betaFeedback

WorksComputer Science

U.S. National Liquefaction Hazard Maps and their Implications for Engineering Practice and Policy

Abstract

This study introduces U.S. national liquefaction hazard maps (NLHMs) developed using a mechanics-informed, geospatial machine learning model which surrogates state-of-practice liquefaction models, exploits a large library of geospatial predictors to infer subsurface conditions, and is anchored to measured conditions with in-situ test data. By convolving this geospatial liquefaction model with the 2023 U.S. national seismic hazard model, liquefaction hazard is mapped across the contiguous U.S. at ~90 m resolution within both conditional (2,475-year design event) and unconditional (return period of ground failure) formulations using high-performance computing for the high-resolution magnitude-disaggregation. The resulting NLHMs provide insights for land-use policy, preliminary site assessment, regional-scale earthquake simulation and response planning, and screening tools for regulatory enforcement, among other applications. Beyond quantifying and visualizing liquefaction hazard, the NLHMs are used herein to examine three questions of engineering practice and policy across a continuous spatial domain: (i) the effect of selecting modal versus mean magnitude in conditional analyses; (ii) the differences between conditional and unconditional hazard formulations; and (iii) the extent to which liquefaction hazard compounds with socioeconomic vulnerability. Results elucidate where and how the choice of magnitude alters computed hazards; that unconditional maps reveal important spatial deviations suppressed by single-scenario maps, which are convenient and widely used in current building codes, but less than completely rational; and that modest but statistically significant socioeconomic gradients in liquefaction exposure exist.

Introduction

Probabilistic seismic hazard analysis (PSHA) forms the basis of seismic design codes and provides a communication framework among scientists, engineers, insurers, policymakers, and the public. PSHA quantifies seismic risk as the occurrence of ground-motion parameters (e.g., peak ground acceleration, PGA) within a given return period (e.g., 2,475 years). Assuming earthquakes are “Poissonian” (i.e., independent), these values may also be expressed as having some annual rate or some exceedance probability in some timespan (e.g., a 2,475-year return period equates to a 2% probability in 50 years). In this way, PSHA translates complex data into actionable insights, and national-scale seismic hazard maps resulting from PSHA are known by experts and laypersons alike. By contrast, analogous national maps communicating the hazard posed by soil liquefaction do not exist. This introduction presents the utility of such maps, new regional-scale liquefaction models that facilitate their development, and the questions of practice and policy these maps can be used to investigate.

Liquefaction hazards are routinely studied in site-specific detail and are sometimes mapped across municipalities or regions for the purposes of land-use planning, disaster simulation, insurance estimating, and regulatory enforcement (e.g., among many, Holzer et al., 2006, 2009; Baise et al., 2006; Cramer et al., 2008, 2017; Hayati and Andrus, 2008; Maurer et al., 2014; Sharifi-Mood et al., 2018). State-wide liquefaction zonation maps exist in Washington, for example, and have been used to plan emergency response [e.g. 15] and screen construction permit applications [e.g. 62]. Yet these and many other regional-scale maps provide only coarse classifications of hazard (e.g., “Low” versus “High”) and do not consider seismic demand. In effect, the maps predict classifications of liquefaction susceptibility, usually inferred from surficial geology maps, but do not explicitly predict liquefaction occurrence or consequences for any earthquake scenario or return period. In California, the 1990 Seismic Hazard Mapping Act required state geologists to delineate zones where liquefaction may occur. Landowners must disclose if their parcel resides in such a zone during real-estate transactions. Yet as of our writing, only portions of the San Francisco Bay and Los Angeles regions have been mapped [9], leaving ~95% of the state unevaluated. Specific to residential structures, one- and two-story homes (i.e., 90% of the U.S. building stock according to Potter, 2022) are typically under the purview of the International Residential Code (e.g., [32]), which makes no mention of liquefaction. This means any requirement to consider or disclose liquefaction hazard is at the discretion of local officials. This state-of-practice in the U.S., and the paucity of informative hazard maps, has likely led to liquefaction being overlooked for residences in many locations and, in turn, to uninsurance or underinsurance. It is estimated, for example, that less than 20% of homeowners in Oregon and Washington have earthquake insurance [16].

Regardless of the type of structure, the lack of spatially continuous predictions of liquefaction makes it challenging to accurately account for this hazard when forming land-use policy, simulating earthquakes and planning response, prioritizing retrofits within portfolios of distributed infrastructure, or creating screening tools for regulatory enforcement. We attribute the lack of U.S. national liquefaction hazard maps, or NLHMs, to two factors.

First, state-of-practice liquefaction models require subsurface data, such as those from the cone penetration test (CPT), but these data cannot feasibly be collected continuously across regional scales. Consequently, regional-scale studies often employ models based on “geospatial” proxies of subsurface conditions, including metrics of topography, geology, hydrology, geomorphology, ecology, and climate. Using these proxy variables, geospatial liquefaction models (GLMs) infer the makeup and response of subsurface soils without subsurface explorations. Although simple GLMs have existed for decades (e.g., [71, 47]), the adoption and acceptance of these models for certain use cases is increasing along with the sophistication of the models, spurred by growth in field observations, geospatial data, and algorithmic learning (e.g., machine learning, ML). Recent studies that train, test, or employ GLMs include Rashidian and Baise [55], Geyin et al. [22], Bozzoni et al. [6], Lin et al. [40], Todorovic and Silva [65], Jena et al. [35], Geyin et al. [23], Kim [36], Bullock et al. [8], Asadi et al. [1], and Azul et al. [3]. All these efforts have grown the science of liquefaction modeling at regional scales, yet most GLMs suffer from one or more limitations. Namely, they: (i) predict liquefaction without learning from, or anchoring to, state-of-practice triggering and manifestation models (e.g., CPT-based models) that reflect knowledge of liquefaction mechanics; (ii) are not updated by local geotechnical data, even though such data may be prevalent and contradict the inferences of the geospatial model; (iii) use relatively little of the publicly available geospatial information; (iv) are trained by traditional statistical methods (e.g., logistic regression) that cannot capture complex nonlinear relationships or exploit large libraries of geospatial data; and (v) are not provided as code or executable software, meaning it is difficult to impossible for anyone to use the model. Thus, the perception may be that current GLMs are insufficient or unavailable to develop useful NLHMs.

Second, the development of an NLHM at high spatial resolution (say, the size of a building parcel, or that of a GLM) requires execution of a PSHA model at hundreds of millions of locations. The contiguous 48 U.S. states, for instance, comprise 889 million cells at ∼90\sim90 m resolution when considering only relatively flat ground. And, because state-of-practice liquefaction models require both PGAPGA and earthquake moment magnitude (MM) as inputs, magnitude disaggregation of the PGAPGA hazard curve is necessary, growing the computational burden. We estimate, for example, that executing the U.S. national seismic hazard model [51] in the manner, extent, and resolution above could require 30 years of serial runtime on a typical PC for just one return period of shaking. Moreover, because liquefaction can be induced by shaking over a wide range of return periods, a true depiction of hazard necessitates consideration of the full return-period domain, meaning the PSHA should be executed at numerous return periods for every location.

In this study we develop U.S. NLHMs using the GLM of Sanger et al. [58], a mechanics-informed ML model that surrogates geotechnical liquefaction models, and which was trained on over 37,000 CPTs from 48 U.S. states and 19 countries. This model has conceptual benefits over prior GLMs in that predictions: (i) are anchored to geotechnical models and the knowledge of liquefaction mechanics embedded therein; (ii) use ML to exploit a large library of predictive information; (iii) are geostatistically updated near in-situ tests, thereby ground-truthing the ML predictions; and (iv) are effectively precomputed everywhere on earth for all possible earthquakes [58]. This GLM is coupled herein with high-performance computing (HPC) to execute and disaggregate the 2023 national seismic hazard model at high spatial resolution, over a wide range of return periods, for the entire contiguous U.S., resulting in what we believe to be the first U.S. NLHMs.

While the NLHMs themselves are useful for quantifying and visualizing liquefaction hazard across the U.S., they also provide a means to investigate questions of practice and policy, three of which are posed in this study. The first relates to the choice of MM used in conventional liquefaction hazard analyses, for which the result is conditioned on the occurrence of a specified design-level earthquake (e.g., the 2,475-year return-period event). Although building codes such as ASCE 7-22 [2] define a conditional event in terms of shaking intensity (e.g., the 2,475-year PGAPGA), they do not explicitly specify whether the associated MM be taken as the mean, modal, or some other MM from PSHA disaggregation. This ambiguity has led to inconsistent guidance and different selections by practicing engineers, both in the U.S. and internationally (e.g., [19, 18, 25, 5, 50]). Although prior studies have shown at point locations the sway this decision can have on liquefaction predictions, we elucidate over a continuous national domain how the choice of either mean or modal magnitude interacts with local conditions to alter the computed liquefaction hazard.

The second question concerns the difference between conditional and unconditional hazard formulations. Although the conditional approach is familiar, conveniently simple, and easy to communicate, it is not completely rational, as it represents only one scenario from a continuous distribution of possible events. Weaker motions that occur more frequently, and stronger motions that occur more rarely, can also induce liquefaction. Thus, the unconditional approach integrates over the full spectrum of possible ground motions to yield the annualized rate, or return period, of liquefaction in terms of triggering, surface manifestation, or some other consequence. This approach is very seldom used in practice, but it has clear and compelling advantages (e.g., [38, 67, 41, 44, 42]). Prior studies have demonstrated the merits of the unconditional approach at point locations, typically using simple hypothetical soil profiles. We contribute to this discussion by comparing the two hazard formulations on a continuous spatial basis while accounting for the expected in-situ soil and groundwater conditions.

The third question explores how liquefaction hazard patterns relate to population density and socioeconomic exposure. Overlaying the NLHMs with census tract data enables the first nationwide survey of which communities, and how many people, are exposed to liquefaction hazard. Although socioeconomic correlations with other hazards have been studied, such as air pollution (e.g., [64]), flood risk (e.g. [70]), and heat islands (e.g., [29]), we are unaware of any such work in the context of liquefaction hazard. Collectively, our inquiries using the NLHMs provide insights for engineering decision making, policy formation, and social science.

Data and Methodology

Geospatial Liquefaction Model (GLM)

The Sanger et al. [58] GLM couples mechanics-based insights from CPT-based liquefaction models with geospatial data and ML. Rather than predict liquefaction triggering in a certain soil at a certain depth, the GLM instead predicts a soil profile’s cumulative liquefaction response, or damage potential, at the ground surface, via one of three manifestation indices (MIsMIs): the liquefaction potential index (LPILPI) (Iwasaki, [34]); a modified LPILPI, termed LPIISHLPI_{\mathrm{ISH}} (Maurer et al., [43]); and the liquefaction severity number (LSNLSN) (van Ballegooy et al., [69]). Because these MIsMIs are well known in the literature and included in popular software (e.g., CLIQCLIQ by GeoLogismiki), their formulae are omitted here but are given and discussed in the Supplemental Materials.

To predict each MIMI, the GLM used 37 geospatial predictors that correlate to subsurface traits relevant to liquefaction susceptibility and response, such as soil typology, saturation, relative density, and thickness. Formally, the MIMI at a given location is expressed as a function of ML-predicted parameters (AA, BB) and the magnitude-scaled peak ground acceleration (PGAMPGA_M):

MI={0,for PGAM<A100BgA∗(tan⁡−1(B∗(PGAM−A100B)2)),for PGAM≥A100Bg(1)MI = \begin{cases} 0, & \text{for } PGA_M < \dfrac{A}{100B}g \\ A * \left(\tan^{-1}\left(B * \left(PGA_M - \dfrac{A}{100B}\right)^2\right)\right), & \text{for } PGA_M \ge\dfrac{A}{100B}g \end{cases} \tag*{(1)}

where MIMI is the manifestation index (i.e., LPILPI, LPIISHLPI_{\mathrm{ISH}}, or LSNLSN), tan⁡−1\tan^{-1} is expressed in radians, gg is the gravitational constant, AA relates to the MIMI value attained at large PGAMPGA_M, and BB relates to the rate at which the MIMI increases as a function of PGAMPGA_M. To train the model, ~37,000 CPTs, mapped in fig:S1 of the Supplemental Materials, were sourced from existing compilations (e.g., New Zealand EQC, 2016; USGS, 2019; Rateria et al., [56]; Regione Emilia-Romagna, [57]) and from newly compiled datasets in North America (Sanger et al., [59]; Rasanen et al., [54]). Each CPT was subjected to a range of seismic loading, MIMI values were computed by a state-of-practice triggering model, and the resulting MIMI-PGAMPGAM response, which is a signature unique to each site, was fit by Eq. (1). ML models were then trained to predict the fitted AA and BB values via the geospatial data at each CPT site, and the trained models were executed worldwide in the forward direction at 0.000833° (~90 m) resolution, for 13 billion locations, using HPC. Lastly, predictions of AA and BB were geostatistically updated near CPTs, an example of which is shown in Fig. S2. The resulting AA and BB values for LPILPI are mapped in Figure 1 for a portion of the Puget Sound region of Washington. The Sanger et al. [58] outputs also include a variance map that communicates where, and to what degree, the predicted liquefaction response is updated by local geotechnical data, as demonstrated in Fig. S3.

Sanger et al. (2025) GLM products mapped in the Puget Sound region of Washington state: (a) LPI A parameter; (b) LPI B parameter

Figure 1. Sanger et al. [58] GLM products mapped in the Puget Sound region of Washington state: (a) LPI ALPI\ A parameter; (b) LPI BLPI\ B parameter (Basemap from NOAA NCEI, 2024).

By storing the expected MIMI as two mapped parameters awaiting a PGAMPGAM (e.g., from an event that has just occurred, or a scenario of interest), the model is easily executed via Eq. (1) without HPC or advanced programming (though HPC is still needed in this study due to the national extent and number of return periods at which the PSHA is executed to produce PGAMPGAM values). To extend each MIMI to a consequence prediction, fragility functions conditioned on these MIsMIs have been trained on case-history observations to predict certain outcomes, including general surface manifestation (Geyin and Maurer, [20]), pipeline rupture (Toprak et al., [66]), and foundation damage (Maurer et al., [44]). In this paper, we adopt Geyin and Maurer [20] to compute the probability of “ground failure” (PGFPGF), which may be interpreted as the median probability of observing surface manifestations of liquefaction, such as ejecta, settlement, and cracking, at any location within a given map pixel; the function is defined as:

PGF∣MI=Φ(ln⁡(MI)−ln⁡(θ)β)(2)PGF \mid MI = \Phi\left(\frac{\ln(MI)-\ln(\theta)}{\beta}\right) \tag*{(2)}

where Φ\Phi denotes the cumulative normal distribution; β\beta is the logarithmic standard deviation (e.g., 1.436 for LPILPI); and θ\theta is the distribution median, or MIMI at which there is a 50% PGFPGF (e.g., 6.993 for LPILPI) (Geyin and Maurer, [20]). In summary, the adopted GLM enables high-resolution, regional-scale prediction of liquefaction manifestation, with conceptual and statistical improvements relative to prior GLMs. For complete coverage of its development, performance, limitations, etc., see Sanger et al. [58].

Conditional and Unconditional NLHM Development

Using Sanger et al. [58] to predict MIMI (e.g., LPILPI) and Geyin and Maurer [20] to predict liquefaction surface manifestations conditioned on MIMI, we map liquefaction hazard within the conditional and unconditional hazard formulations. For the conditional approach, these models are executed using the 2,475-year PGAMPGA_M, where: PGAPGA is obtained from the 2023 national seismic hazard model (Petersen et al., [51]) assuming seismic site class D; MM is the modal and, alternatively, mean (i.e., weighted average) MM from disaggregation of the PGAPGA hazard curve; and PGAMPGA_M is the magnitude-scaled PGAPGA computed using the magnitude-scaling factor of Idriss and Boulanger [33]:

PGAM=PGAMSF, where MSF=6.9exp⁡(−M4)−0.058≤1.8(3)PGA_M = \frac{PGA}{MSF}, \text{ where } MSF = 6.9\exp\left(\frac{-M}{4}\right)-0.058 \le1.8 \tag*{(3)}

The Idriss and Boulanger [33] factor is used because the Sanger et al. [58] GLM was trained to predict MIMI values computed by the Idriss and Boulanger [33] triggering model; thus, for consistency in forward application, the same factor must be used. Limitations and uncertainties, including those stemming from the adoption of certain models and the assumptions mentioned here, will be discussed in a dedicated section. The conditional modeling workflow is demonstrated in Figure 2 for the same extent shown in Figure 1, culminating in a prediction of PGFPGF for the 2,475-year earthquake hazard. For brevity, only results using LPILPI are presented and discussed here, but analogous results for LPIISHLPI_{ISH}, LSNLSN, and an ensemble of the three models are provided in the Supplemental Materials and as a data repository from Zdanovski et al. [72].

Three maps showing the conditional modeling workflow in the Puget Sound region

Figure 2. Demonstration of conditional modeling workflow in the Puget Sound region: (a) 2,475-year PGAMPGA_M computed using mean MM; (b) 2,475-year LPILPI; and (c) 2,475-year PGFPGF (Basemap from NOAA NCEI, 2024).

In contrast to the approach conditioned on a single return-period event, the unconditional hazard considers every earthquake that could impact a site while also considering the probabilities of those earthquakes occurring. Such an approach is commonly called performance-based earthquake engineering, or PBEE. In its complete form, the PBEE framework computes the mean annual exceedance frequency (λ\lambda) for some decision variable (DVDV) of interest to decision making. This calculation relies on a series of component models and may be generically expressed as:

λdv=∑k=1NDM∑j=1NEDP∑i=1NIMP[DV>dv∣DM=dmk]×P[DM=dmk∣EDP=edpj]×P[EDP=edpj∣IM=imi]Δλimi(4)\lambda_{dv} = \sum_{k=1}^{N_{DM}} \sum_{j=1}^{N_{EDP}} \sum_{i=1}^{N_{IM}} P[DV > dv \mid DM = dm_k] \times P[DM = dm_k \mid EDP = edp_j] \times P[EDP = edp_j \mid IM = im_i]\Delta\lambda_{im_i} \tag*{(4)}

where DMDM is damage measure, EDPEDP is engineering demand parameter, IMIM is intensity measure, and where NDMN_{DM}, NEDPN_{EDP}, and NIMN_{IM} are the number of increments of DMDM, EDPEDP, and IMIM, respectively. In this context, the DMDM and EDPEDP are intermediate variables that link the seismic hazard (i.e., IMIM) to loss (i.e., DVDV). By truncating Eq. (4), the mean annual exceedance frequency of some damage measure, λdm\lambda_{dm}, or engineering demand parameter, λedp\lambda_{edp}, may alternatively be computed. The latter, for example, is:

λedp=∑i=1NIMP[EDP>edp∣IM=imi]Δλimi(5)\lambda_{edp} = \sum_{i=1}^{N_{IM}} P[EDP > edp|IM = im_i]\Delta\lambda_{im_i} \tag*{(5)}

Notably, the inverse of λ\lambda is the return period, which could be computed for any IMIM, EDPEDP, DMDM, or DVDV using the PBEE framework. In the context of the NLHMs, LPILPI is effectively a “liquefaction demand parameter” that characterizes the cumulative response, or damage potential, of a liquefiable soil profile. LPILPI therefore relates seismic hazard to the potential for liquefaction-induced damage. λLPI\lambda_{LPI} is computed at a given site by convolving the Sanger et al. [58] GLM with the PGAPGA hazard curve, which describes the mean annual rate of PGAPGA exceeding a given value (λPGA\lambda_{PGA}). However, to compute λLPI\lambda_{LPI}, the PGAPGA hazard-curve must be disaggregated by MM, given that both PGAPGA and MM are required inputs to the GLM (and to any state-of-practice liquefaction model). λLPI\lambda_{LPI} is then computed as:

λLPI=∑j=1NM∑i=1NPGAP(LPI>lpi|pga=pgai,m=mj)Δλpgai,mj(6)\lambda_{LPI} = \sum_{j=1}^{N_M}\sum_{i=1}^{N_{PGA}} P\left(LPI > lpi\middle|pga = pga_i,m = m_j\right)\Delta\lambda_{pga_i,m_j} \tag*{(6)}

where NMN_M and NPGAN_{PGA} are respectively the number of MM and PGAPGA increments into which the seismic hazard is subdivided, and Δλpgai,mj\Delta\lambda_{pga_i,m_j} is the incremental annual-exceedance rate for intensity measure, pgaipga_i, and magnitude, mjm_j, which is an approach first performed by Kramer and Mayfield [38]; and P(LPI>lpi|pga=pgai,m=mj)P\left(LPI > lpi\middle|pga = pga_i,m = m_j\right) is the probability that the LPILPI exceeds some value, lpilpi, conditioned on PGAPGA and MM. Calculation of λLPI\lambda_{LPI} has previously been shown in the literature (e.g., [24, 25, 44]), aside from using the Sanger et al. [58] GLM to do so. To illustrate, a series of λLPI\lambda_{LPI} curves are plotted in Figure 3 using the 2023 national seismic hazard model, assuming seismic site class D. In Figure 3(a), λLPI\lambda_{LPI} curves are shown for Seattle, Washington for a site where the GLM AA parameter (see Eq. (1)) varies, and the BB parameter is 15. As liquefaction hazard (i.e., AA) decreases, λLPI\lambda_{LPI} diminishes for any given LPILPI. If AA is 5, for example, the LPILPI with a 1,000-year return period (λLPI=10−3\lambda_{LPI} = 10^{-3}) is 6.5, whereas if AA is 25, the LPILPI with this return period is 32.5. In Figure 3(b), λLPI\lambda_{LPI} curves are shown for cities in a range of seismic settings, given a site where the GLM AA and BB are 25 and 15, respectively, indicative of a high liquefaction hazard. As seismic hazard decreases, so does λLPI\lambda_{LPI}. In Seattle, San Francisco, California, and Memphis, Tennessee the resulting λLPI\lambda_{LPI} curves converge near a 10,000-year return period (λLPI=10−4\lambda_{LPI}=10^{-4}), which is to say the 10,000-year PGAMPGAM values are similar in these cities, but for all other return periods the λLPI\lambda_{LPI} curves are different. This alludes to the fact that basing decisions on the hazard at one return period, as is ubiquitous in current building codes, can result in locations having the same perceived hazard when the “actual” hazards – considering all return periods – are very different. For every return period less than 10,000 years, λLPI\lambda_{LPI} is greater in San Francisco than in Seattle, and greater in Seattle than in Memphis. For this reason, the return periods of ground failure are quite different in the three cities, as discussed and computed below.

Example LPI hazard curves

Figure 3. Example LPILPI hazard curves: (a) a site with varying AA and B=15B=15 in Seattle, Washington; (b) a high liquefaction hazard site (A=25A=25, B=15B=15) located in a range of seismic settings.

Having developed λLPI\lambda_{LPI} curves at a site, the mean annual exceedance frequency of ground failure, λGF\lambda_{GF}, is computed by truncating the PBEE framework prior to the calculation of a DVDV:

λGF=∫LPI=0∞PGF∣LPI⋅∣dλLPIdLPI∣⋅dLPI(7)\lambda_{GF}=\int_{LPI=0}^{\infty}P_{GF|LPI}\cdot\left|\frac{d\lambda_{LPI}}{dLPI}\right|\cdot dLPI \tag*{(7)}

where PGF∣LPIPGF|LPI is defined in Eq. (2); and λLPI\lambda_{LPI} is defined in Eq. (6). Although not intuitive, the terms by which PGF∣LPIPGF|LPI is multiplied in Eq. (7) equate to the probability of a given LPILPI value. Finally, the return period of ground failure, TGFT_{GF}, is computed as:

TGF=1/λGF(8)T_{GF} = 1/\lambda_{GF} \tag*{(8)}

where λGF\lambda_{GF} is defined in Eq. (7). Using this approach, TGFT_{GF} is computed for each λLPI\lambda_{LPI} curve in Figure 3 and added as a label. In Figure 3(a), TGFT_{GF} varies in Seattle from 54 years to 947 years for the range of AA and BB values plotted. In Figure 3(b), San Francisco, Seattle, and Memphis have respective TGFT_{GF} values of 35, 66, and 254 years (given the same hypothetical AA and BB values), despite the LPILPI with a 10,000-year return period being very similar in the three cities. In Madison, Wisconsin, an ice age may occur before the next manifestation of liquefaction. Assuming earthquakes are Poissonian, the probability of ground failure occurring at least once in a timeframe, tt, may be computed as:

PGF(t)=1−e−t/TGF(9)PGF(t) = 1 - e^{-t/T_{GF}} \tag*{(9)}

where TGFT_{GF} is defined in Eq. (8). Using this approach, the probability of at least one ground failure in 50 years, or PGF50yearsPGF_{50years}, is computed for each λLPI\lambda_{LPI} curve in Figure 3 and added as a label. Our unconditional NLHM map products include TGFT_{GF}, PGF50yearsPGF_{50years}, and PGF100yearsPGF_{100years}. Using the same demonstration area as in Figure 2, these unconditional products are mapped in Figure 4. Within these map extents, some of the highest hazards are found in Seattle’s “South-of-Downtown”, or SODO district, where artificial fill and alluvium are prevalent. The computed TGFT_{GF}, for example, commonly ranges from 65 to 75 years in much of SODO.

Three maps demonstrating unconditional modeling in the Puget Sound region: TGF and probabilities of one or more ground failures over 50-year and 100-year periods

Figure 4. Demonstration of unconditional modeling in the Puget Sound region: (a) TGFT_{GF}; probability of one or more ground failures in the next (b) 50 years; and (c) 100 years (Basemap from NOAA NCEI, 2024).

Historically, liquefaction manifestations have been observed throughout SODO during earthquakes in 1949, 1965, and 2001 [10, 7, 53]. Taking TGFT_{GF} to be 70 years and assuming a 175-year observation period from 1850 (Seattle’s founding) to 2025, two occurrences are most likely with 26% probability, followed by three, with 21% probability. Differences between historic observations and predicted return periods would not necessarily discredit the latter, but their relative agreement here nonetheless lends some credibility to the proposed maps. When interpreting Figure 4, it should be recognized that the return period of liquefaction triggering at-depth in the most susceptible stratum could be different, and likely shorter, than TGFT_{GF}, and that the return period of some liquefaction consequences (e.g., foundation damage) could be different, and likely longer, than TGFT_{GF}. That is, liquefaction triggering may occur more frequently than some surface manifestation of liquefaction, which in turn may occur more frequently than certain measures of infrastructure damage. Although surface manifestation is a pragmatic and popular proxy of damage potential for infrastructure, it is not a panacea for diagnosing liquefaction effects. Surface manifestation and asset damage due to liquefaction are strongly correlated, but each can occur without the other.

Socioeconomic Correlates to Liquefaction Hazard

To investigate whether computed liquefaction hazards exhibit socioeconomic patterns, we integrate the NLHMs with 150 demographic variables compiled by Esri [17] at the census-tract level. The roughly 84,000 census tracts have a median area of 4.6 km2^{2} (1.8 miles2^{2}) and are generally much smaller in urban areas; 25% of the tracts are less than 1.5 km2^{2} (0.6 miles2^{2}), for example, which could equate to the size of a city block. For each tract, indicators of income, housing value, educational attainment, age structure, and employment status are appended to the median 2,475-year PGFPGF sampled within each tract, permitting comparison between modeled hazard and the characteristics of affected communities. Linear relationships are quantified using Pearson’s correlation coefficient (rr) and evaluated for statistical significance via twotailed pp-values (because the sample is very large, pp-values are usually ∼\simzero and indicate significance by any benchmark). These analyses are conducted omitting: (i) map cells to which the GLM does not apply – foremost terrain with 90-m resolution slope >5∘>5^\circ; and (ii) census tracts wherein the median 2,475-year PGAMPGA_M is less than 0.1 g, thus constraining the analyses to areas where seismic loading is conceivably sufficient for liquefaction.

Within the remaining ∼44,000\sim44{,}000 tracts, it is also important to further isolate liquefaction hazard from seismic hazard. Because liquefaction is strongly influenced by PGAMPGA_M, correlations computed without correcting for PGAMPGA_M may primarily reflect variations in seismic loading rather than intrinsic differences in site susceptibility or land-use patterns. Analysis of PGAMPGA_M alone, for example, shows that high seismic hazard coincides with higher wealth metrics, such as average home value (r=0.44r = 0.44) and household income (r=0.15r = 0.15). This is because many of the most expensive coastal and metro corridors, including constrained land markets and those enriched by ports, technology, and finance (e.g., San Francisco, California; San Jose, California; Seattle, Washington, etc.) also have very high seismic hazards. To isolate associations not attributable to seismic hazard, we computed r(PGF∣PGAM)r(PGF|PGA_M), or the partial correlation between the 2,475-year PGFPGF and each variable, while conditioning on the 2,475-year PGAMPGA_M. Partial correlation removes the effects of PGAMPGA_M from both variables prior to evaluating their correlation, enabling direct comparison among locations subject to the same shaking levels. This approach is well-established in statistical analysis (e.g., [39]) for disentangling the effects of confounding variables.

Results and Discussion

All outputs are digitally available from Zdanovski et al. [72] and shown in Figs. S4-S32. These include: (i) 2,475-year MIMI and PGFPGF maps, computed using both mean and modal MM; (ii) a map showing the effect of selecting mean versus modal MM on the computed 2,475-year PGFPGF; (iii) unconditional map products TGFT_{GF}, PGF50yearsPGF_{50\text{years}}, and PGF100yearsPGF_{100\text{years}}; and (iv) the GLM model variance classified by Sanger et al. [58] which shows where, and to what degree, the mapped values are updated by local geotechnical data and models. In the following, the LPILPI products are selectively presented and discussed to address the three research questions.

Mean versus Modal Magnitude in Conditional Hazard Assessment

Interest in the use of the mean or modal MM from PSHA disaggregation has long been recognized in general contexts [e.g. 26, 27] yet in liquefaction assessment, guidance and practices are inconsistent and the issue is controversial. The only guidance appearing in ASCE 7-22 [2] in the context of liquefaction is that the chosen MM should be “consistent” with the PGAPGA, which is usually interpreted as taking either the mean (i.e., weighted average) or modal MM from disaggregation. In settings dominated by one seismic source, the two are similar or identical. But in settings with multiple sources, the mean may not represent a realistic scenario; for example, where a hazard is dominated by a nearby small MM source and distant large MM source, the mean may correspond to a moderate MM at moderate distance, but no such source may exist. For this reason, some engineers believe the mean should never be used, and some guidelines explicitly endorse this. The Oregon Department of Transportation geotechnical design manual [50], for example, states “mean values of MM and RR [site-to-source distance] are not recommended for use in liquefaction hazard analyses.”

Others have argued that the mean MM need not represent an actual source to be the choice more consistent with the intents of probabilistic analyses. As said by Kramer [37]: “the fact the mean magnitude itself may not contribute strongly to peak acceleration should not be any more troubling than the fact that 3.5, the expected value of the numbers returned by multiple tosses of a fair die, does not appear on any of the faces of that die.” Notably, where the seismic hazard distribution is diffuse, the modal MM represents a real source, but like any one face of the die, contributes modestly to the overall distribution (e.g., at some locales the modal MM contributes less than 5% to the total hazard). Although we are unaware of any code or guideline that compels use of mean MM, many engineers and studies have chosen it [e.g. 38, 12, 42], especially when comparing conditional and unconditional formulations. Meneses and Chang [46] summarized nine building codes in the U.S. and abroad: one required modal MM, and the remaining ten either stated that both mean and modal MM are acceptable or – most often – provided even lesser guidance. Some engineers adopt whichever MM is larger in the name of conservatism (e.g., [5]). Still others have argued that given the nonlinear relationship between MM and liquefaction hazard, the correct approach is to assess the liquefaction hazard for all MM values that contribute to the seismic hazard (in terms of factor of safety, PGFPGF, or some other metric) and then weigh each output by the relative contribution of each MM [37]. What this latter recommendation alludes to is that the unconditional formulation, wherein all MM contributions are explicitly accounted for, would be more rational and eliminate the need to choose a magnitude altogether.

Putting this aside momentarily, the national 2,475-year PGFPGF map is shown in Figure 5, derived from the 2,475-year LPILPI using mean MM. After generating the same PGFPGF product using the modal MM, we map in Figure 6 the difference (ΔPGF\Delta PGF) resulting from the MM selection, where positive values indicate the mean MM is greater, and negative values indicate the modal MM is greater. Across 889 million flatland cells, around 50% see ∼0\sim0 change in PGFPGF, either because the PGFPGFs are zero (10% of cells), or because the mean and modal MM are the same or very similar. Around 20% of cells are positive (mean hazard greater) and largely between 0 and +10% (1% of values are greater than +10%), with a maximum of +22%. Around 30% of cells are negative (modal hazard greater) and largely between 0 and -10% (2% of values are lower than -10%), with a minimum of -34%. On average, there is a -0.34% downshift in PGFPGF using the modal magnitude, with a standard deviation of 2.1%.

Map of 2,475-year mean M PGF (%)

Figure 5. 2,475-year PGFPGF (%) computed using mean MM (Basemap from NOAA NCEI, 2024).

Map of the effects of selecting mean relative to modal M in conditional hazard formulation

Figure 6. The effects of selecting mean relative to modal MM in conditional hazard formulation: 2,475-year PGFPGF computed using mean MM minus 2,475-year PGFPGF computed using modal MM (Basemap from NOAA NCEI, 2024).

Thus, for most sites, the choice of MM translates to PGFPGF swings less than ±2.5%\pm2.5\%, but for select areas it can alter the perceived hazard more meaningfully. The areas most affected tend to have: (i) high liquefaction susceptibility; (ii) PGAPGA near thresholds for liquefaction; and (iii) diffuse seismicity – often dominated by areal, or “grid” sources – where multiple earthquakes contribute to the hazard. In these areas, both large positive and large negative ΔPGF\Delta PGF values may occur in proximity. Whereas the mean MM weighs the entire seismic hazard distribution and tends to smoothly vary in space (Fig. S4), the mode can be sensitive to minor fluctuations in PSHA inputs and to decisions made in the disaggregation (e.g., magnitude-distance bin sizes; the handling of uncertainty from ground-motion models). For this reason, the modal MM can spatially vacillate between distinctly different seismic sources, as shown nationally in Fig. S5.

Near St. Louis, Missouri, for example, the PGA\mathit{PGA} hazard distribution is strongly bimodal: 70% is low-MM grid seismicity and 30% is associated with the high-MM New Madrid seismic zone. At one location (38.820, -90.653) the mean and modal MM are 6.4 and 4.9, respectively, where the mode is associated with a local grid source. Nearby (38.879, -90.674), the mean MM is unchanged, but the modal MM is 7.8 and associated with the distant New Madrid source. Similar examples are found in all directions radiating from New Madrid. In California’s central valley – near the town of Visalia (36.396, -119.119), for example – 80% of the PGA\mathit{PGA} hazard is grid seismicity of ∼M\sim M 5.5, with various finite-fault sources contributing 20%, led by a MM 7.9 San Andreas fault rupture. Here the mean MM is 5.7, whereas the mode vacillates between MM 5.3 and MM 7.9. A final example, yet more extreme, is found along the Cascadia subduction margin for inland Washington, Oregon, and California. Near Klamath Falls, Oregon (41.920, -121.200), for example, the PGA\mathit{PGA} hazard is mostly grid seismicity (∼\sim60%), with shallow finite-faults contributing ∼\sim20% and Cascadia interface ruptures contributing ∼\sim10%. Here, the modal MM swings between 5.3 and 9.3, whereas the mean is a steady MM 6.7. It is clearly problematic, if not disqualifying, that the mode can dramatically alter a computed liquefaction hazard from one side of a street to the other, all else being equal.

Conditional versus Unconditional Hazard Formulation

Shown in Figure 7 is the computed TGFT_{GF} at national scale. Following the discussion in Figure 3, it can be shown that locations with identical 2,475-year hazards have very different “actual” (i.e., unconditional) hazards. Sites near Charleston, South Carolina, and Auburn, Washington, for example, have the same 2,475-year PGAM\mathit{PGAM} (0.77 g) and profiles that are modeled as being very similar (i.e., the same AA and BB values). Hence these sites have the same 2,475-year LPI\mathit{LPI} (36) and PGF\mathit{PGF} (87%), reflecting the same very high liquefaction hazard. Yet the seismic settings are distinctly different, giving rise to different λLPI\lambda_{\mathit{LPI}} curves, aside from a common crossing point at 2,475-years. Auburn is subject to shallow crustal events, deep intraslab ruptures, and subduction interface earthquakes, collectively having a wide range of return periods, all potentially large magnitude. Conversely, the seismic hazard in Charleston is dominated by one crustal fault that can produce very strong shaking, but which is believed to have a long return period. As a result, the computed return periods of ground failure are very different: 80 years in Auburn and 386 years in Charleston. These TGFT_{GF} values translate into PGF50yearsPGF_{50\mathrm{years}} values of 46% and 12%, respectively.

Map showing computed return period of ground failure across the United States

Figure 7. Computed return period of ground failure (years) (Basemap from NOAA NCEI, 2024).

The conditional approach suppresses patterns in the actual liquefaction hazard by ignoring all return periods but one. Yet it is challenging to quantify how the codified hazard might change if it were shifted away from the traditional, conditional formulation, given that the outputs from the two formulations are distinctly different. The conditional approach results in a PGFPGF conditioned on the 2,475-year seismic loading (i.e., a single outcome in a single event). The unconditional approach results in a return period of ground failure, which can be expressed as the probability of at least one ground failure over a given exposure time, tt (e.g., PGF50yearsPGF_{50\mathrm{years}} for t=50t = 50 years). Although both approaches output a probability, the comparison is complicated by the different frames of reference: one is a probability given a singular event; the other is a probability over a specific period. If building codes were to adopt unconditional formulations, the acceptable level of risk (e.g., expressed as TGFT_{GF}) would need to be defined through careful analysis and community consensus. Just as engineers may presently deem a site “hazardous” (i.e., design unacceptable, mitigation required) when the likelihood of some outcome (e.g., liquefaction triggering, surface manifestation, etc.) in a 2,475-year event exceeds some threshold (e.g., 15%, 50%), an analogous decision threshold is required using the unconditional formulation (e.g., a specified TGFT_{GF}, PGF50yearsPGF_{50years}, or PGF100yearsPGF_{100years}).

A wide range of new decision thresholds could conceivably be justified. One approach demonstrated here is to determine the unconditional threshold that, on average, results in the perceived hazard remaining the same as in the 2,475-year event; specifically, for what time, tt, does the probability of at least one ground failure, PGF(t)PGF(t), equal the 2,475-year PGFPGF? In Figure 8 we compute and map the exposure time, tt, that satisfies this condition, making use of the 2,475-year PGFPGF in Figure 5 and the TGFT_{GF} in Figure 7. Simply taking the arithmetic mean tt across all 889 million flatland cells results in a decision threshold of 400 years (of course, weighting schemes based on population density, liquefaction hazard, etc. can be imagined). Where the mapped, required tt is less than 400 years, the unconditional hazard is relatively high compared to the 2,475-year hazard, whereas when the required tt is more than 400 years, the unconditional hazard is relatively low compared to the 2,475-year hazard. Again, using the sites from Auburn, Washington and Charleston, South Carolina as an example, the tt required in Auburn (TGF=80T_{GF} = 80 years, 2,475-year PGF=87%PGF = 87\%) is 163 years whereas that required in Charleston (TGF=386T_{GF} = 386 years, 2,475-year PGF=87%PGF = 87\%) is 787 years. Adopting the decision threshold of 400 years, engineers would be required to determine the probability of at least one ground failure in 400 years, analogous to how they currently determine and interpret the 2,475-year PGFPGF. With this approach, the newly computed hazard, relative to the 2,475-year conditional hazard, would increase in Auburn and decrease in Charleston.

Map of exposure time required for unconditional hazard to match conditional hazard

Figure 8. Exposure time, tt (years) required for unconditional hazard to “match” conditional hazard (Basemap from NOAA NCEI, 2024).

Although limitations will be discussed comprehensively in a dedicated section, we note here that using LPILPI or other MIsMIs to quantify liquefaction hazards may not be desirable for all use-cases; an analogous approach centered on liquefaction triggering would undoubtedly produce different results from those mapped in Figure 8, given that LPILPI transforms PGAMPGA_M into a probability of surface manifestation, whereas an alternative framing could transform PGAMPGA_M into a probability of triggering in a specific stratum at depth. Each of these approaches could be preferrable in certain contexts. Our example should not be interpreted as an endorsement for framing building codes around manifestation probabilities, but rather as a contribution to the discussion of how unconditional and conditional hazards can differ.

Socioeconomic Exposure to Liquefaction Hazard

After controlling for PGAMPGA_M, residual correlations between liquefaction hazard (2,475-year PGFPGF) and several categories of socioeconomic metrics are observed, meaning that liquefaction hazard is not uniformly distributed across communities. Select correlations are given in Table 1, grouped by six categories, and results for all 150 metrics are presented in Table S1 of the Supplemental Materials. Across tracts with comparable PGAMPGA_M, liquefaction hazard has positive correlation with various measures of population density (e.g., r=+0.19r = +0.19), meaning that denser, more urban tracts tend to sit on more liquefiable deposits (e.g., river valleys, deltas, fill, waterfronts, industrial corridors.). Tracts with lower homeownership rates and higher mortgage-cost burdens are also associated with higher PGFPGF. Before controlling for PGAMPGA_M, PGFPGF is positively associated with high home-value areas due to the underlying positive correlation between seismic hazard and real estate value. Once PGAMPGA_M is held constant, however, high PGFPGF is more common in lower-wealth, lower-income tracts, while high-wealth enclaves at the same PGAMPGA_M have lower PGFPGF. In this category, household income, disposable income, the socioeconomic status index, and many high-value home brackets (e.g., $2M+, $1.5M+) have negative rr (i.e., PGFPGF decreases as wealth metrics increase), while very low-income tracts (e.g., household income << $15k) have positive rr (i.e., PGFPGF increases as poverty metrics increase). Consistent with the portrait of wealth and income, tracts with lower educational attainment tend to have higher PGFPGF. In this category, the greatest association was measured in tracts where a higher percent of adults have attained less than a 9{sup}th-grade education (r=+0.11r = +0.11). At the same time, liquefaction hazard is elevated in younger, working-age neighborhoods and reduced in older, senior-dominated areas (e.g., r=+0.12r = +0.12); the hazard is also higher where measures of economic polarization are greater (e.g., Gini index, 90%:10% income ratio). Taken together, these results indicate liquefaction exposure is more common in densely populated communities with lower income, lower wealth, and lower rates of educational attainment and homeownership.

CategoryVariablerr (PGFPGFPGAMPGAM)
Urban FormPopulation Density+0.189
Urban FormDaytime Population Density+0.133
Tenure & Housing StressHomeownership Rate-0.206
Tenure & Housing Stress% of Income for Mortgage+0.103
Wealth, Income, & Socio-Economic StatusWealth Index-0.133
Wealth, Income, & Socio-Economic StatusSocioeconomic Status Index (SES)-0.127
Wealth, Income, & Socio-Economic StatusMedian Household Income-0.102
Wealth, Income, & Socio-Economic StatusHome Value $1.5M-$2M-0.102
Wealth, Income, & Socio-Economic StatusDisposable Income > $200k | -0.090
Wealth, Income, & Socio-Economic StatusHouseholds with Income < $15,000 | +0.072
Education% Age 25+ with < 9th Grade Education+0.112
Education% Age 25+ with < High School Degree+0.111
Education% Age 25+ with Bachelor's or Higher-0.046
Age StructureMedian Age-0.123
Age StructureSenior Population (65+)-0.093
Age StructurePopulation Age 25-29+0.076
Economic InequalityP90/P10 Income Ratio+0.093
Economic InequalityGini Index+0.087

Table 1. Partial correlations between 2,475-year PGFPGF and select variables, controlling for PGAMPGAM.

All demographic correlations can be considered moderate or weak per standard benchmarks, but at the population scale can amount to disproportionate exposure for large numbers of people; these correlations are similar in magnitude, for example, to those measured in economic stratifications of air pollution [11]. These results provide an initial indication that socioeconomic vulnerability may compound with physical hazard exposure in shaping earthquake impacts. Liquefaction has the potential for both short and long-term harm by reducing housing stability, inhibiting recovery, disrupting infrastructure, degrading environmental quality, and exacerbating wealth disparities.

Limitations, Uncertainties, and Future Work

The NLHMs are subject to limitations and uncertainties that encourage further work. First, the sciences of predicting ground motions and liquefaction are imperfect and ever improving. Future versions of the national seismic hazard model, released every few years, could alter the modeled hazard in some areas. Similarly, the in-situ data available to Sanger et al. [58] GLM, which are used to train the model and to geostatistically update its predictions in the field, are continually growing. The Sanger et al. [58] approach is intended to be a “living model” with version updates that reflect new data and the latest science. The triggering and manifestation models surrogated by Sanger et al. [58] and adopted here will inevitably be supplanted, and new models might alter the mapped liquefaction hazard. The NLHMs are also subject to other GLM limitations discussed in detail by Sanger et al. [58]. For example, the GLM is limited by the spatial resolutions and accuracies of geospatial variables, some of which are themselves predictions. As a result, errors in liquefaction predictions can arise where key inputs, such as modeled groundwater level, are incorrect, where soil conditions vary at a resolution finer than the mapped geospatial variables, or where those variables fail to predict important aspects of the subsurface.

Additional subsurface geotechnical data would inevitably improve reliability. In this regard, CPT soundings are often collected where liquefaction is anticipated or where refusal is less likely. If so, the models could bias toward higher liquefaction probabilities in terrains poorly represented in the training set. Incorporating SPT data in future GLM updates should help strengthen NLHM accuracy in regions or geologic settings where CPTs are scarce (e.g., glacial deposits). Another GLM limitation pertains to lateral spreading. Manifestation models like LPILPI are known not to predict it as efficiently as other expressions of liquefaction (i.e., settlement, ejecta, cracking) (e.g., Maurer et al. [43]), principally because lateral spreading may occur near a free face or on sloping ground, even if the liquefiable stratum is thin. In such a case, the computed LPILPI and PGFPGF may be relatively low, but the consequences of liquefaction could exceed those expected in the absence of lateral spreading.

Second, all PSHA analyses assumed seismic site class D. If the site class was uniformly different (e.g., E), or if a variable site class were assigned via a VS30V_{S30} model (e.g., Geyin and Maurer, [21]), the NLHM values could change to some degree. However, because PGAPGA is used in the GLM (like the state-of-practice models the GLM surrogates), and because PGAPGA is less sensitive to site class than lower-frequency spectral accelerations, the changes are often negligible. We performed a sensitivity test in 25 cities having a range of seismic hazards and changed the class from D to E. The change to a softer site generally decreases the PGAPGA at longer return periods (for which the rock motion tends to be strong) and increases the PGAPGA at shorter return periods (for which the rock motion tends to be weak). In Seattle, for example, the 2,475-year PGAPGA changes by -0.048 g while the 50-year PGAPGA changes by +0.019 g. Specific to the 2,475-year NLHMs, the hazard mapped throughout the county would generally diminish, albeit typically by a trivial amount. The 2,475-year D-to-E PGAPGA changes in select cities include: -0.003 g in Boston, Massachusetts; -0.005 g in Richmond, Virginia; -0.028 g in Memphis, Tennessee; -0.040 g in Portland, Oregon; -0.139 g in San Francisco, California; -0.159 g in Salt Lake City, Utah; and -0.178 g in Los Angeles, California. Notably, the largest changes are associated with large PGAsPGAs which, when considering Eqs. (1) and (3), cause only a small change in PGFPGF. In San Francisco’s Marina District, for example, where the mapped liquefaction hazard is among the highest in the city, the -0.159 g shift in PGAPGA changes PGFPGF by just -0.5%. In Los Angeles, Marina Del Ray has among the highest mapped hazard in the city; there, the -0.178 g change in PGAPGA changes PGFPGF by -0.8%. In our limited tests, changes to the 2,475-year PGFPGF never exceed 1% regardless of the seismic and liquefaction hazards. The effect of the D-to-E change on the unconditional hazard is less straightforward, since PGAPGA decreases for some return periods, but increases for others, and since different return periods contribute differently to TGFT_{GF}. For the tests in 25 cities, the D-to-E change had a median effect on TGFT_{GF} of +1.64 years, or +0.25%, meaning the hazard diminished slightly. Yet in select locations, larger changes to TGFT_{GF}, both up and down, were observed. For example, at a site in Newport, Oregon, with low liquefaction hazard, TGFT_{GF} shortened by 85 years, or -9%, and at a site in Charleston, South Carolina, with high liquefaction hazard, TGFT_{GF} lengthened by 8 years, or +2%. In summary, the NLHMs might, on average, remain the same if site class was changed, but could communicate a meaningfully different hazard in specific places.

Third, some compromises between computational expense and accuracy were made within the unconditional approach. PSHA calculations and disaggregation were performed at 0.04∘0.04^\circ (~4 km) spatial resolution, then interpolated to the finer 0.0008∘0.0008^\circ (~90 m) resolution of the GLM. Sensitivity tests established that the resulting error was acceptably small and unbiased. Throughout King County, Washington, for example, the ensuing percent error in TGFT_{GF} ranged from -2.53% to +2.38%, with a median of ~0%, thereby justifying the less expensive computation. Additionally, because this approach integrates over PGAPGA hazard curves – each with a given return period – it can be sensitive to the number of datapoints used to define those curves (i.e., PGAPGA-λ\lambda pairs), with coarser discretization tending to misrepresent TGFT_{GF}. Because PSHA execution at just one return period across the contiguous U.S. requires extensive resources, we assessed the sensitivity of TGFT_{GF} to the quantity of data defining the PGAPGA hazard curves in various cities, and for a range of soil conditions (i.e., GLM AA and BB values). From these analyses, 20 return periods were found to produce sufficiently accurate results and were used to generate the NLHMs in all locations. Although we find these compromises acceptable for the intended regional-scale purposes of the NLHMs, and necessary considering the computational burden, they do produce small errors.

Fourth, the socioeconomic correlation analysis was performed at the census-tract scale using the median modeled liquefaction hazard within each tract and should not be interpreted as applying to individual households. This analysis controlled only for PGAMPGA_M and only in a linear sense; it did not account for non-linear relationships or unobserved confounders. The socioeconomic indices are derived from survey data and inevitably contain measurement errors. With 44,000 tracts, very small effect sizes are significant, so emphasis should be placed on the magnitude of relationships rather than pp-values. Finally, the analysis examined present-day conditions against a long-return-period hazard metric and did not capture how future demographic shifts, land-use change, or adaptation measures may alter the distribution of liquefaction risk. These limitations suggest the correlations should be viewed as hypothesis-generating and complementary to, rather than a substitute for, detailed local studies.

Finally, it is emphasized that the NLHMs are not intended to supersede intensive city- or region-specific hazard mapping efforts that may benefit from expert knowledge of local geology, access to larger subsurface datasets, laboratory testing, or more accurate estimates of groundwater depth. Rather, the intention herein is to provide baseline NLHMs, developed by a standard approach, for the entire contiguous US; a future iteration of the NLHMs may include Alaska, Hawaii, and other U.S. territories. Notwithstanding these limitations, this study may be the first effort to develop U.S. NLHMs. As the availability of community geotechnical data increases, so too will the feasibility and accuracy of such attempts. Ultimately, new subsurface data and future earthquake observations will verify or refine the results shared here and succinctly summarized below.

Conclusions

By coupling a geospatial liquefaction model with probabilistic seismic hazard analyses, we produced spatially continuous national liquefaction hazard models across the contiguous U.S. using both conditional and unconditional hazard formulations. Potential applications for these models include preliminary site assessment, land-use policy, regional-scale response and recovery planning, prioritization of distributed assets for site-specific study, and screening tools for regulatory enforcement. Beyond these general uses, we investigated questions of engineering practice and policy. The ambiguous choice between mean and modal magnitude in conditional analyses can materially influence predictions in certain settings, altering design-level interpretations of the hazard. Our findings delineate where, to what degree, these alterations are expected and motivate clearer guidance on magnitude selection in design standards. Comparison between unconditional and conditional hazards demonstrates how the latter can obscure the true hazard and result in inconsistent levels of codified risk across the country. Our findings show where these inconsistencies may occur and encourage migration away from conditional hazard formulations in current building codes, even if only incremental, such as that recently proposed by Makdisi et al. [42]. The models enable national-scale evaluation of exposure to liquefaction hazard and socioeconomic metrics, providing preliminary evidence that liquefaction hazard may compound with social vulnerability, shaping post-event mobility, access, and recovery. While not a substitute for site-specific investigation, the products provide a consistent national reference in support of regional-scale applications and inquiries. As geotechnical datasets expand and liquefaction models improve, the presented national liquefaction hazard models can be refined and updated, advancing toward increasingly accurate national representations of liquefaction hazard.

Data Availability

The geotechnical and geospatial data used in model development are all publicly available, as described and referenced in the text. The Sanger et al. [58] GLM code and map products are available from Sanger et al. [60]. All map products produced in this study are digitally available on DesignSafe as geotiff files from Zdanovski et al. [72].

Acknowledgements

The presented work is based on research supported by the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) under award G23AP00017, the Cascadia Region Earthquake Science Center (CRESCENT) via National Science Foundation (NSF) award 2225286, the Cascadia Coastlines and Peoples (CoPes) Hub via NSF award 2103713, the Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research (PEER) Center under award 1185-NCTRMB, and the Pacific Northwest Transportation Consortium (PacTrans) under award 69A3552348310. However, any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed herein are those of the authors and may not reflect the views of USGS, NSF, CoPes, CRESCENT, PEER, or PacTrans. Furthermore, this work was facilitated using HPC infrastructure provided by the Hyak supercomputer and funded by the University of Washington’s student technology fund, and through DesignSafe at the Texas Advanced Computing Center.

Supplemental Materials

Figs. S1–S32 and Table S1 are available as a data repository from Zdanovski et al. [72].

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

  1. [1]Asadi, A., Sanon, C., Cakir, E., Zhan, W., Shirzadi, H., Baise, L. G., Cetin, K. O., & Moaveni, B. (2024). Geospatial liquefaction modeling of the 2023 Türkiye earthquake sequence by an ensemble of global, continental, regional, and event-specific models. Seismological Research Letters, 95(2A), 697-719. https://doi.org/10.1785/0220230287
  2. [2]ASCE (American Society of Civil Engineers). (2022). ASCE/SEI 7-22: Minimum design loads and associated criteria for buildings and other structures (Standard No. ASCE/SEI 7-22). Reston, VA. https://doi.org/10.1061/9780784415786
  3. [3]Azul, K. M., Orense, R., & Wotherspoon, L. (2024). Investigation of representative geotechnical data for the development of a hybrid geotechnical-geospatial liquefaction assessment model. Japanese Geotechnical Society Special Publication, 10(17), 585-590. https://doi.org/10.3208/jgssp.v10.OS-6-07
  4. [5]Barani, S., Ferretti, G., & Scafidi, D. (2023). Evaluation of liquefaction triggering potential in Italy: a seismic-hazard-based approach. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 23(5), 1685-1698. https://doi.org/10.5194/nhess-23-1685-2023
  5. [6]Bozzoni, F., Bonì, R., Conca, D., Meisina, C., Lai, C. G., & Zuccolo, E. (2021). A geospatial approach for mapping the earthquake-induced liquefaction risk at the European scale. Geosciences, 11(1), 32. https://doi.org/10.3390/geosciences11010032
  6. [7]Bray, J.D., Sancio, R.B., Kammerer, A.M., Merry, S.M., Rodriguez-Marek, A., Khazal, B., Chang, S., Bastani, A., Collins, B., Hausler, E., Dreger, D., Perkins, W.J., & Nykamp, M. (2001). Some observations of geotechnical aspects of the February 28, 2001, Nisqually earthquake in Olympia, south Seattle, and Tacoma, Washington. Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center. http://peer.berkeley.edu/publications/nisqually/geotech/index.htmlDOI
  7. [8]Bullock, Z., Zimmaro, P., Lavrentiadis, G., Wang, P., Ojomo, O., Asimaki, D., Rathje, E. M., & Stewart, J. P. (2023). A latent Gaussian process model for the spatial distribution of liquefaction manifestation. Earthquake Spectra, 39(2), 1189-1213. https://doi.org/10.1177/87552930231163894
  8. [9]CGS (California Geological Survey) (2024). EZQ App (web map application). California Department of Conservation. https://maps.conservation.ca.gov/cgs/informationwarehouse/ezqapp/
  9. [10]Chleborad, A. F., & Schuster, R. L. (1990). Ground failure associated with the Puget Sound region earthquakes of April 13, 1949, and April 29, 1965 (No. 90-687). US Geological Survey. https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/1990/0687/report.pdfDOI
  10. [11]Collins, T. W., Grineski, S. E., & Nadybal, S. M. (2022). A comparative approach for environmental justice analysis: Explaining divergent societal distributions of particulate matter and ozone pollution across US neighborhoods. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 112(2), 522-541. https://doi.org/10.1080/24694452.2021.1935690
  11. [12]Cox, B. R., & Griffiths, S. C. (2010). Practical recommendations for evaluation and mitigation of soil liquefaction in Arkansas. Report No. MBTC 3017, United States Department of Transportation, University Transportation Centers (UTC) Program. https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/20363/dot_20363__DS1.pdf
  12. [15]DHS (Department of Homeland Security) (2019). Resiliency Assessment: Washington State Transportation Systems, Regional Resiliency Assessment Program (RRAP), Executive Agency Publication HS 1.2:R 31/4. https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/GOVPUB-HS-PURL-gpo126643
  13. [16]Doughton, S., & Gilbert, D. (2018, February 7). Survey finds only 11.3% of Washington homes have earthquake insurance. The Seattle Times. https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/science/survey-finds-only-11-3-of-washington-homes-have-earthquake-insurance/
  14. [17]Esri. (2023). Esri Updated Demographics Variables 2023 [Hosted Feature Layer]. ArcGIS Online. https://www.arcgis.com/home/item.html?id=ddd1510ed1964e2e8fb1ded93e9b03b1
  15. [18]Franke, K. W., Lingwall, B. N., Youd, T. L., Blonquist, J., & Liang, J. H. (2019). Overestimation of liquefaction hazard in areas of low to moderate seismicity due to improper characterization of probabilistic seismic loading. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 116, 681-691. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soildyn.2018.10.040
  16. [19]Franke, K. W., Ulmer, K. J., Ekstrom, L. T., & Meneses, J. F. (2016). Clarifying the differences between traditional liquefaction hazard maps and probabilistic liquefaction reference parameter maps. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 90, 240-249. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soildyn.2015.08.019
  17. [20]Geyin, M., & Maurer, B. W. (2020). Fragility functions for liquefaction-induced ground failure. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 146(12), 04020142. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)GT.1943-5606.0002416
  18. [21]Geyin, M., & Maurer, B. W. (2023). US national Vs30 models and maps informed by remote sensing and machine learning. Seismological Society of America, 94(3), 1467-1477. https://doi.org/10.31224/2466
  19. [22]Geyin, M., Baird, A. J. & Maurer, B.W. (2020). Field assessment of liquefaction prediction models based on geotechnical vs. geospatial data, with lessons for each. Earthquake Spectra, 36(3), 1386–1411. https://doi.org/10.1177/8755293019899995
  20. [23]Geyin, M., Maurer, B. W., & Christofferson, K. (2022). An AI driven, mechanistically grounded geospatial liquefaction model for rapid response and scenario planning. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 159, 107348. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soildyn.2022.107348
  21. [24]Goda, K., Atkinson, G.M., Hunter, J.A., Crow, H., & Motazedian, D. (2011). Probabilistic liquefaction hazard analysis for four Canadian cities. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, 101(1), 190-201. https://doi.org/10.1785/0120100094
  22. [25]Green, R. A., & Kizer, R. (2020). Evaluating liquefaction triggering potential using seismic input parameters that are consistent with ASCE 7-16. Geo-Congress 2020, 87-95. https://doi.org/10.1061/9780784482810.010
  23. [26]Harmsen, S. C. (2001). Mean and modal value of the deaggregation of probabilistic ground motion. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, 91(6), 1537-1552. https://doi.org/10.1785/0120000289
  24. [27]Harmsen, S. C., Frankel, A. D., & Petersen, M. D. (2003). Deaggregation of US seismic hazard sources: The 2002 Update. Open-File Report 2003-03-440, US Department of the Interior, US Geological Survey. https://pubsdata.usgs.gov/pubs/of/2003/ofr-03-440/ofr-03-440.html
  25. [29]Hoffman, J. S., Shandas, V., & Pendleton, N. (2020). The effects of historical housing policies on resident exposure to intra-urban heat: a study of 108 US urban areas. Climate, 8(1), 12. https://doi.org/10.3390/cli8010012
  26. [32]ICC (International Code Council). (2021). International Residential Code. International Code Council. https://codes.iccsafe.org/content/IRC2021V3.0
  27. [33]Idriss, I. M., & Boulanger, R. W. (2008). Soil liquefaction during earthquakes. Earthquake Engineering Research Institute.
  28. [34]Iwasaki, T. (1978). A practical method for assessing soil liquefaction potential based on case studies at various sites in Japan. In Proc. of 2nd Int. National Conf. on Microzonation, 1978 (Vol. 2, pp. 885-896).
  29. [35]Jena, R., Pradhan, B., Almazroui, M., Assiri, M., & Park, H. J. (2023). Earthquake-induced liquefaction hazard mapping at national-scale in Australia using deep learning techniques. Geoscience Frontiers, 14(1), 101460. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsf.2022.101460
  30. [36]Kim, H. S. (2023). Geospatial data-driven assessment of earthquake-induced liquefaction impact mapping using classifier and cluster ensembles. Applied Soft Computing, 140, 110266. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asoc.2023.110266
  31. [37]Kramer, S. L. (2008). Evaluation of liquefaction hazards in Washington state (No. WA-RD 668.1). Washington (State). Dept. of Transportation. Office of Research and Library Services. https://www.wsdot.wa.gov/research/reports/fullreports/668.1.pdf
  32. [38]Kramer, S. L., & Mayfield, R. T. (2007). Return period of soil liquefaction. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 133(7), 802-813. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)1090-0241(2007)133:7(802).
  33. [39]Kutner, M. H., Nachtshheim, C. J., Neter, J., & Li, W. (2005). Applied Linear Statistical Models (5th ed.). McGraw-Hill, New York, NY.
  34. [40]Lin, A., Wotherspoon, L., Bradley, B., & Motha, J. (2021). Evaluation and modification of geospatial liquefaction models using land damage observational data from the 2010–2011 Canterbury Earthquake Sequence. Engineering Geology, 287, 106099. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enggeo.2021.106099
  35. [41]Makdisi, A. J., & Kramer, S. L. (2024). Framework for mapping liquefaction hazard–targeted design ground motions. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 150(12), 04024123. https://doi.org/10.1061/JGGEFK.GTENG-12804
  36. [42]Makdisi, A. J., Kramer, S. L., Bassal, P., Maurer, B. W., Perkins, W., Anderson, D., Crouse, C. B., Dashti, S., & Teague, D. (2026). Development of liquefaction-targeted design basis in U.S. building codes. Earthquake Spectra, in press. Wiley.DOI
  37. [43]Maurer, B. W., Green, R. A., Cubrinovski, M., & Bradley, B. A. (2015). Assessment of CPT-based methods for liquefaction evaluation in a liquefaction potential index framework. Géotechnique, 65(5), 328-336. https://doi.org/10.1680/geot.SIP.15.P.007
  38. [44]Maurer, B.W., Geyin, M., & van Ballegooy, S. (2025). A pragmatic framework for cost-benefit analysis of liquefaction mitigation applicable to lightweight residential structures on shallow foundations. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 151(6), 04025045. https://doi.org/10.1061/JGGEFK.GTENG-13142
  39. [46]Meneses, J. F., & Chang, K. E. (2019). Seismic ground motions for evaluation of liquefaction triggering. In Earthquake Geotechnical Engineering for Protection and Development of Environment and Constructions (pp. 3876-3883). CRC Press. https://www.issmge.org/uploads/publications/59/104/ch423.pdf
  40. [47]NIBS (National Institute of Building Sciences). (1997). Earthquake Loss Estimation Methodology: HAZUS Technical Manual (Vol. 1). Federal Emergency Management Agency.
  41. [50]ODOT (Oregon Department of Transportation). (2024). Geotechnical Design Manual (GDM April 2024) Delivery & Operations Division, Geotechnical Engineering & Engineering Geology Section. https://www.oregon.gov/odot/GeoEnvironmental/Docs_GeologyGeotech/GDM_2024.pdf
  42. [51]Petersen, M. D., Shumway, A. M., Powers, P. M., Field, E. H., Moschetti, M. P., Jaiswal, K. S., ... & Witter, R. C. (2024). The 2023 US 50-state national seismic hazard model: Overview and implications. Earthquake Spectra, 40(1), 5-88. https://doi.org/10.1177/87552930231215428
  43. [53]Rasanen, R. A., Geyin, M., & Maurer, B. W. (2023). Select liquefaction case histories from the 2001 Nisqually, Washington earthquake: A digital dataset and assessment of model performance. Earthquake Spectra, 39(3), 1534-1557. https://doi.org/10.1177/87552930231174244
  44. [54]Rasanen, R., Geyin, M., Sanger, M. D., & Maurer, B. W. (2024). A database of cone penetration tests from the Cascadia Subduction Zone [Dataset]. DesignSafe-CI. https://doi.org/10.17603/ds2-snvv-jv27
  45. [55]Rashidian, V., & Baise, L. G. (2020). Regional efficacy of a global geospatial liquefaction model. Engineering Geology, 272, 105644. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enggeo.2020.105644
  46. [56]Rateria, G., Geyin, M., & Maurer, B. W. (2024). CPT-based liquefaction case histories from global earthquakes: a digital dataset [Dataset]. DesignSafe-CI. https://doi.org/10.17603/ds2-8hvd-hd43
  47. [57]Regione Emilia-Romagna. (2024). Banca dati prove geognostiche - Prove penetrometriche numeriche (punti) [Dataset]. Geoportale. https://geoportale.regione.emilia-romagna.it/catalogo/dati-cartografici/informazioni-geoscientifiche/geologia/banca-dati-geognostica/layer-3
  48. [58]Sanger, M. D., Geyin, M., & Maurer, B. W. (2025). Mechanics-informed machine learning for geospatial modeling of soil liquefaction: global and national surrogate models for simulation and near-real-time response. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 151(11), 04025126. https://doi.org/10.1061/JGGEFK.GTENG-13737
  49. [59]Sanger, M. D., Geyin, M., Shin, A., & Maurer, B. W. (2024a). A database of cone penetration tests from North America [Dataset]. DesignSafe-CI. https://doi.org/10.17603/ds2-gqjm-t836
  50. [60]Sanger, M. D., Geyin, M., & Maurer, B. W. (2024b). Mechanics-informed machine learning for geospatial modeling of soil liquefaction: Global model map products for LPI, LPIish, and LSN [Dataset]. DesignSafe-CI. https://doi.org/10.17603/ds2-c0z7-hc12
  51. [62]SDCI (Seattle Department of Construction and Inspections) (2023). Update of ECA Liquefaction-Prone Areas Map. Regulations for Critical Areas. Available at: https://www.seattle.gov/dpd/codes/dr/2-2023.pdf <Accessed 7 Feb. 2025>.
  52. [64]Tessum, C. W., Apte, J. S., Goodkind, A. L., Muller, N. Z., Mullins, K. A., Paolella, D. A., ... & Hill, J. D. (2019). Inequity in consumption of goods and services adds to racial–ethnic disparities in air pollution exposure. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116(13), 6001-6006. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1818859116
  53. [65]Todorovic, L., & Silva V. (2022). A liquefaction occurrence model for regional analysis. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 161(1), 107430. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soildyn.2022.107430
  54. [66]Toprak, S., Nacaroglu, E., van Ballegooy, S., Koc, A. C., Jacka, M., Manav, Y., Torvelainen, E., & O'Rourke, T. D. (2019). Segmented pipeline damage predictions using liquefaction vulnerability parameters. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 125, 105758. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soildyn.2019.105758
  55. [67]Ulmer, K. J., & Franke, K. W. 2016. Modified performance-based liquefaction triggering procedure using liquefaction loading parameter maps. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 142(3), 04015089. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)GT.1943-5606.0001421.
  56. [69]van Ballegooy, S., Malan, P., Lacrosse, V., Jacka, M.E., Cubrinovski, M., Bray, J.D., O’Rourke, T.D., Crawford, S.A., & Cowan, H. (2014). Assessment of liquefaction-induced land damage for residential Christchurch. Earthquake Spectra, 30(1), 31-55. https://doi.org/10.1193/081318EQS070M
  57. [70]Wing, O. E., Lehman, W., Bates, P. D., Sampson, C. C., Quinn, N., Smith, A. M., ... Kousky, C. (2022). Inequitable patterns of US flood risk in the Anthropocene. Nature Climate Change, 12(2), 156-162. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-021-01265-6
  58. [71]Youd, T. L., & Perkins, D. M. (1978). Mapping liquefaction-induced ground failure potential. Journal of the Geotechnical Engineering Division, 104(4), 433-446. https://doi.org/10.1061/AJGEB6.0000612
  59. [72]Zdanovski, V. Sanger, M. D., & Maurer, B. W. (2026). U.S. National Liquefaction Hazard Maps [Dataset]. DesignSafe-CI. https://doi.org/10.17603/ds2-05v8-d571

Paper details

vlnc:W_hgdd3efb
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Computer Science

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents