betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

The mean analytic rank of quadratic twists of elliptic curves

Abstract

For every elliptic curve over ℚ, we prove that the average analytic rank of its quadratic twists tends to 1/2 when signed squarefree twist parameters are ordered by absolute value. This resolves Goldfeld's mean analytic-rank conjecture in this counting convention.

Introduction

Goldfeld’s mean-rank conjecture predicts that the average central order of vanishing in a quadratic-twist family is 1/21/2 [5], p. 113, Conjecture (B). The issue addressed here is the contribution of rare twists of large analytic rank: knowing the densities of ranks zero and one does not determine the mean without control of this contribution.

Let E/QE/\mathbb{Q} be an elliptic curve. For a nonzero squarefree integer dd, write E(d)E^{(d)} for its quadratic twist, and put

D(Y)={d∈Z:0<∣d∣≤Y, d squarefree},a(E(d))=ord⁡s=1L(E(d),s).\mathcal{D}(Y)=\{d\in\mathbb{Z}:0<|d|\leq Y,\ d\text{ squarefree}\},\qquad a(E^{(d)})=\operatorname{ord}_{s=1}L(E^{(d)},s).

Both signs of dd are included. We call aa the analytic rank and write r(E(d))=rank⁡ZE(d)(Q)r(E^{(d)})=\operatorname{rank}_{\mathbb{Z}}E^{(d)}(\mathbb{Q}) for the algebraic or Mordell–Weil rank. Outside the explicitly algebraic statements below, rank means analytic order of vanishing.

Theorem 1.1. For every elliptic curve E/QE/\mathbb{Q},

lim⁡Y→∞1#D(Y)∑d∈D(Y)a(E(d))=12.\lim_{Y\to\infty}\frac{1}{\#\mathcal{D}(Y)}\sum_{d\in\mathcal{D}(Y)}a(E^{(d)})=\frac{1}{2}.

Theorem 1.1 resolves positively Goldfeld’s mean analytic-rank conjecture in this signed squarefree counting convention. It applies without restrictions on complex multiplication, rational torsion, rational isogenies, or reduction type.

The analytic density theorem [12], Theorem 1.2 states that, for this same family and every E/QE/\mathbb{Q},

#{d∈D(Y):a(E(d))=j}#D(Y)⟶12(j=0,1).(1)\frac{\#\{d\in\mathcal{D}(Y):a(E^{(d)})=j\}}{\#\mathcal{D}(Y)}\longrightarrow\frac{1}{2}\qquad(j=0,1). \tag*{(1)}

For the analytic mean theorem, (1) is the only input from the companion manuscript identified in the bibliography. A zero-density exceptional family can still contribute to a rank-weighted average. The new assertion needed for the mean is the following tail estimate, whose proof is independent of (1).

Theorem 1.2. For every elliptic curve E/QE/\mathbb{Q}, there are constants CE>0C_E > 0 and an integer RE≥1R_E \ge1 such that, for every integer R≥RER \ge R_E,

lim sup⁡Y→∞1Y∑d∈D(Y)a(E(d))>Ra(E(d))≤CER.\limsup_{Y \to\infty} \frac{1}{Y} \sum_{\substack{d \in\mathcal{D}(Y) \\ a(E^{(d)}) > R}} a(E^{(d)}) \le\frac{C_E}{R}.

Together, (1.1) and Theorem 1.2 show that

∑d∈D(Y)a(E(d))≥2a(E(d))=oE(Y).\sum_{\substack{d \in\mathcal{D}(Y) \\ a(E^{(d)}) \ge2}} a(E^{(d)}) = o_E(Y).

For each fixed sufficiently large integer RR, (1.1) makes the complement of ranks zero and one have density zero, so ranks 2 through RR contribute oE,R(Y)o_{E,R}(Y). For the remaining ranks, use the height limsup in Theorem 1.2 and then let RR tend to infinity. This order of limits will be made explicit in Section 6.

Algebraic-rank moments

The same signed squarefree family has the following algebraic-rank moment limits. This consequence uses the companion’s density conclusions and its density-one equality of analytic and algebraic ranks, together with the exponential-moment bound of Koymans and Smith. It does not use the analytic tail estimate of Theorem 1.2.

Corollary 1.3 (Fixed algebraic-rank moments). Fix an elliptic curve E/QE/\mathbb{Q}. For every fixed real tt,

lim⁡Y→∞1#D(Y)∑d∈D(Y)exp⁡(tr(E(d)))=1+et2.\lim_{Y \to\infty} \frac{1}{\#\mathcal{D}(Y)} \sum_{d \in\mathcal{D}(Y)} \exp(t r(E^{(d)})) = \frac{1 + e^t}{2}.

For every fixed positive integer mm,

lim⁡Y→∞1#D(Y)∑d∈D(Y)r(E(d))m=12.\lim_{Y \to\infty} \frac{1}{\#\mathcal{D}(Y)} \sum_{d \in\mathcal{D}(Y)} r(E^{(d)})^m = \frac{1}{2}.

The proof appears in Section 7.

All parameters tt and moment orders mm in Corollary 1.3 are fixed before Y→∞Y \to\infty. The corollary concerns algebraic ranks only: it gives no higher analytic-rank moments, no uniformity for parameters varying with YY, and no moment limit for thin polynomial subfamilies.

History and significance

Goldfeld’s original question concerns the change of rank when a fixed elliptic curve is viewed over quadratic fields. Under Birch–Swinnerton-Dyer, that change is the central order of the associated quadratic twist. His Conjecture (B) formulates the average directly in terms of this analytic order, using quadratic-field discriminants ordered by absolute value [5]. Here the counting parameter is instead the signed squarefree integer dd in D(Y)\mathcal{D}(Y). The rank-zero/rank-one density prediction describes the smallest orders allowed by the two functional-equation signs. The mean prediction also requires the larger orders, however sparse, to have negligible total contribution.

Conditional analytic estimates illustrate both aspects of the problem. Heath-Brown proved an upper bound 3/2+o(1)3/2 + o(1) for smooth averages over fundamental discriminants coprime to the conductor, separately for each functional-equation sign [7]. His nonnegative compactly supported weight selects one sign of the discriminant, and his Riemann-hypothesis assumption concerns every quadratic twist, including those not coprime to the conductor. Under the same twistwise Riemann-hypothesis assumption, Miller and Wong bounded higher analytic-rank moments and obtained exponentially decreasing large-rank counting tails [11]. Their weighted sums run over integer parameters, with possible repeated squareclasses; the weight selects one parameter sign without fixing the functional-equation sign. Their tail estimate fixes the rank threshold before taking the height limit. Fiorilli obtained the exact mean 1/21/2 over signed squarefree parameters coprime to the conductor, assuming the Riemann hypothesis for elliptic-curve LL-functions and an additional averaged cancellation hypothesis for nonreal zeros [4]. Thus this exact conditional mean uses more than the Riemann hypothesis.

A different route to densities comes from Selmer groups. Smith proved that, for every rational elliptic curve, the full 2-power Selmer corank is zero or one with density 1/21/2 each, using signed integer twist parameters [17]. His analytic density corollary assumes Birch–Swinnerton-Dyer [17]. The companion’s 2-converse supplies the analytic implication needed for (1.1) in the signed squarefree convention. Theorem 1.2 addresses the additional rank-mass question independently of that density argument.

Koymans and Smith prove exponential moment bounds for Mordell–Weil rank in polynomial quadratic-twist families [9]. The specialization in the proof of Corollary 1.3 supplies the needed algebraic tail control. Such bounds do not supply an analytic-rank identity or higher analytic-rank moments.

Hanners claims the full Birch–Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture for every rational elliptic curve [6]. We do not use this claim. The unresolved point is how the bridge conditions supported by tests on eighteen curves in Section 39.1 are established for every rational elliptic curve, as required by the transfer in Section 39.2. This is not a refutation of the claimed theorem.

Modularity provides the analytic continuation and functional equation for every curve in the argument [1]. Our estimates use these analytic properties and the local coefficient bounds. The proof invokes neither the Birch–Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture nor the generalized Riemann hypothesis.

Earlier work on a fixed elliptic curve already connected derivative moments to nonvanishing and analytic-rank averages. Perelli and Pomykala proved first-derivative nonvanishing results and bounds for the sum of analytic ranks [13]; Pomykala extended this nonvanishing approach to higher derivatives of fixed order in a congruence-restricted twisting family [14]. In the family of weight-two newforms of varying prime level, Kowalski, Michel, and VanderKam combined high completed derivatives, mollification, and consecutive derivative orders to control both functional-equation signs. Their passage from these nonvanishing counts to rank-weighted tails also uses a separate bound for the second moment of analytic rank [8]. In the present quadratic-twist argument the derivative order grows with height. This uniformity, together with a pointwise rank bound, controls the rank mass beyond the available counting range without requiring a bounded second analytic-rank moment.

Second moments of the twist LL-functions themselves supply the analytic comparison used below. For full-level holomorphic Hecke forms of weight divisible by four, Soundararajan and Young obtained the second-moment asymptotic over positive discriminants 8d8d, with dd odd and squarefree, under GRH for the twists, the Riemann zeta function, and the symmetric-square LL-function [19]. Li proved the asymptotic unconditionally in this full-level setting [10], Theorem 1.1. We adapt the Fourier-cutoff and prime-square inflation mechanism in Li’s proof, establishing the needed logarithmic bounds for our finite family of arbitrary elliptic curves with its conductor and bad-prime factors retained. Neither asymptotic is an input to the argument.

The analytic argument

The starting point is the exact identity of Lemma 4.1, forced by the vanishing of a derivative of order kk of the completed LL-function. Its Dirichlet-series weight is obtained by exponentially smoothing a kk-th power of a truncated logarithm. Near the square root of the conductor, at lengths of order XX for twists of height XX, this weight suppresses the late terms. The approximation (1−u)k≈e−ku(1-u)^k \approx e^{-ku} for u=O(1/k)u=O(1/k) motivates mollification: at u=log⁡n/log⁡Xu=\log n/\log X, the exponential corresponds to a small positive shift from the center of the LL-function. A short approximation to its inverse Euler product then makes the first weighted piece close to a positive main term. We split the weighted series using smooth cutoffs into finite pieces and a terminal series, use progressively shorter mollifiers as the lengths of the finite pieces increase, and estimate the terminal series without mollification.

Two features make the resulting estimates uniform for kk as large as a fixed power of log⁡X\log X. First, a Poisson argument and inflation give unmollified second moments with only powers of logarithms (Propositions 3.1 and 3.2). The inflation mechanism is related to Li’s work on quadratic twists [10]; we prove the estimate needed here for the entire fixed finite family of curves, including its local factors at bad primes. Second, Proposition 5.9 gives mean-square bounds for the mollified finite pieces in a model that replaces odd-prime character values by independent variables with their complete-residue distributions. The mean-square estimates use the whole probability space, without discarding exceptional outcomes. Proposition 3.7 transfers these bounds to integer averages. Separately, Proposition 5.3 compares the mollifiers with positive reciprocal Euler products on most integer parameters and relates these products to one another. We can then remove the mollifiers and compare every piece with the same positive product: the first piece dominates the later pieces and the terminal series. The resulting nonzero sum contradicts the completed-derivative identity whenever the rank exceeds the derivative order of matching parity. Consecutive orders cover both signs.

For admissible twists of height XX, Proposition 6.1 proves a bound OE(X/k2)O_E(X/k^2) for the number of ranks exceeding kk, uniformly up to k=(log⁡X)3/5k=(\log X)^{3/5}. A conductor-uniform Jensen bound (Lemma 6.2) gives the pointwise estimate a(E(d))=OE(log⁡X)a(E^{(d)})=O_E(\log X). The count at the largest permissible kk then controls the remaining rank mass, and summation of the integer tails proves Theorem 1.2. The numerical exponents used in the length partition leave ample room between the comparison error and the later thresholds; their optimization is not needed.

The sections follow the inputs required by this argument. Section 2 fixes the finite auxiliary family and the integer residue model. Section 3 proves the moments and the comparison with that model. Section 4 constructs the completed-derivative weights and bounds their terminal series. Section 5 constructs the short mollifiers and proves the model estimates. Section 6 combines them into the counting and rank-weighted tail bounds, and uses the companion density theorem only in the final deduction of the mean. Section 7 proves the separate algebraic-rank moment corollary.

Conventions

Implied constants may depend on the original curve EE, on fixed smooth functions, and on a specified fixed order of differentiation. They do not depend on the varying height, derivative order, or scale index unless this is explicitly stated. We write τ(n)\tau(n) for the divisor function and use the Fourier kernel e−2πixye^{-2\pi ixy} when applying Poisson summation. All sufficiently large lower thresholds for the integer kk are chosen after the fixed analytic exponents and smoothness orders.

Twist families and the integer model

We first reduce upper bounds for arbitrary twists to a fixed finite family of curves with coprime twisting parameters. This gives exact conductor formulas while preserving the bounds for nonnegative sums needed later. We then define the probability model for complete integer residue averages.

We use unitary normalization:

LF(s)=L(F,s+1/2)=∑n≥1λF(n)ns,qF=cond⁡(F),CF=qF2π.L_F(s)=L(F,s+1/2)=\sum_{n\ge1}\frac{\lambda_F(n)}{n^s},\qquad q_F=\operatorname{cond}(F),\qquad C_F=\frac{\sqrt{q_F}}{2\pi}.

The series converges absolutely in ℜs>1\Re s>1. Modularity and the local rules for the Hasse–Weil LL-function give real multiplicative coefficients and inverse Euler factors

1−λF(p)p−s+ξF,pp−2s,ξF,p=1p∤qF.(2)1-\lambda_F(p)p^{-s}+\xi_{F,p}p^{-2s},\qquad\xi_{F,p}=1_{p\nmid q_F}. \tag*{(2)}

At a good prime the two factor parameters have modulus one by Hasse’s bound [16]. At a multiplicative prime there is one parameter, of modulus p−1/2p^{-1/2}, and at an additive prime the factor is one [2]. In particular,

∣λF(n)∣≤τ(n).(3)|\lambda_F(n)|\le\tau(n). \tag*{(3)}

The completed function

ΛF(s)=CFsΓ(s+1/2)LF(s)\Lambda_F(s)=C_F^s\Gamma(s+1/2)L_F(s)

is entire of finite order and satisfies

ΛF(s)=ϵFΛF(1−s),ϵF∈{1,−1}.(4)\Lambda_F(s)=\epsilon_F\Lambda_F(1-s),\qquad\epsilon_F\in\{1,-1\}. \tag*{(4)}

Analytic continuation and the functional equation follow from modularity [1] and the standard completion [16]. The standard finite-order bounds follow, for example, from the split Mellin integral of the modular cusp form and its Fricke transform. They also give polynomial growth in every fixed vertical strip for each fixed curve FF, independently of the averaged estimates proved below. Indeed, enclose the strip in a≤ℜs≤ba\le\Re s\le b, with a≤−1a\le-1 and b≥2b\ge2. Absolute convergence bounds LFL_F on the right boundary; (2.3) and Stirling’s formula give LF(a+it)≪F,a(1+∣t∣)1−2aL_F(a+it)\ll_{F,a}(1+|t|)^{1-2a} on the left boundary. Take A=1−aA=1-a and an integer N>1−2aN>1-2a, so that LF(s)/(s+A)NL_F(s)/(s+A)^N is bounded on both boundaries. For ε>0\varepsilon>0 and 0<κ<π/(b−a)0<\kappa<\pi/(b-a), multiply this quotient by

exp⁡{−εcos⁡(κ(s−a+b2))}.\exp\left\{-\varepsilon\cos\left(\kappa\left(s-\frac{a+b}{2}\right)\right)\right\}.

The multiplier has modulus at most one on the vertical boundaries and at most exp⁡(−cεcosh⁡(κℑs))\exp(-c\varepsilon\cosh(\kappa\Im s)) on the horizontal sides, for a fixed c>0c>0. This dominates the finite-order growth. The maximum principle on expanding rectangles, followed by ε↓0\varepsilon\downarrow0, therefore gives LF(σ+it)≪F,a,b(1+∣t∣)NL_F(\sigma+it)\ll_{F,a,b}(1+|t|)^N on the strip. These individual bounds justify contour displacements. Their constants may depend on the fixed curve; estimates uniform in the varying twist parameters will be proved separately.

A finite family closed under reduction

Fix the primes

S={p:p∣2qE},QS=∏p∈Sp.S = \{p : p \mid2q_E\}, \qquad Q_S = \prod_{p\in S} p.

Let F\mathcal{F} be the finite set, up to Q\mathbb{Q}-isomorphism, of curves obtained from EE by twisting by signed squarefree products of primes in SS. The curve EE is included. Every F∈FF \in\mathcal{F} has good reduction outside SS.

Call a signed squarefree integer dd admissible if

d≡1(mod4),(d,QS)=1.d \equiv1 \pmod{4}, \qquad(d,Q_S)=1.

For a dyadic XX, put

A(X)={d:d admissible, X≤∣d∣<2X}.\mathcal{A}(X) = \{d : d\ \text{admissible},\ X \leq\lvert d\rvert< 2X\}.

Lemma 2.1. For every F∈FF \in\mathcal{F} and signed squarefree bb, there are F′∈FF' \in\mathcal{F} and an admissible dd such that

F(b)≃(F′)(d),∣d∣≤∣b∣.F^{(b)} \simeq(F')^{(d)}, \qquad\lvert d\rvert\leq\lvert b\rvert.

The correspondence can be chosen to have bounded multiplicity, uniformly in bb. Every sum of nonnegative functions of these twists can therefore be bounded by a fixed multiple of the corresponding sums over F\mathcal{F} and admissible parameters of no greater height.

References

  1. [1]Christophe Breuil, Brian Conrad, Fred Diamond, and Richard Taylor. On the modularity of elliptic curves over ℚ: Wild 3-adic exercises. Journal of the American Mathematical Society, 14(4):843–939, 2001. doi: 10.1090/S0894-0347-01-00370-8. URL https://www.imo.universite-paris-saclay.fr/~christophe.breuil/PUBLICATIONS/STW.pdf.DOI
  2. [2]Vladimir Dokchitser and Samuele Anni. ℓ-adic representations and their associated invariants, 2014. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1410.1039v1. Lecture course by V. Dokchitser, notes by S. Anni.
  3. [3]Paul Erdős. Beweis eines satzes von Tschebyschef. Acta Scientiarum Mathematicarum (Szeged), 5:194–198, 1932. URL https://acta.bibl.u-szeged.hu/13396/1/math_005_194-198.pdf.
  4. [4]Daniel Fiorilli. A conditional determination of the average rank of elliptic curves. Journal of the London Mathematical Society, 94(3):767–792, 2016. doi: 10.1112/jlms/jdw058. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1403.7108v1. Preprint locators refer to arXiv:1403.7108v1.
  5. [5]Dorian Goldfeld. Conjectures on elliptic curves over quadratic fields. In Melvyn B. Nathanson, editor, Number Theory, Carbondale 1979, volume 751 of Lecture Notes in Mathematics, pages 108–118. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 1979. doi: 10.1007/BFb0062705. URL https://www.math.columbia.edu/~goldfeld/ConjecturesonEllipticCurves.pdf. Conjecture (B), p. 113.DOI
  6. [6]Michael Hanners. Resolution of the Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture. Author-uploaded manuscript, 2026. URL https://www.researchgate.net/publication/403514375_Resolution_of_the_Birch_and_Swinnerton-Dyer_Conjecture. Author upload of 5 April 2026; concept DOI; Theorems 28.1, 39.4 and 39.5; Sections 39.1–39.2.DOI
  7. [7]D. R. Heath-Brown. The average analytic rank of elliptic curves. Duke Mathematical Journal, 122(3):591–623, 2004. doi: 10.1215/S0012-7094-04-12235-3. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0305114v1. Theorem 3 of the 7 May 2003 preprint, arXiv:math/0305114v1.
  8. [8]Emmanuel Kowalski, Philippe Michel, and Jeffrey VanderKam. Non-vanishing of high derivatives of automorphic L-functions at the center of the critical strip. Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik, 526:1–34, 2000. doi: 10.1515/crll.2000.074. URL https://people.math.ethz.ch/~kowalski/high-derivatives.pdf.DOI
  9. [9]Peter Koymans and Alexander Smith. Tamagawa ratios and unbounded Selmer moments, 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.31649v1. Version 1, 30 June 2026; Theorem 1.4.
  10. [10]Xiannan Li. Moments of quadratic twists of modular L-functions. Inventiones Mathematicae, 237:697–733, 2024. doi: 10.1007/s00222-024-01265-1. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.07343v2. Preprint locators refer to arXiv:2208.07343v2.
  11. [11]Steven J. Miller and Siman Wong. Moments of the rank of elliptic curves. Canadian Journal of Mathematics, 64(1):151–182, 2012. doi: 10.4153/CJM-2011-037-7.DOI
  12. [12]OpenAI. Goldfeld’s analytic density conjecture and the 2-converse for elliptic curves. OpenAI Math Release preprint OAI:Goldfelds-analytic-density-conjecture-and-the-2-converse-for-elliptic-curves-October-7-2026, 2026. Theorem 1.2.hub.valency.io/works/W_b4ww7z53
  13. [13]Alberto Perelli and Jacek Pomykala. Averages of twisted elliptic L-functions. Acta Arithmetica, 80(2):149–163, 1997. doi: 10.4064/aa-80-2-149-163. URL https://matwbn.icm.edu.pl/ksiazki/aa/aa80/aa8024.pdf.DOI
  14. [14]Jacek Pomykala. Non-vanishing of n-th derivatives of twisted elliptic L-functions in the critical point. Journal de théorie des nombres de Bordeaux, 9(1):1–10, 1997. doi: 10.5802/jtnb.185. URL https://www.numdam.org/item/JTNB_1997__9_1_1_0.pdf.DOI
  15. [15]Maksym Radziwiłł and Kannan Soundararajan. Moments and distribution of central L-values of quadratic twists of elliptic curves. Inventiones Mathematicae, 202(3):1029–1068, 2015. doi: 10.1007/s00222-015-0582-z. URL https://www.math.mcgill.ca/radziwill/QuadraticTwists.pdf.DOI
  16. [16]Joseph H. Silverman. The Arithmetic of Elliptic Curves, volume 106 of Graduate Texts in Mathematics. Springer, second edition, 2009. doi: 10.1007/978-0-387-09494-6.DOI
  17. [17]Alexander Smith. The Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture implies Goldfeld’s conjecture, 2025. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.17619v1. Version 1; Theorem 1.1 and Corollary 1.2.
  18. [18]Kannan Soundararajan. Nonvanishing of quadratic Dirichlet L-functions at s = ½. Annals of Mathematics, 152(2):447–488, 2000. URL https://annals.math.princeton.edu/articles/11847.
  19. [19]Kannan Soundararajan and Matthew P. Young. The second moment of quadratic twists of modular L-functions. Journal of the European Mathematical Society, 12(5):1097–1116, 2010. doi: 10.4171/JEMS/224. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/0907.4747v1. Preprint locators refer to arXiv:0907.4747v1.

Paper details

vlnc:W_gnem2sga
Version
v2 · latest
Published
License
LicenseRef-OpenAI-public
Usage

views · 19

downloads · 10

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

unreleased internal OpenAI model

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents