betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

A new tautological relation on M‾2,14\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{2,14} in cohomology

Abstract

We construct a relation Q\mathsf{Q} in the cohomological tautological ring RH∗(M‾2,14)\mathsf{RH}^*(\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{2,14}) which lies outside the space of 33-spin relations. Q\mathsf{Q} is a simple linear combination of pure boundary strata classes of codimension 9 supported on the divisor Δ0⊂M‾2,14Δ_0 \subset \overline{\mathcal{M}}_{2,14} of irreducible nodal curves, and transforms according to the irreducible representation of Σ14Σ_{14} associated to the partition (27)(2^7). The result shows that the set of 33-spin relations cannot be complete in cohomology. Motivic conjectures relating algebraic cycles to special values of LL-functions suggest that Q\mathsf{Q} is nonzero in Chow. More precisely, we prove that the Chow nonvanishing of Q\mathsf{Q} follows from a conjecture of Harder concerning the failure of the Manin–Drinfeld principle in genus 2. We prove that Q\mathsf{Q} vanishes in cohomology by pairing with generators of the tautological ring. To prove Q\mathsf{Q} is not in the set of 33-spin relations requires an argument involving the Σ14Σ_{14}-representation-theoretic properties of the 33-spin relations and the cohomology of local systems on A2\mathcal{A}_2 and M2\mathcal{M}_2. Parallel constructions for other moduli spaces M‾g,n\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{g,n} are discussed in the paper. There are many open questions.

Introduction

Tautological relations

Let RH∗(M‾g,n)⊂H2∗(M‾g,n)\mathrm{RH}^{*}(\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{g,n}) \subset\mathrm{H}^{2*}(\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{g,n}) be the tautological ring in the cohomology1 of the moduli spaces of stable curves of genus gg with nn markings. The ideal of cohomological relations, by definition, is the kernel of the canonical Q\mathbb{Q}-algebra homomorphism from the strata algebra to the tautological ring:

CohRelg,n∗=Ker⁡(Sg,n∗→RH∗(M‾g,n)).\mathrm{CohRel}^{*}_{g,n} = \operatorname{Ker}\left(\mathcal{S}^{*}_{g,n} \to\mathrm{RH}^{*}(\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{g,n})\right).

Similarly, the ideal of relations in Chow is defined by:

ChowRelg,n∗=Ker⁡(Sg,n∗→R∗(M‾g,n)),\mathrm{ChowRel}^{*}_{g,n}=\operatorname{Ker}\left(\mathcal{S}^{*}_{g,n}\to R^{*}(\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{g,n})\right),

where R∗(M‾g,n)⊂CH∗(M‾g,n)R^{*}(\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{g,n})\subset\mathrm{CH}^{*}(\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{g,n}) is the tautological ring in Chow. Using the cycle class map,

ChowRelg,n∗⊂CohRelg,n∗.\mathrm{ChowRel}^{*}_{g,n}\subset\mathrm{CohRel}^{*}_{g,n}.

The investigation of the ideal of tautological relations goes back to Mumford [37]. We refer the reader to [18, 41] for an introduction to the study of tautological classes. In addition to governing the tautological ring, the relations also constrain Gromov-Witten theory and play a role in several other directions in mathematics.

An explicit ideal, 3Sping,n∗⊂Sg,n∗{}^{3}\mathrm{Spin}^{*}_{g,n}\subset\mathcal{S}^{*}_{g,n}, was proposed by Pixton in [52] and was proven to yield relations in both cohomology and Chow [31, 42]:

3Sping,n∗⊂ChowRelg,n∗⊂CohRelg,n∗.{}^{3}\mathrm{Spin}^{*}_{g,n}\subset\mathrm{ChowRel}^{*}_{g,n}\subset\mathrm{CohRel}^{*}_{g,n}.

Pixton conjectured2

3Sping,n∗=ChowRelg,n∗(1){}^{3}\mathrm{Spin}^{*}_{g,n}=\mathrm{ChowRel}^{*}_{g,n} \tag*{(1)}

for all gg and nn. A folklore conjecture which has generally been believed is the equality

ChowRelg,n∗=CohRelg,n∗(2)\mathrm{ChowRel}^{*}_{g,n}=\mathrm{CohRel}^{*}_{g,n} \tag*{(2)}

for all gg and nn.

The new relation Q

The main result here is a new tautological relation Q∈CohRel2,149Q\in\mathrm{CohRel}^{9}_{2,14}. The formula for QQ is a linear combination of pure boundary strata classes. The construction requires a family of stable graphs for M‾2,14\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{2,14} with 8 vertices (all of genus 0) and 9 edges.

To start, we color the markings {1,…,7}\{1,\ldots,7\} red and the markings {8,…,14}\{8,\ldots,14\} blue. We fix the pairing of the red and blue markings given by

(1,8), (2,9),…, (7,14).(3)(1,8),\ (2,9),\ldots,\ (7,14). \tag*{(3)}

For positive integers a,b,ca,b,c with sum 9, let Θabc\Theta_{abc} be the subdivided theta graph consisting of two vertices v,wv,w connected by three parallel paths of lengths a,b,ca,b,c, with one red leg and one blue leg (both unlabeled) on every vertex other than vv. For example, Θ135\Theta_{135} is:

Figure 5.

We define the class [Θabc]∈S2,149[\Theta_{abc}] \in S^{9}_{2,14} by the following procedure.

  1. Place marking numbers of the corresponding colors on the red and blue legs in a way which respects the pairing (3). The result is a stable graph Γ\Gamma for M2,14\mathcal{M}_{2,14}. Let [Γ]∈S2,149[\Gamma] \in S^{9}_{2,14} be the associated class in the strata algebra.

  1. Anti-symmetrize with respect to the Σ7\Sigma_{7}-action on the red markings and the Σ7\Sigma_{7}-action on the blue markings:

[Θabc]=17!⋅7!∑(σ,τ)∈Σ7×Σ7⊂Σ14sgn⁡(σ)⋅sgn⁡(τ)⋅(σ,τ)[Γ].(4)[\Theta_{abc}] = \frac{1}{7! \cdot7!} \sum_{(\sigma,\tau)\in\Sigma_{7}\times\Sigma_{7}\subset\Sigma_{14}} \operatorname{sgn}(\sigma)\cdot\operatorname{sgn}(\tau)\cdot(\sigma,\tau)[\Gamma]. \tag*{(4)}

The final result (4) is independent of the initial placing (i).

Definition 1.1. Let Q∈S2,149Q \in S^{9}_{2,14} be given by

Q=[Θ135]−[Θ144]−[Θ225]+2[Θ234]−[Θ333].Q=[\Theta_{135}]-[\Theta_{144}]-[\Theta_{225}]+2[\Theta_{234}]-[\Theta_{333}].

Theorem 1.2. We have Q∈CohRel⁡2,149Q \in\operatorname{CohRel}^{9}_{2,14}.

Theorem 1.3. We have Q∉3Spin⁡2,149Q \notin{}^{3}\operatorname{Spin}^{9}_{2,14}.

As a consequence of Theorem 1.2 and Theorem 1.3, at least one of the two conjectured equalities (1) and (2) must not hold.3 The Q\mathbb{Q}-vector spaces

3Spin⁡2,149⊂ChowRel⁡2,149⊂CohRel⁡2,149⊂S2,149{}^{3}\operatorname{Spin}^{9}_{2,14}\subset\operatorname{ChowRel}^{9}_{2,14}\subset\operatorname{CohRel}^{9}_{2,14}\subset S^{9}_{2,14}

are naturally representations of Σ14\Sigma_{14}. Since QQ is defined by the Σ7×Σ7\Sigma_{7}\times\Sigma_{7} anti-symmetrization of an (Σ2)7(\Sigma_{2})^{7}-invariant4 class, QQ generates a copy of the irreducible Σ14\Sigma_{14}-representation of type (27)(2^{7}) in S2,149S^{9}_{2,14}. Theorems 1.2 and 1.3 therefore imply:

Corollary 1.4. The class QQ generates an irreducible Σ14\Sigma_{14}-subrepresentation

Q⊂CohRel⁡2,149/3Spin⁡2,149Q \subset\operatorname{CohRel}^{9}_{2,14}/{}^{3}\operatorname{Spin}^{9}_{2,14}

of type (27)(2^{7}).

Concerning the Chow tautological relations, there are two distinct possibilities:

(i) Q⊂ChowRel⁡2,149/3Spin⁡2,149Q \subset\operatorname{ChowRel}^{9}_{2,14}/{}^{3}\operatorname{Spin}^{9}_{2,14},

(ii) Q⊂CohRel⁡2,149/ChowRel⁡2,149Q \subset\operatorname{CohRel}^{9}_{2,14}/\operatorname{ChowRel}^{9}_{2,14},

which imply the failure of the conjectural equalities (1) and (2), respectively, in the (27)(2^{7})-isotypical component. To settle the dichotomy, the following question must be answered.

Question 1.5. Is Q∈ChowRel⁡2,149Q \in\operatorname{ChowRel}^{9}_{2,14}?

We expect the answer to Question 1.5 to be no, and, therefore, we expect possibility (ii) holds.

Since QQ is a linear combination of strata classes with vertices all of genus 0, QQ yields a universal genus 0 relation in Gromov-Witten theory by the splitting axiom. Whether new results in Gromov-Witten theory can be deduced from QQ is an interesting direction which we do not pursue here.

In Section 2.1, the formula for QQ is generalized: for each homogeneous symmetric polynomial PP of degree mm in three variables, there is an associated class

QP∈S2,14+2m9+m,Q_{P} \in S^{9+m}_{2,14+2m},

with Q1=6QQ_{1}=6Q. Which of the above properties of QQ hold for the other classes QPQ_{P}? Some results can be found in Sections 2 and 3.

Harder’s conjecture and the Chow class of Q

The question whether QQ vanishes in Chow has an arithmetic interpretation. The motive S[18]S[18] associated to the unique cusp form of weight 18 for SL⁡2(Z)\operatorname{SL}_{2}(\mathbb{Z}) occurs in H17(M2,14)H^{17}(\mathcal{M}_{2,14}), transforming as the Σ14\Sigma_{14}-representation (27)(2^{7}). Its LL-function has a simple zero at the central point. Beilinson’s conjectures therefore predict the existence of a nonzero homologically trivial 8-cycle on M2,14\mathcal{M}_{2,14}, defined over Q\mathbb{Q}, transforming according to the representation (27)(2^{7}). Our cycle QQ provides an explicit candidate for this cycle.

There is a more precise connection with a conjecture of Harder. Let A2A_{2} be the moduli space of principally polarized abelian surfaces. In the cohomology of the local system V7,7V_{7,7} on A2A_{2} one finds an extension

0⟶S[18]⟶W18H3(A2,V7,7)⟶Q(−9)⟶0.(5)0 \longrightarrow S[18] \longrightarrow W_{18}H^{3}(A_{2},V_{7,7}) \longrightarrow\mathbb{Q}(-9) \longrightarrow0. \tag*{(5)}

Beilinson’s conjectures predict likewise that Ext⁡1(Q(−9),S[18])\operatorname{Ext}^{1}(\mathbb{Q}(-9),S[18]), the extension group in “mixed motives over Q\mathbb{Q}”, is 1-dimensional. A 1993 conjecture of Harder predicts that the extension5 (5) is nontrivial and hence generates the motivic extension group. It turns out that this conjecture can be expressed in terms of the cycle Q.

Theorem 1.6. The Abel–Jacobi class of the homologically trivial cycle Q coincides with the extension class (5). In particular, Harder’s conjecture implies that Q is nonzero in Chow.

Theorem 1.6 gives a promising avenue towards proving the nonvanishing of Q, even without assuming a conjectural category of mixed motives over Q\mathbb{Q}. If the extension (5) is nontrivial in mixed Hodge structures or ℓ\ell-adic Galois representations then this already implies nonvanishing of Q.

In Section 6, we explain Beilinson’s conjectures and their predictions for M‾g,n\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{g,n} in case g=1g = 1 and g=2g = 2. We then prove Theorem 1.6 and explain why there are good reasons to believe in Harder’s conjecture.6

Path of the proof of Theorem 1.2

The proof of Theorem 1.2 relies upon the equality

RH⁡∗(M‾2,14)=H2∗(M‾2,14)\operatorname{RH}^{*}(\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{2,14}) = H^{2*}(\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{2,14})

established by Petersen and Tommasi [47, 51]. Since H2∗(M‾2,14)H^{2*}(\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{2,14}) satisfies Poincaré duality, Q ∈CohRel⁡2,149\in\operatorname{CohRel}^{9}_{2,14} if and only if

References

  1. [1]Alexander Beilinson. Height pairing between algebraic cycles. In K-theory, arithmetic and geometry (Moscow, 1984–1986), volume 1289 of Lecture Notes in Math., pages 1–25. Springer, Berlin, 1987.
  2. [2]Alexander Beilinson, Joseph Bernstein, and Pierre Deligne. Faisceaux pervers. In Analysis and topology on singular spaces, I (Luminy, 1981), volume 100 of Astérisque, pages 5–171. Soc. Math. France, Paris, 1982.
  3. [3]Pavel Belorousski. Chow rings of moduli spaces of pointed elliptic curves. PhD thesis, University of Chicago, 1998.
  4. [4]Jonas Bergström. Cohomology of moduli spaces of curves. GitHub repository. https://github.com/jonasbergstroem/Cohomology-of-moduli-spaces-of-curves.
  5. [5]Spencer Bloch and Kazuya Kato. L-functions and Tamagawa numbers of motives. In The Grothendieck Festschrift. Vol. I, volume 86 of Progr. Math., pages 333–400. Birkhäuser Boston, Boston, MA, 1990.
  6. [6]Samir Canning and Hannah Larson. On the Chow and cohomology rings of moduli spaces of stable curves. J. Eur. Math. Soc. (JEMS), 28(9):3869–3918, 2026.
  7. [7]Samir Canning, Hannah Larson, and Sam Payne. Extensions of tautological rings and motivic structures in the cohomology of 𝓜_{g,n}. Forum Math. Pi, 12:Paper No. e23, 31, 2024.DOI
  8. [8]Samir Canning, Hannah Larson, Sam Payne, and Thomas Willwacher. FA-modules of holomorphic forms on 𝓜_{g,n}. arXiv preprint arXiv:2509.08774, 2025.
  9. [9]Samir Canning, Hannah Larson, and Johannes Schmitt. The Gorenstein property and Pixton’s conjecture for compact type moduli. arXiv preprint arXiv:2607.02249, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2607.02249
  10. [10]Caterina Consani and Carel Faber. On the cusp form motives in genus 1 and level 1. In Moduli spaces and arithmetic geometry, volume 45 of Adv. Stud. Pure Math., pages 297–314. Math. Soc. Japan, Tokyo, 2006.
  11. [11]Pierre Deligne. Formes modulaires et représentations ℓ-adiques. Sém. Bourbaki, 355:139–172, 1969.
  12. [12]Pierre Deligne. Théorie de Hodge. II. Inst. Hautes Études Sci. Publ. Math., (40):5–57, 1971.DOI
  13. [13]Pierre Deligne. Théorie de Hodge. III. Inst. Hautes Études Sci. Publ. Math., (44):5–77, 1974.DOI
  14. [14]Pierre Deligne. Valeurs de fonctions L et périodes d’intégrales. In Automorphic forms, representations and L-functions (Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., Oregon State Univ., Corvallis, Ore., 1977), Part 2, Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., XXXIII, pages 313–346. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1979. With an appendix by N. Koblitz and A. Ogus.
  15. [15]Vladimir Drinfeld. Two theorems on modular curves. Funkcional. Anal. i Priložen., 7(2):83–84, 1973.DOI
  16. [16]Renée Elkik. Le théorème de Manin-Drinfel’d. Astérisque, (183):59–67, 1990. Séminaire sur les Pinceaux de Courbes Elliptiques (Paris, 1988).
  17. [17]Carel Faber and Rahul Pandharipande. Relative maps and tautological classes. J. Eur. Math. Soc. (JEMS), 7(1):13–49, 2005.
  18. [18]Carel Faber and Rahul Pandharipande. Tautological and non-tautological cohomology of the moduli space of curves. In Handbook of moduli. Vol. I, volume 24 of Adv. Lect. Math. (ALM), pages 293–330. Int. Press, Somerville, MA, 2013.
  19. [19]William Fulton and Robert MacPherson. A compactification of configuration spaces. Ann. of Math. (2), 139(1):183–225, 1994.DOI
  20. [20]Ezra Getzler. The semi-classical approximation for modular operads. Comm. Math. Phys., 194(2):481–492, 1998.arxiv.org/abs/alg-geom/9612005
  21. [21]Ezra Getzler. Resolving mixed Hodge modules on configuration spaces. Duke Math. J., 96(1):175–203, 1999.arxiv.org/abs/alg-geom/9611003
  22. [22]Alexandru Ghitza and Angus McAndrew. Experimental evidence for Maeda’s conjecture on modular forms. Tbil. Math. J., 5(2):55–69, 2012.arxiv.org/abs/1207.3480
  23. [23]Alexey Gorinov. Rational cohomology of the moduli spaces of pointed genus 1 curves. Preprint available at arXiv:1303.5693, 2013.arxiv.org/abs/1303.5693
  24. [24]Tom Graber and Rahul Pandharipande. Constructions of nontautological classes on moduli spaces of curves. Michigan Math. J., 51(1):93–109, 2003.DOI
  25. [25]Tom Graber and Ravi Vakil. Relative virtual localization and vanishing of tautological classes on moduli spaces of curves. Duke Math. J., 130(1):1–37, 2005.DOI
  26. [26]Miao Pam Gu, Yu-Sheng Lee, and Kartik Prasanna. Periods of the Saito–Kurokawa lift. Manuscript in preparation.
  27. [27]Günter Harder. Eisensteinkohomologie und die Konstruktion gemischter Motive, volume 1562 of Lecture Notes in Mathematics. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1993.DOI
  28. [28]Günter Harder. The Eisenstein motive for the cohomology of GSp₂(ℤ). In Carel Faber, Gavril Farkas, and Robin de Jong, editors, Geometry and arithmetic, EMS Ser. Congr. Rep., pages 143–164. Eur. Math. Soc., Zürich, 2012.
  29. [29]Günter Harder. Can we compute denominators of Eisenstein classes? Advanced Studies: Euro-Tbilisi Mathematical Journal, Special Issue 9:131–165, 2021.
  30. [30]Brendan Hassett. Moduli spaces of weighted pointed stable curves. Adv. Math., 173(2):316–352, 2003.DOI
  31. [31]Felix Janda. Relations on M̄g,n via equivariant Gromov-Witten theory of P¹. Algebra. Geom., 4(3):311–336, 2017.
  32. [32]Uwe Jannsen. Motivic sheaves and filtrations on Chow groups. In Motives (Seattle, WA, 1991), volume 55 of Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., pages 245–302. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1994.DOI
  33. [33]Xiaobo Liu and Rahul Pandharipande. New topological recursion relations. J. Algebraic Geom., 20(3):479–494, 2011.arxiv.org/abs/0805.4829
  34. [34]The LMFDB Collaboration. The L-functions and modular forms database. https://www.lmfdb.org, 2026. [Online; accessed 20 October 2026].
  35. [35]Yuri Manin. Parabolic points and zeta functions of modular curves. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Ser. Mat., 36:19–66, 1972.
  36. [36]David Mumford. Rational equivalence of 0-cycles on surfaces. J. Math. Kyoto Univ., 9:195–204, 1968.
  37. [37]David Mumford. Towards an enumerative geometry of the moduli space of curves. In Arithmetic and geometry, Vol. II, volume 36 of Progr. Math., pages 271–328. Birkhäuser Boston, Boston, MA, 1983.
  38. [38]Jan Nekovář. Bĕilinson’s conjectures. In Motives (Seattle, WA, 1991), volume 55 of Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., pages 537–570. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1994.DOI
  39. [39]OpenAI. A high-arity counterexample to Pixton completeness in Chow. OpenAI Math Release preprint OAI:A-high-arity-counterexample-to-Pixton-completeness-in-Chow-September-24-2026, 2026.
  40. [40]OpenAI. Prompt used for A Proof of the Cycle Double Cover Conjecture. https://cdn.openai.com/pdf/04d1d1e4-bc75-476a-97cf-49055cd98d31/cdc_prompt.pdf, 2026.
  41. [41]Rahul Pandharipande. A calculus for the moduli space of curves. In Algebraic geometry: Salt Lake City 2015, volume 97.1 of Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., pages 459–487. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2018.arxiv.org/abs/1603.05151
  42. [42]Rahul Pandharipande, Aaron Pixton, and Dimitri Zvonkine. Relations on 𝓜̄g,n via 3-spin structures. J. Amer. Math. Soc., 28(1):279–309, 2015.
  43. [43]Dan Petersen. Cohomology of local systems on loci of d-elliptic abelian surfaces. Michigan Math. J., 62(4):705–720, 2013.
  44. [44]Dan Petersen. Cohomology of moduli of stable pointed curves of low genus. IV. https://people.math.ethz.ch/~rahul/DP-notes4.pdf, 2013.
  45. [45]Dan Petersen. The structure of the tautological ring in genus one. Duke Math. J., 163(4):777–793, 2014.
  46. [46]Dan Petersen. Cohomology of local systems on the moduli of principally polarized abelian surfaces. Pacific J. Math., 275(1):39–61, 2015.
  47. [47]Dan Petersen. Tautological rings of spaces of pointed genus two curves of compact type. Compos. Math., 152(7):1398–1420, 2016.
  48. [48]Dan Petersen. The Chow ring of a Fulton-MacPherson compactification. Michigan Math. J., 66(1):195–202, 2017.
  49. [49]Dan Petersen. A spectral sequence for stratified spaces and configuration spaces of points. Geom. Topol., 21(4):2527–2555, 2017.
  50. [50]Dan Petersen, Mehdi Tavakol, and Qizheng Yin. Tautological classes with twisted coefficients. Ann. Sci. Éc. Norm. Supér. (4), 54(5):1179–1236, 2021.
  51. [51]Dan Petersen and Orsola Tommasi. The Gorenstein conjecture fails for the tautological ring of \overline{M}_{2,n}. Invent. Math., 196(1):139–161, 2014.
  52. [52]Aaron Pixton. Conjectural relations in the tautological ring of \overline{M}_{g,n}. arXiv:1207.1918, July 2012.arxiv.org/abs/1207.1918
  53. [53]Aaron Pixton. The tautological ring of the moduli space of curves. PhD thesis, Princeton University, 2013.
  54. [54]Aaron Pixton. The tautological ring of M_{25} is not Gorenstein, 2026.
  55. [55]A. A. Roitman. Rational equivalence of zero-dimensional cycles. Mat. Zametki, 28(1):85–90, 169, 1980.
  56. [56]Anthony J. Scholl. Motives for modular forms. Invent. Math., 100(2):419–430, 1990.DOI
  57. [57]Mehdi Tavakol. The tautological ring of the moduli space M^{rt}_{2,n}. Int. Math. Res. Not., 2014(24):6661–6683, 2014.
  58. [58]Burt Totaro. Configuration spaces of algebraic varieties. Topology, 35(4):1057–1067, 1996.DOI
  59. [59]Andrzej Weber. Pure homology of algebraic varieties. Topology, 43(3):635–644, 2004.DOI
  60. [60]Shou-Wu Zhang. Heights of Heegner cycles and derivatives of L-series. Invent. Math., 130(1):99–152, 1997.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_gt5eu94g
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Codex, GPT-6 Astra, Claude Code

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents