WorksMathematics
Topological notions of Shadowing under Semi-Conjugacy
Abstract
We study various notions of shadowing and investigate whether they are preserved under semi-conjugacy and inverse limits. In particular, we study Inverse shadowing, -shadowing, Periodic shadowing, Ramsey shadowing, Density shadowing and Ergodic shadowing.
Introduction
Let be a compact metric space and be a continuous function. Given a point , we define the orbit of as the set . Let . A -pseudo-orbit is a sequence such that for all . Intuitively a -pseudo orbit is a sequence that behaves like an orbit, however at every stage of the iteration there is an error of at most . Given , a sequence in is said to -shadow the sequence if for all . We say that has shadowing if every , there exists a , such that every -pseudo-orbit is -shadowed by a true orbit.
Shadowing has become an important tool in the study of dynamical systems. Anosov’s shadowing lemma shows that diffeomorphisms restricted to a hyperbolic set exhibit shadowing [1]. This result has been used to study the stability of hyperbolic dynamical systems. Bowen used shadowing to study Axiom A diffeomorphisms and their -limit sets [3].
Shadowing has also emerged as an important tool in applied contexts, particularly in numerical modelling. Computers operate with finite precision, hence the iteration of a function typically introduces small rounding errors. The resulting numerical trajectory can therefore be viewed as a pseudo-orbit rather than an exact orbit. If the dynamical system possesses the shadowing property, then this pseudo-orbit remains close to a genuine orbit. Thus, despite the presence of numerical errors, the computed trajectory can still be interpreted as representing a valid behaviour of the underlying dynamical system. For this reason, shadowing has been studied extensively in the context of numerical modelling and the reliability of numerical simulations [HJ05].
In [8] it was shown that shadowing can be formulated in purely topological terms and therefore does not require the underlying space to be metrizable. Building on this observation, they introduced the almost lifting property, which characterizes when a factor map preserves the shadowing property.
A factor map between two dynamical systems is a continuous surjection, , such that the following holds, . The authors also showed that shadowing was preserved under inverse limits provided it satisfied the Mittag-Leffler condition.
Since shadowing was first introduced, various other notions of shadowing have been developed. These include inverse shadowing, orbital shadowing and ergodic shadowing. Work has been done on studying whether these differing notions of shadowing are preserved under various actions such as factor maps and inverse limits [9].
In this paper, we expand upon the work of [9] by considering several other notions of shadowing and addressing some of the unresolved questions in the paper. In particular, we look at inverse shadowing, -shadowing, periodic shadowing, Ramsey shadowing, density shadowing and ergodic shadowing. We characterize the property that determines whether they are preserved under factor maps and investigate whether they are preserved under inverse limits, and the hyperspace topology.
Preliminaries
Definition 2.1. A dynamical system is a compact Hausdorff space , with a continuous function .
The orbit of a point is defined to be the set . Given two dynamical systems , , a factor map from to is a continuous surjection, , such that the following holds, . is often also called a semi-conjugacy and we say that and are semi-conjugate. If is also a homeomorphism, we call it a conjugacy, and say that and are conjugate.
Definition 2.2. Given a dynamical system , let denote the set of non-empty compact subsets of . Given a subset of define . For subsets , of , we define the Hausdorff metric by . This forms a compact topological space under the Hausdorff metric. Then induces a continuous function, from to defined by sending to . Hence is also a dynamical system.
Definition 2.3. Consider a collection of dynamical systems . Suppose for all we have maps which satisfy:
is the identity.
For all we have that .
We call this an inverse system and its inverse limit space is given by:
The inverse limit is the dynamical system given by where
An inverse system of dynamical systems satisfies the Mittag-Leffler condition provided that for all , we can find an such that for all we have that . Clearly if each is surjective, the Mittag-Leffler condition is satisfied.
Definition 2.4 (Shadowing). Let . A sequence is called a -pseudo-orbit if for all . Given , a sequence in is said to -shadow the sequence if for all . We say that has shadowing if for every , there exists a , such that if is a -pseudo-orbit, then there exists a such that is -shadowed by a true orbit.
The definition given for shadowing is given in a metric space. However in [8], Good and Meddaugh showed that an equivalent definition of shadowing could be formulated on topological spaces.
Definition 2.5. Let be a dynamical system, where is a topological compact space. Let denote the set of finite open covers of . Let . We say a sequence is a -pseudo orbit provided that for all , there exists a such that .
We say a sequence is -shadowed by a sequence if for all , there exists a such that . We say has topological shadowing if for all , there exists such that if is a -pseudo orbit, then there exists a such that the orbit of -shadows .
Theorem 2.1 ([8], Lemma 6). Let be a compact metric space. A dynamical system has shadowing if and only if for every , there exists a such that every -pseudo orbit is -shadowed by a point $z \in X.
Analogously to [8], for each metric definition of an alternative notion of shadowing, we also provide the corresponding topological definition. We will show that these definitions are equivalent to their corresponding metric definition, provided the underlying metric space is compact.
Inverse shadowing
Definition 3.1. Inverse shadowing- Metric definition:
Let be a dynamical system, and let denote the set of all infinite sequences of . For , let denote the set of all sequences given by a -pseudo orbit. A -method for is a map , which sends every to a pseudo orbit sequence which begins with . We let denote the set of all -methods of .
A dynamical system has inverse shadowing if for all there exist such that for all and all , there exists such that -shadows the orbit of .
Under the standard notion of shadowing, we are interested in whether pseudo-orbits can be approximated by a real orbit. Inverse shadowing consider the converse problem: whether any orbit can be approximated using a suitable pseudo-orbit from any -method of . Inverse shadowing arises when studying the structural stability and hyperbolicity of various dynamical systems [11]. In particular, it has been shown that on compact manifolds, hyperbolic homeomorphisms have inverse shadowing under certain conditions on the set of -methods [13].
Definition 3.2. Inverse shadowing- Topological definition:
A dynamical system has inverse shadowing if for all , there exists an , such that for all and all , there exists an such that, -shadows .
We use the following well-known theorem to prove the equivalence between the topological and metric notions of inverse-shadowing in a compact metric space.
Theorem 3.1. (Lebesgue’s number lemma) Let be a compact metric space. Let be an open cover of . There exists a such that for every , there exists a such that . We call this the Lebesgue number of .
Theorem 3.2. Let be a dynamical system where is a compact metric space. The topological and metric definitions of inverse shadowing are equivalent.
Proof. Suppose the topological definition of inverse shadowing holds in . Let . Since is compact we can choose an open cover of which consists of a finite number of balls. Choose which satisfies Definition 3.2 with respect to . Let denote the Lebesgue number of . Pick an arbitrary and an arbitrary . Then is a map , which sends every to a -pseudo orbit sequence which begins with . For all we have . As is the Lebesgue number of , we know that there exists such that . Hence is also a -pseudo orbit which starts with . Therefore is also a member of . Choose a which satisfies Definition 3.2 with respect to and . As we have topological inverse shadowing, we know that for all , there exists a such that and both belong to . Since consists of -balls, we know that . Hence the metric definition of inverse shadowing is satisfied.
Now we consider the case where the metric definition holds. Consider an finite open cover of . Let denote the Lebesgue number of . Choose which satisfies Definition 3.1 with respect to . As is compact we can choose a finite open cover of which consists of -balls. Pick an arbitrary and an arbitrary .
Then is a map , which sends every to a -pseudo orbit sequence which begins with . For all , there exists such that . consists of -balls, so we know that . Hence is also a -pseudo orbit which starts with . Therefore is also a member of . Choose which satisfies Definition 3.1. For we have . Hence there exists a such that . Hence the topological definition of inverse shadowing is also satisfied.
Definition 3.3. Almost lifting delta method property (ALDM)- Metric definition:
A factor map has almost lifting delta method property, if for all and there exist , such that if , then there exists such that -shadows .
When we say that -shadows , we mean that for all we have -shadows some element of .
Definition 3.4. Almost lifting delta method property (ALDM)- Topological definition:
has almost lifting delta method property, if for all and there exist , such that if , then there exists such that -shadows .
It is straightforward to show that the topological and metric definitions of ALDM are equivalent, hence we omit the proof.
Theorem 3.3. Suppose is a factor map from to . We will prove that if has inverse shadowing, then must have ALDM.
Proof. Let and . Choose such that witnesses inverse shadowing with respect to . Let be arbitrary. Let be arbitrary. For each , consider its orbit. This clearly define a -pseudo orbit for each . So consider defined by the orbits on . Let be arbitrary. Now consider . Then clearly is the orbit of . But since has inverse shadowing, we know there exists a such that -shadows the orbit of , and hence -shadows . Hence has the ALDM property.
Theorem 3.4. Let and be two dynamical systems. suppose has inverse shadowing and has the ALDM property, then has inverse shadowing.
Proof. Fix an open cover of . Let be an open cover of such that if and , there exist such that . Let be an open cover of such that refines . Since has inverse shadowing, let witness this with respect to . Since has ALDM, let witness this with respect to and .
Let . Let be arbitrary. Consider . By inverse shadowing we know that for all , there exists a , such that -shadows . Take , such that it satisfies the conditions of the ALDM property. Hence, we know that is -shadowed by for some . Since refines . We must have that for all , and are both in , for some . But notice that . Hence for all , and are both in .
But by the ALDM property -shadows for some . Hence for all , and belong to for some . So for all we must have that and both contain , and hence their intersection is non empty. But by construction of , we know that there exists a such that and are both contained in . Hence is -shadowed by . And so we have shown that has inverse shadowing.
In [9] it was shown that that inverse shadowing is preserved under inverse limits and the induced hyperspace.
H-shadowing
Definition 4.1. -shadowing - Metric definition: We say that has -shadowing if for all there exists such that if is a finite -pseudo orbit, then there exists a such that and .
Definition 4.2. -shadowing- Topological definition: A dynamical system has -shadowing if for all , there exists a such that for all finite -pseudo orbits , we can find such that and .
-shadowing arises naturally when studying shadowing in shift spaces. In a shift space, if a -pseudo orbit is shadowed by a point , then there exists an such that for all we have that . If a dynamical systems has -shadowing, this can be used to characterize their -limit sets [2].
Theorem 4.1. Let be a dynamical system where is a compact metric space. The topological and metric definitions of -shadowing are equivalent.
Proof. Suppose the topological definition of -shadowing holds in . Let . Since is compact we can choose an open cover of which consists of a finite number of -balls. Let which satisfies Definition 4.2 with respect to . Let denote the Lebesgue number of . Let be a finite -pseudo orbit. Then for all we have . Hence there exists a such that . Hence this pseudo orbit is also a pseudo orbit. Choose a which satisfies Definition 4.2. As we have topological -shadowing, we know that for all , there exists a such that and both belong to with . Since consists of -balls, we know that . Hence the metric definition of -shadowing holds in .
Now we consider the case where the metric definition of -shadowing holds. Consider an finite open cover of . Let denote the Lebesgue number of . Choose which satisfies Definition 4.1 with respect to . As is compact we can choose a finite open cover of which consists of -balls. Let be a finite -pseudo orbit. Hence for all , we have that for some . As consists of -balls, clearly is also a finite -pseudo orbit. Choose a which satisfies Definition 4.1. satisfies for with . Hence there exists a such that . Hence also exhibits topological -shadowing.
Definition 4.3. Almost lifting hit pseudo orbit property (ALhP) - Topological definition: We say a factor map has almost lifting hit pseudo orbit property if for all , and , there exists , such that if is a finite pseudo orbit in , then there exists a pseudo orbit in , such that , for some and .
Definition 4.4. Almost lifting hit pseudo orbit property (ALhP) - Metric definition: We say a factor map has almost lifting hit pseudo orbit property if for all and , there exists such that if is a finite pseudo orbit in , then there exists a pseudo orbit in , such that , and .
Theorem 4.2. Let and be two dynamical systems. suppose has -shadowing and has the ALhP property, then has -shadowing.
Proof. Fix an open cover of . Let be an open cover of such that if and , there exist such that . Let be an open cover of such that refines . Since has -shadowing, let witness this with respect to . Since has ALhP, let witness this with respect to and .
Let be a finite pseudo orbit. Let be the pseudo orbit, such that -shadows and .
Since has -shadowing, we know that is shadowed by a point say , such that . Hence for all we have that for some . Since is a factor map we know that . And since refines , it follows that there exists such that and lie in . But we also know that and belong to for some . Hence is in . But by construction of we know there exists a such that and lie in it. Hence is shadowed by , and . Hence has -shadowing.
Theorem 4.3. Suppose is a factor map from to . We will prove that if has -shadowing, then must have the ALhP property.
Proof. Let and . Choose such that witnesses -shadowing with respect to . Let be a finite pseudo orbit. Then it must be -shadowed by a point say , such that . Since is surjective we know there exists such that . Now consider . This is trivially a pseudo orbit. Note that for each we must have that , so -shadows . In particular . And so has the ALhP property.
In [9], it was shown that -shadowing is preserved under the induced hyperspace.
Periodic shadowing
Definition 5.1. Periodic shadowing - Metric definition: We say that has periodic shadowing if for all there exists such that if is a periodic -pseudoorbit, then there exists a periodic such that .
Definition 5.2. Periodic shadowing- Topological definition: A dynamical system has periodic shadowing if for all , there exists a such that if is a periodic -pseudoorbits , we can find a periodic such that .
Periodic shadowing considers pseudo-orbits that approximate the behaviour of periodic orbits. It states that periodic pseudo-orbits can be shadowed by a genuine periodic point. It has been shown that there is a close relationship between a dynamical system exhibiting periodic shadowing, and it being -stable [12, 5].
Theorem 5.1. Let be a dynamical system where is a compact metric space. The topological and metric definitions of periodic shadowing are equivalent.
Proof. Suppose the topological definition of periodic shadowing holds in . Let . Since is compact we can choose an open cover of which consists of a finite number of -balls. Choose which satisfies Definition 5.2 with respect to . Let denote the Lebesgue number of . Let be a -periodic pseudo orbit. Then for all we have . Hence there exists a such that . Hence this -periodic pseudo orbit is also a -periodic pseudo orbit. Choose a periodic which satisfies Definition 5.2. As we have topological shadowing, we know that for all , there exists a such that and both belong to . Since consists of -balls, we know that . Hence the metric definition is satisfied.
Now we consider the case where the metric definition holds. Consider an finite open cover of . Let denote the Lebesgue number of . Choose which satisfies Definition 5.1 with respect to . As is compact we can choose a finite open cover of which consists of -balls. Let be a -periodic pseudo orbit. Hence for all , we have that for some . As consists of -balls, clearly is also a -periodic pseudo orbit. Choose which satisfies Definition 5.1. is periodic and satisfies for . Hence there exists a such that . Hence the topological definition is also satisfied.
Definition 5.3. Almost Lifting Periodic Pseudo orbit property (ALPP) Metric definition : We say a factor map has ALPP if for all and for all , there exist a , such that if is a periodic pseudo orbit in , then there exists a periodic pseudo orbit in , such that .
We can extend this definition more generally to topological spaces by using the following definition:
Definition 5.4. Almost Lifting Periodic Pseudo orbit property (ALPP) Topological definition: We say a factor map has ALPP if for all , and , there exists , such that if is a periodic pseudo orbit in , then there exists a periodic pseudo orbit in , such that , for some . In this definition just means finite open cover.
Theorem 5.2. Let and be two dynamical systems. suppose has periodic shadowing and has the ALPP property, then has periodic shadowing.
Proof. Fix an open cover of . Let be an open cover of such that if and , there exist such that . Let be an open cover of such that refines . Since has periodic shadowing, let witness this with respect to . Since has ALPP, let witness this with respect to and .
Let be a periodic periodic pseudo orbit. Let be the periodic pseudo orbit, such that shadows .
Since has periodic shadowing, we know that is shadowed by a periodic point say . Hence for all we have that for some . Since is a factor map we know that . And since refines , it follows that there exists such that and lie in . But we also know that and belong to for some . Hence is in . But by construction of we know there exists a such that and lie in it. Hence is shadowed by , and since the image of periodic points under factor maps are periodic, we have shown that has periodic shadowing.
:::
Theorem 5.3. Suppose is a factor map from to . We will prove that if has the periodic shadowing property, then must have the ALPP property.
Proof. Let and . Choose such that it witnesses periodic shadowing with respect to . Let be a periodic pseudo orbit. Then it must be shadowed by a periodic point say . So there exists an such that . Consider a covering of by open balls of radius . Since is compact this covering has a finite sub cover. Hence is contained in finite number of these open balls of radius . Since is surjective we know there exists such that . Consider the sequence . Note that all belong in . By the pigeonhole principle, at least one of the open balls of
radius that cover contains , where . But then consider the periodic pseudo orbit given by , , , , , , , ,
Clearly this periodic pseudo orbit satisfies the condition needed for the ALPP property to hold. Hence the map satisfies the ALPP property.
Ramsey shadowing
Definition 6.1. Furstenberg family:
We call a Furstenberg family, if it is a nonempty set of subsets of and it is closed under supersets.
Definition 6.2. Ramsey property:
We say , a Furstenberg family, has the Ramsey property, if whenever and , then for some .
Ramsey shadowing has shown itself to be strongly connected to minimal points and other fundamental concepts in dynamical systems, including recurrence. In particular, it has been shown that Ramsey shadowing is equivalent to the existence of a dense set of minimal points [4].
Definition 6.3. Ramsey shadowing- Metric definition: A dynamical system has Ramsey shadowing if for all , for all with the Ramsey property, any sequence can be -shadowed on a set in .
Definition 6.4. Ramsey shadowing- Topological definition: A dynamical system has Ramsey shadowing if for all finite open cover of , for all with the Ramsey property, any sequence can be -shadowed on a set in .
Theorem 6.1. Let be a dynamical system where is a compact metric space. The topological and metric definitions of Ramsey shadowing are equivalent.
Proof. Suppose the topological definition of Ramsey shadowing holds in . Let . Since is compact we can choose an open cover of which consists of a finite number of -balls. Pick an arbitrary Furstenberg family with the Ramsey property and an arbitrary sequence . Choose a which satisfies Definition 6.4. As we have topological Ramsey shadowing, we know that there exists a and an such that for all , there exists a such that and both belong to . Since consists of -balls, we know that . Hence the metric definition of Ramsey shadowing holds in , as is -shadowed by on .
Now we consider the case where the metric definition of Ramsey-shadowing holds. Consider a finite open cover of . Let denote the Lebesgue number of . Pick an arbitrary sequence and an arbitrary Furstenberg family with the Ramsey property. Choose which satisfies Definition 6.3. We know that there exists a and a such that for all , we have . Therefore is -shadowed on , and so also exhibits topological Ramsey shadowing.
:::
Theorem 6.2. Suppose is a factor map from to . We will show that if has Ramsey shadowing, then so does
Proof. Fix an open cover of . Let be an open cover of such that if and , there exist such that . Let be an open cover of such that refines .
Let . Let be arbitrary with the Ramsey property. Let be the sequence defined by . By Ramsey shadowing we know that is -shadowed by a point on some . We note that certainly -shadows on . From now on we assume the subscript is on . But then and belong to some . But also and also belong to some , hence and is non empty so by construction we must have that and belong to some . But note that . And so -shadows on .
:::
Theorem 6.3. If the hyperspace has Ramsey shadowing then so does the .
Proof. Let . Let be an arbitrary Furstenberg family with the Ramsey property. Consider an arbitrary sequence . Now consider the sets . These are compact sets hence belong to . Since the hyperspace has Ramsey shadowing we know that there exist a compact set which -shadows on a set in . But then by the definition of Hausdorff distance we see that any element of must shadow on . Hence has Ramsey shadowing.
Theorem 6.4. The inverse limit of a sequence of dynamical systems, each exhibiting the Ramsey shadowing property and satisfying the Mittag-Leffler condition, also has the Ramsey shadowing property.
Proof. Suppose is conjugate to the inverse limit system where each has the Ramsey shadowing property. Let be a finite open cover of . Let be a Furstenberg family with the Ramsey property. We can find a and a finite open cover of such that the refine .
Using the Mittag-Leffler condition we know there exists a which satisfies the condition with respect to . . Let be an arbitrary sequence of point in . This means that is a sequence of points in . Hence we know that there exists a point which -shadows on it on some . Hence it follows that -shadows on .
Note that we have that
And so, using the Mittag-Leffler condition we know there exists an such that . And so we must have that . Hence is -shadowed on . But since refines , we must also have that is -shadowed on .
Ergodic Shadowing
Definition 7.1. Ergodic pseudo-orbit - Metric Definition:
Let . Let be a sequence. Let . Let . Let and . We call a -ergodic pseudo orbit provided that
We say that a -ergodic pseudo orbit is -ergodic shadowed by a point provided that
Definition 7.2. Ergodic pseudo-orbit - Topological definition:
Let , we call a -ergodic pseudo-orbit if:
Definition 7.3. Ergodic shadowing - Metric definition:
We say the dynamical system has ergodic-shadowing if for all , there exists such that if is a -ergodic pseudo orbit, then it is ergodic shadowed by a point .
Ergodic shadowing was introduced in [6], and has shown itself to be closely linked to various notions of mixing. In fact, in [6], they showed that ergodic shadowing was equivalent to having both the normal shadowing property as well as topological mixing.
Definition 7.4. Ergodic shadowing- Topological definition: A dynamical system has ergodic shadowing if for all , there exists a such that for all ergodic -pseudo orbits, we can find a such that:
As in the previous cases, the metric and topological definitions of the Ergodic shadowing can be shown to be equivalent. We omit the proof, as it follows essentially the same arguments as before.
Definition 7.5. Ergodic Lifting Property (ELP) - Topological definition:
We say a factor map has ELP if for all and for all , there exists , such that if is a -ergodic pseudo orbit, there exists a -ergodic pseudo orbit in such that:
Definition 7.6. Ergodic Lifting Property (ELP) - Metric definition:
We say the dynamical system has ELP if for all and for all , there exists , such that if -ergodic pseudo orbit, there exists a -ergodic pseudo orbit in such that:
Theorem 7.1. Suppose is a factor map from to . We will prove that if has ergodic shadowing, then must have ELP.
Proof. Let and . Choose , such that satisfies ergodic shadowing with respect to . Let be a -ergodic pseudo orbit. We know it is -ergodic shadowed by a point say .
So we must have that
Take and consider the sequence given by its orbit . This is clearly a -ergodic pseudo orbit. And by semi-conjugacy we know that when . And since -ergodic shadows we know that:
Hence must have ELP.
:::
Theorem 7.2. Let and be two dynamical systems. suppose has ergodic shadowing and has ELP, then has ergodic shadowing.
Proof. Fix an open cover of . Let be an open cover of such that if and , there exist such that . Let be an open cover of such that refines . Since has ergodic-shadowing, let be an open cover that satisfies this with respect to . Since has ELP let respect it with regards to and .
Let be a -ergodic pseudo orbit. Let be the -ergodic pseudo orbit in that satisfies ELP. By ergodic-shadowing we know that is -shadowed by a point , in such a way that:
But by the ELP property we note that -shadows in such a way that:
Since refines , we know that whenever and belong the same , then and must also belong to some .
We want to show that:
Let . We know there exists such that for all :
and
We note that Hence we must have that:
Hence: .
But then . And so -ergodic shadows , hence we have ergodic shadowing.
Theorem 7.3. If the hyperspace has ergodic shadowing then so does the .
Proof. Let . Choose such that has ergodic shadowing. Now consider a -ergodic pseudo orbit in , . Now consider the sets . These are compact sets hence belong to . Since the hyperspace has ergodic-shadowing we know that there exist a compact set such that:
But then by the definition of Hausdorff distance we see that any element of must satisfy:
Hence also has ergodic shadowing.
Density shadowing
Definition 8.1. d-shadowing- Metric definition :
We say the dynamical system has d-shadowing if for all , there exists such that if is a -ergodic pseudo orbit, then there is a point such that:
Density shadowing was introduced in [7] and has been shown to be a useful tool in the study of equicontinuity and transitivity [14].
Definition 8.2. d-shadowing- Topological definition: A dynamical system has d shadowing if for all , there exists a such that for all ergodic -pseudo orbits, we can find a such that:
Theorem 8.1. Let be a dynamical system where is a compact metric space. The topological and metric definitions of density shadowing are equivalent.
Proof. Suppose the topological definition of Density-shadowing holds in . Let . Since is compact we can choose an open cover of which consists of a finite number of balls. Choose which satisfies Definition 8.2 with respect to . Let denote the Lebesgue number of .
. .
Let be a -ergodic pseudo orbit. Then . Pick , then there is no such that . As is the Lebesgue number of this implies that and so . Hence and so this ergodic pseudo orbit is also a -ergodic pseudo orbit. Choose a which satisfies Definition 8.2. As we have topological density-shadowing, we know that
Since consists of -balls, we know that whenever we must also have that . Hence , and the metric definition of density shadowing also holds.
Now we consider the case where the metric definition of density shadowing holds. Consider an finite open cover of . Let denote the Lebesgue number of . Choose which satisfies Definition 8.1 with respect to . As is compact we can choose a finite open cover of which consists of -balls. Let be a ergodic pseudo orbit. Then . As consists of -balls, clearly . By taking complements we see that , and so . Hence also a -ergodic pseudo orbit. Choose which satisfies Definition 8.1. Then . As is the Lebesgue number of , we know that whenever we must also have that for some . This implies that and so also exhibits topological -shadowing.
Theorem 8.2. If the hyperspace has -shadowing then so does the .
Proof. Let . Choose such that has -shadowing. Consider an ergodic pseudo orbit . Now consider the sets These are compact sets hence belong to . Since the hyperspace has -shadowing we know that there exist a compact set such that:
But then by the definition of Hausdorff distance we see that any element of must satisfy:
Hence has -shadowing.
Theorem 8.3. The inverse limit of a sequence of dynamical systems, each exhibiting -shadowing and also satisfying the Mittag-Leffler condition, also has shadowing.
Proof. Suppose is conjugate to the inverse limit system where each has the shadowing property. Let be a finite open cover of . We can find a and a finite open cover of such that the refine .
Using the Mittag-Leffler condition we know there exists a which satisfies the condition with respect to . Consider the open cover of given by . Since has -shadowing, let be the open cover that satisfies the definition. Let . Let be an ergodic -pseudo orbit sequence in , which is given by the sequence . This means that is an ergodic -pseudo orbit in with sequence . Since has -shadowing we know that there exists an point such that:
Hence it follows that satisfies:
Let denotes the values for which . Note that we have that .
And so, using the Mittag-Leffler condition we know there exists an such that . And so we must have that for .
Hence is -shadowed. But since refines , we must also have that is -shadowed.
Acknowledgments
The first author, Bura, is thankful to EPSRC grants EP/S02297X/1 for financial support during the development of this article.
References
- [1]Dmitri V. Anosov. Geodesic flows on closed Riemannian manifolds with negative curvature, volume 90 of Proceedings of the Steklov Institute of Mathematics. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1969. Translation of the 1967 Russian original.
- [2]Andrew D. Barwell, Chris Good, Piotr Op̨rocha, and Brian E. Raines. Characterizations of ω-limit sets in topologically hyperbolic systems. Discrete & Continuous Dynamical Systems, 33(5):1819–1833, 2013.DOI
- [3]Rufus Bowen. ω-limit sets for axiom a diffeomorphisms. Journal of Differential Equations, 18(2):333–339, 1975.DOI
- [4]W. R. Brian. Ramsey shadowing and minimal points. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society, 144(6):2697–2703, 2016.DOI
- [5]Jifeng Chu, Zhaosheng Feng, and Ming Li. Periodic shadowing of vector fields. Discrete & Continuous Dynamical Systems, 36(7):3623–3638, 2016.DOI
- [6]A. Fakhari and F. H. Ghane. On shadowing: Ordinary and ergodic. Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, 364(1):151–155, 2010.DOI
- [7]A. Fakhari and F. H. Ghane. Subshadowings. Nonlinear Analysis: Theory, Methods & Applications, 72(9-10):3759–3766, 2010.
- [8]C. Good and J. Meddaugh. Shifts of finite type as fundamental objects in the theory of shadowing. Invent. math., 220:715–736, 2020.arxiv.org/abs/1702.05170
- [9]Chris Good, Joel Mitchell, and Joe Thomas. Preservation of shadowing in discrete dynamical systems. Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, 485(1):123767, 2020.DOI
- [11]Keonhee Lee. Continuous inverse shadowing and hyperbolicity. Bulletin of the Australian Mathematical Society, 79(2):315–323, 2009.
- [12]Alexey V. Osipov, Sergei Yu. Pilyugin, and Sergey B. Tikhomirov. Periodic shadowing and ω-stability. Regular and Chaotic Dynamics, 15(4):404–417, 2010.DOI
- [13]S. Yu. Pilyugin. Inverse shadowing by continuous methods. Discrete and Continuous Dynamical Systems, 8(1):29–38, 2002.DOI
- [14]Xinxing Wu, Piotr Oprocha, and Guanrong Chen. On various definitions of shadowing with average error in tracing. Nonlinearity, 29(7):1942–1972, 2014.arxiv.org/abs/1406.5822