WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Synchronization transitions in Kuramoto oscillators with mixed interactions
Abstract
The Kuramoto model is a paradigmatic system for emergent synchronization phenomena, and significant efforts have been made to investigate its transition from incoherent to coherent dynamics. However, previous studies have almost exclusively assumed global coupling between the oscillators, even though many real-world systems are organized in specific network structures. Here, we fill this gap by examining finite-size effects in Kuramoto oscillator ensembles on networks with mixed-order interactions. Using numerical simulations, we show how parameters such as the size of the system, the average degree of the nodes and the strength of the interactions alter the behaviour of the transition to synchronization with respect to the known theoretical results that are derived for globally coupled infinite systems.
Introduction
Synchronization in dynamical systems is an emergent phenomenon in which the trajectories of a population of coupled oscillators reach some level of macroscopic coherence induced by their interactions. Since coherent collective behaviour is commonly necessary for the correct functioning of complex systems, the study of synchronization has received considerable attention in a broad range of topics and disciplines [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]. A paradigmatic framework for its investigation is provided by the Kuramoto model, in which oscillators interact via a pairwise sinusoidal coupling that can induce spontaneous phase locking once its strength exceeds a critical threshold [8]. Owing to its relative simplicity and analytical tractability, the Kuramoto model and its variants have become very popular in the study of a wide range of real-world complex systems [9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17].
Recently, however, there has been a growing scientific interest in studying the phenomenology of systems in which the interactions between elements are of a higher order than just pairwise ones [18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23]. The inclusion of higher-order interactions in models of complex systems has thus raised new questions about their impact on collective behavior, especially when combined with traditional pairwise couplings. Understanding these combined effects is crucial, as both pairwise and higher-order interactions coexist in real-world systems, and their synergy can give rise to highly non-trivial effects [24, 25, 26, 27]. In the specific case of globally coupled Kuramoto oscillators, the presence of higher-order interactions is known to cause a histeresis loop in the synchronization transition, which is therefore a first-order one [28, 29, 30, 31, 32], in contrast with the continuous transition that occurs when only pairwise interactions exist.
Additionally, most investigations on Kuramoto oscillators have focused on large ensembles where analytical results are typically derived in the thermodynamic limit. However, numerous physical and biological systems have small sizes that are not well approximated by an infinite system. It becomes thus essential to study how finite-size fluctuations can affect the emergent collective dynamics of commonly used models. This is a particularly relevant endeavour since their effects can be highly non-trivial [33, 34, 35] [36]. For example, in oscillators with only higher-order coupling, synchronization transitions arise only in finite systems, and disappear in the thermodynamic limit [37, 38]. However, all the studies on finite-size effects have been restricted so far to all-to-all topologies.
Here, we carry out a numerical study of the dynamics of a system consisting of a finite number of oscillators connected in a traditional, pairwise, Erdős-Rényi (ER) random graph with the addition of higher-order global connections, revealing the effects that system size, density and coupling strengths have on the synchronization transition, and highlighting the differences with globally coupled systems in the thermodynamic limit. We have introduced mixed interactions to understand the finite size effect in a system with network topology and distinction between network and globally connected system.
Results
The model
Consider a system of interacting phase oscillators, each with characteristic frequency , interacting via two different couplings, namely a pairwise one with strength and a triadic one with strength . The pairwise interactions occur over the edges of an ER random network with connection probability , yielding an average degree , whereas the higher-order interactions are all-to-all. The dynamics of the system is described by
where is the element of the adjacency matrix of the ER network. To study the system, we measure the local order parameter , which quantifies the degree of local synchrony between the th oscillator and its neighbours, and the Kuramoto-Daido global order parameters , which characterize the extent of higher-harmonics synchronization of the entire population:
In the equations above, the magnitude of the local order parameter, , is the fraction of oscillators that are entrained to oscillator , and is the local mean phase. The Kuramoto-Daido order parameters, instead, correspond to the Fourier modes of the probability density of phases. Thus, their magnitudes measure the extent by which the system splits into synchronized clusters with phase difference between them. Eq. (1) can then be rewritten as
For the sake of completeness, we note that the equation above, for a globally coupled system and in the thermodynamic limit, admits a low-dimensional solution using the Ott-Antonsen Ansatz [39] that provides the time evolution for :
Characterization of the synchronization transition
To investigate finite-size effects on the behaviour of the system, we solve Eq. (4) numerically, varying the system size from to , while keeping the average degree fixed at 20, to ensure that the network remains well above the connectivity threshold of an ER graph. Also, we sample the characteristic frequencies from a Lorentzian distribution , for which the critical coupling for the transition to synchronization is known to have a theoretical upper bound of 2 [40].
As illustrated in Figure 1(a), in the absence higher-order interactions, the transition from incoherent dynamics to a synchronized state is continuous, and the onset of synchronization is independent of system size, apart from scaling corrections in the vicinity of the critical point [41]. Upon inclusion of higher-order coupling, the transition becomes abrupt and it is accompanied by a bistable region, as shown in Figure 1(b).
Figure 1. Higher-order interactions change the character of the synchronization transition. (a) The global order parameter changes continuously with the pairwise coupling strength in the absence of higher-order interactions. (b) When the higher-order coupling strength is set to , the synchronization transition becomes first-order, with the appearance of a hysteresis loop. Also, the forward transition point changes with system size, whereas the backwards one remains constant. In all cases, the average degree of the network is fixed at 20.
Moreover, a clear dependence emerges of the forward transition point with system size.
Note that, as we mentioned above, in a globally coupled system, the forward critical coupling approaches 2 in the thermodynamic limit. In contrast, here we find that, with mixed-order interactions, the transition point exceeds this theoretical maximum for . To better show this, in Figure 2 we report the time evolution of for large but finite system sizes. The magnitude of the Kuramoto order parameter shows that the system undergoes an abrupt transition to the synchronized state at distinct coupling strengths that are larger than 2, confirming that, in contrast to what happens on complete graphs, the transition point in a random network is not bounded by 2.
Figure 2. The transition point in random networks is not bounded by 2. The time evolution of the magnitude of the Kuramoto order parameter for (a), (b), and (c) shows that the abrupt transition to synchronization happens for values of the coupling strength that are greater than the theoretical limit of 2 that is valid for complete graphs. In all cases, the higher-order coupling was , and the initial conditions were completely random, corresponding to .
To better characterize the effect of network size on the synchronization transition in the presence of mixed couplings, we simulated the system over 3000 realizations, each corresponding to a different network structure and with different initial conditions, and recorded the transition point for each. denotes the critical coupling strength at which the system jumps from a stable incoherent state and undergoes a transition to a stable coherent state; this value is referred to as the transition point. For each realization, characterized by distinct initial conditions and network topologies, we recorded the coupling value at the transition point and subsequently constructed the probability distribution of . The distributions of transition points, reported in Figure 3, is unimodal, with the peak that shifts toward larger coupling strengths for increasing system sizes. The evolution of the distribution is more rapid for globally connected systems than it is for random networks of the same size, even though the qualitative behaviour is the same. Also, in general, in ER networks, the peak is found at lower couplings than those at which it occurs in complete graphs.
Figure 3. The mean transition coupling strength increases with system size. (a)–(c) The probability distributions of the transition points shift towards higher values and become narrower as the size of the ER network increases from 100 to 300 and 500. The same qualitative behaviour is found for complete graphs. (d)–(e) The same data are plotted by network type.
Estimation of the unstable fixed points
The trend of the distributions of transition points reported in the previous section can be explained by means of unstable fixed points and fluctuations in order parameter. However, a theoretical estimate of the unstable state can only be provided for the case of globally coupled oscillators in the thermodynamic limit. Thus, we use a numerical approach to identify them in the case of finite systems with random-network topology.
Specifically, for each fixed value of the pairwise coupling strength , we initialize the phases to generate a set of initial order parameter values in the range . Each realization of the system is subsequently evolved to obtain an updated order parameter value . In our simulations, the resulting value of the order parameter is always smaller than 0.1 or greater than 0.6. Thus, we adopt a discriminating criterion based on this observation: if , the corresponding initial conditions are classified as belonging to the coherent basin, whereas if , they are classified as belonging to the incoherent one. This allows us to determine, for each value of , the largest associated with a coherent state and the smallest associated with an incoherent state. The unstable fixed point is then the arithmetic mean of these two extreme values.
The results, illustrated in Figure 4(a) for in the case of an ER network with , as well as in the case of a complete graph, show a behaviour of the unstable fixed point that is similar to that of a globally connected infinite network obtained by solving Eq. (5). The finite size of the system, however, causes it to shift towards lower values of for low , and towards higher values of for high , with a crossover at . In fact, the unstable fixed point reaches 0 only at even for the complete graph.

Figure 4. Crossover of the sign of finite size effects on unstable fixed points. (a) For low values of , the locations of the unstable fixed point for an ER network with nodes and average degree 20 (red), and for a complete graph of the same size (green) are lower than those for an infinite complete graph (black), obtained by solving Eq. (5). However, their shift is in the opposite direction for high values of . (b) The unstable fixed points for ER networks with 1000 nodes approach the behaviour of a complete graph in the thermodynamic limit as the average degree is increased. (c) versus . Probability distribution of for the incoherent state with , , and , computed over a time window of 200000.
Furthermore, for higher values of the coupling strength, the distance of the unstable branch from decreases with the average degree, as shown in Figure 4(b). This is consistent with the previous observations, and it indicates that as the average degree approaches the value it has in fully connected graphs, the unstable branch moves closer to 0 as approaches 2.
The effects of the average degree are measurable also for low coupling strengths. In fact, the distribution of values of for networks of size 1000 and , shown in Figure 4(c), indicate that the average value of decreases with the average degree. This complements the results shown in Figure 1(a), from which one can notice that the baseline of the order parameter in the incoherent state scales like , consistently with known theoretical treatments [42]. Additionally, both the mean and the standard deviation of the distribution decrease with the average degree, implying that fluctuations in the order parameter, which are relevant for the transition to synchronization, are smaller in complete graphs than they are in ER networks.
Effects of density and higher-order coupling
Further simulations reveal that system size and higher-order coupling have opposite effects on the transition point. In fact, the value of at which the synchronization transition happens increases with the number of oscillators, as shown in Figure 5(a). Note that, while the results reported in the figure are for , the same behaviour occurs regardless of the strenght of the higher-order coupling.
Figure 5. System size and higher-order coupling have opposite effects on the transition point. (a) For a fixed value of , increasing the number of nodes in the network shifts the transition point to higher values of . (b)–(c) Increasing the higher-order coupling shifts the distribution of transition points towards lower values and increases its width, with the effect being more dramatic on fully connected networks (c) than on ER random graphs (b). The results are averaged over 3000 independent realizations, and the system size is 300 in panels (b) and (c).
Conversely, an increase in for a fixed system size leads to a leftward shift in the distribution of regardless of the structure of connections, as illustrated in Figure 5(b)–(c). This is caused by a change in the location of the unstable fixed points, which depends on the value of . In turn, the difference in this change between ER networks and complete graphs causes the effect of to be stronger for fully connected networks than for random ones.
Additionally, we find that the density of the network has only a minor effect compared to the network size, especially for small systems. In fact, we have already shown that, as the average degree of a network increases, the baseline value of the order parameter in the incoherent state decreases. However, the ultimate influence of this change on the distribution of the forward transition point is fairly small, as shown in Figure 6, with no noticeable shift in its peak. In contrast, increasing for a fixed density clearly shifts the distribution towards higher values of , reducing its standard deviation and making the peak sharper, as already illustrated in Figure 3(d).
Figure 6. Density has only a minor effect on the distribution of transition points. For a system of fixed size () and fixed higher-order coupling (), increasing the density does not shift the peak of the distribution of . The only noticeable effect is a smoothening of the distribution for higher values of , due to the smaller relative importance of fluctuations.
Conclusion
In summary, we carried out an extensive numerical investigation of the synchronization transition of Kuramoto oscillators in systems with mixed-order coupling. Specifically, we imposed pairwise interactions along the edges of Erdős-Rényi random graphs, together with all-to-all three-body interactions. Also, crucially, we focused on systems whose sizes are small enough that finite-size effects play a significant role.
In such systems, fluctuations in the stationary value of the order parameter are strongly influenced by system size, so that, given enough time, they can drive the system across the basin boundary of the unstable fixed point and induce a transition from incoherence to coherence. As the system size increases, fluctuations become weaker, and the system remains confined below the unstable branch, eventually preventing a transition in the thermodynamic limit.
Indeed, our simulations demonstrate that the forward synchronization transition is strongly affected by the fluctuations of the order parameter, which induce a size-dependent shift in the coupling strength at which the transition happens. For relatively small ER networks, the effective transition point is lower than that of the corresponding globally coupled system. In contrast, for large enough system size, globally coupled systems always synchronize at , whereas ER networks require a larger coupling strength. We describe this result by numerically identifying the unstable fixed points of the system, and showing how for low pairwise couplings, their value is lower than that of complete graphs, crossing over to higher values for high coupling strengths.
Finally, we examined the distribution of transition thresholds across a large ensemble of network realizations and initial conditions. This distribution exhibits a well-defined peak, and its width decreases with system size, reflecting the gradual suppression of fluctuations.
As most real-world systems with random network topologies possess finite sizes that cannot be accurately represented by the thermodynamic limit, our results underline the importance of accounting for finite-size effects when studying and interpreting synchronization transitions with network topology.
Acknowledgements
Abhishek Sharma acknowledges UGC for a Senior Research Fellowship. Ayushi Suman acknowledges CSIR award SRF-NET2021/11014. Mehernaz Anvari acknowledges IGSTC WISER award with Grant No. 11-20286-3180-00001. Charo del Genio acknowledges funding from the Bulgarian Ministry of Education and Science, under Project No. BG-RRP-2.004-0006-C02. Sarika Jalan acknowledges SERB POWER Grant No. SPF/2021/000136.
Declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Author contribution
SJ and CIDG developed the research concept and supervised the study. AS conducted the numerical simulations. All authors contributed to the analysis and interpretation of the results. AS, MS, CDG and SJ prepared the manuscript. All authors approved the manuscript.
References
- [1]Pikovsky, A., Rosenblum, M., Kurths, J.: Synchronization: A Universal Concept in Nonlinear Sciences. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2003)
- [2]Arenas, A., Díaz-Guilera, A., Kurths, J., Moreno, Y., Zhou, C.: Synchronization in complex networks. Phys. Rep. 469, 93 (2008)DOI
- [3]del Genio, C.I., Romance, M., Criado, R., Boccaletti, S.: Synchronization in dynamical networks with unconstrained structure switching. Phys. Rev. E 92, 062819 (2015)DOI
- [4]del Genio, C.I., Gómez-Gardeñes, J., Bonamassa, I., Boccaletti, S.: Synchronization in networks with multiple interaction layers. Sci. Adv. 2, 1601679 (2016)DOI
- [5]Boccaletti, S., Pisarсhik, A.N., del Genio, C.I., Amann, A.: Synchronization: From Coupled Systems to Complex Networks. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2018)
- [6]del Genio, C.I., Faci-Lazaro, S., Gómez-Gardeñes, J., Boccaletti, S.: Mean-field nature of synchronization stability in networks with multiple interaction layers. Commun. Phys. 5, 121 (2022)arxiv.org/abs/2203.01673
- [7]Jafari, S., Bayani, A., Parastesh, F., Rajagopal, K., del Genio, C.I., Minati, L., Boccaletti, S.: Periodic systems have new classes of synchronization stability. Phys. Rev. Research 6, 043105 (2024)arxiv.org/abs/2409.04193
- [8]Kuramoto, Y.: Self-entrainment of a population of coupled non-linear oscillators. In: Araki, H. (ed.) International Symposium on Mathematical Problems in Theoretical Physics, vol. 39, p. 420. Springer, New York (1975)
- [9]Ermentrout, B.: An adaptive model for synchrony in the firefly Pteroptyx malaccae. J. Math. Biol. 29, 571 (1991)DOI
- [10]Sepulchre, R., Paley, D., Leonard, N.: Collective motion and oscillator synchronization. In: Cooperative Control: a Post-workshop Volume, p. 189. Springer, New York (2004)DOI
- [11]Childs, L.M., Strogatz, S.H.: Stability diagram for the forced Kuramoto model. Chaos 18, 043128 (2008)DOI
- [12]Marvel, S.A., Strogatz, S.H.: Invariant submanifold for series arrays of Josephson junctions. Chaos 19, 013132 (2009)DOI
- [13]Breakspear, M., Heitmann, S., Daffertshofer, A.: Generative models of cortical oscillations: neurobiological implications of the Kuramoto model. Front. Hum. Neurosci. 4, 190 (2010)DOI
- [14]Hong, H., Strogatz, S.H.: Kuramoto model of coupled oscillators with positive and negative coupling parameters: an example of conformist and contrarian oscillators. Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 054102 (2011)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21405399
- [15]Zhu, B., Schachenmayer, J., Xu, M., Herrera, F., Restrepo, J.G., Holland, M.J., Rey, A.M.: Synchronization of interacting quantum dipoles. New J. Phys. 17, 083063 (2015)DOI
- [16]O’Keeffe, K.P., Hong, H., Strogatz, S.H.: Oscillators that sync and swarm. Nat. Commun. 8, 1504 (2017)DOI
- [17]Osaka, M.: Modified Kuramoto phase model for simulating cardiac pacemaker cell synchronization. Appl. Math. 8, 1227 (2017)DOI
- [18]Kachhvah, S.H., Jalan, S.: Hebbian plasticity rules abrupt desynchronization in pure simplicial complexes. New J. Phys. 24, 052002 (2022)arxiv.org/abs/2110.13553
- [19]Kachhvah, S.H., Jalan, S.: First-order route to antiphase clustering in adaptive simplicial complexes. Phys Rev. E 105, 062203 (2022)arxiv.org/abs/2203.16254
- [20]Boccaletti, S., De Lellis, P., del Genio, C.I., Alfaro-Bittner, K., Criado, R., Jalan, S., Romance, M.: The structure and dynamics of networks with higher order interactions. Phys. Rep. 1018, 1 (2023)
- [21]Ma, Y.-J., Jiang, Z.-Q., Fang, F., del Genio, C.I., Boccaletti, S.: “reconstructing simplicial complexes from evolutionary games. Phys. Rev. E 111, 044304 (2025)arxiv.org/abs/2503.15923
- [22]del Genio, C.I.: Hypermodularity and community detection in hypergraphs. Phys. Rev. Research 7, 033045 (2025)arxiv.org/abs/2412.06935
- [23]del Genio, C.I., Vasilyeva, E., Tupikina, L., Fedorov, D., Musatov, D., Raigorodskii, A.M., Boccaletti, S.: Distances in weighted higher-order networks. Commun. Phys. 9, 178 (2026)DOI
- [24]Parastesh, F., Mehrabbeik, M., Rajagopal, K., Jafari, S., Perc, M., del Genio, C.I., Boccaletti, S.: Synchronization stability in simplicial complexes of near-identical systems. Phys. Rev. Research 7, 033039 (2025)
- [25]Semenov, V.V., Dutta, S., Boccaletti, S., del Genio, C.I., Jalan, S., Zakharova, A.: Solitary states in spiking oscillators with higher-order interactions. Phys. Rev. E 112, 034302 (2025)arxiv.org/abs/2504.19016
- [26]Kovalenko, K., Contreras-Aso, G., del Genio, C.I., Boccaletti, S., Sánchez-García, R.: Equitability and explosive synchronisation in multiplex and higher-order networks. Commun. Phys. 9, 117 (2026)arxiv.org/abs/2507.09319
- [27]Guo, Z., Liu, Z., Guan, S., del Genio, C.I., Boccaletti, S., Zhou, J.: Higher-order interactions induce chimera states in globally coupled oscillators. Phys. Rev. Research 8, 023011 (2026)DOI
- [28]Dutta, S., Mondal, A., Kundu, P., Khanra, P., Pal, P., Hens, C.: Impact of phase lag on synchronization in frustrated kuramoto model with higher-order interactions. Phys. Rev. E 108, 034208 (2023)arxiv.org/abs/2305.01706
- [29]Rajwani, P., Suman, A., Jalan, S.: Tiered synchronization in kuramoto oscillators with adaptive higher-order interactions. Chaos 33, 061102 (2023)DOI
- [30]Biswas, D., Gupta, S.: Symmetry-breaking higher-order interactions in coupled phase oscillators. Chaos Soliton. Fract. 181, 114721 (2024)DOI
- [31]Pal, P.K., Anwar, M.S., Perc, M., Ghosh, D.: Global synchronization in generalized multilayer higher-order networks. Phys. Rev. Research 6, 033003 (2024)DOI
- [32]Lourenço, M., Sharma, A., Rajwani, P., Madrigal Solis, E.A., Anvari, M., Jalan, S.: Finite size effect in Kuramoto oscillators with inertia on simplicial complex. Chaos 35, 071103 (2025)arxiv.org/abs/2506.23181
- [33]Daido, H.: Scaling behaviour at the onset of mutual entrainment in a population of interacting oscillators. J. Phys. A 20, 629 (1987)DOI
- [34]Daido, H.: Intrinsic fluctuations and a phase transition in a class of large populations of interacting oscillators. J. Stat Phys. 60, 753 (1990)DOI
- [35]Daido, H.: Onset of cooperative entrainment in limit-cycle oscillators with uniform all-to-all interactions: bifurcation of the order function. Physica D 91, 24 Suman, A., Jalan, S.: Finite-size effect in Kuramoto oscillators with higher-order interactions. Chaos 34, 101101 (2024)
- [37]Komarov, M., Pikovsky, A.: Finite-size-induced transitions to synchrony in oscillator ensembles with nonlinear global coupling. Phys. Rev. E 92, 020901 (2015)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26382333
- [38]Peter, F., Pikovsky, A.: Transition to collective oscillations in finite Kuramoto ensembles. Phys. Rev. E 97, 032310 (2018)DOI
- [39]Ott, E., Antonsen, T.M.: Low dimensional behavior of large systems of globally coupled oscillators. Chaos 18, 037113 (2008)DOI
- [40]Jalan, S., Suman, A.: Multiple first-order transitions in simplicial complexes on multilayer systems. Phys. Rev. E 106, 044304 (2022)DOI
- [41]Hong, H., Chaté, H., Tang, L.-H., Park, H.: Finite-size scaling, dynamic fluctuations, and hyperscaling relation in the Kuramoto model. Phys. Rev. E 18, 037113 (2008)
- [42]Strogatz, S.H.: From Kuramoto to Crawford: exploring the onset of synchronization in populations of coupled oscillators. Physica D 143, 1 (2000)DOI



