betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The Fundamental Nature of Low-Energy Pion-Nucleon Interactions

Abstract

A historical review of pion-nucleon interactions at low energy is presented, with aims toward an introductory, pedagogic approach focusing on issues germane to current research. These topics include the use of chiral effective field theory, the sigma term, qualitative understanding of low-energy phase shifts, the physics of the ΔΔ resonance, and isospin violation. A theme is that low-energy pion-nucleon scattering is directly related to QCD via effective field theory. Another theme is that modern needs regarding the pion-nucleon sigma term and the study of isospin violation requires a better low-energy data set.

Introduction

The pion is the lightest of the strongly interacting particles, with a mass only about 1/7 of that of the nucleon. The large Compton wavelength of 1/mπ≈1.41/m_{\pi} \approx1.4 fm provides the longest-ranged contribution to the nucleon-nucleon interaction and is therefore an element of all models, from the ancient to the newest, of the nucleon-nucleon interaction. The one pion exchange potential is crucially responsible for the binding of nuclei [1, 2]. Moreover, the presence of the pion as a significant component of the nuclear wave function is reinforced by the dominance of the pion in meson exchange corrections to a variety of nuclear properties. This was discussed long ago [3, 4, 5] and recently [6]. Moreover, the pion cloud of the nucleon presents an important component of the nucleon sea by causing the asymmetry of the nucleon sea, dˉ>uˉ\bar{d} > \bar{u}, [7, 8] as verified by the SeaQuest experiment [9].

The smallness of the pion mass is a central feature of theories that describe low-energy hadron physics. Knowledge of the mass hints to an approximate symmetry of nature, chiral symmetry. A chiral transformation, in its simplest form, changes a fermion field-operator ψ\psi to γ5ψ\gamma_{5}\psi. The Lagrangians of QED and QCD are invariant under this transformation except for terms involving mass, mψˉψm\bar{\psi}\psi, and the small quark masses of QCD are related to the small value of the pion mass [10].

The remainder of this review is mainly concerned with describing the consequences of the small pion mass for pion nucleon scattering. Sect. II is concerned with the fundamental Lagrangian as expressed in both quark and hadronic degrees of freedom. Sect. III describes chiral symmetry breaking and the sigma term. The current importance of the sigma term and means to extract it are also described. Sect. IV describes the low-energy phase shifts. A pedagogic description of the Δ\Delta resonance is presented in Sect. V.

Isospin violation is described in Sect. VI. A brief summary appears in Sect. VII.

The Chiral Lagrangian and its Relation to QCD

The well-known QCD Lagrangian for the light up and down quark flavors is given by

L(x)=qˉ(x)γμ(i∂μ−gλa2Gμa)q(x)−qˉ(x)mqq(x)−14GaμνGμνa(1)\mathcal{L}(x)=\bar{q}(x)\gamma^{\mu}\left(i\partial_{\mu}-g\frac{\lambda^{a}}{2}G_{\mu}^{a}\right)q(x)-\bar{q}(x)m_{q}q(x)-\frac{1}{4}G^{a\mu\nu}G_{\mu\nu}^{a} \tag*{(1)}

where GμaG_{\mu}^{a} are the gluon-field operators, aa represents the color, qq are the quark-field operators (a column vector), λa\lambda^{a} are the eight matrices generating SU(3)colorSU(3)_{\mathrm{color}} and

mq=[mu00md](2)m_{q}=\begin{bmatrix}m_{u} & 0\\0 & m_{d}\end{bmatrix} \tag*{(2)}

is the quark-mass matrix. The masses in the Lagrangian are known as current quark masses. If md=mum_{d}=m_{u} the theory is invariant under isospin rotations:

q(x)→eia⋅τ/2q(x)(3)q(x)\rightarrow e^{i\boldsymbol{a}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}/2}q(x) \tag*{(3)}

where a\boldsymbol{a} is a constant vector. The relevant transformation that interchanges the uu and dd quarks is obtained with a=πy^\boldsymbol{a}=\pi\hat{y}, a rotation of π\pi about the yy-axis in isospin space, with the zz-axis associated with charge. This transformation is known as charge symmetry, a specific rotation in isospin space [11, 12]. In the further limit that the current quark masses vanish mu=md=0m_{u}=m_{d}=0 the right- and left-handed (1±γ5)q(1\pm\gamma_{5})q decouple and the theory is symmetric under two copies of isospin symmetry:

q(x)→eia⋅τ(1+γ5)/2q(x),q(x)→eia⋅τ(1−γ5)/2q(x).(4)q(x)\rightarrow e^{i\boldsymbol{a}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}(1+\gamma_{5})/2}q(x),\qquad q(x)\rightarrow e^{i\boldsymbol{a}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}(1-\gamma_{5})/2}q(x). \tag*{(4)}

These chiral transformations represent the global symmetry group SU(2)R×SU(2)L\mathrm{SU}(2)_{R}\times\mathrm{SU}(2)_{L}. The current quark masses are small enough so that QCD respects this symmetry to a good approximation.

The conserved Noether currents related to the transformations of Eq. (4) are the isospin currents:

Jμa(x)=qˉ(x)γμτa2q(x).(5)J_{\mu}^{a}(x)=\bar{q}(x)\gamma_{\mu}\frac{\tau^{a}}{2}q(x). \tag*{(5)}

and the axial currents

Aμa(x)=qˉ(x)γμγ5τa2q(x).(6)A_{\mu}^{a}(x)=\bar{q}(x)\gamma_{\mu}\gamma_{5}\frac{\tau^{a}}{2}q(x). \tag*{(6)}

The volume integral of A0aA_{0}^{a} is known as the axial charge QAaQ_{A}^{a}.

The elegant QCD Lagrangian is not immediately applicable to understanding low-energy pion-nucleon scattering because of the non-perturbative difficulties associated with strong interactions at low energies. However there is another long-standing technique: that of using effective Lagrangians that embody the physics of QCD. The parameters of the effective Lagrangian can sometimes be computed using lattice QCD techniques, and this aspect is discussed below.

Weinberg [13] wrote that quantum field theory has no content beyond analyticity, unitarity, cluster decomposition and symmetry. In particular, “if one writes the most general possible Lagrangian, including all terms consistent with assumed symmetry principles, and then computes matrix elements with this Lagrangian to any given order of perturbation theory, the result will be the most general SS-matrix consistent with analyticity, perturbative unitarity, cluster decomposition and the assumed symmetry principles.”.

This means that a properly constructed theory of pion-nucleon interactions contains, in principle, the same information content as QCD. Here the symmetries are isospin and chiral. Although approximate, using these should give a good guide to the correct results. Weinberg [14] illustrates the suggested procedure by considering a theory of massless pions, governed by a chiral SU(2)R×SU(2)L\mathrm{SU}(2)_{R}\times\mathrm{SU}(2)_{L} symmetry. The Lagrangian will be SU(2)R×SU(2)L\mathrm{SU}(2)_{R}\times\mathrm{SU}(2)_{L} invariant provided it conserves isospin and is constructed only from a chiral-covariant derivative of the pion field, which may be taken to be

Dμπ=∂μπ1+π2/4fπ2.(7)D_{\mu}\boldsymbol{\pi}=\frac{\partial_{\mu}\boldsymbol{\pi}}{1+\boldsymbol{\pi}^{2}/4f_{\pi}^{2}}. \tag*{(7)}

Then the most general such Lagrangian consists of an infinite series of operators:

L=∑n=1∞gn(Dμπ⋅Dμπ)n.(8)\mathcal{L}=\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}g_{n}(D_{\mu}\boldsymbol{\pi}\cdot D_{\mu}\boldsymbol{\pi})^{n}. \tag*{(8)}

When this Lagrangian is used to compute pionic SS-matrix elements it yields the most general matrix elements consistent with the stated general principles, provided that all terms of all orders in the coupling constants gng_n are included. Weinberg explains that using the effective Lagrangian allows a systematic way to calculate corrections to results of leading order. One may derive an expansion in powers of (small values) of momentum divided by a large mass scale.

The Lagrangian for pion-baryon interactions is more complicated. Displaying only the interaction terms to the first-and second-order in powers of the pion field, we use

Lint=−gA2fπψˉγμγ5τaψ ∂μπa−14fπ2ψˉγμτaψ ϵabcπb∂μπc−gπNΔ2M(Δˉμaψ ∂μπa+H.C.).(9)\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{int}}=-\frac{g_{A}}{2f_{\pi}}\bar{\psi}\gamma_{\mu}\gamma_{5}\tau^{a}\psi\,\partial_{\mu}\pi^{a}-\frac{1}{4f_{\pi}^{2}}\bar{\psi}\gamma_{\mu}\tau^{a}\psi\,\epsilon^{abc}\pi^{b}\partial_{\mu}\pi^{c} -\frac{g_{\pi N\Delta}}{2M}\left(\bar{\Delta}_{\mu}^{a}\psi\,\partial_{\mu}\pi^{a}+\mathrm{H.C.}\right). \tag*{(9)}

where ψ\psi is the nucleon Dirac field of the nucleon, πa\pi^{a} (a=1,2,3a=1,2,3) the chiral pion field and MM is the nucleon mass. In Eq. (9) gAg_A denotes the nucleon axial vector coupling and fπf_\pi the pion decay constant. The second term is the Weinberg-Tomozawa term which describes low-energy π\pi–nucleon scattering. In the third term gπNΔg_{\pi N\Delta} is the πNΔ\pi N\Delta coupling constant, and the Δμa\Delta_{\mu}^{a} field is a vector in both spin and isospin space. Notice that only derivatives of the pion field enter.

The meson factories LAMPF, SIN (now PSI) and TRIUMF began to operate in the 1970’s with a focus on pion-nucleon and pion-nucleus interactions with an earlier motivation involving the pion as a fundamental carrier of the strong interaction. The very close connection between the hadronic Lagrangians in use at the time and QCD was mainly not understood during the peak of the activities of the meson factories [15]. Thus opportunities for improved studies of the fundamental interaction involving better low-energy pion beams were not realized or perhaps not even dreamed about. We shall see that determination of the pion-nucleon sigma term would be greatly improved by better quality data.

The Lagrangian of Eq. (9) enjoys remarkable success when applied to compute pion-nucleon scattering amplitudes at threshold. Then terms involving spatial momenta drop out. A simple discussion is provided in the book by Ericson & Weise [16]. The only surviving term, expressed as a Hamiltonian density H\mathcal{H} is given by

H=14fπ2τ⋅(π×∂π∂t).(10)\mathcal{H}=\frac{1}{4f_{\pi}^{2}}\boldsymbol{\tau}\cdot\left(\boldsymbol{\pi}\times\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\pi}}{\partial t}\right). \tag*{(10)}

This interaction may be used to compute the isovector ss-wave pion-nucleon interaction. First take the matrix elements between in- and outgoing pion states to find

⟨πb∣τ⋅(π×∂π∂t)∣πb⟩=2imπϵabcτc.(11)\langle\pi_b|\boldsymbol{\tau}\cdot\left(\boldsymbol{\pi}\times\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\pi}}{\partial t}\right)|\pi_b\rangle= 2 i m_\pi\epsilon_{abc}\tau_c . \tag*{(11)}

This Hamiltonian density corresponds to a zero range (ss-wave) pion-nucleon potential, Vs(r)V_s(r) given by

Vs(r)=14fπ2τ⋅tδ(r),(12)V_s(r)=\frac{1}{4f_\pi^2}\boldsymbol{\tau}\cdot\mathbf{t}\delta(r) , \tag*{(12)}

where t\mathbf{t} is the pion isospin operator. Using the Born approximation the scattering length, aa is given by

a=−m~π∫d3rVs(r),(13)a=-\widetilde{m}_\pi\int d^3r V_s(r) , \tag*{(13)}

where m~π=mπ/(1+mπ/M)\widetilde{m}_\pi=m_\pi/(1+m_\pi/M) is the pion-nucleon reduced mass. The isospin operator operator τ⋅t\boldsymbol{\tau}\cdot\mathbf{t} evaluates to 1 for an πN\pi N isospin state 3/2 and −2-2 for an isospin state of 1/2. Thus the two scattering lengths a1,3a_{1,3} are given by

a1=m~π4πfπ2,a3=−m~π8πfπ2.(14)a_1=\frac{\widetilde{m}_\pi}{4\pi f_\pi^2},\qquad a_3=-\frac{\widetilde{m}_\pi}{8\pi f_\pi^2}. \tag*{(14)}

The scattering length can be expressed as

a=(a1+2a3)/3+(a3−a1)/3τ⋅t(15)a=(a_1+2a_3)/3+(a_3-a_1)/3\boldsymbol{\tau}\cdot\mathbf{t} \tag*{(15)}

so the isovector combination is

a1−a3=3m~π8πfπ2=0.234mπ−1(16)a_1-a_3=3\frac{\widetilde{m}_\pi}{8\pi f_\pi^2}=0.234m_\pi^{-1} \tag*{(16)}

and the isoscalar term is given by

a1+2a3=0.(17)a_1+2a_3=0 . \tag*{(17)}

A more complete analysis is necessary because the second Born approximation for the potential of Eq. (12) is divergent. This has been provided via the detailed chiral perturbation theory analyses [17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23] that [17] finds

a1−a3=0.264(15)mπ−1,(18)a_1-a_3=0.264(15)m_\pi^{-1}, \tag*{(18)}

while [16] reports

a1+2a3=−0.029(9)mπ−1.(19)a_1+2a_3=-0.029(9)m_\pi^{-1}. \tag*{(19)}

The large magnitude of the isospin-dependent term and the small magnitude of the isospin-independent term of the scattering length, aa, are a striking success of the simple Lagrangian. It has been argued [24, 25], in the spirit of an expansion in the pion mass, that it is the pion mass, instead of the reduced pion mass, that should appear in the above equations. In that case the agreement between the simple estimate Eq. (16) and empirical extraction Eq. (18) would be perfect.

Chiral Symmetry Breaking and the Sigma Term

The quark mass term of Eq. (1) is not invariant under the transformations of Eq. (4). It may be put in the form [14]:

Lmass=−(mu+md)V4−(mu−md)A3,(20)\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{mass}}=-(m_u+m_d)V_4-(m_u-m_d)A_3 , \tag*{(20)}

where

V4=12(uˉu+dˉd),A3=12(uˉu−dˉd).(21)V_4=\frac{1}{2}(\bar{u}u+\bar{d}d),\qquad A_3=\frac{1}{2}(\bar{u}u-\bar{d}d). \tag*{(21)}

The operators V4V_4 and A3A_3 are spatial scalars and components of independent chiral four vectors VαV_\alpha and AαA_\alpha. Following Weinberg, terms must be added to the effective chiral Lagrangian with the same transformation properties. The aim is to construct chiral symmetry breaking terms without derivatives of the pion field. Using only the pion field, there is no Lagrangian term in A3A_3 and only one term in V4V_4. This is the pion mass term

V4(mπ)=−mπ2π22(1+π2/(4fπ2)).(22)V_4(m_\pi)=-\frac{m_\pi^2\boldsymbol{\pi}^2}{2(1+\boldsymbol{\pi}^2/(4f_\pi^2))}. \tag*{(22)}

Using pion fields and a nucleon bi-linear (with no derivatives) and assuming the isospin limit of mu=mdm_u=m_d one finds a term

δLint=−A2(1−π2/4fπ21+π2/4fπ2)ψˉψ,(23)\delta\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{int}}=-\frac{A}{2}\left(\frac{1-\boldsymbol{\pi}^2/4f_\pi^2}{1+\boldsymbol{\pi}^2/4f_\pi^2}\right)\bar{\psi}\psi, \tag*{(23)}

where AA is a constant proportional to mu+mdm_u+m_d and ψ\psi is the nucleon doublet. This term gives a contribution to the isoscalar scattering length (the first term of Eq. (15)):

a1+2a33=A2fπ2.(24)\frac{a_1+2a_3}{3}=\frac{A}{2f_\pi^2}. \tag*{(24)}

The term AA is the sigma term, σπN\sigma_{\pi N}, which has recently emerged as a quantity related to many aspects of physics, such as the origin of the mass of ordinary matter, studies of dark matter, nuclear binding and nucleosynthesis. The plan here is to first consider the relation of σπN\sigma_{\pi N} to pion-nucleon scattering and then discuss its significance. My discussion parallels that of the recent review by Alarcón [26].

Consider the pion-nucleon scattering process:

πa(q)N(p)→πb(q′)N(p′).(25)\pi^a(q)N(p)\rightarrow\pi^b(q')N(p'). \tag*{(25)}

where aa (bb) are the isospin indices of the initial (final) pion of momentum qq (q′q'), and pp (p′p') are the momentum of the initial (final) nucleon. The off-shell scattering amplitude for pions of squared four-momentum q2q^2 and q′2q'^2, TT, is given by [27]

Tba(ν,t,q2,q′2)K(q,q′)=∫d4x⟨N(p′)∣qμqγT(Abμ(x)∂γAaγ(0))+iqμ′δ(x0)[Abμ(x),∂γAaγ(0)]∣N(p)⟩e−iq′⋅x−∫d4x⟨N(p′)∣δ(x0)[Ab0(x),Aaγ(0)]∣N(p)⟩eiq′⋅x.(26)\frac{T^{ba}(\nu,t,q^{2},q'^{2})}{K(q,q')} = \int d^{4}x\langle N(p')|q_{\mu}q_{\gamma}T\left(A^{b\mu}(x)\partial_{\gamma}A^{a\gamma}(0)\right)+iq'_{\mu}\delta(x_{0})[A^{b\mu}(x),\partial_{\gamma}A^{a\gamma}(0)]|N(p)\rangle e^{-iq'\cdot x} -\int d^{4}x\langle N(p')|\delta(x_{0})[A^{b0}(x),A^{a\gamma}(0)]|N(p)\rangle e^{iq'\cdot x}. \tag*{(26)}

where K(q,q′)≡i(q2−mπ2)(q′2−mπ2)mπ4fπ2K(q,q')\equiv i\frac{(q^{2}-m_{\pi}^{2})(q'^{2}-m_{\pi}^{2})}{m_{\pi}^{4}f_{\pi}^{2}}, ν=s−u4M\nu=\frac{s-u}{4M}, with MM the nucleon mass, AaμA^{a\mu} the axial current, fπf_{\pi} the weak decay constant of the pion and mπm_{\pi} the pion mass. The last term is not determined by the commutation relations provided by current algebra, but instead is isolated by taking the so-called “soft-meson limit” qμ′,qν→0q'_{\mu},q_{\nu}\to0. Then, using Eq. (26) and ∂νAaν=−i[Q5a,H]\partial_{\nu}A^{a\nu}=-i[Q_{5}^{a},\mathcal{H}] yields

Tba(0,0,0,0)=−1fπ2⟨N(p′)∣[QAb(0),[QAa(0),H(0)]]∣N(p)⟩(27)T^{ba}(0,0,0,0)=-\frac{1}{f_{\pi}^{2}}\langle N(p')|[Q_{A}^{b}(0),[Q_{A}^{a}(0),\mathcal{H}(0)]]|N(p)\rangle \tag*{(27)}

where QAiQ_{A}^{i} are the axial charges and H\mathcal{H} is the Hamiltonian density. Only terms that break chiral symmetry enter in its commutator with the axial charges. The double commutator of the last matrix element of Eq. (27) is the πN\pi N sigma commutator, σπN\sigma_{\pi N}. The Jacobi identity tells us that the sigma commutator is symmetric in the isospin indices and, therefore, contributes only to the isoscalar part of the scattering amplitude. The mass matrix mqm_{q} of Eq. (2) provides the part of H\mathcal{H} that does not commute with the axial charge and yields

σπN=mˉ2M⟨N(p)∣uˉu+dˉd∣N(p)⟩,(28)\sigma_{\pi N}=\frac{\bar m}{2M}\langle N(p)|\bar u u+\bar d d|N(p)\rangle, \tag*{(28)}

where mˉ≡mu+md2\bar m\equiv\frac{m_{u}+m_{d}}{2}, usually called the pion-nucleon sigma term. The factor 2M2M in the denominator arises from the covariant normalization ⟨N(p′)∣N(p)⟩=(2π)32Eδ(p⃗′−p⃗)\langle N(p')|N(p)\rangle=(2\pi)^{3}2E\delta(\vec p'-\vec p), used here. Note also that mˉ\bar m arises because here we use md=mum_{d}=m_{u}.

The sigma term appears in many areas of modern physics as explained below. First it is necessary to understand its rather indirect relation to scattering. The amplitude of Eq. (27) is not evaluated at measurable kinematics, so one needs to find a way to connect the experimental data to Tba(0,0,0,0)T^{ba}(0,0,0,0). Ref. [28] showed that one can expand the amplitude in q2q^{2} and q′2q'^{2} to relate the physical amplitude to its soft limit. One invokes the Adler consistency conditions [29] and evaluates the amplitude at (ν=0,t=2mπ2)(\nu=0,t=2m_{\pi}^{2}) to cancel the leading correction in q2q^{2} and q′2q'^{2}, and relate the physical amplitude to Tba(0,0,0,0)T^{ba}(0,0,0,0) plus a remainder. This kinematical point is called the Cheng-Dashen point (with ν=0\nu=0, s=mN2s=m_{N}^{2}, t=2mπ2t=2m_{\pi}^{2}) and lies in the unphysical (subthreshold) region of πN\pi N scattering. The ability to extract the amplitudes depends on having very high quality scattering data at low energies and a very precise method of handling the effects of the Coulomb interaction. The date begins for pion kinetic energies of about only 30 MeV. Moreover, there is no unique way to split the interaction into strong and electromagnetic parts [30], so in general models must be used.

Cheng and Dashen, assumed that the remainder was of order mπ4m_{\pi}^{4}, but Brown, Pardee and Peccei showed that there were non-analytic contributions that made this relation valid only up to order mπ2m_{\pi}^{2} [31]. They presented a widely-used modified form of the Cheng-Dashen theorem valid up to O(mπ4)\mathcal{O}(m_{\pi}^{4}). To be more specific, one writes the πN\pi N scattering amplitude in terms of the four Lorentz invariant amplitudes A±A^{\pm}, B±B^{\pm},

Tba=δbaT++12[τb,τa]T−(29)T^{ba}=\delta^{ba}T^{+}+\frac{1}{2}[\tau^{b},\tau^{a}]T^{-} \tag*{(29)}
T±=uˉ′[A±+12(q′+q)B±]u(30)T^{\pm}=\bar u'\left[A^{\pm}+\frac{1}{2}(q'+q)B^{\pm}\right]u \tag*{(30)}

where T±T^{\pm} are the isoscalar and isovector parts of the amplitude. The combination D±=A±+νB±D^{\pm}=A^{\pm}+\nu B^{\pm} is amenable to a detailed analysis. The original result by Cheng and Dashen states that ΣπN≡fπ2Dˉ+(ν=0,t=2mπ2)\Sigma_{\pi N}\equiv f_{\pi}^{2}\bar D^{+}(\nu=0,t=2m_{\pi}^{2}) and σπN\sigma_{\pi N} are equal up to order mπ2m_{\pi}^{2}, with Dˉ+\bar D^{+} the Born-subtracted part of the amplitude. In Ref. [31] this theorem was recast as follows

ΣπN=fπ2Dˉ+(ν=0,t=2mπ2)=σ(t=2mπ2)+ΔR,(31)\Sigma_{\pi N}=f_{\pi}^{2}\bar D^{+}(\nu=0,t=2m_{\pi}^{2}) =\sigma(t=2m_{\pi}^{2})+\Delta_{R}, \tag*{(31)}

where

σ(t)=12M⟨N(p′)∣mˉ(uˉu+dˉd)∣N(p)⟩.(32)\sigma(t)=\frac{1}{2M}\langle N(p')|\bar m(\bar u u+\bar d d)|N(p)\rangle. \tag*{(32)}

This expression is useful because ΔR\Delta_{R} is of order mπ4m_{\pi}^{4} and small (ΔR≃2\Delta_{R}\simeq2 MeV [32]), and the scalar form factor of the nucleon at t=2mπ2t=2m_{\pi}^{2}, σ(t=2mπ2)\sigma(t=2m_{\pi}^{2}), can be related to the sigma term though dispersion relations or other methods, because σ(t=0)=σπN\sigma(t=0)=\sigma_{\pi N}. The latter was first calculated in Ref. [33].

Why is the sigma term important?

This sub-section presents a brief discussion explaining the current importance of the sigma term.

Origin of the mass of ordinary matter

Recently there has been an increasing effort to understand the the proton (or nucleon) mass in terms of QCD, see e.g. [34, 35, 36, 37, 38]. The usual strategy to analyze its decomposition is to consider that the energy-momentum tensor of QCD can be related to the mass of a hadron (in this case the nucleon) in the following way:

M=12M⟨N(p)∣T μμ∣N(p)⟩(33)M = \frac{1}{2M}\langle N(p)|T^\mu_{\ \mu}|N(p)\rangle \tag*{(33)}

where T μμT^\mu_{\ \mu} is the trace of the energy momentum tensor. This trace, in its renormalized form, is given by [39, 40, 41, 42]:

M=12M⟨N(p)|β(αs)4αsGμνaGaμν+∑q=u,d,sγmqmqqˉq|N(p)⟩+12M⟨N(p)|∑qmqqˉq|N(p)⟩(34)M = \frac{1}{2M}\left\langle N(p)\middle|\frac{\beta(\alpha_s)}{4\alpha_s}G^a_{\mu\nu}G^{a\mu\nu}+\sum_{q=u,d,s}\gamma_{m_q}m_q\bar{q}q\middle|N(p)\right\rangle+\frac{1}{2M}\left\langle N(p)\middle|\sum_q m_q\bar{q}q\middle|N(p)\right\rangle \tag*{(34)}

where αs\alpha_s is the strong coupling constant, β(αs)\beta(\alpha_s) its beta function, mqm_q is the mass of the quark qq and γmq\gamma_{m_q} the anomalous dimension of the mass operator. In the limit in which strange quarks are neglected, the last term in (34) is σπN\sigma_{\pi N}. This term is renormalization scheme and scale independent, and can be interpreted as the light quark mass contribution to the nucleon mass. This term arises from the Higgs boson couplings to quarks, so that its accurate determination would tell us the amount of ordinary matter mass that is generated though this mechanism and how much is dynamically generated. Other mass decompositions include [34, 35, 36, 37, 38], but all contain the quark-mass term.

Dark matter detection

The main recent interest in the precise value of σπN\sigma_{\pi N} arises from its role in for detecting scalar dark matter. If one assumes that dark matter is a scalar, an effective Lagrangian that couples dark matter (χ\chi) to quarks (qq) is given by:

Lχq=CmqΛ3χˉχqˉq(35)\mathcal{L}_{\chi q}=C\frac{m_q}{\Lambda^3}\bar{\chi}\chi\bar{q}q \tag*{(35)}

where CC is a Wilson coefficient containing information regarding energy scales higher than the cutoff Λ\Lambda. This effective Lagrangian leads to a χ\chi–nucleon and consequently a χ\chi–nuclear cross section [43] that is proportional to the square of σπN\sigma_{\pi N} (if uu and dd quarks are sufficient) so that uncertainties in σπN\sigma_{\pi N} are magnified in dark matter searches [44, 45]. These authors stressed the vital importance of an experimental campaign to determine a better value of σπN\sigma_{\pi N}.

It is noteworthy that Ref. [46] showed how to avoid unnecessary and uncontrolled assumptions usually made in the literature about soft SU(3) flavor symmetry breaking in determining the two-flavor nucleon matrix elements relevant for direct detection of weakly interacting massive particles (WIMPs). This work was the first to allow for an accurate assessment of hadronic uncertainties in spin-independent WIMP-nucleon scattering and for a reliable calculation of isospin-violating effects.

Nuclear binding and Nucleosynthesis

The σ\sigma-model Lagrangian [31, 47, 48] contains a term that violates chiral symmetry of the form (mπ2−mπ2)/(2M)gσ⋅π(m_\pi^2-m_\pi^2)/(2M)g\sigma\cdot\pi, where σ\sigma represents the field of a scalar-isoscalar interaction and gg is the pion-nucleon coupling constant. This terms yields a contribution to T+T^+ of Eq. (29) and therefore to σπN\sigma_{\pi N}. The σ\sigma-model when enhanced by the inclusion of vector mesons incorporates the dynamics necessary to bind nuclei: long- and medium-ranged attractive forces and short-ranged repulsive forces.

More generally, the pion-nucleon sigma term is related to the strength of the πN\pi N interaction with scalar-isoscalar quantum numbers. This part of the interaction plays a prominent role in alpha-like particle clustering [49]. Understanding this process becomes essential in order to explain the observed 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} abundance, which is possible only though to the formation of a 0+0^+ resonance near the 4He+8Be{}^{4}\mathrm{He}+{}^{8}\mathrm{Be} threshold (the Hoyle state). This state is important for nucleosynthesis.

Nuclear thermodynamics

The matrix element of QCD related to the sigma term also provides valuable information about the properties of nuclear matter. When one studies the restoration of chiral symmetry in nuclear matter, one of the quantities used as order parameter in the phase transition is the chiral condensate in the nuclear medium, ⟨Ψˉ∣qq∣Ψ⟩\langle\bar{\Psi}|q q|\Psi\rangle, where ∣Ψ⟩|\Psi\rangle is the nuclear ground state [50]. Applying the Hellmann-Feynman theorem, for nuclear matter of Fermi momentum kFk_F, to the Hamiltonian density of QCD one finds [51]

⟨Ψ∣qˉq∣Ψ⟩⟨0∣qˉq∣0⟩(ρ)=1−ρfπ2{σπNmπ2(1−3kf210mN2+9kf456mN4)+∂E(ρ)/A∂mπ2}(36)\frac{\langle\Psi|\bar{q}q|\Psi\rangle}{\langle0|\bar{q}q|0\rangle}(\rho)=1-\frac{\rho}{f_{\pi}^{2}}\left\{\frac{\sigma_{\pi N}}{m_{\pi}^{2}}\left(1-\frac{3k_{f}^{2}}{10m_{N}^{2}}+\frac{9k_{f}^{4}}{56m_{N}^{4}}\right)+\frac{\partial E(\rho)/A}{\partial m_{\pi}^{2}}\right\} \tag*{(36)}

where ⟨0∣qˉq∣0⟩\langle0|\bar{q}q|0\rangle is the quark condensate in the vacuum, and EE is the energy of nuclear matter. This means that the sigma term is important for determining the density for the transition to a chiral symmetric regime in which ⟨Ψ∣qˉq∣Ψ⟩=0\langle\Psi|\bar{q}q|\Psi\rangle=0. Increasing the value of σπN\sigma_{\pi N} reduces the value of the transition density. However, the interaction terms ∂E(ρ)/A∂mπ2\frac{\partial E(\rho)/A}{\partial m_{\pi}^{2}} are very important [51].

without a need for a huge value of σs\sigma_s. Therefore the above analysis is seems dated.

The strangeness content of the nucleon, related to σs\sigma_s has also been postulated to reduce the proton spin below the value obtained in simple quark models, and therefore play a role in the proton spin crisis; see the reviews [75, 76].

Strangeness content of the nucleon

The quantity ⟨N∣mssˉs∣N⟩≡2Mσs\langle N|m_s\bar{s}s|N\rangle\equiv2M\sigma_s is related to the contribution of the strange quark to the nucleon mass. This matrix element has been related to σπN\sigma_{\pi N} though group-theoretical arguments as follows. Consider the extended mass term of the QCD Hamiltonian:

Hm=13(ms+2mˉ)(uˉu+dˉd+sˉs)+13(mˉ−ms)(uˉu+dˉd−2sˉs).(37)\mathcal{H}_m=\frac{1}{3}(m_s+2\bar{m})(\bar{u}u+\bar{d}d+\bar{s}s) +\frac{1}{3}(\bar{m}-m_s)(\bar{u}u+\bar{d}d-2\bar{s}s). \tag*{(37)}

The second term can be related to the mass splitting of the strange and non-strange baryons at leading order in the SU(3)SU(3)-breaking parameter ms−mˉm_s-\bar{m}, using octet mass-splitting [52, 53]:

σ0≡mˉ2M⟨N∣(uˉu+dˉd−2sˉs)∣N⟩=mˉms−mˉ(mΞ+mΣ−2M).(38)\sigma_0\equiv\frac{\bar{m}}{2M}\langle N|(\bar{u}u+\bar{d}d-2\bar{s}s)|N\rangle =\frac{\bar{m}}{m_s-\bar{m}}(m_{\Xi}+m_{\Sigma}-2M). \tag*{(38)}

The relation of σ0\sigma_0 with the octet baryon mass splitting provides an estimate of σs\sigma_s, assuming a known value of σπN\sigma_{\pi N}:

σs=ms2mˉ(σπN−σ0)(39)\sigma_s=\frac{m_s}{2\bar{m}}(\sigma_{\pi N}-\sigma_0) \tag*{(39)}

Assuming ⟨N∣sˉs∣N⟩=0\langle N|\bar{s}s|N\rangle=0 (Zweig rule), the value of σπN\sigma_{\pi N} should be well approximated by σ0\sigma_0 [54]. Then using the present day-values of neutral baryon masses and the current quark ratio [55]: ms/2mˉ≈27m_s/2\bar{m}\approx27, then σπN\sigma_{\pi N} should be around 24 MeV. Estimates of the SU(3)SU(3)-breaking effects increase this value to about 35 MeV [56]. If one allows for a non-zero value of σs\sigma_s, then one finds σπN≈0.073σs+35\sigma_{\pi N}\approx0.073\sigma_s+35 MeV. Then using a typical value of σπN≈60\sigma_{\pi N}\approx60 MeV one obtains σs≈350\sigma_s\approx350 MeV, a huge value. In contrast, lattice QCD calculations give results for σs\sigma_s between 30 and 50 MeV [58, 59, 60, 61, 62]. Recent developments, discussed in the next section show that σπN\sigma_{\pi N} can be about 60 MeV

B Methods to determine the sigma term

In this section I briefly discuss some of the different approaches and strategies that have been used to determine the sigma term. The problem in using experimental measurements is in relating T(0,0,0,0)T(0,0,0,0) to measurable kinematics in which q2=q0′2=mπ2q^{2}=q_{0}^{\prime2}=m_{\pi}^{2}.

The earliest attempts used the simple assumption, explained above that using (38) with σs=0\sigma_s=0 gives σπN≈35\sigma_{\pi N}\approx35 MeV. The second is the use of dispersion relations that allow a continuation from πN\pi N scattering data to the Cheng-Dashen point See the review [26] and the original works [32, 57, 63, 64, 65]. Sum rules can also be used to express Σ\Sigma in terms of pion nucleon threshold parameters [66, 67, 68].

Another method is the use of chiral perturbation theory. As a systematic way to determine QCD Green’s functions [69], chiral EFT is widely used to study strong interactions at low energies. Chiral EFT is constructed to systematically provide corrections to the low-energy theorems of QCD, so it is a natural tool to calculate the pion-nucleon sigma term. One writes a Lagrangian that complies with chiral symmetry, with unknown short-distance, high-momentum transfer effects modeled by the use of low energy constants that are determined by data. Then explicit chiral symmetry breaking is provided by including a term of the form

LπN(2)⊃c1⟨χ+⟩ψˉψ(40)\mathcal{L}_{\pi N}^{(2)}\supset c_1\langle\chi_{+}\rangle\bar{\psi}\psi \tag*{(40)}

where ψ\psi refers to the nucleon isodoublet, and ⟨χ+⟩\langle\chi_{+}\rangle is a trace in the isospin space of a matrix involving even powers of the pion field and quark masses (see Ref. [70] for more details). The value of c1c_1 is determined by using the Lagrangian to compute πN\pi N phase shifts fits to data, and accurate results for c1c_1 are obtained only if all of the low energy constants can be determined.

Lattice QCD is well-known to allows direct, non-perturbative numerical calculations using the QCD Lagrangian, a numerical method to compute QCD Green functions. Two different strategies have been used. The first one is to calculate the sigma term through the Hellmann-Feynman theorem. For that, one needs the quark mass dependence of the nucleon mass. Another approach is to calculate the sigma term as the scalar form factor of the nucleon at q2=0q^{2}=0 [59, 60, 71, 72, 73] [74].

Ref. [77] used pionic πH\pi H atom data to estimate the sigma term. The strategy of this approach is to relate the observed modification of the isovector scattering length a0+−≡(a1−a3)/3a_{0+}^{-} \equiv(a_{1}-a_{3})/3 in pionic atoms to σπN\sigma_{\pi N}. They construct the relation from the leading order chiral result for a0+−a_{0+}^{-} in vacuum, given by the Weinberg-Tomozawa term

a0+−=−MπmN8π(mN+Mπ)fπ2(41)a_{0+}^{-}=-\frac{M_{\pi}m_{N}}{8\pi(m_{N}+M_{\pi})f_{\pi}^{2}} \tag*{(41)}

One obtains the in-medium modification of a0+−a_{0+}^{-} by noting that the ratio of condensates appearing in Eq. (36) is equal to (following [10]) the ratio fπ2(ρ)fπ2\frac{f_{\pi}^{2}(\rho)}{f_{\pi}^{2}} then

fπ2(ρ)fπ2=⟨Ψ∣qˉq∣Ψ⟩⟨0∣qˉq∣0⟩(ρ)≈1−ρσπNfπ2Mπ2(42)\frac{f_{\pi}^{2}(\rho)}{f_{\pi}^{2}}=\frac{\langle\Psi|\bar{q}q|\Psi\rangle}{\langle0|\bar{q}q|0\rangle}(\rho)\approx1-\rho\frac{\sigma_{\pi N}}{f_{\pi}^{2}M_{\pi}^{2}} \tag*{(42)}

which modifies the free scattering length to

a^0+−=a0+−(1−ρσπNfπ2Mπ2)−1(43)\hat{a}_{0+}^{-}=a_{0+}^{-}\left(1-\rho\frac{\sigma_{\pi N}}{f_{\pi}^{2}M_{\pi}^{2}}\right)^{-1} \tag*{(43)}

where a^0+−\hat{a}_{0+}^{-} refers to the in-medium value of a0+−a_{0+}^{-}. For details see [77]. This method is based on the medium modification of the dominant isovector s-wave term. But the medium modification also modifies the nuclear isoscalar s-wave term that is much larger than predicted by the impulse approximation [78–81] of the pion nucleus optical potential related to the isoscalar s-wave term.

Determining the sigma term

Alarcon [26] presented a detailed discussion of the lengthy history of determinations and the great variation of the results. The latest results are tabulated in the 2021 FLAG review [82]. We present their results in Figure 1.

Lattice results and FLAG averages for the nucleon sigma term

Figure 1. Lattice results and FLAG averages for the nucleon sigma term, σπN\sigma_{\pi N}, for the Nf=2N_f=2, 2+12+1, and 2+1+12+1+1 flavor calculations. Determinations via the direct approach are indicated by squares and the Feynman-Hellmann method by triangles. Results from calculations which analyze more than one lattice data set within the Feynman-Hellmann approach [83–92], are shown for comparison (pentagons) along with those from recent analyses of πN\pi N scattering [65] [93, 94, 120] (circles). The results that pass the FLAG criteria are shown in green, and are reasonably consistent.

FLAG presents its results as Nf=2+1+1N_f=2+1+1: σπN=64.9(1.5)(13.2)\sigma_{\pi N}=64.9(1.5)(13.2) MeV, a result that is larger than for the case of Nf=2+1N_f=2+1 of 37(8)(6)37(8)(6) MeV. The meaning of 2+1+12+1+1 is that mu=md<ms<mcm_u=m_d<m_s<m_c.

latter value is believed to be more reliable because of the smaller error bar. A weighted average of the two results would greatly favor the more precise latter value. The FLAG review cite a tension with the result of [65] of σπN=(59.1±3.5)\sigma_{\pi N}=(59.1\pm3.5) MeV of about three or four standard deviations. A significant source of uncertainty in lattice calculations is contamination due to excited states. A recent calculation [96] forces the first excited state to be that of a nucleon-pion pp-wave energy. This procedure results in a sigma term of σπN=(59.6±7.4)\sigma_{\pi N}=(59.6\pm7.4) MeV consistent with phenomenology. Ref. [96] also states that further calculations are needed to confirm their result and finally resolve the tension between lattice QCD and phenomenology. I also note that pionic atom data are used in [65] and there is possibly an additional uncertainty due to medium effects that are not included in the analyses.

The strangeness sigma term [82] is presented in Figure 2. The result for Nf=2+1+1N_f=2+1+1 is σs=41.0(8.8)\sigma_s=41.0(8.8) MeV, and for Nf=2+1N_f=2+1, σs=52.9(7.0)\sigma_s=52.9(7.0) MeV. There is no need for a very large value of σs\sigma_s.

Lattice results and FLAG averages for $\sigma_s$

Figure 2. Lattice results and FLAG averages for σs\sigma_s for the Nf=2N_f = 2, 2+12+1, and 2+1+12+1+1 flavor calculations. Determinations via the direct approach are indicated by squares and the Feynman-Hellmann method by triangles. Results from calculations which analyze more than one lattice data set within the Feynman-Hellmann approach [85, 86, 88, 89, 92], are shown for comparison (pentagons) (circles). he results that pass the FLAG criteria are shown in green, and are reasonably consistent.

Momentum dependence of the low-energy π−N\pi-N phase shifts

A nice discussion of these phase shifts is presented in the book [16]. This is updated here based on more recent data from the SAID data base using the WI08 fit [97] which is an update of that of [98].

For ss-wave scattering the isospin 1/21/2 phase shifts are designated as S11S_{11}, while those of isospin 3/23/2 are termed S33S_{33}. These are shown in Figure 3. The range of pion lab momenta is from 0 to 350 MeV/c which corresponds to a range in lab kinetic energy from 0 to 240 MeV, and cm momenta, c from 0 to 260 MeV/c.

Figure 3. S11S_{11} and S33S_{33} phase shifts as a function of the cm momentum of the pion beam, qq. The points are from the single-energy fits and the curves are energy dependent fits. The data are from the SAID data base, SAID and are from the WI08 fit [97], an update of that of [98].

These phase shifts of small magnitude are approximately linear in the cm momentum q=M/sQLq=M/\sqrt{s_{QL}} for this values of qq up to about qcmq_{\rm cm} of about 100 MeV/c. There δ(S11)≈4.9×10−2q/(MeV/c)deg\delta(S_{11})\approx4.9\times10^{-2}q/(\mathrm{MeV}/c)\mathrm{deg} and δ(S31)≈−2.9×10−2q/(MeV/c)deg\delta(S_{31})\approx-2.9\times10^{-2}q/(\mathrm{MeV}/c)\mathrm{deg}. The combination δ(S11)+2δ(S31)\delta(S_{11})+2\delta(S_{31}) nearly vanishes, consistent with early chiral perturbation theory. Effective range corrections must be included to describe the phase shifts for momenta greater than about 90 MeV/c. Detailed chiral perturbation theory calculations are

presented in Refs. [17, 18, 19, 21, 22, 23]. These have been updated in Refs. [99–101, 103? ].

The pp-wave phase shifts are designated P2I,2JP_{2I,2J}. The P33P_{33} and P11P_{11} phase shifts are shown in Figure 4. They are proportional to q3q^3 near threshold. The P33P_{33} channel is clearly dominant, with the phase shift rising rapidly to 90∘90^\circ at q≈292q\approx292 MeV/c, the position of the Δ\Delta resonance. The P11P_{11} phase shift is small at the low energies of relevance here. At low energies it is negative and crosses 0 at about q=195q=195 MeV/c and rises at higher energies, reflecting the broad N∗(1440)N^*(1440) resonance.

P33 and P11 phase shifts as a function of the cm momentum of the pion

Figure 4. P33P_{33} and P11P_{11} phase shifts as a function of the cm momentum of the pion, qq. The points are from the single-energy fits and the curves are energy dependent fits. The data are from the SAID data base, SAID and are from the WI08 fit [97], an update of that of [98].

The P33P_{33}, P13P_{13} and P31P_{31} phase shifts are shown in Figure 5. The other phase shifts remain small in the low-energy range of interest.

P33 and P11 phase shifts as a function of the cm momentum of the pion

Figure 5. P33P_{33} and P11P_{11} phase shifts as a function of the cm momentum of the pion, qq. The points are from the single-energy fits and the curves are energy dependent fits. The data are from the SAID data base, SAID and are from the WI08 fit [97], an update of that of [98].

The most detailed treatment of low-energy phase shifts is to be found in Refs. [99–103]. These authors found that much higher precision (and accuracy) can be achieved by combining dispersion relations with the experimental input that is available (either at threshold from scattering lengths or at higher energies from phase-shift analyses). The low-energy data set for πN\pi N scattering is scarce. So Ref. [100] summarizes that one can do much better by combining theory input in the form of Roy-Steiner equations, experiment for the scattering lengths from pionic atoms, and the phase-shift analyses only for the high-energy input.

The figures in this section seem to indicate that the data set is in good shape. However, as pointed out in Sect. III, improved knowledge of σπN\sigma_{\pi N} requires better data. Section VI below also points out that understanding of isospin violation requires better low-energy data. The Muon Scattering Experiment (MUSE) [104–106] intends to obtain a better determination of the proton radius, and more generally test lepton-universality by comparing μ±p\mu^\pm p with e±pe^\pm p scattering. Pion-nucleon scattering is an important background so the collaboration plans to measure π±\pi^\pm-nucleon cross sections at beam momenta of about 115, 160, and 210 MeV/c. The angular range is 20 - 100 degrees in the lab. These measurements would greatly improve the data base.

Analysis of the Δ33\Delta_{33} resonance

The Δ33\Delta_{33} resonance (or Δ\Delta) is the simplest of all resonances. Nevertheless it has some interesting complications caused by the need to include the crossed nucleon Born graph and the effects of renormalizing the Δ\Delta mass caused by the need to maintain unitarity. The aim here is to present a simple discussion to illustrate the features that are perhaps the minimal ones needed to understand more complicated resonances. These basic features were first included in the Cloudy Bag Model calculations [107, 108] and are absent in the calculations of [109, 110]. See Ref. [25] for a detailed chiral perturbation theory analysis.

The starting point is the Born graphs (irreducible diagrams) of Figure 6 a and b. The iteration of Δ\Delta excitation term, Figure 6 c, via an integral equation causes the inclusion of terms (isolated in the box) that correspond to the dressing of the Δ\Delta and a shift in the resonance peak away from the energy of the bare Δ\Delta, MΔ0M_\Delta^0. The iteration of the crossed nucleon term is not shown in Figure 6 but must be included. The crossed graph with an intermediate Δ\Delta is not included for simplicity and because it is small.

Irreducible diagrams in the 33 channel

Figure 6. Irreducible diagrams in the 33 channel. (a) Crossed nucleon term (b) Excitation of bare Δ\Delta. (c) Iteration of (b) via an integral equation

Detailed discussion of the methods to project amplitudes onto the 33 channel are shown in the book [16]. Here I use projected amplitudes in which the (cm) Born terms take the form

V^(s)=γ(s)∣Δ⟩⟨Δ∣(44)\hat{V}(s)=\gamma(s)|\Delta\rangle\langle\Delta| \tag*{(44)}

with ss the square of the πN\pi N cm energy,

γ(s)=13Msq2[fπN24π2M2E(s)ω(s)+fπNΔ24π2MΔ0s−MΔ2](45)\gamma(s)=\frac{1}{3}\frac{M}{\sqrt{s}}q^2\left[\frac{f_{\pi N}^2}{4\pi}\frac{2M}{2E(s)\omega(s)}+\frac{f_{\pi N\Delta}^2}{4\pi}\frac{2M_\Delta^0}{s-M_\Delta^2}\right] \tag*{(45)}

and ∣Δ⟩|\Delta\rangle representing the form factor arising from the finite extent of the pion and baryon. The first term in the bracket is inversely proportional to M2−uˉM^2-\bar{u}, in which uˉ\bar{u} accurately approximates the Mandelstam variable uu [16]. I use ⟨q∣Δ⟩=1/(1+q2/MA2)2≡v(q)\langle q|\Delta\rangle=1/(1+q^2/M_A^2)^2\equiv v(q) with MAM_A the axial mass of 1030 MeV. I use fπN2/(4π)=0.08f_{\pi N}^2/(4\pi)=0.08 and fπNΔ=1.5fπNf_{\pi N\Delta}=1.5f_{\pi N}, obtained from the large NcN_c limit. See Refs. [111–114].

The KK-matrix then takes the form

K^(s)=D(s)∣Δ⟩⟨Δ∣.(46)\hat{K}(s)=D(s)|\Delta\rangle\langle\Delta|. \tag*{(46)}

The on-shell KK-matrix element in a given channel is tan⁡δ(q)/q\tan\delta(q)/q, with qq the cm momentum. Solving the integral equation:

K^(s)=V^(s)+V^(s)PG(s)K^(s),(47)\hat{K}(s)=\hat{V}(s)+\hat{V}(s)PG(s)\hat{K}(s), \tag*{(47)}

with PP representing a principle-value integral, yields the result

D(s)=γ(s)1−γ(s)v2(q)⟨Δ∣G(s)∣Δ⟩(48)D(s)=\frac{\gamma(s)}{1-\gamma(s)v^2(q)\langle\Delta|G(s)|\Delta\rangle} \tag*{(48)}

with Green’s function matrix element given by:

⟨Δ∣G(s)∣Δ⟩=P∫dp p4v2(p)1s−(E(p)+ω(p))2(49)\langle\Delta|G(s)|\Delta\rangle=P\int dp\,p^4v^2(p)\frac{1}{s-(E(p)+\omega(p))^2} \tag*{(49)}

Defining the smooth function γ^(s)≡(s−MΔ02)γ(s)\hat{\gamma}(s)\equiv(s-M_\Delta^0{}^2)\gamma(s) allows D(s)D(s) to be re-written as

D(s)=γ^(s)s−MΔ02−γ^(s)v2(q)⟨Δ∣G(s)∣Δ⟩(50)D(s)=\frac{\hat{\gamma}(s)}{s-M_\Delta^0{}^2-\hat{\gamma}(s)v^2(q)\langle\Delta|G(s)|\Delta\rangle} \tag*{(50)}

This shows that the resonance position is shifted away from s=MΔ0\sqrt{s}=M_\Delta^0 by the iteration of both the nucleon crossed Born term and the Δ\Delta excitation. The calculations of [109, 110] use K^(s)→γ(s)∣Δ⟩⟨Δ∣\hat{K}(s)\to\gamma(s)|\Delta\rangle\langle\Delta|, a procedure that amounts to unitarizing the Born approximation.

Results of a numerical calculation are shown in Figure 7. The solid (blue) curve is the full calculation that approximately reproduces the data. The

Figure 7. P33P_{33} phase shifts computed with the model explained in the text. Solid (blue) curve: full calculation. Dashed(red): Unitarized Born approximation of [109, 110]. Dotted: full calculation without the crossed nucleon Born term of fig (a).

dashed (red) curve shows result of using the Born approximation procedure of [109, 110] with the present parameters. The dotted (black) curve shows the results obtained by omitting the crossed nucleon Born term. The figure shows that the cross Born term must be kept and that the Born approximation to the KK-matrix is a poor approximation.

VI Isospin violation in pion-nucleon interactions

The basis for isospin violation in the strong interaction is the mass difference between the up and down quarks, as written in Eq. (20). All isospin violations within the standard model arise from this term and electro-weak interactions, as stressed in Ref. [11].

Weinberg Weinberg [14] wrote the effective interaction arising from this term as a charge symmetry breaking (csb) contribution to the effective interaction

δLcsb=−B[ψˉτ3ψ−12fπ2(π31+π24fπ2)ψˉ⋅πψ](51)\delta\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{csb}}=-B\left[\bar{\psi}\tau_3\psi-\frac{1}{2f_\pi^2}\left(\frac{\pi_3}{1+\frac{\pi^2}{4f_\pi^2}}\right)\bar{\psi}\cdot\pi\psi\right] \tag*{(51)}

with B∝mu−mdB\propto m_u-m_d. This term leads to a term in the scattering length for the process of Eq. (25):

δaab(csb)=14π(1+mπ/mN)B2fπ2(taδ3b+tbδ3a)(52)\delta a_{ab}(\mathrm{csb})=\frac{1}{4\pi(1+m_\pi/m_N)}\frac{B}{2f_\pi^2}(t_a\delta_{3b}+t_b\delta_{3a}) \tag*{(52)}

Weinberg comments that the immediate consequence of Eq. (51) is that “isospin violation never appears in a process that does not involve at least one neutral pion.”. I believe that Weinberg meant to say that “isospin violation from the strong interaction never appears in a process that does not involve at least one neutral pion.” For example, the Coulomb interaction causes isospin violating differences between π+d\pi^{+}d and π−d\pi^{-}d scattering.

Weinberg [115] used Eq. (52) estimated that the π0n→π0n\pi^{0}n \rightarrow\pi^{0}n scattering length was 30% larger than the one for π0p→π0p\pi^{0}p \rightarrow\pi^{0}p, although both are of the order of 0.01 fm. Of course, the related scattering experiments are not possible with current techniques.

I turn to the more general case of πN\pi N scattering. If isospin invariance is respected one can write the π−N\pi^{-}N scattering amplitude as an operator in a schematic form

f=f0+f1t⋅tπ,(53)f = f_{0} + f_{1}\mathbf{t} \cdot\mathbf{t}_{\pi}, \tag*{(53)}

where f0,1f_{0,1} are operators that depend on relative momentum and nucleon spin. There are eight reactions of the form πa(q)N(p)→πb(q′)N(p′)\pi^{a}(q)N(p) \rightarrow\pi^{b}(q^{\prime})N(p^{\prime}), but only three are available to experiments [118]: π±p\pi^{\pm}p elastic scattering with amplitudes f±f_{\pm} and π−p→π0n\pi^{-}p \rightarrow\pi^{0}n charge exchange (CEX) scattering with amplitude frmCEXf_{rmCEX}. The use of Eq. (53) yields the so-called triangle identity:

fCEX=12(f+−f−).(54)f_{\mathrm{CEX}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(f_{+} - f_{-}). \tag*{(54)}

The failure of this equality is a failure of isospin invariance, but not of charge symmetry. The BB term of Eq. (51) causes no difference between the left and right-hand sides of the above equation. Thus a powerful conclusion results: the only Standard Model effects that break the triangle identity come from electroweak and hadronic mass-difference effects. The neutron-proton mass difference does arises from light quark mass differences and from the electroweak interaction, but is an indirect effect through its kinematic influence.

If isospin symmetry is broken the term f1t⋅tπf_{1}\mathbf{t} \cdot\mathbf{t}_{\pi} is replaced by the isospin-breaking (ib) term f1(ib)f_{1}(\mathrm{ib}) with

f1(ib)=αtztπz+β(txtπx+tytπy),(55)f_{1}(\mathrm{ib}) = \alpha t_{z}t_{\pi z} + \beta(t_{x}t_{\pi x} + t_{y}t_{\pi y}), \tag*{(55)}

with α≠β\alpha\ne\beta and α−β∝mu−md\alpha- \beta\propto m_{u} - m_{d} if electromagnetic effects are neglected. The α\alpha term causes differences between π+p\pi^{+}p and π−p\pi^{-}p scattering, the terms proportional to β\beta are responsible for charge exchange. One can get a quick glimpse of the size the effects by examining the kinematics of the π−p→π0n\pi^{-}p \rightarrow\pi^{0}n reaction. The π−\pi^{-} experiences a Coulomb attraction of about α/rp≈1.7\alpha/r_{p} \approx1.7 MeV and the proton is lighter than the neutron by about 1.3 MeV the sum of these two effects of 3 MeV is offset by the π−−π0\pi^{-}-\pi^{0} mass difference of 4.6 MeV.

Early analyses [118, 119] of the triangle identity in πN\pi N low-energy scattering data indications for significant 6-7 % csb effects in the strong-interaction sector. Fettes and Meissner [22] have found a smaller violation using a third-order chiral perturbation theory calculation without electromagnetic effects, and even smaller violations once the latter were included [23]. They found -0.7% violation in the ss-wave. An interesting feature of this work is the inclusion of the effects of the γn\gamma n channel in the final state. A detailed comprehensive partial-wave analysis of π±p\pi^{\pm}p elastic scattering and charge-exchange data, covering the region from threshold to 2.1 GeV in the lab pion kinetic energy found no compelling evidence for sizable isospin breaking effects beyond those of the standard model.

Isospin breaking through quark mass differences and virtual photons in scattering lengths was analyzed using covariant baryon chiral perturbation theory [116, 117]. This work found that the so-called triangle relation that vanishes in the isospin limit is violated by about 1.5% consistent with earlier findings and inconsistent with the much larger deviations extracted from the data at lowest pion momenta in [118, 119]. Isospin violation in the triangle identity was studied later in [120] using cross-section data. The conclusion was that these data are simply not precise enough to test the triangle relation at the percent level.

An experimental study of isospin symmetry in the π−p→π0n\pi^{-}p \rightarrow\pi^{0}n reaction at momenta between 104 and 143 MeV/cc was made at TRIUMF [121]. This kinematic region exhibits a vanishing zero-degree cross section from destructive interference between ss and pp waves, thus yielding special sensitivity to pion-nucleon dynamics. Their data and previous data [122] disagree. The key feature is that the predictions of Gibbs et al. [118, 123] and Matsinos et al. [119, 124] based on fitting π∓p\pi^{\mp}p data that constrain the term α\alpha of Eq. (55) agree with the angular distributions obtained in [121], but not with those obtained in [122]. This means that no significant isospin breaking effect is observed. The difference in data sets was attributed to normalization uncertainties and background subtraction.

The net result regarding tests of the triangle identity is that there isn’t any evidence for these huge isospin-breaking effects.

One also studies charge symmetry breaking and isospin violation involving light nuclei 3d{}^{3}\mathrm{d}, 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H}, 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He}, 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} as detailed in the review [11]. Here I focus on later experiments involving π±\pi^{\pm} scattering on the deuteron[125], 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He} and 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H} [126].

Charge symmetry breaking effects in experimental measurements have been expressed in terms of AπA_{\pi} for the deuteron:

Aπ=dσ/dΩ(π−d)−dσ/dΩ(π+d)dσ/dΩ(π−d)+dσ/dΩ(π+d)(56)A_{\pi}=\frac{d\sigma/d\Omega(\pi^{-}d)-d\sigma/d\Omega(\pi^{+}d)}{d\sigma/d\Omega(\pi^{-}d)+d\sigma/d\Omega(\pi^{+}d)} \tag*{(56)}

and for the nuclei with A=3A=3:

r1=dσ/dΩ(π+3H)dσ/dΩ(π−3He)(57)r_{1}=\frac{d\sigma/d\Omega(\pi^{+}{}^{3}\mathrm{H})}{d\sigma/d\Omega(\pi^{-}{}^{3}\mathrm{He})} \tag*{(57)}
r2=dσ/dΩ(π−3H)dσ/dΩ(π+3He)(58)r_{2}=\frac{d\sigma/d\Omega(\pi^{-}{}^{3}\mathrm{H})}{d\sigma/d\Omega(\pi^{+}{}^{3}\mathrm{He})} \tag*{(58)}
R=r1r2(59)R=r_{1}r_{2} \tag*{(59)}

Charge symmetry predicts that Aπ=1A_{\pi}=1, r1=1r_{1}=1, r2=1r_{2}=1 and R=1R=1. Of course it is necessary to remove the effects of the Coulomb interaction. These experiments were performed at energies near and on that of the Δ\Delta resonance and one must account for the mass and width differences amongst the four charge states of the Δ\Delta as well as the neutron-proton mass difference and the 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He}-3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H} mass difference.

The early history suggested evidence for a small effect, Aπ≃2%A_{\pi}\simeq2\% at 143 MeV [127]. A sizable effect was reported in the 3He3H{}^{3}\mathrm{He}{}^{3}\mathrm{H} case. For example, r2=0.7±0.1r_{2}=0.7\pm0.1 for Tπ=256T_{\pi}=256 MeV at θ=82∘\theta=82^{\circ} [128].

Ref. [125] described the charge symmetry breaking effect on the deuteron in terms of single and double scattering amplitudes, taking the Δ\Delta mass splitting into account. The results of that study indicate that the Δ\Delta mass and width differences, can along with the Coulomb interaction are of the same order as the deviations between AπA_{\pi} and unity.

Ref. [126] described pion scattering from the three-nucleon system in terms of single- and double-scattering amplitudes. Coulomb interactions and Δ\Delta-mass splitting are taken into account as sources of charge symmetry breaking. Reasonable agreement between theoretical calculations and the experimental data was obtained for Tπ=180T_{\pi}=180, 220, and 256 MeV. For these energies, it is found that the Δ\Delta-mass splitting and the differences in wave functions of the A=3A=3 nuclei are the most important contributions for charge symmetry breaking. Data for r2r_{2} and RR at Tπ=142T_{\pi}=142 MeV did not agree with the predictions of the model, which may indicate that there are additional mechanisms for charge symmetry breaking that are important only at lower energies.

The summary of the activity for elastic pion scattering from nuclei with A=2A=2 or 3 is that the Δ\Delta mass differences and Coulomb effects account for most of the charge symmetry breaking effects. Other mechanisms involving non-resonant charge symmetry breaking in ss-wave π\pi-nucleon scattering that occurs in the intermediate state, as indicated in Eq. (55) and Eq. (52) were not included in the calculations.

Weinberg’s statements [14] about charge symmetry breaking involving the π0\pi^{0} were borne out in experiments on the np→π0dnp\to\pi^{0}d reaction [129] in which charge symmetry breaking predicts a symmetry in the angular distribution about a production angle of 90∘90^{\circ} and in the dd→4He π0dd\to{}^{4}\mathrm{He}\,\pi^{0} reaction [130, 131] that is forbidden by charge symmetry. Ref. [129] observed a forward-backward asymmetry [17.2±8.0(stat)±5.5(syst)]×10−4[17.2\pm8.0(\mathrm{stat})\pm5.5(\mathrm{syst})]\times10^{-4} at an incident neutron energy of 279.5 MeV. This result could be accounted for by the effects of the mass difference between up and down quarks. Refs. [130, 131] measured total cross sections for neutral pion production of 12.7±2.212.7\pm2.2 pb at 228.5 MeV and 15.1±3.115.1\pm3.1 pb at 231.8 MeV. The uncertainty is dominated by statistical errors. These cross sections arise fundamentally from the down-up quark mass difference and quark electromagnetic effects that contribute in part through meson mixing (e.g., π0−η\pi^{0}-\eta) mechanisms.

The results of these experiments and the related theory are discussed in the review [12]. The simplest summary is that the effects of the mass difference between up and down quarks of Eq. (20) cause the charge symmetry breaking . Initial calculations of the manifestation of the mass difference in terms of the necessary hadronic degrees of freedom accounted for the findings of experiments with reasonable accuracy. The effects of the light-quark mass difference has made its presence felt in nuclear physics.

Summary

Chiral effective field theory is a greatly useful tool to understand low-energy pion-nucleon interactions and their connection with the fundamental theory of QCD. The breaking of chiral symmetry via quark mass differences is manifest in specific features of Lagrangians using hadronic interactions. The progress in understanding the sigma term and its widespread importance is reviewed. The extraction of the sigma term would benefit from improving the low-energy data set. The features of the low-energy πN\pi N phase shifts are reviewed. The complicated physics of the simplest baryon resonant state—the Δ\Delta is explained. Recent progress in understanding isospin violation in theory and fact is reviewed. The experimental observations of isospin violation seem to be accounted for by the effects of light-quark mass differences and electromagnetic effects. However, higher energy phase shifts provide the dominant experimental information. This is a second reason for why it would be very useful to have better low-energy pion-nucleon scattering data.

The study of pion-nucleon scattering is equivalent to the study of the fundamental strong interaction of QCD. Its importance remains vital to this day.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the US Department of Energy Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences program under Grant No. DE-FG02-97ER41014. I thank Avraham Gal, Ronald Gilman, Andre Walker-Loud and Martin Hoferichter for useful discussions and Igor Strakovsky for providing Figs. 3-5.

References

  1. [1]N. Kaiser, R. Brockmann and W. Weise, Nucl. Phys. A 625, 758-788 (1997) doi:10.1016/S0375-9474(97)00586-1 [arXiv:nucl-th/9706045 [nucl-th]].DOI
  2. [2]N. Kaiser, S. Fritsch and W. Weise, Nucl. Phys. A 697, 255-276 (2002) doi:10.1016/S0375-9474(01)01231-3 [arXiv:nucl-th/0105057 [nucl-th]].DOI
  3. [3]D. O. Riska and G. E. Brown, Phys. Lett. B 32, 662-664 (1970) doi:10.1016/0370-2693(70)90437-5DOI
  4. [4]D. O. Riska and G. E. Brown, Phys. Lett. B 38, 193-195 (1972) doi:10.1016/0370-2693(72)90376-0DOI
  5. [5]V. R. Brown and J. Franklin, Phys. Rev. C 8, 1706-1720 (1973) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.8.1706DOI
  6. [6]G. B. King, L. Andreoli, S. Pastore, M. Piarulli, R. Schiavilla, R. B. Wiringa, J. Carlson and S. Gandolfi, Phys. Rev. C 102, no.2, 025501 (2020) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.102.025501 [arXiv:2004.05263 [nucl-th]].DOI
  7. [7]M. Alberg and G. A. Miller, Phys. Rev. C 100, no.3, 035205 (2019) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.100.035205 [arXiv:1712.05814 [nucl-th]].DOI
  8. [8]M. Alberg, L. E. Elvander and G. A. Miller, Phys. Rev. D 105, no.11, 114054 (2022) doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.105.114054 [arXiv:2108.12439 [nucl-th]].DOI
  9. [9]J. Dove et al. [SeaQuest], Nature 590, no.7847, 561-565 (2021) [erratum: Nature 604, no.7907, E26 (2022)] doi:10.1038/s41586-022-04707-z [arXiv:2103.04024 [hep-ph]].
  10. [10]M. Gell-Mann, R. J. Oakes and B. Renner, Phys. Rev. 175 (1968), 2195-2199.
  11. [11]G. A. Miller, B. M. K. Nefkens and I. Slaus, Phys. Rept. 194, 1-116 (1990) doi:10.1016/0370-1573(90)90102-8DOI
  12. [12]G. A. Miller, A. K. Opper and E. J. Stephenson, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 56, 253-292 (2006) doi:10.1146/annurev.nucl.56.080805.140446 [arXiv:nucl-ex/0602021 [nucl-ex]].DOI
  13. [13]S. Weinberg, Physica A 96, no.1-2, 327-340 (1979) doi:10.1016/0378-4371(79)90223-1DOI
  14. [14]S. Weinberg, Lect. Notes Phys. 452, 1 (1995) doi:10.1007/3-540-59279-2_61 [arXiv:hep-ph/9412326 [hep-ph]].DOI
  15. [15]T. E. O. Ericson, V. W. Hughes and D. E. Nagle, “The Meson Factories”, 1991, University of California Press, Berkeley California.
  16. [16]T. E. O. Ericson and W. Weise, Clarendon Press, 1988, ISBN 978-0-19-852008-5
  17. [17]N. Fettes, U. G. Meissner and S. Steininger, Nucl. Phys. A 640, 199-234 (1998) doi:10.1016/S0375-9474(98)00452-7 [arXiv:hep-ph/9803266 [hep-ph]].DOI
  18. [18]N. Fettes, U. G. Meissner and S. Steininger, Phys. Lett. B 451, 233-240 (1999) doi:10.1016/S0370-2693(99)00201-4 [arXiv:hep-ph/9811366 [hep-ph]].DOI
  19. [19]N. Fettes, U. G. Meissner, M. Mojzis and S. Steininger, Annals Phys. 283, 273-302 (2000) [erratum: Annals Phys. 288, 249-250 (2001)] doi:10.1006/aphy.2000.6059 [arXiv:hep-ph/0001308 [hep-ph]].DOI
  20. [20]N. Fettes and U. G. Meissner, Nucl. Phys. A 679, 629-670 (2001) doi:10.1016/S0375-9474(00)00368-7 [arXiv:hep-ph/0006299 [hep-ph]].DOI
  21. [21]N. Fettes and U. G. Meissner, Nucl. Phys. A 676, 311 (2000) doi:10.1016/S0375-9474(00)00199-8 [arXiv:hep-ph/0002162 [hep-ph]].DOI
  22. [22]N. Fettes and U. G. Meissner, Phys. Rev. C 63, 045201 (2001) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.63.045201 [arXiv:nucl-th/0008181 [hep-ph]].
  23. [23]N. Fettes and U. G. Meissner, Nucl. Phys. A 693, 693-709 (2001) doi:10.1016/S0375-9474(01)00977-0 [arXiv:nucl-th/0101030 [hep-ph]].
  24. [24]S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 17, 616-621 (1966).
  25. [25]B. Long and U. van Kolck, Nucl. Phys. A 840, 39-75 (2010) doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2010.03.008 [arXiv:0907.4569 [hep-ph]].DOI
  26. [26]J. M. Alarcón, Eur. Phys. J. ST 230, no.6, 1609-1622 (2021) doi:10.1140/epjs/s11734-021-00145-6 [arXiv:2205.01108 [hep-ph]].DOI
  27. [27]E. Reya, Rev. Mod. Phys. 46 (1974), 545-580.
  28. [28]T. P. Cheng and R. F. Dashen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 26 (1971), 594.
  29. [29]S. L. Adler, Phys. Rev. 137, B1022-B1033 (1965); Phys. Rev. 139, B1638-B1643 (1965).
  30. [30]J. Gasser, A. Rusetsky and I. Scimemi, Eur. Phys. J. C 32, 97-114 (2003) doi:10.1140/epjc/s2003-01383-1 [arXiv:hep-ph/0305260 [hep-ph]].
  31. [31]L. S. Brown, W. J. Pardee and R. D. Peccei, Phys. Rev. D 4 (1971), 2801-2810.
  32. [32]V. Bernard, N. Kaiser and U. G. Meissner, Phys. Lett. B 389 (1996), 144-148.
  33. [33]H. Pagels and W. J. Pardee, Phys. Rev. D 4 (1971), 3335-3337.
  34. [34]H. x. He and X. D. Ji, Phys. Rev. D 52, 2960-2963 (1995) doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.52.2960 [arXiv:hep-ph/9412235 [hep-ph]]. [arXiv:hep-ph/9410274 [hep-ph]].DOI
  35. [35]A. Metz, B. Pasquini and S. Rodini, Phys. Rev. D 102, 114042 (2020) doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.102.114042 [arXiv:2006.11171 [hep-ph]].DOI
  36. [36]C. Lorcé, A. Metz, B. Pasquini and S. Rodini, JHEP 11, 121 (2021) doi:10.1007/JHEP11(2021)121 [arXiv:2109.11785 [hep-ph]].DOI
  37. [37]X. Ji, Y. Liu and A. Schäfer, Nucl. Phys. B 971, 115537 (2021) doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2021.115537 [arXiv:2105.03974 [hep-ph]].DOI
  38. [38]R. J. Crewther, Phys. Rev. Lett. 28, 1421 (1972).
  39. [39]M. S. Chanowitz and J. R. Ellis, Phys. Lett. B 40, 397-400 (1972).
  40. [40]J. C. Collins, A. Duncan and S. D. Joglekar, Phys. Rev. D 16, 438-449 (1977).
  41. [41]M. A. Shifman, A. I. Vainshtein and V. I. Zakharov, Phys. Lett. B 78, 443-446 (1978).
  42. [42]R. J. Hill and M. P. Solon, Phys. Lett. B 707 (2012), 539-545.
  43. [43]A. Bottino, F. Donato, N. Fornengo and S. Scopel, Astropart. Phys. 18, 205-211 (2002); Phys. Rev. D 78, 083520 (2008).
  44. [44]J. R. Ellis, K. A. Olive and C. Savage, Phys. Rev. D 77, 065026 (2008).
  45. [45]A. Crivellin, M. Hoferichter and M. Procura, Phys. Rev. D 89, 054021 (2014) doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.89.054021 [arXiv:1312.4951 [hep-ph]]DOI
  46. [46]M. Gell-Mann and M. Levy, Nuovo Cim. 16, 705 (1960) doi:10.1007/BF02859738
  47. [47]J. V. Noble, Phys. Rev. C 20, 225-234 (1979) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.20.225DOI
  48. [48]S. El Hatashri, N. Li, A. Rokash, J. M. Alarcón, D. Du, N. Klein, B. n. Lu, U. G. Meißner, E. Epelbaum and H. Krebs, et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, no.13, 132501 (2016).
  49. [49]N. Kaiser, P. de Homont and W. Weise, Phys. Rev. C 77, 025204 (2008).
  50. [50]J. M. Alarcon, L. S. Geng, J. Martin Camalich and J. A. Oller, Phys. Lett. B 730, 342-346 (2014).
  51. [51]I. P. Fernando, J. M. Alarcón and J. L. Goity, Phys. Lett. B 781, 719-722 (2018).
  52. [52]T. P. Cheng, Phys. Rev. D 13, 2161 (1976).
  53. [53]P.A. Zyla et al. [Particle Data Group], PTEP 2020, no.8, 083C01 (2020) and 2021 update doi:10.1093/ptep/ptaa104DOI
  54. [54]J. Gasser, Annals Phys. 136, 62 (1981) doi:10.1016/0003-4916(81)90086-5DOI
  55. [55]J. Gasser, H. Leutwyler, M. P. Locher and M. E. Sainio, Phys. Lett. B 213 (1988), 85-90.
  56. [56]S. Dürr, Z. Fodor, T. Hemmert, C. Hoelbling, J. Fri-son, S. D. Katz, S. Krieg, T. Kurth, L. Lellouch and T. Lippert, et al. Phys. Rev. D 85, 014509 (2012) [erratum: Phys. Rev. D 93, no.3, 039905 (2016)] doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.85.014509 [arXiv:1109.4265 [hep-lat]].
  57. [57]S. Dürr, Z. Fodor, C. Hoelbling, S. D. Katz, S. Krieg, L. Lellouch, T. Lippert, T. Metivet, A. Portelli and K. K. Szabo, et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, no.17, 172001 (2016) doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.116.172001 [arXiv:1510.08013 [hep-lat]].DOI
  58. [58]Y. B. Yang et al. [χQCD], Phys. Rev. D 94, no.5, 054503 (2016) doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.94.054503 [arXiv:1511.09089 [hep-lat]].DOI
  59. [59]W. Freeman et al. [MILC], Phys. Rev. D 88, 054503 (2013) doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.88.054503 [arXiv:1204.3866 [hep-lat]]DOI
  60. [60]P. Junnarkar and A. Walker-Loud, Phys. Rev. D 87, 114510 (2013) doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.87.114510 [arXiv:1301.1114 [hep-lat]].DOI
  61. [61]J. Gasser, H. Leutwyler and M. E. Sainio, Phys. Lett. B 253, 260-264 (1991).
  62. [62]J. Gasser, H. Leutwyler and M. E. Sainio, Phys. Lett. B 253, 252-259 (1991).
  63. [63]M. Hoferichter, J. Ruiz de Elvira, B. Kubis and U. G. Meißner, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 092301 (2015) doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.092301 [arXiv:1506.04142 [hep-ph]].DOI
  64. [64]G. Altarelli, N. Cabibbo and L. Maiani, Phys. Lett. B 35 (1971), 415-418.
  65. [65]M. G. Olsson and E. T. Osypowski, J. Phys. G 6 (1980), 423.
  66. [66]M. G. Olsson, Phys. Lett. B 482, 50-56 (2000).
  67. [67]J. Gasser and H. Leutwyler, Phys. Lett. B 125, 325-329 (1983); Annals Phys. 158, 142 (1984); Nucl. Phys. B 250, 465-516 (1985).
  68. [68]J. M. Alarcon, J. Martin Camalich and J. A. Oller, Annals Phys. 336, 413-461 (2013).
  69. [69]A. Abdel-Rehim et al. [ETM], Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, no.25, 252001 (2016).
  70. [70]G. S. Bali et al. [RQCD], Phys. Rev. D 93, no.9, 094504 (2016).
  71. [71]C. Alexandrou, M. Constantinou, P. Dimopoulos, R. Frezzotti, K. Hadjiyiannakou, K. Jansen, C. Kallidonis, B. Kostrzewa, G. Koutsou and M. Mangin-Brinet, et al. Phys. Rev. D 95, no.11, 114514 (2017) [erratum: Phys. Rev. D 96, no.9, 099906 (2017)].
  72. [72]S. Borsanyi, Z. Fodor, C. Hoelbling, L. Lellouch, K. K. Szabo, C. Torrero and L. Varnhorst, [arXiv:2007.03319 [hep-lat]].
  73. [73]D. H. Beck and R. D. McKeown, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 51, 189-217 (2001) doi:10.1146/annurev.nucl.51.101701.132312DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_fx4uur2x
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents