betaFeedback

WorksEconomics, Econometrics and Finance

Social Networks and the Propagation of Household Shocks to Asset Prices

Abstract

When can local household disturbances move credit prices? I develop a financially weighted propagation operator on the social network. In a conditional household-intermediary equilibrium, its projection determines the household-demand component of the excess bond premium. Because responses decay at different rates across network patterns and channels, a location's relative financial importance generically changes with the horizon, so no single centrality measure summarizes exposure across horizons. Household measurements recover this projection exactly when they span independently measured demand sensitivities. Empirically, social exposure to storm-damaged counties is negatively associated with spending weeks later in counties outside the recorded footprints. In simulations on the observed network under the model's diffusion law, the operator predicts the propagated credit-premium component of held-out storms with about 30 percent less error than direct social exposure.

Introduction

When do local household shocks, such as losses of income or wealth, move aggregate credit prices? The purpose of this paper is to derive conditions under which local shocks move aggregate credit prices, not to classify shocks by their innate properties. I show that the financial importance of such shocks depends on two features, where the effects travel over time and whose investment demand changes. I build an object that captures these conditions: it follows a local shock along social ties to the responses of households in every county at every horizon, and weights each response by how strongly households there change their desired credit holdings. I call it the financially weighted propagation operator, and I call its weights the financial weights. My main result shows when household measurements are sufficient to recover this financially relevant response without reconstructing the entire propagation system.

I develop the mechanism in four steps. First, a local disturbance, such as a storm, lowers income, wealth, and spending in affected counties. Second, its effects travel along social ties to friends and relatives in other counties through short-lived news and changes in household spending and saving that can persist for months. The non-affected households may send money to those who lost homes or jobs, or save more in case of a similar loss, so spending falls in counties the disturbance never hit. Third, households there change their demand for corporate bonds, which many hold through mutual funds and retirement accounts. For example, a family that sends money to their affected relatives may redeem fund shares, and its thinner cushion above usual spending can make risky holdings less attractive [7]. Precautionary behavior can reinforce or offset this change since a cautious household may move from bonds into safer balances or from stocks into bonds. The financial weights account for how many households in each county hold bonds and how strongly their demand responds [28, 31]. Fourth, intermediaries and other investors adjust their holdings as household bond demand changes. If the combined effects of transfers and precautionary behavior reduce household demand on net, these investors would require higher expected returns to hold the additional bonds, and vice-versa. The return response would be larger when intermediary balance sheets are tight. In the model, this adjustment changes the excess bond premium (EBP), the part of corporate bond spreads not explained by expected default [15]. A local disturbance could therefore move national credit prices months later.

I devise a law of transmission to track these effects. Studies using the Social Connectedness Index (SCI) of Bailey et al. [6] show that households spend less after COVID-19 outbreaks in socially connected counties [27] and purchase more flood insurance after floods affecting distant friends (Hu, 2022). Similarly, Gao et al. [14] study household financial outcomes after shale-income shocks, and social ties also shape investment and the diffusion of news [26, 20]. For credit prices, this evidence leaves two questions open. The first is what additional financial information is needed to translate household responses into a change in credit demand. The SCI records social ties, not the resources or financial claims exchanged through them. Its weights therefore do not directly measure the strength of economic transmission or households’ bond-demand responses.

The second question concerns timing. A regression on a fixed exposure score, such as an SCI-weighted average of shocks in connected counties, lets the response change with the horizon but holds counties’ relative exposure fixed. The question is whether one such score can reproduce locations’ relative credit-price effects at every horizon. Estimating the law of transmission county by county would answer both questions, but it is not feasible without strong restrictions on it, since it links every county to every other at every horizon, far more than a few dozen storms can pin down. I therefore develop a method that needs only the part of the law that matters for credit prices.

I model transmission with two channels on one social graph. Each channel assigns a value to every county, and this value spreads over time to socially connected counties. I call such a channel a field. Both fields spread along the same social ties and differ in when they start to respond and how quickly they fade. The fast field carries news and attention, which react at once and die out quickly. The slow field carries changes in household demand, which start a period later and last longer. Building on the spectral approach to networks of Galeotti et al. [13], I write every response as a sum of regional patterns of the graph, each fading at its own speed. Under the diffusion law, patterns that vary sharply across strong social ties decay faster than broad ones.

The slow field could thus lower household bond demand, and markets would then need to price that shift. Building on demand-system asset pricing [24] (Koijen and Yogo 2026) and intermediary risk-bearing capacity [4, 16] (He and Krishnamurthy 2013; He et al. 2017), I derive a conditional equilibrium in which lower household demand raises the compensation required to hold credit. When intermediaries can still expand their holdings, lower capital increases the premium response to the same household demand shift. In the model, an explicit measurement relation links this premium to the EBP. The operator supplies the demand shift, and the equilibrium determines its price impact.

I then aggregate household responses across counties using the financial weights to derive their effect on the credit premium. Gabaix [11], Acemoglu et al. [1] (2012), Carvalho et al. [8] show how firm size and production linkages shape the aggregate effects of microeconomic disturbances, and Herskovic [19] connects the production-network structure to equilibrium asset prices. In these models, the weights are tied to firms’ and sectors’ sales. Building on these insights, I construct financial weights that measure how strongly households in each county change their desired credit holdings. Holding intermediary capital and payoff moments fixed, the household-demand part of the premium therefore depends on the propagation system only through one financially weighted sum of responses at each horizon, given in equation (14). Consequently, two propagation systems with the same sum imply the same response of this part of the premium, however differently they move individual counties.

I answer the first question with Proposition 6, which gives the exact condition under which household measurements are sufficient to recover this sum. Suppose two patterns of adjustment look identical in the measurements but imply different changes in credit demand. The measurements then cannot distinguish their price implications. Given how each response shows up in the measurements and independently measured financial sensitivities, recovery holds exactly when this cannot happen for the shocks and horizons studied. Household measurements can therefore support a credit-price prediction without identifying the propagation system itself. Consumption measurements, measurements of desired portfolio holdings at given prices, or both together can meet this condition. Additionally, estimates of household portfolio demand supply the financial sensitivities and their signs, which spending alone cannot reveal, since a household can absorb a loss by cutting spending or by drawing down assets. The condition holds whether households lower or raise their bond demand. An error bound separates error in predicting the measured responses from financial information the measurements miss.

I also show that the response common to all counties needs outside information, since comparisons across counties within an event reveal only how responses differ ([29, 33]). The network GIV of Chodorow-Reich et al. [9] addresses this problem with granular shocks. Here the common level matters for prices whenever the financial sensitivities do not sum to zero, because credit demand adds up all counties. Without restrictions on how responses propagate, recovering the aggregate response then requires an independent measurement of the common level or a bound on it.

I answer the second question with Theorem 1 and in general the answer is no. A location’s relative importance for credit prices generically changes with the horizon when the regional patterns or channels carrying the financially relevant response fade at different speeds. A location can account for a large share of the response soon after a shock and a smaller share later, even though its social ties have not changed. One fixed score then cannot reproduce these relative magnitudes at every horizon, except in the special case where the patterns’ horizon profiles are proportional. The diffusion model, applied to the observed social graph with proxy financial weights, implies that counties with nearly the same total connectedness can even reverse their relative importance (Figure 2).

Figure 2. Horizon-specific importance on the observed network. Panel A covers 1,590 counties. The pair distribution in Panel B uses counties with populations of at least 50,000 each. Its initial upper quartile (6.62) lies above the displayed limit of 4. Results are model-implied for equal initial field inputs in symmetric coordinates and dividend-proxy weights. Converting network spreading τ=κD(h−1)\tau= \kappa_D(h - 1) into weeks requires the rate κD\kappa_D. Appendix E.5 gives the selection rules and additional comparisons.

I begin the empirical analysis with the spending step of the mechanism, using the SCI and weekly county spending, with storms as localized disturbances. Spending is lower weeks later in counties more socially connected to storm-damaged places, although these counties lie outside the storms’ recorded footprints, after accounting for their own weather and for geographic and production links to the damaged places. This gradient remains similar across alternative records of where and when damage occurred, and it gives the propagation analysis its empirical starting point.

Finally, I use simulations to show that the method can work on the actual network. I use the SCI graph and candidate storm footprints and simulate the household accounts, aggregate measurements and fund data that recovery requires. When the data follow the specified diffusion law, the operator predicts the financially weighted responses to held-out storms more accurately than exposure through direct ties to the hit counties, with near-nominal interval coverage. Moreover, it keeps this advantage when the scale of the financial sensitivities and the price impact must be estimated. Adão et al. (2025) similarly judge quantitative models by the causal predictions that a particular economic question requires.

§ 2 develops the propagation model and § 3 derives the pricing kernel. § 4 and § 5 present the spending evidence and its dynamic counterpart, § 6 financial geography, EBP associations and fund demand, and § 7 the recovery program and its simulations.

Propagation on a social graph

Two fields on the social network

The SCI measures friendship links between counties. I use these links to model how a shock in one county affects households elsewhere. Households may respond briefly to news that friends were hit. They may also change spending and saving for months as they help relatives or prepare for future losses. I represent these responses with a fast attention field and a slow demand field. I use the slow field for the household bond-demand channel in § 3.

I represent the links among nCn_C counties, indexed by i=1,…,nCi = 1, \ldots, n_C, by symmetric weights A=(W+W′)/2A = (W + W^{\prime})/2, where W∈RnC×nCW \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C \times n_C} contains the retained, nonnegative SCI links, normalized so that W1=1W\mathbf{1} = \mathbf{1}. Here 1∈RnC\mathbf{1} \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C} is the vector of ones. I let D≡diag⁡(A1)D \equiv\operatorname{diag}(A\mathbf{1}) record each county’s total connectedness, which is positive, and use the normalized Laplacian L≡Id⁡nC−D−1/2AD−1/2\mathcal{L} \equiv\operatorname{Id}_{n_C} - D^{-1/2} A D^{-1/2} to model diffusion through these links, with Id⁡nC\operatorname{Id}_{n_C} denoting the nC×nCn_C \times n_C identity matrix.

Let εt∈RnC\varepsilon_t \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C} denote a fixed vector of local shocks at date tt, with one entry for each county, such as the damage a storm causes in the counties it hits. I compare two paths with the same pre-shock history that differ only by this shock at date tt. I report consumption and field responses relative to the path without the shock. Time is discrete, with h=0,1,…h = 0, 1, \ldots measuring periods after the shock.

Let ct∈RnC\mathbf{c}_t \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C} collect the direct component of county log-consumption responses, excluding contributions carried by the fields, with Δct≡ct−ct−1\Delta\mathbf{c}_t \equiv\mathbf{c}_t - \mathbf{c}_{t-1}. Its growth response is Δct+h=Φhεt\Delta\mathbf{c}_{t+h} = \Phi_h \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_t, where Φh∈RnC×nC\Phi_h \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C \times n_C}. I feed the impact response, νt≡Φ0εt\boldsymbol{\nu}_t \equiv\Phi_0 \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_t, into the slow field. The same shock generates a signal st=Bεt\mathbf{s}_t = B\boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_t, with B∈RnC×nCB \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C \times n_C}, which enters the fast field. I assume the following dynamics.2

Assumption 1 (Two fields on one graph). The slow demand field dt∈RnC\mathbf{d}_t \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C} and the fast attention field bt∈RnC\mathbf{b}_t \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C} evolve as

dt+1=ADdt+ηDνt,AD≡ρDe−κDL,bt=Aattbt−1+ηattst,Aatt≡ρatte−κattL,\begin{aligned} \mathbf{d}_{t+1} &= A_D\mathbf{d}_t + \eta_D\boldsymbol{\nu}_t, & A_D &\equiv\rho_D e^{-\kappa_D\mathcal{L}}, \\ \mathbf{b}_t &= A_{\mathrm{att}}\mathbf{b}_{t-1} + \eta_{\mathrm{att}}\mathbf{s}_t, & A_{\mathrm{att}} &\equiv\rho_{\mathrm{att}}e^{-\kappa_{\mathrm{att}}\mathcal{L}}, \end{aligned}

with ρD∈(0,1)\rho_D \in(0,1), ρatt∈[0,1)\rho_{\mathrm{att}} \in[0,1) and κD,κatt,ηD,ηatt>0\kappa_D, \kappa_{\mathrm{att}}, \eta_D, \eta_{\mathrm{att}} > 0.

The shared pre-shock history gives initial field responses dt=bt−1=0\mathbf{d}_t = \mathbf{b}_{t-1} = 0. The attention field responds on impact, while the demand field begins one period later. The coefficients ηD\eta_D and ηatt\eta_{\mathrm{att}} determine how strongly each input enters its field. I use ρm\rho_m to govern persistence and κm\kappa_m to govern diffusion through social links, m∈{D,att}m \in\{D, \mathrm{att}\}.

I decompose county responses into spatial patterns called modes, the orthonormal eigenvectors U=(u1,…,unC)U = (u_1, \ldots, u_{n_C}) of L\mathcal{L}, ordered so that their eigenvalues satisfy 0=λ1≤⋯≤λnC0 = \lambda_1 \le\cdots\le\lambda_{n_C}. Each mode gives counties’ relative movements, with counties of the same sign moving together. Its eigenvalue λk\lambda_k, the graph frequency of mode kk, measures how sharply the pattern differs across social ties. Smooth modes have low graph frequency and assign similar degree-adjusted values D−1/2ukD^{-1/2}u_k to strongly connected counties. Figure 1 contrasts a smooth mode, which separates the Upper Midwest and Plains from Appalachia, the Mid-Atlantic and the Carolinas, with a rough mode that alternates in sign among neighboring counties of the Upper Midwest.

Two eigenvectors of the SCI Laplacian on the sampled counties

Figure 1. Two eigenvectors of the SCI Laplacian on the sampled counties, plotted at county centroids. Loadings are D−1/2ukD^{-1/2}u_k, scaled to the 97th percentile of their absolute value. Signs are arbitrary.

The transition satisfies Amuk=rm,kukA_m u_k = r_{m,k}u_k, where rm,k≡ρme−κmλkr_{m,k} \equiv\rho_m e^{-\kappa_m\lambda_k}. Without further inputs, each mode therefore keeps its shape and retains a fraction rm,kr_{m,k} of its amplitude each period. Diffusion makes rougher patterns fade faster when ρm>0\rho_m > 0 (Appendix § 12.8.§ 4 gives the implied half-lives). The first mode has λ1=0\lambda_1 = 0 and is proportional to square-root connectedness, u1∝D1/21u_1 \propto D^{1/2}\mathbf{1}. Let’s call it the stationary mode. I assume the graph is connected, meaning chains of friends link every two counties. The stationary mode is then the only mode with λ=0\lambda= 0, and it survives at rate ρm\rho_m. The persistence parameter therefore sets how long the broadest pattern lasts. Calling the demand field slow presumes rD,k>ratt,kr_{D,k} > r_{\mathrm{att},k} for the modes carrying the response.

The regressions in § 4 measure exposure through direct SCI links. The dynamic model allows transmission along longer paths and links responses across horizons, so a one-hop coefficient is not an estimate of κD\kappa_D (Appendix § 13.§ 3).

I also allow a storm’s economic effects to spread through production links. I represent this channel by a slow field dtP∈RnCd_t^P \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C} on a graph built from county industry shares and the BEA input–output matrix. It follows the slow law dt+1P=ADPdtP+ηDPνtd_{t+1}^P = A_D^P d_t^P + \eta_D^P \nu_t, with initial response dtP=0d_t^P = 0 and its own transition ADPA_D^P and input coefficient ηDP\eta_D^P (Appendix § 13.§ 2). I include production exposure as a competing channel because production disruptions can affect household resources and intermediary capital.

The response operator

To compare channels and counties, I combine the direct consumption effect and the fields into one response per county, the local valuation vt∈RnCv_t \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C},

vt≡−γΔct−aDdt−aattbt−aDPdtP,γ,aD,aatt>0, aDP≥0.(1)v_t \equiv-\gamma\Delta c_t - a_D d_t - a_{\mathrm{att}} b_t - a_D^P d_t^P,\qquad\gamma, a_D, a_{\mathrm{att}} > 0,\ a_D^P \ge0. \tag*{(1)}

Under power utility with curvature γ\gamma, the direct consumption response contributes −γct-\gamma c_t to the log-marginal-utility response, and the first term records the change in this contribution between periods. I choose the signs so that negative direct consumption-growth responses and adverse field responses raise the index. I interpret a higher index as payoffs becoming more valuable to households in that county, though not necessarily to the investors who set prices. I combine county valuations with fixed weights π∈RnC\pi\in\mathbb{R}^{n_C}. Holding these weights fixed lets me ask whether a source county’s relative importance changes across horizons. The weights can have either sign, so the results below also apply to the financial loadings that § 3 derives for credit prices.

Definition 1 (Response operator and valuation projection). For the one-time shock εt\varepsilon_t of § 2.1, the local response operator is Oh≡∂vt+h/∂εt′∈RnC×nC\mathcal{O}_h \equiv\partial v_{t+h}/\partial\varepsilon_t' \in\mathbb{R}^{n_C \times n_C}, h≥0h \ge0. The valuation projection is the row vector

Ωh=π′Oh∈R1×nC.\Omega_h = \pi^{\prime}\mathcal{O}_h \in\mathbb{R}^{1 \times n_C}.

References

  1. [1]Acemoglu, Daron, Ufuk Akcigit, and William Kerr, “Networks and the Macroeconomy: An Empirical Exploration,” in “NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2015,” Vol. 30, University of Chicago Press, 2016, pp. 273–335.
  2. [4]Adrian, Tobias, Erkko Etula, and Tyler Muir, “Financial Intermediaries and the Cross-Section of Asset Returns,” Journal of Finance, 2014, 69 (6), 2557–2596.DOI
  3. [5]Anderson, T. W. and Herman Rubin, “Estimation of the Parameters of a Single Equation in a Complete System of Stochastic Equations,” Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 1949, 20 (1), 46–63.DOI
  4. [6]Bailey, Michael, Rachel Cao, Theresa Kuchler, Johannes Stroebel, and Arlene Wong, “Social Connectedness: Measurement, Determinants, and Effects,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2018, 32 (3), 259–280.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30362698
  5. [7]Campbell, John Y. and John H. Cochrane, “By Force of Habit: A Consumption-Based Explanation of Aggregate Stock Market Behavior,” Journal of Political Economy, 1999, 107 (2), 205–251.
  6. [8]Carvalho, Vasco M., Makoto Nirei, Yukiko U. Saito, and Alireza Tahbaz-Salehi, “Supply Chain Disruptions: Evidence from the Great East Japan Earthquake,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2021, 136 (2), 1255–1321.
  7. [9]Chodorow-Reich, Gabriel, Xavier Gabaix, and Davide Viviano, “Propagation of Shocks in Networks: Identification and Applications,” 2026. Working paper. July 20 version.
  8. [10]Favara, Giovanni, Simon Gilchrist, Kurt F. Lewis, and Egon Zakrajšek, “Updating the Recession Risk and the Excess Bond Premium,” FEDS Notes, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, October 6 2016.DOI
  9. [11]Gabaix, Xavier, “The Granular Origins of Aggregate Fluctuations,” Econometrica, 2011, 79 (3), 733–772.
  10. [13]Galeotti, Andrea, Benjamin Golub, and Sanjeev Goyal, “Targeting Interventions in Networks,” Econometrica, 2020, 88 (6), 2445–2471.
  11. [14]Gao, Zhenyu, Bing Han, Chanik Jo, and Zhecheng Luo, “Social Transmission of Consumption,” Technical Report, Working paper 2026. July 15 version. SSRN 6401498.DOI
  12. [15]Gilchrist, Simon and Egon Zakrajšek, “Credit Spreads and Business Cycle Fluctuations,” American Economic Review, 2012, 102 (4), 1692–1720.
  13. [16]Haddad, Valentin and Tyler Muir, “Do Intermediaries Matter for Aggregate Asset Prices?,” Journal of Finance, 2021, 76 (6), 2719–2761.
  14. [19]Herskovic, Bernard, “Networks in Production: Asset Pricing Implications,” Journal of Finance, 2018, 73 (4), 1785–1818.
  15. [20]Hirshleifer, David, Lin Peng, and Qiguang Wang, “News Diffusion in Social Networks and Stock Market Reactions,” Review of Financial Studies, 2025, 28 (3), 883–937.
  16. [22]Kilts Center for Marketing, “NielsenIQ Consumer Panel and Retail Scanner Data,” University of Chicago Booth School of Business 2026. Official data documentation, accessed September 28, 2026.
  17. [23]Kimball, Miles S., “Standard Risk Aversion,” Econometrica, 1993, 61 (3), 589–611.
  18. [24]Koijen, Ralph S. J. and Motohiro Yogo, “A Demand System Approach to Asset Pricing,” Journal of Political Economy, 2019, 127 (4), 1475–1515.
  19. [26]Kuchler, Theresa, Yan Li, Lin Peng, Johannes Stroebel, and Dexin Zhou, “Social Proximity to Capital: Implications for Investors and Firms,” Review of Financial Studies, 2022, 35 (6), 2743–2789.
  20. [27]Makridis, Christos A. and Tao Wang, “Learning from Friends in a Pandemic: Social Networks and the Macroeconomic Response of Consumption,” European Economic Review, 2024, 169, 104836.
  21. [28]Mankiw, N. Gregory and Stephen P. Zeldes, “The Consumption of Stockholders and Nonstockholders,” Journal of Financial Economics, 1991, 29 (1), 97–112.
  22. [29]Nakamura, Emi and Jón Steinsson, “Fiscal Stimulus in a Monetary Union: Evidence from US Regions,” American Economic Review, 2014, 104 (3), 753–792.DOI
  23. [30]Opportunity Insights, “Economic Tracker Data Documentation,” Official data documentation 2026. Consumer Spending section, accessed September 29, 2026.
  24. [31]Vissing-Jørgensen, Annette, “Limited Asset Market Participation and the Elasticity of Intertemporal Substitution,” Journal of Political Economy, 2002, 110 (4), 825–853.
  25. [32]Webb, Matthew D., “Reworking Wild Bootstrap-Based Inference for Clustered Errors,” Canadian Journal of Economics, 2023, 56 (3), 839–858.
  26. [33]Wolf, Christian K., “The Missing Intercept: A Demand Equivalence Approach,” American Economic Review, 2023, 113 (8), 2232–2269.

Paper details

vlnc:W_gmmgpjgr
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Economics, Econometrics and Finance

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents