betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Characterization of parabolic rectifiability in terms of Jones' square function

Abstract

We show that a measure μμ in Rn×R\mathbb{R}^n \times \mathbb{R} equipped with the parabolic metric is rectifiable (in the parabolic sense) if and only if the Jones' square function is finite μμ-almost everywhere. This square function is constructed using the parabolic version of the Jones' beta numbers, which control how close μμ is to being supported in time-independent planes (these planes are the paradigmatic example of parabolic rectifiable set). Our only background assumption is that μμ has positive and finite densities (qualitatively) almost everywhere. A key feature of our proof is the use of a parabolic version of the Reifenberg parametrization theorem, which in the Euclidean setting is due to David and Toro (MAMS, 2012), and has recently been extended to the parabolic setting by Hoffman, Mourgoglou and the fourth author. In the latter work, the authors construct a bi-Hölder map. Here, under an additional summability condition, we improve this construction to obtain a parabolic regular bi-Lipschitz map. This improvement in regularity plays a crucial role in our arguments.

Disclaimer for this version

The results in this manuscript are parabolic extensions of the Euclidean papers of Tolsa [19] and Azzam and Tolsa [3]. In the advanced stages of writing this article, we learned of the preprint [13] which announces a proof of the main result here (and actually, many other results). While the article [13] does provide a Lean certificate for these results (based on 176000 lines of Lean code, according to the author), there are no real details about the strategy or the proof itself.

This article is a polished version of the parts of the manuscript which were already written at the time of the announcement [13]. There are several new difficulties that arise only in the parabolic setting, and these are the ones we treat in detail in this manuscript, including detailed proofs of all the truly parabolic challenges. However, in order to offer a fully self-contained proof of our main result, we should include an abstract stopping-time arguments from [3] that carries over to the parabolic setting with essentially no change. These arguments have not yet been written out in full and are therefore only presented as a sketch.

While we believe this article offers genuine new insights into the main problem, and parabolic rectifiability in general, it was not our original intention to make the manuscript public before these remaining details had been completed. Unfortunately, we decided that we could not delay the upload any further; the missing details will appear in a revised version as soon as possible. We apologize for the possible inconveniences that this may offer to the reader, this is just one of the many unusual scenarios in which we find ourselves as we transition from the pre-AI to the post-AI world.

Introduction

Rectifiability is a central concept in modern geometric measure theory and, more generally, analysis. It has deep connections with different areas, like harmonic analysis: for instance, in [17], it is shown that if the Riesz transforms are bounded in L2L^2 weighted by the surface measure of a set, then such set is rectifiable. This, in turn, has implications in PDE theory: in [1] it was shown that the subset of the boundary of a domain in which the harmonic and surface measure are absolutely continuous, is in fact rectifiable. Similarly, in free boundary problems, it is often the case that lower dimensional strata of the singular set of the free boundary are rectifiable, and this is very informative about their structure; see e.g. [9, 15].

In the Euclidean setting, a finite Borel measure μ\mu is (n−1)(n-1)-rectifiable if it is absolutely continuous with respect to Hausdorff measure (n−1)(n-1)-dimensional Hausdorff measure and if we can cover μ\mu-a.e. its support with a countable number of Lipschitz images of Rn−1\mathbb{R}^{n-1}. Tolsa [19] and Azzam-Tolsa [3] showed that (under background density assumptions) rectifiability of μ\mu is equivalent to the square function associated to the Jones’ beta numbers of μ\mu being finite μ\mu-a.e. (these coefficients measure how close is μ\mu to being supported over planes, at all scales; we will present them more rigorously soon).

In connection with parabolic PDE, rectifiability necessarily takes a different form. Indeed, the natural metric of space-time Rn×R\mathbb{R}^n \times\mathbb{R} that respects the natural homogeneity/invariance of the heat equation (the equation is invariant under the transformation (X,t)↦(λX,λ2t)(X,t) \mapsto(\lambda X,\lambda^2t) for λ>0\lambda> 0), is not just the Euclidean metric in Rn+1\mathbb{R}^{n+1}. Under this metric, parabolic Lipschitz functions are Lipschitz in space, but only Hölder-1/2 in time. And it turns out that covering a set (like supp⁡μ\operatorname{supp}\mu) by images of these parabolic Lipschitz functions is not enough to provide meaningful applications (see e.g. the counterexample of [14]).

After the quantitative results of Lewis and Murray [16], and Hofmann, Martell, Nyström and the first author [5], and the qualitative result of Egert, Ferris, Saari and the first author [4] (among several other relevant related works), it is now understood what is the correct notion of parabolic rectifiability in order to obtain the analogous PDE applications as in the Euclidean case. Indeed, not only parabolic Lipschitzianity is needed, but an additional regularity in time (certain control on the oscillations of the half-order time derivatives, see § 3.2), and concretely, parabolic flatness means being close to vertical (that is, time-independent) planes (as opposed to arbitrary planes in the Euclidean setting). This imposes real new difficulties when trying to show that a set or a measure is parabolic rectifiable. In this paper, we overcome these difficulties to show that a measure is parabolic rectifiable if and only if the associated parabolic Jones square function is finite μ\mu-a.e. (under background density hypotheses), thus, adapting [19, 3] to the parabolic setting.

Main result

We quantify how flat a measure μ\mu in space-time Rn×R\mathbb{R}^n \times\mathbb{R} is by using the parabolic version of the beta numbers originally introduced by Jones in [12]. Beta numbers measure, at a concrete scale and location, and in a scale-invariant fashion, how close the set is to a vertical plane:

βμ((X,t),r):=inf⁡P(1rn+1∫Bp((X,t),r)(dist⁡p((Y,s),P)r)2 dμ(Y,s))1/2,\beta_\mu((X,t),r) := \inf_P \left( \frac{1}{r^{n+1}} \int_{B_p((X,t),r)} \left( \frac{\operatorname{dist}_p((Y,s),P)}{r} \right)^2 \,d\mu(Y,s) \right)^{1/2},

where PP runs over the family of affine planes in Rn+1\mathbb{R}^{n+1} which contain a line in the time direction, the so-called vertical or tt-independent planes. Vertical planes are the prototypical example of a parabolic rectifiable set. For this and more notation, like parabolic distance dist⁡p\operatorname{dist}_p or cylinders BpB_p, we direct the reader to § 3.1.

In light of this definition, our main result reads as follows.

Theorem 1.1 (Summability of beta numbers is equivalent to rectifiability). Let μ\mu be a finite Borel measure in space-time Rn×R\mathbb{R}^n \times\mathbb{R} endowed with the parabolic metric, and assume that

0<Θn+1,∗((X,t),μ):=lim sup⁡r→0μ(Bp((X,t),r))rn+1<+∞,for μ-a.e. (X,t)∈Rn×R.0 < \Theta^{n+1,*}((X,t),\mu) := \limsup_{r \to0} \frac{\mu(B_p((X,t),r))}{r^{n+1}} < +\infty,\qquad\text{for }\mu\text{-a.e. }(X,t) \in\mathbb{R}^n \times\mathbb{R}.

Then, the square function of the beta numbers is finite μ\mu-a.e., that is,

∫01βμ((X,t),r)2drr<+∞,for μ-a.e. (X,t)∈Rn×R,(1)\int_0^1 \beta_\mu((X,t),r)^2\frac{\mathrm{d}r}{r}<+\infty,\qquad\text{for }\mu\text{-a.e. }(X,t)\in\mathbb{R}^n\times\mathbb{R}, \tag*{(1)}

if and only if μ\mu is parabolic rectifiable, that is, μ≪Hpn+1\mu\ll\mathcal{H}_p^{n+1} and there exist countably many regular Lip⁡(1,1/2)\operatorname{Lip}(1,1/2) graphs Γj\Gamma_j such that

μ(Rn+1∖⋃j=1∞Γj)=0.\mu\left(\mathbb{R}^{n+1}\setminus\bigcup_{j=1}^{\infty}\Gamma_j\right)=0.

For the definition of regular Lip⁡(1,1/2)\operatorname{Lip}(1,1/2) graphs, we refer to § 3.2.

Remark 1.2 (Homogeneities and dimension). As a quick note to understand the homogeneities in our main result: the prototypical parabolic rectifiable set is a vertical plane, such as P:={(X,t)∈Rn×R:Xn=0}P:=\{(X,t)\in\mathbb{R}^n\times\mathbb{R}:X_n=0\}. A good example of measure to test our theorem would be \mu:=\mathcal{H}_p^{n+1}\mathbin{\vrule height 1.4ex depth -0.3ex width 0.07ex\vrule height 0.07ex depth -0.02ex width 0.8ex}P. Indeed, although PP has topological dimension nn, the fact that we have endowed space-time with the parabolic metric (see § 3.1) makes PP have homogeneous dimension n+1n+1. In the same way, the ambient space-time Rn×R\mathbb{R}^n\times\mathbb{R} has homogeneous dimension n+2n+2.

Remark 1.3 (Background assumptions). The implication that rectifiability yields μ\mu-a.e. finiteness of the beta square function does not require the background assumption on the density, as was that case in the Euclidean counterpart, see [19].

Sketch of the proof and organization of the article

After a section giving the necessary definitions and preliminaries (§ 3), the article is divided into two parts. In the first part, we prove the implication that finiteness of the square function of the beta numbers implies rectifiability (that is, the parabolic version of the theorem of Azzam and Tolsa [3]): the proof is given across Sections 33, 44 and 55. The second part deals with the converse implication that rectifiability implies finiteness of the Jones’ square function (that is, the parabolic version of the theorem of Tolsa [19]): the proof is given in Sections 66, 77 and 88.

First implication. The proof that finiteness of the beta square function implies parabolic rectifiability, requires harder work to be adapted from the Euclidean analogue of Azzam and Tolsa [3]. Indeed, the main problem when extending Azzam-Tolsa’s proof to the parabolic setting is that we need to prove that the graphs Γj\Gamma_j are not only (parabolic) Lipschitz, but also regular (in the sense of Definition 2.7), which is crucial to prove parabolic rectifiability.

To prove that the approximating graphs are regular Lip⁡(1,1/2)\operatorname{Lip}(1,1/2), one needs to strengthen the construction in [3 Subsection 6.2], in which these graphs are constructed using a theorem of David-Toro [8], inspired by earlier work of Reifenberg. Given a grid of nested balls (associated to a stopping-time regime in which the densities of μ\mu and the β\beta numbers are under control) and the associated best approximating planes (which form controlled angles with their neighbors because of the control on the β\beta numbers), the David-Toro argument constructs a bi-Hölder map by carefully gluing together these planes across all scales. Under an additional summability condition on the angles between consecutive planes, one can guarantee that this map is bi-Lipschitz, which is what is used in [3]. The bi-Hölder version of this theorem has recently been implemented in the parabolic setting by Hoffman, Mourgoglou and the fourth author [HHM26]. In this paper we deal with the bi-Lipschitz result. Moreover, we show how to obtain a map which is regular parabolic bi-Lipschitz.

More precisely, in § 4, we show that the construction from [HHM26] can be imported to our setting (see Theorem 3.5, and Subsection 3.1), and actually can be enhanced to a bi-Lipschitz map (see Theorem 3.6). The key idea is that, as happened in the Euclidean setting, the control on the beta square function gives a control over how much the angles can change and how those changes accumulate over scales. So under the assumption of smallness of the beta square function, the constructed parametrization can be chosen not to oscillate too much, which ultimately gives bi-Lipschitzianity. This argument is carried out along Subsection 3.2. We note that, as well as this bi-Lipschitz construction, we show that the sequence of approximating set i.e., the images of the functions in the approximation, can be written locally as Lipschitz graphs with precise estimates on the first-order time and second order spatial derivatives (see Lemma 3.18). Although, we found a way in this case to prove parabolic regularity without this, we believe that such properties will be essential in future works.

In Section 4, we show that the constructed graphs are actually regular Lip⁡(1,1/2)\operatorname{Lip}(1,1/2), at least in appropriate stopping-time regimes; see Proposition 4.1. After some technical work adapting the arguments of [3] to the parabolic setting, we arrive at Subsection 4.3, where regularity of the map is shown (Proposition 4.16), which is the main novelty. We need to control how the beta numbers (or even better, the Omega numbers) accumulate over scales: after separating several easier cases, like scales which are much larger (Lemma 4.18), smaller (Lemma 4.26) or very far (Lemma 4.19) from the scales associated to the stopping-time regime under consideration, we are left to estimate what happens precisely at those relevant scales. Upon establishing a precise relationship between the stopping-time cubes and the geometrical scales in Lemma 4.20, we exploit further properties of the construction and the stopping-time regime to show the required bound for the beta numbers in Lemma 4.25.

Finally, in Section 5, once we know that the graphs constructed via the Reifenberg parametrization scheme are regular parabolic bi-Lipschitz, we can simply follow the rest of the abstract arguments from [3] to finish the proof of the implication in Theorem 1.1.

Second implication. The proof of the implication of Theorem 1.1 in which parabolic rectifiability implies finiteness of the square function of the beta numbers is an adaptation to the parabolic setting of the Euclidean work of Tolsa in [19]. We start by some preliminary notation (in Section 6) which sometimes differs from the previous sections.

In Section 7, we prove a related version of the required implication, which instead of considering the square function of the beta numbers, uses the alpha numbers instead. The main result is Theorem 7.1, in which the square function of the αμ\alpha_{\mu} numbers (measuring flatness of μ\mu) are seen to be σ\sigma-a.e. finite, where σ\sigma is the surface measure of a regular Lip⁡(1,1/2)\operatorname{Lip}(1,1/2) graph Γ\Gamma. In order to prove this, one first restricts to the case where μ\mu is not just an arbitrary measure, but it supported over Γ\Gamma (Subsection 7.2): the proof in this case is very harmonic analytical in nature, using a Calderón-Zygmund decomposition of μ\mu with respect to σ\sigma to handle cancellations. For the general case where μ\mu is not necessarily supported over Γ\Gamma, we construct (in Subsection 7.3) a measure η\eta supported over Γ\Gamma which somehow resembles μ\mu (we use Whitney cubes to encapsulate the behavior at different scales, and then project them towards Γ\Gamma), and then show that the alpha numbers of μ\mu are controlled with respect to those for η\eta up to some error terms (in Subsection 7.4). Since η\eta is supported over Γ\Gamma, Subsection 7.2 provides its control; and we handle the rest of error terms in Subsection 7.5.

In Section 8, we prove that, whenever the alpha-square function is finite μ\mu-a.e., then so is the beta-square function, which jointly with the previous section, gives the full implication of Theorem 1.1. To prove the main result of this section, namely Proposition 8.1, we perform a stopping-time argument, restricting to cubes with controlled densities and small alpha numbers (Subsection 8.2). In Subsection 8.3, we control angles between approximating planes at neighboring scales, and iterating these along chains of cubes in the stopping-time regimes that finish in a good cube. Then, in Subsection 8.4, we use the results from the last section and our choice for the stopping-time regimes, to first show that they imply bounds for the beta-square function restricted to the good cubes, and later to all the cubes in the regime, which finishes the proof of Proposition 8.1.

Preliminaries

We will utilize the customary notation that C,c>0C,c>0 stands for a constant that may change from line to line, and X≲YX\lesssim Y is an equivalent notation to X≤CYX\le CY. We sometimes make explicit what the implicit constant depends on using the notation X≲AYX\lesssim_A Y. In turn, X≈YX\approx Y mean X≲Y≲XX\lesssim Y\lesssim X, and X≈κYX\approx_{\kappa}Y is defined in the obvious way.

Parabolic setting

  • (Points) We denote points in space-time Rn+1\mathbb{R}^{n+1} by (X,t)∈Rn×R(X,t)\in\mathbb{R}^n\times\mathbb{R}.

  • (Parabolic norm) Let ∣⋅∣|\cdot| denote the standard Euclidean norm on Rn\mathbb{R}^n and define the parabolic norm on Rn+1\mathbb{R}^{n+1} by

∥(X,t)∥:=∣X∣+∣t∣12.\|(X,t)\|:=|X|+|t|^{\frac{1}{2}}.
  • (Parabolic distance) For (X,t),(Y,s)∈Rn+1(X,t),(Y,s)\in\mathbb{R}^{n+1}, define

dp(X,t,Y,s):=dp((X,t),(Y,s)):=∥(X,t)−(Y,s)∥.d_p(X,t,Y,s):=d_p((X,t),(Y,s)):=\|(X,t)-(Y,s)\|.

Diameters of sets with respect to this metric are denoted by diam⁡p\operatorname{diam}_p.

  • (Parabolic cylinders) For (X,t)∈Rn+1(X,t)\in\mathbb{R}^{n+1} and r>0r>0, let

Bp(X,t,r):=Bp((X,t),r):={(Y,s)∈Rn+1:∣X−Y∣≤r and ∣t−s∣≤r2}.B_p(X,t,r):=B_p((X,t),r):=\{(Y,s)\in\mathbb{R}^{n+1}:|X-Y|\le r\text{ and }|t-s|\le r^2\}.

We sometimes denote this cylinder by Br(X,t)B_r(X,t), too. We write r(B)r(B) for the radius of the cylinder, and θB\theta B (for some θ>0\theta>0) is the cylinder with the same center as BB, and radius θr(B)\theta r(B).

  • (Vertical planes) An affine plane V⊆Rn+1V\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{n+1} is tt-independent if VV contains a line in the tt-direction. Such a plane is also called vertical.

  • (Parabolic Hausdorff measure and dimension) We define parabolic Hausdorff measure and dimension as usual, but using the parabolic metric. Indeed, for η,δ>0\eta,\delta>0 and E⊆Rn+1E\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{n+1}, define

Hp,δη(E):=inf⁡{∑jdiam⁡p(Ej)η:E⊆⋃jEj and diam⁡p(Ej)≤δ}.\mathcal{H}_{p,\delta}^{\eta}(E):=\inf\left\{\sum_j\operatorname{diam}_p(E_j)^\eta:E\subseteq\bigcup_j E_j\text{ and }\operatorname{diam}_p(E_j)\le\delta\right\}.

Then, define the parabolic Hausdorff measure of dimension η\eta by

Hpη(E):=lim⁡δ→0Hp,δη(E).\mathcal{H}_p^\eta(E):=\lim_{\delta\to0}\mathcal{H}_{p,\delta}^\eta(E).

We also define parabolic Hausdorff dimension by

dim⁡Hp(E):=inf⁡{η>0:Hpη(E)=0}=sup⁡{η>0:Hpη(E)=∞}.\dim_{\mathcal{H}_p}(E):=\inf\{\eta>0:\mathcal{H}_p^\eta(E)=0\}=\sup\{\eta>0:\mathcal{H}_p^\eta(E)=\infty\}.
  • (Bilateral distance between sets) Given two closed sets E,F⊂Rn+1E,F\subset\mathbb{R}^{n+1}, (X,t)∈Rn+1(X,t)\in\mathbb{R}^{n+1} and r>0r>0, we denote

d(X,t),r(E,F):=1rmax⁡{sup⁡(Y,s)∈E∩Bp(X,t,r)dp((Y,s),F),sup⁡(Y,s)∈F∩Bp(X,t,r)dp((Y,s),E)}.d_{(X,t),r}(E,F):=\frac{1}{r}\max\left\{\sup_{(Y,s)\in E\cap B_p(X,t,r)}d_p((Y,s),F),\sup_{(Y,s)\in F\cap B_p(X,t,r)}d_p((Y,s),E)\right\}.

Sometimes we also denote this quantity dBp(X,t,r)(E,F)d_{B_p(X,t,r)}(E,F).

Flatness coefficients and parabolic rectifiability

As already said in the introduction, we quantify how flat a measure is by using the parabolic version of the beta numbers originally introduced by Jones in [12]:

Definition 2.1 (Beta numbers). For a given (X,t)∈Rn×R(X,t)\in\mathbb{R}^n\times\mathbb{R} and r>0r>0, we define

References

  1. [1]J. Azzam, S. Hofmann, J. M. Martell, S. Mayboroda, M. Mourgoglou, X. Tolsa, and A. Volberg. Rectifiability of harmonic measure. Geom. Funct. Anal., 26(3):703–728, 2016.DOI
  2. [2]J. Azzam and R. Schul. An analyst’s traveling salesman theorem for sets of dimension larger than one. Math. Ann., 370(3):1389–1476, 2018.arxiv.org/abs/1609.02892
  3. [3]J. Azzam and X. Tolsa. Characterization of n-rectifiability in terms of Jones’ square function. II. Geom. Funct. Anal., 25(5):1371–1412, 2015.arxiv.org/abs/1501.01572
  4. [4]S. Bortz, M. Egert, S. Ferris, and O. Saari. The parabolic Dini-β condition and absolute continuity of surface and caloric measure. arXiv preprint arXiv:2608.23240, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2608.23240
  5. [5]S. Bortz, S. Hofmann, J. M. Martell, and K. Nyström. Solvability of the L^p Dirichlet problem for the heat equation is equivalent to parabolic uniform rectifiability in the case of a parabolic lipschitz graph. Inventiones mathematicae, 239(1):165–217, 2025.
  6. [6]S. Bortz, M. Hyde, and M. Sharp. Big pieces of regular parabolic (bi-)Lipschitz images is equivalent to parabolic uniform rectifiability, 2026. arXiv:2608.23250v1.arxiv.org/abs/2608.23250
  7. [7]G. David and P. Mattila. Removable sets for Lipschitz harmonic functions in the plane. Revista Matematica Iberoamericana, 16(1):137–215, 2000.DOI
  8. [8]G. David and T. Toro. Reifenberg parameterizations for sets with holes, volume 1012 of Mem. Am. Math. Soc. American Mathematical Society, 2012.arxiv.org/abs/0910.4869
  9. [9]N. Edelen and M. Engelstein. Quantitative stratification for some free-boundary problems. Transactions of the American Mathematical Society, 371(3):2043–2072, 2019.
  10. [11]T. Hytönen and A. Kairema. Systems of dyadic cubes in a doubling metric space. Colloq. Math., 126(1):1–33, 2012.arxiv.org/abs/1012.1985
  11. [12]P. W. Jones. Rectifiable sets and the traveling salesman problem. Invent. Math., 102(1):1–15, 1990.DOI
  12. [13]R. Koirala. Parabolic rectifiable Reifenberg for measures. arXiv preprint arXiv:2610.35809v1, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2610.35809
  13. [14]R. Kaufman and J.-M. Wu. Singularity of parabolic measures. Compositio Mathematica, 40(2):243–250, 1980.
  14. [15]D. Kriventsov and G. Weiss. Rectifiability, finite Hausdorff measure, and compactness for non-minimizing Bernoulli free boundaries. Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, 78(3):545–591, 2025.
  15. [16]J. L. Lewis and M. Murray. The method of layer potentials for the heat equation in time-varying domains. Mem. Amer. Math. Soc., 114:viii+157, 1995.DOI
  16. [17]F. Nazarov, X. Tolsa, and A. Volberg. The Riesz transform, rectifiability, and removability for Lipschitz harmonic functions. Publ. Mat., 58:517–532, 2014.
  17. [18]X. Tolsa. Uniform rectifiability, Calderón-Zygmund operators with odd kernel, and quasiorthogonality. Proc. Lond. Math. Soc. (3), 98(2):393–426, 2009.DOI
  18. [19]X. Tolsa. Characterization of n-rectifiability in terms of Jones’ square function: Part I. Calculus of Variations and Partial Differential Equations, 54(4):3643–3665, 2015.arxiv.org/abs/1501.01569

Paper details

vlnc:W_j8ygpu32
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents