betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Structure-Property Correlation of Cr/Cu-MnFeCoNi High-Entropy Alloys for Alkaline Water Electrolysis

Abstract

High-entropy alloys (HEAs), with their unique compositional-complexity and tunable surface chemistry, have emerged as promising electrocatalysts for energy conversion. The catalytic activity of HEA often arises from the interplay between the intrinsic activity of the individual elements and the synergistic effects generated at the interfaces. Even a single-element substitution in a multicomponent HEA can substantially alter the surface-chemistry and electrochemical kinetics of the active surface. Here we investigated the structure-property relationship of CrMnFeCoNi (HEA-Cr) and MnFeCoNiCu (HEA-Cu) HEAs by comparing the alkaline hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and oxygen evolution reaction (OER) activity. Under the same experimental condition, HEA-Cu outperforms HEA-Cr towards both HER and OER. Substituting Cr with Cu significantly enhances the bifunctional activity, where HEA-Cu achieved a lower overpotential (538 mV) and Tafel slope (165 mVdec-1) when compared with HEA-Cr. Computational analysis corroborates these findings, showing that Cu substitution modulates the electronic-structure to provide favorable binding energies for reaction intermediates (H*, O*, OH*, and OOH*). Interestingly, unlike HER, recovered HEA-Cu after OER showed migration of Cu forming a Cu-rich outer layer shell with a multimetallic core. These findings demonstrate the potential of single-element substitution in HEAs as a strategy for designing high-performance, cost-effective catalysts for efficient water electrolysis.

Introduction

The growing demand for sustainable hydrogen production has intensified the search for advanced electrocatalysts capable of replacing noble-metal-based materials in water-splitting systems. Although Pt-, Ru-, and Ir-based catalysts exhibit excellent hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and oxygen evolution reaction (OER) activity, their scarcity, high cost, and limited long-term availability restrict large-scale implementation[1, 2, 3]. High-entropy alloys (HEAs), composed of multiple principal elements distributed within a single or near-single-phase solid solution, have emerged as a promising catalyst platform. The compositionally complex atomic environments of HEAs enable simultaneous modulation of electronic structure, adsorption energetics, lattice strain, charge transfer, and surface reconstruction. Unlike conventional mono- or bimetallic catalysts, HEAs provide a broad compositional design space in which neighboring atomic configurations can generate diverse catalytic sites and tune the adsorption of reaction intermediates. The catalytic activity of a HEA often arises from the interplay between the intrinsic activity of the individual elements and the synergistic effects generated at the interfaces within its structure. Understanding this interplay includes designing high-performance HEA via compositional optimization for favorable adsorption/desorption of reaction intermediates subject to Sabatier relations which is crucial for electrocatalysis.[4, 5, 6, 7]

Recent reports demonstrate that compositional tuning in Fe-Co-Ni-Cu-Mn/Zn-based HEAs can substantially influence both HER and OER activity. In particular, substitution of Mn by Zn in Fe-Co-Ni-Cu-based HEAs was shown to alter reaction energetics and improve bifunctional water-splitting performance, highlighting the sensitivity of catalytic behavior to the identity of a single constituent element.[8] The importance of compositional tuning in HEAs is also evident from recent supercapacitor studies. Related studies on FeCoNiCrZn/Mn HEAs also showed that replacing one transition-metal component can shift the d-band characteristics and modify electrochemical behavior through multielement electronic synergy.[9] In addition, nanostructuring of multicomponent Fe-Co-Ni-Cu-Zn HEAs has been reported to increase accessible surface area and alter the electrochemical response, emphasizing that catalytic performance is governed not only by composition but also by particle size, defect density, surface oxidation, and elemental distribution.[10] Interestingly, replacing Cr with Cu in the MnFeCoNi framework has also been reported to provide competitive or slightly enhanced charge-storage behavior. indicating that Cu incorporation can preserve the pseudocapacitive response of the parent Mn-Fe-Co-Ni system while modifying its electronic structure and surface redox chemistry. The nearly comparable capacitance values of CrMnFeCoNi and MnFeCoNiCu suggest that both compositions possess multiple redox-active transition-metal centers; however, the identity of the fifth element is expected to influence charge-transfer resistance, surface oxidation behavior, ion accessibility, and the balance between capacitive and diffusion-controlled processes. HEA with a theoretical composition of Ni14Co14Fe14Mo6Mn52\mathrm{Ni}_{14}\mathrm{Co}_{14}\mathrm{Fe}_{14}\mathrm{Mo}_{6}\mathrm{Mn}_{52} has been synthesized for HER and OER bifunctional catalytic activity for efficient water splitting.[11] Another theoretical calculation demonstrated that Ni exhibits a downshifted d-band center once alloyed by Cu, which promoted the desorption of H from the Ni surface to improve the catalytic activity for hydrogenation reactions.[12] In another work, four adjacent 3d-metal elements (Fe, Co, Ni, and Mn) were assembled to form an HEA without phase separation. The HEA with a high d-band center where Mn has the largest atomic radius among the composition was found to be a face-centered cubic (fcc) phase without phase separation and it showed substantial OER catalytic activity which was further enhanced after modification of d-band center using Pt and Ir.[13]

All these findings highlight that even a single-element substitution in a multicomponent alloy can substantially alter the redox accessibility and electrochemical kinetics of the active surface. Among transition-metal HEAs, the CrMnFeCoNi Cantor alloy is one of the most extensively studied model systems because of its relatively stable face-centered cubic structure, compositional homogeneity that allows scope to investigate structure-property relationships.[9, 14, 15, 16, 17] In particular, Cr is generally associated with the formation of stable oxide/hydroxide surface layers and improved structural durability, whereas replacing Cu may promote electronic conductivity, local compositional heterogeneity, and modify adsorption/desorption kinetics of the redox intermediates. Therefore, comparing CrMnFeCoNi (HEA-Cr) and MnFeCoNiCu (HEA-Cu) provides an opportunity to establish composition-structure-electrocatalytic activity relationships in structurally related HEAs, yet to be reported. Such a systematic study can clarify how Cr-to-Cu substitution affects phase constitution, electronic structure, electrochemically active surface area, reaction kinetics, surface reconstruction, and long-term stability, thereby guiding the rational design of low-cost multicomponent alloy catalysts for efficient water electrolysis.

Results and discussion

Structural analysis

The equiatomic FeCoNiCrMn alloy nanoparticles were synthesized via arc melting followed by cryo-milling. Room-temperature X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis confirmed the formation of a single-phase face-centered cubic (FCC) solid solution in both the bulk alloy and the cryomilled powder, crystallizing in the Fm-3m space group. The diffraction pattern exhibited characteristic reflections at 2θ≈43.5∘2\theta\approx43.5^\circ, 50.6∘50.6^\circ, 74.4∘74.4^\circ, 90.3∘90.3^\circ, and 95.6∘95.6^\circ, corresponding to the (111), (200), (220), (311), and (222) crystallographic planes, respectively (fig:S1). These diffraction peaks agree well with the standard reference pattern for the Co–Cr–Fe–Mn–Ni alloy system (JCPDS No. 04-029-1381). They are consistent with previously reported results for as-cast CoCrFeMnNi alloys. [18, 19, 20] fig:1a presents the XRD pattern of the synthesized HEA-Cu nanoparticles. Subsequent substitution of Cr with Cu did not induce any phase transformation, and the alloy retained its single-phase FCC structure. Notably, the systematic shift of the diffraction peaks indicates that although Cu inclusion into the FeCoNiMn matrix did not change the crystal structure, it did cause a modest adjustment of the lattice parameters, resulting from the lattice distortion effect and which might also influence the high-entropy effect. [12] These observations confirm the successful formation of a Cu-containing FCC HEA while preserving the structural integrity of the parent alloy. The elemental composition and oxidation states of the HEA-Cu high-entropy alloy nanoparticles were further examined by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), as illustrated in fig:1b-g. The survey-scan XPS spectrum (fig:1b) confirms the presence of Co, Cu, Fe, Mn, and Ni, demonstrating the successful incorporation of Cu into the CoFeMnNi alloy structure.

The high-resolution Cu 2p XPS spectrum (Figure 1) exhibits two distinct peaks centered at 932.5 and 952.3 eV, corresponding to the Cu 2p3/2_{3/2} and Cu 2p1/2_{1/2} spin–orbit components, respectively. [21] The satellite peaks at 933.2 and 954.2 eV are associated to Cu 2p. The dominant peaks at 932.5 and 952.3 eV suggest that copper predominantly exists in the Cu(I) (Cu+^{+} oxidation state). Furthermore, the Cu LMM Auger peak observed at approximately 570 eV in the survey spectrum (Figure 1) provides additional evidence for the presence of Cu+^{+} species. Cu2+^{2+} is characterized by weak shake-up satellite features that appear in the 940–945 eV region. Weak shake-up satellite features in the 940–945 eV range are characteristic of Cu2+^{2+}. Since metallic Cu never has a satellite peak, the presence of shakeup peaks further supports the absence of CuO. As shown in Figure 1, the high-resolution Ni 2p spectrum can be deconvoluted into four components. The peaks located at 886.2 and 872.8 eV are assigned to the Ni 2p3/2_{3/2} and Ni 2p1/2_{1/2} levels, respectively, indicating the presence of Ni2+^{2+} species. The peaks at 887.7 and 861.9 eV correspond to characteristic satellite features of Ni 2p. In addition, a peak observed at 852.2 eV is attributed to metallic Ni0^{0} (Ni 2p3/2_{3/2}), suggesting a minor fraction of elemental nickel within the alloy nanoparticles. [22] The Co 2p spectrum (Figure 1) is resolved into four distinct peaks. Co3+^{3+} species have peaks at 780.4 eV (Co 2p3/2_{3/2}) and 796.7 eV (Co 2p1/2_{1/2}), while Co2+^{2+} has peaks at 786.1 and 803.4 eV (Co 2p3/2_{3/2} and Co 2p1/2_{1/2}, respectively). [23] Two satellite peaks are also present. These results indicate the coexistence of both +2 and +3 oxidation states of cobalt on the nanoparticle surface. Fe 2p XPS (Figure 1) spectrum shows two prominent peaks for Fe 2p3/2_{3/2} and Fe 2p1/2_{1/2}, which are deconvoluted into four peaks and a satellite peak, indicating the coexistence of Fe in +3 and +2 valence states. [24] No peak for Fe metal is found. The high-resolution Mn 2p spectrum shown in Figure 1 exhibits two well-defined peaks centered at 645.8 and 659.4 eV, corresponding to the Mn 2p3/2_{3/2} and Mn 2p1/2_{1/2} spin–orbit components, respectively. [25] These binding energies are characteristic of Mn4+^{4+} species, indicating that manganese predominantly exists in the +4 oxidation state within the alloy nanoparticles. Overall, the XPS analysis reveals that Cu, Ni, and Mn are present predominantly in single oxidation states, namely Cu+^{+}, Ni2+^{2+}, and Mn4+^{4+}, respectively. In contrast, Fe and Co exhibit mixed-valence characteristics, suggesting the coexistence of multiple

Characterization of MnFeCoNiCu: (a) XRD; (b-g) XPS; (h-i) TEM analysis (j-o) TEM elemental mapping

Figure 1. Characterization of MnFeCoNiCu: (a) XRD; (b-g) XPS; (h-i) TEM analysis (j-o) TEM elemental mapping.

oxidation states on the nanoparticle surface. Detailed XPS analysis of the HEA-Cr alloy shown in fig:S2 demonstrates the predominant presence of Ni2+^{2+}, Co2+/3+^{2+/3+}, Mn4+^{4+}, Fe2+/3+^{2+/3+} and Cr3+/6+^{3+/6+}. Overall, the XPS analysis reveals that Ni, and Mn are present predominantly in single oxidation states, namely, Ni2+^{2+}, and Mn4+^{4+}, respectively. In contrast, Fe, Co and Cu exhibit mixed-valence characteristics, suggesting the coexistence of multiple oxidation states on the nanoparticle surface.

The microstructural characteristics of the HEA-Cr and HEA-Cu high-entropy alloys were further investigated. SEM analysis of the HEA-Cu (fig:S3) and HEA-Cr (fig:S4) shows homogeneous distribution of the elements. Furthermore, the low- and high-magnification HRTEM images are presented in Figure 1 (h–i) and fig:S5. The high-resolution image of HEA-Cu in Figure 1i reveals well-defined lattice fringes, indicative of the high crystallinity of the synthesized nanoparticles. The measured interplanar spacing of approximately 0.25 nm, corresponds to the (111) crystallographic plane of the FCC HEA structure. The absence of additional lattice features or secondary phases confirms the formation of a single-phase alloy, in agreement with the XRD results. Furthermore, the high-angle annular dark-field scanning transmission electron microscopy (HAADF-STEM) image (Figure 1o) and the corresponding elemental mapping images (Figure 1j–n) demonstrate a uniform spatial distribution of Co, Cu, Fe, Mn, and Ni throughout the nanoparticles. No evidence of elemental segregation or agglomeration is observed, confirming the homogeneous incorporation of all constituent elements within the HEA matrix.

Electrochemical Characterization

Activity of both HEA-Cr and HEA-Cu was investigated for both HER and OER in 1M alkaline water splitting a series of electrochemical tests. To understand the actual process, the catalyst ink was prepared without any conducting carbon and has been used for electrocatalysis study. The performance of the HEA-Cu catalyst was compared with the HEA-Cr analog and pure Cu. Optimization of ink loading was also done and the best result for homogeneous ink loading on GCE surface was found to be 0.5mg cm−2^{-2}. Linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) polarization curves

HER activity of MnFeCoNiCu HEA in 1M KOH

Figure 2. HER activity of MnFeCoNiCu HEA in 1M KOH: (a, b) LSV curves and Tafel plot of HEAs and Cu for HER, respectively; (c, d) LSV and Tafel plot of HEAs and Cu for OER, respectively. (e, f) ECSA measurement: (e) CV plot at different scan rate and (f) current density vs scan rate plot.

were employed to analyze the HER activity, as illustrated in fig:2a. Cu required an overpotential of 0.786 V vs RHE to achieve a current density of 10 mA cm−2\mathrm{mA\,cm^{-2}}. In contrast, the onset potential for CrMnFeCoNi and MnFeCoNiCu were observed to 0.601 and 0.538 V vs RHE, demonstrating superior performance over replacement of Cr by Cu. Tafel analysis is a valuable tool for elucidating electrocatalytic kinetics and identifying the potential rate-determining step (RDS) of the reaction.[2, 6] The reaction mechanism for both materials was further studied through Tafel analysis, as shown in fig:2b. The Tafel slopes obtained were 226 mV dec−1\mathrm{mV\,dec^{-1}}, 184 and 165 mV dec−1\mathrm{mV\,dec^{-1}} for Cu, CrMnFeCoNi and MnFeCoNiCu, respectively. These values correspond to the Volmer-Heyrovsky mechanism governing the reaction. These results indicate that the synergy of the five metals in the high entropy alloy enhances the catalytic HER activity compared to single Cu metal catalyst. Moreover, replacing Cr with Cu in HEA structure facilitates the kinetics and result in enhancement in activity. For further understanding, EIS measurement was conducted for both HEA-Cr and HEA-Cu HEAs. Electrocatalysis activity testing results under OER reaction condition are shown in fig:2c, fig:2d. HEA-Cu was found to lower overpotential 10 mA cm−2\mathrm{10\,mA\,cm^{-2}} and Tafel slope than HEA-Cr, suggesting improvement in activity via compositional modification.

Electrochemical Active Surface area (ECSA) value of HEA-Cu was further evaluated by determining the double layer capacitance (CdlC_{\mathrm{dl}}) value (fig:2e, fig:2f). Corresponding CdlC_{\mathrm{dl}} and ECSA values were found to be 0.12 mF cm−2\mathrm{mF\,cm^{-2}} and 3 cm2\mathrm{cm^2}.

To assess the structural stability and surface chemistry of HEA-Cu, accelerated degradation tests (ADT) were conducted. After 3000 cycles, an increase in the catalytic activity was observed, as depicted in fig:3a. The onset potential decreased by 22.8 mV. This improvement can be attributed to the structural stabilization of the HEA and possible activation of the surface.

Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy was carried out to determine the charge-transfer resistance (RCTR_{\mathrm{CT}}) values for the HEA, both before and after 3000 cycles. Figure 3 shows the Nyquist plots, where the x- and y-axes represent the real and negative imaginary parts of impedance, respectively. These plots were fitted using an equivalent Randles circuit. The RCTR_{\mathrm{CT}} values obtained were 339 Ω\Omega and 208 Ω\Omega before and after 3000 cycles, respectively. These values align with the results from the ADT studies, indicating a significant improvement in the charge-transfer mechanisms after cycling. This enhancement boosts the catalytic activity and reduces the RCTR_{\mathrm{CT}} value of the HEA. For OER, a decrease in current density value was observed after 3000 cylces at higher potential region (fig:3c). However, no significant change in overpotential was observed, which suggests good stability of HEA-Cu during OER. Corroborating the LSV data obtained before and after OER, a slight increase in RCTR_{\mathrm{CT}} value in EIS analysis (fig:3d) after 3000 cycles also suggests change in activity.

Stability analysis of MnFeCoNiCu by accelerated durability test for 3000 cycles, showing LSV and EIS plots for HER and OER

Figure 3. Stability analysis of MnFeCoNiCu by accelerated durability test for 3000 cycles. (a, b) LSV and EIS for HER; (c, d) LSV and EIS for HER.

TEM analysis of the recovered catalysts after HER (Figure 4) and OER (Figure 5) were done to investigate the structural change/reconstruction that might influence the HER/OER activity behavior. TEM analysis results of the recovered HEA-Cu after HER and OER are shown in Figure 4, Figure 5 and fig:S5. It is noteworthy that crystalline structure of the HEA catalyst retained after the ADT testing as can be seen from the fringes present in fig:4b, fig:5b. Interestingly, unlike HER,

TEM images, HRTEM image, and TEM-EDS elemental mapping of recovered HEA-Cu catalysts after HER

Figure 4. TEM analysis of the recovered HEA-Cu catalysts after HER. (a) TEM images, (b) HRTEM, (c-f) TEM-EDS mapping showing the distribution of the elements.

TEM images and TEM-EDS elemental mapping of the recovered HEA-Cu catalyst after OER

Figure 5. TEM analysis of the recovered HEA-Cu catalyst after OER. (a) TEM images, (b) HRTEM, (c-h) low-magnification TEM-EDS mapping (i-k) EDS mapping of magnified area close to the outer shell showing the distribution of the elements, (l) TEM image of the corresponding outer layer region.

formation of an outer layer (fig:5c-k) was found for the catalyst recovered after OER, forming a near core-shell structure. EDS mapping on recovered catalyst after HER showed homogeneous distribution of the existing elements (fig:4c-f) without any separation. Whereas Cu found to exist on the outer layer formed after OER (fig:5d, fig:5j). Notably, the core was found to contain all five metals including Cu. These results suggest that under OER conditions, Cu tends to migrate to the surface resulting in surface structural reconstruction, which could be the reason behind activity deterioration. HER condition did not allow such migration therefore showed retention of homogeneous distribution of the elements and HER activity. The change in elemental distribution during OER can be due to high affinity of Cu with oxygen which results in diffusion of Cu atoms in oxygen rich environment. On the other hand, such layer does not form in a reducing environment (in HER) due to low affinity of hydrogen with Cu. The observation can be further supported by EDS map after HER clearly shows uniform distribution of Cu (fig:4d), whereas other elements

show redistribution during reaction (fig:4e-fig:4f). On the other hand, for OER, we observe oxygen rich Cu on the surface (fig:5j) followed by a Cu depleted region which is common in diffusion control reaction.

To demonstrate practical applicability and enable comparison with literature reports in which Vulcan carbon is usually incorporated into catalyst inks, the HER and OER activities of the HEA catalysts were also evaluated. A better kinetics were observed with an increase in overall current density values with minimal decrease in overpotential @10 mA cm−2\mathrm{cm}^{-2}, while testing HEA-Cr and HEA-Cu in 1 M KOH using inks containing 10 wt% added Vulcan carbon (fig:6a–fig:6d). The overall trend was found to be same as observed from the results obtained from no carbon added catalyst inks and other experimental conditions, HEA-Cu is better than HEA-Cr. Notably, addition of Vulcan carbon improves HER and OER performance by improving conductivity, charge transfer, catalyst dispersion, and active-site utilization. While comparing the HER overpotential values, Pt/C catalyst outperformed the HEA catalysts under same experimental condition. However, for OER, HEA-Cu showed close activity to RuO2_2 demonstrating the potential to replace the noble metal catalyst.

Computational Analysis

Detail computational investigation was conducted to support our experimental observations and determine the structure-property relationship. Our analysis began with optimizing all structures. As we had a large number of structures to optimize, it was necessary to adopt certain quality parameters for which structures we would use for catalytic activity. Thus, at the end of the optimization of the two-hundred structures (100 for HEA with Cu and 100 for HEA with Cr), we organized them by increasing energy stability. During structural optimization, we also allowed the lattice parameters to change. In general, the HEA-Cr systems preserved a more cohesive FCC framework, with the lattice angles α\alpha, β\beta, and γ\gamma deviating by approximately 0.1% from the ideal cubic value of 90°. In contrast, the HEA-Cu HEA structures exhibited pronounced distortions, with at least one lattice angle varying by 10-15%. This behavior is consistent with the difference in the van der Waals radii of Cu and Cr, since Cr presents a van der Waals radius approximately 10% larger than that of Cu, which can influence local atomic packing and the resulting structural relaxation. [26] This allows for a more cohesive structure during optimization. This can result in less atomic movement during the optimization process. We focus this analysis on the lattice angles, since the lattice vectors depend more on the initial atom distribution. Since all structures were previously ranked according to their energetic stability, the five most stable configurations of each HEA type, HEA-Cu and HEA-Cr, were selected to evaluate their HER performance.

Figure 7. (a) FeNiMnCoCu and (b) to FeNiMnCoCr, with the H atom placed at the most favorable adsorption site; (c) Gibbs Free Energy for each one of the structures. Atomic species are represented as Fe (yellow), H (red), Cu (purple), Mn (green), Co (mauve), Ni (silver), and Cr (orange).

Adsorption sites for H were identified using a Monte Carlo sampling approach, allowing the determination of the lowest-energy adsorption configuration for each of the ten selected structures.

After placing H at the most favorable adsorption site, the hydrogen adsorption free energy (ΔGH\Delta G_{\mathrm{H}}, see eq:5) was estimated considering T=300T = 300 K, pH =14= 14, and U=−0.80U = -0.80 V. Figure 6 and fig:SI present the ten structures with the H atom positioned at the energetically preferred adsorption site obtained from the Monte Carlo calculations. In Figure 6, we display the two structures with the best value of the ΔGH\Delta G_{\mathrm{H}}; meanwhile, in fig:SI, we display the rest of the configurations of HEA-Cu and HEA-Cr HEA. In case of the HEA-Cr HEA, H preferentially remains on Cr-rich regions of the surface and, in some configurations, is located nearly on top of a Cr atom, consistent with the electron-donor character commonly associated with Cr. This behavior has been related to facilitated water dissociation and multisite synergistic effects in Cr-containing HEAs.[27]

HER and OER activity plots for HEA-Cu, HEA-Cr, RuO₂, and Pt/C

Figure 6. HER and OER activity of HEA-Cu, HEA-Cr ink prepared with mixing 10% Vulcan C in 1M KOH: (a, b) LSV curves and overpotential of HEAs, respectively for HER; (c, d) LSV and overpotential of HEAs OER, respectively. Comparisons with RuO2_2 for OER and Pt/C for HER are also included.

In contrast, for the HEA-Cu HEA, even when the most favorable adsorption site lies within a Cu-rich region, the H atom tends to remain relatively distant from the nearest Cu atom, typically occupying bridge or hollow positions adjacent to Ni, Co, or Fe atoms, thus avoiding direct top-Cu binding. This trend is consistent with the higher electronegativity of Cu compared to other 3d transition metals, leading Cu to behave as an electron-acceptor species that mainly modulates the electronic environment of neighboring atoms rather than acting as the preferred adsorption center for H.[7, 28] fig:7c shows a comparison between the ΔGH\Delta G_{\mathrm{H}} value for the HEA-Cu and HEA-Cr third structures, and Table SI presents the rest of those values. fig:7c reveals that ΔGH\Delta G_{\mathrm{H}} is less negative for HEA-Cu, indicating weaker hydrogen binding than for HEA-Cr. Notably, the third-most-structurally-stable configuration in each HEA set has the highest ΔGH\Delta G_{\mathrm{H}} value, resulting in a difference of approximately 0.2 eV between the two systems. According to the Sabatier principle,[29, 30] the reaction intermediate (H∗H^{*} in this case) should exhibit moderate binding strength to favor efficient desorption and enhanced HER kinetics.[7] The obtained results are consistent with the experimental trend, in which HEA-Cu shows higher catalytic activity than HEA-Cr. Cu-containing HEAs have been frequently reported as highly active HER catalysts, where Cu contributes to the formation of optimally bound H∗H^{*} intermediates through electron-acceptor behavior and d-band modulation effects.[7, 28, 31] In contrast, Cr plays a different role: although its electron-donor character may facilitate water dissociation through cooperative multi-site interactions, Cr-rich systems tend to form Cr2O3\mathrm{Cr}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3} passivation layers under alkaline conditions, which can reduce the intrinsic HER activity.[27]

For the OER calculations, one structure was selected for each HEA type, based on the configurations previously identified in the HER analysis. A Monte Carlo sampling approach was employed to identify the most favorable adsorption site for each intermediate molecule. Figure 8(a), (b), and (c) show, respectively, O, OH, and OOH in the HEA-Cu system, whereas Figure 8(d), (e), and (f) correspond to O, OH, and OOH in FeNiMnCoCr. In both HEAs, the preferred adsorption site for OOH differs from that observed for H adsorption. Nevertheless, a similar tendency is observed: in HEA-Cu, the molecules do not preferentially adsorb near Cu atoms, and regions with lower local Cu concentration tend to be energetically favored. In contrast, in HEA-Cr, the intermediate molecules remain adsorbed on Cr-rich surface regions, typically near Cr atoms. After full structural optimization, the Gibbs free energies of the intermediate molecules were estimated as ΔGo\Delta G_{\mathrm{o}}, ΔGOH\Delta G_{\mathrm{OH}}, and ΔGOOH\Delta G_{\mathrm{OOH}}; the values are presented in Table 1. These results indicate that HEA-Cr binds more strongly than HEA-Cu with all the molecules considered during the OER process, consistent with the trend previously observed for H∗H^{*}. The stronger adsorption may influence the catalytic response by stabilizing intermediates more strongly, whereas the weaker binding observed for HEA-Cu is consistent with improved OER performance. This behavior aligns with experimental reports of higher OER activity in Cu-containing HEAs.

FeNiMnCoCu and FeNiMnCoCr structures with O, OH, and OOH intermediates

Figure 8. FeNiMnCoCu (a), (b), and (c), and FeNiMnCoCr (d), (e), and (f) structures selected from the OER analysis, with the O, OH, and OOH intermediate, respectively, placed at the most favorable adsorption site. Atomic species are represented as Fe (yellow), H (red), Cu (purple), Mn (green), Co (mauve), Ni (silver), Cr (orange), and O (blue).

MoleculeΔGo\Delta G_{\mathrm{o}}ΔGOH\Delta G_{\mathrm{OH}}ΔGOOH\Delta G_{\mathrm{OOH}}
FeNiMnCoCu-1.0-1.03-2.27
FeNiMnCoCr-1.3-1.48-3.48

Table 1. ΔG\Delta G (in eV) for the sub-reactions of the OER to the HEA-Cu and HEA-Cr structures.

Conclusion

The current work investigates the structural and electrochemical impacts of substituting Cr with Cu in MnFeCoNi high-entropy alloy (HEA) towards alkaline water electrolysis. Electrochemical evaluations in 1M KOH revealed that the Cu-substituted alloy (HEA-Cu) significantly outperformed its Cr-containing counterpart in both the HER and OER. Specifically, MnFeCoNiCu shows a lower HER onset potential of 0.538 V and a Tafel slope of 165 mV dec−1165\ \mathrm{mV\,dec}^{-1}, and when tested with Vulcan carbon, its OER activity proved comparable to the noble-metal standard RuO2_2.

Computational and stability analyses further elucidate why the Cu-substituted HEA exhibits superior performance and how it behaves during prolonged electrolysis. Accelerated durability tests (ADT) showed that while HER conditions preserved a homogeneous elemental distribution, OER conditions triggered Cu migration to the surface, forming an oxygen-rich outer layer that can eventually lead to activity deterioration. DFT calculations supported these findings by showing that Cu substitution induces significant lattice distortions (10-15%) and acts as an electron acceptor to modulate the electronic environment of neighboring atoms. This electronic shift results in weaker, more optimal binding energies for reaction intermediates like H∗H^*, O∗O^*, OH∗OH^*, and OOH∗OOH^*, which, facilitates more efficient adsorption and desorption kinetics for enhanced water splitting. The work clearly highlights the efficacy of HEA with controlled composition as building blocks for developing low cost, noble metal free sustainable catalyst for water splitting.

Associated Content

Supporting Information. Experiment and Characterization, Electrochemical measurement details, Computational methodology, XRD of HEA-Cr (fig:S1), XPS of HEA-Cr (fig:S2), SEM analysis of HEA-Cu (fig:S3) and HEA-Cr (fig:S4), Low magnification TEM image of HEA-Cu HEA catalyst after HER and OER stability test (fig:S5).

Author Information

Corresponding Author

Douglas S. Galvão ([email protected]) Chandra Sekhar Tiwary ([email protected])

Krishanu Biswas ([email protected])

Pulickel M Ajayan ([email protected])

Author Contributions

S.C. designed the experiment, performed the characterization, data collection and analysis, wrote the original manuscript and manuscript editing. R.B.O. performed computational analysis, analysis, wrote the original manuscript and manuscript editing. D.G. performed data analysis, writing and editing. T.S.P. and M.L.P. performed formal analysis. D.B., A.C.M., A.P., S.R. contributed to reviewing and editing. D.S.G., C.S.T., K.B., P.M.A. conceptualized the project and supervised. All the authors discussed the results and commented on the manuscript.

Notes

The authors declare no competing financial interest.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

References

  1. [1]Lawan, B. Non-Noble Metal Catalysts for the Alkaline Hydrogen Evolution Reaction: A Review. Discov. Chem. 2026 31 2026, 3 (1), 166-. https://doi.org/10.1007/S44371-026-00555-2.
  2. [2]Chattopadhyay, S.; de Oliveira, C. C.; Bhar, R.; Banik, D.; Pieshkov, T. S.; Puthirath, A. B.; Pramanik, A.; Sreeram, P. R.; Saju, S. K.; Costin, G.; Vajtai, R.; Dubey, B. K.; Biswas, K.; da Silva Autreto, P. A.; Tiwary, C. S.; Ajayan, P. M. Exploring Sustainable Hydrogen Production from Alkaline Fresh and Seawater Using Natural Ore Derived 2D Bi2S3. Small 2025, 21 (47), e09283. https://doi.org/10.1002/SMLL.202509283;WEBSITE:WEBSITE:PERICLES;REQUEST EDJOURNAL:JOURNAL:16136829;WGROUP:STRING:PUBLICATION.
  3. [3]Ibn Shamsah, S. M. Earth-Abundant Electrocatalysts for Water Splitting: Current and Future Directions. Catal. 2021, Vol. 11, Page 429 2021, 11 (4), 429. https://doi.org/10.3390/CATAL11040429.
  4. [4]Medford, A. J.; Vojvodic, A.; Hummelshøj, J. S.; Voss, J.; Abild-Pedersen, F.; Studt, F.; Bligaard, T.; Nilsson, A.; Nørskov, J. K. From the Sabatier Principle to a Predictive Theory of Transition-Metal Heterogeneous Catalysis. J. Catal. 2015, 328, 36–42. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.JCAT.2014.12.033.
  5. [5]Wang, B.; Liu, W.; Leng, Y.; Yu, X.; Wang, C.; Hu, L.; Zhu, X.; Wu, C.; Yao, Y.; Zou, Z. Strain Engineering of High-Entropy Alloy Catalysts for Electrocatalytic Water Splitting. iScience 2023, 26 (4), 106326. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.ISCI.2023.106326.
  6. [6]Chattopadhyay, S.; Wang, X.; Campos-Mata, A.; Liang, F.; Ajayan, P. M. High-Entropy Oxide Toward Practical Hydrogen Production From Alkaline Fresh and Seawater. Small 2026, 22 (25), e12191. https://doi.org/10.1002/SMLL.202512191;WGROUP:STRING:PUBLICATION.
  7. [7]Asghari Alamdari, A.; Jahangiri, H.; Yagci, M. B.; Igarashi, K.; Matsumoto, H.; Motallebzadeh, A.; Unal, U. Exploring Roleof Mo and Mn in Improving the OERand HER Performance of CoCuFeNi-Based High-Entropy Alloys. ACS Appl. Energy Mater. 2024, 7 (6), 2423–2435. https://doi.org/10.1021/ACSAEM.3C03227.
  8. [8]Campos-Mata, A.; Gak had, P.; Banik, D.; Chandra Mohanty, G.; Chattopadhyay, S.; Gangwar, B. P.; Tiwary, C. S.; Singh, A. K.; Roy, S.; Ajayan, P. M.; Biswas, K. Composition Tuning of Structural High Entropy Alloy (Fe-Co-Ni-Cu-Mn/Zn) Nano-Electrocatalysts for Synergistic Water Splitting. J. Mater. Chem. A 2025, 13 (48), 42006–42016. https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ta04595a.
  9. [9]Mohanty, G. C.; Chowde Gowda, C.; Gak had, P.; Sanjay, M.; Singh, A.; Biswas, K.; Tiwary, C. S. Effect of Zn/Mn on the Supercapacitor Behavior of High-Entropy FeCoNiCrZn/Mn Alloy. Energy Adv. 2024, 3 (12), 2972–2985. https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ya00376d.
  10. [10]Mohanty, G. C.; Chowde Gowda, C.; Gakhad, P.; Das, S.; Sanjay, M.; Chowdhury, S.; Biswas, K.; Singh, A.; Tiwary, C. S. Iron-Cobalt-Nickel-Copper-Zinc (FeCoNiCuZn) High Entropy Alloy as Positive Electrode for High Specific Capacitance Supercapacitor. Electrochim. Acta 2023, 470, 143272. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.ELECTACTA.2023.143272.
  11. [11]Liu, H.; Qin, H.; Kang, J.; Ma, L.; Chen, G.; Huang, Q.; Zhang, Z.; Liu, E.; Lu, H.; Li, J.; Zhao, N. A Freestanding Nanoporous NiCoFeMoMn High-Entropy Alloy as an Efficient Electrocatalyst for Rapid Water Splitting. Chem. Eng. J. 2022, 435, 134898. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.CEJ.2022.134898.
  12. [12]Tang, F.; Wang, L.; Dessie Walle, M.; Mustapha, A.; Liu, Y. N. An Alloy Chemistry Strategy to Tailoring the D-Band Center of Ni by Cu for Efficient and Selective Catalytic Hydrogenation of Furfural. J. Catal. 2020, 383, 172–180. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.JCAT.2020.01.019.
  13. [13]Tian, J.; Rao, Y.; Shi, W.; Yang, J.; Ning, W.; Li, H.; Yao, Y.; Zhou, H.; Guo, S. Sabatier Relations in Electrocatalysts Based on High-Entropy Alloys with Wide-Distributed d-Band Centers for Li-O2 Batteries. Angew. Chemie Int. Ed. 2023, 62 (44), e202310894. https://doi.org/10.1002/ANIE.202310894.
  14. [14]Talbot, A.; Shang, X.; Wang, W.; Cheng, C.; Lyu, T.; Zou, Y. Laser Remelting of a CrMnFeCoNi High-Entropy Alloy: Effect of Energy Density on Elemental Segregation. Adv. Eng. Mater. 2025, 27 (18), 2501194.
  15. [15]Mohanty, G. C.; Gowda, C. C.; Gakhad, P.; Sanjay, M.; Sarkar, S.; Biswas, K.; Singh, A.; Tiwary, C. S. High Energy Density Liquid State Asymmetric Supercapacitor Devices Using Co–Cr–Ni–Fe–Mn High Entropy Alloy. Mater. Adv. 2023, 4 (17), 3839–3852. https://doi.org/10.1039/D3MA00327B.
  16. [16]Kumar, J.; Linda, A.; Sadhasivam, M.; Pradeep, K. G.; Gurao, N. P.; Biswas, K. The Effect of Al Addition on Solid Solution Strengthening in CoCrFeMnNi: Experiment and Modelling. Acta Mater. 2022, 238, 118208. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.ACTAMAT.2022.118208.
  17. [17]Medvedev, N. Thermodynamic Properties of CrMnFeCoNi High Entropy Alloy at Elevated Electronic Temperatures. Sci. Reports 2025 151 2025, 15 (1), 37335-. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-21367-x.
  18. [18]Cantor, B.; Chang, I. T. H.; Knight, P.; Vincent, A. J. B. Microstructural Development in Equiatomic Multicomponent Alloys. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 2004, 375–377 (1-2 SPEC. ISS.), 213–218. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.MSEA.2003.10.257.
  19. [19]Otto, F.; Dlouhý, A.; Somsen, C.; Bei, H.; Eggeler, G.; George, E. P. The Influences of Temperature and Microstructure on the Tensile Properties of a CoCrFeMnNi High-Entropy Alloy. Acta Mater. 2013, 61 (15), 5743–5755. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.ACTAMAT.2013.06.018.
  20. [20]Chen, B. R.; Yeh, A. C.; Yeh, J. W. Effect of One-Step Recrystallization on the Grain Boundary Evolution of CoCrFeMnNi High Entropy Alloy and Its Subsystems. Sci. Reports 2016 61 2016, 6 (1), 22306-. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep22306.
  21. [21]Karikalan, N.; Karthik, R.; Chen, S. M.; Karuppiah, C.; Elangovan, A. Sonochemical Synthesis of Sulfur Doped Reduced Graphene Oxide Supported CuS Nanoparticles for the Non-Enzymatic Glucose Sensor Applications. Sci. Reports 2017 71 2017, 7 (1), 2494-. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-02479-5.
  22. [22]Wang, Y.; Wang, L.; Wei, B.; Miao, Q.; Yuan, Y.; Yang, Z.; Fei, W. Electrodeposited Nickel Cobalt Sulfide Nanosheet Arrays on 3D-Graphene/Ni Foam for High-Performance Supercapacitors. RSC Adv. 2015, 5 (121), 100106–100113. https://doi.org/10.1039/CSRA20898J.
  23. [23]He, X.; Hu, Z.; Zou, Q.; Yang, J.; Guo, R.; Wu, L. Co-Deposition of Co–Ni Alloy Catalysts from an Ethylene Glycol System for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction. RSC Adv. 2023, 13 (13), 8901–8914. https://doi.org/10.1039/D2RA08233K.
  24. [24]Tiwari, P.; Gangwar, D.; Rath, C. Studies on the Structural, Magnetic and Electrochemical Properties of GdMn1−xFexO3 (x = 0, 0.1 and 0.2) Perovskite Compounds. New J. Chem. 2021, 45 (30), 13608–13619. https://doi.org/10.1039/D1NJ02026A.
  25. [25]Gangwar, D.; Rath, C. Spin Dynamics of Hydrothermally Synthesized δ-MnO2 Nanowhiskers. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2020, 22 (25), 14236–14245. https://doi.org/10.1039/D0CP02245D.
  26. [26]Charry, J.; Tkatchenko, A. Van Der Waals Radii of Free and Bonded Atoms from Hydrogen (Z = 1) to Oganesson (Z = 118). J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2024, 20 (17), 7469–7478. https://doi.org/10.1021/ACS.JCTC.4C00784.
  27. [27]Bencherifa, I.; Belkhettab, I.; Derkaoui, K.; Dabou, O.; Chetoui, A.; Latreche, S.; Daoud, I. Unveiling the Impact of Al and Cr Alloying on Structure and HER Performance of CoCuZnMnNiFe High-Entropy Alloy Nanoparticles. J. Mater. Sci. 2025 6044 2025, 60 (44), 22443–22467. https://doi.org/10.1007/S10853-025-11760-2.
  28. [28]Wang, F.; Chen, S.; Tong, Z.; Liu, X.; Zhou, H.; He, Y.; Shu, G.; Jin, Y.; Zheng, W. Electronegativity-Modulated High-Entropy Catalysts for Efficient HER and OER. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 2025, 17 (49), 66617–66629. https://doi.org/10.1021/ACSAMI.5C17409.
  29. [29]Ipaves, B.; Justo, J. F.; de Almeida, J. M.; Assali, L. V. C.; Alves da Silva Autreto, P. Metal-Free Doping in Two-Dimensional Carbon C4N2 for Enhanced Hydrogen Evolution. ACS Omega 2025, 10 (38), 44248–44259. https://doi.org/10.1021/ACSOMEGA.5C05773.
  30. [30]Chodvadiya, D.; Som, N. N.; Jha, P. K.; Chakraborty, B. Enhancement in the Catalytic Activity of Two-Dimensional α-CN by B, Si and P Doping for Hydrogen Evolution and Oxygen Evolution Reactions. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2021, 46 (43), 22478–22498. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.IJHYDENE.2021.04.080.
  31. [31]Kamaruddin, H.; Jianghong, Z.; Yu, L.; Yuefan, W.; Yizhong, H. A Review of Noble Metal-Free High Entropy Alloys for Water Splitting Applications. J. Mater. Chem. A 2024, 12 (17), 9933–9961. https://doi.org/10.1039/D4TA00690A.

Paper details

vlnc:W_hyt7s359
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents