betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Investigating Roles of Triple Excitations for High-precision Determination of Clock Properties of Alkaline Earth Metal Singly Charged Ions

Abstract

High-accuracy calculations of electric dipole polarizabilities and quadrupole moments (ΘΘ) of the clock states of the singly charged calcium (Ca+^+), strontium (Sr+^+) and barium (Ba+^+) alkaline-earth ions are estimated by employing relativistic coupled-cluster (RCC) theory. It demonstrates importance of the triple excitations in the RCC method for precise determination of the above quantities. We also observe a different trend of correlations in the ΘΘ values than an earlier study with respect to orbitals from higher angular momenta. Reliability of the results is verified by comparing the calculated energies, magnetic dipole hyperfine structure constants, and lifetimes of the atomic states with the experimental values of the 43^{43}Ca+^+, 87^{87}Sr+^+ and 137^{137}Ba+^+ ions. Nuclear quadrupole moments of these isotopes are also estimated by combining calculations with the measured electric quadrupole hyperfine structure constants, showing large deviations from the literature values.

Singly charged alkaline-earth metal ions are instrumental in investigating many fundamental physics. Transitions between the ground (nsns) and metastable (n−1)d 2D3/2,5/2n-1)d\,{}^{2}D_{3/2,5/2} states, with principal quantum number nn, in the heavier alkaline ions play key roles in the clock frequency measurements [1, 2, 3], probing atomic parity violation (APV) [4, 5, 6] and analyzing isotope shift (IS) data to extract nuclear charge radii [7, 8, 9] and mass of a possible new vector boson from the non-linear effects in the King’s plot [10], constructing qubits [11–13] etc. to name a few. Owing to laser-accessible energy level structures, many of these ions can be efficiently manipulated with lasers, allowing for long interrogation times and thereby enabling high-precision measurements. In fact, a recent proposal aims to measure the APV amplitude in Ba+^{+} to 0.1% precision using an ion trap technique [14].

From the perspective of carrying out above studies, high-accuracy calculations score as much as the precision measurements. It, therefore, necessitates to underscore roles of higher-order electron correlation effects in different atomic properties for more reliable outcomes. The prominent systematic effects in the high-precision atomic experiments are Stark shifts, blackbody radiation shifts, quadrupole shifts, and Zeeman shifts. In this regard, independent experiments are required to set-up to measure these systematic effects to the intended precision. Sometimes managing these experiments could be extremely challenging, time consuming and expensive. In such situation, high-accuracy atomic calculations to estimate systematics can be the alternative. In view of this, precise knowledge of electric dipole polarizabilities (αd\alpha_d) and quadrupole moments (Θ\Theta) of the clock states of the Ca+^{+}, Sr+^{+} and Ba+^{+} ions are of immense interest.

Over the past decades, several experimental techniques like resonant excitation, Stark ionization and single ion trapping methods have been applied to measure transition probabilities, lifetimes, and hyperfine structure constants of the clock states of the Ca+^{+}, Sr+^{+} and Ba+^{+} ions [15–33]. However, only a few measured measurements of αd\alpha_d and Θ\Theta of the considered ions are available in the literature [34–38]. Again, poor agreement between these values with the calculations reported using different theories are being observed [36–41]. This obscures improving accuracy of the clock transitions of the aforementioned ions. The ab initioab\ initio calculations of αd\alpha_d were performed using lower-order methods, while other values were estimated in the semi-empirical approaches by adopting a mixture of methods utilizing some of the dominantly contributing electric dipole (E1) matrix elements from the calculations along with the experimental energies [3] [42, 43, 44, 45]. On the other hand, the Θ\Theta values were estimated using the relativistic coupled-cluster (RCC) method [39, 41] and multi-configuration Dirac Hartree-Fock (MCDHF) method [40] approximating at the singles and doubles excitation levels. It has also been noticed that the extracted nuclear quadrupole moments (QnQ_n) of 43{}^{43}Ca, 87{}^{87}Sr and 137{}^{137}Ba from the hyperfine structure studies of these atoms or their ions substantially differ from each other [46–49], which needs to be addressed.

In this work, we intend to perform first-principle calculations of αd\alpha_d and Θ\Theta of the clock states of Ca+^{+}, Sr+^{+}, and Ba+^{+} by employing the recently developed singles, doubles and triples approximated RCC (RCCSDT) method. In order to validate the calculations, we present energies and magnetic dipole hyperfine structure constants (AhfA_{hf}) of the clock states using the RCCSDT method and compare them with the experimental values. We also extract the QnQ_n values of the 43{}^{43}Ca, 87{}^{87}Sr and 137{}^{137}Ba isotopes by combining the precisely measured electric quadrupole hyperfine structure constants (BhfB_{hf}) with their corresponding calculations of the above ions. We consider as many as 40, 39, 38, 37, 36, 35, and 34 Gaussian-type orbital (GTO) basis functions for constructing Dirac-Hartree-Fock (DHF) orbitals of the ss, pp, dd, ff, gg, hh, and ii symmetries, respectively. The GTO parameters are optimized such that energies of core orbitals agree reasonably well with the numerical values from GRASP [50]. Contributions from the orbitals belonging to orbital angular momentum l≥7l \ge7 (quoted as +Basis) are extracted using the third-order many-body perturbation (MP) theory (refer to Supplemental Materials [51] for details). To account electron correlation effects, we have considered the Dirac-Coulomb (DC) Hamiltonian (HDCH_{DC}) in the RCCSDT method, while contributions from the Breit interactions (given as +Breit) and lower-order vacuum polarization (VP) effects (given as +VP) are estimated at the singles and doubles approximation in the RCC (RCCSD) method [62, 63] to improve accuracy of the calculations. Below, we present results from the DHF, RCCSD and RCCSDT methods to demonstrate how electron correlation effects arising through the triple excitations play important roles in improving the results.

MethodCa+^{+} 4s 2S1/24s\,^{2}S_{1/2}3d 2D3/23d\,^{2}D_{3/2}3d 2D5/23d\,^{2}D_{5/2}Sr+^{+} 5s 2S1/25s\,^{2}S_{1/2}4d 2D3/24d\,^{2}D_{3/2}4d 2D5/24d\,^{2}D_{5/2}Ba+^{+} 6s 2S1/26s\,^{2}S_{1/2}5d 2D3/25d\,^{2}D_{3/2}5d 2D5/25d\,^{2}D_{5/2}
DHF91440.0272618.6572594.5584041.9667384.8067241.9775339.3568139.7567665.52
RCCSD95906.3182293.8082212.3389094.9374404.6874101.5880883.8075738.9474907.46
RCCSDT95681.8681912.2081836.5188859.8374239.3473953.8680482.2375420.5674629.95
+Basis10.3477.3977.1416.5781.1779.8830.06125.91121.71
+Breit−7.3337.6752.85−10.2541.7458.52−10.7651.5574.77
+VP0.92−0.38−0.383.32−0.90−0.887.02−2.19−2.07
Final95685.7982026.8881999.1288869.4774391.4874091.3880508.5575595.8374824.36
Expt. [64]95751.8782101.6882040.9988965.1874409.2874128.9480686.3075812.44875011.493
Δ\Delta (%)0.070.090.050.110.020.050.220.290.25
DHF98.90104.92102.24127.03148.90139.42185.5291.2988.78
RCCSD76.3332.0131.8792.0564.5363.32125.3752.4552.56
+Basis−0.02−0.14−0.14−0.05−0.28−0.27−0.12−0.19−0.18
+Breit∼\sim 0.0−0.18−0.22−0.01−0.52−0.57∼\sim 0.0−0.23−0.28
+VP−0.03−0.03−0.03−0.03−0.05−0.04−0.10−0.04−0.04
Final76.3(5)31.7(5)31.5(5)92.0(7)63.7(8)62.4(8)125.2(9)52.0(8)52.1(8)
Theory76.1(5)a^{a}32.0(3)a^{a}31.8(3)a^{a}88.29(1.0)c^{c}61.43(52)c^{c}62.87(75)c^{c}124.26(1.0)c^{c}48.81(46)c^{c}50.67(58)c^{c}
73.0(1.5)b^{b}28.5(1.0)b^{b}29.5(10)b^{b}91.3(9)d^{d}62.0(5)d^{d}124.15e^{e}
Expt.123.88(5) [34]
125.5(10) [35]

Table 1. Calculated energies (in cm−1^{-1}) and αdS\alpha_d^S values (in a.u.) of the clock states of Ca+^{+}, Sr+^{+}, and Ba+^{+} at the DHF and RCC methods. The final values are compared with experimental values (Expt.) and other precise calculations. αdS\alpha_d^S values in a.u. a^{a}[42]; b^{b}[45]; c^{c}[3]; d^{d}[44]; e^{e}[43].

Our calculated results for the energies of various states of the alkaline-earth metal ions are presented in Table I. We find that in all the states across all the considered ions, correlation effects improve the results significantly over the DHF results and inclusion of triples contributions decrease the values by 0.2-0.5% from the RCCSD method compared to the overall correlation contributions, which are about 4-7% in the ground states and about 9-12% in the metastable states. +Basis and +Breit contributions are on the order of 0.1%, whereas the +VP corrections are generally found to be very small. Comparison of our final results with the experimental energies from the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) database [64] show small percentage differences. The calculated values can be improved further after inclusion of correlation effects from the quadruple excitations and self-energy corrections, which we defer to our future work but the present level of accuracy is sufficient enough to estimate properties of our interest using the calculated wave functions to the intended accuracy.

In the presence of external DC electric field E⃗\vec{\mathcal{E}}, the Stark shift due to the second-order correction to EvE_v of the ∣Jv,Mv⟩|J_v,M_v\rangle state is Ev(2)=−12αd(Jv,Mv)∣E⃗∣2E_v^{(2)}=-\frac{1}{2}\alpha_d(J_v,M_v)|\vec{\mathcal{E}}|^2. Conventionally, the dependency of MvM_v is taken care by expressing αd(Jv,Mv)=αdS(Jv)+3Mv2−Jv(Jv+1)Jv(2Jv−1)αdT(Jv)\alpha_d(J_v,M_v)=\alpha_d^S(J_v)+\frac{3M_v^2-J_v(J_v+1)}{J_v(2J_v-1)}\alpha_d^T(J_v), where αdS\alpha_d^S and αdT\alpha_d^T are referred as scalar and tensor components of αd\alpha_d. Detailed computational procedures for evaluating αdS\alpha_d^S and αdT\alpha_d^T in linear response (LR) RCC method, are given in Refs. [65, 66] (also refer to Supplemental Materials [51]). In the bottom part of Table I, we report our results for αdS\alpha_d^S. In these quantities, the +Breit corrections are found to be consistently larger than the +VP contributions, and also outweighs the +Basis contributions. We also compare our final values with the available measurements [34, 35] and other precise estimations [3] [42, 43, 44, 45] in the same table. In Table II, we present αdT\alpha_d^T values obtained from the DHF and RCC methods which show similar behavior as for αdS\alpha_d^S. In fact, we provide additional values from the MP methods based on the Rayleigh-Schrödinger (MPRS^{RS}) and Brillouin-Wigner (MPBW^{BW}) approaches, and random phase approximation (RPA) in the Supplemental Materials [51]. Due to unavailability of the experimental results, we compare our final values with other high-accuracy calculations from Refs. [3] [42, 45] and they seem to have good agreement overall. Apart from theoretical estimations in Refs. [3] [45], other calculations mentioned above make use of experimental energies and/or E1 matrix elements to offer the precise values. Very good agreement between our ab initio results with the semi-empirical and measured values demonstrate potential of our employed LR-RCC method. It is to be noted that contributions from the triples are included in the uncertainties listed in the table, but they are discussed later.

MethodCa+^{+} 3D3/23D_{3/2} αdT\alpha_d^TCa+^{+} 3D3/23D_{3/2} Θ\ThetaCa+^{+} 3D5/23D_{5/2} αdT\alpha_d^TCa+^{+} 3D5/23D_{5/2} Θ\ThetaSr+^{+} 4D3/24D_{3/2} αdT\alpha_d^TSr+^{+} 4D3/24D_{3/2} Θ\ThetaSr+^{+} 4D5/24D_{5/2} αdT\alpha_d^TSr+^{+} 4D5/24D_{5/2} Θ\ThetaBa+^{+} 5D3/25D_{3/2} αdT\alpha_d^TBa+^{+} 5D3/25D_{3/2} Θ\ThetaBa+^{+} 5D5/25D_{5/2} αdT\alpha_d^TBa+^{+} 5D5/25D_{5/2} Θ\Theta
DHF−66.391.712−90.682.451−93.832.469−118.323.559−45.502.733−58.633.994
RCCSD−17.051.288−23.991.846−35.722.038−48.022.948−22.452.278−30.143.353
RCCSDT−1.296−1.857−2.037−2.984−2.279−3.354
+Basis0.10−0.0030.14−0.0040.19−0.0050.26−0.0070.12−0.0060.16−0.009
+Breit0.14−0.0020.22−0.0030.39−0.0020.53−0.0060.18−0.0030.26−0.006
+VP0.03∼0.0\sim0.00.03∼0.0\sim0.00.04∼0.0\sim0.00.04∼0.0\sim0.00.04∼0.0\sim0.00.040.001
Final−16.8(2)1.291(6)−23.6(3)1.850(9)−35.1(4)2.030(8)−47.2(5)2.971(10)−22.1(2)2.270(9)−29.7(3)3.339(12)
Theory−17.43(23)a^{a}1.289(11)c^{c}−24.51(29)a^{a}1.849(17)c^{c}−35.42(25)e^{e}2.029(12)c^{c}−48.83(30)e^{e}2.935(17)c^{c}−24.62(28)e^{e}2.256(11)c^{c}−30.85(31)e^{e}3.319(15)c^{c}
Theory−15.8(7)b^{b}1.338d^{d}−22.45(5)b^{b}1.917d^{d}2.107d^{d}−47.7(3)f^{f}3.048d^{d}2.297d^{d}3.379d^{d}
Expt.1.83(1) [36]2.6(3) [37], 2.9730.0260.033[38]

Table II. TABLE II. αdT\alpha_d^T and Θ\Theta values (both are in a.u.) of the metastable states of Ca+^{+}, Sr+^{+}, and Ba+^{+} from different contributions of the present calculation and their comparisons with the available experimental values (Expt.) and accurate calculations.

In Table II, we report electric quadrupole (E2) moments of the metastable clock states of the considered ions and compare them with the literature values [36–40]. Though our calculations and measured values are close, yet they are outside the quoted error bars. Compared to other calculations, our results are more precise and do not sometime agree with others due to inclusion of triples contributions. More importantly, analysis of MP, RPA and +Basis results, in the Supplemental Materials [51], suggests that the calculations reported using the B-spline basis functions in Ref. [39] and GTOs in the present case show very different trends of contributions from orbitals belonging to different ll-quantum number. For example, Ref. [39] reported a large contribution from basis extrapolation with l≥7l \ge7, amounting to nearly 0.9% in some cases. By contrast, we find that the basis extrapolation effects are generally smaller than our quoted uncertainties. It may be attributed to the way continuum are generated in both the works.

Inclusion of triples effects in the evaluation of αdS\alpha_d^S and αdT\alpha_d^T is strenuous in the LR-RCC method and it requires to determine amplitudes for both the unperturbed and perturbed wave operators. D\mathbf{D} being a vector operator, the perturbed RCC operators generates unusually large number of amplitudes, especially for the metastable DD states, compared to their unperturbed counterparts at the given set of active orbitals. This is why we only estimated triples contributions to the ground state of

αd\alpha_d. However to gauge their influences to the αd\alpha_d values of the DD states, we also estimated them in the lighter Ca+^+ ion. From Table III, we find that triples contributions to αd\alpha_d are smaller than 0.5% in the ground states and 1.5% in the DD states. To understand the reason for small contributions arising from triples to the ground state αd\alpha_d values, we analyzed changes in the excitation energies and E1 matrix elements. We find that when moving from RCCSD to RCCSDT, the values of the E1 matrix elements decrease, from 2.912 atomic units (a.u.) and 4.119 a.u. to 2.903 a.u. and 4.109 a.u., and at the same time energies also decrease, from 25419.02 cm−1^{-1} and 25509.06 cm−1^{-1} to 25145.23 cm−1^{-1} and 25374.59 cm−1^{-1}, for the 4S1/2↔4P1/24S_{1/2}\leftrightarrow4P_{1/2} and 4S1/2↔4P3/24S_{1/2}\leftrightarrow4P_{3/2} transitions, respectively, in Ca+^+. Since polarizability depends on the square of the E1 matrix elements and inversely on the transition energies, similar correlation trends in both the properties largely compensate to produce almost similar αd\alpha_d values in the RCCSD and RCCSDT methods.

QuantityCa+^{+} 4s 2S1/24s\,^2S_{1/2}Ca+^{+} 3d 2D3/23d\,^2D_{3/2}Ca+^{+} 3d 2D5/23d\,^2D_{5/2}Sr+^{+} 5s 2S1/25s\,^2S_{1/2}Ba+^{+} 6s 2S1/26s\,^2S_{1/2}
αdS\alpha_d^S−0.250.420.40−0.47−0.08
αdT\alpha_d^T0.0−0.31−0.300.00.0

Table III. TABLE III. Demonstration of triples contributions to the αdS\alpha_d^S and αdT\alpha_d^T values (in a.u.) of the ground states of the three considered ions and metastable states of Ca+^{+}.

We now intend to fathom the observed inconsistencies in the lifetime studies, both from theoretical and experimental, of the metastable states of the considered clock candidates that are mainly governed by the forbidden magnetic dipole (M1) and E2 transition amplitudes. By evaluating the M1 (An→kM1A^{\mathrm{M1}}_{n\to k}) and E2 (An→kE2A^{\mathrm{E2}}_{n\to k}) transition rates (in s−1^{-1}) for the ∣Jn,Mn⟩→∣Jk,Mk⟩|J_n,M_n\rangle\to|J_k,M_k\rangle transition, its lifetime is determined as τn=1∑k,oAn→ko\tau_n=\frac{1}{\sum_{k,o}A^o_{n\to k}}, where the sum for oo runs over all possible decay modes (E2 and M1) and sum for kk runs for all possible decay states. We present our calculated E2 and M1 matrix elements from the DHF, RCCSD and RCCSDT methods along

MethodCa+^{+} 4s 2S1/24s\,{}^{2}S_{1/2}Ca+^{+} 3d 2D3/23d\,{}^{2}D_{3/2}Ca+^{+} 3d 2D5/23d\,{}^{2}D_{5/2}Sr+^{+} 5s 2S1/25s\,{}^{2}S_{1/2}Sr+^{+} 4d 2D3/24d\,{}^{2}D_{3/2}Sr+^{+} 4d 2D5/24d\,{}^{2}D_{5/2}Ba+^{+} 6s 2S1/26s\,{}^{2}S_{1/2}Ba+^{+} 5d 2D3/25d\,{}^{2}D_{3/2}Ba+^{+} 5d 2D5/25d\,{}^{2}D_{5/2}
DHF−588.26−33.21−14.15−734.39−31.14−12.982935.35128.4151.5
RCCSD−810.77−47.55−4.32−1009.14−46.150.994094.24189.74−5.99
RCCSDT−805.41−47.60−3.25−997.32−46.262.644026.31191.21−14.06
+Basis−0.34−0.06−0.03−0.83−0.10−0.058.140.650.29
+Breit−0.72−0.12−0.04−1.55−0.22−0.066.701.190.36
+VP−0.38∼ 0.00.01−1.12−0.010.028.670.11−0.14
+BW0.880.02−0.013.150.05−0.05−36.46−0.580.60
Final−806(3)−47.8(3)−3.3(4)−998(4)−46.5(2)2.5(2)4013(9)193(4)−12.9(9)
Theory [46]−806.4(2.5)−47.3(3)−3.6(3)−1001.203−45.6042.145190.89−11.99
Theory [69]−808.126−45.294−4.008−990.638−44.3202.1684021.721185.013−12.593
Theory [40]−47.27−4.84−45.60−2.77192.99−9.39
Expt.−806.40207a^{a}−48.3(1.6)c^{c}−3.8(6)d^{d}−1000.5(1.0)f^{f}2.1743(14)h^{h}4018.2i^{i}189.7296(7)j^{j}−12.028(11)j^{j}
−805(2)b^{b}47.3(2)d^{d}−3.8931(2)e^{e}−1000.47367g^{g}
DHF54.4577.1580.35110.04133.57171.09
RCCSD68.6395.90116.48160.16194.51256.34
RCCSDT69.3895.83115.47157.87191.61251.23
+Basis0.100.130.260.350.530.66
+Breit0.010.10−0.060.10−0.30−0.07
+VP−0.01∼ 0.0−0.01∼ 0.0−0.02−0.01
Final69.5(8)96.1(9)115.7(8)158.3(10)191.8(20)251.8(25)
Expt.−3.7(1.9)d^{d}−3.9(6.0)d^{d}−4.241(4)e^{e}49.11(6)h^{h}44.5408(17)j^{j}59.533(43)j^{j}
This work−0.0441(4)0.3102(19)0.2344(17)
Other work−0.0444(6) [46]0.305(2) [46]0.246(1) [46]
−0.0479(6) [47]0.323(20) [48]0.245(4) [49]
−0.0408(8) [49]0.335(20) [49]

Table VI. Calculated AhfA_{hf} and Bhf/QnB_{hf}/Q_n values of the ground and metastable states of 43Ca+{}^{43}\mathrm{Ca}^{+}, 87Sr+{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr}^{+}, and 137Ba+{}^{137}\mathrm{Ba}^{+} using the DHF and many-body methods, and their comparisons with the literature values. The extracted QnQ_n values of the above isotopes from precise measurements of BhfB_{hf} are also given.

Ref: a^{a}[24], b^{b}[25]; c^{c}[26], d^{d}[27], e^{e}[28], f^{f}[29], g^{g}[30], h^{h}[31], i^{i}[32], j^{j}[33]

with other corrections in Table IV. These values from the MP methods and RPA can be found in the Supplemental Materials [51]. Comparing our final results with other calculations [67, 68], we find the E2 and M1 values are improved substantially due to inclusion of contributions from the triple excitations. Using the above discussed E2 and M1 matrix elements and wavelength values from the experiments [64], we present lifetimes for the metastable 2D3/2{}^{2}D_{3/2} and 2D5/2{}^{2}D_{5/2} states of the considered ions in Table V. For completeness, we give the calculated transition probabilities from both the metastable states of each ion due to the E2 and M1 decay channels in the above table. Our analysis shows that, for all ions, the lifetimes are governed primarily by the E2 channel with an exception arises in the case of the 5d 2D5/25d\,{}^{2}D_{5/2} state of Ba+^{+}, where the 5d 2D5/2→5d 2D3/25d\,{}^{2}D_{5/2} \rightarrow5d\,{}^{2}D_{3/2} M1 channel provides a significant additional contribution. It can be observed from the above table that our τ\tau values agree well with some of the calculations and measurements [15, 17–22, 67], yet differ significantly from others [16, 23, 68]. Since we use the E2 and M1 matrix elements that accounts more physical effects through the triples, +Breit and +VP compared to the earlier calculations, our estimated values are considered to be very reliable.

Method\multicolumn{3}{c}{Ca+^+}\multicolumn{3}{c}{Sr+^+}\multicolumn{3}{c}{Ba+^+}
S1/2−D3/2S_{1/2}-D_{3/2}S1/2−D5/2S_{1/2}-D_{5/2}D3/2−D5/2D_{3/2}-D_{5/2}S1/2−D3/2S_{1/2}-D_{3/2}S1/2−D5/2S_{1/2}-D_{5/2}D3/2−D5/2D_{3/2}-D_{5/2}S1/2−D3/2S_{1/2}-D_{3/2}S1/2−D5/2S_{1/2}-D_{5/2}D3/2−D5/2D_{3/2}-D_{5/2}
\multicolumn{10}{c}{E2 amplitudes}
DHF9.76711.9785.01812.96915.9737.26114.76418.3858.092
RCCSD7.9149.7163.77711.14213.7626.00512.66215.8506.777
RCCSDT7.9599.7703.80311.15913.7796.00812.70015.8906.797
+Basis−0.011−0.013−0.008−0.017−0.020−0.014−0.029−0.036−0.019
+Breit−0.006−0.009−0.005−0.007−0.014−0.008−0.009−0.020−0.010
+VP∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0
Final7.942(7)9.748(11)3.790(5)11.135(15)13.745(20)5.986(7)12.662(20)15.834(25)6.768(9)
Theory [68]7.78(4)9.56(4)3.68(2)11.01(4)13.60(5)5.90(2)12.49(11)15.65(14)6.65(6)
Theory [67]7.94(4)9.750(47)11.13(39)13.745(29)12.63(11)15.800(79)
\multicolumn{10}{c}{M1 amplitudes}
DHF−4.1[−7]1.5491.6[−6]1.5495.5[−6]1.549
RCCSD3.5[−4]1.5553.0[−5]1.5533.1[−4]1.554
RCCSDT3.5[−4]1.5553.2[−5]1.5533.2[−4]1.554
+Basis∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0
+Breit−1.1[−5]∼0.0\sim0.01.1[−5]−0.0021.0[−5]∼0.0\sim0.0
+VP∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0∼0.0\sim0.0
Final3.4(2)[−4]1.555(2)4.3(3)[−5]1.551(2)3.3(3)[−4]1.554(2)
Theory [68]∼0.0\sim0.01.5491∼0.0\sim0.01.54920.00021.5493

Table IV. Reduced E2 and M1 amplitudes (in a.u.) of the clock transitions in Ca+^+, Sr+^+, and Ba+^+ at different levels of calculations and their comparisons with previously available precise calculations. Numbers appearing as a[b]a[b] mean a×10ba \times10^b.

Atomic StateDecay StateModeAn→koA^o_{n\to k} in s−1^{-1}τn\tau_n (in s), Theoryτn\tau_n (in s), Expt.
Ca+^+ ion
3D3/2^3D_{3/2}4S1/2^4S_{1/2}M11.98[−6]1.195(4)*1.20(1) [15]
E20.836901.194(11) [67]1.176(11) [16]
1.24(1) [68]
3D5/2^3D_{5/2}3D3/2^3D_{3/2}M12.43[−6]1.164(5)*1.168(7) [15]
E22.21[−13]1.163(11) [67]1.168(9) [16]
4S1/2^4S_{1/2}E20.859361.21(1) [68]
Sr+^+ ion
4D3/2^4D_{3/2}5S1/2^5S_{1/2}M13.84[−8]0.441(2)*0.435(4) [17, 18]
E22.268220.437(14) [67]0.455(29) [18]
0.451(3) [68]
4D5/2^4D_{5/2}4D3/2^4D_{3/2}M10.24[−3]0.394(2)*0.408(22) [18]
E21.16[−9]0.3945(22) [67]0.3908(16) [19]
5S1/2^5S_{1/2}E22.534670.403(3) [68]0.372(25) [22]
Ba+^+ ion
5D3/2^5D_{3/2}6S1/2^6S_{1/2}M10.08[−6]81.0(5)*79.8(4.6) [20]
E20.0123481.4(1.4) [67]89(16) [21]
83(1) [68]
5D5/2^5D_{5/2}5D3/2^5D_{3/2}M10.0055830.2(2)*32.0(4.6) [21]
E22.82[−7]30.34(48) [67]34.5(3.5) [23]
6S1/2^6S_{1/2}E20.0275430.81(65) [68]

Table V. Estimated lifetimes of clock states of the considered ions computed using the experimental wavelengths (shown with *), their comparisons with the literature values. Transition rates from the M1 and E2 modes are also given.

In Table XI, we report our calculated magnetic dipole hyperfine structure constants (AhfA_{hf}) and ratio of QnQ_n and electric quadrupole hyperfine structure constants (Bhf/QnB_{hf}/Q_n) of the 43Ca+{}^{43}\mathrm{Ca}^{+}, 87Sr+{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} and 137Ba+{}^{137}\mathrm{Ba}^{+} ions from the DHF, RCCSD and RCCSDT methods including +Basis, +Breit, +VP and Bohr-Weisskopf effect (+BW) contributions. We find, our AhfA_{hf} values are in good agreement with other calculations and available precise measurements [24–33, 40, 46, 69]. Details of correlation trends through MP and RPA results, and also the nuclear magnetic moments used for estimating AhfA_{hf} by us are discussed in the Supplemental Materials [51]. From our AhfA_{hf} values, we anticipate that the obtained Bhf/QnB_{hf}/Q_{n} are equally accurate. Combining our B/QnB/Q_{n} calculations with the precisely measured BhfB_{hf} values from Refs. [28, 31, 33], we have extracted the QnQ_{n} values of 43Ca{}^{43}\mathrm{Ca}, 87Sr{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr} and 137Ba{}^{137}\mathrm{Ba}. They are compared with the earlier extracted values [46–49] in the above table. We find differences of about 4–9% from previously reported values compared to ours. Since our calculations incorporate correlations and relativistic effects in a more rigorous manner, the inferred QnQ_{n} values in the present work are expected to be more accurate.

Method4s 2S1/24s\,{}^{2}S_{1/2}3d 2D3/23d\,{}^{2}D_{3/2}3d 2D5/23d\,{}^{2}D_{5/2}5s 2S1/25s\,{}^{2}S_{1/2}4d 2D3/24d\,{}^{2}D_{3/2}4d 2D5/24d\,{}^{2}D_{5/2}6s 2S1/26s\,{}^{2}S_{1/2}5d 2D3/25d\,{}^{2}D_{3/2}5d 2D5/25d\,{}^{2}D_{5/2}
DHF−588.26-588.26−33.21-33.21−14.15-14.15−734.39-734.39−31.14-31.14−12.98-12.982935.352935.35128.41128.4151.5251.52
MP(2)RS^{RS}−683.49-683.49−32.62-32.62−1.02-1.02−843.21-843.21−31.41-31.411.401.403349.473349.47131.65131.65−9.88-9.88
MP(3)RS^{RS}−796.22-796.22−44.10-44.10−6.49-6.49−1016.75-1016.75−40.43-40.43−2.79-2.794249.284249.28167.05167.056.396.39
MP(2)BW^{BW}−683.16-683.16−32.70-32.70−1.17-1.17−842.67-842.67−31.52-31.521.211.213346.503346.50132.19132.19−8.72-8.72
MP(3)BW^{BW}−789.87-789.87−42.59-42.59−5.95-5.95−1004.41-1004.41−39.47-39.47−2.55-2.554165.224165.22162.98162.985.745.74
RPA−710.77-710.77−34.51-34.515.935.93−873.80-873.80−34.85-34.8511.7711.773478.633478.63149.92149.92−56.69-56.69
RCCSD−810.77-810.77−47.55-47.55−4.32-4.32−1009.14-1009.14−46.15-46.150.990.994094.244094.24189.74189.74−5.99-5.99
RCCSDT−805.41-805.41−47.60-47.60−3.25-3.25−997.32-997.32−46.26-46.262.642.644026.314026.31191.21191.21−14.06-14.06
DHF54.4554.4577.1577.1580.3580.35110.04110.04133.57133.57171.09171.09
MP(2)RS^{RS}52.7052.7075.0275.0297.8997.89136.92136.92170.47170.47229.94229.94
MP(3)RS^{RS}70.8570.85100.39100.39114.42114.42158.51158.51190.93190.93253.38253.38
MP(2)BW^{BW}53.0153.0175.4775.4798.2998.29137.45137.45171.36171.36230.95230.95
MP(3)BW^{BW}68.6368.6397.2797.27112.28112.28155.68155.68187.74187.74249.51249.51
RPA47.8447.8468.2468.2486.4286.42121.55121.55146.95146.95200.25200.25
RCCSD68.6368.6395.9095.90116.48116.48160.16160.16194.51194.51256.34256.34
RCCSDT69.3869.3895.8395.83115.47115.47157.87157.87191.61191.61251.23251.23

Table XI. Calculated AhfA_{hf} and Bhf/QnB_{hf}/Q_n values of the ground and metastable states of 43Ca+{}^{43}\mathrm{Ca}^{+}, 87Sr+{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr}^{+}, and 137Ba+{}^{137}\mathrm{Ba}^{+} using the DHF and many-body methods.

This work is supported by ANRF with grant no. CRG/2023/002558 and Department of Space, Government of India. All calculations were performed on the ParamVikram-1000 HPC cluster at the Physical Research Laboratory (PRL), Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India.

References

Supplemental Materials: Investigating Roles of Triple Excitations for High-precision Determination of Clock Properties of Alkaline Earth Metal Singly Charged Ions

For an atomic state ∣JvMv⟩\lvert J_v M_v\rangle, αd(Jv,Mv)\alpha_d(J_v,M_v) depends on JvJ_v and MvM_v. Using the MvM_v-dependent factors, it yields [1, 2]

αd(Jv,Mv)=αdS(Jv)+3Mv2−Jv(Jv+1)Jv(2Jv−1)αdT(Jv).(1)\alpha_d(J_v,M_v)=\alpha_d^S(J_v)+\frac{3M_v^2-J_v(J_v+1)}{J_v(2J_v-1)}\alpha_d^T(J_v). \tag*{(1)}

Here αdS(Jv)\alpha_d^S(J_v) and αdT(Jv)\alpha_d^T(J_v) are called as the scalar and tensor polarizabilities, respectively. These MvM_v independent quantities can be written in terms of reduced matrix elements as [1, 3]

αdS(Jv)=C0∑k∣⟨Jv∥D∥Jk⟩∣2EJv(0)−EJk(0).(2)\alpha_d^S(J_v)=C_0\sum_k\frac{\lvert\langle J_v\Vert D\Vert J_k\rangle\rvert^2}{E_{J_v}^{(0)}-E_{J_k}^{(0)}}. \tag*{(2)}

and

αdT(Jv)=40Jv(2Jv−1)3(Jv+1)(2Jv+3)(2Jv+1)∑k(−1)Jv+Jk+1×{Jv2Jv1Jk1}(−1)Jv−Jk∣⟨Jv∥D∥Jk⟩∣2EJv(0)−EJk(0)=∑kCk∣⟨Jv∥D∥Jk⟩∣2EJv(0)−EJk(0).(3)\begin{aligned} \alpha_d^T(J_v)&=\sqrt{\frac{40J_v(2J_v-1)}{3(J_v+1)(2J_v+3)(2J_v+1)}}\sum_k(-1)^{J_v+J_k+1}\\ &\quad\times\begin{Bmatrix}J_v&2&J_v\\1&J_k&1\end{Bmatrix}(-1)^{J_v-J_k}\frac{\lvert\langle J_v\Vert D\Vert J_k\rangle\rvert^2}{E_{J_v}^{(0)}-E_{J_k}^{(0)}}\\ &=\sum_k C_k\frac{\lvert\langle J_v\Vert D\Vert J_k\rangle\rvert^2}{E_{J_v}^{(0)}-E_{J_k}^{(0)}}. \tag*{(3)} \end{aligned}

where C0=−23(2Jv+1)C_0=-\frac{2}{3(2J_v+1)}, Ck=40Jv(2Jv−1)3(Jv+1)(2Jv+3)(2Jv+1)×(−1)Jv+Jk+1{Jv2Jv1Jk1}C_k=\sqrt{\frac{40J_v(2J_v-1)}{3(J_v+1)(2J_v+3)(2J_v+1)}}\times(-1)^{J_v+J_k+1}\begin{Bmatrix}J_v&2&J_v\\1&J_k&1\end{Bmatrix} with D=∑qdqD=\sum_q d_q is the E1 operator. In the linear response (LR) approach, we express αdS/T\alpha_d^{S/T} as

αdS/T=⟨Ψv(0)∣D~S/T∣Ψv(1)⟩+⟨Ψv(1)∣D~S/T∣Ψv(0)⟩=2⟨Ψv(0)∣D~S/T∣Ψv(1)⟩.(4)\begin{aligned} \alpha_d^{S/T}&=\langle\Psi_v^{(0)}\lvert\widetilde{D}^{S/T}\rvert\Psi_v^{(1)}\rangle+\langle\Psi_v^{(1)}\lvert\widetilde{D}^{S/T}\rvert\Psi_v^{(0)}\rangle\\ &=2\langle\Psi_v^{(0)}\lvert\widetilde{D}^{S/T}\rvert\Psi_v^{(1)}\rangle. \tag*{(4)} \end{aligned}

where ∣Ψv(0)⟩\lvert\Psi_v^{(0)}\rangle and ∣Ψv(1)⟩\lvert\Psi_v^{(1)}\rangle denote the unperturbed wave function of the atomic Hamiltonian (HatH_{at}) and first-order perturbed wave function due to the E1 interaction, respectively. The term D~S/T\widetilde{D}^{S/T} refers to the effective dipole operators for scalar and tensor components, given by D~S=C0D\widetilde{D}^S=C_0D and D~T=∑kCkD\widetilde{D}^T=\sum_k C_kD.

To begin with, we consider HatH_{at} at the Dirac-Coulomb (DC) approximation, given by (in a.u.)

Hat≡∑i[cαiD⋅pi+(βiD−1)c2+Vn(ri)]+∑i,j>i1rij.H_{at}\equiv\sum_i\left[c\boldsymbol{\alpha}_i^D\cdot\boldsymbol{p}_i+(\beta_i^D-1)c^2+V_n(r_i)\right]+\sum_{i,j>i}\frac{1}{r_{ij}}.

Here, αD\boldsymbol{\alpha}^D and βD\beta^D are the Dirac matrices, p\boldsymbol{p} is the single-particle momentum operator, Vn(r)V_n(r) represents the nuclear potential felt by an electron, and 1rij\frac{1}{r_{ij}} represents the Coulomb repulsion between two electrons. Since all the considered atomic states have closed-core and a valence orbital with different parity and angular momentum, we consider the VN−1V^{N-1} potential formalism, where NN is the total number of electron of the considered singly charged ion, to produce the initial wave function, ∣Φ0⟩\lvert\Phi_0\rangle, using the DHF Hamiltonian, HDHFH_{DHF}.

At the first step, we express the exact unperturbed wave function of the closed-core, ∣Ψ0(0)⟩\lvert\Psi_0^{(0)}\rangle, due to HatH_{at} by

∣Ψ0(0)⟩=Ω0(0)∣Φ0⟩.(5)\lvert\Psi_0^{(0)}\rangle=\Omega_0^{(0)}\lvert\Phi_0\rangle. \tag*{(5)}

where Ω0(0)\Omega_0^{(0)} is referred to as the wave operator, which accounts for the electron correlation effects arising from the residual interaction Vres=Hat−HDHFV_{res}=H_{at}-H_{DHF}. In order to obtain the desired wave function of an intended state we append the required valence orbital, vv, to the closed-core configuration in the next step by defining the modified DHF wave function as ∣Φv⟩=av†∣Φ0⟩\lvert\Phi_v\rangle=a_v^\dagger\lvert\Phi_0\rangle. This follows the final unperturbed wave function in the wave operator formalism

∣Ψv(0)⟩=(Ω0(0)+Ωv(0))∣Φv⟩.(6)\lvert\Psi_v^{(0)}\rangle=(\Omega_0^{(0)}+\Omega_v^{(0)})\lvert\Phi_v\rangle. \tag*{(6)}

where Ωv(0)\Omega_v^{(0)} is responsible for accounting the correlation effects involving the electron from the valence orbital vv. Similarly, the corresponding first-order perturbed wave functions can be expressed as

∣Ψ0(1)⟩=Ω0(1)∣Φ0⟩(7)\lvert\Psi_0^{(1)}\rangle=\Omega_0^{(1)}\lvert\Phi_0\rangle \tag*{(7)}

and

∣Ψv(1)⟩=(Ω0(1)+Ωv(1))∣Φv⟩,(8)\lvert\Psi_v^{(1)}\rangle=(\Omega_0^{(1)}+\Omega_v^{(1)})\lvert\Phi_v\rangle, \tag*{(8)}

where superscript (1) on wave operators stands for the first-order perturbation. In the DHF method contribution from VresV_{res} is completely neglected; thus Ω0(0)=Ωv(0)=1\Omega_0^{(0)}=\Omega_v^{(0)}=1.

In order to understand roles correlation effects in different properties of our interest, we start calculations considering VresV_{res} as perturbation in the second-order and third-order perturbation theory (denoted as MP(2) and MP(3), respectively), then include VresV_{res} to all-orders through the random phase approximation (RPA) and relativistic coupled-cluster (RCC) theory. In the MP method, amplitudes of the wave operators are obtained using the Bloch equation [4]

[Ω0(0),HDHF]=(VresΩ0(0)−Ω0(0)[VresΩ0(0)])l.(9)\left[\Omega_0^{(0)},H_{DHF}\right]=\left(V_{res}\Omega_0^{(0)}-\Omega_0^{(0)}\left[V_{res}\Omega_0^{(0)}\right]\right)_l. \tag*{(9)}

and

[Ωv(0),HDHF]=(Vres(Ω0(0)+Ωv(0))−Ωv(0)[Vres(Ω0(0)+Ωv(0))])l.(10)\left[\Omega_v^{(0)},H_{DHF}\right]=\left(V_{res}(\Omega_0^{(0)}+\Omega_v^{(0)})-\Omega_v^{(0)}\left[V_{res}(\Omega_0^{(0)}+\Omega_v^{(0)})\right]\right)_l. \tag*{(10)}

where ‘l’ means that only the linked diagrams will contribute to the wave operator. It should be noted that energy of the state is given by

Ev=⟨Φv∣Vres(Ω0(0)+Ωv(0))∣Φv⟩.(11)E_v = \langle\Phi_v | V_{\mathrm{res}}(\Omega_0^{(0)} + \Omega_v^{(0)}) | \Phi_v \rangle. \tag*{(11)}

In the Rayleigh-Schrödinger MP approach (MPRS^{RS} method), the wave function and energies are evaluated order-by-order explicitly [4, 5]. On the other hand, in the Brillouin-Wigner MP approach (MPBW^{BW} method), amplitudes of the wave operators are obtained by rewriting Eq. (10) as [4, 5]

[Ωv(0),HDHF]=(Vres(Ω0(0)+Ωv(0)))l−Ωv(0)Ev(12)\left[\Omega_v^{(0)},H_{DHF}\right] = \left(V_{\mathrm{res}}(\Omega_0^{(0)}+\Omega_v^{(0)})\right)_l-\Omega_v^{(0)}E_v \tag*{(12)}

Similarly, the first-order perturbed wave operators in the MPRS/BW^{RS/BW} method can be derived by extending the

Bloch equation [4, 5, 6]

[Ω0(1),HDHF]=(DΩ0(0)+VresΩ0(1))l(13)\left[\Omega_0^{(1)},H_{DHF}\right] = \left(D\Omega_0^{(0)}+V_{\mathrm{res}}\Omega_0^{(1)}\right)_l \tag*{(13)}

and

[Ωv(1),HDHF]=(D(Ω0(0)+Ωv(0))+Vres(Ω0(1)+Ωv(1)))l−Ωv(1)Ev.(14)\left[\Omega_v^{(1)},H_{DHF}\right] = \left(D(\Omega_0^{(0)}+\Omega_v^{(0)})+V_{\mathrm{res}}(\Omega_0^{(1)}+\Omega_v^{(1)})\right)_l-\Omega_v^{(1)}E_v. \tag*{(14)}

In the RPA, Ω0/v(0)\Omega_{0/v}^{(0)} are equivalent to the DHF method and the first-order perturbed wave operators are obtained by

(HDHF−E0)Ω0(1)∣Φ0⟩=−D∣Φ0⟩−U0RPA∣Φ0⟩(15)(H_{DHF}-\mathcal{E}_0)\Omega_0^{(1)}|\Phi_0\rangle=-D|\Phi_0\rangle-U_0^{RPA}|\Phi_0\rangle \tag*{(15)}

and

(HDHF−Ev)Ωv(1)∣Φv⟩=−D∣Φv⟩−UvRPA∣Φv⟩.(16)(H_{DHF}-\mathcal{E}_v)\Omega_v^{(1)}|\Phi_v\rangle=-D|\Phi_v\rangle-U_v^{RPA}|\Phi_v\rangle. \tag*{(16)}

where E0=⟨Φ0∣HDHF∣Φ0⟩\mathcal{E}_0=\langle\Phi_0|H_{DHF}|\Phi_0\rangle, Ev=⟨Φv∣HDHF∣Φv⟩\mathcal{E}_v=\langle\Phi_v|H_{DHF}|\Phi_v\rangle and the RPA potentials are defined as

U0RPA∣Φ0⟩=∑a,b[⟨b∣VresΩ0(1)∣b⟩∣a⟩−⟨b∣VresΩ0(1)∣a⟩∣b⟩+⟨b∣Ω0(1)†Vres∣b⟩∣a⟩−⟨b∣Ω0(1)†Vres∣a⟩∣b⟩](17)U_0^{RPA}|\Phi_0\rangle=\sum_{a,b}\left[\langle b|V_{\mathrm{res}}\Omega_0^{(1)}|b\rangle|a\rangle-\langle b|V_{\mathrm{res}}\Omega_0^{(1)}|a\rangle|b\rangle+\langle b|\Omega_0^{(1)\dagger}V_{\mathrm{res}}|b\rangle|a\rangle-\langle b|\Omega_0^{(1)\dagger}V_{\mathrm{res}}|a\rangle|b\rangle\right] \tag*{(17)}

and

UvRPA∣Φv⟩=∑b[⟨b∣VresΩ0(1)∣b⟩∣v⟩−⟨b∣VresΩ0(1)∣v⟩∣b⟩+⟨b∣Ω0(1)†Vres∣b⟩∣v⟩−⟨b∣Ω0(1)†Vres∣v⟩∣b⟩].(18)U_v^{RPA}|\Phi_v\rangle=\sum_b\left[\langle b|V_{\mathrm{res}}\Omega_0^{(1)}|b\rangle|v\rangle-\langle b|V_{\mathrm{res}}\Omega_0^{(1)}|v\rangle|b\rangle+\langle b|\Omega_0^{(1)\dagger}V_{\mathrm{res}}|b\rangle|v\rangle-\langle b|\Omega_0^{(1)\dagger}V_{\mathrm{res}}|v\rangle|b\rangle\right]. \tag*{(18)}

In the RCC method, we express the exact wave function ∣Ψv⟩|\Psi_v\rangle of a one-valence atomic system (with valence orbital vv) as ∣Ψv⟩=eS∣Φv⟩|\Psi_v\rangle=e^S|\Phi_v\rangle, where SS is an wave operator that accounts for excitation amplitudes to all-orders of the residual interactions that are neglected at producing the mean-field wave function ∣Φv⟩|\Phi_v\rangle. In the expanded form, it yields S=S1+S2+⋯+SNS=S_1+S_2+\cdots+S_N with total number of electrons in the system NN and the subscript denotes level of excitation of electrons from core orbitals of ∣Φv⟩|\Phi_v\rangle to its virtuals; i.e. in the RCCSD method S=S1+S2S=S_1+S_2 and in the RCCSDT method S=S1+S2+S3S=S_1+S_2+S_3. We adopt the Fock-space approach to express S=T+SvS=T+S_v, where TT is the excitation operator responsible for exciting only the core electrons and SvS_v takes care of excitation of the valence electron coupling with the core-electrons. Due to presence of only one valence electron in the considered systems, the exact form of wave function yields ∣Ψv⟩=eT{1+Sv}∣Φv⟩|\Psi_v\rangle=e^T\{1+S_v\}|\Phi_v\rangle. The amplitudes of the TT and SvS_v operators are obtained by solving

⟨Φv∗∣[(HeT)l−Ev]Sv+(HeT)l∣Φv⟩=0,(19)\langle\Phi_v^*|[(He^T)_l-E_v]S_v+(He^T)_l|\Phi_v\rangle=0, \tag*{(19)}

where subscript ll means it retains only linked terms and ∣Φv∗⟩|\Phi_v^*\rangle denotes for core and valence excitation determinants. In the ab initio approach, the energy is calculated as Ev=⟨Φv∣(HeT)l{1+Sv}∣Φv⟩E_v=\langle\Phi_v|(He^T)_l\{1+S_v\}|\Phi_v\rangle. Since both amplitude and energy solving equations are interdependent, they are solved simultaneously. In the LR-RCC method, the TT and SvS_v operators are expanded up to the zeroth- and first-order due to D⋅E\mathbf{D}\cdot\mathbf{E} for a small value of ∣E∣|\mathbf{E}|; i.e. T=T(0)+∣E∣T(1)T=T^{(0)}+|\mathbf{E}|T^{(1)} and Sv=Sv(0)+∣E∣Sv(1)S_v=S_v^{(0)}+|\mathbf{E}|S_v^{(1)}.

In the RCC theory ansatz, the unperturbed wave operators are defined as

Ω0(0)=eT(0)(20)\Omega_0^{(0)}=e^{T^{(0)}} \tag*{(20)}

and

Ωv(0)=eT(0)Sv(0).(21)\Omega_v^{(0)}=e^{T^{(0)}}S_v^{(0)}. \tag*{(21)}

Extending these definitions to the first-order perturbed wave functions, we can define the corresponding wave operators as

Ω0(1)=eT(0)T(1)(22)\Omega_0^{(1)}=e^{T^{(0)}}T^{(1)} \tag*{(22)}

and

Ωv(1)=eT(0)(Sv(1)+T(1)Sv(0)).(23)\Omega_v^{(1)}=e^{T^{(0)}}\left(S_v^{(1)}+T^{(1)}S_v^{(0)}\right). \tag*{(23)}

Following the second-order energy expression Ev(2)=2⟨Ψv(0)∣D⋅E∣Ψv(1)⟩E_v^{(2)}=2\langle\Psi_v^{(0)}|\mathbf{D}\cdot\mathbf{E}|\Psi_v^{(1)}\rangle, we arrive at the LR-RCC expressions

αdS=2⟨Φv∣{1+Sv(0)†}D~S{T(1)(1+Sv(0))+Sv(1)}∣Φv⟩⟨Φv∣{Sv(0)†+1}N‾{1+Sv(0)}∣Φv⟩+2⟨Φ0∣D~T(1)∣Φ0⟩(24)\alpha_d^S=2\frac{\langle\Phi_v|\{1+S_v^{(0)\dagger}\}\widetilde{D}S\{T^{(1)}(1+S_v^{(0)})+S_v^{(1)}\}|\Phi_v\rangle}{\langle\Phi_v|\{S_v^{(0)\dagger}+1\}\overline{N}\{1+S_v^{(0)}\}|\Phi_v\rangle}+2\langle\Phi_0|\widetilde{D}T^{(1)}|\Phi_0\rangle \tag*{(24)}

and

αdT=2⟨Φv∣{1+Sv(0)†}D~T{T(1)(1+Sv(0))+Sv(1)}∣Φv⟩⟨Φv∣{Sv(0)†+1}N‾{1+Sv(0)}∣Φv⟩,(25)\alpha_d^T=2\frac{\langle\Phi_v|\{1+S_v^{(0)\dagger}\}\widetilde{D}T\{T^{(1)}(1+S_v^{(0)})+S_v^{(1)}\}|\Phi_v\rangle}{\langle\Phi_v|\{S_v^{(0)\dagger}+1\}\overline{N}\{1+S_v^{(0)}\}|\Phi_v\rangle}, \tag*{(25)}

where D~S/T=eT(0)†D~S/TeT(0)\widetilde{D}_{S/T}=e^{T^{(0)\dagger}}\widetilde{D}S/T e^{T^{(0)}}, N‾=eT(0)†eT(0)\overline{N}=e^{T^{(0)\dagger}}e^{T^{(0)}}.

In order to evaluate the M1 and E2 transition matrix elements, electric quadrupole moment (Θ\Theta), magnetic dipole hyperfine structure constants (AhfA_{hf}) and electric quadrupole hyperfine structure constants (BhfB_{hf}), we use the following general expression

⟨O⟩fi=⟨Ψf(0)∣O∣Ψi(0)⟩⟨Ψf(0)∣Ψf(0)⟩⟨Ψi(0)∣Ψi(0)⟩=⟨Φf∣(Ωf(0)†+Ω0(0)†)O(Ω0(0)+Ωi(0))∣Φi⟩NfNi,(26)\langle O\rangle_{fi}=\frac{\langle\Psi_f^{(0)}|O|\Psi_i^{(0)}\rangle}{\sqrt{\langle\Psi_f^{(0)}|\Psi_f^{(0)}\rangle\langle\Psi_i^{(0)}|\Psi_i^{(0)}\rangle}} =\frac{\langle\Phi_f|(\Omega_f^{(0)\dagger}+\Omega_0^{(0)\dagger})O(\Omega_0^{(0)}+\Omega_i^{(0)})|\Phi_i\rangle}{\sqrt{N_fN_i}}, \tag*{(26)}

where Nk=i,f=⟨Φk∣(Ωk(0)†+Ω0(0)†)(Ω0(0)+Ωk(0))∣Φk⟩N_{k=i,f}=\langle\Phi_k|(\Omega_k^{(0)\dagger}+\Omega_0^{(0)\dagger})(\Omega_0^{(0)}+\Omega_k^{(0)})|\Phi_k\rangle with the respective operator OO. In the evaluation of Θ\Theta, AhfA_{hf} and BhfB_{hf} expressions, we set ∣Ψf(0)⟩=∣Ψi(0)⟩|\Psi_f^{(0)}\rangle=|\Psi_i^{(0)}\rangle.

To account for the Bohr-Weisskopf (BW) effect [7], we define the nuclear magnetization function (F(r)F(r)) in the Fermi nuclear charge distribution approximation as

F(r)=fWSN[(r/c)3−3(a/c)(r/c)2R1((c−r)/a)+6(a/c)2(r/c)R2((c−r)/a)−6(a/c)3R3((c−r)/a)+6(a/c)3R3(c/a)](27)F(r)=\frac{f_{WS}}{\mathcal{N}}\left[(r/c)^3-3(a/c)(r/c)^2R_1((c-r)/a)+6(a/c)^2(r/c)R_2((c-r)/a)-6(a/c)^3R_3((c-r)/a)+6(a/c)^3R_3(c/a)\right] \tag*{(27)}

for r≤cr \le c and

F(r)=1−1N[3(a/c)(r/c)2R1((r−c)/a)+6(a/c)2(r/c)R2((r−c)/a)](28)F(r)=1-\frac{1}{\mathcal{N}}\left[3(a/c)(r/c)^2R_1((r-c)/a)+6(a/c)^2(r/c)R_2((r-c)/a)\right] \tag*{(28)}

for r>cr>c, where

N=1+(a/c)2π2+6(a/c)3R3(c/a)(29)\mathcal{N}=1+(a/c)^2\pi^2+6(a/c)^3R_3(c/a) \tag*{(29)}

and

Rk(x)=∑n=1∞(−1)n−1e−nxnk.(30)R_k(x)=\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}(-1)^{n-1}\frac{e^{-nx}}{n^k}. \tag*{(30)}

In Eq. (27) fWF=1f_{WF}=1 when Woods-Saxon potential correction is not taken into account, else it is estimated using following expressions after neglecting the spin-orbit interaction within the nucleus [8, 9]

fWS=1−(3μI)ln⁡(rc)[−2I−18(I+1)gS+(I−12)gL]f_{WS}=1-\left(\frac{3}{\mu_I}\right)\ln\left(\frac{r}{c}\right)\left[-\frac{2I-1}{8(I+1)}g_S+(I-\tfrac{1}{2})g_L\right]

for I=L+12I=L+\frac{1}{2} and

fWS=1−(3μI)ln⁡(rc)[2I+38(I+1)gS+I(2I+3)2(I+1)gL]f_{WS}=1-\left(\frac{3}{\mu_I}\right)\ln\left(\frac{r}{c}\right)\left[\frac{2I+3}{8(I+1)}g_S+\frac{I(2I+3)}{2(I+1)}g_L\right]

for I=L−12I=L-\frac{1}{2}.

Our calculated energies and αDS\alpha_D^S values for the clock states of the alkaline-earth-metal ions, obtained using DHF and different many-body methods, are summarized in Table VII. To analyze correlation effects in the energies, we present contributions from the DC Hamiltonian at the DHF and MP(2) levels, together with results from the RCC methods. The data show that core-polarization (CP) effects, which first appear at the MP(2) level, contribute as much as 5–12% to the total energies. In contrast, the difference between the RCCSD and MP(2) results is only about 0.3–1.6%, indicating all-order CP and pair-correlation (PC) effects play a relatively minor role in energy calculation. To illustrate the role of correlation effects on αDS\alpha_D^S, we include perturbative results from both the RSRS and BWBW perturbation schemes. It is evident that the BWBW approach provides values closer to the final results. This is expected, since unlike the RSRS scheme, the BWBW method accounts for correlation-corrected energies in the property evaluation, leading to improved accuracy. A comparison of DHF results with MP(2)RS^{RS} and MP(2)BW^{BW} shows that the lower-order CP effects generally reduce the αDS\alpha_D^S values. However, the correlation trend from MP(2) to MP(3) differs significantly between the two perturbation schemes. For the RSRS method, the PC contribution, which appears at the MP(3) level, increases αdS\alpha_d^S. In contrast, the BWBW method shows an increase at MP(3) only for the ground state; for the D3/2,5/2D_{3/2,5/2} states, MP(3)BW^{BW} values are smaller than MP(2)BW^{BW}, except in the case of Ba+^{+}, where the difference is negligible. We also find that the RPA results remain much closer to the DHF values compared to those from MP(2). Since RPA includes CP contributions from MP(2)RS^{RS} to all orders, this close agreement suggests that there are cancellations between the lowest-order and higher-order CP effects in determining αdS\alpha_d^S. Finally, we compare these results with those obtained using the RCCSD method. The RCCSD approach accounts for CP and PC effects to all orders and incorporates correlation in the state energies, thereby providing more reliable values.

MethodCa+^{+} 4s 2S1/2^{2}S_{1/2}Ca+^{+} 3d 2D3/2^{2}D_{3/2}Ca+^{+} 3d 2D5/2^{2}D_{5/2}Sr+^{+} 5s 2S1/2^{2}S_{1/2}Sr+^{+} 4d 2D3/2^{2}D_{3/2}Sr+^{+} 4d 2D5/2^{2}D_{5/2}Ba+^{+} 6s 2S1/2^{2}S_{1/2}Ba+^{+} 5d 2D3/2^{2}D_{3/2}Ba+^{+} 5d 2D5/2^{2}D_{5/2}
Method\multicolumn{9}{c}{Energies in cm−1^{-1}}
DHF91440.0272618.6572594.5584041.9667384.8067241.9775339.3568139.7567665.52
MP(2)96176.4082729.1382650.1489577.1775061.2274741.7681794.9476934.1676014.21
RCCSD95906.3182293.8082212.3389094.9374404.6874101.5880883.8075738.9474907.46
RCCSDT95681.8681912.2081836.5188859.8374239.3473953.8680482.2375420.5674629.95
Method\multicolumn{9}{c}{αdS\alpha_d^S values in a.u.}
DHF98.90104.92102.24127.03148.90139.42185.5291.2988.78
MP(2)RS^{RS}86.4993.1490.85106.46126.86120.02146.37771.3870.49
MP(3)RS^{RS}90.91104.88100.19113.17163.90145.56162.9476.3072.89
MP(2)BW^{BW}72.5636.6436.5586.2161.2961.09112.0449.5250.59
MP(3)BW^{BW}75.3130.3330.2090.1760.2059.41121.0949.9550.50
RPA93.2899.7897.27117.80139.15130.53168.3782.0780.17
RCCSD76.3332.0131.8792.0564.5363.32125.3752.4552.56

Table VII. Calculated energies (in cm−1^{-1}) and αdS\alpha_d^S values (in a.u.) of the clock states of Ca+^{+}, Sr+^{+}, and Ba+^{+} using the DHF and various many-body methods.

In Table VIII, we present the values of αdT\alpha_d^T and Θ\Theta obtained from DHF and various many-body methods. The overall correlation behavior is generally consistent with that observed for αdS\alpha_d^S. Owing to the inclusion of correlation effects in the energy values, the results from the BWBW scheme are more accurate than those from the RSRS perturbation scheme. Similar to the case of αdS\alpha_d^S, the lowest-order CP contribution reduces the magnitude of the tensor polarizability. However, in the RSRS scheme, the value of αdT\alpha_d^T increases when going from MP(2)RS^{RS} to MP(3)RS^{RS}, whereas in the BWBW scheme, the inclusion of PC effects produces the opposite trend, further decreasing the magnitude. Similar to the case of αdS\alpha_d^S, we find that the lowest-order CP effect reduces the Θ\Theta values. However, due to cancellations between lower-order and higher-order CP contributions, the RPA results remain much closer to DHF values than to those from MP(2)RS^{RS} or MP(2)BW^{BW}. Unlike αdS\alpha_d^S, where the correlation trends in RSRS and BWBW perturbation theories differ, in the case of Θ\Theta, both schemes show a consistent behavior; the inclusion of PC effects at the MP(3) level leads to a further reduction in the Θ\Theta values.

MethodCa+^{+} 3D3/2D_{3/2} αdT\alpha_d^TCa+^{+} 3D3/2D_{3/2} Θ\ThetaCa+^{+} 3D5/2D_{5/2} αdT\alpha_d^TCa+^{+} 3D5/2D_{5/2} Θ\ThetaSr+^{+} 4D3/2D_{3/2} αdT\alpha_d^TSr+^{+} 4D3/2D_{3/2} Θ\ThetaSr+^{+} 4D5/2D_{5/2} αdT\alpha_d^TSr+^{+} 4D5/2D_{5/2} Θ\ThetaBa+^{+} 5D3/2D_{3/2} αdT\alpha_d^TBa+^{+} 5D3/2D_{3/2} Θ\ThetaBa+^{+} 5D5/2D_{5/2} αdT\alpha_d^TBa+^{+} 5D5/2D_{5/2} Θ\Theta
DHF−66.391.712−90.682.451−93.832.469−118.323.559−45.502.733−58.633.994
MP(2)RS^{RS}−58.791.666−80.412.386−79.502.390−100.933.457−34.972.595−45.973.809
MP(3)RS^{RS}−70.271.152−93.041.653−112.121.916−130.322.780−40.082.153−48.843.185
MP(2)BW^{BW}−19.241.666−27.212.386−31.992.396−44.333.458−20.152.597−28.123.811
MP(3)BW^{BW}−16.291.265−22.891.814−33.032.008−44.722.908−20.882.249−28.223.315
RPA−63.151.687−86.292.416−87.712.426−110.873.501−41.222.640−53.433.874
RCCSD−17.051.288−23.991.846−35.722.038−48.022.948−22.452.278−30.143.353
RCCSDT-1.296-1.857-2.037-2.984-2.279-3.354

Table VIII. αdT\alpha_d^T and Θ\Theta values (both are in a.u.) of the metastable 2D3/2,5/2^{2}D_{3/2,5/2} states of Ca+^{+}, Sr+^{+}, and Ba+^{+} using the DHF and different many-body methods.

In order to illustrate how the value of Θ\Theta varies with the size of the basis functions, we present in Table IX the results obtained using the MP(3)RS^{RS} and MP(3)BW^{BW} methods. For this purpose, we have employed three different basis sets characterized by maximum angular quantum numbers lmax⁡=4l_{\max}=4, 6, and 9. As can be seen from Table IX, in the case of the RSRS scheme, the difference between the results obtained with lmax⁡=4l_{\max}=4 and lmax⁡=6l_{\max}=6 is about 2–3%, while the corresponding change between lmax⁡=6l_{\max}=6 and lmax⁡=9l_{\max}=9 reduces to only 0.4%. In contrast, for the BWBW scheme, the variations are even smaller; the difference between the MP(3)BW^{BW} results with lmax⁡=4l_{\max}=4 and lmax⁡=6l_{\max}=6 still exceeds 1%, but the change between lmax⁡=6l_{\max}=6 and lmax⁡=9l_{\max}=9 is less than 0.3%. This trend indicates that the basis with lmax⁡=6l_{\max}=6 already incorporates the dominant part of the correlation contributions. Taking into account both this observation and the practical limitations of our computational resources, we have therefore carried out the RCC calculations with lmax⁡=6l_{\max}=6. Nevertheless, in order to ensure that the contributions from higher angular momentum orbitals are not neglected, their contributions have been explicitly included in the manuscript as the +Basis correction, evaluated within the BWBW scheme, since this approach accounts for correlation effects rigorously in energies and matrix elements, in contrast to the RSRS scheme.

BasisCa+^{+} 3D3/23D_{3/2}Ca+^{+} 3D5/23D_{5/2}Sr+^{+} 4D3/24D_{3/2}Sr+^{+} 4D5/24D_{5/2}Ba+^{+} 5D3/25D_{3/2}Ba+^{+} 5D5/25D_{5/2}
lmax⁡=4l_{\max}=41.1861.7011.9612.8442.2033.256
lmax⁡=6l_{\max}=61.1521.6531.9162.7802.1533.185
lmax⁡=9l_{\max}=91.1471.6471.9092.7702.1443.171
MP(3)BW^{BW}, lmax⁡=4l_{\max}=41.2721.8452.0402.9542.2843.365
lmax⁡=6l_{\max}=61.2651.8142.0082.9082.2493.315
lmax⁡=9l_{\max}=91.2621.8102.0032.9012.2433.306

Table IX. Convergence of the MP(3)RS^{RS} and MP(3)BW^{BW} values for the estimated Θ\Theta (in a.u.) of the metastable states of Ca+^{+}, Sr+^{+}, and Ba+^{+} with different sizes of basis functions.

We present our calculated E2 and M1 matrix elements in Table X. For the E2 matrix elements, we observe a correlation trend similar to that found for the quadrupole moment Θ\Theta, which is expected. In this case as well, the PC effects are far more significant than the CP contributions, bringing the MP(3) results much closer to our recommended RCC values. As shown in Table X, the M1 transition amplitudes are significantly smaller in magnitude compared to the corresponding E2 transitions in all the considered ions. Interestingly, the two cases we consider, namely the S1/2−D3/2S_{1/2}-D_{3/2} and D3/2−D5/2D_{3/2}-D_{5/2} transitions, display distinct correlation trends. For the S1/2−D3/2S_{1/2}-D_{3/2} transition, both CP and PC effects increase the M1 amplitude relative to the DHF value, often by one or even two orders of magnitude, with the PC contribution being more prominent than the CP effect. By contrast, in the D3/2−D5/2D_{3/2}-D_{5/2} transition, a comparison between MP(2) and MP(3) results reveals an opposite interplay; while CP effects tend to reduce the M1 amplitude, the PC contributions act in the opposite direction and increase it. Despite these competing trends, there is strong cancellation among the different correlation effects, which results in only small net changes in the M1 amplitudes across the many-body methods.

Method\multicolumn{3}{c}{Ca+^+}\multicolumn{3}{c}{Sr+^+}\multicolumn{3}{c}{Ba+^+}
S1/2−D3/2S_{1/2}-D_{3/2}S1/2−D5/2S_{1/2}-D_{5/2}D3/2−D5/2D_{3/2}-D_{5/2}S1/2−D3/2S_{1/2}-D_{3/2}S1/2−D5/2S_{1/2}-D_{5/2}D3/2−D5/2D_{3/2}-D_{5/2}S1/2−D3/2S_{1/2}-D_{3/2}S1/2−D5/2S_{1/2}-D_{5/2}D3/2−D5/2D_{3/2}-D_{5/2}
\multicolumn{10}{c}{E2 amplitudes}
DHF9.76711.9785.01812.96915.9737.26114.76418.3858.092
MP(2)RS^{RS}9.60811.7844.88412.70015.6517.05214.30017.8447.712
MP(3)RS^{RS}7.4499.1503.38010.64813.1725.65411.93915.0116.423
MP(2)BW^{BW}9.60911.7854.88512.70115.6537.05314.30417.8487.717
MP(3)BW^{BW}7.8849.6793.71211.00113.5915.92112.41615.5636.698
RPA9.71211.9124.94512.85415.8417.14214.53918.1427.849
RCCSD7.9149.7163.77711.14213.7626.00512.66215.8506.777
RCCSDT7.9599.7703.80311.15913.7796.00812.70015.8906.797
\multicolumn{10}{c}{M1 amplitudes}
DHF−4.1[−7]-4.1[-7]1.5491.6[−6]1.6[-6]1.5495.5[−6]5.5[-6]1.549
MP(2)RS^{RS}3.8[−6]3.8[-6]1.5282.7[−5]2.7[-5]1.5281.5[−4]1.5[-4]1.520
MP(3)RS^{RS}9.9[−5]9.9[-5]1.5446.2[−5]6.2[-5]1.5453.3[−4]3.3[-4]1.544
MP(2)BW^{BW}3.8[−6]3.8[-6]1.5282.7[−5]2.7[-5]1.5281.4[−4]1.4[-4]1.520
MP(3)BW^{BW}9.9[−5]9.9[-5]1.5446.1[−5]6.1[-5]1.5443.3[−4]3.3[-4]1.542
RPA6.6[−6]6.6[-6]1.5494.1[−5]4.1[-5]1.5492.3[−4]2.3[-4]1.550
RCCSD3.5[−4]3.5[-4]1.5553.0[−5]3.0[-5]1.5533.1[−4]3.1[-4]1.554
RCCSDT3.5[−4]3.5[-4]1.5553.2[−5]3.2[-5]1.5533.2[−4]3.2[-4]1.554

Table X. Reduced E2 and M1 amplitudes (in a.u.) of the clock transitions in Ca+^+, Sr+^+, and Ba+^+ ions with various many-body methods. Numbers appearing as a[b]a[b] mean a×10ba \times10^b.

In Table XI, we present our results for the AhfA_{hf} and Bhf/QnB_{hf}/Q_n values. For AhfA_{hf} calculation, we have used gI=−0.376469g_I=-0.376469 for 43Ca^{43}\mathrm{Ca}, gI=−0.2430229g_I=-0.2430229 for 87Sr^{87}\mathrm{Sr}, and gI=0.6249g_I=0.6249 for 137Ba^{137}\mathrm{Ba} [10]. Similar to the E2 and M1 amplitudes, the differences between the RSRS and BWBW results for AhfA_{hf} and Bhf/QnB_{hf}/Q_n at a given perturbative level are found to be small. For the ground state, our analysis shows that both CP and PC effects contribute in the same direction, increasing the magnitude of AhfA_{hf} value. However, for D5/2D_{5/2}, AhfA_{hf} value is found to be very sensitive to correlation effects. As can be seen from the MP(2) results in Table XI, the CP effects contribute up to 600-1500% in D5/2D_{5/2} states. The D5/2D_{5/2} states also exhibit a striking sensitivity to PC effects, with contributions reaching as high as 200%. Furthermore, we observe that triple excitations contribute only marginally to AhfA_{hf} in the S1/2S_{1/2} and D3/2D_{3/2} states, but play a dominant role in the D5/2D_{5/2} states, where they account for more than 50% of the total value. This unusually large contribution also hints at non-negligible contributions from higher-order excitations, such as quadrupole excitations. Interestingly, the correlation behavior in Bhf/QnB_{hf}/Q_n is quite different. In this case, the sensitivity to correlation effects is far less pronounced. Contributions from CP, PC, and even triple excitations remain relatively small across all states, including the D5/2D_{5/2} levels. This contrast between AhfA_{hf} and Bhf/QnB_{hf}/Q_n demonstrates the property-dependent nature of correlation and emphasizes the need for a case-by-case treatment when evaluating the hyperfine structure constants.

References

References

  1. [1]N. L. Manakov, V. D. Ovsiannikov, and L. P. Rapoport, Atoms in a laser field, Phys. Rep. 141, 320 (1986).DOI
  2. [2]J. E. Stalnaker, D. Budker, S. J. Freedman, J. S. Guzman, S. M. Rochester, and V. V. Yashchuk, Dynamic Stark effect and forbidden-transition spectral line shapes, Phys. Rev. A 73, 043416 (2006).DOI
  3. [3]M. G. Kozlov and S. G. Porsev, Polarizabilities and hyperfine structure constants of the low-lying levels of barium, Eur. Phys. J. D 5, 59 (1999).DOI
  4. [4]I. Lindgren and J. Morrison, Atomic many-body theory, Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg (1986).
  5. [5]I. Shavitt, R. J. Bartlett, Many-body methods in chemistry and physics: MBPT and coupled-cluster theory, Cambridge University Press (2009).
  6. [6]A. Chakraborty and B. K. Sahoo, Deciphering core, valence, and double-core-polarization contributions to parity violating amplitudes in 133Cs using different many-body methods, J. Phys. Chem. A 127, 7518 (2023).DOI
  7. [7]A. Bohr and V.F. Weisskopf, The influence of nuclear structure on the hyperfine structure of heavy elements, Phys. Rev. 77, 94 (1950).DOI
  8. [8]V. M. Shabaev, M. Tomaselli, T. Kühl, A. N. Artemyev, and V. A. Yerokhin, Ground-state hyperfine splitting of high-Z hydrogenlike ions, Phys. Rev. A 56, 252 (1997).DOI
  9. [9]A. V. Volotka, D. A. Glazov, I. I. Tupitsyn, N. S. Oreshkina, G. Plunien, and V. M. Shabaev, Ground-state hyperfine structure of H-, Li-, and B-like ions in the intermediate-Z region, Phys. Rev. A 78, 062507 (2008).DOI
  10. [10]N. J. Stone, Table of nuclear magnetic dipole and electric quadrupole moments, At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 90, 75 (2005).

Paper details

vlnc:W_fub8ujfn
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents