WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Extended SAID Partial-Wave Analysis of Pion Photoproduction
Abstract
A unified Chew-Mandelstam description of single-pion photoproduction data, together with pion- and eta-hadroproduction data, has been extended to include measurements carried out over the last decade. We consider photo-decay amplitudes evaluated at the pole with particular emphasis on ng couplings and the influence of weighting on our fits. Both energy-dependent and single-energy analysis (energy-binned data) are considered.
Introduction
Our knowledge of the baryon spectrum, as determined from analyses of experimental data, has advanced rapidly [24] over the past decade. The progress has been most significant for non-strange baryons, due largely to the wealth of new and more precise measurements made at electron accelerators worldwide. The majority of these new measurements have been performed at Jefferson Lab, USA (using the CLAS and Hall A detectors), with the MAMI accelerator in Mainz, Germany (the Crystal Ball/TAPS detector being particularly well suited for the measurement of neutral final states), and with the Crystal Barrel detector at ELSA in Bonn, Germany. While most of the early progress [1–4] in baryon spectroscopy was based on the analysis of meson-nucleon scattering data, particularly pion-nucleon scattering (, ), photon-nucleon interactions offer the possibility of detecting unstable intermediate states with small branchings to the channel. Many groups have performed either single-channel or multi-channel analyses of these photon-induced reactions. In the more recent single-channel analyses, fits have typically used isobar models [5, 6] with unitarity constraints at the lower energies, -matrix-based formalisms, having built-in cuts associated with inelastic channels [7], and dispersion-relation constraints [6, 8]. Multi-channel fits have analyzed data (or, in some cases, amplitudes) from hadronic scattering experiments together with the photon-induced channels. These approaches have utilized unitarity more directly. Among others, analyses have been carried out by MAID [5], the Bonn-Gatchina [9], ANL-Osaka [10], Kent State [11], and JPAC [12] groups, SAID [7] (Scattering Analysis Interactive Database) and Jülich-Bonn [13]. Here we should also briefly mention the possibility of extracting reaction amplitudes directly from scattering
data with minimal model input. Examples of this approach are described in the analyses of kaon photoproduction data by the Jefferson Lab [14] and Bonn-Gatchina [15] groups. The measurements required for an amplitude extraction with minimal model bias differ depending on whether the goal is to obtain helicity amplitudes (the usual complete experiment case [16]) or partial-wave amplitudes [17]. A number of recent studies have shown the limits to model independence [18] and the convergence [19] of independent fits with the availability of more observables measured with high precision. The above studies have also recently been extended to pseudo-scalar-meson electroproduction [20].
An objective of this program is the determination of all relevant characteristics of these resonances, i.e., pole positions, widths, principal decay channels, and branching ratios. In order to compare directly with QCD-inspired models and Lattice QCD predictions, there has also been a considerable effort to find “hidden” or “missing” resonances [21], predicted by quark models [22] and LQCD [23] but not yet confirmed. Actually, PDG [24] reports a third of predicted states by QMs and LQCD.
Knowledge of the and resonance photodecay amplitudes has largely been restricted to the charged states. Apart from lower-energy inverse reaction measurements, the extraction of the two-body and observables requires the use of a model-dependent nuclear correction, which mainly comes from final state interaction (FSI) effects within the target deuteron [25–27]. As a result, the observables for proton-target experiments are most thoroughly explored and, among neutron-target (deuteron) measurements, the charge channel is least explored. This problem is less severe if isospin relations are used to express the four charge-channel amplitudes in terms of three isospin amplitudes [28]. Then, in principle, the production channel can be predicted in terms of the , , and production channel amplitudes. This approach has been tested [29] with the improved availability of data; we will consider this again in the fits to data that follow.
The GW SAID pion photoproduction analyses have been updated periodically since 1990 [30, 31], with more frequent updates published through our GW website [32]. Often, we present our results with CLAS and A2 Collaborations including determination of the resonance parameters (see, for instance, Refs. [33, 34, 35, 36, 37]) while our full analysis was reported 10 years ago [38] [7]. The present work updates our SAID partial-wave analysis (PWA) results and reports a new determination of photodecay amplitudes and pole positions in the complex energy plane.
High activity of worldwide electromagnetic facilities (JLab, MAMI, CBELSA, MAX-lab, Spring-8, and ELPH) increased the body of the SAID database by a significant amount (see Table I). 60% of these are data. A review of the last two decades of using photon beams to measure the production of mesons, and in particular the information that can be obtained on the spectrum of light, non-strange baryons is given in Ref. [59]. A wealth of data, for single- and double-polarization observables, have been anticipated over the past ten years. These data are pivotal in determining the underlying amplitudes in nearly complete experiments, and in discerning between various microscopic models of multichannel reaction theory.
The amplitudes from these analyses can be utilized, in particular, in evaluating contributions to the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn (GDH) sum rule and related integrals, as was reported recently [60].
In the following section (Sec. II), we summarize changes to the SAID database since 2012. The changes reflected in our multipoles are displayed in Section III. A comparison of past and recent photo-decay amplitudes, for resonances giving a significant contribution to pion photoproduction, is made in Section IV. Finally, in Section V, we summarize our results and comment on possible changes due to further measurements and changes in our parametrization form.
Extended SAID Database
At present, the SAID database [32] has 35,898 , 12,494 , 13,473 , and 2,515 data below MeV.
Table I accumulates 21,190 , 1,502 , 10,923 , and 1,763 data published since 2012 [32]. New measurements mostly cover the sector. Then there are a lot of single (, P, and T,) and double (E, G, F, and H) polarized data which came recently. It is an essential input for the amplitude reconstruction of the pion photoproduction and determination photocouplings. One can see that the “neutron” database grows rapidly which is important for the determination of the neutral photocouplings.
A full /data contribution for each pion photoproduction reaction vs different PWAs reports in tbl:II. It presents a partial /data contribution of data from tbl:III vs different PWAs.
SAID Multipole Amplitudes
The SAID parametrization of the transition amplitude used in the hadronic fits to the scattering data is given as
where , , and are channel indices for the , , , and channels. Here are the Chew-Mandelstam -matrices, which are parameterized as polynomials in the scattering energy. is the Chew-Mandelstam function, an element of a diagonal matrix in channel space, which is expressed as a dispersion integral with an imaginary part equal to the two-body phase space [65].
In Ref. [7], it was shown that this form could be extended to to include the electromagnetic channel as
Here, the Chew-Mandelstam K-matrix elements associated with the hadronic channels are kept fixed from the previous SAID solution SP06 [2], and only the electromagnetic elements are varied. The resonance pole and cut structures are also fixed from hadronic scattering. This provides a minimal description of the photoproduction process, where only the and states present in the SAID scattering amplitudes are included in this multipole analysis.
For each angular distribution, a normalization constant () and its uncertainty () were assigned. The quantity is generally associated with the normalization uncertainty (if known). The modified function to be minimized is given by
where the subscript labels the data points within the distribution, is an individual measurement, is the corresponding calculated value, and represents the total angle-dependent uncertainty. The total is then found by summing over all measurements. This re-normalization freedom is essential for obtaining the best SAID fit results. For other data analyzed in the fit, such as the total cross sections and excitation data, the statistical and systematic uncertainties were combined in quadrature and no re-normalization was allowed.
In the previous fits to differential cross sections, the unrestricted best fit gave re-normalization constants significantly different from unity. As can be seen from Eq. (3), if an angular distribution contains many measurements with small statistical uncertainties, a change in the re-normalization may improve the fit with only a modest penalty. Here, however, the weight of the second term in Eq. (3) has been adjusted by the fit for each dataset to keep the re-normalization constants approximately within X of unity.
| Reaction | Observable | Nexp | Ndata | (min) (MeV) | (max) (MeV) | (min) (deg) | (max) (deg) | Laboratory/Collaboration | Ref |
| 30 | 600 | 147 | 218 | 18 | 162 | MAMI/A2 | [39] | ||
| 269 | 7978 | 218 | 1573 | 15 | 165 | MAMI/A2 | [40] | ||
| 41 | 560 | 862 | 2475 | 15 | 165 | CBELSA/CBELSA/TAPS | [41] | ||
| 80 | 2030 | 1275 | 5425 | 27 | 140 | JLab/CLAS | [42] | ||
| 22 | 350 | 1325 | 2375 | 47 | 162 | SPring-8/LEPS2&BGOegg | [43] | ||
| 26 | 220 | 147 | 206 | 25 | 155 | MAMI/A2 | [39] | ||
| 78 | 1403 | 319 | 649 | 31 | 158 | MAMI/A2 | [44] | ||
| 39 | 700 | 1102 | 1862 | 32 | 148 | JLab/CLAS | [34] | ||
| 16 | 252 | 1325 | 2350 | 57 | 162 | SPring-8/LEPS2&BGOegg | [43] | ||
| 8 | 152 | 683 | 917 | 51 | 163 | CBELSA/CBELSA/TAPS | [45] | ||
| 11 | 11 | 1845 | 5631 | 79 | 143 | JLab/GEp-III & GEp2gamma | [46] | ||
| 245 | 4343 | 151 | 419 | 5 | 175 | MAMI/A2 | [47] | ||
| 34 | 397 | 440 | 1430 | 30 | 162 | MAMI/A2 | [48] | ||
| 29 | 601 | 683 | 2805 | 29 | 163 | CBELSA/CBELSA/TAPS | [45] | ||
| 33 | 456 | 615 | 2250 | 22 | 158 | CBELSA/CBELSA/TAPS | [49] | ||
| 22 | 197 | 632 | 2187 | 37 | 144 | JLab/CLAS | [50] | ||
| 19 | 318 | 633 | 1300 | 23 | 156 | CBELSA/CBELSA/TAPS | [51] | ||
| 34 | 397 | 440 | 1430 | 30 | 162 | MAMI/A2 | [48] | ||
| 8 | 154 | 683 | 917 | 51 | 163 | CBELSA/CBELSA/TAPS | [45] | ||
| 45 | 45 | 462 | 1337 | 75 | 140 | MAMI/A2 | [52] | ||
| 13 | 13 | 1845 | 5643 | 82 | 143 | JLab/GEp-III & GEp2gamma | [46] | ||
| 13 | 13 | 1845 | 5643 | 80 | 143 | JLab/GEp-III & GEp2gamma | [46] | ||
| 39 | 386 | 1102 | 1862 | 32 | 148 | JLab/CLAS | [34] | ||
| 35 | 900 | 363 | 2181 | 20 | 146 | JLab/CLAS | [53] | ||
| 22 | 216 | 632 | 2229 | 29 | 142 | MAMI/A2 | [50] | ||
| 6 | 6 | 150 | 162 | MAX-lab/PIONS@MAX-lab | [54] | ||||
| 14 | 104 | 301 | 455 | 58 | 133 | MAMI/A2 | [55] | ||
| 156 | 8428 | 445 | 2510 | 26 | 128 | JLab/CLAS | [35] | ||
| 68 | 816 | 1050 | 3500 | 32 | 157 | JLab/CLAS | [33] | ||
| 93 | 1293 | 947 | 2498 | 24 | 145 | JLab/CLAS | [56] | ||
| 21 | 266 | 727 | 2345 | 26 | 154 | JLab/CLAS | [36] | ||
| 27 | 492 | 290 | 813 | 32 | 139 | MAMI/A2 | [37] | ||
| 49 | 931 | 446 | 1427 | 32 | 162 | MAMI/A2 | [57] | ||
| 12 | 189 | 390 | 610 | 49 | 148 | MAMI/A2 | [29] | ||
| 17 | 151 | 446 | 1427 | 46 | 154 | MAMI/A2 | [58] |
Table 1. Published data for reactions since 2012 as given in the SAID database [32]: 1st column is the reaction, 2nd column is the observable, 3rd column is the number of energy bins, 4th column is the number of data points.
With the new quality datasets (Table I), a new SAID multipole analysis has been completed. This new global energy-dependent solution has been labeled as SM22.
The overall fit quality of the present SM22 and previous SAID CM12 solutions are compared in Table III and Table IV. There are many cases where the CM12 fit produces a per datum, for new measurements, which is significantly than greater than unity. The new best fit, SM22, includes these new measurements, reducing the /data to more acceptable values.
| Reaction | Obs | (MeV) | Data | MAID2007 | CM12 | SM22 | SM44 | WM22 | NM22 | Ref. |
| 675–2875 | 620 | 40.56 | 2.38 | 3.28 | 3.09 | 2.18 | 3.34 | [61] | ||
| 1845–2776 | 3 | 242. | 107. | 83.1 | 26.13 | 89.01 | [46] | |||
| 773–2472 | 29 | 8.47 | 5.45 | 12.83 | 12.93 | 8.69 | 13.10 | [62] | ||
| 632–2187 | 197 | 11.45 | 46.34 | 4.23 | 4.43 | 4.02 | 3.87 | [50] | ||
| 1845–2776 | 3 | 985. | 8.75 | 5.18 | 9.39 | 7.53 | [46] | |||
| 773–2472 | 28 | 28.25 | 9.96 | 7.64 | 7.82 | 4.89 | 8.39 | [62] | ||
| 1845–2776 | 3 | 1370. | 8.68 | 14.40 | 2.46 | 7.87 | [46] | |||
| 773–2472 | 25 | 35.44 | 12.80 | 12.00 | 8.44 | 9.16 | 13.28 | [62] | ||
| 725–2875 | 618 | 65.71 | 2.08 | 2.75 | 2.83 | 1.82 | 2.44 | [63] | ||
| 632–2229 | 216 | 21.09 | 25.33 | 4.42 | 4.66 | 3.57 | 4.49 | [50] | ||
| 703–1475 | 216 | 100.1 | 2.37 | 4.72 | 2.81 | 2.93 | 19.26 | [64] | ||
| 446–1427 | 151 | 29.75 | 13.14 | 6.21 | 5.89 | 5.66 | 10.85 | [58] |
Table III. List of data with large for the SM22 and associated fits. Notation for solutions is given in the caption of Table II.
Comparison /data for published data since 2012 as given in Table I and available in the SAID database [32]. Notation for solutions is given in the caption of Table II. Data, which are partially (completely) excluded in the SAID fits, denoted by ‡ (†).
| Reaction | Obs | MAID2007 /data | CM12 /data | SM22 /data | SM44 /data | WM22 /data | NM22 /data | Ref. |
| 10.44 | 7.08 | 1.32 | 1.36 | 1.32 | 1.33 | [39]‡ | ||
| 12.50 | 3.01 | 1.40 | 1.44 | 1.51 | 1.40 | [40]‡ | ||
| 4.44 | 2.33 | 3.46 | 3.41 | 3.22 | 3.49 | [41]† | ||
| 18.28 | 2.34 | 2.69 | 2.50 | 2.37 | 2.77 | [42]† | ||
| 16.15 | 3.63 | 2.39 | 2.31 | 2.74 | 2.45 | [43] | ||
| 41.69 | 0.99 | 1.40 | 1.39 | 1.33 | 1.39 | [39] | ||
| 2.25 | 1.42 | 1.16 | 1.12 | 1.22 | 1.17 | [44]‡ | ||
| 72.13 | 43.81 | 3.62 | 3.87 | 4.04 | 3.47 | [34] | ||
| 4.93 | 11.21 | 1.95 | 1.96 | 2.46 | 1.81 | [43] | ||
| 2.13 | 1.50 | 1.04 | 1.09 | 1.17 | 1.05 | [45] | ||
| 241.0 | 6.47 | 82.62 | 26.1 | 89.01 | [46] | |||
| 1.30 | 1.41 | 1.06 | 1.07 | 1.09 | 1.04 | [47]‡ | ||
| 9.15 | 5.80 | 3.09 | 3.25 | 3.28 | 2.94 | [48] | ||
| 12.25 | 4.14 | 2.17 | 2.24 | 2.43 | 2.05 | [45] | ||
| 15.14 | 4.22 | 2.11 | 2.20 | 2.62 | 2.03 | [49] | ||
| 11.45 | 6.38 | 4.23 | 4.43 | 4.02 | 4.20 | [50] | ||
| 3.42 | 3.90 | 1.26 | 1.26 | 1.21 | 1.20 | [51] | ||
| 3.48 | 3.34 | 2.33 | 2.34 | 2.26 | 2.28 | [48] | ||
| 4.38 | 6.25 | 1.70 | 1.96 | 1.89 | 1.44 | [45] | ||
| 2.07 | 2.36 | 1.71 | 1.71 | 1.76 | 1.73 | [52] | ||
| 984.0 | 8.90 | 5.28 | 9.53 | 7.53 | [46] | |||
| 1370. | 8.74 | 14.49 | 2.48 | 7.87 | [46] | |||
| 285.1 | 18.37 | 3.00 | 3.14 | 3.81 | 2.97 | [34] | ||
| 5.09 | 9.82 | 1.96 | 1.86 | 2.21 | 2.03 | [53]‡ | ||
| 21.09 | 25.33 | 4.42 | 6.64 | 3.57 | 4.49 | [50] | ||
| 0.33 | 0.05 | 0.06 | 0.20 | 0.10 | 0.90 | [54] | ||
| 5.99 | 4.61 | 3.27 | 3.96 | 2.78 | 3.22 | [55] | ||
| 14.88 | 20.39 | 1.28 | 1.30 | 1.33 | 1.25 | [35]‡ | ||
| 30.39 | 76.83 | 3.97 | 3.97 | 3.77 | 4.17 | [33]† | ||
| 7.21 | 118.8 | 2.38 | 2.27 | 2.57 | 2.24 | [56] | ||
| 18.25 | 17.43 | 2.84 | 2.62 | 3.11 | 3.68 | [36] | ||
| 3.77 | 7.29 | 2.88 | 2.43 | 3.14 | 3.89 | [37] | ||
| 20.32 | 18.72 | 11.22 | 9.52 | 9.97 | 15.73 | [57]† | ||
| 2.44 | 2.46 | 1.25 | 1.15 | 1.33 | 2.17 | [29] | ||
| 29.75 | 13.11 | 6.21 | 5.89 | 5.66 | 10.85 | [58] |
Table IV. Comparison /data for published data since 2012 as given in Table I and available in the SAID database [32]. Notation for solutions is given in the caption of Table II. Data, which are partially (completely) excluded in the SAID fits, denoted by ‡ (†).
Both energy-dependent (ED) and single-energy (SE) solutions were obtained from fits to the combined proton and neutron target database, extending from threshold to GeV for the ED fit and to GeV for SE fits.
Apart from the main ED result (SM22) several supplemental fits were done in order to gauge the importance of including data (which can, in principle, be at least qualitatively predicted from the remaining more fully populated charge channels). Here fits were done with increased weight for the data and conversely the removal of all such data. In addition, a fit was done more heavily weighting all data poorly fitted by SM22. Figures 1 and 2 plot representative comparisons of SAID fits to data. In addition, older MAID and more recent Bonn-Gatchina results are plotted for comparison. Numerical comparisons of the various SAID fits are given in
Tables II to IV.
Comparisons of the present SAID and multipoles amplitudes from threshold to GeV ( GeV) shown in Figure 3 - Figure 8. Also included, for comparison, are the BnGa and MAID multipoles.
Figure 3. Comparison multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV ( GeV). For the amplitudes, the subscript gives the value of , and the superscript gives the isospin index. Notation for solutions is given in the caption of Table II. New SAID SM22 fit is shown by red solid curves. Previous SAID CM12 [7] (MAID2007 [5], terminates at GeV) predictions show by blue dash-dotted (green dashed) curves. BG2019 [67] predictions show by magenta short dash-dotted curves.
Figure 8. Comparison neutron multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV. Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 7.
Figure 7. Comparison of neutron multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV ( GeV). Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 3. Additionally, cyan short-dashed curves are SM44 fits.
Comparisons of the present and ED and SE multipole amplitudes from threshold to GeV ( GeV) shown on Figure 9 - Figure 14.
Figure 9. Comparison of multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV ( GeV). Notation for solutions is given in the caption of Table II. For the amplitudes, the subscript denotes a neutron target, New SAID SM22 fit is shown by red solid curves. Previous SAID CM12 [7] (MAID2007 [5], terminates at GeV) predictions show by blue dash-dotted (green dashed) curves. BG2019 [67] predictions show by magenta short dash-dotted curves. SE associated with SM22 shown as blue open circles. Vertical arrows indicate resonance energies, , and horizontal bars show full () and partial () widths associated with the SAID solution SP06 (Breit-Wigner parameters) [2].
Figure 14. Comparison of neutron multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV. Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 13.
Figure 13. Comparison neutron multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV ( GeV). For the amplitudes, the subscript denotes a neutron target, the subscript gives the value of , and the superscript gives the isospin index. Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 9. The blue vertical arrows for (a) and (b) indicate the production threshold.
Figure 1. Samples of pion photoproduction off the proton. Data for are from Refs. [42, 46, 50, 51, 52, 61, 62, 66] and for are from Ref. [50]. Notation for solutions is given in the caption of Table II. The SAID SM22 (WM22) fit is shown as a red solid (yellow dashed) curve. SAID CM12 [7] (MAID2007 [5]) predictions shown as blue dash-dotted (green dashed) curves. BG2019 [67] predictions are shown as magenta short dash-dotted curves.
| Solution | Observable | ||||
| SM22 | Total | 30399/15901 = 1.92 | 13945/6194 = 2.25 | 12267/6662 = 1.84 | 4190/1205 = 3.48 |
| UnPol | 9842/5730 = 1.72 | 4984/2603 = 1.91 | 7497/4706 = 1.59 | 1995/649 = 3.07 | |
| SinglePol | 16036/8249 = 1.94 | 6078/2483 = 2.45 | 4014/1684 = 2.38 | 1258/405 = 3.11 | |
| DoublePol | 4521/1922 = 2.35 | 2883/1108 = 2.60 | 765/275 = 2.78 | 937/151 = 6.21 | |
| SM44 | Total | 30870/15901 = 1.94 | 14293/6194 = 2.31 | 12358/6662 = 1.86 | 3361/1205 = 2.79 |
| UnPol | 9880/5730 = 1.72 | 5154/2603 = 1.98 | 7832/4706 = 1.66 | 1648/649 = 2.54 | |
| SinglePol | 16405/8249 = 1.99 | 6229/2483 = 2.51 | 3830/1684 = 2.27 | 823/405 = 2.03 | |
| DoublePol | 4585/1922 = 2.39 | 2910/1108 = 2.63 | 696/275 = 2.53 | 890/151 = 5.89 | |
| NM22 | Total | 29998/15901 = 1.89 | 13592/6194 = 2.19 | 11992/6662 = 1.80 | 8531/1205 = 7.08 |
| UnPol | 9887/5730 = 1.73 | 4757/2603 = 1.83 | 7262/4706 = 1.54 | 2322/649 = 3.58 | |
| SinglePol | 15662/8240 = 1.90 | 5915/2483 = 2.38 | 3746/1684 = 2.22 | 4570/405 = 11.28 | |
| DoublePol | 4449/1922 = 2.31 | 2920/1108 = 2.64 | 984/275 = 3.58 | 1639/151 = 10.85 | |
| WM22 | Total | 31315/15901 = 1.97 | 14038/6194 = 2.27 | 12819/6662 = 1.92 | 3853/1205 = 3.20 |
| UnPol | 9816/5730 = 1.71 | 4659/2603 = 1.79 | 7735/4706 = 1.64 | 2113/649 = 3.26 | |
| SinglePol | 16922/8249 = 2.05 | 6537/2483 = 2.63 | 4258/1684 = 2.53 | 885/405 = 2.19 | |
| DoublePol | 4577/1922 = 2.38 | 2842/1108 = 2.57 | 826/275 = 3.00 | 855/151 = 5.66 | |
| CM12 (current DB) | Total | 78254/15901 = 4.92 | 27933/6194 = 4.51 | 222454/6662 = 33.39 | 7024/1205 = 5.89 |
| UnPol | 18074/5730 = 3.15 | 4565/2603 = 1.75 | 65514/4706 = 13.92 | 4063/649 = 6.26 | |
| SinglePol | 50016/8249 = 6.06 | 12221/2483 = 4.92 | 154303/1684 = 91.62 | 976/405 = 2.41 | |
| DoublePol | 10164/1922 = 5.26 | 11147/1108 = 10.06 | 2637/275 = 9.59 | 1985/151 = 13.15 | |
| CM12 (old DB) | Total | 10544/4507 = 2.34 | 10444/4916 = 2.12 | 2486/1509 = 1.65 | 987/373 = 2.65 |
| UnPol | 2682/1094 = 2.45 | 4247/2459 = 1.73 | 1769/1118 = 1.58 | 475/157 = 3.03 | |
| SinglePol | 5846/2723 = 2.15 | 3312/1523 = 2.18 | 564/304 = 1.86 | 512/216 = 2.37 | |
| DoublePol | 2016/690 = 2.92 | 2885/934 = 3.09 | 153/87 = 0.82 | ||
| MAID2007 (current DB) | Total | 170832/14454 = 11.82 | 128063/5396 = 23.73 | 102968/5520 = 18.65 | 29390/1205 = 24.39 |
| UnPol | 74153/5188 = 14.29 | 24533/2210 = 11.10 | 40840/4166 = 9.80 | 2812/649 = 4.33 | |
| SinglePol | 84286/7578 = 11.12 | 96337/2168 = 44.44 | 59097/1182 = 50.00 | 22087/405 = 54.54 | |
| DoublePol | 12393/1688 = 7.34 | 7193/1018 = 7.07 | 3031/172 = 17.62 | 4494/151 = 29.76 |
Table II. Comparison of per datum values for all charged and neutral channels covering fit energy range. The previous SAID fit, CM12, was published in Ref. [7] (and is valid up to MeV). CM12 is compared to both the current database and data before 2012. All data are available in the SAID database (DB) [32]. For the SM44 fit, data were weighted by an arbitrary factor of 4. For the WM22 fit, all data with large /data for the SM22 solution (data are listed in Table III) were weighted by an arbitrary factor of 4. The NM22 solution represents a fit without the inclusion of data. The previous MAID2007 solution is valid up to MeV ( GeV) [5].
Figure 2. Samples of pion photoproduction off the neutron. Data for are from Refs. [56, 68] and for are from Refs. [58, 64, 69]. Notation for solutions is given in the caption of Table II. The SAID SM22 (NM22) fit is shown as a red solid (black dotted) curve. SAID CM12 [7] (MAID2007 [5]) predictions are shown as blue dash-dotted (green dashed) curves. BG2019 [67] predictions are shown as magenta short dash-dotted curves.
Figure 4. Comparison multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV. Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 3. Additionally, the WM22 fit is shown by yellow dashed curves.
Figure 5. Comparison proton multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV ( GeV). Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 3. Additionally, WM22 fit is shown by yellow dashed curves.
Figure 6. Comparison of proton multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV. Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 3. For the amplitudes, the subscript denotes a proton target, Additionally, WM22 fit shown by yellow dashed curves.
Figure 10. Comparison multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV. Notation of the solutions and data is the same as in Figure 9.
Figure 11. Comparison of proton multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV ( GeV). Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 9. The blue vertical arrows for (a) and (b) indicate the production threshold.
Figure 12. Comparison proton multipole amplitudes (orbital momentum ) from threshold to GeV. Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 9.
Resonance Couplings
Following the notation of Refs. [38, 70], the T-matrix element for helicity is given by
where denotes the partial wave and , are the center-of-mass (c.m.) momenta of the photon and the pion. The factor is for isospin and for isospin . The helicity multipoles are given in terms of electric and magnetic multipoles
with for “+” multipoles and for “−” multipoles, all having the same total spin .
In Tables V to XIV, we list the pole positions together with the photo-decay amplitudes
where the subscript denotes quantities evaluated at the pole position and is the nucleon mass. In Ref. [38], the elastic residues, , and the pole positions, , were taken from the GWU SAID PWA, SP06 [2] and each multipole was fitted separately, using the Laurent plus Pietarinen (L+P) method [38], to determine the corresponding residues.
Here, we have made a coupled multipole fit of all partial-wave amplitudes associated with particular resonances, including the pion-nucleon elastic scattering amplitudes. Thus, for example, the L+P fit of Ref. [38] for the multipole has been expanded to a simultaneous fit of the elastic amplitude, and (proton target), plus and (neutron target), yielding more self-consistent results.
As in Ref. [38], the fitted partial waves are , , , , , , and with pion-nucleon partial waves taken from Ref. [71].
Results and Conclusions
The present results update the SAID fit (CM12) which first utilized a Chew-Mandelstam K-matrix approach (as opposed to the Heitler K-matrix formalism used in the original SAID analyses). The L+P method for pole parameter extraction has been extended to simultaneously incorporate all connected elastic and photoproduction amplitudes.
The amplitude tables give pole positions and helicity amplitudes at the pole where available. Values for the amplitudes were not extracted in the 2014 SAID analysis; comparisons can now be made to multi-channel determinations. Complex amplitudes are given in terms of modulus and phase. In cases where a large phase is found, close to 180 degrees, a minus sign is commonly extracted to ease comparison with the real amplitudes found in older Breit-Wigner fits. The “modulus” then has a sign and a phase closer to zero. Here, however, the modulus remains positive.
In cases where the fitted multipoles have a clear canonical resonance variation, with a relatively small non-resonance contribution, comparison to the Bonn-Gatchina multi-channel analysis generally shows good agreement (to the 10% level). This includes the , , , and and applies to both the , and helicity amplitudes.
Comparisons are more complicated for states associated with the low-angular momentum states and . The and have some overlap and are close to the threshold cusp. The is complicated by the close proximity of its pole position to the threshold. We note that differences in amplitudes disappear if one compares instead with the recent Jülich-Bonn analysis [75]. For the amplitudes, the agreement is qualitative and no Jülich-Bonn values are available. Qualitative agreement is also seen for the .
Agreement for the is good for the moduli and at least qualitative for the phases. For the , within fairly large uncertainties, there is qualitative agreement of the helicity amplitude moduli, with less agreement at the level of phases. Hunt and Manley [11] note that the decays to violate the Moorhouse selection rule [76]. We see the moduli of photo-decay amplitudes to be small but non-zero.
In Figs. 15 - 18, we display L+P fits for the partial-wave and multipole amplitudes, where resonance behavior is clear and the dominant feature, and the amplitudes, where resonance overlap and a nearby cusp complicate this process.
TABLE V. Photon-decay helicity amplitudes at the pole for and decays. Fit to pion-nucleon elastic amplitude and multipole . Complex quantities given as modulus and phase. Results from present study (first row), PR2014 [38] (second row), and BnGa [72] (for proton couplings) and [73] (for neutron couplings) (third row).
| Resonance | (GeV) | (GeV) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) |
Table V.
TABLE VI. Photon-decay helicity amplitudes at the pole for and decays. Fit to pion-nucleon elastic amplitude and multipole . Complex quantities given as modulus and phase. Results from present study (first row), PR2014 [38] (second row), and BnGa [72] (for proton couplings) and [73] (for neutron couplings) (third row).
| Resonance | (GeV) | (GeV) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) |
Table VI.
TABLE VII. Photon-decay helicity amplitudes at the pole for and decays. Fit to pion-nucleon elastic amplitude and multipoles and . Complex quantities given as modulus and phase. Results from present study (first row), PR2014 [38] (second row), and BnGa [72] (for proton couplings) and [73] (for neutron couplings) (third row).
| Resonance | (GeV) | (GeV) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) |
Table VII.
TABLE VIII. Photon-decay helicity amplitudes at the pole for and decays. Fit to pion-nucleon elastic amplitude and multipoles and . Complex quantities given as modulus and phase. Results from present study (first row), PR2014 [38] (second row), and BnGa [72] (for proton couplings) and [73] (for neutron couplings) (third row).
| Resonance | (GeV) | (GeV) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) |
Table VIII.
TABLE IX. Photon-decay helicity amplitudes at the pole for and decays. Fit to pion-nucleon elastic amplitude and multipoles and . Complex quantities given as modulus and phase. Results from present study (first row), PR2014 [38] (second row), and BnGa [72] (for proton couplings) and [73] (for neutron couplings) (third row).
| Resonance | (GeV) | (GeV) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) |
Table IX.
TABLE X. Photon-decay helicity amplitudes at the pole for and decays. Fit to pion-nucleon elastic amplitude and multipoles and . Complex quantities given as modulus and phase. Results from present study (first row), PR2014 [38] (second row), and BnGa [72] (for proton couplings) and [73] (for neutron couplings) (third row).
| Resonance | (GeV) | (GeV) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) |
Table X.
TABLE XI. Photon-decay helicity amplitudes at the pole for decay. Fit to pion-nucleon elastic amplitude and multipoles and . Complex quantities given as modulus and phase. Results from present study (first row), PR2014 [38] (second row), and BnGa [74] (for ) and [72] (for ) (third row).
| Resonance | (GeV) | (GeV) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) |
Table XI.
TABLE XII. Photon-decay helicity amplitudes at the pole for decay. Fit to pion-nucleon elastic amplitude and multipoles and . Complex quantities given as modulus and phase. Results from present study (first row), PR2014 [38] (second row), and BnGa [72] (third row).
| Resonance | (GeV) | (GeV) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) |
Table XII.
TABLE XIII. Photon-decay helicity amplitudes at the pole for decay. Fit to pion-nucleon elastic amplitude and multipoles and . Complex quantities given as modulus and phase. Results from present study (first row), PR2014 [38] (second row), and BnGa [72] (third row).
| Resonance | (GeV) | (GeV) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) |
Table XIII.
TABLE XIV. Photon-decay helicity amplitudes at the pole for decay. Fit to pion-nucleon elastic amplitude and multipoles and . Complex quantities given as modulus and phase. Results from present study (first row), PR2014 [38] (second row), and BnGa [72] (third row).
| Resonance | (GeV) | (GeV) | () | (deg) | () | (deg) |
Table XIV.
Figure 16. Samples of Laurent+Pietarinen (L+P) coupled fit of the partial wave of the GWU-SAID fit WI08 [71] and SM22 SE4 GWU-SAID multipole solutions. Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 15.
Figure 15. Samples of Laurent+Pietarinen (L+P) coupled fit of the partial wave of the GWU-SAID fit WI08 [71] and the SM22 ED GWU-SAID multipole solutions. Blue symbols are the GWU-SAID solutions, solid black curves are the L+P coupled-multipole fit, and thin red curves are the resonant contribution in the L+P coupled-multipole fit.
Figure 17. Samples of Laurent+Pietarinen (L+P) coupled fit of the partial wave of the GWU-SAID fit WI08 [71] and SM22 SE4 GWU-SAID multipole solutions. Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 15.
Figure 18. Samples of Laurent+Pietarinen (L+P) coupled fit of the partial wave of the GWU-SAID WI08 [71] and SM22 SE4 GWU-SAID multipole solutions. Notation of the solutions is the same as in Figure 15.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported in part by the U. S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics, under Awards No. DE–SC0016583 and No. DE–SC0016582, and in part by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics under contract DE-AC05-06OR23177.
References
References
- [30]B. A. Arndt, R. L. Workman, Z. Li, and L. D. Roper, “Partial wave analysis of pion photoproduction,” Phys. Rev. C 42, 1853 (1990).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9966929
- [31]R. A. Arndt, R. L. Workman, Z. Li, and L. D. Roper, “Pion photoproduction resonance couplings in the second resonance region,” Phys. Rev. C 42, 1864 (1990).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9966930
- [32]The SAID analyses are available through the GWU web-site http://gwdac.phys.gwu.edu/; W. J. Briscoe, M. Döring, H. Haberzettl, I. I. Strakovsky, and R. L. Workman, Institute of Nuclear Studies of The George Washington University Database.
- [33]W. Chen, H. Gao, W. J. Briscoe, D. Dutta, A. E. Kudryavtsev, M. Mirazita, M. W. Paris, P. Rossi, S. Stepanyan, I. I. Strakovsky, V. E. Tarasov, and R. L. Workman, “Amplitude analysis of γn → π⁻p data above 1 GeV,” Phys. Rev. C 86, 015206 (2012); W. Chen, T. Mibe, D. Dutta, H. Gao, J. M. Laget, M. Mirazita, P. Rossi, S. Stepanyan, I. I. Strakovsky, M. J. Amaryan et al. “A measurement of the differential cross section for the reaction γn → π⁻p from deuterium,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 012301 (2009); W. Chen (private communication).DOI
- [34]M. Dugger et al. [CLAS Collaboration], “Beam asymmetry Σ for π⁺ and π⁰ photoproduction on the proton for photon energies from 1.102 to 1.862 GeV,” Phys. Rev. C 88, 065203 (2013); M. Dugger (private communication).DOI
- [35]P. T. Mattioine et al. [CLAS Collaboration], “Differential cross section measurements for γn → π⁻p above the first nucleon resonance region,” Phys. Rev. C 96, 035204 (2017); P. T. Mattioine (private communication).
- [36]D. Ho et al. [CLAS Collaboration], “Beam-target helicity asymmetry for γ̄n → π⁻p in the N* resonance region,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 242002 (2017); F. Klein (private communication).DOI
- [37]W. J. Briscoe et al. [A2 Collaboration at MAMI], “Cross section for γn → π⁰p at the Mainz A2 experiment,” Phys. Rev. C 100, 065205 (2019); M. Martemianov (private communication).DOI
- [38]A. Švarc, M. Hadžimehmedović, H. Osmanović, J. Stahov, L. Tiator, and R. L. Workman, “Pole positions and residues from pion photoproduction using the Laurent-Pietarinen expansion method,” Phys. Rev. C 89, 065208 (2014).DOI
- [39]D. Hornidge et al. [A2 and CB-TAPS Collaborations], “Accurate test of chiral dynamics in the γp → π⁰p reaction,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 016204 (2013); S. Prakhov (private communication).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23971564
- [40]P. Adlarson et al. [A2 Collaboration at MAMI], “Measurement of π⁰ photoproduction at the proton at MAMI C,” Phys. Rev. C 92, 024617 (2015); S. Prakhov (private communication).DOI
- [41]V. Crede et al. [CBELSA/TAPS Collaboration], “Photoproduction of neutral pions off protons,” Phys. Rev. C 84, 055203 (2011). V. Crede (private communication).DOI
- [42]M. C. Kunkel et al. [CLAS Collaboration], “Exclusive photoproduction of π⁰ up to large values of Mandelstam variables s, t and u with CLAS,” Phys. Rev. C 98, 015207 (2018); M. Kunkel (private communication).DOI
- [43]N. Muramatsu et al. [LEPS2 and BGOegg Collaborations], “Measurement of neutral pion photoproduction off the proton with the large acceptance electromagnetic calorimeter BGOegg,” Phys. Rev. C 100, 055202 (2019); N. Muramatsu (private communication).
- [44]S. Gardner et al. [A2 Collaboration at MAMI], “Photon asymmetry measurements of γ⃗p → π⁰p for Eγ = 320-650 MeV,” Eur. Phys. J. A 52, 333 (2016); S. Gardner (private communication).
- [45]J. Hartmann et al. [CBELSA/TAPS], “The polarization observables T, P, and H and their impact on γp → pπ⁰ multipoles,” Phys. Lett. B 748, 212 (2015); R. Beck (private communication).DOI
- [46]W. Luo et al. [GEp-III and GEp2gamma Collaborations], “Polarization components in π⁰ photoproduction at photon energies up to 5.6 GeV,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 222004 (2012); W. Luo (private communication).
- [47]S. Schumann et al. [A2 Collaboration at MAMI], “Threshold π⁰ photoproduction on transversely polarised protons at MAMI,” Phys. Lett. B 750, 252 (2015); S. Schumann (private communication).DOI
- [48]J. R. M. Annand et al. [A2 Collaboration at MAMI], “T and F asymmetries in π⁰ photoproduction on the proton,” Phys. Rev. C 93, 055209 (2016); V. Kashevarov (private communication).DOI
- [49]M. Gottschall et al. [CBELSA/TAPS Collaboration], “First measurement of the helicity asymmetry for γp → pπ⁰ in the resonance region,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 012003 (2014); R. Beck (private communication).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24483889
- [50]N. Zachariou et al. [CLAS Collaboration], “Double polarisation observable G for single pion photoproduction from the proton,” Phys. Lett. B 817, 136304 (2021); N. Zachariou (private communication).DOI
- [51]A. Thiel, A. V. Anisovich, D. Bayadilov, B. Bantes, R. Beck, Y. Belogazov, M. Bichows, S. Bose, K. T. Brinkmann, T. Challand et al. “Well-established nucleon resonances revisited by double-polarization measurements,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 102001 (2012); A. Thiel (private communication).DOI
- [52]M. H. Sikora, D. P. Watts, D. I. Glazier, P. Aguar-Bartholome, L. K. Akasoy, J. R. M. Annand, H. J. Arends, K. Bantawa, R. Beck, V. S. Bekrenev et al. “Measurement of the ¹H(γ⃗, π)π⁰ reaction using a novel nucleon spin polarimeter,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 022501 (2014); M. H. Sikora (private communication).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24484003
- [53]S. Strauch et al. [CLAS], “First measurement of the polarization observable E in the p⃗(γ⃗, π⁺)n reaction up to 2.25 GeV,” Phys. Lett. B 750, 53 (2015); S. Strauch (private communication).DOI
- [54]W. J. Briscoe, A. E. Kudryavtsev, I. I. Strakovsky, V. E. Tarasov, and R. L. Workman, “Threshold π⁻ photoproduction on the neutron,” Eur. Phys. J. A 56, 218 (2020); B. Strandberg, K. G. Fissum, J. R. M. Annand, W. J. Briscoe, J. Brudvik, F. Cividini, L. Clark, E. J. Downie, K. England, G. Feldman et al. “Near-threshold π⁻ photoproduction on the deuteron,” Phys. Rev. C 101, 035207 (2020).DOI
- [55]W. J. Briscoe, A. E. Kudryavtsev, P. Pedroni, I. I. Strakovsky, V. E. Tarasov, and R. L. Workman, “Evaluation of the γn → π⁻p differential cross sections in the Delta-isobar region,” Phys. Rev. C 86, 065207 (2012); J. Ahrens, S. Altieri, J. R. M. Annand, H. J. Arends, R. Beck, M. A. Blackston, C. Bradtke, A. Braghieri, N. d’Hose, H. Dutz et al. “Helicity dependence of the γd → πNN reactions in the Delta-resonance region,” Eur. Phys. J. A 44, 189 (2010); M. M. Fabregate, Ph. D. Thesis, Johannes Gutenberg University of Mainz (2007); P. Pedroni (private communication).DOI
- [56]D. Sokhan et al. [CLAS], “A new measurement of beam asymmetry in pion photoproduction from the neutron using CLAS,” Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 24, 497 (2009); D. Sokhan, “Beam asymmetry measurement from pion photoproduction on the neutron,” Ph. D. Thesis, University of Edinburgh (2009); D. Sokhan (private communication).DOI
- [57]M. Dieterle et al. [A2 Collaboration at MAMI], “Photoproduction of π⁰ mesons off protons and neutrons in the second and third nucleon resonance region,” Phys. Rev. C 97, 065205 (2018); M. Dieterle (private communication).DOI
- [58]M. Dieterle, L. Witthauer, F. Cividini, S. Abt, P. Achenbach, P. Adlarson, F. Afzal, Z. Ahmed, C. S. Akondi, J. R. M. Annand et al. “First measurement of the polarization observable E and helicity-dependent cross sections in single π⁰ photoproduction from quasi-free nucleons,” Phys. Lett. B 770, 523 (2017); M. Dieterle (private communication).DOI
- [59]D. G. Ireland, E. Pasyuk, and I. Strakovsky, “Photoproduction reactions and non-strange baryon spectroscopy,” Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 111, 103752 (2020).DOI
- [60]I. Strakovsky, S. Sirca, W. J. Briscoe, A. Deur, A. Schmidt, and R. L. Workman, “Single-pion contribution to the Gerasimov-Drell-Hearn sum rule and related integrals,” Phys. Rev. C 105, 045202 (2022).DOI
- [61]M. Dugger, B. G. Ritchie, J. P. Ball, P. Collins, E. Pasyuk, R. A. Arndt, W. J. Briscoe, I. I. Strakovsky, R. L. Workman, G. S. Adams et al. “π⁰ photoproduction on the proton for photon energies from 0.675 to 2.875-GeV,” Phys. Rev. C 76, 025211 (2007).DOI
- [62]K. Wijesooriya, A. Afanasev, M. Amarian, K. Aniol, S. Becher, K. Benslama, L. Bimbot, P. Bosted, E. J. Brash, J. C. Calarco et al. “Polarization measurements in neutral pion photoproduction,” Phys. Rev. C 66, 034614 (2002).
- [63]M. Dugger et al. [CLAS Collaboration], “π⁺ photoproduction on the proton for photon energies from 0.725 to 2.875-GeV,” Phys. Rev. C 79, 065206 (2009).DOI
- [64]R. Di Salvo, A. Fantini, G. Mandaglio, F. Mammoliti, O. Bartalini, V. Bellini, J. P. Bocquet, L. Casano, A. D’Angelo, J. P. Didelez et al. “Measurement of Sigma beam asymmetry in pi0 photoproduction off the neutron in the second and third resonances region,” Eur. Phys. J. A 42, 151 (2009).DOI
- [65]R. A. Arndt, J. M. Ford, and L. D. Roper, “Pion - nucleon partial wave analysis to 1100-MeV,” Phys. Rev. D 32, 1085 (1985).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9956252
- [66]P. J. Bussey, C. Raine, J. G. Rutherglen, P. S. L. Booth, L. J. Carroll, G. R. Court, P. R. Daniel, A. W. Edwards, R. Gamet and C. J. Hardwick, et al. “Polarization parameters in neutral pion photoproduction,” Nucl. Phys. B 154, 492 (1979).DOI
- [67]E. Gutz et al. [CBELSA/TAPS Collaboration], “High statistics study of the reaction γp → pπ⁰η,” Eur. Phys. J. A 50, 74 (2014). The Bonn-Gatchina analyses (BnGa19) are available through the Bonn website: http://pwa.hiskp.uni-bonn.de/.
- [68]F. V. Adamian, P. I. Galumian, V. O. Grabsky, G. G. Akopian, V. K. Oktanian, G. V. Karapetian, V. V. Karapetian, and G. A. Karapetian, “Single π− meson photoproduction on neutrons by linearly polarized photons in the third and fourth resonance region,” J. Phys. G 15, 1797 (1989).DOI
- [69]C. R. Clinesmith, “π⁰ photoproduction from the deuteron at forward angles in the energy range from 900-MeV to 1400-MeV,” RX-184; Ph. D. Thesis, California Institute of Technology (1967).
- [70]R. L. Workman, L. Tiator, and A. Sarantsev, “Baryon photo-decay amplitudes at the pole,” Phys. Rev. C 87, 068201 (2013).DOI
- [71]R. L. Workman, R. A. Arndt, W. J. Briscoe, M. W. Paris, and I. I. Strakovsky, “Parameterization dependence of T matrix poles and eigenphases from a fit to πN elastic scattering data,” Phys. Rev. C 86, 035202 (2012).DOI
- [72]V. Sokhoyan et al. [CBELSA/TAPS Collaboration], “High-statistics study of the reaction γp → p 2π⁰,” Eur. Phys. J. A 51, 95 (2015); [erratum: Eur. Phys. J. A 51, 187 (2015)].DOI
- [73]V. V. Anisovich, R. Burkert, N. Compton, K. Hicks, F. J. Klein, E. Klempt, V. A. Nikonov, A. M. Sandorfi, A. V. Sarantsev, and U. Thoma, “Neutron helicity amplitudes,” Phys. Rev. C 96, 055202 (2017).
- [74]A. V. Anisovich, R. Beck, E. Klempt, V. A. Nikonov, A. V. Sarantsev, and U. Thoma, “Properties of baryon resonances from a multichannel partial wave analysis,” Eur. Phys. J. A 48, 15 (2012).DOI
- [75]D. Rönchen, M. Döring, U. G. Meißner, and C. W. Shen, “Light baryon resonances from a coupled-channel study including KΣ photoproduction,” Eur. Phys. J. A 58, 229 (2022).DOI
- [76]R. G. Moorhouse, “Photoproduction of N* resonances in the quark model,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 16, 772 (1966).DOI

















