WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Revisiting nuclear states
Abstract
Observing -nuclear quasibound states requires that the -nuclear potential is both sufficiently attractive and weakly absorptive, as confirmed by the CBELSA/TAPS collaboration analysis of inclusive production experiments on nuclear targets, including liquid hydrogen (LH). Here we present an alternative derivation of the -nuclear potential, constrained by near-threshold and production experiments on a free proton. The resulting -nuclear potential is weakly attractive and strongly absorptive, to the extent that observation of clear signals of -nuclear quasibound states is unlikely. Possible exceptions resulting from the dynamics of the nearby nucleon resonance (1895) are briefly discussed.
Introduction
There is considerable interest at present in meson-nuclear quasibound states, specifically for -- pseudoscalar mesons and - vector mesons, all of which with masses lower than or about 1 GeV [1]. Of these meson candidates, the only meson-nuclear quasibound state established so far experimentally is , likely a , state, bound by about 42 MeV but with a very large width of about 100 MeV [2]. Experimental searches for and quasibound nuclear states are ongoing [3, 4] but so far without success. While both and nuclear interactions are likely to be attractive [1], it is not clear whether or not they are sufficiently strong to enable quasibound states across the periodic table. For , considerable uncertainty arises from the model dependence of the poorly known near-threshold scattering amplitude which serves as input in -nuclear bound state calculations; see for example Refs. [5, 6].
For , in contrast, most phenomenological -nuclear potentials devised for calculating quasibound states are not directly connected to the near-threshold scattering amplitude . Rather, they are constrained by fitting inclusive photoproduction spectra taken on nuclei, such as and [7, 8, 9, 10, 11]. A common parametrization of such -nuclear potentials is given by [1]
where is the nuclear density. The most recent values derived for the strength (or depth) parameters of the real [11] and imaginary [10] parts are
Given these values, only broad and overlapping quasibound nuclear states are expected in nuclear production spectra, as demonstrated in Table 1 for and . However, the and -photoproduction data used to extract and consist dominantly of input, MeV is the Fermi momentum at nuclear-matter density , whereas construction of a near-threshold optical potential relevant to -nucleus bound states requires input data, preferably two-body -nucleon data.
| 15.9 | 17.9 | 28.6 | 22.7 | |
| 8.0 | 16.6 | 19.7 | ||
| – | – | 3.7 | 15.5 |
Table 1. single-particle binding energies and widths in and (in MeV) calculated using , Eq. (1), with MeV, MeV, and . Actual densities are discussed in Sect. 3.
Experiments attempting to observe -nuclear quasibound states have been limited to target. A reaction using the fragment separator FRS at GSI was proposed by Itahashi et al. [12], with negative results published subsequently by Tanaka et al. [13, 14]. Arguments in favor of trying the semi-exclusive reaction were made by Fujioka et al. [15, 16] and very recently by Ikeno et al. [17]. Another attempt, running the reaction in the LEPS2 beamline at SPring-8, failed to observe a clear quasibound signal [18]. Very recently, as the present paper was under review, a paper by Sekiya et al. [19] was submitted to PRL claiming the observation of two relatively narrow deeply bound - states in the reaction at GSI. Remarks on these findings are made here in the concluding section.
In the present work we construct a low-energy -nuclear optical potential by using available near-threshold data of production on a free proton. The selected data set is briefly reviewed in Sect. 2, and the associated -nuclear optical potential is discussed in Sect. 3. Results of -nuclear quasibound state calculations are listed in Sect. 4. It is found that, since the imaginary part of is sizable, no clear binding signals are expected across the periodic table. Concluding remarks are made in Sect. 5.
low-energy interaction parameters
Low energy scattering parameters, in particular the scattering length , were derived from two near-threshold production reactions on a free proton. In the first one, was determined from the rise of the total cross section of the near-threshold production reaction at COSY [20], with real and imaginary parts given by
where the systematic uncertainty of is negligible. In the second one, using data from several near-threshold photoproduction experiments, only the absolute value of was constrained [21]:
with indications that the real part of is small compared to the imaginary part. And furthermore, provided there is no narrow -wave resonance near threshold, a more restrictive constraint arises [21]:
In fact, the nearby , resonance is quite broad, [22], thereby justifying this latter constraint which together with Eq. (3) imply that and is dominantly imaginary. We note that a situation where a meson-nucleon scattering length is dominantly imaginary is not often encountered in studies of mesic atoms and nuclei. For example, for mesons, various meson-baryon coupled-channel models of the broad resonance, which is peaked about 50 MeV above the threshold with MeV, all have [23].
Regarding the sign of , the (10-40)% branching ratio observed for decay [22] suggests that , projected onto the channel, is a resonance rather than a bound state which within our phase convention for a positive implies that is positive.
Optical-potential methodology
bound states in nuclei are calculated here using -nuclear density-dependent optical potential,
with a density-dependent c.m. scattering amplitude in units of fm (). In this expression is the mass number of the nuclear core, is a nuclear density normalized to , stands for nuclear-matter density, is the -nucleus reduced mass and is a kinematical factor transforming from the center-of-mass (c.m.) system, to the -nucleus c.m. system:
The density-dependent c.m. scattering amplitude is given by
where is the Fermi momentum associated with local density . The density dependence of accounts for long-range Pauli correlations in in-medium multiple scatterings, starting at [24, 25] in a nuclear-density expansion, as practised in our -atom studies [26]. Note that in Eq. (8) is not affected by Pauli correlations since all two-body decays proceed with c.m. momentum larger than . The low-density limit of is obtained by setting where is identified in the present exploratory study with the c.m. scattering length considered in the previous section (note that since , , here denoted ). Similar forms of were used by us recently for constructing the () induced component of the -nuclear optical potential [27, 28, 29, 30, 31].
For nuclear densities we used harmonic-oscillator type densities [32] for , with the same radial parameters for neutrons and protons, and two-parameter Fermi (2pF) distributions for , normalized to for protons and for neutrons, all derived from nuclear charge distributions assembled in Ref. [33]. The corresponding r.m.s. radii follow closely values derived from experiment by relating proton densities to charge densities and including the proton charge finite size and recoil effects. This approach is equivalent to assigning some finite range to the interaction. Folding reasonably chosen interaction ranges other than corresponding to the proton charge radius, varying the spatial form of the charge density, or introducing realistic differences between neutron and proton r.m.s. radii, made little difference.
Results
Using of Eq. (6), we report here in Table 2 on calculations of -nuclear binding energies and widths for and . The strength parameter was identified with the complex scattering length. Representative values of , satisfying constraints deduced from production experiments on a free proton, Eqs. (3)-(5), were used for input. We first chose from Eq. (3), together with either implied by the central value , Eq. (4), or implied by the upper value there. Our second choice, which is lower by than its central value of , goes together with either which satisfies the central value in Eq. (5), or which satisfies , the upper value in Eq. (4).
Table 2. single-particle binding energies and widths (MeV) in and , calculated using , Eq. (6), for four values of its complex scattering length (fm). Potential depth values (MeV), with , are also listed.
The potential depth values listed in this table are smaller than the depth value , Eq. (2). This translates into smaller -nuclear binding energies here than those listed in Table 1. Some of the single-particle levels bound there are unbound here, and the presently calculated widths are considerably larger than width values listed there. With widths exceeding 20 MeV and reaching as high values as 50 MeV, there is not much to expect in searching experimentally for -nuclear quasibound states.
Concluding remarks
In this work we explored to what extent -nuclear quasibound states are sufficiently narrow to allow experimental observation. For this task we used a low-energy -nuclear density-dependent optical potential , Eq. (6), that has been applied by us quite successfully to hypernuclei [29, 30] and hypernuclei [27, 28, 31]. The density dependence of such hadron-nucleus optical potential accounts for the leading long-range Pauli correlations. For , the input to consisted of the scattering length which is dominated by its imaginary (absorptive) part. This made the -nuclear quasibound states calculated here, in and in , too broad to allow clear experimental observation.
Future work should consider at subthreshold energies, as done for in Refs. [5, 6], where the subthreshold scattering amplitude was derived by following a dynamical model of in terms of its main two-body decay channels, foremost . Given the apparent proximity of the resonance to the threshold (1896-1897 MeV), a promising path to consider for would be a dynamical model of in terms of its main decay channels , , , , , , and the higher-mass channel as well. Some work in this direction was done by Bruns and Cieplý [34], and more recently by Sakai and Jido [35].
Assuming that the resonance peak is only a few MeV from the threshold provides a natural explanation for the near-vanishing of . Going to subthreshold, one expects to rise to values of order 1 to 2 fm before subsiding to ‘normal’ values of less than 1 fm, while quickly falls down from its maximum value at the resonance peak.2 In a preliminary attempt to apply such a scenario to the two - quasibound states with MeV and MeV observed very recently in the reaction at GSI [19], we found that a subthreshold value fm would come close to fit these values for and states in . Such a large would place severe constraints on any meson-baryon model devised for , posing a major challenge to any related theoretical work in the near future.3
Acknowledgments
We thank Volker Metag for drawing our attention to the recent results of the experiment at GSI [19] and its possible consequences. This work started as part of a project funded by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research & innovation programme, grant agreement 824093.
References
- [1]V. Metag, M. Nanova, E. Paryev, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 97 (2017) 199.
- [2]T. Yamaga, et al. (J-PARC E15 Collab.), Phys. Rev. C 102 (2020) 044002.
- [3]S.D. Bass, P. Moskal, Rev. Mod. Phys. 91 (2019) 015003.
- [4]S.D. Bass, V. Metag, P. Moskal, Handbook of Nuclear Physics (2023) 2783 [Springer Nature, Eds: I. Tanihata, H. Toki, T. Kajino].
- [5]E. Friedman, A. Gal, J. Mareš, Phys. Lett. B 725 (2013) 334.
- [6]A. Cieplý, E. Friedman, A. Gal, J. Mareš, Nucl. Phys. A 925 (2014) 126.
- [7]M. Nanova, et al. (CBELSA/TAPS Collab.), Phys. Lett. B 710 (2012) 600.
- [8]M. Nanova, et al. (CBELSA/TAPS Collab.), Phys. Lett. B 727 (2013) 417.
- [9]M. Nanova, et al. (CBELSA/TAPS Collab.), Phys. Rev. C 94 (2016) 025205.
- [10]S. Friedrich, et al. (CBELSA/TAPS Collab.), Eur. Phys. J. A 52 (2016) 297.
- [11]M. Nanova, et al. (CBELSA/TAPS Collab.), Eur. Phys. J. A 54 (2018) 182.
- [12]K. Itahashi, et al., Prog. Theor. Phys. 128 (2012) 601.
- [13]Y.K. Tanaka, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 117 (2016) 202501.
- [14]Y.K. Tanaka, et al., Phys. Rev. C 97 (2018) 015202.
- [15]H. Fujioka, et al., EPJ Web Conf. 66 (2014) 09006.
- [16]H. Fujioka, et al., Hyperfine Interactions 234 (2015) 33.
- [17]N. Ikeno, et al., arXiv:2406.06058.DOI
- [18]N. Tomida, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 124 (2020) 202501.
- [19]R. Sekiya, et al., arXiv:2509.07824v1.arxiv.org/abs/2509.07824
- [20]E. Czerwinski, P. Moskal, M. Silarski, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 113 (2014) 062004.
- [21]A.V. Anisovich, et al., Phys. Lett. B 785 (2018) 626.
- [22]S. Navas, et al. (Particle Data Group), Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 030001.
- [23]R.A. Arndt, W.J. Briscoe, T.W. Morrison, I.I. Strakovsky, R.L. Workman, A.B. Gridnev, Phys. Rev. C 72 (2005) 045202.
- [24]C.B. Dover, J. Hüfner, R.H. Lemmer, Ann. Phys. (NY) 66 (1971) 248.
- [25]T. Waas, M. Rho, W. Weise, Nucl. Phys. A 617 (1997) 449.
- [26]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Nucl. Phys. A 959 (2017) 66, and references listed there to earlier work on K⁻ atoms.
- [27]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Phys. Lett. B 820 (2021) 136555.
- [28]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Phys. Lett. B 837 (2023) 137640.
- [29]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Phys. Lett. B 837 (2023) 137669.
- [30]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Nucl. Phys. A 1039 (2023) 122725.
- [31]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Phys. Lett. B 868 (2025) 139728.
- [32]L.R.B Elton, Nuclear Sizes, Oxford University Press, 1961.
- [33]I. Angeli, K.P. Marinova, At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 99 (2013) 69.
- [34]P.C. Bruns, A. Cieplý, Nucl. Phys. A 992 (2019) 121630.
- [35]S. Sakai, D. Jido, Phys. Rev. C 107 (2023) 035207.
- [36]A. Gal, E. Friedman, A. Cieplý, J. Hrt́ánková, J. Mareš, PoS(Hadron17) 310 (2018) 195 (DOI: doi.org/10.22323/1.310.0195).