betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Two correlation scales in homogeneous density-matrix functionals: the Müller logarithm and the sharp Csányi–Arias asymptotics

Abstract

We resolve the exact high-density correlation scales and coefficients of the three-dimensional translation-invariant, spin-symmetric Müller and Csányi–Arias corrected Hartree–Fock (CHF) functionals, settling long-standing numerical observations of Müller overcorrelation and apparently vanishing CHF correlation. In Hartree units, for fixed spin multiplicity qq and Fermi momentum k=(6π2ρ/q)1/3k=(6π^2ρ/q)^{1/3}, their gains per particle over the filled Fermi sea satisfy DM(k)=34π2log⁡k+O(1),DCHF(k)=12e−1/2−π2/8k2e−π3/2k(1+o(1)). D_{\rm M}(k)=\frac{3}{4π^2}\log k+O(1),\qquad D_{\rm CHF}(k)=12e^{-1/2-π^2/8} k^2e^{-π^{3/2}\sqrt{k}}(1+o(1)). The Müller proof retains the occupation cap and identifies the factor-of-two cancellation between exchange defect and energy gain. For periodic Müller jellium, convexity and translation–spin averaging allow a global minimizer to be chosen invariant and identify the unrestricted thermodynamic energy with the homogeneous spin-symmetric value. The CHF upper bound follows from a deterministic comparison built from the explicit Hartree–Fock dispersion, combining a full Birman–Schwinger bound with one-sided norms and completion of the square; a number-preserving trial state provides the matching lower bound, and the retained remainder yields weighted L2L^2 convergence of the occupation defect without analyzing the self-consistent gap. We also prove existence for both functionals and uniqueness of the CHF minimizer. Relative to the unpolarized quantum high-density benchmark, Müller has a larger logarithmic coefficient, providing quantitative evidence for the conjectured Müller lower-bound property, whereas CHF misses the logarithmic scale altogether. The quantum benchmark is not used in either functional proof.

Introduction: origins, benchmarks, and the two correlation scales

Reduced density-matrix functionals aim to retain the exact one-body kinetic energy while replacing the two-body interaction by an explicit expression in the one-particle density matrix.

The work has been supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG TRR 352), grant 470903074.

The author acknowledges the use of OpenAI’s ChatGPT and Google’s Gemini for mathematical discussions, the development and checking of arguments, and assistance in preparing the manuscript. The author takes full responsibility for the final text and proofs. This places fractional natural-orbital occupations, rather than an idempotent Hartree–Fock projector, among the variational degrees of freedom. The foundational background includes Coleman’s characterization of ensemble-representable one-particle density matrices [7] and Gilbert’s extension of the density-functional framework to nonlocal external potentials [12]. The conditions 0≤γ≤10 \le\gamma\le1 and tr⁡γ=N\operatorname{tr}\gamma= N concern one-particle representability; they must not be confused with representability of an approximate two-particle density matrix.

From the square-root ansatz to corrected Hartree–Fock

In 1984 Müller [18] proposed an approximation to the two-particle density matrix that replaces the Hartree–Fock occupation factor ninjn_i n_j in the exchange term by ninj\sqrt{n_i n_j}. The square-root choice is tied to the contraction relation between reduced density matrices and to Pauli-type constraints. Buijse and Baerends [2] later obtained the same square-root expression from an exchange-correlation hole construction. These are related routes to the functional now usually called the Müller functional.

Csányi and Arias [8] developed a tensor-product approximation to the two-particle density matrix. Their “corrected Hartree” (CH) functional coincides with the Müller functional. Their distinct “corrected Hartree–Fock” (CHF) functional retains ordinary exchange and adds an exchange-type term involving γ(1−γ)\sqrt{\gamma(1-\gamma)}. For homogeneous spin-symmetric occupations the two interaction factors are, respectively,

n(p)n(p′),n(p)n(p′)+n(p)(1−n(p))n(p′)(1−n(p′)).\sqrt{n(p)n(p')}, \qquad n(p)n(p')+\sqrt{n(p)(1-n(p))n(p')(1-n(p'))}.

Throughout this paper, CHF denotes this original corrected Hartree–Fock functional, not the later Csányi–Goedecker–Arias functional [9]. Staroverov and Scuseria [22] related CHF optimization to Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov methods, with a reversal of the pairing-energy sign. The associated gap equation is a useful variational structure; it is not, by itself, a statement about superconductivity of the repulsive many-electron Coulomb Hamiltonian.

What was known about these functionals

Cioslowski and Pernal [5] analyzed homogeneous momentum occupations and the regime in which the occupation cap is inactive. Csányi and Arias [8] numerically observed excess correlation for CH and near-zero correlation for CHF at high density, reporting a fitted logarithmic slope for CH in a study covering 0.01<rs<300.01 < r_s < 30. Lathiotakis, Helbig, and Gross [15] subsequently compared these and other density-matrix functionals on the homogeneous electron gas, confirming both occupation pinning for Müller and the rapid collapse of the CHF correlation energy as rs↓0r_s \downarrow0, while Cioslowski, Ziesche, and Pernal [6] derived high-density momentum constraints on simple natural-spin-orbital functionals. The earlier finite-density calculations reveal this qualitative contrast, but they do not determine the exact high-density scales and coefficients with controlled asymptotic errors. For Müller, a finite-range logarithmic fit does not identify the limiting coefficient. For CHF, the stretched-exponential gain poses a severe resolution problem, particularly when it is obtained by subtracting total energies. The calculations in [8] discuss discretization, momentum-cutoff, regularization, and minimization errors; [15] also discusses numerical false pinning of occupations. These issues are not limitations of every possible numerical method: higher precision, suitable rescaling, and a direct calculation of energy differences can improve numerical access. The present analysis determines the exact asymptotic scales and sharp limiting coefficients without relying on finite-range extrapolations.

The mathematical theory of Müller’s functional was developed by Frank, Lieb, Seiringer, and Siedentop [10]: among other results, they established convexity, uniqueness of the minimizing spatial density, and existence in the atomic and molecular binding regime N≤ZN \le Z. These are results for the general density-matrix problem, not a claim of uniqueness of every minimizing density matrix. Siedentop [20] showed that the neutral-atom Müller energy agrees with the quantum energy through the Thomas–Fermi, Scott, and Dirac–Schwinger orders. More recently, Siedentop [21] proved the general comparison EM≤ECHF≤EHF\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{M}} \le\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{CHF}} \le\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{HF}} and reduced the same atomic accuracy for CHF. Agreement through these large atomic energy orders leaves smaller correlation terms unresolved. It does not imply agreement of homogeneous correlation energies.

Why the high-density comparison is discriminating

In the homogeneous setting, the common filled-Fermi-sea energy per particle is

eHFhom(k)=310k2−34πk.e_{\mathrm{HF}}^{\mathrm{hom}}(k)=\frac{3}{10}k^2-\frac{3}{4\pi}k.

Both approximations recover these kinetic and exchange terms. Our results show, however, that their next energy scales are radically different. The Müller gain is 3(4π2)−1log⁡k+O(1)3(4\pi^2)^{-1}\log k+O(1), whereas the CHF gain is

12e−1/2−π2/8k2e−π3/2/k(1+o(1)).12e^{-1/2-\pi^2/8}k^2e^{-\pi^{3/2}/\sqrt{k}}(1+o(1)).

In particular, the CHF correction is positive at every finite density but smaller than every inverse power of kk at high density. This resolves the scale hidden behind a numerical observation of “essentially zero” correlation. In the Müller case, identifying the coefficient, rather than only logarithmic growth, tests the quantitative quality of its correlation mechanism.

For physical, unpolarized electrons, the high-density quantum benchmark is the Macke–Gell-Mann–Brueckner logarithm. Macke [17] and Pines [19] obtained the leading logarithmic behavior; Gell-Mann and Brueckner [11] developed the systematic resummation and the next constant term. In Hartree units the logarithmic coefficient is (1−log⁡2)/π2(1-\log2)/\pi^2; see also Loos and Gill [16] for the normalization and the role of the Hartree–Fock reference. Consequently Müller has the right logarithmic scale but a different coefficient, while CHF has a different scale altogether. Neither the functional ordering nor agreement of leading total energies can detect this distinction.

A complementary motivation is the conjecture that the Müller ground-state energy bounds the exact quantum ground-state energy from below for Coulomb systems [10, 21]. From this perspective, the larger logarithmic correlation coefficient is not merely an inaccuracy of approximation: relative to the quantum benchmark it places the Müller energy on the conjectured side, with a strictly positive leading separation. § 10.2 makes this comparison quantitative. It supplies evidence for the conjecture, without proving it for general Coulomb systems.

The mathematical status of this comparison requires care. The results below are theorems about two specified homogeneous variational functionals. Christiansen, Hainzl, and Nam [3, 4] proved a Coulomb Gell-Mann–Brueckner analogue in a mean-field regime. That result must not be identified with the unscaled thermodynamic jellium asymptotic. We keep this distinction explicit in § 10; the latter formula is used as the physical benchmark, not as an input to either functional proof.

A direct variational proof

The CHF upper bound is a comparison for every admissible occupation, not a consequence of an asymptotic solution of the gap equation. We choose an explicit comparison energy E∗E_* whose Coulomb Birman–Schwinger operator has norm at most one. The norms restricted to either side of the Fermi ball tend to one half; this additional fact controls the ordinary exchange of the signed occupation defect. Completion of the square then leaves a positive weighted L2L^2 remainder. Thus the energy estimate also controls profiles of approximate minimizers. A trial state on the scale selected by the same deterministic spectrum supplies the matching lower bound.

There is also an important structural difference regarding symmetry restrictions. In Hartree–Fock theory, the energy improvement due to translation-symmetry breaking is exponentially small at high density [13]. Our CHF analysis remains in the homogeneous spin-symmetric class: we neither remove this restriction nor prove symmetry breaking for CHF. For the Müller functional, by contrast, convexity with respect to the one-particle density matrix [10] implies that averaging over translations and U(q)U(q) spin rotations cannot increase the periodic energy and eliminates the direct Coulomb term. Proposition 4.4 proves existence of an invariant global periodic minimizer and identifies the unrestricted thermodynamic energy with the homogeneous spin-symmetric value. This energy reduction does not assert that every minimizing density matrix is itself invariant.

After the common setting and Coulomb estimates, § 4 proves the Müller theorem and its periodic global optimality. The CHF uniqueness result in § 5 is independent of its high-density energy proof. § 6–§ 8 give the deterministic comparison, its spectral input, and the matching trial calculation; § 9 deduces the defect profile. § 10 discusses the quantum benchmark and the lower-bound motivation. No pointwise high-density asymptotic for the self-consistent CHF gap, or atomic local-density transfer, is asserted.

Common setting and main results

We first formulate both variational problems in the translation-invariant, spin-symmetric class. For Müller, Proposition 4.4 shows that this entails no loss in the periodic thermodynamic energy. For CHF, the symmetry restriction remains part of the problem studied. All units are Hartree units. Fix a spin multiplicity q∈Nq \in\mathbb{N} and a positive total electron density ρ\rho. We use the notation dpˉ=dp/(2π)\mathrm{d}\bar{p} = \mathrm{d}p/(2\pi) for the one-dimensional normalized measure, and correspondingly

d3pˉ=d3p(2π)3,(Vf)(p)=∫R34πf(p′)∣p−p′∣2 d3pˉ′,X(f)=q2∫f(Vf) d3pˉ.\mathrm{d}^{3}\bar{p} = \frac{\mathrm{d}^{3}p}{(2\pi)^{3}}, \qquad(Vf)(p) = \int_{\mathbb{R}^{3}} \frac{4\pi f(p')}{\lvert p-p'\rvert^{2}}\,\mathrm{d}^{3}\bar{p}', \qquad\mathcal{X}(f) = \frac{q}{2}\int f(Vf)\,\mathrm{d}^{3}\bar{p}.

All other differentials are written with an upright d\mathrm{d}. Unless indicated otherwise, LpL^{p} norms are taken on (R3,d3pˉ)(\mathbb{R}^{3},\mathrm{d}^{3}\bar{p}), whereas ∥⋅∥\|\cdot\| on linear operators denotes the operator norm. Fix once and for all 0<θ<1/120<\theta<1/12; the shell parameter is independent of kk, and no limit θ↓0\theta\downarrow0 is needed. Constants CθC_{\theta} may depend on this fixed choice but not on kk. The Coulomb quadratic form X\mathcal{X} is nonnegative even for real sign-changing functions. Define

EHF(n)=q2∫R3∣p∣2n(p) d3pˉ−X(n),(1)\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{HF}}(n)=\frac{q}{2}\int_{\mathbb{R}^{3}}\lvert p\rvert^{2}n(p)\,\mathrm{d}^{3}\bar{p}-\mathcal{X}(n), \tag*{(1)}
EM(n)=q2∫R3∣p∣2n(p) d3pˉ−X(n),(2)\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{M}}(n)=\frac{q}{2}\int_{\mathbb{R}^{3}}\lvert p\rvert^{2}n(p)\,\mathrm{d}^{3}\bar{p}-\mathcal{X}(\sqrt{n}), \tag*{(2)}
E(n)=ECHF(n)=q2∫R3∣p∣2n(p) d3pˉ−X(n)−X(wn),wn=n(1−n).(3)\mathcal{E}(n)=\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{CHF}}(n)=\frac{q}{2}\int_{\mathbb{R}^{3}}\lvert p\rvert^{2}n(p)\,\mathrm{d}^{3}\bar{p}-\mathcal{X}(n)-\mathcal{X}(w_n), \qquad w_n=\sqrt{n(1-n)}. \tag*{(3)}

The abbreviation E\mathcal{E} without a subscript always denotes CHF. The Müller energy in (2) is the unshifted functional; adding a density-linear self-energy correction would only change its per-particle remainder by a constant, not the logarithmic coefficient. The admissible set is

Aρ={n:R3→[0,1]:q∫n d3pˉ=ρ,∫∣p∣2n d3pˉ<∞}.\mathcal{A}_{\rho}=\left\{n:\mathbb{R}^{3}\to[0,1]:q\int n\,\mathrm{d}^{3}\bar{p}=\rho,\quad\int\lvert p\rvert^{2}n\,\mathrm{d}^{3}\bar{p}<\infty\right\}.

For the general density-matrix comparison see [21]. In the present scalar class the pointwise ordering can be checked directly: for s,t∈[0,1]s,t\in[0,1], Schwarz’s inequality gives

st+s(1−s)t(1−t)=st(st+(1−s)(1−t))≤st.st+\sqrt{s(1-s)t(1-t)}=\sqrt{st}\left(\sqrt{st}+\sqrt{(1-s)(1-t)}\right)\leq\sqrt{st}.

Therefore, on the same admissible set,

EM(n)≤ECHF(n)≤EHF(n).(4)\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{M}}(n)\leq\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{CHF}}(n)\leq\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{HF}}(n). \tag*{(4)}

This is an ordering of approximate functionals, not an assertion about where the exact many-body quantum energy lies.

The homogeneous direct Coulomb term is canceled by the neutralizing background. This variational problem is not unrestricted Hartree–Fock; in particular we do not allow general spatially varying one-body density matrices or spin-symmetry breaking in the CHF analysis. For the Müller functional, however, convexity permits an invariant global minimizer for periodic jellium, and restricting to invariant states does not change the minimum (Proposition 4.4). Set

k=(6π2ρq)1/3,Pk(p)=1{∣p∣<k},D(k)=E(Pk)−inf⁡n∈AρE(n)ρ.(5)k=\left(\frac{6\pi^{2}\rho}{q}\right)^{1/3}, \qquad P_k(p)=1_{\{\lvert p\rvert<k\}}, \qquad D(k)=\frac{\mathcal{E}(P_k)-\inf_{n\in\mathcal{A}_{\rho}}\mathcal{E}(n)}{\rho}. \tag*{(5)}

For ν∈{M,CHF}\nu\in\{\mathrm{M},\mathrm{CHF}\} define the energy per particle and the nonnegative gain by

eνhom(k)=ρ−1inf⁡n∈AρEν(n),Dν(k)=eHFhom(k)−eνhom(k).(6)e_{\nu}^{\mathrm{hom}}(k)=\rho^{-1}\inf_{n\in\mathcal{A}_{\rho}}\mathcal{E}_{\nu}(n),\qquad D_{\nu}(k)=e_{\mathrm{HF}}^{\mathrm{hom}}(k)-e_{\nu}^{\mathrm{hom}}(k). \tag*{(6)}

At fixed kk, the constraint ∫n d3p=k3/(6π2)\int n\,\mathrm{d}^{3}p=k^{3}/(6\pi^{2}) is independent of qq. Both the energy functionals and ρ=qk3/(6π2)\rho=qk^{3}/(6\pi^{2}) carry the same factor qq. Consequently, the entire energies per particle and their gains are independent of qq when expressed as functions of kk:

eνhom(k;q)=eνhom(k;1),Dν(k;q)=Dν(k;1),ν∈{M,CHF}.e_{\nu}^{\mathrm{hom}}(k;q)=e_{\nu}^{\mathrm{hom}}(k;1),\qquad D_{\nu}(k;q)=D_{\nu}(k;1),\qquad\nu\in\{\mathrm{M},\mathrm{CHF}\}.

The same observation applies to the Hartree–Fock reference energy; it does not concern a change of qq at fixed total density. The reference energy is common to all three functionals:

References

  1. [1]N. Benedikter, P. T. Nam, M. Porta, B. Schlein, and R. Seiringer, Correlation energy of a weakly interacting Fermi gas, Invent. Math. 225 (2021), 885–979. doi:10.1007/s00222-021-01041-5.
  2. [2]M. A. Buijse and E. J. Baerends, An approximate exchange-correlation hole density as a functional of the natural orbitals, Mol. Phys. 100 (2002), 401–421. doi:10.1080/00268970110070243.DOI
  3. [3]M. R. Christiansen, C. Hainzl, and P. T. Nam, The Gell-Mann–Brueckner formula for the correlation energy of the electron gas: a rigorous upper bound in the mean-field regime, Comm. Math. Phys. 401 (2023), 1469–1529. doi:10.1007/s00220-023-04672-2.DOI
  4. [4]M. R. Christiansen, C. Hainzl, and P. T. Nam, The correlation energy of the electron gas in the mean-field regime, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 40 (2027), 235–316; published electronically July 31, 2026. doi:10.1090/jams/1080. arXiv:2405.01386.DOI
  5. [5]J. Cioslowski and K. Pernal, Description of a homogeneous electron gas with simple functionals of the one-particle density matrix, Phys. Rev. A 61 (2000), 034503. doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.61.034503.DOI
  6. [6]J. Cioslowski, P. Ziesche, and K. Pernal, On the exactness of simple natural spin-orbital functionals for a high-density homogeneous electron gas, Phys. Rev. B 63 (2001), 205105. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.63.205105.DOI
  7. [7]A. J. Coleman, Structure of fermion density matrices, Rev. Mod. Phys. 35 (1963), 668–686. doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.35.668.DOI
  8. [8]G. Csányi and T. A. Arias, Tensor product expansions for correlation in quantum many-body systems, Phys. Rev. B 61 (2000), 7348–7352. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.61.7348.DOI
  9. [9]G. Csányi, S. Goedecker, and T. A. Arias, Improved tensor-product expansions for the two-particle density matrix, Phys. Rev. A 65 (2002), 032510. doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.65.032510.DOI
  10. [10]R. L. Frank, E. H. Lieb, R. Seiringer, and H. Siedentop, Müller’s exchange-correlation energy in density-matrix-functional theory, Phys. Rev. A 76 (2007), 052517. doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.76.052517.DOI
  11. [11]M. Gell-Mann and K. A. Brueckner, Correlation energy of an electron gas at high density, Phys. Rev. 106 (1957), 364–368. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.106.364.
  12. [12]T. L. Gilbert, Hohenberg–Kohn theorem for nonlocal external potentials, Phys. Rev. B 12 (1975), 2111–2120. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.12.2111.DOI
  13. [13]D. Gontier, C. Hainzl, and M. Lewin, Lower bound on the Hartree–Fock energy of the electron gas, Phys. Rev. A 99 (2019), 052501. doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.99.052501.DOI
  14. [14]G. M. Graf and J. P. Solovej, A correlation estimate with applications to quantum systems with Coulomb interactions, Rev. Math. Phys. 6 (1994), 977–997. doi:10.1142/S0129055X94000328.DOI
  15. [15]N. N. Lathiotakis, N. Helbig, and E. K. U. Gross, Performance of one-body reduced density-matrix functionals for the homogeneous electron gas, Phys. Rev. B 75 (2007), 195120. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.75.195120.DOI
  16. [16]P.-F. Loos and P. M. W. Gill, Leading-order behavior of the correlation energy in the uniform electron gas, Int. J. Quantum Chem. 112 (2012), 1712–1716. doi:10.1002/qua.23155.DOI
  17. [17]W. Macke, Über die Wechselwirkungen in Fermi-Gas. Polarisationserscheinungen, Correlationsenergie, Elektronenkondensation, Z. Naturforsch. A 5 (1950), 192–208. doi:10.1515/zn-1950-0402.
  18. [18]A. M. K. Müller, Explicit approximate relation between reduced two- and one-particle density matrices, Phys. Lett. A 105 (1984), 446–452. doi:10.1016/0375-9601(84)91034-X.DOI
  19. [19]D. Pines, A collective description of electron interactions: IV. Electron interaction in metals, Phys. Rev. 92 (1953), 626–636. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.92.626.DOI
  20. [20]H. Siedentop, Das asymptotische Verhalten der Grundzustandsenergie des Müllerfunktions für schwere Atome, J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 42 (2009), 085201. doi:10.1088/1751-8113/42/8/085201.DOI
  21. [21]H. Siedentop, On Csányi’s and Arias’ functional for ground states energy of multi-particle fermion systems: asymptotics, arXiv:2603.15301 (2026). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2603.15301.DOI
  22. [22]V. N. Staroverov and G. E. Scuseria, Optimization of density matrix functionals by the Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov method, J. Chem. Phys. 117 (2002), 11107–11112. doi:10.1063/1.1523060.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_jbcrmhbk
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents