betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Reactor Antineutrino Spectral "Bump": Cumulative Fission Yields of Irradiated U-235 and Pu-239 Measured by HPGe Gamma-Ray Spectroscopy

Abstract

Recent measurements of the reactor antineutrino emission show that there exists a spectral excess (the "bump") in the 5-7 MeV region when compared to the Huber-Muller prediction based on the conversion method. Analysis within an alternate prediction technique, the summation method, suggests that the bump could be due to excess contributions from a certain few of the beta-decaying fission products. However, it has been shown that when updated fission yield values are used in the summation method, the predicted excess vanishes. In the present preliminary study, fission yields for nuclides suspected of causing the neutrino spectral bump are investigated using gamma-ray spectroscopy of U-235 and Pu-239 samples freshly irradiated using the High Flux Isotope Reactor. For several of the suspect nuclides, the derived fission yields are consistent with JEFF3.3 fission yield library. The exception is the case of Cs-140 from Pu-239, where the discrepancy between the fitted and expected values suggests a potential error in the fission yield library. This highlights the importance of using accurate nuclear data libraries in the analysis of the reactor antineutrino spectra, and the need for ongoing efforts to improve these libraries.

Introduction

Nuclear reactors are intense sources of electron antineutrinos, and are therefore widely used to study the complex properties of these intriguing particles. From one fission, approximately 6 νˉe\bar{\nu}_{e} are produced, and a 1 GW thermal reactor emits about 102010^{20} νˉe\bar{\nu}_{e} per second [1]. Fission fragments are neutron-rich, resulting in β\beta decays. Recent large-scale anti-neutrino spectral measurements [2, 3] show that there is a spectral bump in the 5 to 7 MeV region of νˉe\bar{\nu}_{e} that is not predicted by the β\beta-conversion method of predicting the expected neutrino spectrum from measured beta spectra (Huber-Muller method). The aggregated beta spectrum is made up of thousands of decay channels with different end point beta energies. Conversion to an antineutrino spectrum is performed by fitting the measured electron spectrum with a superposition of 30 end-point beta energies and using the kinematics of β\beta-decay to obtain the corresponding neutrino spectra [4].

In the summation method, an alternate approach is used to evaluate the νˉe\bar{\nu}_{e} spectrum. Nuclear data files such as Evaluated Nuclear Data File (ENDF) library and Joint Evaluated Fission and Fusion File (JEFF) library are used to estimate the associated neutrino spectrum using all the relevant tabulated fission yields and β\beta-decay parameters. Based on the ENDF/B-VII library, the summation method suggests that the spectral bump could be due to yields in excess of the eight particular β\beta-decaying fission products, which give a combined 42% of the total decay rate in the β\beta-energy region of 4 to 6 MeV (νˉe\bar{\nu}_{e} energy region of 5 to 7 MeV) [5]. Table I lists the same eight fission products discussed in Ref. [5] as the primary contributors to the spectral bump.

IsotopeHalf life (s)Gamma Energy (keV)Intensity
93Rb^{93}\mathrm{Rb}5.84(2)432.61(3)0.202(14)
100Nb^{100}\mathrm{Nb}1.4(2)535.666(14)0.46(6)
140Cs^{140}\mathrm{Cs}63.7(3)602.25(5)0.53(3)
95Sr^{95}\mathrm{Sr}23.90(14)685.60.226
92Rb^{92}\mathrm{Rb}4.49(3)814.98(3)0.032(4)
96Y^{96}\mathrm{Y}5.34(5)1750.4(2)0.0235(24)
97Y^{97}\mathrm{Y}3.75(3)3287.6(4)0.181(19)
142Cs^{142}\mathrm{Cs}1.68(14)359.598(14)0.27(3)

Table I. Decay data for 8 nuclides singled out in Ref. [5] from the ENDF/B-VIII decay data sublibrary, including the decay chain gamma-ray with the strongest intensity selected for the present analysis. Uncertainty is given in the parenthesis.

In a follow-up study, Sonzogni et al.[6] demonstrate that reproduction of the bump based on the summation method is due to errors in the fission yield values contained in ENDF/B-VII library. When corrected and improved fission yield values are used, no excess contributions from the eight nuclides are observed. In the present work, fission is induced in 235U^{235}\mathrm{U} and 239Pu^{239}\mathrm{Pu} samples by neutron irradiation in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR), and the resulting gamma-ray spectra are measured by a high purity germanium (HPGe) detector after rapid transport out of the core. The measured spectra are compared to predictions based on data from JEFF3.3 fission yield library and the ENDF/B-VIII decay data sublibrary.

Experiment

The 235U^{235}\mathrm{U} sample consists of 252.72 nanograms of natural uranium nitrate in an Inductively Coupled Plasma calibration solution. The 239Pu^{239}\mathrm{Pu} sample consists of 301.3 nanogram of National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Certified Reference Material (CRM-137). The samples are irradiated using the PT-2 pneumatic tube of the HFIR at the Neutron Activation Analysis laboratory (NAA) of Oak Ridge national Laboratory. The measured thermal and epithermal neutron fluxes at the irradiation location are 4.59×10134.59 \times10^{13} n/cm2^{2}/sec and 1.96×10111.96 \times10^{11} n/cm2^{2}/sec respectively for 235U^{235}\mathrm{U}, and 4.43×10134.43 \times10^{13} n/cm2^{2}/sec and 3.24×10113.24 \times10^{11} n/cm2^{2}/sec respectively for 239Pu^{239}\mathrm{Pu}. The neutron fluxes are measured using manganese and gold activation foils.

Each sample is irradiated for 30 seconds, and then transported to the detector chamber using the pneumatic tube transfer system [7] which introduces a 20-second delay prior to the gamma-ray measurement. This delay is problematic for the short-lived 97Y^{97}\mathrm{Y} and 142Cs^{142}\mathrm{Cs}. Future work is planned to reduce the delay and improve detection sensitivity. Figure 1 shows the measured gamma-ray spectra of the irradiated 235U^{235}\mathrm{U} and 239Pu^{239}\mathrm{Pu}.

Figure 1. Measured gamma-ray spectra from freshly irradiated 235U^{235}\mathrm{U} and 239Pu^{239}\mathrm{Pu} are plotted. See text for details.

The gamma rays are measured with a 44% relative efficiency, ORTEC p-type coaxial HPGe detector with an aluminum end cap. Each sample is placed at 33 cm above the detector and measured for 30 seconds. For the analysis presented in this work, only the β\beta-decay path for the parent-daughter chains is used, neglecting β\beta-delayed neutron emission channels.

Calculated gamma rays

The expected gamma-ray yield calculation starts by determining the number of 235U^{235}\mathrm{U} and 239Pu^{239}\mathrm{Pu} nuclides initially present in the sample from the sample mass (mm), Avogadro’s number (NAN_A) and the molar weight (MM). Total fission production and decay of the gamma emitter during the irradiation (NfdN_{\mathrm{fd}}) is determined using Eq. (1).

Nfd=IFY σf ϕ mNAM(1−e−λt)(1)N_{\mathrm{fd}}=\mathrm{IFY}\,\sigma_f\,\phi\,\frac{mN_A}{M}\left(1-e^{-\lambda t}\right) \tag*{(1)}

The equation includes the independent fission yield (IFY) of a specific nuclide, the thermal neutron cross section (σf\sigma_f) and the thermal neutron flux (ϕ\phi) and the irradiation [8]. The IFY is obtained from the JEFF3.3 library, and the neutron cross section is based on the ENDF/B-VIII.0 neutron cross section standard sublibrary. The JEFF3.3 and ENDF/B-VIII.0 fission yield libraries contain different IFY values for certain nuclides. This is demonstrated using the 140Cs^{140}\mathrm{Cs} decay chain in Table II. In this example, JEFF3.3 does not have IFY for 140Sb^{140}\mathrm{Sb}, so the IFY value from ENDF/B-VIII.0 is used instead in our analysis. Thus, NfdN_{\mathrm{fd}} will be different depending on the fission library used.

In addition, NfdN_{\mathrm{fd}} of each precursor of the gamma emitter needs to be determined and β\beta-decayed to properly account for the total number of the gamma emitter produced at the end of the irradiation. Cumulative yield (CY) used in this study is described in Eq. (2).

CYi=[Nfd]i+∑ijDecay([Nfd]j)(2)CY_i=[N_{\mathrm{fd}}]_i+\sum_{ij}Decay([N_{\mathrm{fd}}]_j) \tag*{(2)}

The second term describes the total number of ii gamma emitter resulting from the β\beta-decay of jthj^{\mathrm{th}} precursor of ii gamma emitter. Each decay chain leading from primary fission products to a gamma ray emitter measured in this study is described by a set of coupled linear differential equations describing the radioactive decays. These equations are reformulated as a set of matrices and solved using Matlab. The solution to each decay chain gives the number of gamma emitter resulting from the decay of its precursors during the 30-second irradiation. Resulting total CY is further decayed for 20 seconds modeling the RABBIT transportation delay.

Expected gamma-ray yields during the subsequent (delayed) 30-second measurement time are calculated as factors of the decayed CY, decay constant (λ\lambda), absolute efficiency (ϵ\epsilon) of the HPGe, and the gamma emission intensity (IγI_\gamma). The yield calculation is aided by Radiation Intensity Calculator (RadICal), a python-based application developed by Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) researchers [9]. Its solutions are built on Laplace transform of the Bateman equation.

The half lives of the nuclides investigated here are much shorter than the detector measurement time, therefore, it is necessary to decay-correct the measured peak counts for the count time. The ANSI standard for the correction factor is described in Ref.[10]. The largest uncertainty contribution comes from the uncertainties associated with IFY. The relative uncertainty [11] of IFY from each nuclides is: 93Rb^{93}\mathrm{Rb}(18%), 100Nb^{100}\mathrm{Nb}(35%), 140Cs^{140}\mathrm{Cs}(24%), 95Sr^{95}\mathrm{Sr}(10%), 92Rb^{92}\mathrm{Rb}(18%), 96Y^{96}\mathrm{Y}(24%), 97Y^{97}\mathrm{Y}(15%) and 142Cs^{142}\mathrm{Cs}(20%).

IFY (235U^{235}\mathrm{U})140Sb^{140}\mathrm{Sb}140Te^{140}\mathrm{Te}140I^{140}\mathrm{I}140Xe^{140}\mathrm{Xe}140Cs^{140}\mathrm{Cs}
JEFF3.3No data6.57E-08 (2.26E-08)3.03E-04 (1.03E-04)1.25E-02 (3.10E-03)1.84E-02 (3.85E-03)
ENDF/B-VIII.02.82E-09 (1.81E-09)9.04E-06 (5.78E-06)1.11E-03 (7.13E-04)2.59E-02 (1.04E-03)3.05E-02 (1.83E-03)
IFY (239Pu^{239}\mathrm{Pu})140Sb^{140}\mathrm{Sb}140Te^{140}\mathrm{Te}140I^{140}\mathrm{I}140Xe^{140}\mathrm{Xe}140Cs^{140}\mathrm{Cs}
JEFF3.3No data2.33E-07 (8.06E-08)4.77E-04 (1.63E-04)1.83E-02 (4.06E-03)2.18E-02 (4.52E-03)
ENDF/B-VIII.05.61E-11 (3.59E-11)1.41E-06 (9.02E-07)5.94E-04 (3.80E-04)1.54E-02 (4.31E-04)2.28E-02 (3.64E-03)

Table 2. Examples from the 140^{140}Cs decay chain, showing the differing IFY of 235^{235}U and 239^{239}Pu from JEFF3.3 and ENDF/B-VIII.0 fission yield libraries. Uncertainty of each IFY is indicated in the parenthesis.

Measured gamma rays

The energy and full width at half maximum (FWHM) calibrations of the HPGe detector have previously been determined by analyzing known gamma ray peaks. The absolute efficiency of the detector is estimated using the Geometry and Tracking[12] simulation package. In the simulation, 17 gamma ray energies are selected to cover the energy range from 50 keV to 3.5 MeV. Each gamma-ray simulation was performed using 1E+6 photons to determine the efficiency of the detector at each photon energy. The detector model in GEANT4 includes all the details of detector construction, including a 0.1 cm thick aluminum window on the endcap of the detector and a 0.07 cm thick dead layer on the surface of the HPGe crystal. Dimensions of the HPGe were taken to be 6.5 cm in the diameter and 6.45 cm in the length based on published ORTEC documents[13]. According to the ANSI/IEEE standard 325[14], the relative efficiency of an HPGe is defined by Eq. (3). The absolute efficiency of HPGe at 1.33 MeV is measured with a source to detector distance of 25 cm. The relative efficiency is the ratio of this HPGe absolute efficiency to the absolute efficiency of a 3-inch by 3-inch Na(Tl) at 1.33 MeV measured at 25 cm (1.2E-3).

Relative efficiency=Absolute efficiency1.2×10−3(3)\mathrm{Relative\ efficiency} = \frac{\mathrm{Absolute\ efficiency}}{1.2 \times10^{-3}} \tag*{(3)}

To establish a benchmark, a GEANT4 simulation was performed for a point source placed at the standard distance of 25 cm from the detector. The absolute efficiency at 1333 keV was expected to be 5.3E-4 for a 44% relative efficient HPGe[15]. The simulated absolute efficiency was 5.9E-4 (7.7E-5). Figure 2 shows the simulated detector efficiency. The efficiency is fitted using the parametric equation given in the RADWARE software package[16]. Above 150 keV, efficiency is fitted with the parameters (D, E and F) in the form of:

Figure 2. GEANT4 simulated efficiency for the ORTEC P-type 44% relative efficiency HPGe detector used here. The efficiency is fitted using the parametric equation given in the RADWARE program.

Efficiency=eD+Ey+Fy2(4)\mathrm{Efficiency} = e^{D+Ey+Fy^{2}} \tag*{(4)}

where y=ln⁡(Eγ/1000)y = \ln(E_{\gamma}/1000) and EγE_{\gamma} is a gamma-ray energy in keV.

Peaks were analyzed from the measured energy spectra using two methods: non-linear fitting and a simple summation. The ANSI standard for the summation method is given in [10, 17, 18], and the detailed explanation is given in [19, 20]. The fit function was a combination of a Gaussian and a linear continuum. Fit analysis was performed using GF3M program from the RADWARE package[16] and an open-source software, GNUPLOT

[21]. Details for the fitting method are described in the references. Figure 3 and Figure 4 show the data and fits for fission product gamma-ray peaks of interest resulting from neutron irradiation of 235^{235}U and 239^{239}Pu, respectively. Table III and Table IV summarize the fitting statistics of 235^{235}U and 239^{239}Pu.

Figure 3. Data and fits for the six gamma-ray peaks of interest from 235^{235}U fission are shown. The measured spectra are shown by the circled dots with 1-σ\sigma uncertainties, and the fits by solid lines. Due to low yield, environmental backgrounds, and Compton scattering from higher energy photons, gamma ray peaks from 97^{97}Y and 142^{142}Cs are not detectable, and omitted in this figure.

235U{}^{235}\mathrm{U}χ2\chi^2 /DOFCalibrated CentroidFitted CentroidCalibrated FWHMFitted FWHMp-value
140Cs{}^{140}\mathrm{Cs}1.63602.33602.28(4)1.932.87(8)0.05
95Sr{}^{95}\mathrm{Sr}1.43685.57685.43(6)2.012.50(11)0.03
100Nb{}^{100}\mathrm{Nb}1.26535.61535.4(3)1.872.4(10)0.02
93Rb{}^{93}\mathrm{Rb}1.21432.67430.38(15)1.763.4(3)< 0.01
92Rb{}^{92}\mathrm{Rb}2.26814.98814.6(5)2.121.1(12)< 0.01
96Y{}^{96}\mathrm{Y}1.621750.501749.4(3)2.731.9(6)< 0.01

Table III. Best-fit values and fitting statistics for the fission products from 235U{}^{235}\mathrm{U} are summarized. Fitted energies are consistent with the calibrated energies. But fitted FWHMs show some divergence. The fit statistics (p-values) indicate acceptable fits for 100Nb{}^{100}\mathrm{Nb}, 140Cs{}^{140}\mathrm{Cs} and 95Sr{}^{95}\mathrm{Sr}. (see Results section for detail).

239Pu{}^{239}\mathrm{Pu}χ2\chi^2 /DOFCalibrated CentroidFitted CentroidCalibrated FWHMFitted FWHMp-value
140Cs{}^{140}\mathrm{Cs}1.90602.33602.03(5)1.933.41(11)< 0.01
95Sr{}^{95}\mathrm{Sr}1.37685.57685.45(6)2.012.41(11)< 0.01
100Nb{}^{100}\mathrm{Nb}2.74535.61534.75(10)1.872.09(23)< 0.01
93Rb{}^{93}\mathrm{Rb}2.92432.68434(10)1.765(18)< 0.01
92Rb{}^{92}\mathrm{Rb}1.89814.96815.4(3)2.121.9(10)< 0.01
96Y{}^{96}\mathrm{Y}1.91750.501750.19(13)2.732.23(23)< 0.01

Table IV. Best-fit values and fitting statistics for the fission products from 239Pu{}^{239}\mathrm{Pu} are summarized. Similar to the case of 235U{}^{235}\mathrm{U}, fitted energies are consistent with the calibrated energies while fitted FWHMs show some divergence. Unlike 235U{}^{235}\mathrm{U}, the fit statistics (p-values) indicate poor fit quality for 100Nb{}^{100}\mathrm{Nb}, 140Cs{}^{140}\mathrm{Cs} and 95Sr{}^{95}\mathrm{Sr} due to interference from other gamma rays. (see Results section for detail).

Figure 4. Data and fits for the six gamma-ray peaks of interest from 239^{239}Pu are shown. The measured spectra are shown by the circled dots with 11-σ\sigma uncertainties, and the fits by solid lines. Due to low yield, environmental backgrounds, and Compton scattering from higher energy photons, gamma ray peaks from 97^{97}Y and 142^{142}Cs are not detectable, and omitted in this figure.

In general, the fitted peak energies are consistent with tabulated values for both 235^{235}U and 239^{239}Pu. However, the p-values suggest that a single Gaussian may be a poor model for some peaks, likely indicating interference from additional unidentified gamma rays. This could be clarified with greatly improved statistics. As shown in Figure 1, 239^{239}Pu generates generally more gamma-ray activities than 235^{235}U, suggesting more interference. This fact appears to be consistent with all p-values being lower for 239^{239}Pu compared to 235^{235}U.

Results

For each gamma-ray, the statistical significance is determined using the method of Refs. [17, 19, 20]. This method involves two statistical limits: Lc and Ld. The critical limit (Lc) is defined as the net count of a gamma ray peak above which a sample net count is statistically significant with the probability of false positive given by α\alpha. The detection limit (Ld) is defined as the net count of a gamma ray peak above Lc that has a probability of false negative given by β\beta. We adopt the usual convention of using α=β=0.05\alpha= \beta= 0.05 as the desired level of statistical

significance. We note that the statistics in this method are based on a one-sided 95% confidence level so that the z statistic cutoff is 1.65, not 1.96. For the non-linear fitting method, Lc and Ld are given by Eq. (5) and Eq. (6) where σ=B\sigma= \sqrt{B} and B = background count (no sample is present) respectively [19].

Lc=2.33σ(5)L_c = 2.33 \sigma \tag*{(5)}
Ld=2.71+4.65σ(6)L_d = 2.71 + 4.65 \sigma \tag*{(6)}

Due to low yield, environmental backgrounds, and Compton scattering from higher energy photons, gamma ray peaks from 97^{97}Y and 142^{142}Cs are not detectable in the present data. A follow-on experiment is under consideration, using larger sample sizes and a shorter RABBIT transit time. For 93^{93}Rb, 92^{92}Rb and 96^{96}Y, the fitted net counts are much larger than the expected. This is suspected to be mainly due to interference from other gamma rays. When fitted net counts are adjusted appropriately to account for interference, they are shown to be consistent with the expected net count. However, the results are below the statistical significance and are inconclusive.

The contribution from interference is estimated as described below. For 93Rb{}^{93}\mathrm{Rb}, 6 nuclides (A = 90, 134, 138, 143, 144, 145) produce a similar or larger order of magnitude of gamma-ray yield (Iγ×I_\gamma\times total fission yield) in the 432 keV region in our data [9, 22]. Based on the estimate of the gamma rays having a measurable effect, the proportion of gamma-ray yield of 93Rb{}^{93}\mathrm{Rb} with respect to the 6 nuclides gives about 6% which is consistent with the expected net count of 93Rb{}^{93}\mathrm{Rb}. In addition, 93Rb{}^{93}\mathrm{Rb} (432.61 KeV, IγI_\gamma = 0.202) and 143Ba{}^{143}\mathrm{Ba} (431.2 KeV, IγI_\gamma = 0.0276) are expected to produce approximately the same number of counts in our data. The 431.2 keV gamma-ray peak was fitted to obtain its net count which shows consistency with 93Rb{}^{93}\mathrm{Rb}. As for 92Rb{}^{92}\mathrm{Rb}, 13 nuclides (A = 82, 91, 92, 101, 132, 133, 132, 136, 137, 139, 140, 144, 147) produce a similar or larger order of magnitude of gamma-ray yields than 92Rb{}^{92}\mathrm{Rb} in the 815 keV energy region [9, 22]. The proportion of measured peak counts from 92Rb{}^{92}\mathrm{Rb} with respect to the thirteen nuclides is about 1.4% which is consistent with the expected net count of 92Rb{}^{92}\mathrm{Rb}. For 96Y{}^{96}\mathrm{Y}, the strongest gamma ray energy is at 1750.4 KeV with IγI_\gamma = 0.0235, with interference from 96mY{}^{96m}\mathrm{Y} (1750.06 KeV, IγI_\gamma = 0.88). A proportion of gamma rays yield from 96Y{}^{96}\mathrm{Y} with respect to the total gamma rays yields from both 96Y{}^{96}\mathrm{Y} and 96mY{}^{96m}\mathrm{Y} is about 3% which is consistent with the expected net count of 96Y{}^{96}\mathrm{Y}.

Figure 5 and Figure 6 show the main results of the present study. The net peak counts, the limits (Lc and Ld), and the expected counts calculated from the JEFF3.3 fission yields and the detector simulations, are plotted vs. gamma ray energy.

Figure 5. Fitted and expected net counts and statistical limits and uncertainties for 235^{235}U. The yields of 100^{100}Nb, 140^{140}Cs and 95^{95}Sr are shown to be consistent with the expected values. 93^{93}Rb, 92^{92}Rb and 96^{96}Y are below the statistical limit of detection, and are excluded from the plot for clarity.

Figure 6. Fitted and expected net counts and statistical limits and uncertainties for 239^{239}Pu. The yields of 100^{100}Nb and 95^{95}Sr are plotted and shown to be consistent with the expected values. The fitted 140^{140}Cs is about 35% larger than the expected value, suggesting a possible problem with the JEFF3.3 fission yield library. 93^{93}Rb, 92^{92}Rb and 96^{96}Y are below the statistical limit of detection, and are excluded from the plot for clarity.

For both 235U{}^{235}\mathrm{U} and 239Pu{}^{239}\mathrm{Pu}, the measured gamma rays for 100Nb{}^{100}\mathrm{Nb} and 95Sr{}^{95}\mathrm{Sr} are statistically significant (α\alpha = 0.05), above the minimum detection limit (β\beta = 0.05), and are fully consistent with the expected counts. This indicates that the independent fission yield from JEFF3.3 fission yield library and gamma-ray intensity from ENDF/B-VIII.0 decay data sublibrary are reliable for these nuclides. For 140Cs{}^{140}\mathrm{Cs}, the measured gamma ray yield is statistically significant, and for the case of 235U{}^{235}\mathrm{U} its value is consistent with that expected. But for the case of 239Pu{}^{239}\mathrm{Pu}, the measured count is 35% larger than the expected value. This suggests a possible problem with the fission yield value in JEFF3.3, which should be confirmed by a follow-up study. A possible complication for the present type of measurement was pointed out by Hayes et al. [1] in the form of a potential contribution from epithermal neutron induced fission. The measured epithermal neutron flux at HFIR for this study is 0.4% (0.7%) of the thermal neutron flux for 235U{}^{235}\mathrm{U} (239Pu{}^{239}\mathrm{Pu}). In this analysis, the contribution from epithermal neutrons is too low to make any significant difference in the data. The role of epithermal neutrons should be further investigated in an actual reactor environment where the fuel composition is precisely known.

Conclusion

The summation method [4] used to estimate the νˉe\bar{\nu}_e spectrum analysis depends on accurate data values in the nuclear libraries. To check the fission yield library values, 235^{235}U and 239^{239}Pu samples are irradiated using HFIR, and gamma-ray spectroscopy is used evaluate the gamma-rays from 8 short-lived fission products which were suggested[5] as a possible source of the spectral bump in the reactor neutrino spectrum at the 5 to 7 MeV region .

The gamma ray yields for 100^{100}Nb and 95^{95}Sr from both 235^{235}U and 239^{239}Pu, as well as 140^{140}Cs from 235^{235}U are found to be statistically significant and consistent with expectation based on the JEFF3.3 fission yield library. However, an inconsistent result was found for 140^{140}Cs from 239^{239}Pu, which suggests that the JEFF3.3 fission yield value for this nuclide may be incorrect.

The results for remaining fission products are inconclusive due to insufficient statistics. A follow-on experiment with increased sample sizes and a faster reactor-to-counting station transfer is in discussion. Overall, the present study underscores the importance of continuous improvement and refinement of nuclear data libraries. Additional experimental data and continued analysis of

existing data are important for verifying and improving fission yield values.

Acknowledgments

Authors would like to thank A. Sonzogni and E. Mc-Cutchan for valuable comments. This work was funded by the U. S. National Science Foundation under grant NSF-PHY1242611, NSF-1812504, 1747523, and 1314483. The work at Brookhaven National Laboratory was sponsored by the Office of Nuclear Physics, Office of Science of the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC02-98CH10886 with Brookhaven Science Associates, LLC.

References

References

  1. [1]A. C. Hayes and P. Vogel, Reactor neutrino spectra, Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science 66, 219 (2016).DOI
  2. [2]S. B. Kim, New results from reno and prospects with reno-50, Nuclear and Particle Physics Proceedings 265-266, 93 (2015), proceedings of the Neutrino Oscillation Workshop.arxiv.org/abs/1412.2199
  3. [3]Y. Abe, C. Aberle, T. Akiri, J. Dos Anjos, F. Ardellier, A. Barbosa, A. Baxter, M. Bergevin, A. Bernstein, T. Bezerra, et al., Indication of reactor νe disappearance in the double chooz experiment, Physical Review Letters 108, 131801 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22540693
  4. [4]T. A. Mueller, D. Lhuillier, M. Fallot, A. Letourneau, S. Cormon, M. Fechner, L. Giot, T. Lasserre, J. Martino, G. Mention, A. Porta, and F. Yermia, Improved predictions of reactor antineutrino spectra, Physical Review C 83, 054615 (2011).DOI
  5. [5]D. Dwyer and T. Langford, Spectral structure of electron antineutrinos from nuclear reactors, Physical review letters 114, 012502 (2015).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25615462
  6. [6]A. Sonzogni, E. McCutchan, T. Johnson, and P. Dimitriou, Effects of fission yield data in the calculation of antineutrino spectra for U-235 (n, fission) at thermal and fast neutron energies, Physical review letters 116, 132502 (2016).DOI
  7. [7]ORNL, High flux isotope reactor (HFIR) user guide to in-vessel irradiations and experiments (2015).
  8. [8]J. Knowles, S. Skutnik, D. Glasgow, and R. Kapsimalis, A generalized method for characterization of 235U and 239Pu content using short-lived fission product gamma spectroscopy, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 833, 38 (2016).DOI
  9. [9]J. W. Robinson, M. P. Dion, G. C. Eiden, O. T. Farmer, and M. Liezer, Radical: a program for estimating radiation intensity of radionuclide mixtures, Journal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry 303, 1955 (2015).DOI
  10. [10]American national standard for calibration and use of germanium spectrometers for the measurement of gamma-ray emission rates of radionuclides, ANSI N42.14-1999 (1999).
  11. [11]J. Taylor, Introduction to error analysis, the study of uncertainties in physical measurements (1997).DOI
  12. [12]S. Agostinelli et al., Geant4–a simulation toolkit, Nucl.Instrum.Meth. A506, 250 (2003).DOI
  13. [13]E. G. Roth, HPGe detectors at ORTEC/AMETEK 12 (Ortec, 2018).
  14. [14]E. Fairstein, S. Wagner, et al., IEEE standard test procedures for germanium gamma-ray detectors, IEEE std 325–1996 (1996).
  15. [15]ORTEC, Overview of Semiconductor Photon Detectors (Ortec).
  16. [16]D. Radford, Radware software package (2011).
  17. [17]Multi-agency radiological laboratory analytical protocols manual, EPA 402-B-17-001 III (2004).
  18. [18]High resolution gamma-ray spectrometry analyses for normal operations and radiological incident response, EPA 402-B-17-001 (2019).
  19. [19]G. F. Knoll, Radiation detection and measurement JOHN WILEY & SONS (John Wiley & Sons, 2000).
  20. [20]G. Gilmore, Practical gamma-ray spectroscopy (John Wiley & Sons, 2008).
  21. [21]T. Williams, C. Kelley, R. Lang, D. Kotz, and J. Campbell, gnuplot, (2004).
  22. [22]A. G. Croff, ORIGEN2: a revised and updated version of the oak ridge isotope generation and depletion code https://doi.org/10.2172/5352089 (1980).

Paper details

vlnc:W_g5gqc7cj
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents