Introduction
The phase structure of dense, strongly interacting matter continues to be an important open problem of modern physics. In particular, only limited knowledge exists about cold quantum chromodynamics (QCD) matter at densities above a few times nuclear saturation density. Yet, this region is of particular relevance for the physics of neutron stars and their mergers [1 ] [2]. Owing to the rapid progress in multi-messenger astronomy, a wealth of data sensitive to the equation of state and transport properties of cold and dense QCD matter is being expected [3 , 4 , 5 ] . It is hence imperative to understand this region.
Matter in the core of neutron stars can potentially be compressed to a point where hadrons break apart and exotic quark matter is revealed. Since there is an attractive interaction between quarks in the color–anti-triplet channel [6 ] , a Cooper instability towards the formation of diquark states is expected at sufficiently high density. Indeed, at asymptotically large μ B \mu_B μ B where perturbation theory is applicable, it is known that cold QCD matter is in a color-flavor-locked (CFL) color-superconducting state [7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . At lower density, a rich structure of homogeneous and inhomogeneous phases is expected based on model calculations [11 ] . In particular, at scales where the mass difference between light, i.e., up and down, and strange quarks becomes relevant, two-flavor color-superconductivity (2SC) seems to be likely. This is supported by the observation that the formation of nucleons in nuclear matter is well described by the emergence of an intermediate scalar diquark state [12 ] , whose condensation gives rise to the 2SC phase; see also Ref. [13 ] for a general review on diquark correlations. It is therefore conceivable that, upon dissociation of nucleons at sufficiently high densities in the cores of neutron stars, a 2SC phase may form. Consequently, 2SC matter plays a central role in theoretical studies of dense QCD matter and in the construction of quark-matter equations of state for neutron stars [9 , 10 , 14 ] .
Ideally, cold and dense QCD matter should be described from first principles. This is a formidable task. For all phenomenologically relevant densities QCD is strongly coupled and may exhibit multiple competing phases. Consequently, neither perturbative methods nor controlled effective field-theory descriptions are generally applicable throughout the entire density range of interest. Moreover, owing to the sign problem, importance-sampling methods such as lattice QCD are severely limited at finite baryon chemical potential, μ B \mu_B μ B [15 ] . These challenges can be addressed with functional approaches, in particular the functional renormalization group (FRG) and Dyson-Schwinger equations (DSE); for QCD-related reviews, see Refs. [16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] for the FRG and Refs. [12 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 ] for DSE. Rapid progress has been made in description of dense QCD matter from first principles in recent years [27 , 28 , 29 ] . This includes predictions for the QCD critical point [30 , 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 ] , spatially modulated moat regimes [31 , 34 , 35 ] , the equation of state (EoS) of hot and dense matter [36 , 37 , 38 ] , and first results on color-superconducting matter [39 , 40 , 41 , 42 ] . A key result of FRG studies is that, in two-flavor QCD, the 2SC phase is indeed favored over the chirally broken phase at intermediate and high baryon densities [43 ] .
Despite this progress, a first-principles determination of the neutron-star equation of state is not yet available. Consequently, phenomenological models remain indispensable for predicting and interpreting astrophysical observations. Such models inevitably involve parameters that must be constrained by external input, most commonly by experimental data. Typical examples include particle masses, decay constants and other vacuum observables [44 , 45 ] . However, this already entails a first subtlety that is often ignored: while experiments usually determine pole masses, which manifest themselves as peaks in scattering processes, most model calculations are often calibrated using the curvature masses. For a propagator G ϕ ( p 0 , p ⃗ ) G_\phi(p_0,\vec{p}) G ϕ ( p 0 , p ) of a field ϕ \phi ϕ with Euclidean frequency p 0 p_0 p 0 , the pole mass, m ϕ , p o l e m_{\phi,\mathrm{pole}} m ϕ , pole , is defined via
G ϕ − 1 ( − i m ϕ , p o l e , 0 ) = 0 , (1) G_\phi^{-1}(-\mathrm{i}m_{\phi,\mathrm{pole}},0)=0, \tag*{(1)} G ϕ − 1 ( − i m ϕ , pole , 0 ) = 0 , (1)
while the curvature mass is defined as
m ϕ , c u r v 2 = G ϕ − 1 ( 0 , 0 ) / Z ϕ , (2) m_{\phi,\mathrm{curv}}^2=G_\phi^{-1}(0,0)/Z_\phi, \tag*{(2)} m ϕ , curv 2 = G ϕ − 1 ( 0 , 0 ) / Z ϕ , (2)
where Z ϕ Z_\phi Z ϕ is an appropriate wave function renormalization factor to ensure RG invariance. Given that the EoS is most naturally computed in Euclidean space, the determination of pole masses requires an additional analytic continuation to Minkowski space, whereas curvature masses are directly accessible. Consequently, the latter are widely employed in model calculations. Fortunately, for very light mesons, such as pions, curvature and pole masses are known to be nearly identical [35 , 46 ] . Whether a similarly close correspondence exists for other mesons remains largely unexplored. A related issue arises in the determination of effective couplings. While experimental information is extracted from scattering processes involving on-shell particles, model calculations typically employ off-shell interactions, often approximated as pointlike.
However, even in models whose parameters can, in principle, be fixed from pole masses and on-shell couplings, some of the required input quantities are not experimentally accessible. Of particular relevance in the present context are diquarks, whose masses and interactions have never been measured directly. Yet, they are essential input for effective models of cold and dense QCD matter. Various theoretical approaches have predicted the vacuum pole mass of the scalar diquark Δ \Delta Δ , consistently placing it at approximately twice the constituent quark mass, m Δ , p o l e ≈ 2 m q ≈ 600 − 700 M e V m_{\Delta,\mathrm{pole}}\approx2m_q\approx600-700\,\mathrm{MeV} m Δ , pole ≈ 2 m q ≈ 600 − 700 MeV [47 , 48 , 49 , 50 , 51 , 52 , 53 , 54 , 55 , 56 ] . This can be understood naturally within the quark–diquark picture of nucleons mentioned above. If nucleons are viewed as quark–diquark bound states, their mass is expected to be approximately given by m Δ , p o l e + m q m_{\Delta,\mathrm{pole}}+m_q m Δ , pole + m q minus some binding energy, at least for physical quark masses [57 ] . Thus, while no direct experimental determination of the diquark mass exists, theoretical considerations provide at least a reasonably well constrained estimate that can be used to fix one of the model parameters.
In many model studies, however, the diquark pole mass is often identified with the corresponding curvature mass. As we will demonstrate below, the relation between these quantities depends sensitively on the quark–diquark interaction, which is considerably less constrained. Information on diquark self-interactions is even more scarce. While one may attempt to constrain the corresponding model parameters using astrophysical observations [58 , 59 , 60 , 61 , 62 , 63 , 64 ] , the large number of poorly known parameters substantially limits the predictive power of such approaches.
In the present work, we address these shortcomings by determining quantities relevant for the modeling of dense two-flavor quark matter directly from QCD within a FRG approach. In particular, we compute the diquark curvature and pole masses, the pointlike quark–diquark coupling, and diquark self-interactions. To this end, we build on the techniques for the self-consistent treatment of QCD developed in Refs. [65 , 66 , 67 ] , in particular the efficient framework introduced in Ref. [68 ] , as well as on methods for describing emergent bound states developed in Refs. [16 , 31 , 69 , 70 , 71 , 72 , 73 , 74 ] . This framework enables the determination of low-energy constants (LECs) associated with emergent QCD degrees of freedom without requiring any phenomenological input beyond the scale setting that is inherent to any first-principles calculation. Consequently, we obtain genuine first-principles predictions for a variety of phenomenologically relevant vacuum LECs based solely on the values of the strong coupling and the current quark masses specified at a perturbatively high energy scale.
This paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II, we introduce the FRG approach to QCD and briefly review key aspects of infrared QCD. In Sec. III, we present our truncation for the gluonic and low-energy sectors, while in Sec. IV is devoted to the renormalization group (RG) flows of the corresponding correlation functions. Readers primarily interested in the results may wish to proceed directly to § 2 . There, we present and discuss our numerical results for the QCD flow in Euclidean space. In § 3 , we compute the spectral functions of the pion, the σ \sigma σ -meson, and the scalar diquark directly from QCD, with particular emphasis on clarifying the relation between pole and curvature masses. Finally, § 4 , contains our conclusions and an outlook. Technical details are collected in the appendices, including explicit expressions for all flow equations employed in this work.
Functional Renormalization Group Approach to QCD
To set the stage and fix our notation, we start with briefly introducing QCD. The gauge-fixed QCD action is given by
S [ A , c , c ˉ , q , q ˉ ] = S Q C D [ A , q ˉ , q ] + S g f [ A ] + S g h [ A , c ˉ , c ] , (3) S[A,c,\bar{c},q,\bar{q}] = S_{\mathrm{QCD}}[A,\bar{q},q] + S_{\mathrm{gf}}[A] + S_{\mathrm{gh}}[A,\bar{c},c], \tag*{(3)} S [ A , c , c ˉ , q , q ˉ ] = S QCD [ A , q ˉ , q ] + S gf [ A ] + S gh [ A , c ˉ , c ] , (3)
with the QCD action S Q C D S_{\mathrm{QCD}} S QCD , the gauge fixing term S g f S_{\mathrm{gf}} S gf and the ghost contribution S g h S_{\mathrm{gh}} S gh arising from the Faddeev-Popov procedure. It describes the classical dynamics of quarks q q q , gluons A A A and ghosts c c c . As usual, the bar denotes the Dirac-conjugate.
While we will also consider analytic continuation to Minkowski space in § 3 , we are focusing on equilibrium properties in this work so that our basic setup is in Euclidean space. The QCD action then is
S Q C D [ A , q ˉ , q ] = ∫ x { 1 4 ( F μ ν a ) 2 + q ˉ ( i D̸ + m q ) q } , (4) S_{\mathrm{QCD}}[A,\bar{q},q] = \int_x \left\{ \frac{1}{4}(F_{\mu\nu}^{a})^2 + \bar{q}(i\not{D}+m_q)q \right\}, \tag*{(4)} S QCD [ A , q ˉ , q ] = ∫ x { 4 1 ( F μν a ) 2 + q ˉ ( i D + m q ) q } , (4)
where we use the shorthand ∫ x = ∫ d 4 x \int_x = \int d^4x ∫ x = ∫ d 4 x . We only consider the physically relevant case of three-colors N c = 3 N_c=3 N c = 3 . As alluded to in the introduction, we focus on the N f = 2 N_f=2 N f = 2 light quark sector, q = ( u , d ) q=(u,d) q = ( u , d ) , as the strange quark is known to be subleading for the quantities of interest here, [9 , 31 ] . In addition, we only consider isospin symmetric matter. We use Euclidean γ \gamma γ -matrices defined such that { γ μ , γ ν } = 2 δ μ ν \{\gamma_\mu,\gamma_\nu\}=2\delta_{\mu\nu} { γ μ , γ ν } = 2 δ μν and γ ˉ μ = γ μ \bar{\gamma}_\mu=\gamma_\mu γ ˉ μ = γ μ .
The field strength tensor is given by
F μ ν a = ∂ μ A ν a − ∂ ν A μ a + g s f a b c A μ b A ν c , (5) F_{\mu\nu}^{a} = \partial_\mu A_\nu^{a} - \partial_\nu A_\mu^{a} + g_s f^{abc} A_\mu^{b} A_\nu^{c}, \tag*{(5)} F μν a = ∂ μ A ν a − ∂ ν A μ a + g s f ab c A μ b A ν c , (5)
and the covariant derivative in the fundamental representation is
( D μ ) a b = ∂ μ δ a b − i g s ( A μ ) a b , (6) (D_\mu)_{ab} = \partial_\mu\delta_{ab} - i g_s(A_\mu)_{ab}, \tag*{(6)} ( D μ ) ab = ∂ μ δ ab − i g s ( A μ ) ab , (6)
where we use Latin letters a , b , c , … ∈ { 1 , … , N c 2 − 1 } a,b,c,\ldots\in\{1,\ldots,N_c^2-1\} a , b , c , … ∈ { 1 , … , N c 2 − 1 } for adjoint color indices and Fraktur letters a , b , c , … ∈ { 1 , … , N c } \mathfrak{a},\mathfrak{b},\mathfrak{c},\ldots\in\{1,\ldots,N_c\} a , b , c , … ∈ { 1 , … , N c } for fundamental color indices. The strong quark-gluon coupling strength is given by g s = 4 π α s g_s=\sqrt{4\pi\alpha_s} g s = 4 π α s . The gluon field and the generators of the gauge group S U ( N c ) SU(N_c) S U ( N c ) are
A μ = A μ a T a , T a = λ a / 2 , (7) A_\mu= A_\mu^a T^a,\qquad T^a=\lambda^a/2, \tag*{(7)} A μ = A μ a T a , T a = λ a /2 , (7)
where for N c = 3 N_c=3 N c = 3 the generators can be given in terms of the Gell-Mann matrices λ a \lambda^a λ a . They obey
[ T a , T b ] = i f a b c T c , Tr ( T a T b ) = 1 2 δ a b . (8) [T^a,T^b]=if^{abc}T^c,\qquad\operatorname{Tr}(T^aT^b)=\frac{1}{2}\delta^{ab}. \tag*{(8)} [ T a , T b ] = i f ab c T c , Tr ( T a T b ) = 2 1 δ ab . (8)
The gauge is fixed by
S g f [ A ] = 1 2 ξ ∫ x ( ∂ μ A μ a ) 2 . (9) S_{\mathrm{gf}}[A]=\frac{1}{2\xi}\int_x(\partial_\mu A_\mu^a)^2. \tag*{(9)} S gf [ A ] = 2 ξ 1 ∫ x ( ∂ μ A μ a ) 2 . (9)
Landau gauge, ξ = 0 \xi=0 ξ = 0 , is used throughout this work. To ensure consistent gauge fixing in functional QCD, ghosts are required,
S g h [ A , c ˉ , c ] = − ∫ x c ˉ a ∂ μ D μ a b c b . (10) S_{\mathrm{gh}}[A,\bar{c},c]=-\int_x \bar{c}^a\partial_\mu D_\mu^{ab}c^b. \tag*{(10)} S gh [ A , c ˉ , c ] = − ∫ x c ˉ a ∂ μ D μ ab c b . (10)
The covariant derivative in the adjoint representation is
D μ a b = ∂ μ δ a b − g s f a b c A μ c , (11) D_\mu^{ab}=\partial_\mu\delta^{ab}-g_sf^{abc}A_\mu^c, \tag*{(11)} D μ ab = ∂ μ δ ab − g s f ab c A μ c , (11)
with the S U ( 3 ) SU(3) S U ( 3 ) structure constant f a b c f^{abc} f ab c .
FRG with scale-dependent fields
The FRG implements Wilson’s RG idea to gradually include quantum fluctuations from the ultraviolet (UV) to the infrared (IR) [75 ] . QCD is particularly well suited for such an approach, as asymptotic freedom provides a well-controlled starting point at high momentum scales. The FRG describes a RG flow of the scale-dependent effective action Γ k \Gamma_k Γ k , which is given by a modified Legendre transformation,
Γ k [ Φ ] = sup J ( J a Φ a − ln Z k [ J ] ) − Δ S k [ Φ ] , (12) \Gamma_k[\Phi] = \sup_J \left(J_a\Phi^a-\ln Z_k[J]\right)-\Delta S_k[\Phi] , \tag*{(12)} Γ k [ Φ ] = J sup ( J a Φ a − ln Z k [ J ] ) − Δ S k [ Φ ] , (12)
of the scale-dependent generating functional
Z k [ J ] = ∫ D Φ ^ exp ( − S [ Φ ^ ] − Δ S k [ Φ ^ ] + J a Φ ^ k a [ Φ ^ ] ) . (13) Z_k[J]=\int\mathcal{D}\hat{\Phi}\exp\left(-S[\hat{\Phi}]-\Delta S_k[\hat{\Phi}]+J_a\hat{\Phi}^a_k[\hat{\Phi}]\right) . \tag*{(13)} Z k [ J ] = ∫ D Φ ^ exp ( − S [ Φ ^ ] − Δ S k [ Φ ^ ] + J a Φ ^ k a [ Φ ^ ] ) . (13)
Φ ^ \hat{\Phi} Φ ^ are the quantum fields, i.e., quarks, gluons and ghosts for QCD, which are sourced by J J J . The RG scale k k k -dependence enters through the cutoff term,
Δ S k [ Φ ] = 1 2 R a b , k Φ b Φ a . (14) \Delta S_k[\Phi]=\frac{1}{2}R_{ab,k}\Phi^b\Phi^a . \tag*{(14)} Δ S k [ Φ ] = 2 1 R ab , k Φ b Φ a . (14)
Summation over bold latin letters assumes a non-trivial metric in field space including appropriate signs and Dirac conjugations for fermions, see Refs. [16 , 76 ] for details. Furthermore, it entails momentum integration and summation over all internal indices. The field space matrix R k R_k R k is a regulator that suppresses all field modes with p 2 ≲ k 2 p^2\lesssim k^2 p 2 ≲ k 2 through a mass-like contribution ∼ k \sim k ∼ k , while modes with p 2 ≳ k 2 p^2\gtrsim k^2 p 2 ≳ k 2 are left unaltered. Our explicit choices for this regulator are specified below.
Z k [ J ] Z_k[J] Z k [ J ] describes the generating functional where all “hard modes” with p 2 ≳ k 2 p^2\gtrsim k^2 p 2 ≳ k 2 are taken into account, while the “soft modes” are decoupled. Hence, all quantum fluctuations from the deep UV down to the IR scale k k k are included. So at k = 0 k=0 k = 0 the full quantum theory is resolved. In practice, it is advantageous to express this in terms of the scale-dependent effective action Γ k \Gamma_k Γ k in Eq. (12) , where the sources J J J are replaced by mean-fields
Φ ( x ) ≡ δ ln Z k [ J ] δ J ( x ) ∣ J = J s u p = ⟨ Φ ^ ( x ) ⟩ . (15) \Phi(x)\equiv\left.\frac{\delta\ln Z_k[J]}{\delta J(x)}\right|_{J=J_{\mathrm{sup}}}=\langle\hat{\Phi}(x)\rangle. \tag*{(15)} Φ ( x ) ≡ δ J ( x ) δ ln Z k [ J ] J = J sup = ⟨ Φ ^ ( x )⟩ . (15)
Γ k \Gamma_k Γ k is hence the quantum effective action that contains all quantum fluctuations down to the scale k k k . Γ 0 = Γ \Gamma_0=\Gamma Γ 0 = Γ is the full effective action.
The basic idea of applying FRG to QCD is to start from a large initial scale k = Λ ≫ 1 G e V k=\Lambda\gg1\,\mathrm{GeV} k = Λ ≫ 1 GeV , where perturbation theory is valid and the initial effective action is, essentially (this is specified below), the classical QCD action in Eq. (3) . The fluctuations of increasingly soft modes are then successively included in order to finally arrive at the full QCD effective action. In the course of this procedure, one faces all the nontrivial, nonperturbative features characteristic for QCD, i.e., chiral symmetry breaking, confinement and the formation of bound states like hadrons. We will go though these features in more detail below, but will already point out that, while this in principle can be done solely in terms of the fundamental fields of QCD, it is most efficient to account for the
formation of bound states explicitly. This is done by also introducing sources for composite operators into the path integral. Here, we consider the lightest scalar and pseudoscalar mesons in terms of the O ( 4 ) O(4) O ( 4 ) field ϕ = ( σ , π ⃗ ) \phi=(\sigma,\vec{\pi}) ϕ = ( σ , π ) , and the complex diquark field Δ \Delta Δ . Note that this does not imply that these are the only composite operators in the system. It simply facilitates the direct extraction of information about these operators. All the details are given in Sec. III C and Sec. IV C.
Of course, composite operators like mesons and diquarks can only exist as dynamical degrees of freedom at low energies. Hence, the corresponding quantum fields must be considered to be scale dependent, ϕ ^ = ϕ ^ k \hat{\phi}=\hat{\phi}_k ϕ ^ = ϕ ^ k and Δ ^ = Δ ^ k \hat{\Delta}=\hat{\Delta}_k Δ ^ = Δ ^ k . The scale dependence is determined by the quark scattering channels where these composite states emerge as resonances. The dynamical hadronization technique ensures that the transition from quark scattering to composite operators is done in an exact manner within the FRG [16 , 31 , 69 , 70 , 72 , 73 , 74 , 77 ] , see Sec. IV C.
By taking a k k k -derivative, we turn the path integral in Eq. (13) into a differential equation for Γ k \Gamma_k Γ k . It is given by the Wetterich flow equation in the presence of scale-dependent quantum fields [16 , 31 ] ,
∂ t Γ k [ Φ ] + Φ ˙ k a [ Φ ] ( δ Γ k [ Φ ] δ Φ a + h δ a σ ) = Flow k [ Φ ] , (16) \partial_t\Gamma_k[\Phi]+\dot{\Phi}^a_k[\Phi]\left(\frac{\delta\Gamma_k[\Phi]}{\delta\Phi^a}+h\,\delta_{a\sigma}\right)=\operatorname{Flow}_k[\Phi] , \tag*{(16)} ∂ t Γ k [ Φ ] + Φ ˙ k a [ Φ ] ( δ Φ a δ Γ k [ Φ ] + h δ aσ ) = Flow k [ Φ ] , (16)
with the flow contribution
Flow k [ Φ ] = 1 2 G k a b [ Φ ] ( δ a c ∂ t + 2 δ Φ ˙ k c [ Φ ] δ Φ a ) R c b , k (17) \operatorname{Flow}_k[\Phi]=\frac{1}{2}G_k^{ab}[\Phi]\left(\delta^c_a\partial_t+2\frac{\delta\dot{\Phi}^c_k[\Phi]}{\delta\Phi^a}\right)R_{cb,k} \tag*{(17)} Flow k [ Φ ] = 2 1 G k ab [ Φ ] ( δ a c ∂ t + 2 δ Φ a δ Φ ˙ k c [ Φ ] ) R c b , k (17)
and where
G k [ Φ ] = ( Γ k ( 2 ) [ Φ ] + R k ) − 1 , (18) G_k[\Phi]=\left(\Gamma_k^{(2)}[\Phi]+R_k\right)^{-1} , \tag*{(18)} G k [ Φ ] = ( Γ k ( 2 ) [ Φ ] + R k ) − 1 , (18)
is the scale-dependent generalized (field-dependent) propagator. The RG-time is defined as t = ln k / Λ t=\ln k/\Lambda t = ln k /Λ . The n n n -point functions in momentum space are defined as
Γ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n , k ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) = δ n Γ k [ Φ ] δ Φ i 1 ( p 1 ) ⋯ δ Φ i n ( p n ) . (19) \Gamma^{(n)}_{\Phi_{i_1}\cdots\Phi_{i_n},k}(p_1,\ldots,p_n)=\frac{\delta^n\Gamma_k[\Phi]}{\delta\Phi_{i_1}(p_1)\cdots\delta\Phi_{i_n}(p_n)} . \tag*{(19)} Γ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n , k ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) = δ Φ i 1 ( p 1 ) ⋯ δ Φ i n ( p n ) δ n Γ k [ Φ ] . (19)
If only n − 1 n-1 n − 1 momentum indices are given, the momentum conserving δ \delta δ -function δ ( p 1 + ⋯ + p n ) \delta(p_1+\cdots+p_n) δ ( p 1 + ⋯ + p n ) is excluded,
Γ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n , k ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n − 1 ) = ∫ p n Γ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n , k ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) . (20) \Gamma^{(n)}_{\Phi_{i_1}\cdots\Phi_{i_n},k}(p_1,\ldots,p_{n-1})=\int_{p_n}\Gamma^{(n)}_{\Phi_{i_1}\cdots\Phi_{i_n},k}(p_1,\ldots,p_n) . \tag*{(20)} Γ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n , k ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n − 1 ) = ∫ p n Γ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n , k ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) . (20)
with the shorthand ∫ p = ∫ d 4 p ( 2 π ) 4 \int_p = \int\frac{\mathrm{d}^4p}{(2\pi)^4} ∫ p = ∫ ( 2 π ) 4 d 4 p . For scale-independent fields Φ ˙ k = 0 \dot{\Phi}_k=0 Φ ˙ k = 0 , Eq. (16) reduces to the conventional Wetterich equation [75 ] . The superfield Φ \Phi Φ includes all the degrees of freedom we consider in our truncation. As we want to provide prediction for the (pseudo-)scalar meson and diquark correlations, we use
Φ a = ( A μ , c ˉ , c , q ˉ , q , ϕ , Δ ˉ † , Δ ) a . (21) \Phi^a = (A_\mu,\bar{c},c,\bar{q},q,\phi,\bar{\Delta}^{\dagger},\Delta)^a . \tag*{(21)} Φ a = ( A μ , c ˉ , c , q ˉ , q , ϕ , Δ ˉ † , Δ ) a . (21)
In Eq. (16) , the term ∼ h \sim h ∼ h reflects the explicit chiral symmetry breaking from nonzero current quark masses. It ensures that chiral symmetry is manifest in the flow equation, with a linear term σ ^ k ∼ q ˉ ^ q ^ \hat{\sigma}_k \sim\hat{\bar{q}}\hat{q} σ ^ k ∼ q ˉ ^ q ^ as the only source of chiral symmetry breaking [31 ] . A diagrammatic representation of the flow equation for QCD is shown in Figure 1 .
Figure 1. Diagrammatic representation of the flow contribution for the different fields considered in this work: gluons (orange curly line), ghosts (dotted line), quarks (solid line), mesons (double line) and diquarks (double line with arrow). The circle with a cross denotes the regulator insertions ∂ t R k \partial_tR_k ∂ t R k .
In order to make the RG-invariance of the flow equation manifest, it is customary to rescale all fields and correlation function with appropriate powers of the wave function renormalizations. Note that we mean RG-invariance in the conventional sense, i.e. in terms of a renormalization scale μ \mu μ , not in terms of the RG scale k k k , see also [16 , 78 , 79 ] . For the fields, this entails the we are working with renormalized fields,
Φ → Z Φ , k 1 / 2 Φ . (22) \Phi\rightarrow Z_{\Phi,k}^{1/2}\Phi. \tag*{(22)} Φ → Z Φ , k 1/2 Φ. (22)
While the renormalized fields are RG-invariant, μ d Φ d μ = 0 \mu\frac{\mathrm{d}\Phi}{\mathrm{d}\mu}=0 μ d μ d Φ = 0 , they are scale dependent,
( ∂ t Φ k ) [ Φ ] ≡ − 1 2 η Φ , k Φ , (23) (\partial_t\Phi_k)[\Phi] \equiv-\frac{1}{2}\eta_{\Phi,k}\Phi, \tag*{(23)} ( ∂ t Φ k ) [ Φ ] ≡ − 2 1 η Φ , k Φ , (23)
with the anomalous dimension
η Φ , k = − ∂ t ln Z Φ , k . (24) \eta_{\Phi,k}=-\partial_t\ln Z_{\Phi,k}. \tag*{(24)} η Φ , k = − ∂ t ln Z Φ , k . (24)
The running of the fields in Eq. (16) therefore has two contributions,
Φ ˙ k [ Φ ] = ⟨ ∂ t Φ ^ k ⟩ − 1 2 η Φ , k Φ . (25) \dot{\Phi}_k[\Phi]=\langle\partial_t\hat{\Phi}_k\rangle-\frac{1}{2}\eta_{\Phi,k}\Phi. \tag*{(25)} Φ ˙ k [ Φ ] = ⟨ ∂ t Φ ^ k ⟩ − 2 1 η Φ , k Φ. (25)
The first contribution stems from dynamical hadronization, and is specified in Sec. IV C. It is important to note that this scale dependence arises from the fluctuating fields, not the mean fields [16 ] . The last term follows from RG invariance.
As usual, RG-invariant correlation functions are simply determined by the external fields,
Γ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n , k ( n ) → Γ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n , k ( n ) Z Φ i 1 , k 1 / 2 ⋯ Z Φ i n , k 1 / 2 , (26) \Gamma_{\Phi_{i_1}\cdots\Phi_{i_n},k}^{(n)}\rightarrow\frac{\Gamma_{\Phi_{i_1}\cdots\Phi_{i_n},k}^{(n)}}{Z_{\Phi_{i_1},k}^{1/2}\cdots Z_{\Phi_{i_n},k}^{1/2}}, \tag*{(26)} Γ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n , k ( n ) → Z Φ i 1 , k 1/2 ⋯ Z Φ i n , k 1/2 Γ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n , k ( n ) , (26)
so that the effective action remains unchanged under the transformation in Eq. (22) . This way, the wave function renormalization factors Z Φ , k Z_{\Phi,k} Z Φ , k do not appear explicitly, and only the anomalous dimensions enter the flow equations. From the anomalous dimension η Φ , k \eta_{\Phi,k} η Φ , k , one can directly integrate over k k k to recover the wave function renormalization through
Z Φ , k = Z Φ , Λ exp { − ∫ Λ k d k k η Φ , k } , (27) Z_{\Phi,k}=Z_{\Phi,\Lambda}\exp\left\{-\int_{\Lambda}^{k}\frac{\mathrm{d}k}{k}\eta_{\Phi,k}\right\}, \tag*{(27)} Z Φ , k = Z Φ , Λ exp { − ∫ Λ k k d k η Φ , k } , (27)
where Z Φ , Λ Z_{\Phi,\Lambda} Z Φ , Λ is the value of the wave function renormalization at the ultraviolet scale Λ \Lambda Λ . Note that the choice of Z Φ , Λ Z_{\Phi,\Lambda} Z Φ , Λ is arbitrary and corresponds to a given choice of global normalization for the field Φ \Phi Φ . Hence, the physical content of the wave function renormalization is given by its k k k -derivative, or, equivalently, by the anomalous dimension.
For later convenience, we introduce the (generalized) regulator scale derivative,
∂ ~ t = ( δ a c ∂ t + 2 δ Φ ˙ k c [ Φ ] δ Φ a ) R c b , k δ δ R b a , k , (28) \tilde{\partial}_t=\left(\delta_a^c\partial_t+2\frac{\delta\dot{\Phi}_k^c[\Phi]}{\delta\Phi^a}\right)R_{cb,k}\frac{\delta}{\delta R_{ba,k}}, \tag*{(28)} ∂ ~ t = ( δ a c ∂ t + 2 δ Φ a δ Φ ˙ k c [ Φ ] ) R c b , k δ R ba , k δ , (28)
so that the flow contribution may be expressed as
F l o w k [ Φ ] = 1 2 ∂ ~ t Tr ( ln G k [ Φ ] − 1 ) . (29) \mathrm{Flow}_k[\Phi]=\frac{1}{2}\tilde{\partial}_t\operatorname{Tr}\left(\ln G_k[\Phi]^{-1}\right). \tag*{(29)} Flow k [ Φ ] = 2 1 ∂ ~ t Tr ( ln G k [ Φ ] − 1 ) . (29)
For the field running Eq. (25) , the regulator scale derivative ensures proper insertion of the regulator, including the appropriate anomalous dimension contribution ∼ ∂ t R − η R \sim\partial_tR-\eta R ∼ ∂ t R − η R in the one-loop diagrams.
To simplify notation, the dependence on the RG-scale k k k of most quantities will be left implicit in what follows.
Key aspects of infrared QCD
In this section we briefly review some key aspects of low-energy QCD, with a special attention to the properties of quark and gluon correlation functions related to confinement and chiral symmetry breaking from first principles. While the main focus of this work is on a semi-quantitative description of the scalar diquark, these properties play a crucial role in the construction of our self-consistent approximation and the interpretation of our results.
At UV energy scales, where perturbative QCD is applicable, the system contains free quarks and gluons. In this regime the strong coupling is relatively weak. As the renormalization scale is lowered toward the IR, the coupling becomes stronger and nonperturbative effects emerge. Crucially, these include color confinement and chiral symmetry breaking. Confinement in QCD means the absence of colored asymptotic states. Instead of individual massless gluons, QCD features massive glueballs in the IR [80 ] . In gauge-fixed functional approaches, this is directly related to the behavior of the gluon and ghost propagators in the IR. In particular, in linear covariant gauges, including the Landau gauge used here, the gluon itself has a mass gap, m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap , while ghosts remain ungapped in the confined phase, see, e.g., Refs. [24 , 26 , 65 , 68 , 81 , 82 , 83 , 84 , 85 , 86 , 87 , 88 , 89 , 90 , 91 , 92 , 93 , 94 ] . There are two prominent scenarios regarding the behavior of ghost and gluon propagators in the IR. One is the Kugo-Ojima confinement criterion, which relies on canonical quantization and hence the existence of a BRST charge [82 ] . Defining the ghost and transverse gluon dressing functions Z ˉ A / c ( p 2 ) \bar{Z}_{A/c}(p^2) Z ˉ A / c ( p 2 ) via the propagators,
[ G A A ( p 2 ) ] μ ν a b = ( Π μ ν T Z ˉ A ( p 2 ) p 2 + ξ Π μ ν L Z ˉ A ( p 2 ) p 2 ) δ a b , (30) \left[G_{AA}(p^2)\right]_{\mu\nu}^{ab} = \left(\frac{\Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{T}}}{\bar{Z}_{A}(p^2)p^2}+\xi\frac{\Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{L}}}{\bar{Z}_{A}(p^2)p^2}\right)\delta^{ab}, \tag*{(30)} [ G AA ( p 2 ) ] μν ab = ( Z ˉ A ( p 2 ) p 2 Π μν T + ξ Z ˉ A ( p 2 ) p 2 Π μν L ) δ ab , (30)
[ G c c ˉ ( p 2 ) ] a b = 1 Z ˉ c ( p 2 ) p 2 δ a b , (31) \left[G_{c\bar{c}}(p^2)\right]^{ab} = \frac{1}{\bar{Z}_{c}(p^2)p^2}\delta^{ab}, \tag*{(31)} [ G c c ˉ ( p 2 ) ] ab = Z ˉ c ( p 2 ) p 2 1 δ ab , (31)
with the transverse and longitudinal projection operators Π μ ν T / L \Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{T/L}} Π μν T/L , the Kugo-Ojima criterion is consistent with the scaling solution,
lim p → 0 Z ˉ c ( p 2 ) ∝ ( p 2 ) κ , (32) \lim_{p\to0}\bar{Z}_{c}(p^2) \propto(p^2)^{\kappa}, \tag*{(32)} p → 0 lim Z ˉ c ( p 2 ) ∝ ( p 2 ) κ , (32)
lim p → 0 Z ˉ A ( p 2 ) ∝ ( p 2 ) − 2 κ , (33) \lim_{p\to0}\bar{Z}_{A}(p^2) \propto(p^2)^{-2\kappa}, \tag*{(33)} p → 0 lim Z ˉ A ( p 2 ) ∝ ( p 2 ) − 2 κ , (33)
with scaling exponent 1 / 2 < κ < 1 1/2<\kappa<1 1/2 < κ < 1 [65 , 84 , 85 ] . Hence, the gluon propagator vanishes in the IR, while the ghost propagator is enhanced over the free 1 / p 2 1/p^2 1/ p 2 behavior. This may be interpreted as a divergent gluon mass gap.
The other, so-called decoupling scenario involves a constant ghost dressing function and a transverse gluon dressing function that diverges exactly like 1 / p 2 1/p^2 1/ p 2 [90 , 91 , 95 , 96 ] ,
lim p → 0 Z ˉ c ( p 2 ) ∝ 1 , (34) \lim_{p\to0}\bar{Z}_{c}(p^2) \propto1, \tag*{(34)} p → 0 lim Z ˉ c ( p 2 ) ∝ 1 , (34)
lim p → 0 Z ˉ A ( p 2 ) ∝ ( p 2 ) − 1 . (35) \lim_{p\to0}\bar{Z}_{A}(p^2) \propto(p^2)^{-1}. \tag*{(35)} p → 0 lim Z ˉ A ( p 2 ) ∝ ( p 2 ) − 1 . (35)
This implies that in the deep IR the ghost propagator diverges like the tree-level propagator, while the gluon propagator tends to a constant. Global BRST symmetry is broken in this case [82 , 96 ] .
It has been argued that the difference in these scenarios is related to nonperturbative gauge fixing [91 , 97 ] : The Fadeev-Popov procedure only fixes the gauge locally, globally there are Gribov copies. Dealing with these copies involves global constraints from nonperturbative gauge fixing, which modify the boundary conditions of n n n -point functions at vanishing momenta. One may hence view these scenarios as manifestations of different resolutions of the Gribov problem.
For our purposes, two features of these scenarios are relevant. First, they only manifest in the deep IR and involve gapped gluons. Hence, as we will also verify explicitly below, the physics is the same regardless of which scenario is realized. Second, while the scaling solution is unique [98 , 99 ] , there is a whole class of decoupling solutions. In the present work, we use a bootstrap approach within the FRG to arrive at these solutions [67 , 68 , 94 ] : we supplement the longitudinal part of the gluon propagator with a running mass gap parameter, m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap , and tune its initial value in the UV so that we find either scaling or decoupling. This is described in detail in the next section.
We emphasize that this does not imply explicit gauge symmetry breaking. On the contrary, the modification of the conventional Slavnov-Taylor identities (STIs) due to the gluon regulator in the gauge-fixed FRG framework requires such a mass term [66 , 67 , 100 , 101 ] . Instead of using these modified STIs (mSTIs) to determine m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap , we can simply tune its initial value m g a p , U V m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}} m gap , UV such that the system flows into the desired confining solution. Unless stated otherwise, we choose the scaling solution, as its uniqueness makes it most appealing.
Chiral symmetry breaking means the formation of a chiral condensate ⟨ q ˉ q ⟩ \langle\bar{q}q\rangle ⟨ q ˉ q ⟩ . In QCD, this formation proceeds through an effective four-quark interaction in the scalar channel, which is generated by gluon exchange between quark pairs. Spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking is signaled by a peak in this channel at zero momentum exchange, corresponding to a soft sigma mode at zero momentum. In case of a second-order transition, the peak is a divergence and the sigma mode is massless.
Within the FRG, a transparent picture emerges: at small gauge coupling α s \alpha_s α s the flow of the four-quark interaction has an IR attractive, weakly interacting fixed point. This is expected in the perturbative regime, where no large coupling should be generated dynamically. There exists, however, a critical α s \alpha_s α s where this fixed point vanishes, allowing for the four-quark interaction to diverge [19 , 70 ] . An analogous picture holds for any spontaneous symmetry breaking with a quark bilinear order parameter, and can directly be generalized also to more exotic order parameters. The possibility to construct a complete set of such four-quark interaction channels facilitates an unbiased determination of the phase structure [19 , 43 ] .
All this entails that both confinement and chiral symmetry breaking emerge within a self-consistent setup here, without any free parameters besides the strong coupling and the current quark masses, which we fix in the perturbative regime. The FRG flow for QCD describes the scale evolution from the perturbative UV regime to the nonperturbative IR regime. Owing to the mass gap, gluons will decouple at low energies while quarks form hadronic bound states due to strong correlations. The soft pseudo-Goldstone bosons from chiral symmetry breaking will eventually take over as dominant degrees of freedom in the IR. All features of QCD at low energies emerge dynamically, without any free parameters. For the low-energy sector, this is intimately related to the intermediate fixed point mentioned above [70 , 71 , 72 , 73 , 74 ] . This also includes the parameters of intermediate, non-asymptotic states like diquarks, which we extract here. In the following, we discuss details of this setup and the approximations we use.
Truncation Scheme
An exact solution to Wetterich equation requires evaluating infinite tower of coupled flow equations for all possible correlation functions of the system. As such, this tower must be truncated, ensuring that the most relevant physical processes for the quantities we are interested in are captured for reliable results. It is convenient to express this in terms of an effective action Γ k \Gamma_k Γ k , where we only write down explicitly the terms related to the correlations that we keep in our truncation. It is important to emphasize that this does not mean that it is assumed that other correlations are zero, only that their feedback into the quantities of interest is small, so that we can neglect it.
Building on previous FRG studies [31 , 67 , 68 , 70 , 71 , 72 , 73 , 74 ] , we decompose the effective action into three distinct parts,
Γ k [ Φ ] = Γ g l u e , k [ A , c ˉ , c ] + Γ q u a r k − g l u o n , k [ A , q ˉ , q ] + Γ q m d , k [ A , q ˉ , q , ϕ , Δ † , Δ ] , (36) \Gamma_k[\Phi] = \Gamma_{\mathrm{glue},k}[A,\bar{c},c] + \Gamma_{\mathrm{quark-gluon},k}[A,\bar{q},q]
+ \Gamma_{\mathrm{qmd},k}[A,\bar{q},q,\phi,\Delta^\dagger,\Delta], \tag*{(36)} Γ k [ Φ ] = Γ glue , k [ A , c ˉ , c ] + Γ quark − gluon , k [ A , q ˉ , q ] + Γ qmd , k [ A , q ˉ , q , ϕ , Δ † , Δ ] , (36)
which describe the gluonic, quark-gluon, and composite low-energy sectors of QCD, respectively. Here, Γ g l u e , k \Gamma_{\mathrm{glue},k} Γ glue , k denotes the pure glue contribution involving only ghosts and gluons, Γ q u a r k − g l u o n , k \Gamma_{\mathrm{quark-gluon},k} Γ quark − gluon , k contains the quark kinetic term together with quark-gluon and four-quark interactions, and Γ q m d , k \Gamma_{\mathrm{qmd},k} Γ qmd , k encodes our truncation of the composite low-energy sector of QCD.
Glue sector
In the glue sector, we follow Ref. [68 ] and employ a zero-momentum expansion around the gauge-fixed classical tensor structure, providing a simple semi-quantitative truncation of gluonic fluctuations. To this end, we define the classical tensor structure derived from the classical action, Eq. (4) , as
T Φ i 1 … Φ i n ( 1 ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) = δ n S [ Φ ] δ Φ i 1 ( p 1 ) … δ Φ i n ( p n ) ∣ g s = 1 . (37) \mathcal{T}^{(1)}_{\Phi_{i_1}\ldots\Phi_{i_n}}(p_1,\ldots,p_n)
= \left.\frac{\delta^n S[\Phi]}{\delta\Phi_{i_1}(p_1)\ldots\delta\Phi_{i_n}(p_n)}\right|_{g_s=1}. \tag*{(37)} T Φ i 1 … Φ i n ( 1 ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) = δ Φ i 1 ( p 1 ) … δ Φ i n ( p n ) δ n S [ Φ ] g s = 1 . (37)
The explicit expressions are given in App. B2. Here, the superscript (1) indicates that the corresponding tensor structure is the first element of a complete tensor basis in the respective interaction channel. We reserve the number one for the classical tensor structure defined through the classical action. Both FRG and DSE studies have investigated the impact of additional tensor structures and higher-order tensor contributions, see, e.g., Refs. [26 , 67 , 72 , 102 , 103 , 104 , 105 ] . The resulting truncation of the effective action is then given by
Γ g l u e , k [ A , c ˉ , c ] = 1 2 ∫ p A μ a ( p ) [ ( p 2 + m g a p 2 ) Π μ ν T ( p ) + 1 ξ ( p 2 + m m S T I 2 ) Π μ ν L ( p ) ] A ν a ( − p ) + λ A 3 1 3 ! ∫ p 1 p 2 [ T A 3 ( 1 ) ( p 1 , p 2 ) ] μ 1 μ 2 μ 3 a 1 a 2 a 3 ∏ i = 1 3 A μ i a i ( p i ) + λ A 4 1 4 ! ∫ p 1 p 2 p 3 [ T A 4 ( 1 ) ( p 1 , p 2 , p 3 ) ] μ 1 μ 2 μ 3 μ 4 a 1 a 2 a 3 a 4 ∏ i = 1 4 A μ i a i ( p i ) + ∫ p c ˉ a ( p ) p 2 δ a b c b ( − p ) + λ A c ˉ c ∫ p 1 p 2 [ T c ˉ c A ( 1 ) ( p 1 , p 2 ) ] μ a 1 a 2 a 3 c ˉ a 2 ( p 2 ) c a 1 ( p 1 ) A μ a 3 ( − p 1 − p 2 ) . (38) \begin{aligned}
\Gamma_{\mathrm{glue},k}[A,\bar{c},c] ={}& \frac{1}{2}\int_p A_\mu^a(p)\left[(p^2+m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)\Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{T}}(p)+\frac{1}{\xi}(p^2+m_{\mathrm{mSTI}}^2)\Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{L}}(p)\right]A_\nu^a(-p)\\
&+\lambda_{A^3}\frac{1}{3!}\int_{p_1p_2}\left[\mathcal{T}_{A^3}^{(1)}(p_1,p_2)\right]_{\mu_1\mu_2\mu_3}^{a_1a_2a_3}\prod_{i=1}^{3}A_{\mu_i}^{a_i}(p_i)
+\lambda_{A^4}\frac{1}{4!}\int_{p_1p_2p_3}\left[\mathcal{T}_{A^4}^{(1)}(p_1,p_2,p_3)\right]_{\mu_1\mu_2\mu_3\mu_4}^{a_1a_2a_3a_4}\prod_{i=1}^{4}A_{\mu_i}^{a_i}(p_i)\\
&+\int_p\bar{c}^a(p)p^2\delta^{ab}c^b(-p)+\lambda_{A\bar{c}c}\int_{p_1p_2}\left[\mathcal{T}_{\bar{c}cA}^{(1)}(p_1,p_2)\right]_{\mu}^{a_1a_2a_3}\bar{c}^{a_2}(p_2)c^{a_1}(p_1)A_\mu^{a_3}(-p_1-p_2). \tag*{(38)}
\end{aligned} Γ glue , k [ A , c ˉ , c ] = 2 1 ∫ p A μ a ( p ) [ ( p 2 + m gap 2 ) Π μν T ( p ) + ξ 1 ( p 2 + m mSTI 2 ) Π μν L ( p ) ] A ν a ( − p ) + λ A 3 3 ! 1 ∫ p 1 p 2 [ T A 3 ( 1 ) ( p 1 , p 2 ) ] μ 1 μ 2 μ 3 a 1 a 2 a 3 i = 1 ∏ 3 A μ i a i ( p i ) + λ A 4 4 ! 1 ∫ p 1 p 2 p 3 [ T A 4 ( 1 ) ( p 1 , p 2 , p 3 ) ] μ 1 μ 2 μ 3 μ 4 a 1 a 2 a 3 a 4 i = 1 ∏ 4 A μ i a i ( p i ) + ∫ p c ˉ a ( p ) p 2 δ ab c b ( − p ) + λ A c ˉ c ∫ p 1 p 2 [ T c ˉ c A ( 1 ) ( p 1 , p 2 ) ] μ a 1 a 2 a 3 c ˉ a 2 ( p 2 ) c a 1 ( p 1 ) A μ a 3 ( − p 1 − p 2 ) . (38)
The first line includes the transverse and longitudinal part of the gluon kinetic term, as indicated by their associated projectors
Π μ ν T ( p ) = δ μ ν − p μ p ν p 2 , (39) \Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{T}}(p)=\delta_{\mu\nu}-\frac{p_\mu p_\nu}{p^2}, \tag*{(39)} Π μν T ( p ) = δ μν − p 2 p μ p ν , (39)
Π μ ν L ( p ) = δ μ ν − Π μ ν T ( p ) = p μ p ν p 2 . (40) \Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{L}}(p)=\delta_{\mu\nu}-\Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{T}}(p)=\frac{p_\mu p_\nu}{p^2}. \tag*{(40)} Π μν L ( p ) = δ μν − Π μν T ( p ) = p 2 p μ p ν . (40)
The second line of Eq. (38) includes the three and four gluon interactions, while the last line contains the ghost kinetic term and the ghost-gluon coupling characteristic of a gauge-fixed setup. It is crucial to distinguish between the different strong-coupling tensor structures, as the degeneracy of the associated couplings is lifted by non-perturbative effects. In the following, we refer to these couplings as avatars of the strong coupling α s \alpha_s α s . In the glue sector, they are directly related to λ A 3 , k \lambda_{A^3,k} λ A 3 , k , λ A 4 , k \lambda_{A^4,k} λ A 4 , k and λ A c ˉ c , k \lambda_{A\bar{c}c,k} λ A c ˉ c , k .
As discussed in Sec. II B, a key part of the truncation is the inclusion of a running transverse gluon mass gap. The modifications of the STIs due to the explicit gauge symmetry breaking of the regulator give rise to a nonzero longitudinal gluon mass parameter m m S T I m_{\mathrm{mSTI}} m mSTI [100 ] . At k = 0 k=0 k = 0 the regulator vanishes and the mSTIs reduce to the conventional STIs. These state that the longitudinal gluon propagator is fully determined by the gauge fixing term, with no quantum corrections. Hence, m m S T I m_{\mathrm{mSTI}} m mSTI needs to vanish in the IR.
In the perturbative regime, the mSTIs are identical for transverse and longitudinal couplings. Yet, as pointed out in Sec. II B, confinement is related to a nonzero mass gap m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap at k = 0 k=0 k = 0 in the gluon propagator in Landau gauge. So while the appearance of a gluon mass parameter m g a p , U V = m m S T I , U V m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}=m_{\mathrm{mSTI,UV}} m gap , UV = m mSTI , UV in the UV is a direct consequence of gauge invariance in the presence of the momentum cutoff of the FRG, the running of m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap and $m_{\mathrm{mSTI}} need to become different below the confinement scale, k < k c o n f k < k_{\mathrm{conf}} k < k conf , in order to generate confinement. This is why in the first line of Eq. (38) , we included both mass parameters. The difference between these masses should be generated dynamically through irregular vertices in the nonperturbative regime [67 ] .
In the present bootstrap approach, we circumvent the need to generate the necessary irregularities by simply tuning the initial value of m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap so that the system runs into the confining scaling solution discussed in Sec. II B. The flow of m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap is readily extracted from the flow of the gluon two-point function, see Sec. IV B. Furthermore, we use Landau gauge, ξ = 0 \xi= 0 ξ = 0 . In this case, the transverse system is closed, so information on the longitudinal contributions is not required. Hence, there is no need to explicitly deal with the mSTIs, which in general involve both transverse and longitudinal contributions, here. Note that the agreement between the avatars of the strong couplings shown in Figure 7 suggests that these identities, and hence gauge symmetry, is respected at least at higher energies here.
Figure 7. Running of the strong coupling avatars α \alpha α Eqs. (110) to (115) on a linear (left) and a log (right) scale. The black dashed line indicates the perturbative running of the strong coupling α s \alpha_s α s at one-loop. Note that the peculiar behavior of α A 3 \alpha_{A^3} α A 3 is caused by a sign change below about 1 GeV.
Depending on the choice of m g a p , U V 2 m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}^2 m gap , UV 2 , three distinct regimes are found relative to the initial value that leads to the scaling solution, m g a p , U V 2 = m g a p , s c a l i n g 2 m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}^2 = m_{\mathrm{gap,scaling}}^2 m gap , UV 2 = m gap , scaling 2 [67 ] :
Higgs regime : for m g a p , U V 2 ≫ m g a p , s c a l i n g 2 m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}^2 \gg m_{\mathrm{gap,scaling}}^2 m gap , UV 2 ≫ m gap , scaling 2 the high effective gluon mass suppresses non-perturbative effects in the glue sector, and the gluon propagator behaves like the one of an ordinary massive vector field. Furthermore, the theory displays no dynamical chiral symmetry breaking (DχSB) or any of the non-trivial structure of IR QCD.
confining regime : for m g a p , U V 2 ≳ m g a p , s c a l i n g 2 m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}^2 \gtrsim m_{\mathrm{gap,scaling}}^2 m gap , UV 2 ≳ m gap , scaling 2 the non-perturbative effects in the glue sector are non-negligible, and lead to the appearance of a peak at a finite momentum in the gluon propagator [67 ] . This regime corresponds to physical QCD, and depending on the exact value of m g a p , U V 2 m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}^2 m gap , UV 2 , scaling or decoupling solutions are found, also featuring DχSB.
Landau pole regime : for m g a p , U V 2 < m g a p , s c a l i n g 2 m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}^2 < m_{\mathrm{gap,scaling}}^2 m gap , UV 2 < m gap , scaling 2 a Landau pole appears for a finite RG-scale k > 0 k > 0 k > 0 at which the strong coupling avatars diverge and the ghost wave function renormalization Z c Z_c Z c tends to 0. As such the IR cannot be reached in this regime.
For further details we refer to Refs. [67 , 68 ] and § 2 D.
Finally, we note that the gluon mass parameter m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap should not be identified with the physical gluon mass gap, which is clear in various ways. For instance, m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap is not an RG-invariant quantity and depends on the infrareded details of the gluon dynamics, see § 2 D, two properties that are not wanted in the definition of the gluon mass gap. As a proxy to the gluon mass gap, we follow Ref. [68 ] , and use the peak location of the gluon dressing function. For a recent discussion on the gluon mass gap see Ref. [106 ] .
Quark-gluon sector
In this section, we introduce the quark fields and the interactions relevant for the emergence of the mesonic and diquark states of interest here. This part of the truncation hence forms the link between the high-energy description in terms of quarks and gluons and the low-energy description in terms of quarks and composites.
The contribution to the effective action is given by
\begin{aligned}
\Gamma_{\mathrm{quark-gluon},k}[A,\bar q,q] ={}& \int_p \bar q(-p) i\slashed{p}q(p) - \sum_{i=1,4}\lambda_{\bar A q q}^{(i)} \int_{p_1p_2} \left[\mathcal{T}_{\bar A q q}^{(i)}(p_1,p_2)\right]^a_{\mu\alpha\beta} A_\mu^a(p_1)\bar q_\alpha(p_2)q_\beta(-p_1-p_2) \\
&+ \sum_{i=\mathrm{sps,csc}}\lambda_{\bar q\bar q q q}^{(i)}\frac{1}{4}\int_{p_1p_2p_3}\left[\mathcal{T}_{\bar q\bar q q q}^{(i)}(p_1,p_2,p_3)\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}\bar q_\alpha(p_1)\bar q_\beta(p_2)q_\gamma(p_3)q_\delta(-p_1-p_2-p_3), \tag*{(41)}
\end{aligned}
where the first line consist of the quark kinetic term and the quark-gluon interaction. A complete basis for the quark-gluon interaction is given by eight tensor structures, three of which are relevant for quantitative accuracy [92 , 107 ] . In this work we retain the two dominant tensor structures
[ T A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ( p 1 , p 2 ) ] μ a = i γ μ T a , (42) \left[\mathcal{T}_{\bar A q q}^{(1)}(p_1,p_2)\right]^a_\mu= i\gamma_\mu T^a \,, \tag*{(42)} [ T A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ( p 1 , p 2 ) ] μ a = i γ μ T a , (42)
\left[\mathcal{T}_{\bar A q q}^{(4)}(p_1,p_2)\right]^a_\mu= (\slashed{p}_2+\slashed{p}_3)\gamma_\mu T^a \,, \tag*{(43)}
with the associated dressing functions λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) \lambda_{\bar A q q}^{(1)} λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) and λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) \lambda_{\bar A q q}^{(4)} λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) .
The remaining quantitatively important tensor structure, conventionally denoted by T A ˉ q q ( 7 ) \mathcal{T}_{\bar A q q}^{(7)} T A ˉ q q ( 7 ) , is known to induce corrections of approximately 10% to the quark mass [107 , 108 ] . Since this effect is within our estimated systematic uncertainty, we neglect it in the present study. Through the quark-gluon interaction, the matter sector couples directly to the gluonic sector. Towards lower RG scales, the non-perturbative quark-gluon interaction generates strong effective four-quark interactions that drive DχSB and the formation of bound-states, as mentioned in Sec. II B.
Accordingly, we include in the second line a sum of four-quark interaction channels. For two-flavor QCD, and assuming a broken chiral symmetry, a Fierz complete basis invariant under U ( 1 ) V × S U ( 2 ) V U(1)_{\mathrm{V}} \times SU(2)_{\mathrm{V}} U ( 1 ) V × S U ( 2 ) V for these channels consists of 10 elements [72 ] . In this work we focus on two four-quark channels. First, we include the scalar-pseudoscalar (SPS) channel (i = s p s i = \mathrm{sps} i = sps ) which is known to be the dominant channel at low densities, and is capital to properly capture DχSB. Furthermore, an approximation using only this channels is known to give accurate results on the phase structure even at finite temperature and moderate baryon chemical potential [31 , 43 , 73 , 74 ] . In addition, we consider the color-superconducting (CSC) channel (i = c s c i = \mathrm{csc} i = csc ) required to access properties of the scalar diquark, which is the main focus of this work. This interaction channel is commonly used in low-energy model (LEM) such as in the Nambu–Jona-Lasinio (NJL) model [45 ] or, after bosonization, in the quark–meson–diquark (QMD) model [109 , 110 , 111 , 112 , 113 ] . It is also expected to be the dominant channel for two-flavor QCD at high densities [43 ] .
The tensor structure of the SPS and CSC channels, T q ˉ q q ˉ q ( s p s ) \mathcal{T}_{\bar{q} q \bar{q} q}^{(\mathrm{sps})} T q ˉ q q ˉ q ( sps ) and T q ˉ q q ˉ q ( c s c ) \mathcal{T}_{\bar{q} q \bar{q} q}^{(\mathrm{csc})} T q ˉ q q ˉ q ( csc ) , follow from the interaction channels
L ( s p s ) = ( q ˉ q ) 2 − ( q ˉ γ 5 τ ⃗ q ) 2 , (44) \mathcal{L}^{(\mathrm{sps})} = (\bar{q}q)^2 - (\bar{q}\gamma_5\vec{\tau}q)^2 , \tag*{(44)} L ( sps ) = ( q ˉ q ) 2 − ( q ˉ γ 5 τ q ) 2 , (44)
L ( c s c ) = 1 2 ( q T C γ 5 i ϵ a τ 2 q ) ( q ˉ γ 5 i ϵ a τ 2 C q ˉ T ) , (45) \mathcal{L}^{(\mathrm{csc})} = \frac{1}{2}(q^{\mathrm{T}}C\gamma_5 i\epsilon_a\tau_2q)(\bar{q}\gamma_5 i\epsilon_a\tau_2 C\bar{q}^{\mathrm{T}}) , \tag*{(45)} L ( csc ) = 2 1 ( q T C γ 5 i ϵ a τ 2 q ) ( q ˉ γ 5 i ϵ a τ 2 C q ˉ T ) , (45)
and are given explicitly in App. B 2. In the SPS channel we introduced the Pauli matrices τ ⃗ \vec{\tau} τ in flavor space, while in the CSC channel we introduced the charge conjugation matrix C = γ 2 γ 4 C = \gamma_2\gamma_4 C = γ 2 γ 4 and the epsilon tensor acting in color space ( ϵ a ) b c = ϵ a b c (\epsilon_a)_{bc} = \epsilon_{abc} ( ϵ a ) b c = ϵ ab c . The charge conjugation matrix C C C has the following properties
C γ μ T C = γ μ and C T = C − 1 = − C † = − C , (46) C\gamma_\mu^{\mathrm{T}}C = \gamma_\mu\quad\text{and} \quad C^{\mathrm{T}} = C^{-1} = -C^\dagger= -C , \tag*{(46)} C γ μ T C = γ μ and C T = C − 1 = − C † = − C , (46)
and ensures that the pairing interaction Eq. (45) is Lorentz invariant. Similarly, the epsilon tensor ϵ a \epsilon_a ϵ a ensures invariance under S U ( 3 ) c SU(3)_c S U ( 3 ) c gauge transformations. As explained in more detail in Sec. IV C, the emergence of mesons and diquarks in the four-quark scattering described by Eq. (41) is made explicit through dynamical hadronisation. This procedure then continuously generates the low-energy sector of QCD in the form of bosonic fields carrying the quantum numbers of the associated four-quark interactions, in our case the sigma, pion and scalar diquark fields.
Composite sector
The last part of our truncation consist of the composite sector of QCD, including here the sigma, σ \sigma σ , pions, π ⃗ \vec{\pi} π and the scalar diquark, Δ \Delta Δ . The sigma and pion are understood as a quark-antiquark bilinears of the form
σ ∼ q ˉ q and π ⃗ ∼ q ˉ τ ⃗ γ 5 q , (47) \sigma\sim\bar{q}q \quad\text{and} \quad\vec{\pi} \sim\bar{q}\vec{\tau}\gamma_5q , \tag*{(47)} σ ∼ q ˉ q and π ∼ q ˉ τ γ 5 q , (47)
and are conveniently combined into the O ( 4 ) O(4) O ( 4 ) chiral field ϕ = ( σ , π ⃗ ) \phi= (\sigma,\vec{\pi}) ϕ = ( σ , π ) , while the diquark field corresponds to a quark-quark composite of the form
Δ a ∼ q T C γ 5 i ϵ a τ 2 q . (48) \Delta_a \sim q^{\mathrm{T}}C\gamma_5 i\epsilon_a\tau_2q . \tag*{(48)} Δ a ∼ q T C γ 5 i ϵ a τ 2 q . (48)
The effective action of this QMD part is
Γ q m d , k [ A , q ˉ , q , ϕ , Δ † , Δ ] = ∫ x { 1 2 ( ∂ μ ϕ ) ( ∂ μ ϕ ) + ( ∂ μ Δ ) † ( ∂ μ Δ ) + U k ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) − h σ + g q ˉ q ϕ q ˉ ( σ + i γ 5 τ ⃗ ⋅ π ⃗ ) q + 1 2 g Δ q q ( Δ a q ˉ γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a C q ˉ T − Δ a ∗ q T C γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a q ) − i λ A Δ † Δ A μ a [ ( ∂ μ Δ T ) T a Δ ∗ − Δ T T a ( ∂ μ Δ ∗ ) ] + λ A 2 Δ † Δ A μ a A μ b Δ T T a T b Δ ∗ } , (49) \begin{aligned}
\Gamma_{\mathrm{qmd},k}[A,\bar{q},q,\phi,\Delta^\dagger,\Delta] = \int_x \Bigl\{ &\frac{1}{2}(\partial_\mu\phi)(\partial_\mu\phi) + (\partial_\mu\Delta)^\dagger(\partial_\mu\Delta) + U_k(\rho_\phi,\rho_\Delta) - h\sigma\\
&+ g_{\bar{q}q\phi}\bar{q}(\sigma+ i\gamma_5\vec{\tau}\cdot\vec{\pi})q + \frac{1}{2}g_{\Delta q q}\left(\Delta_a\bar{q}\gamma_5\tau_2 i\epsilon_a C\bar{q}^{\mathrm{T}} - \Delta_a^*q^{\mathrm{T}}C\gamma_5\tau_2 i\epsilon_a q\right) \\
&- i\lambda_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta}A_\mu^a\left[(\partial_\mu\Delta^{\mathrm{T}})T^a\Delta^* - \Delta^{\mathrm{T}}T^a(\partial_\mu\Delta^*)\right] + \lambda_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta}A_\mu^aA_\mu^b\Delta^{\mathrm{T}}T^aT^b\Delta^* \Bigr\}, \tag*{(49)}
\end{aligned} Γ qmd , k [ A , q ˉ , q , ϕ , Δ † , Δ ] = ∫ x { 2 1 ( ∂ μ ϕ ) ( ∂ μ ϕ ) + ( ∂ μ Δ ) † ( ∂ μ Δ ) + U k ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) − hσ + g q ˉ q ϕ q ˉ ( σ + i γ 5 τ ⋅ π ) q + 2 1 g Δ q q ( Δ a q ˉ γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a C q ˉ T − Δ a ∗ q T C γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a q ) − i λ A Δ † Δ A μ a [ ( ∂ μ Δ T ) T a Δ ∗ − Δ T T a ( ∂ μ Δ ∗ ) ] + λ A 2 Δ † Δ A μ a A μ b Δ T T a T b Δ ∗ } , (49)
In the first line, we introduced the meson and diquark kinetic terms, the effective potential U k ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) U_k(\rho_\phi,\rho_\Delta) U k ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) and an explicit chiral symmetry breaking term − h σ -h\sigma − hσ , which can be directly mapped onto the non-vanishing current quark mass of (degenerate) up and down quarks. The effective potential is kept as an arbitrary function of the chiral invariant
ρ ϕ = 1 2 ϕ 2 = 1 2 ( σ 2 + π ⃗ 2 ) , (50) \rho_\phi= \frac{1}{2}\phi^2 = \frac{1}{2}(\sigma^2 + \vec{\pi}^{\,2}) , \tag*{(50)} ρ ϕ = 2 1 ϕ 2 = 2 1 ( σ 2 + π 2 ) , (50)
and the diquark invariant
ρ Δ = ∣ Δ ∣ 2 = Δ † Δ = ∑ a = 1 N c Δ a ∗ Δ a . (51) \rho_\Delta= |\Delta|^2 = \Delta^\dagger\Delta= \sum_{a=1}^{N_c}\Delta_a^*\Delta_a . \tag*{(51)} ρ Δ = ∣Δ ∣ 2 = Δ † Δ = a = 1 ∑ N c Δ a ∗ Δ a . (51)
It includes all possible zero-momentum meson-meson, meson-diquark and diquark-diquark interactions consistent with QCD symmetries. A selection of the most relevant interactions used in this work can be found in App. B 2. The second line includes the standard quark-meson and quark-diquark interactions. The exact form of the interactions directly follows from bosonizing the four quark interactions in Eq. (41) . By using the dynamical hadronization procedure detailed in Sec. IV C, the duality between four-quark interactions in certain channels and fundamental meson or diquark fields is rigorously taken into account, especially avoiding any double counting.
We see that the presence of a non-vanishing condensate for the σ \sigma σ meson directly leads to a nonzero finite quark mass
m q = g ϕ ⟨ σ ⟩ . (52) m_q = g_\phi\langle\sigma\rangle. \tag*{(52)} m q = g ϕ ⟨ σ ⟩ . (52)
The presence of finite condensate for the diquark field, for example in the 3 direction, would lead to a gap around the Fermi-surface Δ g a p = g Δ ⟨ Δ 3 ⟩ \Delta_{\mathrm{gap}} = g_\Delta\langle\Delta_3 \rangle Δ gap = g Δ ⟨ Δ 3 ⟩ [9 ] . While there is no such condensate in the QCD vacuum, it can appear at large chemical potential [43 ] .
The last line on Eq. (49) corresponds to the diquark-gluon interactions and follows from the kinetic term of the diquark field expressed in terms of covariant derivatives. Under an S U ( 3 ) c SU(3)_c S U ( 3 ) c gauge transformation q → U q q \to Uq q → U q , it follows from Eq. (48) and the relation U T ϵ a U = U a b ∗ ϵ b U^{T}\epsilon_a U = U^{*}_{ab}\epsilon_b U T ϵ a U = U ab ∗ ϵ b that the diquark transforms as an anti-triplet and the anti-diquark as a triplet, see also [113 ] , i.e.,
Δ ∗ → U Δ ∗ and Δ T → Δ T U † . (53) \Delta^{*} \to U\Delta^{*} \quad\text{and} \quad\Delta^{T} \to\Delta^{T}U^{\dagger}. \tag*{(53)} Δ ∗ → U Δ ∗ and Δ T → Δ T U † . (53)
As such the covariant diquark kinetic term is
( D μ Δ ∗ ) † ( D μ Δ ∗ ) = ( ∂ μ Δ ) † ( ∂ μ Δ ) + g s 2 Δ T A μ A μ Δ ∗ − i g s [ ( ∂ μ Δ T ) A μ Δ ∗ − Δ T A μ ( ∂ μ Δ ∗ ) ] , (54) (D_\mu\Delta^{*})^\dagger(D_\mu\Delta^{*}) = (\partial_\mu\Delta)^\dagger(\partial_\mu\Delta) + g_s^2\Delta^{T}A_\mu A_\mu\Delta^{*} - ig_s\left[(\partial_\mu\Delta^{T})A_\mu\Delta^{*} - \Delta^{T}A_\mu(\partial_\mu\Delta^{*})\right], \tag*{(54)} ( D μ Δ ∗ ) † ( D μ Δ ∗ ) = ( ∂ μ Δ ) † ( ∂ μ Δ ) + g s 2 Δ T A μ A μ Δ ∗ − i g s [ ( ∂ μ Δ T ) A μ Δ ∗ − Δ T A μ ( ∂ μ Δ ∗ ) ] , (54)
which directly leads to the tensor structure of the gluon-diquark interactions in Eq. (49) , where we introduced two additional strong coupling avatars λ A Δ † Δ \lambda_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta} λ A Δ † Δ and λ A 2 Δ † Δ \lambda_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta} λ A 2 Δ † Δ .
Finally, we note that the interaction term proportional to λ A 2 Δ † Δ \lambda_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta} λ A 2 Δ † Δ is responsible for the appearance of a Higgs mass m H i g g s 2 m_{\mathrm{Higgs}}^2 m Higgs 2 for the gluon field in presence of a finite diquark condensate.
Correlation Functions
In this section we discuss the different correlation functions that we will consider and specify the projections employed for the different couplings in Eq. (36) . For this, it will prove useful to introduce the flow contribution defined as
Flow Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) = δ n Flow [ Φ ] δ Φ i 1 ( p 1 ) ⋯ δ Φ i n ( p n ) ∣ Φ c , (55) \operatorname{Flow}^{(n)}_{\Phi_{i_1}\cdots\Phi_{i_n}}(p_1,\ldots,p_n) = \left.\frac{\delta^n\operatorname{Flow}[\Phi]}{\delta\Phi_{i_1}(p_1)\cdots\delta\Phi_{i_n}(p_n)}\right|_{\Phi_c}, \tag*{(55)} Flow Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) = δ Φ i 1 ( p 1 ) ⋯ δ Φ i n ( p n ) δ n Flow [ Φ ] Φ c , (55)
where Φ c \Phi_c Φ c stands for a constant field configuration where every field vanishes, expect for the sigma field, which assumes a spatially homogeneous value σ ( x ) = 2 ρ ϕ \sigma(x) = \sqrt{2\rho_\phi} σ ( x ) = 2 ρ ϕ , with ρ ϕ ∈ R \rho_\phi\in\mathbb{R} ρ ϕ ∈ R . This can be understood as the diagrammatic contributions resulting from the flow equation Eq. (16) , see for example Figure 2 .
Figure 2. Diagrammatic representation of the flow contribution to the two-point function of the gluon (orange curly line), ghost (dotted line), quark (black solid line), meson (blue double line) and diquark fields (blue double line with an arrow). The black dots stand for the full vertex contributions originating from higher order flow equations. The tilde-derivative ∂ ~ t \widetilde{\partial}_t ∂ t implies an RG-time derivative performed only on the regulators and includes an anomalous dimension insertion, see Eq. (28) .
Furthermore, we will formulate all flows in terms of dimensionless couplings, rescaled by an appropriate factor of the RG-scale k k k . The dimensionless couplings will be denoted by a bar, for example m ˉ g a p 2 = m g a p 2 / k 2 \bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2 = m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2/k^2 m ˉ gap 2 = m gap 2 / k 2 and, accordingly, we define the dimensionless flow as
Flow ‾ Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) = k − 4 k d Φ i 1 ⋯ k d Φ i n Flow Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) , (56) \overline{\operatorname{Flow}}^{(n)}_{\Phi_{i_1}\cdots\Phi_{i_n}}(p_1,\ldots,p_n) =
k^{-4}k^{d_{\Phi_{i_1}}}\cdots k^{d_{\Phi_{i_n}}}\operatorname{Flow}^{(n)}_{\Phi_{i_1}\cdots\Phi_{i_n}}(p_1,\ldots,p_n), \tag*{(56)} Flow Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) = k − 4 k d Φ i 1 ⋯ k d Φ i n Flow Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n ( n ) ( p 1 , … , p n ) , (56)
with d Φ i d_{\Phi_i} d Φ i the canonical dimension of the field Φ i \Phi_i Φ i . Similarly to Eq. (19) we sometimes omit one of the momentum arguments, see Eq. (20) . When no momentum arguments are given, it is assumed that the flow is evaluated at vanishing momenta, i.e.,
Flow Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n ( n ) ≡ Flow Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n ( n ) ( 0 , … , 0 ) . (57) \operatorname{Flow}^{(n)}_{\Phi_{i_1}\cdots\Phi_{i_n}} \equiv\operatorname{Flow}^{(n)}_{\Phi_{i_1}\cdots\Phi_{i_n}}(0,\ldots,0). \tag*{(57)} Flow Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n ( n ) ≡ Flow Φ i 1 ⋯ Φ i n ( n ) ( 0 , … , 0 ) . (57)
Lastly, we note that the analytic expression of all flows discussed in the following can be found in App. D2.
Anomalous dimensions
In the RG-invariant formulation introduced in Sec. II, the anomalous dimensions are determined by imposing that all fields are canonically normalized at each RG-scale k k k . This translates to the following set of constraints on the scale-dependent two-point functions
1 6 lim p → 0 ∂ p 2 Π μ ν T ( p ) [ Γ A A ( 2 ) ( p ) ] μ ν a b = ! δ a b , (58) \frac{1}{6}\lim_{p\to0}\partial_p^2\Pi_{\mu\nu}^{T}(p)\left[\Gamma_{AA}^{(2)}(p)\right]_{\mu\nu}^{ab} \stackrel{!}{=} \delta^{ab}, \tag*{(58)} 6 1 p → 0 lim ∂ p 2 Π μν T ( p ) [ Γ AA ( 2 ) ( p ) ] μν ab = ! δ ab , (58)
− 1 2 lim p → 0 ∂ p 2 [ Γ c ˉ c ( 2 ) ( p ) ] a b = ! δ a b , (59) -\frac{1}{2}\lim_{p\to0}\partial_p^2\left[\Gamma_{\bar{c}c}^{(2)}(p)\right]^{ab} \stackrel{!}{=} \delta^{ab}, \tag*{(59)} − 2 1 p → 0 lim ∂ p 2 [ Γ c ˉ c ( 2 ) ( p ) ] ab = ! δ ab , (59)
-\frac{1}{8N_cN_f}\lim_{p\to0}\partial_p^2\operatorname{tr}\left[i\slashed{p}\,\Gamma_{q\bar{q}}^{(2)}(p)\right] \stackrel{!}{=} 1, \tag*{(60)}
1 2 lim p → 0 ∂ p 2 [ Γ ϕ ϕ ( 2 ) ( p ) ] i j = ! δ i j , (61) \frac{1}{2}\lim_{p\to0}\partial_p^2\left[\Gamma_{\phi\phi}^{(2)}(p)\right]_{ij} \stackrel{!}{=} \delta_{ij}, \tag*{(61)} 2 1 p → 0 lim ∂ p 2 [ Γ ϕϕ ( 2 ) ( p ) ] ij = ! δ ij , (61)
1 2 lim p → 0 ∂ p 2 [ Γ Δ ∗ Δ ( 2 ) ( p ) ] a b = ! δ a b , (62) \frac{1}{2}\lim_{p\to0}\partial_p^2\left[\Gamma_{\Delta^{*}\Delta}^{(2)}(p)\right]_{ab} \stackrel{!}{=} \delta_{ab}, \tag*{(62)} 2 1 p → 0 lim ∂ p 2 [ Γ Δ ∗ Δ ( 2 ) ( p ) ] ab = ! δ ab , (62)
where we only considered the transverse component of the gluon two-point function as we work in Landau gauge. Inserting the constraints Eqs. (58) to (62) into the RG-invariant formulation of the flow equation Eq. (16) we obtain the following expression for the anomalous dimensions of the different fields
η A = − 1 6 ( N c 2 − 1 ) × lim p → 0 δ a b ∂ 2 ∂ p 2 Π μ ν T ( p ) [ Flow ‾ A A ( 2 ) ( p ) ] μ ν a b , (63) \eta_A = -\frac{1}{6(N_c^2-1)} \times\lim_{p\to0}\delta_{ab}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial p^2}\Pi_{\mu\nu}^{T}(p)\left[\overline{\operatorname{Flow}}_{AA}^{(2)}(p)\right]_{\mu\nu}^{ab}, \tag*{(63)} η A = − 6 ( N c 2 − 1 ) 1 × p → 0 lim δ ab ∂ p 2 ∂ 2 Π μν T ( p ) [ Flow AA ( 2 ) ( p ) ] μν ab , (63)
η c = 1 2 ( N c 2 − 1 ) lim p → 0 δ a b ∂ 2 ∂ p 2 [ F l o w c ˉ c ( 2 ) ( p ) ] a b (64) \eta_c = \frac{1}{2(N_c^2-1)}\lim_{p\to0}\delta_{ab}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial p^2}\left[\mathrm{Flow}^{(2)}_{\bar{c}c}(p)\right]^{ab} \tag*{(64)} η c = 2 ( N c 2 − 1 ) 1 p → 0 lim δ ab ∂ p 2 ∂ 2 [ Flow c ˉ c ( 2 ) ( p ) ] ab (64)
η q = − i 8 N f N c lim p → 0 ∂ 2 ∂ p 2 Tr [ ̸ p F l o w q ˉ q ( 2 ) ( − p ) ] (65) \eta_q = -\frac{i}{8N_fN_c}\lim_{p\to0}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial p^2}\operatorname{Tr}\left[\not\!p\,\mathrm{Flow}^{(2)}_{\bar{q}q}(-p)\right] \tag*{(65)} η q = − 8 N f N c i p → 0 lim ∂ p 2 ∂ 2 Tr [ p Flow q ˉ q ( 2 ) ( − p ) ] (65)
η ϕ = − 1 2 ( N f 2 − 1 ) lim p → 0 δ i j ∂ 2 ∂ p 2 [ F l o w π π ( 2 ) ( p ) ] i j (66) \eta_\phi= -\frac{1}{2(N_f^2-1)}\lim_{p\to0}\delta_{ij}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial p^2}\left[\mathrm{Flow}^{(2)}_{\pi\pi}(p)\right]_{ij} \tag*{(66)} η ϕ = − 2 ( N f 2 − 1 ) 1 p → 0 lim δ ij ∂ p 2 ∂ 2 [ Flow π π ( 2 ) ( p ) ] ij (66)
η Δ = − 1 2 N c lim p → 0 δ a b ∂ 2 ∂ p 2 [ F l o w Δ † Δ ( 2 ) ( p ) ] a b (67) \eta_\Delta= -\frac{1}{2N_c}\lim_{p\to0}\delta_{ab}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial p^2}\left[\mathrm{Flow}^{(2)}_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}(p)\right]_{ab} \tag*{(67)} η Δ = − 2 N c 1 p → 0 lim δ ab ∂ p 2 ∂ 2 [ Flow Δ † Δ ( 2 ) ( p ) ] ab (67)
The diagrammatic representations of the different flow contributions for the two-point functions are shown in Figure 2 .
Although the anomalous dimension only takes into account the first correction in a small-momentum expansion, it is known to provide quantitatively accurate results for many systems. In particular, in Ref. [68 ] it was shown to provide a good approximation to QCD, for example providing a correct description of the gluon dressing function. Furthermore, in presence of a gluon mass parameter this approximation was shown to be sufficient in capturing both the scaling and decoupling solutions. We also note that the anomalous dimension of the composite fields plays an essential roles in the dynamical hadronization procedure as we will show in § 2 C.
For the mesonic sector, we do not distinguish between the sigma and pion anomalous dimensions, and employ the pion two-point function to fix the common anomalous dimension η ϕ ≡ η π = η σ \eta_\phi\equiv\eta_\pi= \eta_\sigma η ϕ ≡ η π = η σ . This approximation has been repeatedly confirmed to be reliable in the low density regime, see, e.g., Refs. [31 , 114 ] . This is expected, because pions are the most relevant dynamical degrees of freedom at low energies.
In the infrared, the gluon anomalous dimension diverges [67 ] . This is presumably an artifact of the present bootstrap approach. It is, however, inconsequential, as this only occurs in the deep IR, where the gluon propagator of the scaling solution is dominated by the diverging gap parameter [68 ] . To deal with this, we modify the flow of the anomalous dimension as
η A → η A k n − 1 ( k n + k c o n f n ) 1 − n n (68) \eta_A \to\eta_A k^{n-1}\left(k^n+k_{\mathrm{conf}}^n\right)^{\frac{1-n}{n}} \tag*{(68)} η A → η A k n − 1 ( k n + k conf n ) n 1 − n (68)
with k c o n f = 1 G e V k_{\mathrm{conf}}=1\,\mathrm{GeV} k conf = 1 GeV and n = 10 n=10 n = 10 . This procedure ensures that for k ≲ k c o n f k\lesssim k_{\mathrm{conf}} k ≲ k conf the gluon anomalous dimension remains constant. This does not affect the IR observables, because the gluons are already decoupled. We checked explicitly that our results are independent of the exact choice of n n n and k c o n f k_{\mathrm{conf}} k conf . However, k c o n f k_{\mathrm{conf}} k conf must be chosen above the RG scale where the gluon anomalous dimension diverges, i.e., k ≳ 350 M e V k\gtrsim350\,\mathrm{MeV} k ≳ 350 MeV , and below the gluon decoupling scale k g a p ≲ 1.2 G e V k_{\mathrm{gap}}\lesssim1.2\,\mathrm{GeV} k gap ≲ 1.2 GeV ; see § 2 .
Strong-coupling avatars and gluon mass gap
In this section, we extend the previous discussion to the remaining couplings related to the gauge sector. For the two-point functions, it only remains to specify the flow of m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap , which is found by the k k k -dependence of the transverse part of the gluon two-point function at vanishing momentum,
∂ t m ˉ g a p 2 = ( − 2 + η A ) m ˉ g a p 2 + 1 3 ( N c 2 − 1 ) lim p → 0 δ a b Π μ ν T ( p ) [ F l o w A 2 ( 2 ) ( p ) ] μ ν a b (69) \partial_t\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2=(-2+\eta_A)\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2
+\frac{1}{3(N_c^2-1)}\lim_{p\to0}\delta_{ab}\Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{T}}(p)\left[\mathrm{Flow}^{(2)}_{A^2}(p)\right]^{ab}_{\mu\nu} \tag*{(69)} ∂ t m ˉ gap 2 = ( − 2 + η A ) m ˉ gap 2 + 3 ( N c 2 − 1 ) 1 p → 0 lim δ ab Π μν T ( p ) [ Flow A 2 ( 2 ) ( p ) ] μν ab (69)
This flow equation plays a crucial role in the infrared scaling behavior.
Next, we come to the strong couplings. As discussed earlier, the avatars of the strong coupling become degenerate in the perturbative regime, where they all take the same value. As they are evolved toward the infrared, nonperturbative quantum fluctuations drive them to exhibit different behaviors. The diagrammatic representations of the different contributions to the flow that we take into account can be found in Figure 3 .
Figure 3. Diagrammatic representation of the flows of the different strong coupling avatars. Additional diagrams obtained by permuting external legs are implied.
For the three and four gluon couplings, we use their associated classical tensor structure to perform the projection, which yields
∂ t λ A 3 = 3 2 η A λ A 3 + i 12 N c ( N c 2 − 1 ) lim p → 0 ∂ 2 ∂ p 2 f a b c δ μ ν p ρ [ Flow A 3 ( 3 ) ( p , − p ) ] μ ν ρ a b c (70) \partial_t\lambda_{A_3}=\frac{3}{2}\eta_A\lambda_{A_3}+\frac{i}{12N_c(N_c^2-1)}\lim_{p\to0}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial p^2}f^{abc}\delta_{\mu\nu}p_\rho\left[\operatorname{Flow}^{(3)}_{A_3}(p,-p)\right]^{abc}_{\mu\nu\rho} \tag*{(70)} ∂ t λ A 3 = 2 3 η A λ A 3 + 12 N c ( N c 2 − 1 ) i p → 0 lim ∂ p 2 ∂ 2 f ab c δ μν p ρ [ Flow A 3 ( 3 ) ( p , − p ) ] μν ρ ab c (70)
∂ t λ A 4 = 2 η A λ A 4 + [ P A 4 ( 1 ) ] μ ν ρ σ a b c d [ Flow A 4 ( 4 ) ] μ ν ρ σ a b c d , (71) \partial_t\lambda_{A_4}=2\eta_A\lambda_{A_4}+\left[\mathcal{P}_{A_4}^{(1)}\right]^{abcd}_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\left[\operatorname{Flow}^{(4)}_{A_4}\right]^{abcd}_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}, \tag*{(71)} ∂ t λ A 4 = 2 η A λ A 4 + [ P A 4 ( 1 ) ] μν ρ σ ab c d [ Flow A 4 ( 4 ) ] μν ρ σ ab c d , (71)
where we introduced the projector
[ P A 4 ( 1 ) ] μ ν ρ σ a b c d = 1 108 N c 2 ( N c 2 − 1 ) [ T A 4 ( 1 ) ] μ ν ρ σ a b c d , (72) \left[\mathcal{P}_{A_4}^{(1)}\right]^{abcd}_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}=\frac{1}{108N_c^2(N_c^2-1)}\left[\mathcal{T}_{A_4}^{(1)}\right]^{abcd}_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}, \tag*{(72)} [ P A 4 ( 1 ) ] μν ρ σ ab c d = 108 N c 2 ( N c 2 − 1 ) 1 [ T A 4 ( 1 ) ] μν ρ σ ab c d , (72)
with the normalization
[ T A 4 ( 1 ) ] μ ν ρ σ a b c d [ T A 4 ( 1 ) ] μ ν ρ σ a b c d = 108 N c 2 ( N c 2 − 1 ) . (73) \left[\mathcal{T}_{A_4}^{(1)}\right]^{abcd}_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\left[\mathcal{T}_{A_4}^{(1)}\right]^{abcd}_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}=108N_c^2(N_c^2-1). \tag*{(73)} [ T A 4 ( 1 ) ] μν ρ σ ab c d [ T A 4 ( 1 ) ] μν ρ σ ab c d = 108 N c 2 ( N c 2 − 1 ) . (73)
For the external momentum in the three gluon vertex, we have taken a simple configuration in which only two external gluon legs carry the momenta, similarly to Refs. [31 , 73 ] . Note that all momentum configurations are expected to yield the same flow equation in the zero-momentum limit in our case2
For the ghost-gluon vertex we employ the projection
∂ t λ A c c ˉ = ( 1 2 η A + η c ) λ A c c ˉ − i 2 N c ( N c 2 − 1 ) lim p → 0 ∂ 2 ∂ p 2 f a b c p μ [ Flow A c c ˉ ( 3 ) ( 0 , p ) ] μ a b c . (74) \partial_t\lambda_{A c\bar{c}}=\left(\frac{1}{2}\eta_A+\eta_c\right)\lambda_{A c\bar{c}}-\frac{i}{2N_c(N_c^2-1)}\lim_{p\to0}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial p^2}f^{abc}p_\mu\left[\operatorname{Flow}^{(3)}_{A c\bar{c}}(0,p)\right]^{abc}_{\mu}. \tag*{(74)} ∂ t λ A c c ˉ = ( 2 1 η A + η c ) λ A c c ˉ − 2 N c ( N c 2 − 1 ) i p → 0 lim ∂ p 2 ∂ 2 f ab c p μ [ Flow A c c ˉ ( 3 ) ( 0 , p ) ] μ ab c . (74)
However, in the limit of vanishing momentum, the flow contribution vanishes because the ghost-gluon vertex is directly proportional to ghost momenta. Hence, the flow of the ghost-gluon coupling only receives a canonical contribution from the anomalous dimensions
∂ t λ A c c ˉ = ( 1 2 η A + η c ) λ A c c ˉ . (75) \partial_t\lambda_{A c\bar{c}}=\left(\frac{1}{2}\eta_A+\eta_c\right)\lambda_{A c\bar{c}}. \tag*{(75)} ∂ t λ A c c ˉ = ( 2 1 η A + η c ) λ A c c ˉ . (75)
We now turn to the strong coupling avatars involving matter fields. To obtain the flows of the two tensor structures of the quark-gluon coupling, we choose the following projections
∂ t λ A q q ( 1 ) = ( 1 2 η A + η q ) λ A q q ( 1 ) − i 8 N f ( N c 2 − 1 ) Tr { γ μ T a [ Flow A q q ( 3 ) ] μ a } , (76) \partial_t\lambda_{Aqq}^{(1)}=\left(\frac{1}{2}\eta_A+\eta_q\right)\lambda_{Aqq}^{(1)}-\frac{i}{8N_f(N_c^2-1)}\operatorname{Tr}\left\{\gamma_\mu T^a\left[\operatorname{Flow}^{(3)}_{Aqq}\right]^a_\mu\right\}, \tag*{(76)} ∂ t λ A q q ( 1 ) = ( 2 1 η A + η q ) λ A q q ( 1 ) − 8 N f ( N c 2 − 1 ) i Tr { γ μ T a [ Flow A q q ( 3 ) ] μ a } , (76)
∂ t λ A q q ( 4 ) = ( 1 + 1 2 η A + η q ) λ A q q ( 4 ) + i 24 N f ( N c 2 − 1 ) lim p → 0 ∂ 2 ∂ p 2 Tr { Π μ ν T ( p ) γ ν γ a [ Flow A q q ( 3 ) ( − 2 p , p ) ] μ a } , (77) \partial_t\lambda_{Aqq}^{(4)}=\left(1+\frac{1}{2}\eta_A+\eta_q\right)\lambda_{Aqq}^{(4)}+\frac{i}{24N_f(N_c^2-1)}\lim_{p\to0}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial p^2}\operatorname{Tr}\left\{\Pi^T_{\mu\nu}(p)\gamma_\nu\gamma^a\left[\operatorname{Flow}^{(3)}_{Aqq}(-2p,p)\right]^a_\mu\right\}, \tag*{(77)} ∂ t λ A q q ( 4 ) = ( 1 + 2 1 η A + η q ) λ A q q ( 4 ) + 24 N f ( N c 2 − 1 ) i p → 0 lim ∂ p 2 ∂ 2 Tr { Π μν T ( p ) γ ν γ a [ Flow A q q ( 3 ) ( − 2 p , p ) ] μ a } , (77)
where the trace over quark indices is understood.
Finally, we specify the flow of the two diquark-gluon strong coupling avatars. We choose the following projec-
∂ t λ A Δ † Δ = ( 1 2 η A + η Δ ) + 1 2 ( N c 2 − 1 ) lim p → 0 ∂ 2 ∂ p 2 p μ T α β a [ F l o w A Δ † Δ ( 3 ) ( 0 , − p ) ] μ α β a (78) \partial_t\lambda_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta}=\left(\frac{1}{2}\eta_A+\eta_\Delta\right)+\frac{1}{2(N_c^2-1)}\lim_{p\to0}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial p^2}p_\mu T^a_{\alpha\beta}\left[\mathrm{Flow}^{(3)}_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta}(0,-p)\right]^a_{\mu\alpha\beta} \tag*{(78)} ∂ t λ A Δ † Δ = ( 2 1 η A + η Δ ) + 2 ( N c 2 − 1 ) 1 p → 0 lim ∂ p 2 ∂ 2 p μ T α β a [ Flow A Δ † Δ ( 3 ) ( 0 , − p ) ] μα β a (78)
∂ t λ A 2 Δ † Δ = ( η A + η Δ ) + 1 4 ( N c 2 − 1 ) δ a b δ μ ν δ a b [ F l o w A 2 Δ † Δ ( 4 ) ] μ ν a b a b (79) \partial_t\lambda_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta}=(\eta_A+\eta_\Delta)+\frac{1}{4(N_c^2-1)}\delta^{ab}\delta_{\mu\nu}\delta_{ab}\left[\mathrm{Flow}^{(4)}_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta}\right]^{ab}_{\mu\nu ab} \tag*{(79)} ∂ t λ A 2 Δ † Δ = ( η A + η Δ ) + 4 ( N c 2 − 1 ) 1 δ ab δ μν δ ab [ Flow A 2 Δ † Δ ( 4 ) ] μν ab ab (79)
where the momentum configuration of the two-diquark-one-gluon avatar is similar to the one used for the three-gluon avatar.
Four-quark interactions & emergent composites
We now move to the connection between the high- and low-energy degrees of freedom. It is established by exactly mapping emergent four-quark interactions onto effective meson or diquark exchange interactions. In the following we first discuss the projection onto the four-quark channels and then focus on the dynamical hadronization procedure.
Four-quark interactions
As one flows from the UV to the IR, effective four-quark interactions inevitably are generated through the quark-gluon interactions. For a given four-quark channel (i = s p s , c s c i=\mathrm{sps},\mathrm{csc} i = sps , csc ) we use the projection
∂ t λ ˉ q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) = ( 2 + η q ) λ ˉ q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) + [ P q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) ] α β γ δ [ F l o w ‾ q ˉ q q q ˉ ( 4 ) ] α β γ δ (80) \partial_t\bar{\lambda}^{(i)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}=(2+\eta_q)\bar{\lambda}^{(i)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}+\left[\mathcal{P}^{(i)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}\left[\overline{\mathrm{Flow}}^{(4)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta} \tag*{(80)} ∂ t λ ˉ q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) = ( 2 + η q ) λ ˉ q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) + [ P q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) ] α β γ δ [ Flow q ˉ q q q ˉ ( 4 ) ] α β γ δ (80)
with λ ˉ q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) = k 2 λ q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) \bar{\lambda}^{(i)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}=k^2\lambda^{(i)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}} λ ˉ q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) = k 2 λ q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) . The diagrammatic contribution to the flow of the four-quark channel are shown in Figure 4 . As explained in the next section, we only need to take into account box diagrams, as the four-quark interactions themselves are zero owing to dynamical hadronization. We define the projector for a given four-quark channel by
Figure 4. Diagrammatic representation of the flow of the four-quark interaction.
[ P q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) ] α β γ δ = ∑ k c i k [ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( k ) ] γ δ α β (81) \left[\mathcal{P}^{(i)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}=\sum_k c_{ik}\left[\mathcal{T}^{(k)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}\right]_{\gamma\delta\alpha\beta} \tag*{(81)} [ P q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) ] α β γ δ = k ∑ c ik [ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( k ) ] γ δ α β (81)
where the order of the fermionic indices is adjusted such that each q ˉ \bar{q} q ˉ index matches a q q q index when applied on a tensor structure. The coefficients c i k c_{ik} c ik are determined by imposing the condition
[ P q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) ] α β γ δ [ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( j ) ] α β γ δ = ! δ i j (82) \left[\mathcal{P}^{(i)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}\left[\mathcal{T}^{(j)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}\overset{!}{=}\delta_{ij} \tag*{(82)} [ P q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) ] α β γ δ [ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( j ) ] α β γ δ = ! δ ij (82)
from which we immediately conclude c i j = ( a − 1 ) i j c_{ij}=(a^{-1})_{ij} c ij = ( a − 1 ) ij where the matrix a a a has components
a i j = [ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) ] γ δ α β [ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( j ) ] α β γ δ (83) a_{ij}=\left[\mathcal{T}^{(i)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}\right]_{\gamma\delta\alpha\beta}\left[\mathcal{T}^{(j)}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta} \tag*{(83)} a ij = [ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( i ) ] γ δ α β [ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( j ) ] α β γ δ (83)
In the case of a single tensor structure, this coefficient can be interpreted as a normalization factor similar to Eq. (72) . We find that the diquark sector is sensitive to the choice of projection onto the corresponding four-quark channel. In general, different choices of projections lead to different flow equations. Without considering a complete set of interaction channels, this can result in contamination from channels that are not taken into account. We found that the SPS sector is mostly insensitive to the details of the projection, while the CSC sector is more sensitive. This is clear in the QCD vacuum, where the SPS channel is by far the most dominant one due to spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking. In order to obtain a stable projection while keeping the calculation relatively simple, we choose to adopt a Fierz complete basis invariant under U ( 1 ) V × S U ( 2 ) L × S U ( 2 ) R U(1)_V\times SU(2)_L\times SU(2)_R U ( 1 ) V × S U ( 2 ) L × S U ( 2 ) R for the construction of the projectors Eq. (81) . Such a basis consists of six elements, which we choose as
L ( s p s ) = ( q ˉ q ) 2 − ( q ˉ γ 5 τ ⃗ q ) 2 , \mathcal{L}^{(\mathrm{sps})}=(\bar{q}q)^2-(\bar{q}\gamma_5\vec{\tau}q)^2, L ( sps ) = ( q ˉ q ) 2 − ( q ˉ γ 5 τ q ) 2 ,
L ( n ′ ) = ( q ˉ τ ⃗ q ) 2 − ( q ˉ γ 5 q ) 2 , \mathcal{L}^{(\mathrm{n'})}=(\bar{q}\vec{\tau}q)^2-(\bar{q}\gamma_5q)^2, L ( n ′ ) = ( q ˉ τ q ) 2 − ( q ˉ γ 5 q ) 2 ,
L ( c s c ) = 1 2 ( q ˉ T C γ 5 τ ⃗ ϵ τ 2 q ) ( q ˉ γ 5 τ ⃗ ϵ τ 2 C q ˉ T ) , \mathcal{L}^{(\mathrm{csc})}=\frac{1}{2}(\bar{q}^{T}C\gamma_5\vec{\tau}\epsilon\tau_2q)(\bar{q}\gamma_5\vec{\tau}\epsilon\tau_2C\bar{q}^{T}), L ( csc ) = 2 1 ( q ˉ T C γ 5 τ ϵ τ 2 q ) ( q ˉ γ 5 τ ϵ τ 2 C q ˉ T ) ,
L ( V − A ) = ( q ˉ γ μ q ) 2 + ( q ˉ γ μ γ 5 τ ⃗ q ) 2 , \mathcal{L}^{(\mathrm{V-A})}=(\bar{q}\gamma_\mu q)^2+(\bar{q}\gamma_\mu\gamma_5\vec{\tau}q)^2, L ( V − A ) = ( q ˉ γ μ q ) 2 + ( q ˉ γ μ γ 5 τ q ) 2 ,
L ( V + A ) = ( q ˉ γ μ q ) 2 − ( q ˉ γ μ γ 5 τ ⃗ q ) 2 , \mathcal{L}^{(\mathrm{V+A})}=(\bar{q}\gamma_\mu q)^2-(\bar{q}\gamma_\mu\gamma_5\vec{\tau}q)^2, L ( V + A ) = ( q ˉ γ μ q ) 2 − ( q ˉ γ μ γ 5 τ q ) 2 ,
L ( V − A ) a d j = ( q ˉ γ μ T a q ) 2 + ( q ˉ γ μ γ 5 T a τ ⃗ q ) 2 (84) \mathcal{L}^{(\mathrm{V-A})_{\mathrm{adj}}}=(\bar{q}\gamma_\mu T^a q)^2+(\bar{q}\gamma_\mu\gamma_5T^a\vec{\tau}q)^2 \tag*{(84)} L ( V − A ) adj = ( q ˉ γ μ T a q ) 2 + ( q ˉ γ μ γ 5 T a τ q ) 2 (84)
and where the associated tensor structures are derived similarly to Eq. (37) . This basis is taken from Ref. [72 ] with the replacement of L a d j ( S + P ) \mathcal{L}^{(\mathrm{S+P})}_{\mathrm{adj}} L adj ( S + P ) with L ( c s c ) \mathcal{L}^{(\mathrm{csc})} L ( csc ) , which both break U ( 1 ) A U(1)_A U ( 1 ) A explicitly. Assuming invariance only under U ( 1 ) V × S U ( 2 ) V U(1)_V\times SU(2)_V U ( 1 ) V × S U ( 2 ) V , which is motivated by chiral symmetry breaking, leads to four additional tensor structures. However, we found only minor change upon including the last elements of the basis in Eq. (84) and hence chose to restrict ourselves to a basis invariant under U ( 1 ) V × S U ( 2 ) L × S U ( 2 ) R U(1)_V\times SU(2)_L\times SU(2)_R U ( 1 ) V × S U ( 2 ) L × S U ( 2 ) R . For a recent discussion on the construction of tensor basis, see Ref. [115 ] . Based on this basis, we can extract the projections onto the SPS and CSC channels which are orthogonal to all other channels, hence avoiding contamination that will most drastically affect the subdominant CSC channel.
In a truncation which includes only quark and gluons and do not resolve the full momentum dependency of the four-quark couplings, Dχ \chi χ SB is found through a resonance of the SPS channel. In particular, in such a truncation the SPS channel evaluated at vanishing momenta diverges for a finite RG scale k > 0 k>0 k > 0 [72 , 73 , 116 ] . The dynamical hadronization procedure provides a convenient way to capture this resonance by introducing an additional scale dependent field for the σ \sigma σ -meson and pions, and Dχ \chi χ SB then translate into a finite condensate for the σ \sigma σ -meson. Furthermore, this procedure can be directly generalized to capture additional resonances corresponding to other quark composite like the scalar diquark.
Dynamical hadronization
Dynamical hadronization is based on the generalized flow equation Eq. (16) , and is implemented through an appropriate choice for the flow Φ ˙ \dot{\Phi} Φ ˙ of the composite fields. These fields serve a dual purpose: at high energies they simply encode quark correlations in certain channels, while at low energies they can become relevant degrees of freedom. Conventionally, four-quark interactions are bosonized into the corresponding meson and diquark fields through a Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation, replacing the four-quark interactions by Yukawa interactions and bosonic fields. This procedure is, however, not appropriate for QCD. First, the scale where the bosonization is carried out must be chosen by hand. Second, four-quark interactions that are re-generated through boson exchanges between quarks at scales below the bosonization scale are not taken into account.
These problems are circumvented by bosonizing at each RG scale k k k , hence neither introducing an arbitrary bosonization scale, nor losing any information on four-quark interactions generated at any scale. It has been shown in Ref. [69 ] that this can be done exactly by choosing the flows of the composite operators in Eq. (25) such that the flows of the associated four-quark interactions vanish. As illustrated in Figure 5 , this amounts to an exact rewriting of parts of the fundamental four-quark interactions in terms of single-boson exchanges. Through the scale dependence, these bosons reflect their composite nature at high energies, while they can act as the relevant degrees of freedom at low energies. Crucially, as we will also explicitly demonstrate below, all features related to low-energy degrees of freedom and spontaneous symmetry breaking are emergent with this procedure, allowing for predictions from first principles.
Figure 5. Diagrammatic illustration of the dynamical hadronization procedure. During the RG flow, the sum of four quark interactions in Eq. (41) is continuously mapped onto a sum of single-boson exchanges (here involving the σ \sigma σ -meson, pions and the scalar diquark) in a chosen momentum configuration and a “rest”. The rest contains all four-quark interaction channels which are not dynamically hadronized, and the momentum dependencies not taken into account in the dynamically hadronized channels. In this work, we focus purely on the dynamically hadronized SPS and CSC channels at zero momentum exchange and neglect the rest.
The latter property is intimately tied to an IR attractive fixed point in the flow of the four-quark couplings in the regime of small gauge coupling [70 ] . All information on the initial values of composite operators is lost as the system gets close to the fixed point. By the time the system enters the strong coupling regime, where the fixed point vanishes, all low-energy parameters have settled to values uniquely determined by QCD. Crucially, this not only applies to composites built from the four-quark interactions themselves, but also higher-order operators [70 , 74 ] ; see also § 2 D.
In this work, we focus on six low-energy composite degrees of freedom, namely the σ \sigma σ -meson, the pions, the diquark Δ \Delta Δ , and the anti-diquark Δ † \Delta^\dagger Δ † . We hence parametrize the scale dependence of the fields with respect to these degrees of freedom,
Φ ˙ [ Φ ] = δ a ϕ ϕ ˙ [ q ˉ , q ] + δ a Δ Δ ˙ [ q ] + δ a Δ † Δ ˙ † [ q ˉ ] . (85) \dot{\Phi}[\Phi] = \delta_{a\phi}\dot{\phi}[\bar{q},q] + \delta_{a\Delta}\dot{\Delta}[q] + \delta_{a\Delta^\dagger}\dot{\Delta}^{\dagger}[\bar{q}] \, . \tag*{(85)} Φ ˙ [ Φ ] = δ a ϕ ϕ ˙ [ q ˉ , q ] + δ a Δ Δ ˙ [ q ] + δ a Δ † Δ ˙ † [ q ˉ ] . (85)
The scale dependence of the composite field is chosen directly proportional to their quark content. Hence for the mesonic fields ϕ = ( σ , π ⃗ ) \phi=(\sigma,\vec{\pi}) ϕ = ( σ , π ) we have
ϕ ˙ [ q ˉ , q ] = A ˙ ϕ ( q ˉ q i q ˉ γ 5 τ ⃗ q ) , (86) \dot{\phi}[\bar{q},q] = \dot{A}_{\phi}\begin{pmatrix}\bar{q}q\\ i\bar{q}\gamma^{5}\vec{\tau}q\end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(86)} ϕ ˙ [ q ˉ , q ] = A ˙ ϕ ( q ˉ q i q ˉ γ 5 τ q ) , (86)
while for the diquark and antidiquark we use
Δ ˙ a [ q ] = A ˙ Δ q T C γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a q , (87) \dot{\Delta}_{a}[q] = \dot{A}_{\Delta}q^{T}C\gamma_{5}\tau_{2}i\epsilon_{a}q \, , \tag*{(87)} Δ ˙ a [ q ] = A ˙ Δ q T C γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a q , (87)
Δ ˙ a ∗ [ q ˉ ] = − A ˙ Δ q ˉ γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a C q ˉ T , (88) \dot{\Delta}^{*}_{a}[\bar{q}] = -\dot{A}_{\Delta}\bar{q}\gamma_{5}\tau_{2}i\epsilon_{a}C\bar{q}^{T} \, , \tag*{(88)} Δ ˙ a ∗ [ q ˉ ] = − A ˙ Δ q ˉ γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a C q ˉ T , (88)
where A ˙ ϕ \dot{A}_{\phi} A ˙ ϕ and A ˙ Δ \dot{A}_{\Delta} A ˙ Δ are two functions of the RG-scale that must be determined.
Inserting these transformation on the left-hand side of Eq. (16) and imposing that the flow of the SPS and CSC four-quark channel vanish at all scales, we obtain
A ˙ ϕ = 1 g ϕ q ˉ q [ P q ˉ q ˉ q q ( s p s ) ] α β γ δ [ F l o w q ˉ q ˉ q q ( 4 ) ] α β γ δ , (89) \dot{A}_{\phi} = \frac{1}{g_{\phi\bar{q}q}}\left[\mathcal{P}^{(\mathrm{sps})}_{\bar{q}\bar{q}qq}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}\left[\mathrm{Flow}^{(4)}_{\bar{q}\bar{q}qq}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}, \tag*{(89)} A ˙ ϕ = g ϕ q ˉ q 1 [ P q ˉ q ˉ q q ( sps ) ] α β γ δ [ Flow q ˉ q ˉ q q ( 4 ) ] α β γ δ , (89)
and
A ˙ Δ = 1 2 g Δ q q [ P q ˉ q ˉ q q ( c s c ) ] α β γ δ [ F l o w q ˉ q ˉ q q ( 4 ) ] α β γ δ . (90) \dot{A}_{\Delta} = \frac{1}{2g_{\Delta qq}}\left[\mathcal{P}^{(\mathrm{csc})}_{\bar{q}\bar{q}qq}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}\left[\mathrm{Flow}^{(4)}_{\bar{q}\bar{q}qq}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}. \tag*{(90)} A ˙ Δ = 2 g Δ q q 1 [ P q ˉ q ˉ q q ( csc ) ] α β γ δ [ Flow q ˉ q ˉ q q ( 4 ) ] α β γ δ . (90)
If in addition we assume that the four-quark interactions vanish in the UV, consistent with the QCD classical action, we then ensure that the SPS and CSC four-quark interactions vanish for all k k k . Note that the criterion of vanishing four-quark flows can directly be used to motivate the parametrization of the composite fields Eqs. (86) to (88) .
Through the generalized flow equation Eq. (16) , the dynamical hadronization functions A ˉ ˙ ϕ \dot{\bar{A}}_{\phi} A ˉ ˙ ϕ and A ˉ ˙ Δ \dot{\bar{A}}_{\Delta} A ˉ ˙ Δ now enter the flow of the quark-meson and quark-diquark Yukawa couplings, g ϕ q q ˉ g_{\phi q\bar{q}} g ϕq q ˉ and g Δ q q g_{\Delta qq} g Δ q q . Hence, as illustrated in Figure 5 , the flow of the four-quark interactions is captured through those two couplings. In fact, in the present pointlike approximation, the four quark interactions are effectively given by the ratios
λ s p s , e f f = g ϕ q q ˉ 2 2 ( k 2 + m ϕ 2 ) , λ c s c , e f f = g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 2 ( k 2 + m Δ 2 ) . (91) \lambda_{\mathrm{sps},\mathrm{eff}} = \frac{g_{\phi q\bar{q}}^{2}}{2(k^{2}+m_{\phi}^{2})}, \qquad\lambda_{\mathrm{csc},\mathrm{eff}} = \frac{g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{2}}{2(k^{2}+m_{\Delta}^{2})}. \tag*{(91)} λ sps , eff = 2 ( k 2 + m ϕ 2 ) g ϕq q ˉ 2 , λ csc , eff = 2 ( k 2 + m Δ 2 ) g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 . (91)
These expressions are obtained by integrating out auxiliary meson and diquark fields. As discussed in Sec. II B, it is evident that peaks in the four-quark interaction directly translate into soft bosonic modes.
Yukawa couplings
For the sake of simplicity, we follow Ref. [117 ] and choose to project the flow of the quark-meson couplings using the quark two-point function,
∂ t g ϕ q q ˉ = ( 1 2 η ϕ + η q ) g ϕ q q ˉ − A ˉ ˙ ϕ m ˉ π 2 − 1 4 N f N c 1 σ Tr [ F l o w q ˉ q ( 2 ) ] . (92) \partial_t g_{\phi q\bar{q}} = \left(\frac{1}{2}\eta_{\phi}+\eta_q\right)g_{\phi q\bar{q}}-\dot{\bar{A}}_{\phi}\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2}-\frac{1}{4N_fN_c}\frac{1}{\sigma}\operatorname{Tr}\left[\mathrm{Flow}_{\bar{q}q}^{(2)}\right]. \tag*{(92)} ∂ t g ϕq q ˉ = ( 2 1 η ϕ + η q ) g ϕq q ˉ − A ˉ ˙ ϕ m ˉ π 2 − 4 N f N c 1 σ 1 Tr [ Flow q ˉ q ( 2 ) ] . (92)
For the quark-diquark Yukawa coupling, we instead use the three point function for the projection,
∂ t g Δ q q = ( 1 2 η Δ + η q ) g Δ q q + 2 A ˉ ˙ Δ m ˉ Δ 2 + 1 24 N f Tr { ( C γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a ) [ F l o w Δ q ˉ q ˉ ( 3 ) ] a } . (93) \partial_t g_{\Delta qq} = \left(\frac{1}{2}\eta_{\Delta}+\eta_q\right)g_{\Delta qq}+2\dot{\bar{A}}_{\Delta}\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2}+\frac{1}{24N_f}\operatorname{Tr}\left\{\left(C\gamma_{5}\tau_{2}i\epsilon_a\right)\left[\mathrm{Flow}_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(3)}\right]_a\right\}. \tag*{(93)} ∂ t g Δ q q = ( 2 1 η Δ + η q ) g Δ q q + 2 A ˉ ˙ Δ m ˉ Δ 2 + 24 N f 1 Tr { ( C γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a ) [ Flow Δ q ˉ q ˉ ( 3 ) ] a } . (93)
This choice is motivated by the absence of a diquark condensate in the derivation of the flows, which prevent us to use the quark-quark or antiquark-antiquark two point function to project on the quark-diquark Yukawa coupling. The diagrammatic contributions to the flow of the quark-diquark Yukawa coupling are shown in Figure 6 .
Figure 6. Diagrammatic representation of the flow of the quark-diquark coupling.
Effective potential
The effective potential corresponds to the vanishing momentum part of the effective action, hence its flow is directly given by evaluating the flow contribution Eq. (16) on a constant field configuration Φ c \Phi_c Φ c . In order to facilitate the extraction of the flows of all zero-momentum meson-meson, meson-diquark and diquark-diquark interactions, we express the effective potential as a general function of both, a non-vanishing sigma field σ ( x ) = 2 ρ ϕ \sigma(x)=\sqrt{2\rho_{\phi}} σ ( x ) = 2 ρ ϕ and a non-vanishing diquark condensate
Δ a ( x ) = δ a 3 ρ Δ , (94) \Delta_a(x)=\delta_{a3}\sqrt{\rho_{\Delta}}, \tag*{(94)} Δ a ( x ) = δ a 3 ρ Δ , (94)
with ρ Δ ∈ R \rho_{\Delta}\in\mathbb{R} ρ Δ ∈ R . For non-vanishing ρ Δ \rho_{\Delta} ρ Δ , this field configuration corresponds to the so-called 2SC phase. In this phase, the diquark condensate “breaks”3 the color symmetry S U ( 3 ) c SU(3)_c S U ( 3 ) c to an S U ( 2 ) c SU(2)_c S U ( 2 ) c subgroup involving only red (a = 1 a=1 a = 1 ) and green (a = 2 a=2 a = 2 ) quarks. This leads to important consequences, first the emergence of a superconducting gap
Δ g a p = g Δ ρ Δ , (95) \Delta_{\mathrm{gap}}=g_{\Delta}\sqrt{\rho_{\Delta}}, \tag*{(95)} Δ gap = g Δ ρ Δ , (95)
in the dispersion relation of the red and green quarks, while the blue (a = 3 a=3 a = 3 ) quark dispersion is unchanged. Because we only consider vanishing chemical potential in this work, the superconducting gap only acts as a shift in the quark mass.
Furthermore, the gluon acquires a gluon mass through the Higgs mechanism,
( m H i g g s 2 ) a b = λ A 2 Δ † Δ ρ Δ ( { T a , T b } ) 33 , (96) \left(m_{\mathrm{Higgs}}^{2}\right)^{ab}=\lambda_{A^{2}\Delta^{\dagger}\Delta}\rho_{\Delta}\left(\left\{T^{a},T^{b}\right\}\right)_{33}, \tag*{(96)} ( m Higgs 2 ) ab = λ A 2 Δ † Δ ρ Δ ( { T a , T b } ) 33 , (96)
see App. B 1 for the explicit expressions of the quark and gluon propagators.
Lastly we note that, a non-vanishing chiral and diquark condensate leads to a sigma-diquark mixing in the two point function. This mixing can be resolved by diagonalizing the two-point function, yielding modified dispersion relation for the sigma meson and the blue (a = 3 a=3 a = 3 ) diquark. For more details in effective models, see, e.g., Refs. [45 , 109 , 111 ] , and for a discussion in a FRG-QCD setup, see Ref. [42 ] .
For arbitrary chiral and diquark condensates, the flow of the dimensionless effective potential is given by
∂ t U ˉ k ( ρ ˉ ϕ , ρ ˉ Δ ) = − 4 U ˉ k + ( 2 + η ϕ ) ρ ˉ ϕ ∂ ρ ˉ ϕ U ˉ k \partial_t\bar{U}_k(\bar{\rho}_{\phi},\bar{\rho}_{\Delta})=-4\bar{U}_k+(2+\eta_{\phi})\bar{\rho}_{\phi}\partial_{\bar{\rho}_{\phi}}\bar{U}_k ∂ t U ˉ k ( ρ ˉ ϕ , ρ ˉ Δ ) = − 4 U ˉ k + ( 2 + η ϕ ) ρ ˉ ϕ ∂ ρ ˉ ϕ U ˉ k
+ ( 2 + η Δ ) ρ ˉ Δ ∂ ρ ˉ Δ U ˉ k + 1 V 4 F l o w ‾ ( 0 ) ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) , (97) {}+(2+\eta_{\Delta})\bar{\rho}_{\Delta}\partial_{\bar{\rho}_{\Delta}}\bar{U}_k+\frac{1}{\mathcal{V}_4}\overline{\mathrm{Flow}}^{(0)}(\rho_{\phi},\rho_{\Delta}), \tag*{(97)} + ( 2 + η Δ ) ρ ˉ Δ ∂ ρ ˉ Δ U ˉ k + V 4 1 Flow ( 0 ) ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) , (97)
where V 4 \mathcal{V}_4 V 4 is the 4-dimensional Euclidean spacetime volume. A diagrammatic representation of the flow contribution is given in Figure 1 . For consistency with all other flow equations, we Taylor expand the effective potential around a vanishing diquark condensate ρ Δ = 0 \rho_{\Delta}=0 ρ Δ = 0 and a flowing chiral condensate ρ ϕ = ρ ϕ , 0 \rho_{\phi}=\rho_{\phi,0} ρ ϕ = ρ ϕ , 0 ,
U k ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) = ∑ n = 0 , m = 0 m + n ≤ N exp λ n , m n ! m ! ( ρ ϕ − ρ ϕ , 0 ) n ρ Δ m . (98) U_k(\rho_\phi,\rho_\Delta)=\sum_{\substack{n=0,m=0\\m+n\leq N_{\exp}}}\frac{\lambda_{n,m}}{n!m!}(\rho_\phi-\rho_{\phi,0})^n\rho_\Delta^m . \tag*{(98)} U k ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) = n = 0 , m = 0 m + n ≤ N e x p ∑ n ! m ! λ n , m ( ρ ϕ − ρ ϕ , 0 ) n ρ Δ m . (98)
We choose N exp = 5 N_{\exp}=5 N e x p = 5 , as the expansion is under control at this order. The running expansion coefficients λ n , m \lambda_{n,m} λ n , m encode multi-meson and diquark interactions at zero momentum. In particular, the sigma and pion curvature masses are readily extracted from the coefficients,
m π 2 = λ 1 , 0 , (99) m_\pi^2=\lambda_{1,0}, \tag*{(99)} m π 2 = λ 1 , 0 , (99)
m σ 2 = λ 1 , 0 + 2 ρ ϕ , 0 λ 2 , 0 , (100) m_\sigma^2=\lambda_{1,0}+2\rho_{\phi,0}\lambda_{2,0}, \tag*{(100)} m σ 2 = λ 1 , 0 + 2 ρ ϕ , 0 λ 2 , 0 , (100)
while the diquark curvature mass is given by
m Δ 2 = λ 0 , 1 . (101) m_\Delta^2=\lambda_{0,1}. \tag*{(101)} m Δ 2 = λ 0 , 1 . (101)
The flow of the different couplings λ n , m \lambda_{n,m} λ n , m is found by taking appropriate derivative of Eq. (97) ,
∂ t λ ˉ n , m = ( ( − 4 + 2 n + 2 m ) + n η ϕ + m η Δ ) λ ˉ n , m + ( ( 2 + η ϕ ) ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 + ∂ t ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 ) λ ˉ n + 1 , m + 1 ν 4 ( ∂ ρ ˉ ϕ n ∂ ρ ˉ Δ m Flow ‾ ( 0 ) ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) ) ∣ ρ ϕ = ρ ϕ , 0 ρ Δ = 0 . (102) \begin{aligned}
\partial_t\bar{\lambda}_{n,m}={}&\left((-4+2n+2m)+n\eta_\phi+m\eta_\Delta\right)\bar{\lambda}_{n,m}\\
&+\left((2+\eta_\phi)\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}+\partial_t\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}\right)\bar{\lambda}_{n+1,m}\\
&+\frac{1}{\nu_4}\left(\partial_{\bar{\rho}_\phi}^{n}\partial_{\bar{\rho}_\Delta}^{m}\overline{\operatorname{Flow}}^{(0)}(\rho_\phi,\rho_\Delta)\right)\bigg|_{\rho_\phi=\rho_{\phi,0}}^{\rho_\Delta=0}. \tag*{(102)}
\end{aligned} ∂ t λ ˉ n , m = ( ( − 4 + 2 n + 2 m ) + n η ϕ + m η Δ ) λ ˉ n , m + ( ( 2 + η ϕ ) ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 + ∂ t ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 ) λ ˉ n + 1 , m + ν 4 1 ( ∂ ρ ˉ ϕ n ∂ ρ ˉ Δ m Flow ( 0 ) ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) ) ρ ϕ = ρ ϕ , 0 ρ Δ = 0 . (102)
It only remains to discuss the flow of ρ ϕ , 0 \rho_{\phi,0} ρ ϕ , 0 , which is derived by imposing that the solution of the equation of motion resulting from the effective potential Ω k = U k − h σ \Omega_k=U_k-h\sigma Ω k = U k − hσ is located at ρ ϕ = ρ ϕ , 0 \rho_\phi=\rho_{\phi,0} ρ ϕ = ρ ϕ , 0 for every RG-scale k k k [31 ] . This can be expressed as the following condition
[ ∂ ρ ϕ ( U k − h σ ) ] ∣ ρ ϕ = ρ ϕ , 0 ρ Δ = 0 = 0 , (103) \left[\partial_{\rho_\phi}(U_k-h\sigma)\right]\bigg|_{\rho_\phi=\rho_{\phi,0}}^{\rho_\Delta=0}=0, \tag*{(103)} [ ∂ ρ ϕ ( U k − hσ ) ] ρ ϕ = ρ ϕ , 0 ρ Δ = 0 = 0 , (103)
from which we conclude that the running minimum is implicitly given by
ρ ϕ , 0 = 1 2 h 2 U k ′ ( ρ ϕ , 0 ) 2 . (104) \rho_{\phi,0}=\frac{1}{2}\frac{h^2}{U_k'(\rho_{\phi,0})^2}. \tag*{(104)} ρ ϕ , 0 = 2 1 U k ′ ( ρ ϕ , 0 ) 2 h 2 . (104)
Taking a t t t -derivative, we obtain the flow of the running minimum
∂ t ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 = − h ˉ 2 λ ˉ 1 , 0 3 + λ ˉ 2 , 0 h ˉ 2 { ( 1 + 1 2 η ϕ ) λ ˉ 1 , 0 + ( 2 + η ϕ ) ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 2 , 0 + 1 ν 4 ( ∂ ρ ˉ ϕ Flow ‾ ( 0 ) ) ∣ ρ ϕ = ρ ϕ , 0 ρ Δ = 0 } . (105) \partial_t\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}=-\frac{\bar{h}^2}{\bar{\lambda}_{1,0}^{\,3}+\bar{\lambda}_{2,0}\bar{h}^2}\left\{\left(1+\frac{1}{2}\eta_\phi\right)\bar{\lambda}_{1,0}+(2+\eta_\phi)\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}\bar{\lambda}_{2,0}+\frac{1}{\nu_4}\left(\partial_{\bar{\rho}_\phi}\overline{\operatorname{Flow}}^{(0)}\right)\bigg|_{\rho_\phi=\rho_{\phi,0}}^{\rho_\Delta=0}\right\}. \tag*{(105)} ∂ t ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 = − λ ˉ 1 , 0 3 + λ ˉ 2 , 0 h ˉ 2 h ˉ 2 { ( 1 + 2 1 η ϕ ) λ ˉ 1 , 0 + ( 2 + η ϕ ) ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 2 , 0 + ν 4 1 ( ∂ ρ ˉ ϕ Flow ( 0 ) ) ρ ϕ = ρ ϕ , 0 ρ Δ = 0 } . (105)
We note that even though the explicit symmetry breaking term h h h is scale independent, in an RG-invariant, dimensionless formulation it receives a contribution from the anomalous dimension and its mass dimension, leading to the flow
∂ t h ˉ = ( − 3 + 1 2 η ϕ ) h ˉ . (106) \partial_t\bar{h}=\left(-3+\frac{1}{2}\eta_\phi\right)\bar{h}. \tag*{(106)} ∂ t h ˉ = ( − 3 + 2 1 η ϕ ) h ˉ . (106)
We now briefly summarize this section. We have presented the projection procedure that defines the set of coupled flow equations we will solve to determine the relevant correlation functions for this work. Within the truncation employed here, all flow equations are evaluated at vanishing external momentum. We note, though, that owing to the combined UV and IR regularization of the flow equation, momenta around the RG scale, p 2 ≈ k 2 p^2\approx k^2 p 2 ≈ k 2 , contribute to the flow of the correlation functions. Hence, information on the momentum dependence of the correlation functions is, to some extend and in a regulator-dependent way, still encoded and taken into account through their k k k -dependence; see, e.g., Figure 9 . Furthermore, through the dynamical hadronization procedure, we get direct access to the correlations of composite operators. These include high-order correlations through the couplings λ n , m \lambda_{n,m} λ n , m , which are related to ( 2 n + 2 m ) (2n+2m) ( 2 n + 2 m ) -quark correlations in the hadronized channels. As we will show in the next section, the present truncation provides an accurate description of vacuum QCD, allowing for simplified numerical computation while still providing reliable predictions.
Figure 9. Comparison between the transverse gluon dressing function Z ˉ A − 1 \bar{Z}_{A}^{-1} Z ˉ A − 1 Eq. (117) from this work (lines) and N f = 2 N_f = 2 N f = 2 lattice results [126 ] (dots). To facilitate a qualitative comparison, we approximate the momentum dependence with the k k k -dependence of our results. As the gluon propagator is an RG-variant quantity, each FRG result is rescaled to account for the different normalization of the gluon field in the lattice and FRG computations.
Low-Energy Constants from QCD Flows
In this section, we present our numerical results and describe the details of the parameter-fixing procedure. Unless stated otherwise, all results are shown as bands obtained from three different regulator shape functions: the flat shape function r f l a t r_{\mathrm{flat}} r flat , Eq. (148) , and the exponential regulator r e x p r_{\mathrm{exp}} r exp , Eq. (149) , with m = 1 m=1 m = 1 and m = 2 m=2 m = 2 . The corresponding central results are indicated by the faint dashed, dotted, and solid lines, respectively.
These regulators span a broad range of momentum-shell widths (see Figure 22 ), ranging from relatively sharp to strongly smeared momentum shells integrated out along the RG flow. Consequently, the width of the band provides a measure of the residual regulator dependence of our results. Since this dependence vanishes for exact solutions by construction, the bands serve as an estimate of the systematic uncertainty associated with the present truncation.
Figure 22. ∂ t R k / k 2 \partial_tR_k/k^2 ∂ t R k / k 2 for the bosonic regulator R k = p 2 r R_k=p^2r R k = p 2 r as a function of x = p 2 / k 2 x=p^2/k^2 x = p 2 / k 2 for the two regulator shape functions r = r f l a t r=r_{\mathrm{flat}} r = r flat and r = r e x p r=r_{\mathrm{exp}} r = r exp used in this work. This figure illustrates how the different regulators probe different momentum regions in the flow, essentially determining how sharp the momentum shells in the RG flow are. The line style associated with each regulator (solid, dotted, or dashed) is used consistently throughout most figures in this work.
Parameter fixing
Within our self-consistent QCD truncation, the only parameters that require fixing at the UV scale k = Λ k=\Lambda k = Λ are the strong coupling and the current quark mass. As we demonstrate below, all other initial conditions for the running couplings and masses in our setup including the gluon mass gap parameter, the Yukawa couplings, and the parameters of the composite sector, are associated with emergent low-energy degrees of freedom. Consequently, they are either determined self-consistently by the QCD dynamics or correspond to irrelevant directions whose precise UV values leave no imprint on physical observables.
Asymptotic freedom allows us to choose a UV scale sufficiently deep in the perturbative regime – unless stated otherwise, we employ Λ = 20 \Lambda= 20 Λ = 20 GeV – where the strong coupling is small and a perturbation theory is applicable. In this regime, STIs ensure that the flows of all strong-coupling avatars coincide [73 , 118 ] . Accordingly, at k = Λ k = \Lambda k = Λ we identify them with a common coupling α s , U V \alpha_{\mathrm{s,UV}} α s , UV such that
α A 3 , Λ = α A 4 , Λ = α A c ˉ c , Λ = α A q ˉ q , Λ = α A Δ † Δ , Λ = α A 2 Δ † Δ , Λ = α s , U V . (107) \alpha_{A^3,\Lambda} = \alpha_{A^4,\Lambda} = \alpha_{A\bar{c}c,\Lambda} = \alpha_{A\bar{q}q,\Lambda}
= \alpha_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta,\Lambda} = \alpha_{A2\Delta^\dagger\Delta,\Lambda} = \alpha_{\mathrm{s,UV}} . \tag*{(107)} α A 3 , Λ = α A 4 , Λ = α A c ˉ c , Λ = α A q ˉ q , Λ = α A Δ † Δ , Λ = α A 2 Δ † Δ , Λ = α s , UV . (107)
The value of α s , U V \alpha_{\mathrm{s,UV}} α s , UV is fixed by requiring that the IR constituent quark mass satisfies m q = 350 m_q = 350 m q = 350 MeV in accordance with [92 , 108 , 119 , 120 ] .
This choice leads to good agreement between our computation and lattice results for the gluon dressing function Z ˉ A − 1 \bar{Z}_A^{-1} Z ˉ A − 1 , see Figure 9 and the associated discussion. We emphasize that the value of the strong coupling cannot be determined directly from more conventional renormalization schemes, such as MS, since the perturbative running in our FRG scheme differs beyond one-loop order [17 ] .
As explained in Sec. II A, explicit chiral symmetry breaking is encoded in the source term h h h . It is fixed through the pion mass, m π = 137 m_\pi= 137 m π = 137 MeV. Note that pole and curvature masses of the pion are almost identical in the present setup; we return to this point in § 3 .
As discussed in Sec. III A, the initial value of the gluon mass-gap parameter, m g a p , U V 2 m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}^2 m gap , UV 2 , is tuned such that the flow approaches the confining scaling solution. In practice, this amounts to adjusting m g a p , U V 2 m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}^2 m gap , UV 2 such that it lies closest to the onset of the Landau-pole regime. This requires fine-tuning, and the resulting solution exhibits scaling behavior only down to the IR scale k I R = 10 k_{\mathrm{IR}} = 10 k IR = 10 MeV where we terminate the RG flow. In § 2 D, we explicitly demonstrate that the choice between scaling and decoupling solutions affects only the deep-IR behavior of the gapped glue sector and hence leaves physical low-energy
observables unchanged.
It only remains to specify the UV value of the couplings in the composite sector. The UV value of those couplings can be chosen mostly arbitrarily as an IR attractive fixed point ensures independence of the IR results on the initial conditions of the composite sector, see Sec. IV C 2. One must only ensure that the initial conditions are on the critical surface of this fixed point. Otherwise, the system would describe a gauged NJL model instead of QCD. Fortunately, all initial conditions are on this critical surface as long as the four-quark interactions are sufficiently small in the UV. With dynamical hadronization, this entails that the ratios of the corresponding Yukawa couplings and boson masses must be small, see Eq. (91) . This is clear intuitively, as mesons and diquarks should be decoupled, auxiliary degrees of freedom in the perturbative regime. In practice we make the choice
g ϕ q ˉ q , U V = g Δ q ˉ q ˉ , U V = 1 , (108) g_{\phi\bar{q}q,\mathrm{UV}} = g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q},\mathrm{UV}} = 1 , \tag*{(108)} g ϕ q ˉ q , UV = g Δ q ˉ q ˉ , UV = 1 , (108)
and
m ϕ , U V 2 = m Δ , U V 2 = Λ 2 × 10 4 G e V 2 , (109) m_{\phi,\mathrm{UV}}^2 = m_{\Delta,\mathrm{UV}}^2 = \Lambda^2 \times10^4\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 , \tag*{(109)} m ϕ , UV 2 = m Δ , UV 2 = Λ 2 × 1 0 4 GeV 2 , (109)
but note that any mass much larger than the initial scale Λ \Lambda Λ suffices to ensure that these fields are auxiliary. The initial values for all other couplings in the composite sector can be chosen arbitrarily. For definiteness, we set them to zero. In § 2 D we demonstrate explicitly the independence of our results on the UV behavior of the composite sector.
In Table I , we show the UV parameters used for the different regulators we consider. For different regulators the initial values of the strong coupling, explicit chiral symmetry breaking strength and the IR-enhancement exhibit only small differences. Compared to other studies, e.g., Refs. [31 , 68 , 121 ] , we need a slightly smaller strong coupling at the UV scale Λ = 20 \Lambda= 20 Λ = 20 GeV to obtain a constituent quark mass m q = 350 m_q = 350 m q = 350 MeV. This originates from the missing tensor structure T A q ˉ q ( 7 ) \mathcal{T}_{A\bar{q}q}^{(7)} T A q ˉ q ( 7 ) in the quark-gluon vertex, which slightly overestimates the quark-gluon interaction strength. However, the initial condition for the mass gap parameter strongly depends on the regulator. This is expected, as m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap encodes the modifications of the STIs due to the presence of the regulator, see Sec. III A.
Table I. UV parameters for the three regulator shape functions considered in this work. The quoted precision of m g a p , U V m_{\mathrm{gap,UV}} m gap , UV reflects the fine-tuning required to obtain the scaling solution. Consequently, the least significant digits may depend on numerical details.
Table II shows a selection of results for IR observables in comparison to the FRG-QCD studies in Ref. [31 , 121 ] . In this work, the parameters in Table I are fixed using the pion mass m π = 137 m_\pi= 137 m π = 137 MeV and the constituent quark mass m q = 350 m_q = 350 m q = 350 MeV, while the uncertainties in the sigma mass, light quark chiral condensate, and diquark mass originate from different regulator choices. The differences in the σ \sigma σ mass can be related to different projections for the meson wave function renormalization [31 ] . For the vacuum expectation value of the light scalar meson, our result for the flat regulator, σ 0 , l ∼ 71 \sigma_{0,l} \sim71 σ 0 , l ∼ 71 MeV, is similar to the other two works, σ 0 , l ∼ 70 \sigma_{0,l} \sim70 σ 0 , l ∼ 70 MeV. The reasonable agreement despite considerable differences in the truncations of these different works, especially regarding the gauge sector and momentum dependencies, underscores the predictive power of the FRG approach to QCD.
Table II. IR values of various quantities obtained in this work and compared with previous FRG studies. The quoted uncertainties correspond to the variation under changes of the regulator. No uncertainty is shown for the pion and quark masses, since these quantities are used as input in the parameter-fixing procedure.
Gauge sector
We now move to a selection of numerical results in the gauge sector of QCD. In most figures we show the chiral symmetry breaking scale k χ S B k_{\chi\mathrm{SB}} k χ SB , defined as the RG-scale where the mass of the pion and sigma are no longer degenerate, and the “confinement” scale k g a p k_{\mathrm{gap}} k gap , defined as the RG-scale where the gluon dressing function Z ˉ A − 1 \bar{Z}_A^{-1} Z ˉ A − 1 peaks, see Figure 9 . At this scale gluonic fluctuations decouple from the flow, m g a p ≳ k m_{\mathrm{gap}} \gtrsim k m gap ≳ k for k ≲ k g a p k \lesssim k_{\mathrm{gap}} k ≲ k gap .
We start with a discussion of the flow of the six strong coupling avatars. To make a meaningful comparison between each coupling, we express all couplings in a form similar to the strong coupling constant defined as α s = g s 2 / 4 π \alpha_s = g_s^2/4\pi α s = g s 2 /4 π , where g s g_s g s is the strong coupling that appears in the covariant derivative, see Eq. (6) . Furthermore, to ensure RG invariance, each strong coupling avatar must be dressed by an appropriate power of the inverse gluon dressing function corresponding to the number of external gluon legs of the coupling. This leads to the following definitions
α A 3 = λ A 3 2 4 π 1 ( 1 + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 (110) \alpha_{A^3} = \frac{\lambda_{A^3}^2}{4\pi}\frac{1}{(1+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3} \tag*{(110)} α A 3 = 4 π λ A 3 2 ( 1 + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 1 (110)
α A 4 = λ A 4 4 π 1 ( 1 + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 (111) \alpha_{A^4} = \frac{\lambda_{A^4}}{4\pi}\frac{1}{(1+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2} \tag*{(111)} α A 4 = 4 π λ A 4 ( 1 + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 1 (111)
α A c ˉ c = λ A c ˉ c 2 4 π 1 ( 1 + m ˉ g a p 2 ) (112) \alpha_{A\bar{c}c} = \frac{\lambda_{A\bar{c}c}^2}{4\pi}\frac{1}{(1+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)} \tag*{(112)} α A c ˉ c = 4 π λ A c ˉ c 2 ( 1 + m ˉ gap 2 ) 1 (112)
α A q ˉ q = λ A q ˉ q 2 4 π 1 ( 1 + m ˉ g a p 2 ) (113) \alpha_{A\bar{q}q} = \frac{\lambda_{A\bar{q}q}^2}{4\pi}\frac{1}{(1+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)} \tag*{(113)} α A q ˉ q = 4 π λ A q ˉ q 2 ( 1 + m ˉ gap 2 ) 1 (113)
while for the gluon-diquark avatars we have
α A Δ † Δ = λ A Δ † Δ 2 4 π 1 ( 1 + m ˉ g a p 2 ) (114) \alpha_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta} = \frac{\lambda_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta}^2}{4\pi}\frac{1}{(1+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)} \tag*{(114)} α A Δ † Δ = 4 π λ A Δ † Δ 2 ( 1 + m ˉ gap 2 ) 1 (114)
α A 2 Δ † Δ = λ A 2 Δ † Δ 2 4 π 1 ( 1 + m ˉ g a p 2 ) (115) \alpha_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta} = \frac{\lambda_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta}^2}{4\pi}\frac{1}{(1+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)} \tag*{(115)} α A 2 Δ † Δ = 4 π λ A 2 Δ † Δ 2 ( 1 + m ˉ gap 2 ) 1 (115)
In Figure 7 we show the flows of these couplings. As explained in § 2 A, all strong coupling avatars coincide in the UV as enforced by perturbative STIs. Accordingly, at high RG scale, all avatars follow the perturbative running of the strong coupling
∂ t α s = − α s 2 6 π ( 11 N c − 2 N f ) + O ( α s 3 ) (116) \partial_t \alpha_s = -\frac{\alpha_s^2}{6\pi}(11N_c-2N_f)+\mathcal{O}(\alpha_s^3) \tag*{(116)} ∂ t α s = − 6 π α s 2 ( 11 N c − 2 N f ) + O ( α s 3 ) (116)
as shown by the dashed black line. We see that the perturbative running is recovered in the UV for all regulators, highlighting the RG-scheme independence of the one-loop perturbative running [122 ] . We note that even though our truncation includes an additional colored bosonic field, the scalar diquark, it does not enter as an additional contribution to the perturbative running of the strong coupling. This is a direct consequence of the dynamical hadronization procedure, ensuring that the composite fields are fully decoupled from the UV dynamic.
At intermediate RG scale k ≲ 2 G e V k \lesssim2\ \mathrm{GeV} k ≲ 2 GeV , the flows of the different strong coupling avatars start to differ as non-perturbative effects are no longer negligible. At k ∼ k g a p ∼ 1 G e V k \sim k_{\mathrm{gap}} \sim1\ \mathrm{GeV} k ∼ k gap ∼ 1 GeV , the flows of all avatars (except the ghost-gluon vertex α A c ˉ c \alpha_{A\bar{c}c} α A c ˉ c ) peak, signaling the suppression of gluonic fluctuations due to the mass gap. As reflected in the width of the bands in Figure 7 , this coincides with the scale where different regulators have the largest impact on the flow. At lower k k k , the couplings decrease and reach an (almost) vanishing value, again with the exception of the ghost-gluon vertex α A c ˉ c \alpha_{A\bar{c}c} α A c ˉ c . In particular, as visible in the log-scale plot in Figure 7 (right), the ghost-gluon and three-gluon couplings, α A c ˉ c \alpha_{A\bar{c}c} α A c ˉ c and α A 3 \alpha_{A^3} α A 3 , become constant in the IR. This is a direct consequence of scaling [91 , 123 ] . We would expect that at least the four-gluon vertex, but presumably also the other vertices shown in Figure 7 become constant in the IR due to scaling. However, closed loops of the soft ghost modes do not contribute to the flows of these couplings within our approximations, see Figure 3 and App. D 2. As a result, the quark-gluon vertex, α A q ˉ q \alpha_{A\bar{q}q} α A q ˉ q , and the diquark-gluon vertices, α A Δ † Δ \alpha_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta} α A Δ † Δ and α A 2 Δ † Δ \alpha_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta} α A 2 Δ † Δ , vanish with a slope proportional to ( k 2 ) κ (k^2)^\kappa ( k 2 ) κ , while the four-gluon α A 4 \alpha_{A^4} α A 4 vertex vanishes with a slope proportional to ( k 2 ) 4 κ (k^2)^{4\kappa} ( k 2 ) 4 κ , where κ = 0.64 \kappa= 0.64 κ = 0.64 is the scaling exponent introduced in Eqs. (32) and (33) . These slopes stem from the gluon contributions in our definitions of the couplings in Eqs. (110) to (115) . Similar observations have been made in Refs. [67 , 68 ] . Note that for the decoupling solution, all of these vertices vanish in the deep IR [67 , 68 ] .
The ghost-gluon vertex displays a strong sensibility on the choice of regulator, especially in the IR. This has no effects on observables as the ghost only couples to the gluons, which decouple in the IR due to the mass gap. This sensibility is expected to some extent, as the ghosts encode the explicit gauge symmetry breaking from gauge fixing by construction, and the regulator acts as an additional source for this breaking. This is what gives rise to the modification of the STIs in the first place [100 ] . The close connection between regularization and gauge fixing can be the basis for a gauge-invariant formulation of the FRG see, i.e., Ref. [124 ] .
Furthermore, we checked explicitly that the two diquark-gluon vertices, α A Δ † Δ \alpha_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta} α A Δ † Δ and α A 2 Δ † Δ \alpha_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta} α A 2 Δ † Δ , only lead to minor modifications of around 1% of the inferred properties of the system. This result is expected as the gluon and diquark fields are relevant degrees of freedom in different regimes: the gluon is important in the UV and decouples in the IR, while the diquark is a low-energy degree of freedom, and hence only relevant at low RG-scale; see Figure 12 and the associate discussion. However, the inclusion of the diquark-gluon interactions becomes of high interest at finite densities, where a diquark condensate is expected to form. In such a regime, these interactions play an important role, especially regarding the generation of a gluon mass by means of the Higgs-mechanism. As such, this work is a first step towards a non-perturbative treatment of the formation of a Higgs mass in dense QCD matter.
Figure 12. Curvature masses of the different fields considered in this work as functions of the RG-scale k k k . The gluon mass is given by m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap . In the gray region, the masses of the fields are greater than k k k , and thus decouple from the dynamics.
In Figure 8 we show the two dressings of the quark-gluon vertex λ A q ˉ q ( 1 , 4 ) \lambda_{A\bar{q}q}^{(1,4)} λ A q ˉ q ( 1 , 4 ) against the RG-scale k k k . Since λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) \lambda_{A\bar{q}q}^{(1)} λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) is associated to the classical tensor-structure, it is nonzero in the UV, while the non-classical dressing λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) \lambda_{A\bar{q}q}^{(4)} λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) vanishes. λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) \lambda_{A\bar{q}q}^{(4)} λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) breaks chiral symmetry explicitly, see Eq. (43) , and hence only becomes nonzero close to the chiral symmetry breaking scale k χ S B k_{\chi\mathrm{SB}} k χ SB . Consistent with previous results [72 , 92 , 107 , 108 ] , we find that λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) \lambda_{A\bar{q}q}^{(4)} λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) is smaller than λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) \lambda_{A\bar{q}q}^{(1)} λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) by roughly an order of magnitude. However, its inclusion leads to an increase of the constituent quark mass of more than 50%, highlighting the sensitivity of the chiral symmetry breaking strength to the strength of quark-gluon interactions [125 ] .
Figure 8. Dimensionless classical and non-classical dressings of the quark-gluon vertex, λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) \lambda_{A\bar{q}q}^{(1)} λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) and λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) \lambda_{A\bar{q}q}^{(4)} λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) , as functions of the RG-scale k k k . Since λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) \lambda_{A\bar{q}q}^{(4)} λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) breaks chiral symmetry, it only becomes nonzero close to the chiral symmetry breaking scale k χ S B k_{\chi\mathrm{SB}} k χ SB .
In Figure 9 , we show the transverse gluon dressing function Z ˉ A − 1 \bar{Z}_A^{-1} Z ˉ A − 1 defined in Eq. (30) as a function of momentum p p p . The momentum dependence is approximated by the RG-scale dependence of the gluon propagator evaluated at vanishing momenta [31 , 73 ] , yielding
Z ˉ A ( p ) = Z A , k = p [ 1 + r A , k = p + m ˉ g a p , k = p 2 ] , (117) \bar{Z}_A(p) = Z_{A,k=p}\left[1+r_{A,k=p}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap},k=p}^{2}\right], \tag*{(117)} Z ˉ A ( p ) = Z A , k = p [ 1 + r A , k = p + m ˉ gap , k = p 2 ] , (117)
where Z A Z_A Z A is the gluon wave function renormalization and r A r_A r A the gluon regulator shape function; see App. A for details. As explained in § 2 A, the peak of Z ˉ A − 1 \bar{Z}_A^{-1} Z ˉ A − 1 agrees for all regulator choices as a consequence of the parameter fixing procedure. Furthermore, we use the peak location to define the “confinement” scale k g a p k_{\mathrm{gap}} k gap .
Similar to Ref. [68 ] , we find a good agreement for momenta above the gluon peak, but some discrepancies around and below. This is a result of our zero-momentum approximation and neglected tensor structures, especially T A q ˉ q ( 7 ) T_{A\bar{q}q}^{(7)} T A q ˉ q ( 7 ) [92 ] . Owing to the decoupling of the gluons around the scale k g a p k_{\mathrm{gap}} k gap , these discrepancies are expected to have a small quantitative effect. The deviations at large momentum are due to finite size effects on the lattice; our results correctly capture the expected logarithmic running in the UV. Importantly, the identification p = k p = k p = k is only an approximation which is sensitive to the regulator choice and not guaranteed to be quantitatively reliable, see for example Ref. [121 ] .
In Figure 10 we show the ghost and gluon inverse dressing functions Z ˉ c \bar{Z}_{c} Z ˉ c and Z ˉ A \bar{Z}_{A} Z ˉ A as functions of momentum. Again, we identify p = k p = k p = k , which yields for the ghost inverse dressing function
Figure 10. Inverse gluon Eq. (117) and ghost Eq. (118) scaling functions against momentum p p p . The momentum dependence is again approximated by the RG-scale dependence of the ghost and gluon propagators evaluated at vanishing momentum. The colored dashed lines indicate the behavior of the scaling solution, Z ˉ A ∝ ( p 2 ) − 2 κ \bar{Z}_{A} \propto(p^{2})^{-2\kappa} Z ˉ A ∝ ( p 2 ) − 2 κ and Z ˉ c ∝ ( p 2 ) κ \bar{Z}_{c} \propto(p^{2})^{\kappa} Z ˉ c ∝ ( p 2 ) κ , with a scaling exponent κ = 0.64 \kappa= 0.64 κ = 0.64 .
Z ˉ c ( p ) = Z c , k = p [ 1 + r c , k = p ] . (118) \bar{Z}_{c}(p) = Z_{c,k=p}\left[1+r_{c,k=p}\right]. \tag*{(118)} Z ˉ c ( p ) = Z c , k = p [ 1 + r c , k = p ] . (118)
Furthermore, we show the expected scaling Eqs. (32) and (33) for the ghost and gluon inverse dressing function for κ = 0.64 \kappa= 0.64 κ = 0.64 . As discussed in § 2 A, we find a solution of scaling type for both the gluon and ghost propagator in the IR. Furthermore, this IR behavior can be used to extract the scaling exponent, the precise value of which we discuss in the next paragraph.
To conclude this section, we show in Figure 11 the flow of the ghost and gluon anomalous dimensions and wave function renormalizations. The latter are obtained from
Figure 11. Wave function renormalizations, Z A Z_A Z A and Z c Z_c Z c , and anomalous dimensions, η A \eta_A η A and η c \eta_c η c , of the gluon and ghost fields as function of the RG-scale k k k .
Eq. (27) with the choice Z A , Λ = Z c , Λ = 1 Z_{A,\Lambda}=Z_{c,\Lambda}=1 Z A , Λ = Z c , Λ = 1 , but note that the choice of initial values is irrelevant in our RG-invariant setup. As we tune the UV mass gap to the scaling solution, we find that the ghost anomalous dimension η c \eta_c η c saturates to a negative value in the IR, which in turn leads to the vanishing of the IR ghost wave function renormalization Z c Z_c Z c . The scaling exponent κ \kappa κ can be readily obtained from the IR value of the ghost anomalous dimension: using the scaling ansatz Eq. (32) with the identification p = k p = k p = k , we find
lim k → 0 η c = − lim k → 0 ∂ t log [ ( k 2 ) κ ] = − 2 κ , (119) \lim_{k\to0}\eta_c = -\lim_{k\to0}\partial_t\log\left[(k^2)^\kappa\right] = -2\kappa\,, \tag*{(119)} k → 0 lim η c = − k → 0 lim ∂ t log [ ( k 2 ) κ ] = − 2 κ , (119)
yielding
κ = 0.63 – 0.66 (120) \kappa= 0.63\text{--}0.66 \tag*{(120)} κ = 0.63 – 0.66 (120)
consistent with we the expected value 1 / 2 < κ < 1 1/2 < \kappa< 1 1/2 < κ < 1 [65 , 84 , 85 ] . We find only a slight dependence on the choice of regulator for the value of the scaling exponent κ \kappa κ . Finally, we note that the gluon anomalous dimension saturates to zero in the IR as a consequence of the freezing procedure detailed in Eq. (68) .
Emergent composites
We now discuss the properties of the emergent composite in our approach, i.e. the σ \sigma σ -meson, the pions, and the scalar diquarks. In Figure 12 we show the curvature masses of the different fields that are considered in this work as functions of the RG-scale. The gray region indicates where the mass m m m of a given field is higher than the RG-scale k k k . When this occurs, the associated field effectively decouples from the dynamics of the flow equation. This can be inferred from the shape of the propagator at zero momentum, G k = 1 / ( k 2 + m 2 ) G_k = 1/(k^2 + m^2) G k = 1/ ( k 2 + m 2 ) , showing that for m > k m > k m > k the propagator becomes effectively constant and hence irrelevant for the flow.
As expected in QCD, gluons and quarks dominate in the deep UV. As explained in § 2 A, the composite fields must be initialized with a mass well above the initial scale to ensure their decoupling in the UV. Flowing down to scales of a few GeV, the gluon mass gap parameter m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap starts to decrease, signaling the increasing of the strong coupling α s \alpha_s α s , while the quark mass m q m_q m q starts rising but remains negligibly small. The mass of the composite fields drops sharply as a consequence of the dynamical
hadronisation procedure: quark-gluon interactions generates effective four-quark interactions which are directly absorbed into the composite sector. Flowing to lower scales, the gluon mass gap m g a p 2 m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2 m gap 2 starts to increase, correspondingly the gluon propagator develop a maximum at the confinement scale k g a p k_{\mathrm{gap}} k gap , see Figure 9 . Rapidly after this point, the mass gap parameter m g a p 2 m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2 m gap 2 reaches the decoupling region, and the gluon field is the first to effectively decouple. In contrast to the other fields, the gluon mass gap parameter does not reach a plateau in the IR. This is a direct consequence of the scaling solution. Because we freeze the anomalous dimension, see Sec. IV A, the gluon wave-function renormalization is constant in the IR as shown in Figure 11 . Hence, the scaling condition of the gluon dressing function, Eq. (33) , can only be realized by a diverging m g a p 2 m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2 m gap 2 . Imposing the scaling relation of the gluon dressing function Z ˉ A ( p 2 ) \bar{Z}_A(p^2) Z ˉ A ( p 2 ) in Eq. (33) on the gluon propagator we find, again identifying p = k p=k p = k , that the IR behavior of the mass gap parameters is given by
lim k → 0 m g a p 2 ∝ ( k 2 ) 1 − 2 κ . (121) \lim_{k\to0} m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2 \propto(k^2)^{1-2\kappa}. \tag*{(121)} k → 0 lim m gap 2 ∝ ( k 2 ) 1 − 2 κ . (121)
This scaling is explicitly realized in Figure 12 .
Close to the chiral symmetry breaking scale k χ S B k_{\chi\mathrm{SB}} k χ SB , the quark mass m q m_q m q is no longer negligible, signaling D χ S B \mathrm{D}\chi\mathrm{SB} D χ SB , while pions and σ \sigma σ -mesons become light enough to be relevant. As the sigma meson is tightly connected to the soft mode associated with the chiral crossover [127 ] , its mass dips at k χ S B k_{\chi\mathrm{SB}} k χ SB . As a consequence of D χ S B \mathrm{D}\chi\mathrm{SB} D χ SB , the degeneracy of the masses of the σ \sigma σ -meson and pion is lifted around k χ S B k_{\chi\mathrm{SB}} k χ SB . Ultimately, the last fields to decouple from the dynamics are the pions, as expected from pseudo-Goldstone bosons, the lightest QCD excitations.
We find that the scalar diquark is always decoupled. This implies that the inclusion of diquark fluctuations only leads to sub-leading correction in the vacuum compared to the other fields considered in this work. This explains the observation that the diquark-gluon vertices only lead to negligible modifications of the IR observables, as mentioned in the discussion of Figure 7 . Strikingly, we find that scalar diquark curvature mass is around 1 GeV. This is much heavier than the naive expectation of about twice the constituent quark mass. We will get back to this point in § 3 .
In Figure 13 , we show the flow of the anomalous dimension and wave function renormalization of the mesons ϕ \phi ϕ and the diquark fields. In contradistinction to the ghost, gluon and quark fields, we choose here Z ϕ , k I R = Z Δ , k I R = 1 Z_{\phi,k_{\mathrm{IR}}}=Z_{\Delta,k_{\mathrm{IR}}}=1 Z ϕ , k IR = Z Δ , k IR = 1 . We find that the meson wave function renormalization Z ϕ Z_{\phi} Z ϕ increases by several orders of magnitude from the UV to the IR, consistent with previous studies [31 , 73 , 74 ] . This effects is a direct consequence of the dynamical hadronization procedure and ensures that mesons become auxiliary fields in the UV. This effect drives the sharp drop of the renormalized masses towards the IR seen in Figure 12 . The plateau in the anomalous dimension in the region of a few GeV reflects the intermediate-scale fixed point of the four-quark interaction discussed in Secs. II B and IV C 2.
Figure 13. Wave function renormalization and anomalous dimension of the mesonic and diquark fields as a function of the RG-scale k k k , where we choose Z ϕ , k I R = Z Δ , k I R = 1 Z_{\phi,k_{\mathrm{IR}}}=Z_{\Delta,k_{\mathrm{IR}}}=1 Z ϕ , k IR = Z Δ , k IR = 1 .
For the scalar diquark, we find a similar behavior, however the diquark wave function renormalization is smaller by roughly an order of magnitude. This is consistent with the mass difference between the σ \sigma σ -meson and scalar diquark. Notably, this difference in the value of the meson and diquark wave function renormalization is not reflected in a generally smaller value of the diquark anomalous dimension η Δ \eta_{\Delta} η Δ , but is caused by the absence of a sharp rise of η Δ \eta_{\Delta} η Δ for scales near the UV scale Λ \Lambda Λ present in the meson anomalous dimension η ϕ \eta_{\phi} η ϕ . Furthermore, we checked explicitly that this difference is caused by the behavior of the UV flow of the SPS and the CSC four-quark
channels. While the former is nonzero, the latter almost vanishes. We will see below that leaves an imprint in the UV flow of all observables related to the composite fields.
In Figure 14 we show the quark anomalous dimension and wave function renormalization. In contrast to the composite and gauge fields, η q \eta_q η q remains small for all scales, ∣ η q ∣ ≲ 0.15 |\eta_q| \lesssim0.15 ∣ η q ∣ ≲ 0.15 . Again, this is consistent with other studies FRG studies [31 , 70 , 72 , 73 , 74 , 92 ] . It is related to the fact that, unlike the other fields, the decoupling of quarks in the IR (in the sense of Figure 12 ) is due to Δ χ S B \mathit{\Delta}\chi_{\mathrm{SB}} Δ χ SB . Furthermore, we find an IR quark wave function renormalization larger than one, consistent with lattice results [128 ] .
Figure 14. Wave function renormalization and anomalous dimension of the quark field as a function of the RG-scale k k k , where we choose Z ϕ , U V = Z Δ , U V = 1 Z_{\phi,\mathrm{UV}}=Z_{\Delta,\mathrm{UV}}=1 Z ϕ , UV = Z Δ , UV = 1 .
In Figure 15 , we show as a function of the RG-scale the dimensionless effective four-quark interactions
Figure 15. Dimensionless effective four-quark scalar-pseudoscalar λ ˉ σ , π \bar{\lambda}_{\sigma,\pi} λ ˉ σ , π and color superconducting λ ˉ c s c \bar{\lambda}_{\mathrm{csc}} λ ˉ csc channels as functions of the RG-scale k k k .
λ ˉ σ / π , e f f = 1 2 g ϕ q ˉ q 2 1 + m ˉ σ / π 2 , λ ˉ c s c , e f f = 1 2 g Δ q q 2 1 + m ˉ Δ 2 (122) \bar{\lambda}_{\sigma/\pi,\mathrm{eff}} = \frac{1}{2}\frac{g_{\phi\bar{q}q}^{2}}{1+\bar{m}_{\sigma/\pi}^{2}}, \qquad\bar{\lambda}_{\mathrm{csc},\mathrm{eff}} = \frac{1}{2}\frac{g_{\Delta qq}^{2}}{1+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2}} \tag*{(122)} λ ˉ σ / π , eff = 2 1 1 + m ˉ σ / π 2 g ϕ q ˉ q 2 , λ ˉ csc , eff = 2 1 1 + m ˉ Δ 2 g Δ q q 2 (122)
see Eq. (91) . In the deep UV, the running of the four-quark interactions is governed by the weakly interacting fixed point discussed in Secs. II B and IV C 2. At lower scales, four-quark interactions are generated with a clear hierarchy: the SPS interactions dominates over the color superconducting channel by roughly an order of magnitude, and this hierarchy persists for all k k k . This confirms the role of the SPS channel as the dominant vacuum four-quark interactions. This is expected, as the soft modes associated with DχSB emerge from this channel; see also Figure 12 . Consequently, below the chiral symmetry breaking scale k χ S B k_{\chi\mathrm{SB}} k χ SB , the Goldstone channel λ π \lambda_{\pi} λ π starts to dominate over λ σ \lambda_{\sigma} λ σ . Furthermore, each effective four-quark interactions follows the canonical k 2 k^{2} k 2 -running of 1 / m ˉ 2 1/\bar{m}^{2} 1/ m ˉ 2 once the RG-scale reaches the mass of the associated composite.
In Figure 16 we show the quark-meson and quark-diquark Yukawa couplings. The running of both couplings is qualitatively very similar, as the large-k k k behavior is determined by the intermediate scale fixed point and all fields decouple in the IR, leading to frozen flows. The differences in the deep-UV behavior are due to the different anomalous dimensions, see Figure 13 and the associated discussion. Furthermore the quark-diquark Yukawa coupling is considerably stronger than the quark-meson Yukawa coupling in the IR. As we will discuss in more details in § 3 , this relatively high value of the Yukawa coupling plays an important role in the determination of the diquark pole mass, and combined with the diquark curvature mass m Δ ∼ 1 G e V m_{\Delta} \sim1\,\mathrm{GeV} m Δ ∼ 1 GeV , yields a pole mass below twice the quark mass 2 m q ≃ 700 M e V 2m_{q} \simeq700\,\mathrm{MeV} 2 m q ≃ 700 MeV which is consistent with the quark-diquark picture of the nucleon.
Figure 16. Quark-meson g ϕ q ˉ q g_{\phi\bar{q}q} g ϕ q ˉ q and quark-diquark g Δ q q g_{\Delta qq} g Δ q q Yukawa couplings as a function of the RG-scale k k k .
Finally, in Figure 17 we show the flow of the meson-meson, diquark-meson and diquark-diquark quartic couplings. We find the diquark-diquark coupling values are higher than the meson-meson and meson-diquark ones, supporting a stiffer effective potential in the ρ Δ \rho_{\Delta} ρ Δ direction
Figure 17. Quartic meson-meson λ 2 , 0 \lambda_{2,0} λ 2 , 0 , diquark-diquark λ 0 , 2 \lambda_{0,2} λ 0 , 2 and meson-diquark λ 1 , 1 \lambda_{1,1} λ 1 , 1 couplings as a function of the RG-scale k k k .
compared to the ρ ϕ \rho_{\phi} ρ ϕ direction. This result is consistent with the sub-leading role played by the diquark sector in vacuum QCD. And also here, the approximate plateaus at large k k k relate to the underlying weak-coupling fixed point. We will discuss this in more detail in the next section, this is key for the predictive power of our approach.
In addition to the Yukawa couplings in Figure 16 and the curvature mass in Figure 12 , these are key quantities needed to fix parameters of commonly used LEM of CSC quark matter, and forms one of the main results of our study. For convenience, we report in Table III the quark-meson coupling, quark-diquark coupling and the derivatives of the effective potential up to the fourth order for the three regulator employed in this work.
Table III. Definition of selected low-energy constants and their extracted values from our QCD computation. All quantities are evaluated in the infrared. The effective potential is defined as Ω = U k = 0 − h σ \Omega= U_{k=0} - h\sigma Ω = U k = 0 − hσ . All quantities given in an RG-invariant manner, i.e., rescaled by the appropriate powers of the infrared meson and/or diquark wave-function renormalizations. As a minimal estimate of the systematic uncertainty of the computation, we quote the variation of the results obtained with different regulators.
Independence on the UV parameters
In this section we show the predictive power of our approach by demonstrating the independence of the infrared bound-state properties on the choice of the initial UV values for the gluon mass gap and the couplings in the composite sector. Hence, as appropriate for QCD, all quantities, including emergent ones, are fully determined by the initial values for the strong coupling and the current quark masses. For the gluon mass gap, this entails a discussion of the scaling and decoupling solutions, and the independence of our results on the choice of a specific solution. For the properties of the composite fields, we explicitly confirm that the weak-coupling fixed point at intermediate scales in conjunction with dynamical hadronization leads to unique predictions.
In Figure 18 , we show the curvature mass of all fields against the difference between the UV mass gap, m ˉ g a p , U V 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,UV}} m ˉ gap , UV 2 , and the UV gap corresponding to the scaling solution, m ˉ g a p , s c a l i n g 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,scaling}} m ˉ gap , scaling 2 . We find that the mass gap parameter m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap displays a minimum for a specific UV value m ˉ g a p , U V 2 = m ˉ g a p , m i n 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}=\bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,min}} m ˉ gap , UV 2 = m ˉ gap , min 2 . This point corresponds to the delimitation between the Higgs regime, where the gluon propagator is that of a massive vector particle, and the confining regime, where the gluon propagator peaks at nonzero momentum, see, e.g., Refs. [67 , 68 ] for details. In the Higgs regime, we find no sign of DχSB: the quark mass tends towards the current quark mass and the pion and σ \sigma σ -meson masses are degenerate. Furthermore, the mass of all composite fields are large as the strong interaction is suppressed by the large effective gluon mass.
Figure 18. Mass of the different fields considered in this work against the difference between the dimensionless mass gap at the UV scale, m ˉ g a p , U V 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,UV}} m ˉ gap , UV 2 , and the UV dimensionless mass gap yielding the scaling solution, m ˉ g a p , s c a l i n g 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,scaling}} m ˉ gap , scaling 2 . The gluon mass parameter is given by m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap . The minimum of m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap is indicated by a vertical line, and yields the delimitation between the confining (left) and Higgs branch (right).
For m ˉ g a p , U V 2 ≲ m ˉ g a p , m i n 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,UV}}\lesssim\bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,min}} m ˉ gap , UV 2 ≲ m ˉ gap , min 2 we enter the confining regime. However, close to m ˉ g a p , m i n 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,min}} m ˉ gap , min 2 we do not have DχSB as the pion and σ \sigma σ -meson masses are still degenerate. For smaller m ˉ g a p , U V 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,UV}} m ˉ gap , UV 2 , we find DχSB with a non-negligible quark mass and non-degenerate pions and σ \sigma σ -mesons. We emphasize that this behavior indicates a direct relation between confinement and DχSB. In general, DχSB requires strong four-quark interactions which are only obtained in the confining regime, see also Ref. [68 ] .
For m ˉ g a p , U V 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,UV}} m ˉ gap , UV 2 well below m ˉ g a p , m i n 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,min}} m ˉ gap , min 2 , we find that all the masses, with the exception of m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap itself, are independent of the value of the UV mass gap parameter. All so-
lutions in this region correspond to decoupling, and they are identical to those corresponding to scaling. Thus, the precise choice of a confining solution has no effect on physical observables. This confirms that choosing the scaling solution to fine-tune m ˉ g a p , U V 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,UV}} m ˉ gap , UV 2 is a well-defined and, crucially, unique procedure. Because m g a p m_{\mathrm{gap}} m gap corresponds to the transverse part of the gluon propagator at vanishing momenta, it is RG-invariant and gauge dependent. It therefore depends on m ˉ g a p , U V 2 \bar{m}^{2}_{\mathrm{gap,UV}} m ˉ gap , UV 2 even within the confining regime.
In Figure 19 , we show the flow of the quark-meson and quark-diquark Yukawa couplings (upper panels), as well as the three composite quartic couplings (lower panels), for different initial UV scales, Λ = 10 G e V \Lambda=10\,\mathrm{GeV} Λ = 10 GeV , 20 G e V 20\,\mathrm{GeV} 20 GeV and 50 G e V 50\,\mathrm{GeV} 50 GeV , and for initial coupling values differing by several orders of magnitude. In all cases, we follow the parameter-fixing procedure detailed in § 2 A, ensuring that all results reproduce the same IR pion and quark masses. For all initial conditions, the flows at large k k k are attracted to the intermediate-scale fixed point, such that for k ≲ 1 k \lesssim1 k ≲ 1 GeV they agree quantitatively; see also Refs. [17 , 73 , 76 ] . Note that the relevant UV parameters of the composite sector are determined through the effective four-quark couplings in Eq. (91) . Hence, Eq. (91) implies that varying the UV Yukawa couplings is equivalent to varying the UV masses of the composite fields. All in all, these results explicitly demonstrate that the emergent properties of QCD are independent of the choice of initial conditions. We emphasize that, although its precise value is unimportant for the resulting IR physics, the initial scale Λ \Lambda Λ must nevertheless lie sufficiently deep in the perturbative regime.
Figure 19. Quark-meson g ϕ q ˉ q g_{\phi\bar{q}q} g ϕ q ˉ q and quark-diquark g Δ q ˉ q ˉ g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}} g Δ q ˉ q ˉ Yukawa couplings (top) and quartic meson-meson λ 2 , 0 \lambda_{2,0} λ 2 , 0 , diquark-diquark λ 0 , 2 \lambda_{0,2} λ 0 , 2 and meson-diquark λ 1 , 1 \lambda_{1,1} λ 1 , 1 couplings (bottom) as a function of the RG-scale k k k for different initial UV conditions Λ \Lambda Λ with g ϕ q ˉ q = g Δ q ˉ q ˉ = g Λ g_{\phi\bar{q}q}=g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}=g_{\Lambda} g ϕ q ˉ q = g Δ q ˉ q ˉ = g Λ and λ 2 , 0 = λ 0 , 2 = λ 1 , 1 = λ Λ \lambda_{2,0}=\lambda_{0,2}=\lambda_{1,1}=\lambda_{\Lambda} λ 2 , 0 = λ 0 , 2 = λ 1 , 1 = λ Λ . For clarity, we present only results obtained with the optimized regulator shape function, but the same conclusion holds for any regulator.
Real-Time Correlation Functions
A striking result from our QCD computation is the large value for the diquark curvature mass, m Δ ∼ 1 m_{\Delta} \sim1 m Δ ∼ 1 GeV. As discussed in § 1 , this seems surprising because a value around twice the constituent quark mass, ≲ 700 \lesssim700 ≲ 700 MeV, appears to be natural. In this section, we clarify this discrepancy. To this end, we will compute the diquark two-point function in real time. For completeness, we will also do the same for the mesons.
Within our approach, this pose two difficulties. First, our computation is performed within a zero-momentum expansion. As such we do not have access to correlation functions at finite external momenta. Second, our approach is based on Euclidean time and getting access to real time quantities (such as pole masses) requires analytic continuation and additional care regarding the choice of regulator. Because of these two difficulties, we focus on providing qualitative estimates here, while the quantitative focus remains on correlation functions at vanishing momenta. As explained previously, such quantities are readily accessible by LEM.
Curvature vs pole masses
A simple way to estimate the mass of the diquark field is based on the quark-diquark picture of the nucleons. Within this picture, one naturally expect the mass of the diquark to be around, or slightly below twice the constituent quark mass (350 MeV in this work), such that the quark and diquark form a bound state with enough binding energy to reproduce the correct nucleon mass m N ∼ 940 m_N \sim940 m N ∼ 940 MeV. Previous estimates for the scalar diquark mass support this picture and predict a value around twice the quark mass [47 , 48 , 49 , 50 , 51 , 52 , 53 , 54 , 55 , 56 ] . However, as pointed out in § 1 , such estimates apply to the diquark pole mass, defined in Eq. (1) , and it is not obvious how it relates to the curvature mass , see Eq. (2) , computed here.
In order to understand the origin of possible differences between pole and curvature mass, it is instructive to consider the Euclidean meson or diquark propagator G ( p 0 ) G(p_0) G ( p 0 ) in the vicinity of the relevant frequency p 0 p_0 p 0 . We can set the spatial momenta to zero for our argument. The propagator can in general be expressed as
G ( p 0 ) = 1 Z ∥ ( p 0 ) p 0 2 + m 2 + Δ Π ( p 0 ) (123) G(p_0) = \frac{1}{Z^{\parallel}(p_0)p_0^2 + m^2 + \Delta\Pi(p_0)} \tag*{(123)} G ( p 0 ) = Z ∥ ( p 0 ) p 0 2 + m 2 + ΔΠ ( p 0 ) 1 (123)
where m m m is the bare mass and we split the self-energy into a temporal wave function renormalization correction, Z ∥ Z^{\parallel} Z ∥ , and all the rest, Δ Π \Delta\Pi ΔΠ . Expanding these corrections to leading order around a frequency p exp p_{\exp} p e x p yields
G ( p 0 ) ≈ 1 Z ∥ ( p exp ) p 0 2 + m 2 + Δ Π ( p exp ) . (124) G(p_0) \approx\frac{1}{Z^{\parallel}(p_{\exp})p_0^2 + m^2 + \Delta\Pi(p_{\exp})}. \tag*{(124)} G ( p 0 ) ≈ Z ∥ ( p e x p ) p 0 2 + m 2 + ΔΠ ( p e x p ) 1 . (124)
To access the pole and curvature masses defined in Eqs. (1) and (2) from the Euclidean propagator, we set p exp = − i m p o l e p_{\exp} = -i m_{\mathrm{pole}} p e x p = − i m pole and p exp = 0 p_{\exp} = 0 p e x p = 0 , respectively. We then readily read off the RG-invariant relations
m p o l e = m 2 + Δ Π ( − i m p o l e ) Z ∥ ( − i m p o l e ) , m_{\mathrm{pole}} = \frac{m^2 + \Delta\Pi(-i m_{\mathrm{pole}})}{Z^{\parallel}(-i m_{\mathrm{pole}})}, m pole = Z ∥ ( − i m pole ) m 2 + ΔΠ ( − i m pole ) ,
m c u r v = m 2 + Δ Π ( 0 ) Z ∥ ( 0 ) . (125) m_{\mathrm{curv}} = \frac{m^2 + \Delta\Pi(0)}{Z^{\parallel}(0)}. \tag*{(125)} m curv = Z ∥ ( 0 ) m 2 + ΔΠ ( 0 ) . (125)
The difference between pole and curvature mass clearly lies in the momentum dependence of the self-energy corrections. If this dependence is weak and/or the pole mass is close to zero, pole and curvature mass can be very similar. This is, in fact, the case for pions, where the pole is indeed close to the origin compared to the rest of the low-energy spectrum [35 , 46 ] .
In turn, for heavy states it seems more natural to expect a considerable difference between pole and curvature masses. As we demonstrate in the following, this turns out to be true for the scalar diquark.
Flows of momentum-dependent two-point functions
In order to analytically continue the Euclidean two-point functions to Minkowski space, we need access to their full momentum dependence. Within our zero-momentum expansion, we therefore solve three additional flow equations for the pion, sigma and diquark two-point functions at finite external momenta
∂ t Γ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = η Δ † Δ Γ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + Flow Δ † Δ ( 2 ) ( p ) , (126) \partial_t \Gamma_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}^{(2),E}(p) = \eta_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta} \Gamma_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}^{(2),E}(p) + \operatorname{Flow}_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}^{(2)}(p), \tag*{(126)} ∂ t Γ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = η Δ † Δ Γ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + Flow Δ † Δ ( 2 ) ( p ) , (126)
∂ t Γ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = η ϕ Γ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + Flow π π ( 2 ) ( p ) , (127) \partial_t \Gamma_{\pi\pi}^{(2),E}(p) = \eta_{\phi} \Gamma_{\pi\pi}^{(2),E}(p) + \operatorname{Flow}_{\pi\pi}^{(2)}(p), \tag*{(127)} ∂ t Γ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = η ϕ Γ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + Flow π π ( 2 ) ( p ) , (127)
∂ t Γ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = η ϕ Γ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + Flow σ σ ( 2 ) ( p ) . (128) \partial_t \Gamma_{\sigma\sigma}^{(2),E}(p) = \eta_{\phi} \Gamma_{\sigma\sigma}^{(2),E}(p) + \operatorname{Flow}_{\sigma\sigma}^{(2)}(p). \tag*{(128)} ∂ t Γ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = η ϕ Γ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + Flow σ σ ( 2 ) ( p ) . (128)
The superscript E E E denotes the Euclidean quantities. The diagrammatic representation of these flows is shown in Figure 20 . We use the procedure put forward in [129 , 130 ] and use our solutions for the k k k -dependent vertices and propagators obtained in the fully coupled system at zero momentum as input for the diagrams shown in Figure 20 . This will give us the full momentum dependence of the two-point function based on the zero-momentum solutions. This procedure is not self-consistent as the zero-momentum masses and couplings are used instead of fully momentum dependent dressing functions. However, it still provides a good approximation to the momentum dependence of the full correlation functions [131 ] .
Figure 20. Diagrammatic representation of the flows of the momentum-dependent two-point functions of the diquark, pion, and σ \sigma σ -meson fields. The conventions are the same as in Figure 2 .
In contrast to the rest of the flow equations, we employ here a three dimensional regulator which leaves the temporal component of the four-momentum unaffected,
R q ˉ q 3 d ( p ) = i p̸ ⃗ ( − 1 + 1 + r q ( x 3 d ) ) (129) R_{\bar{q}q}^{3d}(p)=i\vec{\not p}\left(-1+\sqrt{1+r_q(x_{3d})}\right) \tag*{(129)} R q ˉ q 3 d ( p ) = i p ( − 1 + 1 + r q ( x 3 d ) ) (129)
[ R ϕ ϕ 3 d ( p ) ] i j = p ⃗ 2 r ϕ ( x 3 d ) δ i j (130) \left[R_{\phi\phi}^{3d}(p)\right]_{ij}=\vec{p}^{\,2}r_\phi(x_{3d})\delta_{ij} \tag*{(130)} [ R ϕϕ 3 d ( p ) ] ij = p 2 r ϕ ( x 3 d ) δ ij (130)
[ R Δ † Δ 3 d ( p ) ] a b = p ⃗ 2 r Δ ( x 3 d ) δ a b (131) \left[R_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}^{3d}(p)\right]_{ab}=\vec{p}^{\,2}r_\Delta(x_{3d})\delta_{ab} \tag*{(131)} [ R Δ † Δ 3 d ( p ) ] ab = p 2 r Δ ( x 3 d ) δ ab (131)
with x 3 d = p ⃗ 2 / k 2 x_{3d}=\vec{p}^{\,2}/k^2 x 3 d = p 2 / k 2 . The flow equation resulting from this choice can be found in App. D 1. A three dimensional regulator ensure that the pole structure of the two-point functions in the complex p 0 p_0 p 0 -plane is not affected by potential fictitious poles introduced by four dimensional regulators [132 ] . As in the zero-momentum QCD expansion, we choose the same shape function for all fields. To estimate the systematic error, we use different shape functions also here, see App. A.
For the diquark two-point function we ignore all gluonic contributions to the flow as we expect them to be subleading, consistent with the effect of the diquark-gluon interactions in the zero-momentum expansion, see § 2 B. Furthermore, the mixed gluon-diquark diagram, i.e. the second-to-last diagram in the first line of Figure 20 , may seem to contain a threshold for the process Δ → Δ + g \Delta\to\Delta+g Δ → Δ + g . In the current approximation, and since we only consider correlation function at vanishing spatial momenta p ⃗ = 0 \vec{p}=0 p = 0 , this threshold is located at the sum of the diquark and gluon curvature masses, m Δ , c u r v + m g a p m_{\Delta,\mathrm{curv}}+m_{\mathrm{gap}} m Δ , curv + m gap . Since the mass gap parameter diverges for the scaling solution, this threshold is removed from the spectrum and can hence not affect the diquark pole mass.
Since the mass gap parameter diverges for the scaling solution, this threshold is removed from the spectrum and can hence not affect the diquark pole mass.
Choosing 3 d 3d 3 d regulators for Eqs. (126) to (128) , but using input obtained with 4 d 4d 4 d regulators can lead to inconsistencies. As a direct consequence, the curvature masses resulting from Eqs. (126) to (128) and the zero-momentum QCD expansion differ, although they should match by definition. For the diquark two-point functions this inconsistency results in a small variation of the curvature mass of around 100 100 100 MeV, while for the pion and σ \sigma σ -meson the difference is more drastic, as both curvature masses turn negative.
The curvature masses are given by the curvature of the effective potential in the corresponding field direction, evaluated at its minimum, see Eqs. (98) to (100) . The inconsistency in regularization schemes in Eqs. (126) to (128) apparently leads to a mismatch between the underlying evaluation point and the minimum of the potential. A negative meson curvature mass implies that the potential is evaluated at a field value below its minimum in ρ ϕ \rho_\phi ρ ϕ -direction. Hence, this mismatch can in principle be resolved by adjusting the location of the minimum through the explicit symmetry breaking parameter h h h . Since the effective potential is the zero-momentum part of the effective action, this leads to constant shifts in the two-point functions of mesons and diquarks, while leaving the momentum-dependence unaffected.
In practice, we can therefore directly apply constant shifts to the two-point functions so that the curvature masses obtained with the 3 d 3d 3 d regulators match the ones with 4 d 4d 4 d regulators,
Δ Γ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = Γ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) − Γ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( 0 ) + m Δ 2 (132) \Delta\Gamma_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}^{(2),E}(p)=\Gamma_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}^{(2),E}(p)-\Gamma_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}^{(2),E}(0)+m_\Delta^2 \tag*{(132)} Δ Γ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = Γ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) − Γ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( 0 ) + m Δ 2 (132)
Δ Γ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = Γ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) − Γ π π ( 2 ) , E ( 0 ) + m π 2 (133) \Delta\Gamma_{\pi\pi}^{(2),E}(p)=\Gamma_{\pi\pi}^{(2),E}(p)-\Gamma_{\pi\pi}^{(2),E}(0)+m_\pi^2 \tag*{(133)} Δ Γ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = Γ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) − Γ π π ( 2 ) , E ( 0 ) + m π 2 (133)
Δ Γ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = Γ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) − Γ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( 0 ) + m σ 2 (134) \Delta\Gamma_{\sigma\sigma}^{(2),E}(p)=\Gamma_{\sigma\sigma}^{(2),E}(p)-\Gamma_{\sigma\sigma}^{(2),E}(0)+m_\sigma^2 \tag*{(134)} Δ Γ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = Γ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) − Γ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( 0 ) + m σ 2 (134)
With this prescription, we find very good agreement between the pion pole and curvature mass, as expected from other studies [35 , 46 ] . As mentioned above, the modification of the diquark two-point function is only minor, and hence irrelevant for our estimate of the diquark pole mass. It may be possible to directly find the pole mass from Eqs. (132) to (134) at imaginary Euclidean frequency,
Δ Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , E ( p 0 = − i m p o l e , p ⃗ = 0 ) = 0. (135) \Delta\Gamma_{\Phi_i\Phi_j}^{(2),E}(p_0=-im_{\mathrm{pole}},\vec{p}=0)=0 . \tag*{(135)} Δ Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , E ( p 0 = − i m pole , p = 0 ) = 0. (135)
This works for single particle poles, but fails for resonances where proper analytic continuation is necessary to account for the branch cuts from multi-particle thresholds. In the present approximation, the location of these thresholds is determined by the curvature masses of the different fields. Clearly, in a self-consistent treatment of the momentum-dependence, it would be the pole masses. For example, the cut for the decay into two quarks starts at 2 m q ≃ 700 M e V 2m_q \simeq700\,\mathrm{MeV} 2 m q ≃ 700 MeV and for two pions at 2 m π ≃ 274 M e V 2m_\pi\simeq274\,\mathrm{MeV} 2 m π ≃ 274 MeV .
To access the full spectrum, we follow the direct analytic continuation of flow equations first introduced in Refs. [130 , 133 ] , and recently used in Ref. [35 ] in a setting similar to ours. This procedure exploits the simple one loop structure of the flow equations to provide the correct i ϵ i\epsilon i ϵ prescription for the analytic continuation of Euclidean to retarded two-point functions,
Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , R ( ω ) = lim ϵ → 0 + Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , E ( p 0 = − i ( ω + i ϵ ) , p ⃗ = 0 ) . (136) \Gamma_{\Phi_i\Phi_j}^{(2),R}(\omega)=\lim_{\epsilon\to0^+}\Gamma_{\Phi_i\Phi_j}^{(2),E}\left(p_0=-i(\omega+i\epsilon),\vec{p}=0\right) . \tag*{(136)} Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , R ( ω ) = ϵ → 0 + lim Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , E ( p 0 = − i ( ω + i ϵ ) , p = 0 ) . (136)
We keep ϵ = 0.1 M e V \epsilon=0.1\,\mathrm{MeV} ϵ = 0.1 MeV , and focus on vanishing spatial momentum as this is sufficient for our purposes. It is convenient to compute the spectral function from the retarded propagator,
ρ = − 1 π Im G R . (137) \rho=-\frac{1}{\pi}\operatorname{Im}G^R . \tag*{(137)} ρ = − π 1 Im G R . (137)
This leads to
ρ Φ i Φ j = − 1 π Im Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , R ( Re Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , R ) 2 + ( Im Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , R ) 2 . (138) \rho_{\Phi_i\Phi_j}=-\frac{1}{\pi}\frac{\operatorname{Im}\Gamma_{\Phi_i\Phi_j}^{(2),R}}{\left(\operatorname{Re}\Gamma_{\Phi_i\Phi_j}^{(2),R}\right)^2+\left(\operatorname{Im}\Gamma_{\Phi_i\Phi_j}^{(2),R}\right)^2} . \tag*{(138)} ρ Φ i Φ j = − π 1 ( Re Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , R ) 2 + ( Im Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , R ) 2 Im Γ Φ i Φ j ( 2 ) , R . (138)
From the spectral function ρ Φ i Φ j \rho_{\Phi_i\Phi_j} ρ Φ i Φ j , we can directly read off all information regarding single-particle excitations, resonances and decay channels of the field Φ \Phi Φ .
For simple truncations, such as the local potential approximation, this procedure provides a powerful way to compute spectral functions. However, difficulties can arise for more complex approximations. These difficulties are a direct consequence of the lack of self-consistency of the procedure: some of the finite momentum behavior is extracted from the RG-scale dependence of zero-momentum correlation functions, and not from the genuine momentum structure.
In the present work, we encounter these problems in two distinct forms. First, for the exponential shape function, Eq. (149) , the k k k -dependent quark energy ϵ q = k 2 + m q 2 \epsilon_q=\sqrt{k^2+m_q^2} ϵ q = k 2 + m q 2 has a local minimum at nonzero k k k , which in turn leads to a singularity reminiscent of a Van-Hove singularity [134 ] . This singularity is an approximation artifact, as self-consistent computation of the momentum dependent quark-mass indicate a monotonous quark energy, see Refs. [92 , 108 , 119 , 120 , 121 ] . A similar behavior was already observed in Ref. [135 ] . The second problem is encountered for all shape functions, and is caused by the non-monotonic behavior of the quark-meson Yukawa coupling, see Figure 16 , which induces spurious oscillation in the retarded two-point functions for p ≳ 800 M e V p\gtrsim800\,\mathrm{MeV} p ≳ 800 MeV .
Based on this two observations, we restrict our results to external momenta p < 800 M e V p<800\,\mathrm{MeV} p < 800 MeV . Furthermore, we compare the analytically continued results to the Euclidean results to ensure that analytical continuation artifacts are not present in the range of interest, see Figure 21 .
Figure 21. Euclidean two-point functions Δ Γ ( 2 ) , E \Delta\Gamma^{(2),E} Δ Γ ( 2 ) , E as functions of the squared Euclidean frequency p 0 2 p_0^2 p 0 2 (left) and spectral functions Δ ρ \Delta\rho Δ ρ as functions of the real-time frequency ω \omega ω (right) for the diquark, pion, and sigma-meson, obtained from the 3d-regulated flow. Gray dashed lines indicate the thresholds of different multi-particle processes, while the colored solid lines denote the corresponding curvature masses.
Numerical results and discussion
We now present the numerical results we obtain for the analytically continued two-point functions. In Figure 21 (left) we show the shifted euclidean two-point functions Δ Γ Φ ( 2 ) , E \Delta\Gamma_{\Phi}^{(2),E} Δ Γ Φ ( 2 ) , E of the composite fields defined in Eqs. (132) to (134) against the squared temporal Euclidean momenta p 0 2 p_0^2 p 0 2 . Negative values of p 0 2 p_0^2 p 0 2 corresponds to imaginary temporal Euclidean momenta, i.e., Minkowski time. As explained above, this procedure is only valid until the first branch cut on the real frequency axis, which is located at the smallest threshold for the decay of the associated field. These thresholds are indicated by gray dashed vertical lines in the figure. By definition of the shifted two-point functions, the value of the two-point function at vanishing momenta p 0 = 0 p_0=0 p 0 = 0 corresponds to squared curvature mass of the associated field.
A zero crossing of Δ Γ ( 2 ) , E \Delta\Gamma^{(2),E} Δ Γ ( 2 ) , E for negative p 0 2 p_0^2 p 0 2 indicates the pole mass of the associated field. As expected for QCD, we find a small pole mass for the pion field, and no isolated pole for the σ \sigma σ -meson, confirming that it is a resonance. As mentioned above, we also confirm that the pion pole mass is close to its curvature mass (indicated by the vertical solid orange line). Note that these observations justify a posteriori the shifting prescription defined in Eqs. (132) to (134) . Furthermore, we find a relatively small regulator dependence for the Euclidean two-point functions of the pion and the σ \sigma σ -meson, supporting the idea that the current truncation can be used for quantitative predictions, at least in the SPS sector.
We now turn to the analytically continued diquark two-point function, which constitutes the central result of this section. For all regulators, we find a diquark pole mass below the two-quark threshold,
m Δ , p o l e = 580 – 619 M e V , (139) m_{\Delta,\mathrm{pole}}=580\text{--}619\,\mathrm{MeV} , \tag*{(139)} m Δ , pole = 580 – 619 MeV , (139)
consistent with the diquark as a two-quark bound state. In contrast to the pion, the diquark curvature mass differs significantly from its pole mass, see Table IV . Following our discussion in § 3 A, this indicates that the diquark self-energy corrections have a strong frequency dependence. Furthermore, consistent with the results obtained for the diquark curvature mass, we also find a non-negligible regulator dependence of the corresponding pole mass. Importantly, we predict a diquark bound state for all regulator choices considered. We have explicitly verified that the shifting prescription in Eq. (132) has a negligible impact on the diquark pole mass.
Table IV. Pion and diquark pole masses for different regulators, extracted from the composite two-point functions shown in Figure 21 . The corresponding curvature masses are also shown for comparison.
The diquark pole mass constrains the phase structure of cold QCD matter through the Silver-Blaze property [136 ] , which predicts the onset of diquark condensation at μ B = 2 m Δ , p o l e / 3 \mu_B = 2m_{\Delta,\mathrm{pole}}/3 μ B = 2 m Δ , pole /3 , provided that no first-order transition occurs at lower chemical potential; see, e.g., Ref. [113 ] . Since nuclear matter sets in at μ B = m N − E B = 923 \mu_B = m_N - E_B = 923 μ B = m N − E B = 923 MeV (using the measured nucleon mass and binding energy), a diquark pole mass below this value would imply diquark condensation prior to the onset of nuclear matter and would therefore be phenomenologically excluded. Our predicted pole mass corresponds to a condensation threshold at μ B = 870 \mu_B = 870 μ B = 870 –929 929 929 MeV, consistent with the onset of nuclear matter within our estimated systematic uncertainty. Moreover, beyond the nuclear onset the Silver-Blaze property no longer determines the true ground state, so a diquark pole mass slightly above 923 MeV does not necessarily imply early diquark condensation.
By analytically continuing our results according to Eq. (136) , we obtain access to real-time frequencies also in the presence of multi-particle branch cuts. In the right panel of Figure 21 we show the spectral functions of the composite fields. Since we keep a finite value of ϵ = 0.1 \epsilon= 0.1 ϵ = 0.1 MeV for numerical convenience, the pion and diquark single-particles poles appear as narrow peaks rather than Dirac delta peaks. Moreover, the pole masses extracted from the spectral functions agree with those obtained from the Euclidean two-point functions, corroborating our results.
We also confirm that the σ \sigma σ -meson is a very broad resonance. Any putative single-particle peak in its spectral function appears to be swallowed by the low-lying σ → π π \sigma\to\pi\pi σ → π π contribution.
The existence of a single-particle pole in the scalar diquark channel suggests the presence of a stable excitation in the QCD vacuum. Superficially, this appears to be in tension with confinement, since the diquark field carries a net color charge. A similar issue arises in studies of the real-time properties of quark correlators. However, the connection between the pole structure of colored correlation functions and confinement remains an open question, particularly in gauge-fixed settings [22 , 137 , 138 ] . Furthermore, similar poles are well-known from Bethe-Salpeter equation studies of the hadron spectrum [12 ] .
To summarize, we confirm that the pion is a stable single-particle excitation with very similar pole and curvature masses, while the σ \sigma σ -meson appears as a broad resonance. Most importantly, we find that the scalar diquark forms a two-quark bound state with a binding energy of approximately 100 MeV, consistent with the quark-diquark picture of the nucleon. Our analysis demonstrates that the low-energy constants reported in Table III , including the large diquark curvature mass, are fully consistent with the expected QCD spectrum.
Conclusion and Outlook
In this work, we present a self-consistent, first-principles framework for vacuum QCD based on the FRG. It allows us to smoothly interpolate between the high-energy quark and gluon degrees of freedom and a low-energy description in terms of dynamically generated composite operators. In this way, it establishes a direct first-principles connection between QCD and low-energy models. Key non-perturbative phenomena, including DχSB and confinement, signaled by the emergence of a gluon mass gap, arise naturally within the framework. This facilitates the direct computation of the LECs required as input in LEMs of QCD.
While some model parameters can be constrained by well-established hadronic properties in vacuum, others remain largely unconstrained. A prominent example are diquark parameters, which are essential for describing CSC quark matter and therefore play a key role in our understanding of the interior neutron stars and their mergers. As a first application of our framework, we determine for the first time the vacuum properties of the scalar diquark directly from QCD. In particular, we compute its curvature and pole masses, as well as the corresponding point-like quark-diquark, meson-diquark, and diquark-diquark couplings.
A key result of this work is the substantial difference between the diquark curvature and pole masses. While the curvature mass is found to be m Δ , c u r v = 1030 m_{\Delta,\mathrm{curv}} = 1030 m Δ , curv = 1030 –1187 M e V 1187\,\mathrm{MeV} 1187 MeV , the pole mass lies in the range m Δ , p o l e = 580 m_{\Delta,\mathrm{pole}} = 580 m Δ , pole = 580 –619 M e V 619\,\mathrm{MeV} 619 MeV . Since the latter is significantly below the constituent quark-antiquark decay threshold, it provides strong support for the quark-diquark picture of the nucleon in terms of a diquark bound state. Beyond its conceptual significance, the pronounced discrepancy between the curvature and pole masses has important implications for the parameter-fixing procedure of LEMs, where theses quantities are often identified, at least implicitly.
The natural next step is to apply the derived LECs to constrain LEMs of CSC quark matter. This significantly enhances their predictive power by replacing previously free parameters with quantities determined directly from QCD. In a forthcoming companion study, we use our results to constrain the renormalized QMD model, Ref. [111 ] and the RG-consistent NJL model, Ref. [139 ] , enabling parameter-free predictions for dense CSC quark matter.
The numerical efficiency and versatility of our self-consistent QCD framework open several avenues for further improvements and extensions. While regulator variations provide a first estimate of the associated systematic uncertainties, a more comprehensive error analysis requires also a detailed assessment of truncation effects [121 , 140 ] . Furthermore, it will be important to investigate the impact of additional interaction channels, tensor structures, and the momentum dependence of correlation functions. Significant progress in this direction has already been achieved for the gauge and scalar-pseudoscalar sectors [92 ] . It will be interesting to explore whether similar improvements extend to other composite degrees of freedom, such as scalar diquarks. Finally, we are currently extending our setup to finite temperature and density along the lines of [31 , 141 ] in order to gain access to the QCD phase diagram and the in-medium properties of hadrons and other bound states.
Acknowledgment
We are indebted to Álvaro Pastor-Gutiérrez and Chuang Huang for fruitful discussions and helpful guidance. We thank Michael Buballa, Christian S. Fischer, Wei-jie Fu, Markus Q. Huber, Jan M. Pawlowski, Ralf Rapp, Lorenz von Smekal, Jonas Wessely and Jonathan Y. Yigzaw for discussions. The authors gratefully acknowledge support from the Helmholtz Graduate School for Hadron and Ion Research (HGS-HIRe) for FAIR, the GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung, and the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) through the CRC-TR211 ’Strong-interaction matter under extreme conditions’, project number 315477589 – TRR 211.
Data Availability
The numerical data presented in all figures in this work are openly available in the ancillary files of the corresponding arXiv submission.
Regulator choice
In this appendix we give more details regarding our regulators. For clarity, we define the elements of the propagator in field space as
R Φ i Φ j ( p ) = ( R k ( p ) ) i j , (140) R_{\Phi_i\Phi_j}(p) = \left(R_k(p)\right)_{ij}, \tag*{(140)} R Φ i Φ j ( p ) = ( R k ( p ) ) ij , (140)
where the regulator matrix is defined in Eq. (14) . We make the following choices for the regulators,
[ R A A ( p ) ] μ ν a b = p 2 r A ( x ) δ a b Π μ ν T ( p ) , (141) \left[R_{AA}(p)\right]_{\mu\nu}^{ab} = p^2 r_A(x)\delta^{ab}\Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{T}}(p), \tag*{(141)} [ R AA ( p ) ] μν ab = p 2 r A ( x ) δ ab Π μν T ( p ) , (141)
[ R c c ( p ) ] a b = p 2 r c ( x ) δ a b , (142) \left[R_{cc}(p)\right]^{ab} = p^2 r_c(x)\delta^{ab}, \tag*{(142)} [ R cc ( p ) ] ab = p 2 r c ( x ) δ ab , (142)
R q ˉ q ( p ) = i p̸ ( − 1 + 1 + r q ( x ) ) , (143) R_{\bar q q}(p) = i\not{p}\left(-1+\sqrt{1+r_q(x)}\right), \tag*{(143)} R q ˉ q ( p ) = i p ( − 1 + 1 + r q ( x ) ) , (143)
[ R ϕ ϕ ( p ) ] i j = p 2 r ϕ ( x ) δ i j , (144) \left[R_{\phi\phi}(p)\right]_{ij} = p^2 r_\phi(x)\delta_{ij}, \tag*{(144)} [ R ϕϕ ( p ) ] ij = p 2 r ϕ ( x ) δ ij , (144)
[ R Δ † Δ ( p ) ] a b = p 2 r Δ ( x ) δ a b , (145) \left[R_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}(p)\right]_{ab} = p^2 r_\Delta(x)\delta_{ab}, \tag*{(145)} [ R Δ † Δ ( p ) ] ab = p 2 r Δ ( x ) δ ab , (145)
while all other combinations vanish. With these, all momentum-dependent terms in the propagators are replaced by their regularized counterparts,
p Φ i 2 = p 2 ( 1 + r Φ i ( x ) ) (146) p_{\Phi_i}^2 = p^2 \left(1+r_{\Phi_i}(x)\right) \tag*{(146)} p Φ i 2 = p 2 ( 1 + r Φ i ( x ) ) (146)
where r Φ i ( x ) r_{\Phi_i}(x) r Φ i ( x ) is a dimensionless shape function with x = p 2 / k 2 x=p^2/k^2 x = p 2 / k 2 for each field Φ i \Phi_i Φ i .
In all expression that follow we keep our choice of regulator general, such that different fields can in principle get different shape functions. This may prove useful in choosing different scales for the bosonic and fermionic fields of the theory, see for example Ref. [79 ] . In practice, we use the same shape function for all fields in this work, though, i.e.,
r A = r c = r q = r ϕ = r Δ = r (147) r_A=r_c=r_q=r_\phi=r_\Delta=r \tag*{(147)} r A = r c = r q = r ϕ = r Δ = r (147)
where r r r is a common shape function for every field. In order to obtain an estimate of our systematic error, we assess the sensitivity of our results to the choice of regulator by considering three different shape functions. We either employ the smooth flat shape function
r f l a t ( x ) = ( 1 x − 1 ) 1 1 + e x − 1 a (148) r_{\mathrm{flat}}(x)=\left(\frac{1}{x}-1\right)\frac{1}{1+e^{\frac{x-1}{a}}} \tag*{(148)} r flat ( x ) = ( x 1 − 1 ) 1 + e a x − 1 1 (148)
with a = 0.02 a=0.02 a = 0.02 , or the exponential shape function
r e x p , m ( x ) = x m − 1 e − x m 1 − e − x m (149) r_{\mathrm{exp},m}(x)=\frac{x^{m-1}e^{-x^m}}{1-e^{-x^m}} \tag*{(149)} r exp , m ( x ) = 1 − e − x m x m − 1 e − x m (149)
with m = 1 m=1 m = 1 or m = 2 m=2 m = 2 . The behavior of the t t t -derivative of the regulator associated with the two different shape functions is shown in Figure 22 .
Diagrammatics
In this appendix, we list all the building blocks needed for the computation of the flow equations, i.e. the propagators and vertices. For all n n n -point functions we choose all momenta to be incoming, which is equivalent to a similar convention for the Fourier transformation of all fields
Φ ( x ) = ∫ d 4 p ( 2 π ) 4 e i p x Φ ( p ) (150) \Phi(x)=\int\frac{\mathrm{d}^4p}{(2\pi)^4}e^{ipx}\Phi(p) \tag*{(150)} Φ ( x ) = ∫ ( 2 π ) 4 d 4 p e i p x Φ ( p ) (150)
Propagators
In this section we list the two-point functions and the associated regularized propagators. We express the propagators of the different fields through
G Φ i Φ j ( p ) = ( G k ( p ) ) i j (151) G_{\Phi_i\Phi_j}(p)=\left(G_k(p)\right)_{ij} \tag*{(151)} G Φ i Φ j ( p ) = ( G k ( p ) ) ij (151)
where G k ( p ) G_k(p) G k ( p ) is defined in Eq. (18) . Furthermore, we show all expressions on a non-vanishing diquark background, as this is necessary for the computation of the effective potential, see the discussion in Sec. IV D. Note than in the following we use the notation defined in Eq. (146) to denote the regularized momenta.
The gluon propagator is given by
[ G A A ( p ) ] μ ν a b = ( 1 p A 2 + m g a p 2 + m H i g g s 2 ) a b Π μ ν T ( p ) (152) \left[G_{AA}(p)\right]_{\mu\nu}^{ab}=\left(\frac{1}{p_A^2+m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2+m_{\mathrm{Higgs}}^2}\right)^{ab}\Pi_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{T}}(p) \tag*{(152)} [ G AA ( p ) ] μν ab = ( p A 2 + m gap 2 + m Higgs 2 1 ) ab Π μν T ( p ) (152)
where we already enforced Landau gauge ξ = 0 \xi=0 ξ = 0 and hence only the transverse parts remains. In presence of a non-vanishing diquark condensate, the Higgs mechanism leads to the generation of a mass term for the gluon field, which for the 2SC phase (where ⟨ Δ a ⟩ = δ a 3 ρ Δ \langle\Delta_a\rangle=\delta_{a3}\sqrt{\rho_\Delta} ⟨ Δ a ⟩ = δ a 3 ρ Δ ) reads
( m H i g g s 2 ) a b = λ A 2 Δ † Δ ρ Δ ( { T a , T b } ) 33 = λ A 2 Δ † Δ ρ Δ ( diag ( 0 , 0 , 0 , 1 2 , 1 2 , 1 2 , 1 2 , 2 3 ) ) a b . (153) \begin{aligned}
\left(m_{\mathrm{Higgs}}^2\right)^{ab}=\lambda_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta}\rho_\Delta\left(\left\{T^a,T^b\right\}\right)_{33} \\
&=\lambda_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta}\rho_\Delta\left(\operatorname{diag}\left(0,0,0,\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2},\frac{2}{3}\right)\right)^{ab}. \tag*{(153)}
\end{aligned} ( m Higgs 2 ) ab = λ A 2 Δ † Δ ρ Δ ( { T a , T b } ) 33 = λ A 2 Δ † Δ ρ Δ ( diag ( 0 , 0 , 0 , 2 1 , 2 1 , 2 1 , 2 1 , 3 2 ) ) ab . (153)
The ghost propagator reads
[ G c c ˉ ( p ) ] a b = 1 p c 2 δ a b . (154) \left[G_{c\bar c}(p)\right]^{ab}=\frac{1}{p_c^2}\delta^{ab}. \tag*{(154)} [ G c c ˉ ( p ) ] ab = p c 2 1 δ ab . (154)
The quark propagator is given by
G_{q\bar q}=-\frac{m_q-i\slashed{p}_q}{p_q^2+m_q^2+\Delta_{\mathrm{gap}}^2}P_r-\frac{m_q-i\slashed{p}_q}{p_q^2+m_q^2}P_b. \tag*{(155)}
with the quark mass m q = g ϕ q ˉ q 2 ρ ϕ m_q=g_{\phi\bar q q}\sqrt{2\rho_\phi} m q = g ϕ q ˉ q 2 ρ ϕ and the diquark gap Δ g a p = g Δ ρ Δ \Delta_{\mathrm{gap}}=g_{\Delta}\sqrt{\rho_\Delta} Δ gap = g Δ ρ Δ . Furthermore, we introduced the red-green projector P r g = diag ( 1 , 1 , 0 ) P_{rg} = \operatorname{diag}(1,1,0) P r g = diag ( 1 , 1 , 0 ) and the blue projector P b = diag ( 0 , 0 , 1 ) P_b = \operatorname{diag}(0,0,1) P b = diag ( 0 , 0 , 1 ) in color space. The pion propagators is given by
[ G π π ( p ) ] i j = δ i j p ϕ 2 + m π 2 (156) \left[G_{\pi\pi}(p)\right]_{ij} = \frac{\delta_{ij}}{p_{\phi}^{2} + m_{\pi}^{2}} \tag*{(156)} [ G π π ( p ) ] ij = p ϕ 2 + m π 2 δ ij (156)
with the pion curvature mass m π 2 = ∂ ρ ϕ U k m_{\pi}^{2} = \partial_{\rho_{\phi}} U_k m π 2 = ∂ ρ ϕ U k .
In presence of diquark condensate, there is a mixing between the two-point function of sigma meson and the diquark field. The propagator for the correct physical excitation is found by diagonalization, see Refs. [129 , 142 , 143 ] for a similar discussion in the QMD model. For simplicity, and since this procedure is only needed for the flow of the effective potential, we only show the propagators in the absence of mixing. For the σ \sigma σ -meson we find
G σ σ ( p ) = 1 p ϕ 2 + m σ 2 (157) G_{\sigma\sigma}(p) = \frac{1}{p_{\phi}^{2} + m_{\sigma}^{2}} \tag*{(157)} G σ σ ( p ) = p ϕ 2 + m σ 2 1 (157)
with the sigma curvature mass m σ 2 = ∂ ρ ϕ U k + 2 ρ ϕ ∂ ρ ϕ 2 U k m_{\sigma}^{2} = \partial_{\rho_{\phi}} U_k + 2\rho_{\phi}\partial_{\rho_{\phi}}^{2} U_k m σ 2 = ∂ ρ ϕ U k + 2 ρ ϕ ∂ ρ ϕ 2 U k , while for the diquark field we have
[ G Δ † Δ ( p ) ] a b = δ a b p Δ 2 + m Δ 2 (158) \left[G_{\Delta^{\dagger}\Delta}(p)\right]_{ab} = \frac{\delta_{ab}}{p_{\Delta}^{2} + m_{\Delta}^{2}} \tag*{(158)} [ G Δ † Δ ( p ) ] ab = p Δ 2 + m Δ 2 δ ab (158)
where the diquark curvature mass is m Δ 2 = ∂ ρ Δ U k m_{\Delta}^{2} = \partial_{\rho_{\Delta}} U_k m Δ 2 = ∂ ρ Δ U k .
Vertices
Strong coupling avatars
In the pure glue sector we only consider the classical tensor structure which are given by
[ T c c ˉ A ( 1 ) ( p , q ) ] μ a b c = i f a b c q μ (159) \left[\mathcal{T}_{c\bar{c}A}^{(1)}(p,q)\right]_{\mu}^{abc} = i f^{abc}q_{\mu} \tag*{(159)} [ T c c ˉ A ( 1 ) ( p , q ) ] μ ab c = i f ab c q μ (159)
[ T A 3 ( 1 ) ( p , q ) ] μ ν ρ a b c = i f a b c [ ( q − p ) ρ δ μ ν − ( p + 2 q ) μ δ ρ ν + ( 2 p + q ) ν δ μ ρ ] (160) \left[\mathcal{T}_{A_{3}}^{(1)}(p,q)\right]_{\mu\nu\rho}^{abc} = i f^{abc}\left[(q-p)_{\rho}\delta_{\mu\nu} - (p+2q)_{\mu}\delta_{\rho\nu} + (2p+q)_{\nu}\delta_{\mu\rho}\right] \tag*{(160)} [ T A 3 ( 1 ) ( p , q ) ] μν ρ ab c = i f ab c [ ( q − p ) ρ δ μν − ( p + 2 q ) μ δ ρ ν + ( 2 p + q ) ν δ μ ρ ] (160)
[ T A 4 ( 1 ) ] μ ν ρ σ a b c d = f e a b f e c d ( δ μ ρ δ ν σ − δ μ σ δ ν ρ ) + f e a c f e b d ( δ μ ν δ ρ σ − δ μ σ δ ν ρ ) + f e a d f e b c ( δ μ ν δ ρ σ − δ μ ρ δ ν σ ) (161) \begin{aligned}
\left[\mathcal{T}_{A_{4}}^{(1)}\right]_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}^{abcd}
={}& f^{eab}f^{ecd}\left(\delta_{\mu\rho}\delta_{\nu\sigma}-\delta_{\mu\sigma}\delta_{\nu\rho}\right) \\
&+ f^{eac}f^{ebd}\left(\delta_{\mu\nu}\delta_{\rho\sigma}-\delta_{\mu\sigma}\delta_{\nu\rho}\right) \\
&+ f^{ead}f^{ebc}\left(\delta_{\mu\nu}\delta_{\rho\sigma}-\delta_{\mu\rho}\delta_{\nu\sigma}\right) \tag*{(161)}
\end{aligned} [ T A 4 ( 1 ) ] μν ρ σ ab c d = f e ab f ec d ( δ μ ρ δ ν σ − δ μ σ δ ν ρ ) + f e a c f e b d ( δ μν δ ρ σ − δ μ σ δ ν ρ ) + f e a d f e b c ( δ μν δ ρ σ − δ μ ρ δ ν σ ) (161)
For the quark-gluon vertex, we consider the classical tensor structure
[ T A q q ˉ ( 1 ) ] μ a = i γ μ T a (162) \left[\mathcal{T}_{Aq\bar{q}}^{(1)}\right]_{\mu}^{a} = i\gamma_{\mu}T^{a} \tag*{(162)} [ T A q q ˉ ( 1 ) ] μ a = i γ μ T a (162)
and the non-classical tensor structure
\left[\mathcal{T}_{Aq\bar{q}}^{(4)}(p,q)\right]_{\mu}^{a} = -\slashed{p}\gamma_{\mu}T^{a} \tag*{(163)}
Four-quark vertices
The four-quark tensor structures are given by
[ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( s p s ) ] α β γ δ = 2 [ δ β γ δ α δ − ( τ ⃗ γ 5 ) β γ ( τ ⃗ γ 5 ) α δ − δ β δ δ α γ + ( τ ⃗ γ 5 ) β δ ( τ ⃗ γ 5 ) α γ ] (164) \left[\mathcal{T}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}^{(\mathrm{sps})}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}
= 2\left[\delta_{\beta\gamma}\delta_{\alpha\delta} - (\vec{\tau}\gamma_{5})_{\beta\gamma}(\vec{\tau}\gamma_{5})_{\alpha\delta} - \delta_{\beta\delta}\delta_{\alpha\gamma} + (\vec{\tau}\gamma_{5})_{\beta\delta}(\vec{\tau}\gamma_{5})_{\alpha\gamma}\right] \tag*{(164)} [ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( sps ) ] α β γ δ = 2 [ δ β γ δ α δ − ( τ γ 5 ) β γ ( τ γ 5 ) α δ − δ β δ δ α γ + ( τ γ 5 ) β δ ( τ γ 5 ) α γ ] (164)
[ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( c s c ) ] α β γ δ = 2 ( C γ 5 i ϵ a τ 2 ) α β ( C γ 5 i ϵ a τ 2 ) γ δ (165) \left[\mathcal{T}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}^{(\mathrm{csc})}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}
= 2(C\gamma_{5}i\epsilon_{a}\tau_{2})_{\alpha\beta}(C\gamma_{5}i\epsilon_{a}\tau_{2})_{\gamma\delta} \tag*{(165)} [ T q ˉ q q q ˉ ( csc ) ] α β γ δ = 2 ( C γ 5 i ϵ a τ 2 ) α β ( C γ 5 i ϵ a τ 2 ) γ δ (165)
Yukawa vertices
The quark-meson and quark-diquark vertices are given by
[ Γ σ q q ˉ ( 3 ) ] α β = − g ϕ q q δ α β (166) \left[\Gamma_{\sigma q\bar{q}}^{(3)}\right]_{\alpha\beta} = -g_{\phi qq}\delta_{\alpha\beta} \tag*{(166)} [ Γ σ q q ˉ ( 3 ) ] α β = − g ϕq q δ α β (166)
[ Γ π q q ˉ ( 3 ) ] i α β = − i g ϕ q q ( γ 5 τ i ) α β (167) \left[\Gamma_{\pi q\bar{q}}^{(3)}\right]_{i\alpha\beta} = -ig_{\phi qq}\left(\gamma_{5}\tau_{i}\right)_{\alpha\beta} \tag*{(167)} [ Γ π q q ˉ ( 3 ) ] i α β = − i g ϕq q ( γ 5 τ i ) α β (167)
[ Γ Δ ˉ q q ( 3 ) ] α β = − g Δ q q ( C γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a ) α β (168) \left[\Gamma_{\bar{\Delta}qq}^{(3)}\right]_{\alpha\beta} = -g_{\Delta qq}\left(C\gamma_{5}\tau_{2}i\epsilon_{a}\right)_{\alpha\beta} \tag*{(168)} [ Γ Δ ˉ q q ( 3 ) ] α β = − g Δ q q ( C γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a ) α β (168)
[ Γ Δ † q q ( 3 ) ] α β = g Δ q q ( C γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a ) α β (169) \left[\Gamma_{\Delta^{\dagger}q q}^{(3)}\right]_{\alpha\beta} = g_{\Delta qq}\left(C\gamma_{5}\tau_{2}i\epsilon_{a}\right)_{\alpha\beta} \tag*{(169)} [ Γ Δ † q q ( 3 ) ] α β = g Δ q q ( C γ 5 τ 2 i ϵ a ) α β (169)
Meson and diquark self-interactions
The effective potential U k ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) U_k(\rho_{\phi},\rho_{\Delta}) U k ( ρ ϕ , ρ Δ ) generates all the zero-momentum meson-meson, diquark-diquark and diquark-meson interactions allowed by symmetry. As discussed in Sec. IV D, we expand this potential up to tenth order in the meson and diquark fields. For the meson-meson interactions we find
[ Γ π π σ ( 3 ) ] i j = δ i j 2 ρ ϕ U k ( 2 , 0 ) (170) \left[\Gamma_{\pi\pi\sigma}^{(3)}\right]_{ij} = \delta_{ij}\sqrt{2\rho_{\phi}}U_k^{(2,0)} \tag*{(170)} [ Γ π π σ ( 3 ) ] ij = δ ij 2 ρ ϕ U k ( 2 , 0 ) (170)
[ Γ π π σ σ ( 4 ) ] i j = δ i j ( U k ( 2 , 0 ) + 2 ρ ϕ U k ( 3 , 0 ) ) (171) \left[\Gamma_{\pi\pi\sigma\sigma}^{(4)}\right]_{ij} = \delta_{ij}\left(U_k^{(2,0)} + 2\rho_{\phi}U_k^{(3,0)}\right) \tag*{(171)} [ Γ π π σ σ ( 4 ) ] ij = δ ij ( U k ( 2 , 0 ) + 2 ρ ϕ U k ( 3 , 0 ) ) (171)
[ Γ π π π π ( 4 ) ] i j k l = ( δ i j δ k l + δ i k δ j l + δ i l δ j k ) U k ( 2 , 0 ) (172) \left[\Gamma_{\pi\pi\pi\pi}^{(4)}\right]_{ijkl} = \left(\delta_{ij}\delta_{kl}+\delta_{ik}\delta_{jl}+\delta_{il}\delta_{jk}\right)U_k^{(2,0)} \tag*{(172)} [ Γ π π π π ( 4 ) ] ij k l = ( δ ij δ k l + δ ik δ j l + δ i l δ j k ) U k ( 2 , 0 ) (172)
Γ σ σ σ ( 3 ) = 2 ρ ϕ ( U k ( 2 , 0 ) + 2 ρ ϕ U k ( 3 , 0 ) ) (173) \Gamma_{\sigma\sigma\sigma}^{(3)} = \sqrt{2\rho_{\phi}}\left(U_k^{(2,0)}+2\rho_{\phi}U_k^{(3,0)}\right) \tag*{(173)} Γ σ σ σ ( 3 ) = 2 ρ ϕ ( U k ( 2 , 0 ) + 2 ρ ϕ U k ( 3 , 0 ) ) (173)
Γ σ σ σ σ ( 4 ) = 3 U k ( 2 , 0 ) + 12 ρ ϕ U k ( 3 , 0 ) + 4 ρ ϕ 2 U k ( 4 , 0 ) (174) \Gamma_{\sigma\sigma\sigma\sigma}^{(4)} = 3U_k^{(2,0)}+12\rho_{\phi}U_k^{(3,0)}+4\rho_{\phi}^{2}U_k^{(4,0)} \tag*{(174)} Γ σ σ σ σ ( 4 ) = 3 U k ( 2 , 0 ) + 12 ρ ϕ U k ( 3 , 0 ) + 4 ρ ϕ 2 U k ( 4 , 0 ) (174)
For the diquark-diquark and diquark-meson interaction, because of the vanishing diquark condensate in vacuum, the U ( 1 ) B U(1)_B U ( 1 ) B symmetry constrains every interaction to include both Δ \Delta Δ and Δ † \Delta^{\dagger} Δ † . This yields only one possible diquark-diquark interaction
[ Γ Δ † Δ † Δ Δ ( 4 ) ] a b c d = ( δ a c δ b d + δ a d δ b c ) U k ( 0 , 2 ) (175) \left[\Gamma_{\Delta^{\dagger}\Delta^{\dagger}\Delta\Delta}^{(4)}\right]_{abcd}
= \left(\delta_{ac}\delta_{bd}+\delta_{ad}\delta_{bc}\right)U_k^{(0,2)} \tag*{(175)} [ Γ Δ † Δ † ΔΔ ( 4 ) ] ab c d = ( δ a c δ b d + δ a d δ b c ) U k ( 0 , 2 ) (175)
while for the diquark-meson interactions we find
[ Γ Δ † Δ π π ( 4 ) ] a b i j = δ a b δ i j U k ( 1 , 1 ) (176) \left[\Gamma^{(4)}_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta\pi\pi}\right]_{abij}=\delta_{ab}\delta_{ij}U_k^{(1,1)} \tag*{(176)} [ Γ Δ † Δ π π ( 4 ) ] abij = δ ab δ ij U k ( 1 , 1 ) (176)
[ Γ Δ † Δ σ ( 3 ) ] a b = δ a b 2 ρ φ U k ( 1 , 1 ) (177) \left[\Gamma^{(3)}_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta\sigma}\right]_{ab}=\delta_{ab}\sqrt{2\rho_\varphi}U_k^{(1,1)} \tag*{(177)} [ Γ Δ † Δ σ ( 3 ) ] ab = δ ab 2 ρ φ U k ( 1 , 1 ) (177)
[ Γ Δ † Δ σ σ ( 4 ) ] a b = δ a b ( U k ( 1 , 1 ) + 2 ρ φ U k ( 2 , 1 ) ) (178) \left[\Gamma^{(4)}_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta\sigma\sigma}\right]_{ab}=\delta_{ab}\left(U_k^{(1,1)}+2\rho_\varphi U_k^{(2,1)}\right) \tag*{(178)} [ Γ Δ † Δ σ σ ( 4 ) ] ab = δ ab ( U k ( 1 , 1 ) + 2 ρ φ U k ( 2 , 1 ) ) (178)
Diquark-gluon vertices
Finally, the tensor structure of the diquark-gluon interaction are given by
[ Γ A Δ † Δ ( 3 ) ( p , q ) ] μ a b a = − λ A Δ † Δ ( p + 2 q ) μ ( T a ) b a (179) \left[\Gamma^{(3)}_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta}(p,q)\right]^a_{\mu ab}=-\lambda_{A\Delta^\dagger\Delta}(p+2q)_\mu(T^a)_{ba} \tag*{(179)} [ Γ A Δ † Δ ( 3 ) ( p , q ) ] μ ab a = − λ A Δ † Δ ( p + 2 q ) μ ( T a ) ba (179)
[ Γ A 2 Δ † Δ ( 4 ) ] μ ν a b a b = λ A 2 Δ † Δ δ μ ν { T a , T b } b a (180) \left[\Gamma^{(4)}_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta}\right]^{ab}_{\mu\nu ab}=\lambda_{A^2\Delta^\dagger\Delta}\delta_{\mu\nu}\left\{T^a,T^b\right\}_{ba} \tag*{(180)} [ Γ A 2 Δ † Δ ( 4 ) ] μν ab ab = λ A 2 Δ † Δ δ μν { T a , T b } ba (180)
The reversed diquark index ordering on each sides follows directly from the color antitriplet nature of the diquark field Δ \Delta Δ .
Numerical implementation
The analytic expressions of the flow equations were derived using DoFun [144 , 145 ] and traced numerically with FormTracer [146 ] . The flow equations are solved numerically in Julia [147 ] making use of the SciML ecosystem [148 ] . Numerical integration over loop momenta is performed using Gauss–Legendre quadrature with N = 192 N=192 N = 192 for the flat regulator and N = 64 N=64 N = 64 for the exponential regulators. We checked explicitly that the results do not change upon doubling the number of points. The time stepping of the system of flow equations is performed using the Tsit5 [149 ] algorithm. In such a setting, solving our system of flow equations numerically takes around ten seconds on a standard laptop, highlighting the efficiency of our approach. All figures are produced using Makie.jl [150 ] and TikZ-Feynman [151 ] .
Flow equations
For completeness, we list the analytic expressions of all flow equations used in this work. Details of the projection procedure used to derive these equations can be found in Sec. IV. A Mathematica notebook with all these equations can be found in the supplemental material.
Two-point functions
In the following, we collect the explicit expressions entering the computation of the QCD two-point functions discussed in § 3 . Throughout, all quantities are given in Euclidean space and evaluated at vanishing external spatial momentum, p = ( p 0 , 0 ⃗ ) p=(p_0,\vec{0}) p = ( p 0 , 0 ) . Furthermore, we employ a three-dimensional spatial regulator. The dimensionless momentum is defined as x = p ⃗ 2 / k 2 x=\vec{p}^{\,2}/k^2 x = p 2 / k 2 and the regulated dispersion relation of the field Φ i \Phi_i Φ i is given by
ϵ Φ i = p ⃗ 2 ( 1 + r Φ i 3 d ) + m Φ i 2 . (181) \epsilon_{\Phi_i}=\sqrt{\vec{p}^{\,2}\left(1+r_{\Phi_i}^{3d}\right)+m_{\Phi_i}^2}. \tag*{(181)} ϵ Φ i = p 2 ( 1 + r Φ i 3 d ) + m Φ i 2 . (181)
The flow equation for the dimensionless diquark two-point function reads
∂ t Γ ˉ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = ( − 2 + η Δ ) Γ ˉ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + 1 4 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 / 2 { λ 0 , 2 ( 1 + N c ) ( η Δ r Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 1 4 ϵ ˉ Δ 3 + λ 1 , 1 2 ( η φ r φ + 2 x r φ ′ ) ( 3 4 ϵ ˉ φ 3 + 1 4 ϵ ˉ φ 3 ) − 2 ρ ˉ φ , 0 λ 1 , 1 2 [ ( η φ r φ + 2 x r φ ′ ) ( ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ Δ ) 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ Δ ) + p 0 2 ϵ ˉ Δ 4 ϵ ˉ σ 3 ϵ ˉ Δ ( ( ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ Δ ) 2 + p 0 2 ) 2 + ( η Δ r Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( ϵ ˉ Δ + ϵ ˉ σ ) 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ Δ + ϵ ˉ σ ) + p 0 2 ϵ ˉ σ 4 ϵ ˉ Δ 3 ϵ ˉ σ ( ( ϵ ˉ Δ + ϵ ˉ σ ) 2 + p 0 2 ) 2 ] − g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 N f ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 1 + r q ) 1 ϵ ˉ q [ 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ q − i p 0 ) 2 + 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ q + i p 0 ) 2 ] } . (182) \begin{aligned}
\partial_t\bar{\Gamma}^{(2),E}_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}(p)
={}&\left(-2+\eta_\Delta\right)\bar{\Gamma}^{(2),E}_{\Delta^\dagger\Delta}(p)
+\frac{1}{4\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^{3/2}\Bigg\{
\lambda_{0,2}(1+N_c)(\eta_\Delta r_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)\frac{1}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta^3}\\
&+\frac{\lambda_{1,1}}{2}(\eta_\varphi r_\varphi+2xr'_\varphi)\left(\frac{3}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\varphi^3}+\frac{1}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\varphi^3}\right)\\
&-2\bar{\rho}_{\varphi,0}\lambda_{1,1}^2\left[
\frac{(\eta_\varphi r_\varphi+2xr'_\varphi)(\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma+\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta)^2(2\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma+\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta)+p_0^2\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma^3\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta\left((\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma+\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta)^2+p_0^2\right)^2}\right.\\
&\left.\qquad+\frac{(\eta_\Delta r_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)(\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta+\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma)^2(2\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta+\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma)+p_0^2\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta^3\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma\left((\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta+\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma)^2+p_0^2\right)^2}
\right]\\
&-g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}^2N_f(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)(1+r_q)\frac{1}{\bar{\epsilon}_q}
\left[\frac{2}{(2\bar{\epsilon}_q-ip_0)^2}+\frac{2}{(2\bar{\epsilon}_q+ip_0)^2}\right]
\Bigg\}. \tag*{(182)}
\end{aligned} ∂ t Γ ˉ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = ( − 2 + η Δ ) Γ ˉ Δ † Δ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + 4 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3/2 { λ 0 , 2 ( 1 + N c ) ( η Δ r Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 4 ϵ ˉ Δ 3 1 + 2 λ 1 , 1 ( η φ r φ + 2 x r φ ′ ) ( 4 ϵ ˉ φ 3 3 + 4 ϵ ˉ φ 3 1 ) − 2 ρ ˉ φ , 0 λ 1 , 1 2 [ 4 ϵ ˉ σ 3 ϵ ˉ Δ ( ( ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ Δ ) 2 + p 0 2 ) 2 ( η φ r φ + 2 x r φ ′ ) ( ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ Δ ) 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ Δ ) + p 0 2 ϵ ˉ Δ + 4 ϵ ˉ Δ 3 ϵ ˉ σ ( ( ϵ ˉ Δ + ϵ ˉ σ ) 2 + p 0 2 ) 2 ( η Δ r Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( ϵ ˉ Δ + ϵ ˉ σ ) 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ Δ + ϵ ˉ σ ) + p 0 2 ϵ ˉ σ ] − g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 N f ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 1 + r q ) ϵ ˉ q 1 [ ( 2 ϵ ˉ q − i p 0 ) 2 2 + ( 2 ϵ ˉ q + i p 0 ) 2 2 ] } . (182)
The corresponding flow equations for the dimensionless pion and sigma two-point functions are given by
∂ t Γ ˉ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = ( − 2 + η ϕ ) Γ ˉ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + 1 4 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 / 2 { λ 1 , 1 N c ( η Δ r Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 1 4 ϵ ˉ Δ 3 + 1 2 ( η ϕ r ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( 3 λ 2 , 0 4 ϵ ˉ π 3 + λ 2 , 0 + 2 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 3 , 0 4 ϵ ˉ σ 3 ) \partial_t\bar{\Gamma}^{(2),E}_{\pi\pi}(p)=(-2+\eta_\phi)\bar{\Gamma}^{(2),E}_{\pi\pi}(p)+\frac{1}{4\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^{3/2}\{\lambda_{1,1}N_c(\eta_\Delta r_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)\frac{1}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta^3}+\frac{1}{2}(\eta_\phi r_\phi+2xr'_\phi)(\frac{3\lambda_{2,0}}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\pi^3}+\frac{\lambda_{2,0}+2\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}\bar{\lambda}_{3,0}}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma^3}) ∂ t Γ ˉ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = ( − 2 + η ϕ ) Γ ˉ π π ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + 4 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3/2 { λ 1 , 1 N c ( η Δ r Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 4 ϵ ˉ Δ 3 1 + 2 1 ( η ϕ r ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( 4 ϵ ˉ π 3 3 λ 2 , 0 + 4 ϵ ˉ σ 3 λ 2 , 0 + 2 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 3 , 0 )
− 2 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 2 , 0 2 ( η ϕ r ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) [ ( ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ π ) 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ π ) + p 0 2 ϵ ˉ π 4 ϵ ˉ σ 3 ϵ ˉ π ( ( ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ π ) 2 + p 0 2 ) 2 + ( ϵ ˉ π + ϵ ˉ σ ) 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ π + ϵ ˉ σ ) + p 0 2 ϵ ˉ σ 4 ϵ ˉ π 3 ϵ ˉ σ ( ( ϵ ˉ π + ϵ ˉ σ ) 2 + p 0 2 ) 2 ] -2\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}\bar{\lambda}_{2,0}^2(\eta_\phi r_\phi+2xr'_\phi)\left[\frac{(\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma+\bar{\epsilon}_\pi)^2(2\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma+\bar{\epsilon}_\pi)+p_0^2\bar{\epsilon}_\pi}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma^3\bar{\epsilon}_\pi((\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma+\bar{\epsilon}_\pi)^2+p_0^2)^2}+\frac{(\bar{\epsilon}_\pi+\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma)^2(2\bar{\epsilon}_\pi+\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma)+p_0^2\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\pi^3\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma((\bar{\epsilon}_\pi+\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma)^2+p_0^2)^2}\right] − 2 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 2 , 0 2 ( η ϕ r ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) [ 4 ϵ ˉ σ 3 ϵ ˉ π (( ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ π ) 2 + p 0 2 ) 2 ( ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ π ) 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ σ + ϵ ˉ π ) + p 0 2 ϵ ˉ π + 4 ϵ ˉ π 3 ϵ ˉ σ (( ϵ ˉ π + ϵ ˉ σ ) 2 + p 0 2 ) 2 ( ϵ ˉ π + ϵ ˉ σ ) 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ π + ϵ ˉ σ ) + p 0 2 ϵ ˉ σ ]
− g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 N f N c ( η q r q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 1 + r q ) 1 ϵ ˉ q [ 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ q − i p 0 ) 2 + 2 ( 2 ϵ ˉ q + i p 0 ) 2 ] } . (183) -g_{\phi\bar{q}\bar{q}}^2N_fN_c(\eta_qr_q+2xr'_q)(1+r_q)\frac{1}{\bar{\epsilon}_q}[\frac{2}{(2\bar{\epsilon}_q-ip_0)^2}+\frac{2}{(2\bar{\epsilon}_q+ip_0)^2}]\}. \tag*{(183)} − g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 N f N c ( η q r q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 1 + r q ) ϵ ˉ q 1 [ ( 2 ϵ ˉ q − i p 0 ) 2 2 + ( 2 ϵ ˉ q + i p 0 ) 2 2 ]} . (183)
and
∂ t Γ ˉ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = ( − 2 + η ϕ ) Γ ˉ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + 1 4 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 / 2 { − 2 N c ( η Δ r Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) p 0 2 + 12 ϵ ˉ Δ 2 4 ϵ ˉ Δ 3 ( p 0 2 + 4 ϵ ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 \partial_t\bar{\Gamma}^{(2),E}_{\sigma\sigma}(p)=(-2+\eta_\phi)\bar{\Gamma}^{(2),E}_{\sigma\sigma}(p)+\frac{1}{4\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^{3/2}\{-2N_c(\eta_\Delta r_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)\frac{p_0^2+12\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta^2}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta^3(p_0^2+4\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta^2)^2} ∂ t Γ ˉ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) = ( − 2 + η ϕ ) Γ ˉ σ σ ( 2 ) , E ( p ) + 4 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3/2 { − 2 N c ( η Δ r Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 4 ϵ ˉ Δ 3 ( p 0 2 + 4 ϵ ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 p 0 2 + 12 ϵ ˉ Δ 2
− ( η ϕ r ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) 2 ρ ˉ 0 ( 3 λ ˉ 2 , 0 1 4 ϵ ˉ π 3 p 0 2 + 12 ϵ ˉ π 2 ( p 0 2 + 4 ϵ ˉ π 2 ) 2 + ( λ 2 , 0 + 2 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 3 , 0 ) 1 4 ϵ ˉ σ 3 p 0 2 + 12 ϵ ˉ σ 2 ( p 0 2 + 4 ϵ ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ) + 1 2 ( η ϕ r ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( 3 λ 2 , 0 + 2 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 3 , 0 4 ϵ ˉ π 3 + 3 λ 2 , 0 + 12 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 3 , 0 + 4 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 2 λ ˉ 4 , 0 4 ϵ ˉ σ 3 ) + N c ( η Δ r Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) λ 1 , 1 + 2 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 2 , 1 4 ϵ ˉ Δ + 8 N f N c g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( η q r q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 1 + r q ) 1 ϵ ˉ q 3 8 ϵ ˉ q 4 + 2 ( p 0 2 − 6 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ) ϵ ˉ q 2 − p 0 2 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( p 0 2 + 4 ϵ ˉ q 2 ) 2 } . (184) \begin{aligned}
-(\eta_\phi r_\phi+2xr'_\phi)2\bar{\rho}_0\left(3\bar{\lambda}_{2,0}\frac{1}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\pi^3}\frac{p_0^2+12\bar{\epsilon}_\pi^2}{(p_0^2+4\bar{\epsilon}_\pi^2)^2}+(\lambda_{2,0}+2\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}\bar{\lambda}_{3,0})\frac{1}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma^3}\frac{p_0^2+12\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma^2}{(p_0^2+4\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma^2)^2}\right) \\
&+\frac{1}{2}(\eta_\phi r_\phi+2xr'_\phi)\left(3\frac{\lambda_{2,0}+2\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}\bar{\lambda}_{3,0}}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\pi^3}+\frac{3\lambda_{2,0}+12\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}\bar{\lambda}_{3,0}+4\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}^2\bar{\lambda}_{4,0}}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\sigma^3}\right)+N_c(\eta_\Delta r_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)\frac{\lambda_{1,1}+2\bar{\rho}_{\phi,0}\bar{\lambda}_{2,1}}{4\bar{\epsilon}_\Delta} \\
&+8N_fN_cg_{\phi\bar{q}\bar{q}}^2(\eta_qr_q+2xr'_q)(1+r_q)\frac{1}{\bar{\epsilon}_q^3}\frac{8\bar{\epsilon}_q^4+2(p_0^2-6x(1+r_q)^2)\bar{\epsilon}_q^2-p_0^2x(1+r_q)^2}{(p_0^2+4\bar{\epsilon}_q^2)^2}\}. \tag*{(184)}
\end{aligned} − ( η ϕ r ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) 2 ρ ˉ 0 ( 3 λ ˉ 2 , 0 4 ϵ ˉ π 3 1 ( p 0 2 + 4 ϵ ˉ π 2 ) 2 p 0 2 + 12 ϵ ˉ π 2 + ( λ 2 , 0 + 2 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 3 , 0 ) 4 ϵ ˉ σ 3 1 ( p 0 2 + 4 ϵ ˉ σ 2 ) 2 p 0 2 + 12 ϵ ˉ σ 2 ) + 2 1 ( η ϕ r ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( 3 4 ϵ ˉ π 3 λ 2 , 0 + 2 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 3 , 0 + 4 ϵ ˉ σ 3 3 λ 2 , 0 + 12 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 3 , 0 + 4 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 2 λ ˉ 4 , 0 ) + N c ( η Δ r Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 4 ϵ ˉ Δ λ 1 , 1 + 2 ρ ˉ ϕ , 0 λ ˉ 2 , 1 + 8 N f N c g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( η q r q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 1 + r q ) ϵ ˉ q 3 1 ( p 0 2 + 4 ϵ ˉ q 2 ) 2 8 ϵ ˉ q 4 + 2 ( p 0 2 − 6 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ) ϵ ˉ q 2 − p 0 2 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 } . (184)
Zero-momentum expansion
Effective potential
The flow of the effective potential is given by
∂ t U ˉ k = − 4 U ˉ k + ( 2 + η ϕ ) ρ ˉ ϕ ∂ ρ ˉ ϕ U ˉ k + ( 2 + η Δ ) ρ ˉ Δ ∂ ρ ˉ Δ U ˉ k + 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { 8 ( r c η c + 2 x r c ′ ) x ( 1 + r c ) + 8 ( 1 + r q ) ( 2 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 + m ˉ q 2 + 3 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 + m ˉ q 2 + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ρ ˉ Δ ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) \partial_t\bar{U}_k=-4\bar{U}_k+(2+\eta_\phi)\bar{\rho}_\phi\partial_{\bar{\rho}_\phi}\bar{U}_k+(2+\eta_\Delta)\bar{\rho}_\Delta\partial_{\bar{\rho}_\Delta}\bar{U}_k+\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^3\{8\frac{(r_c\eta_c+2xr'_c)}{x(1+r_c)}+8(1+r_q)(\frac{2}{x(1+r_q)^2+\bar{m}_q^2}+\frac{3}{x(1+r_q)^2+\bar{m}_q^2+g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}^2\bar{\rho}_\Delta})(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q) ∂ t U ˉ k = − 4 U ˉ k + ( 2 + η ϕ ) ρ ˉ ϕ ∂ ρ ˉ ϕ U ˉ k + ( 2 + η Δ ) ρ ˉ Δ ∂ ρ ˉ Δ U ˉ k + 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { 8 x ( 1 + r c ) ( r c η c + 2 x r c ′ ) + 8 ( 1 + r q ) ( x ( 1 + r q ) 2 + m ˉ q 2 2 + x ( 1 + r q ) 2 + m ˉ q 2 + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ρ ˉ Δ 3 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ )
− 3 2 ( 4 x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 + 1 x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 + 1 2 λ A 2 Δ † Δ ρ ˉ Δ + 1 x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 + 2 3 λ A 2 Δ † Δ ρ ˉ Δ ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( − 2 x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 − ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 3 2 ) − χ ˉ ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 3 2 ) − 2 χ ˉ ) ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) + 1 2 ( − 3 x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 − x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 3 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) ( ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 3 2 ) − 2 χ ˉ ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) } . (185) \begin{aligned}
-\frac{3}{2}\left(\frac{4}{x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2}+\frac{1}{x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2+\frac{1}{2}\lambda_{A2\Delta^\dagger\Delta}\bar{\rho}_\Delta}+\frac{1}{x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2+\frac{2}{3}\lambda_{A2\Delta^\dagger\Delta}\bar{\rho}_\Delta}\right)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A) \\
&+\left(-\frac{2}{x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2}-\frac{(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\sigma^2)(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_{\Delta_3}^2)-\bar{\chi}}{(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)((x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\sigma^2)(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_{\Delta_3}^2)-2\bar{\chi})}\right)(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta) \\
&+\frac{1}{2}(-\frac{3}{x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\pi^2}-\frac{x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_{\Delta_3}^2}{(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\sigma^2)((x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_{\Delta_3}^2)-2\bar{\chi})})(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)\}. \tag*{(185)}
\end{aligned} − 2 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 4 + x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 + 2 1 λ A 2 Δ † Δ ρ ˉ Δ 1 + x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 + 3 2 λ A 2 Δ † Δ ρ ˉ Δ 1 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( − x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 2 − ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) (( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 3 2 ) − 2 χ ˉ ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 3 2 ) − χ ˉ ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) + 2 1 ( − x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 3 − ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) (( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 3 2 ) − 2 χ ˉ ) x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 3 2 ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ )} . (185)
Note that, in this subsection only, we allow for a non-vanishing diquark field configuration ρ Δ \rho_\Delta ρ Δ ; see Sec. IV D for details. Furthermore, we introduce the mass of the third diquark in the absence of σ \sigma σ -Δ \Delta Δ mixing, m Δ 3 2 = λ 0 , 1 + ρ Δ λ 0 , 2 m_{\Delta_3}^2=\lambda_{0,1}+\rho_\Delta\lambda_{0,2} m Δ 3 2 = λ 0 , 1 + ρ Δ λ 0 , 2 and the mixing parameter χ = 2 ρ ϕ ρ Δ λ 1 , 1 \chi=2\rho_\phi\rho_\Delta\lambda_{1,1} χ = 2 ρ ϕ ρ Δ λ 1 , 1 .
Anomalous dimensions
η c = 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { λ A c ˉ c 2 ( 9 ( r c η c + 2 x r c ′ ) 4 x 2 ( 1 + r c ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) + 9 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 4 x ( 1 + r c ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ) } . (186) \eta_c=\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^3\left\{\lambda_{A\bar{c}c}^2\left(\frac{9(r_c\eta_c+2xr'_c)}{4x^2(1+r_c)^2(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)}+\frac{9(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{4x(1+r_c)(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2}\right)\right\}. \tag*{(186)} η c = 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { λ A c ˉ c 2 ( 4 x 2 ( 1 + r c ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 9 ( r c η c + 2 x r c ′ ) + 4 x ( 1 + r c ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 9 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) } . (186)
η A = 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { 24 ( 1 + r q ) 2 m ˉ q λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 − 16 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 + λ A c ˉ c 2 ( r c η c + 2 x r c ′ ) ( 1 + r c 2 + x r c ′ − 2 x 2 ( r c ′ ) 2 + x 2 r c ′ ′ + r c ( 2 + x r c ′ + x 2 r c ′ ′ ) ) 2 x 3 ( 1 + r c ) 5 − 1 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 5 8 ( λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( ( 1 + r q ) 3 ( x 2 + 4 x r q 3 + x 2 r q 4 + 2 x m ˉ q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 4 + 4 x r q ( x + m ˉ q 2 ) + 2 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ q 2 ) ) + ( x 3 + 6 x 3 r q 5 + x 3 r q 6 + 5 x 2 m ˉ q 2 + 15 x m ˉ q 4 + 3 m ˉ q 6 + 20 x 2 r q 3 ( x + m ˉ q 2 ) + 15 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + 5 x 2 r q 4 ( 3 x + m ˉ q 2 ) + 2 x r q ( 3 x 2 + 10 x m ˉ q 2 + 15 m ˉ q 4 ) r q ′ − 2 x 3 ( 1 + r q ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 5 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q ′ ) 2 + x ( x 3 + 6 x 3 r q 5 + x 3 r q 6 + 5 x 2 m ˉ q 2 + 5 x m ˉ q 4 + m ˉ q 6 + 20 x r q 3 ( x + m ˉ q 2 ) + 5 x r q 2 ( 3 x + m ˉ q 2 ) + 5 x r q 2 ( 3 x + 6 x m ˉ q 2 + m ˉ q 4 ) + 2 x r q ( 3 x 2 + 10 x m ˉ q 2 + 5 m ˉ q 4 ) r q ′ ′ ) + 1 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 5 λ A 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( 25 x 2 + 25 x r A 2 + 44 x m ˉ g a p 2 + 31 m ˉ g a p 4 − 6 x 2 ( x + 5 m ˉ g a p 2 ) r A ′ + 12 x 4 ( r A ′ ) 2 − 6 x 4 r A ′ ′ − 6 x 3 m ˉ g a p 2 r A ′ ′ + 2 x r A ( 25 x + 22 m ˉ g a p 2 − 3 x r A ′ − 3 x 3 r A ′ ′ ) ) − 1 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 5 x λ A Δ ˉ Δ 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ 2 + 3 m ˉ Δ 2 + x ( x + 5 m ˉ Δ 2 ) r Δ ′ − 2 x 3 ( r Δ ′ ) 2 + x 3 r Δ ′ ′ + x 2 m ˉ Δ 2 r Δ ′ ′ + r Δ ( 2 x + 3 m ˉ Δ 2 + x 2 r Δ ′ + x 3 r Δ ′ ′ ) ) } . (187) \eta_A=\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^3\{\frac{24(1+r_q)^2\bar m_q\lambda_{A\bar q q}^{(1)}\lambda_{A\bar q q}^{(4)}(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3}-\frac{16(1+r_q)\bar m_q^2(\lambda_{A\bar q q}^{(4)})^2(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3}+\frac{\lambda_{A\bar c c}^2(r_c\eta_c+2xr'_c)(1+r_c^2+xr'_c-2x^2(r'_c)^2+x^2r''_c+r_c(2+xr'_c+x^2r''_c))}{2x^3(1+r_c)^5}-\frac{1}{3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^5}8(\lambda_{A\bar q q}^{(1)})^2(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)((1+r_q)^3(x^2+4xr_q^3+x^2r_q^4+2x\bar m_q^2+3\bar m_q^4+4xr_q(x+\bar m_q^2)+2xr_q^2(x+\bar m_q^2))+(x^3+6x^3r_q^5+x^3r_q^6+5x^2\bar m_q^2+15x\bar m_q^4+3\bar m_q^6+20x^2r_q^3(x+\bar m_q^2)+15xr_q^2(x+\bar m_q^2)^2+5x^2r_q^4(3x+\bar m_q^2)+2xr_q(3x^2+10x\bar m_q^2+15\bar m_q^4)r'_q-2x^3(1+r_q)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+5\bar m_q^2)(r'_q)^2+x(x^3+6x^3r_q^5+x^3r_q^6+5x^2\bar m_q^2+5x\bar m_q^4+\bar m_q^6+20xr_q^3(x+\bar m_q^2)+5xr_q^2(3x+\bar m_q^2)+5xr_q^2(3x+6x\bar m_q^2+\bar m_q^4)+2xr_q(3x^2+10x\bar m_q^2+5\bar m_q^4)r''_q)+\frac{1}{2(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^5}\lambda_A^2(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)(25x^2+25xr_A^2+44x\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2+31\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^4-6x^2(x+5\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)r'_A+12x^4(r'_A)^2-6x^4r''_A-6x^3\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2r''_A+2xr_A(25x+22\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2-3xr'_A-3x^3r''_A))-\frac{1}{3(x+xr_A+\bar m_\Delta^2)^5}x\lambda_{A\bar\Delta\Delta}^2(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)(x+xr_\Delta^2+3\bar m_\Delta^2+x(x+5\bar m_\Delta^2)r'_\Delta-2x^3(r'_\Delta)^2+x^3r''_\Delta+x^2\bar m_\Delta^2r''_\Delta+r_\Delta(2x+3\bar m_\Delta^2+x^2r'_\Delta+x^3r''_\Delta))\}. \tag*{(187)} η A = 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 24 ( 1 + r q ) 2 m ˉ q λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 16 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 2 x 3 ( 1 + r c ) 5 λ A c ˉ c 2 ( r c η c + 2 x r c ′ ) ( 1 + r c 2 + x r c ′ − 2 x 2 ( r c ′ ) 2 + x 2 r c ′′ + r c ( 2 + x r c ′ + x 2 r c ′′ )) − 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 5 1 8 ( λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) (( 1 + r q ) 3 ( x 2 + 4 x r q 3 + x 2 r q 4 + 2 x m ˉ q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 4 + 4 x r q ( x + m ˉ q 2 ) + 2 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ q 2 )) + ( x 3 + 6 x 3 r q 5 + x 3 r q 6 + 5 x 2 m ˉ q 2 + 15 x m ˉ q 4 + 3 m ˉ q 6 + 20 x 2 r q 3 ( x + m ˉ q 2 ) + 15 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + 5 x 2 r q 4 ( 3 x + m ˉ q 2 ) + 2 x r q ( 3 x 2 + 10 x m ˉ q 2 + 15 m ˉ q 4 ) r q ′ − 2 x 3 ( 1 + r q ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 5 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q ′ ) 2 + x ( x 3 + 6 x 3 r q 5 + x 3 r q 6 + 5 x 2 m ˉ q 2 + 5 x m ˉ q 4 + m ˉ q 6 + 20 x r q 3 ( x + m ˉ q 2 ) + 5 x r q 2 ( 3 x + m ˉ q 2 ) + 5 x r q 2 ( 3 x + 6 x m ˉ q 2 + m ˉ q 4 ) + 2 x r q ( 3 x 2 + 10 x m ˉ q 2 + 5 m ˉ q 4 ) r q ′′ ) + 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 5 1 λ A 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( 25 x 2 + 25 x r A 2 + 44 x m ˉ gap 2 + 31 m ˉ gap 4 − 6 x 2 ( x + 5 m ˉ gap 2 ) r A ′ + 12 x 4 ( r A ′ ) 2 − 6 x 4 r A ′′ − 6 x 3 m ˉ gap 2 r A ′′ + 2 x r A ( 25 x + 22 m ˉ gap 2 − 3 x r A ′ − 3 x 3 r A ′′ )) − 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 5 1 x λ A Δ ˉ Δ 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ 2 + 3 m ˉ Δ 2 + x ( x + 5 m ˉ Δ 2 ) r Δ ′ − 2 x 3 ( r Δ ′ ) 2 + x 3 r Δ ′′ + x 2 m ˉ Δ 2 r Δ ′′ + r Δ ( 2 x + 3 m ˉ Δ 2 + x 2 r Δ ′ + x 3 r Δ ′′ ))} . (187)
η q = 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { ( λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 [ ( − 12 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 + 12 x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( m ˉ g a p 2 − x 2 r A ′ ) x ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ] + λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) [ − 4 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( 1 + r q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 − 8 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + 2 m ˉ g a p 2 − x 2 r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ] + ( λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) ) 2 [ − 2 x 2 ( ( 1 + r q ) 3 + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 2 x + 2 x r A + 3 m ˉ g a p 2 − x 2 r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ] + g Δ q ˉ q 2 [ − ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 1 + r Δ + x r Δ ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 + ( − 6 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 2 m ˉ q 2 ) + 6 x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 6 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ] + g ϕ q ˉ q 2 [ − 1 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 1 + r ϕ + x r ϕ ′ ) + 1 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( − ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 2 m ˉ q 2 ) + x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ] } . (188) \eta_q=\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^3\left\{(\lambda_{A\bar q q}^{(1)})^2\left[\frac{(-12(1+r_q)\bar m_q^2+12x(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar m_q^2)r'_q)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{6(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}+\frac{2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar m_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)(\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2-x^2r'_A)}{x(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}\right]+\lambda_{A\bar q q}^{(1)}\lambda_{A\bar q q}^{(4)}\left[-\frac{4x(1+r_q)\bar m_q(1+r_q+2xr'_q)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}-\frac{8(1+r_q)\bar m_q(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)(x+xr_A+2\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2-x^2r'_A)}{(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}\right]+(\lambda_{A\bar q q}^{(4)})^2\left[-\frac{2x^2((1+r_q)^3+(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar m_q^2)r'_q)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}+\frac{2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar m_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)(2x+2xr_A+3\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2-x^2r'_A)}{(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}\right]+g_{\Delta\bar q q}^2\left[-\frac{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar m_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)(1+r_\Delta+xr'_\Delta)}{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^2}+\frac{(-6(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+2\bar m_q^2)+6x(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar m_q^2)r'_q)(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{6(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^2}\right]+g_{\phi\bar q q}^2\left[-\frac{1}{2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar m_q^2)(4x^2+4xr_\phi^2+2x\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\pi^4+6x\bar m_\sigma^2+3\bar m_\sigma^4+2xr_\phi(4x+\bar m_\pi^2+3\bar m_\sigma^2))(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)(1+r_\phi+xr'_\phi)+\frac{1}{2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}(4x^2+4xr_\phi^2+2x\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\pi^4+6x\bar m_\sigma^2+3\bar m_\sigma^4+2xr_\phi(4x+\bar m_\pi^2+3\bar m_\sigma^2))(-(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+2\bar m_q^2)+x(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar m_q^2)r'_q)(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)\right]\right\}. \tag*{(188)} η q = 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { ( λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 [ 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( − 12 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 + 12 x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + x ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( m ˉ gap 2 − x 2 r A ′ ) ] + λ A q ˉ q ( 1 ) λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) [ − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 4 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( 1 + r q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 8 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + 2 m ˉ gap 2 − x 2 r A ′ ) ] + ( λ A q ˉ q ( 4 ) ) 2 [ − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 2 x 2 (( 1 + r q ) 3 + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 2 x + 2 x r A + 3 m ˉ gap 2 − x 2 r A ′ ) ] + g Δ q ˉ q 2 [ − ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 1 + r Δ + x r Δ ′ ) + 6 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( − 6 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 2 m ˉ q 2 ) + 6 x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ] + g ϕ q ˉ q 2 [ − 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 1 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 1 + r ϕ + x r ϕ ′ ) + 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 1 ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( − ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 2 m ˉ q 2 ) + x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ] } . (188)
η ϕ = 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { − 1 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 24 g ϕ q ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( ( 1 + r q ) 3 + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ − 2 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( r q ′ ) 2 + x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ ′ ) − g ˉ σ 0 2 λ σ 0 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( x m ˉ π 2 + x m ˉ σ 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 2 x ( x m ˉ σ 2 + m ˉ π 2 ( x + 2 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) r ϕ ′ − x 3 ( 2 x + m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r ϕ ′ ) 2 + x 4 r ϕ ′ ′ + x 3 m ˉ π 2 r ϕ ′ ′ + x 3 m ˉ σ 2 r ϕ ′ ′ + x 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 r ϕ ′ ′ + x r ϕ 2 ( m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ σ 2 + x 3 r ϕ ′ ′ ) + r ϕ ( 2 x m ˉ σ 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 ( x + m ˉ σ 2 ) + 2 x 2 ( m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ σ 2 ) r ϕ ′ − 2 x 4 ( r ϕ ′ ) 2 + x 3 ( 2 x + m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ σ 2 ) r ϕ ′ ′ ) ) } . (189) \eta_\phi=\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^3\left\{-\frac{1}{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3}24g_{\phi\bar q q}^2(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)\left((1+r_q)^3+(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+3\bar m_q^2)r'_q-2x^2(1+r_q)(r'_q)^2+x(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)r''_q\right)-\frac{\bar g_{\sigma0}^2\lambda_{\sigma0}^2}{(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)^3(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}\left(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi\right)\left(x\bar m_\pi^2+x\bar m_\sigma^2+2\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2+2x(x\bar m_\sigma^2+\bar m_\pi^2(x+2\bar m_\sigma^2))r'_\phi-x^3(2x+\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\sigma^2)(r'_\phi)^2+x^4r''_\phi+x^3\bar m_\pi^2r''_\phi+x^3\bar m_\sigma^2r''_\phi+x^2\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2r''_\phi+xr_\phi^2(\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\sigma^2+x^3r''_\phi)+r_\phi(2x\bar m_\sigma^2+2\bar m_\pi^2(x+\bar m_\sigma^2)+2x^2(\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\sigma^2)r'_\phi-2x^4(r'_\phi)^2+x^3(2x+\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\sigma^2)r''_\phi)\right)\right\}. \tag*{(189)} η ϕ = 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { − ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 1 24 g ϕ q ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( ( 1 + r q ) 3 + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ − 2 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( r q ′ ) 2 + x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′′ ) − ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 g ˉ σ 0 2 λ σ 0 2 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( x m ˉ π 2 + x m ˉ σ 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 2 x ( x m ˉ σ 2 + m ˉ π 2 ( x + 2 m ˉ σ 2 )) r ϕ ′ − x 3 ( 2 x + m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r ϕ ′ ) 2 + x 4 r ϕ ′′ + x 3 m ˉ π 2 r ϕ ′′ + x 3 m ˉ σ 2 r ϕ ′′ + x 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 r ϕ ′′ + x r ϕ 2 ( m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ σ 2 + x 3 r ϕ ′′ ) + r ϕ ( 2 x m ˉ σ 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 ( x + m ˉ σ 2 ) + 2 x 2 ( m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ σ 2 ) r ϕ ′ − 2 x 4 ( r ϕ ′ ) 2 + x 3 ( 2 x + m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ σ 2 ) r ϕ ′′ ) ) } . (189)
η Δ = 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { λ Δ Δ Δ 2 [ 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) + 4 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ] − 8 g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( ( 1 + r q ) 3 + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ − 2 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( r q ′ ) 2 + x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 − σ ˉ 0 2 λ 1 , 1 2 [ ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( 2 m ˉ Δ 2 + 4 x m ˉ Δ 2 r Δ ′ − 2 x 3 ( r Δ ′ ) 2 + x 3 r Δ ′ ′ + x 2 m ˉ Δ 2 r Δ ′ ′ + r Δ ( 2 m ˉ Δ 2 + x 3 r Δ ′ ′ ) ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 2 + ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( 2 m ˉ ϕ 2 + 4 x m ˉ ϕ 2 r ϕ ′ − 2 x 3 ( r ϕ ′ ) 2 + x 3 r ϕ ′ ′ + x 2 m ˉ ϕ 2 r ϕ ′ ′ + r ϕ ( 2 m ˉ ϕ 2 + x 3 r ϕ ′ ′ ) ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 3 ] } . (190) \eta_{\Delta}=\frac{1}{16\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}dx\,x^{3}\left\{\lambda_{\Delta\Delta\Delta}^{2}\left[\frac{4(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})}+\frac{4(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{2}}\right]-\frac{8g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{2}(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})\left((1+r_{q})^{3}+(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+3\bar{m}_{q}^{2})r'_{q}-2x^{2}(1+r_{q})(r'_{q})^{2}+x(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})r''_{q}\right)}{(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{3}}-\bar{\sigma}_{0}^{2}\lambda_{1,1}^{2}\left[\frac{(r_{\phi}\eta_{\phi}+2xr'_{\phi})(2\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2}+4x\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2}r'_{\Delta}-2x^{3}(r'_{\Delta})^{2}+x^{3}r''_{\Delta}+x^{2}\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2}r''_{\Delta}+r_{\Delta}(2\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2}+x^{3}r''_{\Delta}))}{2(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{3}(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\phi}^{2})^{2}}+\frac{(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})(2\bar{m}_{\phi}^{2}+4x\bar{m}_{\phi}^{2}r'_{\phi}-2x^{3}(r'_{\phi})^{2}+x^{3}r''_{\phi}+x^{2}\bar{m}_{\phi}^{2}r''_{\phi}+r_{\phi}(2\bar{m}_{\phi}^{2}+x^{3}r''_{\phi}))}{2(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{2}(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\phi}^{2})^{3}}\right]\right\}. \tag*{(190)} η Δ = 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { λ ΔΔΔ 2 [ ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 4 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ] − ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 8 g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( ( 1 + r q ) 3 + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′ − 2 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( r q ′ ) 2 + x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) r q ′′ ) − σ ˉ 0 2 λ 1 , 1 2 [ 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 2 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( 2 m ˉ Δ 2 + 4 x m ˉ Δ 2 r Δ ′ − 2 x 3 ( r Δ ′ ) 2 + x 3 r Δ ′′ + x 2 m ˉ Δ 2 r Δ ′′ + r Δ ( 2 m ˉ Δ 2 + x 3 r Δ ′′ )) + 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 3 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( 2 m ˉ ϕ 2 + 4 x m ˉ ϕ 2 r ϕ ′ − 2 x 3 ( r ϕ ′ ) 2 + x 3 r ϕ ′′ + x 2 m ˉ ϕ 2 r ϕ ′′ + r ϕ ( 2 m ˉ ϕ 2 + x 3 r ϕ ′′ )) ] } . (190)
Strong coupling avatars and gluon mass gap
∂ t m ˉ g a p 2 = ( − 2 + η A ) m ˉ g a p 2 + 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { 3 λ A ˉ c c 2 ( r c η c + 2 x r c ′ ) 2 x 2 ( 1 + r c ) 3 − 4 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 2 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 − 9 x λ A 3 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 + 27 λ A 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 − x λ Δ Δ 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 + λ A 2 Δ Δ ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 } . (191) \partial_{t}\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2}=(-2+\eta_{A})\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2}+\frac{1}{16\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}dx\,x^{3}\left\{\frac{3\lambda_{\bar{A}cc}^{2}(r_{c}\eta_{c}+2xr'_{c})}{2x^{2}(1+r_{c})^{3}}-\frac{4(1+r_{q})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+3\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(1)})^{2}(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{3}}-\frac{9x\lambda_{A^{3}}^{2}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{3}}+\frac{27\lambda_{A^{4}}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{4(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}}-\frac{x\lambda_{\Delta\Delta}^{2}(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{3}}+\frac{\lambda_{A^{2}\Delta\Delta}(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{2}}\right\}. \tag*{(191)} ∂ t m ˉ gap 2 = ( − 2 + η A ) m ˉ gap 2 + 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ 2 x 2 ( 1 + r c ) 3 3 λ A ˉ cc 2 ( r c η c + 2 x r c ′ ) − ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 4 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 2 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 9 x λ A 3 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 27 λ A 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 x λ ΔΔ 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) + ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 λ A 2 ΔΔ ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ⎭ ⎬ ⎫ . (191)
∂ t λ A 3 = 3 2 η A λ A 3 + 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { − 3 λ A ˉ c c 2 ( r c η c + 2 x r c ′ ) 8 x 3 ( 1 + r c ) 4 + 4 ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 2 m ˉ q 2 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 3 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 4 − 16 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 4 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 + 9 x λ A 3 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 4 − 45 λ A 3 λ A 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 + x λ Δ Δ 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 4 } . (192) \partial_{t}\lambda_{A^{3}}=\frac{3}{2}\eta_{A}\lambda_{A^{3}}+\frac{1}{16\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}dx\,x^{3}\left\{-\frac{3\lambda_{\bar{A}cc}^{2}(r_{c}\eta_{c}+2xr'_{c})}{8x^{3}(1+r_{c})^{4}}+\frac{4(1+r_{q})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+2\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(1)})^{3}(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{4}}-\frac{16(1+r_{q})\bar{m}_{q}(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(1)})^{2}\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(4)}(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{3}}+\frac{9x\lambda_{A^{3}}^{2}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{2(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{4}}-\frac{45\lambda_{A^{3}}\lambda_{A^{4}}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{4(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{3}}+\frac{x\lambda_{\Delta\Delta}^{2}(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{2(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{4}}\right\}. \tag*{(192)} ∂ t λ A 3 = 2 3 η A λ A 3 + 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ − 8 x 3 ( 1 + r c ) 4 3 λ A ˉ cc 2 ( r c η c + 2 x r c ′ ) + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 4 4 ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 2 m ˉ q 2 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 3 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 16 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 4 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 4 9 x λ A 3 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 45 λ A 3 λ A 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 4 x λ ΔΔ 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ⎭ ⎬ ⎫ . (192)
∂ t λ A 4 = 2 η A λ A 4 + 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { 8 ( 1 + r q ) ( 2 x + 4 x r q + 2 x r q 2 + 5 m ˉ q 2 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 4 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 4 + 6 x λ A 3 2 λ A 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 4 − 8 λ A 4 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 − x λ Δ Δ 2 λ A 2 Δ Δ ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 4 − λ A 2 Δ Δ 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 } . (193) \partial_{t}\lambda_{A^{4}}=2\eta_{A}\lambda_{A^{4}}+\frac{1}{16\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}dx\,x^{3}\left\{\frac{8(1+r_{q})(2x+4xr_{q}+2xr_{q}^{2}+5\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(1)})^{4}(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{3(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{4}}+\frac{6x\lambda_{A^{3}}^{2}\lambda_{A^{4}}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{4}}-\frac{8\lambda_{A^{4}}^{2}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{3}}-\frac{x\lambda_{\Delta\Delta}^{2}\lambda_{A^{2}\Delta\Delta}(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{4}}-\frac{\lambda_{A^{2}\Delta\Delta}^{2}(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{3(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{3}}\right\}. \tag*{(193)} ∂ t λ A 4 = 2 η A λ A 4 + 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 4 8 ( 1 + r q ) ( 2 x + 4 x r q + 2 x r q 2 + 5 m ˉ q 2 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 4 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 4 6 x λ A 3 2 λ A 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 8 λ A 4 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 4 x λ ΔΔ 2 λ A 2 ΔΔ ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) − 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 λ A 2 ΔΔ 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ⎭ ⎬ ⎫ . (193)
∂ t λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) = ( η q + 1 2 η A ) λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) + 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − x ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 − x 2 ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 4 ) m ˉ q ( − 3 x − 6 x r q − 3 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 − x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ) + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 3 ( − ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 − m ˉ q 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ) + \partial_{t}\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(1)}=(\eta_{q}+\tfrac{1}{2}\eta_{A})\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(1)}+\frac{1}{16\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}dx\,x^{3}\{\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(1)}(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(4)})^{2}(-\frac{x(1+r_{q})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}-\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{2(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{3}}-\frac{x^{2}(1+r_{q})^{2}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{4(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}}+\frac{(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(1)})^{2}\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(4)}\bar{m}_{q}(-3x-6xr_{q}-3xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{2(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{3}}-\frac{x(1+r_{q})\bar{m}_{q}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{2(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}})+(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}q}^{(1)})^{3}(-\frac{(1+r_{q})\bar{m}_{q}^{2}(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{3}}-\frac{\bar{m}_{q}^{2}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{4(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}})+ ∂ t λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) = ( η q + 2 1 η A ) λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) + 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 x ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 4 ) m ˉ q ( − 3 x − 6 x r q − 3 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 3 ( − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 m ˉ q 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) +
λ A 3 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( 9 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + 9 x ( 1 + r q ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ) + λ A 3 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 9 x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 − 9 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ) + λ A 3 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ( − 9 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 − 9 x m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ) + g Δ ˉ q q 2 λ Δ λ Δ ( ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 + x ( 1 + r q ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ) + g Δ ˉ q q 2 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ( ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 2 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ) + g ϕ q ˉ q 2 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ( ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 2 ) ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) + 1 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 2 m ˉ σ 2 ) × ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r q 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) (194) \begin{aligned}
&\lambda_{A^3}\left(\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(1)}\right)^2\left(\frac{9(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}+\frac{9x(1+r_q)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{2(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)}\right)\\
&+\lambda_{A^3}\left(\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(4)}\right)^2\left(-\frac{9x(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}-\frac{9x^2(1+r_q)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{2(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)}\right)\\
&+\lambda_{A^3}\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(1)}\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(4)}\left(-\frac{9x(1+r_q)\bar{m}_q(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}-\frac{9x\bar{m}_q(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)}\right)\\
&+g_{\bar{\Delta}qq}^2\lambda_{\Delta}\lambda_{\Delta}\left(\frac{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^2)^2}+\frac{x(1+r_q)(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^2)^3}\right)\\
&+g_{\bar{\Delta}qq}^2\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(1)}\left(\frac{(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+3\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^2)}+\frac{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+2\bar{m}_q^2)(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^2)^2}\right)\\
&+g_{\phi\bar{q}q}^2\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(1)}\left(\frac{(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+3\bar{m}_q^2)(4x+4xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^2+3\bar{m}_{\sigma}^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^2)}\right.\\
&\left.\qquad+\frac{1}{2(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^2)^2}(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+2\bar{m}_{\sigma}^2)\right.\\
&\left.\qquad\qquad\times(4x^2+4xr_q^2+2x\bar{m}_{\pi}^2+\bar{m}_{\pi}^4+6x\bar{m}_{\sigma}^2+3\bar{m}_{\sigma}^4+2xr_{\phi}(4x+\bar{m}_{\pi}^2+3\bar{m}_{\sigma}^2))(r_{\phi}\eta_{\phi}+2xr'_{\phi})\right) \tag*{(194)}
\end{aligned} λ A 3 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 9 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 9 x ( 1 + r q ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + λ A 3 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 9 x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 9 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + λ A 3 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ( − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 9 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 9 x m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + g Δ ˉ q q 2 λ Δ λ Δ ( 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 x ( 1 + r q ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + g Δ ˉ q q 2 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ( ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 2 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + g ϕ q ˉ q 2 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ( ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ q 2 ) ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 1 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 2 m ˉ σ 2 ) × ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r q 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) (194)
∂ t λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) = ( 1 + η q + 1 2 η λ ) λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) + 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { ( λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ) 2 λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ( 1 + r q ) ( 49 x + 98 x r q + 49 x r q 2 − 57 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 72 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) + x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) + ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 3 ( − x ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − 51 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 72 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 + x m ˉ q 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ) + λ A 3 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) 33 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + 133 x ( 1 + r q ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) + λ A 3 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( 15 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + 15 m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ) + λ A 3 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 9 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 − 73 x m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ) + λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − x m ˉ q ( 6 + 6 r q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 12 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 − m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 36 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( 58 x 2 + 116 x r q + 58 x r q 2 + 61 x m ˉ g a p 2 + 122 x r q m ˉ g a p 2 + 61 x r q 2 m ˉ g a p 2 − 13 x m ˉ q 2 − 10 m ˉ g a p 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r A ( 58 x + 116 x r q + 58 x r q 2 − 13 m ˉ q 2 ) − 3 x 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) r A ′ ) ) + \begin{aligned}
\partial_t\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(4)}={}&\left(1+\eta_q+\frac{1}{2}\eta_{\lambda}\right)\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(4)}+\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^3\Bigg\{\left(\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(1)}\right)^2\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(4)}\frac{(1+r_q)(49x+98xr_q+49xr_q^2-57\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{72(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)}\\
&+\frac{x(1+r_q)^2(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{3(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)}+\left(\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(4)}\right)^3\left(-\frac{x(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-51\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{72(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3}\right.\\
&\left.\qquad+\frac{x\bar{m}_q^2(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{6(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}\right)+\lambda_{A^3}\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(1)}\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(4)}\frac{33(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}\\
&+\frac{133x(1+r_q)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{8(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)}+\lambda_{A^3}\left(\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(1)}\right)^2\left(\frac{15(1+r_q)\bar{m}_q(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{2(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}\right.\\
&\left.\qquad+\frac{15\bar{m}_q(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{2(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)}\right)+\lambda_{A^3}\left(\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(4)}\right)^2\left(-\frac{9x(1+r_q)\bar{m}_q(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}\right.\\
&\left.\qquad-\frac{73x\bar{m}_q(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{8(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)}\right)+\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(1)}\left(\lambda_{\bar{A}qq}^{(4)}\right)^2\left(-\frac{x\bar{m}_q(6+6r_q+2xr'_q)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{12(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}\right.\\
&\left.\qquad-\frac{\bar{m}_q(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{36(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3}\left(58x^2+116xr_q+58xr_q^2+61x\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2+122xr_q\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2+61xr_q^2\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2-13x\bar{m}_q^2-10\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2\bar{m}_q^2\right.\right.\\
&\left.\left.\qquad\qquad+xr_A(58x+116xr_q+58xr_q^2-13\bar{m}_q^2)-3x^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)r'_A\right)\right)+
\end{aligned} ∂ t λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) = ( 1 + η q + 2 1 η λ ) λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) + 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { ( λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ) 2 λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) 72 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( 1 + r q ) ( 49 x + 98 x r q + 49 x r q 2 − 57 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 3 ( − 72 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 x ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − 51 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 x m ˉ q 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + λ A 3 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 33 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 133 x ( 1 + r q ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + λ A 3 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 15 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 15 m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + λ A 3 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 9 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 73 x m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 12 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 x m ˉ q ( 6 + 6 r q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 36 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( 58 x 2 + 116 x r q + 58 x r q 2 + 61 x m ˉ gap 2 + 122 x r q m ˉ gap 2 + 61 x r q 2 m ˉ gap 2 − 13 x m ˉ q 2 − 10 m ˉ gap 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r A ( 58 x + 116 x r q + 58 x r q 2 − 13 m ˉ q 2 ) − 3 x 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) r A ′ ) ) +
\begin{aligned}
&(\lambda_{\bar A\bar q q}^{(1)})^3(-\frac{x\bar m_q r'_q(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{12(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\rm gap}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}\\
&+\frac{1}{36x(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\rm gap}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3}\bar m_q(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)(5x^2+10x^2r_q+5x^2r_q^2+2x\bar m_{\rm gap}^2\\
&+4xr_q\bar m_{\rm gap}^2+2xr_q^2\bar m_{\rm gap}^2-3x\bar m_q^2-6\bar m_q^2\bar m_q^2+xr_A(5x+10xr_q+5xr_q^2-3\bar m_q^2)+3x^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)r'_A))\\
&+g_{\Delta\bar\Delta\bar q\bar q}^{2}\lambda_{\bar A\bar q q}^{(4)}(-\frac{4(1+r_q)\bar m_q^2(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)}\\
&-\frac{\bar m_q^2(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^2})\\
&+g_{\Delta\bar\Delta\bar q\bar q}^{2}\lambda_{\bar A\bar q q}^{(1)}\lambda_{\bar A\bar q q}^{(2)}
(\frac{\bar m_q(2+2r_q+xr'_q)(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^2}\\
&-\frac{\bar m_q(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)(-5x-10xr_q-5xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2+r_\Delta(-5x-10xr_q-5xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)-6\bar m_\Delta^2-12r_\Delta\bar m_\Delta^2-6r_q^2\bar m_\Delta^2+x(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)r'_\Delta)}{2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)})\\
&+g_{\phi\phi q q}^{2}\lambda_{\bar A\bar q q}^{(4)}
(\frac{4(1+r_q)\bar m_q^2(-2x-2xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2-3\bar m_\sigma^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)}\\
&+\frac{\bar m_q^2(-2x^2-2xr_\phi^2+2x\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\pi^4-6x\bar m_\sigma^2-3\bar m_\sigma^4+2xr_\phi(-2x+\bar m_\pi^2-3\bar m_\sigma^2))(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)}{(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2})\\
&+g_{\phi\phi q q}^{2}\lambda_{\bar A\bar q q}^{(1)}
(-\frac{\bar m_q(-2x^2-2xr_\phi^2+2x\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\pi^4-6x\bar m_\sigma^2-3\bar m_\sigma^4+2xr_\phi(-2x+\bar m_\pi^2-3\bar m_\sigma^2))(2+2r_q+xr'_q)(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)}{2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}\\
&+\frac{\bar m_q(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)(10x^3+20x^3r_q+10x^3r_q^2+8x^2\bar m_\pi^2+16x^2r_q\bar m_\pi^2+8x^2r_q^2\bar m_\pi^2+8x^2\bar m_q^2+16x^2r_q\bar m_q^2+8x^2r_q^2\bar m_q^2-5x\bar m_\pi^4-10xr_q\bar m_\pi^4-5xr_q^2\bar m_\pi^4-6x\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2-12xr_q\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2-6xr_q^2\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2-6\bar m_\pi^4\bar m_\sigma^2-12r_q\bar m_\pi^4\bar m_\sigma^2-6r_q^2\bar m_\pi^4\bar m_\sigma^2+15x\bar m_\sigma^4+30xr_q\bar m_\sigma^4+15xr_q^2\bar m_\sigma^4+18\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^4+36r_q\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^4+18r_q^2\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^4-3\bar m_\pi^4\bar m_\sigma^4+x(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)(-2x^2+2x\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\pi^4-6x\bar m_\sigma^2-3\bar m_\sigma^4)r'_\phi+2xr_\phi^2(15x^2+4x\bar m_\pi^2-3x\bar m_\sigma^2+\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2+12x\bar m_\sigma^2-3\bar m_\sigma^2\bar m_\sigma^2)+2xr_q(15x+4\bar m_\pi^2+12\bar m_\sigma^2)+xr_q^2(15x+4\bar m_\pi^2+12\bar m_\sigma^2)-x^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)r'_\phi)+r_\phi(30x^3+16x^2\bar m_\pi^2-5x\bar m_\pi^4-6x^2\bar m_q^2+4x\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_q^2+\bar m_\pi^4\bar m_q^2+48x^2\bar m_\sigma^2+24x\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2-12x\bar m_q^2\bar m_\sigma^2+15x\bar m_\sigma^4-3\bar m_q^2\bar m_\sigma^4+2xr_q(30x^2+16x\bar m_\pi^2-5\bar m_\pi^4+48x\bar m_\sigma^2+24\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2+15\bar m_\sigma^4)+xr_q^2(30x^2+16x\bar m_\pi^2-5\bar m_\pi^4+48x\bar m_\sigma^2+24\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2+15\bar m_\sigma^4)+2x^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)(-2x+\bar m_\pi^2-3\bar m_\sigma^2)r'_\phi))\}.
\end{aligned}} \tag*{(195)}\end{aligned}
∂ t λ Δ Δ Δ ˉ Δ = ( η Δ + 1 2 η A ) λ Δ Δ Δ ˉ Δ + 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { 12 g Δ Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( 1 + r q ) 2 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 + λ Δ Δ Δ ˉ Δ λ Δ Δ Δ Δ ( − 7 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) − 7 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ) + λ Δ Δ Δ Δ 2 x σ ˉ 0 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( 1 + r ϕ + x r ϕ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 + σ ˉ 0 2 ( m ˉ Δ 2 − 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 } . (196) \begin{aligned}
\partial_t\lambda_{\Delta\Delta\bar\Delta\Delta}
={}&\left(\eta_\Delta+\frac{1}{2}\eta_A\right)\lambda_{\Delta\Delta\bar\Delta\Delta}
+\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^3\left\{\frac{12g_{\Delta\bar\Delta\bar q\bar q}^{2}(1+r_q)^2\lambda_{\bar A\bar q q}^{(1)}(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3}\right.\\
&+\lambda_{\Delta\Delta\bar\Delta\Delta}\lambda_{\Delta\Delta\Delta\Delta}\left(-\frac{7(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\rm gap}^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)}-\frac{7(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\rm gap}^2)(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^2}\right)\\
&\left.+\frac{\lambda_{\Delta\Delta\Delta\Delta}^{2}x\bar\sigma_0^2(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)(1+r_\phi+xr'_\phi)}{(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^3(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}
+\frac{\bar\sigma_0^2(\bar m_\Delta^2-2xr'_\Delta)(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)}{(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^3(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}\right\}. \tag*{(196)}
\end{aligned} ∂ t λ ΔΔ Δ ˉ Δ = ( η Δ + 2 1 η A ) λ ΔΔ Δ ˉ Δ + 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 12 g Δ Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( 1 + r q ) 2 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + λ ΔΔ Δ ˉ Δ λ ΔΔΔΔ ( − 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 7 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 7 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 λ ΔΔΔΔ 2 x σ ˉ 0 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( 1 + r ϕ + x r ϕ ′ ) + ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 2 ( m ˉ Δ 2 − 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) } . (196)
∂ t λ A 2 Δ 4 = ( η Δ + η A ) λ A 2 Δ 4 + 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { 16 g Δ Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 4 m ˉ q 2 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 4 + 27 x λ A 3 2 λ A 2 Δ 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 4 − 27 λ A 4 λ A 2 Δ 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 + 12 x λ A 2 Δ 4 λ A 2 Δ 4 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 4 − 8 λ A 2 Δ 4 λ Δ Δ , 0 , 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 + λ A 2 Δ 4 2 ( − 7 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) − 7 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ) + λ A 2 Δ 4 λ A 2 Δ 4 , 1 , 1 ( − 3 x σ ˉ 0 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 4 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) + x σ ˉ 0 2 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ) \begin{aligned}
\partial_t\lambda_{A^2\Delta^4}={}&\left(\eta_\Delta+\eta_A\right)\lambda_{A^2\Delta^4}
+\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^3\left\{\frac{16g_{\Delta\bar\Delta\bar q\bar q}^{2}(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+4\bar m_q^2)\left(\lambda_{\bar A\bar q q}^{(1)}\right)^2(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^4}\right.\\
&+\frac{27x\lambda_{A^3}^2\lambda_{A^2\Delta^4}(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\rm gap}^2)^4}
-\frac{27\lambda_{A^4}\lambda_{A^2\Delta^4}(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{2(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\rm gap}^2)^3}\\
&+\frac{12x\lambda_{A^2\Delta^4}\lambda_{A^2\Delta^4}(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^4}
-\frac{8\lambda_{A^2\Delta^4}\lambda_{\Delta\Delta,0,2}(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^3}\\
&+\lambda_{A^2\Delta^4}^{2}\left(-\frac{7(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\rm gap}^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)}-\frac{7(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\rm gap}^2)(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^2}\right)\\
&\left.+\lambda_{A^2\Delta^4}\lambda_{A^2\Delta^4,1,1}\left(-\frac{3x\bar\sigma_0^2(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^4(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)}+\frac{x\bar\sigma_0^2(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)}{(x+xr_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^2)^3(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}\right)\right.
\end{aligned} ∂ t λ A 2 Δ 4 = ( η Δ + η A ) λ A 2 Δ 4 + 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 4 16 g Δ Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 4 m ˉ q 2 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 4 27 x λ A 3 2 λ A 2 Δ 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 27 λ A 4 λ A 2 Δ 4 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 4 12 x λ A 2 Δ 4 λ A 2 Δ 4 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) − ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 8 λ A 2 Δ 4 λ ΔΔ , 0 , 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) + λ A 2 Δ 4 2 ( − 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 7 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 7 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + λ A 2 Δ 4 λ A 2 Δ 4 , 1 , 1 ( − ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 4 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 3 x σ ˉ 0 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) + ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 x σ ˉ 0 2 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) )
λ A 2 Δ † Δ 1 , 1 † ( 2 σ ˉ 0 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) + σ ˉ 0 2 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ) . (197) \lambda_{A^{2}\Delta^{\dagger}\Delta^{\dagger}_{1,1}}\left(\frac{2\bar{\sigma}_{0}^{2}(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{3}(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})}+\frac{\bar{\sigma}_{0}^{2}(r_{\phi}\eta_{\phi}+2xr'_{\phi})}{(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{2}(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})^{2}}\right). \tag*{(197)} λ A 2 Δ † Δ 1 , 1 † ( ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) + ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 2 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) . (197)
Yukawa couplings
∂ t g ϕ q ˉ q = ( η q + 1 2 η ϕ ) g ϕ q ˉ q + 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { λ A q ~ q ~ ( 1 ) λ A q ~ q ~ ( 4 ) ( 8 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 + 8 x ( 1 + r q ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) σ ˉ 0 ) + ( λ A q ~ q ~ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( 8 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 + 4 m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) σ ˉ 0 ) + ( λ A q ~ q ~ ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 8 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 − 4 x r m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) σ ˉ 0 ) + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( 4 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) σ ˉ 0 + 2 m ˉ q ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 ) + g ϕ q ˉ q 2 ( − 2 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( − 2 x − 2 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 − 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) σ ˉ 0 − m ˉ q ( − 2 x − 2 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 − 6 x m ˉ σ 2 − 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( − 2 x + m ˉ π 2 − 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 ) } . (198) \begin{aligned}
\partial_{t}g_{\phi\bar{q}q}={}&\left(\eta_{q}+\frac{1}{2}\eta_{\phi}\right)g_{\phi\bar{q}q}+\frac{1}{16\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}dx\,x^{3}\Bigg\{\lambda_{A\tilde{q}\tilde{q}}^{(1)}\lambda_{A\tilde{q}\tilde{q}}^{(4)}\left(\frac{8(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}-\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}\bar{\sigma}_{0}}\right.\\
&\left.+\frac{8x(1+r_{q})(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})\bar{\sigma}_{0}}\right)\\
&+\left(\lambda_{A\tilde{q}\tilde{q}}^{(1)}\right)^{2}\left(\frac{8(1+r_{q})\bar{m}_{q}(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}\bar{\sigma}_{0}}\right.\\
&\left.+\frac{4\bar{m}_{q}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})\bar{\sigma}_{0}}\right)\\
&+\left(\lambda_{A\tilde{q}\tilde{q}}^{(4)}\right)^{2}\left(-\frac{8x(1+r_{q})\bar{m}_{q}(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}\bar{\sigma}_{0}}\right.\\
&\left.-\frac{4xr\bar{m}_{q}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})\bar{\sigma}_{0}}\right)\\
&+g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{2}\left(\frac{4(1+r_{q})\bar{m}_{q}(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})\bar{\sigma}_{0}}+\frac{2\bar{m}_{q}(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{2}\bar{\sigma}_{0}}\right)\\
&+g_{\phi\bar{q}q}^{2}\left(-\frac{2(1+r_{q})\bar{m}_{q}(-2x-2xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2}-3\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})\bar{\sigma}_{0}}\right.\\
&\left.-\frac{\bar{m}_{q}(-2x-2xr_{\phi}^{2}+2x\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^{4}-6x\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2}-3\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{4}+2xr_{\phi}(-2x+\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2}-3\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2}))(r_{\phi}\eta_{\phi}+2xr'_{\phi})}{(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})^{2}\bar{\sigma}_{0}}\right)\Bigg\}. \tag*{(198)}
\end{aligned} ∂ t g ϕ q ˉ q = ( η q + 2 1 η ϕ ) g ϕ q ˉ q + 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { λ A q ~ q ~ ( 1 ) λ A q ~ q ~ ( 4 ) ( ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 8 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) σ ˉ 0 8 x ( 1 + r q ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + ( λ A q ~ q ~ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 8 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) σ ˉ 0 4 m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + ( λ A q ~ q ~ ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 8 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) σ ˉ 0 4 x r m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) σ ˉ 0 4 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 2 m ˉ q ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + g ϕ q ˉ q 2 ( − ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) σ ˉ 0 2 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( − 2 x − 2 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 − 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 σ ˉ 0 m ˉ q ( − 2 x − 2 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 − 6 x m ˉ σ 2 − 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( − 2 x + m ˉ π 2 − 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) } . (198)
∂ t g Δ q ˉ q ˉ = ( η q + 1 2 η Δ ) g Δ q ˉ q ˉ + 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { g Δ q ˉ q ˉ ( λ A q ~ q ~ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( 4 ( 1 + r q ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ) + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ ( λ A q ~ q ~ ( 4 ) ) 2 ( 4 x ( 1 + r q ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + 2 x ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ) + g ϕ q ˉ q 2 Δ g Δ q ˉ q ˉ ( 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) + ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ) + g ϕ q ˉ q g Δ q ˉ q ˉ λ 1 , 1 ( 4 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q σ ˉ 0 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) + 2 m ˉ q σ ˉ 0 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) + 2 m ˉ q σ ˉ 0 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ) } . (199) \begin{aligned}
\partial_{t}g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}={}&\left(\eta_{q}+\frac{1}{2}\eta_{\Delta}\right)g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}+\frac{1}{16\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}dx\,x^{3}\Bigg\{g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}\left(\lambda_{A\tilde{q}\tilde{q}}^{(1)}\right)^{2}\left(\frac{4(1+r_{q})(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}}+\frac{2(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})}\right)\\
&+g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}\left(\lambda_{A\tilde{q}\tilde{q}}^{(4)}\right)^{2}\left(\frac{4x(1+r_{q})(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}}+\frac{2x(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})}\right)\\
&+g_{\phi\bar{q}q}^{2}\Delta g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}\left(\frac{2(1+r_{q})(4x+4xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2}+3\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2})(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})}\right.\\
&\left.+\frac{(4x^{2}+4xr_{\phi}^{2}+2x\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^{4}+6x\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2}+3\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{4}+2xr_{\phi}(4x+\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2}+3\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2}))(r_{\phi}\eta_{\phi}+2xr'_{\phi})}{(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\pi}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})^{2}}\right)\\
&+g_{\phi\bar{q}q}g_{\Delta\bar{q}\bar{q}}\lambda_{1,1}\left(\frac{4(1+r_{q})\bar{m}_{q}\bar{\sigma}_{0}(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})}\right.\\
&\left.+\frac{2\bar{m}_{q}\bar{\sigma}_{0}(r_{\Delta}\eta_{\Delta}+2xr'_{\Delta})}{(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})^{2}(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})}+\frac{2\bar{m}_{q}\bar{\sigma}_{0}(r_{\phi}\eta_{\phi}+2xr'_{\phi})}{(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(x+xr_{\Delta}+\bar{m}_{\Delta}^{2})(x+xr_{\phi}+\bar{m}_{\sigma}^{2})^{2}}\right)\Bigg\}. \tag*{(199)}
\end{aligned} ∂ t g Δ q ˉ q ˉ = ( η q + 2 1 η Δ ) g Δ q ˉ q ˉ + 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { g Δ q ˉ q ˉ ( λ A q ~ q ~ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 4 ( 1 + r q ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ ( λ A q ~ q ~ ( 4 ) ) 2 ( ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 4 x ( 1 + r q ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 x ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + g ϕ q ˉ q 2 Δ g Δ q ˉ q ˉ ( ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) + g ϕ q ˉ q g Δ q ˉ q ˉ λ 1 , 1 ( ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 4 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q σ ˉ 0 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 m ˉ q σ ˉ 0 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 2 m ˉ q σ ˉ 0 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) } . (199)
Four-quark flows
[ P q ˉ q q q ˉ ( s p ) ] α β γ δ [ F l o w q ˉ q q q ˉ ( 4 ) ] α β γ δ = 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { ( λ A q ~ q ~ ( 1 ) ) 3 λ A q ~ q ~ ( 4 ) m ˉ q ( 3 x + 6 x r q + 3 x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 + x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + ⋯ } . \left[P_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}^{(\mathrm{sp})}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}\left[\mathrm{Flow}_{\bar{q}qq\bar{q}}^{(4)}\right]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}
=
\frac{1}{16\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}dx\,x^{3}\Bigg\{\left(\lambda_{A\tilde{q}\tilde{q}}^{(1)}\right)^{3}\lambda_{A\tilde{q}\tilde{q}}^{(4)}
\frac{\bar{m}_{q}(3x+6xr_{q}+3xr_{q}^{2}-\bar{m}_{q}^{2})(r_{q}\eta_{q}+2xr'_{q})}{6(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{3}}
+
\frac{x(1+r_{q})\bar{m}_{q}(r_{A}\eta_{A}+2xr'_{A})}{3(x+xr_{A}+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^{2})^{3}(x+2xr_{q}+xr_{q}^{2}+\bar{m}_{q}^{2})^{2}}
+\cdots\Bigg\}. [ P q ˉ q q q ˉ ( sp ) ] α β γ δ [ Flow q ˉ q q q ˉ ( 4 ) ] α β γ δ = 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { ( λ A q ~ q ~ ( 1 ) ) 3 λ A q ~ q ~ ( 4 ) 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 m ˉ q ( 3 x + 6 x r q + 3 x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ⋯ } .
λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 3 ( m ˉ q ( − 3 x − 6 x r q − 3 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 − x 2 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ) \lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(1)}(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(4)})^3\left(\frac{\bar{m}_q(-3x-6xr_q-3xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{6(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3}-\frac{x^2(1+r_q)\bar{m}_q(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{3(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}\right) λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 3 ( 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 m ˉ q ( − 3 x − 6 x r q − 3 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) )
− ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 4 ( − ( 1 + r q ) ( 57 x + 114 x r q + 57 x r q 2 + 41 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 96 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 -(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(1)})^4(-\frac{(1+r_q)(57x+114xr_q+57xr_q^2+41\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{96(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3} − ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 4 ( − 96 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( 1 + r q ) ( 57 x + 114 x r q + 57 x r q 2 + 41 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ )
− ( 57 x + 114 x r q + 57 x r q 2 + 49 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 96 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ) + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 4 ( − x 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( 57 x + 114 x r q + 57 x r q 2 + 41 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 96 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 \begin{aligned}
-\frac{(57x+114xr_q+57xr_q^2+49\bar{m}_q^2)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{96(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}) \\
&+(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(4)})^4(-\frac{x^2(1+r_q)(57x+114xr_q+57xr_q^2+41\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{96(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3}
\end{aligned} − 96 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( 57 x + 114 x r q + 57 x r q 2 + 49 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 4 ( − 96 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( 57 x + 114 x r q + 57 x r q 2 + 41 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ )
− x 2 ( 57 x + 114 x r q + 57 x r q 2 + 49 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 96 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ) + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − x ( 1 + r q ) ( 41 x + 82 x r q + 41 x r q 2 + 89 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 48 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 \begin{aligned}
-\frac{x^2(57x+114xr_q+57xr_q^2+49\bar{m}_q^2)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{96(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}) \\
&+(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(1)})^2(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(4)})^2(-\frac{x(1+r_q)(41x+82xr_q+41xr_q^2+89\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{48(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3}
\end{aligned} − 96 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 x 2 ( 57 x + 114 x r q + 57 x r q 2 + 49 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 48 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 x ( 1 + r q ) ( 41 x + 82 x r q + 41 x r q 2 + 89 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ )
− x ( 41 x + 82 x r q + 65 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 48 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ) + g Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 4 ( − ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 5 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 8 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 − ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 8 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ) + g Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ( 3 m ˉ q ( 3 x + 6 x r q + 3 x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) \begin{aligned}
-\frac{x(41x+82xr_q+65\bar{m}_q^2)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{48(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2}) \\
&+g_{\bar{\Delta}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^4\left(-\frac{(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+5\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{8(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)^2}
-\frac{(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+3\bar{m}_\Delta^2)(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{8(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)^3}\right) \\
&+g_{\bar{\Delta}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^2\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(1)}\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(4)}
\left(\frac{3\bar{m}_q(3x+6xr_q+3xr_q^2-\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)}
\right.
\end{aligned} − 48 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 x ( 41 x + 82 x r q + 65 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) + g Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 4 ( − 8 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 5 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 8 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 3 m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + g Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ( 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 m ˉ q ( 3 x + 6 x r q + 3 x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ )
+ 3 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) + 3 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ) + g Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( ( 1 + r q ) ( − 2 x − 4 x r q − 2 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) \begin{aligned}
\left.+\frac{3x(1+r_q)\bar{m}_q(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)}
+\frac{3x(1+r_q)\bar{m}_q(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)^2}\right) \\
&+g_{\bar{\Delta}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^2\left(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(1)}\right)^2\left(\frac{(1+r_q)(-2x-4xr_q-2xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{2(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)}
\right.
\end{aligned} + 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 3 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + g Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( 1 + r q ) ( − 2 x − 4 x r q − 2 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ )
− ( 4 x + 8 x r q + 4 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) − ( 4 x + 8 x r q + 4 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ) + g Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − x ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 7 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) \begin{aligned}
\left.-\frac{(4x+8xr_q+4xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{8(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)}
-\frac{(4x+8xr_q+4xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{8(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)^2}\right) \\
&+g_{\bar{\Delta}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^2\left(\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(4)}\right)^2\left(-\frac{x(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+7\bar{m}_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)}
\right.
\end{aligned} − 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( 4 x + 8 x r q + 4 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( 4 x + 8 x r q + 4 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + g Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) x ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 7 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ )
− x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 4 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) − x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 4 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ) + g ϕ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ( m ˉ q ( − 3 x − 6 x r q − 3 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + 7 m ˉ π 2 − 6 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) 12 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) \begin{aligned}
\left.-\frac{x(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+4\bar{m}_q^2)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{8(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)}
-\frac{x(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+4\bar{m}_q^2)(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{8(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)^2}\right) \\
&+g_{\bar{\phi}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^2\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(1)}\lambda_{\bar{A}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^{(4)}
\left(\frac{\bar{m}_q(-3x-6xr_q-3xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)(x+xr_\phi+7\bar{m}_\pi^2-6\bar{m}_\sigma^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_\phi)}{12(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\pi^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\sigma^2)}
\right.
\end{aligned} − 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 4 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 x ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + 4 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + g ϕ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ( 12 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) m ˉ q ( − 3 x − 6 x r q − 3 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + 7 m ˉ π 2 − 6 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r ϕ ′ )
− x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( x 2 + x 2 r ϕ 2 + 14 x m ˉ π 2 + 7 m ˉ π 4 − 12 x m ˉ σ 2 − 6 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( x + 7 m ˉ π 2 − 6 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) 12 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ) + g ϕ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 g Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( − ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 8 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) \begin{aligned}
\left.-\frac{x(1+r_q)\bar{m}_q(x^2+x^2r_\phi^2+14x\bar{m}_\pi^2+7\bar{m}_\pi^4-12x\bar{m}_\sigma^2-6\bar{m}_\sigma^4+2xr_\phi(x+7\bar{m}_\pi^2-6\bar{m}_\sigma^2))(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)}{12(x+xr_A+\bar{m}_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\pi^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\sigma^2)^2}\right) \\
&+g_{\bar{\phi}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^2g_{\bar{\Delta}\bar{q}\bar{q}}^2\left(-\frac{(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-\bar{m}_q^2)(4x+4xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\pi^2+3\bar{m}_\sigma^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{8(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\pi^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^3(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\sigma^2)}
\right.
\end{aligned} − 12 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( x 2 + x 2 r ϕ 2 + 14 x m ˉ π 2 + 7 m ˉ π 4 − 12 x m ˉ σ 2 − 6 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( x + 7 m ˉ π 2 − 6 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) + g ϕ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 g Δ ˉ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( − 8 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ )
− x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) 8 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) -\frac{x(1+r_q)^2(4x+4xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\pi^2+3\bar{m}_\sigma^2)(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{8(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\pi^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\sigma^2)} − 8 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ )
− x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) 8 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ) + -\frac{x(1+r_q)^2(4x^2+4xr_\phi^2+2x\bar{m}_\pi^2+\bar{m}_\pi^4+6x\bar{m}_\sigma^2+3\bar{m}_\sigma^4+2xr_\phi(4x+\bar{m}_\pi^2+3\bar{m}_\sigma^2))(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)}{8(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\pi^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar{m}_q^2)^2(x+xr_\Delta+\bar{m}_\Delta^2)(x+xr_\phi+\bar{m}_\sigma^2)^2})+ − 8 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) +
g q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 1 12 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) x ( 1 + r q ) ( 9 x 2 + 9 x m ˉ π 2 + 18 x r q ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 9 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 7 x m ˉ q 2 − 5 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r ϕ ( 9 x + 18 x r q + 9 x r q 2 + 7 m ˉ q 2 ) + 12 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 1 24 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 x ( 9 x 2 + 9 x m ˉ π 2 + 18 x r q ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 9 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 8 x m ˉ q 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r ϕ ( 9 x + 18 x r q + 9 x r q 2 + 8 m ˉ q 2 ) + 6 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 1 24 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 x ( 9 x 3 + 18 x 2 m ˉ π 2 + 9 x m ˉ π 4 + 18 x r q ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 + 9 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 + 8 x m ˉ q 2 + 4 x m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r ϕ 2 ( 9 x + 18 x r q + 9 x r q 2 + 8 m ˉ q 2 ) + 12 x m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 6 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 9 x 2 + 9 x m ˉ π 2 + 18 x r q ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 9 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 8 x m ˉ q 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) + g q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ( − ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( 10 x 2 + 10 x r ϕ 2 + 8 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 12 x m ˉ σ 2 + 6 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 4 x r ϕ ( 5 x + 2 m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 1 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 1 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 3 m ˉ q 2 ( 10 x 3 + 10 x r ϕ 3 + m ˉ π 6 + 18 x 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 12 x m ˉ σ 4 + 3 m ˉ σ 6 + 3 m ˉ π 4 ( 2 x + m ˉ σ 2 ) + 3 m ˉ π 2 ( 2 x + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 + 6 x 2 r ϕ 2 ( 5 x + 2 m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) + 6 x r ϕ ( 5 x 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 2 m ˉ σ 4 ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) + g q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( − 1 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) ( 1 + r q ) ( 4 x 2 + x m ˉ π 2 + 5 x m ˉ q 2 + 8 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r ϕ ( 4 x + 8 x r q + 4 x r q 2 + 5 m ˉ q 2 ) + 3 x m ˉ σ 2 − 3 m ˉ q 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 2 x r q ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) + x r q 2 ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 1 24 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ( 8 x 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + 9 x m ˉ q 2 + 9 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r ϕ ( 8 x + 16 x r q + 8 x r q 2 + 9 m ˉ q 2 ) + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 4 x r q ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) + 2 x r q 2 ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 1 24 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 ( 8 x 3 + 4 x 2 m ˉ π 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 4 + 9 x 2 m ˉ q 2 + 18 x m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + 9 m ˉ π 4 m ˉ q 2 + x 2 r ϕ 2 ( 8 x + 16 x r q + 8 x r q 2 + 9 m ˉ q 2 ) + 12 x 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 6 x m ˉ σ 4 + 4 x r q ( 4 x 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 ) + 2 x r q 2 ( 4 x 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 ) + 2 x r ϕ ( 8 x 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + 9 x m ˉ q 2 + 9 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 4 x r q ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) + 2 x r q 2 ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) } (200) g_{\bar q\bar q}^{(4)}(\lambda_{\bar A\bar q\bar q}^{(4)})^2(-\frac{1}{12(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)}x(1+r_q)(9x^2+9x\bar m_\pi^2+18xr_q(x+\bar m_\pi^2)+9xr_q^2(x+\bar m_\pi^2)+7x\bar m_q^2-5\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_q^2+xr_\phi(9x+18xr_q+9xr_q^2+7\bar m_q^2)+12\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)
-\frac{1}{24(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}x(9x^2+9x\bar m_\pi^2+18xr_q(x+\bar m_\pi^2)+9xr_q^2(x+\bar m_\pi^2)+8x\bar m_q^2+2\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_q^2+xr_\phi(9x+18xr_q+9xr_q^2+8\bar m_q^2)+6\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)
-\frac{1}{24(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}x(9x^3+18x^2\bar m_\pi^2+9x\bar m_\pi^4+18xr_q(x+\bar m_\pi^2)^2+9xr_q^2(x+\bar m_\pi^2)^2+8x\bar m_q^2+4x\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_q^2+2\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_q^2+xr_\phi^2(9x+18xr_q+9xr_q^2+8\bar m_q^2)+12x\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2+6\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^4+2xr_\phi(9x^2+9x\bar m_\pi^2+18xr_q(x+\bar m_\pi^2)+9xr_q^2(x+\bar m_\pi^2)+8x\bar m_q^2+2\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_q^2))(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)
+g_{\bar q\bar q}^{(4)}(-(1+r_q)\bar m_q^2(10x^2+10xr_\phi^2+8x\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\pi^4+12x\bar m_\sigma^2+6\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2+3\bar m_\sigma^4+4xr_\phi(5x+2\bar m_\pi^2+3\bar m_\sigma^2))(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)
-\frac{1}{(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}
\frac{1}{2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^3}\bar m_q^2(10x^3+10xr_\phi^3+\bar m_\pi^6+18x^2\bar m_\sigma^2+12x\bar m_\sigma^4+3\bar m_\sigma^6+3\bar m_\pi^4(2x+\bar m_\sigma^2)+3\bar m_\pi^2(2x+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2+6x^2r_\phi^2(5x+2\bar m_\pi^2+3\bar m_\sigma^2)+6xr_\phi(5x^2+\bar m_\pi^4+6x\bar m_\sigma^2+2\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2+2\bar m_\sigma^4))(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi))
+g_{\bar q\bar q}^{(4)}(\lambda_{\bar A\bar q\bar q}^{(1)})^2(-\frac{1}{6(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)}(1+r_q)(4x^2+x\bar m_\pi^2+5x\bar m_q^2+8\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_q^2+xr_\phi(4x+8xr_q+4xr_q^2+5\bar m_q^2)+3x\bar m_\sigma^2-3\bar m_q^2\bar m_\sigma^2+2xr_q(4x+\bar m_\pi^2+3\bar m_\sigma^2)+xr_q^2(4x+\bar m_\pi^2+3\bar m_\sigma^2))(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)
-\frac{1}{24(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}(8x^2+2x\bar m_\pi^2+9x\bar m_q^2+9\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_q^2+xr_\phi(8x+16xr_q+8xr_q^2+9\bar m_q^2)+6x\bar m_\sigma^2+4xr_q(4x+\bar m_\pi^2+3\bar m_\sigma^2)+2xr_q^2(4x+\bar m_\pi^2+3\bar m_\sigma^2))(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)
-\frac{1}{24(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2(x+xr_\phi+\bar m_\sigma^2)^2}(8x^3+4x^2\bar m_\pi^2+2x\bar m_\pi^4+9x^2\bar m_q^2+18x\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_q^2+9\bar m_\pi^4\bar m_q^2+x^2r_\phi^2(8x+16xr_q+8xr_q^2+9\bar m_q^2)+12x^2\bar m_\sigma^2+6x\bar m_\sigma^4+4xr_q(4x^2+2x\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\pi^4+6x\bar m_\sigma^2+3\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2+3\bar m_\sigma^4)+2xr_q^2(4x^2+2x\bar m_\pi^2+\bar m_\pi^4+6x\bar m_\sigma^2+3\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_\sigma^2+3\bar m_\sigma^4)+2xr_\phi(8x^2+2x\bar m_\pi^2+9x\bar m_q^2+9\bar m_\pi^2\bar m_q^2+6x\bar m_\sigma^2+4xr_q(4x+\bar m_\pi^2+3\bar m_\sigma^2)+2xr_q^2(4x+\bar m_\pi^2+3\bar m_\sigma^2)))(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)\} \tag*{(200)} g q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 12 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 1 x ( 1 + r q ) ( 9 x 2 + 9 x m ˉ π 2 + 18 x r q ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 9 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 7 x m ˉ q 2 − 5 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r ϕ ( 9 x + 18 x r q + 9 x r q 2 + 7 m ˉ q 2 ) + 12 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 24 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 1 x ( 9 x 2 + 9 x m ˉ π 2 + 18 x r q ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 9 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 8 x m ˉ q 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r ϕ ( 9 x + 18 x r q + 9 x r q 2 + 8 m ˉ q 2 ) + 6 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 24 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 1 x ( 9 x 3 + 18 x 2 m ˉ π 2 + 9 x m ˉ π 4 + 18 x r q ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 + 9 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 + 8 x m ˉ q 2 + 4 x m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r ϕ 2 ( 9 x + 18 x r q + 9 x r q 2 + 8 m ˉ q 2 ) + 12 x m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 6 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 9 x 2 + 9 x m ˉ π 2 + 18 x r q ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 9 x r q 2 ( x + m ˉ π 2 ) + 8 x m ˉ q 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 )) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) + g q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ( − ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( 10 x 2 + 10 x r ϕ 2 + 8 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 12 x m ˉ σ 2 + 6 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 4 x r ϕ ( 5 x + 2 m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 1 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 3 1 m ˉ q 2 ( 10 x 3 + 10 x r ϕ 3 + m ˉ π 6 + 18 x 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 12 x m ˉ σ 4 + 3 m ˉ σ 6 + 3 m ˉ π 4 ( 2 x + m ˉ σ 2 ) + 3 m ˉ π 2 ( 2 x + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 + 6 x 2 r ϕ 2 ( 5 x + 2 m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) + 6 x r ϕ ( 5 x 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 2 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 2 m ˉ σ 4 )) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ )) + g q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( − 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 1 ( 1 + r q ) ( 4 x 2 + x m ˉ π 2 + 5 x m ˉ q 2 + 8 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r ϕ ( 4 x + 8 x r q + 4 x r q 2 + 5 m ˉ q 2 ) + 3 x m ˉ σ 2 − 3 m ˉ q 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 2 x r q ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) + x r q 2 ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 24 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 1 ( 8 x 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + 9 x m ˉ q 2 + 9 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + x r ϕ ( 8 x + 16 x r q + 8 x r q 2 + 9 m ˉ q 2 ) + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 4 x r q ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) + 2 x r q 2 ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − 24 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ σ 2 ) 2 1 ( 8 x 3 + 4 x 2 m ˉ π 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 4 + 9 x 2 m ˉ q 2 + 18 x m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + 9 m ˉ π 4 m ˉ q 2 + x 2 r ϕ 2 ( 8 x + 16 x r q + 8 x r q 2 + 9 m ˉ q 2 ) + 12 x 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 6 x m ˉ σ 4 + 4 x r q ( 4 x 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 ) + 2 x r q 2 ( 4 x 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 ) + 2 x r ϕ ( 8 x 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + 9 x m ˉ q 2 + 9 m ˉ π 2 m ˉ q 2 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 4 x r q ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) + 2 x r q 2 ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ))) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ )} (200)
[ P q ˉ q ˉ ( s c ) ] α β γ δ [ F l o w ‾ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ] α β γ δ = 1 16 π 2 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 { ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 3 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) 5 m ˉ q ( 3 x + 6 x r q + 3 x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 + 5 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ) − λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 3 5 m ˉ q ( − 3 x − 6 x r q − 3 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 − 5 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 4 5 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 + 5 m ˉ q 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 4 5 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 + 5 x m ˉ q 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 2 5 x ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − 2 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 + 5 x ( 2 x + 4 x r q + 2 x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 } [P_{\bar q\bar q}^{(\mathrm{sc})}]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}[\overline{\mathrm{Flow}}_{\bar q\bar q}^{(4)}]_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}
=
\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\int_0^\infty dx\,x^3\{(\lambda_{\bar A\bar q\bar q}^{(1)})^3\lambda_{\bar A\bar q\bar q}^{(4)}\frac{5\bar m_q(3x+6xr_q+3xr_q^2-\bar m_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3}
+
\frac{5x(1+r_q)\bar m_q(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{2(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)}
)
-\lambda_{\bar A\bar q\bar q}^{(1)}(\lambda_{\bar A\bar q\bar q}^{(4)})^3\frac{5\bar m_q(-3x-6xr_q-3xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3}
-\frac{5x^2(1+r_q)\bar m_q(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{2(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}
+(\lambda_{\bar A\bar q\bar q}^{(1)})^4\frac{5(1+r_q)\bar m_q^2(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3}
+\frac{5\bar m_q^2(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{8(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}
+(\lambda_{\bar A\bar q\bar q}^{(4)})^4\frac{5x^2(1+r_q)\bar m_q^2(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3}
+\frac{5x\bar m_q^2(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{8(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}
+(\lambda_{\bar A\bar q\bar q}^{(1)})^2(\lambda_{\bar A\bar q\bar q}^{(4)})^2\frac{5x(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2-2\bar m_q^2)(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{2(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^2(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^3}
+\frac{5x(2x+4xr_q+2xr_q^2-\bar m_q^2)(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{4(x+xr_A+\bar m_{\mathrm{gap}}^2)^3(x+2xr_q+xr_q^2+\bar m_q^2)^2}
\} [ P q ˉ q ˉ ( sc ) ] α β γ δ [ Flow q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ] α β γ δ = 16 π 2 1 ∫ 0 ∞ d x x 3 {( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 3 λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 5 m ˉ q ( 3 x + 6 x r q + 3 x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 5 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ) − λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 3 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 5 m ˉ q ( − 3 x − 6 x r q − 3 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 5 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 4 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 5 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 5 m ˉ q 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 4 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 5 x 2 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 8 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 5 x m ˉ q 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 1 ) ) 2 ( λ A ˉ q ˉ q ˉ ( 4 ) ) 2 2 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 5 x ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − 2 m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 4 ( x + x r A + m ˉ gap 2 ) 3 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 5 x ( 2 x + 4 x r q + 2 x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) }
g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 4 ( − ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 − m ˉ q 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( − 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) − x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) + x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ( 2 m ˉ q ( 3 x + 6 x r q + 3 x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) + 2 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) + 2 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ) + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − 4 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) − x m ˉ q 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) − x m ˉ q 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ) + g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( 8 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) + 2 m ˉ q 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) + 2 m ˉ q 2 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) ) + g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( 5 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) + 5 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) + 5 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 2 ) + g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ( 5 m ˉ q ( − 3 x − 6 x r q − 3 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) − 5 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) + 5 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 2 ) + g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( 10 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) + 5 x m ˉ q 2 ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) + 5 x m ˉ q 2 ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 2 ) } . (201) \begin{aligned}
g_{\Delta\bar q\bar q}^{4}\Bigg(&-\frac{(1+r_q)\bar m_q^{2}(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{3}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})^{2}}-\frac{\bar m_q^{2}(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})^{3}}\\
&+g_{\Delta\bar q\bar q}^{2}(\lambda_{\bar Aqq}^{(1)})^{2}\Bigg(-\frac{2(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}-\bar m_q^{2})(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{3}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})}\\
&-\frac{x(1+r_q)^{2}(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})}\\
&+\frac{x(1+r_q)^{2}(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})^{2}}\\
&+g_{\Delta\bar q\bar q}^{2}\lambda_{\bar Aqq}^{(1)}\lambda_{\bar Aqq}^{(4)}\Bigg(\frac{2\bar m_q(3x+6xr_q+3xr_q^{2}-\bar m_q^{2})(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{3}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})}\\
&+\frac{2x(1+r_q)\bar m_q(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})}\\
&+\frac{2x(1+r_q)\bar m_q(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})^{2}}\Bigg)\\
&+g_{\Delta\bar q\bar q}^{2}(\lambda_{\bar Aqq}^{(4)})^{2}\Bigg(-\frac{4x(1+r_q)\bar m_q^{2}(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{3}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})}\\
&-\frac{x\bar m_q^{2}(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})}\\
&-\frac{x\bar m_q^{2}(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})^{2}}\Bigg)\\
&+g_{\phi\bar q\bar q}^{2}g_{\Delta\bar q\bar q}^{2}\Bigg(\frac{8(1+r_q)\bar m_q^{2}(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{3}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})}\\
&+\frac{2\bar m_q^{2}(r_\Delta\eta_\Delta+2xr'_\Delta)}{(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})}\\
&+\frac{2\bar m_q^{2}(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)}{(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\Delta+\bar m_\Delta^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})}\Bigg)\\
&+g_{\phi\bar q\bar q}^{2}(\lambda_{\bar Aqq}^{(1)})^{2}\Bigg(\frac{5(1+r_q)(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}-\bar m_q^{2})(4x+4xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{2})(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{3(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{3}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})}\\
&+\frac{5x(1+r_q)^{2}(4x+4xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{2})(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{6(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})}\\
&+\frac{5x(1+r_q)^{2}(4x^{2}+4x r_\phi^{2}+2x\bar m_\pi^{2}+\bar m_\pi^{4}+6x\bar m_\sigma^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{4}+2xr_\phi(4x+\bar m_\pi^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{2}))(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)}{6(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})^{2}}\Bigg)\\
&+g_{\phi\bar q\bar q}^{2}\lambda_{\bar Aqq}^{(1)}\lambda_{\bar Aqq}^{(4)}\Bigg(\frac{5\bar m_q(-3x-6xr_q-3xr_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})(4x+4xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{2})(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{3(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{3}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})}\\
&-\frac{5x(1+r_q)\bar m_q(4x+4xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{2})(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{3(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})}\\
&+\frac{5x(1+r_q)\bar m_q(4x^{2}+4x r_\phi^{2}+2x\bar m_\pi^{2}+\bar m_\pi^{4}+6x\bar m_\sigma^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{4}+2xr_\phi(4x+\bar m_\pi^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{2}))(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)}{3(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})^{2}}\Bigg)\\
&+g_{\phi\bar q\bar q}^{2}(\lambda_{\bar Aqq}^{(4)})^{2}\Bigg(\frac{10x(1+r_q)\bar m_q^{2}(4x+4xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{2})(r_q\eta_q+2xr'_q)}{3(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{3}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})}\\
&+\frac{5x\bar m_q^{2}(4x+4xr_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{2})(r_A\eta_A+2xr'_A)}{6(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2})(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})}\\
&+\frac{5x\bar m_q^{2}(4x^{2}+4x r_\phi^{2}+2x\bar m_\pi^{2}+\bar m_\pi^{4}+6x\bar m_\sigma^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{4}+2xr_\phi(4x+\bar m_\pi^{2}+3\bar m_\sigma^{2}))(r_\phi\eta_\phi+2xr'_\phi)}{6(x+x r_A+\bar m_{gap}^{2})(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\pi^{2})^{2}(x+2xr_q+x r_q^{2}+\bar m_q^{2})^{2}(x+x r_\phi+\bar m_\phi^{2})^{2}}\Bigg)\Bigg\}. \tag*{(201)}
\end{aligned} g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 4 ( − ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 3 m ˉ q 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( − ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ( ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 m ˉ q ( 3 x + 6 x r q + 3 x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 2 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( − ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 4 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) x m ˉ q 2 ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) − ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 x m ˉ q 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) ) + g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 g Δ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 8 ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 2 m ˉ q 2 ( r Δ η Δ + 2 x r Δ ′ ) + ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r Δ + m ˉ Δ 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 2 m ˉ q 2 ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) + g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) ) 2 ( 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 5 ( 1 + r q ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 − m ˉ q 2 ) ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 5 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 2 5 x ( 1 + r q ) 2 ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) + g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 λ A ˉ q q ( 1 ) λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ( 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 5 m ˉ q ( − 3 x − 6 x r q − 3 x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) − 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 5 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 2 5 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) + g ϕ q ˉ q ˉ 2 ( λ A ˉ q q ( 4 ) ) 2 ( 3 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 3 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 10 x ( 1 + r q ) m ˉ q 2 ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r q η q + 2 x r q ′ ) + 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 5 x m ˉ q 2 ( 4 x + 4 x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 ) ( r A η A + 2 x r A ′ ) + 6 ( x + x r A + m ˉ g a p 2 ) ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ π 2 ) 2 ( x + 2 x r q + x r q 2 + m ˉ q 2 ) 2 ( x + x r ϕ + m ˉ ϕ 2 ) 2 5 x m ˉ q 2 ( 4 x 2 + 4 x r ϕ 2 + 2 x m ˉ π 2 + m ˉ π 4 + 6 x m ˉ σ 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 4 + 2 x r ϕ ( 4 x + m ˉ π 2 + 3 m ˉ σ 2 )) ( r ϕ η ϕ + 2 x r ϕ ′ ) ) } . (201)
References