betaFeedback

WorksComputer Science

Ensured Energy: How a Serious Game can Reach and Engage Diverse Societal Groups in Swiss Energy Transition

Abstract

In support of Switzerland's energy and climate strategy for 2050, researchers investigate scenarios for the transition of energy systems towards a higher share of renewables, assessing their social, environmental and economic impact. Their results guide stakeholders and policy makers in designing resilient and sustainable systems. A crucial condition to successfully implement these solution in the real-world is that the population supports these transitions. Social scientists have identified the high complexity of energy systems and energy policy as one reason why popular support for the implementation of the energy transition is often limited. This paper proposes serious gaming as a novel approach to inform and sensitize a broader public for the transition of the energy system in Switzerland. We motivate and describe the design of an online game in which players experience an accurate simulation of current and future energy provision and manage transition towards a sustainable future. We present the embedding of this serious game into a large-scale population survey and report findings on player characteristics and engagement. We show that a serious game can successfully attract participants from diverse societal groups and highlight the challenge of balancing complexity and entertainment.

Introduction

The role of serious gaming in opinion formation about the energy transition

To reach the Swiss goal of a net-zero energy system compatible with the 2015 Paris Agreement [1], [2], different pathways [3] towards energy transition are simulated and evaluated in terms of their potential effects on society and the environment. While one criterion is set, namely that these pathways should lead to a carbon-neutral energy system by 2050, they differ in other important aspects [4]. For example, they emphasize varying energy technologies, rely on varying degrees of energy imports, or use different policy measures to generate incentives for an accelerated transition or for reduced energy consumption.

While this research suggests that different paths to net-zero are both technically possible and feasible for Switzerland, one of the main challenges to implementation seems to be a lack of social acceptance [5]. This challenge is not specific to Switzerland. Indeed, public resistance to transition towards net-zero energy systems that mitigate climate change has become a polarized issue involving electoral risks for established parties and potential for democratic backlash [6]. However, what is specific to the Swiss case is that the participatory context provides citizens with ample possibilities to directly decide on relevant legislation and block renewable energy projects [7].

To better anticipate and plan the implementation of renewable energy pathways, it is therefore crucial to better understand and include citizens’ perceptions with regard to future energy systems [8, 9, 10]. One finding of existing research is that people are generally in favour of a carbon neutral energy system [4], but are reluctant to support projects and policies aimed at transition towards renewables [11]. This apparent mismatch can be attributed in part to the high complexity of the topic, making it difficult for people to understand and recognize the benefits of net zero policies and technologies [12], [13]. Even more so, the evaluation of transition pathways (not single policy measures) towards net-zero involves questions around complex concepts over long time-frames, and includes a potentially infinite number of different hypothetical states. At the same time, research shows that simple information provision on these complex issues is often insufficient to effectively engage key social groups or to build greater support for transition measures [14], [15].

This is the starting point of the present study, which proposes serious gaming as a tool to sensitize the broader public to energy transition. Serious games allow players to immerse themselves in scenarios and are thus beneficial in gaining attention, simplifying information processing, and inducing emotion towards decision-making. This approach is expected both to facilitate opinion formation in players and to contribute to a more accurate analysis of preferences [16, 17, 18, 19]. Furthermore, through the use of a serious game, a variety of scenarios and disruptive events can be presented, testing how preferences for the configuration of an energy system are context dependent [20, 21].

One crucial precondition for serious games to unfold these positive properties is that they are able to attract and engage players. Therefore, the guiding question of the present study is: Can a serious game about energy transition function as an effective tool to engage a wider audience? Investigating this question provides insights on the potential of serious games to reach the broader population. Only if players really engage with the game and if game engagement goes beyond the typical gamers’ group of young male individuals, we can expect that a serious game could eventually “make a difference”, e.g., by enhancing the population’s awareness and comprehension of a complex issue like energy transition.

To answer the question, we present the development and design of the online game Ensured Energy (see Figure 1) in which players experience an accurate simulation of current and future energy provision and are asked to secure Switzerland’s energy supply until 2050, thereby managing the transition towards a sustainable future. In addition, we propose a novel approach to embed the serious game into a large-scale population survey as a randomized intervention, which enables us to test in how far it is able to engage the broader population. More specifically, we use the information collected in the survey to study characteristics of the players compared to non-players. Furthermore, we can compare the treatment group (who was sent to the game in the middle of the survey) and the control (who was only informally invited to the game at the end of the survey) with respect to their game engagement.

Screenshot from Ensured Energy

Figure 1. Screenshot from Ensured Energy.

Our approach extends previous methods in public opinion research in two distinct ways. Firstly, the game can be conceptualized as a sophisticated information treatment, providing participants with structured insights into complex energy transition pathways. Our study informs about the potential of such games to indeed “treat” respondents of a broader population sample. Secondly, the game itself can capture context-specific preferences by immersing participants in hypothetical but realistic future scenarios.

Serious games as sophisticated information treatment

The complex topic of energy transition reduces the ability of survey respondents to grasp the pros and cons of various measures and the trade-offs involved in the decision-making process [12, 13]. Serious games can mitigate this issue and are widely used to foster learning [22, 23]. In general, the potential to make complex topics more understandable is seen as an advantage of serious games [16, 24, 25]. Player engagement can change perceptions [26, 27] and preferences [28, 29], but it can improve efficacy, which is defined as “beliefs in one’s capabilities to execute the competencies needed to exercise control over events that affect one’s welfare” [30]. Serious games that provide feedback have the potential to allow survey respondents to make informed decisions even in situations of high complexity [31, 32, 33].

In the context of Ensured Energy, players manage the Swiss energy system, with the aim of ensuring the energy supply for Switzerland until 2050. For this purpose, they can, for example, construct new power plants, take political measures or decide to import more energy from neighbouring countries. During the game, players are shown indicators relating to the energy system and its economic and environmental impact. These indicators effectively confront the player with a trade-off, since it is not possible to choose a single best option. All potential decisions come with advantages and disadvantages at the level of certain indicators. Thus, we can investigate how different contexts, provided by the game and mimicking realistic real-world situations, influence the decisions of the respondents.

Outline

The rest of the paper is organised as follows: Section II describes the design of the game and the gameplay itself in more detail. Section III presents the calculation model that underlies the game and its calibration to official statistics. Section IV includes details of how the game was integrated into a public opinion survey and presents empirical results to answer our research question. Finally, Section V gives an overall assessment of the game and an outlook for applications and future work.

Gameplay Design

Gameplay Objectives

We adhere to the Gameplay/Purpose/Scope (GPS) framework, which states that serious games have three different purposes: to communicate, to educate, and to collect data [34]. Ensured Energy informs players about the potentials and limitations of the Swiss energy system and collects their priorities regarding energy transition through their in-game decisions. The latter is the most relevant aspect of the game, effectively performing a Multiple-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) [35] study with lay subjects. Although the game is not designed as an educational tool in the narrow sense, it contains informative elements and feedback relating to the Swiss energy landscape.

When it comes to data collection, agency and the ability to choose between different options are crucial in understanding preferences. The fictive point of view of a national energy manager who has to secure energy supply for Switzerland is therefore chosen, allowing players to plan energy transition, manage different resources, and trade-off outcomes. The gameplay of simulation/management games fits this frame [34], although some of the main characteristics of the genre had to be abandoned in order to give a more realistic context to the game. The traditional Tabula Rasa or blank slate of simulation games [36] did not make sense in a game that replicates the current energy system of Switzerland. The game therefore is initialised with a Swiss map that contains multiple power plants representing the current reality. Players allocate capacity for power generation to nuclear, hydroelectric, solar, wind, biomass, biogas and waste. Even though the Swiss map is used as the background of the game interface, the geographical location of these sites has no impact on the constructed power plants, both as a simplification and to avoid regional bias. Another necessary change was in resource management. While there has been a shift in the goals and game loops of simulation games recently, the most common purpose is still growth (population, economic, etc.). Growth in our game is not under the control of the player, instead their objective is balance, in the supply and demand of energy as well as in their financial budget.

Several game elements help shape a more realistic political landscape. Switzerland has decided to opt out of nuclear power [37], so there is no possibility to build new nuclear reactors in the game. In addition, instead of unlimited unused space, as, e.g., in SimCity [38], construction sites are limited, which integrates the important and strongly politicised trade-off between energy infrastructure and land use. Moreover, differing construction times for power plants are accounted for by type, with an appropriate delay between the player’s decision to build and the moment at which a plant contributes to energy supply [39]. Similarly, resistance to large solar parks requires the player to implement policies that allow an increased number of upgrades to solar plants in-game.

Gameplay Overview

The game is structured into 10 turns over 30 years and the player must provide sufficient energy for both summer and winter at each turn in order to move on to the next. The player has different options to reach the required energy demand:

  • Select a free building area and build a new power plant.

  • Increase or decrease the capacity of existing power plants.

  • Import energy from abroad.

  • Implement political measures (policies) that reduce demand or help build power plants more quickly.

  • Hold political campaigns to increase the chances of policies being accepted.

Each power plant has characteristics such as financial cost per energy output, construction time and impacts on different factors such as land use, emissions and the seasonal availability of electricity. Policies have a probability of acceptance, which can increase through information campaigns or be lowered according to the player’s choices for energy supply. Throughout the game, the player must react to various random shocks, see Table III, that impact energy supply and demand, testing the resilience of their strategy.

In the introductory text at the start of the game, the player is assigned one of two different frames: one instructs them solely to maintaining energy supply, while the other emphasises the need to also effectively manage the transition to renewables. Regardless of this context, all players are free to set their own goals, as long as there is sufficient energy supplied in each round. Each player is scored according to a set of metrics that are calculated and displayed at the end of the game. Scores are ranked and stored on a leader board that can be ordered by each of the metrics. The game is available in four languages: German, French, Italian and English.

KeyDescription
AImport slider, summer/winter energy levels
BLand use and emissions gauges
CPolitical support bar
DBudget and borrowing buttons
EPolicy button and link to metric charts
FCost and impact of selected power plant
GCapacity for summer/winter and upgrade button
HSelected power plant
IWater construction site
JLand construction site
KCurrent turn and year

Table 1.

Game Implementation

Ensured Energy was created using the Godot 4 game engine [40] and deployed via a web browser to facilitate navigation to and from the survey. During the development of the game, limitations around software led to a decision that the game should be developed for a desktop-only browser environment. This in turn guided the design of the user interface and gameplay, allowing a more detailed display and controls, but with unexpected consequences that are discussed in § 5-B.

The layout and function of the game controls are shown in Figure 2. Every player starts with the same scenario, which is the state of the Swiss energy system in 2022. For simplicity, the map shows one or two power plants of each type, with the sum of their capacities reflecting the current energy mix.

Components of the game user interface

Figure 2. Components of the game user interface

At each turn, the player is given a budget that can be used to build new power plants, upgrade existing structures and import energy. Each plant has a building cost, an upgrade cost and production cost, which is taken automatically at every turn. The player can borrow money up to a fixed amount per turn with the loan repaid automatically with interest at the subsequent turn. All power plants have an impact on land use and emissions. The player can find the relevant information by clicking on a specific station or by clicking on the overall corresponding gauge for the total.

Table I shows percentage increase in initial capacity that results from building or upgrading the various power installations, as well as the total number of upgrades that can be applied. Most power plants are built immediately, but

Power PlantBuildUpgradeTotal
River50%1%10
Reservoir50%1%10
Solar25%5%7
Wind100%50%7
Gas100%50%0
Biomass100%50%0
Biogas100%50%0
Waste25%6.25%0

TABLE I

BUILD AND UPGRADE PARAMETERS FOR POWER PLANTS SHOWING PERCENTAGE INCREASES TO CAPACITY AND MAXIMUM NUMBER OF UPGRADES.

wind, river and reservoir installations take 2, 3 and 6 turns respectively.

Build times can be reduced by implementing policies which provide education or support for corresponding energy technologies. Players may try to implement one policy per turn. The list of policies, their effects, and their initial acceptance probability are summarised in tbl:2:

PolicyEffectAccept
Enable alpine PVincrease solar upgrades80%
Fast track wind parkslower wind build time60%
Wind park regulationincrease wind upgrades50%
Building insulationlower household demand70%
Industry subsidylower industry demand60%

TABLE II

SUMMARY OF POLICIES SHOWING DESCRIPTION, EFFECTS AND PROBABILITY OF ACCEPTANCE.

Decisions made in response to shocks affect the probabilities for future policy acceptance, with unpopular responses reducing future acceptance and vice-versa. Shocks are events that occur randomly during the game and that have an effect on supply, demand or political support. If the energy supply of the player can withstand the shock, the player is rewarded with an increased budget and increased political support. The different types of shock are summarised in tbl:3.

ShockEffect
Cold spellincrease winter demand by 5%
Heat waveincrease summer demand by 5%
Mass immigrationincrease demand by 5%
Renewable supportincrease support by 10%
Glaciers meltingfor user information only
Nuclear re-introductiongather user preference only

TABLE III

SUMMARY OF SHOCKS SHOWING DESCRIPTION AND EFFECT.

In the case of a cold spell or heat wave, the player is given a choice which allows them to trade-off the effects with respect to political support, emissions or financial resources. The choice to re-introduce nuclear power always takes place on turn 5.

Schematic representation of the energy balance for 2022

Figure 3. Excerpt from [41] showing a schematic representation of the energy balance for 2022.

In addition to allocating resources to electricity generation, a player may reduce emissions by carbon sequestration. In this case, players allocate the capacity of carbon capture and storage at a price set in the model.

Model and Calculation

Energy Balance

To correctly record decisions, realistic questions must be posed. We use a reduced representation of the Swiss energy system that remains accurate with respect to the quantitative nature of the full model, while providing simplified and timely interaction for the player. The economic and environmental model that underlies the game takes its structure from the annual reporting of the Swiss federal offices for energy [41] [42] and the environment [43] [44]. The energy balance is part of official statistics for most countries [45] and accounts for the flow of energy through the economy. A schematic view is shown in Figure 3 and a brief description follows:

  1. Primary energy enters the economy either as fuels (oil, gas, nuclear) which may be imported, exported, produced domestically, moved to and from stocks, or drawn directly from the environment (such as hydroelectric, wind or solar energy).

  2. Transformation converts primary energy in its raw state into other forms, most importantly electricity. Instal-

lations such as nuclear or gas fuelled power plants, hydroelectric facilities, solar panels or wind turbines perform these functions. Conversion processes are not completely efficient, and thus total energy is reduced during transformation.

  1. Delivery of energy in its various forms to final users then takes place, either via power distribution networks, pipelines, or by transport of physical fuel. Delivery also incurs losses which must be accounted for.

  1. Final consumption of energy, either in its raw or transformed state is carried out by the five main economic sectors: households, industry, services, transport and agriculture. Excess energy may be stored or exported, and (most significantly for electricity) any shortfall must be imported directly.

Excerpt from the energy balance table for 2022

Figure 4. Excerpt from [41] showing a tabular representation of the energy balance for 2022.

Figure 4 shows the same energy balance in tabular form [41], where units are terajoules (1TJ=10121\mathrm{TJ} = 10^{12} joules, 3.6TJ=1GWh3.6\mathrm{TJ} = 1\mathrm{GWh}). Columns represent energy in different forms, more detailed data for renewables were obtained from the Swiss Federal Office of Energy (SFOE). Rows at the top of the table represent quantities of primary energy available to the system. The central part of the table shows transformation processes moving quantities of energy from one column to another as they are converted. Losses due to delivery and processing are then shown, and in the lower part of the table are the quantities removed from the system by consumption in the five economic sectors.

Thus, all of the energy entering, leaving and transformed by the system is accounted for. Changing these quantities over time while maintaining the balance of energy allows the model to describe different scenarios for energy transition.

Scenario Construction

The model constructs a complete energy balance for each year of the game. Players install or remove power plants representing different energy conversion technologies. These changes in capacity affect the supply of final energy and demand for primary energy. Similarly, players may alter demand for final energy by enacting policies that subsidise renewable power generation or reduce consumption. Changes to supply and demand may also arise from shocks to the system as described earlier. The calculation of a synthetic energy balance thus takes place as follows:

  1. Given forecasts for final consumption, the total delivery requirement for each type of energy is calculated.

  2. Losses associated with storage and delivery of each energy type are added to give the amounts required after transformation.

  3. The quantities of each energy type made available by the various transformation processes are deducted from the amounts required.

  4. Any remaining unfulfilled requirement is satisfied by imports and excesses of supply removed via exports.

The approach reflects and extends the work of [46], [47], providing a complete description of the Swiss energy balance over time.

Calibration & Forecasting

In order to reconstruct the energy balance at a future point in time, we require estimates for levels of production, consumption, energy transformation, and the efficiencies and losses associated with each process. The model is calibrated to historic energy balance data [41], [42] which includes time series for traditional sources since 1980 and renewables since 1990.

Since 2010 total final energy consumption in Switzerland has been decreasing on a linear trend, due mainly to increasing environmental temperatures [41]. In order to reproduce this overall trend, demand is projected using a linear regression over 8 years of time series data with supply and efficiency values held constant at their current time-averaged levels. The regression removes some of the effects of the COVID19 pandemic, which caused large distortions to recent data points dues to decreased economic activity. It also has the effect of damping the rapid growth in new technologies (e.g. biofuels, geothermal) which would otherwise be over-represented in future energy supply.

The linear model therefore represents a compromise in design which favours slower change. Fewer parameters reduce uncertainty in estimation and computational complexity. The forecast thus provides a linear baseline to which shocks are then applied, allowing players to experience nonlinear changes in demand as events within the game. The problem for the player is thus not only to satisfy demand but to re-allocate resources to more sustainable and resilient forms of supply.

Historic data is annualised but in reality there are fluctuations in supply, demand and processing. Demand for heating is greater in winter and cooling in summer. Solar and run-of-river have increased availability in summer and nuclear power generation is therefore decreased during this period. Seasonal calibration uses hourly energy market data [48] over a four year history. For annual seasonality the demand data was aggregated by quarter and allocated to summer or winter but daily, weekly and intraday variations [45] are beyond the scope of the model.

Metrics

To assess and compare instances of the model and game, we calculate a set of economic and environmental metrics which are shown to the players as final scores. Some metrics are intrinsic to the energy balance itself, specifically net imports of fuel and electricity itself. These measure self-sufficiency in the energy economy and are a proxy measure of cost. We do not attempt to forecast energy market prices but estimates of the cost of electricity generation (in CHF/TJ) are available in the literature [49, 50, 51].

Emissions of greenhouse gases (CO2_2, N2_2O, CH4_4, and SF6_6) related to both electricity generation and consumption are calculated as an equivalent mass of CO2_2 in kg [43], [44], [52]. We also calculate equivalent CO2_2-emissions for final consumption by combustion (fossil fuels, wood, biofuels, biogas and waste). The values are not directly available but can be calibrated from publicly available data [43], [44] using regression as before.

Finally, we calculate a land use metric for energy transformation. This gives an environmental opportunity cost associated with each type of electricity generation. Values in km2^2/TJ are available in the literature [47], [49, 50, 51].

The metrics are calculated annually and summed over the period of the simulation. They are summarised in Table IV.

MetricUnits
Nuclear fuel consumptionTJ
Fossil fuel consumptionTJ
Electricity importsTJ
Emissions (CO2_2 equivalent)t (mln)
Investment costsCHF (mln)
Land usekm2^2
Seasonality (summer/total)%

Table IV. Summary of metrics calculated per simulation with units.

Model Implementation

The model is implemented on a web server using the LAMP architecture. Interaction is via HTML, XMLHTTP or JSON interfaces. Details of the API can be provided on request. Actions made by players are stored in an SQL database along with cookies that allow cross-referencing of game instances with survey data.

Integration of Survey and Game

Survey Overview

In order to evaluate whether the game can effectively engage players and enhance their awareness and comprehension of energy transition, in accordance with our research question, the game was embedded in a large-n survey study and used as an experimental treatment. The sample for the project was drawn from the official Swiss population register. The Swiss Federal Statistical Office provided the contact addresses of 6,000 randomly selected Swiss residents between the ages of 18 and 75. We used a stratified sample across the 26 Swiss cantons to account for differences in population size and to ensure representation from all cantons. Respondents were recruited through a postal invitation containing a link to an online survey and a personal identification token. The self-administered survey was prepared in German, French, Italian, and English using Qualtrics software, with essential infrastructure and support provided by the Decision Sciences Laboratory1 at ETH Zurich. All respondents entered the survey and filled out a first survey block assessing pre-treatment variables (e.g., environmental attitudes, perceived efficacy of individuals and the society to deal with the energy transition). After this first survey block respondents were assigned either to treatment or control group. For the assignment, a blocked randomization approach was based on respondents age, gender, language and pre-treatment individual and collective efficacy levels. Blocking ensures that respondents are precisely randomized on the included variables, while maintaining average randomization on all other variables [53]. The treatment group was then invited to play the game before continuing with the second part of the survey. The control group directly continued with the second part of the survey. Only after finishing the survey, the control group was invited to play the game.

Using a personal identification token, we combined survey responses with information on decisions taken by respondents during the game. Specifically, the game recorded parameter changes, including adjustments in energy production for different technologies and changes in various indicators at each round. In addition, the game stored information about shocks and policies, including their timing, options provided to players, and the responses they chose.

Respondents’ survey answers, including socio-demographic characteristics and attitudes, can thus be linked to their ingame decisions. This enables us to explore and compare how different groups interact with and respond to the game environment.

Participant Flow and Attrition

Figure 5 illustrates the study flow and attrition across the different stages of participation. Of the 6,000 individuals contacted through the Swiss population register, 2,164 accessed the survey and 2,029 completed the first survey block. A total of 2,024 respondents were successfully randomised into the treatment or control group. Among these, 1,453 launched the game and 542 completed at least one round. Overall, 354 respondents reached the final game round, and 1,758 respondents across both groups completed the second part of the survey (1,007 in the control group and 751 in the treatment group). Attrition occurred primarily between completing the first survey block and launching the game, as well as between launching the game and completing the first round. Because the survey and the game were self-administered and voluntary, detailed reasons for dropout are not systematically available.

Figure 5. Study flow and attrition.

Participants and Group Composition

In this subsection we examine which respondents participated in the game and explore key group differences in socio-demographic variables and pre-existing attitudes. These analyses thus inform about the game’s effectiveness to engage a wider audience, in accordance with the first part of the research question.

Figure 6 shows the number of rounds played in the game by the treatment and control groups. While both groups exhibit a similar number of respondents entering the game, many more respondents in the control group exited within the first round, whereas a substantially larger share of the treatment group played until the final round. This indicates that participants who received an explicit invitation to play the game (i.e., the treatment group) exhibited greater engagement with it than

Figure 6. Rounds played in the game, by random treatment assignment.

those in the control group, who were only informed about the optional game after completing both parts of the survey. To examine in more detail how engagement with the game relates to respondents’ socio-demographic and attitudinal characteristics, we define “engagement” as playing a minimum of seven (out of ten) rounds. This threshold is somewhat arbitrary but does not materially affect the results. As shown in Figure 6, most respondents either did not enter the game, exited before completing the first round, or completed all ten rounds.

To explore potential associations between game engagement patterns and socio-demographic variables, we consider age, gender, language, and educational attainment levels (see Figure 7). Looking at the age distribution of respondents by engagement, the median age for the group of engaged respondents has a lower median age (40 years old) compared to the non-engaged respondents (51 years old). This reflects similar patterns observed in the Canadian context by Yiannakoulias et al. [21], who employed a serious game in their study and noted a over-representation of respondents aged 20 to 39. Regarding gender, we see that respondents identifying as male or nonbinary have slightly higher proportions of engagement with the game compared to female respondents. In contrast, there are no distinct patterns based on the language of the respondents. A slightly higher percentage of individuals from tertiary and secondary 1 education levels engaged with the game compared to those from secondary 2.

Figure 7. Game engagement by socio-demographic groups.

Figure 8 depicts game engagement by varying political attitudes. In general, the findings reveal that the game engaged people with varying attitudes to a similar degree. However, it can be observed that participation was slightly higher among respondents with a politically left-leaning political orientation and among respondents with a higher climate concern, as well as among respondents who stated at the beginning of the survey that they consider energy politics a priority issue.

Figure 8. Game engagement by political attitudes.

Discussion

Overall, the findings portray mixed conclusions. On one hand, assuming a “glass half-empty” position, it can be emphasised that an important share of respondents, despite being assigned to the treatment, did not engage with the game. Moreover, game engagement showed to be systematically dependent on socio-demographic and attitudinal factors. In view of the fact that especially less interested and less educated individuals were less likely to engage with the game, it can be concluded that the serious game was likely not able to reach and engage those individuals who would profit most from it. Rather, the capacity to form preferences on energy transition pathways and game engagement is likely driven by similar factors. This interpretation is supported by additional quantitative, pre-registered analyses on efficacy and policy support reported elsewhere [54]. These findings indicate that there were no general treatment effects on either individual or collective efficacy beliefs. Accordingly, playing the game did not lead to a significant increase in people’s perceptions of their own, or society’s, ability to advance energy transitions [54].

On the other hand, however, a “glass half-full” position is also reasonable. Roughly a quarter of the treatment group did intensively engage with the game. Moreover, while the socio-demographic and attitudinal differences between players and non-players were statistically significant, they were in many cases not substantial in size. In particular, educational differences, which are known to be important drivers of higher sensitisation and acceptance of the energy transition and of receptivity to information information treatments, are small. These patterns suggest that the game was relatively successful in reaching individuals with lower educational resources.

Conclusions

Review

In this paper, we motivated and described the development of a serious game around the Swiss energy transition and its integration into a large-scale population survey to evaluate the game’s potential as an effective information tool. As the article documents, the game was successfully designed, developed and released as an interdisciplinary collaboration between political science, computational science, and professional game and graphic designers. This interdisciplinarity enabled us to create a game that is as realistic as possible in terms of the pathways for the Swiss energy system towards net zero.

Integrating a serious game into a large-scale population survey proved to be a high-risk high-gain strategy. Previous research suggested that the immersive nature of a serious game could facilitate individual preference formation in the complex energy field, especially for those without strong prior knowledge or motivation to engage with the topic in a more traditional way. However, from a survey design perspective, it was unclear to what extent a broader population sample would be willing to engage with a serious game within a survey context. In general, this study demonstrated that the approach worked rather well, as only a relatively low number of respondents were deterred from the survey because of the game treatment.

Based on the successful integration of the game into a population survey three important conclusions can be drawn. First, the game “works”, i.e. it is in itself engaging and self-explanatory. User comments which were submitted alongside both the survey and game suggest that the game was evaluated positively by many (interested) players. Second, our analyses of socio-demographic and attitudinal characteristics of the players documents that the game was able to engage clearly beyond the stereotypical group of young males. While men were slightly more likely to engage with the game, the difference is not large. The same is true for education and age. It is also important to note that, even though the energy transition is strongly politicized in Switzerland, players with different ideological views engaged with the game in a similar way. Finally however, one caveat is that individuals less climate concern and those less interested in politics seem difficult to reach.

Insights for Future Design

The question that guided this study was whether a serious game about energy transition can engage the broader population and can thus eventually be an effective tool for sensitisation and information. In addition to the empirical findings presented here, we want to return to this question from the perspective of game design. Our experience shows that the key element in design is to find the balance between the complexity of the information which is presented and the simplicity required for the game to be accessible and enjoyable for the players. While the interdisciplinary work was an important element for the game to become relevant, playable and feasible at the same time, the different disciplinary perspectives also are a challenge in terms of varying interests and expertise.

Moreover, from the analysis of the results and from user feedback, it is clear that those interested and invested in the subject matter were happy to engage with the game. What is harder is to engage those who are not naturally drawn to the subject matter or intimidated by its complexity. We further note that the game was developed for a desktop-only browser environment. It became apparent during the survey that potential players were attempting to access the game using smartphone browsers, but were not able to continue due to the incompatibility of their devices. This represents a loss of engagement and data from a potentially valuable cohort to the study, most notably young people, who could, in turn, be hardest to engage through formal channels. We would advise future serious game designers Therefore, future studies should fully support smartphone users. The size and functionality of a touchscreen user interface thus places constraints on gameplay design which should be carefully considered.

Research Implications

A potential of the game that has not been exploited yet is the analysis of data collected in-game that records decisions relating to energy conversion technology, nuclear power decommissioning and political policy will be further analysed. For this, more players need to play the game to make this information a rich source for future analyses. Moreover, the model that provides the foundation for the game can be used independently and will be used to generate data for further studies.

While our analyses pointed to the limitation in reaching the broader population, a fruitful approach for future dissemination and research activities could be the game’s use in the educational sector. It can be assumed that students at the secondary II or tertiary level would be a suitable target group for the game. Further research could systematically evaluate whether the integration of the game in the classroom could be more effective than targeting the broader population.

Together, these additional analyses and perspectives will provide further insight as to whether developing a serious game is worthwhile for social science research and knowledge transfer purposes.

Acknowledgments

The research published in this report was carried out with the support of the Swiss Federal Office of Energy (SFOE) as part of the SWEET SURE consortium. The authors bear sole responsibility for the conclusions and the results presented in this publication. We thank all those who helped us testing the game and the participants recruited through the scientific survey.

References

  1. [1]Swiss Federal Office of Energy, “Langfristige Klimastrategie der Schweiz,” 2021.
  2. [2]J. Baker, M. Kammerer, P. Castro, and K. Ingold, “The vertical policy harmonization indices: assessing the gap between climate mitigation pledges and policies,” Climate Policy, 2025.
  3. [3]V. Panos, R. Kannan, S. Hirschberg, and T. Kober, “An assessment of energy system transformation pathways to achieve net-zero carbon dioxide emissions in Switzerland,” Communications Earth & Environment, vol. 4, 05 2023.DOI
  4. [4]E. Trutnevyte, J.-P. Sasse, V. Heinisch, M. Dukan, P. Gabrielli, J. Garrison, P. Jain, S. Renggli, G. Sansavini, C. Schaffner, M. Schwarz, B. Steffen, J. Dujardin, M. Lehning, P. Ripoll, P. Thalman, M. Viele, and I. Stadelmann-Steffen, “Renewable Energy Outlook for Switzerland,” Université de Genève, Tech. Rep., 2024.
  5. [5]C. Dermont, K. Ingold, L. Kammermann, and I. Stadelmann-Steffen, “Bringing the policy making perspective in: A political science approach to social acceptance,” Energy Policy, vol. 108, pp. 359–368, 9 2017. [Online]. Available: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421517303531
  6. [6]V. Bosetti, I. Colantonе, C. E. D. Vries, and G. Musto, “Green backlash and right-wing populism,” 8 2025.
  7. [7]I. Stadelmann-Steffen, “Citizens as veto players: Climate change policy and the constraints of direct democracy,” Environmental Politics, vol. 20, pp. 485–507, 2011.DOI
  8. [8]G. Delafield, C. Donnison, P. Roddis, T. Arvanitopoulos, A. Sfyridis, S. Dunnett, T. S. Ball, and K. G. Logan, “Conceptual framework for balancing society and nature in net-zero energy transitions,” Environmental Science & Policy, vol. 125, pp. 189–201, Nov. 2021.DOI
  9. [9]G. Perlaviciute and L. Steg, “Contextual and psychological factors shaping evaluations and acceptability of energy alternatives: Integrated review and research agenda,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 35, pp. 361–381, 2014. [Online]. Available: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364032114002305DOI
  10. [10]Y. Blumer, L. Braunreiter, A. Kachi, R. Lordan-Perret, and F. Oeri, “A two-level analysis of public support : exploring the role of beliefs in opinions about the Swiss energy strategy,” Energy research and social science, vol. 43, pp. 109–118, Jun. 2018.DOI
  11. [11]I. Stadelmann-Steffen, K. Ingold, S. Rieder, C. Dermont, L. Kammermann, and C. Strotz, Akzeptanz erneuerbarer Energie. Universität Bern, Interface Politkstudien Forschung Beratung, EAWAG, 2018.
  12. [12]I. Stadelmann-Steffen and C. Dermont, “The unpopularity of incentive-based instruments: what improves the cost-benefit ratio?” Public Choice, vol. 175, no. 1-2, pp. 37–62, 2018. [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11127-018-0513-9
  13. [13]J. W. Stoutenborough and A. Vedlitz, “The effect of perceived and assessed knowledge of climate change on public policy concerns: An empirical comparison,” Environmental Science & Policy, vol. 37, pp. 23–33, 3 2014.DOI
  14. [14]R. Bürgisser, I. Stadelmann-Steffen, and K. Armingeon, “Can information, compensation and party cues increase mass support for green taxes?” Journal of European Public Policy, p. 1–28, Dec. 2024.
  15. [15]A. Fremstad, M. Mildenberger, M. Paul, and I. Stadelmann-Steffen, “The role of rebates in public support for carbon taxes,” Environmental Research Letters, vol. 17, 2022.DOI
  16. [16]A. H. Aubert, R. Bauer, and J. Lienert, “A review of water-related serious games to specify use in environmental Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis,” Environmental Modelling & Software, vol. 105, pp. 64–78, Jul. 2018. [Online]. Available: https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S1364815217307661DOI
  17. [17]D. Kahneman, “Maps of bounded rationality: A perspective on intuitive judgment and choice. prize lecture, december, 8, 2002//the nobel foundation,” 2003.
  18. [18]G. B. Chapman and E. J. Johnson, “Incorporating the irrelevant: Anchors in judgments of belief and value,” in Heuristics and Biases: The Psychology of Intuitive Judgment, T. Gilovich, D. Griffin, and D. Kahneman, Eds. Cambridge University Press, 2002, p. 120–138.DOI
  19. [19]J. S. Lerner, Y. Li, P. Valdesolo, and K. S. Kassam, “Emotion and decision making,” Annual Review of Psychology, vol. 66, no. 1, pp. 799–823, 2015, pMID: 25251484. [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-010213-115043
  20. [20]J. N. Gordon and N. Yiannakoulias, “A serious gaming approach to understanding household flood risk mitigation decisions,” Journal of Flood Risk Management, vol. 13, no. 4, Dec. 2020. [Online]. Available: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jfr3.12648DOI
  21. [21]N. Yiannakoulias, J. N. Gordon, and J. C. Darlington, “The decision game: a serious game approach to understanding environmental risk management decisions,” Journal of Risk Research, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 81–94, Jan. 2020. [Online]. Available: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13669877.2018.1517379DOI
  22. [22]F. Keusch and C. Zhang, “A review of issues in gamified surveys,” Social Science Computer Review, vol. 35, no. 2, pp. 147–166, 2017.
  23. [23]D. Goldstein, S. Becker, and T. Sweeney, “Getting serious about play. observations from an experiment in gamified research,” in CASRO 2013 Online Research Conference, San Francisco, CA. Retrieved April, vol. 13, 2013, p. 2015.
  24. [24]G. Bekebrede, E. van Bueren, and I. Wenzler, “Towards a Joint Local Energy Transition Process in Urban Districts: The GOZero Simulation Game,” Sustainability, vol. 10, no. 8, p. 2602, Jul. 2018. [Online]. Available: http://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/10/8/2602
  25. [25]C. Ampatzidou and K. Gugerell, “Mapping Game Mechanics for Learning in a Serious Game for the Energy Transition:,” International Journal of E-Planning Research, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 1–23, Apr. 2019. [Online]. Available: http://services.igi-global.com/resolvedoi/resolve.aspx?doi=10.4018/IJEPR.2019040101
  26. [26]R. Kazhamiakin, A. Marconi, M. Perillo, M. Pistore, G. Valetto, L. Piras, F. Avesani, and N. Perri, “Using gamification to incentivize sustainable urban mobility,” in 2015 IEEE First International Smart Cities Conference (ISC2), 2015, pp. 1–6.
  27. [27]K. Schiele, Utilizing Gamification to Promote Sustainable Practices. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2018, pp. 427–444. [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-71312-0_16
  28. [28]J. Cechanowicz, C. Browne, B. Brownell, and L. Goodfellow, “Effects of gamification on participation and data quality in a real-world market research domain,” in Proceedings of the First International Conference on Gameful Design, Research, and Applications, ser. Gamification ’13. New York, NY, USA: Association for Computing Machinery, 2013, p. 58–65. [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1145/2583008.2583016
  29. [29]M. Sailer, J. U. Hense, S. K. Mayr, and H. Mandl, “How gamification motivates: An experimental study of the effects of specific game design elements on psychological need satisfaction,” Computers in Human Behavior, vol. 69, pp. 371–380, 2017. [Online]. Available: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S074756321630855X
  30. [30]A. Bandura, Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive theory. Prentice Hall Inc., 1986. [Online]. Available: https://books.google.com/books?hl=de&lr=&id=PdY9o315vpYC&oi=fnd&pg=PA94&ots=uHb_rV_j7M&sig=ld7wOiBR5jAnbY5lnDqZW8PG4vU
  31. [31]J. Harms, S. Biegler, C. Wimmer, K. Kappel, and T. Grechenig, “Gamification of online surveys: Design process, case study, and evaluation,” in Human-Computer Interaction – INTERACT 2015, J. Abascal, S. Barbosa, M. Fetter, T. Gross, P. Palanque, and M. Winckler, Eds. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2015, pp. 219–236.DOI
  32. [32]A. Aubert and J. Lienert, “Gamified online surveys to elicit citizens’ preferences and enhance learning for environmental decisions,” Environmental Modelling & Software, vol. 111, 09 2018.DOI
  33. [33]J. Abad, L. Booth, A. Baills, K. Fleming, M. Leone, L. Schueller, and B. Petrovic, “Assessing policy preferences amongst climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction stakeholders using serious gaming,” International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, vol. 51, p. 101782, Dec. 2020. [Online]. Available: https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S221242092031284XDOI
  34. [34]D. Djaouti, J. Alvarez, and J.-P. Jessel, “Classifying serious games: the g/p/s model,” Handbook of Research on Improving Learning and Motivation through Educational Games: Multidisciplinary Approaches, 01 2011.
  35. [35]M. Köksalan, J. Wallenius, and S. Zionts, Multiple Criteria Decision Making: From Early History to the 21st Century, ser. World Scientific Books. World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd., 2011, no. 8042. [Online]. Available: https://ideas.repec.org/b/wsi/wsbook/8042.html
  36. [36]Molleindustria.org, “Simcities and simcrises,” 2017, keynote at International City Gaming Conference, Rotterdam, 2017. [Online]. Available: https://molleindustria.org/GamesForCities/
  37. [37]Federal Assembly, “Energiegesetz (EnG),” https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/cc/2016/1642/de, 30 2016, [Accessed 05-08-2025].
  38. [38]“Simcity,” 1989. [Online]. Available: https://www.ea.com/en-gb/games/simcity
  39. [39]J. Schmid, Decentralization and Wind Energy Permitting, 1st ed., ser. Politik und Demokratie in den kleineren Ländern Europas | Politics and Governance in the Smaller European Democracies. Baden-Baden: Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft mbH & Co. KG, 2024, vol. 20. [Online]. Available: http://dx.doi.org/10.5771/978374894454-1
  40. [40]The Godot Foundation, “Godot.” [Online]. Available: https://godotengine.org
  41. [41]Swiss Federal Office of Energy (SFOE), “Schweizerische gesamtenergiestatistik 2022,” 2022. [Online]. Available: https://www.bfe.admin.ch/bfe/en/home/supply/statistics-and-geodata/energy-statistics/overall-energy-statistics.html/
  42. [42]——, “Switzerland energy balance,” 2022. [Online]. Available: https://opendata.swiss/en/dataset/energiebilanz-der-schweiz
  43. [43]Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN), “Latest greenhouse gas inventory of switzerland,” 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.bafu.admin.ch/bafu/en/home/topics/climate/state/data.html
  44. [44]——, “Switzerland’s greenhouse gas inventory 1990–2022,” 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.bafu.admin.ch/bafu/en/home/topics/climate/state/data/climate-reporting/ghg-inventories/latest.html
  45. [45]C. Weber, D. Möst, and W. Fichtner, Economics of Power Systems: Fundamentals for Sustainable Energy, ser. Springer Texts in Business and Economics. Springer International Publishing, 2022. [Online]. Available: https://books.google.ch/books?id=xmPtzgEACA AJ
  46. [46]P. B. Berntsen and E. Trutnevyte, “Ensuring diversity of national energy scenarios: Bottom-up energy system model with modeling to generate alternatives,” Energy, vol. 126, pp. 886–898, 2017. [Online]. Available: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360544217304097
  47. [47]E. Trutnevyte, “Does cost optimization approximate the real-world energy transition?” Energy, vol. 106, pp. 182–193, 2016. [Online]. Available: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360544216302821DOI
  48. [48]Swiss Energy-Charts, “Public net electricity generation in switzerland,” 2024. [Online]. Available: https://www.energy-charts.info
  49. [49]G. Xekakis, R. Hansmann, S. P. Volken, and E. Trutnevyte, “Models on the wrong track: Model-based electricity supply scenarios in switzerland are not aligned with the perspectives of energy experts and the public,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 134, p. 110297, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364032120305852
  50. [50]M. Ghodsvali, G. Dane, and B. de Vries, “An online serious game for decision-making on food-water-energy nexus policy,” Sustainable Cities and Society, vol. 87, p. 104220, 2022. [Online]. Available: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221067702200525X
  51. [51]S. Holzer, A. Dubois, J. Cousse, G. Xekakis, and E. Trutnevyte, “Swiss electricity supply scenarios: Perspectives from the young generation,” Energy and Climate Change, vol. 4, p. 100109, 05 2023.DOI
  52. [52]Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN), “Klimawirkung von treibhausgasen und weiteren substanzen,” 2023. [Online]. Available: https://www.bafu.admin.ch/bafu/en/home/dokumente/klima/fachinfo-daten/CO2_Emissionsfaktoren_THG_Inventar.pdf
  53. [53]G. King, R. Nielsen, C. Chernev, J. E. Pope, and A. Wells, “Avoiding randomization failure in program evaluation, with application to the medicare health support program,” Population Health Management, vol. 14, no. S1, pp. S–11–S–22, 2011. [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1089/pop.2010.0074
  54. [54]G. Brückmann, W. El-Ajou, and I. Stadelmann-Steffen, “When citizens and researchers learn from a serious game—An experimental analysis of information and efficacy in political opinion formation,” SocArXiv, no. x5u6b_v1, Jan. 2026. [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/x5u6b_v1

Paper details

vlnc:W_htt3wwa5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 2

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Computer Science

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents