betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Flow birefringence of cellulose nanocrystal suspensions in three-dimensional flow fields: revisiting the stress-optic law

Abstract

This study systematically investigates the flow birefringence of cellulose nanocrystal (CNC) suspensions. The aim is to clarify the importance of the stress component along the camera's optical axis in the stress-optic law (SOL), which describes the relationship between birefringence, the retardation of transmitted polarized light, and the stress field. More than 100 datasets pertaining to the retardation of CNC suspensions (concentrations of 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, and 1.0 wt%) in a laminar flow field within a rectangular channel (aspect ratios of 0.1, 1, and 3) are systematically obtained. The measured retardation data are compared with the predictions given by the conventional SOL excluding the stress component along the camera's optical axis and by the SOL including these components as second-order terms (2nd-order SOL). The results show that the 2nd-order SOL gives a significantly better agreement with the measurements. Based on the 2nd-order SOL, the retardation at the center of the channel, where the effect of the stress component along the camera's optical axis is most pronounced, is predicted to be proportional to the square of the flow rate, which agrees with the experimental data. The results confirm the importance of considering the stress component along the camera's optical axis in the flow birefringence of CNC suspensions at high flow rates, even for quasi-two-dimensional channel flow.

Introduction

Cellulose nanocrystals (CNCs) are rod-shaped crystals with a high aspect ratio (Beck-Candanedo et al., 2005). These rigid, highly crystalline nanoparticles are made from wood and plants [16], and have characteristics including a low density and high strength [36], as well as interesting thermodynamic and rheological properties [7]. Many researchers have discussed the potential applications of such properties [37, 28, 22].

One property of CNCs that we are interested in is birefringence [19, 14]. When a suspension containing particles with a large aspect ratio, such as CNCs, is at rest, the particles within the fluid are randomly oriented, resulting in optical isotropy. As the fluid flows, the shear forces orient the particles in a preferred direction, resulting in the fluid exhibiting birefringence (Abel and Puro, 1997; Kádár et al., 2021). This birefringence property of a fluid (or flow birefringence) appears when the particles are under a mechanical force (corresponding to shear in our case) and are aligned in a uniform direction (Hausmann et al., 2018; Gregoret et al., 2021b). Flow birefringence strongly and directly depends on the stress applied to the bulk fluid; details are given in § 2.1. Therefore, quantitative measurements of flow birefringence provide a direct estimation of the fluid stress field, without the need for velocity field measurements through techniques such as particle image velocimetry.

If light is passed through a fluid while it is subject to shear-induced birefringence, the light is elliptically polarized with a retardation Δ\Delta that depends on the magnitude of the birefringence and an orientation ϕ\phi that depends on the direction of the particle. The relationship between Δ\Delta, ϕ\phi, and the stresses in the material is called the stress-optic law (SOL) [1, 35]. Using the SOL, the stress can be estimated from the retardation Δ\Delta and orientation ϕ\phi of the emitted polarized light obtained by optical measurements [34, 21, 30] (Janeschitz-Kriegl 2012). Studies using CNC suspensions have reported the applicability of the SOL in quasi-two-dimensional flow fields, such as rectangular channels, in which the channel depth is greater than the width, or in Taylor–Couette flows [23, 8, 10, 25], as a means of understanding the flow birefringence of such fluids. Studies on flow birefringence in three-dimensional flow fields are limited compared with those on two-dimensional flows.

In the three-dimensional case, previous studies have suggested that the SOL exhibits a nonlinear relationship between the retardation and stresses [26, 15, 2]. McAfee and Pih [26] observed a three-dimensional flow in a channel and stated that “the isoclinic [retardation in this paper] was dependent on shear strain rates both normal and parallel [camera’s optical axis in this paper] to the light ray”, but they did not derive the direct relation between the SOL and their observations. Doyle [15] extended the SOL to three-dimensional flows by including the stress component along the camera’s optical axis as second-order terms. This study highlighted the importance of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis, although the theory was not validated against experiments. The effect of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis in the SOL has been neglected in the birefringence of solids, i.e., photoelasticity. Aben and Puro [2] discussed the flow birefringence by referring to Doyle’s work, although their extended SOL neglected the stress component along the camera’s optical axis. Other significant works [4, 20, 31] (Clemeur et al. 2004) have also omitted the stress component along the camera’s optical axis. Thus, the influence of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis on flow birefringence has not been incorporated into many previous studies, although its importance has been identified. The negative effects of this omission seem to have been avoided by using a quasi-two-dimensional flow field,

as described above. Nevertheless, the results of several studies using quasi-two-dimensional channels highlight the discrepancies between the retardation predicted by the SOL for the two-dimensional case and the experimental data, especially in the center of the channel [20, 31, 11]. Thus, to clarify the effect of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis on flow birefringence, it is necessary to revisit the extended SOL described by Doyle [15] and verify it experimentally. To the best of the authors’ knowledge, the SOL considering the stress component along the camera’s optical axis has never been experimentally validated, although fluid flows are always strictly three-dimensional.

This study determines the effect of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis on the flow birefringence of CNC suspensions by revisiting Doyle’s SOL [15]. For this purpose, we performed systematic experiments measuring the flow birefringence of CNC suspensions in steady laminar flow in rectangular channels. The retardation field measured during the experiments was compared with that predicted by the SOL proposed by Doyle [15]. The methodology used in this study is shown in Figure 1. A steady laminar flow of a Newtonian fluid in a rectangular channel is considered because analytical solutions for the stress field are available for such cases. The aspect ratio of the rectangular channel was varied to change the stress component’s contribution along the camera’s optical axis.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Schematic of the concept of this study. The theoretical retardation field, calculated using an SOL from the analytical solution of the flow field, is compared with the experimentally obtained retardation field to verify the SOL.

Methodology: Polarization measurements in rectangular channel flow of CNC suspensions

In this section, we explain the SOL, which is the relationship between retardation and stress component. We then explain how retardation is measured and how the theoretical retardation of a fluid is calculated.

Stress-optic law

In this section, we carefully review the SOLs described by Aben and Doyle ([2, 15]). We consider which formulations include three-dimensional effects, i.e., the effect of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis, and refer to 1st-order SOLs for those that do not include the stress component along the camera’s optical axis and 2nd-order SOLs for those that do include the stress component along the camera’s optical axis.

The retardation of light causes birefringence due to the anisotropic refractive index tensor of a birefringent material when loaded by stress. The material’s refractive index is determined by the relative permittivity, also known as the dielectric constant. If zz is set as the camera’s optical axis in Cartesian coordinates, the dielectric tensor ε\boldsymbol{\varepsilon} can be written as

ε=(εxxεxyεxzεyxεyyεyzεzxεzyεzz).(1)\boldsymbol{\varepsilon} = \begin{pmatrix} \varepsilon_{xx} & \varepsilon_{xy} & \varepsilon_{xz} \\ \varepsilon_{yx} & \varepsilon_{yy} & \varepsilon_{yz} \\ \varepsilon_{zx} & \varepsilon_{zy} & \varepsilon_{zz} \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(1)}

The retardation Δ\Delta and orientation ϕ\phi of the polarized light through the material are related to the components of the dielectric tensor in Cartesian coordinates as follows ([2, 15]):

V1≡Δcos⁡2ϕ=12n0∫(εyy−εxx) dz,(2)V_{1} \equiv\Delta\cos2\phi= \frac{1}{2n_{0}} \int\left(\varepsilon_{yy} - \varepsilon_{xx}\right)\,\mathrm{d}z, \tag*{(2)}
V2≡Δsin⁡2ϕ=1n0∫εxy dz,(3)V_{2} \equiv\Delta\sin2\phi= \frac{1}{n_{0}} \int\varepsilon_{xy}\,\mathrm{d}z, \tag*{(3)}

where n0n_{0} is the initial refractive index of the material. Therefore, Δ\Delta and ϕ\phi can be expressed as

Δ=V12+V22,ϕ=12tan⁡−1V2V1.(4)\Delta= \sqrt{V_{1}^{2} + V_{2}^{2}}, \qquad\phi= \frac{1}{2}\tan^{-1}\frac{V_{2}}{V_{1}}. \tag*{(4)}

If Δ\Delta is less than λ/4\lambda/4 and the rotation of the principal stress direction does not exceed π/6\pi/6, Eqs. (2) and (3) are valid ([3, 1]). This approximation holds for the conditions considered in this study because the measured retardation is always less than λ/4\lambda/4. The optical effect is a function of the strain rate e˙jk\dot{e}_{jk} ([2, 15]):

12n0εjk=f(e˙jk).(5)\frac{1}{2n_{0}}\varepsilon_{jk} = f(\dot{e}_{jk}). \tag*{(5)}

Using the Cayley–Hamilton theorem ([2, 15]), the optical effect can be written as

12n0εjk=α0δjk+α1e˙jk+α2e˙jle˙lk,(6)\frac{1}{2n_{0}}\varepsilon_{jk} = \alpha_{0}\delta_{jk} + \alpha_{1}\dot{e}_{jk} + \alpha_{2}\dot{e}_{jl}\dot{e}_{lk}, \tag*{(6)}

where α0\alpha_{0}, α1\alpha_{1}, and α2\alpha_{2} are material-specific constants and δjk\delta_{jk} is the Kronecker delta. Here, jj, kk, and ll are Einstein’s notation indices. As described in previous studies ([2, 15]), the relationship between the retardation, orientation, and the components of the strain rate tensor can be expressed using Eqs. (2) and (3) as:

V1=Δcos⁡2ϕ=∫{α1(e˙yy−e˙xx)+α2[(e˙yy+e˙xx)(e˙xx−e˙yy)+e˙yz2−e˙xz2]} dz,(7)V_{1} = \Delta\cos2\phi= \int\left\{\alpha_{1}\left(\dot{e}_{yy}-\dot{e}_{xx}\right) + \alpha_{2}\left[\left(\dot{e}_{yy}+\dot{e}_{xx}\right)\left(\dot{e}_{xx}-\dot{e}_{yy}\right)+\dot{e}_{yz}^{2}-\dot{e}_{xz}^{2}\right]\right\}\,\mathrm{d}z, \tag*{(7)}
V2=Δsin⁡2ϕ=∫{2α1e˙xy+α2[2(e˙yy+e˙xx)e˙xy+2e˙yze˙xz]} dz.(8)V_{2} = \Delta\sin2\phi= \int\left\{2\alpha_{1}\dot{e}_{xy}+\alpha_{2}\left[2\left(\dot{e}_{yy}+\dot{e}_{xx}\right)\dot{e}_{xy}+2\dot{e}_{yz}\dot{e}_{xz}\right]\right\}\,\mathrm{d}z. \tag*{(8)}

For a Newtonian fluid, the viscous stress is proportional to the strain rate, i.e., σjk=ηe˙jk\sigma_{jk}=\eta\dot{e}_{jk}, where η\eta is the liquid viscosity. Thus, these equations become

V1=Δcos⁡2ϕ=∫{C1(σyy−σxx)+C2[(σyy+σxx)(σyy−σxx)+σyz2−σxz2]} dz,(9)V_{1} = \Delta\cos2\phi= \int\left\{C_{1}\left(\sigma_{yy}-\sigma_{xx}\right)+C_{2}\left[\left(\sigma_{yy}+\sigma_{xx}\right)\left(\sigma_{yy}-\sigma_{xx}\right)+\sigma_{yz}^{2}-\sigma_{xz}^{2}\right]\right\}\,\mathrm{d}z, \tag*{(9)}
V2=Δsin⁡2ϕ=∫{2C1σxy+C2[2(σyy+σxx)σxy+2σyzσxz]} dz.(10)V_{2} = \Delta\sin2\phi= \int\left\{2C_{1}\sigma_{xy}+C_{2}\left[2\left(\sigma_{yy}+\sigma_{xx}\right)\sigma_{xy}+2\sigma_{yz}\sigma_{xz}\right]\right\}\,\mathrm{d}z. \tag*{(10)}

Note that C1=α1/ηC_{1}=\alpha_{1}/\eta and C2=α2/η2C_{2}=\alpha_{2}/\eta^{2}.

As described in § 1, the second-order terms of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis in Eqs. (9) and (10), i.e., σxz\sigma_{xz} and σyz\sigma_{yz}, have been neglected in previous studies of flow birefringence, which assumed that C2=0C_{2}=0 ([2, 31]). This approach leads to the following well-known equations of integrated photoelasticity for solids ([1, 38]):

V1=Δcos⁡2ϕ=C1∫(σyy−σxx) dz,(11)V_{1} = \Delta\cos2\phi= C_{1}\int\left(\sigma_{yy}-\sigma_{xx}\right)\,\mathrm{d}z, \tag*{(11)}
V2=Δsin⁡2ϕ=2C1∫σxy dz.(12)V_{2} = \Delta\sin2\phi= 2C_{1}\int\sigma_{xy}\,\mathrm{d}z. \tag*{(12)}

Hereafter, we refer to Eqs. (11) and (12) as the “1st-order SOL”, often simply called the SOL in conventional studies. This formulation excludes the stress component along the camera’s optical axis. In the remainder of this paper, we call Eqs. (9) and (10), in which C2≠0C_{2}\ne0, the “2nd-order SOL”. This formulation includes the stress component along the camera’s optical axis.

Based on 1st- and 2nd-order SOLs, we can calculate the retardation Δ\Delta if the stress field is known a priori.

Working fluids

The working fluids disperse CNCs (CNC-HSFD, Cellulose Lab, Ltd.) in ultra-pure water. The CNCs are mixed with ultra-pure water using a magnetic stirrer (CHPS-170DF, ASONE Co., Ltd.) at 25 °C and 600 rpm for at least 1 h. The CNC suspensions are then sonicated using an ultrasonic processor (UX-300, Mitsui Electric Co. Ltd.) for 10 min, which reduces the error between the experimental and theoretical orientation [23, 31]. CNC suspensions with concentrations of 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, and 1.0 wt% are used in the experiments. Figure 2 shows the shear viscosity η\eta versus the shear rate γ˙\dot{\gamma} of the CNC suspensions and ultra-pure water, as measured using a rheometer (MCR302, Anton Paar Co., Ltd.). The shear viscosities at γ˙=103\dot{\gamma} = 10^3 1/s are 1.01, 1.06, 1.27, and 1.58 mPa·s for 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, and 1.0 wt% CNC suspensions, respectively. These values are used when the theoretical flow field is calculated. There is negligible interparticle interaction in the CNC suspensions if the concentration is less than 0.5 wt% [23, 6]. The shear rheology of the 1.0 wt% CNC suspension exhibits a slight shear-thinning viscosity. We evaluated the effect of this weak shear-thinning property on the flow field through numerical simulations using commercial software (COMSOL Multiphysics). As described in detail in Appendix § 5, its flow field is very similar to that of a Newtonian fluid. Therefore, all CNC suspensions used in this study can be considered as Newtonian fluids.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Shear viscosity η\eta versus shear rate γ˙\dot{\gamma} of CNC suspensions with concentrations cc of 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, and 1.0 wt% and ultra-pure water, as measured by a rheometer. The dashed line indicates the low-torque limit of the rheometer.

Experiments

A schematic diagram of the experimental setup is shown in Figure 3, along with the coordinates of the system. A linear polarizer, a quarter-wave plate, and a rectangular channel are placed between a light source (SOLIS-565C, Thorlabs), which generates green light with a typical wavelength λ\lambda of 540 nm, and a high-speed polarization camera (CRYSTA PI-5WP, Photron, temporal resolution: 250 fps, spatial resolution: 848 ×\times 680 pixels for an 8-bit light intensity image). The light passes through the linear polarizer at 0° and the quarter-wave plate at 45° with respect to the yy-axis, and becomes circularly polarized. As the light passes through the stress field, it accumulates a retardation and orientation corresponding to the stress states encountered along the camera’s optical axis. After passing through the stress field, the light becomes elliptically polarized and is recorded by the polarization camera, which contains “super-pixels” ([24]). Each super-pixel of the image sensor within the polarization camera consists of four linear polarizers with four different directions: 0°, 45°, 90°, and 135°. The light intensity values measured by the camera’s sensor through each linear polarizer are denoted as I0∘I_{0^\circ}, I45∘I_{45^\circ}, I90∘I_{90^\circ}, and I135∘I_{135^\circ}, respectively, as shown in Figure 3(b).

Image not extracted

Figure 3. (a) Schematic diagram of the experimental setup. (b) Raw image taken by the polarization camera. The inset shows that the neighboring pixels are polarizers with different directions. The retardation is calculated from the intensity values of the four pixels next to each other.

Using the four-step phase-shifting method [35, 33, 32, 39, 27], the retardation Δ\Delta is obtained from the four intensity values of the super-pixels as follows:

Δ=λ2πsin⁡−1(I90∘−I0∘)2+(I45∘−I135∘)2I/2,(13)\Delta= \frac{\lambda}{2\pi}\sin^{-1}\frac{\sqrt{(I_{90^\circ}-I_{0^\circ})^2+(I_{45^\circ}-I_{135^\circ})^2}}{I/2}, \tag*{(13)}

where I=I0∘+I45∘+I90∘+I135∘I = I_{0^\circ} + I_{45^\circ} + I_{90^\circ} + I_{135^\circ}. An example of the measured retardation calculated using software (Photron Ltd., CRYSTA Stress Viewer) is shown in Figure 4(a). The spatial resolution of the retardation data is 424 ×\times 340 pixels, which is a quarter of 848 ×\times 680 pixels. The background noise is subtracted before measuring the retardation field during fluid flow. To reduce the shot noise of the camera, the measured retardation is spatially averaged in the flow direction (xx-direction) and temporally averaged over 0.4 s, resulting in a line profile (Figure 4(b)). As discussed later, the flow field is effectively constant in the flow direction and time. We verified the lowest measurable retardation of the polarization camera used in this study by measuring the retardation field of the rectangular channel filled by a non-flowing CNC suspension. Figure 5 shows the temporal evolution of the spatially averaged retardation Δmean\Delta_{\mathrm{mean}}, which exhibits retardation of approximately 1.27 nm. This is considered ered to be the lowest measurable retardation of the polarization camera.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. (a) Spatial distribution of the measured retardation field Δ\Delta of CNC 0.5 wt% in the case of Q=30Q = 30 ml/min with an aspect ratio of w/d=1w/d = 1. (b) Line profile of the spatiotemporally averaged retardation of (a) over a period of 0.4 s.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. Temporal evolution of spatially averaged retardation at rest for 0.5 wt% CNC suspension and aspect ratio of 1. Error bars indicate the standard deviation of the calculated average retardation over the entire image.

We prepared channels with three aspect ratios w/dw/d, i.e., w/d=0.1w/d = 0.1, 1, and 3. The aspect ratio w/d=0.1w/d = 0.1 was produced using a channel width of 2w=12w = 1 mm and a channel depth of 2d=102d = 10 mm. The aspect ratio w/d=1w/d = 1 was produced using a channel width of 2w=22w = 2 mm and a channel depth of 2d=22d = 2 mm. The aspect ratio w/d=3w/d = 3 was produced using a channel width of 2w=62w = 6 mm and a channel depth of 2d=22d = 2 mm. The rectangular channel with w/d=1w/d = 1 was made of quartz glass. The rectangular channels with aspect ratios of w/d=0.1w/d = 0.1 and 3 were prepared using a three-dimensional printer (Form3, Formlabs; material: clear resin). To create a flat surface, the front and back sides of the channels were polished. The flow channels were

sealed with two glass plates level with the surfaces. The flow of the channel with w/d=0.1w/d = 0.1 can be considered quasi-two-dimensional, as mentioned above.

The coordinate system is set up as shown in Figure 3. The length of the channel is around 50 mm. The fluid was supplied using a syringe pump (Pump 11 Elite, Harvard Apparatus) to produce a steady laminar flow. The flow rates in the experiments ranged from 1–100 ml/min. The Reynolds number Re=ρUmeanRH/ηRe = \rho U_{\mathrm{mean}}R_H/\eta reaches a maximum value of approximately 200 when the flow rate is 100 ml/min using the channel with w/d=1w/d = 1. Here, UmeanU_{\mathrm{mean}} is the mean velocity, defined by Umean=Q/(4wd)U_{\mathrm{mean}} = Q/(4wd), and RHR_H is the hydraulic radius, defined by RH=wd/(w+d)R_H = wd/(w+d). The measurement area extends over x∼45x \sim45 mm. The entrance length LeL_e, which is defined as Le=0.06ReRHL_e = 0.06ReR_H, is sufficiently smaller than the distance between the flow inlet and the measurement position in all experimental conditions. Therefore, the flow field is effectively fully developed.

Theoretical flow field

This section describes the theoretical flow field in a rectangular channel to calculate the retardation and orientation field to be compared with experiments. First, the velocity distribution of a steady laminar flow in a rectangular channel is derived from the Navier–Stokes equations as follows [13, 29]:

(∂2∂y2+∂2∂z2)ux=−4Qwd3K,(14)\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial y^2}+\frac{\partial^2}{\partial z^2}\right)u_x=-\frac{4Q}{wd^3K}, \tag*{(14)}
uy=uz=0,(15)u_y=u_z=0, \tag*{(15)}

where

K=163−1024π5dw∑n=0∞1(2n+1)5tanh⁡((2n+1)πw2d).(16)K=\frac{16}{3}-\frac{1024}{\pi^5}\frac{d}{w}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{1}{(2n+1)^5}\tanh\left(\frac{(2n+1)\pi w}{2d}\right). \tag*{(16)}

Here, QQ is the flow rate and ww, dd are the channel width and channel depth, respectively. uyu_y and uzu_z are the velocities in the yy- and zz-directions, respectively. The velocity distribution ux(y,z)u_x(y,z), which satisfies Eqs. (14)–(16), and the no-slip boundary condition at the wall (y=±w(y = \pm w or z=±d)z = \pm d) are defined as follows:

ux(y,z)=64Qwdπ3K∑n=0∞(−1)n(2n+1)3[1−cosh⁡((2n+1)πy2d)cosh⁡((2n+1)πw2d)]cos⁡((2n+1)πz2d)(17)u_x(y,z) = \frac{64Q}{wd\pi^3K}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{(-1)^n}{(2n+1)^3}\left[1-\frac{\cosh\left(\frac{(2n+1)\pi y}{2d}\right)}{\cosh\left(\frac{(2n+1)\pi w}{2d}\right)}\right]\cos\left(\frac{(2n+1)\pi z}{2d}\right) \tag*{(17)}
uy=uz=0.(18)u_y = u_z = 0. \tag*{(18)}

Examples of the theoretical velocity distributions with different aspect ratios w/dw/d are shown in Figure 6(a,Figure 6b,Figure 6c). From Eqs. (17) and (18), the viscous stresses are calculated as follows:

Image not extracted

Figure 6. (a,b,c) Velocity fields for different aspect ratios w/dw/d. (d,e,f) Distributions of shear stress σxy\sigma_{xy} for different aspect ratios w/dw/d. (g,h,i) Distributions of shear stress σxz\sigma_{xz} for different aspect ratios w/dw/d. All quantities calculated using Q=30Q = 30 ml/min, η=1.12\eta= 1.12 mPa·s.

σxy(y,z)=η∂ux∂y=64Qηwdπ3K∑n=0∞(−1)n(2n+1)3(2n+1)π2dsinh⁡((2n+1)πy2d)cosh⁡((2n+1)πw2d)cos⁡((2n+1)πz2d)(19)\sigma_{xy}(y,z) = \eta\frac{\partial u_x}{\partial y} = \frac{64Q\eta}{wd\pi^3K}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{(-1)^n}{(2n+1)^3}\frac{(2n+1)\pi}{2d}\frac{\sinh\left(\frac{(2n+1)\pi y}{2d}\right)}{\cosh\left(\frac{(2n+1)\pi w}{2d}\right)}\cos\left(\frac{(2n+1)\pi z}{2d}\right) \tag*{(19)}
σxz(y,z)=η∂ux∂z=64Qηwdπ3K∑n=0∞(−1)n(2n+1)3(−1)(2n+1)π2d[1−cosh⁡(2n+1)πw2dcosh⁡(2n+1)πw2d]sin⁡(2n+1)πz2d,(20)\sigma_{xz}(y,z)=\eta\frac{\partial u_x}{\partial z}=\frac{64Q\eta}{wd\pi^3K}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{(-1)^n}{(2n+1)^3}(-1)^{\frac{(2n+1)\pi}{2d}}\left[1-\frac{\cosh\frac{(2n+1)\pi w}{2d}}{\cosh\frac{(2n+1)\pi w}{2d}}\right]\sin\frac{(2n+1)\pi z}{2d}, \tag*{(20)}
σxx=σyy=σzz=σyz=0.(21)\sigma_{xx}=\sigma_{yy}=\sigma_{zz}=\sigma_{yz}=0. \tag*{(21)}

Examples of the theoretical stress fields in the channel are shown in Figure 6(d,Figure 6e,Figure 6f) and 6(g,h,i). Therefore, Eqs. (9) and (10) in this flow field become

V1=Δcos⁡2ϕ=−C2∫σxz2 dz,(22)V_1=\Delta\cos2\phi=-C_2\int\sigma_{xz}^2\,dz, \tag*{(22)}
V2=Δsin⁡2ϕ=2C1∫σxy dz.(23)V_2=\Delta\sin2\phi=2C_1\int\sigma_{xy}\,dz. \tag*{(23)}

In particular, the stress component at the wall (y=±wy=\pm w) and at the channel center (y=0y=0) are

σxy(±w,z)=64Qηwdπ3K∑n=0∞(−1)n(2n+1)3(±1)(2n+1)π2d(2n+1)π2dtanh⁡(2n+1)πw2dcos⁡(2n+1)πz2d,(24)\sigma_{xy}(\pm w,z)=\frac{64Q\eta}{wd\pi^3K}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{(-1)^n}{(2n+1)^3}(\pm1)^{\frac{(2n+1)\pi}{2d}}\frac{(2n+1)\pi}{2d}\tanh\frac{(2n+1)\pi w}{2d}\cos\frac{(2n+1)\pi z}{2d}, \tag*{(24)}
σxz(±w,z)=0,(25)\sigma_{xz}(\pm w,z)=0, \tag*{(25)}
σxy(0,z)=0,(26)\sigma_{xy}(0,z)=0, \tag*{(26)}
σxz(0,z)=64Qηwdπ3K∑n=0∞(−1)n(2n+1)3(−1)(2n+1)π2d[1−1cosh⁡(2n+1)πw2d]sin⁡(2n+1)πz2d.(27)\sigma_{xz}(0,z)=\frac{64Q\eta}{wd\pi^3K}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{(-1)^n}{(2n+1)^3}(-1)^{\frac{(2n+1)\pi}{2d}}\left[1-\frac{1}{\cosh\frac{(2n+1)\pi w}{2d}}\right]\sin\frac{(2n+1)\pi z}{2d}. \tag*{(27)}

Thus, the theoretical retardation and orientation can be calculated using Eqs. (4), (20)–(23) and compared with the experimental data. In particular, the scaling of the retardation at the wall (y=±wy=\pm w), Δwall\Delta_{\mathrm{wall}}, and the retardation at the center (y=0y=0), Δcenter\Delta_{\mathrm{center}}, can be calculated as follows:

Δwall=∣2C1∫σxy(±w,z)dz∣∝Q,(28)\Delta_{\mathrm{wall}}=\left|2C_1\int\sigma_{xy}(\pm w,z)dz\right|\propto Q, \tag*{(28)}
Δcenter=∣−C2∫σxz2(0,z)dz∣∝Q2.(29)\Delta_{\mathrm{center}}=\left|-C_2\int\sigma_{xz}^2(0,z)dz\right|\propto Q^2. \tag*{(29)}

These equations suggest that the retardation at the wall increases in proportion to the 1st power of QQ and the retardation at the center increases in proportion to the 2nd power of QQ. Furthermore, if we use the 1st-order SOL, i.e., C2=0C_2=0, the retardation is expected to be zero at the center of the channel.

In terms of the effects of stress components along the camera’s optical axis on flow birefringence, i.e., C2C_2 term in the SOL, the effect is most pronounced at the center of the channel. The effect is negligible at the wall. In other words, if the effect is not ignored, the retardation at the center of the channel will not be zero, although the retardation at the wall may not be affected. Therefore, the retardation at the wall and at the center of the channel are the main targets of discussion in this study.

Results and discussion

Retardation distributions

The retardation fields were systematically measured using three rectangular channels and four CNC suspensions with different concentrations. We collected more than 100 data. Figure 7 shows the line profiles of the measured retardation at each flow rate QQ. In all cases, the highest retardation values appear at the channel wall (y=±wy=\pm w) and the lowest values occur at the channel center (y=0y=0). The retardation at each yy-position increases with the flow rate. At the wall (y=±yy=\pm y), the retardation for the same flow rate increases with the concentration cc of CNC. This means that the concentration of CNC Equation (29) suggests that the retardation at the center of the channel, Δcenter\Delta_{\mathrm{center}}, should be zero if there is no effect of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis on the flow birefringence, i.e., C2=0C_2 = 0. However, when the flow rate is sufficiently high, Δcenter\Delta_{\mathrm{center}} clearly shows a finite value and increases with the flow rate QQ, even for the quasi-two-dimensional channel (w/d=0.1w/d = 0.1) and at low CNC concentrations. This result indicates that the term relating to the stress component along the camera’s optical axis in the SOL must be considered in the flow birefringence, except when the flow rate is sufficiently low and when the channel flow is quasi-two-dimensional.

Image not extracted

Figure 7. Line profiles of the retardation for different aspect ratios, CNC concentrations, and flow rates. The horizontal axis is normalized by the width of the channel ww. The error bars show the standard deviation calculated when the retardation is temporally averaged over 250 frames, but the size of the marker tends to obscure these quantities.

Effect of stress component along the camera’s optical axis on flow birefringence

To quantitatively assess the effect of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis on flow birefringence, the retardation values at the wall Δwall\Delta_{\mathrm{wall}} and center Δcenter\Delta_{\mathrm{center}} of the channel are plotted against the flow rate QQ in Figure 8. The left-hand side of Figure 8 shows that the retardation at the wall increases in proportion to the 1st power of QQ. This result agrees with the expectation of both the 1st- and 2nd-order SOLs described in Eq. (28). Although a previous study suggested that retardation will reach a saturation level because of the saturated alignment of CNC ([14, 11]) at sufficiently high flow rates, the relationship between retardation and flow rate remains linear within the range considered in this study. The right-hand side of Figure 8 shows that the retardation at the center increases in proportion to the 2nd power of QQ if QQ is sufficiently large (Q≥10Q \ge10 ml/min in our study). This result does not agree with the 1st-order SOL in Eqs. (11) and (12), but does agree with the ex-

Image not extracted

Figure 8. (Left column) Relationship between retardation at y=±wy = \pm w Δwall\Delta_{\mathrm{wall}} and flow rate QQ with different CNC concentrations: (a) 0.1 wt%, (c) 0.3 wt%, (e) 0.5 wt%, and (g) 1.0 wt%. (Right column) Relationship between retardation at the center Δcenter\Delta_{\mathrm{center}} and flow rate QQ with different CNC concentrations: (b) 0.1 wt%, (d) 0.3 wt%, (f) 0.5 wt%, and (h) 1.0 wt%. Solid lines in (a,c,e,g) have a slope of 1, indicating Δwall∝Q\Delta_{\mathrm{wall}} \propto Q predicted by Eq. (28). Dashed lines in (b,d,f,h) have a slope of 2, indicating Δcenter∝Q2\Delta_{\mathrm{center}} \propto Q^2 predicted by Eq. (29). The error bars show the standard deviation calculated when the measured retardation is temporally averaged over 250 frames.

pectation of the 2nd-order SOL in Eqs. (9) and (10), for which the stress component along the camera’s optical axis, i.e., C2C_2, is nonzero. These results indicate that the flow birefringence of CNC suspensions in a three-dimensional flow field can be better understood using the 2nd-order SOL, which considers the effect of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis, rather than the 1st-order SOL that has conventionally been used.

As the lowest measurable retardation of the polarization camera used in this study is around 1.27 nm, retardation values of less than around 1 nm can be considered as noise. For example, almost all Δcenter\Delta_{\mathrm{center}} for w/d=3w/d = 3 are at the noise level because the stress along the zz-axis and its integrating length are small for this case. This region can be further verified using a long channel with a larger cross-section to gain a longer integrating length. Additionally, Δcenter\Delta_{\mathrm{center}} is at the noise level for w/d=0.1w/d = 0.1 with the 1.0 wt% CNC suspension because of the low flow rate, Q≤9Q \leq9 ml/min.

To illustrate the practicality of the 2nd-order SOL, we now reexamine the retardation distribution. Figure 9 compares the experimental and theoretical retardation line profiles for all channel aspect ratios. The retardation profiles are normalized by the retardation at the wall, Δwall\Delta_{\mathrm{wall}}. In calculating the line profiles of the retardation using the 2nd-order SOL, C1C_1 and C2C_2 match the retardation at the wall and center of the channel with the respective experimental values. The values of C2C_2 and C1C_1 for all cases are described in Appendix § 6. Figure 9 clearly shows that, for any aspect ratio, the retardation profiles calculated using the 2nd-order SOL, i.e., C2≠0C_2 \ne0, are in better agreement with the experimental results than those calculated using the 1st-order SOL, i.e., C2=0C_2 = 0.

Image not extracted

Figure 9. Comparison between (a) experimental and (b) theoretical retardation profiles for the 0.5 wt% CNC suspension and different aspect ratios w/dw/d. The retardation distributions Δ(y)\Delta(y) are normalized by the retardation at the wall Δwall\Delta_{\mathrm{wall}}. The dashed and solid lines in (b) are calculated using 1st- and 2nd-order SOLs, respectively. For w/d=0.1w/d = 0.1, the flow rate is Q=20Q = 20 ml/min and we use C1=1.51×10−5C_1 = 1.51 \times10^{-5} 1/Pa and C2=4.19×10−4C_2 = 4.19 \times10^{-4} 1/Pa2^2 to calculate the theoretical retardation profile. For the case of w/d=1w/d = 1, the flow rate is Q=70Q = 70 ml/min and we use C1=1.52×10−5C_1 = 1.52 \times10^{-5} 1/Pa and C2=1.11×10−5C_2 = 1.11 \times10^{-5} 1/Pa2^2 to calculate the theoretical retardation profile. For the case of w/d=3w/d = 3, the flow rate is Q=50Q = 50 ml/min and we use C1=1.35×10−5C_1 = 1.35 \times10^{-5} 1/Pa and C2=2.8×10−5C_2 = 2.8 \times10^{-5} 1/Pa2^2 to calculate the theoretical retardation profile.

Conclusion

This study has attempted to clarify the effect of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis on the flow birefringence of CNC suspensions by revisiting the SOL described by Doyle [15]. This effect has often been neglected in conventional 1st-order SOLs. The 2nd-order SOL includes the stress component along the camera’s optical axis. In this study, systematic experiments were carried out to measure the flow birefringence of CNC suspensions in steady laminar flow through rectangular channels, and more than 100 datasets were assessed. The retardation distributions were measured for various CNC suspensions (with 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, and 1.0 wt% CNC concentrations) flowing through rectangular channels with aspect ratios of 0.1, 1, and 3. The measured retardation values were compared with those predicted theoretically by the 1st- and 2nd-order SOLs.

The results show that the retardation distribution varies with the channel aspect ratio. The 1st-order SOL holds in flow fields where the stress component along the camera’s optical axis (zz-axis) is negligible, such as in a quasi-two-dimensional flow channel with a small aspect ratio and low flow rate. However, in cases where the stress component along the camera’s optical axis cannot be ignored, such as in the case of a high flow rate, the 1st-order SOL cannot be applied, even for quasi-two-dimensional channel flows. In such cases, the 2nd-order SOL predicts the retardation distribution with reasonable accuracy based on experimental data. Focusing on the retardation at the channel center, where the effect of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis is most pronounced, the 2nd-order SOL predicts the retardation to be proportional to the 2nd power of the flow rate QQ, in agreement with the experimental retardation results. To conclude, when measuring flow birefringence in the three-dimensional flow of CNC suspensions, the stress component along the camera’s optical axis must be considered. The results of this study will be of great importance in studies of flow birefringence in three-dimensional channels for CNCs and other materials.

Non-Newtonian effect of 1.0 wt% CNC Suspension

We now verify the non-Newtonian effect of the 1.0 wt% CNC suspension. The slight shear-thinning viscosity of the suspension was fitted by a power law model described by the following equation:

η=Kγ˙n−1,(30)\eta= K\dot{\gamma}^{n-1}, \tag*{(30)}

where KK is the flow consistency index and nn is the power exponent. Figure 10(a) shows the viscosity of the 1.0 wt% CNC suspension and the fitted power law model using K≃4.0K \simeq4.0 and n≃0.9n \simeq0.9. The velocity profiles of the 1.0 wt% CNC suspension flowing in rectangular channels with different aspect ratios were numerically calculated using commercial software (COMSOL Multiphysics) with the power law model and these constants.

Image not extracted

Figure 10. (a) Viscosity of 1.0 wt% CNC suspension. The solid line shows the power law model of η=Kγ˙n−1\eta= K\dot{\gamma}^{n-1} with n≃0.9n \simeq0.9 and K≃4.0K \simeq4.0. (b,c,a) are the velocity profiles along the zz-axis at y=0y = 0 when Q=30Q = 30 ml/min for aspect ratios w/dw/d of 0.1, 1, and 3, respectively. The dashed lines show the theoretical velocity profile calculated by Eq. (17) using a constant viscosity of 1.58 mPa · s. The solid lines show the numerically calculated velocity profile of the power law fluid.

Figure 10(b,Figure 10c,Figure 10d) show the measured velocity profiles (solid lines) for aspect ratios of 0.1, 1, and 3, respectively, and the theoretical distribution (dashed lines) calculated by Eq. (17) using a constant viscosity of 1.58 mPa · s. The difference between the velocity distributions of non-Newtonian and Newtonian fluids is particularly small because the power exponent of 0.9 is close to 1. Therefore, the non-Newtonian effect of the 1.0 wt% CNC suspension is negligible.

Stress-optic coefficients

Figure 11 shows the adjusted C1C_1 and C2C_2 such that the retardation at the wall and the center of the channel, Δwall\Delta_{\mathrm{wall}} and Δcenter\Delta_{\mathrm{center}}, are closest to the experimental value when calculating the theoretical retardation distribution. C1C_1 is linearly proportional to the CNC concentration cc and is nearly independent of the aspect ratio w/dw/d. The value of C2C_2 also increases with the CNC concentration, but varies with the aspect ratio. This means that the magnitude of the effect of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis on flow birefringence changes with the flow condition, because C2C_2 is the contribution level of the stress component along the camera’s optical axis in the SOL. Additionally, the procedure performed in this study provides a method for determining C1C_1 and C2C_2 in birefringent fluids.

Image not extracted

Figure 11. (a) C1C_1 and (b) C2C_2 adjusted to minimize the difference between the calculated theoretical retardation distribution and the experimental values at the wall and center of the channel, denoted as Δwall\Delta_{\mathrm{wall}} and Δcenter\Delta_{\mathrm{center}}, respectively. The solid line in (a) shows the linear relationship between C1C_1 and cc, C1∝c1C_1 \propto c^1.

Statements and Declarations

Acknowledgments

We thank Dr. T. Shikata, Dr. T. Rösgen, and Dr. C. Lane for their valuable discussions and suggestions.

Funding

This work was funded by Japan Society for the Promotion of Science KAKENHI (Grant Numbers: JP19K23483, JP20K14646, JP20H00222, JP20H00223, JP22KJ1239), Japan Science and Technology Agency PRESTO (Grant Number: JPMJPR21O5), and Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development (Grant Number: JP22he0422016).

Author contributions

Y.T. and M.M. conceptualized and supervised the study. K.N., Y.Y., W.W., and M.M. developed the methodology. K.N., Y.Y., and W.W. conducted the formal analysis and investigation. K.N., Y.Y., and W.W. prepared the original draft manuscript. All authors reviewed and edited the manuscript.

Competing interest

The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare that are relevant to the content of this article.

Data availability

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

References

References

  1. [1]Aben H, Guillement C (1993) Photoelasticity of glass. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, Heidelberg, DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-50071-8DOI
  2. [2]Aben H, Puro A (1997) Photoelastic tomography for three-dimensional flow birefringence studies. Inverse Problems 13(2):215–221, DOI 10.1088/0266-5611/13/2/002DOI
  3. [3]Aben HK, Josepson JI, Kell KJE (1989) The case of weak birefringence in integrated photoelasticity. Optics and Lasers in Engineering 11(3):145–157, DOI 10.1016/0143-8166(89)90029-8DOI
  4. [4]Ainola L (1998) Application of integrated photoelasticity to the determination of viscous flow velocity in closed conduits. Proceedings of the Estonian Academy of Sciences, Physics and Mathematics 47(1):48–55DOI
  5. [6]Bertsch P, Sánchez-Ferrer A, Bagnani M, Isettbetini S, Kohlbrecher J, Mezzenga R, Fischer P (2019) Ion-induced formation of nanocrystalline cellulose colloidal glasses containing nematic domains. Langmuir 35(11):4117–4124, DOI 10.1021/acs.langmuir.9b00281DOI
  6. [7]Buffa JM, Casado U, Mucci V, Aranguren MI (2019) Cellulose nanocrystals in aqueous suspensions: rheology of lyotropic chiral liquid crystals. Cellulose 26(4):2317–2332, DOI 10.1007/s10570-019-02278-3DOI
  7. [8]Calabrese V, Haward SJ, Shen AQ (2021a) Effects of shearing and extensional flows on the alignment of colloidal rods. Macromolecules 54(9):4176–4185DOI
  8. [10]Calabrese V, Varchanis S, Haward SJ, Shen AQ (2022) Alignment of colloidal rods in crowded environments. Macromolecules 55(13):5610–5620, DOI 10.1021/acs.macromol.2c00769DOI
  9. [11]Calabrese V, Santos TP, Lopez CG, Lettinga MP, Haward SJ, Shen AQ (2023) Extensibility governs the flow-induced alignment of polymers and rod-like colloids. DOI 10.48550/arXiv.2311.13093, 2311.13093DOI
  10. [13]Delplace F (2018) Laminar flow of Newtonian liquids in ducts of rectangular cross-section a model for both physics and mathematics. Open Access J Math Theor Phys 1:198–201DOI
  11. [14]Detert M, Santos TP, Shen AQ, Calabrese V (2023) Alignment–rheology relationship of biosourced rod-like colloids and polymers under flow. Biomacromolecules DOI 10.1021/acs.biomac.3c00347DOI
  12. [15]Doyle JF (1982) On nonlinearity in flow birefringence. Experimental Mechanics 22(1):37–38DOI
  13. [16]Habibi Y, Lucia LA, Rojas OJ (2010) Cellulose Nanocrystals: Chemistry, Self-Assembly, and Applications. Chemical Reviews 110(6):3479–3500, DOI 10.1021/cr900339wDOI
  14. [19]Kádár R, Spirk S, Nyplot T (2021) Cellulose nanocrystal liquid crystal phases: progress and challenges in characterization using rheology coupled to optics, scattering, and spectroscopy. ACS Nano 15(5):7931–7945, DOI 10.1021/acsnano.0c09829DOI
  15. [20]Kim J, Michelin S, Hilbers M, Martinelli L, Chaudan E, Amselem G, Fradet E, Boilot JP, Brouwer AM, Baroud CN, et al. (2017) Monitoring the orientation of rare-earth-doped nanorods for flow shear tomography. Nature nanotechnology 12(9):914–919DOI
  16. [21]Knight Jr CE, Pih H (1976) Orthotropic stress-optic law for plane stress photoelasticity of composite materials. Fibre Science and Technology 9(4):297–313DOI
  17. [22]Lagerwall JPF, Schütz C, Salajkova M, Noh J, Hyun Park J, Scalia G, Bergström L (2014) Cellulose nanocrystal-based materials: from liquid crystal self-assembly and glass formation to multifunctional thin films. NPG Asia Materials 6(1):e80–e80, DOI 10.1038/am.2013.69DOI
  18. [23]Lane C, Rode D, Rösgen T (2022a) Birefringent properties of aqueous cellulose nanocrystal suspensions. Cellulose 29(11):6093–6107, DOI 10.1007/s10570-022-04646-yDOI
  19. [24]Lane C, Rode D, Rösgen T (2022b) Calibration of a polarization image sensor and investigation of influencing factors. Applied Optics 61(6):C37–C45, DOI 10.1364/AO.437391DOI
  20. [25]Lane C, Baumann F, Rode D, Rösgen T (2023) Two-dimensional strain rate imaging study using a polarization camera and birefringent aqueous cellulose nanocrystal suspensions. Experiments in Fluids 65(1):8, DOI 10.1007/s00348-023-03730-8DOI
  21. [26]McAfee WJ, Pih H (1974) Scattered-light flow-optic relations adaptable to three-dimensional flow birefringence. Experimental Mechanics 14(10):385–391, DOI 10.1007/BF02324941DOI
  22. [27]Miyazaki Y, Usawa M, Kawai S, Yee J, Muto M, Tagawa Y (2021) Dynamic mechanical interaction between injection liquid and human tissue simulant induced by needle-free injection of a highly focused microjet. Scientific Reports 11(1):14,544, DOI 10.1038/s41598-021-94018-6DOI
  23. [28]Mu R, Hong X, Ni Y, Li Y, Pang J, Wang Q, Xiao J, Zheng Y (2019) Recent trends and applications of cellulose nanocrystals in food industry. Trends in Food Science & Technology 93:136–144, DOI 10.1016/j.tifs.2019.09.013DOI
  24. [29]Nagamoto H, Kobayashi Y, Otomo J, Oshima E (2006) Laminar flow characteristics in a rectangular microchannel. Kagaku Kougaku Ronbunshu 32(3):293–296, DOI 10.1252/kakoronbunshu.32.293DOI
  25. [30]Noto D, Tasaka Y, Hitomi J, Murai Y (2020) Applicability evaluation of the stress-optic law in Newtonian fluids toward stress field measurements. Physical Review Research 2(4):043,111DOI
  26. [31]Ober TJ, Soulages J, McKinley GH (2011) Spatially resolved quantitative rheo-optics of complex fluids in a microfluidic device. Journal of Rheology 55(5):1127–1159DOI
  27. [32]Onuma T, Otani Y (2014) A development of two-dimensional birefringence distribution measurement system with a sampling rate of 1.3mhz. Optics Communications 315:69–73, DOI 10.1016/j.optcom.2013.10.086DOI
  28. [33]Otani Y, Shimada T, Yoshizawa T, Umeda N (1994) Two-dimensional birefringence measurement using the phase shifting technique. Optical Engineering 33(5):1604–1609, DOI 10.1117/12.168435DOI
  29. [34]Prabhakaran R (1975) On the stress-optic law for orthotropic model materials in biaxial-stress fields. Experimental Mechanics 15(1):29–34DOI
  30. [35]Ramesh K (2021) Developments in photoelasticity. IOP Publishing, DOI 10.1088/978-0-7503-2472-4DOI
  31. [36]Saito T, Kuramae R, Wohlert J, Berglund LA, Isogai A (2013) An Ultrastrong Nanofibrillar Biomaterial: The Strength of Single Cellulose Nanofibrils Revealed via Sonication-Induced Fragmentation. Biomacromolecules 14(1):248–253, DOI 10.1021/bm301674eDOI
  32. [37]Thiruganasambanthan T, Ilyas RA, Norrahim MNF, Kumar TSM, Siengchin S, Misenan MSM, Farid MAA, Nurazzi NM, Asyraf MRM, Zakaria SZS, Razman MR (2022) Emerging Developments on Nanocellulose as Liquid Crystals: A Biomimetic Approach. Polymers 14(8):1546, DOI 10.3390/polym14081546DOI
  33. [38]Yokoyama Y, Ichihara S, Tagawa Y (2023a) High-speed photoelastic tomography for axisymmetric stress fields in a soft material: temporal evolution of all stress components. DOI 10.48550/arXiv.2311.10107, 2311.10107DOI
  34. [39]Yokoyama Y, Mitchell BR, Nassiri A, Kinsey BL, Korkolis YP, Tagawa Y (2023b) Integrated photoelasticity in a soft material: phase retardation, azimuthal angle, and stress-optic coefficient. Optics and Lasers in Engineering 161:107,335, DOI 10.1016/j.optlaseng.2022.107335DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_g6jy6wk5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents