Let R be a Noetherian N-graded ring. Assume that L and M are finitely generated Z-graded R-module, and I a homogeneous ideal of R. Let N be a graded submodule of M. Fix k∈N. Denote H:=ExtRk(L,M) (or TorkR(L,M)) and Hn:=ExtRk(L,M/InN) (or TorkR(L,M/InN)). When I is generated by elements of positive degree, we show that the local v-number of Hn either coincides with that of colon submodule (0:HI) or is a polynomial in n of degree one whose leading coefficient is one of the degrees of the generators of I. This extends the main result of Ghosh-Pramanik [J. Algebra 671 (2025), 61-74], where asymptotic linearity was shown under the assumption that (0:HI)=0.
Introduction
The concept of the Vasconcelos invariant, associated with a homogeneous ideal in a polynomial ring over a field, was proposed in [4] to investigate the limiting behavior of the minimum distance of projective Reed-Muller type codes. This invariant, currently known as the v-number, was generalized to the setting of graded modules in [10]. The asymptotic behavior of v-numbers for graded modules has attracted significant attention in recent years (see, for instance, [1, 8, 16, 9, 15, 3, 6, 7]). In addition to these developments, our investigation is motivated by several other prominent works [10, 13, 12] in this direction.
Setup 1.1. Let R be a Noetherian N-graded ring. Assume that L and M are finitely generated Z-graded R-module, and I a homogeneous ideal of R. Let N be a graded submodule of M. Suppose I is generated by homogeneous elements y1,…,yc of degree d1≤…≤dc respectively.
Recall, for p∈AssR(M), the local v-number of M at p is defined as vp(M)=inf{n∣p=(0:Rx) for some x∈Mn}. The global v-number of M is defined by
v(M)=min{vp(M):p∈AssR(M)}.
By convention, v(0)=∞. In [2], Brodmann proved that the set AssR(M/InM) stabilize eventually. Let AM(I) be the stable set. Motivated by this result of Brodmann, Conca showed that when R is a domain and p∈AR(I), vp(R/In)=apn+bp for all n≫0, where ap is equal to one of the degrees of the generators of I, and bp∈Z[3 Theorem 1.1]. When R is a polynomial ring over a field, the same result was proved by Ficarra-Sgroi in [7]. In [10 Theorem 2.14], Fiorindo-Ghosh showed that when p∈AM(I), then for n≫0, vp(M/InM) is linear functions of n whose leading coefficients are from the degree of the generators of I provided (0:MI)=0. In a recent paper [12], the authors study the case when (0:MI)=0. When I is generated by elements of positive degree, the authors in [12] show that the local v-number of M/InM either coincides with that of colon submodule (0:MI) or is a polynomial in n of degree one whose leading coefficient is one of the degrees of the generators of I.
Now let M, N and L be finitely generated graded R-modules with N⊆M. In [14 Corollary 3.5], Katz–West proved that, for fixed k∈N, the sets AssR(ExtRk(L,M/InN)) and AssR(TorkR(L,M/InN)) are independent of n for n≫0. In [13], Ghosh–Pramanik proved that, for fixed k∈N, the local v-number of ExtRk(L,M/InN) is eventually a linear function of n for n≫0 with leading coefficient being the degree of a generators of I whenever (0:ExtRk(L,M)I)=0. They also showed that an analogous statement holds for TorkR(L,M/InN) whenever (0:TorkR(L,M)I)=0. Keeping these results in mind, the following questions arise naturally.
Question 1.2. Let R be a Noetherian N-graded ring. Assume that L and M are finitely generated Z-graded R-module, and I a homogeneous ideal of R. Let N be a graded submodule of M. Fix k∈N. Denote H:=ExtRk(L,M) (or TorkR(L,M)) and Hn:=ExtRk(L,M/InN) (or TorkR(L,M/InN)). Let (0:HI)=0.
Let p∈AssR(Hn) for n≫0. What is the asymptotic behaviour of vp(Hn) as a function of n?
What is the asymptotic behaviour of v(Hn)?
We answer the above question via the following theorem which is the main result of this paper.
Theorem 1.3. (Theorem 4.7 below) Let R be a Noetherian N-graded ring. Assume that L and M are finitely generated Z-graded R-modules, and I a homogeneous ideal of R, generated by homogeneous elements y1,…,yc of degree d1≤…≤dc respectively. Let N be a graded submodule of M. Fix k∈N. Denote H:=ExtRk(L,M) (or TorkR(L,M)) and Hn:=ExtRk(L,M/InN) (or TorkR(L,M/InN)). Then the following statements hold:
(1) Let p∈(AssRHn∩V(I))∖AssR(0:HI) for n≫0. Then there exists ap∈{d1,…,dc} and bp∈Z such that vp(Hn)=apn+bp for n≫0.
(2) Let p∈AssR(Hn)∩AssR(0:HI) for n≫0. If di≥1 for 1≤i≤c, then vp(Hn)=vp(0:HI) for n≫0.
(3) Let (0:HI)=0. Then, v(Hn)≤v(0:HI) for n≫0. Further, if di≥1 for 1≤i≤c, and AssR(Hn)⊆V(I), then v(Hn)=v(0:HI) for n≫0.
Organization of the article: This paper is structured into five sections. § 2 introduces the required preliminaries. In § 3, we establish the formula for AssR(U+InV/InW), while § 4 presents the proof of our main result (Theorem 1.3). § 5 concludes with examples demonstrating our main results.
Preliminaries
Throughout this article, all rings are commutative Noetherian rings with unity, and all modules are finitely generated graded R-modules. In this section, we discuss some preliminary results concerning associated primes and local v-numbers of graded modules that will be useful in our proofs.
Definition 2.1. The I-torsion submodule of an R-module M is defined by ΓI(M)={m∈M:Inm=0 for some n≥1}=⋃n≥1(0:MIn).
Lemma 2.2.[12 Lemma 2.5] For any R-module M and an ideal I of R we have AssR(M)∩V(I)=AssR(ΓI(M))=AssR((0:RIn)) for all n≥1.
We frequently rely on the next two propositions throughout our proofs. The first one shows the behavior of v-numbers in an exact sequence.
Proposition 2.3.[12 Proposition 3.1] Let 0→M1→M2→M3→0 be a short exact sequence of finitely generated Z-graded modules over a Noetherian N-graded ring R. Then the following statements are true.
(1) If p∈Ass(M1), then vp(M2)≤vp(M1). Consequently, v(M2)≤v(M1).
(2) If p∈AssR(M2)∖AssR(M1), then vp(M3)≤vp(M2).
The following proposition relates the local v-numbers of a module, its I-torsion submodule, and the associated colon ideals (0:MIn), which will be crucial for our subsequent proofs.
Proposition 2.4.[12 Proposition 3.2] Let R be a Noetherian N-graded ring, M a finitely generated Z-graded R-module, an I a homogeneous ideal of R.
(1) If p∈AssR((0:MI)), then vp(M)=vp(ΓI(M))=vp(0:MIn) for each n≥1.
(2) v(ΓI(M))=v(0:MIn) for each n≥1.
(3) If AssR(M)⊆V(I), then v(M)=v(ΓI(M)).
The following result is an elementary observation concerning the v-numbers.
Proposition 2.5. Let M and N be finitely generated Z-graded R-modules. Then,
(1) For every p∈AssR(M)∩AssR(N), we have vp(M⊕N)=min{vp(M),vp(N)}.
(2) Fix r∈Z. We have v(M(r))=v(M)−r and vp(M(r))=vp(M)−r for all p∈AssR(M).
The following well-known Artin–Rees Lemma will be useful in our later proofs.
Lemma 2.6.[11 Theorem 17.1.6] Let R be a Noetherian ring, I an ideal of R, and M be a finitely generated R-module. Let N be a submodule of M. Then there exists an integer c≥0 such that
ImM∩N=In−c(IcM∩N),for all n≥c.
We now recall the following two lemmas that says ExtRk(L,M/InN) and TorkR(L,M/InN) can be expressed as a quotient of graded modules involving powers of I.
Lemma 2.7.[13 Lemma 3.3] With Setup 1.1, fix k∈N. Then there exists q∈N such that
ExtRk(L,M/InN)≅(U+In−qV)/In−qW for all n≥q
and for some graded submodules U, V and W of a finitely generated R-module E satisfying W⊆V and U≅ExtRk(L,M).
An analogous result holds for Tor-modules, as stated in the following lemma.
Lemma 2.8.[13 Lemma 3.4] With Setup 1.1, fix k∈N. Then there exists q∈N such that
TorkR(L,M/InN)≅(U+In−qV)/In−qW for all n≥q
and for some graded submodules U, V and W of a finitely generated R-module E satisfying W⊆V and U≅TorkR(L,M).
Throughout this article, we assume the following hypothesis
2.9. Hypothesis: Let R be a Noetherian N-graded ring and I be a homogeneous ideal of R generated by homogeneous elements y1,…,yc of degree d1≤…≤dc respectively. Let U,V,W be submodules of a finitely generated Z-graded R-module E such that W⊆V.
For each integer n≥1, put Mn=U+InV, Dn=Mn∩((0:EI)+In−1W), Mn′=Mn/InW, Dn′=Dn/InW, and Tn=(Mn∩In−1W)/InW. Note that InW⊆Mn as W⊆V. Also since InW⊆Dn, Dn′ is well-defined.
Note that in view of Lemma 2.7 and Lemma 2.8, we need to study the behaviour of the local v-number of the graded R-module (U+InV)/InW, i.e., of the graded R-module Mn′. Note that with the hypothesis above and by [14 Proposition 3.4] and its proof, the set AssR((U+InV)/InW) stabilizes eventually, that is the set AssR(Mn′) stabilize for all n≫0.
Associated primes of (U+InV)/InW
In this section, under the Hypothesis 2.9, we investigate the behavior of the set AssR((U+InV)/InW) and establish a result analogous to [12 Theorem 2.2].
Lemma 3.1. Assume the Hypothesis as in 2.9. There exists k∈N such that for every n≥k, the following statements hold:
(a) For every p∈V(I), we have
{x∈Mn:p=(InW:Rx)}⊆Dn.
(b) AssR(Mn′)∩V(I)=AssR(Dn′).
Proof. Since W⊆E, by [5 Corollary 2.1] there exists k∈N such that for all n≥k
(InW:EI)=(0:EI)+In−1W(1)
(a) Let n≥k and let p∈V(I). Suppose that x∈Mn satisfies p=(InW:Rx). Since p∈V(I), we have I⊆p. Consequently, Ix⊆InW. Thus, x∈(InW:EI). By (1) we obtain x∈(0:EI)+In−1W, for all n≥k. Since x∈Mn, it follows that x∈Mn∩((0:EI)+In−1W)=Dn, for all n≥k. Therefore,
{x∈Mn:p=(InW:Rx)}⊆Dn
for every n≥k.
(b) For every n≥1, Dn=Mn∩((0:EI)+In−1W)⊆Mn. Therefore, Dn′⊆Mn′, and hence
AssR(Dn′)⊆AssR(Mn′).(2)
Note that IDn⊆IMn∩(I(0:EI)+InW)=IMn∩InW⊆InW. Consequently, IDn′=I(Dn/InW)=(IDn+InW)/InW=0. Hence,
Conversely, let n≥k and p∈V(I)∩Ass(Mn′). By definition of associated primes, there exists an element xˉ∈Mn′=Mn/InW such that p=(0:Rxˉ)=(InW:Rx). Since p⊇I, it follows from part (a) that x∈Mn∩((0:EI)+In−1W)=Dn. Consequently, xˉ∈Dn/InW=Dn′. Thus, p∈AssR(Dn′). Therefore,
Theorem 3.2. Assume the Hypothesis as in 2.9. we have, for all sufficiently large integers n,
AssR(Mn′)∩V(I)=AssR(0:UI)∪AssR(Tn).
Proof. Let C=(0:EI)={x∈E:Ix=0}. Applying the Artin-Rees lemma to the inclusion C⊆E, there exists an integer r such that C∩InE=In−r(C∩IrE) for all n≥r+1. Since IC=0, it follows that C∩InE=0 for all sufficiently large n. In particular,
C∩In−1W=0(6)
for all sufficiently large n. We claim that
Dn=(C∩Mn)⊕(Mn∩In−1W)(7)
for all sufficiently large n.
Indeed, let x∈Dn. By the definition of Dn, we have x∈Mn and x∈C+In−1W. Thus, we can write x=a+b, where a∈C and b∈In−1W. We first claim that a∈Mn. Let “x” denote reduction modulo U. Consider the quotient module E=E/U, and let C denote the image of C in E. Since IC=0, we have IC=0. Applying the Artin-Rees lemma to the inclusion C⊆E, we obtain C∩InE=0 for all sufficiently large n. Now, x=a+b and hence a=x−b. Since x∈Mn=U+InV⊆U+InE, we have x∈InE⊆In−1E. Also, as b∈In−1W, we have b∈In−1E. Consequently, a∈In−1E. On the other hand, a∈C implies that a∈C. Therefore, a∈C∩In−1E=0 for all sufficiently large n. Thus a=0, which implies that a∈U⊆Mn. Since x,a∈Mn, it follows that b=x−a∈Mn. Therefore, b∈Mn∩In−1W. Hence, x∈(C∩Mn)+(Mn∩In−1W), and hence, Dn⊆(C∩Mn)+(Mn∩In−1W).
Conversely, by the definition of Dn, we have C∩Mn⊆Dn and Mn∩In−1W⊆Dn. Thus, Dn=(C∩Mn)+(Mn∩In−1W). Moreover, by (6), (C∩Mn)∩(Mn∩In−1W)⊆C∩In−1W=0. Therefore, Dn=(C∩Mn)⊕(Mn∩In−1W).
Now define an R-module homomorphism
φ:(C∩Mn)⊕Tn⟶Dn/InWbyφ(a,bˉ)=a+b,
where a∈C∩Mn and b∈Mn∩In−1W.
It is clear that, φ is a well-defined R-module homomorphism. To prove injectivity, suppose that φ(a,bˉ)=0. Then a+b∈InW⊆In−1W. Since b∈In−1W, we obtain a∈C∩In−1W=0, for all sufficiently large n. Thus a=0, and consequently, b∈InW. Therefore, (a,bˉ)=(0,0ˉ), which proves
that φ is injective for n≫0. To prove surjectivity, let x∈Dn/InW. We can write x=a+b, where a∈C∩Mn and b∈Mn∩In−1W. Hence φ(a,b)=a+b=x. Thus φ is surjective. Consequently,
Dn/InW≅(C∩Mn)⊕Tn,n≫0.
By the definitions of Dn′ and Tn, we obtain Dn′≅(C∩Mn)⊕Tn, for all sufficiently large n. Therefore, AssR(Dn′)=AssR(C∩Mn)∪AssR(Tn). Since C∩Mn=(0:MnI), it follows that AssR(Dn′)=AssR((0:MnI))∪AssR(Tn). Finally, by Lemma 3.1(b), AssR(Mn′)∩V(I)=AssR(Dn′) for all sufficiently large n. Hence AssR(Mn′)∩V(I)=AssR(0:MnI)∪AssR(Tn). This completes the proof using the fact (0:MnI)=(0:UI) for n≫0, see [13 Lemma 3.7]. □
We end this section with the following useful remark.
Remark 3.3. Note that in Theorem 3.2 we have proved for n≫0,
Dn′≅(C∩Mn)⊕Tn≅(0:U+InVI)⊕Tn≅(0:UI)⊕Tn
The last isomorphism follows from [13 Lemma 3.7]. Let (−) denote modulo ΓI(U). Then Dn′≅Tn since (0:UI)=0. Also, by definition we have
Dn′=Dn/InW=Mn∩((0:EI)+In−1W)/InW=Mn∩(InW:EI)/InW=(InW:MnI)/InW=(0:Mn/InWI)=(0:Mn′I)for n≫0, by citep‘[Dao21, Corollary 2.1]‘for n≫0,for n≫0,for n≫0.
It follow that (0:Mn′I)≅Tn for n≫0.
V-numbers of Ext and Tor modules
Let the hypothesis be as in 2.9. In this section, we first prove that the local v-number of Mn′ is eventually a non-zero constant or a linear polynomial. We also prove that if (0:UI)=0 then the global v-number of Mn′ is eventually equal to a non-zero constant provided I is generated in positive degree and AssR(Mn′)⊆V(I). Finally, using the identification of ExtRk(L,InM/N) and TorkR(L,InM/N) (see Lemma 2.7 and 2.8), we prove the main result (Theorem 1.3) of this article. We begin with the following preparatory lemma.
Lemma 4.1.Assume the Hypothesis as in 2.9. Let (−) denote reduction modulo ΓI(U). Then Tn≅Tn for n≫0.
Proof. Note that Tn=(Mn∩In−1W)/InW. First, we show that ΓI(U)∩In−1W=0 for n≫0. Since U is finitely generated, there exists an integer k≥1 such that IkΓI(U)=0. Applying Artin–Rees lemma on ΓI(U)∩W⊂W, there exists an integer c≥0 such that, for all sufficiently large n,
Here, the second equality follows from the second isomorphism theorem and the third equality follows from the modular law since InW⊆Mn∩In−1W. The second last equality holds from the fact that ΓI(U)∩In−1W=0 for n≫0.
Note that by Theorem 3.2, we have for all n≫0, AssR(Mn′)∩V(I)=AssR(0:UI)∪AssR(Tn). In the next result, we consider the case when p∈(AssR(Mn′)∩V(I))∖Ass(0:UI) and prove the asymptotic linearity of vp(Mn′) for all n≫0.
Theorem 4.2. Assume the Hypothesis as in 2.9. Let p∈(AssR(Mn′)∩V(I))∖Ass(0:UI). Then there exists a∈{d1,…,dc} and b∈Z such that vp(Mn′)=an+b for n≫0.
By assumption, p∈AssR(Tn). Note that Mn′=(U+InV)/(InW+ΓI(U))≅U+InV/InW, where (−) denotes modulo ΓI(U). Consider the following short exact sequence
0→InW+ΓI(U)/InW→U+InV/InW→U+InV/InW+ΓI(U)→0.
By Artin-Rees lemma, InW∩ΓI(U)=0 for n≫0. Consequently, we get InW+ΓI(U)/InW=ΓI(U)/ΓI(U)∩InW=ΓI(U) for n≫0. Therefore, for all n≫0, the above exact sequence becomes
0→ΓI(U)→Mn′→Mn′→0.(8)
This gives us AssR(Mn′)⊆AssR(ΓI(U))∪AssR(Mn′), for all sufficiently large n. Lemma 2.2 implies that p∈Ass(Mn′). Since (0:UI)=0, by [13 Theorem 3.8] there exists a∈{d1,…,dc} and b∈Z such that
vp(Mn′)=an+b for n≫0.
We claim that vp(Mn′)=vp(Mn′). By Proposition 2.3, vp(Mn′)≤vp(Mn′)≤vp(Tn). Also by Lemma 4.1, we have vp(Tn)=vp(Tn). By Remark 3.3, (0:Mn′I)≅Tn for n≫0. Let p=(0:Rf) for some f∈Mn′, such that deg(f)=vp(Mn′). Since p∈V(I), we have I⊆p=(0:Rf). Thus, If=0, and hence f∈(0:Mn′I)=Tn. Therefore, vp(Tn)≤deg(f)=vp(Mn′) for all n≫0. This implies that vp(Mn′)=vp(Mn′)=an+b for all n≫0.
In the next result, we deal with the case when p∈AssR((0:UI)). Since the set AssR(0:UI)∩AssR(Tn) may be non-empty, we split the proof in two cases depending on whether p∈AssR(Tn) or p∈/AssR(Tn). We begin with the case when p∈/AssR(Tn).
Theorem 4.3. Assume the Hypothesis as in 2.9. Let p∈(AssRMn′∩V(I))∖Ass(Tn). Then, vp(Mn′)=vp(0:UI) for n≫0.
Proof. By Theorem 3.2, for all sufficiently large integers n, we have
AssR(Mn′)∩V(I)=AssR(0:UI)∪AssR(Tn).
Since p∈/AssR(Tn), p∈AssR((0:UI)). By Remark 3.3, we have (0:Mn′I)=(0:UI)⊕Tn for all n≫0. This gives the following two exact sequences
Now we address the case when p∈AssR(Tn) in the following theorem. However, to establish a comparable result, we must assume that I is generated in positive degrees.
Theorem 4.4. Assume the Hypothesis as in 2.9. Let p∈AssR(0:UI)∩AssR(Tn). Suppose that di≥1 for 1≤i≤c. Then, vp(Mn′)=vp(0:UI) for n≫0.
Proof. Due to Remark 3.3, we have (0:Mn′I)≅(0:UI)⊕Tn for all n≫0. By Lemma 2.5 we have, vp(Mn′)=min{vp(0:UI),vp(Tn)}. Since Tn=(Mn∩In−1W)/InW is submodule of In−1W/InW, by Proposition 2.3, vp(In−1W/InW)≤vp(Tn). By [10 Theorem 2.11], vp(In−1W/InW)=an+b for n≫0, where a∈{d1,…,dc} and b∈Z. Since a≥1, we have vp(Tn)→∞ as n→∞. Thus, for all n≫0, vp(Tn)>vp(0:UI). This proves the result.
Theorem 4.5. Assume the Hypothesis as in 2.9. Let p∈AssR(Mn′)∩AssR(0:UI). If di≥1 for 1≤i≤c, then vp(Mn′)=vp(0:UI) for n≫0.
Proof. By Theorem 3.2, for all sufficiently large integers n, we have
AssR(Mn′)∩V(I)=AssR(0:UI)∪AssR(Tn).
There are two possibilities: either p∈AssR(Tn) or p∈/AssR(Tn). The result now follows from Theorem 4.3 and Theorem 4.4.
Next, we describe the asymptotic behavior of the global Vasconcelos invariant of Mn′ when the module (0:UI) is non-zero.
Theorem 4.6. Assume the Hypothesis as in 2.9. Let (0:UI)=0. Then, v(Mn′)≤v(0:UI) for n≫0. Further if di≥1 for 1≤i≤c and AssR(Mn′)⊆V(I), then for all n≫0,
v(Mn′)=v(0:UI).
Proof. Due to Remark 3.3, we have (0:Mn′I)=(0:UI)⊕Tn for all n≫0. Therefore, (0:UI) is isomorphic to a submodule of Mn′. Thus, by Proposition 2.3, vp(Mn′)≤vp(0:UI) whenever p∈AssR((0:UI)). Note that
Now by assumption AssR(Mn′)⊆V(I). Let p∈AssR(Mn′). Note that by Theorem 3.2 we have
AssR(Mn′)∩V(I)=AssR(0:UI)∪AssR(Tn).
This implies that p∈AssR(0:UI)∪AssR(Tn). If p∈/AssR(0:UI), then by Theorem 4.2, vp(Mn′)=an+b→∞ as n→∞. In other cases, by Theorem 4.3 and Theorem 4.4, we have
vp(Mn′)=vp(0:UI).
This proves that v(Mn′)=v(0:UI). □
We conclude this section by combining the preceding results to establish the main theorem of this article, stated as Theorem 1.3 in the introduction.
Theorem 4.7. Let R be a Noetherian N-graded ring. Assume that L and M are finitely generated Z-graded R-modules, and I a homogeneous ideal of R, generated by homogeneous elements y1,…,yc of degree d1≤⋯≤dc respectively. Let N be a graded submodule of M. Fix k∈N. Denote H:=ExtRk(L,M) (or TorkR(L,M)) and Hn:=ExtRk(L,M/InN) (or TorkR(L,M/InN)). Then the following statements hold:
(1) Let p∈(AssRHn∩V(I))∖AssR(0:HI) for n≫0. Then there exists ap∈{d1,…,dc} and bp∈Z such that vp(Hn)=apn+bp for n≫0.
(2) Let p∈AssR(Hn)∩AssR(0:HI) for n≫0. If di≥1 for 1≤i≤c, then vp(Hn)=vp(0:HI) for n≫0.
(3) Let (0:HI)=0. Then, v(Hn)≤v(0:HI) for n≫0. Further, if di≥1 for 1≤i≤c, and AssR(Hn)⊆V(I), then v(Hn)=v(0:HI) for n≫0.
Proof. We first prove (1) for the Ext-module and the similar proof will follow for the Tor-modules as well. Note that by Lemma 2.7, there exists q∈N such that
ExtRk(L,M/InN)≅(U+In−qV)/In−qW=Mn−q′
for all n≥q and for some graded submodules U, V and W of a finitely generated R-module E satisfying W⊆V and U≅ExtRk(L,M). From the given condition, one has p∈Ass(Mn′∩V(I))∖Ass((0:UI)) for n≫0. By Theorem 4.2, there exists ap∈{d1,…,dc} and b∈Z such that vp((U+InV)/InW)=apn+b for n≫0. Set bp=b−apq. Therefore,
In this section, we give some examples in support of our results. We start with the following which can be derived from [10 Example 3.1] as observed in [13 Example 4.1].
Example 5.1. Let R=K[X,Y] be a standard graded polynomial ring in two variables X and Y over a field K. Consider U=V=W:=R/(XYb), I=(Xa), p:=(X), and m:=(X,Y), where a and b are some positive integers. Then
A=(0:UI)=YbU=0. Thus, AssR(A)={p} and p=(XYb:RYb). Therefore, vp(A)=b.
AssR(U+InV/InW)={p,m} if bn≥2 and p if bn=1.
vp(U+InV/InW)=b whenever an≥2.
vm(U+InV/InW)=an+(b−2) whenever bn≥2.
v(U+InV/InW)=b whenever an≥2.
In particular, whenever (0:UI)=0 and p∈AssR(0:UI), vp(U+InV/InW)=v(U+InV/InW)=vp(0:UI) for all n≫0. If p∈AssR(U+InV/InW)∖AssR(0:UI) for all n≫0, then vp(U+InV/InW) is eventually linear.
Recall that, by Proposition 2.5, v(M(r))=v(M)−r and vp(M(r))=vp(M)−r for all p∈AssR(M) and r∈Z. We use this result repeatedly in the next example, which is the general version of [13 Example 4.4] and satisfies Theorem 4.7.
Example 5.2. Let R=K[X,Y]/(XaYb) with a,b≥1 and deg(X)=deg(Y)=1, where K is a field. Suppose x and y are the residue classes of X and Y in R, respectively. Set L=R/(xa), I=M=N=(yb), and m=(x,y). Then,
(0:ExtRk(L,M)I)={0,(yb)/(y2b)(r(a+b)),if k=0 or k≥1 is odd,if k=2r≥2.
For k=2r≥2, AssR((0:ExtRk(L,M)I))={m} and v((0:ExtRk(L,M)I))=(1−r)(a+b)+b−2.
ExtRk(L,M)=⎩⎨⎧M,0,(yb)/(y2b)(r(a+b))if k=0,if k odd,if k=2r≥2.(12)
and
TorkR(L,M)=⎩⎨⎧M,(yb)/(y2b)(−((r+1)a+rb)),0,if k=0,if k=2r+1≥1,if k even.(13)
Since (xa,yb) annihilates modules in (12) for all k=2r≥2, we have AssR((0:ExtRk(L,M)I))={m}. Further, m=(0:Rz), where z=y2b−1xa−1∈(yb)/(y2b). Therefore, v((0:ExtRk(L,M)I)=a+2b−2−r(a+b)=b−2−(r−1)(a+b). This proves (1). From (13) and by the same argument as above, (2) follows.
Since M/InN=(yb)/(y(n+1)b) for all n≥1 and by replacing M by M/InN in (11), we obtain
Note that (xa,ynb) or (xa,yb) annihilates the modules in (14) and (15). Therefore, we obtain
AssR(ExtRk(L,M/InN))=AssR(TorkR(L,M/InN))={m}
for all k≥0 and n≥1. This proves (3).
We now prove (4). By (14), we have for k=0 and 2r+1≥1, we have m=(0:Rz), where z=y(n+1)b−1xa−1∈(yb)/(y(n+1)b). Therefore, for k=0, v(ExtRk(L,M/InN))=nb+a+b−2.
For k=2r+1≥1, we also have m=(0:Rz), where z=y(n+1)b−1xa−1∈(ynb)/(y(n+1)b). Thus,
v(ExtRk(L,M/InN))=(n+1)b+a−2−(r+1)a−rb=nb−r(a+b)+b−2for all n≥1.
Now, for k=2r≥2, we have m=(0:Rzˉ), where zˉ=yˉ2b−1xˉa−1∈(yb)/(y2b). Therefore,
v(ExtRk(L,M/InN))=2b+a−2−r(a+b)=(1−r)(a+b)+b−2=v((0:ExtRk(L,M)I))for all n≥1.
Using (15) and by the same argument as above, (5) follows. □
Acknowledgment
This work was initiated when the three authors met at the Advanced Instructional School (AIS) on Topics in Commutative Algebra and Algebraic Geometry, held at IIT Palakkad in June 2026. The authors gratefully acknowledge the institute for its warm hospitality and wonderful campus environment. The first named author acknowledges the Government of India for support through the Prime Minister’s Research Fellowship (ID: 1303161). The second named author acknowledges the University Grants Commission (UGC) for their support (Reference number 231610213879).
References
Indian Institute of Technology Bombay, Mumbai, India Email address:[email protected]
Department of Mathematics and Statistics, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Kolkata, Mohanpur, India Email address:[email protected]
[1][BMS26] P. Biswas, M. Mandal and K. Saha, Asymptotic behaviour and stability index of ν-numbers of graded ideals, Vietnam J. Math. (2026), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10013-026-00817-783. 1
[2][Bro79] M. Brodmann, Asymptotic stability of Ass(M/IⁿM), Proc. Am. Math. Soc. 74 (1979), 16–18. 1
[3][Con24] A. Conca, A note on the ν-invariant, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 152 (2024), no. 6, 2349–2351. 1
[4][CST+20] S. M. Cooper, A. Seceleanu, S.O. Tohăneanu, M. Pinto Vaz, and R.H. Villarreal, Generalized minimum distance functions of algebraic invariants of Grӧbner ideals, Adv. in Appl. Math. 112 (2020), 101940, 34. 1arxiv.org/abs/1812.06529
[5][Dao21] H. Dao, On colon operations and special types of ideals, Palest. J. Math. 10 (2021), 383–388. 4, 6arxiv.org/abs/2005.04483
[6][Fic24] A. Ficarra, Simon conjecture and the ν-number of monomial ideals, Collect. Math. 76 (2025), no. 3, 477–492. 1DOI
[7][FS26] A. Ficarra and E. Sgroi, Asymptotic behaviour of the ν-Number of Homogeneous Ideals, J. Algebra 704 (2026), 273–297. 1DOI
[8][FS25] A. Ficarra and E. Sgroi, Asymptotic behaviour of integer programming and the ν-function of a graded filtration, Journal of Algebra and Its Applications (2025), https://doi.org/10.1142/S0219498826502361. 1
[9][FM25] A. Ficarra and P. M. Marques, The ν-function of powers of sums of ideals, J. Algebraic Combin., 62(1):Paper No. 13, 21, 2025. 1
[10][FG25] L. Fiorindo, D. Ghosh, On the asymptotic behaviour of the Vasconcelos invariant for graded modules, Nagoya Math. J. 258 (2025), 296–310. 1, 8, 10DOI
[11][HS06] C. Huneke and I. Swanson, Integral Closure of Ideals, Rings, and Modules, London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series, vol. 336, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2006. 3
[12][GNP26] D. Ghosh, R. Nanduri, and S. Pramanik, Asymptotic prime divisors and Vasconcelos invariant, arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.11961 (2026). 1, 3, 4arxiv.org/abs/2603.11961
[13][GP25] D. Ghosh and S. Pramanik, Asymptotic ν-numbers of graded (co)homology modules involving powers of an ideal, J. Algebra, 671 (2025), 61–74. 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 10DOI
[14][KW04] D. Katz, E. West, A linear function associated to asymptotic prime divisors, Proc. Am. Math. Soc. 132 (2004) 1589–1597. 2, 4DOI
[15][VS26] A. Vanmathi and P. Sarkar, ν-numbers of symbolic power filtrations, Collect. Math., 77 (2026), 461–481. 1
[16][VS25] A. Vanmathi and P. Sarkar, ν-numbers of integral closure filtrations of monomial ideals, arXiv:2506.09051, (2025). 1arxiv.org/abs/2506.09051