betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Fundamental MHD scales – II: the kinematic phase of the supersonic small-scale dynamo

Abstract

Many astrophysical small-scale dynamos (SSDs) amplify weak magnetic fields via highly compressible, supersonic turbulence, but established SSD theories have overlooked these compressible effects. To address this, we perform visco-resistive SSD simulations across a range of sonic Mach numbers (M\mathcal{M}), hydrodynamic Reynolds numbers (Re\mathrm{Re}), and magnetic Prandtl numbers (Pm\mathrm{Pm}). We develop robust methods to measure kinetic and magnetic energy dissipation scales (ℓν\ell_ν and ℓη\ell_η) and the scale of strongest magnetic fields (ℓp\ell_\mathrm{p}) during the kinematic phase. We demonstrate that ℓν/ℓη∼Pm1/2\ell_ν/\ell_η\sim \mathrm{Pm}^{1/2} is a universal feature for Pm≥1\mathrm{Pm} \geq 1 SSDs, regardless of M\mathcal{M} or Re\mathrm{Re}. Incompressible SSDs (either M≤1\mathcal{M} \leq 1 or Re<Recrit≈100\mathrm{Re} < \mathrm{Re}\mathrm{crit} \approx 100) concentrate magnetic energy at ℓp∼ℓη\ell_\mathrm{p} \sim \ell_η with inversely correlated field strength and curvature. However, for compressible SSDs (M>1\mathcal{M} > 1 and Re>Recrit\mathrm{Re} > \mathrm{Re}\mathrm{crit}), shocks concentrate magnetic energy in large structures with ℓp∼(ℓturb/ℓshock)1/3ℓη≫ℓη\ell_\mathrm{p} \sim (\ell_\mathrm{turb} / \ell_\mathrm{shock})^{1/3} \ell_η\gg \ell_η, where ℓshock\ell_\mathrm{shock} is the characteristic shock width, and ℓturb\ell_\mathrm{turb} is the outer scale of the turbulent field. In this regime, magnetic field-line curvature becomes nearly independent of field strength. These results have implications for galaxy mergers and cosmic ray transport models in the interstellar medium.

Introduction

Setting the Stage for Present-Day Galactic Magnetism

As far as we understand, the Universe was born without magnetic fields. This, however, stands in stark contrast with the present-day Universe, where dynamically important magnetic fields are observed to be ubiquitous (see Krumholz & Federrath 2019; Brandenburg & Ntormousi 2023, for recent reviews on magnetic fields in galaxies and their impact on star formation). While the origin of these fields remains uncertain, two main candidates exist: phase transitions during inflation, which could have generated fields with strengths ranging from 10−3610^{-36} to 10−810^{-8} G, varying on ∼\sim Mpc scales (Quashnock et al. 1989; Sigl et al. 1997; Kahnashvili et al. 2013), and battery processes during the epoch of re-ionisation (z∼35z \sim35–6) (Biermann 1950; Naoz & Narayan 2013), which could have produced fields of around 10−2410^{-24} G on ∼10\sim10 kpc scales.

Regardless of which mechanism seeded the first magnetic fields, primordial fields are believed to have decayed until the structure formation era at z∼2z \sim2 (e.g., Brandenburg et al. 2017; Vachaspati 2021; Hosking & Schekochihin 2022; Mtchedlidze et al. 2022, 2023; Hosking & Schekochihin 2023), by which time they would have been more than 15 orders of magnitude weaker than the ∼μ\sim\muG fields observed on ∼\sim kpc scales in the Milky Way and in other nearby galaxies (e.g., Kulsrud et al. 1997; Beck et al. 2019; Shah & Seta 2021).

© 2024 The Authors Lopez-Rodriguez et al. 2022. Present-day magnetic fields, therefore, cannot simply be relics from electroweak phase transitions or battery processes in the early Universe, and instead some mechanism must have amplified them dramatically.

Flavours of Dynamo

Dynamo action is believed to be the most plausible mechanism for amplifying primordially-produced fields to the levels we observe in the present-day (e.g., Latif et al. 2013; Mtchedlidze et al. 2022, 2023), and broadly describes the process by which initially weak magnetic fields are amplified and subsequently maintained through the conversion of kinetic into magnetic energy (see Rincon 2019; Brandenburg & Ntormousi 2023 for recent reviews, and Tzeferacos et al. 2018; Bott et al. 2021, 2022 for recent laboratory experiments). These mechanisms are categorised either as small-scale dynamos (SSDs) or large-scale dynamos (LSDs), determined by the scale on which magnetic fields are grown relative to the fields that amplify them. In the current paradigm for the origin of galactic magnetic fields, both SSDs and LSDs are believed to be important, but are understood to play very different roles (see, e.g., Bhat et al. 2016; Pakmor et al. 2017; Rieder & Teyssier 2017a,b; Steinwandel et al. 2023; Gent et al. 2023, for recent works).

Small-Scale Dynamos

SSDs in the interstellar medium (ISM) of galaxies are primarily driven by supersonic turbulence, in turn supported by a combination of supernova feedback and gravitational instabilities (Krumholz & Burkhart 2016; Bacchini et al. 2020). Starting with initially weak (primordial) seed fields, these SSDs follow roughly a three-stage process: (1) random kinetic motions (or more precisely, random velocity gradients) (e.g., Vainshtein et al. 1972; Zel’dovich et al. 1984; Archontis et al. 2003) amplify magnetic energy exponentially fast-in-time (termed the kinematic phase); (2), once magnetic fields are strong enough to impart a backreaction on the flow via the Lorentz force, growth slows down to polynomial-in-time (termed the non-linear phase; e.g., Schekochihin et al. 2004; Beresnyak 2012; Schleicher et al. [130]; Xu & Lazarian 2016; Seta & Federrath 2020, see also § 5.3 for a discussion); finally (3), once the magnetic field is in close equipartition with kinetic energy, the field strength saturates and continues to be maintained at this level via the velocity field (e.g., Schekochihin et al. 2002b; Cho et al. 2009; Seta & Federrath 2021; Beattie et al. 2023b).

Large-Scale Dynamos

Galactic LSDs are also capable of exponential magnetic growth over ∼\sim Gyr timescales, which could be driven by a mix of helical turbulence (e.g., Bhat et al. 2016; Rincon 2021), potentially due in part to galactic differential rotation/shear (e.g., Vishniac & Brandenburg 1997; Käpylä et al. 2008; Squire & Bhattacharjee 2015; Gent et al. 2023), or magnetic instabilities (e.g., Johansen & Levin 2008; Qazi et al. 2023). While catastrophic quenching at high magnetic resistivity has been a concern, particularly in domains with either closed or periodic boundaries, where magnetic helicity cannot escape (see Vishniac & Cho 2001), this effect is believed to be less severe than previously thought, especially in shearing systems (Hubbard & Brandenburg 2012). Moreover, quenching can be alleviated by factors like non-conservation of helicity flux (Verma 2003; Sur et al. 2007; Del Sordo et al. 2013), as would be the case in the presence of outflows (e.g., galactic winds) and accreting flows, or with the additional influence of cosmic ray pressure (Parker 1992; Hanasz et al. 2004). Nonetheless, LSDs alone are not believed to be solely responsible for amplifying primordial fields to the magnitudes we observe today, as they operate much slower than the kinematic phase of SSDs (Schober et al. 2012; Gent et al. 2023) and are less efficient in the presence of low resistivity SSDs (e.g., Gent et al. 2023). However, some LSDs, like the shear-current dynamo (Squire & Bhattacharjee 2015), can directly feed on the turbulent magnetic fluctuations produced by SSDs (see Brandenburg & Ntormousi 2023, for a recent, thorough review of LSDs).

Dynamos in Young Galaxies

Supernova-driven SSDs operating in the ISM of young, isolated Milky Way-like galaxies, have been numerically shown to be capable of amplifying primordial magnetic fields with an e-folding time of ∼100\sim100 Myr, reaching a saturated field strength of 10–50 μ\muG (corresponding to ∼10%\sim10\% of equipartition with the kinetic energy) by z∼3z \sim3–2 (Pakmor et al. 2017; Rieder & Teyssier 2016, 2017a; Steinwandel et al. 2023; Zhou et al. 2024). As these galaxies evolve and become more quiescent, some yet unconstrained combination of the aforementioned galactic mechanisms creates a LSD that operates on the SSD-amplified fields, gradually contributing to the total magnetic field amplitude and efficiently developing large-scale, ordered fields observed in present-day galaxies (Rieder & Teyssier 2017a; Gent et al. 2023; Brandenburg & Ntormousi 2023). This was demonstrated by Gent et al. 2023, where a rotation-driven LSD was shown to be capable of amplifying the saturated SSD energy state by a factor ≲10\lesssim10, over several Gyr, and in doing so, efficiently reorganise SSD amplified magnetic fields to produce large-scale, coherent structures on scales larger than where the SSD operates.

Galaxy mergers are an example of systems where both a SSD and LSD operates in concert (Berlok & Frommer 2019; Frommer et al. 2022). While the exact interaction between these two dynamo processes largely remains an open problem, the interplay between the non-linear phase of the SSD and the LSD is important for re-establishing large-scale order after temporary merger-induced disruption, and for redistributing kinematic SSD-amplified fields from the inner regions, outward (Whittingham et al. 2021, 2023). Nonetheless, for most of this paper, we focus on the kinematic phase, returning briefly to the non-linear phase in § 5.3.

The Question: Does The Small-Scale Dynamo Always Produce Small-Scale Magnetic Fields?

Our current paradigm for magnetogenesis has recently been challenged by the detection of ≲500 μ\lesssim500\,\muG magnetic fields ordered on 5 kpc scales in a distant (z∼2.6z \sim2.6) gravitationally micro-lensed galaxy 9io9 (Geach et al. 2023), as well as ∼\sim kpc fields in a z∼5.6z \sim5.6 galaxy (Chen et al. 2024). While the field strength of 9i09 remains poorly constrained2, the fact that it is ordered on ∼\sim kpc scales poses a problem for the model outlined above, since a LSD would not have had enough time to become established3 at z∼2.6z \sim2.6. Moreover, SSDs have been traditionally thought to produce fields that are chaotic on large scales, only becoming ordered on the smallest scales allowed by magnetic dissipation (e.g., Schekochihin et al. 2004; Kriel et al. 2022; Brandenburg et al. 2023), which are expected to be ≪\ll pc in size for ISM conditions (Marchand et al. 2016). A similar problem exists in galaxy mergers, where the rapid growth of magnetic energy seen in simulations points to SSD action, but the fields are correlated on ∼\sim kpc scales, which have been thought to be too large scale to be generated during the kinematic SSD phase (e.g., Rodenbeck & Schleicher 2016; Basu et al. 2017; Brzycki & ZuHone 2019; Whittingham et al. 2021).

Now, the expectation that SSDs only produce small-scale fields, stems from extensive explorations of SSDs in incompressible (e.g., subsonic) flow regimes (see seminal works by, e.g., Kazantsev 1968; Vainshtein 1982; Vincenzi 2002; Schekochihin et al. 2004; Boldyrev & Cattaneo 2004). This expectation was confirmed in Paper I of this series (Kriel et al. 2022, herein Fundamental Scales I), where we used direct numerical simulations (DNSs) to explore the magnetic fields produced during the kinematic phase, and showed that the bulk of magnetic energy becomes concentrated at the smallest possible scales in the incompressible problem, i.e., the scale where magnetic fields dissipate. Given that these scales are much smaller than a galactic scale height, and fall within the regime where turbulence becomes independent of the anisotropy imposed by the galactic potential (Körtgen et al. 2021), the presence of large-scale shear, differential rotation or other similar organised galactic flows, does not alter this conclusion. However, this understanding may not fully capture the dynamics of more compressible environments.

Both the first galaxies (Maio et al. 2011; Mandelker et al. 2020) and later galaxy mergers (Geng et al. 2012; Sparre et al. 2022), are expected to host highly compressible (i.e., supersonic) turbulence. This is because the great majority of their mass, and a substantial fraction of their volume, consists of dense, atomic and molecular gas (Cox et al. 2006; Krumholz et al. 2009; Popping et al. 2014; Nandakumar & Dutta 2023) where rapid cooling keeps the sound speed well below the characteristic flow velocity (Rees & Ostriker 1977; White & Rees [164]; Birnboim & Dekel 2003; Krumholz et al. 2020; Li et al. 2020). While it has been shown that supersonic flow decreases the efficiency of SSDs (Federrath et al. 2011, 2014; Seta & Federrath 2021, 2022; Hew & Federrath [63]), there has to date been no systematic study of how compressibility changes magnetic field geometry, characteristic turbulence and dynamo scales, or structure of the magnetic field. Given the discrepancy between the observations and the predictions of incompressible SSD models, there is a clear need for such a study. Our goal in this paper is to carefully explore how magnetic fields become organised during the kinematic phase of SSDs driven by supersonic turbulence, and in turn to explore its implications for galaxy mergers and other phenomena that depend on magnetic field structure, most notably new cosmic ray transport models relying on curvature and gyro-radii resonances (e.g. Kempski et al. 2023; Lemoine 2023).

Structure of the Paper

The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. In § 2 we describe the numerical simulation suite we use to develop our theoretical model for compressible SSDs. In § 4 we present and interpret the simulation results, and in § 5 we discuss the implications of these results for a variety of astrophysical systems. We summarise our results and conclusions in § 6.

Simulating the Problem

In this study we use DNSs to explore the kinematic phase of SSDs in plasma flows ranging from viscous to turbulent, and subsonic to supersonic. In § 2.1 we introduce the basic equations that we solve, the numerical method by which we do so, and the initial conditions for our simulations. In § 3 we introduce the key dimensionless parameters that describe different plasma flow regimes, and how we vary these parameters to explore different flow properties. In § 3.3, we then discuss issues of convergence.

Numerical Approach

Solving the MHD Equations

For all the simulations in this study, we solve the compressible set of non-ideal (visco-resistive) magnetohydrodynamical (MHD) fluid equations, which in conservative form are

∂ρ∂t+∇⋅(ρu)=0,(1)\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t} + \nabla\cdot(\rho\boldsymbol{u}) = 0, \tag*{(1)}
∂ρu∂t+∇⋅[ρu⊗u−14πb⊗b+(cs2ρ+b28π)I−2νρS]=ρf,(2)\frac{\partial\rho\boldsymbol{u}}{\partial t} + \nabla\cdot\left[\rho\boldsymbol{u} \otimes\boldsymbol{u} - \frac{1}{4\pi}\boldsymbol{b} \otimes\boldsymbol{b} + \left(c_{\mathrm{s}}^{2}\rho+ \frac{b^{2}}{8\pi}\right)\mathbf{I} - 2\nu\rho\mathbf{S}\right] = \rho\boldsymbol{f}, \tag*{(2)}
∂b∂t−∇×(u×b−ηj)=0,(3)\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{b}}{\partial t} - \nabla\times(\boldsymbol{u} \times\boldsymbol{b} - \eta\boldsymbol{j}) = 0, \tag*{(3)}
∇⋅b=0,(4)\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{b} = 0, \tag*{(4)}

for an isothermal plasma evolving over a uniformly discretised, cubic-domain ℓ(x,y,z)∈[0,ℓbox]\ell_{(x,y,z)} \in[0,\ell_{\mathrm{box}}], with triply periodic boundary conditions. We use one constant (in both space and time) kinematic shear viscosity and Ohmic resistivity, parameterised by the coefficients ν\nu and η\eta, respectively, in combination with an external forcing field f\boldsymbol{f}, to achieve flows with desired plasma numbers (see § 3 for details). The remaining quantities in the equations are the gas density ρ\rho, the gas velocity u\mathbf{u}, the sound speed csc_{\mathrm{s}}, the current density j=∇×b/(4π)\mathbf{j} = \nabla\times\mathbf{b}/(4\pi), and the magnetic field b=b0+δb\mathbf{b} = \mathbf{b}_0 + \delta\mathbf{b}, which has mean field b0\mathbf{b}_0, and fluctuating (turbulent) field δb\delta\mathbf{b} components. Finally, our viscosity model is based on the traceless strain rate tensor, S\mathbf{S}, where

S=12(∇⊗u+(∇⊗u)T)−13(∇⋅u)I,(5)\mathbf{S} = \frac{1}{2}\left(\nabla\otimes\mathbf{u} + (\nabla\otimes\mathbf{u})^{\mathrm{T}}\right) - \frac{1}{3}(\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u})\mathbf{I}, \tag*{(5)}

and ⊗\otimes is the tensor product ∇⊗u≡∂iuj\nabla\otimes\mathbf{u} \equiv\partial_i u_j.

We solve Equation (1)-(4) with a modified version of the finite-volume FLASH code (Fryxell et al. 2000; Dubey et al. 2008), employing a second-order conservative MUSCL-Hancock 5-wave approximate Riemann solver, described in Bouchut et al. (2007, 2010), and implemented into FLASH by Waagan et al. (2011), who showed that it possesses excellent stability properties for highly supersonic MHD flows, with improved efficiency and stability compared with Roe-type solvers. Since our primary interest lies in studying the effects of shocks (a hallmark of supersonic flows), this solver proves highly suitable. Moreover, we utilise the parabolic divergence-cleaning method described by Marder (1987) to enforce that ∇⋅b=0\nabla\cdot\mathbf{b} = 0 modes are diffused away.

Initial Conditions

All our simulations use a dimensionless unit system where the simulation box size ℓbox=1\ell_{\mathrm{box}} = 1, mean density ρ0=1\rho_0 = 1, the sound speed cs=1c_{\mathrm{s}} = 1, and magnetic fields are measured in units of ρ01/2cs=1\rho_0^{1/2}c_{\mathrm{s}} = 1. We initialise every simulation with uniform density ρ=ρ0=1\rho= \rho_0 = 1, zero velocity u=0\mathbf{u} = 0, and zero mean magnetic field b0=0\mathbf{b}_0 = 0. Since there is no mean magnetic field, and magnetic flux through the simulation volume is conserved, only a fluctuating component can exist, b=δb\mathbf{b} = \delta\mathbf{b}. We initialise this fluctuating component with a spectral distribution (using TurbGen; Federrath et al. 2022) that is non-zero only over the wavenumber range 1≤kℓbox/2π≤31 \leq k\ell_{\mathrm{box}}/2\pi\leq3, with a parabolic profile that peaks at kℓbox/2π=2k\ell_{\mathrm{box}}/2\pi= 2, and goes to zero at kℓbox/2π=1k\ell_{\mathrm{box}}/2\pi= 1 and kℓbox/2π=3k\ell_{\mathrm{box}}/2\pi= 3. Here, the isotropic wavenumber kk is defined as per usual: k≡2π/ℓk \equiv2\pi/\ell. We choose the amplitude of this initial parabolic δb\delta\mathbf{b} profile such that the plasma–β≡pth/pmag=8πcs2ρ0/b2=1010\beta\equiv p_{\mathrm{th}}/p_{\mathrm{mag}} = 8\pi c_{\mathrm{s}}^2\rho_0/b^2 = 10^{10}. We note that the exact configuration of the initial seed δb\delta\mathbf{b} field is not important, because it is quickly forgotten by the Markovian-like flow dynamics, and has been shown to not affect the amplification nor the final saturation of the dynamo (Seta & Federrath 2020; Bott et al. 2022; Beattie et al. 2023b).

Important Dimensionless Numbers and Flow Regimes

In this study we explore 34 different simulation configurations, each parameterised by a set of dimensionless numbers that characterise the flow and plasma regimes. Here we introduce each of these numbers, as well as the range of values over which we vary them, before summarising our full set of simulations in Table 1.

Sim. IDReRmPmνturb/ℓturb2\nu_{\mathrm{turb}}/\ell_{\mathrm{turb}}^{2}ηturb/ℓturb2\eta_{\mathrm{turb}}/\ell_{\mathrm{turb}}^{2}M\mathcal{M}γturb\gamma_{\mathrm{turb}}(Emag/Ekin)sat\left(E_{\mathrm{mag}}/E_{\mathrm{kin}}\right)_{\mathrm{sat}}kν/kboxk_{\nu}/k_{\mathrm{box}}kη/kboxk_{\eta}/k_{\mathrm{box}}kρ/kboxk_{\rho}/k_{\mathrm{box}}Extra NresN_{\mathrm{res}}
(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6)(7)(8)(9)(10)(11)(12)(13)
M=0.3\mathcal{M}=0.3
M0.3Re500Pm1\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}500\mathrm{Pm}150050013.0×10−43.0\times10^{-4}3.0×10−43.0\times10^{-4}0.30±0.010.30\pm0.010.42±0.010.42\pm0.010.14±0.030.14\pm0.0323.9±0.523.9\pm0.513±113\pm14±14\pm1–
M0.3Re100Pm5\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}100\mathrm{Pm}510050051.5×10−31.5\times10^{-3}3.0×10−43.0\times10^{-4}0.30±0.020.30\pm0.020.48±0.010.48\pm0.010.36±0.060.36\pm0.068.4±0.28.4\pm0.29±19\pm14±14\pm1–
M0.3Re50Pm10\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}50\mathrm{Pm}1050500103.0×10−33.0\times10^{-3}3.0×10−43.0\times10^{-4}0.30±0.020.30\pm0.020.46±0.010.46\pm0.010.4±0.10.4\pm0.15.8±0.25.8\pm0.29±19\pm14±14\pm1–
M0.3Re10Pm50\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}10\mathrm{Pm}5010500501.5×10−21.5\times10^{-2}3.0×10−43.0\times10^{-4}0.29±0.020.29\pm0.020.40±0.010.40\pm0.010.05±0.060.05\pm0.063.0±0.13.0\pm0.19±19\pm14±14\pm1–
M0.3Re3000Pm1\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}3000\mathrm{Pm}13000300015.0×10−55.0\times10^{-5}5.0×10−55.0\times10^{-5}0.29±0.010.29\pm0.010.76±0.010.76\pm0.010.32±0.040.32\pm0.0475.5±1.375.5\pm1.341±141\pm116±116\pm1576
M0.3Re600Pm5\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}600\mathrm{Pm}5600300052.5×10−42.5\times10^{-4}5.0×10−55.0\times10^{-5}0.31±0.010.31\pm0.011.00±0.011.00\pm0.010.43±0.050.43\pm0.0527.7±0.627.7\pm0.630±130\pm110±110\pm1576
M0.3Re300Pm10\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}300\mathrm{Pm}103003000105.0×10−45.0\times10^{-4}5.0×10−55.0\times10^{-5}0.30±0.010.30\pm0.010.93±0.010.93\pm0.010.7±0.10.7\pm0.116.7±0.316.7\pm0.322±122\pm18±18\pm1–
M0.3Re100Pm30\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}100\mathrm{Pm}301003000301.5×10−31.5\times10^{-3}5.0×10−55.0\times10^{-5}0.30±0.010.30\pm0.010.76±0.010.76\pm0.010.9±0.20.9\pm0.28.4±0.28.4\pm0.220±120\pm18±18\pm1–
M0.3Re24Pm125\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}24\mathrm{Pm}1252430001256.3×10−36.3\times10^{-3}5.0×10−55.0\times10^{-5}0.31±0.020.31\pm0.020.83±0.010.83\pm0.011.6±0.31.6\pm0.34.2±0.14.2\pm0.116±116\pm17±17\pm1–
M0.3Re10Pm300\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}10\mathrm{Pm}3001030003001.5×10−21.5\times10^{-2}5.0×10−55.0\times10^{-5}0.30±0.020.30\pm0.020.79±0.010.79\pm0.012.4±0.42.4\pm0.43.0±0.13.0\pm0.114±114\pm17±17\pm1–
M0.3Re2000Pm5\mathcal{M}0.3\mathrm{Re}2000\mathrm{Pm}520001000057.0×10−57.0\times10^{-5}1.0×10−51.0\times10^{-5}0.29±0.010.29\pm0.011.34±0.011.34\pm0.010.36±0.040.36\pm0.0470.6±1.070.6\pm1.080±180\pm126±126\pm1576, 1152
M=1\mathcal{M}=1
M1Re3000Pm1\mathcal{M}1\mathrm{Re}3000\mathrm{Pm}13000300011.7×10−41.7\times10^{-4}1.7×10−41.7\times10^{-4}0.97±0.040.97\pm0.040.59±0.010.59\pm0.010.18±0.030.18\pm0.0378.0±1.378.0\pm1.338±138\pm113±113\pm1576
M1Re600Pm5\mathcal{M}1\mathrm{Re}600\mathrm{Pm}5600300058.5×10−48.5\times10^{-4}1.7×10−41.7\times10^{-4}1.02±0.031.02\pm0.030.72±0.010.72\pm0.010.40±0.050.40\pm0.0530.7±0.930.7\pm0.927±127\pm18±18\pm1576
M1Re300Pm10\mathcal{M}1\mathrm{Re}300\mathrm{Pm}103003000101.7×10−31.7\times10^{-3}1.7×10−41.7\times10^{-4}1.04±0.041.04\pm0.040.78±0.010.78\pm0.010.45±0.080.45\pm0.0818.9±0.818.9\pm0.822±122\pm18±18\pm1–
M1Re24Pm125\mathcal{M}1\mathrm{Re}24\mathrm{Pm}1252430001252.1×10−22.1\times10^{-2}1.7×10−41.7\times10^{-4}1.04±0.061.04\pm0.060.83±0.010.83\pm0.011.1±0.21.1\pm0.24.4±0.14.4\pm0.116±116\pm18±18\pm1–
M=5\mathcal{M}=5
M5Re10Pm25\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}10\mathrm{Pm}2510250252.5×10−12.5\times10^{-1}1.0×10−21.0\times10^{-2}5.1±0.35.1\pm0.30.43±0.010.43\pm0.010.14±0.050.14\pm0.053.2±0.13.2\pm0.17±17\pm13±13\pm1576
M5Re10Pm50\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}10\mathrm{Pm}5010500502.5×10−12.5\times10^{-1}5.0×10−35.0\times10^{-3}5.1±0.35.1\pm0.30.64±0.010.64\pm0.010.26±0.060.26\pm0.063.2±0.13.2\pm0.19±19\pm14±14\pm1576
M5Re10Pm125\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}10\mathrm{Pm}1251012501252.5×10−12.5\times10^{-1}2.0×10−32.0\times10^{-3}5.0±0.35.0\pm0.30.77±0.010.77\pm0.010.29±0.040.29\pm0.043.2±0.13.2\pm0.113±113\pm16±16\pm1576
M5Re10Pm250\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}10\mathrm{Pm}2501025002502.5×10−12.5\times10^{-1}1.0×10−31.0\times10^{-3}5.0±0.35.0\pm0.30.81±0.010.81\pm0.010.40±0.070.40\pm0.073.2±0.13.2\pm0.116±116\pm19±19\pm1576
M5Re500Pm1\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}500\mathrm{Pm}150050015.0×10−35.0\times10^{-3}5.0×10−35.0\times10^{-3}5.1±0.35.1\pm0.30.19±0.010.19\pm0.010.01±0.010.01\pm0.0137.5±0.737.5\pm0.716±416\pm43±13\pm1–
M5Re500Pm2\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}500\mathrm{Pm}2500100025.0×10−35.0\times10^{-3}2.5×10−32.5\times10^{-3}5.2±0.35.2\pm0.30.34±0.010.34\pm0.010.04±0.010.04\pm0.0137.8±0.737.8\pm0.721±321\pm34±24\pm2–
M5Re500Pm4\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}500\mathrm{Pm}4500200045.0×10−35.0\times10^{-3}1.3×10−31.3\times10^{-3}5.1±0.35.1\pm0.30.42±0.010.42\pm0.010.06±0.010.06\pm0.0137.6±0.737.6\pm0.725±225\pm24±24\pm2–
M5Re3000Pm1\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}3000\mathrm{Pm}13000300018.3×10−48.3\times10^{-4}8.3×10−48.3\times10^{-4}5.1±0.25.1\pm0.20.35±0.010.35\pm0.010.03±0.010.03\pm0.01101.5±1.2101.5\pm1.246±546\pm55±25\pm2576
M5Re1500Pm2\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}1500\mathrm{Pm}21500300021.7×10−31.7\times10^{-3}8.3×10−48.3\times10^{-4}5.1±0.35.1\pm0.30.37±0.010.37\pm0.010.05±0.010.05\pm0.0180.8±1.280.8\pm1.241±341\pm34±24\pm2576
M5Re600Pm5\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}600\mathrm{Pm}5600300054.2×10−34.2\times10^{-3}8.3×10−48.3\times10^{-4}5.0±0.25.0\pm0.20.44±0.010.44\pm0.010.07±0.010.07\pm0.0143.9±0.843.9\pm0.834±334\pm34±14\pm1576
M5Re300Pm10\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}300\mathrm{Pm}103003000108.3×10−38.3\times10^{-3}8.3×10−48.3\times10^{-4}5.1±0.35.1\pm0.30.50±0.010.50\pm0.010.11±0.040.11\pm0.0427.0±0.627.0\pm0.625±225\pm25±15\pm1–
M5Re120Pm25\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}120\mathrm{Pm}251203000252.1×10−22.1\times10^{-2}8.3×10−48.3\times10^{-4}5.0±0.35.0\pm0.30.57±0.010.57\pm0.010.13±0.010.13\pm0.0114.3±0.414.3\pm0.425±125\pm17±17\pm1576
M5Re60Pm50\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}60\mathrm{Pm}50603000504.2×10−24.2\times10^{-2}8.3×10−48.3\times10^{-4}4.9±0.34.9\pm0.30.72±0.010.72\pm0.010.25±0.030.25\pm0.039.0±0.39.0\pm0.323±123\pm17±17\pm1576
M5Re24Pm125\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}24\mathrm{Pm}1252430001251.0×10−11.0\times10^{-1}8.3×10−48.3\times10^{-4}4.9±0.34.9\pm0.30.76±0.010.76\pm0.010.38±0.090.38\pm0.095.0±0.25.0\pm0.219±119\pm18±18\pm1576
M5Re12Pm250\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}12\mathrm{Pm}2501230002502.1×10−12.1\times10^{-1}8.3×10−48.3\times10^{-4}4.8±0.34.8\pm0.30.72±0.010.72\pm0.010.42±0.060.42\pm0.063.4±0.13.4\pm0.117±117\pm18±18\pm1576
M5Re2000Pm5\mathcal{M}5\mathrm{Re}2000\mathrm{Pm}520001000051.3×10−31.3\times10^{-3}2.5×10−42.5\times10^{-4}4.9±0.34.9\pm0.30.49±0.010.49\pm0.010.09±0.020.09\pm0.02104.2±1.5104.2\pm1.571±371\pm39±29\pm2576, 1152
M=10\mathcal{M}=10
M10Re3000Pm1\mathcal{M}10\mathrm{Re}3000\mathrm{Pm}13000300011.7×10−31.7\times10^{-3}1.7×10−31.7\times10^{-3}9.6±0.59.6\pm0.50.44±0.010.44\pm0.010.02±0.010.02\pm0.0198.5±1.798.5\pm1.753±453\pm45±25\pm2576
M10Re600Pm5\mathcal{M}10\mathrm{Re}600\mathrm{Pm}5600300058.3×10−38.3\times10^{-3}1.7×10−31.7\times10^{-3}9.8±0.59.8\pm0.50.55±0.010.55\pm0.010.05±0.010.05\pm0.0145.5±0.845.5\pm0.837±237\pm26±16\pm1576
M10Re300Pm10\mathcal{M}10\mathrm{Re}300\mathrm{Pm}103003000101.7×10−21.7\times10^{-2}1.7×10−31.7\times10^{-3}10.1±0.510.1\pm0.50.65±0.010.65\pm0.010.07±0.020.07\pm0.0228.5±0.628.5\pm0.626±226\pm26±26\pm2–

Table 1. Main simulation parameters and derived quantities.

References

  1. [63]Hew J. K. J., Federath C., 2023, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 520, 6268
  2. [130]Schleicher D. R. G., Schober J., Federath C., Bovino S., Schmidt W., 2013, New Journal of Physics, 15, 023017
  3. [158]Van Der Walt S., Colbert S. C., Varoquaux G., 2011, Computing in science & engineering, 13, 22
  4. [164]White S. D. M., Rees M. J., 1978, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 183, 341

Paper details

vlnc:W_gmj6xges
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents