betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

A boundary-only obstruction to four-dimensional disk embedding

Abstract

We disprove the four-dimensional disc embedding conjecture without a fundamental-group hypothesis, even when no homotopy classes or output framings are prescribed. We construct a compact oriented smooth four-manifold containing finitely many disc maps with framed algebraic dual spheres whose boundary circles bound no disjoint locally flat discs. Consequently, the free group on two generators is not good in the sense of Freedman–Quinn, and neither is any group containing it as a subgroup.

Introduction

The Whitney trick is the geometric step that turns algebraic cancellation of intersections into disjoint embedded surfaces. In dimension four, the Whitney discs needed for this step may themselves meet the surfaces one is trying to separate. The disc embedding problem asks whether algebraic intersection data, supplemented by suitable dual spheres, suffice to produce the embedded discs. Its solution for good fundamental groups underlies topological surgery and the five-dimensional ss-cobordism theorem for four-manifolds [7], Theorem 5.1A and Chapters 7 and 11.

Here is the formulation we use. Let MM be an oriented four-manifold, let π=π1(M)\pi= \pi_1(M), and fix basing paths, or whiskers, for all surfaces. The equivariant intersection pairing λ\lambda records an intersection point with its sign and the element of π\pi obtained from these paths; its values lie in Z[π]\mathbb{Z}[\pi]. A family of sphere maps gjg_j is algebraically dual to disc maps fif_i if λ(fi,gj)=δij1\lambda(f_i,g_j)=\delta_{ij}1. A geometric dual meets its corresponding disc in one transverse point and misses the other discs. We use the reduced Wall invariant

μ~ ⁣:π2(M)⟶Z[π]/⟨h−h−1,Z⋅1⟩add.(1)\widetilde{\mu}\colon\pi_2(M) \longrightarrow\mathbb{Z}[\pi]/\langle h-h^{-1},\mathbb{Z}\cdot1\rangle_{\mathrm{add}}. \tag*{(1)}

The quotient is additive, rather than a quotient by a group-ring ideal; these are the oriented conventions of [19], Section 1.3.

The disc embedding theorem applies to disc maps with disjoint locally flatly embedded boundaries and algebraic dual spheres satisfying λ(gi,gj)=0=μ~(gi)\lambda(g_i,g_j)=0=\widetilde{\mu}(g_i). When π\pi is good, it produces disjoint locally flat discs with those boundaries, with geometric duals, and with the induced boundary framings preserved for generically immersed input discs [19], Theorem A. The unrestricted disc embedding conjecture asks for this implication without the good-group assumption. Theorem 1.1 disproves it by excluding every disjoint locally flat filling of the specified boundary circles, even when no output framing or dual sphere is required.

Theorem 1.1. There exist a compact connected oriented smooth four-manifold MM with nonempty boundary, an integer k≥1k \ge1, proper generically immersed discs

fi ⁣:(D2,S1)⟶(M,∂M),1≤i≤k,f_i\colon(D^2,S^1)\longrightarrow(M,\partial M),\qquad1\le i\le k,

whose boundary restrictions form an embedding of ∐iS1\coprod_i S^1, and framed sphere maps gi ⁣:S2⟶Mg_i\colon S^2\longrightarrow M such that

λ(fi,gj)=δij1,λ(gi,gj)=0,μ~(gi)=0(1≤i,j≤k),(2)\lambda(f_i,g_j)=\delta_{ij}1,\qquad\lambda(g_i,g_j)=0,\qquad\widetilde{\mu}(g_i)=0\qquad(1\le i,j\le k), \tag*{(2)}

but the given boundary circles do not bound pairwise disjoint proper locally flat embedded discs in MM. Each gig_i can be chosen to be a smooth embedded sphere; different gig_i are allowed to intersect.

The boundary condition in this formulation is classical. The additional force of the conclusion is its nonexistence assertion: changing the relative homotopy classes of the prospective discs cannot evade the obstruction. The vanishing assumptions are placed on the dual spheres; no vanishing of the intersections among the input discs is needed.

Good groups and the free-group problem

Casson supplied the handle-embedding construction that makes the simply connected theory possible. Freedman proved that every Casson handle is homeomorphic, relative to its attaching region, to an open two-handle [3], Theorems 3.1 and 1.1. Together these results replace the unavailable smooth Whitney discs by topological ones. Freedman–Quinn developed a version using capped gropes, obtained by attaching surfaces along symplectic basis curves and closing the upper curves with immersed caps [7], Chapters 2–5. The caps may intersect; the loops through these intersections carry the fundamental-group information that must be controlled.

Goodness is a local condition on such models. In the formulation of [19], every height-1.5 disc-like capped grope, equipped with a homomorphism from its fundamental group to the group in question, must have an immersed disc in its four-dimensional thickening with the same framed boundary whose double-point loops map to the identity. A height-1.5 grope has a first surface stage with further surface stages attached along one curve from each symplectic pair; its remaining tips are capped. The thickenings used in this test have free fundamental groups, which explains the central role of the free-group case [8].

Freedman–Teichner extended the positive theory to all groups of subexponential growth [8]. Krushkal–Quinn gave a different proof based on splitting gropes into dyadic branches and organizing the resulting double-point words [17]. Their paper also contains the correction to the earlier height-raising argument. The known class is closed under subgroups, quotients, extensions and directed colimits; it includes finite and solvable groups as well as groups of subexponential growth [19]. Thus exponential growth alone does not mark the boundary of the theorem. The nonabelian free-group case remained open in the 2025 account [19]; see also [12] for its place among four-manifold problems.

The construction of geometric dual spheres requires attention even in the positive theory. Powell–Ray–Teichner supplied the missing construction in the proof of Freedman–Quinn’s theorem and also controlled the homotopy classes of those duals [19]. Their correction concerns output geometric duals and is distinct from the height-raising correction in [17].

Corollary 1.2 (Nongoodness of the free group). The free group F2F_2 on two generators is not good in the sense of Freedman–Quinn. Every group containing a subgroup isomorphic to F2F_2 is likewise not good.

Proof. The group π1(M)\pi_1(M) of the manifold in Theorem 1.1 is finitely presented because compact smooth manifolds have finite CW homotopy type. It is not good: otherwise [19], applied to the discs and spheres in (1.2), would supply the forbidden embedded discs.

Choose a finite generating list for π1(M)\pi_1(M) of length r≥2r \ge2, padding if necessary. There is then a surjection Fr↠π1(M)F_r \twoheadrightarrow\pi_1(M). The elements ajba−ja^jba^{-j} for 0≤j<r0 \le j < r freely generate a rank-rr subgroup of F2=⟨a,b⟩F_2 = \langle a,b\rangle, as follows from reduced-word normal form. Subgroups and quotients of good groups are good [19]. If F2F_2 were good, its subgroup FrF_r and then the quotient π1(M)\pi_1(M) would be good, a contradiction. Finally, a good group containing a subgroup isomorphic to F2F_2 would make F2F_2 good by subgroup closure, which proves the last assertion.

The conclusion about F2F_2 is group-theoretic: it does not identify π1(M)\pi_1(M) with F2F_2, and the geometric counterexample remains the one in Theorem 1.1.

Surgery and previous obstruction approaches

The free-group problem also has concrete link formulations. Freedman asked whether the Borromean rings are AA–BB slice [4]. Here each component is assigned a decomposition D4=Ai∪BiD^4 = A_i \cup B_i extending the standard genus-one decomposition of S3S^3. One seeks disjoint copies of all the pieces with attaching curves given by the link and a parallel copy; each copy must extend to an ambient self-homeomorphism of D4D^4. Freedman–Lin relate this condition for the full generalized Borromean family to topological surgery, equivalently to slicing the corresponding Whitehead doubles with meridians freely generating the slice-complement group [6].

Two results show why this obstruction program is delicate. Krushkal proved that every link with vanishing pairwise linking numbers is weakly AA–BB slice, where the ambient-extension requirement is removed [15]. Freedman–Krushkal subsequently constructed homotopy AA–BB slices for the universal generalized Borromean family using the 2-Engel relation [5] [Theorem 1 and Definition 3.10]. These are positive results for weakened embedding problems. The present obstruction instead starts from the actual images of hypothetical embedded discs and extracts restrictions on them through representation deformations. The independent conjugates of all triple commutators used here are specified in Section 2; they are not an invocation of the Engel relation.

Positive surgery results for free fundamental groups also persist in important special cases. Krushkal–Lee solve the unobstructed surgery problem for a degree-one normal map from a closed four-manifold to a Poincare complex with free fundamental group, when the target intersection pairing is extended from the integers [16] [Theorem 1]. Their proof cuts along inverse images of points under a map to a graph and reduces the stabilized problem to the simply connected case. In our construction the corresponding cuts have torus boundaries. Their boundary restriction data are retained throughout the obstruction; the closed-manifold result does not supply fillings for them [16] [Introduction, Remark].

For precision, we use the following two unrestricted assertions in the sense of [13] [Conjectures 1.5–1.6]. The topological surgery assertion says that a degree-one normal map from a compact four-manifold to a four-dimensional Poincare pair (Z,∂Z)(Z,\partial Z), which is a Z[π1(Z)]\mathbb{Z}[\pi_1(Z)]-homology equivalence on the boundary and has zero Wall surgery obstruction, is normally bordant relative to the boundary to a homotopy equivalence. The s-cobordism assertion says that every compact five-dimensional topological ss-cobordism with a specified product on its boundary is homeomorphic to a product extending that boundary structure. Neither assertion restricts the fundamental group.

Corollary 1.3. The unrestricted topological surgery and ss-cobordism assertions cannot both hold.

Proof. Together these assertions imply the unrestricted disc embedding conjecture [13] [Section 3]. Its algebraic hypotheses apply to the finite family of discs and framed spheres in the compact manifold of Theorem 1.1, so it would give the excluded boundary filling. □

The corollary concerns their conjunction; it does not determine which assertion fails. In particular, the free-group conclusion above is not being used as a substitute for the quoted equivalence.

The obstruction

The construction starts with a smooth four-manifold having the homotopy type of a finite graph. A finite family of capped gropes inside it encodes every triple commutator of suitably conjugated end generators. Removing neighborhoods of the grope bases gives the actual manifold MM. The shallow caps are the input discs. Product tori, compressed using the upper stages, give the spheres in (37). The proof checks their framings and all equivariant cancellation labels in π1(M)\pi_1(M).

Suppose disjoint locally flat discs with the prescribed boundaries existed. They would permit a graph map to be altered near their images and then cut along regular levels. The resulting three-dimensional walls have one torus boundary apiece, and the complementary four-dimensional region carries the triple commutator relations. An adjoint SL⁡2(C)\operatorname{SL}_2(\mathbb{C}) local system turns these relations into a cube-zero ideal in a representation deformation ring. A two-sheeted Mayer–Vietoris calculation supplies two complementary tangent spaces.

The comparison of representation deformations and flat connections has a classical differential graded Lie algebra formulation in Goldman–Millson [9] [Proposition 2.6 and Section 6]. Here finite transition-cochain charts retain the equations themselves, which will be needed with their full ideal structure.

To describe the resulting obstruction, label the walls 1,…,d1,\ldots,d. Write ai∈C3a_i\in\mathbb{C}^3 for holonomy coordinates centered at the identity along a chosen boundary circle on the iith wall’s torus, and yiy_i for its remaining deformation coordinates. Its function Pi(ai,yi)P_i(a_i,y_i) is a boundary-polarized version of the Chern–Simons transgression integral [1] [Section 3]. Write a=(ai)ia=(a_i)_i, and let tt be the remaining deformation parameters of the cut four-manifold. Label its two copies of each wall so that the chosen holonomy may vary on the positive copy and is trivial on the negative copy. Their restrictions then have the form (ai,Yi+(a,t))(a_i,Y_i^+(a,t)) and (0,Yi−(a,t))(0,Y_i^-(a,t)). Let Y=(Yi+,Yi−)iY=(Y_i^+,Y_i^-)_{i}, and let C=(Ci+,Ci−)iC=(C_i^+,C_i^-)_{i} be independent tuples with each Ci±C_i^\pm of the same size as yiy_i. Put

Ψ(a,C)=∑i(Pi(ai,Ci+)−Pi(0,Ci−)),v(a,t)=(∂CΨ)(a,Y(a,t)).\Psi(a,C)=\sum_i\left(P_i(a_i,C_i^+)-P_i(0,C_i^-)\right), \qquad v(a,t)=(\partial_C\Psi)(a,Y(a,t)).

Here differentiation precedes restriction to the graph C=Y(a,t)C=Y(a,t). If r\mathfrak r is the ideal of equations for the four-dimensional representation chart, the two identities are

(v)=r,Ψ(a,Y(a,t))∈r2.(v)=\mathfrak r,\qquad\Psi(a,Y(a,t))\in\mathfrak r^2.

The first identifies the whole ideal, including its nilpotent information. If the derivatives missed an equation, the resulting first obstruction to flatness would pair trivially with every wall variation. Duality and the paired Mayer–Vietoris isomorphism would then kill its curvature class, permitting a flat lift that contradicts the minimality of the defect equations. The second identity comes from comparing the wall connections on the closed boundary of the cut manifold: Stokes turns their total value into an integral of curvature squared.

Choose one scalar coordinate ai,1a_{i,1} on each wall and set pi(yi)=∂ai,1Pi(0,yi)p_i(y_i)=\partial_{a_{i,1}}P_i(0,y_i). The end-holonomy cube law gives two distinct families of memberships, for every triple of labels:

ai,1aj,1ak,1∈(v),pi(Yi−)pj(Yj−)pk(Yk−)∈(v).a_{i,1}a_{j,1}a_{k,1}\in(v),\qquad p_i(Y_i^-)p_j(Y_j^-)p_k(Y_k^-)\in(v).

The boundary term in polarized variation places each pi(Yi−)p_i(Y_i^-) in the end-deviation ideal modulo r\mathfrak r, giving the second family. These are ideal memberships with coefficients, stronger than statements about the common zero set.

The next step makes these identities available in positive characteristic. All gradient jets of each original PiP_i have representatives in one fixed smooth complex algebraic chart. This allows replacement of PiP_i, to sufficiently high order along its wall ideal, by an algebraic germ. The replacement uses exactness and faithful flatness of completion [20] and differential tests for symbolic powers [2]. The square-value identity then permits a formal correction of YY making Ψ\Psi vanish exactly on the corrected graph. An invertible change of gradient generators transports both displayed cubic memberships to that graph. Only finitely many constants and inverse Jacobians are needed for the new potentials, the correction and its membership witnesses, so all these data specialize to a field kk of positive characteristic. The corrected graph need not describe representations; the original end-holonomy cube law has already supplied the two memberships that the remaining argument uses.

In characteristic ℓ\ell, quotienting by the separate ℓ\ellth powers of the coordinates gives a finite-dimensional complex of differential forms. The corrected graph at a=0a=0 and its copy with the positive and negative blocks exchanged have complementary tangent spaces, and the potential vanishes on both. They determine cohomology classes with nonzero pairing. Using this pairing and the cubic law for the pip_i, we construct, when there are at least five walls, two classes in a deformation of the complex whose pairing is a unit in the deformation ring. The cubic law for the ai,1a_{i,1} then forces a nonzero parameter product times that pairing to vanish. Section 6 constructs this contradiction in the finite complex.

Lemma 5.3 and Theorem 6.1 are stated independently of the geometric construction. They are available for other problems meeting their respective stated hypotheses; in Theorem 6.1 these include both cubic ideal-membership laws. No additional application is asserted here.

Conventions and organization

All manifolds used in the construction are compact and smooth until the hypothetical locally flat discs are introduced. Corners are rounded when needed. Boundary orientations use the outward-normal-first convention. The commutator is [x,y]=xyx−1y−1[x,y]=xyx^{-1}y^{-1}, and changes of basing are retained as explicit conjugating words. A framed surface has a trivialized real normal two-plane bundle. The symbol m\mathfrak{m} denotes the maximal ideal of the local parameter ring currently in use. Formal series are always completed at the specified reference representation or origin.

Section 2 constructs the input discs and algebraic duals, and converts a hypothetical boundary filling into smooth cut data. Section 3 obtains complementary restriction tangents and the cubic holonomy law. Section 4 constructs the wall potentials and proves the derivative-ideal and square-ideal identities. Section 5 replaces the potentials by algebraic germs, corrects the restriction graph, and specializes the identities to positive characteristic. Section 6 proves the finite algebraic obstruction. Section 7 assembles these implications to prove Theorem 1.1.

A finite geometric test for disc embedding

We construct the input discs and their algebraic duals in an actual smooth four-manifold. The geometric conclusion needed later is conditional: any system of disjoint proper topological discs with the prescribed boundaries produces the smooth cut data specified in Proposition 2.8. In particular, the reduction places no relative homotopy requirement on those hypothetical discs. Intersection and reduced self-intersection invariants have the conventions of [19]; no disc-embedding theorem is used in this section.

The ambient manifold and its boundary

2.1. The ambient manifold and its boundary. Fix an integer d≥5d \ge5. For each e∈{1,…,d}e \in\{1,\ldots,d\} take two end labels (e,0),(e,1)(e,0),(e,1), and put

E={(e,ε):1≤e≤d, ε∈{0,1}}.\mathcal{E}=\{(e,\varepsilon):1\le e\le d,\ \varepsilon\in\{0,1\}\}.

The two ends have no preferred positive or negative designation yet.

References

  1. [1]Shiing-Shen Chern and James Simons, Characteristic forms and geometric invariants, Annals of Mathematics. Second Series 99 (1974), no. 1, 48–69.
  2. [2]Alessandro De Stefani, Eloisa Grifo, and Jack Jeffries, A Zariski–Nagata theorem for smooth Z-algebras, Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik 761 (2020), 123–140, Theorem and Lemma numbering refers to arXiv:1709.01049v3.
  3. [3]Michael H. Freedman, The topology of four-dimensional manifolds, Journal of Differential Geometry 17 (1982), no. 3, 357–453.DOI
  4. [4]———, Are the Borromean rings A–B-slice?, Topology and its Applications 24 (1986), no. 1–3, 143–145.DOI
  5. [5]Michael H. Freedman and Vyacheslav S. Krushkal, Engel relations in 4-manifold topology, Forum of Mathematics, Sigma 4 (2016), e22, 57 pp.arxiv.org/abs/1412.5024
  6. [6]Michael H. Freedman and Xiao-Song Lin, On the (A, B)-slice problem, Topology 28 (1989), no. 1, 91–110.DOI
  7. [7]Michael H. Freedman and Frank Quinn, Topology of 4-manifolds, Princeton Mathematical Series, vol. 39, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 1990.
  8. [8]Michael H. Freedman and Peter Teichner, 4-manifold topology. I. Subexponential groups, Inventiones Mathematicae 122 (1995), 509–529.DOI
  9. [9]William M. Goldman and John J. Millson, The deformation theory of representations of fundamental groups of compact Kähler manifolds, Publications Mathématiques de l’IHÉS 67 (1988), 43–96.
  10. [10]Allen Hatcher, Algebraic topology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2002.
  11. [11]Nicholas M. Katz, Nilpotent connections and the monodromy theorem: applications of a result of Turrittin, Publications Mathématiques de l’IHÉS 39 (1970), 175–232.DOI
  12. [12]Min Hoon Kim, Patrick Orson, JungHwan Park, and Arunima Ray, Open problems, The Disc Embedding Theorem (Stefan Behrens, Boldizsár Kalmár, Min Hoon Kim, Mark Powell, and Arunima Ray, eds.), Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2021, pp. 353–382.
  13. [13]Min Hoon Kim, Mark Powell, and Peter Teichner, Round handle problem, Pure and Applied Mathematics Quarterly 17 (2021), no. 1, 237–247.arxiv.org/abs/1706.09571
  14. [14]Jean-Louis Koszul, Homologie et cohomologie des algèbres de Lie, Bulletin de la Société Mathématique de France 78 (1950), 65–127.DOI
  15. [15]Vyacheslav S. Krushkal, A counterexample to the strong version of Freedman’s conjecture, Annals of Mathematics. Second Series 168 (2008), no. 2, 675–693.arxiv.org/abs/math/0610865
  16. [16]Vyacheslav S. Krushkal and Ronnie Lee, Surgery on closed 4-manifolds with free fundamental group, Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 133 (2002), no. 2, 305–310.DOI
  17. [17]Vyacheslav S. Krushkal and Frank Quinn, Subexponential groups in 4-manifold topology, Geometry & Topology 4 (2000), 407–430. With an appendix by Michael H. Freedman and Peter Teichner.DOI
  18. [18]John W. Milnor, Topology from the differentiable viewpoint, University Press of Virginia, Charlottesville, 1965.
  19. [19]Mark Powell, Arunima Ray, and Peter Teichner, The 4-dimensional disc embedding theorem and dual spheres, Selecta Mathematica. New Series 31 (2025), no. 4, Paper No. 80, 25 pp.arxiv.org/abs/2006.05209
  20. [20]The Stacks Project Authors, The stacks project, https://stacks.math.columbia.edu, 2026, Permanent tags cited in the text; accessed 18 September 2026.

Paper details

vlnc:W_gyjg9z9t
Version
v1 · latest
Published
License
LicenseRef-OpenAI-public
Usage

views · 8

downloads · 2

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

unreleased internal OpenAI model

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents