betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Numerical evidence for a small-scale dynamo approaching solar magnetic Prandtl numbers

Abstract

Magnetic fields on small scales are ubiquitous in the universe. Though they can often be observed in detail, their generation mechanisms are not fully understood. One possibility is the so-called small-scale dynamo (SSD). Prevailing numerical evidence, however, appears to indicate that an SSD is unlikely to exist at very low magnetic Prandtl numbers (PrMPr_M) such as are present in the Sun and other cool stars. We have performed high-resolution simulations of isothermal forced turbulence employing the lowest PrMPr_M values so far achieved. Contrary to earlier findings, the SSD turns out to be not only possible for PrMPr_M down to 0.0031, but even becomes increasingly easier to excite for PrMPr_M below ≃ \simeq\,0.05. We relate this behaviour to the known hydrodynamic phenomenon referred to as the bottleneck effect. Extrapolating our results to solar values of PrMPr_M indicates that an SSD would be possible under such conditions.

Astrophysical flows are considered to be susceptible to two types of dynamo instabilities. Firstly, a large-scale dynamo (LSD) is excited by flows exhibiting helicity, or more generally, lacking mirror-symmetry, due to rotation, shear, and/or stratification. It generates coherent, dynamically significant, magnetic fields on the global scales of the object in question [1]. Characteristics of LSDs vary depending on the dominating generative effects, such as differential rotation in the case of the Sun. Convective turbulence provides both generative and dissipative effects [2], and their presence and astrophysical relevance is no longer strongly debated.

The presence of the other type of dynamo instability, namely the small-scale or fluctuation dynamo (SSD), however, remains controversial in solar and stellar physics. In an SSD-active system, the magnetic field is generated at scales comparable to, or smaller than the characteristic scales of the turbulent flow, enabled by chaotic stretching of field lines at high magnetic Reynolds number [3]. In contrast to the LSD, excitation of an SSD requires significantly stronger turbulence [1]. Furthermore, it has been theorized that it becomes more difficult to excite SSD at very low magnetic Prandtl number PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{M} [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10], the ratio of kinematic viscosity ν\nu and magnetic diffusivity η\eta. In the Sun, PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{M} can reach values as low as 10−610^{-6}–10−410^{-4} [11], thus seriously repudiating whether an SSD can at all be present. Numerical models of SSD in near-surface solar convection typically operate at PrM≈1\mathrm{Pr}_{M} \approx1 [12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18] and thus circumvent the issue of low-PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{M} dynamos.

A powerful SSD may potentially have a large impact on the dynamical processes in the Sun. It can, for example, influence the angular momentum transport and therefore the generation of differential rotation [19, 20], interact with the LSD [21, 22, 23, 24, 25] or contribute to coronal heating via enhanced photospheric Poynting flux [26]. Hence, it is of great importance to clarify whether or not an SSD can exist in the Sun. Observationally, it is still debated whether the small-scale magnetic field on the surface of the Sun has contributions from the SSD or is solely due to the tangling of the large-scale magnetic field by the turbulent motions [27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32]. However, these studies show a slight preference of the small-scale fields to be cycle-independent. SSD at small PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{M} are also important for the interiors of planets and for liquid metal experiments [33].

Various numerical studies have reported increasing difficulties in exciting the SSD when decreasing PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{M} [6, 10, 34], confirming the theoretical predictions. However, current numerical models reach only PrM=0.03\mathrm{Pr}_{M} = 0.03 using explicit physical diffusion or slightly lower (estimated) PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{M}, relying on artificial hyperdiffusion [7, 8]. To achieve even lower PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{M}, one needs to increase the grid resolution massively, see also [35]. Exciting the SSD requires a magnetic Reynolds number (ReM\mathrm{Re}_{M}) typically larger than 100; hence, e.g., PrM=0.01\mathrm{Pr}_{M} = 0.01 implies a fluid Reynolds number Re=104\mathrm{Re} = 10^{4}, where Re=urmsℓ/ν\mathrm{Re} = u_{\mathrm{rms}}\ell/\nu, urmsu_{\mathrm{rms}} being the volume integrated root-mean-squared velocity, ℓ\ell a characteristic scale of the velocity, and ReM=PrMRe\mathrm{Re}_{M} = \mathrm{Pr}_{M}\mathrm{Re}. In this paper, we take this path and lower PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{M} significantly using high-resolution simulations.

Results

We include simulations with resolutions of 2563256^3 to 460834608^3 grid points and Re⁡=46\operatorname{Re} = 46 to 3300033000. This allows us to explore the parameter space from Pr⁡M=1\operatorname{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 1 to 0.00250.0025, which is closer to the solar value than has been investigated in previous studies. For each run, we measure the growth rate λ\lambda of the magnetic field in its kinematic stage and determine whether or not an SSD is being excited.

To afford an in-depth exploration of the effect of Pr⁡M\operatorname{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, we omit large-scale effects such as stratification, rotation and shear. We avoid the excessive integration times, required to simulate convection, by driving the turbulent flow explicitly under isothermal conditions. Our simulation setup consists of a fully periodic box with a random volume force, see Online Methods for details; the flow exhibits a Mach number of around 0.08. In Figure 1, we visualize the velocity and magnetic fields of one of the highest resolution and Reynolds number cases. As might be anticipated for low Pr⁡M\operatorname{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} turbulence, the flow exhibits much finer, fractal-like structures than the magnetic field. Note, that all our results refer to the kinematic stage of the SSD, where the magnetic field strength is far too weak to influence the flow and otherwise arbitrary.

Flow speed and magnetic field strength visualisations

Figure 1. Visualisation of flow and SSD solution. Flow speed (left) and magnetic field strength (right) from a high resolution SSD-active run with Re⁡=18200\operatorname{Re} = 18200 and Pr⁡M=0.01\operatorname{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 0.01 on the surface of the simulation box.

Growth rates and critical magnetic Reynolds numbers

In Figure 2 we visualize the growth rate λ\lambda as function of Re⁡\operatorname{Re} and Re⁡M\operatorname{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}. We find positive growth rates for all sets of runs with constant Pr⁡M\operatorname{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} if Re⁡M\operatorname{Re}_{\mathrm{M}} is large enough. λ\lambda increases always with increasing Re⁡M\operatorname{Re}_{\mathrm{M}} as expected. Surprisingly, the growth rates are significantly lower within the interval from Re⁡=2000\operatorname{Re} = 2000 to

Figure 2. Small-scale dynamo growth rate as function of the fluid and magnetic Reynolds numbers (Re\mathrm{Re} and ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}). The diamonds represent the results of this work and the triangles those of [10]. The color coding indicates the value of the normalized growth rate λτ\lambda\tau with τ=1/urmskf\tau= 1/u_{\mathrm{rms}}k_{\mathrm{f}}, a rough estimate for the turnover time. Dotted lines indicate constant magnetic Prandtl number PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}. White circles indicate zero growth rate for certain PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, obtained from fitting for the critical magnetic Reynolds number, as shown in Figure 3; fitting errors are signified by yellow-black bars. see Supplementary Material, § 15. The background colors including the thin black line (zero growth) are assigned via linear interpolation of the simulation data. The green dashed line shows the power-law fit of the critical ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}} for PrM≤0.08\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \le0.08, with power 0.125, see Figure 3b.

Small-scale dynamos at low Prandtl numbers

10000 than below and above. With the ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}} values used, this maps roughly to a PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} interval from about 0.1 to 0.04.

The growth rates for PrM=0.1\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 0.1 match very well the ones from [10], indicated by triangles. From Figure 2, we clearly see that the critical magnetic Reynolds number ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{\mathrm{crit}}, defined by growth rate λ=0\lambda= 0, first rises as a function of Re\mathrm{Re} and then falls for Re>3×103\mathrm{Re} > 3 \times10^{3}, see the thin black line. Looking at ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{\mathrm{crit}} as a function of magnetic Prandtl number PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, it first increases with decreasing PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} and then decreases for PrM<0.05\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} < 0.05. Hence, an SSD is easier to excite here than for 0.05<PrM<0.10.05 < \mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} < 0.1. We could even find a nearly marginal, positive growth rate for PrM=0.003125\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 0.003125. The decrease of λ\lambda at low PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} is an important result as the SSD was believed to be even harder [4, 9] or at least equally hard [7, 8] to excite when PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} was decreased further from previously investigated values. The growth rates agree qualitatively with the earlier work at low PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} [6, 7, 8].

For a more accurate determination of ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{\mathrm{crit}}, we next plot the growth rates for fixed PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} as a function of ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}, see Figure 3(a). The data are consistent with λ∝ln⁡(ReM/ReMcrit)\lambda\propto\ln\left(\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}/\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{\mathrm{crit}}\right) as theoretically predicted [36, 37]. Fitting accordingly, we are able to determine ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{\mathrm{crit}} as a function of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, see Figure 3(b). The latter plot clearly shows that there are three distinct regions of dynamo excitation: When PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} decreases in the range 1≥PrM≥0.11 \ge\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \ge0.1 it becomes much harder to excite the SSD. In the range 0.1≥PrM≥0.040.1 \ge\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \ge0.04, excitation is most difficult with little variation of ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}}. For PrM≤0.04\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \le0.04, it again becomes easier as PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} reduces.

Growth rate and critical Reynolds number

Figure 3. Growth rate and critical Reynolds number. Panel (a): normalized growth rate λτ\lambda\tau as function of magnetic Reynolds number ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}} for simulation sets with fixed magnetic Prandtl number PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, indicated by different colors. Logarithmic functions λτ∝ln⁡(ReM/ReMcrit)\lambda\tau\propto\ln(\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}/\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}}) according to [36, 37] were fitted separately to the individual sets, as indicated by the colored lines; see the dashed-dotted line for the mean slope. Panel (b): critical magnetic Reynolds number ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} as function of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} obtained from the fits in panel (a). Error bars show the fitting error, see Supplementary Material, Section 5. The diamond indicates a run with growth rate λ≈0\lambda\approx0, hence its ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}} represents ≈ReMcrit\approx\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} for the used PrM=0.003125\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 0.003125. The red dashed line is a power law fit ReMcrit∝PrM0.125\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} \propto\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}^{0.125}, valid for PrM≲0.08\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \lesssim0.08. The grey shaded area indicates the PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} interval where the dynamo is hardest to excite (ReMcrit≳150\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} \gtrsim150).

In [7, 8], the authors already found an indication of ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} to level-off with decreasing PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, however only when using artificial hyperdiffusion. Similarly, with our error bars, a constant ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} cannot be excluded for 0.01<PrM<0.10.01 < \mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} < 0.1. However, at PrM=0.005\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 0.005, the error bar allows to conclude that ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} is here lower than at PrM=0.05\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 0.05. This again confirms our result that ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} is decreasing with PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} for very low PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}.

For PrM≤0.05\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \le0.05, the decrease of ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} with PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} can be well represented by the power-law ReMcrit∝PrM0.125\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} \propto\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}^{0.125}. Extrapolating this to the Sun and solar-like stars would lead to ReMcrit≈40\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} \approx40 at PrM=10−6\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 10^{-6}, which means that we could expect an SSD to be present. For increasing Re\mathrm{Re}, by decreasing ν\nu, it would be reasonable to assert that the statistical properties of the flow and hence ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} become independent of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}. However, episodes of non-monotonic behavior of ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} when approaching this limit cannot be ruled out.

The well-determined ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}^{\mathrm{crit}}_{\mathrm{M}} dependency on PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} together with its error bars and the power-law fit have been added to Figure 2, and agree very well with the thin black line for λ=0\lambda= 0 interpolated from the growth rates.

Regions of dynamo excitation

Next we seek answers to the obvious question arising: why is the SSD harder to excite in a certain intermediate range of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} and easier at lower and higher values? For this, we investigate the kinetic and magnetic energy spectra of a representative subset of the runs, see Supplementary Table 2. We show in Figure 4 spectra of two exemplary cases: Run F005, with PrM=0.05\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 0.05, probes the PrM\mathrm{Pr}_M interval of impeded dynamo action, while Run H0005, with PrM=0.005\mathrm{Pr}_M=0.005, is clearly outside it; see Supplementary Figure 1 and Supplementary Figure S2 for spectra of other cases.

Figure 4. Energy spectra. Kinetic (top row) and magnetic (bottom row) energy spectra for two exemplary runs with Re=7958\mathrm{Re}=7958, PrM=0.05\mathrm{Pr}_M=0.05 (left column) and Re=32930\mathrm{Re}=32930, PrM=0.005\mathrm{Pr}_M=0.005 (right column). In the middle row, the kinetic spectra are compensated by k5/3k^{5/3}. Vertical lines indicate the forcing wavenumber kfk_f (green solid), the wavenumber of the bottleneck’s peak kbk_b (red solid) and its starting point kbsk_{bs} (red dotted), the viscous dissipation wavenumber kνk_\nu (orange), the ohmic dissipation wavenumber kη=kνPrM3/4k_\eta=k_\nu\mathrm{Pr}_M^{3/4} (dark blue) and the characteristic magnetic wavenumber kMk_M (light blue). All spectra are averaged over the kinematic phase whereupon each individual magnetic spectrum was normalized by its maximum, thus taking out the exponential growth.

Slope of the low-wavenumber part of the bottleneck

Supplementary Figure 1. Slope of the low-wavenumber part of the bottleneck, αb\alpha_b, as a function of fluid Reynolds number ReRe. The blue line indicates the slope −5/3-5/3 in the inertial range without bottleneck; the red line shows a power-law fit with Re0.03Re^{0.03}.

Kinetic energy spectra for a representative subset of the runs

Figure S2. Kinetic energy spectra, for explanations see Figure 4. The notation “kν→k_{\nu} \to” indicates that kνk_{\nu} is outside the accessible kk range.

In all cases the kinetic energy clearly follows a Kolmogorov cascade with Ekin∝k−5/3E_{\mathrm{kin}}\propto k^{-5/3} in the inertial range. When compensating with k5/3k^{5/3}, we find the well-known bottleneck effect [38, 39]: a local increase in spectral energy, deviating from the power-law, as found both in fluid experiments [40, 41, 42] and numerical studies [43, 44]. It has been postulated to be detrimental to SSD growth [4, 10]. For the magnetic spectrum on the other hand, yet clearly visible only for PrM≤0.005\mathrm{Pr}_M\leq0.005, we find a power-law following Emag∝k−3E_{\mathrm{mag}}\propto k^{-3}. A 3/23/2 slope at low wavenumbers as predicted by [45] is seen only in the runs with PrM\mathrm{Pr}_M close to one, while for the intermediate and low PrM\mathrm{Pr}_M runs, the positive-slope part of the spectrum shrinks to cover only the lowest kk values, and the steep negative slopes at high kk values become prominent. A steep negative slope in the magnetic power spectra was also seen by [7] for PrM\mathrm{Pr}_M slightly below unity. However, the authors propose a tentative power of −1-1 given that the −3-3 slope is not yet clearly visible for their PrM\mathrm{Pr}_M values.

Analyzing our simulations, we adopt the following strategy: For each spectrum, we determine the wavenumber of the bottleneck, kbk_b, as the location of its maximum in the (smoothed) compensated spectrum, along with its starting point kbs<kbk_{\mathrm{bs}} < k_{\mathrm{b}} at the location with 75% of the maximum, see the middle-row panels of Figure 4. We additionally calculate a characteristic magnetic wavenumber, defined as kM=∫kEmag(k)k dk∫kEmag(k) dkk_{\mathrm{M}} = \frac{\int_k E_{\mathrm{mag}}(k) k\,\mathrm{d}k}{\int_k E_{\mathrm{mag}}(k)\,\mathrm{d}k}, which is often connected with the energy-carrying scale. Furthermore, we calculate the viscous dissipation wavenumber kν=(ϵK/ν3)1/4k_{\nu} = (\epsilon_{\mathrm{K}}/\nu^3)^{1/4} following Kolmogorov theory, where ϵK\epsilon_{\mathrm{K}} is the viscous dissipation rate 2νS22\nu\boldsymbol{S}^2 with the traceless rate-of-strain tensor of the flow, S\boldsymbol{S}. From the relations between these four wavenumbers (listed in Supplementary Table 2), we will draw insights about the observed behavior of ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{\mathrm{crit}} with respect to PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}.

We plot kb/kνk_{\mathrm{b}}/k_{\nu} and kbs/kνk_{\mathrm{bs}}/k_{\nu} as functions of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} in Figure 5. As is expected, kb/kνk_{\mathrm{b}}/k_{\nu}, or the ratio of the viscous scale to the scale of the bottleneck, does not depend on PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, as the bottleneck is a purely hydrodynamic phenomenon. The start of the bottleneck kbsk_{\mathrm{bs}} should likewise not depend on PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, but the low Re values for PrM=1\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 1 to 0.10.1 lead to apparent thinner bottlenecks, hence an unsystematic weak dependency. The red shaded area between kbk_{\mathrm{b}} and kbsk_{\mathrm{bs}} is the low-wavenumber part of bottleneck where the slope of the spectrum is larger (less negative) than −5/3-5/3 see Supplementary Table 2 for values of the modified slope αb\alpha_{\mathrm{b}} and Supplementary, Section 1 for a discussion. We note that αb≈−1.3…−1.5\alpha_{\mathrm{b}} \approx-1.3\ldots-1.5 and can thus deviate significantly from −5/3-5/3. Overplotting the kM/kνk_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\nu} curve reveals that it intersects with the red shaded where the dynamo is hardest to excite (region II). This lets us conclude that the shallower slope of the low-wavenumber part of the bottleneck may indeed be responsible for enhancing ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{\mathrm{crit}} in the interval 0.04≤PrM≤0.10.04 \leq\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \leq0.1. Using this plot, we can now clearly explain the three regions of dynamo excitation. For 0.1≤PrM≤10.1 \leq\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \leq1 the low-wavenumber part of bottleneck and the characteristic magnetic scale are completely decoupled. This makes the SSD easy to excite (region I). For 0.04≤PrM≤0.10.04 \leq\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \leq0.1, (grey, region II), the dynamo is hardest to excite because of the shallower slope of the kinetic spectra. In region III, where PrM≤0.04\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \leq0.04 the low-wavenumber part of bottleneck and the characteristic magnetic scale are again completely decoupled making the dynamo easier to excite.

Figure 5. Relation of the characteristic magnetic wavenumber kMk_{\mathrm{M}} to the bottleneck. We show its peak kbk_{\mathrm{b}} and its starting point kbsk_{\mathrm{bs}} in red, the characteristic magnetic wavenumber kMk_{\mathrm{M}} in light blue and the ohmic dissipation wavenumber kηk_{\eta} in dark blue. The red shaded area between kbk_{\mathrm{b}} and kbsk_{\mathrm{bs}} corresponds to the low-wavenumber part of the bottleneck where the turbulent flow is rougher than for a −5/3-5/3 power-law. The Roman numbers indicate the three distinct regions of dynamo excitation. The region of the weakest growth (II) is over-plotted in grey. The characteristic magnetic wavenumber kMk_{\mathrm{M}} can be fitted by two power laws (black dotted lines): kM/kν∝PrM0.54k_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\nu} \propto\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}^{0.54} for PrM≥0.05\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \ge0.05 and kM/kν∝PrM0.71k_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\nu} \propto\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}^{0.71} for PrM≤0.05\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \le0.05. All wavenumbers are normalized by the viscous one kνk_{\nu}. We find that the dynamo is hardest to excite if kMk_{\mathrm{M}} lies within the low-wavenumber side of the bottleneck. Leaving this region towards lower or higher wavenumbers makes the dynamo easier to excite. The inset shows kM/kηk_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\eta} as a function of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}.

Further, we find that the dependence of kM/kνk_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\nu} on PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} also differs between the regions. In region I kM/kνk_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\nu} depends on PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} via kM/kν∝PrM0.54k_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\nu} \propto\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}^{0.54} and in region II and III via kM/kν∝PrM0.71k_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\nu} \propto\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}^{0.71}. This becomes particularly interesting when comparing the characteristic magnetic wavenumber kMk_{\mathrm{M}} with the ohmic dissipation wavenumber which is defined as kη=kνPrM3/4k_{\eta} = k_{\nu}\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}^{3/4}. In region I, we find a significant difference of kMk_{\mathrm{M}} and kηk_{\eta} in value and scaling. However, in region III the scaling of kMk_{\mathrm{M}} comes very close to the 3/43/4 scaling of kηk_{\eta}. This behaviour can be even better seen in the inset of Figure 5, where the ratio kM/kηk_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\eta} is 0.3 for PrM=1\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 1 and tends towards unity for decreasing PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, but is likely to saturate below 0.75.

Discussion

In conclusion, we find that the SSD is progressively easier to excite for magnetic Prandtl numbers below 0.04, in contrast to earlier findings, and thus is very likely to exist in the Sun and other cool stars. Provided saturation at sufficiently high levels, the SSD has been proposed to strongly influence the dynamics of solar-like stars: previous numerical studies, albeit at PrM≈1\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \approx1, indicate that this influence concerns for example the angular momentum transport [19, 20], and the LSD [21, 22, 23, 24, 25]. Our kinematic study, however, only shows that a positive growth rate is possible at very low PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, but not whether an SSD is able to generate dynamically important field strengths. As the ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}} of the Sun and solar-like stars is several orders of magnitude higher than the extrapolated ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{\mathrm{crit}} value of 40, we yet expect dynamically important SSDs as indicated by PrM=1\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} = 1 simulations [15]. However, numerical simulations with PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} down to 0.01 show a decrease of the saturation strength with decreasing PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} [46].

The results of our study are well in agreement with previous numerical studies considering partly overlapping PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} ranges [6, 7, 8, 10]. Those found some discrepancies with the Kazantsev theory [45] for low PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, for example the narrowing down of the positive Kazantsev spectrum at low and intermediate wavenumbers, and the emergence of a negative slope instead at large wave numbers [7]. We could extend this regime to even lower PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} and therefore study these discrepancies further. For PrM≤0.005\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \leq0.005 we find that the magnetic spectrum shows a power-law scaling k−3k^{-3}, which is significantly steeper than the tentative k−1k^{-1} one proposed in [7] for 0.03≲PrM≲0.070.03 \lesssim\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \lesssim0.07 (but only for 8th-order hyperdiffusivity). This latest finding of such a steep power law in the magnetic spectrum challenges the current theoretical predictions and might indicate that the SSD operating at low PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} is fundamentally different from that at PrM≈1\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \approx1.

Secondly, we find that the growth rates near the onset follow an ln⁡(ReM)\ln(\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}) dependence as predicted by [36, 37], and not a ReM1/2\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{1/2} one as would result from intertial-range-driven SSD [1, 7]. We do not observe a tendency of the growth rate to become independent of ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}} at the highest PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} either, which could be an indication of an outer-scale driven SSD, as postulated by [7]. Furthermore, we find that the pre-factor of γ∝ln⁡(ReM/ReMcrit)\gamma\propto\ln(\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}/\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{\mathrm{crit}}) is nearly constant with its mean around 0.022, in agreement with 0.023 of [10]. A constant value means that the logarithmic scaling is independent of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} and seems to be of general validity.

Thirdly, we find that the measured characteristic magnetic wavenumber kMk_{\mathrm{M}} is always smaller than the estimated kηk_{\eta}, and furthermore, kMk_{\mathrm{M}} is not always following the theory-predicted scaling of kη∝PrM3/4k_{\eta} \propto\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}^{3/4} with PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}. For the region I, where PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} is close to 1, this discrepancy is up to a factor of three and the deviation from the expected PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}-scaling is most significant here. These discrepancies have been associated with the numerical setups injecting energy at a forcing scale far larger than the dissipation scale, i.e. kf≪kηk_f \ll k_{\eta} [1]. Furthermore, our runs in region I also have relatively low Re\mathrm{Re} and therefore numerical effects are not dismissible. In region III (low PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}), kM/kηk_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\eta} is approaching the constant offset factor 0.75. Hence, the scaling of kM/kνk_{\mathrm{M}}/k_{\nu} with PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} gets close to the expected one. This result again indicates that the SSD at low PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} is different from that at PrM≈1\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \approx1.

An increase of ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}^{\mathrm{crit}} with decreasing PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} followed by an asymptotic levelling-off for PrM≪1\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \ll1 was expected in the light of theory and previous numerical studies. Instead, we found non-monotonic behavior as function of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}; we could relate it to the hydrodynamical phenomenon of the bottleneck. If the characteristic magnetic wavenumber lies in the positive-gradient part of the compensated spectrum, where the spectral slope is significantly reduced from −5/3-5/3 to ∼−1.4\sim-1.4, the dynamo is hardest to excite (0.1≥PrM≥0.040.1 \ge\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} \ge0.04). For higher or lower PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, the dynamo becomes increasingly easier to excite. The local change in slope due to the bottleneck has often been related to an increase of the “roughness” of the flow [1, 10, 43], which is expected to harden dynamo excitation based on theoretical predictions [4, 9] from kinematic Kazantsev theory [45]. In line with theory, the roughness-increasing part of the bottleneck appears decisive in our results, however, only when kMk_{\mathrm{M}} is used as a criterion. The usage of kηk_{\eta} would in contrast suggest that the peak of the bottleneck is decisive [10]. Such interpretation appears incorrect, as the rough estimate of kηk_{\eta} employed here does not represent the magnetic spectrum adequately and the peak of the bottleneck does not coincide with the maximum of “roughness”.

Online Methods

Numerical setup

For our simulations, we use a cubic Cartesian box with edge length LL and solve the isothermal magnetohydrodynamic equations without gravity, similar as in [5, 47].

DuDt=−cs2∇ln⁡ρ+J×B/ρ+∇⋅(2ρνS)/ρ+f,(1)\frac{\mathrm{D}\mathbf{u}}{\mathrm{D}t}=-c_{\mathrm{s}}^{2}\nabla\ln\rho+\mathbf{J}\times\mathbf{B}/\rho+\nabla\cdot(2\rho\nu\mathbf{S})/\rho+\mathbf{f}, \tag*{(1)}
∂A∂t=u×B+η∇2A,(2)\frac{\partial\mathbf{A}}{\partial t}=\mathbf{u}\times\mathbf{B}+\eta\nabla^{2}\mathbf{A}, \tag*{(2)}
DρDt=−∇⋅(ρu),(3)\frac{\mathrm{D}\rho}{\mathrm{D}t}=-\nabla\cdot(\rho\mathbf{u}), \tag*{(3)}

where u\mathbf{u} is the flow speed, csc_{\mathrm{s}} is the sound speed, ρ\rho is the mass density, and B=∇×A\mathbf{B}=\nabla\times\mathbf{A} is the magnetic field with A\mathbf{A} being the vector potential. J=∇×B/μ0\mathbf{J}=\nabla\times\mathbf{B}/\mu_{0} is the current density with magnetic vacuum permeability μ0\mu_{0}, while ν\nu and η\eta are constant kinematic viscosity and magnetic diffusivity, respectively. The rate-of-strain tensor Sij=(ui,j+uj,i)/2−δij∇⋅u/3S_{ij}=(u_{i,j}+u_{j,i})/2-\delta_{ij}\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}/3 is traceless. The forcing function f\mathbf{f} provides random white-in-time non-helical transversal plane waves, which are added in each time step to the momentum equation, see [5] for details. The wavenumbers of the forcing lie in a narrow band around kf=2k1k_{\mathrm{f}}=2k_{1} with k1=2π/Lk_{1}=2\pi/L. Its amplitude is chosen such that the Mach number Ma=urms/csMa=u_{\mathrm{rms}}/c_{\mathrm{s}} is always around 0.082, where urms=⟨u2⟩Vu_{\mathrm{rms}}=\sqrt{\langle\mathbf{u}^{2}\rangle_{V}} is the volume and time-averaged root-mean-square value. The MaMa values of all runs are listed in Supplementary Material Table 1. To normalize the growth rate λ\lambda, we use an estimated turnover time τ=1/urmskf≈6/k1cs\tau=1/u_{\mathrm{rms}}k_{\mathrm{f}}\approx6/k_{1}c_{\mathrm{s}}. The boundary conditions are periodic for all quantities and we initialise the magnetic field with weak Gaussian noise.

Diffusion is controlled by the prescribed parameters ν\nu and η\eta. Accordingly, we define the fluid and magnetic Reynolds numbers with the forcing wavenumber kfk_{\mathrm{f}} as

Re=urmsνkf,ReM=urmsηkf.(4)\mathrm{Re}=\frac{u_{\mathrm{rms}}}{\nu k_{\mathrm{f}}},\quad\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}=\frac{u_{\mathrm{rms}}}{\eta k_{\mathrm{f}}}. \tag*{(4)}

We performed numerical free decay experiments (see Supplementary Material, Section 7), from which we confirm that the numerical diffusivities are negligible.

The spectral kinetic and magnetic energy densities are defined via

∫kEkin(k) dk=urms2⟨ρ⟩V/2,(5)\int_{k} E_{\mathrm{kin}}(k)\,\mathrm{d}k=u_{\mathrm{rms}}^{2}\langle\rho\rangle_{V}/2, \tag*{(5)}
∫kEmag(k) dk=Brms2/2μ0.(6)\int_{k} E_{\mathrm{mag}}(k)\,\mathrm{d}k=B_{\mathrm{rms}}^{2}/2\mu_{0}. \tag*{(6)}

where Brms=⟨B2⟩VB_{\mathrm{rms}} = \sqrt{\langle B^2\rangle_V} is the volume-averaged root-mean-square value and ⟨ρ⟩V\langle\rho\rangle_V the volume-averaged density.

Our numerical setup employs a drastically simplified model of turbulence compared to the actual one in the Sun. There, turbulence is driven by stratified rotating convection being of course neither isothermal nor isotropic. However, these simplifications were to date necessary when performing a parameter study at such high resolutions as we do. Nevertheless, we can connect our study to solar parameters in terms of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_M and Ma\mathrm{Ma}. Their chosen values best represent the weakly stratified layers within the bulk of the solar convection zone, where PrM≪1\mathrm{Pr}_M \ll1 and Ma≪1\mathrm{Ma} \ll1. The anisotropy in the flow on small scales is much weaker there than near the surface and therefore close to our simplified setup.

Data availability

Data for reproducing Figure 2, Figure 3, and Figure 5 are included in the article and its supplementary information files. The raw data (time-series, spectra, slices, and snapshots) are provided through IDA/Fairdata service hosted at CSC, Finland, under https://doi.org/10.23729/206af669-07fd-4a30-9968-b4ded5003014. From the raw data, Figure 1 and Figure 4 can be reproduced.

Code availability

We use the Pencil Code [48] to perform all simulations, with parallelized fast-Fourier-transforms to calculate the spectra on the fly [49]. Pencil Code is freely available under https://github.com/pencil-code/.

Acknowledgements

We acknowledge fruitful discussions with Axel Brandenburg, Igor Rogachevskii, Alexander Schekochihin, and Jennifer Schober during the Nordita program on “Magnetic field evolution in low density or strongly stratified plasmas”. Computing resources from CSC during the Mahti pilot project and from Max Planck Computing and Data Facility (MPCDF) are gratefully acknowledged. This project including all authors, has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (Project UniSDyn, grant agreement n:o 818665). This work was done in collaboration with the COFFIES DRIVE Science Center.

Author Contributions Statement

JW was leading, but all the authors contributed, to the design and performing the numerical simulations. JW was leading the data analysis. MJKL was in charge of acquiring the computational resources from CSC. All the authors contributed to the interpretation of the results and writing up the manuscript.

Competing Interests Statement

The authors declare no competing interests.

Supplementary Material

Discussion on the roughness of the flow

We calculate the slope in the low-wavenumber part of the bottleneck by fitting Emag∼kαbE_{\mathrm{mag}} \sim k^{\alpha_b} in the interval kbs…kbk_{bs}\ldots k_b. As shown in Supplementary Figure 1, the values of αb\alpha_b are significantly different from −5/3-5/3 without the bottleneck. Furthermore, we find no clear systematic dependence of αb\alpha_b on ReRe.

Spectra of a representative subset of the runs

Normalized magnetic energy spectra

Supplementary Figure 3. Normalized magnetic energy spectra, for explanations see Figure 4. The notation “kν,η→k_{\nu,\eta} \to” indicates that kν,ηk_{\nu,\eta} is outside the accessible kk range.

Table of all runs

RunResolutionPrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}Re\mathrm{Re}ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}Ma\mathrm{Ma}λτ\lambda\tauσλτ\sigma_{\lambda\tau}
P102563256^31.0046460.0750.01020.0015
A802563256^38.00997900.0800.09620.0013
A402563256^34.00993940.0800.07940.0016
A202563256^32.00991970.0800.05570.0009
A152563256^31.50991480.0800.04580.0010
A102563256^31.0099990.0800.03150.0007
A082563256^30.8098780.0790.02000.0008
A052563256^30.5098490.079-0.00080.0019
A042563256^30.4097390.079-0.00520.0016
B202563256^32.004058110.0810.11290.0010
B102563256^31.004044040.0810.07070.0004
B052563256^30.504042020.0810.03340.0019
B03752563256^30.3754031510.0810.01820.0011
B0252563256^30.254051010.0810.00150.0010
B022563256^30.2405810.082-0.00600.0025
B01252563256^30.125405510.082-0.02170.0025
B012563256^30.1404400.082-0.02870.0015
C102563256^31.00102210220.0820.14280.0075
C082563256^30.8010148110.0820.10790.0028
C042563256^30.4010134050.0820.04860.0007
C022563256^30.2010082010.0810.01320.0009
C0152563256^30.1510141520.0820.00270.0008
C012563256^30.1010131010.081-0.00740.0010
C0082563256^30.081015810.082-0.01540.0022
C0052563256^30.051019510.082-0.02390.0014
D105123512^31.00205320530.0830.18530.0052
D045123512^30.4020388150.0820.06820.0017
D025123512^30.2020264050.0820.02350.0006
D015123512^30.1020382040.0820.00530.0021
D00755123512^30.07520291520.082-0.00050.0015
D0055123512^30.0520311020.082-0.00580.0017
D0045123512^30.042034810.082-0.01210.0009
D00255123512^30.0252030510.082-0.02360.0017
E10102431024^31.00406940690.0820.27690.0126
E08102431024^30.80399931990.0810.21410.0091
E04102431024^30.40408716350.0820.11480.0324
E02102431024^30.2040648130.0820.04010.0025
E01102431024^30.1040754070.0820.01550.0009
E008102431024^30.0840893250.0820.01910.0025
E005102431024^30.0540902050.0820.00440.0021
E00375102431024^30.037541211550.0830.00060.0024
E003102431024^30.0340841230.082-0.00350.0012
E002102431024^30.024037810.081-0.01630.0023
E001102431024^30.014043400.082-0.02320.0029

Table 1. Overview of all performed runs.

PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} is the magnetic Prandtl number, Re\mathrm{Re} and ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}} are the fluid and magnetic Reynolds numbers, Ma=urms/cs\mathrm{Ma}=u_{\mathrm{rms}}/c_{\mathrm{s}} is the Mach number, τ=1/urmskf\tau=1/u_{\mathrm{rms}}k_{\mathrm{f}} is a rough estimate for the turnover time, λ\lambda is the SSD growth rate with its error σλ\sigma_{\lambda}.

RunResolutionPrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}Re\mathrm{Re}ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}Maλτ\lambda_{\tau}σλτ\sigma_{\lambda_{\tau}}
F01204832048^30.1080288030.0810.03200.0046
F005204832048^30.0579593980.0800.01920.0029
F0025204832048^30.02580502010.0810.01080.0026
F001875204832048^30.0187580931520.0820.00390.0027
F00125204832048^30.012581711020.082-0.00040.0022
F001204832048^30.018178820.082-0.00090.0033
F0005204832048^30.0058217410.083-0.01620.0035
FG00125204832048^30.0125125801570.0840.00260.0015
FG001204832048^30.01123131230.082-0.00410.0021
FG0005204832048^30.00512415620.083-0.01460.0039
G00125409634096^30.0125183912290.0930.03720.0063
G001409634096^30.01182001820.0920.00650.0062
G000625409634096^30.00625161261010.081-0.00490.0069
G0005409634096^30.00516071800.081-0.01520.0008
H0005409634096^30.005329301650.0830.01030.0019
H00031409634096^30.003125327171020.0820.00210.0052
H00025460834608^30.002532910820.083-0.00970.0035

Table S1. Supplementary Table 1: continued.

Table of spectral properties of a subset of the runs

PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}Re\mathrm{Re}ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}}kνk_{\nu}kbsk_{\mathrm{bs}}kbk_{\mathrm{b}}kMk_{\mathrm{M}}kηk_{\eta}αb\alpha_{\mathrm{b}}
1.00000010221022157112156157-1.30
1.000000205320532681636100268-1.43
1.000000406940694562262173456-1.38
0.8000001012810157112148132-1.29
0.800000399831984442262146376-1.40
0.400000101440515611213578-1.30
0.400000408716344592262105231-1.38
0.200000101320215711212447-1.29
0.100000101810115711211627-1.29
0.08000010158115711211423-1.29
0.080000406832545122624167-1.39
0.050000408620445822623148-1.38
0.0500007958397755321015079-1.41
0.04000020338126616361523-1.44
0.02000040388044922621623-1.39
0.0125008167102766321011928-1.41
0.012500125801571026501372738-1.39
0.012500183912291332451733349-1.48
0.010000123131231013491372232-1.39
0.010000182001821388451833043-1.48
0.006250161261001291481731928-1.45
0.005000821741767321011014-1.41
0.00500012415621013491371319-1.39
0.00500016044801273451651623-1.46
0.005000329301642037972642638-1.39
0.0031253271710220361002721926-1.38

Table 2. Selected runs with spectral properties.

PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} is the magnetic Prandtl number, Re\mathrm{Re} and ReM\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{M}} are the fluid and magnetic Reynolds numbers, respectively. kν=(ϵK/ν3)1/4k_{\nu} = (\epsilon_{\mathrm{K}}/\nu^{3})^{1/4} is the viscous dissipation wavenumber with the viscous dissipation rate ϵK\epsilon_{\mathrm{K}}. kbk_{\mathrm{b}} and kbsk_{\mathrm{bs}} locate the maximum of the bottleneck and its starting point (75% of the maximum), respectively. kM=∫kEmag(k) dk/∫Emag(k) dkk_{\mathrm{M}} = \int k E_{\mathrm{mag}}(k)\,\mathrm{d}k / \int E_{\mathrm{mag}}(k)\,\mathrm{d}k is the characteristic magnetic wavenumber. kη=kνPrM3/4k_{\eta} = k_{\nu}\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}^{3/4} is the ohmic dissipation wavenumber and αb\alpha_{\mathrm{b}} is the slope of the low-wavenumber part of the bottleneck. All wavenumbers in units of k1k_{1}.

Details of fitting procedures and error calculation

Growth rates

The growth rate λ\lambda is calculated from the time series of BrmsB_{\rm rms} of the hydrodynamically saturated stage. For this, we fit Brms(t)B_{\rm rms}(t) with exp⁡(λt)\exp(\lambda t) using a least-χ2\chi^2 fit. For a small number of runs, mostly at PrM≈1\mathrm{Pr}_{\rm M}\approx1, we need to exclude that part of the time series, where no longer Brms≪ρμ0urmsB_{\rm rms}\ll\sqrt{\rho\mu_0}u_{\rm rms} holds, i.e. the kinematic stage is left. The majority of runs always stays in the kinematic stage though. The error of the growth rate, σλ\sigma_\lambda, is estimated from the maximum deviation of the fit, which is determined as follows: the time series is divided into three equal parts, each fitted to obtain its value λi\lambda_i, i=1,…,3i=1,\ldots,3. We then use half the maximum difference to λ\lambda for the error, i.e. σλ=max⁡∣λi−λ∣/2\sigma_\lambda=\max\lvert\lambda_i-\lambda\rvert/2. The minimal length of the time series was chosen to guarantee that σλ\sigma_\lambda is small enough while the maximum is bound by the resolution, hence the computational cost. For resolutions of 2563−5123256^3-512^3, we have tmax⁡/τ≈500t_{\max}/\tau\approx500, for 10243−204831024^3-2048^3, tmax⁡/τ≈150t_{\max}/\tau\approx150 and for 409634096^3, tmax⁡/τ≈15t_{\max}/\tau\approx15. λ\lambda and its error σλ\sigma_\lambda are listed in Supplementary Table 1.

Critical magnetic Reynolds number

To calculate the critical magnetic Reynolds number ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit} for each PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\rm M} set, we fit a logarithmic function to the growth rate, i.e. λτ=C1ln⁡(ReM)+C2\lambda\tau=C_1\ln(\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M})+C_2. This functional form is motivated by the theoretical expectation of [4, 1] and also by the distribution of the growth rates in Figure 3a. We again use a least-χ2\chi^2 fit, but take into account the growth rate errors, σλ\sigma_\lambda, for the weights. It turns out that the pre-factor C1C_1 varies between 0.017 and 0.028 with a mean of 0.022. Thus, we conclude that the chosen functional form is appropriate. ReMcrit(PrM)\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}(\mathrm{Pr}_{\rm M}) is calculated analytically from the zero of the fitting function, ReMcrit=exp⁡(−C2/C1)\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}=\exp(-C_2/C_1), and its error σReMcrit\sigma_{\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}} is derived directly from each fit, representing a one-sigma uncertainty of ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}. The values and errors of ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit} are then used in Figure 3b and are listed in Supplementary Table 3 together with C1C_1. For the relative error σReMcrit/ReMcrit\sigma_{\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}}/\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}, one finds for most of the runs values around 10–20%. However, taking these errors into account the decrease of ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit} as function of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\rm M} is still significant.

PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\rm M}ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}σReMcrit\sigma_{\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}}C1C_1
1.0000321.00.028
0.4000602.60.025
0.200010110.10.017
0.100015011.70.021
0.080015321.10.025
0.050015313.40.021
0.025013815.30.024
0.012511949.80.018
0.010013631.80.017
0.005010818.50.022
0.003125102––

Table 3. Critical magnetic Reynolds number

ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit} is the critical magnetic magnetic Reynolds number obtained by a fit λτ=C1ln⁡(ReM/ReMcrit)\lambda\tau=C_1\ln(\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}/\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}) to the growth rate and σReMcrit\sigma_{\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}} its error. The last row refers to the only run for PrM=0.003125\mathrm{Pr}_{\rm M}=0.003125 with λ≈0\lambda\approx0, hence ReM≈ReMcrit\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}\approx\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit} (no fit).

Other fits

To obtain ReMcrit(PrM)∝PrM0.125\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}(\mathrm{Pr}_{\rm M})\propto\mathrm{Pr}_{\rm M}^{0.125} in Figure 3b, we use also a least-χ2\chi^2 fit, employing the errors σReMcrit\sigma_{\mathrm{Re}_{\rm M}^{\rm crit}}, similar for kM/kν∝PrMαMk_{\rm M}/k_\nu\propto\mathrm{Pr}_{\rm M}^{\alpha_{\rm M}} in Figure 4.

Magnetic energy transfer functions

Seeking further insight into the dynamo operating in the three regimes of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}, we look at the spectral magnetic energy transfer functions. We follow the approach of [2], but using the convention by [3], where the contribution of compressibility is subsumed in the stretching/shearing and advection terms, TStrT_{\mathrm{Str}} and TAdvT_{\mathrm{Adv}}, respectively, as follows

TStr(k)=B^(k)⋅(+B⋅∇u−B∇⋅u/2)∗(k)/2μ0+c.c.(7)T_{\mathrm{Str}}(k)=\hat{\mathbf{B}}(k)\cdot\left(+\mathbf{B}\cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}-\mathbf{B}\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}/2\right)^{*}(k)/2\mu_{0}+\mathrm{c.c.} \tag*{(7)}
TAdv(k)=B^(k)⋅(−u⋅∇B−B∇⋅u/2)∗(k)/2μ0+c.c.(8)T_{\mathrm{Adv}}(k)=\hat{\mathbf{B}}(k)\cdot\left(-\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla\mathbf{B}-\mathbf{B}\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}/2\right)^{*}(k)/2\mu_{0}+\mathrm{c.c.} \tag*{(8)}

Here, the hats indicate the Fourier transform and c.c. refers to the complex conjugate expressions. In Supplementary Figure 4, we show these functions after shell integration, i.e. as functions of k=∣k∣k=|\mathbf{k}|, for six runs with 0.005≤PrM≤0.80.005\leq\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}\leq0.8. As expected, the curves peak at higher wavenumbers for higher PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}. We also look at the ratio of the wavenumbers at which TStrT_{\mathrm{Str}} and TAdvT_{\mathrm{Adv}} has its maximum and minimum, respectively, kStr/kAdvk_{\mathrm{Str}}/k_{\mathrm{Adv}}, which is determined from the curves after smoothing. We find that this ratio is maximal where the dynamo is hardest to excite, shown as grey shade in the Supplementary Figure 4. However, we should note that the simulations with the two lowest PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} have a higher resolution than the other four, which could also influence the result. It remains unclear whether, or how, this enhanced ratio would relate to the difficulty in exciting the dynamo at 0.1≥PrM≥0.040.1\geq\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}\geq0.04.

Shell integrated spectral magnetic energy transfer functions

Supplementary Figure 4. Shell integrated spectral magnetic energy transfer functions vs. magnetic Prandtl number PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}. Panel a: transfer by stretching/shearing, TStrT_{\mathrm{Str}}, and by advection, TAdvT_{\mathrm{Adv}}, normalized by the total magnetic energy density ⟨Emag⟩V=∫kEmag(k) dk\langle E_{\mathrm{mag}}\rangle_{V}=\int_k E_{\mathrm{mag}}(k)\,dk divided by turnover time τ\tau and averaged over time. Color coding refers to PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} as shown in the legend. Panel b: ratio of the wavenumbers of maximal stretching and minimal advection, kStr/kAdvk_{\mathrm{Str}}/k_{\mathrm{Adv}}, as a function of PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}. The grey shaded area indicates the interval 0.1≥PrM≥0.040.1\geq\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}}\geq0.04, where the dynamo is hardest to excite. The errors are calculated using an estimated uncertainty in determining kStrk_{\mathrm{Str}} and kAdvk_{\mathrm{Adv}}, Used runs: E08, E04, E008, E005, G001, H0005.

Numerical diffusivity

In our low PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} simulations, η≫ν\eta\gg\nu, hence numerical diffusion might only play a role for the velocity field. We estimate the numerical viscosity in our simulations in two ways. Firstly, we follow the approach of [2], to estimate the fluid Reynolds number from the power spectra. For this we determine the Taylor microscale

λTM=(∫kEkin(k) dk∫kk2Ekin(k) dk)1/2,(9)\lambda_{\mathrm{TM}} = \left(\frac{\int_k E_{\mathrm{kin}}(k)\,\mathrm{d}k}{\int_k k^2 E_{\mathrm{kin}}(k)\,\mathrm{d}k}\right)^{1/2}, \tag*{(9)}

and the integral scale for turbulent motions

λint=∫kk−1Ekin(k) dk∫kEkin(k) dk.(10)\lambda_{\mathrm{int}} = \frac{\int_k k^{-1} E_{\mathrm{kin}}(k)\,\mathrm{d}k}{\int_k E_{\mathrm{kin}}(k)\,\mathrm{d}k}. \tag*{(10)}

These scales can be used to estimate the effective Reynolds number as

Reeff∝(λintλTM)2.(11)\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{eff}} \propto\left(\frac{\lambda_{\mathrm{int}}}{\lambda_{\mathrm{TM}}}\right)^2. \tag*{(11)}

This is often used to estimate Reeff\mathrm{Re}_{\mathrm{eff}} from observations or in simulations that use only numerical diffusivities, although the proportionality constant is unknown. As shown in Supplementary Figure 5, the effective Re\mathrm{Re} based on Equation (5) scales linearly with Re\mathrm{Re} based on the prescribed value of ν\nu. Assuming now plausibly numerical diffusion to enter mainly in the form of hyperdiffusion, we infer that from this linear relationship a notable influence of numerical diffusion can be ruled out.

Effective Reynolds number proxy as a function of Re

Supplementary Figure 5. Effective Reynolds number proxy (5) as a function of Re\mathrm{Re} from the prescribed ν\nu. The red line indicates (λint/λTM)2=0.026 Re(\lambda_{\mathrm{int}}/\lambda_{\mathrm{TM}})^2 = 0.026\,\mathrm{Re}.

In addition, we performed a flow decay experiment to estimate the numerical diffusion from the flow decay rate in the absence of all other terms. The resulting effective viscosity is to high precision the same as the prescribed ν\nu up to wavenumbers k≲1000 k1k \lesssim1000\,k_1, covering safely all scales relevant for the magnetic field. From these two results we conclude that our numerical simulations are not affected by numerical diffusion, and that the PrM\mathrm{Pr}_{\mathrm{M}} regimes are accurately identified.

References

  1. [1]Brandenburg, A., Subramanian, K.: Astrophysical magnetic fields and nonlinear dynamo theory. Phys. Rep. 417, 1–209 (2005) https://arxiv.org/abs/arXiv:astro-ph/0405052. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2005.06.005
  2. [2]Charbonneau, P.: Dynamo models of the solar cycle. Living Reviews in Solar Physics 17(1), 4 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s41116-020-00025-6
  3. [3]Childress, S., Gilbert, A.D.: Stretch, twist, fold: The fast dynamo. Lecture Notes in Physics Monographs 37 (1995)DOI
  4. [4]Boldyrev, S., Cattaneo, F.: Magnetic-Field Generation in Kolmogorov Turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92(14), 144501 (2004) https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0310780 [astro-ph]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.92.144501
  5. [5]Haugen, N.E.L., Brandenburg, A.: Suppression of small scale dynamo action by an imposed magnetic field. Phys. Rev. E 70(3), 036408 (2004) https://arxiv.org/abs/arXiv:astro-ph/0402281. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.70.036408
  6. [6]Schekochihin, A.A., Cowley, S.C., Maron, J.L., McWilliams, J.C.: Critical Magnetic Prandtl Number for Small-Scale Dynamo. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92(5), 054502 (2004) https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0308336 [astro-ph]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.92.054502
  7. [7]Schekochihin, A.A., Iskakov, A.B., Cowley, S.C., McWilliams, J.C., Proctor, M.R.E., Yousef, T.A.: Fluctuation dynamo and turbulent induction at low magnetic Prandtl numbers. New Journal of Physics 9(8), 300 (2007) https://arxiv.org/abs/0704.2002 [physics.flu-dyn]. https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/9/8/300
  8. [8]Iskakov, A.B., Schekochihin, A.A., Cowley, S.C., McWilliams, J.C., Proctor, M.R.E.: Numerical Demonstration of Fluctuation Dynamo at Low Magnetic Prandtl Numbers. Phys. Rev. Lett. 98(20), 208501 (2007) https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0702291 [astro-ph]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.208501
  9. [9]Schober, J., Schleicher, D., Bovino, S., Klessen, R.S.: Small-scale dynamo at low magnetic Prandtl numbers. Phys. Rev. E 86(6), 066412 (2012) https://arxiv.org/abs/1212.5979 [astro-ph.CO]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.86.066412
  10. [10]Brandenburg, A., Haugen, N.E.L., Li, X.-Y., Subramanian, K.: Varying the forcing scale in low Prandtl number dynamos. MNRAS 479(2), 2827–2833 (2018) https://arxiv.org/abs/1805.01249 [physics.flu-dyn]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/sty1570
  11. [11]Stix, M. (2002). The Sun: an Introduction. In Springer.
  12. [12]Cattaneo, F.: On the Origin of Magnetic Fields in the Quiet Photosphere. ApJ 515(1), 39–42 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1086/311962
  13. [13]Vögler, A., Schüssler, M.: A solar surface dynamo. A&A 465(3), 43–46 (2007) https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0702681 [astro-ph]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20077253
  14. [14]Kitiashvili, I.N., Kosovichev, A.G., Mansour, N.N., Wray, A.A.: Realistic Modeling of Local Dynamo Processes on the Sun. ApJ 809(1), 84 (2015) https://arxiv.org/abs/1506.08924 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/809/1/84
  15. [15]Hotta, H., Rempel, M., Yokoyama, T.: Efficient Small-scale Dynamo in the Solar Convection Zone. ApJ 803(1), 42 (2015) https://arxiv.org/abs/1502.03846 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/803/1/42
  16. [16]Rempel, M.: Numerical Simulations of Quiet Sun Magnetism: On the Contribution from a Small-scale Dynamo. ApJ 789, 132 (2014) https://arxiv.org/abs/1405.6814 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/789/2/132
  17. [17]Rempel, M.: Small-scale Dynamo Simulations: Magnetic Field Amplification in Exploding Granules and the Role of Deep and Shallow Recirculation. ApJ 859(2), 161 (2018) https://arxiv.org/abs/1805.08390 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aabba0
  18. [18]Riva, F., Steiner, O.: Methodology for estimating the magnetic Prandtl number and application to solar surface small-scale dynamo simulations. A&A 660, 115 (2022) https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.12115 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202142644
  19. [19]Käpylä, P.J., Käpylä, M.J., Olspert, N., Warnecke, J., Brandenburg, A.: Convection-driven spherical shell dynamos at varying Prandtl numbers. A&A 599, 4 (2017) https://arxiv.org/abs/1605.05885 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201628973
  20. [20]Hotta, H., & Kusano, K. (2021). Solar differential rotation reproduced. Nature Astronomy, 5, 1100–1102. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41550-021-01459-0
  21. [21]Tobias, S.M., Cattaneo, F.: Shear-driven dynamo waves at high magnetic Reynolds number. Nature 497(7450), 463–465 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature12177
  22. [22]Bhat, P., Subramanian, K., Brandenburg, A.: A unified large/small-scale dynamo in helical turbulence. MNRAS 461(1), 240–247 (2016) https://arxiv.org/abs/1508.02706 [astro-ph.GA]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stw1257
  23. [23]Squire, J., Bhattacharjee, A.: The magnetic shear-current effect: generation of large-scale magnetic fields by the small-scale dynamo. Journal of Plasma Physics 82(2), 535820201 (2016) https://arxiv.org/abs/1512.04511 [astro-ph.HE]. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022377816000258
  24. [24]Hotta, H., Rempel, M., Yokoyama, T.: Large-scale magnetic fields at high reynolds numbers in magnetohydrodynamic simulations. Science 351(6280), 1427–1430 (2016) https://arxiv.org/abs/http://science.sciencemag.org/content/351/6280/1427.full.pdf. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aad1893
  25. [25]Väisälä, M. S., Pekkilä, J., Käpylä, M. J., Rheinhardt, M., Shang, H., & Krasnopolsky, R. (2021). Interaction of Large- and Small-scale Dynamos in Isotropic Turbulent Flows from GPU-accelerated Simulations. ApJ, 907(2), 83. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/abceca
  26. [26]Rempel, M.: Extension of the MURaM Radiative MHD Code for Coronal Simulations. ApJ 834, 10 (2017) https://arxiv.org/abs/1609.09818 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/834/1/10
  27. [27]Kleint, L., Berdyugina, S.V., Shapiro, A.I., Bianda, M.: Solar turbulent magnetic fields: surprisingly homogeneous distribution during the solar minimum. A&A 524, 37 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201015285
  28. [28]Buehler, D., Lagg, A., Solanki, S.K.: Quiet Sun magnetic fields observed by Hinode: Support for a local dynamo. A&A 555, 33 (2013) https://arxiv.org/abs/1307.0789 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201321152
  29. [29]Lites, B.W., Centeno, R., McIntosh, S.W.: The solar cycle dependence of the weak internetwork flux. PASJ 66, 4 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1093/pasj/psu082
  30. [30]Bellot Rubio, L., Orozco Suárez, D.: Quiet Sun magnetic fields: an observational view. Living Reviews in Solar Physics 16(1), 1 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s41116-018-0017-1
  31. [31]Faurobert, M., Ricort, G.: Magnetic flux structuring of the quiet Sun internetwork. Center-to-limb analysis of solar-cycle variations. A&A 651, 21 (2021) https://arxiv.org/abs/2105.08657 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202140705
  32. [32]Korpi-Lagg, M.J., Korpi-Lagg, A., Olspert, N., Truong, H.-L.: Solar-Cycle Variation of quiet-Sun Magnetism and Surface Gravity Oscillation Mode. arXiv e-prints, 2205–04419 (2022) https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.04419 [astro-ph.SR]
  33. [33]Tobias, S.M.: The turbulent dynamo. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 912, 1 (2021) https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.03685 [physics.flu-dyn]. https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2020.1055
  34. [34]Schekochihin, A.A., Haugen, N.E.L., Brandenburg, A., Cowley, S.C., Maron, J.L., McWilliams, J.C.: The Onset of a Small-Scale Turbulent Dynamo at Low Magnetic Prandtl Numbers. ApJ 625(2), 115–118 (2005) https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0412594 [astro-ph]. https://doi.org/10.1086/431214
  35. [35]Tobias, S.M., Cattaneo, F., Boldyrev, S.: In: Davidson, P.A., Kaneda, Y., Sreenivasan, K.R. (eds.) MHD Dynamos and Turbulence, pp. 351–404. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK (2012). https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139032810.010
  36. [36]Rogachevskii, I., Kleeorin, N.: Intermittency and anomalous scaling for magnetic fluctuations. Phys. Rev. E 56(1), 417–426 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.56.417
  37. [37]Kleeorin, N., Rogachevskii, I.: Growth rate of small-scale dynamo at low magnetic Prandtl numbers. Phys. Scr 86(1), 018404 (2012) https://arxiv.org/abs/1112.3926 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0031-8949/86/01/018404
  38. [38]Falkovich, G.: Bottleneck phenomenon in developed turbulence. Physics of Fluids 6(4), 1411–1414 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1063/1.868255
  39. [39]Lohse, D., Müller-Groeling, A.: Bottleneck Effects in Turbulence: Scaling Phenomena in r versus p Space. Phys. Rev. Lett. 74(10), 1747–1750 (1995) https://arxiv.org/abs/chao-dyn/9405002 [nlin.CD]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.74.1747
  40. [40]She, Z.-S., Jackson, E.: On the universal form of energy spectra in fully developed turbulence. Physics of Fluids A 5(7), 1526–1528 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1063/1.858591
  41. [41]Saddoughi, S.G., Veeravalli, S.V.: Local isotropy in turbulent boundary layers at high Reynolds number. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 268, 333–372 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112094001370
  42. [42]Küchler, C., Bewley, G., Bodenschatz, E.: Experimental Study of the Bottleneck in Fully Developed Turbulence. Journal of Statistical Physics 175(3-4), 617–639 (2019) https://arxiv.org/abs/1812.01370 [physics.flu-dyn]. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10955-019-02251-1
  43. [43]Dobler, W., Haugen, N.E., Yousef, T.A., Brandenburg, A.: Bottleneck effect in three-dimensional turbulence simulations. Phys. Rev. E 68(2), 026304 (2003) https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0303324 [astro-ph]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.68.026304
  44. [44]Donzis, D.A., Sreenivasan, K.R.: The bottleneck effect and the Kolmogorov constant in isotropic turbulence. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 657, 171–188 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112010001400
  45. [45]Kazantsev, A.P.: Enhancement of a Magnetic Field by a Conducting Fluid. Soviet Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics 26, 1031 (1968)
  46. [46]Brandenburg, A.: Nonlinear Small-scale Dynamos at Low Magnetic Prandtl Numbers. ApJ 741(2), 92 (2011) https://arxiv.org/abs/1106.5777 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/741/2/92
  47. [47]Brandenburg, A.: The Inverse Cascade and Nonlinear Alpha-Effect in Simulations of Isotropic Helical Hydromagnetic Turbulence. ApJ 550, 824–840 (2001) https://arxiv.org/abs/arXiv:astro-ph/0006186. https://doi.org/10.1086/319783
  48. [48]Pencil Code Collaboration, Brandenburg, A., Johansen, A., Bourdin, P., Dobler, W., Lyra, W., Rheinhardt, M., Bingert, S., Haugen, N., Mee, A., Gent, F., Babkovskaia, N., Yang, C.-C., Heinemann, T., Dintrans, B., Mitra, D., Candelaresi, S., Warnecke, J., Käpylä, P., Schreiber, A., Chatterjee, P., Käpylä, M., Li, X.-Y., Krüger, J., Aarnes, J., Sarson, G., Oishi, J., Schober, J., Plasson, R., Sandin, C., Karchniwy, E., Rodrigues, L., Hubbard, A., Guerrero, G., Snodin, A., Losada, I., Pekkilä, J., Qian, C.: The Pencil Code, a modular MPI code for partial differential equations and particles: multipurpose and multiuser-maintained. JOSS 6(58), 2807 (2021). https://doi.org/10.21105/joss.02807
  49. [49]Bourdin, P.-A.: Driving solar coronal MHD simulations on high-performance computers. Geophysical and Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics 114(1-2), 235–260 (2020) https://arxiv.org/abs/1908.08557 [astro-ph.SR]. https://doi.org/10.1080/03091929.2019.1643849

Paper details

vlnc:W_gm5gfhr7
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents