betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Free Products of Vector Lattices

Abstract

We study free products of vector lattices and their relation to free products of Banach lattices. We characterize the Archimedean vector lattices whose vector lattice free product with every Archimedean vector lattice is again Archimedean: these are precisely those whose finitely generated sublattices are projective. For finitely generated lattices, this connects the free-product property with polyhedral geometry through Baker–Beynon duality. We also show that the Banach lattice free product is the completion of the Archimedean vector lattice free product under the largest lattice norm making the canonical maps contractive. For finitely many factors, the Archimedean vector lattice free product is order dense in the Banach lattice free product. Moreover, it is shown that bounded families of injective lattice homomorphisms also induce injective homomorphisms between Banach lattice free products. Finally, in analogy with the theory of separably injective Banach lattices, we study relative injectivity and universal disposition for the class of vector lattices with countably many proper prime ideals. Every vector lattice embeds into one of universal disposition for this class, while ordered ultrapowers of the real line provide relatively injective examples of cardinality continuum.

Introduction

Free products, also called coproducts, describe how to combine a family of objects in a way that allows morphisms defined on each of the individual factors to determine uniquely a morphism on the resulting object. In many familiar categories, these constructions include disjoint unions of sets and topological spaces, direct sums of vector spaces and modules, or free products of groups. In the category of Banach spaces and contractive linear operators, the corresponding construction coincides with the ℓ1\ell_1-sum. Although these examples share the same universal property, the structure of a free product depends fundamentally on the class of morphisms under consideration. For vector lattices, when morphisms are the maps preserving the linear and lattice operations, the direct sum with coordinatewise order does not have the required property: its distinct summands are disjoint, whereas the images of independently chosen lattice homomorphisms need not be. A free product must therefore allow lattice operations between elements from different factors without imposing disjointness or any other prescribed relations among them.

The study of these constructions has a substantial history in ordered algebra and functional analysis. The following developments provide background for the questions considered here: In vector lattice theory, Topping [27] studied projective and injective objects and proved that there are no nonzero injective objects in the category of vector lattices and linear lattice homomorphisms. This obstruction motivates extension problems relative to restricted classes of embeddings (see § 6). Free products of lattice-ordered groups were studied by Holland and Scrimger [10] and, in varieties of lattice-ordered groups and in the abelian case, by Martinez [16, 17]. Powell and Tsinakis [24] subsequently gave concrete constructions in the abelian case and proved that embeddings of the factors induce embeddings of their free products. This can be seen as the group-theoretic counterpart of Corollary 2.11. The amalgamation results of Pierce [22, 23] and the treatment of push-outs by Hager and Madden [9] connect these constructions with extension properties of lattice homomorphisms. Broader accounts of free products and amalgamation appear in the chapters by Powell and Tsinakis [25] and by Tsinakis and Powell [28]. See also [20, 26, 8] for further developments.

In the Banach lattice setting, isometric push-outs were constructed in [2] and used to obtain amalgamation and relative injectivity results. Tursi [29] connected amalgamation with metric Fraïssé theory to construct a separable approximately ultrahomogeneous Banach lattice that is isometrically universal for separable Banach lattices. Also, García-Sánchez, Leung, Taylor and the second author [7] adapted push-out constructions in classes of Banach lattices subject to convexity conditions, including pp-convex lattices and lattices with upper pp-estimates, together with quantitative results on preservation of embeddings. This connects the categorical constructions with the geometry of lattice norms.

In our previous paper [18], we constructed arbitrary free products of Banach lattices where morphisms are lattice homomorphisms. These can be described as appropriate quotients of free Banach lattices and we could establish several basic results such as their compatibility with isometric embeddings, quotients and projectivity. For nonempty compact Hausdorff spaces KK, LL, we also obtained the representation

C(K)∗BLC(L)≃C(K∗L),C(K) \ast_{\mathcal{BL}} C(L) \simeq C(K \ast L),

where K∗LK \ast L denotes the topological join, together with an explicit formula for the free-product norm. Through the double suspension theorem, from geometric topology, this representation yields surprising examples of free factors of FBL⁡[ℓ1]\operatorname{FBL}[\ell_{1}] that are not themselves lattice isomorphic to free Banach lattices.

The purpose of the present paper is to understand the vector-lattice structure underlying these constructions and its relation to Banach lattice theory. Three categories enter naturally: vector lattices VL\mathcal{VL}, Archimedean vector lattices AVL\mathcal{AVL}, both with lattice homomorphisms, and Banach lattices BL\mathcal{BL} with contractive lattice homomorphisms. The relations between these categories raise several questions. When is the ordinary vector-lattice free product of Archimedean factors still Archimedean? Which elements are identified on passing to the Banach lattice free product? Do injective homomorphisms remain injective after taking free products, even when their ranges are not closed? These questions concern both the algebraic relations imposed by the order and the additional structure introduced by a lattice norm and its completion.

We begin with the construction of free products and push-outs in VL\mathcal{VL}. Prime ideals reduce the study of embeddings to totally ordered quotients. This gives a direct proof of the classical fact that push-outs preserve injective lattice homomorphisms, and hence that free products preserve embeddings. The arguments use the theory of amalgamation of lattice-ordered groups and vector lattices developed in [22, 23, 9]. These arguments also provide an algebraic counterpart to the Banach lattice amalgamation methods in [2]. The Archimedean category behaves differently: amalgamation can fail, even though its free products still preserve embeddings (Proposition 4.11). Thus stability under free products and stability under general push-outs must be distinguished.

Our first main result characterizes the finitely generated Archimedean vector lattices XX for which X∗VLYX \ast_{\mathcal{VL}} Y is Archimedean for every finitely generated Archimedean YY. We prove that this property is equivalent to projectivity of XX (Proposition 4.6). Equivalently, XX is finitely presented, embeds into a free vector lattice, or is represented by a polyhedral cone in the Baker–Beynon duality (see [3, 4]). The latter equivalences are classical, but the free-product condition gives a further characterization of the same class. The proof uses the description of finitely generated Archimedean vector lattices as lattices of piecewise linear functions on closed cones, under which Archimedean free products correspond to products of cones. For every non-polyhedral cone, one can produce a partner for which the ordinary free product is non-Archimedean. For arbitrary Archimedean XX, the free product with every Archimedean YY is Archimedean precisely when every finitely generated sublattice of XX is projective (Corollary 4.7). We also show that this local condition does not imply that XX itself embeds into a free vector lattice. These results provide a connection between preservation of the Archimedean property, finite presentation and polyhedral geometry.

For Banach lattice factors (Xi)i∈I(X_i)_{i\in I}, we identify precisely the algebraic sublattice generated by their canonical copies in the Banach lattice free product. The canonical maps factor as

\bigast_{i\in I}^{\mathrm{VL}} X_i \longrightarrow\bigast_{i\in I}^{\mathrm{AVL}} X_i \hookrightarrow\bigast_{i\in I}^{\mathrm{BL}} X_i

where the first map is Archimedeanization and the second is injective (Theorem 5.1). Moreover, the Banach lattice free product is the completion of the Archimedean free product under the largest lattice norm making the canonical maps contractive. Thus Archimedeanization accounts for all the algebraic identifications required before taking the norm completion. This step is necessary: the vector-lattice free product of two free Banach lattices can fail to be Archimedean (see Example 4.9).

The join representation is also useful beyond factors of the form C(K)C(K). We first prove that injective lattice homomorphisms from C(K)C(K) and C(L)C(L) into arbitrary Banach lattices induce an injective map on their free products (Theorem 3.3). We then show that every element of the Banach lattice free product of two Banach lattices comes from the free product of two principal ideals, equipped with their order-unit norms (Proposition 5.2). This brings the representation by continuous functions into the study of individual elements of a general free product. It implies that Archimedean free products of order dense sublattices are order dense in the corresponding two-factor Banach lattice free product (Corollary 5.3), and that each factor is a regular sublattice of an arbitrary Banach lattice free product (Corollary 5.5). We give a countable family for which the algebraic sublattice generated by the factors is not order dense, despite being norm dense. Finally, every uniformly bounded family of injective Banach lattice homomorphisms induces an injective homomorphism between the free products (Proposition 5.6). This extends the embedding results of [18] and clarifies how injectivity and order approximation behave under completion.

Our final group of results concerns extension problems for vector lattices. Motivated by the connection between amalgamation, relative injectivity and universal disposition in separable Banach lattices developed in [2], we consider the class

C={X:∣Spec⁡p(X)∣≤ℵ0},\mathcal{C} = \{X : |\operatorname{Spec}_{p}(X)| \leq\aleph_{0}\},

where Spec⁡p(X)\operatorname{Spec}_{p}(X) denotes the set of proper prime ideals of a vector lattice XX. A vector lattice is called C\mathcal{C}-injective, or countable-prime-injective, if lattice homomorphisms into it extend from sublattices of members of C\mathcal{C}. Universal disposition for C\mathcal{C} requires embeddings to admit extensions that are also embeddings.

Writing c=2ℵ0\mathfrak{c}=2^{\aleph_{0}}, we prove that every member of C\mathcal{C} has cardinality at most c\mathfrak{c}, although it may have uncountable dimension (Proposition 6.3 and Example 6.4). This bound permits a transfinite push-out construction which embeds every vector lattice into one of universal disposition for C\mathcal{C} (Theorem 6.9). Such targets are countable-prime-injective, and there exists a nonzero target of universal disposition of cardinality at most 2ℵ12^{\aleph_{1}}. The construction takes place in VL\mathcal{VL}, since C\mathcal{C} is closed under sublattices and quotients but not under free products or countable increasing unions.

A different construction gives smaller vector lattices which are C\mathcal{C}-injective. For every nonprincipal ultrafilter U\mathcal{U} on N\mathbb{N}, the ordered ultrapower RN/U\mathbb{R}^{\mathbb{N}}/\mathcal{U} is countable-prime-injective and has cardinality c\mathfrak{c} (Theorem 6.14). More generally, countable interpolation suffices for a totally ordered real vector space to have this extension property. The proof relates prime quotients and Archimedean classes to the realization of countable order cuts in ultrapowers. Since a totally ordered vector lattice cannot contain coordinatewise ordered R2\mathbb{R}^{2}, these examples also separate relative injectivity from universal disposition. On the other hand, every nonzero C\mathcal{C}-injective vector lattice has at least c\mathfrak{c} proper prime ideals and is necessarily non-Archimedean. The obstruction persists even when all vector lattices involved are Archimedean: no nonzero Archimedean vector lattice is injective relative to C∩AVL\mathcal{C} \cap\mathcal{AVL} (Theorem 6.21). This exhibits a limitation of purely order-theoretic extension properties which is relevant to their comparison with extension problems in Banach lattices.

The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 collects the algebraic constructions and the prime-ideal arguments. In Section 3, we develop the C(K)C(K) injectivity result. Section 4 studies Archimedeanization and the geometric criterion for free products, and Section 5 establishes the completion and order-theoretic consequences for Banach lattices. Finally, Section 6 deals with universal disposition and relative injectivity with respect to the class of vector lattices with countable prime spectra.

Formalization

The results and numbered definitions in this paper have been formalized in Lean 4.35.0. The development uses Mathlib 4.35.0 and the Banach lattice library BanLat, pinned to commits 56a005855ea1 and c3c5e1bfc4b2, respectively. The formalization is maintained in the FreeProductsVecLat repository; the version linked here is revision ca3135e88ade.

Each numbered statement carries a linked ∀\forall symbol and the name of its corresponding Lean declaration. When a statement is split into several formal results, we provide the relevant links together. The links target source lines at the fixed revision above, independently of subsequent changes to the repository. The mathematical sources contain no proof placeholders, and the build includes a transitive check that the registered results use only Lean’s standard axioms.

Statement on AI use

GPT models were used in developing several of the mathematical arguments and constructions in this paper. GPT-5.5 was used to develop the proof, based on prime ideals, that push-outs of vector lattices preserve injective lattice homomorphisms (Proposition 2.10). The same model was used for the proof that injective lattice homomorphisms from C(K)C(K) spaces induce an injective map on their Banach lattice free products (Theorem 3.3), and for the proof that every element of the Banach lattice free product of two Banach lattices belongs to the image of the free product of two principal ideals equipped with their order-unit norms (Proposition 5.2).

GPT-5.6 was used to develop the discussion of polyhedral cones and the main characterization result in Section 4 (Proposition 4.6 and Corollary 4.7). In particular, it suggested using cone duality and helped formulate the precise conditions under which vector lattice free products of Archimedean factors remain Archimedean.

GPT-6 Astra was used to develop some of the results and proofs in § 6, on vector lattices with countable spectra, relative injectivity, and universal disposition. GPT-6 Astra and Sol were also used to assist with the Lean formalization. The authors subsequently reviewed, corrected, and refined the AI-assisted arguments, adapting them to the mathematical framework and exposition of the paper.

Preliminaries on vector lattices

Throughout, all vector spaces and lattices are over the real field. An ideal of a vector lattice is a vector subspace which is solid (x∈Ix \in I whenever ∣x∣≤∣y∣|x| \le|y| for some y∈Iy \in I). Lattice homomorphisms are linear and preserve finite suprema and infima. We write lat⁡(A)\operatorname{lat}(A) for the vector sublattice generated by a set AA. For background on vector and Banach lattices, see [14, 19].

For a vector space EE, the free vector lattice FVL⁡[E]\operatorname{FVL}[E] is generated by a linear copy of EE and has the property that every linear map from EE into a vector lattice extends uniquely to a lattice homomorphism; see [3].

When EE is a Banach space, FBL⁡[E]\operatorname{FBL}[E] denotes the free Banach lattice generated by EE. It contains a canonical linear isometric copy of EE, and every bounded linear map from EE into a Banach lattice extends uniquely to a lattice homomorphism from FBL⁡[E]\operatorname{FBL}[E] of the same norm. This construction was introduced by Avilés, Rodríguez and Tradacete [1], generalizing the construction over sets due to de Pagter and Wickstead [5]. For a systematic study of their structure and their relation to the geometry of the generating Banach space, see Oikhberg, Taylor, Tradacete and Troitsky [21].

For free products of Banach lattices, we follow the conventions of [18].

Given a family of vector lattices (Xi)i∈I(X_i)_{i\in I}, a free product of this family is a vector lattice XX together with lattice homomorphisms φi:Xi⟶X\varphi_i:X_i\longrightarrow X such that, for every family of lattice homomorphisms Ti:Xi⟶YT_i:X_i\longrightarrow Y, there is a unique lattice homomorphism T:X⟶YT:X\longrightarrow Y satisfying Ti=TφiT_i=T\varphi_i for every i∈Ii\in I. The corresponding definitions in AVL\mathcal{AVL} and BL\mathcal{BL} use Archimedean targets and contractive Banach lattice homomorphisms, respectively. By rescaling, a uniformly bounded family of Banach lattice homomorphisms also induces a bounded homomorphism on the Banach lattice free product, of norm at most sup⁡i∥Ti∥\sup_i\|T_i\|.

Proposition 2.1. ∀ nonempty_freeProduct The free product of a family of vector lattices always exists.

Proof. Let (Xi)i∈I(X_i)_{i\in I} be a family of vector lattices, and let ιi:Xi⟶Z=(⨁j∈IXj)\iota_i:X_i\longrightarrow Z=\left(\bigoplus_{j\in I}X_j\right) be the inclusions into their algebraic direct sum. Given lattice homomorphisms Ti:Xi⟶YT_i:X_i\longrightarrow Y, set S=⨁iTi:Z⟶YS=\bigoplus_iT_i:Z\longrightarrow Y. The induced lattice homomorphism S^:FVL⁡[Z]⟶Y\widehat{S}:\operatorname{FVL}[Z]\longrightarrow Y satisfies S^δ=S\widehat{S}\delta=S, where δ:Z⟶FVL⁡[Z]\delta:Z\longrightarrow\operatorname{FVL}[Z] is the canonical inclusion.

Consider the ideal JJ of FVL⁡[Z]\operatorname{FVL}[Z] generated by elements of the form δi∣x∣−∣δi(x)∣\delta_i|x|-|\delta_i(x)|, with i∈Ii\in I and x∈Xix\in X_i. If q:FVL⁡[Z]⟶X=FVL⁡[Z]/Jq:\operatorname{FVL}[Z]\longrightarrow X=\operatorname{FVL}[Z]/J denotes the quotient map and φi=qδi\varphi_i=q\delta_i, then

φi∣x∣=qδi∣x∣=q∣δi(x)∣=∣φi(x)∣.(1)\varphi_i|x|=q\delta_i|x|=q|\delta_i(x)|=|\varphi_i(x)|. \tag*{(1)}

S^\widehat{S} vanishes on JJ because

S^(δi∣x∣−∣δi(x)∣)=Si∣x∣−∣S^δi(x)∣=Ti∣x∣−∣Ti(x)∣=0.\widehat{S}(\delta_i|x| - |\delta_i(x)|) = S_i|x| - |\widehat{S}\delta_i(x)| = T_i|x| - |T_i(x)| = 0.

Hence S^\widehat{S} induces a lattice homomorphism T:X⟶YT:X \longrightarrow Y with Tq=S^Tq=\widehat{S}. The map TT satisfies

Tφi=Tqδi=S^δi=Sιi=Ti.T\varphi_i = Tq\delta_i = \widehat{S}\delta_i = S\iota_i = T_i.

Uniqueness follows because the sublattices φi(Xi)\varphi_i(X_i) generate XX.

As usual, the free product of a family of vector lattices is unique up to lattice isomorphism. We denote by ∗VLi∈IXi\ast_{\mathrm{VL}_{i\in I}}X_i the vector lattice free product of the family (Xi)i∈I(X_i)_{i\in I}.

Observation 2.2. ∀\forall inclusion_injective The inclusions φi0:Yi0⟶∗VLYi\varphi_{i_0}:Y_{i_0}\longrightarrow\ast_{\mathrm{VL}}Y_i are injective.

Proof. Choose Ti0=id⁡Yi0T_{i_0}=\operatorname{id}_{Y_{i_0}} and Ti=0T_i=0 when i≠i0i\ne i_0. Then (∗iTi)φi0=id⁡Yi0(\ast_iT_i)\varphi_{i_0}=\operatorname{id}_{Y_{i_0}}, so φi0\varphi_{i_0} is injective.

Proposition 2.3. ∀\forall isFreeOver_directSum For every family of vector spaces (Xi)(X_i),

FVL⁡[⨁Xi]≃∗VLFVL⁡[Xi].\operatorname{FVL}\left[\bigoplus X_i\right]\simeq\ast_{\mathrm{VL}}\operatorname{FVL}[X_i].

Proof. The argument in [18 Proposition 5.5] shows that FVL⁡[⨁Xi]\operatorname{FVL}[\bigoplus X_i] has the required universal property.

References

  1. [1]A. Avilés, J. Rodríguez, and P. Tradacete, The free Banach lattice generated by a Banach space, J. Funct. Anal. 274 (2018), no. 10, 2955–2977.
  2. [2]A. Avilés and P. Tradacete, Amalgamation and injectivity in Banach lattices, Int. Math. Res. Not. 2023 (2023), no. 2, 956–997.
  3. [3]K. A. Baker, Free vector lattices, Can. J. Math. 20 (1968), 58–66.DOI
  4. [4]W. M. Beynon, Duality theorems for finitely generated vector lattices, Proc. Lond. Math. Soc. (3) 31 (1975), 114–128.DOI
  5. [5]B. de Pagter and A. W. Wickstead, Free and projective Banach lattices, Proc. R. Soc. Edinb., Sect. A, Math. 145 (2015), no. 1, 105–143.arxiv.org/abs/1204.4282
  6. [6]D. H. Fremlin, Tensor products of Banach lattices, Math. Ann. 211 (1974), no. 2, 87–106.DOI
  7. [7]E. García-Sánchez, D. H. Leung, M. A. Taylor, and P. Tradacete, Banach lattices with upper p-estimates: free and injective objects, Math. Ann. 391 (2025), 3363–3398.
  8. [8]A. W. Hager and C. M. Kimber, Hyperarchimedean coproducts, Algebra Universalis 71 (2014), no. 4, 375–384.DOI
  9. [9]A. W. Hager and J. J. Madden, Majorizing-injectivity in abelian lattice-ordered groups, Rend. Sem. Mat. Univ. Padova 69 (1983), 181–194.
  10. [10]W. C. Holland and E. Scrimger, Free products of lattice ordered groups, Algebra Universalis 2 (1972), 247–254.
  11. [11]D. G. Johnson and J. E. Kist, Prime ideals in vector lattices, Canad. J. Math. 14 (1962), 517–528.DOI
  12. [12]H. J. Keisler, The ultraproduct construction, Ultrafilters across mathematics, Contemp. Math., vol. 530, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2010, pp. 163–179.DOI
  13. [13]F.-V. Kuhlmann and E. Nart, Cuts and small extensions of abelian ordered groups, J. Pure Appl. Algebra 226 (2022), no. 11, 107103.arxiv.org/abs/2109.12528
  14. [14]W. A. J. Luxemburg and A. C. Zaanen, Riesz spaces. Vol. I, North-Holland Math. Libr., vol. 1, Elsevier (North-Holland), Amsterdam, 1971.
  15. [15]S. Mac Lane, Categories for the working mathematician, 2nd ed., Grad. Texts Math., vol. 5, Springer, New York, 1998.
  16. [16]J. Martinez, Free products in varieties of lattice-ordered groups, Czechoslovak Math. J. 22 (1972), no. 4, 535–553.DOI
  17. [17]———, Free products of abelian ℓ-groups, Czechoslovak Math. J. 23 (1973), no. 3, 349–361.DOI
  18. [18]G. Martínez-Fernández and P. Tradacete, Free products of Banach lattices, Preprint, arXiv:2605.28988, 2026.
  19. [19]P. Meyer-Nieberg, Banach lattices, Universitext, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1991.
  20. [20]D. Mundici, Free products in the category of abelian ℓ-groups with strong unit, J. Algebra 113 (1988), no. 1, 89–109.DOI
  21. [21]T. Oikhberg, M. A. Taylor, P. Tradacete, and V. G. Troitsky, Free Banach lattices, J. Eur. Math. Soc. 28 (2026), no. 10, 4387–4514, Corrigendum, ibid. 28 (2026), no. 10, 4515–4518.
  22. [22]K. R. Pierce, Amalgamations of lattice ordered groups, Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 172 (1972), 249–260.DOI
  23. [23]———, Amalgamated sums of abelian ℓ-groups, Pac. J. Math. 65 (1976), 167–173.
  24. [24]W. B. Powell and C. Tsinakis, Free products in the class of abelian ℓ-groups, Pac. J. Math. 104 (1983), no. 2, 429–442.
  25. [25]———, Free products in varieties of lattice-ordered groups, Lattice-ordered groups: advances and techniques (A. M. W. Glass and W. C. Holland, eds.), Math. Appl., vol. 48, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 1989, pp. 278–307.
  26. [26]D.-R. Ton, The ℓᵣ-free products of Archimedean ℓ-groups, Czechoslovak Math. J. 48 (1998), no. 2, 243–252.DOI
  27. [27]D. M. Topping, Some homological pathology in vector lattices, Canad. J. Math. 17 (1965), 411–428.DOI
  28. [28]C. Tsinakis and W. B. Powell, Amalgamations of lattice-ordered groups, Lattice-ordered groups: advances and techniques (A. M. W. Glass and W. C. Holland, eds.), Math. Appl., vol. 48, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 1989, pp. 308–327.DOI
  29. [29]M. A. Tursi, A separable universal homogeneous Banach lattice, Int. Math. Res. Not. 2023 (2023), no. 7, 5438–5472.

Paper details

vlnc:W_jp2hkbqn
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 6

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents