betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Energetics of particle-size segregation

Abstract

We introduce a continuum framework for the energetics of particle-size segregation in bidisperse granular flows. Building on continuum segregation equations and a recent segregation flux model, the proposed framework offers general analytical expressions to study the physics of granular flows from a mechanical energy perspective. To demonstrate the framework's applicability, we examined the energetics in shear-driven flows. Numerical experiments with varying frictional coefficients and particle-size ratios revealed two distinct phases in the associated energetics with particle segregation and diffusive remixing, and that the potential energy to the kinetic energy ratio in the steady state follows the scaling relationship E^gp(s)/E^k(s)∝Pesr−1/2\hat{E}^{(s)}_{gp} / \hat{E}^{(s)}_{k} \propto Pe^{-1/2}_{sr} for 0.4≤Pesr≤3000.4 \leq Pe_{sr} \leq 300, the segregation-rheology Péclet number. Our findings hint that the bulk segregation-mixing state can be predicted and controlled using PesrPe_{sr}, determined from known system parameters, providing a impactful tool for engineering and geophysical applications.

Banner appropriate to article type will appear here in typeset article

Introduction

Granular materials segregate and mix as they flow [6, 17]. Although no general agreement exists on the determining drivers, relative motion between particles of differing size conforming a granular bulk is essential for segregation, and they occur when available mechanical energy—sourced from external forcing or gravity—is transformed into kinetic energy. However, how the available energy partitions between segregation, mixing and interparticle friction within the granular bulk? Addressing this question is crucial not only for understanding of granular flow dynamics but also for optimising engineering processes aiming to transport or mix polydisperse materials.

Research on polydisperse granular flows from a mechanical energy perspective remains limited. Most of the studies have focused on characterising the energy dissipated by friction (e.g. [11, 7]), yet only a few have connected the energy with granular flow regimes. Using discrete element simulations, Sun et al. [12] found that the effective friction coefficient in sheared bidisperse granular flows is inversely proportional to the ratio of elastic to kinetic energy, and emphasised that energetics studies could bridge the mechanics from quasi-static to rapid flow regimes. Despite these insights, a comprehensive understanding of how mechanical energy transforms and relates to segregation-mixing states in flowing granular mixtures is still lacking.

Combining segregation theory (Gray [6]) with laboratory experiments, Trewhela et al. [15]’s scaling law for particle-size segregation provides robust predictions for segregation in dense granular flows from various physical parameters. Yet, advancing the modelling of granular flows in complex configurations requires characterising the energy source, how this energy partitions and transforms within and by the granular bulk. Having an energetics framework for granular flows is, therefore, instrumental to quantify how much of the available energy in a system leads to particles’ motion, segregation, mixing and irreversible dissipation due to friction.

This paper introduces a new continuum framework for characterising particle-size segregation and mixing from an energetics perspective. In § 2, we present the convection-diffusion model for particle-size segregation based on continuum-mixture theory (Gray [6]). Building on this and a recent segregation scaling law (Trewhela et al. [15]), we derive the energetics for noncohesive, inelastic, bidisperse particle flows in § 3. In § 4, we illustrate the framework’s applicability by studying the energetics for shear-driven, bidisperse granular flows, revealing a new scaling relationship between the ratio of the mechanical energy components and the segregation-rheology Péclet number, which offers potential applications in industrial and geophysical processes.

Theoretical framework

Bidisperse particle-size segregation equations

We consider a granular medium of bidisperse spherical particles—of differing small dsd_s and large dl>dsd_l > d_s diametres but uniform density ρ∗\rho_*—within a fixed volume VV. The mass of the mixture is M=Ml+MsM = M_l + M_s, with Ms=ρ∗ns(π/6)ds3M_s = \rho_* n_s (\pi/6)d_s^3 and Ml=ρ∗nl(π/6)dl3M_l = \rho_* n_l (\pi/6)d_l^3 the mass of the small particles and the large particles, respectively. The solids volume fraction Φ\Phi is then determined by dividing MM by the reference mass M∗=ρ∗VM_* = \rho_* V, so Φ=Φl+Φs\Phi= \Phi_l + \Phi_s. In dynamic systems, each concentration Φν\Phi_\nu (ν∈{s,l}\nu\in\{s,l\}) is, in principle, space- and time-dependent. However, the concentration Φ\Phi usually varies slightly in most dense granular flows. By assuming Φ\Phi to be constant, we can express each particle size concentration in terms of its corresponding species concentration, ϕs=Φs/Φ\phi_s = \Phi_s/\Phi and ϕl=Φl/Φ\phi_l = \Phi_l/\Phi. Thus, ϕs+ϕl=1\phi_s + \phi_l = 1 establishes the inherent mass conservation law for the granular system.

The bidisperse granular material can be treated as a continuum medium, for which mixture theory applied to the granular bulk yields the convective-diffusive equations for segregation,

∂ϕs∂t+∇⋅(ϕsu)+∇⋅(fslϕsϕlg∣g∣)=∇⋅(Dsl∇ϕs),(1)\frac{\partial\phi_s}{\partial t} + \nabla\cdot(\phi_s \mathbf{u}) + \nabla\cdot\left(f_{sl}\phi_s\phi_l\frac{\mathbf{g}}{|\mathbf{g}|}\right) = \nabla\cdot(\mathcal{D}_{sl}\nabla\phi_s), \tag*{(1)}
∂ϕl∂t+∇⋅(ϕlu)−∇⋅(fslϕsϕlg∣g∣)=∇⋅(Dsl∇ϕl),(2)\frac{\partial\phi_l}{\partial t} + \nabla\cdot(\phi_l \mathbf{u}) - \nabla\cdot\left(f_{sl}\phi_s\phi_l\frac{\mathbf{g}}{|\mathbf{g}|}\right) = \nabla\cdot(\mathcal{D}_{sl}\nabla\phi_l), \tag*{(2)}

where u\mathbf{u} is the divergence-free granular bulk velocity, Dsl\mathcal{D}_{sl} is the particle diffusivity and fslϕsϕlg/∣g∣f_{sl}\phi_s\phi_l \mathbf{g}/\lvert\mathbf{g}\rvert characterises the segregation flux, with fslf_{sl} the particle-size segregation velocity magnitude Gray [6]. The gravitational norm vector g/∣g∣\mathbf{g}/\lvert\mathbf{g}\rvert is included to confer a direction to size segregation, determined by the gravity-driven kinetic sieving and squeeze expulsion mechanisms. The functional form of fslf_{sl} has been proposed to be quadratic or cubic, symmetrical or asymmetrical [4, 17]. Recent scaling laws have aimed to parameterise fslf_{sl} in terms of physical quantities, such as pressure pp, shear rate γ˙\dot{\gamma}, local particle concentrations ϕs\phi_s and particle diameter dd. With that goal, Trewhela et al. [15] proposed that the segregation velocity fslf_{sl} could be described by

fsl=(Bρ∗gγ˙dˉ2p)[(Rd−1)+E(1−ϕs)(Rd−1)2],(3)f_{sl} = \left(\frac{B\rho_{*}g\dot{\gamma}\bar{d}^{2}}{p}\right)\left[(R_d-1)+\mathcal{E}(1-\phi_s)(R_d-1)^2\right], \tag*{(3)}

where BB and E\mathcal{E} are empirical constants, dˉ=ϕsds+ϕldl\bar{d}=\phi_s d_s+\phi_l d_l denotes the particles’ concentration-averaged diameter, whereas Rd=dl/dsR_d=d_l/d_s defines the particles’ size ratio. Merging the latter two definitions, the concentration-averaged diameter can be expressed as dˉ=(1−χdϕs)Rdds\bar{d}=(1-\chi_d\phi_s)R_d d_s, which captures the asymmetric behaviour of size segregation by defining χd=(Rd−1)/Rd\chi_d=(R_d-1)/R_d as the asymmetry coefficient [4, 19, 14]. Note that the function (3) is not particular or case-dependent; it describes the segregation velocity for both small and large particles, at variable concentrations ϕs\phi_s and ϕl=(1−ϕs)\phi_l=(1-\phi_s), respectively. It also compiles a comprehensive set of experimental and numerical observations hinting pressure pp, shear rate γ˙\dot{\gamma} and size ratio RdR_d dependence [5, 13, 3, 16].

From the definition of Φν\Phi_\nu, (2.1) can be directly expressed as

∂Φν∂t+∇⋅(Φνu)+∇⋅FΦν=∇⋅(Dsl∇Φν),(4)\frac{\partial\Phi_\nu}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot(\Phi_\nu\mathbf{u})+\nabla\cdot\mathbf{F}_{\Phi_\nu}=\nabla\cdot(D_{sl}\nabla\Phi_\nu), \tag*{(4)}

where the segregation flux FΦν\mathbf{F}_{\Phi_\nu} for the ν\nu-particle species is defined as

FΦν={+fslΦs[1−ϕs]g∣g∣for ν=s,−fslΦl[1−ϕl]g∣g∣for ν=l,(5)\mathbf{F}_{\Phi_\nu}= \begin{cases} +f_{sl}\Phi_s[1-\phi_s]\dfrac{\mathbf{g}}{\lvert\mathbf{g}\rvert} & \text{for }\nu=s,\\ -f_{sl}\Phi_l[1-\phi_l]\dfrac{\mathbf{g}}{\lvert\mathbf{g}\rvert} & \text{for }\nu=l, \end{cases} \tag*{(5)}

whereas the particles’ diffusivity Dsl=Aγ˙dˉ2D_{sl}=A\dot{\gamma}\bar{d}^{2} Utter & Behringer [18] is responsible for diffusive remixing and controls the final segregation state.

Energetics for the ν\nu-particle size segregation

Assuming rigid inelastic grains, the potential energy for the ν\nu-particle species in the volume VV of domain Ω\Omega is only determined by the gravitational component,

Egp(ν)=∫Ωρ∗gzΦν dV,(6)E_{gp}^{(\nu)}=\int_{\Omega}\rho_{*}gz\Phi_\nu\,\mathrm{d}V, \tag*{(6)}

with Egp(ν)(t,x)=ρ∗gzΦν(t,x)\mathcal{E}_{gp}^{(\nu)}(t,\mathbf{x})=\rho_{*}gz\Phi_\nu(t,\mathbf{x}) the gravitational potential energy (GPE) density and zz the vertical coordinate pointing upwards. Likewise, we define the kinetic energy (KE) of the ν\nu-particle species within the volume VV as

Ek(ν)=12∫Ωρ∗Φν∣u∣2 dV,(7)E_k^{(\nu)}=\frac{1}{2}\int_{\Omega}\rho_{*}\Phi_\nu\lvert\mathbf{u}\rvert^2\,\mathrm{d}V, \tag*{(7)}

with Ek(ν)(t,x)=12ρ∗Φν(t,x)∣u(t,x)∣2\mathcal{E}_k^{(\nu)}(t,\mathbf{x})=\frac{1}{2}\rho_{*}\Phi_\nu(t,\mathbf{x})\lvert\mathbf{u}(t,\mathbf{x})\rvert^2 the KE density.

Energetics for the gravitational potential energy

From (4), the evolution equation for the GPE density of the ν\nu-particle species is given by

∂Egp(ν)∂t=ρ∗gz[−∇⋅(Φνuν)−∇⋅FΦν+∇⋅(Dsl∇Φν)].(8)\frac{\partial\mathcal{E}_{gp}^{(\nu)}}{\partial t} = \rho_{*} g z \left[-\nabla\cdot\left(\Phi_{\nu}\mathbf{u}_{\nu}\right) - \nabla\cdot\mathbf{F}_{\Phi_{\nu}} + \nabla\cdot\left(D_{sl}\nabla\Phi_{\nu}\right)\right]. \tag*{(8)}

Therefore, utilising vector identities and the divergence theorem, the evolution equation for the GPE in the volume VV unfolds as follows:

dEgp(ν)dt=−∮∂Ωρ∗gz[Φνu+FΦν−Dsl∇Φν]⋅n^ dS+∫Ωρ∗gΦνw dV+∫Ωρ∗gFΦν⋅k^ dV−∫Ωρ∗gDsl∂Φν∂z dV.(9)\frac{\mathrm{d}E_{gp}^{(\nu)}}{\mathrm{d}t} = -\oint_{\partial\Omega} \rho_{*}gz\left[\Phi_{\nu}\mathbf{u}+\mathbf{F}_{\Phi_{\nu}}-D_{sl}\nabla\Phi_{\nu}\right]\cdot\hat{\mathbf{n}}\,\mathrm{d}S + \int_{\Omega}\rho_{*}g\Phi_{\nu}w\,\mathrm{d}V + \int_{\Omega}\rho_{*}g\mathbf{F}_{\Phi_{\nu}}\cdot\hat{\mathbf{k}}\,\mathrm{d}V - \int_{\Omega}\rho_{*}gD_{sl}\frac{\partial\Phi_{\nu}}{\partial z}\,\mathrm{d}V. \tag*{(9)}

Thus, the rate of change of Egp(ν)E_{gp}^{(\nu)} is determined by four main energetics, which characterise the injection, transformation and dissipation of GPE. The first energetics in the right-hand side of (9) characterises the net surface boundary flux Σgp(ν)\Sigma_{gp}^{(\nu)} that integrates fluxes resulting from advection, segregation and diffusion. The second energetics Ψc(ν)\Psi_{c}^{(\nu)} quantifies the rate of change of Egp(ν)E_{gp}^{(\nu)} due to particle redistribution resulting from vertical convective flows. Whereas the third Ψs(ν)\Psi_{s}^{(\nu)} and fourth Ψgpd(ν)\Psi_{gpd}^{(\nu)} energetics characterise the rate of change of Egp(ν)E_{gp}^{(\nu)} owing to vertical particle segregation and diffusion, respectively.

Energetics for the kinetic energy

The evolution equation for the KE density is derived from

∂Ek(ν)∂t=ρ∗12∣u∣2∂Φν∂t+ρ∗Φνu⋅∂u∂t(10)\frac{\partial\mathcal{E}_{k}^{(\nu)}}{\partial t} = \rho_{*}\frac{1}{2}\lvert\mathbf{u}\rvert^{2}\frac{\partial\Phi_{\nu}}{\partial t}+\rho_{*}\Phi_{\nu}\mathbf{u}\cdot\frac{\partial\mathbf{u}}{\partial t} \tag*{(10)}

and the linear momentum equation for the particles mixture,

ρ∗Φ[∂u∂t+∇(12∣u∣2)]=∇⋅T+ρ∗Φg.(11)\rho_{*}\Phi\left[\frac{\partial\mathbf{u}}{\partial t}+\nabla\left(\frac{1}{2}\lvert\mathbf{u}\rvert^{2}\right)\right]=\nabla\cdot\mathbf{T}+\rho_{*}\Phi\mathbf{g}. \tag*{(11)}

The stress tensor can be decomposed into T=τ−p1\mathbf{T}=\boldsymbol{\tau}-p\mathbf{1} with pp the pressure multiplying the tensor identity and τ\boldsymbol{\tau} the deviatoric shear stress. Consequently, from (4) and (11), the evolution equation of Ek(ν)(t,x)\mathcal{E}_{k}^{(\nu)}(t,x) is given by

∂Ek(ν)∂t=12∣u∣2ρ∗{−∇⋅(Φνu)−∇⋅FΦsl+∇⋅(Dsl∇Φν)}+u⋅{−ρ∗Φν∇(12∣u∣2)+ϕν∇⋅T+ρ∗Φνg}.(12)\frac{\partial\mathcal{E}_{k}^{(\nu)}}{\partial t}=\frac{1}{2}\lvert\mathbf{u}\rvert^{2}\rho_{*}\left\{-\nabla\cdot\left(\Phi_{\nu}\mathbf{u}\right)-\nabla\cdot\mathbf{F}_{\Phi_{sl}}+\nabla\cdot\left(D_{sl}\nabla\Phi_{\nu}\right)\right\} +\mathbf{u}\cdot\left\{-\rho_{*}\Phi_{\nu}\nabla\left(\frac{1}{2}\lvert\mathbf{u}\rvert^{2}\right)+\phi_{\nu}\nabla\cdot\mathbf{T}+\rho_{*}\Phi_{\nu}\mathbf{g}\right\}. \tag*{(12)}

Integrating (12) in the volume VV, the evolution equation for the KE is given by

dEk(ν)dt=−∫∂Ω[ρ∗2∣u∣2(Φνu+FΦν−Dsl∇Φν)−(ϕνu⋅T)]⋅n^ dS+∫ΩFΦsl⋅∇(ρ∗2∣u∣2) dV−∫ΩDsl∇Φν⋅∇(ρ∗2∣u∣2) dV−Ψc(ν)−∫Ω∇(ϕνu):T dV.(13)\frac{\mathrm{d}E_k^{(\nu)}}{\mathrm{d}t} = -\int_{\partial\Omega} \left[\frac{\rho_*}{2}|\boldsymbol{u}|^2\left(\Phi_\nu\boldsymbol{u}+\boldsymbol{F}_{\Phi_\nu}-D_{\mathrm{sl}}\nabla\Phi_\nu\right)-\left(\phi_\nu\boldsymbol{u}\cdot\boldsymbol{T}\right)\right]\cdot\hat{\boldsymbol{n}}\,\mathrm{d}S + \int_{\Omega}\boldsymbol{F}_{\Phi_{\mathrm{sl}}}\cdot\nabla\left(\frac{\rho_*}{2}|\boldsymbol{u}|^2\right)\,\mathrm{d}V - \int_{\Omega}D_{\mathrm{sl}}\nabla\Phi_\nu\cdot\nabla\left(\frac{\rho_*}{2}|\boldsymbol{u}|^2\right)\,\mathrm{d}V - \Psi_c^{(\nu)} - \int_{\Omega}\nabla\left(\phi_\nu\boldsymbol{u}\right):\boldsymbol{T}\,\mathrm{d}V. \tag*{(13)}

The rate of change of KE due to boundary fluxes is determined by the expression Σk(ν)\Sigma_k^{(\nu)}, while changes due to segregation, diffusion, and vertical transport are determined by the expressions Ψks(ν)\Psi_{ks}^{(\nu)}, Ψkd(ν)\Psi_{kd}^{(\nu)}, and Ψc(ν)\Psi_c^{(\nu)}, respectively. Lastly, the dissipation rate of KE due to friction is determined by the expression Ψμ(ν)\Psi_\mu^{(\nu)}.

Application: shear-driven granular flow

The framework introduced in § 3 allows investigating granular flows from an energy perspective. We illustrate its applicability by examining the energetics of sheared granular flows undergoing segregation and mixing dynamics. For such configuration, we must have a constitutive law relating stresses and the granular mixture rheology to determine the energy injection and dissipation resulting from particles’ friction, Ψμ(ν)\Psi_\mu^{(\nu)}; which are defined next.

Stress tensor and μ(I)\mu(I)-rheology for bidisperse granular mixtures

To calculate Σk(ν)\Sigma_k^{(\nu)} and Ψμ(ν)\Psi_\mu^{(\nu)} in (13), the stress tensor T\boldsymbol{T} needs to be described thoroughly. A first relationship to do so is the μ(I)\mu(I)-rheology, that relates the shear τ\tau and normal pp stresses through a Coulombic τ=μ(I)p\tau=\mu(I)p. Embedded within this definition, the frictional coefficient μ(I)\mu(I) is found to be dependent on the inertial number I=γ˙dˉ/p/ρ∗I=\dot{\gamma}\bar{d}/\sqrt{p/\rho_*} (e.g. MiDi [10]). The frictional coefficient is obtained by fitting the empirically-determined function μ(I)=μ1+(μ2−μ1)/(I0/I+1)\mu(I)=\mu_1+(\mu_2-\mu_1)/(I_0/I+1), where μ1\mu_1 and μ2\mu_2 are the static and dynamic frictional coefficients, respectively (Jop et al. [9]). These two coefficients alongside the material parameter I0I_0 correspond to the empirical parameters that define the μ(I)\mu(I)-rheology. However, the above relationship for μ(I)\mu(I) is ill posed. Barker & Gray [1] partially regularised the μ(I)\mu(I) definition with the extended relationship

μ(I)={α/log⁡(A/I),for I≤I1,μ1I0+μ2I+μ∞I2I+I0,for I>I1,(14)\mu(I)= \begin{cases} \sqrt{\alpha/\log(A/I)}, & \text{for } I\le I_1,\\ \dfrac{\mu_1 I_0+\mu_2 I+\mu_\infty I^2}{I+I_0}, & \text{for } I>I_1, \end{cases} \tag*{(14)}

where μ∞\mu_\infty, α\alpha and I1I_1 are material-dependent constants. The two latter parameters with AA serve as fitting constants for the partially-regularised μ(I)\mu(I)-rheology which guarantee continuity of (14). For this work, the values for all these parameters and constants defining the μ(I)\mu(I)-rheology are presented in table 1.

μ1=0.342\mu_1 = 0.342, μ2=0.557\mu_2 = 0.557, I0=0.069I_0 = 0.069, α=1.9\alpha= 1.9, μ∞=0.05\mu_\infty= 0.05, I1=0.005I_1 = 0.005, A=1.5647×104\mathcal{A} = 1.5647 \times10^4
dl=143 μmd_l = 143\ \mu\mathrm{m}, ρ∗=2500 kg m−3\rho_* = 2500\ \mathrm{kg\ m^{-3}}, Φ=0.6\Phi= 0.6, p0=300 Pap_0 = 300\ \mathrm{Pa}, u0=0.2 m s−1u_0 = 0.2\ \mathrm{m\ s^{-1}}, χμ=0.0075\chi_\mu= 0.0075
A=0.108\mathcal{A} = 0.108, B=0.374\mathcal{B} = 0.374, E=2.096\mathcal{E} = 2.096

Table 1. Parameters used in this work. Frictional parameters μ1\mu_1, μ2\mu_2 and I0I_0 for the μ(I)\mu(I)-rheology [9]. Coefficient μ∞\mu_\infty with the fitting parameters α\alpha, I1I_1 and A\mathcal{A} for the partial regularisation of the μ(I)\mu(I)-rheology were measured by Barker & Gray [1] for dl=143 μmd_l = 143\ \mu\mathrm{m} glass beads. Grains’ intrinsic density ρ∗\rho_*; solids volume fraction Φ\Phi; the specific values for pressure p0p_0 and velocity u0u_0 at the wall; and the frictional asymmetry coefficient χμ\chi_\mu (Trewhela [14]). Finally the constants for diffusivity A\mathcal{A} (Utter & Behringer [18]) and segregation B\mathcal{B}, E\mathcal{E} (Trewhela et al. [15]).

To include bidispersity effects in the bulk’s frictional response, we define a concentration-averaged frictional coefficient μˉ=μsϕs+μlϕl=(1−χμϕs)Rμμs\bar{\mu} = \mu_s\phi_s + \mu_l\phi_l = (1 - \chi_\mu\phi_s)R_\mu\mu_s. In the latter, μν\mu_\nu denotes the frictional coefficient for the ν\nu species and Rμ=μl/μsR_\mu= \mu_l/\mu_s a ratio that defines the asymmetry parameter, χμ=(Rμ−1)/Rμ\chi_\mu= (R_\mu- 1)/R_\mu (Trewhela [14]) (table 1). From the above definitions, the stress tensor components are given by

Tij={μˉ(I)p−pfor i=jμˉ(I)p,for i≠j,withi,j={x,z},(15)T_{ij} = \begin{cases} \bar{\mu}(I)p - p & \text{for } i = j \\ \bar{\mu}(I)p, & \text{for } i \ne j \end{cases} ,\qquad\text{with}\qquad i,j = \{x,z\}, \tag*{(15)}

which is naturally averaged over the concentrations of particle species.

Energetics of a sheared bidisperse granular layer

As case study, we consider a bidisperse granular bulk of depth hh sustaining shear exerted by a top plate imposing a uniform normal pressure distribution p=p0p = p_0 and moving at a constant velocity u0u_0 in the streamwise xx-direction (Figure 1a). Based on the rheological model in § 4.1, the pressure, velocity and frictional coefficient μ0\mu_0 set a shear τxz=τ0=p0μ0\tau_{xz} = \tau_0 = p_0\mu_0 (table 1) at the top boundary. In contrast, the granular material in contact with the motionless bottom does not slip nor roll. Under these conditions, the granular system develops a zero-gravity shear flow, which, for simplicity, is treated as two-dimensional and periodic in the xx-direction. As a result, the sheared layer depends on the upper boundary condition: h=(μ0/μ1−1)p0/(ρ∗gΦ)h = (\mu_0/\mu_1 - 1)p_0/(\rho_* g\Phi) (John Soundar Jerome & Di Pierro [8]). The top and bottom boundaries are closed, so fluxes across them are null. Without loss of generality, we examine the momentum-segregation equations of the small particle species, i.e. ν=s\nu= s, which in nondimensional form are given by

Image not extracted

Figure 1. (a) Schematic and numerical results. (b-c) Temporal evolution of the small particle species concentration ϕs(t^,z^)\phi_s(\hat{t},\hat{z}) and velocity profile u^(t^,z^)\hat{u}(\hat{t},\hat{z}) for Rd=2.5R_d = 2.5, μ0=0.5\mu_0 = 0.5.

∂u^∂t^=∂∂z^([1−χμϕs]Rμμsp^),∂ϕs∂t^=∂∂z^(f^slϕs[1−ϕs]+D^sl∂ϕs∂z^),(16)\frac{\partial\hat{u}}{\partial\hat{t}} = \frac{\partial}{\partial\hat{z}}\left([1-\chi_\mu\phi_s]R_\mu\mu_s\hat{p}\right),\qquad\frac{\partial\phi_s}{\partial\hat{t}} = \frac{\partial}{\partial\hat{z}}\left(\hat{f}_{sl}\phi_s[1-\phi_s] + \hat{D}_{sl}\frac{\partial\phi_s}{\partial\hat{z}}\right), \tag*{(16)}

where u^=u/u0\hat{u} = u/u_0, p^=p/p0\hat{p} = p/p_0, z^=z/h\hat{z} = z/h, t^=t/(h/u0)\hat{t} = t/(h/u_0), f^sl=fsl/u0\hat{f}_{sl} = f_{sl}/u_0, and D^sl=Dsl/(u0h)\hat{D}_{sl} = D_{sl}/(u_0h) denote the nondimensional variables (Trewhela [14]). From (16) and considering the energy scale per unit area, Φρ∗gh2\Phi\rho_* g h^2, the evolution equation for the nondimensional GPE, E^gp(s)=∫01ϕsz^ dz^\hat{E}_{gp}^{(s)} = \int_0^1 \phi_s\hat{z}\,\mathrm{d}\hat{z}, reduces to

dE^gp(s)dt=∫01−f^slϕs[1−ϕs] dz^⏟Ψ^gps(s)−∫01D^sl∂ϕs∂z^ dz^⏟Ψ^gpd(s).(17)\frac{\mathrm{d}\hat{E}_{gp}^{(s)}}{\mathrm{d}t} = \underbrace{\int_0^1-\hat{f}_{sl}\phi_s[1-\phi_s]\,\mathrm{d}\hat{z}}_{\hat{\Psi}_{gps}^{(s)}} - \underbrace{\int_0^1\hat{D}_{sl}\frac{\partial\phi_s}{\partial\hat{z}}\,\mathrm{d}\hat{z}}_{\hat{\Psi}_{gpd}^{(s)}}. \tag*{(17)}

Likewise, considering the same energy scale, the evolution equation for the nondimensional KE, E^ke(s)=12Fr2∫01u^2 dz^\hat{E}_{ke}^{(s)} = \frac{1}{2}Fr^2\int_0^1\hat{u}^2\,d\hat{z}, simplifies to

dE^k(s)dt=Fr2(u^[1−χμϕs]Rμμsp^)∣z^=1−Fr2∫01[1−χμϕs]Rμμsp^∂u^∂z^ dz^(18)\frac{d\hat{E}_k^{(s)}}{dt} = Fr^2\left(\hat{u}\left[1-\chi_\mu\phi_s\right]R_\mu\mu_s\hat{p}\right)\bigg|_{\hat{z}=1} - Fr^2\int_0^1\left[1-\chi_\mu\phi_s\right]R_\mu\mu_s\hat{p}\frac{\partial\hat{u}}{\partial\hat{z}}\,d\hat{z} \tag*{(18)}

with Fr=u0/ghFr = u_0/\sqrt{gh} the Froude number. The energetics Σ^k(s)\hat{\Sigma}_k^{(s)} and Ψ^μ(s)\hat{\Psi}_\mu^{(s)} are positive definite and determine the rate of kinetic (mechanical) energy production due to surface shear and KE dissipation owing to friction, respectively. In contrast, the energetics Ψ^gps(s)\hat{\Psi}_{gps}^{(s)} and Ψ^gpd(s)\hat{\Psi}_{gpd}^{(s)} quantify the transformation rate of potential (mechanical) energy due to vertical segregation and diffusion of particles, respectively; their signs are not fixed. The energy pathways controlled by the processes responsible for transforming the mechanical energy—i.e. segregation, particle diffusion and friction—are unknown and investigated next.

Numerical experiments

Following Trewhela [14], we resolved numerically the coupled, nonlinear PDE system in (16) using the Method of Lines (MOL). This numerical scheme is unconditionally-stable and considered a constant pressure distribution p=p0p = p_0 so its robustness is not compromised by the ill-posed μ(I)\mu(I)-rheology, despite it is regularised in (14). A total of 18 simulations were ran, considering first a set of parameters μ0×Rd={0.5,0.8}×{1.25,1.5,1.75,2.0,2.25,2.5}\mu_0 \times R_d = \{0.5, 0.8\} \times\{1.25, 1.5, 1.75, 2.0, 2.25, 2.5\} yielding 12 simulations to understand midrange values and secondly the set {0.4,1.2,1.6}×{1.25,2.5}\{0.4, 1.2, 1.6\} \times\{1.25, 2.5\} to explore extreme values for μ0\mu_0. The resulting set sheds light on the energetics under extreme frictional regimes and a wide range of segregation-mixing dynamics. Here, the fundamental parameter is the segregation-rheology Péclet number Trewhela [14], which spans as Pesr=Pe/Sc∈[0.4,300]Pe_{sr} = Pe/Sc \in[0.4, 300], with Pe=fslh/DslPe = f_{sl}h/D_{sl} the Péclet number and Sc=νg/DslSc = \nu_g/D_{sl} the Schmidt number. Figure 1 illustrates an example of the spatiotemporal evolution of small-particle concentration ϕs(t^,z^)\phi_s(\hat{t},\hat{z}) and vertical profiles of the shear-driven granular flow u^(t^,z^)\hat{u}(\hat{t},\hat{z}), which are utilised to compute the energetics in (17) and (18).

Figure 2(a) shows time series of the segregation energy flux Ψ^gps(s)\hat{\Psi}_{gps}^{(s)} and the diffusive energy flux Ψ^gpd(s)\hat{\Psi}_{gpd}^{(s)} for μ0=0.8\mu_0 = 0.8 and 1.25≤Rd≤2.51.25 \le R_d \le2.5. The energy flux

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Numerical results for μ0×Rd={0.8}×{1.25,1.5,1.75,2.0,2.25,2.5}\mu_0 \times R_d = \{0.8\} \times\{1.25, 1.5, 1.75, 2.0, 2.25, 2.5\}. (a) Energetics of GPE, Ψ^gps(s)\hat{\Psi}_{gps}^{(s)} and Ψ^gpd(s)\hat{\Psi}_{gpd}^{(s)} vs time t^\hat{t}. (b) Energetics of KE, Σ^k(s)\hat{\Sigma}_k^{(s)} and Ψ^μ(s)\hat{\Psi}_{\mu}^{(s)} vs time. (c) KE budget (top panel) and GPE budget (bottom panel) vs time t^\hat{t}.

Ψ^gps(s)\hat{\Psi}_{gps}^{(s)} is always negative, i.e. segregation continuously consumes the available GPE that the small particles have. Yet, Ψ^gps(s)\hat{\Psi}_{gps}^{(s)} exhibits two striking phases. The first phase is characterised by an exponential-like increase of the segregation flux, supported by the diffusive flux Ψ^gpd(s)\hat{\Psi}_{gpd}^{(s)} that also consumes GPE during this phase. The second phase is characterised by a change in the diffusive flux direction, which starts to raise the GPE until the granular flow balances into dE^gp(s)/dt^→0d\hat{E}_{gp}^{(s)}/d\hat{t} \to0. This equilibrium is shown in the bottom panel of Figure 2(c), that illustrates dE^gp(s)/dt^d\hat{E}_{gp}^{(s)}/d\hat{t} vs time. Figure 2(b) shows time series of the KE production due to shear taken by the small particles Σ^k(s)\hat{\Sigma}_k^{(s)} and the KE dissipation rate owing to friction Ψ^μ(s)\hat{\Psi}_{\mu}^{(s)}. The magnitude of KE energetics is larger than the GPE energetics, showing that the system is dominated by particle-particle interactions, with a short-lived transient phase, in which shear production is slightly higher than friction dissipation. This results in the KE reaching a shear-friction equilibrium significantly faster than the GPE equilibrium, which is hindered due to the slow pace segregation and the counter effect of diffusive remixing, as shown in Figure 2(c).

At the equilibrium state, the KE injected by shear is used to mobilise grains horizontally and maintain the bidisperse granular material fully or partially segregated across the sheared layer hh. Such balanced state—and therefore its GPE—should strongly depend on the competition between segregation and diffusion fluxes, which fosters mixing within the granular bulk. This competition is condensed by the segregation-rheology Péclet number Pesr=Pe/ScPe_{sr} = Pe/Sc.

Figure 3(a) shows the partition of the mechanical energy components of the small particle species versus PesrPe_{sr}. For low-PesrPe_{sr} (≤10\le10), the KE is substantially smaller than the GPE, whereas for high-PesrPe_{sr} (≥102\ge10^2), the KE scales with or surpasses the GPE. We therefore expect the segregation-mixing state to be sensible to the energy partition and, in particular, to the ratio between GPE and KE, termed as the bulk Richardson number of the granular flow Ri≡E^gp(s)/E^k(s)Ri \equiv\hat{E}_{gp}^{(s)}/\hat{E}_{k}^{(s)}. Figure 3(b) plots RiRi vs PesrPe_{sr} for our numerical solutions. The results exhibit a distinct scaling relationship Ri∝Pesr−1/2Ri \propto Pe_{sr}^{-1/2} for three decades of PesrPe_{sr}. From this relationship, the energy partition of the granular flow can be readily predicted since PesrPe_{sr} is determined from prescribed system parameters.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Results for all 18 numerical solutions. (a) Mechanical energy partition vs the segregation-rheology Péclet number PesrPe_{sr}. Reddish markers denote E^me(s)/E^me(s)\hat{E}_{me}^{(s)}/\hat{E}_{me}^{(s)}, blueish markers denote E^gp(s)/E^me(s)\hat{E}_{gp}^{(s)}/\hat{E}_{me}^{(s)}, with E^me(s)=E^k(s)+E^gp(s)\hat{E}_{me}^{(s)}=\hat{E}_{k}^{(s)}+\hat{E}_{gp}^{(s)}. (b) Ratio of the mechanical energy components, i.e. the Richardson number RiRi vs PesrPe_{sr}. (c) Degree of mixing Mϕ\mathcal{M}_{\phi} vs the Péclet number PePe.

Yet, how does the energy partition relate to the segregation-mixing state? We investigate this question through the ‘degree of mixing’ Mϕ=1−(σϕ/σg)2\mathcal{M}_{\phi} = 1 - (\sigma_{\phi}/\sigma_{g})^2, with σsg2=1/2\sigma_{sg}^{2}=1/2 the variance of the fully segregated state of the species concentration ϕs\phi_s and σϕ2\sigma_{\phi}^{2} the variance of ϕs\phi_s at the equilibrium. Thus, Mϕ=0\mathcal{M}_{\phi}=0 denotes a perfectly segregated state and Mϕ=1\mathcal{M}_{\phi}=1 a perfectly mixed state. It is apparent that the ‘degree of segregation’ in the system can be quantified from the reciprocal Sϕ=1−Mϕ\mathcal{S}_{\phi}=1-\mathcal{M}_{\phi}. To focus on the segregation-mixing state attained by the system, we examine Mϕ\mathcal{M}_{\phi} in terms of the Péclet number PePe instead of PesgPe_{sg}. This allows us to isolate the mechanisms controlling mass distribution and GPE, excluding the friction needed to account for KE. Figure 3(c) shows Mϕ\mathcal{M}_{\phi} vs PePe. The results show that PePe strongly controls the degree of mixing, characterized by a nonlinear yet monotonic relationship. Within our parameter space, the maximum mixing state is attained at Pe≃1Pe\simeq1, with Mϕ≈0.99\mathcal{M}_{\phi}\approx0.99. Conversely, the minimum mixing state, Mϕ≈0.05\mathcal{M}_{\phi}\approx0.05, is achieved at Pe≃102Pe\simeq10^{2}, indicating the onset of a saturation state. Statistically, we expect Mϕ\mathcal{M}_{\phi} not to be zero at high-PePe values as the transition region between small and large particles experiences a persistent remixing-segregation process, as seen in laboratory experiments (e.g. Golick & Daniels [5]; Ferdowsi et al. [2]).

Concluding remarks

This paper introduces a continuum framework for the energetics of particle-size segregation in granular flows, providing general analytical expressions for the energetics governing the mechanical energy budget in the system. The framework builds upon the convective-diffusion equation for segregation and a recent segregation scaling law (Trewhela et al. [15]), enabling the study of the complex physics of bidisperse granular flows from a mechanical energy perspective.

We illustrate the framework’s applicability by studying the energetics and mechanical energy partition in shear-driven bidisperse granular flows. Numerical solutions exploring different friction coefficients μ0\mu_0 and particle-size ratios RdR_d reveal: (i) the existence of distinctive phases in the segregation-mixing energy pathways and (ii) that the ratio between GPE and KE at equilibrium follows the scaling relationship E^gp(s)/E^k(s)∝(Sc/Pe)1/2\hat{E}_{gp}^{(s)}/\hat{E}_{k}^{(s)}\propto(Sc/Pe)^{1/2}, for 0.4≤Pe/Sc≤3000.4\leq Pe/Sc\leq300. Our findings hints that the energy partition of bidisperse granular flows can be predicted from the Péclet number PePe and the Schmidt number ScSc, providing a powerful tool for controlling and understanding segregation-mixing states in granular flows across various engineering applications and geophysical systems.

Acknowledgements. H.N.U. was supported by the UPenn start-up grant.

Fundings. T.T. received support from Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (ANID) through Fondecyt Initiation Project 11240630.

Declaration of interests. The authors report no conflict of interest.

Author ORCIDs

Tomás Trewhela https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7461-8570 Hugo N. Ulloa https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1995-6630

References

  1. [1]Barker, T. & Gray, J. M. N. T. 2017 Partial regularisation of the incompressible μ(I)-rheology for granular flow. J. Fluid Mech. 828, 5–32.DOI
  2. [2]Ferdowsi, B., Ortiz, C. P., Houssais, M. & Jerolmack, D. J. 2017 River-bed armouring as a granular segregation phenomenon, Nat. Commun., 8, 1363.DOI
  3. [3]Fry, A. M., Umbanhowar, P. B., Ottino, J. M. & Lueptow, R. M. 2018 Effect of pressure on segregation in granular shear flows. Phys. Rev. E 97, 062906.DOI
  4. [4]Gajjar, P. & Gray, J. M. N. T. 2014 Asymmetric flux models for particle-size segregation in granular avalanches. J. Fluid Mech. 757, 297–329.DOI
  5. [5]Golick, L. A. & Daniels, K. E. 2009 Mixing and segregation rates in sheared granular materials. Phys. Rev. E 80, 042301.DOI
  6. [6]Gray, J. M. N. T. 2018 Particle segregation in dense granular flows. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 50 (1), 407–433.DOI
  7. [7]Jiang, Y.-J., Fan, X.-Y., Li, T.-H. & Xiao, S.-Y. 2018 Influence of particle-size segregation on the impact of dry granular flow. Powder Technol. 340, 39–51.DOI
  8. [8]John Soundar Jerome, J. & Di Pierro, B. 2018 A note on Stokes’ problem in dense granular media using the μ(I)-rheology. J. Fluid Mech. 847, 365–385.
  9. [9]Jop, P., Forterre, Y. & Pouliquen, O. 2006 A constitutive law for dense granular flows. Nature 441 (7094), 727–730.DOI
  10. [10]Midi, G. D. R. 2004 On dense granular flows. Eur. Phys. J. E 14 (4), 341–365.
  11. [11]Pereira, G. G. & Cleary, P. W. 2017 Segregation due to particle shape of a granular mixture in a slowly rotating tumbler. Granul. Matter 19 (2), 23.DOI
  12. [12]Sun, Q., Jin, F. & Zhou, G. G. D. 2013 Energy characteristics of simple shear granular flows. Granul. Matter 15 (1), 119–128.DOI
  13. [13]Thornton, A. R., Weinhart, T., Luding, S. & Bokhove, O. 2012 Modeling of particle size segregation: calibration using the discrete particle method. Intl J. Mod. Phys. C 23, 1240014.
  14. [14]Trewhela, T. 2024 Segregation–rheology feedback in bidisperse granular flows: a coupled Stokes’ problem. J. Fluid Mech. 983, A45.DOI
  15. [15]Trewhela, T., Ancey, C. & Gray, J. M. N. T. 2021a An experimental scaling law for particle-size segregation in dense granular flows. J. Fluid Mech. 916 (A55), A55.DOI
  16. [16]Trewhela, T., Gray, J. M. N. T. & Ancey, C. 2021b Large particle segregation in two-dimensional sheared granular flows. Phys. Rev. Fluids 6, 054302.DOI
  17. [17]Umbanhowar, P. B., Lueptow, R. M. & Ottino, J. M. 2019 Modeling segregation in granular flows. Annu. Rev. Chem. Biomol. Eng. 10 (Volume 10, 2019), 129–153.DOI
  18. [18]Utter, B. & Behringer, R. P. 2004 Self-diffusion in dense granular shear flows. Phys. Rev. E 69, 031308.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15089287
  19. [19]van der Vaart, K., Gajjar, P., Epely-Chauvin, G., Andreini, N., Gray, J. M. N. T. & Ancey, C. 2015 Underlying asymmetry within particle size segregation. Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 238001.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26196829

Paper details

vlnc:W_gd7wyeeh
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents