WorksPhysics and Astronomy
The nucleon is not a hard sphere: screening fifth forces with Skyrmions
Abstract
Laboratory searches for chameleon and symmetron fifth forces increasingly rely on individual nucleons as sources or probes, but model them as uniform spheres. Motivated by the Skyrme picture, we instead consider a nucleon profile with a constant-density core and an pion tail, together with its exponential truncation at the physical pion mass. We derive analytic screening charges for the uniform sphere and the profile, and extend the comparison to the exponential truncation at the physical pion mass using numerical solutions. Because the outer tail is too dilute to be screened at any coupling strength, the tail produces a power-law enhancement over the sphere charge in strong screening, and the exponential tail has a weaker, logarithmic enhancement. Propagating this difference through the published analyses, nucleon-sourced exclusion regions extend systematically further into the strongly coupled regime. For example, symmetron constraints from neutron interferometry at reach maximal self-couplings about orders of magnitude higher than for a uniform-sphere neutron ( orders of magnitude in the chiral limit),and at the dark-energy scale the hydrogen – chameleon bound reaches couplings orders of magnitude weaker than for a uniform-sphere proton ( in the chiral limit), overtaking the muonium bound.
Introduction
Light scalar fields coupled to matter arise in many extensions of the standard cosmological model [1, 2, 3, 4], including as explanations for dark energy and dark matter. Screening mechanisms, such as the chameleon’s density-dependent mass [5, 6, 7] and the symmetron’s density-dependent coupling [8, 9] (for earlier related work see Refs. [10, 11]), allow such fields to evade solar-system tests and some laboratory searches. These models of screening rely on self-interactions and non-linearities in the scalar field theory, so that the properties of the force mediator depend on the environment. As a result scalar mediated fifth forces can be dynamically small in experimental searches without the need to fine tune parameters. However, carefully designed experiments can still provide constraints [12, 13, 14].
A distinctive class of laboratory probes uses individual nucleons: gravitational resonance spectroscopy with ultracold neutrons (qBOUNCE) [15, 16], neutron interferometry [17], and precision spectroscopy of hydrogen [18], and these have proved particularly constraining for chameleon and symmetron models with the strongest couplings to matter. In these analyses the nucleon’s response is characterized by a screening charge , which measures the suppression of its scalar coupling relative to an unscreened nucleon. The published analyses compute for a uniform sphere of nuclear density representing the matter distribution of neutrons. In this paper, we revisit this hypothesis.
Indeed a nucleon, contrary to the usual assumption made in analysing laboratory experiments involving neutrons, is not a hard sphere. In this work we use the Skyrme model of baryons [19, 20] to describe a more realistic matter profile. In the Skyrme model the trace of the stress-energy tensor, the source of a conformally coupled scalar, has a localized core and a power-law tail [21]. Skyrmions are solitons which arise in the description of the Goldstone bosons associated with the breaking of chiral symmetry if four-derivative terms are included in the chiral Lagrangian. Reasonable agreement is found with experimental observations, see for example Refs. [22, 23, 24]. The stability of the solitons, and their finite size, is a consequence of balancing the two- and four-derivative terms. As a result of the necessarily large four-derivative terms, questions have been asked about the validity of the Skyrme model within effective field theory (EFT), and whether other, higher-order terms should also be included. However, for the solitons that we consider here the profile is smooth at the center of the Skyrmion and it has been shown that variations in EFT coefficients result in only small changes to the Skyrmion profile [25].
While lattice effective field theories [26] may now provide more detailed insight into the structure of nucleons than the Skyrme model, they do not currently provide a simple profile for the stress-energy of the nucleon state. Therefore we choose to use the Skyrmion profile, as an improvement over the hard sphere profile, to investigate how sensitive constraints on screened models are to nuclear matter distributions.
In what follows we introduce our theoretical model in Sec. II, outlining both the chameleon and symmetron scalar field theories, which we choose as example screening models, and determining the profile of the Skyrmion source. In Secs. III and IV we derive the screening charges for solid spheres, and Skyrmions of equivalent mass, for the chameleon and symmetron models respectively. In Sec. V we determine the changes to these charges when the Skyrmion profile is exponentially truncated at a scale corresponding to the pion mass. In Sec. VI we show how the constraints of the laboratory experiments, introduced above, change with different descriptions of the neutron. We conclude in Sec. VII. Appendices provide further details of our derivations.
In this work we use the metric convention, and set . is the reduced Planck mass squared.
Theoretical setup
Screened scalar fields
Both the chameleon and the symmetron belong to the class of conformally coupled scalars, with scalar sector
and matter action , where represent the matter fields which move on geodesics of the rescaled metric . When considering continuous matter distributions, the scalar couples to the Einstein-frame matter trace according to . For static pressureless matter, writing for the conserved rest-mass density, the scalar obeys
so the dynamics are governed by the density-dependent effective potential , and a test particle feels the fifth force per unit mass
The chameleon [5] combines an inverse-power potential with an approximately linear coupling,
where the energy scale controlling the coupling to matter, , can also be expressed in terms of the dimensionless coupling through . The effective potential has a minimum at , where the mass grows with density. If the corresponding Compton wavelength of the scalar becomes smaller than the size of the object, then such dense objects develop ‘thin shells’, where the mass in the interior of the shell decouples from the exterior field. The fifth force is .
The symmetron [8] combines a -symmetric Higgs-like potential with a quadratic coupling to matter,
so the effective quadratic term, in the presence of a non-relativistic perfect fluid, is . For the symmetry is restored, , and the fifth force switches off. In vacuum the symmetry breaks to with mass .
In both theories the field has a finite range , set by the ambient background density, far larger than a nucleon for the laboratory parameters considered here. Outside a compact source of size , the region , where scalar-potential effects are negligible, is its near zone. Here the exterior field is approximately harmonic, with . We define the screening charge as the exterior coefficient normalized to its unscreened point-source value. The explicit forms for each theory are given in Secs. III and IV.
The Skyrmion source
In the Skyrme model [19, 20] the nucleon is the baryon-number-one soliton of the chiral field , described by the Lagrangian:
where . The soliton is described by the hedgehog ansatz with , [25, 27].
The nucleon is a field configuration with internal stresses, so the trace of its stress-energy tensor, which sources the scalar, is not simply its energy density. Since the Einstein-frame trace is , with the trace computed in the Jordan metric , the matter term in Eq. (2) is . The product is already the leading coupling of the scalar to matter, and the dependence of the Skyrmion profile on contributes only a relative correction of order . We therefore evaluate the profile at , where the two frames coincide, and define the positive source for the scalar field as . Here is the mean of the three principal pressures. This trace source replaces in Eq. (2).
For the static hedgehog this source has a nearly constant core of radius set by , while at large radius the chiral-limit () profile falls as and the trace, given by the two-derivative sigma term, decays as . We therefore adopt the compact phenomenological representation
with the amplitude, , fixed by the total nucleon mass.
Throughout this work we will compare the scalar profiles sourced by Eq. (7) with those sourced by a uniform sphere of equal total mass and equal root-mean-square (RMS) radius, i.e.
so that any difference in screening is a pure shape effect. The trace-source mass has
The factor is twice that of a uniform ball of density and radius , as exactly half of the trace-source mass lies outside (Figure 1). A uniform sphere with equal mass and RMS radius to the trace-source has and .
Figure 1. Enclosed mass (top) and remaining mass beyond radius (bottom) for the chiral-limit trace profile Eq. (7) (blue solid), the pion-truncated profile Eq. (10) (blue dashed) at the neutron core radius, and the uniform sphere (orange), all at equal mass and RMS radius. The radial axis uses the chiral core radius.
For finite pion mass the positive trace source is , where and . The quartic Skyrme term cancels in this combination [21]. The asymptotic profile is Yukawa-suppressed, , which cuts off the trace tail exponentially beyond . Including the explicit mass contribution, the small-field trace is proportional to . Retaining the phenomenological flat core, we therefore use
with
The amplitude is again fixed by requiring the total mass to equal the nucleon mass.
The truncation introduces a single new dimensionless parameter, the ratio of the core radius to the cutoff radius, . Taking , the cutoff radius is , and (0.784) for the neutron (proton) core radius adopted below. The truncation barely alters the total tail mass, 49.9% (49.5%) of the neutron (proton) mass, against 50% in the chiral limit, but it removes the far tail. Replacing by a pure exponential and rematching mass and RMS radius changes the charges by up to about 35%, so we take Eq. (10) as our baseline for the physical tail.
For comparison with previous literature, for the neutron we adopt the Fermi-screening convention of Refs. [16, 17], , and for the proton following Ref. [18]. This corresponds to considering nucleons as classical lumps of matter with a well-defined matter distribution. Other assumptions have also been invoked such as modelling the matter distribution of nucleons using their wave-function in a quantum mechanical treatment [28]. We do not consider this possibility here and
restrict ourselves to a traditional approach where the matter distribution of nucleons can be treated classically.
The matched trace core radius is in either case. The pion-truncated profile carries less of its mass at large radius, so holding the comparison sphere fixed requires a slightly larger core. We solve for the core radius at which the truncated profile keeps the same RMS radius, giving for the neutron and for the proton, so that every comparison in this work is at equal mass and equal RMS radius for both tail variants. For illustration, setting and in Eq. (9) fixes the amplitude by mass normalization, .
All charges below depend on the source only through dimensionless screening parameters. Expressing them in terms of the chameleon coupling (or equivalently ) and the symmetron coupling requires a specified source mass and core radius. Where a specific experimental environment is required, such as a conversion in Figure 2, we adopt the qBOUNCE vacuum residual-gas density [16]. The near-zone symmetron charges are independent of this choice, and the constraint recomputations of Sec. VI use each experiment’s own ambient density.
Figure 2. Analytic chameleon charges against the Skyrmion trace thin-shell parameter of Eq. (13). Both sources are evaluated at the same physical coupling, for which (see text). The top axis converts to for the illustrative core with and an equal-mass, equal-RMS sphere of radius . The conversion uses , and . Top: individual charges; open markers are full nonlinear finite-volume solutions and the solid curves are the thin-shell results of Eqs. (15) and (19). The numerical half-screening point (dashed vertical line) lies at within the mesh-refinement estimates discussed in the text. Bottom: the source-shape ratio , below unity near the screening onset, where the sphere is briefly less screened, and growing as toward strong coupling, where the unscreened tail dominates.
Chameleon screening charges
For the chameleon of Eq. (4) the field around a screened source develops a thin shell. Inside the screening radius , whose value is fixed by the matching below, the field is pinned at the interior minimum , where denotes the core density of the source, for the trace profile and for the sphere. Across the shell the potential term in Eq. (2) is negligible and the field is driven by the bare source,
before relaxing to the ambient value . The exterior field carries the monopole . Integrating Eq. (12) once with the flat-core conditions , gives . A second integration, matched onto the exterior solution, fixes and the monopole . The screening charge is with .
All source dependence of the screening charge enters through a thin-shell parameter, one per source model,
with the Newtonian potential of the mass enclosed within . In what follows, denotes Eq. (13) evaluated with for the trace source, and its evaluation with for the sphere. The Newtonian potential is evaluated at the surface of the source. We now determine the screening charge for each source model.
Uniform sphere
For a uniform sphere we follow the classic thin-shell calculation [5]. The exterior solution is the pure monopole , and matching and at the surface gives
Normalizing by , the charge is a universal function of alone,
whose small- limit recovers the Khoury–Weltman thin-shell suppression, [5]. For the sphere, Eq. (13) reduces at leading order in the thin-shell limit to the thin-shell factor , where the shell with thickness contains the only matter that sources the exterior field.
Skyrmion trace source
For the Skyrmion trace source the tail contributes a particular term to the exterior solution of Eq. (12),
and the thin-shell edge can now sit in either the tail or core region. Matching across the thin shell gives, for a shell edge inside the core (),
while imposing the flat-core conditions directly on Eq. (16) for a shell edge in the tail () gives
The same normalization gives
This form of the solution can be seen to match well with numerically derived screening factors in Figure 2.
Interpretation
The chameleon charge has a simple interpretation in terms of Gauss’s theorem. Integrating Eq. (12) over the volume beyond gives , so the exterior monopole is exactly the unscreened mass beyond the screening radius,
with the second relation fixing . This gives the lower panel of Figure 1, which shows and can be read as the charge as a function of . At higher coupling, corresponding to lower via , is pushed outward, so and hence the charge are smaller.
The two screened regimes of Eq. (19) correspond to the two possible locations of the screening radius: for weaker screening () lies inside the core, while for stronger screening () it recedes into the tail. The two expressions meet continuously at , where crosses the core edge. In the tail, grows as and the charge falls only as , whereas, for a uniform sphere, the charge vanishes For matched constant density sources , and since the ambient density lies far below both source densities, meaning that in Eq. (13), the ratio of the two field excursions differs from unity by only for the benchmark, so at any coupling. Deep in screening the charges take their asymptotic forms and
so the trace source retains parametrically more charge as .
Figure 2 compares Eqs. (15) and (19) with full nonlinear finite-volume solutions of Eq. (2) for the model of Eq. (4). The thin-shell charges track the numerics through the entire screening transition. At the benchmark the numerically determined half-screening point agrees with the thin-shell value with a relative discrepancy of , which decreases under mesh refinement. This corresponds to for the illustrative core at and .
For , fixed mass, and , and neglecting against as in Eq. (13), , so at fixed charge. The matched neutron core therefore rescales the top axis by , giving the thin-shell estimate . The matched sphere reaches half screening at a trace thin-shell parameter smaller by 14.5%.
Symmetron screening charges
The near-zone behaviour
For the symmetron of Eq. (5), the near zone of § 0.2, , is very broad throughout the parameter space of interest to laboratory experiments, since the field’s mass at the ambient density, in the broken phase, which reduces to in vacuum, is far below the inverse size of a nucleon. The full numerical equation uses the total source density, with the residual gas represented by the floor . Subtracting the background leaves the localized density contrast and the background-potential term . Neglecting this term in the near zone and taking where the source controls the charge gives the leading linear problem
with , the ambient value, far beyond the source. The matter coupling survives as an effective mass . Far beyond the source the field propagates as if massless, which is what we mean by the massless near zone below. The exterior near-zone solution is harmonic, , and for an unscreened source, where throughout, integrating Eq. (22) gives . In the near zone we write . Because this near-zone equation is linear in the scalar field, the normalization of drops out, and depends on the source only through the screening parameter
Uniform sphere
For the uniform sphere the near-zone charge is the classic symmetry-restored-interior result
the massless limit of the full Brax–Pitschmann screening factor [29, 30] (Appendix A). The full factor is obtained by matching linearized interior and exterior solutions, and comes in two interior branches, according to whether the source density restores the symmetry inside the sphere (, Eq. (33)) or leaves it broken (, Eq. (35)).
Skyrmion trace source
The Skyrmion trace source admits an equally explicit charge. In the tail the inversion with reduces the radial equation for to the Weber-type equation , solved by . Matching to the evolution in the core, where , at () gives (Appendix A)
This satisfies as , and deep in screening
decaying more slowly than the sphere’s for the same reason as in the chameleon, namely that the tail is never fully screened and always contributes to the exterior monopole.
At the illustrative core with and , the charge in Eq. (25) agrees with the full nonlinear boundary-value solution at the level. Figure 3 shows the source-shape correction in the near zone. The ratio approaches unity for an unscreened source and grows as toward strong coupling.
Figure 3. Near-zone symmetron screening and the source-shape enhancement. Top: the analytical trace charge, Eq. (25) (blue), and equal-RMS sphere charge, Eq. (24) (orange), at fixed mass , trace core and sphere radius . Bottom: their ratio, with . In strong screening the trace charge scales as , whereas the sphere charge scales as , giving the ratio . These near-zone results have no independent dependence on .
For a strongly screened trace the field responds only once the local Compton wavelength exceeds the radius, with . For the tail this is the turning radius , which sets the exterior monopole and plays the role of the matching radius of the chameleon. For the sphere the matching radius is simply . The near-zone solution assumes , so the separation of from , rather than alone, measures where the massless treatment applies. Appendix B examines the finite-mass radial flux and the existence of a near-zone plateau.
Pion-truncated screening charges
The chameleon and symmetron charges for a hedgehog Skyrmion can be computed in the same way once the source tail is exponentially truncated at , as in Eq. (10). For the chameleon, the two integrals of Eq. (20) apply to any tail. For the truncated tail they evaluate in terms of incomplete gamma functions. For the symmetron the massless near-zone problem remains a one-parameter linear equation. Both are checked against full nonlinear solutions at the representative parameters specified below.
Figure 4 compares the resulting source-shape ratios with the chiral limit. The truncation does not switch the mechanism off, since an exponential tail still has unscreened mass beyond any screening radius, so the charge ratio keeps growing logarithmically rather than as a power law. Near the screening onset the truncation has a small effect, since the tail carries a few percent of the source mass at any coupling. Deep in screening is suppressed relative to the chiral limit. The chameleon ratio at falls from 9.7 to 6.9, and the neutron symmetron ratio from 650 to 26 at , from 65 to 14 at , and from 6.5 to 5 at .
Figure 4. Source-shape charge ratio with the physical pion mass and resulting exponential truncation of the Skyrmion density profile, for the chameleon against the trace thin-shell parameter (left) and for the symmetron in the massless near zone against for the neutron core radius (right). Solid black curves are the chiral limit; dashed curves use the physical massive-pion tail of Eq. (10); dotted curves replace by a pure exponential, with deviations up to about 35% over the plotted ranges. Open circles are full nonlinear solutions with the truncated source at 7 points per theory, spanning to and to , the latter at in units of the truncated core radius and zero ambient density.
Laboratory bounds
The charges derived above determine the response whenever the experimental probe or source is an individual nucleon. For the chameleon neutron probes, the charge varies with the ambient field and must be integrated to obtain the neutron’s potential energy. The near-zone symmetron charge is field-independent, and the atomic Yukawa signal is linear in the source charge evaluated at the chamber field. With these prescriptions, exclusion regions can be recomputed without repeating the experimental analysis. We have done this for both the chiral-limit and pion-truncated profiles, for the single-nucleon laboratory probes with published screened-scalar constraints: qBOUNCE gravitational resonance spectroscopy [15, 16], neutron interferometry [16, 17], and hydrogen – spectroscopy [18]. Muonium spectroscopy [18] is sourced by a pointlike antimuon, so it is insensitive to the nucleon model and serves as a fixed reference. Similarly, constraints from scalar oblique corrections to electroweak precision observables, probed with high-energy particle colliders, do not involve the screening of nucleons and so are unchanged [31]. Constraints from macroscopic sources (torsion balances, lunar laser ranging, Casimir experiments) are unaffected, since their screening is governed by the thin shell of the bulk body, not by nucleon substructure. Atom-interferometry bounds [32, 33] sit between these cases. The source mass is macroscopic, but wherever the atomic probe’s nucleus is screened its charge depends on how the trace tails of nucleons combine at the nuclear surface, a multi-nucleon problem beyond the single-nucleon scope of this work.
Experiments and observables
Here we summarize how each experiment works, the observable the published analysis computes, and the point at which the nucleon charge enters. All other inputs follow the published analyses.
qBOUNCE
Ultracold neutrons reflect from polished horizontal surfaces at any angle of incidence, and above a mirror in the Earth’s field they occupy discrete gravitational bound states. The eigenfunctions are Airy functions, , where is the -th zero of Ai. The characteristic gravitational length scale of the bounce, for the neutron mass , is , and the energies , with , form the ladder , set by gravity alone.
A scalar field sourced by the mirror adds the adiabatic potential
where is the static profile above the mirror and is the neutron screening charge of Secs. III–IV evaluated in the local mirror-generated field. The arbitrary reference field changes only a constant energy offset. For the chameleon, at leading order and we integrate the local thin-shell charge. For the symmetron, the field-independent near-zone charge gives . At first order the level shifts are the expectation values , which suffices for the chameleon. The symmetron layer can be deep enough that we instead solve for the full perturbed spectrum, following the published nonperturbative treatment (Sec. VIC). The qBOUNCE experiment at the Institut Laue–Langevin [15] drives the and transitions mechanically and measures and , a precision of a few .
Neutron interferometry
Neutrons are affected by the presence of the scalar field and interfere when a neutron beam is split into two separate paths that recombine after each crosses a chamber. A neutron of kinetic energy , where is the neutron wavevector, crossing a region of potential propagates with the local wavevector at position along its flight path, the index-of-refraction relation of neutron optics [34]. The phase accumulated relative to the empty cell, , is at leading order in
where is the field profile in the chamber [35], and is the same adiabatic energy of Eq. (27), evaluated at the chamber field with a common reference for both paths.
The expansion requires for the beam. This is stronger than the condition for a real local wavevector. Larger transmitting potentials require the unexpanded expression for , and near a turning point, reflection must also be treated.
The searches of Refs. [17, 35] at the S18 instrument of the Institut Laue–Langevin send neutrons of wavelength through two chambers in the same housing: a vacuum cell of length , filled with helium through a leak valve, and a reference chamber open to ambient air. Inside either one the scalar is suppressed at the dense walls, so depends on the transverse position at which the beam crosses. Because only phase differences are measurable, two differential observables isolate the in-cell field. We resolve the field in both the radial and longitudinal directions of the finite cylinder, including its end walls, and integrate along each beam path before forming the differences. The effective length of used in Ref. [35] was obtained by integrating for an unscreened neutron in the chameleon model. The screened energy is nonlinear in , so the same effective length need not apply.
In profile mode the chamber assembly is translated sideways, so the beams cross their chambers on the axis and off-axis, with the cell at ,
In pressure mode both beams stay on axis and the helium filling is stepped between and ,
Each scalar phase contribution is negative, but the observables are differences between two cells, so their signs depend on which cell hosts the larger contrast. The pressure mode is always negative. The profile mode is negative where the vacuum cell carries more transverse contrast than the air reference, but a nearly flat vacuum profile can carry less, in which case is positive. This occurs for a very narrow mass window at . The one-sided thresholds are therefore chosen by the sign of the predicted phase: or , and or .
The in-cell profiles are computed per model. The symmetron field vanishes at the side and end walls and is nonzero only above the finite-cylinder threshold , with and evaluated at the chamber gas density. The chameleon fills the cell with the bubble profile used in Sec. VIB.
Hydrogen and muonium
The analysis of Ref. [18] uses the hydrogen – spectroscopy measurement of Ref. [36], accurate to four parts in , which caps any scalar-induced shift at , and the muonium measurement of Ref. [37], six orders of magnitude less precise at . The screened nucleus adds a Yukawa perturbation on top of the ambient chamber field,
with for the symmetron, where and are the scalar mass and field value in the vacuum chamber. For the chameleon, is the smaller of the minimum of the effective potential at the chamber gas density (the chamber minimum), and the wall-limited value, with effective chamber radii of for the hydrogen apparatus and for muonium, and residual-gas densities of and respectively [18]. The wall-limited value is the field at which the chameleon’s in-chamber Compton wavelength matches the cavity size, , giving with for a spherical chamber, so that . We take , so the field reaches the chamber minimum where , and otherwise stops at .
First-order perturbation theory in the hydrogenic states gives the closed expectation values
with the Bohr radius and , and the observable is the differential shift , exactly linear in , which is evaluated at the ambient field of the apparatus.
The muonium source is the point-like anti-muon, taken to be unscreened with everywhere in parameter space.
Exclusion criteria and validity cuts
A parameter point is excluded when the predicted signal leaves the window (qBOUNCE), crosses the one-sided 95% threshold (interferometry), or exceeds the spectroscopic cap (hydrogen and muonium). Table I summarises the validity and display cuts that delimit every constraint region in the following sections.
Chameleon bounds
Figure 5 shows the chameleon constraints for in the plane, with previously published regions also displayed. Throughout, denotes the dark-energy scale. The chameleon regions are restricted to weak coupling, , so that the higher-order matter-coupling terms dropped by every treatment stay small, and to the domain where the thin-shell matching is self-consistent at the ambient field the probe samples. The matching needs well inside the local Compton wavelength, and we adopt the unit ratio . Only the chiral regions of hydrogen and interferometry lose parameter space to this rule, and there the boundary is not drawn along the removed edge. The interferometry region additionally requires the in-cell potential of the screened neutron, the same charge integral that enters the phase, to stay below a tenth of the beam’s kinetic energy, which is the validity domain of Eq. (28), and keeps the Compton wavelength at the wall density below 0.25 mm so that the field settles to its bubble profile inside the cell. Following Ref. [16], the qBOUNCE regions keep the vacuum interaction range below 1 mm, so that the vacuum chamber can be neglected. All other inputs follow the published analyses.
Figure 5. Combined chameleon () exclusion regions from qBOUNCE (red), neutron interferometry (blue), and hydrogen (orange) and muonium (green) 1s–2s spectroscopy, following the analyses of Refs. [16, 18]. Filled regions with a solid boundary use the Skyrmion trace source with the pion-truncated profile of Eq. (10), the physical nucleon model; dashed boundaries use the equal-mass, equal-RMS Skyrmion trace source in the chiral limit; dotted boundaries use the uniform-sphere nucleon. All three use the same thin-shell charge. Muonium (solid green line) is point-like-sourced and fixed, as is the (grey dashed) bound from electroweak precision tests. All three hydrogen bounds cross the dark-energy scale meV at strong coupling. The chiral-limit trace reaches furthest below it. At strong coupling the chiral hydrogen region, and the lower edge of the chiral interferometry band, end on the thin-shell validity line (Sec. VI B). This edge is not drawn. The dashed boundaries stop where the matching ceases to be valid, not where the signal disappears. Purple dot-dash lines are previously published constraints from Refs. [16, 18] which assume a uniform sphere nucleon.
a. qBOUNCE. For the uniform sphere neutron the exclusion covers , reaching from down across the dark-energy scale at its weak-coupling tip. The bounds differ from the published region of Ref. [16], in both the charge and energy prescriptions. That analysis screens the neutron with a linear-response factor built on a constant interior chameleon mass and uses a fixed-vacuum-charge potential. Here the charge follows from the nonlinear thin-shell matching of Eq. (15) and is integrated over the local field as in Eq. (27). A reference calculation using the previously published methods reproduces its region, including the curved lower boundary.
The Skyrmion changes the uniform sphere result at the strong-coupling edge. The edge exists because the predicted energy shift is proportional to . Toward smaller the explicit , the coupling of an unscreened nucleon, grows, but the neutron’s charge falls faster ( with ), so the shift falls back inside the measured windows and sensitivity is lost. The trace neutron delays this, as its charge falls as (Sec. III), which widens the exclusion by a factor 19 in the matter coupling in the chiral limit at , and 16 with the physical pion mass.
Truncation removes the tail beyond the cutoff radius , and the enhancement is reduced to logarithmic growth only once the screening radius passes that cutoff. At the screening radius at the vacuum field is truncated core radii, well past the cutoff, yet most of the chiral-limit gain remains.
b. Neutron interferometry. The original chameleon analysis of this experiment, Ref. [35], solved the field in the actual square cell and fit the full multi-position phase data, but treated the neutron as an unscreened test particle, an approximation that holds near its weak-coupling bound and fails toward stronger coupling, where the neutron screens. Ref. [16] revisited the experiment with source screening included, bounded the largest attainable phase using its linear-response charge, and concluded that a more detailed analysis would be “futile”. This conclusion depends on the choice of charge equation. The chameleon mass inside the neutron is always very large, so a charge built on it is negligible, whereas the thin-shell criterion leaves the neutron barely screened wherever is of order unity.
With the thin-shell charge the recomputed exclusion, using both interferometry modes with the bubble profile in the cell, has no strong-coupling termination. It spans more than twenty-one decades of matter coupling, from , where the weak-coupling sensitivity edge meets the wall-equilibration validity cut, down past the strong-coupling edge of our computed grid at . The band runs from up to . Its lower boundary is the sensitivity threshold, while its ceiling is the validity domain of Eq. (28) evaluated on the screened potential, with the cut taking over at the extreme edge of the grid. We do not repeat the square-cell, multi-position treatment of Ref. [35], but keep the cylindrical two-point reduction of the symmetry analysis so that both scalars share one experimental model. As a result, at the weak-coupling edge, where no screening physics enters, our bound at is a factor of more conservative than that of Ref. [35].
The Skyrmion gain appears on the band’s sensitivity edge and grows with the depth of screening. At fixed coupling the trace neutron excludes lower than the sphere, by 0.4 decades at rising to 0.8 decades at $10^{-24}$ in the chiral limit (0.3 and 0.3 decades, respectively, with the physical tail). On the validity ceiling the ordering reverses, because the larger surviving trace charge reaches the linear-phase limit sooner, so the sphere band extends to higher there. This edge, like the strong-coupling end of the chiral band’s lower edge, marks the limit of the validity domain and not of the sensitivity. At the latter the thin-shell rule $m_{\rm out}R_\ast \leq 1
of Table 1, evaluated at the field of the cell that generates each phase signal, removes the chiral neutron’s exclusion below . The dashed boundary is left undrawn there. The sphere and pion-tail neutrons satisfy the rule throughout their bands.
| Condition | Applies to | Criterion |
| Weak coupling | all chameleon regions | |
| Weak coupling | all symmetron regions | , the termination read off the published contours [16] |
| Screening range | all regions | chameleon , symmetron , at the field that generates the signal; removes only strong-coupling points of the chiral chameleon hydrogen and interferometry regions, where the boundary is not drawn (Sec. VI B) |
| Linear phase | interferometry | for Eq. (28); symmetron points with and are shown as beyond first order and transmission unverified (Sec. VI C) |
| Wall equilibration | interferometry, chameleon | Compton wavelength at the wall density below 0.25 mm, so that the field reaches its wall minimum inside the aluminium walls |
| Interaction range | qBOUNCE | vacuum Compton wavelength below 1 mm [16] |
| Broken phase | all symmetron regions | and the chamber large enough to support the vev (finite-cylinder threshold for the interferometer, for spectroscopy); symmetric-phase points carry no signal |
Table 1. Validity and display cuts applied to the regions of Figure 5 and Figure 6. Each cut bounds the domain of an approximation or of the comparison with the published contours. is for the chameleon and for the symmetron, evaluated at the ambient field of each apparatus. is the kinetic energy of the interferometer beam and the in-cell potential of the screened neutron, Eq. (27) from a zero reference field.
Using the thin-shell charge restores a neutron-interferometry exclusion band that is absent with the linear-response prescription, for which the maximal-phase envelope of Ref. [16] remains below the experimental threshold. This region is already excluded by atom interferometry, so the result is an independent constraint and does not extend the combined exclusion.
c. Hydrogen and muonium. The sphere and both Skyrmion trace protons use the same thin-shell matching. For comparison, a reference calculation using the published interpolation , with the interior field neglected, reproduces the hydrogen exclusion of Ref. [18]. The right edge, , matches to within 0.05 decades, and the low- boundary to a few hundredths of a decade. Using Eq. (15) for the sphere slightly weakens the crossover corner, while leaving the overall coupling reach and minimum excluded unchanged on our grid. This boundary is set by screening. Toward small the shrinking chamber field deepens the proton’s screening, and the sphere bound ends near , just below the dark-energy scale. The trace proton delays this cutoff, as for qBOUNCE. Under deep screening the sphere charge vanishes linearly in the screening parameter, whereas the tail charge falls only as its power, so the exclusion remains to with the physical tail and to in the chiral limit, more than an order of magnitude below the sphere’s floor.
Toward strong coupling the chiral screening radius grows without bound, , and the matching of Sec. III needs a near zone between the shell and the Yukawa exterior. In this matching , so the ratio compares the tail density at the shell edge with , the density whose minimum is the chamber field, here the gas density . With the tail at the shell edge is still eight times denser than the gas, corresponding to . The electron’s orbit is no longer outside the shell, and the picture of an electron feeling a Yukawa tail from a screened proton breaks down. We therefore terminate the chiral constraint at this point, where the chiral floor quoted above lies, and Figure 5 does not draw the boundary along it. The sphere’s shell never leaves the source and the pion-truncated screening radius grows only logarithmically, so these constraints are unaffected.
Along the sphere proton excludes , the pion-tail Skyrmion , and the chiral Skyrmion , so that the dark-energy scale the Skyrmion proton carries the hydrogen bound beyond muonium’s . Part of the newly excluded region was previously covered only by muonium. Muonium itself, sourced by the pointlike antimuon, has no charge to modify. Its bound, , is the same in all three source models. The published region stops at , where the in-chamber mass still satisfies , a Compton wavelength of roughly fifty Bohr radii. Ref. [18] evaluates the shift in the light-field limit and truncates the bound well within that approximation’s domain of validity. The exact matrix elements of Eq. (32) hold at any mass and keep the exclusion at the weak-coupling edge down to , where the finite-range suppression becomes relevant. The global low- extent reaches the lower edge of our scan.
Symmetron bounds
Figure 6 shows the corresponding symmetron constraints, with previously published regions also shown. The first-order interferometry phase and spectroscopy observables are linear in , so their exclusion boundaries in are rescaled by the nucleon’s charge ratio. The qBOUNCE interaction-range cut is that of Table I. We terminate the displayed regions at , the value read off the published contours of Ref. [16] (their stated criterion is ), common to every slice and to both neutron experiments. Throughout, the Skyrmion trace charges are evaluated in the massless near zone, Eq. (25) and its pion-truncated form, while the sphere uses the full Brax–Pitschmann factor with both interior branches. The near-zone treatment is self-consistent wherever its matching radius of Sec. IV C lies inside the ambient Compton wavelength, , the symmetron form of the screening-range rule of Table I. This is the case for each slice. Figure 3 shows the near-zone source-shape enhancement. Full nonlinear source-profile checks support the near-zone approximation at the few-percent level over the sampled constraint range, including down to . Appendix B gives a quantitative comparison and examines the radial flux at finite background mass.
Figure 6. Combined symmetron exclusion regions in fixed- slices from qBOUNCE, neutron interferometry, and hydrogen and muonium spectroscopy. Line conventions as in Figure 5. For the filled (physical Skyrmion) interferometry region, the shading distinguishes three regimes of the potential envelope : solid shading for , dots for (nonlinear phase required), and diagonal hatching for (transmission unverified). Both hatched regimes show linear-phase extrapolations. Faint contour segments fail the corresponding source’s cut. The published hydrogen and muonium regions of Ref. [18] apply no cut, and they are shown only where , the display floor used for our regions. The keV qBOUNCE regions are conditional on treating the mirror as a hard wall and on reading the measured transitions as transitions out of the lowest eigenvalue (see Appendix C for discussion).
a. qBOUNCE. We follow the nonperturbative treatment of Ref. [16], using the exact one-mirror profile with its residual-gas density, the perturbed spectrum from the full Schrödinger problem, and the published level convention, in which the measured transitions are read off the eigenvalue ladder. The uniform-sphere neutron reproduces the published regions to within 0.25 decades at and . At the published boundary lies 0.1–0.8 decades above ours, while at , the upper boundary differs by up to a factor .
Above the mirror, there is an attractive well due to the neutron’s coupling to the square of the symmetron field. The width of this well is set by the symmetron’s Compton wavelength in the chamber, which at is , four orders of magnitude below the characteristic scale of the gravitational states and far below the resolution of any mesh scaled to them. At a representative point inside the published exclusion region, and , the resolved well has depth scale and surface depth . It binds three states of its own, at , , and meV, each localized within a few ångströms of the surface. The gravitational quartet, by contrast, sits at 1.41, 2.46, 3.32, and 4.08 peV, so the surface states are bound eight to ten orders of magnitude more deeply than the gravitational ladder. The eigenvalue ladder labels them “levels 1–3”, so the predicted at the point above is a 7.62 meV gap between two surface states, far outside the measured peV-scale window, and the point is excluded.
Surface-localized states also occur at lower masses, as illustrated by the and 1 eV examples in Appendix C. At smaller , the broader scalar potential instead modifies the gravitational ladder. At 1 keV, the surface states are confined to ångstrom scales and are well separated from the gravitational states, requiring the resolved-layer treatment described there.
The previously published boundary lies up to a factor in above ours. At a point in the disputed region, GeV and , the well is 0.16 meV deep, roughly a third of the strength needed to bind, and holds no states at all. The binding threshold is obtained from the zero-energy Schrödinger equation for the kink potential with a hard wall at the mirror. In terms of , the threshold is , approaching when the surface field vanishes. Here , well below the threshold.
Its effect on the gravitational spectrum is described by the scattering length nm. We obtain by solving the zero-energy Schrödinger equation in the surface potential, with and gravity neglected. Beyond the well, , which defines . To leading order, this is equivalent to displacing the mirror surface by that distance, which shifts every level by the same peV and cancels in the transition energies, so the predicted transitions stay at their unperturbed values, and peV, inside both measured windows, under every assignment of levels to the eigenvalues. The level convention therefore cannot account for the difference from the published analysis in this region, which must arise in the computed spectra. An unresolved ångstrom-scale layer is a natural candidate, but we have not reproduced the published calculation, and which implementation detail is responsible remains open.
These results rest on a critical assumption. The level convention here reads the measured (and ) as a transition out of whichever state is lowest, so that at 1 keV an ångstrom-scale state, orders of magnitude more deeply bound than the states the experiment prepares and drives, inherits the measured transitions. Whether such a state actually participates in the measurement at all, whether the state selector populates it, the mechanical drive addresses it, or the detector counts it, is worthy of further investigation.
The source shape becomes important toward stronger coupling, including in the lower- panels. At keV and keV, the strongest coupling at which all three sources remain inside the display cuts, the sphere, chiral and pion-truncated upper limits are , and , gains of 200 and 19.8 at fixed , falling to below a factor 10 by MeV.
b. Neutron interferometry. We evaluate both interferometry modes in the shared finite-cylinder model (Sec. VI A 2), and for the uniform-sphere neutron the published boundaries lie above the recomputed ones by a median of 0.04 decades at 1 keV, 0.09 decades at 1 eV and 0.14 decades at 0.1 eV, rising toward the symmetry-restoration edge. At first order the phase observable is linear in , and the displayed regions terminate, like the published ones, at the strong-coupling edge .
This termination is independent of the small-potential condition behind Eq. (28). At the edge the potential envelope , with the broken-phase value in the evacuated cell, reaches , which exceeds wherever . We therefore distinguish three regimes in Figure 6. Only is shown as a linear-phase exclusion. For the beam still propagates but the phase must be evaluated beyond first order, and for transmission itself is unverified.
[17] uses a pressure-mode threshold of , fillings of and mbar, and the field set to its vacuum value throughout the cell. We use the one-sided 95% limit from the measured of [35], which places our boundaries 0.19 decades lower at every . The flat-field approximation is accurate to better than 1% along these boundaries in our finite-cylinder solution, away from the symmetry-restoration edge. At meV the published boundary lies a further factor of up to 5 above ours near GeV, falling to about 1.4 by GeV. For GeV the neutron is unscreened, both fillings are in the broken phase, and the pressure-mode signal reduces to , independent of , so our boundaries at the three slices coincide there. The published 1 meV contour instead sits a factor 5 above the published 0.1 eV contour at GeV.
The increase in the area of the excluded region for a Skyrmion model compared to a uniform sphere is large for neutron interferometry. The exclusion boundary lies well inside the screened regime, and at its apex the neutron’s screening parameter is at eV and at 1 keV. The maximal reach in rises by 1.5 decades at eV and by 3.0 decades at 1 keV. The physical pion mass suppresses this somewhat, to 1.0 and 1.4 decades respectively, because the field held per unit penetrates much farther beyond the pion cutoff than at the chameleon qBOUNCE edge. The turning radius is and core radii, compared with a cutoff at , well inside the regime where the enhancement grows only logarithmically. All these maxima lie well inside the linear-phase domain, with .
c. Hydrogen and muonium. For the uniform sphere proton the recomputed hydrogen and muonium regions track the published contours. One input differs by construction. The published analysis screens the proton with the interpolation , while we evaluate the full Brax–Pitschmann factor. The two coincide in the unscreened and deeply screened limits and differ only where the proton is marginally screened, by up to a factor 2.2 in charge near , which moves our boundaries by at most half a decade in over a few mass contours at the weak-coupling corner. The Skyrmion moves the strong-coupling edges by the proton’s charge ratio, since the spectroscopy observable is linear in . At keV the hydrogen reach in rises by 1.4 decades with the physical tail and by 4.0 in the chiral limit. The muonium regions are again the same for all three source models.
Discussion
Scalar fields are popular as models of dynamical dark energy and ultra-light dark matter. If such fields are introduced, an explanation is needed for why they have not yet been detected. Screening mechanisms provide an alternative to stringent fine-tuning of coupling constants, by allowing the properties of scalar fluctuations to vary with their environment. This comes at the cost of making the theory non-linear.
Whilst screening mechanisms were introduced to avoid local experimental tests, they do not render the scalar invisible. Precision measurements with small and compact objects have proved a powerful probe of these theories. As the sensitivity of these experiments continues to improve, it is vital that the theoretical accuracy of our predictions for the sensitivity of the experiments is refined as well. It is in this spirit that in this work we revisit the assumptions that have been made in existing analyses about the way in which the scalar field behaves around neutrons and protons.
Protons and neutrons are complex objects made of quarks and gluons. When probed at low energies much of this complexity can be neglected, but when computing the effect of such nucleons on screened scalar fields the spatial distribution of mass and energy is important. In this work we have shown that different models of the nucleon make a significant difference to the regions of chameleon and symmetron parameter space excluded by such experiments. Our two models were a hard sphere of constant density and fixed radius, and a Skyrmion profile, which we believe to be a more accurate representation. All preceding analyses assumed that the nucleon was a hard sphere.
Figure 5 and Figure 6 show the consequences for constraints on the chameleon and symmetron models respectively, identifying the parts of parameter space in which the constrained region shifts when the model of the nucleon is changed. Key changes include the fact that symmetron constraints from neutron interferometry at reach maximal self-couplings about 1.4 orders of magnitude higher than for a uniform-sphere neutron (3.0 orders of magnitude in the chiral limit), and at the dark-energy scale the hydrogen – chameleon bound reaches couplings 1.8 orders of magnitude weaker than for a uniform-sphere proton (2.4 in the chiral limit), overtaking the muonium bound. We propose that, in future, the Skyrmion model be used to analyse constraints on chameleons and symmetrons, and related screening models, from precision measurements of protons and neutrons.
We have not addressed here the interesting question of how best to model the nuclei of more complex atoms, such as those used in atom interferometry experiments which also provide important constraints on the type of screening models discussed here. Similar improvements in the accuracy of theoretical predictions are needed to continue to ensure that forecasts match the precision of experiments. Determining how best to model the screening of such atomic nuclei is left as a question for future work.
Acknowledgments
CB and AM are supported by STFC Consolidated Grants [Grant Nos. ST/X000672/1, ST/C004235/1]. For the purpose of open access, the authors have applied a CC BY public copyright license to any Author Accepted Manuscript version arising. We acknowledge the use of Anthropic’s Claude Fable in this work, for the derivation of the near-zone symmetron charge, Eq. (25). This result was subsequently checked by a human researcher.
Data availability
The screening-charge tables, the recomputed exclusion boundaries and the figure files supporting this work are openly available on Zenodo at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23419321 under a CC BY 4.0 licence. The analysis code is available from the authors on reasonable request.
Derivation of the Symmetron profile
Uniform sphere.—For the uniform sphere, where the density in the interior of the sphere restores the symmetry of the symmetron model, the solution of the linearized field equation regular at the origin is with , and the exterior linearized solution is with . Writing and , continuity of the field and its derivative at determines the exterior coefficient, , with the ratio of the two conditions eliminating the interior normalization. Normalizing by its leading small- expression at fixed , the unscreened limit , gives the Brax–Pitschmann screening factor [29, 30]:
whose massless-near-zone limit , is Eq. (24). The point-source reference instead gives
where multiplies . The origin-referenced, point-normalized coefficient is therefore , not . The two coincide only in the massless near zone.
When the sphere density is too low to restore the symmetry, , the interior ansatz with and gives in the same way [30]
In this branch and both carry in place of . The offset cancels in but leaves the point-normalized coefficient of Eq. (34) with a further factor .
Trace source.—In the massless near zone the trace source obeys Eq. (22) with . Regularity gives in the core. In the tail, the inversion reduces the radial equation for to , solved by . As ,
so the branch carries the asymptotic field and the branch carries the exterior monopole coefficient . The derivatives at the core edge collapse via the Bessel recurrences to
Matching and at and normalizing by gives Eq. (25). The -function prefactor is the ratio of the two normalizations in Eq. (36), written using , and the unscreened limit follows identically from them.
The screening charge in a non-empty background
Beyond the near zone the exterior field is Yukawa suppressed, and the coefficient of the suppression depends on the matching convention. To extend the near-zone characterization to finite background mass, we must therefore analyse how the screening can be defined in a background where the symmetron becomes massive. This should also apply to cases where the density is not that of a sphere but slowly decreases away from the objects.
In a non-empty background, the field acquires both a mass and a value far away from the object . In a near-zone interval outside a localized source, with , the field profile simplifies to
with the corresponding point-source description
so that the field seems to emanate from a point with a source determined by . For a true point particle in this background,
and the near-zone screening charge is .
Beyond the near zone the exterior is no longer harmonic, and the monopole coefficient depends on how the Yukawa factor is referenced (Appendix A). We therefore replace it by the flux through a sphere of radius ,
where the second equality integrates the spherical equation of motion
from the radius at which .
from the radius at which . In the massless near zone , so is independent of , while at finite background mass the radius dependence is explicit. The screening charge is then generalized to
which reduces to wherever the flux is approximately constant. The normalization uses the fixed total source mass , not the mass enclosed within .
For a thin-shell solution, is the screening radius below which , the minimum of the interior effective potential. Writing
integration of the field equation gives the condition
For chameleons this is the screening-radius construction with . Neglecting the potential contribution in the thin shell and outside the body, Eq. (44) reduces to Eq. (20), with . For a regular symmetron solution we instead take , since regularity gives , without requiring the central field to equal the interior minimum exactly. In the massless near zone the normalized symmetron charge is independent of . This allows the neutrino energy in the mirror's field to be written as , up to a reference constant. At finite radius the normalized equation depends on the environment only through and the density contrast . No independent field normalization enters.
In the general case, Eq. (44) has the disadvantage that needs to be known. For a massive homogeneous exterior, at infinity, so the field equation also gives
which only depends on the field profile outside the evaluation radius.
For the matched sphere profiles of Appendix A, , hence
Here . In the restored branch, dropping the interior term sets and gives .
a. Radial flux of the trace source. Figure 7 tests this interpretation on full nonlinear trace solutions, holding the source and background density fixed. At and , broad intervals agree with the near-zone charge, extending farther in radius for the lighter case. The interval narrows at 100 keV, and at 10 MeV there is no near-zone plateau, only a pronounced maximum.
Figure 7. Radial dependence of the symmetron flux, Eq. (44), evaluated on full nonlinear trace solutions and normalized to the analytical near-zone charge. All curves use , , and , differing only in . The dashed horizontal line denotes agreement with the near-zone result; circles mark and dotted vertical lines mark . The 10 eV Compton scale lies beyond the plotted range. The 100 keV and 10 MeV curves are displayed only to .
A natural candidate evaluation radius is the density-crossing radius , where and the quadratic term in the effective potential changes sign. For our floored trace tail,
Outside this interval there is no unique tail crossing. At a crossing, , so
on the positive nontrivial branch. The crossing does not exactly terminate scalar sourcing. Its marker lies on the plateaus in the two lightest benchmarks, but not on a broad plateau in the heavier cases.
Beyond , the source’s density tail can still affect the field. Once the density reaches the background floor at and the field is sufficiently close to , the usual Yukawa form applies: . This gives
The resulting decline in flux is a finite-range effect and does not represent additional screening of the source.
b. Near-zone validation. Full nonlinear source solutions support the near-zone approximation for the neutron and proton sizes used in the constraints. We sample broken backgrounds at the laboratory gas densities and in the negligible-density limit, with and . For the chiral trace, agrees with to within 2.0% throughout , where is chosen so the remaining matter contribution is bounded by 1% of the near-zone charge. The largest departure occurs for the proton-sized source at and in the negligible-density background. For the uniform sphere, the nonlinear surface flux, BP prescription and agree within fractionally across the same scan, including both interior branches.
qBOUNCE spectra at the mirror
This appendix examines the qBOUNCE eigenvalue spectra used to obtain the symmetron constraints in Sec. VI C. We present representative energy levels and transition energies in the broad, intermediate, and thin-layer regimes, and test the numerical convergence of the methods used in each regime. Throughout, levels are numbered in order of increasing energy, following the convention used in the constraint analysis.
The stationary Schrödinger equation for a neutron above a single mirror is
The boundary condition treats the mirror as a hard wall, following the published analyses [15, 29]. The glass mirror in fact presents a finite optical potential, into which ultracold neutrons penetrate to a depth . For the gravitational states alone this changes the transition frequencies by only a few parts in [15]. In our slices with , the scalar layer is also much wider than . This separation of scales is lost when the layer width falls below , at for . The hard-wall approximation is therefore not well justified by this scale separation at . We retain it for consistency with the published treatment and return to this caveat at the end of the appendix.
For the one-mirror symmetron kink, the localized surface potential is
where sets the depth scale and is evaluated at the residual-gas density, while is the surface value of . The spatially constant asymptotic contribution to has been subtracted, since it shifts all energy levels equally and therefore cancels from transition energies.
Gravity defines the characteristic length and energy . In the absence of the scalar potential, the four lowest levels are 1.41, 2.46, 3.32, and 4.08 peV. The scalar well is instead characterized by its width and depth scale . Here is the broken-phase symmetron mass at the residual-gas density above the mirror, as in § 0.4, which reduces to in the negligible-density limit.
The relative sizes of and guide the numerical treatment, with the ratio separating two numerical regimes. When the surface layer is resolved on the gravitational-scale mesh, we solve Eq. (52) directly. At the two worked points considered below, and . The gravitational potential energy changes by only across the layer, so the near-surface and gravitational dynamics are well separated. This motivates a two-zone treatment: we solve the surface layer in its own natural units, retain any bound states that it supports, and describe its effect on the outer gravitational spectrum through its scattering length.
Introducing the dimensionless coordinate and eigenvalue , where
the gravitational term in the rescaled Schrödinger equation is . At its coefficient is approximately , and is therefore negligible over the surface layer, where . Dropping this term gives the near-surface (inner) problem
where primes denote derivatives with respect to and
We solve Eq. (55) numerically on the half-line using the full kink potential. Negative eigenvalues correspond to surface-bound states, with physical energies
In the coordinate , the layer has width of order unity and can therefore be resolved without simultaneously discretizing the micrometre-scale gravitational region.
For the gravitational states, , so their response to the surface layer is determined by the zero-energy inner solution . Once the kink potential has decayed, this solution takes the form , which defines the scattering length . At a matching point in the overlap region , the surface potential is negligible while gravity has not yet modified this linear behaviour. We therefore equate the logarithmic derivatives of the inner and outer solutions there. At the two 1 keV worked points, , and the leading effect of this matching is equivalent to displacing the outer hard wall to . The resulting gravitational spectrum is the Airy ladder shifted by the common amount . This shift has magnitude at these points and cancels from gravitational transition energies at this order. The reconstructed two-zone spectrum consists of the surface-bound levels together with this shifted gravitational ladder. This separation requires the surface-bound states to remain localized well within the gravitational length scale. States close to a binding threshold require separate examination.
The spectra presented below are evaluated at exact worked points using the same methods as the constraint grids: direct diagonalization of Eq. (52) for and the two-zone reduction for . The direct calculation uses a graded mesh of 700 nodes extending to , with cell widths increasing from at the mirror to at the top of the domain. The grid is finest near the mirror to resolve the narrow scalar well, and becomes coarser farther away to cover the gravitational states. Besides requiring at least four interior mesh nodes within one interaction range, we check that the local mesh spacing resolves the wavefunction’s oscillations by monitoring , where is the local wave number and is the local mesh spacing.
The mesh must resolve not only the width of the well but also the neutron’s oscillations within it. A useful measure is the zero-energy de Broglie wavelength at the bottom of the well,
At the excluded worked points with and , is for , for , and for . The surface layer contains 653, 139, and 61 interior mesh nodes for , , and , respectively. At the 1 keV worked points, however, is smaller than the first cell, so no interior mesh nodes lie within one interaction range of the mirror.
To test the two-zone approximation, we also solve the full Schrödinger equation with both the surface potential and gravity on a single uniform grid, and compare the surface-bound energies. For the model , , the three deeply bound levels agree to within a relative difference of at , 10, and 100 eV. At 1 keV, a uniform mesh of nodes over gives agreement within . Increasing the node count from to changes the shallowest of these three levels by . These comparisons test the surface-bound energies. The gravitational ladder is obtained through the outer matching described above.
For the displayed slices with , we also compare the 700-node production spectra with refined uniform-grid solutions of the full equation. At the worked points, the five lowest levels agree within 0.4%, except for the shallow fourth state at the excluded 1 eV point, which differs by 5.4%. The allowed comparison points use the same as the corresponding excluded rows of Table II, but with , , and at meV, 0.1 eV, and 1 eV, respectively. At the allowed worked points, the production values of differ from the reference solutions by less than peV, well below the experimental half-width of peV. Doubling the resolution of the uniform reference grids changes at these allowed points by less than peV. At the tested points, these numerical differences are too small to change whether the predicted transitions lie inside or outside the experimental windows.
| [GeV] | method | five lowest levels [peV] | , [peV] | |||||
| 1 meV | 95.4 peV | 1.00 | — | full | −93.9, −92.6, −91.5, −90.5, −89.5 | 2.35, 3.36 | ||
| 0.1 eV | 1 | 143 peV | 1.00 | 14.9 | full | −93.1, −42.8, −11.6, 0.915, 2.52 | 81.5, 94.0 | |
| 1 eV | 1 | 15.9 neV | 1.00 | 14.9 | full | −10344, −4777, −1336, −15.7, 1.59 | , | |
| 1 keV | 1 | 15.9 meV | 0.646 | 14.9 | reduced | , 1.41, 2.46 | ||
| 1 keV | 0.159 meV | 0.996 | 0.15 | reduced | 1.41, 2.46, 3.32, 4.08, 4.78 | 1.915, 2.676 |
Table II. Five lowest levels and transition energies at the exact quoted parameter points. The first four rows lie inside our sphere exclusion regions in Figure 6; the final row lies inside the published exclusion region but outside ours. “Full” denotes diagonalization on the production mesh; “reduced” denotes a reconstructed two-zone spectrum. Energies use the convention and are listed in increasing order. The transitions are and , with measured windows (1.9114, 1.9330) and (2.6726, 2.7022) peV, respectively.
Figure 8 illustrates the spectral distinction at keV. At GeV, , three surface-bound states at meV energies lie below a nearly unchanged gravitational ladder [panels (a,b)]. Under the adopted numbering, these become the lowest three levels, giving meV, far outside the measured peV-scale window. At GeV, , the layer instead supports no bound states [panel (d)]. Its scattering length, nm, produces only a common shift of the gravitational levels at leading order, leaving their transition energies unchanged. The contrasting results therefore arise from the appearance of surface-bound states and the resulting change in level numbering, while the gravitational ladder itself is almost unchanged.
Figure 8. qBOUNCE symmetron spectra at the mirror, for the neutron sphere charge. (a) The resolved layer at the excluded point GeV, , keV (depth scale meV, surface depth meV), with three bound states within ångströms of the surface. Wavefunctions in panels (a,b,d) have arbitrary vertical scaling. In panels (a,b), each is offset by its eigenenergy. (b) The gravitational zone of the same point, the Airy quartet is unchanged at the peV scale, and the three layer states far below it take the lowest indices in the sorted ladder. (c) Reduced-layer energies versus for the model of panel (a). Labels above the panel give representative layer widths. Crosses are full layer-plus-gravity solves at each decade (at keV at relaxed spacing), tracking the reduced branches across roughly eight orders of magnitude in energy. The near-threshold fourth branch (grey) appears as a negative level of the full problem only where its binding exceeds the gravitational tilt (see text). (d) At the disputed-strip point GeV, , the layer binds nothing, and the zero-energy solution approaches with scattering length nm (dashed).
Figure 8(c) varies at fixed and . The dimensionless strength
depends on only through , which varies little along this scan. If were also fixed, the dimensionless eigenvalues would therefore remain nearly constant. The physical energies would then scale as , since away from symmetry restoration. This explains the main trend of the three deeply bound levels. Changes in produce departures from this scaling and remove the shallow fourth inner bound state by 1 keV. For this fourth state, weak binding also makes the neglect of gravity less reliable.
Binding requires the attractive well to overcome the kinetic-energy cost of localizing a neutron next to the hard wall. The parameter compares the well depth with this kinetic-energy scale. When the field vanishes at the mirror (), the first four binding thresholds are . A nonzero surface field changes these thresholds. At the excluded 1 keV worked point, and only three states remain bound, whereas the weaker well at the allowed point supports none.
For the 1 keV constraint grid, binding of the isolated layer is a useful diagnostic but is not the exclusion criterion. Near the first threshold we retain energy and gravity in the inner equation and match to the decaying outer Airy solution, and each cell is decided by spectral bounds on the transition energies under the adopted level
numbering. A nonbinding layer can still be excluded. At and the scattering length is m and the gaps are 2.17669 and 2.97738 peV, both outside the measured windows. The strip so added is narrower than the grid spacing, so no displayed exclusion bound changes.
Table II collects the worked-point spectra across the three regimes. At meV, the broad well mainly lowers the gravitational ladder, while its spatial variation changes the transition energies, so negative energies alone do not imply surface localization. At 0.1 and 1 eV, increasingly localized surface states coexist with a modified gravitational ladder.
This appendix presents the methods used to calculate the ordered qBOUNCE spectra within the hard-wall approximation and tests their numerical convergence at representative worked points. Finite mirror penetration is not included. Nor do these calculations determine whether the surface-bound states actually participate in the measured transitions. That requires a separate analysis of state preparation, transition strengths, and detection, which we leave to future study.
References
References
- [1]A. Joyce, B. Jain, J. Khoury, and M. Trodden, Beyond the Cosmological Standard Model, Phys. Rept. 568, 1 (2015), arXiv:1407.0059 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
- [2]K. Koyama, Cosmological Tests of Modified Gravity, Rept. Prog. Phys. 79, 046902 (2016), arXiv:1504.04623 [astro-ph.CO].
- [3]T. Clifton, P. G. Ferreira, A. Padilla, and C. Skordis, Modified Gravity and Cosmology, Phys. Rept. 513, 1 (2012), arXiv:1106.2476 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
- [4]A. Arza et al., The COSMIC WISPers White Paper: The physics case for Weakly Interacting Slim Particles, (2026), arXiv:2603.03433 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2603.03433
- [5]J. Khoury and A. Weltman, Chameleon Fields: Awaiting surprises for tests of gravity in space, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 171104 (2004), arXiv:astro-ph/0309300.DOI
- [6]J. Khoury and A. Weltman, Chameleon cosmology, Phys. Rev. D 69, 044026 (2004), arXiv:astro-ph/0309411.DOI
- [7]P. Brax, C. van de Bruck, A.-C. Davis, J. Khoury, and A. Weltman, Detecting dark energy in orbit: The cosmological chameleon, Phys. Rev. D 70, 123518 (2004), arXiv:astro-ph/0408415.DOI
- [8]K. Hinterbichler and J. Khoury, Symmetron Fields: Screening Long-Range Forces Through Local Symmetry Restoration, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 231301 (2010), arXiv:1001.4525 [hep-th].DOI
- [9]K. Hinterbichler, J. Khoury, A. Levy, and A. Matas, Symmetron Cosmology, Phys. Rev. D 84, 103521 (2011), arXiv:1107.2112 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
- [10]H. Dehnen, H. Frommert, and F. Ghaboussi, Higgs field and a new scalar - tensor theory of gravity, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 31, 109 (1992).DOI
- [11]E. Gessner, A new scalar tensor theory for gravity and the flat rotation curves of spiral galaxies, Astrophys. Space Sci. 196, 29 (1992).DOI
- [12]C. Burrage and J. Sakstein, Tests of Chameleon Gravity, Living Rev. Rel. 21, 1 (2018), arXiv:1709.09071 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
- [13]P. Brax, S. Casas, H. Desmond, and B. Elder, Testing Screened Modified Gravity, Universe 8, 11 (2021), arXiv:2201.10817 [gr-qc].DOI
- [14]D. F. Mota and D. J. Shaw, Evading Equivalence Principle Violations, Cosmological and other Experimental Constraints in Scalar Field Theories with a Strong Coupling to Matter, Phys. Rev. D 75, 063501 (2007), arXiv:hep-ph/0608078.DOI
- [15]G. Gronenberg, P. Brax, H. Filter, P. Geltenbort, T. Jenke, G. Pignol, M. Pitschmann, M. Thalhammer, and H. Abele, Acoustic Rabi oscillations between gravitational quantum states and impact on symmetron dark energy, Nature Phys. 14, 1022 (2018), arXiv:1902.08775 [hep-ph].
- [16]H. Fischer, C. Käding, and M. Pitschmann, Screened Scalar Fields in the Laboratory and the Solar System, Universe 10, 297 (2024), arXiv:2505.14638 [gr-qc].
- [17]H. Fischer, C. Käding, H. Lemmel, S. Sponar, and M. Pitschmann, Search for Dark Energy with Neutron Interferometry, PTEP 2024, 023E02 (2024), arXiv:2310.18109 [hep-ph].DOI
- [18]P. Brax, A.-C. Davis, and B. Elder, Screened scalar fields in hydrogen and muonium, Phys. Rev. D 107, 044008 (2023), arXiv:2207.11633 [hep-ph].DOI
- [19]T. H. R. Skyrme, A Nonlinear field theory, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 260, 127 (1961).
- [20]G. S. Adkins, C. R. Nappi, and E. Witten, Static Properties of Nucleons in the Skyrme Model, Nucl. Phys. B 228, 552 (1983).
- [21]C. Cebulla, K. Goeke, J. Ossmann, and P. Schweitzer, The Nucleon form-factors of the energy momentum tensor in the Skyrme model, Nucl. Phys. A 794, 87 (2007), arXiv:hep-ph/0703025.
- [22]A. Cherman, T. D. Cohen, and M. Nielsen, Model Independent Tests of Skyrmions and Their Holographic Cousins, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 022001 (2009), arXiv:0903.2662 [hep-ph].DOI
- [23]N. S. Manton and S. W. Wood, Light Nuclei as Quantized Skyrmions: Energy Spectra and Form Factors, in 15th International Seminar on High Energy Physics (2008) arXiv:0809.3501 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/0809.3501
- [24]M. Karliner, C. King, and N. S. Manton, Electron Scattering Intensities and Patterson Functions of Skyrmions, J. Phys. G 43, 055104 (2016), arXiv:1510.00280 [nucl-th].DOI
- [25]N. S. Manton, Robustness of the hedgehog Skyrmion, JHEP 08, 015, arXiv:2405.05731 [hep-th].
- [26]D. Lee, Lattice Effective Field Theory Simulations of Nuclei, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 75, 109 (2025), arXiv:2501.03303 [nucl-th].DOI
- [27]F. Canfora and H. Maeda, Hedgehog ansatz and its generalization for self-gravitating Skyrmions, Phys. Rev. D 87, 084049 (2013), arXiv:1302.3232 [gr-qc].DOI
- [28]T. Jenke, J. Bosina, J. Micko, M. Pitschmann, R. Sedmik, and H. Abele, Gravity resonance spectroscopy and dark energy symmetron fields: qBOUNCE experiments performed with Rabi and Ramsey spectroscopy, Eur. Phys. J. ST 230, 1131 (2021), arXiv:2012.07472 [hep-ph].DOI
- [29]P. Brax and M. Pitschmann, Exact solutions to nonlinear symmetron theory: One- and two-mirror systems, Phys. Rev. D 97, 064015 (2018), arXiv:1712.09852 [gr-qc].DOI
- [30]M. Pitschmann, Exact solutions to nonlinear symmetron theory: One- and two-mirror systems. II., Phys. Rev. D 103, 084013 (2021), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 106, 109902 (2022)], arXiv:2012.12752 [gr-qc].DOI
- [31]P. Brax, C. Burrage, A.-C. Davis, D. Seery, and A. Weltman, Collider constraints on interactions of dark energy with the Standard Model, JHEP 09, 128, arXiv:0904.3002 [hep-ph].DOI
- [32]P. Hamilton, M. Jaffe, P. Haslinger, Q. Simmons, H. Müller, and J. Khoury, Atom-interferometry constraints on dark energy, Science 349, 849 (2015), arXiv:1502.03888 [physics.atom-ph].DOI
- [33]M. Jaffe, P. Haslinger, V. Xu, P. Hamilton, A. Upadhye, B. Elder, J. Khoury, and H. Müller, Testing sub-gravitational forces on atoms from a miniature invacuum source mass, Nature Phys. 13, 938 (2017), arXiv:1612.05171 [physics.atom-ph].DOI
- [34]H. Rauch and S. A. Werner, Neutron Interferometry: Lessons in Experimental Quantum Mechanics, Wave-Particle Duality, and Entanglement, 2nd ed. (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2015).DOI
- [35]H. Lemmel, P. Brax, A. N. Ivanov, T. Jenke, G. Pignol, M. Pitschmann, T. Potocar, M. Wellenzohn, M. Zawisky, and H. Abele, Neutron Interferometry constraints dark energy chameleon fields, Phys. Lett. B 743, 310 (2015), arXiv:1502.06023 [hep-ph].
- [36]C. G. Parthey et al., Improved Measurement of the Hydrogen 1S - 2S Transition Frequency, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 203001 (2011), arXiv:1107.3101 [physics.atom-ph].DOI
- [37]V. Meyer et al., Measurement of the 1s - 2s energy interval in muonium, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 1136 (2000), arXiv:hep-ex/9907013.DOI







