betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Photoproduction γp→f0(980)pγp \to f_0(980) p in an effective Lagrangian approach

Abstract

The most recent data on differential cross sections and photon beam asymmetries ΣΣ from the LEPS2/BGOegg Collaboration for the γp→f0(980)pγp \to f_0(980) p reaction are analyzed within a tree-level effective Lagrangian approach. The tt-channel ρρ and ωω exchanges, the uu- and ss-channel NN exchanges, the interaction current, and the possible ss-channel N∗N^* exchanges are taken into account in constructing the reaction amplitudes to reproduce the data. The results show that the contributions from either the N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ or the N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ resonance exchange in the ss channel are necessarily required to describe the LEPS2/BGOegg data and they dominate the differential cross sections of γp→f0(980)pγp \to f_0(980) p. Further analysis shows that the contributions from the tt-channel ρρ and ωω exchanges and the interaction current are rather small to both differential cross sections and photo beam asymmetries, and the contributions from uu-channel NN exchange are considerable in the case of including N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ in the model while negligible in the case of including N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ in the model. Predictions of target asymmetries TT for γp→f0(980)pγp \to f_0(980) p are given, which can be examined by future experiments.

Introduction

For a long time, our knowledge of the low mass scalar mesons has been mainly coming from the hadron-induced reactions by using hadronic probes such as π\pi, pp or pˉ\bar{p} beams, from the γγ\gamma\gamma collisions, and from the decays of heavier mesons such as ϕ\phi, J/ψJ/\psi, DD, and BB [1, 2]. However, the situation has changed significantly in the past 20 years as the experimental technology advances in the electromagnetic accelerator facilities, including the control and polarization of photon beams, development of polarized gas and solid targets, construction of large solid angle detectors, development of higher rate data acquisition systems and of data analysis and statistical techniques [3], have made the electromagnetic probes become an effective and valuable tool for the investigation of conventional and exotic mesons [2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15].

Stimulated by the most recent data on differential cross sections and photon beam asymmetries Σ\Sigma for the γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p reaction with f0(980)f_0(980) decaying into π0π0\pi^0\pi^0 released by the LEPS2/BGOegg Collaboration [16], in the present work we focus on the analysis of the isoscalar scalar meson f0(980)f_0(980) photoproduction.

Experimentally, suffering from the dominance of vector meson photoproduction in the data sample, the data of the f0(980)f_0(980) photoproduction is scarce. Thanks to the high-intensity and high-quality tagged-photon beams produced at The Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility, the CLAS Collaboration has reported the first data on differential cross sections for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p at one photon beam energy point around Eγ≈3.4 GeVE_\gamma\approx3.4\ \mathrm{GeV} with relative low statistics [2, 12, 13]. Since the CLAS detector is optimized for exclusive meson photoproduction with charged mesons in the final states, the CLAS measurements of the f0(980)f_0(980) photoproduction have been performed by detecting the f0(980)f_0(980) decaying into π+π−\pi^+\pi^- or K+K−K^+K^-. Most recently, the LEPS2/BGOegg Collaboration released the data on differential cross sections and photon beam asymmetries Σ\Sigma for photoproduction of the f0(980)f_0(980) meson decaying into π0π0\pi^0\pi^0 at energies from the reaction threshold up to Eγ≈2.4 GeVE_\gamma\approx2.4\ \mathrm{GeV} [16]. Since the vector meson cannot decay into π0π0\pi^0\pi^0, the LEPS2/BGOegg measurements of the f0(980)f_0(980) photoproduction are free from the influence of the large contributions from the ρ\rho photoproduction and the so-called S-P interference [16]. What’s more, the LEPS2/BGOegg measurements of the polarization observable Σ\Sigma can provide additional constraints on the phenomenological models for the f0(980)f_0(980) photoproduction and thus help to understand more reliably the production mechanisms of the f0(980)f_0(980) meson.

Theoretically, the pioneering CLAS data [2, 12, 13] for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p have been analyzed by several works based on Regge models and/or effective Lagrangian approaches. In Ref. [17], the γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p reaction was analyzed in a Regge model with distinct scenarios for the f0(980)→Vγf_0(980) \to V\gamma decay process being considered. It was shown that the radiative decay rates for f0(980)→Vγf_0(980) \to V\gamma are important in theoretical predictions. In Ref. [18], the γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p reaction was analyzed based on a previous Regge-pole model for the π0\pi^0 photoproduction [19] by further taking into account the Regge cuts, and the authors concluded that the results indicate strongly the presence of the KKˉK\bar{K} molecular component in f0(980)f_0(980). In Ref. [20], the photoproduction of f0(980)f_0(980) was analyzed by using an effective Lagrangian approach with the tt-channel amplitude being constructed by replacing the Feynman propagator with the Regge propagator for ρ\rho exchange to describe the CLAS data [2, 12]. In Ref. [21], the f0(980)f_0(980) photoproduction was analyzed in the reaction threshold region within an effective Lagrangian approach with both the tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges being taken into account to reproduce the CLAS data [2, 12, 13]. Besides, the f0(980)f_0(980) photoproduction has also been investigated in a coupled channel analysis of the SS-wave ππ\pi\pi and KKˉK\bar{K} photoproduction in Ref. [22] and in ππp\pi\pi p, πηp\pi\eta p, and KKˉpK\bar{K}p channels to examine the a0(980)a_0(980)-f0(980)f_0(980) mixing in Ref. [23].

In the present work, we construct a theoretical model to analyze the newly released LEPS2/BGOegg data for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p [16] based on a tree-level effective Lagrangian approach. The major object is to understand the reaction mechanisms of the f0(980)f_0(980) photoproduction and to learn the information about possible N∗N^*'s exchanged in the ss channel of this reaction. Note that, as mentioned above, the LEPS2/BGOegg data cover a much wider energy range, i.e. from threshold up to Eγ≈2.4E_\gamma\approx2.4 GeV, than the CLAS data that are measured at only one energy point around Eγ≈3.4E_\gamma\approx3.4 GeV. Moreover, the LEPS2/BGOegg Collaboration also provides for the first time the data on photon beam asymmetries Σ\Sigma in addition to the differential cross sections. The present work presents so far the first theoretical analysis of the newly reported LEPS2/BGOegg data on both differential cross sections and photon beam asymmetries for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p, and is expected to achieve more reliable theoretical results and a better understanding of the reaction mechanisms of γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p.

The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II, we introduce the basic formalism of our theoretical model by giving the explicit expressions of the Lagrangians for the interaction vertices, the resonance propagators, and the phenomenological form factors. The model results are shown and discussed in detail in Sec. III. A brief summary and the conclusions of the present paper are given in Sec. IV.

Formalism

For the convenience of discussion, we express the reaction of interest as follow

γ(k)+p(p)→f0(980)(q)+p(p′).(1)\gamma(k) + p(p) \to f_0(980)(q) + p(p'). \tag*{(1)}

Here, the arguments kk, pp, qq, and p′p' in parentheses stand for the corresponding four momenta of the initial and final particles. The Mandelstam variables ss, tt, and uu are defined as usual: t≡(p−p′)2=(k−q)2t \equiv(p-p')^2=(k-q)^2, s≡(p+k)2=(q+p′)2s\equiv(p+k)^2=(q+p')^2, u≡(p−q)2=(p′−k)2u\equiv(p-q)^2=(p'-k)^2.

In the present paper, we perform an analysis of the most recent LEPS2/BGOegg data for the γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p reaction within a tree-level effective Lagrangian approach. As diagrammatically depicted in Figure 1, we consider the following reaction mechanisms to construct the reaction amplitudes for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p: (a) the ss-channel NN and N∗N^* exchanges, (b) the tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges, (c) the uu-channel NN exchange, and (d) the interaction current.

Figure 1. Generic structure of the amplitude for γN→f0(980)N\gamma N \to f_0(980)N. Time proceeds from left to right.

In principle the uu-channel N∗N^* exchange should also be considered, which will cause an additional parameter to the model, i.e. the cutoff parameter in the form factor. We have checked and found that the contributions from the uu-channel N∗N^* exchange are rather small and have negligible effects on both fit qualities and the values of extracted parameters. Thus, this dynamics is not included in the present work. According to Figure 1, the transition current MμM^\mu can be written as [24, 25, 26, 27]

Mμ≡Msμ+Mtμ+Muμ+Mintμ,(2)M^\mu\equiv M_s^\mu+ M_t^\mu+ M_u^\mu+ M_{\mathrm{int}}^\mu, \tag*{(2)}

with μ\mu denoting the Lorentz index of the photon field. MsμM_s^\mu, MtμM_t^\mu, and MuμM_u^\mu represent the transition currents calculated from the ss-, tt-, and uu-channel diagrams, respectively. The explicit expressions of MsμM_s^\mu, MtμM_t^\mu, and MuμM_u^\mu can be straightforwardly obtained from the effective Lagrangians, propagators, and form factors given below. The last term in Eq. (2), MintμM_{\mathrm{int}}^\mu, is the interaction current term, which stands for the contributions calculated from the diagrams that do not have ss-, tt-, or uu-channel poles and is responsible for preserving gauge invariance of the full reaction amplitudes. In the present work, we follow Refs. [25, 27] to model the interaction current MintμM_{\mathrm{int}}^\mu by a generalized contact current

Mintμ=ΓNNf0(980)(q)Cμ,(3)M_{\mathrm{int}}^\mu= \Gamma_{NNf_0(980)}(q)C^\mu, \tag*{(3)}

with ΓNNf0(980)(q)\Gamma_{NNf_0(980)}(q) standing for the vertex function of the NNf0(980)NNf_0(980) interaction obtained from the Lagrangian of (9). The auxiliary current CμC^\mu is introduced to ensure that the total reaction amplitude of γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p satisfies the generalized Ward-Takahashi identity and thus is fully gauge invariant. Following Refs. [24, 25, 26, 27], the prescription for CμC^\mu for the γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p reaction can be written as

Cμ=−Qufu−F^u−p′2(2p′−k)μ−Qsfs−F^s−p2(2p+k)μ,(4)C^\mu= -Q_u\frac{f_u-\widehat{F}}{u-p'^2}(2p'-k)^\mu-Q_s\frac{f_s-\widehat{F}}{s-p^2}(2p+k)^\mu, \tag*{(4)}

with QuQ_u and QsQ_s being the charges of the nucleon exchanged in the uu channel and ss channel, respectively. The expression of F^\hat{F} in Eq. (4) is

F^=1−h^(1−fu)(1−fs),(5)\hat{F}=1-\hat{h}(1-f_u)(1-f_s), \tag*{(5)}

where fuf_u and fsf_s are the phenomenological form factors attaching to the amplitudes of the NN exchanged in the uu and ss channels, respectively. h^\hat{h} is set to be 1 for simplicity as usual [28, 29].

Effective Lagrangians

The explicit expressions of the effective Lagrangians for the interaction vertices are given in this subsection. For the sake of simplicity, the notation f0f_0 is used to stand for f0(980)f_0(980) and we define the following operators

Γ(+)=γ5andΓ(−)=1,(6)\Gamma^{(+)}=\gamma_5 \quad\text{and} \quad\Gamma^{(-)}=1, \tag*{(6)}

and the field-strength tensor of the photon field AμA^\mu

Fμν=∂μAν−∂νAμ.(7)F^{\mu\nu}=\partial^\mu A^\nu-\partial^\nu A^\mu. \tag*{(7)}

To calculate the amplitudes of the ss- and uu-channel NN exchanges, we use the following Lagrangians

LγNN=−eNˉ(e^γμ−κ^N2MNσμν∂ν)AμN,(8)\mathcal{L}_{\gamma NN}=-e\bar{N}\left(\hat{e}\gamma^\mu-\frac{\hat{\kappa}_N}{2M_N}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\partial_\nu\right)A_\mu N, \tag*{(8)}
LNNf0=gNNf0NˉNf0,(9)\mathcal{L}_{NNf_0}=g_{NNf_0}\bar{N}Nf_0, \tag*{(9)}

with ee being the elementary charge unit and e^\hat{e} representing the charge operator acting on the NN field. κ^N≡κpe^+κn(1−e^)\hat{\kappa}_N\equiv\kappa_p\hat{e}+\kappa_n(1-\hat{e}) is the anomalous magnetic moment with κp=1.793\kappa_p=1.793 for proton and κn=−1.913\kappa_n=-1.913 for neutron. Since both the experimental and theoretical information on the coupling constant gNNf0g_{NNf_0} are scarce, its value will be determined by adjusting to reproduce the available data for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p\to f_0(980)p.

The following Lagrangians are employed to calculate the amplitudes of the tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges

LωNN=−gωNNNˉ(γμ−κω2MNσμν∂ν)ωμN,(10)\mathcal{L}_{\omega NN}=-g_{\omega NN}\bar{N}\left(\gamma^\mu-\frac{\kappa_\omega}{2M_N}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\partial_\nu\right)\omega_\mu N, \tag*{(10)}
Lγf0ω=egγf0ω2Mω∂μAν(∂μων−∂νωμ)f0,(11)\mathcal{L}_{\gamma f_0\omega}=\frac{eg_{\gamma f_0\omega}}{2M_\omega}\partial_\mu A_\nu(\partial^\mu\omega^\nu-\partial^\nu\omega^\mu)f_0, \tag*{(11)}
LρNN=−gρNNNˉ(γμ−κρ2MNσμν∂ν)τ⃗⋅ρ⃗μN,(12)\mathcal{L}_{\rho NN}=-g_{\rho NN}\bar{N}\left(\gamma^\mu-\frac{\kappa_\rho}{2M_N}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\partial_\nu\right)\vec{\tau}\cdot\vec{\rho}_\mu N, \tag*{(12)}
Lγf0ρ=egγf0ρ2Mρ∂μAν(∂μρ⃗ ν−∂νρ⃗ μ)f0.(13)\mathcal{L}_{\gamma f_0\rho}=\frac{eg_{\gamma f_0\rho}}{2M_\rho}\partial_\mu A_\nu(\partial^\mu\vec{\rho}^{\,\nu}-\partial^\nu\vec{\rho}^{\,\mu})f_0. \tag*{(13)}

Here, the coupling constants gωNN=15.85g_{\omega NN}=15.85, κω=0\kappa_\omega=0, gρNN=3.36g_{\rho NN}=3.36, and κρ=6.1\kappa_\rho=6.1 are taken from Ref. [21]. The constants gγf0ω=0.58g_{\gamma f_0\omega}=0.58 and gγf0ρ=0.61g_{\gamma f_0\rho}=0.61 are calculated from the partial decay widthes of Γf0→ωγ=6.6\Gamma_{f_0\to\omega\gamma}=6.6 keV and Γf0→ργ=7.3\Gamma_{f_0\to\rho\gamma}=7.3 keV obtained in Ref. [34].

To calculate the amplitudes of the ss-channel N∗N^* exchanges, we use the following Lagrangians for the electromagnetic interaction vertices

LRNγ1/2±=egRNγ(1)2MNRˉΓ(∓)σμν(∂νAμ)N+H.c.,(14)\mathcal{L}^{1/2\pm}_{RN\gamma}=e\frac{g_{RN\gamma}^{(1)}}{2M_N}\bar{R}\Gamma^{(\mp)}\sigma_{\mu\nu}(\partial^\nu A^\mu)N+\mathrm{H.c.}, \tag*{(14)}
LRNγ3/2±=−iegRNγ(1)2MNRˉμγνΓ(±)FμνN+egRNγ(2)(2MN)2RˉμΓ(±)Fμν∂νN+H.c.,(15)\mathcal{L}^{3/2\pm}_{RN\gamma}=-ie\frac{g_{RN\gamma}^{(1)}}{2M_N}\bar{R}_\mu\gamma_\nu\Gamma^{(\pm)}F^{\mu\nu}N+e\frac{g_{RN\gamma}^{(2)}}{(2M_N)^2}\bar{R}_\mu\Gamma^{(\pm)}F^{\mu\nu}\partial_\nu N+\mathrm{H.c.}, \tag*{(15)}
LRNγ5/2±=egRNγ(1)(2MN)2RˉμαγνΓ(∓)(∂αFμν)N+iegRNγ(2)(2MN)3RˉμαΓ(∓)(∂αFμν)∂νN+H.c.,(16)\mathcal{L}^{5/2\pm}_{RN\gamma}=e\frac{g_{RN\gamma}^{(1)}}{(2M_N)^2}\bar{R}_{\mu\alpha}\gamma_\nu\Gamma^{(\mp)}(\partial^\alpha F^{\mu\nu})N+ie\frac{g_{RN\gamma}^{(2)}}{(2M_N)^3}\bar{R}_{\mu\alpha}\Gamma^{(\mp)}(\partial^\alpha F^{\mu\nu})\partial_\nu N+\mathrm{H.c.}, \tag*{(16)}
LRNγ7/2±=iegRNγ(1)(2MN)3RˉμαβγνΓ(±)(∂α∂βFμν)N−egRNγ(2)(2MN)4RˉμαβΓ(±)(∂α∂βFμν)∂νN+H.c.,(17)\mathcal{L}^{7/2\pm}_{RN\gamma}=ie\frac{g_{RN\gamma}^{(1)}}{(2M_N)^3}\bar{R}_{\mu\alpha\beta}\gamma_\nu\Gamma^{(\pm)}(\partial^\alpha\partial^\beta F^{\mu\nu})N-e\frac{g_{RN\gamma}^{(2)}}{(2M_N)^4}\bar{R}_{\mu\alpha\beta}\Gamma^{(\pm)}(\partial^\alpha\partial^\beta F^{\mu\nu})\partial_\nu N+\mathrm{H.c.}, \tag*{(17)}

and use the following Lagrangians for the hadronic interaction vertices

LRNf01/2±=−igRNf0NˉΓ(∓)f0R+H.c.,(18)\mathcal{L}^{1/2\pm}_{RNf_0}=-ig_{RNf_0}\bar{N}\Gamma^{(\mp)}f_0R+\mathrm{H.c.}, \tag*{(18)}
LRNf03/2±=+gRNf0Mf0NˉΓ(±)(∂αf0)Rα+H.c.,(19)\mathcal{L}^{3/2\pm}_{RNf_0}=+\frac{g_{RNf_0}}{M_{f_0}}\bar{N}\Gamma^{(\pm)}(\partial^\alpha f_0)R_\alpha+\mathrm{H.c.}, \tag*{(19)}
LRNf05/2±=igRNf0Mf02NˉΓ(∓)(∂α∂βf0)Rαβ+H.c.,(20)\mathcal{L}^{5/2\pm}_{RNf_0}=i\frac{g_{RNf_0}}{M_{f_0}^2}\bar{N}\Gamma^{(\mp)}(\partial^\alpha\partial^\beta f_0)R_{\alpha\beta}+\mathrm{H.c.}, \tag*{(20)}
LRNf07/2±=±gRNf0Mf03NˉΓ(±)(∂α∂β∂γf0)Rαβγ+H.c.(21)\mathcal{L}^{7/2\pm}_{RNf_0}=\pm\frac{g_{RNf_0}}{M_{f_0}^3}\bar{N}\Gamma^{(\pm)}(\partial^\alpha\partial^\beta\partial^\gamma f_0)R_{\alpha\beta\gamma}+\mathrm{H.c.} \tag*{(21)}

In Eq. (14)–Eq. (21), RR represents the N∗N^* resonances and the superscript of L\mathcal{L} denotes the spin and parity of the resonance RR. In our tree-level calculation in the present paper, the model results are only sensitive to the products of hadronic coupling constant gRNf0g_{RNf_0} and the electromagnetic coupling constants gRNγ(i)g_{RN\gamma}^{(i)} (i=1,2i=1,2). If the helicity amplitudes of R→NγR\to N\gamma are available in Review of Particle Physics (RPP) [1], they will be used to calculate the corresponding electromagnetic coupling constants. Otherwise, the products of the hadronic coupling constant and electromagnetic coupling constants will be determined by fitting to the available data of γp→f0(980)p\gamma p\to f_0(980)p.

Resonance propagators

By defining

g~μν=−gμν+pμpνMR2,(22)\widetilde{g}_{\mu\nu}=-g_{\mu\nu}+\frac{p_{\mu}p_{\nu}}{M_{R}^{2}}, \tag*{(22)}
γ~μ=−γμ+pμp̸MR2,(23)\widetilde{\gamma}_{\mu}=-\gamma_{\mu}+\frac{p_{\mu}\not{p}}{M_{R}^{2}}, \tag*{(23)}

the propagators of the resonances with spin 1/21/2, 3/23/2, 5/25/2, and 7/27/2 employed in the present work adopt the following prescriptions [28]:

S1/2(p)=ip̸−MR+iΓR/2,(24)S_{1/2}(p)=\frac{i}{\not{p}-M_{R}+i\Gamma_{R}/2}, \tag*{(24)}
S3/2(p)=ip̸−MR+iΓR/2(g~μν+13γ~μγ~ν),(25)S_{3/2}(p)=\frac{i}{\not{p}-M_{R}+i\Gamma_{R}/2}\left(\widetilde{g}_{\mu\nu}+\frac{1}{3}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\mu}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\nu}\right), \tag*{(25)}
S5/2(p)=ip̸−MR+iΓR/2[12(g~μαg~νβ+g~μβg~να)−15g~μνg~αβ+110(g~μαγ~νγ~β+g~μβγ~νγ~α+g~ναγ~μγ~β+g~νβγ~μγ~α)],(26)S_{5/2}(p)=\frac{i}{\not{p}-M_{R}+i\Gamma_{R}/2}\left[\frac{1}{2}\left(\widetilde{g}_{\mu\alpha}\widetilde{g}_{\nu\beta}+\widetilde{g}_{\mu\beta}\widetilde{g}_{\nu\alpha}\right)-\frac{1}{5}\widetilde{g}_{\mu\nu}\widetilde{g}_{\alpha\beta}+\frac{1}{10}\left(\widetilde{g}_{\mu\alpha}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\nu}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\beta}+\widetilde{g}_{\mu\beta}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\nu}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\alpha}+\widetilde{g}_{\nu\alpha}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\mu}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\beta}+\widetilde{g}_{\nu\beta}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\mu}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\alpha}\right)\right], \tag*{(26)}
S7/2(p)=ip̸−MR+iΓR/2136∑PμPν(g~μ1ν1g~μ2ν2g~μ3ν3−37g~μ1μ2g~ν1ν2g~μ3ν3+37γ~μ1γ~ν1g~μ2ν2g~μ3ν3−335γ~μ1γ~ν1g~μ2μ3g~ν2ν3),(27)S_{7/2}(p)=\frac{i}{\not{p}-M_{R}+i\Gamma_{R}/2}\frac{1}{36}\sum_{P_{\mu}P_{\nu}}\left(\widetilde{g}_{\mu_{1}\nu_{1}}\widetilde{g}_{\mu_{2}\nu_{2}}\widetilde{g}_{\mu_{3}\nu_{3}}-\frac{3}{7}\widetilde{g}_{\mu_{1}\mu_{2}}\widetilde{g}_{\nu_{1}\nu_{2}}\widetilde{g}_{\mu_{3}\nu_{3}}+\frac{3}{7}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\mu_{1}}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\nu_{1}}\widetilde{g}_{\mu_{2}\nu_{2}}\widetilde{g}_{\mu_{3}\nu_{3}}-\frac{3}{35}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\mu_{1}}\widetilde{\gamma}_{\nu_{1}}\widetilde{g}_{\mu_{2}\mu_{3}}\widetilde{g}_{\nu_{2}\nu_{3}}\right), \tag*{(27)}

where MRM_{R} and ΓR\Gamma_{R} denote the mass and width for the resonance RR with four-momentum pp, respectively. The summation over PμP_{\mu} (PνP_{\nu}) in Eq. (27) goes over all the 3!=63! = 6 possible permutations of the indices μ1μ2μ3\mu_{1}\mu_{2}\mu_{3} (ν1ν2ν3\nu_{1}\nu_{2}\nu_{3}).

We mention that the Rarita-Schwinger prescriptions of resonance propagators, i.e. Eqs. (25)–(27), have a problem of consisting unphysical components with lower spins, as discussed in Refs. [30, 31, 32, 33]. This issue might be resolved if the interaction vertices could be constructed in a proper form with a consistent interaction. A pure spin-3/23/2 propagator with consistent interaction Lagrangians was investigated in Ref. [33], where it was shown that for the total cross sections of πN\pi N photoproduction, the pure spin-3/23/2 propagator with consistent interaction Lagrangians and the prescription of Rarita-Schwinger yield similar structures for ss-channel Δ\Delta contribution. In the present work, the Rarita-Schwinger prescription is employed for resonance propagators as an economic and convenient approximation. A serious treatment of the propagators of resonances with high spins as well as the associated consistent interactions will be done in our future work when more data for this reaction becomes available.

Form factors

In actual calculations, a phenomenological form factor is introduced at each hadronic vertex. In accordance with Refs. [27, 28, 29], for the tt-channel meson exchanges we employ the following form factor

fM(qM2)=(ΛM2−MM2ΛM2−qM2)2,(28)f_{M}(q_{M}^{2})=\left(\frac{\Lambda_{M}^{2}-M_{M}^{2}}{\Lambda_{M}^{2}-q_{M}^{2}}\right)^{2}, \tag*{(28)}

with ΛM\Lambda_{M} being the cut off parameter for the tt-channel meson exchange diagrams, MMM_{M} and qMq_{M} denoting the mass and four-momentum of the intermediate meson, respectively. For the ss- and uu-channel baryon exchanges, the form factor employed in the present paper are [27, 28, 29]

fB(px2)=(ΛB4ΛB4+(px2−MB2)2)2,(29)f_{B}(p_{x}^{2})=\left(\frac{\Lambda_{B}^{4}}{\Lambda_{B}^{4}+(p_{x}^{2}-M_{B}^{2})^{2}}\right)^{2}, \tag*{(29)}

with ΛB\Lambda_{B} being the cut off parameter for ss- and uu-channel baryon exchange diagrams, MBM_{B} and pxp_{x} (x=s,ux=s,u) denoting the mass and four-momentum of the exchanged baryon in ss or uu channel, respectively. In the present paper, the values of ΛM\Lambda_{M} and ΛB\Lambda_{B} will be determined by the available data for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p.

Differential cross section

The CLAS and LEPS2/BGOegg Collaborations have measured the cross sections for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p reaction with f0(980)f_{0}(980) decaying into the KKˉK\bar{K} or ππ\pi\pi channels. The signal cross section of γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p with f0(980)f_{0}(980) decaying into a certain final state ii can be calculated via [18]

dσdΩ dM=dσ0(M)dΩ2Mf02πΓi(M)(Mf02−M2)2+M2Γf02.(30)\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma}{\mathrm{d}\Omega\,\mathrm{d}M}=\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{0}(M)}{\mathrm{d}\Omega}\frac{2M f_{0}^{2}}{\pi}\frac{\Gamma_{i}(M)}{\left(M_{f_{0}}^{2}-M^{2}\right)^{2}+M^{2}\Gamma_{f_{0}}^{2}}. \tag*{(30)}

Here, dσ0(M)/dΩ\mathrm{d}\sigma_{0}(M)/\mathrm{d}\Omega is the so-called narrow-width differential cross section at a scalar mass MM. For a given value of MM, dσ0(M)/dΩ\mathrm{d}\sigma_{0}(M)/\mathrm{d}\Omega can be calculated as the on-shell cross section for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p with an on-shell mass MM for f0(980)f_{0}(980). In Eq. (30), Mf0=990M_{f_{0}}=990 MeV is the mass of f0(980)f_{0}(980) and Γi\Gamma_{i} is the partial decay width for f0(980)→KKˉf_{0}(980)\to K\bar{K} or f0(980)→ππf_{0}(980)\to\pi\pi. MM is the invariant mass of KKˉK\bar{K} or ππ\pi\pi which is measured in experiments.

Results and discussion

The CLAS data on differential cross sections for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p [2, 12, 13] were conducted at photon beam energy Eγ≈3.4E_{\gamma}\approx3.4 GeV that corresponds to center-of-mass energy W≈2.7W\approx2.7 GeV. In Ref. [21], these data were analyzed within an effective Lagrangian model. It was shown that the CLAS data can be reproduced by considering only the tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges with a cutoff value ΛM=1070\Lambda_M = 1070 MeV.

The LEPS2/BGOegg data on both differential cross sections and photon beam asymmetries for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p [16] were measured from threshold up to photon beam energy Eγ≈2.4E_\gamma\approx2.4 GeV (W≈2.3W \approx2.3 GeV). The contributions from tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges are rather small in this energy region, as shown in Figure 2. One sees from this figure that the data are much underestimated if only the tt-channel interaction is considered, indicating that the contributions from other reaction mechanisms are still needed. We have checked and found that, even if we further included the contributions from the uu- and ss-channel NN exchanges and the interaction current, the model is still far from being sufficient to describe the data. In this situation, we further considered in the model the possible contributions from N∗N^* exchanges in the ss channel.

Figure 2. Differential cross sections for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p with f0(980)f_0(980) decaying into π0π0\pi^0\pi^0 obtained by considering only the tt-channel amplitudes of the ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges (ΛM=1070\Lambda_M = 1070 MeV) [21]. The quantities in square brackets are the ranges of the center-of-mass energy of the system, in MeV. Data are taken from the LEPS2/BGOegg Collaboration [16] for the two event-selection conditions with (squares) and without (circles) requirement of the N∗N^* cuts.

In RPP [1], there are seven nucleon resonances with spin J≤7/2J \le7/2 lying above the reaction threshold of γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p, namely, the N(2000)5/2+N(2000)5/2^+, N(1990)7/2+N(1990)7/2^+, N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+, N(2060)5/2−N(2060)5/2^-, N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+, N(2120)3/2−N(2120)3/2^-, N(2190)7/2−N(2190)7/2^-, and N(2300)1/2+N(2300)1/2^+ resonances. Since we have no clear reason to discard one resonance in favor of the other, we treat these resonances equally by including them one by one in the ss channel to reproduce the data. The information on the helicity amplitudes of these resonances is scarce, and there is no information for their decays into f0(980)pf_0(980)p channel either. Thus we treat these quantities as parameters in fitting procedure. For the decay ratio of f0(980)→ππf_0(980) \to\pi\pi, we take the average value of 0.52, 0.75, and 0.84 obtained in Refs. [35, 36, 37] as cited in RPP [1]. The resulting χ2/N\chi^2/N, with N=38N = 38, for the inclusion of each of those seven nucleon resonances are listed in Table I.

The last column in Table I represents the χ2/N\chi^2/N evaluated from the Born term where no resonance exchange in the ss channel is included in the model. One can see that, the inclusion of N∗N^* in the model can significantly improve the theoretical description of the LEPS2/BGOegg data for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p. The three best results are obtained by including the N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+, N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+, and N(2300)1/2+N(2300)1/2^+ resonances with χ2/N=2.82\chi^2/N = 2.82, 3.02, and 3.88, respectively. The fits of including other resonances have much larger χ2/N\chi^2/N and the corresponding results are not in agreement with the data. These fits are thus not considered as acceptable.

In Figure 3, we show the comparison of our results of photon beam asymmetries for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p obtained with the inclusion of each of the N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+, N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+, and N(2300)1/2+N(2300)1/2^+ resonances. One can see that there are noticeable discrepancies between the results obtained by inclusion of the N(2300)1/2+N(2300)1/2^+ resonance with the data. Therefore, we will discuss only the results obtained by including the N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ or N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ resonance. We denote the model with N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ as “Model I” and the model with N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ as “Model II”. The corresponding parameters of these two models are listed in Table II. Note that the cutoff value of tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges is taken from Ref. [21], where the value ΛM=1070\Lambda_M = 1070 MeV is determined by fitting the CLAS differential cross section data at Eγ≈3.4E_\gamma\approx3.4 GeV. We have checked that at this energy point the contributions from other interacting diagrams are negligible. This means that our results presented in this paper, even fitted to the LEPS2/BGOegg data at lower energies, can reproduce the CLAS data equally well as shown in Ref. [21]. We don’t repeat this plot here.

Figure 3. Photon beam asymmetries Σ\Sigma for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p obtained by including one of the N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ (blue solid lines), N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ (cyan dotted lines), and N(2300)1/2+N(2300)1/2^+ (red dashed lines) resonances. The quantities in square brackets are the ranges of center-of-mass energy of the system, in MeV. Data are taken from the LEPS2/BGOegg Collaboration [16] for the two event-selection conditions with (squares) and without (circles) requirement of the N∗N^* cuts.

We remark that adding a second or even more resonances in addition to either N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ or N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ to the model will definitely improve the theoretical description of data as more adjustable parameters will be introduced. Nevertheless, as the available data for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p are rather limited, considering more resonances in the model will result in too many fits with similar χ2/N\chi^{2}/N and large error bars for the fitting parameters. One is then not able to draw any conclusive conclusion about the resonance contents in γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p. Therefore, we postpone the analysis of adding two or more resonances to the model until more data for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p become available in the future.

N(2000)5/2+N(2000)5/2^{+}N(1990)7/2+N(1990)7/2^{+}N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^{+}N(2060)5/2−N(2060)5/2^{-}N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^{+}N(2120)3/2−N(2120)3/2^{-}N(2190)7/2−N(2190)7/2^{-}N(2300)1/2+N(2300)1/2^{+}Born
7.085.612.825.593.025.0112.823.8814.40

Table 1. χ2/N\chi^{2}/N evaluated for the inclusion of one nucleon resonance in the ss channel.

Model IModel II
gNNf0g_{NNf_{0}}−2.08±0.50-2.08 \pm0.500.65±0.350.65 \pm0.35
ΛB\Lambda_{B} [MeV]958±11958 \pm11800±15800 \pm15
N∗N^{*} NameN(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^{+}N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^{+}
** * *
MRM_{R} [MeV]2038±12038 \pm12088±22088 \pm2
[2050 − 2150]
ΓR\Gamma_{R} [MeV]350±15350 \pm15320±56320 \pm56
[200 − 320]
gRNf0gRNγ(1)g_{RNf_{0}}g_{RN\gamma}^{(1)}−8.83±0.09-8.83 \pm0.090.53±0.050.53 \pm0.05
gRNf0gRNγ(2)g_{RNf_{0}}g_{RN\gamma}^{(2)}−5.60±0.11-5.60 \pm0.11

Table 2. Fitted values of model parameters. The asterisks below the resonance names denote the overall rating of each resonance evaluated by RPP [1]. The numbers in brackets below the resonance mass and width represent the corresponding values estimated by RPP [1].

We now come to the detailed discussion of the results

obtained from Model I. The differential cross sections and the photon beam asymmetries Σ\Sigma are shown in Figure 4 and Figure 5, respectively. We note that the LEPS2/BGOegg data [16] have been measured by two methods, with or without requirement of the N∗N^{*} cuts, and the difference between the two resulting data sets is modest compared with the evaluated statistical and systematic uncertainties [16].

Figure 4. Differential cross sections (blue solid lines) for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p with f0(980)f_{0}(980) decaying into π0π0\pi^{0}\pi^{0} obtained from Model I. The cyan double-dot-dashed lines, red dotted lines, black dashed lines, and green dot-dashed lines denote the individual contributions from the tt-channel ρ\rho exchange, tt-channel ω\omega exchange, ss-channel resonance exchange, and uu-channel NN exchange, respectively. The quantities in square brackets are the ranges of the center-of-mass energy of the system, in MeV. The data are the same as in Fig. 2.

Photon beam asymmetries $\Sigma$ for $\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p$

Figure 5. Photon beam asymmetries (blue solid lines) Σ\Sigma for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p obtained from Model I. The cyan double-dot-dashed lines, red dotted lines, black dashed lines, and green dot-dashed lines denote the results with the tt-channel ρ\rho exchange, tt-channel ω\omega exchange, ss-channel resonance exchange, and uu-channel NN exchange being switched off, respectively. The quantities in square brackets are the ranges of the center-of-mass energy of the system, in MeV. The data are the same as in Fig. 3.

In Figure 4, the contributions from the individual terms of the tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges, the ss-channel N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^{+} exchange, and the uu-channel NN exchange are also shown. The contributions from the ss-channel NN exchange and the interaction current are too small to be clearly seen with the scale used and they are not plotted. We can see from Figure 4 that the overall agreement of the model results with the data is reasonable. The contributions from the ss-channel N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ exchange dominate the cross sections in the energy region of the LEPS2/BGOegg measurements. Noticeable contributions from the tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges can be seen at forward angles at the higher energy point. Besides, considerable contributions from the uu-channel NN exchange can be seen at the backward angles.

For the beam asymmetries Σ\Sigma shown in Figure 5, the effects of the individual terms of the tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges, the ss-channel N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ exchange, and the uu-channel NN exchange are calculated by switching off the corresponding amplitudes in the full reaction amplitudes. One can see that the full model results describe the data fairly well. The ss-channel N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ exchange has very strong effect on beam asymmetries. The tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega have significant effects mainly at forward angles, and the uu-channel NN exchange has significant effects mainly at backward angles. Effects from the ss-channel NN exchange and the interaction current are very small and not shown in Figure 5.

The results obtained from Model II are shown in Figure 6 and Figure 7 for the differential cross sections and beam asymmetries Σ\Sigma, respectively. Overall, the agreement of the model results with the data is also reasonable. In Figure 6, one can see that the contributions from the ss-channel N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ exchange dominate the cross sections of this reaction. As expected, the contributions from the tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges are the same as the ones in Model I. However, unlike the situation in Model I, the contributions from the uu-channel NN exchange are now much smaller in Model II. This is simply because the fitted cutoff values ΛB=958\Lambda_B = 958 and coupling constant ∣gNNf0∣=2.08\lvert g_{NNf_0}\rvert= 2.08 obtained in Model I are much larger than the corresponding values ΛB=800\Lambda_B = 800 MeV and ∣gNNf0∣=0.65\lvert g_{NNf_0}\rvert= 0.65 obtained in Model II, as shown in Table II. The contributions from the ss-channel NN exchange and the interaction current are too small and they are not shown in Figs. 6. For the beam asymmetries Σ\Sigma shown in Figure 7, we can see that the ss-channel N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ exchange has relatively stronger effects, and the tt-channel ω\omega exchange has considerable effects at forward angles at the higher energy point.

Figure 6. Differential cross sections for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p with f0(980)f_{0}(980) decaying into π0π0\pi^{0}\pi^{0} obtained from Model II. The quantities in square brackets are the ranges of the center-of-mass energy of the system, in MeV. Notations for lines and data are the same as in Fig. 4.

Photon beam asymmetries for $\gamma p \to f_0(980)p$

Figure 7. Photon beam asymmetries for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p obtained from Model II. The effects from individual contributions are calculated by switching off the corresponding amplitudes in the full reaction amplitudes. The quantities in square brackets are the ranges of the center-of-mass energy of the system, in MeV. Notations for lines and data are the same as in Figure 5.

In Figure 8, the predictions of the target asymmetries TT at W=2004W = 2004 MeV and W=2215W = 2215 MeV for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p obtained from Model I and Model II are shown. One can see the predicted target asymmetries from these two models are quite different. Data from future experiments on this observable are called on to distinguish Model I and Model II for the γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p reaction.

Predictions of target asymmetries $T$ for $\gamma p \to f_0(980)p$

Figure 8. Predictions of target asymmetries TT for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p from Model I (blue solid lines) and Model II (cyan dotted lines).

In brief, by including the contributions from either the N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ or N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ resonances, the data from the LEPS2/BGOegg Collaboration [16] on both the differential cross sections and the photon beam asymmetries for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p can be well reproduced. In both cases, contributions from individual reaction mechanism are discussed and predictions of the beam-target asymmetry are given to examine the models.

Summary and conclusion

The data from the LEPS2/BGOegg Collaboration [16] on differential cross sections and photon beam asymmetries for the γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_0(980)p reaction are analyzed within a tree-level effective Lagrangian approach. The theoretical model is constructed by considering the contributions from the tt-channel ρ\rho and ω\omega exchanges, the uu- and ss-channel NN exchanges, the interaction current, and the ss-channel N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ or N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ resonance exchange. The contributions from the ss-channel N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ or N(2100)1/2+N(2100)1/2^+ resonance exchange are found to dominate the differential cross sections and have significant effects on the photon beam asymmetries in the energy region considered. The contributions from the uu-channel NN exchange are considerable in the case of including N(2040)3/2+N(2040)3/2^+ while negligible in the case of including N(2100)1/2−N(2100)_{1/2}^{-}. Predictions of the target asymmetries TT for γp→f0(980)p\gamma p \to f_{0}(980)p in both models with either N(2040)3/2+N(2040)_{3/2}^{+} or N(2100)1/2−N(2100)_{1/2}^{-} resonance are given, which is expected to be examined by the future experiments.

Acknowledgments

The author Neng-Chang Wei thanks N. Muramatsu for kindly providing the experimental data for the present work. This work is partially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grants No. 12305137, No. 12175240, and No. 11635009, the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities, and the China Postdoctoral Science Foundation under Grants No. 2021M693141 and No. 2021M693142.

References

  1. [1]R. L. Workman et al. (Particle Data Group), Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2022, 083C01 (2022).
  2. [2]M. Battaglieri et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 102001 (2009).
  3. [3]D. G. Ireland, E. Pasyuk, and I. Strakovsky, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 111, 103752 (2020).
  4. [4]V. I. Mokeev et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Few Body Syst. 63, 59 (2022).
  5. [5]J. M. Laget, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 111, 103737 (2020).
  6. [6]I. G. Aznauryan and V. D. Burkert, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 67, 1 (2012).
  7. [7]H. Kohri et al. (LEPS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 172001 (2010).
  8. [8]F. W. Wieland et al., Eur. Phys. J A 47, 47 (2011); 47, 133(E) (2011).
  9. [9]K. Moriya et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. C 88, 045201 (2013); 88, 049902(E) (2013).
  10. [10]U. Shrestha et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. C 103, 025206 (2021).
  11. [11]S. Chandavar et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. C 97, 025203 (2018).
  12. [12]M. Battaglieri et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. D 80, 072005 (2009).
  13. [13]S. Lombardo et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. D 98, 052009 (2018).
  14. [14]N. Zachariou et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Lett. B 827, 136985 (2022).
  15. [15]N. Zachariou et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Lett. B 808, 135662 (2020).
  16. [16]N. Muramatsu et al. (LEPS2/BGOegg Collaboration), Phys. Rev. C 107, L042201 (2023).
  17. [17]M. L. L. da Silva and M. V. T. Machado, Phys. Rev. C 87, 065201 (2013).
  18. [18]A. Donnachie and Y. S. Kalashnikova, Phys. Rev. C 93, 025203 (2016).
  19. [19]I. S. Barker and J. K. Storrow, Nucl. Phys. B 137, 413 (1978).
  20. [20]J. H. Lee, H. C. Kim, S. H. Kim, H. Y. Ryu, and B. G. Yu, Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2017, 093D05 (2017).
  21. [21]H. Xing, C. S. An, J. J. Xie, and G. Li, Phys. Rev. D 98, 094007 (2018).
  22. [22]C. R. Ji, R. Kaminski, L. Lesniak, A. Szczepaniak, and R. Williams, Phys. Rev. C 58, 1205 (1998).
  23. [23]V. E. Tarasov, W. J. Briscoe, W. Gradl, A. E. Kudryavtsev, and I. I. Strakovsky, Phys. Rev. C 88, 035207 (2013).
  24. [24]H. Haberzettl, Phys. Rev. C 56, 2041 (1997).
  25. [25]H. Haberzettl, K. Nakayama, and S. Krewald, Phys. Rev. C 74, 045202 (2006).
  26. [26]F. Huang, M. Döring, H. Haberzettl, J. Haidenbauer, C. Hanhart, S. Krewald, U.-G. Meißner, and K. Nakayama, Phys. Rev. C 85, 054003 (2012).
  27. [27]F. Huang, H. Haberzettl, and K. Nakayama, Phys. Rev. C 87, 054004 (2013).
  28. [28]A. C. Wang, W. L. Wang, F. Huang, H. Haberzettl, and K. Nakayama, Phys. Rev. C 96, 035206 (2017).
  29. [29]A. C. Wang, W. L. Wang, and F. Huang, Phys. Rev. C 98, 045209 (2018).
  30. [30]M. Benmerrouche, R. M. Davidson, and N. C. Mukhopadhyay, Phys. Rev. C 39, 2339 (1989).
  31. [31]T. Vrancx, L. De Cruz, J. Ryckebusch, and P. Van-craeyveld, Phys. Rev. C 84, 045201 (2011).
  32. [32]D. Skoupil and P. Bydžovský, Phys. Rev. C 93, 025204 (2016).
  33. [33]T. Mart, J. Kristiano, and S. Clymton, Phys. Rev. C 100, 035207 (2019).
  34. [34]H. Nagorny, L. Roca, and E. Oset, Eur. Phys. J. A 36, 73 (2008).
  35. [35]B. Aubert et al. (BaBar Collaboration), Phys. Rev. D 74, 032003 (2006).
  36. [36]M. Ablikim et al. (BES Collaboration), Phys. Rev. D 72, 092002 (2005).
  37. [37]V. V. Anisovich, V. A. Nikonov, and A. V. Sarantsev, Phys. Atom. Nucl. 65, 1545 (2002).

Paper details

vlnc:W_j7rxfygg
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 7

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents