betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Collective depinning of dipolar skyrmion chains: thermal and athermal rounding of an elastic polymer in a quenched landscape

Abstract

The dynamics of interacting dipole skyrmion chains in a weak pinning landscape is studied through numerical solutions of the stochastic Thiele equation. Chains of different lengths with periodic boundary conditions are driven across quenched attractive pinning sites under different magnetic fields. A clear threshold spin current is identified as the critical depinning force. Three main results emerge: (i) for chains of 50 skyrmions or more, the depinning threshold is independent of chain length and remains close to one third of that of an isolated skyrmion. (ii) The transition rounding is only partly thermal: the width changes from w = 0.334 +/- 0.004 decades at T = 0 to 0.633 +/- 0.002 at 300 K, while the intrinsic Larkin correlation length remains about 2.6 bonds below kBT ~ V0/25. (iii) The width is nearly unchanged up to kBT ~ 0.14 V0, but increases almost fourfold by kBT ~ 0.23 V0, mainly through broadening of the creep regime. It is independent of chain length, ruling out finite-size rounding. Increasing the field from 30 to 40 mT changes the transition shape, widening its core by 26% while shortening the creep tails. For chains of about 200 skyrmions, depinning proceeds through a sequence of internal deformations - growth of the Larkin length and roughness, transient bond stretching, and subsequent recovery of mobility and Hall angle. These collective effects are relevant for skyrmion-based devices in which chains, rather than isolated textures, act as information carriers.

Introduction

Magnetic skyrmions are localized, topologically non-trivial spin textures whose particle-like behavior makes them attractive candidates for information storage and logic [1, 2, 3, 4]. To date, most studies of skyrmion depinning have focused on isolated skyrmions or dense lattices [5, 6, 7]. An intermediate and physically important case, the one-dimensional chain, has received comparatively little attention, even though chains arise naturally in confined geometries and at the edges of skyrmion-hosting stripes.

The object of the present study is the dipolar skyrmion chain, a non-worm-like-chain (non-WLC) magnetic skyrmion polymer. The mechanism binding skyrmions into a chain is dipolar interaction. Dipolar skyrmions are stabilized by the competition between the perpendicular uniaxial anisotropy, which favors uniform out-of-plane spin orientation, and the magnetostatic (shape) energy, which favors flux closure. This means that the energy of pair-wise interactions between skyrmions can be minimized by alternating helicity between neighboring skyrmions. This is possible in the dipolar chain because the helicity of a dipolar skyrmion is not fixed by a microscopic interaction so that dipolar skyrmions are free to assume either right- or left-handed textures.

A chain is qualitatively different from both an isolated skyrmion and a lattice: it is a deformable elastic object with a finite number of internal degrees of freedom, and a collective response to disorder is expected, in analogy with chains studied extensively in soft-matter systems such as polymers. Disorder pins the texture, and a finite driving force in the form of an electric current, a field gradient or thermal bias is required before motion sets in [8, 9]. A fundamental measurable quantity for exploring this dynamic is the threshold drive for the onset of motion. A critical depinning drive can be defined for this transition and its magnitude depends on characteristic length scales of the pinning landscape and of the chain deformations [10, 11, 12, 13].

In our model, a spin current is used as the depinning drive. The current drives spin precession within the skyrmion chain and results in motion of the chain. This is different from field-driven dynamics because the work in field-driven dynamics is measured by the change in area enclosed by a chain, whereas for current driven skyrmion forces, work is done per chain length moved rather than area traversed. In what follows, we show how this difference affects what one expects for the magnitude of the critical driving force and explore depinning dynamics using large-scale stochastic Thiele simulations.

We find that the depinning threshold of the chain is essentially independent of chain length at each field, with a drive value that is approximately one third of that for an isolated skyrmion. When the number of skyrmions in the chain is 50 or more we observe collective elastic behavior where depinning is a bulk property of the chain, as is the case for the depinning of polymers.

The transition is not sharp but rounded, and the width of that rounding is independent of chain length over the whole range studied, so it is not a finite-size effect. Thermal fluctuations account for about half of it and an athermal mechanism for the rest, as the T=0T = 0 simulations of Sec. III E show directly. The depinning is therefore a rounded crossover [14, 15] rather than a sharp critical transition, with both mechanisms contributing at room temperature; at T=0T = 0 the crossover survives with half the width, set by the disorder alone. Figure 1 shows, for the longest chain studied, the three regimes through which the chain passes as the drive is raised.

Figure 1. Simulation snapshots of the N=200N = 200 chain at B=35B = 35 mT in the quenched landscape of attractive Gaussian pins (gray disks of radius σ\sigma; only a transverse window around the chain is shown), at three representative drives: (a) pinned regime, F=0.005F = 0.005; (b) depinning crossover, F=0.02F = 0.02; (c) free flow, F=0.2F = 0.2. Skyrmion positions are colored by the local bond stretch r/reqr/r_{\mathrm{eq}}. In the crossover the chain is rough and a large fraction of bonds is transiently stretched beyond the maximum restoring force, rdissr_{\mathrm{diss}} (yellow); in free flow the compact conformation is recovered.

Model and simulation methods

The film thickness is assumed to be very small so that the dipole skyrmions are treated as two dimensional objects. This has consequences on details of how the skyrmions interact with defects, but for the dipolar skyrmions considered here, these are expected to be significant only when the film thickness approaches the size λw\lambda_w of a domain wall. Here we assume that the thickness is less than λw\lambda_w and that the pinning potential is sufficiently weak that the skyrmion structure remains rigid even when responding to a pinning site. This condition is satisfied by, for example, skyrmions in multilayers of [Co/Ni]5_5 as discussed elsewhere through atomistic calculations [16].

Each skyrmion is described by its center position Ri(t)\mathbf{R}_i(t) and the motion of the center as determined by the Thiele equation [7, 18, 19]

G×R˙i+αDR˙i=Fiext.(1)\mathbf{G} \times\dot{\mathbf{R}}_i + \alpha_D \dot{\mathbf{R}}_i = \mathbf{F}_i^{\mathrm{ext}} . \tag*{(1)}

Here G=Gzz^\mathbf{G} = G_z \hat{\mathbf{z}} is the gyrovector and αD\alpha_D the damping-dissipation coefficient (scalar). In reduced units (a0=1a_0 = 1 nm) we have Gz=4πG_z = 4\pi in all three fields, while αD\alpha_D takes the values 1.70, 1.10, 0.72 in B=30B = 30, 35, 40 mT respectively (Table I). The three applied magnetic fields, B=30B = 30, 35, and 40 mT, are chosen so as to span a reasonably large variation of the underlying gyrotropic and damping parameters, as given in Table I. For an isolated unpinned skyrmion under driving force F=Fx^\mathbf{F} = F\hat{\mathbf{x}}, Eq. (1) gives the free-flow mobility μfree\mu_{\mathrm{free}} and corresponding Hall angle θHfree\theta_H^{\mathrm{free}},

μfree=1αD2+Gz2,θHfree=arctan⁡(−GzαD),(2)\mu_{\mathrm{free}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{\alpha_D^2 + G_z^2}}, \qquad\theta_H^{\mathrm{free}} = \arctan\left(-\frac{G_z}{\alpha_D}\right), \tag*{(2)}

which serve as comparison values throughout the paper. The deterministic force is the sum of a pair interaction, a bending stiffness, the pinning force, and the drive,

B=30B = 30 mTB=35B = 35 mTB=40B = 40 mT
reqr_{\mathrm{eq}} (nm)29.124.519.7
DeD_e3.103.072.94
BrepB_{\mathrm{rep}}74.2063.3642.75
CattC_{\mathrm{att}}48.6343.7233.07
δ\delta (nm)11.6810.549.89
λ\lambda (nm)17.5315.8014.84
κWLC\kappa_{\mathrm{WLC}}1.551.190.87
αD\alpha_D1.701.100.72
μfree\mu_{\mathrm{free}}0.07890.07930.0794
θHfree\theta_H^{\mathrm{free}}−82.3∘-82.3^\circ−85.0∘-85.0^\circ−86.7∘-86.7^\circ

Table 1. Model parameters at the three applied fields, in reduced units (a0=1a_0 = 1 nm). μfree\mu_{\mathrm{free}} and θHfree\theta_H^{\mathrm{free}} follow from Eq. (2).

Fiext=∑j≠iFijpair+Fibend+Fipin+Fx^,(3)\mathbf{F}_i^{\mathrm{ext}} = \sum_{j \ne i} \mathbf{F}_{ij}^{\mathrm{pair}} + \mathbf{F}_i^{\mathrm{bend}} + \mathbf{F}_i^{\mathrm{pin}} + F\hat{\mathbf{x}}, \tag*{(3)}

and thermal fluctuations enter through a Langevin noise term obeying the fluctuation-dissipation relation at reduced temperature kBT=0.207k_B T = 0.207, which corresponds to room temperature for the [Co/Ni]5_5 example studied here.

The skyrmion-skyrmion interaction combines a short-range domain-wall-overlap repulsion with a longer-range magnetostatic attraction. This is modeled with the bi-exponential potential of Eq. (4),

Upair(r)=Brepe−r/δ−Catte−r/λ,λ>δ,(4)U^{\mathrm{pair}}(r) = B_{\mathrm{rep}} e^{-r/\delta} - C_{\mathrm{att}} e^{-r/\lambda}, \qquad\lambda> \delta, \tag*{(4)}

whose four parameters are obtained, at each field, from atomistic Landau-Lifshitz-Gilbert relaxation of two skyrmions of opposite helicity in [Co/Ni]5_5 multilayers [16, 20, 21]. The resulting equilibrium spacing reqr_{\mathrm{eq}}, the binding depth DeD_e, and the bending stiffness κWLC\kappa_{\mathrm{WLC}} are listed in Table I. The ratio λ/δ≈1.5\lambda/\delta\approx1.5 is not significantly affected by the magnetic field strengths considered here. Details concerning the choice of parameters used in the simulations presented here are provided elsewhere [16].

Periodic boundary conditions are used so that the depinning threshold can be identified without edge effects. This is implemented by connecting skyrmion ii to skyrmions (i±1i \pm1) mod NN, thereby approximating an infinite chain. The finite length of the chain determines the size of the simulation box in the drive direction, Lx=NreqL_x = N r_{\mathrm{eq}}, so that all bonds are at equilibrium spacing and the closure bond does not stretch across the box. The transverse dimension of the box is fixed at Ly=0.6×200 reqL_y = 0.6 \times200\,r_{\mathrm{eq}} in each field. Periodic boundary conditions are applied to the box along both axes and interactions are constrained such that each skyrmion interacts with its nearest neighbors only. The bond list is strictly topological: skyrmion ii interacts with skyrmions (i±1i \pm1) mod NN only and no distance-based neighbor search is performed, so non-bonded skyrmions that approach each other during strongly deformed transients do not interact. This simplification ensures that non-bonded skyrmion forces are not included as part of the dipolar attraction and assumes that the average density of non-bonded skyrmions is low and their effects equivalent to small, indistinguishable, perturbations to the random pinning potential. The simplification ensures that the effective nearest-neighbor parameters, listed in Table I, remain calibrated against atomistic simulations of the full chain [16], in which all dipolar contributions between all skyrmions are present. In other words, long range dipolar interactions beyond the nearest neighbor can be absorbed into an effective bond energy. In the pinned and free-flow regimes the chain is locally straight and non-bonded separations are at distances 2req2r_{\mathrm{eq}} or larger, and strongly deformed configurations remain confined to the

transient crossover window.

Disorder is implemented as a frozen array of identical attractive Gaussian wells with random positions in the box, Eq. (5),

Vpin(r)=−V0∑k=1Npinsexp⁡[−∣r−rp(k)∣22σ2].(5)V^{\rm pin}(\mathbf{r})=-V_0\sum_{k=1}^{N_{\rm pins}}\exp\left[-\frac{\left|\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_p^{(k)}\right|^2}{2\sigma^2}\right]. \tag*{(5)}

Each well has depth V0=0.5 DeV_0=0.5\,D_e and width σ=0.3 req\sigma=0.3\,r_{\rm eq}, the same dimensionless ratios for all magnetic fields, giving kBT/V0=0.13k_{\rm B}T/V_0=0.13–0.140.14 at each of the three fields. For the scaling analysis it is necessary to keep the pin density invariant throughout each finite-size scan. This is achieved by scaling the number of pins in proportion to the area of the simulation box such that Npins=104(N/200)N_{\rm pins}=10^4(N/200), giving a fixed areal coverage ηpin≈11.8%\eta_{\rm pin}\approx11.8\% for every chain length and field. Each scan therefore samples statistically the same degree of disorder regardless of size.

Results

Chain transport is studied through motion of the chain’s center, defined as the average position of each skyrmion in the chain. The average is done over the time series of individual skyrmion velocities in order to minimize thermal jitter. In this way, a center-of-mass drift vdrift=⟨R˙CM⟩tv_{\rm drift}=\langle\dot{R}_{\rm CM}\rangle_t is defined from the velocity time series. The drift velocity allows definition of an effective mobility μeff=∣vdrift∣/F\mu_{\rm eff}=|v_{\rm drift}|/F and a Hall angle θH=arctan⁡(⟨vy⟩/⟨vx⟩)\theta_{\rm H}=\arctan(\langle v_y\rangle/\langle v_x\rangle). Note that for small drive fields the chain will drift despite pinning due to thermal activations of skyrmions across barrier saddle points. However this drift is one to two orders of magnitude smaller than the jitter and does not correspond to the unpinned velocity which is a monotonic function of driving field.

Observation of the chain at different times (here referred to as snapshots) allows useful quantities to be extracted. The radius of gyration RgR_g gives information about the degree of alignment of skyrmions; the roughness exponent ζ\zeta is a measure of how chain roughness scales with length; and the Larkin correlation length LcL_c characterizes the elastic response of the chain to pinning. Another quantity of interest is the intact-bond fraction fintactf_{\rm intact}. This is defined as the fraction of bonds with ri<rdissr_i<r_{\rm diss} where rdissr_{\rm diss} is the distance of maximum restoring force of the bi-exponential pair potential. This maximal distance is defined by the inflection point of the bi-exponential potential and is dependent on the strength of the magnetic field. For the parameters used in a N=200N=200 chain, this quantity depends on the magnetic field as rdiss/req=1.48r_{\rm diss}/r_{\rm eq}=1.48, 1.531.53, 1.611.61 at the fields B=30B=30, 3535, 4040 mT.

Large-scale stochastic Thiele simulations of chains were performed. The chain lengths considered are N=50N=50, 100100 and 200200, with periodic boundary conditions. Shorter chains (N=20N=20) were also simulated but are not included in the analysis: their transition is markedly wider than for N≥50N\geq50 and they are not yet in the collective regime, see Sec. IIIB. The scan is repeated with the same frozen potential at the three applied magnetic fields studied. We compare the chain depinning to that of an isolated skyrmion in the identical landscape at each field.

The chain is initialized as a straight line placed uniformly along x^\hat{\mathbf{x}} with spacing reqr_{\rm eq} at y=Ly/2y=L_y/2. Equation (1) is then integrated for each skyrmion element of the chain with a stochastic predictor-corrector (Heun) scheme at Δt=0.05\Delta t=0.05 for 1.0×1081.0\times10^8 measurement steps after 3.3×1073.3\times10^7 equilibration steps, sweeping the drive over 20 logarithmically spaced values of FF, from 3×10−43\times10^{-4} to 1.01.0 at 300300 K and from 5×10−35\times10^{-3} to 0.30.3 at T=0T=0, where the transition sits at higher drive. At each force we run 11 independent disorder realizations, with 16 thermal replicas per realization at finite temperature and a single deterministic trajectory at T=0T=0. Each mobility curve therefore rests on 11 realizations at each of 20 drives, that is 220 realization-force pairs; at finite temperature each pair carries 16 replicas, so 3520 individual trajectories. Statistical uncertainties on quantities derived from it (FcF_c, ww, ζ\zeta) are estimated by bootstrap resampling over disorder realizations, with the replica average taken within each realization. All tabulated quantities and all figures except the temperature scan of the Larkin length in Sec. IIIE use this data set. The temperature scan of the Larkin length in Figure 6(c) follows a separate and lighter protocol, because it is read at fixed drive rather than across the transition: at each of the six intermediate temperatures we sweep five drives inside the pinned window (F≤0.005F\leq0.005) with five disorder realizations each, that is 25 runs per temperature. For each run LcL_c is averaged over the second half of the recorded frames, the first quarter being equilibration from the straight initial chain; the value quoted for a temperature is the mean over the five drives and the uncertainty is the standard error between them, which exceeds the scatter within a single drive. The T=0T=0 and 300300 K anchors of that panel are read from the sweep above with the same estimator.

Figure 6. The athermal limit, at B=35B = 35 mT. (a) Mobility ratio versus drive for the N=200N = 200 chain at T=0T = 0 and 300 K. At T=0T = 0 the curve rises from exactly zero and is monotonic; at 300 K thermal creep gives a finite velocity at arbitrarily small drive, so μeff/μfree=v/(Fμfree)\mu_{\mathrm{eff}}/\mu_{\mathrm{free}} = v/(F\mu_{\mathrm{free}}) diverges as F→0F \to0 and the curve descends into a creep valley before rising through the transition. Dotted lines mark the 10% and 90% levels; the 10% level is read on the near edge of the valley, which is what restricts the width analysis to N≥50N \ge50. (b) Transition width versus chain length at the two temperatures: both constant in NN (dashed lines: weighted means, 0.632±0.0010.632 \pm0.001 and 0.334±0.0040.334 \pm0.004), with no drift to extrapolate away. The gap between the bands is the thermal contribution, 47% of the room-temperature width. (c) Larkin correlation length in the pinned regime (F≤0.005F \le0.005) versus temperature, from the transverse displacement correlation of the N=200N = 200 chain. LcL_c holds at 2.56±0.032.56 \pm0.03 bonds from T=0T = 0 to 87 K (kBT/V0=0.039k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0 = 0.039) and grows linearly from 145 K upward as Lc=2.10+16.7kBT/V0L_c = 2.10 + 16.7 k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0; the two lines meet at kBT/V0≈0.03k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0 \approx0.03 (dotted vertical line). Upper axis: temperature in kelvin for the [Co/Ni]5_5 parameters.

The equilibration does not remove all memory of the straight initial condition. Splitting the measurement window into halves and repeating the threshold analysis on each, Fc(50)F_c^{(50)} rises by 3%3\% from the first to the second half at B=35B=35 and 4040 mT (0.0349→0.03590.0349\rightarrow0.0359 at B=35B=35 mT, N=200N=200) and by 5%5\% at T=0T=0, while ww changes by 1%1\% at B=35B=35 and 4040 mT and by 10%10\% both at T=0T=0 (0.34→0.310.34\rightarrow0.31) and at B=30B=30 mT (0.73→0.660.73\rightarrow0.66), where the creep foot is still relaying. All values quoted below use the full measurement window; the second-half thresholds are listed in Table II as a check. The residual drift is of the order of the field-to-field differences in ww discussed in Sec. IIIB and is kept in mind there. Velocities are the drift velocity ⟨R˙CM⟩t\langle\dot{R}_{\rm CM}\rangle_t throughout; the modulus average ⟨∣R˙CM∣⟩t\langle|\dot{R}_{\rm CM}|\rangle_t gives the same thresholds to within 1%1\% but a creep floor two to four times higher, because it counts thermal excursions that do not transport the chain. For comparison with the isolated-skyrmion limit, we ran an N=1N = 1 benchmark in the same box as the N=200N = 200 chain, with the same 10410^4 pins and hence the same coverage, in each field and at both temperatures, with the same protocol and statistics (11 realizations, 16 thermal replicas at 300 K and one deterministic trajectory at T=0T = 0); its force grid spans 0.02 to 0.4, where the single-skyrmion threshold lies.

B=30B = 30 mTB=35B = 35 mTB=40B = 40 mT
Fc(N=1)F_c(N = 1)0.1153(15)0.1295(31)0.1433(36)
Fc(50),N=50F_c^{(50)}, N = 500.0323(3)0.0354(2)0.0390(4)
Fc(50),N=100F_c^{(50)}, N = 1000.0322(2)0.0354(1)0.0392(3)
Fc(50),N=200F_c^{(50)}, N = 2000.0321(1)0.0354(1)0.0392(2)
2nd half of window0.03290.03590.0396
ww, N=50N = 500.683−0.028+0.0480.683^{+0.048}_{-0.028}0.629(3)0.638(3)
ww, N=100N = 1000.683−0.021+0.0160.683^{+0.016}_{-0.021}0.630(3)0.642(2)
ww, N=200N = 2000.693(9)0.633(2)0.640(1)

Table II. Operational depinning forces of the chain at the three fields. Fc(N=1)F_c(N = 1) is the isolated-skyrmion benchmark at θ=0.5\theta= 0.5. The ratio Fc(N=200)/Fc(N=1)F_c(N = 200)/F_c(N = 1) is close to 1/31/3 at every field. Fc(θ)F_c(\theta) is the largest-FF crossing of μeff/μfree=θ\mu_{\mathrm{eff}}/\mu_{\mathrm{free}} = \theta with log-FF interpolation; parenthesized digits are the half-width of the 16th–84th percentile interval of a bootstrap over disorder realizations. The width w(N)=log⁡10[Fc(90%)/Fc(10%)]w(N) = \log_{10}[F_c(90\%)/F_c(10\%)] is given in decades and is independent of NN over the range listed. The row “2nd half of window” gives Fc(50)(N=200)F_c^{(50)}(N = 200) evaluated on the second half of the measurement window only (Sec. II).

The depinning transition region

A chain length of N=200N = 200 was used to identify depinning and pinning parameters chosen to satisfy two competing requirements: (i) a well-developed sub-mobility plateau in the pinned regime and (ii) a chain that remains structurally intact through the depinning transition. Deeper pins where V0≳DeV_0 \gtrsim D_e, with DeD_e being the energy gained by forming a bond between two skyrmions, produce a stronger plateau but rupture the chain at the transition. The length N=200N = 200 allows the configuration to deform sufficiently to a high density of weak pins so that the cumulative drag is strong and the chain remains connected. Note that bonds between skyrmions can stretch beyond rdissr_{\mathrm{diss}} during depinning. The stretching is transient: the bond list is fixed by the chain topology, so a stretched pair remains connected and recovers its equilibrium separation once the inhomogeneous drag of the landscape disappears in free flow. Permanent separation of a pair would require an energy larger than DeD_e, which is not reached for the parameters used here (as noted earlier). This transient stretching and subsequent recovery is shown explicitly in the movie provided as Supplemental Material [22], which follows the same N=200N = 200 chain at B=35B = 35 mT in the pinned, crossover, and free-flow regimes.

Figure 2 shows transport parameters for three different magnetic fields as a function of FF: (a) the drift velocity, (b) the effective mobility, (c) the Hall angle, and (d) the radius of gyration of the chain. The chain length is N=200N = 200; results are shown for the chain and the isolated-skyrmion benchmark for each field.

Figure 2. Transport observables of the chain (solid markers, N=200N = 200) and the isolated skyrmion (open/dashed) versus drive at the three fields. (a) Drift velocity in log-log scale; dotted lines: free-flow law for each field. (b) Mobility ratio μeff/μfree\mu_{\mathrm{eff}}/\mu_{\mathrm{free}} in lin-log. (c) Hall angle of the chain; dotted lines mark the predicted free-flow values. (d) Radius of gyration normalized to the straight-chain reference Rgstraight=(N−1)req/12R_g^{\mathrm{straight}} = (N - 1)r_{\mathrm{eq}}/\sqrt{12}, showing transient stretching at the transition. Error bars span the 16th to 84th percentiles of a bootstrap over disorder realizations, with the thermal-replica average taken within each realization (the same protocol as in Figure 3–Figure 5); in (a) and (b) they are smaller than the symbols in the pinned and free-flow regimes and become comparable to the symbol size inside the crossover window, where fluctuations are largest.

Three regimes are visible in all fields for each parameter. At low drive (F≲5×10−3F \lesssim5 \times10^{-3}) the chain and isolated skyrmion each creep with strongly reduced linear mobility. This creep region defines plateaus in (b) for the mobility ratio: μpinned/μfree≈0.02\mu_{\mathrm{pinned}}/\mu_{\mathrm{free}} \approx0.02–0.040.04 for the chain, and ≈0.01\approx0.01–0.020.02 for the isolated skyrmion, whose drift at the lowest drives (F≲10−3F \lesssim10^{-3}) is limited by the thermal noise floor of a single particle. At high drive (F≳0.2F \gtrsim0.2) free-flow mobility is recovered to within 5% of that predicted by Eq. (2). The mobility ratio shown in (b) displays the same features as the drift velocity but with a more pronounced initial threshold and thermal rounding for the final transition out of the creep regime into a flow regime. The Hall angle of the chain [Figure 2(c)] matches the single-skyrmion value θHfree\theta_H^{\mathrm{free}} within 1∘1^\circ at high drive for all magnetic fields. Note also that the thermally rounded depinning crossover exists between these limits also for the isolated skyrmion, although with a higher FF onset.

The Hall angle for the chain shown in Figure 2(c) as a function of FF likewise shows a plateau and thermal rounding. The Hall angle provides an independent, transport-free diagnostic of the depinning [23, 24]. In the pinned regime the chain’s lateral motion is locked by the landscape and θH≈0∘\theta_H \approx0^\circ. In free flow θH\theta_H recovers the single-skyrmion value θHfree\theta_H^{\mathrm{free}} predicted by Eq. (2), matching theory within 1∘1^\circ at every field. At the lowest drives there are additional features that can be interpreted as changes in shape of the chains. For comparison, the Hall angle for perfectly straight chains is shown by horizontal dashed lines for each field. The rotation of θH\theta_H from 0∘0^\circ to its asymptote occurs in the same drive window as the mobility rise. The chains are very far from flat in the lowest FF region with correspondingly large fluctuations around zero Hall angle and in (a) and (b) large fluctuations in drift velocities and mobility ratios.

The radius of gyration (RgR_g) is plotted as a function of FF in (d). RgR_g has been normalized to the straight-chain reference Rgstraight=req(N2−1)/12≈Nreq/12R_g^{\mathrm{straight}} = r_{\mathrm{eq}}\sqrt{(N^2 - 1)/12} \approx Nr_{\mathrm{eq}}/\sqrt{12}, the radius of gyration of NN points evenly spaced along a line (the chain is unwrapped from the periodic box before RgR_g is computed). There are large fluctuations throughout the transition region which are also strongly dependent on magnetic field strength. With bonds held near reqr_{\mathrm{eq}} a chain cannot exceed the straight-rod value, so excursions of Rg/RgstraightR_g/R_g^{\mathrm{straight}} above unity are possible only through genuine bond stretching, which makes the transient peak at the crossover a direct signature of stretched bonds rather than mere roughening. In the pinned and free-flow regimes Rg/RgstraightR_g/R_g^{\mathrm{straight}} stays within 0.3% of unity at all fields. The peak excursions are 12±2%12 \pm2\%, 8±4%8 \pm4\% and 20±3%20 \pm3\% at B=30B = 30, 35 and 40 mT (mean and standard error over disorder realizations, averaged over the second half of the run), located at F=0.02F = 0.02 for the two lower fields and at F=0.05F = 0.05 for B=40B = 40 mT; the large realization-to-realization scatter reflects the intermittent character of the stretching events.

Collective chain behaviour and scaling

An operational depinning force Fc(θ)F_c(\theta) is defined as the largest drive at which μeff/μfree\mu_{\mathrm{eff}}/\mu_{\mathrm{free}} crosses a threshold value θ\theta from below. Central values are read from the mobility curve averaged over all disorder realizations, and uncertainties are the 16th and 84th percentiles of a bootstrap over those realizations. Where the bootstrap distribution is asymmetric the two percentiles are quoted separately; this happens only when the creep valley approaches the lower threshold, and at N≥50N \ge50 only for B=30B = 30 mT at N=50N = 50. We also report a reduced threshold, defined as the ratio of the chain and isolated-skyrmion thresholds, Fcchain/Fc(1)F_c^{\mathrm{chain}}/F_c^{(1)}. A linear interpolation of log⁡F\log F is used to determine the threshold in the presence of statistical noise in the creep regime. A range of θ\theta values between 0.3 and 0.7 was tested. The thresholds obtained for an N=200N = 200 chain were statistically independent of thermal noise for all values of θ\theta in this range.

The threshold values were also found to be independent of magnetic field. Choosing θ=0.5\theta= 0.5, we measured Fc(N=200)/Fc(N=1)=0.279±0.004F_c(N = 200)/F_c(N = 1) = 0.279 \pm0.004, 0.273±0.0060.273 \pm0.006 and 0.273±0.0060.273 \pm0.006 at B=30B = 30, 35 and 40 mT, where the uncertainties were estimated from the disorder realizations using bootstrap sampling. The three values coincide with one another within 2.2%. Note that because the force grid is logarithmic and the θ=0.5\theta= 0.5 crossing falls between grid points, the central values carry a scheme-dependent shift of order +0.03+0.03 if FF rather than log⁡F\log F is interpolated (this shifts the ratio to 0.29–0.31). The ratio is therefore ≈0.3\approx0.3, consistent with a ratio of one third.

To test how this ratio and the depinning threshold depend on the periodicity enforced by the periodic boundary conditions, we ran the chain at N=50N = 50, 100, 200 in each of the three fields, holding the pin density and all landscape parameters fixed. A summary of the results is presented in Figure 3.

Figure 3. Field dependence of the depinning transition at 300 K. Panels (a) and (c) use N=100N = 100; panel (d) shows all three chain lengths. (a) Mobility ratio versus drive, with the drive rescaled by Fc(50)F_{\mathrm{c}}^{(50)} of each field. The three curves collapse above threshold but not below it: the creep foot of B=30B = 30 mT sits well above that of B=40B = 40 mT, so the transitions differ in shape and not only in scale. Dotted lines mark the 10% and 90% levels, dashed lines the 20% and 80% levels. (b) The 20%–80% width versus chain length at each field: flat in NN. (c) The three widths versus field. They do not rank the fields in the same order, which is only possible if the curve shape changes with field. (d) The ratio w10−90/w20−80w_{10-90}/w_{20-80}, measuring how much of the transition lies in the tails relative to the core: monotonic in field and independent of chain length, shown for all three sizes with a small horizontal offset so that the coincident points remain visible.

Two features stand out and are robust with respect to the applied field. First, consider the 50% depinning threshold, listed in Table II. This threshold is denoted Fc(50)F_c^{(50)} and is the drive at which the disorder-averaged mobility ratio reaches half of its free-flow value, μeff/μfree=0.5\mu_{\mathrm{eff}}/\mu_{\mathrm{free}} = 0.5. It is essentially NN-independent in all fields, with a spread below 2% between N=50N = 50 and N=200N = 200.

Combined with Fc(N=1)F_c(N = 1) in each field, this gives a collective-advantage ratio

Fc(50)(N≥50)Fc(50)(N=1)≈13,(6)\frac{F_c^{(50)}(N \ge50)}{F_c^{(50)}(N = 1)} \approx\frac{1}{3}, \tag*{(6)}

that is a property of the collective elastic regime and is already realized at N=50N = 50. This ratio is robust both against the threshold θ\theta chosen to define FcF_{\mathrm{c}} (within θ∈[0.3,0.7]\theta\in[0.3, 0.7]) and against the applied field over B=30B = 30–40 mT, even though the underlying damping αD\alpha_D varies by more than a factor of two over this range. The reduction of the depinning threshold by a factor of three reflects the chain’s ability to redistribute forces across the chain. Skyrmions experiencing pinning forces can be pulled away from the pinning site by skyrmions between pinning sites that are able to move more freely in response to FF. In this way the chain advances as a whole at driving FF that would not move an isolated pinned skyrmion.

Second, consider the width of the transition, defined by the separation in drive between the crossings of two chosen mobility levels. We take the levels 10% and 90% and define the width as w(N)=log⁡10[Fc(90%)/Fc(10%)]w(N) = \log_{10}[F_{\mathrm{c}}(90\%)/F_{\mathrm{c}}(10\%)], the number of decades of drive between the 10% and 90% mobility marks. Where the estimator is well defined, the width does not depend on the chain length. At B=35B = 35 mT, w=0.629±0.003w = 0.629 \pm0.003, 0.630±0.0030.630 \pm0.003 and 0.633±0.0020.633 \pm0.002 at N=50N = 50, 100 and 200, each from the full set of 220 realization-force pairs, constant with χ2/dof=0.6\chi^2/\mathrm{dof} = 0.6; a fit w(N)=w∞+a/Nw(N) = w_\infty+ a/N returns a slope consistent with zero, and no extrapolation in NN is required to reach the long-chain value.

The width is defined only where the mobility curve crosses the 10% mark from below, and at finite temperature it need not do so. Thermal creep gives the chain a finite velocity at arbitrarily small drive, so the ratio μeff/μfree=v/(Fμfree)\mu_{\mathrm{eff}}/\mu_{\mathrm{free}} = v/(F\mu_{\mathrm{free}}) diverges as F→0F \to0: the curve descends from that divergence into a creep valley and only then rises through the transition. The 10% level is read on the near edge of that valley, and the reading is meaningful only while the valley floor lies clearly below it. The floor rises as the chain is shortened, a shorter chain being carried over the landscape by thermal activation more easily: at B=35B = 35 mT it is 0.019 for N=200N = 200 and 0.027 for N=20N = 20 (drift velocity). The N=20N = 20 chain is excluded from the width analysis for a different reason: its width, w=0.84w = 0.84 decades at B=35B = 35 mT against 0.63 for N≥50N \ge50, shows that it is not yet in the collective regime, consistent with the Larkin length of ≈4\approx4 bonds no longer being small compared with the chain. For N≥50N \ge50 every bootstrap resample yields a crossing at all three fields. For N≥50N \ge50 the floor lies at 0.02–0.04 at all three fields, well below the 10% level, but the crossing is least well determined at B=30B = 30 mT, where the mobility curve leaves the creep valley most gradually and is still relaxing within the measurement window (Sec. II). The consequence is visible in the error bars of Table II: at B=30B = 30 mT the width at N=50N = 50 carries an uncertainty of −0.03+0.05^{+0.05}_{-0.03} decades, against ±0.003\pm0.003 at B=35B = 35 mT for the same statistics. This is the same failure mode that appears at fixed NN when the temperature is raised instead, and which is documented in Sec. III D at T=510T = 510 K, where the foot falls below the accessible drive window altogether. That the exclusion is a property of the estimator and not of the physics can be checked by moving the thresholds clear of the valley: measured between 20% and 80%, or between 30% and 70%, the width is independent of chain length down to N=20N = 20 at all three fields.

Across fields the width is not constant, and the way it varies depends on where the transition is read. At N=100N = 100, with the full set of 220 realization-force pairs behind every curve, the 20%–80% width is 0.364 ± 0.004, 0.405 ± 0.004 and 0.461 ± 0.003 decades at B=30B = 30, 35 and 40 mT: a monotonic increase of 26%, far outside the uncertainties. The 10%–90% width, by contrast, gives 0.683^{+0.016}_{-0.021}, 0.630 ± 0.003 and 0.642 ± 0.002, which does not order the fields at all, and the 30%–70% width gives 0.243 ± 0.003, 0.237 ± 0.002 and 0.280 ± 0.004, ordering them differently again.

Three definitions of the same quantity cannot rank the same three curves in different orders unless the curves differ in shape and not merely in scale. Figure 3(a) shows this directly: rescaling the drive by Fc(50)F_c^{(50)} of each field collapses the three mobility curves above threshold but not below it, where the creep foot of B=30B = 30 mT lies well above that of B=40B = 40 mT. A single number captures the difference. The ratio w10−90/w20−80w_{10-90}/w_{20-80}, which measures how much of the transition sits in the tails relative to the core, falls monotonically from 1.87−0.06+0.051.87^{+0.05}_{-0.06} at B=30B = 30 mT to 1.55±0.021.55 \pm0.02 at B=35B = 35 mT and 1.39±0.011.39 \pm0.01 at B=40B = 40 mT, see Figure 3(d). It does not depend on chain length: at N=50N = 50 the same three fields give 1.88−0.08+0.141.88^{+0.14}_{-0.08}, 1.56±0.021.56 \pm0.02 and 1.40±0.011.40 \pm0.01.

The effect is not a thermal one in disguise. The reduced temperature kBT/V0k_B T/V_0 changes by only 5% across the three fields, from 0.134 to 0.141, while the core width changes by 26% and the shape ratio by 36%. What does change substantially is the dynamics: over the same range the damping αD\alpha_D falls by a factor of 2.4 and the bending stiffness κWLC\kappa_{\mathrm{WLC}} by 1.8. A less damped, more flexible chain depins through a transition with a wider core and shorter creep tails.

The foot of the transition is likewise stable once the estimator is well posed. Over N=50N = 50 to 200 the low-end threshold Fc(10%)F_c(10\%) varies by at most a factor of 1.3, and at B=35B = 35 mT, where each point rests on 220 runs, it is constant to 1%: Fc(10%)=0.0205F_c(10\%) = 0.0205, 0.0205 and 0.0204 at N=50N = 50, 100 and 200. The strong apparent drift of the foot with NN reported for shorter chains is an artifact of reading the 10% level inside the creep valley.

Internal structure of the chain

Figure 1 shows the chain in the three regimes directly: locally straight and pinned at F=0.005F = 0.005, rough and transiently stretched inside the crossover at F=0.02F = 0.02, and compact again in free flow at F=0.2F = 0.2. As noted earlier, the chain outside the pinned creep regime is straight. In the pinned regime, the chain remains essentially straight with RgR_g equal to its straight-chain value as seen in Figure 2(d). At the crossover, RgR_g peaks transiently above the straight-line reference, signaling internal stretching driven by the inhomogeneous drag of the landscape with sections that have cleared a pin advancing while sections that remain trapped lag behind, so that the bonds connecting them stretch beyond reqr_{\mathrm{eq}}. The peak excursion is largest at B=40B = 40 mT (20%), where the binding is weakest, but does not order monotonically with field (12% and 8% at 30 and 35 mT), see Sec. III A. The microscopic content of this stretching is captured by the Larkin correlation length LcL_c and the roughness exponent ζ\zeta. Results for these parameters are shown in Figure 4(a) and (b), respectively. In the pinned regime LcL_c sits at an intrinsic value of ≈4\approx4 bonds at every field. At the crossover this value rises sharply to a peak at F≈0.02F \approx0.02, reaching 17.7±2.417.7 \pm2.4, 17.8±2.317.8 \pm2.3 and 16.4±1.816.4 \pm1.8 bonds at B=30B = 30, 35 and 40 mT (standard error over disorder realizations), and then relaxes in the flow regime to 10–12 bonds, well above the pinned-regime value: in free flow the chain is smooth on the scale of the pin spacing, so transverse correlations extend further than in the pinned state. The roughness exponent behaves similarly, rising from ζ≈0.56\zeta\approx0.56–0.57 in the pinned regime to a peak ζ≈0.88\zeta\approx0.88–0.89 at F≈0.02F \approx0.02–0.05, and settling at 0.61–0.71 in free flow.

Figure 4. Internal structure of the chain at the three fields (N=200N = 200). (a) Larkin correlation length LcL_c versus drive: an intrinsic ≈4\approx4 bonds in the pinned regime, a sharp peak at F≈0.02F \approx0.02, and relaxation in free flow. (b) Roughness exponent ζ\zeta, peaking in the same FF window. (c) Intact-bond fraction fintactf_{\mathrm{intact}}, dipping deeply in the same window (minima 0.48, 0.37, 0.28 at B=30B = 30, 35, 40 mT) and recovering toward unity in free flow; the dotted line marks fintact=0.95f_{\mathrm{intact}} = 0.95. (d) Largest bond stretch rmax⁡/reqr_{\max}/r_{\mathrm{eq}} in the chain; dotted line rdissr_{\mathrm{diss}}, dashed line 3req3r_{\mathrm{eq}}. All quantities are averaged over the second half of the recorded configurations, after the chain has left its straight initial condition, and over eleven disorder realizations (error bars: standard error). All four signal that the chain deforms internally before recovering macroscopic mobility.

The intact-bond fraction fintactf_{\mathrm{intact}} [Fig. 4(c)] quantifies how the chain restructures. In the pinned regime thermal stretching keeps fintactf_{\mathrm{intact}} at approximately 0.95–0.97. On approach to the transition fintactf_{\mathrm{intact}} falls below 0.95 at F≈0.005F \approx0.005–0.007, which is before the mobility midpoint, and reaches a deep minimum at F=0.05F = 0.05, inside the crossover window, where fintactmin⁡=0.48±0.02f_{\mathrm{intact}}^{\min} = 0.48 \pm0.02, 0.37±0.010.37 \pm0.01 and 0.28±0.020.28 \pm0.02 at B=30B = 30, 35, and 40 mT. The largest bond in the chain, averaged over realizations, reaches 7.5, 9.7 and 13 reqr_{\mathrm{eq}} at the same drive [Fig. 4(d)], with individual configurations reaching 11, 15 and 23 reqr_{\mathrm{eq}}; at these separations the bi-exponential attraction is negligible, so the pair is held together only by the fixed bond topology of the model, and it is the loss of the differential drag in free flow, not the bond force, that brings the two sections back together. As discussed earlier, this means that a large fraction of the bonds are stretched beyond the maximum restoring force distance during depinning but the pinning parameters used in the simulations are such that motion across a pinning site is still possible due to interactions between skyrmions. Thus fintactf_{\mathrm{intact}} recovers toward unity in the free flow regime, fintact=0.99f_{\mathrm{intact}} = 0.99, 0.98 and 0.94 at F=1F = 1 for B=30B = 30, 35 and 40 mT, with the largest bond still at 1.7–2.6 reqr_{\mathrm{eq}}. The depinning of the chain is not a rigid-object process but proceeds through massive bond deformation which is most pronounced at higher fields where the binding is weakest.

The movie included as Supplemental Material [22] makes this sequence directly visible. It follows a single disorder realization of the N=200N = 200 chain at B=35B = 35 mT through the three regimes, at F=0.005F = 0.005, 0.05 (the minimum of fintactf_{\mathrm{intact}}) and 1, i.e. deeper into the crossover and into free flow than the snapshots of Figure 1: in the pinned regime the chain is locally straight and only a handful of bonds (7 of 200 in the frames shown) exceed rdissr_{\mathrm{diss}}; inside the crossover window the chain develops large transverse excursions and more than half of the bonds (114 of 200) are simultaneously stretched beyond rdissr_{\mathrm{diss}}; in free flow the compact, locally straight conformation is recovered and the count returns to a few bonds (4 of 200). The chain retains its connectivity throughout — the bond list is topological and fixed — so that the deep excursion of fintactf_{\mathrm{intact}} registers transient, reversible stretching rather than permanent fragmentation.

All three structural observables peak (or dip) in the same FF window and ahead of the midpoint of the mobility rise and of the Hall-angle recovery. The chain deforms first and recovers once it is finally depinned. The intrinsic LcL_c and the peak ζ\zeta are field-independent, and the peak LcL_c is the same at the three fields within its uncertainty (≈2\approx2 bonds).

Temperature dependence

The width that survives at every chain length must have a source other than the chain length. We test the thermal part of it directly by repeating the scan at fixed landscape (B=35B = 35 mT, chain length N=200N = 200) at two further temperatures, T=210T = 210 and 510 K, bracketing the reference T=300T = 300 K; in reduced units these correspond to kBT/V0=0.094k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0 = 0.094, 0.135 and 0.229. Figure 5(a) shows the mobility curves at N=200N = 200.

Figure 5. Temperature dependence of the depinning transition at fixed landscape (B=35B = 35 mT, chain N=200N = 200). (a) Mobility ratio versus drive at T=210T = 210, 300 and 510 K (kBT/V0=0.094k_\mathrm{B}T/V_0 = 0.094, 0.135, 0.229); dotted and dashed lines mark the 10%, 50% and 90% levels. As TT increases the creep foot lifts and the transition shifts to lower drive. (b) Operational thresholds Fc(10%)F_\mathrm{c}(10\%), Fc(50%)F_\mathrm{c}(50\%) and Fc(90%)F_\mathrm{c}(90\%) versus kBT/V0k_\mathrm{B}T/V_0. The foot Fc(10%)F_\mathrm{c}(10\%) drops fastest and falls below the accessible drive window at T=510T = 510 K (arrow), while the center and the upper end shift only mildly; the widening separation between foot and shoulder is the thermal growth of the residual width ww.

Two effects are visible. First, the 50% threshold decreases monotonically with temperature, with Fc(50)=0.0393F_{\mathrm{c}}^{(50)} = 0.0393, 0.0354 and 0.0237 at T=210T = 210, 300 and 510 K, as thermal activation assists the chain over the pins.

The second point, which is central to the interpretation of the residual width, is seen from Figure 5(b). Between 210 and 300 K the transition shifts almost rigidly: the foot drops from Fc(10%)=0.0225F_{\mathrm{c}}(10\%) = 0.0225 to 0.0204 and the center from Fc(50%)=0.0393F_{\mathrm{c}}(50\%) = 0.0393 to 0.0354, by 9% and 10% respectively, while Fc(90%)F_{\mathrm{c}}(90\%) changes by less than 8%. The rounding from below becomes visible only at the highest temperature: at T=510T = 510 K the creep valley no longer descends below μeff/μfree≈0.24\mu_{\mathrm{eff}}/\mu_{\mathrm{free}} \approx0.24, so the 10% mark is never crossed and the foot lies below our force window altogether, while the center has moved by only a further factor of 1.5.

The width therefore grows with kBT/V0k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0, as expected for a thermally rounded transition, but not uniformly: w=0.62w = 0.62 and 0.63 decades at T=210T = 210 and 300 K, a difference at the level of our uncertainties, and w≈2.4w \approx2.4 decades at T=510T = 510 K, the last value a lower bound set by the foot falling below the accessible drive. The width is thus essentially unchanged over kBT/V0=0.094k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0 = 0.094–0.135 and grows by a factor of at least 3.8 by 0.229 (w≈2.4w \approx2.4 against 0.63). At that temperature the rounding is asymmetric, in that temperature affects the creep foot of the transition strongly while leaving the bulk threshold Fc(50)F_{\mathrm{c}}^{(50)} and the upper end only weakly shifted. The foot of the transition is therefore largely defined by thermally assisted depinning. How much of the residual width this accounts for is settled in Sec. III E, by setting the temperature to zero.

The athermal limit

The temperature scan above establishes that the residual width grows with kBT/V0k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0, but it cannot say how much of the width at room temperature is thermal, because even the coldest temperature reached still rounds the transition. We therefore repeated the size scan at T=0T = 0, with the Langevin term switched off and every other element of the protocol unchanged: same field B=35B = 35 mT, same landscape parameters, same force grid, same estimator.

At T=0T = 0 the mobility curve is qualitatively different [see Fig. 6(a)]. Below threshold the chain does not move at all, so μeff/μfree\mu_{\mathrm{eff}}/\mu_{\mathrm{free}} rises from exactly zero and the curve is monotonic in FF. The creep valley that complicates the 10% crossing at 300 K has no counterpart here, and the width is well defined at every chain length.

The width is again independent of NN. We measure w=0.330±0.016w = 0.330 \pm0.016, 0.331 ±\pm 0.007 and 0.335 ±\pm 0.005 decades at N=50N = 50, 100 and 200, each from the full set of 220 realization-force pairs, consistent with a constant

w(T=0)=0.334±0.004 decades,(7)w(T = 0) = 0.334 \pm0.004\ \text{decades}, \tag*{(7)}

with χ2/dof=0.11\chi^2/\mathrm{dof} = 0.11; the coefficient of a 1/N1/N term is −0.4±1.0-0.4 \pm1.0, consistent with zero. Against w(300 K)=0.633±0.002w(300\ \mathrm{K}) = 0.633 \pm0.002 at the same field, Figure 6(b), the ratio is 1.90 ±\pm 0.02. Finite temperature therefore accounts for 47% of the rounding at room temperature, and an athermal mechanism accounts for the remainder.

Whether that width belongs to the ensemble or to a single sample can be settled directly, because at T=0T = 0 each disorder realization is deterministic. Measuring ww from the mobility curve of each realization on its own, and comparing with the width of the ensemble-averaged

NNww, single realizationww, ensemble average
500.316±0.0440.316 \pm0.0440.331
1000.325±0.0300.325 \pm0.0300.333
2000.332±0.0230.332 \pm0.0230.336

Table 3. Athermal (T=0T = 0) transition width at B=35B = 35 mT, measured within a single disorder realization and from the ensemble-averaged mobility curve. The quoted spread is over the eleven realizations.

curve, gives Table III.

The two columns of Table III agree. The width does not arise from averaging over landscapes: it is already present in one of them, and it would not narrow if the number of realizations were increased without bound.

The part that does come from the ensemble is small. Treating the two contributions as adding in quadrature, the ensemble part is 0.10, 0.07 and 0.05 decades at N=50N = 50, 100 and 200, while the intrinsic part is unchanged at 0.32–0.33. Each of these ensemble values is compatible with zero once the spread over realizations is propagated, so we quote them as upper bounds, consistent with but not by themselves establishing the N−1/2N^{-1/2} decay expected from self-averaging. Self-averaging is seen directly, and with significance, in the position of the transition: the scatter σ(Fc(50))/Fc(50)\sigma(F_{\mathrm{c}}^{(50)})/F_{\mathrm{c}}^{(50)} falls from 4.8% to 2.8% over the same range. The chain does self-average; what self-averages is where the transition sits, not how wide it is.

The split depends on where the thresholds are placed, since the two curves are not related by a simple rescaling: measured between 20% and 80% the thermal share is 59%, and between 30% and 70% it is 61%. The qualitative statement, that the rounding is roughly half thermal, is stable across these choices; the value quoted above refers to the 10%–90% definition used throughout this work.

The athermal regime has a microscopic signature as well. We extract the Larkin correlation length in the pinned regime from the correlation of transverse displacements along the chain, C(d)=⟨uiui+d⟩/⟨ui2⟩C(d) = \langle u_i u_{i+d}\rangle/\langle u_i^2\rangle with uiu_i measured from the chain mean, taking LcL_\mathrm{c} as the separation at which CC falls to 1/e1/e. This is the estimator used for Figure 4(a). Repeating it at fixed drive in the pinned regime (F≤0.005F \le0.005) while varying the temperature yields Figure 6(c). Up to 87 K (kBT/V0=0.039k_\mathrm{B}T/V_0 = 0.039) LcL_\mathrm{c} does not respond to temperature: five points from T=0T = 0 to 87 K agree on 2.56±0.032.56 \pm0.03 bonds. From 145 K upward it grows linearly, reaching 4.29±0.084.29 \pm0.08 at room temperature; the linear fit meets the plateau at kBT/V0≈0.03k_\mathrm{B}T/V_0 \approx0.03 (≈60\approx60 K), and the first point that lies clearly above the plateau is at kBT/V0=0.065k_\mathrm{B}T/V_0 = 0.065 (145 K), so the onset of the thermal response lies between kBT/V0≈0.03k_\mathrm{B}T/V_0 \approx0.03 and 0.065. The temperature scan of Sec. III D lies entirely above this threshold, at kBT/V0=0.094k_\mathrm{B}T/V_0 = 0.094, 0.135 and 0.229, and so could not have seen the flat region.

The two observations are consistent with one another. The width that survives at T=0T = 0 and the correlation length that stops responding to temperature describe the same athermal regime, in which the chain conformation is set by the landscape and not by thermal fluctuations. The chain has an intrinsic correlation length of about two and a half bonds that disorder alone imposes; temperature lengthens it only once kBTk_\mathrm{B}T reaches roughly a twenty-fifth of the well depth, kBT/V0≈0.039k_\mathrm{B}T/V_0 \approx0.039.

It is worth being precise about what is sharp at T=0T = 0 and what is not. The onset of motion is sharp. At F≤0.02F \le0.02 the N=200N = 200 chain advances by less than 0.02 nm over the entire run, a thousandth of a bond length, whereas at F=0.035F = 0.035 it covers 26 nm, more than one bond: a factor of 10310^3 in displacement across one step of the drive grid. Below onset the chain is genuinely static, as it must be in the absence of thermal activation.

What is not sharp is the recovery of mobility above onset. Between the 10% and 90% marks the drive changes by 0.33 decades within a single landscape, because segments that have cleared their pins are held back by segments that have not, and free flow is reached only when the last of them lets go. The athermal width measures that internal process rather than the threshold itself, which is why it is a property of one sample and why lengthening the chain does not reduce it. Thermal activation at 300 K roughly doubles it.

Discussion

The one-third reduction of the depinning threshold, Eq. (6), is a sizable and experimentally relevant effect. In a device that drives skyrmions through a disordered track, organizing the carriers into a chain rather than moving them as isolated textures lowers the threshold drive by a factor of three, with corresponding savings in dissipation. The size scan presented here shows that the effect is not a feature of a particular chain length but is instead a property of the collective elastic regime, valid already at N=50N = 50. The robustness of the ratio across B=30B = 30–40 mT, where the damping varies by more than a factor of two, further establishes that this is a structural, geometry-driven effect, not tied to the specific dissipation parameters of the texture.

A quantitative account of the value 1/31/3 follows from collective (Larkin) pinning [10], provided the two reference forces are correctly identified. The drive is a force per unit length of the chain. Within one Larkin domain of LcL_\mathrm{c} bonds the pinning forces add incoherently, so the collective threshold per skyrmion is Fcchain∼frms/LcF_\mathrm{c}^{\mathrm{chain}} \sim f_\mathrm{rms}/\sqrt{L_\mathrm{c}}, with frms=V0ηpin/σf_\mathrm{rms} = V_0\sqrt{\eta_\mathrm{pin}/\sigma} the r.m.s. pinning force per skyrmion set by the Gaussian wells. Standard Larkin scaling with both thresholds referenced to this same r.m.s. force would therefore give Fcchain/Fc(1)=1/Lc=0.5F_c^{\mathrm{chain}}/F_c^{(1)} = 1/\sqrt{L_c} = 0.5 for the measured Lc≈4L_c \approx4.

The measured single-skyrmion threshold, however, is not set by frmsf_{\mathrm{rms}}. The isolated skyrmion cannot avoid the strongest pins at this coverage and depins at the peak force of a single Gaussian pin, Fc(1)≃fpin=e−1/2V0/σF_c^{(1)} \simeq f_{\mathrm{pin}} = e^{-1/2}V_0/\sigma (the maximum gradient of the well), reproducing the measured Fc(1)F_c^{(1)} of Table Table II to better than 8% at the three fields and exceeding the r.m.s. force by fpin/frms=e−1/2/ηpin≈1.8f_{\mathrm{pin}}/f_{\mathrm{rms}} = e^{-1/2}/\sqrt{\eta_{\mathrm{pin}}} \approx1.8 at our coverage ηpin≈0.118\eta_{\mathrm{pin}} \approx0.118. Using the appropriate reference for each object, r.m.s. for the chain and peak for the single skyrmion, the ratio is

FcchainFc(1)=frmsfpinLc=ηpine−1/2Lc,(8)\frac{F_c^{\mathrm{chain}}}{F_c^{(1)}} = \frac{f_{\mathrm{rms}}}{f_{\mathrm{pin}}\sqrt{L_c}} = \frac{\sqrt{\eta_{\mathrm{pin}}}}{e^{-1/2}\sqrt{L_c}}, \tag*{(8)}

where the collective advantage is coverage\sqrt{\text{coverage}} over Larkin length\sqrt{\text{Larkin length}}: numerically 0.5/1.8≈0.280.5/1.8 \approx0.28 at all three fields, matching the measured 0.279, 0.273 and 0.273. The independence from magnetic field follows because ηpin\eta_{\mathrm{pin}} is fixed by construction and LcL_c is measured to be field-independent.

The T=0T = 0 data test the two halves of this account separately, since LcL_c and both thresholds are measured there as well. The collective half survives. With Lc=2.56L_c = 2.56 bonds at T=0T = 0 against 4.29 at 300 K, frms/Lcf_{\mathrm{rms}}/\sqrt{L_c} predicts Fcchain=0.045F_c^{\mathrm{chain}} = 0.045 and 0.035 respectively, against measured 0.0524 ±\pm 0.0003 and 0.0354 ±\pm 0.0001: ratios of 1.17 and 1.02. Both fall within the O(1/Lc)O(1/L_c) uncertainty discussed below, and the prediction tracks LcL_c as it changes by a factor of 1.7. The collective-pinning estimate is therefore verified at two temperatures rather than fitted at one.

The single-skyrmion reference does not survive. By construction fpinf_{\mathrm{pin}} contains no temperature, and it cannot describe a threshold that doubles when the temperature is set to zero: we measure Fc(1)=0.2588−0.0028+0.0034F_c^{(1)} = 0.2588^{+0.0034}_{-0.0028} at T=0T = 0 against 0.1295 ±\pm 0.0030 at 300 K, that is 2.04 and 1.02 times fpinf_{\mathrm{pin}}. At this coverage the wells overlap, and the deepest composite traps are stronger than any single Gaussian; at T=0T = 0 the isolated skyrmion needs nearly twice the single-pin peak force to escape one, while at 300 K thermal activation brings the threshold back down to fpinf_{\mathrm{pin}}. The agreement at room temperature is thus a coincidence and not a mechanism, and Eq. (8) should be read as accounting for the collective side of the ratio alone.

The ratio itself moves accordingly, from 0.273 ±\pm 0.006 at 300 K to 0.203 ±\pm 0.003 at T=0T = 0. The collective advantage grows on cooling, because thermal activation lowers the isolated-skyrmion threshold by a factor of 2.0 and the chain threshold by only 1.5: a single skyrmion depends on thermal escape from one deep trap, whereas the chain already has a second route, redistributing force along its length, and gains less from being heated.

Three caveats justify a cautious reading of this agreement. The first is the one just described: the single-skyrmion reference is temperature-dependent in a way fpinf_{\mathrm{pin}} is not. Second, the collective-pinning account agrees with mean field only when Lc≫1L_c \gg1. By this measure, Lc≈4L_c \approx4 is not that large, so our estimate carries an O(1/Lc)∼25%\mathcal{O}(1/L_c) \sim25\% uncertainty. Third, there is an order-unity ambiguity in projecting the two-dimensional pinning force onto the drive direction. Using the drive-component variance w2/2w^2/2 in place of the full variance lowers Eq. (8) to ≈0.20\approx0.20. Within these uncertainties we present Eq. (8) as accounting for the magnitude (≈1/3\approx1/3) and for the field-independence of the measured ratio, rather than as a precise prediction. The marginality of LcL_c is itself consistent with the beyond-mean-field roughness ζ≈0.63\zeta\approx0.63 (qKPZ) discussed below, which no mean-field estimate reproduces.

Two distinct sources of rounding contribute to the transition, and the T=0T = 0 comparison of Sec. III E separates them; the size scan rules out a third. One might expect the longest-wavelength modes of the chain, whose wavelengths scale with NN, to raise the depinning probability and so narrow the transition as the chain is lengthened. No such narrowing is observed: the width is flat from N=50N = 50 to N=200N = 200, and the coefficient of a 1/N1/N term is consistent with zero. The rounding therefore cannot be attributed to finite-size modes at all, and must come from sources that do not scale with NN: thermal activation over the pins [14, 15], and the athermal, single-realization mechanism of Sec. III E. The thermal energy in our simulations, kBT/V0=0.13k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0 = 0.13–0.140.14 at the three fields, is not negligible compared to the pin depth, and the resulting thermal activation rounds the transition even in the absence of finite-size effects. The width is not, however, independent of the applied field: as shown in Sec. III B, the core of the transition widens by 26% between B=30B = 30 and 40 mT while kBT/V0k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0 changes by only 5%. That field dependence is therefore not thermal in origin, and it is separate from the attribution made here, which concerns the rounding that survives at fixed field. We test this directly in Sec. III D by a temperature scan at fixed landscape (Figure 5). The width grows monotonically with kBT/V0k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0, with the rounding concentrated on the creep foot of the transition, which smears below the accessible drive at T=510T = 510 K while the bulk threshold Fc(50)F_{\mathrm{c}}^{(50)} shifts only mildly. The T=0T = 0 scan of Sec. III E completes the accounting, showing that this thermal contribution is roughly half of the room-temperature width.

A consequence is that the classic critical depinning of an infinite elastic line [11, 12], with a sharp FcF_{\mathrm{c}} and a power-law v∼(F−Fc)βv \sim(F - F_{\mathrm{c}})^\beta, is not realized here. Fits to v=A(F−Fc)βv = A(F-F_{\mathrm{c}})^\beta on the chain force the threshold Fc→0F_{\mathrm{c}} \to0 at every length NN and at every field BB, suggesting that the depinning is a rounded crossover between two linear-mobility regimes (pinned with μpinned≈0.02\mu_{\mathrm{pinned}} \approx0.02–0.04 μfree0.04\,\mu_{\mathrm{free}} and free with μfree\mu_{\mathrm{free}}), not a critical jump. The finite value of ww is the quantitative statement of this. In the flow regime, the measured roughness exponent is ζ≈0.61\zeta\approx0.61–0.710.71 (with the fit window between 2 and 8 bond lengths), consistent with the quenched-KPZ value ζqKPZ≃0.63\zeta_{\mathrm{qKPZ}} \simeq0.63 in d=1d = 1 [25, 26] and clearly below the quenched-Edwards-Wilkinson depinning value ζQEW≃1.25\zeta_{\mathrm{QEW}} \simeq1.25 [26]. The transient peak ζ≈0.88\zeta\approx0.88–0.890.89 inside the crossover window belongs to neither class. It characterizes the strongly inhomogeneous, partially depinned state and we do not assign it a universality class. We note that the accessible scaling window is limited, since LcL_c reaches up to 17 bonds on a chain of 200, and shifting the fit window by one bond at either end moves the quoted exponents by up to ±0.1\pm0.1.

The NN-independence of the bulk threshold Fc(50)F_{\mathrm{c}}^{(50)}, together with its weak field dependence (Fc(50)F_{\mathrm{c}}^{(50)} varies from 0.032 at B=30B = 30 to 0.039 at B=40B = 40, a change of ≈20%\approx20\%), has a simple physical interpretation. As with polymers, the relevant barrier for depinning is set by local properties of the skyrmion chain. These properties are governed by the bond energy, which determines reqr_{\mathrm{eq}}; by the bending stiffness κWLC\kappa_{\mathrm{WLC}}; and by the dimensionless landscape parameters V0/DeV_0/D_{\mathrm{e}}, σ/req\sigma/r_{\mathrm{eq}} and the coverage. These are independent of the chain length. The mild dependence of Fc(50)F_{\mathrm{c}}^{(50)} on BB reflects the slight dependence of these local parameters on BB. The universal one-third ratio reflects the fact that the same local parameters dictate both the chain and the isolated skyrmion thresholds proportionally.

Finally, our results do not explore the deep creep regime F≪FcF \ll F_{\mathrm{c}}. The classical creep law for a one-dimensional elastic line, v∼exp⁡[−(Uc/kBT)(Fc/F)μ]v \sim\exp[-(U_{\mathrm{c}}/k_{\mathrm{B}}T)(F_{\mathrm{c}}/F)^\mu] with μ=(2ζeq+d−2)/(2−ζeq)=1/4\mu= (2\zeta_{\mathrm{eq}} + d - 2)/(2-\zeta_{\mathrm{eq}}) = 1/4 in d=1d = 1 [13, 15], is derived under the assumption of harmonic elasticity. In a separate work [16] we have shown that the transverse confinement of a skyrmion within the chain is quartic rather than harmonic such that a small transverse displacement changes the bond length only at second order, so the harmonic radial stiffness of the bi-exponential bond generates a quartic transverse potential and a scale-dependent thermal exponent. Since the equilibrium roughness ζeq\zeta_{\mathrm{eq}}, and hence the creep exponent μ\mu, are derived from the harmonic elastic energy, the quartic transverse confinement of the skyrmion polymer raises the possibility of an anomalous creep law, with an exponent distinct from the universal μ=1/4\mu= 1/4 of harmonic interfaces. This question is taken up in companion work on the same calibration [17], which finds that thermal fluctuations generate an effective tension out of the quartic term, so that the equilibrium exponents of the disordered line, and with them the creep exponent, return to their harmonic values; the creep regime itself is shown there to be inaccessible to direct dynamics, for reasons of aging that lie outside the scope of the present study.

Conclusion

We have shown, by stochastic Thiele simulations with an atomistically derived bi-exponential interaction and periodic boundary conditions along the chain contour, that an elastic chain of magnetic skyrmions depins collectively at a drive that is close to one third of the single-skyrmion threshold, and that this ratio is (i) a property of the bulk collective regime, valid already at N=50N = 50 and constant through N=200N = 200, and (ii) robust against the applied magnetic field over B=30B = 30–4040 mT. The depinning is a rounded crossover that proceeds, at N=200N = 200, through a sequence of internal events that begin with an internal deformation characterized by the Larkin length, the roughness exponent and the bond-survival fraction. This is followed by mobility recovery and Hall-angle recovery as the drive is increased. The width of the transition does not depend on NN over the range studied, so the rounding is not of finite-size origin. Repeating the size scan at T=0T = 0 separates the two contributions to it directly: the athermal limit retains w(T=0)=0.334±0.004w(T = 0) = 0.334 \pm0.004 decades, so finite temperature (kBT/V0∼0.1k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0 \sim0.1) accounts for approximately half of the residual rounding and an athermal mechanism accounts for the other half. The same athermal regime is visible in the chain conformation: the Larkin correlation length in the pinned state is 2.56±0.032.56 \pm0.03 bonds and does not respond to temperature up to kBT/V0=0.039k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0 = 0.039 (87 K), growing linearly only above a knee at kBT/V0≈0.03k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0 \approx0.03–0.060.06. The onset of motion is nevertheless sharp: below it the chain advances by less than a thousandth of a bond length over an entire run, as it must in the absence of thermal activation. What the athermal width measures is not that onset but the range of drive over which mobility recovers afterwards, and that range belongs to a single disorder realization rather than to the ensemble.

The width does depend on the applied field, though not as a simple scale. Between B=30B = 30 and 40 mT the core of the transition widens by 26% while its creep tails shorten, so that widths read between different threshold pairs rank the three fields differently; the ratio w10–90/w20–80w_{10\text{–}90}/w_{20\text{–}80} falls monotonically from 1.87 to 1.39. Over the same range kBT/V0k_{\mathrm{B}}T/V_0 changes by only 5% while the damping falls by a factor of 2.4, so this is a change in the shape of the transition driven by the dynamics rather than by the thermal scale.

Finally, the two temperatures test the collective-pinning account of the one-third ratio separately in its two halves. The collective side survives: frms/Lcf_{\mathrm{rms}}/\sqrt{L_c} predicts the chain threshold to within 17% at T=0T = 0 and 2% at 300 K while LcL_c itself changes by a factor of 1.7. The single-skyrmion reference does not: an isolated skyrmion needs 2.04 times the peak force of one Gaussian well at T=0T = 0 against 1.02 times at 300 K, so the agreement of that reference at room temperature is a coincidence. The measured ratio moves from 0.273 to 0.203 on cooling, the collective advantage growing because thermal activation assists an isolated skyrmion more than it assists the chain. These results establish collective elasticity as a practical route to reducing the depinning threshold in devices using skyrmion chains, with a threshold reduction by a factor of three that is robust against the chain length and the operating field.

Data availability

The data that support the findings of this article are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Acknowledgments

R. L. Silva and R. C. Silva acknowledge financial support from CNPq and FAPES (Grant No. T01034/2025). R. L. Stamps acknowledges support from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (RGPIN 05011-18).

References

  1. [1]N. Nagaosa and Y. Tokura, Topological properties and dynamics of magnetic skyrmions, Nat. Nanotechnol. 8, 899 (2013).DOI
  2. [2]A. Fert, N. Reyren, and V. Cros, Magnetic skyrmions: advances in physics and potential applications, Nat. Rev. Mater. 2, 17031 (2017).DOI
  3. [3]S. Woo et al., Observation of room-temperature magnetic skyrmions and their current-driven dynamics in ultrathin metallic ferromagnets, Nat. Mater. 15, 501 (2016).
  4. [4]C. Moreau-Luchaire et al., Additive interfacial chiral interaction in multilayers for stabilization of small individual skyrmions at room temperature, Nat. Nanotechnol. 11, 444 (2016).
  5. [5]C. Reichhardt, D. Ray, and C. J. Olson Reichhardt, Collective transport properties of driven skyrmions with random disorder, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 217202 (2015).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26066455
  6. [6]C. Reichhardt, C. J. O. Reichhardt, and M. V. Milošević, Statics and dynamics of skyrmions interacting with disorder and nanostructures, Rev. Mod. Phys. 94, 035005 (2022).DOI
  7. [7]S.-Z. Lin, C. Reichhardt, C. D. Batista, and A. Saxena, Particle model for skyrmions in metallic chiral magnets: dynamics, pinning, and creep, Phys. Rev. B 87, 214419 (2013).
  8. [8]C. Reichhardt and C. J. Olson Reichhardt, Depinning and nonequilibrium dynamic phases of particle assemblies driven over random and ordered substrates: a review, Rep. Prog. Phys. 80, 026501 (2017).DOI
  9. [9]J. Iwasaki, M. Mochizuki, and N. Nagaosa, Universal current-velocity relation of skyrmion motion in chiral magnets, Nat. Commun. 4, 1463 (2013).
  10. [10]A. I. Larkin and Yu. N. Ovchinnikov, Pinning in type II superconductors, J. Low Temp. Phys. 34, 409 (1979).
  11. [11]D. S. Fisher, Sliding charge-density waves as a dynamical phenomenon, Phys. Rev. B 31, 1396 (1985).
  12. [12]O. Narayan and D. S. Fisher, Threshold critical dynamics of driven interfaces in random media, Phys. Rev. B 48, 7030 (1993).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10006872
  13. [13]A. B. Kolton, A. Rosso, T. Giamarchi, and W. Krauth, Creep dynamics of elastic manifolds via exact transition pathways, Phys. Rev. B 79, 064206 (2009).DOI
  14. [14]S. Bustingorry, A. B. Kolton, and T. Giamarchi, Thermal rounding of the depinning transition, Europhys. Lett. 81, 26005 (2008).
  15. [15]Chauve, T. Giamarchi, and P. Le Doussal, Creep and depinning in disordered media, Phys. Rev. B 62, 6241 (2000).DOI
  16. [16]R. L. Silva, R. C. Silva, and R. L. Stamps, Scale-dependent universality class crossover in magnetic skyrmion polymers, arXiv:2607.26289 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2607.26289
  17. [17]R. L. Silva, R. C. Silva, and R. L. Stamps, Thermally emergent tension in a quartic elastic line, and the aging limit on measuring its creep: a driven magnetic skyrmion chain (companion paper, to be submitted).
  18. [18]A. A. Thiele, Steady-state motion of magnetic domains, Phys. Rev. Lett. 30, 230 (1973).DOI
  19. [19]K. Everschor, M. Garst, R. A. Duine, and A. Rosch, Current-induced rotational torques in the skyrmion lattice phase of chiral magnets, Phys. Rev. B 84, 064401 (2011).DOI
  20. [20]S. Rohart and A. Thiaville, Skyrmion confinement in ultrathin film nanostructures in the presence of Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction, Phys. Rev. B 88, 184422 (2013).DOI
  21. [21]P. F. Bessarab, V. M. Uzdin, and H. Jónsson, Method for finding mechanism and activation energy of magnetic transitions, applied to skyrmion and antivortex annihilation, Comput. Phys. Commun. 196, 335 (2015).DOI
  22. [22]See Supplemental Material at [URL will be inserted by publisher] for [Movie 1 (chain_rupture_reconnection_B35_N200.mp4), which shows the internal deformation of the N = 200 chain at B = 35 mT in the pinned (F = 0.005), crossover (F = 0.05), and free-flow (F = 1) regimes, with the bonds colored by their local stretch r/r_eq and those exceeding r_diss marked explicitly.
  23. [23]W. Jiang et al., Direct observation of the skyrmion Hall effect, Nat. Phys. 13, 162 (2017).DOI
  24. [24]K. Litzius et al., Skyrmion Hall effect revealed by direct time-resolved X-ray microscopy, Nat. Phys. 13, 170 (2017).DOI
  25. [25]L.-H. Tang and H. Leschhorn, Pinning by directed percolation, Phys. Rev. A 45, R8309 (1992).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9907009
  26. [26]H. Leschhorn, Interface depinning in a disordered medium: numerical results, Physica A 195, 324 (1993).

Paper details

vlnc:W_gwa3vnby
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 1

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents