betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Charged current (anti)neutrino induced eta production off the nucleon

Abstract

The charged current (anti)neutrino induced eta production from the nucleons is studied in a model based on the effective Lagrangians to evaluate the contribution from the nonresonant and resonant diagrams. The contribution from the nonresonant background terms has been obtained using a microscopic model based on the SU(3) chiral Lagrangians. The contribution from the resonant diagrams due to the low lying S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11} (1650), and P11(1710)P_{11} (1710) resonances has been evaluated using an effective phenomenological Lagrangian with its parameters determined from the experimental values of their branching ratios and decay widths to the NηNη channel. The model is first used to reproduce satisfactorily the experimental data from the MAINZ and JLab on the total cross sections for the photo- and electro- production of ηη mesons, which fixes the model parameters in the vector current interaction. The PCAC hypothesis and generalized Goldberger-Treiman relation are used to fix the parameters of the axial vector interaction. The model is then applied to study the weak production of eta mesons induced by the neutrinos and antineutrinos, and predicts the numerical values for the Q2Q^2-distribution, ηη-momentum distribution, and the total cross section for the reactions νμ+n⟶μ−+p+ην_μ + n \longrightarrow μ^{-} + p + η and νˉμ+p⟶μ++n+η\barν_μ + p \longrightarrow μ^+ + n + η in the energy region up to 2 GeV. It is found that the photo, electro, and (anti)neutrino production of eta mesons is dominated by the contribution from the S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) resonance. The results discussed in this work are relevant for the present and future accelerator experiments like MicroBooNE, T2K, NOvA, MINERvA, T2-HyperK and DUNE as well as for the atmospheric neutrino experiments.

Introduction

Many efforts are being made around the world to learn more about the neutrinos, with the top priorities focussed on obtaining the precise information about the mass hierarchy of the neutrino mass states, and the CP violating phase delta (δCP\delta_{CP}) [1]. Various experiments using the accelerator and the atmospheric neutrinos are being carried out in the few GeV energy region for this purpose. All of these experiments make use of moderate to heavy nuclear targets such as carbon, oxygen, argon, iron, and lead, which necessitate an understanding of the nuclear medium effects that affects the (anti)neutrino-nucleon cross sections when the interaction takes place with the bound nucleons in these nuclei. The study of such nuclear medium effects makes use of a suitable model of the nucleus for describing the nuclear structure along with a good knowledge of the scattering amplitudes for the basic weak processes of (anti)neutrino scattering from the free nucleons like the neutral current (NC) elastic, charged current (CC) quasielastic, inelastic, and deep inelastic scattering (DIS). While the (anti)neutrino scattering processes of NC elastic, CC quasielastic and DIS from the free nucleons is well studied in the standard model, this is not the case with the inelastic scattering despite the enormous work done on the dominant process of the inelastic single pion production in the region of a few GeV. There are many other inelastic processes, in addition to the single pion production, like the production of kaons, hyperons with (without) accompanying pions, multi pions, ρ\rho, ω\omega and η\eta mesons, which have not been studied with the same rigour as the single pion production. A study of these processes is important in the region of a few GeV energy where many higher resonances are excited which decay into these particles. Such studies contribute to a better understanding of the various electroweak processes of the excitation of higher resonances in the energy region of shallow inelastic scattering (SIS) leading to the DIS region. The results in the SIS region and their comparison with the results in the DIS region provides an opportunity to understand the phenomenon of quark-hadron duality in electroweak interactions.

In recent years, some work on the kaon and hyperon productions with and without accompanying pions have been done, but no work has been done on the η\eta production except a very early work by Dombey [2] and a recent work by Nakamura et al. [3]. In view of the recent developments in the detector technology, it is possible to experimentally look for weak production of η\eta mesons induced by neutrinos and antineutrinos in present experiments at MicroBooNE, T2K, NOvA, MINERvA, and future experiments at T2-HyperK and DUNE. For example, the MicroBooNE collaboration is currently performing the analysis to study the η\eta production cross section [4]. In addition to the additional weak processes of the η\eta production, which should be taken into account in modelling the neutrino cross sections being used in various neutrino event generators, the weak production of η\eta is an important source probe to search for the strangeness content of the nucleons [5]. Moreover, the weak production of η\eta also plays an important role in the background studies in search of the proton decays through the p⟶ηe+p \longrightarrow\eta e^{+} modes. In view of the topical importance of the weak production of η\eta, we have studied in this work the CC production of η\eta from the free nucleons induced by the (anti)neutrinos through the reactions

νμ+n⟶μ−+p+η(1)\nu_{\mu}+n \longrightarrow\mu^{-}+p+\eta \tag*{(1)}
νˉμ+p⟶μ++n+η(2)\bar{\nu}_{\mu}+p \longrightarrow\mu^{+}+n+\eta \tag*{(2)}

in a model using the effective Lagrangian approach. Separate effective Lagrangians are used to evaluate the contributions of the nonresonant Born terms and the resonant terms. An effective Lagrangian based on SU(3) chiral symmetry is used for the nonresonant Born terms. The basic parameters of the model are fmf_{m}, the meson decay constants, Cabibbo angle, the proton and neutron magnetic moments and the axial vector coupling constants for the baryon octet, DD and FF, that are obtained from the analysis of the semileptonic decays of neutron and hyperons. We consider low lying I=12I=\frac{1}{2} resonances such as S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650) and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710). The vector form factors of the N−S11N-S_{11} and N−P11N-P_{11} transitions have been obtained from the helicity amplitudes extracted in the analysis of pion photo- and electro- production data using the MAID analysis in the unitary isobar model [6]. The present model has been earlier used to study the associated particle production using real photons off the proton target [7], weak interaction induced single pion production [8], kaon production [9–11], two pion production [12], etc. For a detailed description, please see Ref. [13].

Firstly, we have applied this model to obtain the results of the cross sections for photo- and electro- induced eta production off the nucleon target. The production of η\eta particle in electromagnetic reactions induced by photons and electrons is well studied theoretically as well as experimentally [14–39] and the contribution of the vector contribution to these processes is fairly known. With the availability of high-duty cycle electron accelerators, such as the MIT-Bates, ELSA at Bonn, MAMI at Mainz, NIKHEF at Watergraafsmeer, and CEBAF at JLab, efforts are being made both theoretically as well as experimentally to study the eta production induced by virtual as well as real photons from the nucleons and nuclei [31–34]. Recently, results have been reported from MAMI-C [27] using Crystal Ball and TAPS multi photon spectrometer in the energy range of 707 MeV to 1.4 GeV for the differential as well as the total scattering cross sections. We find that the theoretical results obtained in this explain well the photoproduction total cross section data from CLAS 2006 for γ+p→Λ+K+\gamma+p\rightarrow\Lambda+K^{+}, and the photoproduction data from MAMI Crystal Ball [26, 27] for γ+p→p+η\gamma+p\rightarrow p+\eta and γ+n→n+η\gamma+n\rightarrow n+\eta, and the electroproduction data from CLAS 2001 for e+p→e+p+ηe+p\rightarrow e+p+\eta. These results have been used to fix the electromagnetic vector couplings and the Q2Q^{2} dependence of the vector N−RN-R transition form factors. These informations are then used to obtain the isovector vector form factors for N−RN-R transitions. The axial vector coupling is fixed using the experimental S11→NπS_{11}\rightarrow N\pi and P11→NπP_{11}\rightarrow N\pi partial decay widths. Assuming the pion-pole dominance together with the PCAC hypothesis, the pseudoscalar form factor is obtained in terms of the axial vector form factor. For the Q2Q^{2} dependence of the axial vector form factor, we have used a dipole form with the value of axial dipole mass taken to be MA=1M_{A}=1 GeV.

The plan of the paper is following. In sections-II A and II B, we present the formalism for photon and electron induced eta production, respectively. In section-II C, the formalism for the charged current νl(νˉl)\nu_{l}(\bar{\nu}_{l}) induced eta production has been presented. The results and discussions are presented in section-III and section-IV concludes our findings.

Formalism

The eta meson is an isoscalar pseudoscalar particle (I=0I=0, JP=0−J^{P}=0^{-}), a member of the ground state SU(3) meson nonet with mass 547.86 MeV, a life time of about 5×10−195\times10^{-19} sec and decays mainly to 3π3\pi (∼56%\sim56\%), 2γ2\gamma (∼39%\sim39\%), and π+π−γ\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\gamma (∼4.5%\sim4.5\%) modes. The η\eta mesons are produced at Eνl(νˉl)≥0.71E_{\nu_{l}(\bar{\nu}_{l})}\geq0.71 (0.88) GeV for νe\nu_{e} (νμ\nu_{\mu}) induced CC reactions. In the following sections, we have first applied our model to study the electromagnetic production of eta mesons induced by real and virtual photons, followed by the weak production of eta induced by (anti)neutrinos from the free nucleon target.

η\eta production induced by photons

The differential cross section for the photoproduction of η\eta mesons off the free nucleon, i.e.,

γ(q)+N(p)⟶N(p′)+η(pη),(3)\gamma(q)+N(p)\longrightarrow N(p')+\eta(p_\eta), \tag*{(3)}

is written as

dσ=14(q⋅p)(2π)4δ4(q+p−pη−p′)d3p⃗η(2π)3(2Eη)d3p⃗′(2π)3(2E′)∑r∑spins∣Mr∣2,(4)d\sigma=\frac{1}{4(q\cdot p)}(2\pi)^4\delta^4(q+p-p_\eta-p')\frac{d^3\vec{p}_\eta}{(2\pi)^3(2E_\eta)}\frac{d^3\vec{p}'}{(2\pi)^3(2E')}\sum_r\sum_{\mathrm{spins}}|\mathcal{M}^r|^2, \tag*{(4)}

where N=pN=p or nn, the quantities in the parentheses of Eq. (3) represent the four momenta of the corresponding particles, EηE_\eta and E′E', respectively, are the energies of the outgoing eta and nucleon. ∑r∑spins∣Mr∣2\sum_r\sum_{\mathrm{spins}}|\mathcal{M}^r|^2 is the square of the transition matrix element Mr\mathcal{M}^r, for the photon polarization state rr, averaged and summed over the initial and final spin states.

Using Eq. (4), the differential cross section dσdΩ\frac{d\sigma}{d\Omega} in the CM frame (Figure 1) is written as

Diagrammatic representation of the process $\gamma(q)+N(p)\longrightarrow\eta(p_\eta)+N(p')$ in the center of mass frame

Figure 1. Diagrammatic representation of the process γ(q)+N(p)⟶η(pη)+N(p′)\gamma(q)+N(p)\longrightarrow\eta(p_\eta)+N(p') in the center of mass (CM) frame. The quantities in the parentheses represent the four momenta of the corresponding particles. θCM\theta^{CM} is the angle between photon and eta in the CM frame.

dσdΩ∣CM=164π2s∣p⃗′∣∣p⃗∣∑r∑spin∣Mr∣2,(5)\left.\frac{d\sigma}{d\Omega}\right|_{CM}=\frac{1}{64\pi^2s}\frac{|\vec{p}'|}{|\vec{p}|}\sum_r\sum_{\mathrm{spin}}|\mathcal{M}^r|^2, \tag*{(5)}

where the CM energy ss is obtained as

s=W2=(q+p)2=M2+2MEγ,(6)s=W^2=(q+p)^2=M^2+2ME_\gamma, \tag*{(6)}

with EγE_\gamma being the energy of the incoming photon in the laboratory frame.

In the above expression, the transition matrix element Mr\mathcal{M}^r for the reaction (3) is written in terms of the real photon polarization vector ϵμr\epsilon_\mu^r, i.e.

Mr=eϵμr(q)⟨N(p′)η(pη)∣Jμ∣N(p)⟩,(7)\mathcal{M}^r=e\epsilon_\mu^r(q)\langle N(p')\eta(p_\eta)|J^\mu|N(p)\rangle, \tag*{(7)}

where e=4παe=\sqrt{4\pi\alpha} with α\alpha being the fine-structure constant, and ϵμr(q)\epsilon_\mu^r(q) satisfy the condition

∑r=±1ϵμ∗(r)ϵν(r)⟶−gμν.(8)\sum_{r=\pm1}\epsilon_\mu^{*(r)}\epsilon_\nu^{(r)}\longrightarrow-g_{\mu\nu}. \tag*{(8)}

The hadronic tensor Jμν\mathcal{J}^{\mu\nu} is defined in terms of the hadronic current JμJ^\mu as

\mathcal{J}^{\mu\nu}=\sum_r\sum_{\mathrm{spins}}J^{\mu\dagger}J^\nu=\operatorname{Tr}\left[(\slashed{p}+M)\widetilde{J}^{\mu}(\slashed{p}'+M')J^\nu\right],\qquad\widetilde{J}^{\mu}=\gamma_0(J^\mu)^\dagger\gamma_0, \tag*{(9)}

where MM and M′M' are the masses of the incoming and outgoing nucleons, respectively. The hadronic matrix element of the electromagnetic current JμJ^\mu receives contributions from the nonresonant background terms and the terms corresponding to the resonance excitations, shown in Figure 2 and discussed later in this section.

Feynman diagrams corresponding to the nonresonant Born terms and resonance excitations

Figure 2. Feynman diagrams corresponding to the nonresonant Born terms (left panel) and resonance excitations (right panel) for the process γ(q)+N(p)→η(pη)+N′(p′)\gamma(q) + N(p) \to\eta(p_\eta) + N'(p'). Diagrams shown in the top panel are the nucleon pole diagrams, while the one shown in the bottom panel corresponds to the cross nucleon pole diagrams. In the case of electromagnetic interactions, W=γ,γ∗W=\gamma,\gamma^* and N′=N=p,nN'=N=p,n, while in the case of CC induced weak interactions, W=W±W=W^\pm and N′N' and NN corresponds to the different nucleons depending upon the charge conservation. The quantities in the parentheses represent the four momenta of the corresponding particles.

Using Eqs. (8) and (9), the transition matrix element squared is obtained as

∑r∑spin∣Mr∣2=−e24gμνJμν,(10)\sum_r \sum_{\mathrm{spin}} \left|\mathcal{M}^r\right|^2 = -\frac{e^2}{4}g_{\mu\nu}\mathcal{J}^{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(10)}

used for the cross sections defined in Eq. (5). The hadronic currents for the various NR terms shown in Figure 2 are obtained using the nonlinear sigma model which in the following has been discussed very briefly.

Nonlinear sigma model

The lowest-order SU(3)SU(3) chiral Lagrangian in the nonlinear sigma model describing the pseudoscalar mesons in the presence of an external current, is given by [40, 41]:

LM=fm24Tr⁡[DμU(DμU)†].(11)\mathcal{L}_M = \frac{f_m^2}{4}\operatorname{Tr}\left[D_\mu U(D^\mu U)^\dagger\right]. \tag*{(11)}

The covariant derivatives DμUD^\mu U and DμU†D^\mu U^\dagger appearing in Eq. (11) are expressed in terms of the partial derivatives as

DμU≡∂μU−irμU+iUlμ,DμU†≡∂μU†+iU†rμ−ilμU†,(12)D^\mu U \equiv\partial^\mu U - ir^\mu U + iUl^\mu,\qquad D^\mu U^\dagger\equiv\partial^\mu U^\dagger+ iU^\dagger r^\mu- il^\mu U^\dagger, \tag*{(12)}

where UU is the SU(3)SU(3) unitary matrix given as

U(x)=exp⁡(iΦ(x)fm),(13)U(x) = \exp\left(i\frac{\Phi(x)}{f_m}\right), \tag*{(13)}

where fmf_m is the meson decay constant, Φ(x)\Phi(x) corresponds to the 3×33 \times3 pseudoscalar meson matrix. rμr_\mu and lμl_\mu, respectively, represent the right and left handed currents, defined in terms of the vector (vμv_\mu) and axial-vector (aμa_\mu) fields as

lμ=12(vμ−aμ),rμ=12(vμ+aμ).(14)l_\mu= \frac{1}{2}(v_\mu-a_\mu),\qquad r_\mu= \frac{1}{2}(v_\mu+a_\mu). \tag*{(14)}

The vector and axial-vector fields are different for the interaction of the different gauge boson fields with the meson fields.

In the case of electromagnetic gauge fields, the left and right handed currents are identical and are expressed as

lμ=rμ=−eQ^Aμ,(15)l_\mu= r_\mu= -e\hat{Q}A_\mu, \tag*{(15)}

where ee is the strength of the electromagnetic interaction, AμA_\mu represents the photon field and Q^=(2/3000−1/3000−1/3)\hat{Q} = \begin{pmatrix} 2/3 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & -1/3 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & -1/3 \end{pmatrix} represents the charge of the uu, dd, and ss quarks. In the case of weak CC induced processes, the left and right handed currents are expressed as

lμ=−g2(Wμ+T++Wμ−T−),rμ=0,(16)l_\mu= -\frac{g}{2}(W_\mu^+T_+ + W_\mu^-T_-), \qquad r_\mu= 0, \tag*{(16)}

where g=esin⁡θWg = \frac{e}{\sin\theta_W}, θW\theta_W is the Weinberg angle, Wμ±W_\mu^\pm represents the W-boson field and T±T_\pm is defined as

T+=(0VudVus000000),andT−=(000Vud00Vus00),(17)T_+ = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & V_{ud} & V_{us} \\ 0 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix}, \qquad\text{and} \qquad T_- = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 0 & 0 \\ V_{ud} & 0 & 0 \\ V_{us} & 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(17)}

with Vud=cos⁡θCV_{ud} = \cos\theta_C and Vus=sin⁡θCV_{us} = \sin\theta_C being the elements of the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix and θC\theta_C being the Cabibbo angle.

The lowest-order chiral Lagrangian for the baryon octet in the presence of an external current, may be written in terms of the SU(3)SU(3) matrix of the baryons BB as [40, 41],

\mathcal{L}_{MB} = \operatorname{Tr}\left[\bar{B}(i\slashed{D}-M)B\right] - \frac{D}{2}\operatorname{Tr}\left(\bar{B}\gamma^\mu\gamma_5\{u_\mu,B\}\right) - \frac{F}{2}\operatorname{Tr}\left(\bar{B}\gamma^\mu\gamma_5[u_\mu,B]\right), \tag*{(18)}

where MM denotes the mass of the baryon octet, D=0.804D = 0.804 and F=0.463F = 0.463 are the symmetric and antisymmetric axial-vector coupling constants for the baryon octet, and the Lorentz vector uμu^\mu is given by [41]:

uμ=i[u†(∂μ−irμ)u−u(∂μ−ilμ)u†].(19)u^\mu= i\left[u^\dagger(\partial^\mu- ir^\mu)u - u(\partial^\mu- il^\mu)u^\dagger\right]. \tag*{(19)}

In the case of meson-baryon interactions, the unitary matrix for the pseudoscalar field is expressed as

u=U≡exp⁡(iΦ(x)2fm),(20)u = \sqrt{U} \equiv\exp\left(i\frac{\Phi(x)}{2f_m}\right), \tag*{(20)}

and the covariant derivative DμD_\mu on the baryon fields BB is given by

DμB=∂μB+[Γμ,B],withΓμ=12[u†(∂μ−irμ)u+u(∂μ−ilμ)u†],(21)D_\mu B = \partial_\mu B + [\Gamma_\mu,B], \qquad\text{with} \qquad\Gamma^\mu= \frac{1}{2}\left[u^\dagger(\partial^\mu- ir^\mu)u + u(\partial^\mu- il^\mu)u^\dagger\right], \tag*{(21)}

which is known as the chiral connection.

Currents for the nonresonant Born terms and resonance excitations

Expanding the Lagrangians given in Eqs. (11) and (18) for the lowest lying baryons and mesons, one obtains the Lagrangians for any desired vertex involving the interactions of mesons and baryons among themselves or with the external fields. Using these Lagrangians, the expressions of the hadronic currents for ss-, uu- channels of the η\eta photoproduction processes, corresponding to the Feynman diagrams shown in Figure 2 (left panel), are obtained as [13]:

J^\mu\big|_{sN} = -A_s F_s(s)\bar{u}(p')\gamma_5\frac{\slashed{p}+\slashed{q}+M}{s-M^2}\left(\gamma^\mu e_N+i\frac{\kappa_N}{2M}\sigma^{\mu\nu}q_\nu\right)u(p), \tag*{(22)}
J^\mu\big|_{uN} = -A_u F_u(u)\bar{u}(p')\left(\gamma^\mu e_N+i\frac{\kappa_N}{2M}\sigma^{\mu\nu}q_\nu\right)\frac{\slashed{p}'-\slashed{q}+M}{u-M^2}\gamma_5\gamma_5u(p), \tag*{(23)}

where NN stands for a proton or a neutron in the initial and final states, ss is defined in Eq. (6) and u=(p′−q)2u = (p'-q)^2, AiA_i's; i=s,ui = s,u are the coupling strengths of ss, and uu channels, respectively, and are obtained as [13]

As=Au=(D−3F23fη).(24)A_s = A_u = \left(\frac{D-3F}{2\sqrt{3}f_\eta}\right). \tag*{(24)}

DD and FF are the axial-vector couplings of the baryon octet and fη=105f_{\eta}=105 MeV [42] is the η\eta decay constant. The value of κ\kappa for proton, and neutron are κp=1.7928\kappa_{p}=1.7928, and κn=−1.913\kappa_{n}=-1.913 in units of μN\mu_{N} [43].

In order to take into account the hadronic structure of the nucleons, the form factors Fs(s)F_{s}(s), and Fu(u)F_{u}(u), are introduced at the strong vertex. Various parameterizations of these form factors are available in the literature [44]. We use the most general form of the hadronic form factor which is taken to be of the dipole form [7]:

Fx(x)=ΛB4ΛB4+(x−Mx2)2,x=s,u(25)F_{x}(x)=\frac{\Lambda_{B}^{4}}{\Lambda_{B}^{4}+\left(x-M_{x}^{2}\right)^{2}}, \qquad x=s,u \tag*{(25)}

where ΛB\Lambda_{B} is the cut-off parameter taken to be the same for the ss- and uu-channel nonresonant Born terms. xx represents the Mandelstam variables ss, uu, and Mx=MM_{x}=M corresponds to the mass of the exchanged nucleons in the ss and uu channels. The value of ΛB\Lambda_{B} is fitted to the experimental data for both the proton and neutron targets simultaneously and the best fitted value is ΛB=0.78\Lambda_{B}=0.78 GeV for ss- and uu-channel diagrams. One of the most important property of the electromagnetic current is the gauge invariance which ensures the current conservation and is implemented in the case of η\eta production.

In the present work, we have taken into account only the low lying resonances, which have mass MR<1.8M_{R}<1.8 GeV and have a significant branching ratio to the NηN\eta mode reported in PDG [43]. Specifically, we have considered three spin 12\frac{1}{2} resonances viz. S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710). The general properties of these resonances like mass, decay width, spin, etc. are given in Table I, where we see that S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) resonance dominates the coupling to the NηN\eta channel.

Resonance → Parameters ↓S11(1535)S_{11}(1535)S11(1650)S_{11}(1650)P11(1710)P_{11}(1710)
MRM_R (GeV)1.510±0.011.510 \pm0.011.655±0.0151.655 \pm0.0151.700±0.021.700 \pm0.02
ΓR\Gamma_R (GeV)0.130±0.020.130 \pm0.020.135±0.0350.135 \pm0.0350.120±0.040.120 \pm0.04
I(JP)I(J^P)12(12−)\frac{1}{2}(\frac{1}{2}^{-})12(12−)\frac{1}{2}(\frac{1}{2}^{-})12(12+)\frac{1}{2}(\frac{1}{2}^{+})
Branching ratio (in %) NπN\pi32−5232-52 (43)50−7050-70 (60)5−205-20 (16)
Branching ratio (in %) NηN\eta30−5530-55 (40)15−3515-35 (25)10−5010-50 (20)
Branching ratio (in %) KΛK\Lambda—5−155-15 (10)5−255-25 (15)
Branching ratio (in %) NππN\pi\pi4−114-11 (17)20−5820-58 (5)14−4814-48 (49)
∣gRNπ∣\lvert g_{RN\pi}\rvert0.10190.09150.0418
∣gRNη∣\lvert g_{RN\eta}\rvert0.36960.14810.1567

Table I. Properties of the spin 12\frac{1}{2} resonances available in the PDG [43], with Breit-Wigner mass MRM_R, the total decay width ΓR\Gamma_R, isospin II, spin JJ, parity PP, the branching ratio full range available from PDG (used in the present calculations) into different meson-baryon like NπN\pi, NηN\eta, KΛK\Lambda, and NππN\pi\pi, and the strong coupling constant gRNπg_{RN\pi} and gRNηg_{RN\eta}.

The hadronic vector transition current for the spin 12\frac{1}{2} resonance state is given by [45]

j12μ=uˉ(p′)Γ12μu(p),(26)j_{\frac{1}{2}}^{\mu}=\bar{u}(p')\Gamma_{\frac{1}{2}}^{\mu}u(p), \tag*{(26)}

where u(p)u(p) and uˉ(p′)\bar{u}(p') are, respectively, the Dirac spinor and the adjoint Dirac spinor for spin 12\frac{1}{2} particles and Γ12μ\Gamma_{\frac{1}{2}}^{\mu} is the vertex function. For a positive parity state, Γ12+μ\Gamma_{\frac{1}{2}+}^{\mu} is given by

Γ12+μ=V12μ,(27)\Gamma_{\frac{1}{2}+}^{\mu}=V_{\frac{1}{2}}^{\mu}, \tag*{(27)}

and for a negative parity resonance, Γ12−μ\Gamma_{\frac{1}{2}-}^{\mu} is given by

Γ12−μ=V12μγ5,(28)\Gamma_{\frac{1}{2}-}^{\mu}=V_{\frac{1}{2}}^{\mu}\gamma_{5}, \tag*{(28)}

where V12μV_{\frac{1}{2}}^{\mu} represents the vector current parameterized in terms of F2R+,R0F_{2}^{R^{+},R^{0}}, as

V12μ=[F2R+,R02Miσμαqα].(29)V_{\frac{1}{2}}^{\mu}=\left[\frac{F_{2}^{R^{+},R^{0}}}{2M}i\sigma^{\mu\alpha}q_{\alpha}\right]. \tag*{(29)}

The coupling F2R+,R0F_{2}^{R^{+},R^{0}} is derived from the helicity amplitudes extracted from the real photon scattering experiments. The explicit relation between the coupling F2R+,R0F_{2}^{R^{+},R^{0}} and the helicity amplitude A12pA_{\frac{1}{2}}^{p} is given by [7]:

A12p,n=2παM(MR∓M)2MR2−M2[MR±M2MF2R+,R0],(30)A_{\frac{1}{2}}^{p,n}=\sqrt{\frac{2\pi\alpha}{M}\frac{\left(M_{R}\mp M\right)^{2}}{M_{R}^{2}-M^{2}}}\left[\frac{M_{R}\pm M}{2M}F_{2}^{R^{+},R^{0}}\right], \tag*{(30)}

where the upper (lower) sign stands for the positive (negative) parity resonance. R+R^{+} and R0R^{0} correspond, respectively, to the charged and neutral states of the isospin 12\frac{1}{2} resonances. MRM_{R} is the mass of corresponding resonance. The value of the helicity amplitude A12p,nA_{\frac{1}{2}}^{p,n} for the S11(1650)S_{11}(1650) resonance is taken from MAID [46], while for the other spin 12\frac{1}{2} nucleon resonances, these values are taken from PDG [43] and are quoted in Table II.

The most general form of the hadronic currents for the ss- and uu- channel processes where a resonance state R12R_{\frac{1}{2}} is produced and decays to a η\eta and a nucleon in the final state, are written as

jsμ=gRNηfηuˉ(p′)pηΓs(p̸+q̸+MRs−MR2+iMRΓR)Γ12±μu(p),juμ=gRNηfηuˉ(p′)Γ12±μ(̸p′−q̸+MRu−MR2+iMRΓR)pηΓuu(p).(31)\begin{aligned} j_{s}^{\mu}&=\frac{g_{RN\eta}}{f_{\eta}}\bar{u}(p')p_{\eta}\Gamma_{s}\left(\frac{\not{p}+\not{q}+M_{R}}{s-M_{R}^{2}+iM_{R}\Gamma_{R}}\right)\Gamma_{\frac{1}{2}\pm}^{\mu}u(p),\\ j_{u}^{\mu}&=\frac{g_{RN\eta}}{f_{\eta}}\bar{u}(p')\Gamma_{\frac{1}{2}\pm}^{\mu}\left(\frac{\not{p}'-\not{q}+M_{R}}{u-M_{R}^{2}+iM_{R}\Gamma_{R}}\right)p_{\eta}\Gamma_{u}u(p). \tag*{(31)} \end{aligned}

where ΓR\Gamma_R is the decay width of the resonance, Γs=1(γ5)\Gamma_s = 1(\gamma_5) stands for the positive (negative) parity resonances. Γ12+\Gamma_{\frac{1}{2}^{+}} and Γ12−\Gamma_{\frac{1}{2}^{-}} are, respectively, the vertex functions for the positive and negative parity resonances, defined in Eqs. (63) and (64), respectively. gRNηg_{RN\eta} is the coupling strength for the process R→NηR \to N\eta, given in Table I.

We determine the RNηRN\eta coupling using the value of branching ratio and decay width of these resonances from PDG [43] and use the expression for the decay rate which is obtained by writing the most general form of RNηRN\eta Lagrangian [47]:

LRNη=gRNηfηΨˉRΓsμ∂μηiτiΨ,(32)\mathcal{L}_{RN\eta} = \frac{g_{RN\eta}}{f_\eta}\bar{\Psi}_R\Gamma_s^\mu\partial_\mu\eta^i\tau_i\Psi, \tag*{(32)}

where gRNηg_{RN\eta} is the RNηRN\eta coupling strength. Ψ\Psi is the nucleon field and ΨR\Psi_R is the resonance field. η\eta is the eta field and τ\tau is the isospin factor for the isospin 12\frac{1}{2} states. The interaction vertex Γsμ=γμγ5\Gamma_s^\mu= \gamma^\mu\gamma_5 (γμ\gamma^\mu) stands for positive (negative) parity resonance states.

Using the above Lagrangian, one obtains the expression for the decay width in the resonance rest frame as [13]:

ΓR→Nη=C4π(gRNηfη)2(MR±M)2EN∓MMR∣p⃗η cm∣,(33)\Gamma_{R\to N\eta} = \frac{C}{4\pi}\left(\frac{g_{RN\eta}}{f_\eta}\right)^2(M_R \pm M)^2\frac{E_N \mp M}{M_R}\lvert\vec{p}_{\eta}^{\,cm}\rvert, \tag*{(33)}

where the upper (lower) sign represents the positive (negative) parity resonance. The parameter CC depends upon the charged state of RR, NηN\eta and is obtained from the isospin analysis and found out to be 1. ∣p⃗η cm∣\lvert\vec{p}_{\eta}^{\,cm}\rvert is the outgoing eta momentum measured from the resonance rest frame and is given by,

∣p⃗η cm∣=(W2−Mη2−M2)2−4Mη2M22MR,(34)\lvert\vec{p}_{\eta}^{\,cm}\rvert= \frac{\sqrt{(W^2-M_\eta^2-M^2)^2-4M_\eta^2M^2}}{2M_R}, \tag*{(34)}

and ENE_N, the outgoing nucleon energy is

EN=W2+M2−Mη22MR,(35)E_N = \frac{W^2+M^2-M_\eta^2}{2M_R}, \tag*{(35)}

where WW is the total center of mass energy carried by the resonance.

In analogy with the NR terms, we have considered the following form factors at the strong vertex, in order to take into account the hadronic structure:

Fx∗(x)=ΛR4ΛR4+(x−Mx2)2,(36)F_x^*(x) = \frac{\Lambda_R^4}{\Lambda_R^4+(x-M_x^2)^2}, \tag*{(36)}

where ΛR\Lambda_R is the cut-off parameter whose value is fitted to the experimental data, xx represents the Mandelstam variables ss, uu, and Mx=MRM_x=M_R corresponding to the mass of the nucleon resonances exchanged in the ss, and uu channels. In general, ΛR\Lambda_R would be different from ΛB\Lambda_B, however, in the case of η\eta production by photons, it happens that the same value of ΛR\Lambda_R as that of ΛB\Lambda_B i.e. ΛR=ΛB=0.78\Lambda_R = \Lambda_B = 0.78 GeV gives the best fit to the experimental data. The same values of ΛR\Lambda_R and ΛB\Lambda_B help us to minimize the number of free parameters used to fit the experimental data.

In Figure 3, we have presented the results for the total scattering cross section σ\sigma as a function of WW for γ+p⟶p+η\gamma+ p \longrightarrow p + \eta and γ+n⟶n+η\gamma+ n \longrightarrow n + \eta processes in the region of WW from η\eta production threshold to KΛK\Lambda production threshold. We have compared our theoretical results with the experimental data obtained by McNicoll et al. [27] for the MAMI crystal ball collaboration on the proton target and the quasifree neutron data from Werthmuller et al. [26] for the MAMI A2 collaboration. It may be observed from the figure that in the case of η\eta production from the proton and neutron targets, our results, with a very few free parameters, are in a very good agreement with the available experimental data.

Figure 3. Total cross section σ\sigma vs. WW for γp⟶ηp\gamma p \longrightarrow\eta p (solid line) and γn⟶ηn\gamma n \longrightarrow\eta n (dashed line) processes. The experimental points for the proton target (solid circle) are obtained from MAMI crystal ball collaboration [27], and for the neutron target (solid diamond) we have used the quasifree neutron data from MAMI A2 collaboration [26].

Electroproduction of eta meson

The electron induced η\eta production off the nucleon target is given by the reaction

e−(k)+N(p)⟶e−(k′)+N(p′)+η(pη),(37)e^{-}(k) + N(p) \longrightarrow e^{-}(k') + N(p') + \eta(p_{\eta}), \tag*{(37)}

where the four-momentum for each particle is indicated in the parentheses. The four-momentum of the virtual photon exchanged in electroproduction is given by q=k−k′q = k - k'.

The differential cross section for the electroproduction process can be written as

dσ=14MEe(2π)5dk⃗′(2El)dp⃗′(2EN)dp⃗η(2Eη)δ4(k+p−k′−p′−pη)∑∑∣M∣2,(38)d\sigma= \frac{1}{4 M E_e (2\pi)^5} \frac{d\vec{k}'}{(2E_l)} \frac{d\vec{p}'}{(2E_N)} \frac{d\vec{p}_{\eta}}{(2E_{\eta})} \delta^4(k+p-k'-p'-p_{\eta}) \sum\sum|\mathcal{M}|^2, \tag*{(38)}

where k(k′)k(k') is the four momentum of the incoming (outgoing) electron with energy Ee(El)E_e(E_l); pp is the four momentum of the incoming nucleon which is at rest, ENE_N and p′p' are respectively the energy and four momentum of the outgoing nucleon, and the four momentum of η\eta is pηp_{\eta} with energy EηE_{\eta}, and MM is the nucleon mass. The different kinematical variables used in the numerical calculations of the scattering cross section are depicted in Figure 4, where the scattering plane is in the laboratory frame while the reaction plane is in the center of mass (CM) frame. ∑∑∣M∣2\sum\sum|\mathcal{M}|^2 is the square of the transition amplitude averaged (summed) over the spins of the initial (final) states and the transition matrix element is written in terms of the leptonic and the hadronic currents as

Electron and neutrino scattering and reaction planes

Figure 4. Electron (electromagnetic)/(anti)neutrino (weak) scattering and reaction planes, depicting the hadronic plane in CM frame and scattering plane in the laboratory frame. The kinematical variables used in the calculation of the scattering cross sections are defined in the figure.

M=e2q2lμjμ,(39)\mathcal{M} = \frac{e^2}{q^2} l_{\mu}j^{\mu}, \tag*{(39)}

where lμl_{\mu} and jμj^{\mu}, respectively, are the leptonic and hadronic currents. The leptonic current is given as

lμ=uˉ(k′)γμu(k),(40)l_{\mu} = \bar{u}(k')\gamma_{\mu}u(k), \tag*{(40)}

and jμj^{\mu} is the sum of the hadronic currents corresponding to the Born terms and resonance excitations, which will be discussed later in Section II B 1.

Integrating over the three momentum of the outgoing nucleon, the expression for the differential scattering cross section given in Eq. (38) in the hadronic CM frame becomes

d5σdEl dΩl dΩq pη=132(2π)5∣k⃗′∣∣p⃗η∣EeMW∑∑∣M∣2.(41)\frac{d^5\sigma}{dE_l\,d\Omega_l\,d\Omega_q\,p_{\eta}} = \frac{1}{32(2\pi)^5}\frac{|\vec{k}'||\vec{p}_{\eta}|}{E_e M W}\sum\sum|\mathcal{M}|^2. \tag*{(41)}

The five-fold differential cross section for the electroproduction can also be expressed as [48, 49, 50]:

dσdΩl dEl dΩq pη=ΓdσvdΩq pη,(42)\frac{d\sigma}{d\Omega_l\,dE_l\,d\Omega_q\,p_{\eta}} = \Gamma\frac{d\sigma_v}{d\Omega_q\,p_{\eta}}, \tag*{(42)}

with the flux of the virtual photon field given by

Γ=α2π2ElEeKQ211−ϵ.(43)\Gamma= \frac{\alpha}{2\pi^2}\frac{E_l}{E_e}\frac{K}{Q^2}\frac{1}{1-\epsilon}. \tag*{(43)}

In the above equation, K=(W2−M2)/2MK = (W^2-M^2)/2M denotes the “photon equivalent energy”, the laboratory energy necessary for a real photon to excite a hadronic system with CM energy WW. The transverse polarization parameter of the virtual photon

ϵ=(1+2∣q⃗∣2Q2tan⁡2θl2)−1,(44)\epsilon= \left(1+2\frac{|\vec{q}|^2}{Q^2}\tan^2\frac{\theta_l}{2}\right)^{-1}, \tag*{(44)}

where Q2=−q2=−(k−k′)2Q^2=-q^2=-(k-k')^2.

It is useful to express the angular distribution of the eta mesons in the CM frame of the final hadronic states, particularly for the use of multipole decompositions. Therefore, the virtual photon cross section dσv/dΩd\sigma_v/d\Omega should be evaluated in the CM frame, while the five-fold differential cross section in Eq. (42) is interpreted with the flux factor in the lab frame. By choosing the energies of the initial and final electrons and the scattering angle θl\theta_l (see Figure 4), we can fix the momentum transfer Q2Q^2 and the polarization parameter ϵ\epsilon of the virtual photon.

Currents for the nonresonant Born terms and resonance excitations

Currents corresponding to the nucleon Born terms for the electroproduction of eta mesons, depicted in Figure 2, are obtained using the nonlinear sigma model discussed in Section II A 1 and are written as:

J^\mu_{N(s)} = \frac{D-3F}{2\sqrt{3}f_\eta}\bar{u}_N(p')\slashed{p}_\eta\gamma_5\frac{\slashed{p}+\slashed{q}+M}{(p+q)^2-M^2}\mathcal{O}^\mu_Nu_N(p)
J^\mu_{N(u)} = \frac{D-3F}{2\sqrt{3}f_\eta}\bar{u}_N(p')\mathcal{O}^\mu_N\frac{\slashed{p}-\slashed{p}_\eta+M}{(p-p_\eta)^2-M^2}\slashed{p}_\eta\gamma_5u_N(p), \tag*{(45)}

where the γNN\gamma NN vertex operator ONμ\mathcal{O}^\mu_N is expressed in terms of the Q2Q^2 dependent nucleon form factors as,

ONμ=F1N(Q2)γμ+F2N(Q2)iσμνqν2M.(46)\mathcal{O}^\mu_N = F^N_1(Q^2)\gamma^\mu+ F^N_2(Q^2)i\sigma^{\mu\nu}\frac{q_\nu}{2M}. \tag*{(46)}

The Dirac and Pauli form factors of the nucleon viz. F1p,n(Q2)F^{p,n}_1(Q^2) and F2p,n(Q2)F^{p,n}_2(Q^2), respectively, may be expressed in terms of the Sach’s electric (GEp,n(Q2)G^{p,n}_E(Q^2)) and magnetic (GMp,n(Q2)G^{p,n}_M(Q^2)) form factors of the nucleons as,

F1p,n(Q2)=(1+Q24M2)−1[GEp,n(Q2)+Q24M2GMp,n(Q2)]F^{p,n}_1(Q^2) = \left(1+\frac{Q^2}{4M^2}\right)^{-1}\left[G^{p,n}_E(Q^2)+\frac{Q^2}{4M^2}G^{p,n}_M(Q^2)\right]
F2p,n(Q2)=(1+Q24M2)−1[GMp,n(Q2)−GEp,n(Q2)].(47)F^{p,n}_2(Q^2) = \left(1+\frac{Q^2}{4M^2}\right)^{-1}\left[G^{p,n}_M(Q^2)-G^{p,n}_E(Q^2)\right]. \tag*{(47)}

There are various parameterization for GE,Mp,n(Q2)G^{p,n}_{E,M}(Q^2) those are available in the literature. For the present work we have taken the parameterization of these form factors from Bradford et al. [51] also known as BBBA05 parameterization.

Now we discuss the hadronic current corresponding to the resonance excitations and their subsequent decay to NηN\eta channel. The general expression of the hadronic current for the resonance excitation in the s- and u- channels, corresponding to the Feynman diagrams shown in Figure 2 (right panel), are written, as,

j^\mu_s = \frac{g_{RN\eta}}{f_\eta}\bar{u}(p')\slashed{p}_\eta\Gamma_s\left(\frac{\slashed{p}+\slashed{q}+M_R}{s-M_R^2+iM_R\Gamma_R}\right)\Gamma^\mu_{\frac12\pm}u(p),
j^\mu_u = \frac{g_{RN\eta}}{f_\eta}\bar{u}(p')\Gamma^\mu_{\frac12\pm}\left(\frac{\slashed{p}'-\slashed{q}+M_R}{u-M_R^2+iM_R\Gamma_R}\right)\slashed{p}_\eta\Gamma_{su}(p), \tag*{(48)}

where gRNηg_{RN\eta} is the strong coupling constant, which we have fixed using the η\eta production data. The vertex function Γ12±μ\Gamma^\mu_{\frac12\pm} for the positive and negative parity resonances is given in Eqs. (63) and (64), respectively, where the vector current V12μV^\mu_{\frac12} in the case of electroproduction processes is expressed in terms of the Q2Q^2 dependent form factors F1,2R+,R0(Q2)F^{R^+,R^0}_{1,2}(Q^2) as

V^\mu_{\frac12} = \frac{F^{R}_{1}(Q^2)}{(2M)^2}(q\slashed{q}+Q^2\gamma^\mu)+\frac{F^{R}_{2}(Q^2)}{2M}i\sigma^{\mu\nu}q_\nu,\qquad R=R^+,R^0. \tag*{(49)}

The electromagnetic transition form factors for the charged (F1,2R+(Q2)F^{R^+}_{1,2}(Q^2)) and neutral (F1,2R0(Q2)F^{R^0}_{1,2}(Q^2)) states are then related to the helicity amplitudes given by the following relations [13];

A12=2παKR⟨R,JZ=12|ϵ+μJiμ|N,JZ=−12⟩ζA_{\frac12}=\sqrt{\frac{2\pi\alpha}{K_R}}\left\langle R,J_Z=\frac12\middle|\epsilon^\mu_+J^\mu_i\middle|N,J_Z=-\frac12\right\rangle\zeta
S12=−2παKR∣q⃗∣Q2⟨R,JZ=12|ϵ0μJiμ|N,JZ=12⟩ζ(50)S_{\frac12}=-\sqrt{\frac{2\pi\alpha}{K_R}}\frac{|\vec{q}|}{\sqrt{Q^2}}\left\langle R,J_Z=\frac12\middle|\epsilon^\mu_0J^\mu_i\middle|N,J_Z=\frac12\right\rangle\zeta \tag*{(50)}

where in the resonance rest frame,

KR=MR2−M22MR,∣q⃗∣2=(MR2−M2−Q2)24MR2+Q2,K_R=\frac{M_R^2-M^2}{2M_R},\qquad|\vec{q}|^2=\frac{(M_R^2-M^2-Q^2)^2}{4M_R^2}+Q^2,
ϵ±μ=∓12(0,1,±i,0),ϵ0μ=1Q2(∣q⃗∣,1,0,q0).(51)\epsilon^\mu_\pm=\mp\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(0,1,\pm i,0),\qquad\epsilon^\mu_0=\frac{1}{\sqrt{Q^2}}(|\vec{q}|,1,0,q^0). \tag*{(51)}
ResonanceHelicity amplitudeProton targetNeutron target
Aα(0)A_{\alpha}(0)a1a_1b1b_1Aα(0)A_{\alpha}(0)a1a_1b1b_1
S11(1535)S_{11}(1535)A1/2A_{1/2}95.00.50.51−78.0-78.01.751.75
S1/2S_{1/2}−2.0-2.023.90.8132.50.41.0
S11(1650)S_{11}(1650)A1/2A_{1/2}33.31.450.6226.00.12.5
S1/2S_{1/2}−3.5-3.52.880.763.80.40.71
P11(1710)P_{11}(1710)A1/2A_{1/2}50.01.40.95−45.0-45.0−0.02-0.020.95
S1/2S_{1/2}27.40.180.88−31.5-31.50.350.85

Table 2. Parameterization of the transition form factors for S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650), P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) resonances on the proton and neutron targets. Aα(0)A_{\alpha}(0) is given in units of 10−3 GeV−210^{-3}\,\mathrm{GeV}^{-2} and the coefficients a1a_1 and b1b_1 in units of GeV−2\mathrm{GeV}^{-2}.

The parameter ζ\zeta is model dependent which is related to the sign of R→NπR \to N\pi, and for the present calculation is taken as ζ=1\zeta=1.

Using Eq. (51) in Eq. (50), the helicity amplitudes A1/2(Q2)A_{1/2}(Q^2) and S1/2(Q2)S_{1/2}(Q^2) in terms of the electromagnetic form factors F1R+,R0F_1^{R^+,R^0} and F2R+,R0F_2^{R^+,R^0} are obtained as [47]:

A1/2p,n(Q2)=2παM(MR+M)2+Q2MR2−M2(Q24MR2F1R+,R0(Q2)+MR−M2MF2R+,R0(Q2))A^{p,n}_{1/2}(Q^2)=\sqrt{\frac{2\pi\alpha}{M}\frac{(M_R+M)^2+Q^2}{M_R^2-M^2}\left(\frac{Q^2}{4M_R^2}F_1^{R^+,R^0}(Q^2)+\frac{M_R-M}{2M}F_2^{R^+,R^0}(Q^2)\right)}
S1/2p,n(Q2)=παM(MR−M)2+Q2MR2−M2(MR+M)2+Q24MRM(MR−M2MF1R+,R0(Q2)−F2R+,R0(Q2))(52)S^{p,n}_{1/2}(Q^2)=\sqrt{\frac{\pi\alpha}{M}\frac{(M_R-M)^2+Q^2}{M_R^2-M^2}\frac{(M_R+M)^2+Q^2}{4M_RM}}\left(\frac{M_R-M}{2M}F_1^{R^+,R^0}(Q^2)-F_2^{R^+,R^0}(Q^2)\right) \tag*{(52)}

The Q2Q^2 dependence of the helicity amplitudes (Eq. (52)) is generally parameterized as [46]:

Aα(Q2)=Aα(0)(1+αQ2)e−βQ2(53)A_{\alpha}(Q^2)=A_{\alpha}(0)(1+\alpha Q^2)e^{-\beta Q^2} \tag*{(53)}

where Aα(Q2)A_{\alpha}(Q^2) are the helicity amplitudes; A1/2(Q2)A_{1/2}(Q^2) and S1/2(Q2)S_{1/2}(Q^2) and parameters Aα(0)A_{\alpha}(0) are generally determined by a fit to the photoproduction data of the corresponding resonance. In the present work, the values of A1/2(0)A_{1/2}(0) are taken from the PDG [43]. While the parameters α\alpha and β\beta for each amplitude are obtained from the electroproduction data available at different Q2Q^2 from the CLAS experiment [52, 53, 54, 55], and the values of these parameters for the different nucleon resonances parameterized are tabulated in Table II. The Q2Q^2 dependence of the helicity amplitudes for S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) resonances is described by Eq. (53), which are then used in Eq. (52) to obtain the electromagnetic F1,2R+,R0(Q2)F_{1,2}^{R^{+},R^{0}}(Q^2) form factors.

In Figure 5 and Figure 6, we have shown the Q2Q^2 dependence of A12P,nA_{\frac{1}{2}}^{P,n} and S12P,nS_{\frac{1}{2}}^{P,n}, respectively, for S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) resonances. The values of A12P,n(0)A_{\frac{1}{2}}^{P,n}(0) are taken from PDG [43]. The data points shown in these figures are obtained from the analysis of the experimentally measured differential cross sections, longitudinally polarized beam asymmetries, and longitudinal target and beam-target asymmetries for π\pi and η\eta electroproductions from the proton target available from the CLAS experiment [52, 53, 54, 55]. To determine the helicity amplitudes at the different values of Q2Q^2, in Refs. [52, 53, 54, 55] the experimental data are analyzed using the two different approaches viz. dispersion relations and a unitary isobar model, and the final results are the average of the two analyses. The Q2Q^2 dependence of the electromagnetic form factors FiR+,R0(Q2)F_i^{R^+,R^0}(Q^2); (i=1,2)(i = 1, 2) for the resonances S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) are presented in Figure 7.

Figure 5. Q2Q^2 dependence of the helicity amplitude A1/2p,nA^{p,n}_{1/2} appearing in Eq. (53) for S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) (left panel), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650) (middle panel), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) (right panel) resonances. Solid (dashed) lines are our results for A1/2pA^p_{1/2} (A1/2nA^n_{1/2}) amplitudes. Solid square (up triangle) are the values of A1/2pA^p_{1/2} (A1/2nA^n_{1/2}) at Q2=0Q^2=0 from the PDG [43]. Solid circle and right triangle are the data points available from the CLAS experiment [52, 53, 54, 55].

Figure 6. Q2Q^2 dependence of the helicity amplitude S1/2p,nS_{1/2}^{p,n} given in Eq. (53) for S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) (left panel), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650) (middle panel), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) (right panel) resonances. Lines and points have the same meaning as in Figure 5.

Figure 7. Q2Q^2 dependence of the electromagnetic form factors FiR+,R0(Q2)F_{i}^{R^{+},R^{0}}(Q^2); (i=1,2)(i = 1, 2) given in Eq. (52) for S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) (left panel), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650) (middle panel), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) (right panel) resonances.

Using the expressions of the hadronic currents given in Eqs. (45) and (48), respectively, for the nonresonant Born terms and resonance excitations, and the leptonic current given in Eq. (40) in Eq. (42), we obtain the angular distribution (dσvdΩqpη)\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{\mathrm{v}}}{\mathrm{d}\Omega_{q p \eta}}\right) of the scattering of virtual photons with proton. Performing integration over cos⁡θqpη\cos\theta_{q p \eta} and ϕqpη\phi_{q p \eta}, we obtain the total cross section σv\sigma_{\mathrm{v}} for γ∗p→ηp\gamma^*p \to\eta p process, which is presented in Figure 8 as a function of CM energy WW at different values of Q2Q^2 viz. Q2=0.375Q^2 = 0.375, 0.6250.625, 0.8750.875, 1.1251.125, and 1.375 GeV21.375\ \mathrm{GeV}^2. The theoretical calculations presented as the full model receives contribution from the nonresonant Born terms as well as from the S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) resonances. In order to depict the individual contribution of the different nucleon resonances to the total cross section, we have also presented the results for the full model by switching off the contribution of an individual resonance. It may be observed from the figure that at all values of Q2Q^2, the first peak region around W∼1.52W \sim1.52 GeV is dominated by S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) resonance while in the region of W>1.65W > 1.65 GeV, the relative contribution from P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) becomes significant. We have also compared our theoretical calculations with the experimental data available from the CLAS experiment [24] and found a good agreement between the experimental and theoretical results especially in the low Q2Q^2 region.

Figure 8. Integrated cross section σv\sigma_{\mathrm{v}} vs WW at different Q2Q^2 for γ∗p→ηp\gamma^*p \to\eta p process. The experimental points are taken from the CLAS data [24]. Solid line shows the results of the full model which receives contribution from the nonresonant Born terms as well as from the nucleon resonance excitations. Double-dashed-dotted, dashed-dotted, and dashed lines, respectively, show the results of the full model without S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) resonances.

η\eta production induced by (anti)neutrinos

(Anti)neutrino induced single η\eta production off the nucleon target (Figure 2) are given by the following reactions

νμ(k)+n(p)⟶μ−(k′)+η(pη)+p(p′)(54)\nu_\mu(k) + n(p) \longrightarrow\mu^-(k') + \eta(p_\eta) + p(p') \tag*{(54)}
νˉμ(k)+p(p)⟶μ+(k′)+η(pη)+n(p′)(55)\bar{\nu}_\mu(k) + p(p) \longrightarrow\mu^+(k') + \eta(p_\eta) + n(p') \tag*{(55)}

where the quantities in the parenthesis are the four momenta of the particles. The general expression of the differential scattering cross section for the reactions shown in Eqs. (54) and (55) in the laboratory frame is given in Eq. (38), where transition matrix element, in the case of weak interaction induced process is given by

M=GF2cos⁡θClμjμ(56)\mathcal{M} = \frac{G_F}{\sqrt{2}}\cos\theta_C l_\mu j^\mu \tag*{(56)}

where GFG_F is the Fermi coupling constant and θC\theta_C is the Cabibbo mixing angle. The leptonic current lμl_\mu is given

lμ=uˉ(k′)γμ(1−γ5)u(k)(57)l_\mu= \bar{u}(k')\gamma_\mu(1-\gamma_5)u(k) \tag*{(57)}

and the hadronic current receives contribution from the nonresonant terms as well as from the resonance excitations and their subsequent decay to NηN\eta final state. The hadronic currents for the Born diagrams (s- and u-channels) with nucleon poles, using the nonlinear sigma model discussed in Section II A 1, are given in Eq. (48), except for the fact that ONO_N is now replaced by OVO_V where OV=Vμ−AμO_V = V^\mu- A^\mu is the weak vertex factor and VμV^\mu and AμA^\mu are defined in terms of the weak vector and axial-vector form factors as

Vμ=f1V(Q2)γμ+f2V(Q2)2Miσμνqν(58)V^\mu= f_1^V(Q^2)\gamma^\mu+ \frac{f_2^V(Q^2)}{2M}i\sigma^{\mu\nu}q_\nu \tag*{(58)}
Aμ=[g1(Q2)γμ+g3(Q2)Mqμ]γ5(59)A^\mu= \left[g_1(Q^2)\gamma^\mu+ \frac{g_3(Q^2)}{M}q^\mu\right]\gamma_5 \tag*{(59)}

where f1,2V(Q2)f_{1,2}^V(Q^2) are respectively the isovector form factors, and g1(Q2)g_1(Q^2) and g3(Q2)g_3(Q^2) are the axial vector and pseudoscalar form factors. The two isovector form factors f1,2V(Q2)f_{1,2}^V(Q^2) are expressed in terms of the Dirac (F1p,n(Q2)F_{1}^{p,n}(Q^2)) and Pauli (F2p,n(Q2)F_{2}^{p,n}(Q^2)) form factors, discussed in Section II B 1, for the protons and the neutrons using the relationships,

f1,2V(Q2)=F1,2p(Q2)−F1,2n(Q2)(60)f_{1,2}^V(Q^2) = F_{1,2}^p(Q^2) - F_{1,2}^n(Q^2) \tag*{(60)}

These electromagnetic form factors may be rewritten in terms of Sachs’ form factors using Eq. (47). The axial form factor, g1(Q2)g_1(Q^2) is parameterized as

g1(Q2)=gA(0)[1+Q2MA2]−2(61)g_1(Q^2) = g_A(0)\left[1+\frac{Q^2}{M_A^2}\right]^{-2} \tag*{(61)}

where gA(0)=1.267g_A(0) = 1.267 is the axial charge and MAM_A is the axial dipole mass, which in the numerical calculations is taken as the world average value i.e. MA=1.026M_A = 1.026 GeV [56]. On the other hand pseudoscalar form factor g3(Q2)g_3(Q^2) may be expressed in terms of g1(Q2)g_1(Q^2) using the PCAC hypothesis and Goldberger-Treiman relation as,

g3(Q2)=2Mg1(Q2)mπ2+Q2(62)g_3(Q^2) = \frac{2M g_1(Q^2)}{m_\pi^2 + Q^2} \tag*{(62)}

with mπm_\pi as the pion mass.

Next, we discuss the positive and negative parity resonance excitation mechanism for the weak interaction induced η\eta production. The general expression of the hadronic current for the s−s- and u−u- channel resonance excitations and their subsequent decay to NηN\eta mode are given in Eq. (48), where the vertex factor Γ12±μ\Gamma^{\mu}_{\frac{1}{2}^{\pm}} is now written as

Γ12+μ=V12μ−A12μ,(63)\Gamma^{\mu}_{\frac{1}{2}^{+}}=V^{\mu}_{\frac{1}{2}}-A^{\mu}_{\frac{1}{2}}, \tag*{(63)}

for the positive parity resonance, and as

Γ12−μ=(V12μ−A12μ)γ5,(64)\Gamma^{\mu}_{\frac{1}{2}^{-}}=(V^{\mu}_{\frac{1}{2}}-A^{\mu}_{\frac{1}{2}})\gamma_{5}, \tag*{(64)}

for the negative parity resonance. The vector and axial vector vertex factors for the weak interaction processes are given by

V12μ=f1CC(Q2)(2M)2(Q2γμ+q̸qμ)+f2CC(Q2)2Miσμαqα,(65)V^{\mu}_{\frac{1}{2}}=\frac{f_{1}^{CC}(Q^{2})}{(2M)^{2}}\left(Q^{2}\gamma^{\mu}+\not{q}q^{\mu}\right)+\frac{f_{2}^{CC}(Q^{2})}{2M}i\sigma^{\mu\alpha}q_{\alpha}, \tag*{(65)}
A12μ=[g1CC(Q2)γμ+g3CC(Q2)Mqμ]γ5,(66)A^{\mu}_{\frac{1}{2}}=\left[g_{1}^{CC}(Q^{2})\gamma^{\mu}+\frac{g_{3}^{CC}(Q^{2})}{M}q^{\mu}\right]\gamma_{5}, \tag*{(66)}

where fiCC(Q2)f_{i}^{CC}(Q^{2}) (i=1,2i=1,2) are the isovector transition form factors which in turn are expressed in terms of the charged (FiR+(Q2)F_{i}^{R+}(Q^{2})) and neutral (FiR0(Q2)F_{i}^{R0}(Q^{2})) electromagnetic transition form factors as:

fiCC(Q2)=FiR+(Q2)−FiR0(Q2),i=1,2(67)f_{i}^{CC}(Q^{2})=F_{i}^{R+}(Q^{2})-F_{i}^{R0}(Q^{2}),\qquad i=1,2 \tag*{(67)}

for isospin 12\frac{1}{2} resonances. Further, these form factors are related to the helicity amplitudes as discussed in Section II B 1. The axial-vector current consists of two form factors viz. g1CC(Q2)g_{1}^{CC}(Q^{2}) and g3CC(Q2)g_{3}^{CC}(Q^{2}), which are determined assuming the PCAC hypothesis and pion pole dominance of the divergence of the axial-vector current through the generalized GT relation for N−RN-R transition [13]. The divergence of the axial vector current, defined in Eq. (66), is obtained as

∂μA12μ=uˉ(pR)[g1CC(Q2)(MR±M)+g3CCMq2]γ5Γu(p)(68)\partial_{\mu}A^{\mu}_{\frac{1}{2}}=\bar{u}(p_{R})\left[g_{1}^{CC}(Q^{2})(M_{R}\pm M)+\frac{g_{3}^{CC}}{M}q^{2}\right]\gamma_{5}\Gamma u(p) \tag*{(68)}

where pRp_{R} is the four momentum of the resonance, Γ=1(γ5)\Gamma=1(\gamma_{5}) and +(−)+(-) in MR±MM_{R}\pm M stands for the positive (negative) parity resonances. The Lagrangian at the strong NRπNR\pi vertex is written as

LRNπ=2gRNπfπΨˉRΓ∂μϕiτiΨ(69)\mathcal{L}_{RN\pi}=\sqrt{2}\frac{g_{RN\pi}}{f_{\pi}}\bar{\Psi}_{R}\Gamma\partial_{\mu}\phi_{i}\tau^{i}\Psi \tag*{(69)}

where gRNπg_{RN\pi} is the coupling constant at the strong vertex, fπf_{\pi} is the pion decay constant, ϕ\phi represents the triplet of the pion field. The value of the strong coupling gRNπg_{RN\pi} is obtained using the partial decay width of the resonance to the NπN\pi mode, using Eq. (33) with C=3C=3 and MηM_{\eta} is replaced by mπm_{\pi}.

The axial vector current obtained in the pion pole dominance of the divergence of the axial vector current (using Eq. (69)) is given by

APPμ=2uˉ(pR)gRNπfπ(MR±M)γ5Γu(p)2fπqμq2−mπ2.(70)A^{\mu}_{PP}=\sqrt{2}\bar{u}(p_{R})\frac{g_{RN\pi}}{f_{\pi}}(M_{R}\pm M)\gamma_{5}\Gamma u(p)\frac{\sqrt{2}f_{\pi}q^{\mu}}{q^{2}-m_{\pi}^{2}}. \tag*{(70)}

The divergence of the above expression, in the limit of mπ→0m_{\pi}\to0, is obtained as

∂μAPPμ=2gRNπuˉ(pR)(MR±M)γ5Γu(p).(71)\partial_{\mu}A^{\mu}_{PP}=2g_{RN\pi}\bar{u}(p_{R})(M_{R}\pm M)\gamma_{5}\Gamma u(p). \tag*{(71)}

Comparing the term associated with g1CC(Q2)g_{1}^{CC}(Q^{2}) at Q2=0Q^{2}=0 in Eq. (68) with the above expression, we obtain

g1CC(0)=2gRNπ,(72)g_{1}^{CC}(0)=2g_{RN\pi}, \tag*{(72)}

with gRNπg_{RN\pi} being the coupling strength for R12→NπR_{\frac{1}{2}}\to N\pi decay, which has been determined by the partial decay width of the resonance and tabulated in Table I. Since no information about the Q2Q^{2} dependence of the axial-vector form factor is known experimentally, therefore, a dipole form is assumed as in the case of N→N′N\to N' or N→YN\to Y transitions:

g1CC(Q2)=g1CC(0)(1+Q2MA2)2.(73)g_{1}^{CC}(Q^{2})=\frac{g_{1}^{CC}(0)}{\left(1+\frac{Q^{2}}{M_{A}^{2}}\right)^{2}}. \tag*{(73)}

with MA=1.026M_A = 1.026 GeV, and the pseudoscalar form factor g3CC(Q2)g_3^{CC}(Q^2) is given by

g3CC(Q2)=MMR±M2mπ2+Q2g1CC(Q2),(74)g_3^{CC}(Q^2) = \frac{MM_R \pm M^2}{m_\pi^2 + Q^2} g_1^{CC}(Q^2), \tag*{(74)}

where +(−)+(-) sign is for positive (negative) parity resonances. However, the contribution of g3CC(Q2)g_3^{CC}(Q^2) being directly proportional to the lepton mass squared is almost negligible.

Results and Discussion

In Figure 9, we have presented the results for the Q2Q^2 distribution in the charged current νμ(νˉμ)\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu) induced η\eta production from the free nucleon target at Eνμ(νˉμ)=1E_{\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu)} = 1 and 1.5 GeV. It may be observed from the figure that at Eν=1.5E_\nu= 1.5 GeV the results obtained with only S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) resonance are comparable to the results of the full model in the region of high Q2Q^2 region. Even in the low Q2Q^2 region, the contribution from the Born terms and other resonances is not more than 10% of the total result. At Eνμ(νˉμ)=1E_{\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu)} = 1 GeV, we find that (not shown here) the contribution of the higher resonances and Born terms is almost negligible as compared to the contribution of S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) resonance.

Figure 9. Q2Q^2 distribution for the charged current induced νμ+n⟶μ−+p+η\nu_\mu+n \longrightarrow\mu^-+p+\eta (left panel) and νˉμ+p⟶μ++n+η\bar{\nu}_\mu+p \longrightarrow\mu^++n+\eta (right panel) processes at Eνμ(νˉμ)=1E_{\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu)} = 1 GeV (dashed line with circle) and 1.5 GeV (solid line) using the full model calculation. Dashed-dotted line shows the results obtained from S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) resonance only at Eνμ(νˉμ)=1.5E_{\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu)} = 1.5 GeV.

In Figure 10, we have presented the results for the η\eta-momentum distribution of νμ(νˉμ)\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu) induced η\eta production from the free nucleon target at Eνμ(νˉμ)=1E_{\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu)} = 1 and 1.5 GeV. As in the case of Q2Q^2 distribution, we find very small contribution of the Born terms and higher resonances to the pηp_\eta distribution as compared to the contribution of S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) resonance.

Figure 10. η\eta-momentum distribution for the charged current induced νμ+n⟶μ−+p+η\nu_\mu+n\longrightarrow\mu^-+p+\eta (left panel) and νˉμ+p⟶μ++n+η\bar{\nu}_\mu+p\longrightarrow\mu^++n+\eta (right panel) processes. Lines and points have the same meaning as in Figure 9.

Figure 11 shows the results for the total scattering cross sections for the processes νμ+n⟶μ−+η+p\nu_\mu+n \longrightarrow\mu^-+\eta+p and νˉμ+p⟶μ++η+n\bar{\nu}_\mu+p \longrightarrow\mu^++\eta+n. The individual contributions from S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) resonance excitations, where both the direct and crossed diagrams are considered, as well as the full model (sum of all the diagrams) are shown. It may be observed from the figure that in the case of both neutrino and antineutrino induced reactions, S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) has the dominant contribution followed by P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) and S11(1650)S_{11}(1650) resonances. We have also compared the present results for the neutrino induced η\eta production with the results of DCC model [3] and found that from threshold up to Eνμ∼1.3E_{\nu_\mu} \sim1.3 GeV our results are consistent with the results of DCC model. While for Eνμ>1.3E_{\nu_\mu} > 1.3 GeV, our results are higher than the results obtained using DCC model.

Figure 11. Total scattering cross section for CC induced η\eta production i.e. νμ+n⟶μ−+η+p\nu_\mu+n\longrightarrow\mu^-+\eta+p (left panel) and νˉμ+p⟶μ++η+n\bar{\nu}_\mu+p\longrightarrow\mu^++\eta+n (right panel). Full model (solid line) consists of the contributions from all the diagrams including S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710). The individual contribution from S11(1535)S_{11}(1535), S11(1650)S_{11}(1650), and P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) resonances are shown by dashed-dotted, double-dashed-dotted, and double-dotted-dashed lines respectively. In the case of neutrino induced η\eta production, we have also compared our results of the full model with the results obtained in the DCC model by Nakamura et al. [3].

To explicitly show the lepton mass effect, in Figure 12, we have presented the results for the total scattering cross section for the η\eta production induced by νe(νˉe)\nu_e(\bar{\nu}_e) and νμ(νˉμ)\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu). It may be noticed that due to the lower threshold for νe(νˉe)\nu_e(\bar{\nu}_e), the cross section is larger than that of νμ(νˉμ)\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu) induced processes even at Eν(νˉ)=2E_{\nu(\bar{\nu})} = 2 GeV. Since the value of axial dipole mass is in debate as the different neutrino experiment quote different values of MAM_A ranging from 1 to 1.3 GeV, therefore, in the case of η\eta production, we have studied the effect of MAM_A on the total scattering cross section (not shown here) by varying it in the range ±10%\pm10\% for the Born as well as the resonance terms. We find that the effect of MAM_A variation is less than 5%, even at Eνμ(νˉμ)=2E_{\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu)}=2 GeV.

Figure 12. Total scattering cross section for CC induced η\eta production i.e. νμ+n⟶μ−+η+p\nu_\mu+n\longrightarrow\mu^-+\eta+p (solid line), νe+n⟶e−+η+p\nu_e+n\longrightarrow e^-+\eta+p (dashed line), νˉμ+p⟶μ++η+n\bar{\nu}_\mu+p\longrightarrow\mu^++\eta+n (dashed-dotted line), and νˉe+p⟶e++η+n\bar{\nu}_e+p\longrightarrow e^++\eta+n (double-dashed-dotted line).

Summary and conclusions

In summary, we have studied the charged current νμ(νˉμ)\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu) induced η\eta production off the nucleons and presented the results for the total scattering cross section σ(Eνμ(νˉμ))\sigma(E_{\nu_\mu(\bar{\nu}_\mu)}), Q2Q^2-distribution (dσdQ2)\left(\frac{d\sigma}{dQ^2}\right) and the momentum distribution (dσdpη)\left(\frac{d\sigma}{dp_\eta}\right) for the η\eta mesons, in a model in which the contribution from the nonresonant Born terms and the resonant terms are calculated in an effective Lagrangian approach. The parameters of the model for evaluating the vector current contribution have been fixed by fitting the experimental data on the total cross sections of the photo- and electroproduction on the nucleons from the MAINZ and CLAS experiments. The vector part of the N⟶RN\longrightarrow R transition form factors has been obtained from the MAID helicity amplitudes while the axial vector part is obtained with the help of PCAC hypothesis and assuming the pion-pole dominance of the divergence of the axial vector current. For the nonresonant background terms we have used a microscopical model based on the SU(3) chiral Lagrangians. The parameters of the model are meson decay constants, Cabibbo’s angle, the proton and neutron magnetic moments, all of which are known with good accuracy, and the parameters DD and FF obtained from the analysis of the hyperon semileptonic decays.

The results are summarized as

(i) In the electromagnetic sector, the cross section is dominated by the contribution from S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) resonance, especially at low WW. With the increase in WW the contribution from P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) starts to show up and around W≥1.7W\geq1.7 GeV its contribution is larger than the other resonances.

(ii) In the weak sector, S11(1535)S_{11}(1535) resonance dominates even at Eν=2E_\nu=2 GeV, while the contribution of S11(1650)S_{11}(1650) is not more than 7% of the total scattering cross section, while that of P11(1710)P_{11}(1710) is about 10%.

(iii) The Q2Q^2 distribution has a peak at Q2≈0.15Q^2\approx0.15 (0.28) GeV2^2 at Eνμ=1E_{\nu_\mu}=1 (1.5)GeV. The nature of Q2Q^2 distribution in the antineutrino channel is almost similar to that observed in the neutrino case.

(iv) The eta momentum distribution has a peak at pη≈0.37p_\eta\approx0.37 (0.47) GeV at Eνμ=1E_{\nu_\mu}=1 (1.5)GeV. The nature of momentum distribution in the antineutrino channel is almost similar to that observed in the neutrino case.

To conclude, the results obtained in this work may be very useful in studying the feasibility of observing the weak production of η\eta in experiments like MicroBooNE, T2K, NOvA, MINERvA and the next generation experiments like T2-HyperK and DUNE. Furthermore, the study of η\eta production is also important in the analysis of atmospheric neutrino events.

Acknowledgements

MSA is thankful to M. J. Vicente Vacas, L. Alvarez Ruso, and M. Rafi Alam for many useful discussions. MSA and AF are thankful to the Department of Science and Technology (DST), Government of India for providing financial assistance under Grant No. SR/MF/PS-01/2016-AMU.

References

References

  1. [43]P. A. Zyla et al. [Particle Data Group] PTEP 2020, 083C01 (2020) doi:10.1093/ptep/ptaa104DOI
  2. [44]D. Skoupil and P. Bydžovský, Phys. Rev. C 93, 025204 (2016) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.93.025204DOI
  3. [45]M. S. Athar and S. K. Singh, Cambridge University Press, 2020, ISBN 978-1-108-77383-6, 978-1-108-48906-5 doi:10.1017/9781108489065DOI
  4. [46]T. Liator, D. Drechsel, S. S. Kamalov and M. Vanderhaeghen, Eur. Phys. J. ST 198, 141 (2011) doi:10.1140/epjst/e2011-01488-9DOI
  5. [47]T. Leitner, O. Buss, L. Alvarez-Ruso and U. Mosel, Phys. Rev. C 79, 034601 (2009) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.79.034601DOI
  6. [48]A. Donnachie and G. Shaw, “Electromagnetic Interactions of Hadrons. 1,” New York 1978, 446p.
  7. [49]E. Amaldi, S. Fubini and G. Furlan, Springer Tracts Mod. Phys. 83, 1 (1979) doi:10.1007/BF b0048209
  8. [50]D. Drechsel, Few Body Syst. Suppl. 7, 325 (1994)
  9. [51]R. Bradford, A. Boddek, H. S. Budd and J. Arrington, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 159 (2006) 127 doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysbps.2006.08.028DOI
  10. [52]I. G. Aznauryan, V. D. Burkert, H. Egiyan, K. Joo, R. Minehart and L. C. Smith, Phys. Rev. C 71, 015201 (2005) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.71.015201DOI
  11. [53]I. G. Aznauryan, V. D. Burkert, G. V. Fedotov, B. S. Ishkhanov and V. I. Mokeev, Phys. Rev. C 72, 045201 (2005) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.72.045201DOI
  12. [54]I. G. Aznauryan et al. [CLAS Collaboration], Phys. Rev. C 80, 055203 (2009) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.80.055203DOI
  13. [55]K. Park et al. [CLAS Collaboration], Phys. Rev. C 91, 045203 (2015) doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.91.045203DOI
  14. [56]V. Bernard, L. Elouadlhiri, U. G. Meissner, J. Phys. G 28, R1 (2002) doi:10.1088/0954-3899/28/1/201DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_hgjfm3km
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents