a=Za=Z), which adopts the decomposition in Eq. (4). The box diagram can be split into the “vector” (V) and “axial” (A) components, contributed by the vector and axial neutral weak current, respectively:

Image not extracted

Figure 6. The γZ\gamma Z-box diagram correction to epep scattering.

□γZ=□γZV+□γZA.(43)\Box_{\gamma Z}=\Box_{\gamma Z}^{V}+\Box_{\gamma Z}^{A}. \tag*{(43)}

Following the notation in Ref.[108], they take the following form:

□γZV=α∫d4q(2π)4∑i=12Vi(q,ℓ)TiγZ(ν,q)\Box_{\gamma Z}^{V}=\alpha\int\frac{\mathrm{d}^{4}q}{(2\pi)^{4}}\sum_{i=1}^{2}V_{i}(q,\ell)T_{i}^{\gamma Z}(\nu,q)
□γWA=α∫d4q(2π)4V3(q,ℓ)T3γZ(ν,q)(44)\Box_{\gamma W}^{A}=\alpha\int\frac{\mathrm{d}^{4}q}{(2\pi)^{4}}V_{3}(q,\ell)T_{3}^{\gamma Z}(\nu,q) \tag*{(44)}

where

V1=−ℓ⋅q2q2(−2ℓ⋅q+3q2)V2=C2(p⋅q)(q2)2[2(ℓ⋅q)2(p⋅q)2+2(ℓ⋅p)2(q2)2+(ℓ⋅q)q2(−4(ℓ⋅p)(p⋅q)−(p⋅q)2+mN2q2)]V3=−12(1−4sw2)C(−ℓ⋅q+ℓ⋅pp⋅qq2)(45)\begin{aligned} V_{1}&=-\frac{\ell\cdot q}{2q^{2}}(-2\ell\cdot q+3q^{2})\\ V_{2}&=\frac{C}{2(p\cdot q)(q^{2})^{2}}\left[2(\ell\cdot q)^{2}(p\cdot q)^{2}+2(\ell\cdot p)^{2}(q^{2})^{2}+(\ell\cdot q)q^{2}\left(-4(\ell\cdot p)(p\cdot q)-(p\cdot q)^{2}+m_{N}^{2}q^{2}\right)\right]\\ V_{3}&=-\frac{1}{2}(1-4s_{w}^{2})C\left(-\ell\cdot q+\frac{\ell\cdot p}{p\cdot q}q^{2}\right) \tag*{(45)} \end{aligned}

where

C=16πℓ⋅pMZ2((ℓ−q)2+iϵ)(q2+iϵ)(MZ2−q2−iϵ).(46)C=\frac{16\pi}{\ell\cdot p}\frac{M_{Z}^{2}}{((\ell-q)^{2}+i\epsilon)(q^{2}+i\epsilon)(M_{Z}^{2}-q^{2}-i\epsilon)}. \tag*{(46)}

with ℓ=(E,l)\ell=(E,\mathbf{l}) the momentum of the electron, where we have taken the me→0m_{e}\to0 limit for simplicity. Unlike nuclear beta decays where the lepton momentum is restricted by the phase space, here the energy of the incoming electron beam is fixed by the experimental setup and can be large; for instance, the QweakQ_{\mathrm{weak}} experiment was conducted with E=1.16E=1.16 GeV. Therefore, it is important to retain the EE-dependence in the expressions above.

Dispersive analysis

Apart from the known point-like proton intermediate state contribution, one can show that □γZV\Box_{\gamma Z}^{V} vanishes when E→0E\to0 while □γZA\Box_{\gamma Z}^{A} approaches a non-zero constant. So, earlier studies of □γZ\Box_{\gamma Z} had always implicitly assumed E=0E=0 and thus focused on the axial component [107]. The situation changed when the first dispersion relation analysis of □γZ\Box_{\gamma Z} was introduced in Ref.[109]. The dispersive representation of Eq. (44) (after removing the point-like proton contribution) reads:

□γZV(E)=2απ∫0∞dQ21+Q2/MZ2∫0∞dν{[12Eln⁡∣E+EmE−Em∣−1Em]F1γZmNE+F2γZ2EνEm\Box_{\gamma Z}^{V}(E)=\frac{2\alpha}{\pi}\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{dQ^{2}}{1+Q^{2}/M_{Z}^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}d\nu\left\{\left[\frac{1}{2E}\ln\left|\frac{E+E_{m}}{E-E_{m}}\right|-\frac{1}{E_{m}}\right]\frac{F_{1}^{\gamma Z}}{m_{N}E}+\frac{F_{2}^{\gamma Z}}{2E\nu E_{m}}\right.
[(1−Q24E2)ln⁡∣E+EmE−Em∣+νEln⁡∣E2−Em2Em2∣]F2γZνQ2}\left.\left[\left(1-\frac{Q^{2}}{4E^{2}}\right)\ln\left|\frac{E+E_{m}}{E-E_{m}}\right|+\frac{\nu}{E}\ln\left|\frac{E^{2}-E_{m}^{2}}{E_{m}^{2}}\right|\right]\frac{F_{2}^{\gamma Z}}{\nu Q^{2}}\right\}
□γZA(E)=α(1−4sw2)πmNE∫0∞dQ21+Q2/MZ2∫0∞dνν[ln⁡∣E+EmE−Em∣+ν2Eln⁡∣E2−Em2Em2∣]F3γZ,(47)\Box_{\gamma Z}^{A}(E)=\frac{\alpha(1-4s_{w}^{2})}{\pi m_{N}E}\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{dQ^{2}}{1+Q^{2}/M_{Z}^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{d\nu}{\nu}\left[\ln\left|\frac{E+E_{m}}{E-E_{m}}\right|+\frac{\nu}{2E}\ln\left|\frac{E^{2}-E_{m}^{2}}{E_{m}^{2}}\right|\right]F_{3}^{\gamma Z}, \tag*{(47)}

where Em=(ν+ν2+Q2)/2E_{m}=(\nu+\sqrt{\nu^{2}+Q^{2}})/2 (do not confuse with the electron end-point energy in Eq. (32)), and the structure functions FiγZF_{i}^{\gamma Z} are defined through Eq. (6) with a=Za=Z. With these expressions, one indeed finds □γZA(0)=0\Box_{\gamma Z}^{A}(0)=0 (for the inelastic contribution). However, when E≠0E\ne0, we see that □γZA\Box_{\gamma Z}^{A} is suppressed by the small factor 1−4sw21-4s_{w}^{2} due to the electron weak coupling while □γZV\Box_{\gamma Z}^{V} is not, so the relative importance of the latter increases with increasing EE. The main discovery in Ref.[109] was that vector box possesses a significant dependence on the electron energy EE, which contributes to a substantial uncertainty at E∼1E\sim1 GeV where the QweakQ_{\mathrm{weak}} experiment was performed [102]. This discovery stimulated a number of follow-up studies [110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122], and also led to the choice of a lower electron beam energy E≈155E\approx155 MeV in the upcoming P2 experiment in order to reduce the theoretical uncertainty in QWpQ_{W}^{p}.

Below we briefly describe the procedure for the dispersive analysis, starting with the vector box which depends on the parity-even structure functions F1,2F_{1,2} [112]. Recall that

F1,2∼∑X(2π)4δ4(p+q−pX)⟨p∣Jemμ∣X⟩⟨X∣(JZν)†∣p⟩,(48)F_{1,2}\sim\sum_{X}(2\pi)^{4}\delta^{4}(p+q-p_{X})\langle p|J_{\mathrm{em}}^{\mu}|X\rangle\langle X|(J_{Z}^{\nu})^{\dagger}|p\rangle, \tag*{(48)}

the two currents in the tensor are different despite that the initial and final states are the same, so it is again not straightforward to relate it to experimental cross sections. The relation, however, can be established case-by-case for each intermediate state XX using isospin symmetry. To do so, we first decompose the EM current and the vector neutral weak current into isosinglet (I=0I=0) and isotriplet (I=1I=1) pieces, neglecting the strange component:

Jemμ=16J0μ+12J1μ,(JZ)Vμ=−13sw2J0μ+(12−sw2)J1μ,(49)J_{\mathrm{em}}^{\mu}=\frac{1}{6}J_{0}^{\mu}+\frac{1}{2}J_{1}^{\mu},\qquad(J_{Z})_{V}^{\mu}=-\frac{1}{3}s_{w}^{2}J_{0}^{\mu}+\left(\frac{1}{2}-s_{w}^{2}\right)J_{1}^{\mu}, \tag*{(49)}

where

J0μ=uˉγμu+dˉγμd,J1μ=uˉγμu−dˉγμd.(50)J_{0}^{\mu}=\bar{u}\gamma^{\mu}u+\bar{d}\gamma^{\mu}d,\qquad J_{1}^{\mu}=\bar{u}\gamma^{\mu}u-\bar{d}\gamma^{\mu}d. \tag*{(50)}

Next, assuming isospin symmetry, the proton, neutron and any intermediate state XX can be expressed as isospin eigenstates:

∣p⟩=∣1/2,1/2⟩,∣n⟩=∣1/2,−1/2⟩,∣X⟩=∣IX,I3X⟩.(51)|p\rangle=|1/2,1/2\rangle,\quad|n\rangle=|1/2,-1/2\rangle,\quad|X\rangle=|I_{X},I_{3X}\rangle. \tag*{(51)}

With these, the transition matrix element of isospin currents between a nucleon state and an intermediate state XX can be expressed in terms of reduced matrix elements in the isospin space using the Wigner-Eckart theorem:

⟨IX,I3X∣JIμ∣1/2,±1/2⟩=C1/2,±1/2;I,0IX,I3X⟨IX∣∣JIμ∣∣1/2⟩,(52)\langle I_{X},I_{3X}|J_{I}^{\mu}|1/2,\pm1/2\rangle=C^{I_{X},I_{3X}}_{1/2,\pm1/2;I,0}\langle I_{X}||J_{I}^{\mu}||1/2\rangle, \tag*{(52)}

where C1/2,±1/2;I,0IX,I3XC^{I_{X},I_{3X}}_{1/2,\pm1/2;I,0} is the Clebsch-Gordan coefficient. The two reduced matrix elements ⟨X∣∣J0,1μ∣∣1/2⟩\langle X||J_{0,1}^{\mu}||1/2\rangle can be fixed by the proton and neutron real [123, 124, 125, 126, 127] and virtual [128, 129, 130, 131] photoabsorption cross section: σγp→X,σγn→X\sigma_{\gamma p\to X},\sigma_{\gamma n\to X}, which allows a data-driven analysis of □γZV\Box_{\gamma Z}^{V}.

In contrast with its vector counterpart, □γZA\Box_{\gamma Z}^{A} only possesses a mild dependence on EE, and its dispersive analysis is analogous to that of the single-nucleon γW\gamma W-box detailed in § 5.1 [113, 122]. First, in the perturbative region (Q2>2 GeV2Q^{2}>2\ {\rm GeV}^{2}), the integrand is well-described by pQCD-corrected sum rules. However, unlike the case of □γWA\Box_{\gamma W}^{A} that depends only on the isosinglet EM current, here we need both the isosinglet and isotriplet EM current. The former satisfies the Bjorken sum rule, while the latter satisfies the Gross-Llewellyn-Smith (GLS) sum rule [132]. The pQCD correction to the latter is also known to O(αs4)O(\alpha_{s}^{4}) [37, 38, 39]. The Born contribution is given by the proton magnetic Sachs form factor and the nucleon axial form factor:

F3γZ,B(x,Q2)=−2GMp(Q2)GA(Q2)δ(1−x).(53)F_{3}^{\gamma Z,B}(x,Q^{2})=-2G_{M}^{p}(Q^{2})G_{A}(Q^{2})\delta(1-x). \tag*{(53)}

The NπN\pi contribution is computed using chiral perturbation theory and is numerically small, while the leading resonance contribution from the Δ\Delta can be fixed using the transition form factor parameterization in [63]. Finally, the high-energy (small xx) contribution is again described by the Regge picture in Figure 4, except that now it is the ZZ-boson that fluctuates into an a1a_{1}, and the Regge trajectories are neutral and couple to the proton. The parameters in the Regge model are directly taken from that in the □γW\Box_{\gamma W} box analysis. Following the procedure above, Ref.[122] deduced the result of the axial γZ\gamma Z box at two beam energies, corresponding to the P2 and QweakQ_{\mathrm{weak}} experiment:

□γZA(155 MeV)=44.6(2.1)×10−4,□γZA(1.165 GeV)=39.7(2.2)×10−4.(54)\Box_{\gamma Z}^{A}(155\ {\rm MeV})=44.6(2.1)\times10^{-4},\qquad\Box_{\gamma Z}^{A}(1.165\ {\rm GeV})=39.7(2.2)\times10^{-4}. \tag*{(54)}

Lattice QCD analysis

Similar to □γW\square_{\gamma W}, the proton γZ\gamma Z-box diagram □γZ(E)\square_{\gamma Z}(E) can also be computed with lattice QCD as a four-point correlation function, which was first performed in Ref.[108]. It turns out that, the EE-dependence greatly complicates the problem, which we briefly describe as follows. Since lattice QCD operates on Euclidean spacetime, one needs to first perform a Wick rotation to the integrals in Eq. (44) to the imaginary energy domain, q0=iνEq^{0}=i\nu_{E}. The electron propagator in Eq. (46) has two poles:

q0=E−∣ℓ−q∣+iϵ,q0=E+∣ℓ−q∣−iϵ.(55)q_{0}=E-\lvert\boldsymbol{\ell}-\mathbf{q}\rvert+i\epsilon,\quad q_{0}=E+\lvert\boldsymbol{\ell}-\mathbf{q}\rvert-i\epsilon. \tag*{(55)}

In the ℓ→0\ell\to0 limit, the pole positions reduce to ±(∣q∣−iϵ)\pm(\lvert\mathbf{q}\rvert-i\epsilon), which are in the second and fourth quadrant and do not affect the Wick rotation; this is the case for the γW\gamma W-box. However, if ℓ\ell is retained, then the pole E−∣ℓ−q∣+iϵE-\lvert\boldsymbol{\ell}-\mathbf{q}\rvert+i\epsilon can move to the first quadrant if νe≡E−∣ℓ−q∣>0\nu_{e}\equiv E-\lvert\boldsymbol{\ell}-\mathbf{q}\rvert>0, and the Wick rotation will pick up this pole. As a result, the full integral splits into two pieces:

□γZ(E)=□γZWick(E)+□γZres(E).(56)\square_{\gamma Z}(E)=\square_{\gamma Z}^{\mathrm{Wick}}(E)+\square_{\gamma Z}^{\mathrm{res}}(E). \tag*{(56)}

The Wick-rotated term simply amounts to replacing q0q_{0} by iνEi\nu_{E}:

□γZWick(E)=iα∫d3q(2π)3∫−∞∞dνE2π∑i=13Vi(iνE,q,ℓ)TiγZ(iνE,q),(57)\square_{\gamma Z}^{\mathrm{Wick}}(E)=i\alpha\int\frac{d^{3}\mathbf{q}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{d\nu_{E}}{2\pi}\sum_{i=1}^{3}V_{i}(i\nu_{E},\mathbf{q},\ell)T_{i}^{\gamma Z}(i\nu_{E},\mathbf{q}), \tag*{(57)}

whereas the other term is contributed by the residue of the electron propagator in the first quadrant:

□γZres(E)=iα∫d3q(2π)3Θ(νe)∑i=13Res⁡[Vi(q,ℓ)]TiγZ(νe,q),(58)\square_{\gamma Z}^{\mathrm{res}}(E)=i\alpha\int\frac{d^{3}\mathbf{q}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\Theta(\nu_{e})\sum_{i=1}^{3}\operatorname{Res}[V_{i}(\mathbf{q},\ell)]T_{i}^{\gamma Z}(\nu_{e},\mathbf{q}), \tag*{(58)}

where

Res⁡[Vi(q,ℓ)]=lim⁡ν→νe(ν−νe)Vi(q,ℓ).(59)\operatorname{Res}[V_{i}(\mathbf{q},\ell)]=\lim_{\nu\to\nu_{e}}(\nu-\nu_{e})V_{i}(\mathbf{q},\ell). \tag*{(59)}

The lattice treatment of the “Wick” and “residue” term in Eq. (56) are very different. They all start with the Euclidean hadronic function Hμν,E(tE,x)\mathcal{H}_{\mu\nu,E}(t_{E},\mathbf{x}) (and its spatial Fourier transform) involving Euclidean current operators, which is directly computable on lattice:

Hμν(tE,x)=⟨p∣T{Jμ,Eem(tE,x)Jν,EZ(0)}∣p⟩,H~μν,E(tE,q)=∫d3xe−iq⋅xHμν,E(tE,x).(60)\mathcal{H}_{\mu\nu}(t_{E},\mathbf{x})=\langle p|T\{J_{\mu,E}^{\mathrm{em}}(t_{E},\mathbf{x})J_{\nu,E}^{Z}(0)\}|p\rangle,\quad\widetilde{\mathcal{H}}_{\mu\nu,E}(t_{E},\mathbf{q})=\int d^{3}x e^{-i\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{x}}\mathcal{H}_{\mu\nu,E}(t_{E},\mathbf{x}). \tag*{(60)}

For the “Wick” component, what we need is just an ordinary temporal Fourier transform:

Tμν,E(iνE,q)=∫dtEe−iνEtEH~μν,E(tE,q),(61)T_{\mu\nu,E}(i\nu_{E},\mathbf{q})=\int dt_{E}e^{-i\nu_{E}t_{E}}\widetilde{\mathcal{H}}_{\mu\nu,E}(t_{E},\mathbf{q}), \tag*{(61)}

which treatment is exactly the same as in the γW\gamma W-box. On the other hand, the “residue” contribution involves a Laplace transform:

Tμν(νe,q)=∫−T/2T/2dtEeνetEH~μν(tE,q),(62)T_{\mu\nu}(\nu_{e},\mathbf{q})=\int_{-T/2}^{T/2}dt_{E}e^{\nu_{e}t_{E}}\widetilde{\mathcal{H}}_{\mu\nu}(t_{E},\mathbf{q}), \tag*{(62)}

where a temporal extent TT is introduced. For any non-zero EE, there exists intermediate states with energy than the external state energy E+mNE+m_{N}, which causes the Laplace transform to diverge as T→∞T\to\infty; such divergence has to be removed using the infinite-volume reconstruction method [133, 134, 135, 136]. In addition, as EE increases, the location of the pole νe\nu_{e} could lie above the NπN\pi production threshold which leads to power-law finite-volume effects. Also, the long-distance reconstruction receives contributions from the NπN\pi states. Overcoming all the obstacles above, Ref.[108] reported the result at E=155E=155 MeV, relevant to the P2 experiment, as:

□γZ(E=155 MeV)=5.76(32)stat(26)ES(11)FV×10−3,(63)\square_{\gamma Z}(E=155\ \mathrm{MeV})=5.76(32)_{\mathrm{stat}}(26)_{\mathrm{ES}}(11)_{\mathrm{FV}}\times10^{-3}, \tag*{(63)}

where the uncertainties are statistical (stat), excited-state contamination (ES), and finite-volume effects (FV), respectively. This result is systematically smaller than the outcome of the dispersive analysis [121, 122], where the main difference comes from the vector box diagram (1.84(31)×10−3 vs 2.94(18)×10−3)(1.84(31)\times10^{-3}\ \mathrm{vs}\ 2.94(18)\times10^{-3}). The origin of such discrepancy is yet to be understood.

Conclusions

Hadronic and nuclear uncertainties that enter the two-gauge-boson exchange diagram corrections to experimental measurables in weak interaction processes, such as beta decay lifetime and asymmetry in PVES, have to be properly taken into account to improve their sensitivity to BSM physics, and this requires non-perturbative treatments of strong interaction physics. Up to single-nucleon level, this can be done through data-driven analysis based on dispersion relation or lattice QCD calculations of four-point correlation functions. For nuclear systems, the above should be supplemented by nuclear ab initio methods to either compute nuclear Green’s functions or effective two-body potentials. Finally, for correlation coefficients in beta decays, the proper treatment of kinematics in radiative corrections, especially the bremsstrahlung process, is crucial for the extraction of the axial-to-vector coupling ratio λ\lambda.

Acknowledgments

The work of C.-Y.S. is supported in part by the DOE Topical Collaboration “Nuclear Theory for New Physics”, award No. DE-SC0023663, and by University of Tennessee, Knoxville.

References

References

  1. [1]S. L. Glashow, Partial Symmetries of Weak Interactions, Nucl. Phys. 22 (1961) 579–588. doi:10.1016/0029-5582(61)900469-2.DOI
  2. [2]S. Weinberg, A Model of Leptons, Phys. Rev. Lett. 19 (1967) 1264–1266. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.19.1264.DOI
  3. [3]A. Salam, Weak and Electromagnetic Interactions, Conf. Proc. C 680519 (1968) 367–377. doi:10.1142/9789812795915_0034.
  4. [4]N. Aghanim, et al., Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters, Astron. Astrophys. 641 (2020) A6. arXiv:1807.06209, doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201833910.
  5. [5]A. G. Riess, et al., Observational evidence for an accelerating universe and a cosmological constant, Astron. J. 116 (1998) 1009–1038. arXiv:astro-ph/9805201, doi:10.1086/300499.DOI
  6. [6]S. Perlmutter, et al., Measurements of Ω and Λ from 42 high redshift supernovae, Astrophys. J. 517 (1999) 565–586. arXiv:astro-ph/9812133, doi:10.1086/307221.DOI
  7. [7]J. D. Simon, The Faintest Dwarf Galaxies, Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 57 (1) (2019) 375–415. arXiv:1901.05465, doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-091918-104453.DOI
  8. [8]P. Salucci, The distribution of dark matter in galaxies, Astron. Astrophys. Rev. 27 (1) (2019) 2. arXiv:1811.08843, doi:10.1007/s00159-018-0113-1.DOI
  9. [9]S. W. Allen, A. E. Evrard, A. B. Mantz, Cosmological Parameters from Observations of Galaxy Clusters, Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 49 (2011) 409–470. arXiv:1103.4829, doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-081710-102514.DOI
  10. [10]V. Mossa, et al., The baryon density of the Universe from an improved rate of deuterium burning, Nature 587 (7833) (2020) 210–213. doi:10.1038/s41586-020-2878-4.DOI
  11. [11]S. Chatrchyan, et al., Observation of a New Boson at a Mass of 125 GeV with the CMS Experiment at the LHC, Phys. Lett. B 716 (2012) 30–61. arXiv:1207.7235, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2012.08.021.DOI
  12. [12]G. Aad, et al., Observation of a new particle in the search for the Standard Model Higgs boson with the ATLAS detector at the LHC, Phys. Lett. B 716 (2012) 1–29. arXiv:1207.7214, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2012.08.020.DOI
  13. [13]S. Weinberg, Baryon and Lepton Nonconserving Processes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 43 (1979) 1566–1570. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.43.1566.DOI
  14. [14]F. Wilczek, A. Zee, Operator Analysis of Nucleon Decay, Phys. Rev. Lett. 43 (1979) 1571–1573. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.43.1571.DOI
  15. [15]W. Buchmuller, D. Wyler, Effective Lagrangian Analysis of New Interactions and Flavor Conservation, Nucl. Phys. B 268 (1986) 621–653. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(86)90262-2.
  16. [16]B. Grzadkowski, M. Iskrzynski, M. Misiak, J. Rosiek, Dimension-Six Terms in the Standard Model Lagrangian, JHEP 10 (2010) 085. arXiv:1008.4884, doi:10.1007/JHEP10(2010)085.DOI
  17. [17]E. E. Jenkins, A. V. Manohar, M. Trott, Renormalization Group Evolution of the Standard Model Dimension Six Operators I: Formalism and lambda Dependence, JHEP 10 (2013) 087. arXiv:1308.2627, doi:10.1007/JHEP10(2013)087.DOI
  18. [18]B. Abi, et al., Measurement of the Positive Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment to 0.46 ppm, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126 (14) (2021) 141801. arXiv:2104.03281, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.126.141801.DOI
  19. [19]T. Aoyama, et al., The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon in the Standard Model, Phys. Rept. 887 (2020) 1–166. arXiv:2006.04822, doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2020.07.006.DOI
  20. [20]D. P. Aguillard, et al., Measurement of the Positive Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment to 127 ppb, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135 (10) (2025) 101802. arXiv:2506.03609, doi:10.1103/7clf-sm2v.
  21. [21]R. Alberti, et al., The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon in the Standard Model: an update, Phys. Rept. 1143 (2025) 1–158. arXiv:2505.21476, doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2025.08.002.
  22. [22]S. Borsanyi, et al., Leading hadronic contribution to the muon magnetic moment from lattice QCD, Nature 593 (7857) (2021) 51–55. arXiv:2002.12347, doi:10.1038/s41586-021-03418-1.DOI
  23. [23]N. Cabibbo, Unitary Symmetry and Leptonic Decays, Phys. Rev. Lett. 10 (1963) 531–533. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.10.531.DOI
  24. [24]M. Kobayashi, T. Maskawa, CP Violation in the Renormalizable Theory of Weak Interaction, Prog. Theor. Phys. 49 (1973) 652–657. doi:10.1143/PTP.49.652.DOI
  25. [25]B. R. Barrett, P. Navrátil, J. P. Vary, Ab initio no core shell model, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 69 (2013) 131–181. doi:10.1016/j.ppnp.2012.10.003.
  26. [26]G. Hagen, T. Papenbrock, M. Hjorth-Jensen, D. J. Dean, Coupled-cluster computations of atomic nuclei, Rept. Prog. Phys. 77 (9) (2014) 096302. arXiv:1312.7872, doi:10.1088/0034-4885/77/9/096302.DOI
  27. [27]K. Tsukiyama, S. K. Bogner, A. Schwenk, In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group for Nuclei, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106 (2011) 222502. arXiv:1006.3639, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.106.222502.DOI
  28. [28]H. Hergert, S. K. Bogner, T. D. Morris, A. Schwenk, K. Tsukiyama, The In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group: A Novel Ab Initio Method for Nuclei, Phys. Rept. 621 (2016) 165–222. arXiv:1512.06956, doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2015.12.007.DOI
  29. [29]J. Carlson, S. Gandolfi, F. Pederiva, S. C. Pieper, R. Schiavilla, K. E. Schmidt, R. B. Wiringa, Quantum Monte Carlo methods for nuclear physics, Rev. Mod. Phys. 87 (2015) 1067. arXiv:1412.2817, doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.87.1067.
  30. [30]T. A. Lähde, U.-G. Meißner, Nuclear Lattice Effective Field Theory: An introduction, Vol. 957, Springer, 2019. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-14189-9.DOI
  31. [31]V. Cirigliano, W. Dekens, J. de Vries, E. Mereghetti, T. Tong, Anomalies in global SMEFT analyses. A case study of first-row CKM unitarity, JHEP 03 (2024) 033. arXiv:2311.00021, doi:10.1007/JHEP03(2024)033.
  32. [32]E. Fermi, An attempt of a theory of beta radiation. 1., Z. Phys. 88 (1934) 161–177. doi:10.1007/BF01351864.
  33. [33]A. Sirlin, Current Algebra Formulation of Radiative Corrections in Gauge Theories and the Universality of the Weak Interactions, Rev. Mod. Phys. 50 (1978) 573, [Erratum: Rev. Mod. Phys.50,905(1978)]. doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.50.573.DOI
  34. [34]C.-Y. Seng, Radiative Corrections to Semileptonic Beta Decays: Progress and Challenges, Particles 4 (4) (2021) 397–467. arXiv:2108.03279, doi:10.3390/particles4040034.DOI
  35. [35]M. Gorchtein, C.-Y. Seng, The Standard Model Theory of Neutron Beta Decay, Universe 9 (9) (2023) 422. arXiv:2307.01145, doi:10.3390/universe9090422.
  36. [36]H. Burkhardt, W. N. Cottingham, Sum rules for forward virtual Compton scattering, Annals Phys. 56 (1970) 453–463. doi:10.1016/0003-4916(70)90025-4.DOI
  37. [37]P. A. Baikov, K. G. Chetyrkin, J. H. Kuhn, Adler Function, DIS sum rules and Crewther Relations, Nucl. Phys. B Proc. Suppl. 205-206 (2010) 237–241. arXiv:1007.0478, doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysbps.2010.08.049.DOI
  38. [38]P. Baikov, K. Chetyrkin, J. H. Kuhn, Adler Function, Bjorken Sum Rule, and the Crewther Relation to Order α⁴s in a General Gauge Theory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104 (2010) 132004. arXiv:1001.3606, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.104.132004.DOI
  39. [39]P. A. Baikov, K. G. Chetyrkin, J. H. Kuhn, J. Rittinger, Adler Function, Sum Rules and Crewther Relation of Order O(α⁴s): the Singlet Case, Phys. Lett. B 714 (2012) 62–65. arXiv:1206.1288, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2012.06.052.DOI
  40. [40]V. Bernard, L. Elouadrhiri, U-G. Meißner, Axial structure of the nucleon: Topical Review, J. Phys. G 28 (2002) R1–R35. arXiv:hep-ph/0107088, doi:10.1088/0954-3899/28/1/201.DOI
  41. [41]B. Bhattacharya, R. J. Hill, G. Paz, Model independent determination of the axial mass parameter in quasielastic neutrino-nucleon scattering, Phys. Rev. D 84 (2011) 073006. arXiv:1108.0423, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.84.073006.DOI
  42. [42]I. T. Lorenz, H. W. Hammer, U.-G. Meißner, The size of the proton - closing in on the radius puzzle, Eur. Phys. J. A 48 (2012) 151. arXiv:1205.6628, doi:10.1140/epja/i2012-12151-1.DOI
  43. [43]I. T. Lorenz, U.-G. Meißner, H. W. Hammer, Y. B. Dong, Theoretical Constraints and Systematic Effects in the Determination of the Proton Form Factors, Phys. Rev. D 91 (1) (2015) 014023. arXiv:1411.1704, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.91.014023.DOI
  44. [44]Z. Ye, J. Arrington, R. J. Hill, G. Lee, Proton and Neutron Electromagnetic Form Factors and Uncertainties, Phys. Lett. B 777 (2018) 8–15. arXiv:1707.09063, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2017.11.023.DOI
  45. [45]Y.-H. Lin, H.-W. Hammer, U.-G. Meißner, High-precision determination of the electric and magnetic radius of the proton, Phys. Lett. B 816 (2021) 136254. arXiv:2102.11642, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2021.136254.DOI
  46. [46]Y.-H. Lin, H.-W. Hammer, U.-G. Meißner, Dispersion-theoretical analysis of the electromagnetic form factors of the nucleon: Past, present and future (6 2021). arXiv:2106.06357.DOI
  47. [47]K. Borah, R. J. Hill, G. Lee, O. Tomalak, Parametrization and applications of the low-Q² nucleon vector form factors, Phys. Rev. D 102 (7) (2020) 074012. arXiv:2003.13640, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.102.074012.DOI
  48. [48]O. Tomalak, A. S. Meyer, C. Wret, T. Cai, R. J. Hill, K. S. McFarland, Nucleon axial-vector form factor and radius from radiatively corrected antineutrino scattering data, Phys. Rev. D 113 (7) (2026) 073004. arXiv:2601.21155, doi:10.1103/f3b2h-1h2.arxiv.org/abs/2601.21155
  49. [49]P. L. Anthony, et al., Determination of the neutron spin structure function, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71 (1993) 959–962. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.71.959.DOI
  50. [50]K. Abe, et al., Precision measurement of the proton spin structure function g1(p), Phys. Rev. Lett. 74 (1995) 346–350. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.74.346.DOI
  51. [51]K. Abe, et al., Precision determination of the neutron spin structure function g1(n), Phys. Rev. Lett. 79 (1997) 26–30. arXiv:hep-ex/9705012, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.79.26.DOI
  52. [52]D. Adams, et al., Measurement of the spin dependent structure function g1(x) of the proton, Phys. Lett. B 329 (1994) 399–406, [Erratum: Phys.Lett.B 339, 332–333 (1994)]. arXiv:hep-ph/9404270, doi:10.1016/0370-2693(94)90793-5.
  53. [53]V. Y. Alexakhin, et al., The Deuteron Spin-dependent Structure Function g1(d) and its First Moment, Phys. Lett. B 647 (2007) 8–17. arXiv:hep-ex/0609038, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2006.12.076.DOI
  54. [54]M. G. Alekseev, et al., The Spin-dependent Structure Function of the Proton g1p and a Test of the Bjorken Sum Rule, Phys. Lett. B 690 (2010) 466–472. arXiv:1001.4654, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2010.05.069.DOI
  55. [55]M. Aghasyan, et al., Longitudinal double-spin asymmetry A1p and spin-dependent structure function g1p of the proton at small values of x and Q², Phys. Lett. B 781 (2018) 464–472. arXiv:1710.01014, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2018.03.044.
  56. [56]K. Ackerstaff, et al., Measurement of the neutron spin structure function g1(n) with a polarized He-3 internal target, Phys. Lett. B 404 (1997) 383–389. arXiv:hep-ex/9703005, doi:10.1016/S0370-2693(97)00611-4.DOI
  57. [57]A. Deur, et al., Experimental determination of the evolution of the Bjorken integral at low Q**2, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004) 212001. arXiv:hep-ex/0407007, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.93.212001.DOI
  58. [58]F. R. Wesselmann, et al., Proton spin structure in the resonance region, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 (2007) 132003. arXiv:nucl-ex/0608003, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.132003.DOI
  59. [59]A. Deur, et al., Experimental study of isovector spin sum rules, Phys. Rev. D 78 (2008) 032001. arXiv:0802.3198, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.78.032001.DOI
  60. [60]N. Guler, et al., Precise determination of the deuteron spin structure at low to moderate Q² with CLAS and extraction of the neutron contribution, Phys. Rev. C 92 (5) (2015) 055201. arXiv:1505.07877, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.92.055201.DOI
  61. [61]R. Fersch, et al., Determination of the Proton Spin Structure Functions for 0.05 < Q² < 5 GeV² using CLAS, Phys. Rev. C 96 (6) (2017) 065208. arXiv:1706.10289, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.96.065208.DOI
  62. [62]M. Gorchtein, C.-Y. Seng, Dispersion relation analysis of the radiative corrections to gA in the neutron β-decay, JHEP 10 (2021) 053. arXiv:2106.09185, doi:10.1007/JHEP10(2021)053.DOI
  63. [63]O. Lalakulich, E. A. Paschos, Resonance production by neutrinos. I. J = 3/2 resonances, Phys. Rev. D 71 (2005) 074003. arXiv:hep-ph/0501109, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.71.074003.DOI
  64. [64]O. Lalakulich, E. A. Paschos, G. Piranishvili, Resonance production by neutrinos: The Second resonance region, Phys. Rev. D 74 (2006) 014009. arXiv:hep-ph/0602210, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.74.014009.DOI
  65. [65]T. Bolognese, P. Fritze, J. Morfin, D. H. Perkins, K. Powell, W. G. Scott, Data on the Gross-Iwellyn Smith Sum Rule as a Function of q², Phys. Rev. Lett. 50 (1983) 224. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.50.224.DOI
  66. [66]P. C. Bosetti, et al., Comparison of Nucleon Structure Functions in Bubble Chamber Neutrino Experiments With QCD Predictions, Nucl. Phys. B 203 (1982) 362–384. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(82)90319-4.DOI
  67. [67]C.-Y. Seng, M. Gorchtein, H. H. Patel, M. J. Ramsey-Musolf, Reduced Hadronic Uncertainty in the Determination of Vud, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121 (24) (2018) 241804. arXiv:1807.10197, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.121.241804.
  68. [68]C. Y. Seng, M. Gorchtein, M. J. Ramsey-Musolf, Dispersive evaluation of the inner radiative correction in neutron and nuclear β decay, Phys. Rev. D100 (1) (2019) 013001. arXiv:1812.03352, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.100.013001.DOI
  69. [69]K. Shiells, P. G. Blunden, W. Melnitchouk, Electroweak axial structure functions and improved extraction of the Vud CKM matrix element, Phys. Rev. D 104 (3) (2021) 033003. arXiv:2012.01580, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.104.033003.DOI
  70. [70]O. Nachtmann, Positivity constraints for anomalous dimensions, Nucl. Phys. B 63 (1973) 237–247. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(73)90144-2.DOI
  71. [71]O. Nachtmann, Is There Evidence for Large Anomalous Dimensions?, Nucl. Phys. B 78 (1978) 147–164. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(74)90591-4.
  72. [72]X. Feng, M. Gorchtein, L.-C. Jin, P.-X. Ma, C.-Y. Seng, First-principles calculation of electroweak box diagrams from lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124 (19) (2020) 192002. arXiv:2003.09798, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.124.192002.DOI
  73. [73]J.-S. Yoo, T. Bhattacharya, R. Gupta, S. Mondal, B. Yoon, Electroweak box diagram contribution for pion and kaon decay from lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. D 108 (3) (2023) 034508. arXiv:2305.03198, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.108.034508.DOI
  74. [74]V. Cirigliano, M. Knecht, H. Neufeld, H. Pichl, The Pion beta decay in chiral perturbation theory, Eur. Phys. J. C 27 (2003) 255–262. arXiv:hep-ph/0209226, doi:10.1140/epjc/s2002-01093-2.DOI
  75. [75]V. Cirigliano, M. Hoferichter, N. Valori, Pion β Decay and τ−→πντ beyond Leading Logarithms, Phys. Rev. Lett. 137 (5) (2026) 051902. arXiv:2602.11253, doi:10.1103/rg2q-m515.
  76. [76]C.-Y. Seng, X. Feng, M. Gorchtein, L.-C. Jin, Joint lattice QCD–dispersion theory analysis confirms the quark-mixing top-row unitarity deficit, Phys. Rev. D 101 (11) (2020) 111301. arXiv:2003.11264, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.101.111301.DOI
  77. [77]P.-X. Ma, X. Feng, M. Gorchtein, L.-C. Jin, K.-F. Liu, C.-Y. Seng, B.-G. Wang, Z.-L. Zhang, Lattice QCD Calculation of Electroweak Box Contributions to Superallowed Nuclear and Neutron Beta Decays, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 (19) (2024) 191901. arXiv:2308.16755, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.132.191901.DOI
  78. [78]J. C. Hardy, I. S. Towner, Superallowed 0+ → 0+ nuclear β decays: 2020 critical survey, with implications for Vud and CKM unitarity, Phys. Rev. C 102 (4) (2020) 045501. doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.102.045501.DOI
  79. [79]M. Brodeur, et al., Nuclear β decay as a probe for physics beyond the Standard Model, 2023. arXiv:2301.03975.arxiv.org/abs/2301.03975
  80. [80]A. Sirlin, General Properties of the Electromagnetic Corrections to the Beta Decay of a Physical Nucleon, Phys. Rev. 164 (1967) 1767–1775. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.164.1767.DOI
  81. [81]Z. Cao, R. J. Hill, R. Plestid, P. Vander Griend, Za2 correction to superallowed beta decays in effective field theory and implications for Vud, Phys. Rev. D 114 (1) (2026) 013011. arXiv:2511.05446, doi:10.1103/ns y w-wfp3.arxiv.org/abs/2511.05446
  82. [82]Ò. L. Crosas, E. Mereghetti, Radiative corrections to superallowed beta decays at O(α2Z), JHEP 02 (2026) 114. arXiv:2511.05481, doi:10.1007/JHEP02(2026)114.DOI
  83. [83]M. Gorchtein, C. Y. Seng, Superallowed Nuclear Beta Decays and Precision Tests of the Standard Model, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 74 (1) (2024) 23–47. arXiv:2311.00044, doi:10.1146/annurev-nucl-102622-020726.DOI
  84. [84]G. H. Sargsyan, G. B. King, A. Glick-Magid, C.-Y. Seng, The Role of Ab Initio Beta-Decay Calculations in Light Nuclei for Probes of Physics Beyond the Standard Model (1 2026). arXiv:2602.00341.DOI
  85. [85]C.-Y. Seng, M. Gorchtein, Dispersive formalism for the nuclear structure correction δNS to the β decay rate, Phys. Rev. C 107 (3) (2023) 035503. arXiv:2211.10214, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.107.035503.DOI
  86. [86]V. Cirigliano, W. Dekens, J. de Vries, S. Gandolfi, M. Hoferichter, E. Mereghetti, Ab initio electroweak corrections to superallowed β decays and their impact on Vud, Phys. Rev. C 110 (5) (2024) 055502. arXiv:2405.18464, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.110.055502.DOI
  87. [87]V. Cirigliano, W. Dekens, J. de Vries, S. Gandolfi, M. Hoferichter, E. Mereghetti, Radiative Corrections to Superallowed β Decays in Effective Field Theory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133 (21) (2024) 211801. arXiv:2405.18469, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.133.211801.DOI
  88. [88]M. Gennari, M. Drissi, M. Gorchtein, P. Navratil, C.-Y. Seng, Ab Initio Strategy for Taming the Nuclear-Structure Dependence of Vud Extractions: The C10→B10 Superallowed Transition, Phys. Rev. Lett. 134 (1) (2025) 012501. arXiv:2405.19281, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.134.012501.
  89. [89]G. B. King, J. Carlson, A. R. Flores, S. Gandolfi, E. Mereghetti, S. Pastore, M. Piarulli, R. B. Wiringa, Quantum Monte Carlo calculation of δNS in 10C using an effective field theory approach (9 2025). arXiv:2509.07310.arxiv.org/abs/2509.07310
  90. [90]B. Märkisch, et al., Measurement of the Weak Axial-Vector Coupling Constant in the Decay of Free Neutrons Using a Pulsed Cold Neutron Beam, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122 (24) (2019) 242501. arXiv:1812.04666, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.122.242501.DOI
  91. [91]M. Beck, et al., Improved determination of the β−ν̄e angular correlation coefficient a in free neutron decay with the aSPECT spectrometer, Phys. Rev. C 101 (5) (2020) 055506. arXiv:1908.04785, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.101.055506.DOI
  92. [92]M. Beck, W. Heil, C. Schmidt, S. Baéβler, F. Glück, G. Konrad, U. Schmidt, Reanalysis of the β−ν̄e Angular Correlation Measurement from the aSPECT Experiment with New Constraints on Fierz Interference, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 (10) (2024) 102501. arXiv:2308.16170, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.132.102501.DOI
  93. [93]A. Garcia, M. Maya, MODEL INDEPENDENT RADIATIVE CORRECTIONS TO M+-(l3) DECAYS, Phys. Rev. D 23 (1981) 2603. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.23.2603.DOI
  94. [94]T. Kinoshita, Mass singularities of Feynman amplitudes, J. Math. Phys. 3 (1962) 650–677. doi:10.1063/1.1724268.DOI
  95. [95]T. D. Lee, M. Naunberg, Degenerate Systems and Mass Singularities, Phys. Rev. 133 (1964) B1549–B1562. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.133.B1549.DOI
  96. [96]V. Cirigliano, J. de Vries, L. Hayen, E. Mereghetti, A. Walker-Loud, Pion-Induced Radiative Corrections to Neutron β Decay, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129 (12) (2022) 121801. arXiv:2202.10439, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.129.121801.DOI
  97. [97]F. Glück, Radiative corrections to neutron and nuclear β-decays: a serious kinematics problem in the literature, JHEP 09 (2023) 188. arXiv:2205.05042, doi:10.1007/JHEP09(2023)188.DOI
  98. [98]C.-Y. Seng, Pseudo-neutrino versus recoil formalism for 4-body phase space and applications to nuclear decay, Phys. Rev. C 109 (3) (2024) 035501. arXiv:2312.08630, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.109.035501.DOI
  99. [99]J. Erler, R. Ferro-Hernández, Weak Mixing Angle in the Thomson Limit, JHEP 03 (2018) 196. arXiv:1712.09146, doi:10.1007/JHEP03(2018)196.DOI
  100. [100]K. S. Kumar, S. Mantry, W. J. Marciano, P. A. Souder, Low Energy Measurements of the Weak Mixing Angle, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 63 (2013) 237–267. arXiv:1302.6263, doi:10.1146/annurev-nucl-102212-170556.DOI
  101. [101]H. Davoudiasl, H.-S. Lee, W. J. Marciano, Low Q^2 weak mixing angle measurements and rare Higgs decays, Phys. Rev. D 92 (5) (2015) 055005. arXiv:1507.00352, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.92.055005.DOI
  102. [102]D. Androić, et al., Measurement of the weak charge of the proton, Nature 557 (7704) (2018) 207–211. arXiv:1905.08283, doi:10.1038/s41586-018-0096-0.DOI
  103. [103]D. Becker, et al., The P2 experiment (2 2018). arXiv:1802.04759, doi:10.1140/epja/i2018-12611-6.DOI
  104. [104]J. Erler, A. Kurylov, M. J. Ramsey-Musolf, The Weak charge of the proton and new physics, Phys. Rev. D 68 (2003) 016006. arXiv:hep-ph/0302149, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.68.016006.
  105. [105]M. J. G. V. Main, Limit on Mass Differences in the Weinberg Model, Nucl. Phys. B 123 (1977) 89–99. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(77)90342-X.
  106. [106]W. J. Marciano, A. Sirlin, RADIATIVE CORRECTIONS TO ATOMIC PARITY VIOLATION, Phys. Rev. D 27 (1983) 552. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.27.552.DOI
  107. [107]W. J. Marciano, A. Sirlin, On Some General Properties of the O(alpha) Corrections to Parity Violation in Atoms, Phys. Rev. D 29 (1984) 75, [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 31, 213 (1985)]. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.29.75.DOI
  108. [108]Z.-I. Zhang, X. Feng, M. Gorchtein, L.-C. Jin, C. Liu, C.-Y. Seng, Lattice QCD determination of the γZ box contribution to the proton weak charge (1 2026). arXiv:2601.06582.arxiv.org/abs/2601.06582
  109. [109]M. Gorchtein, C. J. Horowitz, Dispersion gamma Z-box correction to the weak charge of the proton, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 (2009) 091806. arXiv:0811.0614, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.102.091806.DOI
  110. [110]A. Sibirtsev, P. G. Blunden, W. Melnitchouk, A. W. Thomas, gamma-Z corrections to forward-angle parity-violating e-p scattering, Phys. Rev. D 82 (2010) 013011. arXiv:1002.0740, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.82.013011.DOI
  111. [111]B. C. Rislow, C. E. Carlson, Contributions from γZ box diagrams to parity violating elastic ep scattering, Phys. Rev. D 83 (2011) 113007. arXiv:1011.2397, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.83.113007.DOI
  112. [112]M. Gorchtein, C. J. Horowitz, M. J. Ramsey-Musolf, Model-dependence of the γZ dispersion correction to the parity-violating asymmetry in elastic ep scattering, Phys. Rev. C 84 (2011) 015502. arXiv:1102.3910, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.84.015502.
  113. [113]P. G. Blunden, W. Melnitchouk, A. W. Thomas, New formulation of gamma-Z box corrections to the weak charge of the proton, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107 (2011) 081801. arXiv:1102.5334, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.081801.DOI
  114. [114]C. E. Carlson, B. C. Rislow, Resonance Region Structure Functions and Parity Violating Deep Inelastic Scattering, Phys. Rev. D 85 (2012) 073002. arXiv:1201.3323, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.85.073002.DOI
  115. [115]P. G. Blunden, W. Melnitchouk, A. W. Thomas, γ − Z box corrections to weak charges of heavy nuclei in atomic parity violation, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109 (2012) 262301. arXiv:1208.4310, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.109.262301.DOI
  116. [116]N. L. Hall, P. G. Blunden, W. Melnitchouk, A. W. Thomas, R. D. Young, Constrained γZ interference corrections to parity-violating electron scattering, Phys. Rev. D 88 (1) (2013) 013011. arXiv:1304.7877, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.88.013011.
  117. [117]B. C. Rislow, C. E. Carlson, Modification of electromagnetic structure functions for the γZ-box diagram, Phys. Rev. D 88 (2013) 013018. arXiv:1304.8113, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.88.013018.DOI
  118. [118]N. L. Hall, P. G. Blunden, W. Melnitchouk, A. W. Thomas, R. D. Young, Hadronic γZ box corrections in Møller scattering, Phys. Lett. B 731 (2014) 287–292, [Erratum: Phys.Lett.B 733, 380 (2014)]. arXiv:1311.3389, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2014.04.033.
  119. [119]M. Gorchtein, X. Zhang, Forward Compton Scattering with Weak Neutral Current: Constraints from Sum Rules, Phys. Lett. B 747 (2015) 305–309. arXiv:1501.05357, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2015.06.009.DOI
  120. [120]N. L. Hall, P. G. Blunden, W. Melnitchouk, A. W. Thomas, R. D. Young, Quark–hadron duality constraints on γZ box corrections to parity-violating elastic scattering, Phys. Lett. B 753 (2016) 221–226. arXiv:1504.03973, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2015.11.081.DOI
  121. [121]M. Gorchtein, H. Spiesberger, X. Zhang, How strange is pion electroproduction?, Phys. Lett. B 752 (2016) 135–145. arXiv:1509.08780, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2015.11.038.DOI
  122. [122]J. Erler, M. Gorchtein, O. Koshchii, C.-Y. Seng, H. Spiesberger, Reduced uncertainty of the axial γZ-box correction to the proton’s weak charge, Phys. Rev. D 100 (5) (2019) 053007. arXiv:1907.07928, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.100.053007.DOI
  123. [123]T. A. Armstrong, et al., Total hadronic cross-section of gamma rays in hydrogen in the energy range 0.265-GeV to 4.215-GeV, Phys. Rev. D 5 (1972) 1640–1652. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.5.1640.DOI
  124. [124]D. O. Caldwell, V. B. Elings, W. P. Hesse, R. J. Morrison, F. V. Murphy, D. E. Yount, Total Hadronic Photoabsorption Cross-Sections on Hydrogen and Complex Nuclei from 4-GeV to 18-GeV, Phys. Rev. D 7 (1973) 1362. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.7.1362.
  125. [125]D. O. Caldwell, et al., Measurements of the Photon Total Cross-Section on Protons from 18 GeV to 185 GeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 40 (1978) 1222. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.40.1222.
  126. [126]S. Chekanov, et al., Measurement of the photon proton total cross-section at a center-of-mass energy of 209-GeV at HERA, Nucl. Phys. B 627 (2002) 3–28. arXiv:hep-ex/0202034, doi:10.1016/S0550-3213(02)00068-8.
  127. [127]G. M. Vereshkov, O. D. Lalakulich, Y. F. Novoseltsev, R. V. Novoseltseva, Total cross section for photon nucleon interaction in the energy range √s = 40-GeV - 250-GeV, Phys. Atom. Nucl. 66 (2003) 565–574. doi:10.1134/1.1563723.DOI
  128. [128]Y. Liang, et al., Measurement of R=σL/σT and the separated longitudinal and transverse structure functions in the nucleon-resonance region, Phys. Rev. C 105 (6) (2022) 065205. arXiv:nucl-ex/0410027, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.105.065205.DOI
  129. [129]L. W. Whitlow, E. M. Riordan, S. Dasu, S. Rock, A. Bodek, Precise measurements of the proton and deuteron structure functions from a global analysis of the SLAC deep inelastic electron scattering cross-sections, Phys. Lett. B 282 (1992) 475–482. doi:10.1016/0370-2693(92)90672-Q.DOI
  130. [130]M. R. Adams, et al., Proton and Deuteron Structure Functions in Muon Scattering at 470 GeV, Phys. Rev. D 54 (1996) 3006–3056. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.54.3006.DOI
  131. [131]C. Adloff, et al., Deep inelastic inclusive e p scattering at low x and a determination of alpha(s), Eur. Phys. J. C 21 (2001) 33–61. arXiv:hep-ex/0012053, doi:10.1007/s100520100720.DOI
  132. [132]D. J. Gross, C. H. Llewellyn Smith, Lepton hadron neutrino - nucleon scattering, current algebra and partons, Nucl. Phys. B14 (1969) 337–347. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(69)90213-2.DOI
  133. [133]Y. Fu, X. Feng, L.-C. Jin, C.-F. Lu, Lattice QCD Calculation of the Two-Photon Exchange Contribution to the Muonic-Hydrogen Lamb Shift, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128 (17) (2022) 172002. arXiv:2202.01472, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.128.172002.DOI
  134. [134]X.-H. Wang, Z.-L. Zhang, X.-H. Cao, C.-L. Fan, X. Feng, Y.-S. Gao, L.-C. Jin, C. Liu, Nucleon Electric Polarizabilities and Nucleon-Pion Scattering at the Physical Pion Mass, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133 (14) (2024) 141901. arXiv:2310.0168, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.133.141901.DOI
  135. [135]Y. Fu, X. Feng, L.-C. Jin, C. Liu, S.-D. Wen, Lattice QCD Calculation of the Subtraction Function in Forward Compton Amplitude, Phys. Rev. Lett. 134 (7) (2025) 071903. arXiv:2411.03141, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.134.071903.DOI
  136. [136]X.-Y. Tuo, X. Feng, Finite-volume formalism for physical processes with an electroweak loop integral, Phys. Rev. D 112 (3) (2025) 034512. arXiv:2407.16930, doi:10.1103/4mn6-w366.

Paper details

vlnc:W_fkur6rx9
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 9

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents