betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Preferential orientation of small floaters drifting in water waves

Abstract

Elongated floaters drifting in propagating water waves slowly rotate towards a preferential orientation with respect to the direction of incidence. In this article, we study this phenomenon in the small-floater limit kLx<1k L_x < 1 , with kk the wavenumber and LxL_x the floater length. Experiments show that short and heavy floaters tend to align longitudinally, along the direction of wave propagation, whereas longer and lighter floaters align transversely, parallel to the wave crests and troughs. We show that this preferential orientation can be modeled using an inviscid Froude-Krylov model, ignoring diffraction effects. Asymptotic theory, in the double limit of small wave slope and small floater, suggests that preferential orientation is essentially controlled by the non-dimensional number F=kLx2/h‾F = k L_x^2 / \overline{h}, with h‾\overline{h} the equilibrium submersion depth. Theory predicts the longitudinal-transverse transition {for homogeneous parallelepipeds} at the critical value Fc=60F_c = 60, in fair agreement with the experiments that locate Fc=50±15F_c = 50 \pm 15. Using a simplified model for a thin floater, we elucidate the physical mechanisms that control the preferential orientation. The longitudinal equilibrium for F<FcF<F_c originates from a slight asymmetry between the buoyancy torque induced by the wave crests, that favors the longitudinal orientation, and that induced by the wave troughs, that favors the transverse orientation. The transverse equilibrium for F>FcF>F_c arises from the variation of the submersion depth along the long axis of the floaters, which significantly increases the torque in the trough positions, when the tips are more submersed.

Introduction

The motion of a floating body in gravity waves is a classical problem in fluid mechanics with evident applications in the domain of naval engineering [11, 19, 10]. At first order in wave magnitude, waves cause harmonic oscillations of the floating body in all six degrees of freedom, displacements (heave, surge, sway) and orientation angles (pitch, roll, yaw). At second order, waves also cause a mean drift force and yaw moment on the body that affect surge, sway and yaw angle on long time-scales. For small isotropic floaters, this mean motion reduces to the classical Stokes drift in the direction of the wave propagation [23, 2, 5], a problem that received considerable interest for the modeling of pollutant transport in the oceans [27, 25] (Suarie et al. 2021). For larger floaters of arbitrary shape, such as ships and floating structures, an angular drift can change the floater’s orientation with respect to the wave incidence and this slow reorientation can in turn modify its linear drift. The combined linear and angular drifts are key features in sea keeping and maneuvering [21], and their modeling has been the subject of numerous works. The main methods to analyse ship motion are summarized in the books of Faltinsen [11] and Newman [19].

In this paper, we are specifically interested in the slow, second order yaw motion of small elongated floaters drifting in gravity waves and how it creates a preferential state of orientation with respect to the incident waves. To illustrate this phenomenon, we show in Figure 1 two chronophotographs from our laboratory experiments. Small homogeneous parallelepipeds of centimeter scale are left adrift in a propagating wave in a 3-m long water tank, and pictures synchronized with the wave period are taken from above (details are given in § 2). In just a few wave periods, we observe that shorter floaters align with the direction of wave propagation, whereas longer floaters clearly prefer to align parallel to the wave crests. The main objective of this article to clarify what physically governs this preferential orientation.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Experimental setup and chronophotographies. (a) Side view. Waves are generated in a water channel, of length 3 m and filled at height H=10H = 10 cm. (b) Top View. Floater of length LxL_x, making an angle ψ\psi with the direction of wave propagation. (c-d) Chronophotographies, obtained by superimposing images acquired every wave period, for a wave length λ=29\lambda= 29 cm and wave slope ϵ=ak=0.16\epsilon= ak = 0.16. The short floater (length Lx=60L_x = 60 mm) gradually aligns in the direction of wave propagation (c), while the long floater (Lx=100L_x = 100 mm) aligns parallel to the wave crests (d).

In naval engineering contexts, the slow angular motion of elongated floaters is well known and sometimes referred to as low-frequency yawing. More than a century ago, Suyehiro [26] reported how small boat models rotate towards a preferential state of orientation and proposed a mechanism based on gyrostatic moments. Newman disagreed with this solid-mechanical explanation and proposed in 1967 his famous article that rationalised how ocean waves cause a mean drift force and moment on floating structures [18]. Starting from a global momentum and torque balance and using Green function theory, Newman expresses the second order drift force and yaw moment in terms of Kochin functions. These functions relate to the far-field limit of the hydrodynamic potential of the wave and and hence to how the wave is diffracted or modified by the moving floater. Using slender body theory, Newman was able to calculate these Kochin functions and this lead him to propose an explicit formula for the mean yaw moment acting on slender floaters. This theoretical mean yaw moment compared reasonably well with the few experimental data-points of Spens & Lalangas [22] (reproduced in Newman [18]). However, it also seems that some relevant physical effects are absent in this early theory: according to Newman’s formula, slender floaters that are shorter than the wave-length should always be stable in beam seas, i.e., they should align their long axis parallel to the wave crests, in contradiction with Figure 1.

The far-field approach of Newman triggered many subsequent theoretical works on the topic of mean drift force and moment. Salvesen [20] is a simplification of Newman’s model in which the floater is considered as a weak scatterer of the incoming wave. In Kashiwagi [14] and Kashiwagi & Ohkusu [15], Parseval’s theorem is used to evaluate the mean drift force and yaw moment, instead of the method of stationary phase used by Newman. An entirely different, near-field approach, of direct pressure integration was proposed by Faltinsen [12]. Different theoretical methods are compared in Skejic & Faltinsen [21], and show consistent results. Chen [6] proposed a third method, the so-called middle field formulation, to compute mean wave loads on structures. A boundary element method is used to calculate the hydrodynamic potential and Kochin functions. This method is also implemented in the software pack Hydrostar (Bureau-Veritas [3]) that is specifically designed for naval engineering applications. Experiments on the specific subject of slow yawing are not so common. In Le Boulluec et al. [17] it is briefly mentioned that elongated, container-like floaters can drift either in longitudinal positions (head-seas) or transverse position (beam-seas). Recently, Yasukawa et al. [28] compared the mean yaw moment obtained with a far-field theory to new experimental measurements on a particular ship model, and according to the authors the agreement is not so good.

Overall, few experimental studies were specifically dedicated to the topic of slow yawing or preferential orientation and this was a first motivation to do this study. Secondly, we also want to better understand the physics that controls this preferential orientation. In this article, we propose a new experimental, numerical and theoretical study that is fully dedicated to the subject of preferential orientation of small floaters. When floaters are small with respect to the wavelength, diffraction is less important and preferential orientation likely simpler to understand.

The article is structured as follows. In section 2, we present a systematic series of experiments investigating the preferential orientation of small floaters of varying length and density. In section 3, we define an idealised model for the motion of small floaters in propagating gravity waves. We use the Froude-Krylov approximation that ignores diffraction and we show that numerical solutions of this nonlinear model reproduce well the observed state of preferential orientation in our experiments. In section 4, we propose an asymptotic solution to this Froude-Krylov model in the double limit of small wave slope ϵ=ka\epsilon= ka (with kk the wavenumber and aa the wave amplitude) and small floater size. For elongated floaters with height LzL_z, width LyL_y and length LxL_x ordered as kLz≪kLy≪kLx≪1kL_z \ll kL_y \ll kL_x \ll1, this yields the idealized evolution equation for the average yaw angle ψˉ\bar{\psi},

ψˉ˙≈−ϵ2sin⁡ψˉcos⁡3ψˉ(1−FFc).(1)\dot{\bar{\psi}} \approx-\epsilon^2 \sin\bar{\psi}\cos^3\bar{\psi}\left(1-\frac{F}{F_c}\right). \tag*{(1)}

This equation depends on the non-dimensional number FF, defined as

F=kLx2βLz,(2)F = \frac{kL_x^2}{\beta L_z}, \tag*{(2)}

Here β\beta is the floater-to-water density ratio and we recognise hˉ=βLz\bar{h} = \beta L_z as the equilibrium submersion depth or draft of our parallelepiped floaters. The idealised, dissipation-less evolution equation (1.1) certainly does not capture all the complexity of realistic slow yawing, but it provides insight into the preferential state of orientation of small floaters. It suggests that, for F<FcF < F_c, the longitudinal position ψˉ=0∘\bar{\psi} = 0^\circ is stable and hence preferred, whereas for F>FcF > F_c, the transverse position ψˉ=90∘\bar{\psi} = 90^\circ is stable. Our theory predicts a transition at Fc=60F_c = 60, in fair agreement with the experimental value Fc≃50±15F_c \simeq50 \pm15. Relaxing the assumption kLy≪kLxkL_y \ll kL_x, we obtain a more general theory that suggests bistability in a narrow interval slightly below FcF_c, which may explain in part the experimental uncertainty.

The technicity of this asymptotic theory obscures physical insight and therefore, we propose in section 5 a second derivation of equation (1.1) using a shorter procedure. This shows better what physically controls the preferential orientation. The longitudinal equilibrium for short floaters arises through a mechanism similar to that explaining the Stokes drift of a material point. The buoyancy torque induced by wave crests rotates the floater in the longitudinal orientation, while that induced by wave troughs rotates the floater in the transverse orientation. Because of the slightly stronger buoyancy force on the crests than on the troughs, this produces a mean, second order, torque that favors the longitudinal orientation. Such a phase correlation between oscillating buoyancy force and oscillating level arm is analogous to that of the classical Kapitza pendulum, a pendulum whose anchor point is rapidly vibrated [13, 16, 4], which tends to align along the direction of vibration. The transverse state of orientation is on the other hand due to the fact that long floaters have a variable submersion along their length. This variable submersion significantly enhances the instantaneous yaw moment in trough positions that always favors the transverse position. In section 6, we finally compare our analytical formula for the mean yaw moment to previous results obtained by Newman [18] and Chen [6], and show good agreement in the small floater limit kLx<1kL_x < 1. We find that in Newman’s model, only the part of the mean yaw moment favoring the transverse position is present and this explains why his model does not predict a transition in preferential orientation.

Experiments

A series of laboratory experiments with centimeter-scale floaters of varying size and density have been performed in a water flume. The experimental setup, sketched in Figure 1(a-Figure 1b), consists in a tank of length 3 m, width 0.38 m, filled with water at height H=0.1H = 0.1 m. Waves are generated by a wavemaker consisting in a paddle oscillating at frequency ω/2π\omega/2\pi between 1 and 4 Hz, and are absorbed at the other end of the channel by a sloping plate.

We determine the wave profile ζ(x,t)\zeta(x,t) by imaging the instantaneous contact line through the lateral channel wall and using a line detection algorithm. The wave profile is well described by ζ=a(t)cos⁡(kx+φ(t))\zeta= a(t)\cos(kx + \varphi(t)), from which we determine the wave number kk and the instantaneous amplitude a(t)a(t) and phase φ(t)\varphi(t). Because of imperfect wave attenuation at the sloping plate, the wave contains a small steady component, resulting in temporal oscillations of the amplitude a(t)a(t) of the order of 5%. From this fit, we determine the mean wave amplitude, simply denoted aa in the following. The measured wave number matches the dispersion relation in the gravity regime, ω2=gktanh⁡(kH)\omega^2 = gk \tanh(kH), with wave lengths λ\lambda in the range 10 – 82 cm. Experiments for wavelengths of the order of the channel width are discarded because resonant transverse sloshing modes are excited. We work in the weakly nonlinear wave regime, for wave slopes ϵ=ak\epsilon= ak between 0.02 and 0.23.

The floaters are homogeneous rectangular parallelepipeds of varying length LxL_x, in the range 20 – 140 mm, and fixed width LyL_y and thickness LzL_z. They are cut from various materials of floater-to-water density ratio β=ρs/ρ\beta= \rho_s/\rho between 0.26 and 0.90, as summarized in Table 1. Without capillary effects, the expected equilibrium immersion depth βLz\beta L_z is in the range 1.3–5 mm, but because of the hydrophilic nature of the materials, capillary forces tend to sink the floater slightly more. The immersion depth hh for each floater has been measured from the projection of a narrow laser sheet at a shallow incidence angle of 10∘10^\circ onto the floater positioned at the surface of water. The horizontal displacement of the laser sheet’s intersection with both the water surface and the floater’s surface was measured with accuracy ±0.2\pm0.2 mm. The measured immersion depth hh, given in Table 1, consistently exceeds βLz\beta L_z by approximately 1 mm, in correct agreement with the expected capillary correction 2ℓc2cos⁡θ/Ly2\ell_c^2 \cos\theta/L_y, with ℓc=γ/ρg≃2.5\ell_c = \sqrt{\gamma/\rho g} \simeq2.5 mm the capillary length, γ\gamma the surface tension, and θ\theta the contact angle.

Materialβ\betaLyL_y (mm)LzL_z (mm)hh (mm)βLz\beta L_z (mm)
PU foam0.26±0.020.26 \pm0.0210.4±0.210.4 \pm0.24.9±0.054.9 \pm0.052.4±0.22.4 \pm0.21.3±0.11.3 \pm0.1
PVC foam0.44±0.020.44 \pm0.0210.4±0.210.4 \pm0.24.9±0.054.9 \pm0.052.8±0.22.8 \pm0.22.1±0.12.1 \pm0.1
PVC foam + Rubber0.73±0.020.73 \pm0.0220.5±0.220.5 \pm0.26.9±0.056.9 \pm0.055.3±0.25.3 \pm0.25.0±0.15.0 \pm0.1
ABS0.90±0.020.90 \pm0.0210.2±0.210.2 \pm0.24.3±0.054.3 \pm0.054.1±0.24.1 \pm0.23.9±0.13.9 \pm0.1

Table 1. Floater properties: density ratio β=ρs/ρ\beta= \rho_s/\rho, width LyL_y, thickness LzL_z, measured immersion depth hh, predicted immersion depth without capillary effects βLz\beta L_z. The floater length LxL_x (not shown) is between 20 and 140 mm for each material. PU: Polyurethane. PVC: Polyvinyl Chloride. ABS: Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene.

The equilibrium yaw angle of drifting floaters is determined as follows. For each run, a floater is gently deposited at the surface of water at a distance x0≃0.8x_0 \simeq0.8 m from the wave maker, with an initial yaw angle ψ0\psi_0 of approximately 45∘±15∘45^\circ\pm15^\circ from the xx axis (controlling precisely ψ0\psi_0 is difficult because the phase of the wave is not known at the time the floater is released). The floaters are imaged by a camera located above the wave tank. Using a tracking algorithm (library Tracker in Python), we measure the center of mass xc(t)x_c(t) and the yaw angle ψ(t)\psi(t) of the floater on each frame. For each run, the floater is left adrift for about 1 m, and only trajectories staying approximately along the center line of the channel are retained to discard possible interaction with the side walls.

At first order, the floater motion is a combination of a back-and-forth oscillation of its center of mass, of amplitude given by the typical horizontal excursion of the fluid particle trajectories (Δx=a/tanh⁡(kH)\Delta x = a/\tanh(kH) for waves in finite depth), and angular oscillations. Superimposed to these fast oscillations are a slow drift of the center of mass in the direction of the wave propagation (Stokes drift) and a slow drift of the yaw angle, either towards the longitudinal (ψ=0∘\psi= 0^\circ) or transverse (ψ=90∘\psi= 90^\circ) orientation. To filter out the fast oscillations and focus on the slow dynamics of ψ\psi, we synchronize the image acquisition with the wave maker oscillation, as illustrated in the chronophotographies of Figure 1(c-Figure 1d).

We first consider a set of floaters with a density ratio β=ρs/ρ=0.44\beta= \rho_s/\rho= 0.44 cut from expanded PVC foam boards of thickness Lz=4.9L_z = 4.9 mm, and investigate the influence of the floater length LxL_x, for a fixed wavelength λ=290\lambda= 290 mm and wave amplitude a=7.4a = 7.4 mm (wave slope ϵ=ka=0.16\epsilon= ka = 0.16). The time evolution of the yaw angle ψ\psi, sampled at the wave period, is shown in Figure 2(a). Because of the uncertainty on the initial angle ψ0\psi_0, we shift the time origin so that ψ\psi is 45∘45^\circ at t=0t = 0 for each run. The curves clearly separate in two groups, with small floaters (Lx≤60L_x \le60 mm) tending to ψ=0∘\psi= 0^\circ (longitudinal) and long floaters (Lx≥80L_x \ge80 mm) tending to ψ=90∘\psi= 90^\circ (transverse). We note that while short floaters precisely align in the longitudinal direction, with ψ≃0±5∘\psi\simeq0 \pm5^\circ at large time, long floaters show larger variations around ψ≃90±30∘\psi\simeq90 \pm30^\circ. We provide in section 4 a possible explanation for this behavior.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. (a) Yaw angle ψ\psi, sampled at each wave period, as a function of the time normalized by the wave period, for floaters of various lengths LxL_x. The time origin is chosen such that ψ(0)=45∘\psi(0) = 45^\circ. Wave frequency f=2.3f = 2.3 Hz, wavelength λ=0.29\lambda= 0.29 m, wave slope ak=0.16ak = 0.16, floater immersion depth hˉ=2.2\bar{h} = 2.2 mm. (b) Normalized angular velocity ψ˙/ω\dot{\psi}/\omega measured at ψ=45∘\psi= 45^\circ as a function of LxL_x.

Figure 2(a) shows that the reorientation dynamics is faster for very short or very long floaters: they reach their asymptotic orientation after approximately 5 wave periods only, while the convergence is much slower (at least 20 wave periods) for intermediate lengths. This convergence rate is illustrated in Figure 2(b) for various floater lengths, showing the angular velocity ψ˙\dot{\psi} measured at t=0t = 0 normalized by the wave frequency ω\omega (this ratio measures the fraction of complete turn performed by the floater during one wave period). For this particular floater density and thickness, ψ˙/ω\dot{\psi}/\omega crosses zero for Lx≃75L_x \simeq75 mm, which defines the critical length LxcL_{xc} separating the longitudinal and transverse orientations. Because of the slow dynamics at the crossover, the orientation is very sensitive to any experimental uncertainty for LxL_x close to LxcL_{xc}, such as the precise choice of the initial angle ψ0\psi_0, inhomogeneities in the streaming flow, or small defects in the wetting line.

We have systematically determined the asymptotic yaw angle for various floater lengths LxL_x, wave lengths λ\lambda and amplitudes aa. The preferential orientation of the floaters is first summarized in the plan (Lx,λ)(L_x,\lambda) in Figure 3(a). When the asymptotic angle is ψ≃0±10∘\psi\simeq0 \pm10^\circ, floaters are labeled as “longitudinal” (red circles), and when ψ≃90±30∘\psi\simeq90 \pm30^\circ they are labeled as “transverse” (blue triangles). Floaters with indistinct orientation are marked with black squares. This diagram shows a clear separation between the longitudinal and transverse orientations, with a transition line well described by a square-root law, Lxc≃ℓλL_{xc} \simeq\sqrt{\ell\lambda}, with ℓ≃16±3\ell\simeq16 \pm3 mm a fitting parameter.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. (a) Asymptotic floater orientation as a function of LxL_x and wavelength λ\lambda, for floaters with density β=0.44\beta= 0.44, width Ly=10L_y = 10 mm and thickness Lz=5L_z = 5 mm. Red circles: longitudinal; Blue triangles: transverse. Black squares indicate indistinct states (erratic oscillations or non-reproducible experiments). The separation line is Lx=ℓλL_x = \ell\sqrt{\lambda}, with ℓ≃16±3\ell\simeq16 \pm3 mm. (b) Same data in the plan (F,ϵ)(F,\epsilon), demonstrating the independence of the orientation with the wave steepness ϵ\epsilon. The long dashed line shows the experimental transition at Fc≃50F_c \simeq50, and the short dashed line the theoretical prediction at Fc=60F_c = 60.

References

  1. [1]Abramowitz, Milton & Stegun, Irene A 1948 Handbook of mathematical functions with formulas, graphs, and mathematical tables, vol. 55. US Government printing office.
  2. [2]van den Bremer, T. S. & Breivik, Ø. 2018 Stokes drift. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 376 (2111), 20170104.
  3. [3]Bureau-Veritas 2016 Hydrostar for experts user manual. Bureau Veritas.
  4. [4]Butikov, E.I. 2001 On the dynamic stabilization of an inverted pendulum. Am. J. Phys 69, 1–14.DOI
  5. [5]Calvert, R., McAllister, M. L., Whittaker, C., Raby, A., Borthwick, A.G.L. & Van Den Bremer, T.S. 2021 A mechanism for the increased wave-induced drift of floating marine litter. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 915, A73.
  6. [6]Chen, Xiao-Bo 2007 Middle-field formulation for the computation of wave-drift loads. Journal of Engineering Mathematics 59 (1), 61–82.DOI
  7. [7]DiBenedetto, Michelle H., Koseff, Jeffrey R. & Ouellette, Nicholas T. 2019 Orientation dynamics of nonspherical particles under surface gravity waves. Physical Review Fluids 4 (3), 034301.DOI
  8. [10]Falnes, Johannes & Kurniawan, Adi 2020 Ocean waves and oscillating systems: linear interactions including wave-energy extraction, vol. 8. Cambridge university press.
  9. [11]Faltinsen, Od 1993 Sea loads on ships and offshore structures, vol. 1. Cambridge university press.
  10. [12]Faltinsen, Odd Magnus 1980 Prediction of resistance and propulsion of a ship in a seaway. In 13th Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Tokyo, pp. 505–529.
  11. [13]Kapitza, P.L. 1951 Pendulum with an oscillating pivot. Sov. Phys. Uspekhi 44, 7–20.
  12. [14]Kashiwagi, M 1992 Added resistance, wave-induced steady sway force and yaw moment on an advancing ship. Schiffstechnik 39, 3–16.
  13. [15]Kashiwagi, Masashi & Ohkusu, Makoto 1993 Study on the wave-induced steady force and moment. Journal of The Society of Naval Architects of Japan 1993 (173), 185–194.DOI
  14. [16]Landau, L.D. & Lifschitz, E. M. 1960 Course of Theoretical Physics: Mechanics. Pergamon Press.
  15. [17]Le Boulluec, Marc, Forest, Bertrand & Mansuy, Emmanuel 2008 Steady drift of floating objects in waves - experimental and numerical investigations. Proceedings of the ASME 27th International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering.DOI
  16. [18]Newman, John Nicholas 1967 The drift force and moment on ships in waves. Journal of ship research 11 (01), 51–60.DOI
  17. [19]Newman, John Nicholas 2018 Marine hydrodynamics. The MIT press.
  18. [20]Salvesen, Nils 1974 Second order steady state forces and moments on surface ships in oblique regular waves. In Naval Ship Research and Development Center, Washington DC, USA, Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Dynamics of Marine Vehicles and Structures in Waves, University College London, Paper 22, pp. 225–241.
  19. [21]Skejic, Renato & Faltinsen, Odd M 2008 A unified seakeeping and maneuvering analysis of ships in regular waves. Journal of marine science and technology 13, 371–394.DOI
  20. [22]Spens, Paul G & Lalangas, Petros A 1962 Measurements of the mean lateral force and yawing moment on a series 60 model in oblique regular waves. Tech. Rep. Stevens Inst. of Technology, Davidson Laboratory.
  21. [23]Stokes, G. G. 1847 On the theory of oscillatory waves. Trans. Camb. Phil. Soc. 8, 441–455.
  22. [25]Sutherland, Bruce R, Dibenedetto, Michelle, Kaminski, Alexis & Van Den Bremer, Ton 2023 Fluid dynamics challenges in predicting plastic pollution transport in the ocean: A perspective. Physical Review Fluids 8 (7), 070701.DOI
  23. [26]Suyehiro, K 1921 The yawing of ships caused by the oscillation amongst waves. Journal of Zosen Kōkai 1920 (26), 23–33.DOI
  24. [27]Yang, M., Zhang, B., Chen, X., Kang, Q., Gao, B., Lee, J. & B., Chen 2023 Transport of microplastic and dispersed oil co-contaminants in the marine environment. Environ. Sci. Technol. 57, 5633–5645.DOI
  25. [28]Yasukawa, Hironori, Hirata, Noritaka, Matsumoto, Akinori, Kuroiwa, Ryota & Mizokami, Shuji 2019 Evaluations of wave-induced steady forces and turning motion of a full hull ship in waves. Journal of marine science and technology 24, 1–15.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_ganruuc9
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents