WorksPhysics and Astronomy
input to neutron stars from hypernuclear data
Abstract
This work is a sequel to our two 2023 publications [PLB 837 137669, NPA 1039 122725] where fitting 14 1 and 1 single-particle binding energies in hypernuclei across the periodic table led to a well-defined -nucleus optical potential. The potential consists of a Pauli modified linear-density () and a quadratic-density () terms. The present work reports on extending the above analysis to 21 single-particle data points input by including 1 and 1 states in medium-weight and heavy hypernuclei. The upgraded results for the and potential depths at nuclear-matter density ~fm, ~MeV and ~MeV together with the total depth ~MeV, agree within errors with the earlier results. The hypernuclear overbinding associated with the -induced potential depth agrees quantitatively with a recent combined analysis of low-energy scattering data and correlation functions [PLB 850 (2024) 138550]. These results, particularly the size of the repulsive , provide an essential input towards resolving the 'hyperon puzzle' in the core of neutron stars. We also show that a key property of our -induced potential term, i.e. a need to suppress the quadratic-density term involving an excess neutron and a core nucleon, can be tested in the forthcoming JLab E12-15-008 experiment.
E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected]
Submitted to
Proceedings of International Conference on Exotic Atoms and Related Topics and Conference on Low Energy Antiprotons (EXA-LEAP2024), 26-30 August 2024, Austrian Academy of Sciences, Vienna.
Introduction
Binding energies of hyperons in single-particle states of hypernuclei along the periodic table have been studied since the 1970s [1]. Although these data are fitted by several versions of optical-model and Skyrme-Hartree-Fock (SHF) approaches that differ in their high powers of the nuclear density , the need to consider high powers of has not been demonstrated unambiguously. Recent observations of neutron stars (NS) with mass exceeding twice solar mass are in conflict with the expectation that hyperons in NS cores would soften the NS equation of state, thus preventing NS masses from exceeding solar mass. However, a mechanism of inhibiting the appearance of hyperons through a repulsive interaction apparently explains the astrophysical observations [2].
The present work offers a brief summary and an extension of our recent work [3, 4] on this topic. Using a simple density-dependent optical potential scheme, we check whether a repulsive term is required by fits to the binding-energy data. In Sect. 2 the optical potential is described focussing on nuclear densities based on nuclear sizes. § 3.1 shows optical-potential predictions obtained by fitting and binding energies in and then extrapolating the potential to heavier species. A need to suppress the term when one nucleon is in the charge-symmetric core and the other is an ‘excess’ neutron is established, apparently related to its isospin dependence. § 3.2 shows fits to the full data set, including and states not shown yet. § 3.3 demonstrates a way to study the isospin dependence of the term in electroproduction experiments. And the last section presents comparisons with several interaction models in which the interaction overbinds hypernuclei, thereby implying that the corresponding contribution is indeed repulsive.
Methodology
The -nuclear optical potential employed recently in our 2023 works [3, 4] is of the form , representing a two-body interaction
and three-body interaction
with and strength parameters in units of fm (). In these expressions, is the -nucleus reduced mass, is nuclear density normalized to the mass number of the nuclear core, stands for nuclear-matter density and are kinematical factors involved in going from the and c.m. systems, respectively, to the -nucleus c.m. system [5]:
The novelty of this presentation is connected to including explicitly Pauli correlations through the dependence of on the Fermi momentum which affects strongly the balance between the derived values of potential depths and . This form for including Pauli correlations was suggested in Ref. [6] and practised in atoms studies [7]. It is missing in most of SHF studies. We remark that the potential term derives mostly from OPE diagrams with and intermediate states [8]. Purely contributions are generated by short-range correlations [6], estimated in the present context to affect the derived value of by few percents at most. Finally, we note that the low-density limit of requires that is identified with the c.m. spin-averaged scattering length [5], taken positive here.
In optical-model applications similar to the one adopted here it is crucial to ensure that the radial extent of the densities, e.g., their r.m.s. radii, follow closely values derived from experiment. With , the sum of proton and neutron density distributions, respectively, we relate the proton densities to the corresponding charge densities where the finite size of the proton charge and recoil effects are included. This approach is equivalent to assigning some finite range to the -nucleon interaction. For the lightest elements in the database, harmonic-oscillator type densities were used for protons, assuming that the same radial parameters apply also for the corresponding neutron densities. For species beyond the nuclear 1p shell we chose two-parameter or three-parameter Fermi distributions normalized to for protons and for neutrons, derived from nuclear charge distributions assembled in Ref. [9]. For medium-weight and heavy nuclei, the r.m.s. radii of neutron density distributions assume larger values than those for proton density distributions, as practised in analyses of exotic atoms [5]. Once neutrons occupy single-nucleon orbits beyond those occupied by protons, it is useful to represent the nuclear density by
where refers to the protons plus the charge-symmetric neutrons occupying the same nuclear ‘core’ orbits, and refers to the ‘excess’ neutrons.
Results
Extrapolations from
As a preliminary test of the optical-model approach we chose to fit the binding energies of and states in the hypernucleus because the simple proton-hole structure of the nuclear core removes, in this case, some of the uncertainty from spin-dependent and interactions. and binding energies in hypernuclei, deduced from several strangeness production reactions, are listed in Table IV of Ref. [1] including experimental uncertainties, and summarized in Table 2 of Ref. [4].
The top part of Figure 1 (model X) shows comparisons with experiment when the parameters and of Eqs. (1),(2), determined by a fit to the two binding energies in , are used to predict and binding energies along the periodic table. Clearly seen is underbinding of and states in the heavier hypernuclei, argued [3, 4] to result from treating equally all pairs, including pairs where one nucleon is in the nuclear ‘core’ while the other is an ‘excess’ neutron. Removing the bilinear term from using Eq. (4) we replace for heavy species by
Figure 1. values across the periodic table as calculated in models X (upper) and Y (lower), compared with data points, including uncertainties. Continuous lines connect calculated values. Figure updating Fig. 3 in Ref. [3]. The upper part, model X, uses the full term. The lower part, model Y, replaces by a reduced form, decoupling excess neutrons from symmetric-core nucleons, see text. The dashed lines are for replaced by , with a suppression factor given by Eq. (6) below.
in terms of the available densities and . This prescription follows from the isospin dependence arising from intermediate and hyperons in the OPE interaction [8]. The reduced repulsion by the term is seen in the lower part of Figure 1 (model Y).
In the spirit of the present approach of avoiding explicit models, one can simply multiply by a suppression factor
that is approximately the ratio of the volume integral of to that of . This ratio is significant, going down to for Pb. Also seen in the figure as dashed lines (‘mac. scaling’) are results using instead of Eq. (5), leading to almost identical results for the two options. It is interesting that extrapolating from to is successful in describing the experimental results, while going down from into the nuclear -shell (two smallest A-values) does not support the present simple model.
Least-squares fits
Next we performed conventional fits with the suppression factor included for the four heaviest species. Figure 2 shows several fits to the data where black solid lines show fits to the full data set and open circles with error bars mark data points. It is clearly seen that the states in and do not fit into the otherwise good agreement with experiment for the heavier species. The red dashed lines show a very good fit obtained upon excluding these light elements from the data set. In fact, the potential parameters and of Eqs. (1),(2) are hardly affected by the two lightest and hypernuclei. The fit parameters are:
Figure 2. fits to the full and data (solid black lines) and when excluding and (dashed red lines). Also shown are predictions of and binding energies for the latter choice.
(attraction), (repulsion), with 100% correlation between the two parameters. The fully correlated partial potential depths and the full one at nuclear-matter density are (in MeV):
Also included in Figure 2 are predictions of and binding energies made with these parameters. Although it is not expected that higher states will be well described by the same potential, owing to overlooked secondary effects such as non-local terms, it is seen that while slight overbinding of the calculated energies appears for the heavier species, the present optical potential reproduces quite well the four deepest single-particle states in neutron-rich hypernuclei. It is therefore of interest to repeat the process on the whole set of experimental binding energies of single-particle states, a total of 21 binding-energy values between and . The resulting per degree of freedom is then 0.95 (compared to 0.6 from a fit to only 14 binding-energy values for the and states)
(attraction), (repulsion), with 100% correlation between the two parameters. The fully correlated partial potential depths and the full one at nuclear-matter density are (in MeV):
These values are in agreement with those in Eq. (7) based only on the and states. The uncertainties in the parameter values quoted above are statistical only. To estimate systematic effects within the adopted model we repeated the analysis with slightly modified nuclear densities such as obtained when unfolding the finite size of the proton. Values of came out unchanged whereas values of increased typically by 0.015 fm. The total potential depth at changed to , suggesting a systematic uncertainty of 1 MeV for this value.
Isospin dependence
Figure 3 shows calculated differences of binding energies for the and states between and as a function of the neutron skin in . The figure shows predictions made using our standard -nucleus potential upon including (excluding) in its upper (lower) part the suppression factor , Eq. (6). Regardless of the chosen value of , the effect of applying is about 2.5 MeV for the state and more than 2 MeV for the state, within reach of the approved JLab experiment E12-15-008 on targets [10]. For , our calculated values are close to those calculated in Refs. [11, 12].
Figure 3. values for and states, with and without applying the suppression factor , as a function of the neutron-skin of , see text.
Discussion and summary
The most significant results of the present phenomenological analysis using the methodology are the values at nuclear matter density of the two-body and three-body potentials, namely the partial depths and as well as their sum listed in Eq. (8). Microscopic models employed in calculations of astrophysical scenarios could then be tested for the first time in normal nuclear matter by comparing to the present results. SHF models, in contrast, do not produce reliable values of and . This holds for both old [13] as well as recent [14, 15] SHF calculations.
Table 1 shows comparisons between several recent model predictions and the present results for -nuclear potential depths. Note that all model values of are overbound with respect to the empirical depth value of MeV from hypernuclei [1] which tacitly enters such model calculations. In comparison with our listed value of , this overbinding suggests a repulsive contribution of depth MeV, a value indeed reached by one of the EFT model calculations [18] and in agreement with our listed value. It would be interesting to repeat this model calculation using our value of MeV as input. The bottom line of this NLO19 EFT plus baryon decuplet dominance model calculation is that hyperons are excluded from dense neutron stars owing to a term of a strength commensurate with MeV.
Table 1. Two-body, three-body and total -nucleus potential depths (in MeV) at nuclear matter density from several model calculations and from hypernuclear binding-energy data.
References
- [1]A. Gal, E.V. Hungerford, D.J. Millener, Strangeness in nuclear physics, Rev. Mod. Phys. 88 (2016) 035004.DOI
- [2]D. Gerstung, N. Kaiser, W. Weise, Hyperon-nucleon three-body forces and strangeness in neutron stars, Eur. Phys. J. A 56 (2020) 175.DOI
- [3]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Constraints from Λ hypernuclei on the ΛNN content of the Λ nucleus potential, Phys. Lett. B 837 (2023) 137669.DOI
- [4]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Λ hypernuclear potentials beyond linear density dependence, Nucl. Phys. A 1039 (2023) 122725.DOI
- [5]E. Friedman, A. Gal, In-medium nuclear interactions of low-energy hadrons, Phys. Rep. 452 (2007) 89.DOI
- [6]T. Waas, M. Rho, W. Weise, Effective kaon mass in dense baryonic matter: role of correlations, Nucl. Phys. A 617 (1997) 449.DOI
- [7]E. Friedman, A. Gal, K⁻N amplitudes below threshold constrained by multinucleon absorption, Nucl. Phys. A 959 (2017) 66.DOI
- [8]A. Gal, J.M. Soper, R.H. Dalitz, A shell-model analysis of Λ binding energies, I, Ann. Phys. (NY) 63 (1971) 53.
- [9]I. Angeli, K.P. Marinova, Table of experimental nuclear ground state charge radii: An update, At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 99 (2013) 69.DOI
- [10]S.N. Nakamura, Future prospects of spectroscopic study of Λ hypernuclei at JLab, EPJ Web of Conf. 271 (2022) 11003.
- [11]M. Isaka, Y. Yamamoto, Th.A. Rijken, Effects of a hyperonic many-body force on BΛ values of hypernuclei, Phys. Rev. C 95 (2017) 044308.DOI
- [12]P. Bydžovsky, et al., Self-consistent many-body approach to the electro-production of hypernuclei, Phys. Rev. C 108 (2023) 024615.DOI
- [13]D.J. Millener, C.B. Dover, A. Gal, Λ-nucleus single-particle potentials, Phys. Rev. C 38 (1988) 2700.DOI
- [14]H.-J. Schulze, E. Hiyama, Skyrme force for light and heavy hypernuclei, Phys. Rev. C 90 (2014) 047301.DOI
- [15]A. Jinno, K. Murase, Y. Nara, A. Ohnishi, Repulsive Λ potentials in dense neutron star matter and binding energy of Λ in hypernuclei, Phys. Rev. C 108 (2023) 065803.DOI
- [16]M.M. Nagels, Th.A. Rijken, Y. Yamamoto, Extended-soft-core baryon-baryon model ESC16. II. YN interactions, Phys. Rev. C 99 (2019) 044003.DOI
- [17]J. Haidenbauer, U.-G. Meißner, A. Nogga, Hyperon-nucleon interaction within χEFT revisited, Eur. Phys. J. A 56 (2020) 91.
- [18]W. Weise, Sound velocity, equation of state and strangeness in neutron star matter, EPJ Web of Conf. 291 (2024) 01007.arxiv.org/abs/2309.16438
- [19]J. Haidenbauer, U.-G. Meißner, A. Nogga, H. Le, Hyperon-nucleon interaction in χEFT at N²LO, Eur. Phys. J. A 59 (2023) 63.
- [20]D.L. Mihaylov, J. Haidenbauer, V. Mantovani Sarti, Constraining the pΛ interaction from a combined analysis of scattering data and correlation functions, Phys. Lett. B 850 (2024) 138550.


