betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Kinematics of ultrarelativistic electrons in periodic fields of moderate strength

Abstract

Bright sources of hard x- and gamma-ray electromagnetic radiation are of high demand in physics and technology. Such sources, e.g., x-ray free-electron lasers (XFELs), undulator- or Compton-based sources of polarized positrons, etc., require intense ultrarelativivstic electron beams with small energy spread. Also each electron should emit many photons of almost identical spectra per pass through the periodic field of undulator or laser pulse. We develop a kinematic model based on the energy-momentum conservation law and the corpuscular presentation of the periodic-field photons. The model incorporates the mass shift effect in periodic fields. We made an assumption of equality of the average number of photons, which induce the mass shift, to the Poisson parameter of the coherent field. The model allows to evaluate the evolution of the spectrum of electron bunch passing through the periodic fields of undulators or laser pulses. We propose a method of undulator fine tuning aimed at maximization of the spectral brightness.

Introduction

Bright sources of hard x- and gamma-ray electromagnetic radiation are of high demand in physics and technology. Such sources, e.g., x-ray free-electron lasers (XFELs), undulator- or Compton-based sources of polarized positrons, etc., require intense ultrarelativistic electron beams with small energy spread. Also each electron should emit many photons per pass through the periodic field of undulator or laser pulse: For XFELs, it is typical ∼500\sim500 photons per pass [1], for the undulator of International Linear Collider [2], it is projected 50 . . . 300 photons/pass.

With increase in the electron energy and the frequency of the external driving forces – undulators of XFELs, lasers of Compton sources – recoils caused by emission of quanta induce energy losses. These losses are random, and affect the energy and the angular spreads of the beam distribution in the phase space.

Interactions of coherent photons with ultra-relativistic electrons have been extensively studied both experimentally and theoretically in recent years.

We constructed a multiphoton model of interaction of electrons with periodic fields. The model is based on kinematics of the interactions – the law of momentum-energy preservation. We consider the periodical field as aggregation of the photon number states, which are assumed to be distributed according the Poisson law. Relativistic electrons in such field acquire an additional mass and may interact with an individual number state. The key assumption of the model is that the mass shift (a classical parameter equal to the average squared transverse momentum acquired in the field) is assumed to be equal to the Poisson parameter λ\lambda of the laser/undulator photon states distribution. This interaction results in scattering off the state – the nonlinear Compton radiation, or generation of higher harmonics in the undulator radiation.

In the present paper, we are going to study these effects, aimed at evaluation the evolution of the electron spectrum affected by recoils from scattered off such photon states. We show, that the interactions of electrons with the coherent field are governed by three parameters: (i) the electron energy, (ii) the photon energy, and (iii) the average number of the photons per the laser/undulator wavelength.

The paper is organized as following: The second section contains a formulation of the suggested kinematic model. In the third section, there are presented considerations of equivalence the classical field of undulators and the quantum coherent field of laser pulse. The fourth section describes electron bunch kinetics in strong periodic fields. The paper is ended with summary of results and discussion.

Problem setup

The chosen model aims to study the electron beam kinetics in the sources of hard x-ray and gamma-ray radiation. Specific to these sources are the ultrarelativistic electrons that are emitting photons with energy much smaller than that of the electrons. This condition enables to acquire high intensity photon beams since each electron may radiate a number of photons with near identical spectrum.

Therefore, we avoid some extremal parameters of electron-to-field interaction, such as extreme field strength and extreme energy of the income photons, see a classification of the Compton-like scatterings in [3].

We use the natural system of units for particle and atomic physics, ℏ=c=me=1\hbar= c = m_e = 1, where appropriate. Also, the energy of photons will be reduced to the electron rest energy: Ω=ℏΩlas/(mec2)\Omega= \hbar\Omega_{\mathrm{las}}/(m_e c^2) and the like for scattered off photon ω\omega.

In this system, the reduced four-momentum vectors [contravariant, the metric signature (+,−,−,−)(+, -, -, -)] of the electron and the photon are:

Pγ=[γ,γ2−ζ,0,0] ;P_\gamma= [\gamma, \sqrt{\gamma^2-\zeta}, 0, 0] \,;
Pγ′=[γ′,γ2−ζ,0,0] ;P_{\gamma'} = [\gamma', \sqrt{\gamma^2-\zeta}, 0, 0] \,;
PΩ=[Ω,−Ω,0,0] ;P_\Omega= [\Omega, -\Omega, 0, 0] \,;
Pω=[ω,ω,0,0] ,P_\omega= [\omega, \omega, 0, 0] \,,

where γ\gamma, γ′\gamma' are the initial and final Lorentz-factors of the electron, Ω\Omega, ω\omega are the initial and the scattered reduced energies of the photon [equivalent Lorentz factors, ℏω/(mec2)\hbar\omega/(m_ec^2)]. The dimensionless parameter ζ≥1\zeta\ge1 corresponds to the electron mass-shift in the intense periodic field, see [4]:

me2c4⇒ζme2c4 .m_e^2c^4 \Rightarrow\zeta m_e^2c^4 \,.

Kinematic relations (the energy and momentum conservation laws) Pγ+PΩ=Pγ′+PωP_\gamma+ P_\Omega= P_{\gamma'} + P_\omega enable one to derive the maximum energy of scattered (undergone recoil) photons:

ωm=Ω[(γ+Ω+γ2−ζ)2−Ω2]4Ω(γ+Ω)+ζ(1)\omega_m = \frac{\Omega\left[\left(\gamma+\Omega+\sqrt{\gamma^2-\zeta}\right)^2-\Omega^2\right]}{4\Omega(\gamma+\Omega)+\zeta} \tag*{(1)}

It is worth to note, that the relation (1) is exact, only restricted to γ2≥ζ\gamma^2 \ge\zeta: the classical Compton formula, γ=ζ=1\gamma=\zeta=1 is a limiting case.

For the considered case of the ultrarelativistic electrons γ≫Ω\gamma\gg\Omega, Eq. (1) is reduced to the known ones (see, e.g., [5] [3]):

ωm≈4Ωγ24γΩ+ζ .(2)\omega_m \approx\frac{4\Omega\gamma^2}{4\gamma\Omega+\zeta} \,. \tag*{(2)}

The first term in the denominator, 4γΩ4\gamma\Omega, is equal to the income photon energy in the electron rest frame.

The final energy of the electron that emitted a photon on the Compton edge is

γ′=γ+Ω−ω .\gamma' = \gamma+\Omega-\omega\,.

Equivalence of classical field energy and photons density

Parameter ζ\zeta, used in the previous section, is connected to the field strength as ζ:=1+ξ2\zeta:= 1+\xi^2, where the laser field strength ξ\xi – the classical nonlinearity parameter, see [6] – is:

ξ:=⟨∣E∣⟩∣e∣mecΩlas\xi:= \langle|E| \rangle\frac{|e|}{m_ec\Omega_{\mathrm{las}}}

where ⟨∣E∣⟩\langle|E| \rangle is the averaged over period module of the electric field strength, ee, mem_e are the charge and the mass of electron, resp., cc is the velocity of light, and Ωlas\Omega_{\mathrm{las}} is the angular frequency of the laser field.

Formal presentation of the parameter λ:=ξ2\lambda:= \xi^2 as the number of equivalent photons per their wavelength through the electric field squared needs to be clarified: The average over period electric field strength, E2E^2 in

⟨ξ2⟩=⟨E2⟩(emecΩ)2 ,\langle\xi^2 \rangle= \langle E^2 \rangle\left(\frac{e}{m_ec\Omega}\right)^2 \,,

is equal to its maximum value for the circularly polarized wave. For the linearly polarized wave, the average photons density is λ=ξ2/2\lambda= \xi^2/2.

Employing the physical constants, the fine-structure constant α\alpha and the Compton electron wave length λC\lambda_C,

α=e2ℏc ;λC=ℏmec ,\alpha= \frac{e^2}{\hbar c} \,; \qquad \lambda_C = \frac{\hbar}{m_ec} \,,

and taking into account the energy density (CGS system of units)

w=18π(E2+H2)w = \frac{1}{8\pi}(E^2+H^2)

(∣E∣=∣H∣(|E|=|H| in flat wave) we finally obtain

ξ2=2αλC2λlasρq .\xi^2 = 2\alpha\lambda_C^2\lambda_{\mathrm{las}}\rho_q \,.

Here, ρq=E2/4πℏΩlas\rho_q=E^2/4\pi\hbar\Omega_{\mathrm{las}} is the density of effective laser photons. Therefore, ξ2\xi^2 is equal to the mean number of laser photons contained in the volume

V=2αλC2λlas .V=2\alpha\lambda_C^2\lambda_{\mathrm{las}} \,.

Numerical value for the ‘effective volume’:

V=2.18×10−27λ[m] m3=2.18 λ[nm] nm3 .V=2.18\times10^{-27}\lambda[\mathrm{m}]\,\mathrm{m}^3=2.18\,\lambda[\mathrm{nm}]\,\mathrm{nm}^3 \,.

Recolllecting the Thomson cross section, σT=8πre2/3=8πα2λC2/3\sigma_T=8\pi r_e^2/3=8\pi\alpha^2\lambda_C^2/3, the condition λ=ξ2=1\lambda=\xi^2=1 may be presented as a scattering of one photon over

34πα≈33 periods .\frac{3}{4\pi\alpha}\approx33\ \text{periods} \,.

Quantization of the classical periodic electromagnetic field

Interaction of the ultrarelativistic electron γ≫1\gamma\gg1 with the periodic magnetic field of undulator magnet is similar to the interaction with the flat EM wave. In the electron rest frame, the difference between the actual electric field EwE_w and that of the flat wave EE is significantly reduced:

Ew2−E2Ew2∼γ−2 ,\frac{E_w^2-E^2}{E_w^2}\sim\gamma^{-2} \,,

as a consequence of a Lorentz-invariant scalar (E2−H2)=const(E^2-H^2)=\mathrm{const}.

The role of the laser ξ2\xi^2 parameter is played by the undulator K2K^2 parameter [K:=eB0λu/(2πmec)K:=eB_0\lambda_u/(2\pi m_ec), see [7]]. There is no electrical field in the lab frame, therefore the energy density is half of the equivalent wave; on the other hand, the effective energy of the quantum is half of the wave’s. [For ultrarelativistic electrons, the undulator field may be treated as the flat wave with the half of frequency: Ωu=c/(2λu)\Omega_u = c/(2\lambda_u).] Thus, λ:=ξ2\lambda:= \xi^2 is equal to the number of photons that ‘dressed up’ the electron passing though an oscillating field.

Fundamental assumption: coherent field

In the photon number presentation, a coherent state is defined by the Poisson-weighted sum of the number units, see, e.g., [8, 9], each containing kk photons:

pk=e−λλkk!,p_k = e^{-\lambda}\frac{\lambda^k}{k!},

where pkp_k is the probability of having a unit state containing exactly kk photons, and λ\lambda is the mean number of photons.

Let us consider a mass-shifted (dressed) electron scattered off a certain number unit ‘converting’ it into a single photon (the classical analog of harmonics): γ+kΩ⇒γ′+ω\gamma+ k\Omega\Rightarrow\gamma' + \omega. Its maximum energy, c.f., Eq. (2), is

ωkmax⁡≃4kΩγ24γkΩ+ζ.(3)\omega_k^{\max} \simeq\frac{4k\Omega\gamma^2}{4\gamma k\Omega+\zeta}. \tag*{(3)}

The key assumption is: the mean number of photons, that the electron coupled with, equals to the magnitude of the mass shift:

k‾=λ.(4)\overline{k} = \lambda. \tag*{(4)}

With substitution Ω⇒kΩ\Omega\Rightarrow k\Omega into Eq. (2), we deduce the maximum photon energy in kkth harmonic:

ωkmax⁡≃4kΩγ24kγΩ+1+λ.(5)\omega_k^{\max} \simeq\frac{4k\Omega\gamma^2}{4k\gamma\Omega+1+\lambda}. \tag*{(5)}

For a given spectrum of each harmonic fk(ω)f_k(\omega), the aggregate spectrum reads:

Fλ(ω)=∑k=1∞e−λλk−1(k−1)!fk(ω;λ).F_\lambda(\omega) = \sum_{k=1}^{\infty}\frac{e^{-\lambda}\lambda^{k-1}}{(k-1)!}f_k(\omega;\lambda).

The quasi-Thomson limit of small recoil, 4γΩ≪1+λ4\gamma\Omega\ll1+\lambda, which is specific to the undulator- and Compton sources of x-ray radiation, each harmonic is symmetric around its mean frequency ω‾k\overline{\omega}_k, see [7] and Appendix A. In this practical approximation, the mean energy in the aggregate spectrum is independent from the field strength:

ω‾:=∫ωFλ(ω) dω=ω1max⁡(λ→0)/2.(6)\overline{\omega} := \int\omega F_\lambda(\omega)\,\mathrm{d}\omega= \omega_1^{\max}(\lambda\to0)/2. \tag*{(6)}

It should be noted, that for a very high harmonic number k→∞k \to\infty, the approximation of negligible recoil does not hold. But for the Poisson distribution, the contribution of these harmonics to the aggregate spectrum is exponentially small at k≫λk \gg\lambda.

Electron bunch kinetics

Under the assumption of independently emitted photons with the identical spectrum, and thus independent recoils undergone by the electron, evolution of the energy spectrum of the bunch – its characteristic function – is governed by the formula, [10, 11, 12]:

f^=f^0exp⁡[x(wˇ−1)]=:f^0S^(7)\hat{f} = \hat{f}_0\exp[x(\check{w}-1)] =: \hat{f}_0\hat{S} \tag*{(7)}

where f^\hat{f} is the Fourier transform of the probability density function (PDF) – the characteristic function for the energy spectrum – for the electron bunch, wˇ\check{w} is the inverse Fourier transform of the recoil spectrum, xx is the ensemble average number of recoils from the front end of the field, f0=f(x=0)f_0=f(x=0).

Therefore, for the evaluation of the evolution of bunch spectrum, it is sufficient to evaluate the (inverse) Fourier transform of the recoil spectrum.

The spectrum f(γ;x,w)f(\gamma;x,w) is the convolution of the initial spectrum f0(γ)f_0(\gamma) with the struggling function S(x;w)S(x;w). The struggling function – distribution density of fluctuations – is determined solely by the ensemble-average number of recoils having undergone by the particle since entering the field, and the spectrum of the recoil.

Evolution of spectrum

Equation (7) provides comprehensive description of the electron bunch kinetics that undergoes random independent identically distributed energy losses. For the Thompson scattering, where the spectrum has a compact support, ω∈(0,ωmax⁡]\omega\in(0,\omega^{\max}], we can make a few estimations of the spectrum evolution dependence on the average number of scattering:

x≲1x \lesssim1 Contribution of the initial distribution decays as f0exp⁡(−x)f_0\exp(-x) with addition of a tail directed toward low energy. The tail is formed from the electrons subjected to one (∝x\propto x), two (∝x2/2\propto x^2/2), etc. convolution of the recoil spectrum with the initial distribution. The spectrum may have a number of local maximums.

x≲10x \lesssim10 The spectrum evolves toward a unimodal one (single maximum), which may be approximated with a stable univariate distribution [13], the stability parameter α(x)\alpha(x) increases from one (ballistic diffusion), and asymptotically approaches two (the normal diffusion).

x→∞x \to\infty Quasi-normal diffusion, the distribution is Gaussian with truncated high-energy tail, f(γ>γ0max⁡)=0f(\gamma> \gamma_0^{\max})=0.

Equation (7) allows us to derive the moments of the spectrum:

γ‾(x)=γ‾0−xω‾;\overline{\gamma}(x)=\overline{\gamma}_0-x\overline{\omega};
Var⁡[γ](x)=(γ−γ‾)2‾=Var⁡[γ]0+xω2‾;\operatorname{Var}[\gamma](x)=\overline{(\gamma-\overline{\gamma})^2}=\operatorname{Var}[\gamma]_0+x\overline{\omega^2};

in general

Mncnt[f]=Mncnt[f0]+(−1)nxMnraw[w];n>1,(8)M_n^{\mathrm{cnt}}[f] = M_n^{\mathrm{cnt}}[f_0] + (-1)^n x M_n^{\mathrm{raw}}[w]; \quad n > 1, \tag*{(8)}

where MncntM_n^{\mathrm{cnt}}, MnrawM_n^{\mathrm{raw}} are the nnth centered and raw moments, respectively.

All the moments of the electron spectrum are linear on the number of scatterings xx, which in turn is linear on the number of the laser photons per the wavelength λ\lambda. Since the average energy loss per interaction is independent of the number of photons λ\lambda, see (6), the evolution of the straggling function for a given recoil spectrum is determined only by the number of recoils xx.

The moments of PDF provide adequate description of the evolution for a big number of recoils, x≫1x \gg1: The diffusion approximates the normal one, the scale parameter (width of spectrum) c∼x1/2c \sim x^{1/2}, and the odd moments become negligible.

At x≳1x \gtrsim1, the evolution of the spectrum differs from the normal. The width of the spectrum depends on the number of recoils (see [12]) as:

c(x)=[xmα[w]]1/α,(9)c(x) = [x m_{\alpha}[w]]^{1/\alpha}, \tag*{(9)}

where

α(x)=sDsℜ[w~]1−ℜ[w~]∣s=s∗(x),\alpha(x) = \left.\frac{sD_s\Re[\widetilde{w}]}{1-\Re[\widetilde{w}]}\right|_{s=s_*(x)},

s∗(x)s_*(x) is a root of equation

ℜ[x(1−w~(s∗))]=1,\Re[x(1-\widetilde{w}(s_*))] = 1,

and mα[w]m_{\alpha}[w] is the fractional moment of the recoil spectrum:

mα[w]=∫Rωαw(ω) dω;ω>0,(10)m_{\alpha}[w] = \int_{\mathbb{R}} \omega^\alpha w(\omega)\,\mathrm{d}\omega; \quad\omega> 0, \tag*{(10)}

Dsℜ[w~]D_s\Re[\widetilde{w}] indicates the partial derivative with respect to ss of the real part of the inverse Fourier transform of recoil spectrum.

Aggregate spectrum of recoils

The ‘realistic’ aggregate spectrum of nonlinear Compton radiation (if the components do not differ significantly from the Thomson’s) may be approximated as composition of rectangles with the Poisson weight:

w(ω;γ,Ω,λ)=∑k=1∞Pk−1[λ]Θ[ω,ωkmax⁡−ω]ωkmax⁡,(11)w(\omega;\gamma,\Omega,\lambda) = \sum_{k=1}^{\infty} P_{k-1}[\lambda]\frac{\Theta[\omega,\omega_k^{\max}-\omega]}{\omega_k^{\max}}, \tag*{(11)}

where Θ(⋅,⋅)\Theta(\cdot,\cdot) is the Heaviside 2D step function. A closed form of the spectrum (11) read

w(ω;γ,Ω,λ)=4γ2Ωλ+1λ[1−Q(⌈(λ+1)ω⌉,λ)]:=4γ2Ω×G(ω,λ)(12)\begin{aligned} w(\omega;\gamma,\Omega,\lambda) &= 4\gamma^2\Omega\frac{\lambda+1}{\lambda}\left[1-Q(\lceil(\lambda+1)\omega\rceil,\lambda)\right] \\ &\mathrel{:=} 4\gamma^2\Omega\times G(\omega,\lambda) \tag*{(12)} \end{aligned}

where ⌈x⌉\lceil x\rceil gives the ceiling (the smallest integer greater than or equal to xx), QQ is the incomplete gamma function.

The aggregate recoil spectrum may be factorized into the relativistic Thomson factor 4γ2Ω4\gamma^2\Omega and a spectral function G(ω,λ)G(\omega,\lambda) independent on γ\gamma and Ω\Omega, [Q(⋅,⋅\cdot,\cdot) is the regularized incomplete gamma function].

Figure 1 presents the function G(ω,λ)G(\omega,\lambda) for ω1max⁡(λ→0)=1\omega_1^{\max}(\lambda\to0) = 1, and for a range of the field strengths λ\lambda.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Top panel: Spectral function Q(ω,λ)Q(\omega,\lambda) for λ=0.01,0.25,1,4\lambda= 0.01, 0.25, 1, 4 (blue, orange, green, and red, resp.). Bottom panel: Superposition of the first five harmonics [7] with the Poisson weight, K2=λ=1K^2 = \lambda= 1. Photon’s energy normalized to the ensemble average.

As seen from Figure 1, all the harmonics shrink with increase of λ\lambda, while the amplitudes of higher harmonics

From spectrum of recoils to spectrum of electrons

The inverse Fourier transform (ω→s\omega\to s) of the aggregate recoil spectrum G(ω,λ)G(\omega,\lambda) has a form:

w~(s;λ)=iλϕ{1−exp⁡[λ(exp⁡(iϕ)−1)]}(13)\widetilde{w}(s;\lambda)=\frac{i}{\lambda\phi}\left\{1-\exp\left[\lambda\left(\exp(i\phi)-1\right)\right]\right\} \tag*{(13)}
=iλϕ{1−exp⁡[−λ(1−cos⁡(ϕ))]cos⁡(λsin⁡(ϕ))}(14)=\frac{i}{\lambda\phi}\left\{1-\exp\left[-\lambda(1-\cos(\phi))\right]\cos(\lambda\sin(\phi))\right\} \tag*{(14)}
+1λϕexp⁡[−λ(1−cos⁡(ϕ))]sin⁡[λsin⁡(ϕ)](15)+\frac{1}{\lambda\phi}\exp\left[-\lambda(1-\cos(\phi))\right]\sin\left[\lambda\sin(\phi)\right] \tag*{(15)}

where ϕ:=2πs/(1+λ)\phi:=2\pi s/(1+\lambda).

The electron bunch spectrum – i.e., the probability density function (PDF) – under the assumption of initial delta function f0=δ(γ−γ0)f_0=\delta(\gamma-\gamma_0) is presented in Figure 2.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Electrons’ spectra for different λ\lambda at x=0.1,0.5,0.8x=0.1, 0.5, 0.8, resp., initial delta function not shown.

The initial electron spectrum decays with xx as ∼exp⁡(−x)\sim\exp(-x). The mode (maximum) position moves to the left jump-like, shifting by the width of the first harmonic. The case λ=1\lambda=1 is characterized by the maximum tail ‘weight’.

The second stage of the spectrum evolution, x≲10x\lesssim10, may be approximated with α\alpha-stable distribution, where the stability parameter is a function of xx.

The scale cc – the width of spectrum – evolves as

c(x)=[xmα[w]]1/α(16)c(x)=\left[xm_{\alpha}[w]\right]^{1/\alpha} \tag*{(16)}

where mαm_{\alpha} is a fractional moment of the recoil PDF (10).

The fractional moments of the considered spectrum are functions of λ\lambda, see Figure 3.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Moments Mα(λ)M_{\alpha}(\lambda) for different λ\lambda.

With an increase of the stability parameter α\alpha, the scale cc – width of PDF – builds up slower with number of the emitted photons.

Dependencies of the stability parameter on the number of recoils for different λ\lambda are presented in Figure 4. Corresponding growth of the scale parameter with xx is presented in Figure 5.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. Stability parameter α(x;λ)\alpha(x;\lambda) vs. xx for λ=0.01\lambda= 0.01 (red), λ=1\lambda= 1 (black), and λ=2\lambda= 2 (blue).

Image not extracted

Figure 5. The scale vs number of photons scattered off for λ=0.01\lambda= 0.01 (red), and λ=1\lambda= 1 (black).

In the intermediate range of recoils, 1≲x≲101\lesssim x\lesssim10, the width of the spectrum is increasing faster than predicted for the normal diffusion. The rate of the increase depends nonlinearly on the photons density λ\lambda with its maximum around λ=1\lambda=1.

For the big number of scatterings, x≳20x\gtrsim20, when the electron spectrum is not too different from the normal distribution, α≲2\alpha\lesssim2, essential information can be deduced from the moments. The normalized central nnth moment (n>2n>2) decreases with the increase of xx:

μn≡MnM2n/2∝xxn/2=x1−n/2,\mu_n\equiv\frac{M_n}{M_2^{n/2}}\propto\frac{x}{x^{n/2}}=x^{1-n/2},

where MnM_n is the central nn-moment, c.f. Eq. (8).

When the stability parameter approaches the ‘normal diffusion’ magnitude of α≲2\alpha\lesssim2 (still remaining below it), the skewness Sk⁡[w]>0\operatorname{Sk}[w]>0 – the third central moment – remains positive and increases linearly with xx. We can derive practical information about the mode of the distribution, i.e., the coordinate of the maximum. Making use of Pearson’s skewness for a distribution close to the normal, see, e.g. [12, 14], the maximum of spectrum (mode) is shifted from the mean position to

γmode=γ‾+13μ3M21/2≈γ‾+κ12M3(raw)[w]M2(raw)[w],\gamma_{\mathrm{mode}}=\overline{\gamma}+\frac{1}{3}\mu_3 M_2^{1/2}\approx\overline{\gamma}+\kappa\frac{1}{2}\frac{M_3^{(\mathrm{raw})}[w]}{M_2^{(\mathrm{raw})}[w]},

where κ:=4γ2Ω\kappa:=4\gamma^2\Omega. For x≫1x\gg1, the shift is independent of the number of emitted photons.

The ‘rectangular’ model yields the mode position:

γmode=γˉ+κL(λ) ;\gamma_{\mathrm{mode}}=\bar{\gamma}+\kappa L(\lambda)\,;
L(λ):=3(1+7λ+6λ2+λ3)8(1+λ)(1+3λ+λ2) .L(\lambda):=\frac{3(1+7\lambda+6\lambda^{2}+\lambda^{3})}{8(1+\lambda)(1+3\lambda+\lambda^{2})}\,.

The function L(λ)L(\lambda) is plotted in Figure 6, the maximum shift is attained at λ∗≈0.786\lambda_{*}\approx0.786.

Image not extracted

Figure 6. Shift of the mode from the mean vs. λ\lambda.

Results and Discussion

The energy spectrum of the radiating electrons weakly depends on the driving field magnitude (the higher harmonics composition), which enables us to optimize tapering of the FEL undulators with adjustment to the mode of electron spectrum.

Results

  1. The proposed kinematic model comprises of the mass shift of the ultrarelativistic electrons passing through periodical (electro-)magnetic coherent fields.

  2. The key assumption consists of equality of the mass shift parameter to the average number of photons that the electron interacts.

  3. The considered coherent electromagnetic field has the Poisson distribution of the photon number states, the Poisson parameter – ensemble average number of photons the electron interacted with – equal to that of the mass shift factor.

  4. The model yields well-known dependence of the radiation power on the field strength squared. The power is independent of the harmonics composition.

  5. A simplified ‘rectangular’ model was developed aimed at deriving analytics of evolution of the bunch kinetics as a function of the field strength. The model is based on a given cross section of the Compton scattering, the Poisson distribution of the photon number states, and the Poisson-subordinate process of energy losses of electrons caused by the nonlinear quasi-Thompson scattering.

  6. The most ‘harmful’ field strength – the widest recoil spectrum and thus the fastest increase of the bunch spectrum with number of emitted photons – corresponds to one ‘laser’ photon over the period: λ=1\lambda= 1.

interacted electron beam kinetics allows us to fine tune the undulator. With adjustment of the resonant frequency of undulator to the maximum (mode) of spectrum allows to maximize the efficiency of its operation, see [16, 17]. An example of tuning a (hypothetic) undulator is presented in Appendix B.

The width of electron bunch spectrum increases linearly over the initial section of Free Electron Lasers where the coherent microbunches formed. With increase in energy (aimed at attain higher energy photons) the length of formation increased ∝γ\propto\gamma while the width of the spectrum is proportional to γ2\gamma^2 that limits the formation of coherent microbunches.

Discussion

The developed kinematic model is in agreement with a few known results: First, the kk-harmonic Compton edge (5) is identical to that derived for the ‘nonlinear QED’ case, see [5, 15]. Second, the Poisson distribution of photons over the harmonics as well as equality of the mean energy of photon in nonlinear spectrum to that in the linear spectrum (λ→0\lambda\to0) agrees well with the classical model of the undulator radiation [7]. Third, the Poisson distribution of number of photons in each harmonic together with k(1+λ)−1k(1+\lambda)^{-1} dependence of the mean photon energy in kkth harmonic yields the classical dependence of the radiation power proportional to the magnetic-field strength squared. The latter may validate the effect of the electron mass shift in periodic fields, which has not yet been proven experimentally, see [4].

The developed approach will be a useful basis for simulating codes, that model evolution of the spectrum of electrons passing through nonlinear undulators or laser pulses. (A linear code was already realized, see [10].)

The above presented analysis of multiphoton-interacted electron beam kinetics allows us to fine tune the undulator. With adjustment of the resonant frequency of undulator to the maximum (mode) of spectrum allows to maximize the efficiency of its operation, see [16, 17]. An example of tuning a (hypothetic) undulator is presented in Appendix B.

Acknowledgments

The author would like to thank Drs. Svitozar Serkez, Gianluca Aldo Geloni, and Serguei Molodtsov of Eu-XFEL for fruitful cooperation and interest. Multi-photon processes were extensively discussed with the late Prof. Nikolay Shul’ga of NSC KIPT. Computations were done with the Wolfram Mathematica Cloud package [18]. where

K=eBλ02πnc2K = \frac{eB\lambda_0}{2\pi n c^2}
αn2=nr−1−K2\alpha_n^2 = \frac{n}{r} - 1 - K^2
xn=2Krαnx_n = 2K r \alpha_n
r=ω2γ2ω0r = \frac{\omega}{2\gamma^2\omega_0}
ω0=2πβ∗cλ0\omega_0 = \frac{2\pi\beta^* c}{\lambda_0}
β∗=β[1−(Kγ)2]1/2\beta^* = \beta\left[1-\left(\frac{K}{\gamma}\right)^2\right]^{1/2}

nn is the harmonic number, λ0\lambda_0 is the undulator’s period, KK is the undulator parameter, NN is the number of the undulator’s periods, Jn(⋅)J_n(\cdot), Jn′(⋅)J'_n(\cdot) are the nnth order Bessel function and its derivative, Θ(⋅)\Theta(\cdot) is the Heaviside step function.

For the nn-th harmonics, the maximum frequency coincides with (2):

max⁡ω≡ωn∗=2γ2ω0n1+K2.\max\omega\equiv\omega_n^* = \frac{2\gamma^2\omega_0 n}{1+K^2}.

We introduce a new variable ζ\zeta equal to the ratio of the frequency ω\omega to the maximum frequency,

ζn=ζn(K)=ω(1+K2)2γ2ω0n,\zeta_n = \zeta_n(K) = \frac{\omega(1+K^2)}{2\gamma^2\omega_0 n},

with the support in interval [0,1][0,1].

With this variable, the above definitions read

ω=2ζnγ2ω0n1+K2;\omega= \frac{2\zeta_n\gamma^2\omega_0 n}{1+K^2};
dω=2γ2ω0n1+K2 dζn;d\omega= \frac{2\gamma^2\omega_0 n}{1+K^2}\,d\zeta_n;
αn2=(1+K2)(1−ζn)ζn\alpha_n^2 = \frac{(1+K^2)(1-\zeta_n)}{\zeta_n}
xn=2Kn[ζn(1−ζn)1+K2]1/2;x_n = 2K n\left[\frac{\zeta_n(1-\zeta_n)}{1+K^2}\right]^{1/2};
Θ(αn)=Θ(1−ζn);\Theta(\alpha_n)=\Theta(1-\zeta_n);
(αnK−nxn)2=(1+K2)(1−2ζn)24K2ζn(1−ζn);\left(\frac{\alpha_n}{K}-\frac{n}{x_n}\right)^2 = \frac{(1+K^2)(1-2\zeta_n)^2}{4K^2\zeta_n(1-\zeta_n)};
4Jn′2=Jn−12−2Jn−1Jn+1+Jn+12.4J_n^{\prime2}=J_{n-1}^2-2J_{n-1}J_{n+1}+J_{n+1}^2.

Focused on “quantization” of the multi-harmonics spectrum, we can retain the terms under the sum sign in (A1):

Sn(ζn,K)≡[Jn−12(xn)−2Jn−1(xn)Jn+1(xn)+Jn+12(xn)+(1+K2)(1−2ζn)2K2ζn(1−ζn)Jn2(xn)]Θ(1−ζn).(17)S_n(\zeta_n,K)\equiv \left[ J_{n-1}^2(x_n)-2J_{n-1}(x_n)J_{n+1}(x_n)+J_{n+1}^2(x_n) + \frac{(1+K^2)(1-2\zeta_n)^2}{K^2\zeta_n(1-\zeta_n)}J_n^2(x_n) \right]\Theta(1-\zeta_n). \tag*{(17)}

Figure 7 presents the reduced spectra for the first five harmonics at a different magnitude of KK. As presented in Figure 7, the shape of the first harmonic remains about the same for different KKs, while the higher harmonics shapes vary. All the harmonics are symmetrical around ζ=1/2\zeta=1/2, which confirms its mean value to be equal to a half of the maximum.

Image not extracted

Figure 7. The normalized spectra of the five first harmonics for parameter K=0.5,1,2,3K = 0.5, 1, 2, 3.

Sample of undulator tuning

We illustrate fine tuning of a hypothetical undulator to increase its efficiency. The sample undulator is equivalent to circularly polarized infrared laser interacting head-on with 1 GeV electrons, analogous to the alternative source of polarized positrons for ILC [2]. The source employs the first harmonic at λ→0\lambda\to0.

Evolution of the initially delta-shaped electron spectrum is presented in Figure 8. An optimal tuning may be the following: for the initial interval 0<x≲10<x\lesssim1 the resonant frequency should adjust to the maximum in the initial electron spectrum. Then, for the interval 1≲x≲31\lesssim x\lesssim3 the resonant frequency is adjusted to Einit−ωmax⁡E_{\mathrm{init}}-\omega_{\max}. The remaining fraction of the undulator length should follow the mode line with a constant shift to the right from the mean line.

Image not extracted

Figure 8. Evolution of the spectrum in a hypothetical case of 1 GeV electrons scattered off 1 eV photons, λ→0\lambda\to0 (dipole harmonic).

Such adjustment will produce 10...30% brighter radiation compared with adjustment to the mean frequency. The proposed tuning qualitatively agrees with an empirical approach described in [17].

References

  1. [4]C. Harvey, T. Heinzl, A. Ilderton, and M. Marklund, Intensity-dependent electron mass shift in a laser field: Existence, universality, and detection, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 100402 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23005266
  2. [5]H. Abramowicz et al., Conceptual design report for the LUXE experiment, Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top. 230, 2445 (2021).DOI
  3. [6]H. Abramowicz et al., Technical design report for the LUXE experiment (2023), arXiv:2308.00515 [hep-ex].arXiv
  4. [7]B. M. Kincaid, A short-period helical wiggler as an improved source of synchrotron radiation, Journal of Applied Physics 48, 2684 (1977).DOI
  5. [8]R. J. Glauber, Coherent and incoherent states of the radiation field, Phys. Rev. 131, 2766 (1963).DOI
  6. [9]Fox, M. (2006). Quantum optics: An introduction, 2nd ed., Vol. 1.
  7. [10]E. Bulyak and N. Shul’ga, Kinetics of relativistic electrons passing through quasi-periodic fields, Nucl Instrum Meth Phys Res, Sect B 402, 121 (2017).DOI
  8. [11]Bulyak, E., & Shul’ga, N. (2020). Kinetics of relativistic electrons undergoing small recoils in periodic structures and matter. Journal of Instrumentation, 13(02), C02051.
  9. [12]E. Bulyak and N. Shul’ga, Statistics of relativistic electrons radiating in periodic fields, Physical Review AB 22, 040705 (2019).DOI
  10. [13]Nolan, J. P. (2018). Univariate Stable Distributions - Models for Heavy Tailed Data. In Springer Verlag.
  11. [14]Kenney, J. F., & Keeping, E. S. (1962). Mathematics of Statistics.
  12. [15]C. Harvey, T. Heinzl, and A. Ilderton, Signatures of high-intensity Compton scattering, Physical Review A 79, 10.1103/physreva.79.063407 (2009).DOI
  13. [16]X. J. Wang, H. P. Freund, D. Harder, J. W. H. Miner, J. B. Murphy, H. Qian, Y. Shen, and X. Yang, Efficiency and spectrum enhancement in a tapered free-electron laser amplifier, Phys. Rev. Letters 103, 154801 (2009).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19905644
  14. [17]Mak, A., Curbs, F., Faatz, B., & Werin, S. (2016). Empirical optimization of undulator tapering at flash2 and comparison with numerical simulations. arXiv:1608.08108v1 [physics.acc-ph]
  15. [18]Wolfram Research, I. (2019). Mathematica, Version 12.0.

Paper details

vlnc:W_h7zahprv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents