WorksMathematics
Cofinite derivative zeros at the order-one threshold
Abstract
We give a complete probabilistic construction of a transcendental entire function for which every nonempty open set contains a zero of every sufficiently high derivative. The construction has , hence order exactly one and infinite exponential type. No transcendental entire function of finite exponential type can have this zero property. We also establish a local limiting zero-counting measure for the constructed derivatives. The original existence assertion has prior solution claims, including Eric Hou's preprint. The order-one construction and growth obstruction are the proposed strengthening.
Problem, scope, and attribution
The prize catalogue lists JSP-000752 as Open on the source snapshot read on October 4, 2026 [1]. It asks for an entire function with dense derivative zero sets along every infinite subsequence of derivative orders. The natural, nontrivial interpretation requires a transcendental entire function: a nonzero polynomial would satisfy the literal version because all sufficiently high derivatives vanish identically. This is Erdős Problem 906 in Bloom’s database [3].
The prize rules permit a complete mathematical solution to be supplied before Lean formalization [2]. Its catalogue flag “Eligible to claim” has a different meaning: an award claim requires both an accepted mathematical solution and verified formalization. This manuscript supplies mathematical proof evidence for review; no award entitlement or maintainer acceptance is asserted.
The bounded random-series and zero-free-disk framework has a clear precedent in Hou [4], whose stated construction has order two. Earlier probabilistic proposals are linked in the discussion of Problem 906 [3]. The existence answer itself is therefore not claimed as a new breakthrough. The construction below replaces the Fock weights with slowly increasing derivative weights and proves a stronger growth conclusion. It uses an inverse-amplitude moment and Jensen’s inequality; no Laguerre asymptotics or external random-zero concentration theorem is needed. The order-one strengthening was not located in the cited prior sources; this is not a claim of verified first-discovery priority.
Write and . The zero property we will prove is
All derivative orders are nonnegative integers.
Lemma 1 (The required quantifier). An entire function has property (C) if and only if the union of the zero sets of is dense for every strictly increasing sequence of derivative orders.
Proof. If (C) holds, every such sequence eventually exceeds , so the union meets each nonempty open . Conversely, if (C) fails for one , infinitely many derivative orders have no zero in . Enumerating those orders gives a strictly increasing sequence whose union of zero sets misses .
A sharp order threshold
Theorem 2. There is a transcendental entire function with property (C) such that
It has order exactly one and infinite exponential type. Moreover, no transcendental entire function satisfying (C) has finite exponential type. Thus one is the smallest possible order, and this order is attained.
Finite exponential type here means that for some finite and all . The usual order is .
Proposition 3 (Finite exponential type is impossible). A transcendental entire function of finite exponential type cannot satisfy (C).
Proof. Suppose with . Fix , and let
If (C) holds, for all choose with . The line segment from to any in the closed disk lies in that disk. The fundamental theorem of calculus along this segment gives
Consequently
The factor is strictly positive, since a derivative of a transcendental entire function is not identically zero. Cauchy’s estimate on a circle of radius about , , gives
Take and use . For this yields
Choosing contradicts (3)–(4), because .
The weighted random entire function
Set and, for , define
Define and for . Let be independent random variables, each uniformly distributed with respect to area on the closed unit disk. Our entire function is
These are genuine random complex coefficients; the probabilistic argument extracts one deterministic sample at the end.
We will use only the following elementary facts about :
Indeed, for , , and the remaining limits follow from .
Lemma 4 (Normal convergence and deterministic growth). Every sample in (6) is entire. For all sufficiently large , uniformly over all samples,
Almost surely all Taylor coefficients are nonzero, so is transcendental almost surely.
Proof. Monotonicity gives . The elementary factorial bound gives
Thus the series converges normally on compact sets, uniformly in the bounded coefficients. The same is true after any fixed number of termwise differentiations.
For the growth bound put . For we have , so the sum of these absolute terms is at most . For , , and therefore
By (7), for all sufficiently large the last quantity is at most for every . The tail is at most , which is at most the preceding exponential bound. This proves (8). Finally each coefficient law is nonatomic, so for each . A countable union of null events still has probability zero.
Normalize the derivatives by
The empty product is one. Normalization does not change any zero set.
Lemma 5 (A uniform upper bound for a derivative). For every fixed , for all sufficiently large and all ,
In particular for .
Proof. For , all factors in are at most . These terms sum to at most . For , we have , hence
Since , for all sufficiently large the last quantity is at most simultaneously for every . The sum of these terms is . The last assertion uses .
One-coordinate anti-concentration
Lemma 6 (An inverse-amplitude moment). If is uniform on the unit disk, and , then
Proof. The first inequality follows by comparing areas: the preimage of the disk of radius has area at most in the unit disk. The layer-cake formula and this inequality give
Lemma 7 (A near-peak coefficient). For and ,
Consequently, if , the term with in (9) has coefficient satisfying
Proof. For , comparison with an integral gives
Thus
because , , and . Monotonicity of gives , proving the second assertion.
Lemma 8 (Uniform inverse moments on a compact set). For any , put . For every and ,
The value at is interpreted as .
Proof. If , choose as in Lemma 7 and condition on all coefficients except . The normally convergent series becomes , with fixed under this conditioning. Independence, Lemma 6, and Lemma 7 give
Integration removes the conditioning. If , condition instead on , whose coefficient in is one. The left side is then at most , which is no larger than the right side since . This includes .
Summable probabilities of zero-free disks
Lemma 9 (Strict circular gain). For and ,
Proof. Pair the angles and . The triangle inequality gives . For the inequality is strict on an interval of angles near a direction perpendicular to . For the assertion is immediate. Integrating proves strict positivity.
Fix and , put and , and let be the event that has no zero in . Define the nonnegative random variable
Tonelli’s theorem and (13) imply
On , is harmonic throughout , and therefore
Jensen’s inequality for the exponential, applied to (14), and (16) give
For all sufficiently large , Lemma 5 bounds the last term. Thus, on ,
Markov’s inequality, (15), and (17) now yield
for all sufficiently large . The second inequality uses and .
For every , (7) implies
For example, eventually and , so the summand is at most . Consequently the probabilities in (19) are summable. The first Borel–Cantelli lemma proves that, almost surely, only finitely many are zero-free in this fixed disk. No independence between different derivative orders is used.
For completeness the events above are measurable. Normal convergence makes jointly continuous when the sample space is the countable product of closed unit disks with its product topology. Zero-freeness on an open disk equals positivity of the minimum modulus on each of a countable increasing sequence of closed subdisks. Each minimum is a measurable function; it can also be computed as an infimum over a countable dense set. The nonnegative integrand in (14) is measurable, so Tonelli applies without any integrability assumption in advance.
Completion of Theorem 2. Take the countable family
Every nonempty open subset of contains a member of : choose a nonzero point in it, then a nearby rational complex center and a sufficiently small rational radius. The preceding Borel–Cantelli conclusion holds simultaneously for all disks in outside a countable union of null events. Intersect with the probability-one event on which all coefficients are nonzero. Choose a sample in this intersection. The resulting deterministic transcendental entire has (C); the quantifier lemma gives the original subsequence formulation as well.
Lemma 4 implies (1), since . Thus . Every entire function of order less than one has finite exponential type: choose , then eventually , and adjust a constant on the remaining compact disk. Proposition 3 therefore forces . It also rules out finite exponential type for our chosen function. This proves all assertions of the theorem.
A further check: limiting zero density
The same construction provides a quantitative version. This section is not needed for the existence proof above. Let be the locally finite measure that counts the zeros of , with multiplicities.
Theorem 10. For almost every sample in (6),
locally weakly as . The limiting measure has no atom at zero; its displayed density is locally integrable. In particular, for every fixed ,
Proof. For a fixed , write
The value at a zero causes no difficulty. Nonzero analytic functions have locally integrable logarithms. Moreover and Lemma 8 give
Jensen’s inequality for normalized area measure and Tonelli’s theorem imply
Hence, for every ,
These probabilities are summable by (20). Apply Borel–Cantelli for integer and positive rational to obtain, almost surely, on every compact disk. Set . Lemma 5 gives
uniformly for . The opposite part is exactly . Thus
For a nonzero analytic function , the elementary distributional identity
follows from local factorization at each zero and ; the nonvanishing local factor has harmonic log modulus. Therefore . Taking distributional Laplacians in (20) gives
For the last equality, away from zero the radial Laplacian is . Its flux through a circle of radius is , which tends to zero, so there is no delta mass at the origin.
Distributional convergence of these positive measures implies local weak convergence: a smooth compactly supported upper cutoff bounds their masses on any fixed compact set, and continuous test functions can then be uniformly approximated by smooth ones. Each disk boundary has zero limiting measure, so the masses of any fixed disk converge to the mass prescribed by the limit. Polar integration gives .
General weights and verification notes
The proof uses no special identity for (5). It works for any nondecreasing sequence with
using . The deterministic bound becomes eventually, and the limiting zero measure has normalization . For example, slowly varying factors growing more slowly than can replace that factor in (5), as long as the three displayed conditions hold. The exact least possible growth rate inside the order-one infinite-type class is not determined by this argument.
The main proof is analytic and has no numerical assumptions. An accompanying Python script checks the coefficient peak inequality and the derivative majorant at selected parameter values using high precision arithmetic. Those checks are sanity checks, not substitutes for the proof and not a Lean formalization.
AI assistance and authorship disclosure
Jensen Kohlmeyer (GitHub: JENW1N) and Liam Kruer (GitHub: lkruer) are the designated authors of this AI-assisted research manuscript. OpenAI Codex assisted with the mathematical construction, proof development, coefficient checks, literature comparison, and manuscript preparation. The public submission is made from the JENW1N account. No independent human verification or distinct individual author roles are asserted by this disclosure; attribution and correctness are submitted for review.
The principal points for independent review are the conditional inverse moment, the uniform tail estimate for all , and the summability for every positive disk-dependent constant. The full proof above addresses the original infinite-subsequence quantifier. It has no unproved mathematical premise. First-solution credit is expressly not claimed; novelty of the sharper growth statements remains unverified.
References
- [1]The Justin Sun Prize, problem JSP-000752, catalogue snapshot read October 4, 2026. https://github.com/TheJustinSunPrize/awards/blob/main/problems/catalog-0701–0800.md
- [2]The Justin Sun Prize, contribution guidelines, snapshot read October 4, 2026. https://github.com/TheJustinSunPrize/awards/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md
- [3]T. F. Bloom, Erdős Problem 906 and its discussion. https://www.erdosproblems.com/906 https://www.erdosproblems.com/forum/thread/906?embed=1
- [4]E. Hou, Cofinite Zeros of High Derivatives, arXiv:2607.20816, 2026. Version 3 and the author’s current repository manuscript were inspected for this draft. https://arxiv.org/html/2607.20816v3 https://github.com/erichou1/cofinite-derivative-zeros