betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Rank-One Sutured Instanton Homology Detects Homology Products

Abstract

We prove that a balanced sutured manifold (M,γ)(M,γ) satisfying dim⁡CSHI(M,γ)=1\dim_{\mathbb C} SHI(M,γ)=1 is an integral homology product; that is, H∗(M,R−(γ);Z)=H∗(M,R+(γ);Z)=0H_*(M,R_-(γ);\mathbb Z)=H_*(M,R_+(γ);\mathbb Z)=0. Consequently, for every taut balanced sutured manifold (M,γ)(M,γ), SHI(M,γ)≅CSHI(M,γ)\cong\mathbb C if and only if (M,γ)(M,γ) is a product sutured manifold. The proof uses the enhanced Euler characteristic of SHISHI and a specialization formula for sutured torsion.

Rank One and Homology Products

For a sutured manifold (M,γ)(M,\gamma), let SHI(M,γ)SHI(M,\gamma) denote its sutured instanton homology. Kronheimer and Mrowka proved in [2 Theorem 7.18] that a taut balanced sutured manifold (M,γ)(M,\gamma) which is a homology product is a product sutured manifold if and only if

SHI(M,γ)≅C.SHI(M,\gamma)\cong\mathbb{C}.

We show that the homology-product hypothesis already follows from the rank-one assumption. The key input is the enhanced Euler characteristic constructed by Li and Ye [3].

Throughout, homology groups have integral coefficients unless indicated otherwise. We call (M,γ)(M,\gamma) an integral homology product if the inclusions

R±(γ)↪MR_{\pm}(\gamma)\hookrightarrow M

induce isomorphisms on integral homology. Equivalently,

H∗(M,R−(γ);Z)=H∗(M,R+(γ);Z)=0.H_*(M,R_-(\gamma);\mathbb{Z})=H_*(M,R_+(\gamma);\mathbb{Z})=0.

Theorem 1.1. Let (M,γ)(M,\gamma) be a balanced sutured manifold. If

dim⁡CSHI(M,γ)=1,\dim_{\mathbb{C}} SHI(M,\gamma)=1,

then (M,γ)(M,\gamma) is an integral homology product.

Proof. Write H=H1(M;Z)H=H_1(M;\mathbb{Z}). Applying [3 Theorem 5.1] to (−M,−γ)(-M,-\gamma) gives

χen(SHI(M,γ))=τ(M,γ)in Z[H]/±H.(1)\chi_{\mathrm{en}}(SHI(M,\gamma))=\tau(M,\gamma)\quad\text{in }\mathbb{Z}[H]/\pm H. \tag*{(1)}

Here χen\chi_{\mathrm{en}} denotes the enhanced Euler characteristic, τ(M,γ)\tau(M,\gamma) denotes the sutured torsion, and Z[H]\mathbb{Z}[H] denotes the integral group ring of HH. The notation Z[H]/±H\mathbb{Z}[H]/\pm H identifies elements that differ by multiplication by a unit ±h\pm h, where h∈Hh\in H.

In the HH-indexed decomposition used to define χen\chi_{\mathrm{en}}, there is a unique nonzero summand, which is one-dimensional. Hence χen(SHI(M,γ))\chi_{\mathrm{en}}(SHI(M,\gamma)) has a representative that is a monomial with coefficient ±1\pm1 in Z[H]\mathbb{Z}[H]. By (1), the class of τ(M,γ)\tau(M,\gamma) has such a representative. Thus, there exists a representative τ~(M,γ)∈Z[H]\widetilde{\tau}(M,\gamma)\in\mathbb{Z}[H] of the class τ(M,γ)\tau(M,\gamma) such that

τ~(M,γ)=±h0for some h0∈H.(2)\widetilde{\tau}(M,\gamma)=\pm h_0\quad\text{for some }h_0\in H. \tag*{(2)}

Let

p:H1(M;Z)⟶G:=H1(M,R−(γ);Z)p:H_1(M;\mathbb{Z})\longrightarrow G:=H_1(M,R_-(\gamma);\mathbb{Z})

be the natural map. Write

p∗:Z[H]⟶Z[G]p_*:\mathbb{Z}[H]\longrightarrow\mathbb{Z}[G]

for the induced map of group rings. Proposition 6.5 of [1] gives, up to multiplication by an element of ±G\pm G,

p∗(τ~(M,γ))=±IG,IG={∑g∈Gg,G is finite,0Z[G],G is infinite.(3)p_*\bigl(\widetilde{\tau}(M,\gamma)\bigr)=\pm I_G,\qquad I_G= \begin{cases} \sum_{g\in G}g, & G\text{ is finite},\\ 0_{\mathbb{Z}[G]}, & G\text{ is infinite}. \end{cases} \tag*{(3)}

Here Z[G]\mathbb{Z}[G] is the integral group ring of GG, and IGI_G is the indicated element of that group ring. By (2), the left-hand side of (3) is the nonzero monomial ±p(h0)\pm p(h_0). Hence GG is finite. The support of IGI_G then has cardinality ∣G∣|G|, so (3) forces ∣G∣=1|G| = 1. Thus,

H1(M,R−(γ);Z)=0.(4)H_1(M,R_-(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) = 0. \tag*{(4)}

It remains to check the other relative homology groups. Since the annular and toroidal components of γ\gamma have Euler characteristic zero, we have

2χ(M)=χ(∂M)=χ(R+(γ))+χ(R−(γ)).2\chi(M) = \chi(\partial M) = \chi(R_+(\gamma)) + \chi(R_-(\gamma)).

where χ\chi denotes the Euler characteristic. Since (M,γ)(M,\gamma) is balanced, we have

χ(R+(γ))=χ(R−(γ)).\chi(R_+(\gamma)) = \chi(R_-(\gamma)).

It follows that χ(M)=χ(R−(γ))\chi(M) = \chi(R_-(\gamma)). By the definition of relative Euler characteristic,

χ(M,R−(γ))=χ(M)−χ(R−(γ))=0,\chi(M,R_-(\gamma)) = \chi(M) - \chi(R_-(\gamma)) = 0,

where χ(M,R−(γ))\chi(M,R_-(\gamma)) denotes the relative Euler characteristic of the pair (M,R−(γ))(M,R_-(\gamma)). The balanced condition also implies that every component of MM meets both R−(γ)R_-(\gamma) and R+(γ)R_+(\gamma). Hence the inclusion-induced maps

H0(R±(γ);Z)⟶H0(M;Z)H_0(R_\pm(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) \longrightarrow H_0(M;\mathbb{Z})

are surjective, and therefore

H0(M,R±(γ);Z)=0.H_0(M,R_\pm(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) = 0.

Poincaré–Lefschetz duality gives

H3(M,R−(γ);Z)≅H0(M,R+(γ);Z)=0.H_3(M,R_-(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) \cong H^0(M,R_+(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) = 0.

Together with (4), the relative Euler characteristic shows that the second relative homology group has rank zero. On the other hand, duality and the universal coefficient theorem give

H2(M,R−(γ);Z)≅H1(M,R+(γ);Z)≅Hom⁡(H1(M,R+(γ);Z),Z).\begin{aligned} H_2(M,R_-(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) &\cong H^1(M,R_+(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) \\ &\cong\operatorname{Hom}(H_1(M,R_+(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}),\mathbb{Z}). \end{aligned}

Since H1(M,R+(γ);Z)H_1(M,R_+(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) is finitely generated, the last group is free abelian. Since the first group has rank zero, all three groups vanish. Thus

H∗(M,R−(γ);Z)=0.H_*(M,R_-(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) = 0.

Duality now gives

H∗(M,R+(γ);Z)=0,H^*(M,R_+(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) = 0,

and, since the relative homology groups are finitely generated, the universal coefficient theorem, applied degree by degree, gives

H∗(M,R+(γ);Z)=0H_*(M,R_+(\gamma);\mathbb{Z}) = 0

as well. Hence (M,γ)(M,\gamma) is an integral homology product. □

Corollary 1.2. Let (M,γ)(M,\gamma) be a taut balanced sutured manifold. Then

SHI(M,γ)≅C⟺(M,γ) is a product sutured manifold.SHI(M,\gamma) \cong\mathbb{C} \Longleftrightarrow(M,\gamma)\text{ is a product sutured manifold.}

Proof. The forward implication follows from Theorem 1.1 and [2 Theorem 7.18]; the reverse implication is the remark following [2 Definition 7.10]. □

Acknowledgements

The author thanks Zhenkun Li for helpful discussions.

Use of AI Tools

AI tools were used solely for language polishing. The author takes full responsibility for the mathematical content of this paper.

Department of Mathematics, College of Science, China University of Petroleum-Beijing, Beijing 102249, China

Email address: [email protected]

References

  1. [1]S. Friedl, A. Juhász, and J. Rasmussen, The decategorification of sutured Floer homology, J. Topol. 4 (2011), no. 2, 431–478.DOI
  2. [2]P. B. Kronheimer and T. S. Mrowka, Knots, sutures, and excision, J. Differential Geom. 84 (2010), no. 2, 301–364.arxiv.org/abs/0807.4891
  3. [3]Z. Li and F. Ye, An enhanced Euler characteristic of sutured instanton homology, Int. Math. Res. Not. IMRN 2024 (2024), no. 4, 2873–2936.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_hc966syv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

AI tools

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents