betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Accelerating field decay along nonlocal metasurfaces by suppressing the Norton wave

Abstract

Studying the nature of electromagnetic fields of dipole sources over a homogeneous flat ground or impedance surfaces has a long history. In general, at a long distance rr from the source, the near-surface field is mostly contributed by the geometrical optics term (describing the radiation pattern), a guided wave, and the higher-order reactive contribution referred to as the Norton wave. In the special case of a perfect magnetic conductor interface, the first two terms vanish, so the residual Norton wave determines the steepest achievable field decay profile of  r−3/2~r^{-3/2} (for a two-dimensional horizontal magnetic dipole). In this letter, we reveal that in the presence of a nonlocal metasurface described by the second-order impedance boundary condition, the field decay can be further accelerated by suppressing the Norton wave (approaching the profiles r−5/2r^{-5/2} and r−7/2r^{-7/2} for electric and magnetic fields, respectively). In a proposed practical realization of a nonlocal metasurface, the effect is numerically verified and shown to reduce the edge diffraction effects by 10 dB for the shield diameter of only one wavelength, paving the way toward compact antenna systems.

Studying the nature of electromagnetic fields of dipole sources over a homogeneous flat ground or impedance surfaces has a long history. In general, at a long distance rr from the source, the near-surface field is mostly contributed by the geometrical optics term (describing the radiation pattern), a guided wave, and the higher-order reactive contribution referred to as the Norton wave. In the special case of a perfect magnetic conductor interface, the first two terms vanish, so the residual Norton wave determines the steepest achievable field decay profile of r−3/2r^{-3/2} (for a two-dimensional horizontal magnetic dipole). In this letter, we reveal that in the presence of a nonlocal metasurface described by the second-order impedance boundary condition, the field decay can be further accelerated by suppressing the Norton wave (approaching the profiles r−5/2r^{-5/2} and r−7/2r^{-7/2} for electric and magnetic fields, respectively). In a proposed practical realization of a nonlocal metasurface, the effect is numerically verified and shown to reduce the edge diffraction effects by 10 dB for the shield diameter of only one wavelength, paving the way toward compact antenna systems.

The electromagnetic field solution for a dipole source above a lossy dielectric boundary (Sommerfeld’s problem) is a classical model of an antenna operating over the Earth at radio frequencies [1, 2, 3] or a nano-antenna over a plasmonic metal-air interface in the optical regime [4, 5]. The asymptotics of the exact solution (in the form of Sommerfeld-like integrals) commonly used in the literature to analyze the near-surface field behavior at a long distance rr from the source, in general, contains the following contributions: (i) the geometrical optics (GO) term (related to the radiation pattern) with a decay profile of r−1r^{-1} (in a 3D problem) or r−1/2r^{-1/2} (in a 2D problem); (ii) higher-order terms in a power series of r−1r^{-1}, including the so-called Norton wave decaying as r−2r^{-2} (in a 3D problem) [3] or r−3/2r^{-3/2} (in a 2D problem) [5], which describe reactive fields; and (iii) the guided wave typically having the form of a trapped (surface) wave. The interplay between the above terms substantially defines the near-surface field profile far from the source.

Metasurfaces (MSs; two-dimensional periodic structures with subwavelength periodicity) serve as a platform for synthesizing desired scattered field distributions under the given excitation [6]. The local response of impenetrable (impedance) MSs can be described on the macroscopic level with a frequency-dependent surface impedance ZsZ_s, which connects the averaged tangential electric EtE_t and magnetic HtH_t fields at the same point on the MS through the Leontovich boundary condition: Et=ZsHtE_t = Z_s H_t. The most popular realizations of such local MSs are the corrugated [7] and mushroom-type [8] surfaces, for which ∣Zs∣≫η|Z_s| \gg\eta near the resonance, where η\eta is the characteristic impedance of free space. Such so-called high-impedance surfaces (HISs) serve as artificial magnetic conductor (AMC) reflectors for propagating plane waves and simultaneously suppress any propagating surface waves (the electromagnetic band gap (EBG) property) [8]. For a dipole source above

a local MS with arbitrary ZsZ_s, an asymptotic representation of the near-surface field with the same types of waves as for the lossy dielectric is valid [9]. One limiting case Zs=0Z_s = 0 corresponds to a perfect electric conductor (PEC) ground plane, for which the GO term dominates in the asymptotic behavior of a field excited by an in-plane (located at small height hh compared to wavelength λ\lambda) horizontal magnetic dipole (HMD), while no guided wave is supported (see Figure 1(a)). In another limit when Zs→∞Z_s \to\infty, mimicking the perfect magnetic conductor (PMC) boundary, the GO term is zero because of the destructive interference between the HMD and its mirror image, while still no propagating guided wave is supported. As a result, the main contribution to the near-surface field is the Norton wave (Figure 1(b)). Due to a faster field decay compared to the PEC ground plane (r−3/2r^{-3/2} vs. r−1/2r^{-1/2} for a 2D problem) [10], HISs near the resonance serve as compact antenna shields with improved suppression in the shadow domain [11, 12, 13] and decoupling structures [14].

Fields excited by a HMD placed at height $h \ll \lambda$ above a PEC, PMC and nonlocal boundary

Figure 1. Fields excited by a HMD placed at height h≪λh \ll\lambda above a (a) PEC; (b) PMC and (c) nonlocal boundary with an impedance pole at a grazing angle. The geometry of the 2D problem considered is depicted in the inset of (c).

For a more general nonlocal MS response, EtE_t and HtH_t at different points are related to each other [15]. The nonlocality manifests itself in the spatial dispersion (SD) of ZsZ_s, i.e. its variation with the incident wave vector [16]. Adjusting the law of SD has been shown to control the angular properties of MS absorbers [17], antenna reflectors [18], and the transmittance of the anti-reflection coating [19]. Although the problem of dipole excitation of spatially dispersive wire grids [20] and plasmonic metal boundaries [5] was solved analytically, to our knowledge, the possibility of systematically controlling and accelerating the field decay along the MS has not been studied.

To investigate the near-surface field decay in the presence of nonlocality, let us consider a 2D problem with an infinite magnetic line current of complex amplitude I0mI_0^m (a 2D dipole oriented along the yy axis) at height h≪λh \ll\lambda above a uniform and isotropic MS. The latter is located in the XYXY plane and is modeled by a spatially dispersive surface impedance ZsZ_s, as shown in the inset of Figure 1(c). The source creates a TMy\mathrm{TM}_y-polarized field with only HyH_y, ExE_x, and EzE_z components nonzero. The tangential components of the total field Et=ExE_t = E_x, Ht=HyH_t = H_y (the sums of the incident and reflected fields), observed at angle 0∘≤θ≤90∘0^\circ\le\theta\le90^\circ and distance rr from the source, have the following rigorous spectral representations [21 Sec. 5]:

\begin{Bmatrix} E_x(\theta) \\ H_y(\theta) \end{Bmatrix} = \frac{C}{\sqrt{2\pi}} \int_P f_{\{E_x,H_y\}}(\tau)e^{-j\Omega\cos(\tau-\theta)}\,d\tau, \tag*{(1)}\end{Bmatrix}

where τ\tau is related to the normalized tangential wave vector component γ=kx/k\gamma= k_x/k of a spatial spectrum harmonic as sin⁡τ=γ\sin\tau= \gamma (harmonics with 0≤γ≤10 \le\gamma\le1 and 0∘≤τ=θ≤90∘0^\circ\le\tau= \theta\le90^\circ are propagating plane waves, while harmonics with γ>1\gamma> 1 are evanescent plane waves); C=I0mk/2πηC = I_0^m k/\sqrt{2\pi\eta}; kk is the wavenumber of free space; Ω=kr\Omega= kr; r=x2+(z−h)2r = \sqrt{x^2+(z-h)^2}; PP is the contour of integration (depicted in Fig. S.1 of [22]); and the integrated functions are determined by the SD law Zs(γ)Z_s(\gamma) as:

fHy=−cos⁡τZs(sin⁡τ)/η+cos⁡τ;fEx=−Zs(sin⁡τ)fHy.(2)f_{H_y} = \frac{-\cos\tau}{Z_s(\sin\tau)/\eta+\cos\tau};\qquad f_{E_x}=-Z_s(\sin\tau)f_{H_y}. \tag*{(2)}

A far-field approximation (Ω≫2π\Omega\gg2\pi) of (1) for a specific observation angle τ=θ≤90∘\tau=\theta\le90^\circ can be derived using the steepest descent method [21 Ch. 4]:

\begin{Bmatrix} E_x(\theta) \\ H_y(\theta) \end{Bmatrix} \approx Ce^{-j(\Omega-\frac{\pi}{4})}\left(\begin{Bmatrix} f_{E_x}(\theta) \\ f_{H_y}(\theta) \end{Bmatrix}\frac{1}{\Omega^{1/2}}+\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}j^n f_{\{E_x,H_y\}}^{(2n)}(\theta)\frac{(2n-1)!!}{(2n)!\,\Omega^{2n+1/2}}\right)-\sum_i\begin{Bmatrix} E_{x,i}^{\mathrm{GW}} \\ H_{y,i}^{\mathrm{GW}} \end{Bmatrix}e^{-j\Omega\sin\tau_i}, \tag*{(3)}\end{Bmatrix}

where f(2n)(θ)f^{(2n)}(\theta) denotes the derivative of 2n2n-th order with respect to θ\theta, while “GW” stands for guided waves. In (3) the first term is the GO term, for which functions (2) for 0∘≤τ=θ≤90∘0^\circ\le\tau=\theta\le90^\circ determine the radiation pattern. The next term (n=1n=1) is the Norton wave, which together with other higher-order terms (n≥2n\ge2) exhibits algebraic dependence on the distance Ω\Omega. The last sum in (3) of terms exponentially dependent on the distance, resulting from the poles of (2) with respect to τ\tau, accounts for the contribution of guided waves with excitation amplitudes Ex,iGWE_{x,i}^{\mathrm{GW}}, Hy,iGWH_{y,i}^{\mathrm{GW}}. Depending on the roots τi\tau_i of the characteristic equation, that is, the denominator of (2) equals zero, guided waves may be surface waves (SWs for sin⁡τi∈R\sin\tau_i\in\mathbb{R}) or leaky waves (LWs for sin⁡τi∈C\sin\tau_i\in\mathbb{C}).

Consider the fields near the MS plane. Both fExf_{E_x} and fHyf_{H_y} vanish at θ→90∘\theta\to90^\circ for all SD laws except those that satisfy condition Zs(90∘)=0Z_s(90^\circ)=0, so that the GO term in (3) becomes zero. However, the contribution of other asymptotic terms strongly depends on the SD of ZsZ_s. Let us find the specific conditions under which the fields Ex(90∘)E_x(90^\circ), Hy(90∘)H_y(90^\circ) decay the fastest with Ω\Omega. Obviously, no SWs should be supported by the MS, while the Norton wave and LWs should be minimized or canceled.

Following [18, 23, 24], we assume the MS to be lossless and represent its purely imaginary impedance Zs(γ)Z_s(\gamma) as a rational function, for which a second-order Padé approximation with one zero and one pole is [18]:

Zs(γ)=jX1−∑n=1∞Anγ2n1−∑m=1∞Bmγ2m≈jX1−Aγ21−Bγ2,(4)Z_s(\gamma)=jX\frac{1-\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}A_n\gamma^{2n}}{1-\sum_{m=1}^{\infty}B_m\gamma^{2m}}\approx jX\frac{1-A\gamma^2}{1-B\gamma^2}, \tag*{(4)}

where A≠1A\ne1, X≠0X\ne0 (to keep the GO term zero) and B≠AB\ne A (to keep the nontrivial SD law) are real coefficients of the second-order impedance boundary condition. Note that with A=B=0A=B=0 the value of ZsZ_s becomes constant with γ\gamma (hereafter referred to as a local case). As seen from (3), the electric and magnetic field amplitudes of the Norton wave F1,{Ex,Hy}F_{1,\{E_x,H_y\}} (the term with n=1n=1) are proportional to the second-order derivatives of fExf_{E_x} and fHyf_{H_y}, respectively, at θ=90∘\theta=90^\circ. Taking into account (4) the derivatives can be expressed as:

fHy′′=−2η2(B−1)2X2(A−1)2;fEx′′=2jη2(B−1)X(A−1).(5)f_{H_y}^{\prime\prime}=-\frac{2\eta^2(B-1)^2}{X^2(A-1)^2};\qquad f_{E_x}^{\prime\prime}=\frac{2j\eta^2(B-1)}{X(A-1)}. \tag*{(5)}

Both expressions (5) show that the Norton wave cancels with the choice B=1B=1 (a pole of the impedance is set at the grazing angle θ=90∘\theta=90^\circ). In this case, the next nonzero contributions in (3) are Ex∼Ω−5/2E_x\sim\Omega^{-5/2} and Hy∼Ω−7/2H_y\sim\Omega^{-7/2}, as well as of a single guided wave (with a complex propagation factor of τ0\tau_0 satisfying the characteristic equation). As noted in [18], F0,HyF_{0,H_y} determines the radiation pattern, which for B=1B=1 is proportional to cos⁡3θ\cos^3\theta, as follows from (2) and (4). For comparison, the radiation pattern for the PMC is proportional only to cos⁡θ\cos\theta. This means that the Norton wave suppression is expected to be accompanied by the radiation pattern narrowing. The corresponding excitation coefficients F2,ExF_{2,E_x}, F3,HyF_{3,H_y}, Ex,0GWE_{x,0}^{\mathrm{GW}}, and Hy,0GWH_{y,0}^{\mathrm{GW}} as well as propagation factor τ0\tau_0 can be analytically calculated using the formulas from the Supplemental Material [22 Eq. (S.1)-(S.5)].

The analytically calculated levels of F2,ExF_{2,E_x} (for the contribution Ex∼Ω−5/2E_x\sim\Omega^{-5/2}), as well as the excitation coefficient Ex,0GWE_{x,0}^{\mathrm{GW}} and the decay factor ℑ(τ0)\Im(\tau_0) of the GW, are shown in Figure 2(a–Figure 2c) in the case B=1B=1 (Norton wave suppressed) for different AA and X/ηX/\eta. As follows from Figure 2(a), by simultaneously increasing both ∣A∣\lvert A\rvert and ∣X∣\lvert X\rvert, one can decrease the contribution Ex∼Ω−5/2E_x\sim\Omega^{-5/2} to the overall tangential electric field profile. On the other hand, for some combinations of AA and XX, a propagating surface wave may appear (see the yellow regions in Figure 2(c)) that must be avoided. For other combinations of AA and XX, the guided wave becomes an LW with ℑ(τ0)\Im(\tau_0) strongly dependent on both AA and XX. Although for X<0X<0 and A>0A>0 the LW has a relatively small amplitude, it has the slowest decay. Therefore, to accelerate the overall decay along the MS, it is preferable to select larger positive XX together with negative AA.

Figure 2. Analytical study of fields excited by a 2D HMD on a nonlocal MS with a surface impedance of (4) with B=1B=1 (Norton wave suppressed) depending on AA and X/ηX/\eta: (a) normalized excitation coefficient level ∣F2,Ex∣η/C\lvert F_{2,E_x}\rvert\eta/C of the term decaying as Ex∼Ω−5/2E_x\sim\Omega^{-5/2}; (b) normalized excitation coefficient level ∣Ex,0GW∣η/C\lvert E_{x,0}^{\mathrm{GW}}\rvert\eta/C of a SW/LW; (c) exponential decay factor ℑ(τ0)\Im(\tau_0) of the LW (SW propagation regions are uniformly yellow); normalized levels of the tangential electric (d) and magnetic (e) field (solid lines) calculated with (1) vs. distance from the source x/λx/\lambda compared with their dominating asymptotic expansion terms from (3); (f) radiation pattern shape. The case with the set of parameters B=1B=1, A=−3.5A=-3.5, X/η=3.5X/\eta=3.5, chosen for the practical implementation, is indicated with cross markers in (a–c) and with red lines in (d–f). The local high-impedance case is shown in (d–f) with blue curves. Markers in (d) show the results of full-wave numerical confirmation for the practical MS implementation.

The contributions of the asymptotic term with Ex∼Ω−5/2E_x\sim\Omega^{-5/2} (solid gray curves) and LW (dashed gray curves) for different negative values of AA are plotted versus distance x/λx/\lambda along the MS in Figure 2(d). For the particular case A=−3.5A=-3.5, the asymptotic profiles are shown with black curves, while the total tangential electric field calculated using (1) is shown with the solid red curve. It is clearly seen that at small distances (x/λ<1.5x/\lambda<1.5) the field decay is mainly determined by the LW, while at large distances (x/λ>3x/\lambda>3) it strictly follows the Ex∼Ω−5/2E_x\sim\Omega^{-5/2} profile. In the middle range of distances, an interference of different wave contributions can be observed. A similar conclusion on the dominance of the term Hy∼Ω−7/2H_y\sim\Omega^{-7/2} or LW depending on the distance can be drawn for the magnetic field profile shown in Figure 2(e). For comparison, the profiles of electric and magnetic fields excited by the same source calculated using (1) are presented on the same plots for the local high-impedance MS with X/η=−3.5X/\eta=-3.5 along with asymptotic terms [22 Eq. (S.6)-(S.7)]. Note that in this case, guided waves cannot be excited by the TM-polarized source due to capacitive impedance [25 Par. 6.4.5], hence the field profiles precisely follow the contribution of the Norton wave (Ex∼Ω−3/2E_x \sim\Omega^{-3/2}). This comparison shows that for x/λ>2x/\lambda> 2, despite some LW excitation, the field levels on the nonlocal MS with B=1B = 1 remain drastically lower than for the local MS, which can be explained by the Norton wave suppression. Furthermore, Figure 2(f) confirms that the Norton wave suppression on nonlocal MSs is associated with a significantly narrower beam (especially for larger ∣A∣\lvert A\rvert) pointed in the normal direction.

To confirm the analytical predictions of the field decay acceleration, we numerically compare the excitation of two practical periodic structures implementing local and nonlocal MSs with the same period d=λ/10=3d = \lambda/10 = 3 mm at a frequency of f=10f = 10 GHz and the same thickness h=6.2h = 6.2 mm. The local MS is implemented as a corrugated surface [7, 12] with dielectric-filled (εr=1.6\varepsilon_r = 1.6) PEC grooves (see Figure 3(a)). The nonlocal MS is implemented as a modification of the HIS formed by vertical metal pins of height hh [26, 27, 28], where the pins with a diameter of 2r=0.12r = 0.1 mm are connected to the ground plane through lumped loads Z=jωLZ = j\omega L with inductance LL, and vertical PEC walls with a height of v≤hv \le h and a thickness of 18 μ\mum are placed between the adjacent pins.

Figure 3. Comparison of practical implementations of the local and nonlocal MSs: (a) meta-atoms of the local corrugated HIS (left) and the proposed nonlocal MS (right); (b) numerically extracted (markers) and analytically calculated (solid lines) Zs(γ)Z_s(\gamma); (c) analytically estimated DU(90∘)\mathrm{DU}(90^\circ) for X/η=3.5X/\eta= 3.5, B=1B = 1, and different practically implementable negative values of AA (see [22 Tab. S.1]); (d) full-wave numerically calculated DU(ϕ)\mathrm{DU}(\phi) for D=λD = \lambda.

ZsZ_s as a function of γ\gamma is parametrically calculated in CST Studio Suite for both types of meta-atoms using periodic boundary conditions. The numerical results are shown in Figure 3(b) with markers being in good agreement with the analytical results obtained with (4). At 10 GHz (above the quarter-wave resonance), the local MS (see the blue curve and markers) exhibits a high and γ\gamma-independent capacitive impedance X/η≈−3.5X/\eta\approx-3.5 [29 Par. 11.4]. In contrast, for the nonlocal MS, the family of gray curves corresponding to −3.5≤A≤−0.5-3.5 \le A \le-0.5 for fixed B=1B = 1, X/η=3.5X/\eta= 3.5 exhibits a common pole at γ=1\gamma= 1. This individual variation of AA can be achieved in the proposed structure by adjusting vv and LL simultaneously. Details of the impedance extraction method and the correspondence obtained between vv, LL and AA are given in the Supplemental Material [22 Sec. 2]. In particular, the case with A≈−3.5A \approx-3.5 corresponds to v=h=6.2v = h = 6.2 mm and L=0.63L = 0.63 nH (see the red curve in Figure 3(b)).

To further verify the analytically predicted field decay acceleration, we compared the numerically calculated electric field profiles of the latter nonlocal MS (with A=−3.5A = -3.5) with the local one. With this aim, in CST Studio Suite (full-wave simulation with Frequency Domain Solver), we introduced a 2D HMD implemented as an internally fed open-ended parallel-plate waveguide with thickness w=0.18w = 0.18 mm embedded in the center of the structure with finite size DD (diameter along the xx axis). This finite 1D row containing NN meta-atoms is assumed to be periodically extended in the yy direction. For both MSs, the open end is located in the top plane of the structure. To ensure the validity of the averaged boundary conditions, several closest meta-atoms at distances smaller than one period dd from the source are removed, as schematically depicted in the inset of Figure 3(d). The full-wave numerical results (markers) for D=12λD = 12\lambda and N=118N = 118 are compared with the analytical calculations (solid red and blue curves) in Figure 2(a) showing good agreement. Note that at distances from the source x/λ>2x/\lambda> 2, the electric field decays by more than 70 dB, so that the expected decay profile Ex∼Ω−5/2E_x \sim\Omega^{-5/2} cannot be confirmed for the practical structure due to the insufficient accuracy of numerical calculations (mainly caused by the effects of radiation boundaries). However, even at smaller distances the advantage in field decay along the nonlocal MS of more than 25 dB is clearly reached compared to the local case.

One possible application of the observed effect is mitigating edge diffraction, which typically limits the shielding action of finite-sized antenna reflectors. To evaluate the role of SD, let us compare the same two structures as above, but for different diameters DD. The shielding action can be quantified based on the far-field pattern using the so-called down-to-up ratio: DU(ϕ)=Hyff(−ϕ)/Hyff(ϕ)\mathrm{DU}(\phi) = H_y^{\mathrm{ff}}(-\phi)/H_y^{\mathrm{ff}}(\phi), where HyffH_y^{\mathrm{ff}} denotes the magnetic field in the far-field region; ϕ=π/2−θ\phi= \pi/2 - \theta. As shown in the Supplemental Material [22 Sec. 3], DU(90∘)\mathrm{DU}(90^\circ) can be analytically estimated using the physical optics approach. While the magnetic field in the zenith (θ=0∘\theta= 0^\circ) is determined by fHy(0∘)f_{H_y}(0^\circ), the field in the nadir (θ=180∘\theta= 180^\circ) can be approximated by the sum of two edge diffraction waves. The amplitude of both waves is proportional to the integral of the magnetic surface current density that would be induced by the HMD at an infinite MS (over the range of distances D/2≤∣x∣<∞D/2 \le\lvert x\rvert< \infty, where the finite structure of diameter DD is absent). For the nonlocal MS with X/η≫1X/\eta\gg1 and B=1B = 1 (the Norton wave suppressed), one can write:

DUNL(90∘) [dB]≈16.61−20lg⁡(1−A)−50lg⁡kD.(6)\mathrm{DU}^{\mathrm{NL}}(90^\circ)\ [\mathrm{dB}] \approx16.61 - 20\lg(1-A) - 50\lg kD. \tag*{(6)}

A similar expression for the local HIS (with negative Re(Zs)\mathop{\mathrm{Re}}(Z_s) and ∣X∣/η≫1\lvert X\rvert/\eta\gg1), for which the Norton wave dominates at large distances, reads [10]:

DUL(90∘) [dB]≈1.05−30lg⁡kD.(7)\mathrm{DU}^{\mathrm{L}}(90^\circ)\ [\mathrm{dB}] \approx1.05 - 30\lg kD. \tag*{(7)}

The analytical estimates for the local and nonlocal MSs (for different negative AA) are plotted in Figure 3(c) versus DD. As can be seen, the DU ratio in the nonlocal case with A=−3.5A = -3.5 can be reduced to -35 dB for a diameter of only one wavelength, which is by ≈14\approx14 dB better than for the local HIS of the same size. Full-wave numerical simulations of local and nonlocal practical structures with D=λD = \lambda (N=8N = 8) result in the DU(ϕ)\mathrm{DU}(\phi) curves shown in Figure 3(d). An improvement of 10 dB can be observed at ϕ=90∘\phi= 90^\circ. A 4 dB deviation from the analytical estimation is due to the accuracy of the physical optics approximation and due to not neglecting the contribution of the LW in the analytical estimation of the DU. Compared with a cardioid-shaped radiation pattern of a classical Huygens’ source, both the local and nonlocal compact reflectors provide a steeper radiation pattern’s roll-off near the horizon (ϕ=0∘\phi= 0^\circ), which is a benefit in another important metric of shielding action.

The results obtained clearly demonstrate the possibility of accelerating field decay along nonlocal MSs with second-order SD. Once the surface impedance has a pole at grazing angles, the contribution of the Norton wave in the asymptotic near-surface field expansion is suppressed. Although the contribution of the LW remains dominant near the HMD, the next nonzero higher-order term with profiles of Ex∼Ω−5/2E_x \sim\Omega^{-5/2} and Hy∼Ω−7/2H_y \sim\Omega^{-7/2} remains dominant at large distances from the source. This decay acceleration in comparison to a local HIS (with the Norton wave prescribing the decay profile of Ex∼Ω−3/2E_x \sim\Omega^{-3/2}) is possible to achieve with the proposed practical periodic structure of inductively-loaded pins separated with metal walls, which is found to exhibit the required specific law of SD. Excitation of the proposed nonlocal MS as a wavelength-size reflector is associated with edge diffraction reduced by 10 dB compared to a state-of-the-art local MS reflector of the same size. The investigated properties of nonlocal MSs, therefore, pave the way for efficient miniaturized shields and isolating structures that overcome the properties of conventional widely used corrugated surfaces.

Acknowledgment — This work was supported by the Russian Science Foundation (Project No. 25-19-00712, https://rscf.ru/en/project/25-19-00712/).

Supplemental Material: Accelerating field decay along nonlocal metasurfaces by suppressing the Norton wave

Alexander Zhuravlev; Dmitry Tatarmikov; Yury Kurenkov; Stanislav Glybovski

Terms from the far-field approximation of the field

In this section, we explicitly present the power terms contained in Eq. (3) from the main article when the observation angle (θ\theta) tends to 90∘90^\circ. In this case, assuming that (z−h)2≪x2(z-h)^2 \ll x^2 and h≪λh \ll\lambda, the distance from the source rr can be approximated as xx.

In the case when the Norton wave is suppressed, the power terms determining the field decay along the boundary are:

Ex−5/2(x)=Cjη2X3[(1−A)X2(A(B+2)−4B+1)+3(1−B)3η2(1−A)3]e−j(k∣x∣−π4)(k∣x∣)5/2(8)E_x^{-5/2}(x)=C\frac{j\eta^2}{X^3}\left[\frac{(1-A)X^2(A(B+2)-4B+1)+3(1-B)^3\eta^2}{(1-A)^3}\right]\frac{e^{-j(k|x|-\frac{\pi}{4})}}{(k|x|)^{5/2}} \tag*{(8)}
Hy−7/2(x)=Cjη2X6[K0+K1+K2(1−A)6]e−j(k∣x∣−π4)3(k∣x∣)5/2(9)H_y^{-7/2}(x)=C\frac{j\eta^2}{X^6}\left[\frac{K_0+K_1+K_2}{(1-A)^6}\right]\frac{e^{-j(k|x|-\frac{\pi}{4})}}{3(k|x|)^{5/2}} \tag*{(9)}

where C=I0mk/2πC=I_0^m k/\sqrt{2\pi}, I0mI_0^m is the complex amplitude of magnetic line current, kk is the wavenumber of free space, η\eta is the characteristic impedance of free space, and coefficients KiK_i are given by:

K0=(1−A)2X4(A2(2B2−34B+77)+2A(13B2−86B+28)+107B2−64B+2)K_0=(1-A)^2X^4\left(A^2(2B^2-34B+77)+2A(13B^2-86B+28)+107B^2-64B+2\right)
K1=30(1−A)(1−B)3X2η2(A(B+5)−7B+1)K_1=30(1-A)(1-B)^3X^2\eta^2(A(B+5)-7B+1)
K2=45(1−B)6η4K_2=45(1-B)^6\eta^4

The impact of guided waves (GW) is:

Ex,0GW2πjC=−jηX(1−Asin⁡2τ0)cot⁡τ02jXAcos⁡τ0+3ηBcos⁡2τ0+η(1−B)(10)\frac{E_{x,0}^{\mathrm{GW}}}{2\pi jC}=\frac{-j\eta X(1-A\sin^2\tau_0)\cot\tau_0}{2jXA\cos\tau_0+3\eta B\cos^2\tau_0+\eta(1-B)} \tag*{(10)}
Hy,0GW2πjC=η(1−Bsin⁡2τ0)cot⁡τ02jXAcos⁡τ0+3ηBcos⁡2τ0+η(1−B)(11)\frac{H_{y,0}^{\mathrm{GW}}}{2\pi jC}=\frac{\eta(1-B\sin^2\tau_0)\cot\tau_0}{2jXA\cos\tau_0+3\eta B\cos^2\tau_0+\eta(1-B)} \tag*{(11)}

The propagation constant τ0\tau_0 of the GW can be calculated from the transverse resonance condition (ηcos⁡τ+Zs(τ)=0)(\eta\cos\tau+Z_s(\tau)=0) [1], which can be written in the following form, using the fact that cos⁡2τ+sin⁡2τ=1\cos^2\tau+\sin^2\tau=1:

cos⁡3τ+jXAηBcos⁡2τ+1−BBcos⁡τ+jX(1−A)ηB=0(12)\cos^3\tau+\frac{jXA}{\eta B}\cos^2\tau+\frac{1-B}{B}\cos\tau+\frac{jX(1-A)}{\eta B}=0 \tag*{(12)}

Depending on the roots τi\tau_i of the equation above, guided waves may be surface waves (SWs for sin⁡τi∈R\sin\tau_i\in\mathbb{R}) or leaky waves (LWs for sin⁡τi∈C\sin\tau_i\in\mathbb{C}). The equation above usually has three roots: one root corresponds to a SW and the others correspond to a LW decaying/rising along xx direction (see Fig. S.1). The brown circles in the figure highlight the positions of the root τ0\tau_0 that is crossed when the origin point of integration PP is deformed to the steepest-descent contour PSDP_{\mathrm{SD}}; this GW can propagate along the boundary [2 Ch. 4].

In the case of local artificial magnetic conductor boundary (∣X/η∣≫1|X/\eta| \gg1 and A=B=0A = B = 0 in Eq. (4) from the main article) the first non-zero terms of Eq. (3) from the main article are:

Ex−3/2(x)=−Cγ2(1−B)X(1−A)⏟F1,Exe−j(k∣x∣−π4)(k∣x∣)3/2(13)E_x^{-3/2}(x)=-C\underbrace{\frac{\gamma^2(1-B)}{X(1-A)}}_{F_{1,E_x}}\frac{e^{-j(k|x|-\frac{\pi}{4})}}{(k|x|)^{3/2}} \tag*{(13)}
Hy−3/2(x)=−Cjη2(1−B)2X2(1−A)⏟F1,Hye−j(k∣x∣−π4)(k∣x∣)3/2(14)H_y^{-3/2}(x)=-C\underbrace{\frac{j\eta^2(1-B)^2}{X^2(1-A)}}_{F_{1,H_y}}\frac{e^{-j(k|x|-\frac{\pi}{4})}}{(k|x|)^{3/2}} \tag*{(14)}
Typical location of $\tau_i$ in the complex plane

Figure S.1. Typical location of τi\tau_i in the complex plane τ\tau: (a) corresponds to the excitation of a SW and (b) corresponds to the excitation of a LW. The brown circles in the figure highlight the positions of the root τ\tau that is crossed when the original contour of integration P is deformed to the steepest–descent contour PSD_{\rm SD}; this GW can propagate along the boundary.

Periodic structure of inductively-loaded PINs separated with metal walls

To demonstrate how the height of the vertical dividers affects the spatial dispersion of Zs(γ)Z_s(\gamma), where γ=kx/k=sin⁡θ\gamma=k_x/k=\sin\theta, associated with the structure shown in Fig. S.2(a), we calculated its Zs(γ)Z_s(\gamma) for different values of γ\gamma keeping the Norton wave suppression condition satisfied (B=1B=1). The impedance under normal incidence was chosen to be 3.5η3.5\eta which demanded h=6.22h=6.22 mm. The following parameters were locked: 2r=0.12r=0.1 mm, d=3d=3 mm, while the value of inductance LL was adjusted to control the angular response.

To obtain spatially dispersive surface impedance, we calculated the angular dependence of the reflection coefficient ρ(γ)\rho(\gamma), from the unit cell using CST Studio Suite (CST) with periodic boundary conditions (see Fig. S.2(b)). Spatially dispersive surface impedance was obtained via formula:

Zs(γ)=η1−γ21+ρ(γ)1−ρ(γ)(15)Z_s(\gamma)=\eta\sqrt{1-\gamma^2}\frac{1+\rho(\gamma)}{1-\rho(\gamma)} \tag*{(15)}

The normalized wave vector tangential component of the incident plane wave reads: γ=sin⁡θ+2πn/kD\gamma=\sin\theta+2\pi n/kD [[3], par. 4.1], where DD is the size of the calculation domain along the xx–axis and nn is a mode number. As the structure is self-periodic, we can say that D=dND=dN, where dd is unit cell periodicity and NN is a number of unit cells. Considering fundamental mode (n=0n=0), one can see that γ<1\gamma<1. On the other hand, the normalized tangential component of the wave vector, associated with the high order mode (n=1n=1), can be arbitrarily controlled by the adjusting of NN and θ\theta. The last fact was used to estimate surface impedance for evanescent waves. At the last step the obtained Zs(γ)Z_s(\gamma) curve was fitted by Eq. (4) from the main article to get XX, AA, and BB coefficients.

The results of parametric study are shown in the Tab. S.1. One can see that the increase of ν\nu can decrease the value of AA and implementable values of A∈[−3.5,−0.5]A\in[-3.5,-0.5] for considered geometrical parameters.

Periodic structure of inductively-loaded pins and simulation setup

Figure S.2. (a) Periodic structure of inductively-loaded pins separated with metal walls. (b) Simulation setup for surface impedance extraction in CST.

vv, mmLL, nHX/ηX/\etaAABB
6.220.633.5-3.51
5.920.683.5-3.01
5.700.743.5-2.51
5.440.813.5-1.91
3.121.683.5-0.51

Table S.1. The dependence of XX, AA, and BB coefficients on the structure’s parameters.

Down-to-up ratio estimation with the physical optics approach

Here we present an approximate method of calculation down-to-up ratio (DUN(ϕ=90∘)=Hyff(−90∘)/Hyff(90∘)D^{\mathrm{UN}}(\phi=90^\circ)=H_y^{\mathrm{ff}}(-90^\circ)/H_y^{\mathrm{ff}}(90^\circ)), where HyffH_y^{\mathrm{ff}} denotes the magnetic field in the far-field region and ϕ=π/2−θ\phi=\pi/2-\theta of the system shown in Fig. S.3. The distant magnetic field of the source shielded by a finite screen of length DD can be approximated as Hyff=Hy∞−HycutH_y^{\mathrm{ff}}=H_y^\infty-H_y^{\mathrm{cut}}, where the first term is the radiation of the infinite shielded antenna and the second one is the radiation of the cut parts. The radiation of the cut parts can be found using physical optics as:

Hycut=∫−∞−L/2(Hye+Hym) dx+∫L/2∞(Hye+Hym) dx(16)H_y^{\mathrm{cut}}=\int_{-\infty}^{-L/2}\left(H_y^e+H_y^m\right)\,dx+\int_{L/2}^{\infty}\left(H_y^e+H_y^m\right)\,dx \tag*{(16)}

where we assume that each element Δx\Delta x radiates as a combination of elementary 2-D sources [2 Par. 5.4]:

Hye=−J0ek24πe−j(Ω−π4)Ωcos⁡θejkxsin⁡θΔx(17)H_y^e=-J_0^e\frac{k\sqrt{2}}{4\sqrt{\pi}}\frac{e^{-j\left(\Omega-\frac{\pi}{4}\right)}}{\sqrt{\Omega}}\cos\theta e^{jkx\sin\theta}\Delta x \tag*{(17)}
Hym=−J0mk24ηπe−j(Ω−π4)Ωejkxsin⁡θΔxH_y^m=-J_0^m\frac{k\sqrt{2}}{4\eta\sqrt{\pi}}\frac{e^{-j\left(\Omega-\frac{\pi}{4}\right)}}{\sqrt{\Omega}}e^{jkx\sin\theta}\Delta x

where J0eJ_0^e or J0mJ_0^m is electric or magnetic surface current densities (A/m or V/m), Ω=kr\Omega=kr, and r=x2+z2r=\sqrt{x^2+z^2}.

If we assume that cutting the shield does not affect the field distributions along it, the currents which radiate can be found through the fields distributions along the shield through the boundary conditions: Jm=−z0×E\mathbf{J}^m=-z_0\times\mathbf{E} and Je=z0×H\mathbf{J}^e=z_0\times\mathbf{H}.

As shown above, a specific case when B=1B=1 can provide such field decay along the shield:

Ex≈−Ce−jπ4j3η2X(1−A)e−jk∣x∣(k∣x∣)5/2−Ex,0GWe−jk∣x∣sin⁡τ0(18)E_x\approx-\frac{C}{e^{-j\frac{\pi}{4}}}\frac{j3\eta^2}{X(1-A)}\frac{e^{-jk|x|}}{(k|x|)^{5/2}}-E_{x,0}^{\mathrm{GW}}e^{-jk|x|\sin\tau_0} \tag*{(18)}
Hy≈j15Ce−jπ4η2X2(1−A)2e−jk∣x∣(k∣x∣)7/2−Hy,0GWe−jk∣x∣sin⁡τ0H_y\approx\frac{j15C}{e^{-j\frac{\pi}{4}}}\frac{\eta^2}{X^2(1-A)^2}\frac{e^{-jk|x|}}{(k|x|)^{7/2}}-H_{y,0}^{\mathrm{GW}}e^{-jk|x|\sin\tau_0}
Infinite screen cut from both sides

Figure S.3. Infinite screen is cut from both sides at x=±D/2x = \pm D/2. The cut parts radiate as elementary 2-D sources.

Because the magnetic field decays faster than the electric one along the screen, we can neglect the radiation of the electric currents in (S.9). Moreover, to achieve a simple equation, we presume that the contribution to (S.9) is mainly due to the power term Ex−5/2∼x−5/2E_x^{-5/2} \sim x^{-5/2} in (S.11) and we can neglect the effect of GW.

Using the boundary condition for electric field and then putting magnetic current in (S.10), one can write (S.9) as:

Hycut=C′(∫−∞−kL/2e−jk∣x∣+jkxsin⁡θ(∣x∣)5/2 dx+∫kL/2∞e−jk∣x∣+jkxsin⁡θ(∣x∣)5/2 dx)(19)H_y^{\mathrm{cut}} = C^{\prime}\left(\int_{-\infty}^{-kL/2} \frac{e^{-jk|x|+jkx\sin\theta}}{(|x|)^{5/2}}\,dx + \int_{kL/2}^{\infty} \frac{e^{-jk|x|+jkx\sin\theta}}{(|x|)^{5/2}}\,dx\right) \tag*{(19)}

where C′=−Cj3η2X(1−A)ej3π/4k24ηπe−j(Ω−π/4)ΩC^{\prime}=-C\frac{j3\eta^2}{X(1-A)}e^{j3\pi/4}\frac{k\sqrt{2}}{4\eta\sqrt{\pi}}\frac{e^{-j(\Omega-\pi/4)}}{\sqrt{\Omega}}.

Considering the radiation in normal direction (θ=0∘\theta=0^\circ), we can neglect the radiation of the cut parts Hyff(θ=0∘)≈Hy∞(θ=0∘)H_y^{\mathrm{ff}}(\theta=0^\circ)\approx H_y^\infty(\theta=0^\circ) (see Eq. (3) from the main article):

Hyff(θ=0∘)≈−CηjX+ηe−j(Ω−π/4)Ω(20)H_y^{\mathrm{ff}}(\theta=0^\circ)\approx-C\frac{\eta}{jX+\eta}\frac{e^{-j(\Omega-\pi/4)}}{\sqrt{\Omega}} \tag*{(20)}

The radiation directly below the shield is determined by the cut parts Hyff(θ=180∘)≈−Hycut(θ=180∘)H_y^{\mathrm{ff}}(\theta=180^\circ)\approx-H_y^{\mathrm{cut}}(\theta=180^\circ). Putting the observation angle θ=180∘\theta=180^\circ in (S.12) and making substitution s=kxs=kx, we arrive to:

Hyff(θ=180∘)≈−C′k2∫kL/2∞e−jss5/2 ds≈jC′k2e−jkL/2(kL/2)5/2(21)H_y^{\mathrm{ff}}(\theta=180^\circ)\approx-\frac{C^{\prime}}{k}2\int_{kL/2}^{\infty}\frac{e^{-js}}{s^{5/2}}\,ds\approx\frac{jC^{\prime}}{k}2\frac{e^{-jkL/2}}{(kL/2)^{5/2}} \tag*{(21)}

After dividing the last equation by (S.13), DUNL(90∘)D^{\mathrm{UNL}}(90^\circ) can be found as:

DUNL(90∘)=j92πjX+ηX(1−A)ejπ/4e−jkL/2(0.5kL)5/2(22)D^{\mathrm{UNL}}(90^\circ)=j\sqrt{\frac{9}{2\pi}}\frac{jX+\eta}{X(1-A)}\frac{e^{j\pi/4}e^{-jkL/2}}{(0.5kL)^{5/2}} \tag*{(22)}

References

  1. [1]J. Zenneck, Über die fortpflanzung ebener elektromagnetischer wellen längs einer ebenen leitfläche und ihre beziehung zur drahtlosen telegraphie, Ann. Phys. 328, 846 (1907).DOI
  2. [2]A. Sommerfeld, Über die ausbreitung der wellen in der drahtlosen telegraphie, Ann. Phys. 333, 665 (1909).
  3. [3]K. A. Norton, The propagation of radio waves over the surface of the earth and in the upper atmosphere, Proceedings of the institute of Radio Engineers 24, 1367 (1936).
  4. [4]P. Lalanne, J. Hugonin, and J. Rodier, Theory of surface plasmon generation at nanoslit apertures, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 263902 (2005).DOI
  5. [5]A. Y. Nikitin, S. G. Rodrigo, F. J. García-Vidal, and L. Martín-Moreno, In the diffraction shadow: Norton waves versus surface plasmon polaritons in the optical region, New J. Phys. 11, 123020 (2009).DOI
  6. [6]S. B. Glybovski, S. A. Tretyakov, P. A. Belov, Y. S. Kivshar, and C. R. Simovski, Metasurfaces: From microwaves to visible, Phys. Rep. 634, 1 (2016).DOI
  7. [7]P.-S. Kildal et al., Artificially soft and hard surfaces in electromagnetics, IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 38, 1537 (1990).DOI
  8. [8]D. Sievenpiper, L. Zhang, R. Broas, N. Alexopoulos, and E. Yablonovitch, High-impedance electromagnetic surfaces with a forbidden frequency band, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory Tech. 47, 2059 (1999).DOI
  9. [9]J. R. Wait, Excitation of surface waves on conducting, stratified, dielectric-clad, and corrugated surfaces, J. Res. Natl. Bur. Stand. 59, 365 (1957).DOI
  10. [10]D. Tatarnikov, V. Filippov, I. Sotiaguine, A. Astahov, A. Stepanenko, and P. Shamatulsky, Multipath mitigation by conventional antennas with ground planes and passive vertical structures, GPS Solut. 9, 194–201 (2005).DOI
  11. [11]R. Baggen, M. Martinez-Vazquez, J. Leiss, S. Holzwarth, L. S. Drioli, and P. de Maagt, Low profile GALILEO antenna using EBG technology, IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 56 (2008).DOI
  12. [12]F. Scire-Scapuzzo and S. N. Makarov, A low-multipath wideband GPS antenna with cutoff or non-cutoff corrugated ground plane, IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 57, 33 (2009).
  13. [13]D. Tatarnikov, A. Astakhov, and A. Stepanenko, Broad-band convex impedance ground planes for multi-system GNSS reference station antennas, GPS Solut. 15, 101 (2011).
  14. [14]F. Yang and Y. Rahmat-Samii, Microstrip antennas integrated with electromagnetic band-gap (EBG) structures: a low mutual coupling design for array applications, IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 51, 2936 (2003).DOI
  15. [15]K. Simovski, Composite Media with Weak Spatial Dispersion (Jenny Stanford Publishing, 2018).
  16. [16]O. Loukkonen, C. Simovski, G. Granet, G. Goussetis, D. Lioubtchenko, A. V. Raisanen, and S. A. Tretyakov, Simple and accurate analytical model of planar grids and high-impedance surfaces comprising metal strips or patches, IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 56, 1624 (2008).
  17. [17]D. Zhirihin, C. Simovski, P. Belov, and S. Glybovski, Mushroom high-impedance metasurfaces for perfect absorption at two angles of incidence, IEEE Antennas and Wireless Propagation Letters 16, 2626 (2017).DOI
  18. [18]A. Zhuravlev, Y. Kurenkov, X. Wang, F. Dushko, V. Zalipaev, and S. Glybovski, Radiation-pattern synthesis with uniform nonlocal metasurfaces, Phys. Rev. Appl. 23, 044052 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2411.16210
  19. [19]A. Zhuravlev, S. Kuznetsov, D. Kiselkina, A. Shaham, A. Epstein, and S. Glybovski, Wide-angle reflection suppression of dielectric slabs using nonlocal metasurface coatings (2025), arXiv:2507.11989 [physics.optics].DOI
  20. [20]I. V. Lindell, V. P. Akimov, and E. Alanen, Image theory for dipole excitation of fields above and below a wire grid with square cells, IEEE Trans. Electromagn. Compat. 28, 107 (1986).DOI
  21. [21]L. B. Felsen and N. Marcuvitz, Radiation and Scattering of Waves (Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, USA, 1994).
  22. [22]See supplemental material at [url will be inserted by publisher] for terms from the far-field approximation of the field, characteristic equation, parametric study of spatial dispersion in the periodic structure of inductively-loaded pins separated with metal walls, and down-to-up ratio estimation with the physical optics approach (see also references [16], [21], and [25] therein).
  23. [23]J. G. N. Rahmeier, T. J. Smy, J. Dugan, and S. Gupta, Zero thickness surface susceptibilities and extended GSTCs—Part I: Spatially dispersive metasurfaces, IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 71, 5909 (2022).DOI
  24. [24]J. Dugan, T. J. Smy, F. Monticone, and S. Gupta, Surface susceptibility synthesis of spatially dispersive metasurfaces for space compression and spatial signal processing, IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 72, 6572 (2024).DOI
  25. [25]S. Tretyakov, Analytical Modeling in Applied Electromagnetics (Artech, 2003).
  26. [26]M. G. Silveirinha, C. A. Fernandes, and J. R. Costa, Electromagnetic characterization of textured surfaces formed by metallic pins, IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 56, 405 (2008).DOI
  27. [27]S. Maslovski, T. Morgado, M. Silveirinha, C. S. R. Kaipa, and A. Yakovlev, Generalized additional boundary conditions for wire media, New J. Phys. 12, 113047 (2010).DOI
  28. [28]C. S. R. Kaipa, A. B. Yakovlev, S. I. Maslovski, and M. G. Silveirinha, Mushroom-type high-impedance surface with loaded vias: Homogenization model and ultra-thin design, IEEE Antennas Wirel. Propag. Lett. 10, 1503 (2011).DOI
  29. [29]R. E. Collin, Field Theory of Guided Waves, IEEE/OUP series on electromagnetic wave theory (IEEE Press, 1990).

Paper details

vlnc:W_h4um8jf8
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents